27/02/2017 Breakfast

Hello, this is Breakfast, with Dan Walker and Louise Minchin.

Confusion at the Oscars as the Best Picture award is handed

La La Land was initially named the winner. The producers started their

acceptance speeches but they were interrupted with an announcement

that Moonlight was in fact the best picture. It appears the warrant 80

and Faye Dunaway it were handed the wrong envelope, the most dramatic

twist in the Oscar's final scene. Good morning, it's

Monday 27th February. the Independent Inquiry

into Child Sexual Abuse finally holds its first public hearings more

than two and a half years Sales of Fairtade products hit

?1.6bn last year but does the buying I'll meet a farmer

from Malawi to find out. In sport, Manchester United snatch

victory from Southampton in the EFL The 3-2 win saw Jose Mourinho become

the first United manager to win a trophy in his first

season with the club. Good morning. A day of sunshine and

showers and be showers will be a sundry with hail and possible sleet

and snow. Wherever you worry it will be windy. More details later in the

programme. -- wherever you are. The Oscars ceremony has ended

in confusion, after the wrong film In a farcical ending,

La La Land was announced as the winner, before the award

eventually went to Moonlight. We were here at work. Extraordinary

scenes as everybody tried to work it out.

Let's cross to our Los Angeles correspondent James Cook,

who's at the Vanity Fair after-show party which all the stars attend.

There will be only one subject. What an extraordinary thing to happen.

Can you tell us what happened and how it happened? What happened was

that the award ceremony had been running smoothly and there had been

more than a liberal sprinkling of politics throughout with criticisms

of Donald Trump especially from the host who joked at the start if he

did not know if he would make a good job at hosting. We will come to that

in a moment because what happened at the end was that as they handed the

best picture award to La La Land, Warren Beatty and Faye Dunaway were

opening the envelope. The name La La Land was read out but then the

producers came on stage, they began to make an acceptance speech. They

were quite a long way into them before it became apparent that there

was a mistake. There was confusion and a kerfuffle on stage and

eventually one of the producers snatch the envelope, held it up to

the camera to reveal that Moonlight was the winner. He handled it quite

class Lee. John Floyd, just a few moments ago, even he was saying that

when he won his Oscar back in 1978 he could not have imagined what it

would feel like if someone had taken a moment away from him. There is a

mistake. Moonlight, are you guys won Best Picture. This is not a joke. I

am afraid they read the wrong thing. This is not a joke. Moonlight is a

won. Moonlight. Best picture. Server was the producer of La La Land. He

had made an acceptance speech and quite graciously said that he will

hand over the Oscar to the true winners. It was the most

extraordinary moment. Quite incredible and what had happened in

the run-up to that was that La La Land had done quite well. Not

sweeping the board as some had expected and it had done quite well.

Emma Stone had won. The director had one as well. -- had won as well.

Hello, sir. This is the BBC. What did you think about the moment at

the end? I thought it was an honest mistake. Something that happens. It

is live and so anything can go wrong. It is not the first time this

has happened. I have probably been involved in something like this

before. Could you imagine, you would have won plenty of awards in your

time. If you had won something of that calibre and it was taken from

you at the last moment... The people were very gracious and they handled

it quite well. What is your view about the whole aspect of racial

diversity? That is what we would be talking about were it not for this

last-minute kerfuffle. Has there been an advance this year, do you

think? Something that we constantly need to work on. We constantly need

to try to improve upon it. Because it is the most stupid idea that man

can have, to be prejudiced against each other of colour or belief. We

are all human beings. And we saw the first Muslim advert to win for best

supporting actor, Marshela Ali. Not to mention Viola Davis for best

supporting actress. It is not the first time a black person has won an

Oscar. It is ongoing. There is improvement but we are making

progress. There is a lot of politics in this show. A lot of criticism,

criticism of the policies of Donald Trump. Was the appropriate? What did

you feel? It is America. That is what this country is. You can say

what you want to, that is what this is about. Thank you very much. There

is some reaction from the celebrities arriving here for the

Vanity Fair party. I don't know how much you can hear. Let's have a look

at the line at the photographers down the yen, camera crews at this

end. Stars arriving with right and centre and as you rightly say, there

is only one thing they will be discussing. Huge congratulations to

Moonlight. We had the director here last week. It was beyond his wildest

dreams. Fantastic news for them. What else should we be talking

about, if anything? When I was just talking about there I think is

relevant. The first Muslim actor, we believe, to win acting award at the

Oscars have got to be a significant moment. The Koran was quoted one

moment, invoking Islam is a religion of peace. There was a victory for

the White Helmet and its producer. That is significant. A film about

the civil war in Syria and there were, at various points, please do

not build walls between the United States and other countries and to

remain united. One of the big question is, however that has only

intensified as result of these Oscars, I have to say was

brilliantly hosted by Jimmy Kimmel, at least it was brilliantly hosted

if you take a certain political persuasion. Maybe you could support

President Trump and enjoyed as well that there will certainly be a

significant slice of the United States of America who felt that Mr

Kimmel was harsh on the President, effectively suggesting that he was a

racist, among other things. I think that is a dilemma for producers of

award shores. There is nowhere more liberal in the world than this, than

Hollywood. So to what extent of these people preach to the converted

and to what extent is the other house of the United States simply

turn off the television? Thank you very much. We will return throughout

the programme. We need more reaction on the people involved in that

enormous mistake. The wrong envelope, that is all came down to.

She initially read the nominations. If you look at the picture he

actually has Best actress in her leading role, which is Emma Stone,

La La Land. He gave it to Faye Dunaway because he thought was a

mistake. They read the one and there you go. There were only two people

in the room who knew the truth and they came up onto the stage. Yes.

The people come in under high security, nobody knows who has won

because they are in suitcases, the winners, they go in separate routes.

Someone said that was the wrong envelope and... There you go.

Anyway, Moonlight, best picture. Let us know what you think about that.

We will be speaking about this later on in the morning as well.

The independent inquiry into child sexual abuse will hold its first

public hearings today, more than two and a half years

after it was set up by the government.

It'll begin by examining the mistreatment of British children

in care or from poor families, who were sent to Australia

in the years after the Second World War.

The inquiry will be told that the scale of abuse

they suffered was much wider than previously thought.

Here's our home affairs correspondent Tom Symonds.

NEWSREEL: They arrive at Fremantle from Great Britain with 931

New lives in the sunshine. That is what children in care, or from poor

families were promised. But 70 years old, some like Clifford Walsh, are

still affected by the beatings and sexual abuse they suffered instead.

His Catholic children's home near Perth in Australia has become

notorious. For the next two weeks the televised public enquiry will

consider new evidence about the extent of the abuse, claims that

children were picked by paedophiles to travel aboard and allegations of

a cover-up. You want to know what happened, we want to know who did it

and we want to know who covered it up for so long. Of course we need to

know about it. There were consequences for children today. We

also need to look at why it has taken 30 years to bring about this

enquiry into the horrific abuse of hundreds, if not thousands of young

children. The enquiry rejects suggestions that it is reaching too

far back in history. Many of the migrants are still alive. Getting to

the bottom of what happened to them and why, it says, is still relevant.

Later on we will be speaking to somebody who was sent to Australia

as a young boy and is now a campaigner.

The Labour MP and former minister, Sir Gerald Kaufman, has died

He was an MP in Manchester for 47 years, and a Shadow Minister

In 2015, as the longest continuously serving MP,

The BBC has ordered an investigation into TV licence collectors

following reports that they're deliberately targeting vulnerable

The Daily Mail claims enforcement officers,

who are employed by the private company Capita, are ordered to catch

28 evaders every week and promised financial incentives

Head teachers and school governors are calling on the Chancellor

to make schools a priority in the budget.

The National Association of Head Teachers and the National

Association of Governors have written an open letter

to Philip Hammond to say that they're being forced to make

Here's our Education correspondent, Gillian Hargreaves.

More than a third of small businesses expect their rates

to rise this April, according to the Federation of Small

The Federation says many face unsustainable and unaffordable

increases, and are planning to cut the amount they invest

The government has promised help for those worst hit.

The mobile phone company Nokia is bringing back one of its most

The company has struggled to compete in the smartphone era,

but it hopes there'll be a demand for a simple phone with a battery

The handset was first launched in the year 2000,

You loved that game. I still love it. I think I would purchase one of

those phones just for the game. If Snake on it? If not then they made a

hideous mistake. Chefs from a town in Russia have

tried for the eleventh time to make Despite it measuring

three metres in diameter, it didn't get the award because it

wasn't flipped properly, Apparently it also

tasted a bit too salty. It really was not slept properly.

