19/05/2016 Outside Source

Hello, I'm Ros Atkins, this is Outside Source.

Just one top story in the Newsroom today.

An EgyptAir flight has crashed into the mediterranean sea.

It was travelling from Paris to Cairo with 66 people on board -

We now have a situation where we have reports that the plane swerved

abruptly just before going missing and conflicting accounts of whether

the wreckage has been found. Another big story we'll bring you up

to date on is a major report Superbugs will develop and an

extraordinary way over the next few decades unless we change the way we

consume antibiotics. And in 15 minutes we bring you outside source

sport. Muirfield golf club has inexplicably decided to remain a men

only club and Roger Federer will not be at the French Open.

If you are just joining us let's reiterate this extraordinary

situation where we had and where we have two accounts of the wreckage

that has been picked up and they contradict each other.

Three hours ago Egypt Air released this statement.

The Egyptian Ministry of Civil Aviation has just

received an official letter from the Egyptian Ministry

of Foreign Affairs that confirms the finding of wreckage

of the missing aircraft MS 804 near Karpathos Island.

Most people were assuming that the plane had been located but then this

came through. The association press quoted.

A Senior Greek air safety official says debris found so far

in Mediterranean does not belong to an aircraft.

Those accounts are not compatible. It is difficult to tell you which of

these is all I can do is pass them both on. What I can do is bring you

an account of the day's events from the perspective of Cairo.

Let me play you Quentin Sommerville's latest

Their loved ones left Paris on a flight before midnight.

They woke to the reality that they were gone,

66 people, including crew, took the flight to Cairo.

The passengers were mostly French and Egyptian,

It has just been confirmed he was Richard Osman,

a mining company executive, who had worked in

Here, radar tracks the aircraft, its red tail speeding

across the Mediterranean, until suddenly, it disappears.

Was this a terror attack or mechanical failure?

France's president says that nothing should be ruled out.

TRANSLATION: We also have the duty to know everything about the causes

No hypothesis should be ruled out, or preferred.

In Cairo, relatives gathered at the airport.

Families have been arriving here all morning, desperate to find

out any information they can what happened to the flight.

The flight was just 20 minutes from landing

here at Cairo International Airport, when, according to authorities,

it simply vanished, without any warning or distress call.

This woman explains, "My daughter was a stewardess,

Another says, "We are worried and we are afraid and we are hearing

different things mean the net which we do not know

Egypt's aviation minister was called on for answers, but

Do you have any security concerns about anyone on the aeroplane,

passengers, crew members, whether they were on the flight

Nothing has been reported about that.

We have no security concerns about a specific person.

Don't forget, the investigation is still going on.

I'm pretty sure that there is a profiling process

The concerned security divisions will be taking

Shortly afterwards, a ship's captain posted this picture -

a yellow life jacket and part of an airline seat floating

In Egypt this evening, families continue to wait for news,

burdened by the knowledge that officials here think this was more

likely a terror attack then an accident.

One detail I want to remind you of and this has been highlighted

online, there are talks on the Greek defence minister that people saw

this plane swerving and dropping quickly rather than a sudden

break-up. Richard on the programme earlier insisted we mustn't read too

much into that, it could be explained by a number of different

things so we shouldn't assume it means there was a fight going on in

the cockpit on a technical problem. Most of the main scenarios being

that that could in some way manifest themselves like that and be picked

up by a radar which is recording the information for us to look at. That

is being widely reported and I am not saying it is not connect but we

must treat it with caution. Investigators must collect a lot of

information to understand what has happened. Here is the report on

exactly what they will be looking for.

As more victims' families Headford Cairo the question remains was less

an accident or something more sinister? What do we know so far?

The aircraft was and A320 and if you have ever flown the chances are it

was on one of these. It is one of the most common planes on earth and

has an excellent safety record. This is footage of the actual aircraft

that disappeared filmed last year. It was delivered in November 2000

three. We also know the captain and co-pilot were relatively well

experienced. Let's have a look at what the radar tells us about the

flight itself? Having taken from Paris in the late evening everything

was normal for more than three hours. Greek controllers say the

pilot was in good spirits when they spoke to him. Half an hour later

repeated radio calls go unanswered. Controllers raised the alarm that

the plane simply dropped off the radar. It's made a 90 degrees turn

to the left and the 360 degrees turn to the right descending from 37 to

15,000 feet then the picture was lost. This is why terrorism cannot

be ruled out. A Russian airliner full of tourists was brought down

over the jet last year. It is widely believed a group linked to so-called

Islamic state smuggled a bomb on board. The vote to target Egypt and

Westerners who visit. This is the room at Cranfield University we have

an accident investigators from all over the world have trained. Experts

say there will be early clues but not necessarily answers. Generally

within a few hours we start to get a picture of what may have a card but

the detail will take many months and sometimes even years to fully

understand what might have happened and where the lessons may be. So it

is an anxious wait for the families and for all flyers like these people

off to Cairo today. Before I bring you a couple of other

main stories I should say if you go online on BBC News there is

extensive coverage of this plane crash available for you.