Look at this. You don't cut a pancake like that, do you?

Everything about that is wrong. Disappointing on so many different

levels. We will try to about other things on

the programme apart from the Oscars. Oh, really? Do we have to. How about

Southampton... No, Manchester, winning the cup. Good morning,

everybody. Manchester United beat Southampton

3-2 to win the EFL Cup at Wembley. Southampton will consider themselves

unlucky after Zlatan Ibrahimovic ended their fight back by winning

the match with less than five Spurs go second in the Premier

League after they demolished Stoke One goal from Dele Alli and three

from Harry Kane did the damage - although Spurs are still ten

points behind Chelsea. It's now 17 wins in a row

for Eddie Jones' England side. They survived a scare from Italy

before winning their Six Nations match 36-15 and picking up a bonus

point at Twickenham. And Great Britain's Mark Cavendish

has won the sprinters prize at the Tour of Abu Dhabi,

after finishing second Australia's Caleb Ewan

beat him to win Stage Four, but Cavendish had accumulated enough

points to win the green jersey. Things might be going wrong in the

world, chaos everywhere, everyone making bad decisions and saying the

wrong thing, but we are about to hand over to someone who has it all

under control. You have built it up now! Let's ring her in. What have

you got for us, Carol Kirkwood. I wondered if someone had walked in

behind me. For many of us we will be seeing scenes like this lovely

Weather Watcher's picture. It will be wet and cold. You can see the

cold are coming in and the showers we are looking at will be as sleet

and snow in some parts of the country, especially in the north. As

the cold air filter south we will see some of that as well. Some

showers will be heavy but the very nature of showers means we won't all

see one. Across Scotland, sunshine and showers but some of those will

be sleet and snow, some will be heavy and have hail in them as well.

For Northern Ireland, a similar story. You can expect some showers,

Fleet, snow, hail and thunder. As we come further south across England

and Wales there are a lot of showers, any wintry showers will be

around south-west England, around the Moors, for example. In between

we will see brighter skies but there will be a lot of showers. It is

windy at the moment, the peak of the winds around the Northern Isles and

there is the risk of ice on cold, untreated surfaces which have also

been damp. Increasingly through the day we will see snow at lower

levels. Through Scotland and northern England, we will also have

some more showers coming in on the wind because it will be a windy day,

across Wales in south-west England, and again we will see a wintry

flavour from them, primarily on the hills. These are our maximum

temperatures, nothing to be writing home about. As we head on through

the evening and overnight it will be windy, gales for some of us. Some

snow coming out of the showers, and perhaps even more of the risk of ice

on untreated surfaces this coming night. These are the temperatures

you can expect in towns and cities. In rural areas it will be a lot

lower than this, -6 in parts of Scotland, -2 in parts of England and

Wales. As we go into tomorrow we start off on the cold note with the

risk of ice. Low pressure not to far away. This is the remnants of what

was storm Ewan at the weekend. It will be wintry on its south-western

flank and as it does so it will drive him a lot of showers and some

of those are likely to be wintry in nature. More dry weather than wet

weather across much of the UK tomorrow, and temperatures between

about seven and eight or nine. As we had from Tuesday into Wednesday we

say goodbye to that system which moves off onto the near continent. A

ridge of high pressure building in behind it, but the next set of front

are not too far away. On Wednesday a quieter day for most, and a dry day,

with some bright spells and even some sunshine. We do have a set of

front scooting across the South but here it is still mild, at 10

Celsius, around six or seven as we push further north. Thank you very

much. We're all trying to get things especially right today. We guarantee

it. And we can't do much worse. We are talking about the Oscars, where

there was a big mistake at the end of the night where La La Land was

announced as the winner of Best Picture, but actually it was

Moonlight. We will get to all of that in a minute. That show you some

of the front pages. From Moonlight to limelight, Naomi Harris in

California nominated for Best Supporting Actress for her role in

Moonlight. Just that moment when you think you haven't won and then you

have one. Extraordinary for everybody. Their main story is a

curb on migrants. And the front page of the Times, lots to talk about.

Manchester United winning the League Cup against Southampton and Scots to

demand a new referendum, Number Ten fears. We will get some more Oscars

reaction. The highest representatives we have in this

industry, so you have to give them credit. That was Colin Paterson

speaking to Miles Taylor about what happened. We just missed it, and we

can speak a bit more about what happened. This is what most people

will be talking about this morning. We are aware there is other news

around but when something of this scale happens at such a huge global

ceremony, Warren Beatty and Faye Dunaway were on stage to give away

the Best Picture award and this is what happened. La La Land!

APPLAUSE Guys, I am sorry. There is a

mistake. Moonlight, you guys won Best Picture. This is not a joke. I

am afraid they read the wrong thing. This is not a joke. Moonlight has

won Best Picture. Moonlight, Best Picture. So the way that all

happened essentially is the guy who is explaining that Moonlight one

Best Picture is one of the producers of La La Land, and he had to

interrupt a co-producer, making a speech, thanking various members of

his family. Jimmy Kimmel tries to sort it out, and Warren Beatty is

given an envelope which says Best Actress in a leading role, which is

Emma Stone, and she has been speaking in the last few minutes.

She has been doing a press conference they all do afterwards,

and she says she is interested in how it all happened, because she was

holding her card the entire time. So when you get your statue, you also

get a card which has a winner on it, because you probably want to frame

that. She says she had it all the time. There must be a second card.

What is interesting about the clip is how you see Warren Beatty

basically passed the buck to Faye Dunaway. He opens it, and clearly he

is looking at it, and he sees Emma Stone, La La Land, we think. He is

confused why her name is on that, passes it over and leaves her to

make the announcement. I felt sorry for Faye Dunaway in that moment, it

was what else was she going to do except to read what was on the wrong

card? The wonderful thing is that immediately, we have made a mistake,

let's handed over. Moonlight, congratulations. Yes, eventually. We

will have to be careful we don't make a mistake today!

As the independent inquiry into child sexual abuse finally gets

under way, the first case to be investigated is the story

of the so-called "lost children" who were sent to Australia.

Thousands of youngsters were sent Down-Under after the Second World

Many went on to be beaten and sexually abused

Our home affairs correspondent Tom Symonds reports.

Margaret Humphreys uncovered the scandal of Britain's lost children,

sent abroad without parents in the years following the Second World War

for what they were promised would be a better life. They are now elderly.

But finally, a public enquiry is about to start considering the

damage it has done to their lives, in particular the impact of sexual

abuse. We want to know what happened, we want to know who did

it, and we want to know who covered up for so long. Of course we need to

know about it. There are consequences for children today. We

also need to look at why it has taken 30 years to bring about this

enquiry into what is the horrific abuse of hundreds if not thousands

of young children. NEWSREEL: The liner Asturias arrives

at Fremantle from Great Britain with 931 new migrants

for this country. I've lived for 60-odd

years with this hate. They sent us to a place

that was a living hell. All we did was do as we were told,

and suffered immensely for it. Clifford Walsh was nine

when he arrived here at Fremantle, He ended up at Bindoon, run

by the Catholic Christian Brothers, where barefoot children

built their own accommodation These Brothers, these

paedophiles, must have thought

they were in hog heaven. The public enquiry will hold new

hearings, into claims that children were picked by paedophiles to go

abroad, and allegations of a cover-up. David Hill left Tilbury

docks, near London, for Australia 58 years ago, and grew up at the

Fairbridge farm school north of Sydney. He has written a book on

what went on, and estimates 60% of the children were sexually abused.

He will be a key witness at what has been a much criticised enquiry. What

can best achieve? From my point of view, only good can come of it.

Because the truth will be known. It seems to me that the greater the

evil, the stronger the conspiracy to keep it a secret and keep it covered

up. So, if this inquiry is capable

of opening some of that truth, It takes painstaking work to link

children sent abroad with the families they always had in Britain.

That work happens here at the child migrants trust in Nottingham, and

this is the result. Thousands of long-awaited reunion is. The

government's scheme which pays for these reunions pays for elderly

child migrants to visit Britain is about to finish. The trust is

demanding it continues. At the end of their lives, it says, it is the

least the country of their birth can do.

And a little bit later on BBC Breakfast we will be talking to a

man who as a young boy, aged 12, was sent to Australia. He will talk to

us about his experiences, and his giving evidence as well.

You are watching Breakfast from BBC News.

Coming up in the next half-hour, we will be getting reaction

James Cook is at the Vanity Fair after-show party.

Where everyone is all a flutter about the last minutes of the

Oscars, which were astonishingly dramatic. The Oscar was handed to La

La Land. The Best Picture Oscar, the last of the night, the crowning

glory of the 89th Academy Awards, or so it seemed. Within just a few

minutes, after the producers had come onto the stage and were making

their speeches, it became clear that the wrong envelope had been handed

over, and that in fact the winner of Best Picture was the coming-of-age

drama Moonlight, directed by Barry Jenkins. There was astonishment in

the room, I can tell you. There was astonishment here as well. People

were standing watching the telecast with their mouths Agape and the

stars coming down this red carpet have been astonished by what

happened. We will Vanessa Feltz will have more on the

Oscars and what is going on. Goodbye for now.

Hello, this is Breakfast with Dan Walker and Louise Minchin.

We'll bring you all the latest news and sport in a moment,

A dramatic and farcical ending to the Oscars. La La Land was announced

as the winner before the award eventually went to Moonlight. To

explain this, we crossed to Los Angeles and James Cook who was at

the after show party. There will be all sorts of madness going on behind

you. Can you explain to us what happened?

We are expecting to talk this morning about diversity and some of

the things that Jimmy Kimmel was saying, but there is only one

awkward thing to discuss. We will probably address some of those other

things as well but there is only one headline and that is the

unbelievable drama in the final minutes of the Oscars. A plot twist

that no-one could have predicted. Surely one of the most extraordinary

farces in the history of the Academy Awards. This was the 89th Academy

award. Let's have a look at how the moment unfolded. Come on. La La

Land. I'm sorry, no. There has been a

mistake. Moonlight, you guys won best picture. This is not a joke. I

am afraid they read the wrong thing. This is not a joke. Moonlight has

won best picture. Moonlight. Best picture. I believe I should keep it

anyway. No, sorry. Guys... This is very unfortunate what happened.

Personally I blame Steve Harvey for this. I would like you to have an

Oscar anyway. I will be proud to hand this to my friends from

Moonlight. So that was stored in horror bits and Jimmy Kimmel trying

to explain what happened there. Do we know more about what went on? Was

it just a case of the wrong envelope? I think it was the wrong

envelope and I think the suggestion is that it may have been the

envelope that contained the award that had just been handed to Best

actress, that is that Emma Stone, one of the stars of La La Land. I

have reaction just here in the past few minutes from the director of

Moonlight. He says that it was extraordinary, the moment that

happened there. He said that he had never before seen anything like that

happen. He said the last 20 minutes of his life have been insane. He

really wanted to see the card for himself and why and 80 showed it to

him and then he felt better about what had happened. He said that the

people involved with La La Land had been so generous, that he could not

imagine being in their position and having to do that. Of course, you

know, it was an amazing thing to hear La La Land. I think we would

have loved to have one best picture. But we are so excited for Moonlight.

It is one of the best films of all time so I was beside myself. I was

also holding my best actress in a leading role card that entire time.

So I don't mean to start stuff but whatever story that was... I had

that card. I don't know what happened. I wanted to talk to you

guys first. Well, that was Emma Stone. What a moment. What drama and

we will hear a lot more about that and some of the other issues that

featured in the ceremony which included some attacks on criticism

of President Trump and his policies and also increased diversity after

two years in which only white actors were nominated. He glossed over some

of the other main awards of the night. It has, hasn't it. Best

Director, Damian for La La Land. Best act ever Casey Affleck. We will

remind you, of course, and tell you who won at what the quite an

extraordinary story. There is other news as well, however. Yes. And it

is quite right, and important. The independent inquiry into child

sexual abuse will hold its first public hearings today,

more than two and a half years after it was set up

by the government. It'll begin by examining

the mistreatment of British children in care or from poor families,

who were sent to Australia in the years after

the Second World War. The inquiry will be told

that the scale of abuse they suffered was much wider

than previously thought. The Labour MP and former minister,

Sir Gerald Kaufman, has died He was an MP in Manchester for 47

years, and a Shadow Minister In 2015, as the longest

continuously serving MP, Downing Street has dismissed

discussion that Theresa May will end free movement of EU migrants. The

report is that it could be the 15th of March,. Anyone arriving in the UK

after that point will no longer have the automatic right to stay

permanently. Downing Street has said that node decision has been taken.

Let's have a break, shall we? Sally. I'm pretty sure that Southampton

fans wished that had happened to them yesterday. I think we are

talking about Ibrahimovic. Jose Mourinho has become the first

Manchester United manager to win a trophy in his first season

at the club after guiding his side to a 3-2 win over

Southampton in the EFL Cup. Saints fans will consider their side

to have been unlucky as Manolo Gabbiadini saw a goal

contentiously ruled out. United then went two nil up

through Zlatan Ibrahimovic and Jesse Gabbiadini struck either side

of the interval to bring But Ibrahimovic snatched victory

with just a few minutes left to secure the first domestic

silverware of the season. They gave us a beautiful final. A

beautiful football match. So I want to have these words for them. I feel

happy with our victory and very happy with the fact that I did it

four times, the same as the biggest one, the same as Mr Clough.

Harry Kane scored his third hat-trick in nine games as Tottenham

thrashed Stoke 4-0 at White Hart Lane.

All the goals came in the first half, with Delle Alli scoring

It's Kane's third hat-trick in nine games.

Spurs go second in the Premier League -

but they're still ten points behind Chelsea.

Ten points is a big gap to be behind. But we need to keep going. I

believe that is important. We need to put pressure on trade be there.

-- and try to be there. England made it seventeen wins

in a row after beating Italy 36- 15 in their Six Nations

match at Twickenham. England weren't at their best

and had to come from behind to claim the bonus point victory as Italy

led by five points at half time, but five second-half tries,

including this from Elliot Daly, ensured England top the Six Nations

table but coach Eddie Jones was critical of Italy's

unusual breakdown tactic. It was not rugby, let's face facts.

You must have an offside line to play the game. Italy was smart and

congratulations to their coaching staff and their players, they

executed their plan brilliantly but it was not brilliantly. If I were

the BBC I would be asking for my money back because we have no rugby

game. We need to go outside and train now so we get some proper

rugby. Wasps extended their lead at the top

of the English Premiership At the other end of the table,

Gavin Henson kicked all the points for bottom club Bristol as they beat

local rivals Bath 12-11. Bristol stay bottom,

two points behind Worcester, but it's a win that gives them

great hope of staying up. Meanwhile Opsreys are up

to second in the Pro 12. They came from behind to win

26-15 at home to Glasgow, Great Britain's Mark Cavendish has

won the green jersey at the Tour of Abu Dhabi, after finishing second

on an unusual final stage. After 27 laps around

the Yas Marina Grand Prix circuit in torrential rain, Cavendish

was beaten to the line by Australia's Caleb Ewan,

but he'd accumulated enough points Portugal's Rui Costa

won the overall race. That Eddie Jones clip there, I know

he is known for saying what he thinks but it is unusual for him to

have such a jab at the opposition. Obviously, I do not have the paper

with me, there is a brilliant bit in the paper, a brilliant photo of him

in the back of the times where they captured that moment where he is

watching the game unfold and you can see him thinking "What on earth?! "

That is it. What on earth is going on here. Can we see his face there.

Look at that eyebrow. He is trying to work out... It is reckless rugby

and he does not quite know how to respond to it. That is exactly what

the players were thinking as well. They did a good job at half-time to

get their heads together but he was really not happy. But, Italy, they

did not break the rules. Exactly. You can go change in the tournament,

can we? Certainly not at this point. If you are just waking up this

morning it really is a storyline worthy of an Oscar itself. Chaos at

the Academy Awards last night in the last few hours after the wrong film

was announced as best picture. In a moment we will speak to James Cook

but this is the moment that everyone will be talking about this morning.

Warrant 80 and Faye Dunaway are on stage to give out the final award of

the night, a big moment. Best picture. The actual winner was

Moonlight but this is what went wrong. La La Land.

I'm sorry. No. There has been a mistake. Moonlight, you won Best

picture. This is not a joke. This is not a joke. I am afraid they read

the wrong thing. This is not a joke. Moonlight has won best picture.

Moonlight. This picture. And there is a close-up just -- to prove. Just

to prove that Moonlight won, not La La Land. Quite extraordinary scenes.

There is only one place to go to talk about it, the after party at

Vanity Fair where I can imagine there is little talk of anything

else. Our correspondent is there for us. Extraordinarily awkward. Good

morning. Everything else... Yes, everything else. I mean, have you

ever seen anything like that? I don't think anyone in the room had

ever seen anything like that and they have been to a few of these

things over the years. That leaves many of the actors and actresses in

that room had been to many of these events and no-one can remember

seeing a moment like this. I must say, the producers of La La Land,

who were well into their speeches before it became apparent that they

had not in fact won the crowning prize of the night, they handled it

with considerable grace and class. They really weren't classy. They

handed over the Oscar, they went off the stage and... , you know, their

moment was over. They had had their moment, it is not as if anyone

watching would have suspected anything because it is hardly a

surprise. La La Land had been tipped to win Best picture. Sure people

were saying it was a tight race with Moonlight but La La Land was the

favourite. One of the stars here at the Vanity Fair awards, what do they

make of it? I spoke to Jon Voigt. You put it well. I had not thought

of that. If it had been me, I got halfway up the stairs and he says

excuse me, there was a mistake. Oh, my God. It would break me into.

Would you have kept going? No. But, you know... You can imagine the

emotions that wherein it. When La La Land was announced the kids, they

would have felt so much emotion and then it was taken away and given to

Moonlight. They did handle with class, didn't they? La La Land is a

wonderful team of people. I have known a few of them. They are to

refit people. As are all of these people. And Moonlight is a

spectacular piece. And so they get a little more attention but just

because of this. That is good. The John the making the age-old point

that all publicity is good publicity -- John Voigt. Everything very noisy

down there. Film critic James King is with us now. It is the takeaway

moment, this extraordinary thing when they announced the wrong film.

I have never seen anything like it. I have been watching the Oscars are

long time and I have never seen anything like this. It started at

1:30am UK time and I tweeted at 1:35am saying that Justin Timberlake

has opened the show and it will not get any better, this is the

highlight. Little did I know that there would be something that

everybody would be talking about. It is a standout moment but elsewhere

in the awards, La La Land was up for many. It won seven at one point, but

6.5! Was up to 14, a record number of nominations, and I don't think

anybody expected it to win everything because that is highly

unlikely. Emma Stone had won, they had won an award for cinematography,

and it looked like it would all be La La Land. Forgetting the mistake,

even if the envelope had been right from the start, and Moonlight had

won, that would have been a surprise because Moonlight was not expected

to win. Wonderful news for Moonlight, we spoke to the director

last week and they made it for $1.5 million. I can't even remember if it

was dollars or pounds, but a tiny Budget. Tiny Budget, no major stars,

small-scale, intimate drama, not the kind of thing you would think would

eat the bigger movies. It was a surprise anyway to see it win but

the way in which it won was obviously an even bigger surprise.

And Best Actor went to Casey Affleck for Manchester by the C, and we may

see him in some far more prominent roles. -- Sea. I don't think we as

film fans have entirely known what to do with Casey Affleck. He has

been in lots of different styles of movies, and perhaps hasn't found his

niche, but in Manchester By The Sea, another very serious drama, he has

shown he can do in tents and small very well. It is a small-scale,

subtle performance, up against Denzel Washington who is very weak

and loud in his movie. Casey Affleck is much more small-scale, and it is

great to see him win. Best Supporting Actor, Moonlight. It was

doing very well anyway, and really the night was already between La La

Land and moonlight. I am happy with either winning, but it depends if

you want song and dance and something frothy, or do you want a

more intimate drama? You can't really compare the two. In recent

years, Oscars So White has been a talking point. If this hadn't

happened at the very end we would be talking about diversity because of

the winners of the supporting actor roles. It certainly felt like a more

inclusive ceremony, aside from movies like Hidden Figures and lion,

and things like that, and how art can unite people. So the whole event

actually felt... I know we expected it to be quite angry and vitriolic

but it felt quite optimistic and hopeful, the whole ceremony. And

this wonderful peaceful handover of one Oscar... Maybe it works with the

mood of the night, about being kind to people and understanding one

another. That was the theme of the evening, so in a way, it kind of

works. Although Warren Beatty did throw Faye Dunaway under the bus a

little bit. I thought he was playing the time, a bit of dramatic or

comedy fracture, which was why they were not announcing it immediately,

but for him it didn't look right on the cards. He saw Emma Stone, La La

Land, the card for the previous award. Although Emma Stone says she

had that previous award. Maybe they were two cards, we don't know. Here

is the weather with Matt Taylor. Hold on a minute, it is Carol

Kirkwood! Thanks, Charlie. You will find a cold start for many parts,

except in the south, turning colder as we go through the day. We have

the combination of heavy showers and some will have hail and thunder and

snow embedded in them as well. The cold air filters further south as we

go through the course of the day. Really it is the far south of

England that hangs on to the milder conditions. For Scotland this

morning it is cold. We have the showers, some of them falling as

sleet and snow and a lot of dry weather, some sunshine. For Northern

Ireland, watch out for ice on untreated surfaces. There are

showers coming your way, if you don't already have them. For England

and Wales, frequent showers. Some of those heavy and thundery. There will

be some wintry mess, but the moors of south-west England as well, and

as we go through the day and the cold air cuts in, we will see more

snow showers heading further south. Watch out for ice on untreated

surfaces. Drying up through the course of the day across northern

Scotland. The peak of the winds across the Northern Isles and it

will be quite a blustery day wherever you are, more showers being

driven in on that wind through the day. In between, drier and brighter

spells but as is the way with showers, not all of us will see

them. More wintry sleet and snow coming out at lower levels but they

will be fairly sporadic. For southern Scotland and northern

England we will see more heavy snow across these areas. Again, even at

lower levels. Through the evening and overnight, the wind remains

strong in the south and also the north-west. There will be a lot of

dry weather, a greater risk of ice on untreated surfaces through the

course of the coming night and these temperatures you can see are

indicative of towns and cities. In rural areas they are more likely to

be in Scotland and Northern Ireland between -4 and -6, and in England

and Wales between -2 and freezing. Bear that in mind, a cold start to

the day. What will happen tomorrow is storm Ewan, named by the Irish

Met service on Saturday, is going to come back again. It will still be

windy around it and we will still see some wintry temperatures, quite

cold for some parts of the country but for many of us it is actually

going to be dry. Some rain across the southern counties and quite a

bit of sunshine, temperatures seven to about eight Celsius. As we move

from Tuesday into Wednesday, off goes the low pressure onto the near

continent. A region of high pressure builds in behind it and we have

another set of fronts coming our way so on Wednesday itself, a lot of dry

weather. One or two showers, except in the south where we have a band of

wintry weather coming. Sales of Fairtrade products rose

to ?1.6 billion last year, but could more of us be supporting

the charity's efforts? You may know, or buy already

products, with the Fairtrade mark. It has been going for

more than 20 years. Originally associated with things

like coffee and tea, the mark can be seen

on a whole range of products Products with the mark

are guaranteed to have been produced with internationally agreed

standards on things like pay Charles Chavi is a sugar

cane grower from Malawi. Tell us a bit about the poverty

in Malawi before Fairtrade. Talk me through the difference. What

is it like working with Fairtrade? What difference does it make for you

as a farmer, day-to-day? Fairtrade has the power to transform lives,

making a huge difference in the lives of families. We have done

quite a number of projects through Fairtrade, and these projects have

transformed the lives of our farmers and the communities. For example, we

brought electricity to the villagers. For Fairtrade, farmers

never had access to electricity but now most households have been

connected to electricity. We built a school, and over 900 children can go

to this school. Before this school was built, children had to walk a

distance of eight to ten kilometres to the nearest school. But because

of this school, children can attend school at a tender age. We have also

invested quite a lot in clean water, constructed many boars, we built

taps, we built a clinic, we have also invested part of the premium

back in the business, just to postproduction -- bores. And I think

we can see some pictures of the school built with the proceeds as

well. While we have a look at those let's talk about the farmers

themselves. Those are the ones who, by getting a fair price for their

products, with a bananas, or sugar, or those sorts of things, they make

a difference day to day to farmers. Like I said, before Fairtrade it

wasn't easy for farmers to provide for their families. They could not

be able to afford basic needs. But Fairtrade has enabled them to earn

more and as a result of that they are able to assist their families,

they are able to provide for their families. They are able to buy food,

school fees for their children, have access to electricity, at a minimum.

Talk me through how the process works. If somebody is buying with

this logo on it what does that mean to you day-to-day? It means you will

get a fair price for what you pay, but standards of production as well.

Sure, the Fairtrade mark in my opinion is a widely respected mark.

It guarantees the fact that a farmer receives a fair deal for what they

grow. What was life like before that? Before the Fairtrade mark on

your product, what did that mean? Farmers were not being paid fairly

for their product, but with Fairtrade, they do have more income.

They do have supplementary income as a result of Fairtrade. Before we

become Fairtrade accredited, it was so hard for a farmer, like I say, to

afford basic needs. It is good to talk to you, and thank you for

explaining that. Time is tight, but you are right, it proves what a

difference it makes. Thank you for joining us, and I will have more

after 7am about energy. Time now to get the news,

travel and weather where you are. Film critic Jason Solomons is

speaking to Vanessa Feltz about all that is happening at the Oscars in

LA. Hello, this is Breakfast,

with Dan Walker and Louise Minchin. Confusion at the Oscars

as the Best Picture award is handed La La Land was initially

named the winner. The producers started

their acceptance speeches. But they were interrupted

with an announcement that Moonlight Moonlight, you guys

won best picture. It appears that warrant 80 and Faye

Dunaway had been handed the wrong envelope in one of the most dramatic

plot twists in Oscars history. Good morning, it's

Monday 27th February. The Independent Inquiry

into Child Sexual Abuse finally holds its first public hearings

as it looks at the treatment of British children

who were sent to Australia. The number of us switching energy

suppliers has hit a six year high I'm looking at why it's still worth

shopping around for cheaper deals In sport, Manchester United beat

Southampton in the EFL Cup final. The 3-2 win saw Jose Mourinho become

the first United manager to win a trophy in his first

season with the club. Red and yellow, green and blue. Is

this rainbow of bins and box is the best way to get us campaigning? Is

it the best way -- to get as recycling.

Heavy showers with thunder and pale. It will be windy and feel colder.

More details on 15 minutes. The Oscars ceremony has ended

in confusion, after the wrong film In a dramatic and farcical ending,

La La Land was announced as the winner, before the award

eventually went to Moonlight. Let's cross to our Los Angeles

correspondent James Cook, who's at the Vanity Fair after-show

party which all the stars attend. There's only one topic they will

discuss tonight. What did happen? Yes. There is only one thing on the

minds of people as they arrived and that is the extraordinary plot

twisted the end of the night, the moment when the best picture was

awarded to the wrong film. It was dramatic and left people astonished.

To begin with a lot of people did not know whether it was a joke will

not be but it became clear quickly that it was not a joke. Let us look

at what happened. And the Academy Awards... For best

picture... Moonlight, you guys

won best picture. I am afraid they read

the wrong thing. Not a joke. Congratulations to

Moonlight and it was an extraordinary thing to happen. What

have people been saying about it? Up until that point it had been going

well if not brilliantly for Moonlight. They had won best

director, Emma Stone had won best actress. They won in some of the

below the line categories as well. It really was stunning and we will

hear a little later on about the reaction in detail from some of the

people involved. I'm just having a look around to see who is on the red

carpet at the moment. People are flooding in right now. I don't think

there is anyone right now we need to speak to. It was incredible. The

director of Moonlight, Barry Jenkins, said afterwards that he

thought that La La Land and the producers who were most of the way

through their speeches before this happened, that they handled the

situation with considerable grace. Mahershala Ali, who won best

supporting actor, the first Muslim, incidentally, to won and acting

category we believe that the Academy Awards has also been reacting. He

has been saying that La La Land has done so well and resonated with so

many people. When the name was read he was not surprised that he was

happy for them. And then he got worried when security came and said.

People are concerned in these tense times about what was happening. But

Mahershala Ali said that when he heard that they had won he did not

want to go up there and take something from somebody. He said it

was hard to take joy from a moment like that. I think that has probably

passed now for the cast and crew of Moonlight. I think they will be

enjoying their success now. We will be with you throughout the morning.

We will come back you a little later. A difficult gig, trying to

look both ways at the same time. But as mentioned there, the of Emma

Stone. And after she had been on stage, they came off and she spoke

about her own award because she won best actress for her role in La La

Land. She spoke about the mixup. Of course, you know,

it was an amazing thing to hear I think we would have loved

to have won best picture. It is one of the best films

of all time so I was beside myself. I was also holding

my Best Actress in a So I don't mean to start stuff

but whatever story that was... Well... As it developed, there is

more information coming out, there are apparently two cards, a producer

on either side of the stage and they have identical cards. What happened,

what they think happened anyway was that the previous award was given

out by Leonardo DiCaprio, came off one side of the stage and then

Warren Beatty and Faye Dunaway came on the other side of stage and

instead being handed the card for best picture they were handed a

duplicate card for best actress and that seems to be root of the

problem. It is does, every time you see it is still awkward. Any people

are talking about it. Jane Fonda describing it as a jawdropping

mistake. Jimmy Kimmel blamed it on Steve Harvey, a reference to Miss

universe a few years ago when he was the host and he wrongly gave the

wrong contestant the award of Miss universe and then had to correct

himself. Another actress has tweeted that she feels bad that for the La

La Land produces. Add a reference to Barry Jenkins. He tweeted a picture

of the card saying still speechless. We spoke to him last week on BBC

breakfast. And now his dream is coming true. We have more in Oscars

and what did happen and the late R. There is plenty of other news around

this morning as well. The independent inquiry into child

sexual abuse will hold its first public hearings today,

more than two and a half years after it was set up

by the government. It'll begin by examining

the mistreatment of British children who were in care or from poor

families, who were sent to Australia in the years after

the Second World War. The inquiry will be told

that the scale of abuse they suffered was much wider

than previously thought. Here's our home affairs

correspondent Tom Symonds. NEWSREEL: They arrive at Fremantle

from Great Britain with 931 That is what children

in care, or from poor But 70 years on some,

like Clifford Walsh, are still affected

by the beatings and His Catholic children's home,

Bindoon, near Perth in Australia For the next two weeks the televised

public enquiry will consider new evidence about the extent

of the abuse, claims that children were picked by paedophiles to travel

aboard and allegations We want to know what happened,

we want to know who did it and we want to know

who covered it up for so long. There were consequences

for children today. We also need to look at why it has

taken 30 years to bring about this enquiry into the horrific abuse

of hundreds, if not thousands The enquiry rejects suggestions

that it is reaching too Many of the migrants

are still alive. Getting to the bottom

of what happened to them We will speak to somebody in a few

minutes it was sent to Australia when he was 12 to ask his thoughts.

-- The BBC ordered an investigation into TV licence collectors

following reports that they're deliberately targeting vulnerable

The Daily Mail claims enforcement officers,

who are employed by the private company Capita, are ordered to catch

28 evaders every week and promised financial incentives

Head teachers and school governors are calling on the Chancellor

to make schools a priority in the budget.

The National Association of Head Teachers and the National

Association of Governors have written an open letter

to Philip Hammond to say that they're being forced to make

They have warned that lessons will need to be cut and class sizes

reduced. More than a third of small

businesses expect their rates to rise this April, according

to the Federation of Small The Federation says many face

unsustainable and unaffordable increases, and are planning to cut

the amount they invest The government has promised help

for those worst hit. In about ten minutes time will have

the latest from Los Angeles where the Oscars ceremonies ended in

confusion with the wrong film being given the award for best picture.

Moonlight eventually won La La Land for they had received their seventh

of the night. An extraordinary story. Painfully and wonderfully

awkward. One of those moments you will see for many years to come. It

is 12 minutes past seven and there is plenty of other news around as

well. In the years following thousands of British children

in care or from poor families were sent to start

new lives in Australia. Many went on to be beaten and abused

in homes or institutions. Their stories will be told today

at the first public hearings of the Independent Inquiry

into Child Sexual Abuse. One of those children was David Hill

and he's in our London newsroom. thank you for joining us. Can you

take us back, you were 12 when you were sent to Australia with two of

your brothers. And you are part of the decision. Tell us why you went.

We went because we, like most migrants, were extremely poor. Mum

was a single parent and struggling and there was no way she could keep

us at school and a society, one of the child migrant scams promised us

opportunity and education in Australia that we had no hope of

getting here. Persuaded us to sign up and that is how we went. I was 12

with a twin brother and a 14-year-old brother. We were luckier

than most child migrants because later my mother was able to follow

us out and we got back together as a family. We reunited as a family

where as most of these are the kids, some as young as four never saw

their parents again and spend an entire loveless childhood and they

were the ones who were the most, least protected, most vulnerable and

it turns out the most severely abused, sexually and physically. I

know you have been working on this for many years and you have been

speaking to others who have been abused. What kind of scale was it

on? What can you tell us? Well, that is the frightening part. As a result

of all of the interviews I have done with kids who went to Favourite with

me and others and other research that I have made available eye, for

this enquiry, has estimated that as high as 60% of the children were

sexually abused in the institution. Which is just a devastating fact

that you talk about. This happened from 1938 until 1974. Thousands of

parents effectively signing over their children. I must say,

incidentally, if you need to feel for the parents. My mother was a

case in point. You know, they were told that if you really love your

children you will make this great sacrifice for them and a lot of

parents in innocence and in good faith signed their children over to

these schemes which were widely flawed. There has been a landmark

settlement, hasn't there, against Fairbridge. You again were part of

that. What else do you think needs to be done? I think the case we won

after years of struggle in Sydney last year, what came with it, which

was so important and comforting for the kids, well, the former kids, was

an acknowledgement of the terrible wrong that had been done to them.

But frankly there is not... Yukonite unto the great wrong. You cannot

give back a childhood that has been crushed. -- you can't undo the great

wrong but you can have some recompense. I hope that will happen

far the Child migrants as a result of this enquiry. You will give

written evidence to this enquiry. What would you like to say? There

were a series of things but the abuse was far more widespread than

has been accepted today and the other thing of great significance is

that the authorities, including the British government, knew that these

schemes were flawed at the time and did nothing to correct it. In 2010

the Prime Minister apologised to children who had been shipped

overseas. Is that enough, in your view? Oh, no, there is much more.

The British government condemned and blacklisted a number of institutions

including Fairbridge and then, as a result of political pressure,

quietly tore up the blacklist and allowed hundreds more children to be

sent, including me, to institutions that they had condemned. It has been

kept secret and covered up for over 40 years. I am sure that this

enquiry is going to be very helpful in uncovering all of that. And that

is what you would like to see? Evidence that that happened? I want

to see the evidence out there and I have been research and, you point

out, for many years and I have given all that material to the enquiry

already. We appreciate your time. It is an incredible story. Let's find

out what is happening with the weather. Carol has it this morning.

It certainly has. This morning you will notice a cold start to the day

and generally colder feel which will puts -- push south through the day.

We are looking at heavy showers, a combination of rain, hail, sleet,

thunder, lightning and snow. Watch out for ice on untreated surfaces

and the callback their cuts in further south as we go through the

afternoon and into the evening time. This morning across Scotland it is a

mixture of bright spells, sunshine and showers, some of the showers

wintry with sleet and snow at low levels. The same for Northern

Ireland, a lot of dry weather but the showers are not far away and

there is the risk of ice across northern England. For England and

Wales we are looking at plentiful showers as we go through the course

of the day. Not all of us catching them, that is the nature of showers,

and this morning any wintry feel is going to be across high ground in

the south-west of England. Windy across the Northern Isles, so winds

are now peaking. This the remnants of storm Ewan, and gusty winds

across the South and south-east. As we go through the day, the showers

will be heavy, some with thunder and some with sleet and snow but a

period of heavy snow across south-eastern Scotland and northern

England. If you are travelling, they are all that in mind. As we head on

through the evening and overnight, gusty winds, particularly in the

south. Also north-west Scotland, in between a lot of dry weather. Where

we have showers and overnight temperatures dipping there is the

risk of ice, more widespread than the night just gone. Temperatures in

Scotland falling easily to between -4 and minus six. Then as we move

through tomorrow, this is what is left of storm Ewan. A weakening area

of low pressure, and you can see it is quite windy around its southern

flank and with the accompanying weather front we will see some rain

coming out of it and some snow, particularly across higher ground

across parts of England and Wales. A lot of dry weather to be had as

well. Wall am moving across the South taking showery rain as it

goes. For Tuesday into Wednesday, there goes that system moving away

into the south. You can see the isobars close together for a while,

meaning it will be windy for a while, and then they broaden out. We

are looking at a more settled day on Wednesday, a quieter day except in

the south, where we have a cluster of weather fronts rolling across us

bringing wet and windy weather. Temperatures between about eight and

10 Celsius. In summary, for the early part of the week is going to

feel cold. There will be some wintry showers around but as we head

towards the latter part of the week, the beginning of March, milder but

we will also see some rain. Thank you very much, pretty chilly for

some people. The weather has been the outstanding story of the last

few days, but move over, whether! It is the storyline worthy

of an Oscar itself. Chaos at the Academy Awards,

after the wrong film was announced This is the dramatic moment

at the end of the night where it There was a sort of activity behind

the stage, you are thinking what is going on? Carnage. They have

announced the wrong film. Warren Beatty and Faye Dunaway were on

stage and this is what happened. And the Academy award... For Best

Picture... Moonlight, you guys

won best picture. This is not a joke, I'm afraid

they read the wrong thing. That is Jordan Horovitz, one of the

producers, taking control on the stage.

There is only one place to go, the vanity Fair after-show party,

where we can talk to our Los Angeles correspondent James Cook.

Normally at this point in an Oscars ceremony we are talking about the

winners of all the awards and which film did particularly well, what the

British success was but at the moment there is only one story, and

it is unfortunately the awkward one. That's right. It was awkward, it was

a difficult moment. I think some people for a very brief moment were

concerned about the security when they saw people coming on from the

side of the stage and they wondered what was happening. In fact it is...

In fact, it was a moment when it turned out that it was just the

wrong announcement that had been made, that the wrong envelope had

been handed over. We have been getting plenty of reaction, we will

get more in a minute, but let's first of all hear from Jackie Chan.

It was great drama, great night, I think tomorrow all of the world will

talk about it. I think it is drama, good! It is a good thing? No one is

perfect. The whole world, everybody... It was a great night.

Thank you, chaps, thank you. Well, that was the reaction there from

Jackie Chan, standing alongside Chris Tucker. A few seconds ago we

heard from some -- Salma Hayek. I think it was fantastic. He got a

moment to shine, he was so gracious towards the other winner because

they are all winners, and it was a fantastic moment for him. I know you

are trying to grab people as they go past, so feel free to grab people as

they go by. What are the headlines from the evening? La La Land 16

Oscars from its nominations, but where else are the headlines? You

are right, I do need eyes in the back of my head -- La La Land won

six. The best supporting categories both went to black actors, Viyella

-- Viola Davies, and Mahershala Ali. Plenty more on that Oscars debacle

throughout the programme. If you've missed it, don't worry, we will play

at again. Trying to cover what has happened overnight while everyone is

shouting at you. Once upon a time when the idea of taking pictures on

your phone seemed laughable and social media wasn't a thing, the

Nokia 3310 ruled the world. When smartphones took over it fell out of

fashion but it is making a comeback and you can still play Snaked on it.

Barcelona, and as the mobile phone industry

arrives for its annual jamboree, there is nostalgia in the air.

Nokia, a name that used to rule the mobile world,

This was its first chance to make a big splash.

And, with a range of new smartphones, it unveiled

something very retro, last on sale in 2005.

You cannot do much with this phone except make calls and play a game

of Snake, but the battery lasts forever.

We asked consumers what is the most iconic device that you have ever

We thought, let us have some fun and be creative with this device.

This may be fun, but let us face it, it is a gimmick.

If Nokia wants to be a major force in the world again,

it will not be because of the 3310, but a new range of Android

This is already selling well in China.

But competition in a market where smartphones all look the same

So perhaps it was smart to look backwards as well as forward.

By bringing out this truly iconic device with bags of nostalgia,

for many people it was their first mobile phone.

It captures their attention, and let them know that Nokia is back.

Maybe with my parents' generation, but not something I'd

Here is another phone making a comeback.

This is the Blackberry 31, launched by a Chinese firm.

Two big names making an unlikely bet they could be big again

Rory Cellan-Jones, BBC News, Barcelona.

Hello, this is Breakfast with Dan Walker and Louise Minchin.

The Oscars ceremony has ended in confusion, after the wrong film

In a dramatic and farcical ending, La La Land was announced

as the winner, before the award eventually went to Moonlight.

Let's cross to our Los Angeles correspondent James Cook,

who's at the Vanity Fair after-show party.

And the Academy award... For best picture...

Moonlight, you guys won best picture.

I am afraid they read the wrong thing.

This is very unfortunate what happened.

Personally I blame Steve Harvey for this.

I would like to see you have an Oscar anyway.

I will be proud to hand this to my friends from

To explain what you are seeing there, Jimmy Kimmel was the hottest.

Jordan was the guy holding up the piece of paper that he took took

away from Warren Basey. It seems that they had been handed the wrong

envelope. There are two identical suitcases on either side of the

stage and the award before that was Emma Stone for La La Land for best

actress in a leading role. It seems that Warren Basey and Faye Dunaway

picked up an envelope, got the same envelope in duplicate. When he

opened it it's said Emma Stone, La La Land and you saw him make a face,

is this the right one? Presume your belly she just saw La La Land and

that is what she said. We cut it short. Two speeches had already been

made, thanking family members, what a great night it had been a leather

and then eventually someone took control. Moonlight came up on stage,

gave their speeches and it was spectacularly awkward. And

congratulations to Moonlight. We spoke to the director last week. We

will have more on that later. The independent inquiry into child

sexual abuse will hold its first public hearings today,

more than two and a half years after it was set up

by the government. It'll begin by examining

the mistreatment of British children in care or from poor families,

who were sent to Australia in the years after

the Second World War. The inquiry will be told

that the scale of abuse they suffered was much wider

than previously thought. Downing Street has dismissed

suggestions that Theresa May will announce that the end of free

movement for new EU migrants The Daily Telegraph is reporting

that the cut-off date could be the 15th of March, once

the Government's Article 50 Bill has Anyone arriving in the UK after that

point would no longer have the automatic right to stay

in the UK permanently. Downing Street has said that no

decision has been taken. More than a third of small

businesses expect their rates to rise this April, according

to the Federation of Small The Federation says many face

unsustainable and unaffordable increases, and are planning to cut

the amount they invest The government has promised help

for those worst hit. We have an Oscar winner now. James

Cook is with Colleen Atwood. Good morning. Good morning and thank you

very much. We have an Oscar winner, our first of the morning. Thank you

so much for joining us. You won your award for costume design. Please

show it to us. How does it feel to hold it? It feels great. There was a

total surprise to me but I am thrilled to be here and holding this

lovely statue. You won it for that the adaptation of the JK Rawling

novel, fantastic beasts and we do find them. I think this is the only

Oscar for anything adapted from JK Rawling. That is true. I was quite

shocked but that is the case. I'm happy to be the first hopefully the

first of many. What is it like, walking up the steps when your name

is called. What is it like? Because I am a behind the camera person it

is quite scary. You got up there, you got the award. Who presented it

to you? Um, I can't remember either. Ryan... Ryan Bathie. -- Murphy.

Anyway, you have it. It's fine. You are only live on BBC. Do not worry

about it. What did you think of the end of the show was to mark I was as

shocked as anybody else and I felt bad for everybody, the people up

there, to find that you don't have it after that moment of terror with

your heart in your throat. And I felt for the people who... You know,

I mean, it is just awkward. I think they handled it beautifully in both

cases. They were classy, won't they? Yes. Quite classy. It was a great

opportunity for a movie where people were tied to say thank you to

everyone and then for the next round it was awesome to see them up there,

hugging each other and it was great. And, finally, if there are any young

costume designers watching they will now look up to you for a long time.

What would you say to them? I would say to keep working hard, you know?

Do not be afraid to be yourself and don't be afraid of the magic. Thank

you so much and congratulations. Colleen Atwood has won an Oscar, as

you can see there in her hand, for fantastic beasts and where to find

them. We will try to find some other Oscar winners to speak to live on

the programme. In the end, La La Land won six. Do you think they will

put that on the advert? Won six but thought they won seven? Let's get

some cup winners on now. Good morning, everybody.

Jose Mourinho has become the first Manchester United manager to win

a trophy in his first season at the club after guiding his side

to a 3-2 win over Southampton in the EFL Cup.

Saints fans will consider their side to have been unlucky

as Manolo Gabbiadini saw a goal contentiously ruled out.

United then went two nil up through Zlatan Ibrahimovic and Jesse

Gabbiadini struck either side of the interval to bring

But Ibrahimovic snatched victory with just a few minutes left

to secure the first domestic silverware of the season.

So I want to have these words for them.

I feel happy with our victory and very

happy with the fact that I did it four times,

the same as the biggest one, the same as Mr Clough.

Harry Kane scored his third hat-trick in nine games as Tottenham

thrashed Stoke 4-0 at White Hart Lane.

All the goals came in the first half, with Delle Alli scoring

It's Kane's third hat-trick in nine games.

Spurs go second in the Premier League -

but they're still ten points behind Chelsea.

England made it seventeen wins in a row after beating Italy 36-

15 in their Six Nations match at Twickenham.

England weren't at their best and had to come from behind to claim

the bonus point victory as Italy led by five points at half time,

but five second-half tries, including this from Elliot Daly,

ensured England top the Six Nations table but coach Eddie Jones

was critical of Italy's unusual breakdown tactic.

You must have an offside line to play the game.

Italy was smart and congratulations to their coaching

staff and their players, they executed their plan brilliantly

If I were the BBC I would be asking for my

money back because we have no rugby game.

We need to go outside and train now so we get some proper

He was decidedly unhappy. The referee was expecting the tactic.

Italy had had a word with the referee prior to the game, a tactic

of Rockliff rugby. England, in the first half, did not know what to do

about it. Surely you do whatever you can to overcome your opponent. Yes,

and that is what Italy was doing. Whether that was in the spirit of

the game, I am uncertain. Switching energy suppliers

is at a six-year high according You would think that more people

would switch but the vast majority of people tend to stay with the same

provider. Yes we all know we should be

switching energy suppliers to get a better deal and according

to the latest figures more of us The energy regulator Ofgem has just

published its figures for consumer It says that customers

swapped their energy providers nearly eight million times last year

That's a rise of nearly three So customers are voting

with their feet. Three of the big six energy firms

have just announced price rises Rachel, good morning to you. The

question that I post there, doesn't make any difference? On one hand

these figures are great and it's just that more of us are voting with

our feet, taking ourselves elsewhere but does not stock prices going up.

I think, obviously, this is a very good news story and we are seeing

things move in the right direction in terms of putting pressure on

suppliers. But you are right. We see intense competition for people who

switch regularly. With good prices in the market. We see much less that

two thirds of loyal customers who stay with their supplier. What we're

hoping is that the more switching that there is, the more that that

pressure is felt including for the standard variable tariffs that are

at 65% of people are paying. The vast majority of people are still on

the standard variable tariffs. They tend to be the most expensive and

therefore it penalises people for apathy. If you stick with the status

quo, you pay the price for doing so. Even if you do not want to change

supplier you can usually find a better deal with your current

supplier is you are on a standard variable tariffs. I would encourage

customers in that situation to look at their bills which will include

information about how much they could save from switching to a

better deal, even with their own supplier. But, you know, switching

between suppliers is far easier and faster than it has ever been. Most

switches between suppliers are taken around 21 days and that includes two

weeks cooling off period if you want to change your mind. So the message

it really is, you know, get online, have a look for good deals and vote

with your feet. You say it has never been easier for customers to do this

but if it was so easy I think we would see the figures for the number

of switches rise even more because as you said, the vast majority are

still on the most expensive tariff. We just don't think it is worth the

hassle to move. And then if we do move there is nothing to stop the

provider putting up the prices that was just move to. Most of the good

deals on the market are fixed deals. So not only are you switching to a

lower price but you are also switching to a price guarantee for

12 months or in some cases even further. So there is a really strong

incentive to shop around and, in oh, we will continue to do everything we

can to make the switching process smooth and reliable and we will

continue to do everything we can to give people the information they

need to make a good choice about their energy provider. And making a

good choices about making compensation work in the market.

People will move in that means that the business should, in theory

react. But is it not your job, as a regulator, to make competition were,

not just rely on consumers do the hard work was to mark as I said, we

are working hard to make it as easy as possible to shop around. We are

making it as easy as possible as well for new suppliers to come in

with good offers and innovative offers that are attracting

consumers. We have, also, recently announced a price cap for the 4

million households that are on prepaid meters and are not getting

access to good deals in the market. There is protection available there

for those who are thusly served and in the meantime many people should

be shopping around and voting with their feet if they are unhappy with

the price they are paying. It is good to talk to you. So you have

heard the advice, shop around if you are unhappy. Have you guys switched

it? My wife mentioned it, yesterday. Why haven't we switched yet? Glad

she listens to what we talk about in the studios. I also listen to Carol,

who has very interesting details about the weather. Thank you, good

morning. We're looking at a cold start to the day for many of us and

heavy not just this morning but through the course of the day. Some

of those will be thundery, with hail, and some will have some heat

pants no embedded in them. It is very windy across the Northern

Isles, but this will move away. This is X storm Ewan. And if you look at

the isobars, here through the course of the day it is going to be very

lonely. Ahonen all dollar that we are pulling in cold air, so

increasingly we have got wintry showers in Scotland and Northern

Ireland, but as the cold air cut them across parts of England and

Wales, we'll see some wintry showers but not everyone will see them as we

have through the course of the afternoon. This morning we have the

risk of ice first thing on untreated surfaces. There is quite a bit of

dry weather in between the showers, we are looking at some sunshine, but

wintry flavour across Scotland and Northern Ireland. It will dry and

brighten up in Scotland. For England and Wales we are looking a lot of

showers increasingly turning wintry. The North of Scotland will brighten

up this afternoon, the south, south-east and northern England we

are looking at a spell of heavy snow. For Northern Ireland,

sunshine, bright spells and showers for you and for Wales and south-west

England we are likely to see some wintry conditions this afternoon,

even at lower levels, but it shouldn't be problematic. For the

rest of England and Wales we are looking at rain showers, some of

those heavy and thundery with some hail. Through the evening and

overnight we hang on to some of those wintry showers. Still windy in

the south and north-west but there will be a lot of dry weather and

where we have damp surfaces and low temperatures there is the risk of

ice. More widespread than this morning. We are looking at

temperatures in rural areas in Scotland down as low as possibly -4

minus six. Similar in Northern Ireland, England and Wales -2 to

around about freezing. A cold start to the day on Wednesday morning.

There goes our first front in the next lot coming in, this is storm

Ewan. Still quite windy around its south-western flank and as it comes

in the showers will be driven in by that wind. A lot of them will be

rain showers but there will be some wintry conditions on higher ground.

We also have another system scooting across the south of England,

bringing some wet and windy conditions, but in between dry and

bright, our temperature range between six and about nine. Thank

you very much, see you later. If you are waking up this morning, the big

story is the Oscars and you would expect us to be talking about

diversity and the winners, but the big moment is right at the end. The

final moment of the night, Best Picture, La La Land was expected to

win, but Moonlight was also in contention. Warren Beatty looked

deeply confused and in the middle of it thought it looked so confusing

that he decided to put Faye Dunaway under the bus.

Moonlight, you guys won best picture.

This is not a joke, I'm afraid they read the wrong thing.

I believe I should keep it anyway! They made three acceptance speeches,

the producers of La La Land, and he very graciously tries to put it all

straight, and he does. Moonlight was the winner. And we will have more

after eight a.m.. Grey bins, green bins,

blue boxes, and red boxes. If you are confused about where

to put your recycling, Keep Britain Tidy claims that

complicated bin collections are putting us off from

sorting our rubbish. And, as a result recycling

targets are being missed, Bin collections in England are so

desperate and complicated they are being blamed for a drop in recycling

rates. Keep Britain Tidy said there are more than 300 different systems

for collecting household waste and people are confused about what they

can and cannot recycle. The pressure group on the government to impose a

blueprint for recycling to make the situation simpler for householders.

It is very difficult to actually have a national conversation about

what we should recycle and what should be recycled and everybody is

doing something different. Every local authority in the UK has been

given the target of recycling 50% of its waste by 2020 to meet EU

guidelines, but the figures obtained by BBC Inside Out North-west found

some councils are recycling as little as 15% of their waste. London

boroughs are amongst the worst offenders, with none of the councils

in the capital currently hitting the 50% mark they will have to reach

within the next few years. Keep Britain Tidy believes we can learn

from Wales, which has a 60% recycling rate. The devolved

government has set ambitious targets, and every household has

food waste collected. That is incredibly important as we waste 7

million tons of food in the UK every year.

Richard McIlwain from the campaign group Keep Britain Tidy

Good morning to you. So so many different systems. Shall we talk

about what is going right? We mentioned that Wales seemed to be

really mailing list. How is that different? First of all, Wales have

set a target of 7% by 2025, an ambitious target when England is

currently recycling 40%. Each of the authorities will work to deliver

greater consistency in the way they collect the waste, which ultimately

could be having the same coloured bins, and also the Welsh government

support local authorities with funding where they have hard to

reach areas with low recycling rates. So it is a complete package,

and that is what we are looking at now, saying are voluntary measures

enough or do we need to look at places like Wales and learn from

what they are doing? We are getting better, you go back to 2002 and we

were recycling 10% of household waste, a lot better than what we

were. Yes, local authorities have done a great job, we have increased

from 10% to 44% over the last few years. Over the last four to five

years it has flat lined, so we have struggled to get above that. We are

looking at another step change and part of that is to say let's have a

much more consistent service. We do an awful lot of work with people on

the doorstep, to talk to people about the issues around recycling.

We know that people find it confusing. If we could have a once

only national message about what you recycle, the same waste types,

consistent services, the same coloured bins, it would be very much

easier and overall it would save money. Richard in Leicester makes

the point that the house next door can't recycle what they can, why

isn't there a single country-wide system? Vera says we can't recycle

yoghurt pots or some things like that, so there are so many different

things going on and changes being made. Exactly, and if you want

people to do the right thing, make it easy for them, that is the

classic mantra in policy-making. We are saying let's try to unpick what

has been a very effective system up until now and take a step back and

say what do we need to do next? We would welcome a conversation with

government and local authorities and business. There is already work

going on and a blueprint in England, we just need to see some pace behind

it and some targeting. If we set ourselves timescales for 2025 to

2030, it gives everybody confidence that we can move towards them. Loads

of people getting in contact on that one.

The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs insisted some

councils had excellent recycling rates, but admitted more could be

Viewers in the north-west of England can see more on this story

on Inside Out tonight on BBC One at 7:30pm.

If you are in another part of the country,

it will be available on the BBC iPlayer.

And bins in Liverpool are purple because they cannot be blue and red,

so they combine them and make them purple.

Smoking bans on hospital grounds and travel and weather where you are.

Smoking bans on hospital grounds and the Oscars is all being discussed by

Vanessa Feltz in the next half-hour. For

This is Breakfast, with Dan Walker and Louise Minchin.

Confusion at the Oscars as the best picture award is handed

La La Land was initially named the winner.

The producers started their acceptance speeches.

But they were interrupted with an announcement that Moonlight

It was one of the most dramatic plot twists in the history of the Academy

Awards and we will be getting lots of reaction throughout the

programme. Also this morning: the independent

inquiry into child sexual abuse finally holds its first public

hearings as it looks at the treatment of British children

who were sent to Australia. The number of us switching energy

suppliers has hit a six year high I'm looking at why it's still worth

shopping around for cheaper deals In sport Manchester United beat

Southampton in the EFL Cup final. The 3-2 win saw Jose Mourinho become

the first United manager to win a trophy in his first season

with the club. Good morning. It is a cold day today

but one of bright spells, sunshine and showers. Some of the showers

will be heavy and boundary with pale, but some of them will also be

wintery. -- heavy and thundery with hailstones.

The Oscars ceremony has ended in farce after the wrong film

It doesn't matter how many times you see this clip, it gets more awkward

every time! The team behind La La Land had

begun their acceptance speeches when they were interrupted

by a producer who said the award Let's cross to our Los Angeles

correspondent James Cook, who's I imagine that is top of everything

they are disgusting. How did it happen and do we even know yet? Good

morning. Good morning. The stars are pouring in here. We have just seen

Elton John, Matt Damon and Scarlet Johannson. Loads of stars pouring in

here and not many willing to talk about that moment. What we think

happened is that the wrong envelope was handed to Faye Dunaway and

Warren Beatty, and the envelope contained the winning name of Emma

Stone, who had just won best actress for La La Land, and that was read

out. And that is why the producers of La La Land came up onto the stage

to accept the award. A brief moment of glory for this dazzling musical.

Escapism personified here in Hollywood. But in fact it was a much

more serious work, Moonlight, which actually won the Oscar. Dave Willis

reports. Warren Beatty was about to announce

the award for best picture but he seemed confused. Best picture... In

the end Faye Dunaway made the announcement. La La Land! And the

producers were midway through the acceptance speeches when in came the

man in the headphones frantically trying to clear the stage. It turned

out that La La Land had not won the Oscar after all and it belonged

instead to the producers of Moonlight, the low budget underdog.

This is not a joke. Moonlight has won best picture. Moonlight.

Moonlight, best picture. La La Land producer Jordan Horowitz gallantly

handed the Oscar over as the audience looked on aghast. It was

left to an embarrassed Warren Beatty to try and explain the producers'

mistake. I will tell you what happened. I opened the envelope and

it said Emma Stone, La La Land. That is why I took such a long look at

Faye and at you. I wasn't trying to be funny. Moonlight, the drama of a

gay black man growing up in Miami was dwarfed by La La Land in terms

of nominations but it ended triumphant in the most extraordinary

of circumstances. Even in my dreams this could not be true but too well

with dreams. I'm done with it because this is true. Oh, my

goodness. Academy award organisers are still trying to work out exactly

what went wrong on a night like no other at the Oscars. I blame myself

for this. David Willetts, BBC News, Hollywood. A night like no other.

You can say that again. I am joined now by Davis. Good morning. It is

strange to say that because you are just starting to party. What on

earth did you make of the end of that? I simply... I don't know what

happened. What is so weird, Jimmy Kimmel had been roasting Matt Damon