This is the latest major report on antibiotics -

You can find it online if you would like to read it in full. It's all

about our consumption of antibiotics.

Its warnings are of the utmost seriousness.

It says one person will die every three seconds from superbug

infections by 2050 unless urgent action is taken.

And it calls for billions of dollars to be invested

The person who led the report, Jim O'Neil says, "We've all got

to change how we are behaving, all seven billion of us."

Here's our Medical Correspondent, Fergus Walsh.

Learning about bugs doesn't need to be dull. These children are finding

out how to stop the spread of infections and about the importance

of I antibiotics. Viruses cannot be cured but bacteria can. If you take

too many you will become under have aortic resistance. You should only

use antibiotics if it is necessary. In the two years this review has

taken it is estimated 1 million people worldwide have died from drug

resistant infections but the team believes this could rise to 10

million a year, more than die from cancer, unless action is taken. It

is crucial we stopped eating and of the ticks like sweets and we can

only do that by informing people, whether it is young people in

schools here, people in India that don't go to school, sophisticated

and educated people, all of us. One of our recommendations as to tackle

that head-on with an awareness campaign. From the tiniest newborns

to the elderly, antibiotics are used to underpin nearly every aspect of

modern medicine but there has been no completely new class of these

precious drugs in decades. New antibiotics are desperately

needed so the report recommends a levy on the pharmaceutical industry

to pay for an investment. In return, there would be huge financial

rewards for companies that came up with new drugs. Superbugs pose a

global threat sort will require a coordinated, international response

if we are to ensure that every ticks are for future generations of

patients. In yesterday's programme our top

story was the rescue of this girl - Today, Nigeria's President

Muhammadu Buhari met her. It's a hugely significant moment

for Nigeria this is the first of that huge group kidnapped

by Boko Haram Islamists It is a hugely significant moment

for Nigeria, the first girl to be rescued of that huge grip kidnapped

by Boko Haram. Good news but the situation

remains grave. The meeting with the president shows

how significant the rescue of this teenager is. It is a national issue.

It was two years ago when she and her classmates were taken away by

Boko Haram. It will be important for the military and other security

agencies to get as much information as they can out of horror, where she

and the other girls were kept, the manner in which the captors operated

and more. The army is holding suspected Boko Haram member who is

said to be her husband but overall this news will be welcomed not just

by her family but by the families of other girls and others around the

world hope the remaining girls are still alive and can be brought home.

Let's also not forget that Boko Haram has abducted and possibly

still holds many more people. That is a tool it has used in its violent

campaign in attempting to destabilise the nation, so the

government still has so much more work to do at this moment. We are

going to look at a couple of sports stories and a moment including the

end of an incredible streak for Roger Federer, he would be at the

French Open, the first time he has missed a grand slam for the very

long time. The inquest into the death

of Nick Alexander, the only British victim of the Paris terror attacks

in November, has heard how his Today a coroner ruled

the 35-year-old from Colchester was unlawfully killed

at the Bataclan theatre. 130 people were killed

in a series of attacks in the French capital last year -

89 of them at the concert venue. Nick Alexander was selling

merchandise for the rock band Eagles of Death Metal who were performing

at the Bataclan. The gunmen burst in and fired that the concertgoers. By

the time police took control 89 including Nick Alexander were dead.

His former girlfriend who was by his side survived. Helen Wilson's

harrowing account was read out. Both were playing dead when a gunmen shot

at them. I tried to protect his body. I could feel a burning

sensation around my legs and I could feel the blood. I thought I was

going to die. Next said he had been shot in the stomach and told me it

was hard to believe so I told him to squeeze my hand and was telling him

to stay with me. But as she gave her mouth to mouth resuscitation he died

in her arms. He was, she said, the love of my life. Today the coroner

said the family had shown the utmost dignity. He lost his life and an act

of terror at the Bataclan. He was a much loved family member and friend,

a strong and generous man who lived his life to the pool. We were

blessed to have him in our lives and we are apart beyond measure. From

the continent to Colchester, people held vigils for Nick Alexander and

all those who died in the attacks. The Bantu performed at the Bataclan

knew him well and were devastated. Stayed quiet and never called for

help. He didn't want anyone else to get hurt. There are plans to set up

a charitable trust in his name, a man described as everyone's best

friend. We live the BBC newsroom under a

lead story all day has been the missing EgyptAir flight. Conflicting

reports about the wreckage found. It was said the wreckage belonged to

the plane but some officials are saying that is not the case.

It has a report on domestic violence against women in Mexico.

Six women die a violent death there every day.

And the News at Ten in the UK will report on the recall of nearly

a quarter of a million Vauxhall Zafiras for a second time.

It's because of a problem that has caused some to catch fire.

A couple of important sports stories.

Quite a vote at Muirfield which is one of Scotland's

It also has a ban on women members - today it had the chance to vote

that kind of out of date nonsense into history.

Not enough members voted for change, so women are still not allowed.

It will not be considered as a host course for The Open

Muirfield, prestigious and steeped in tradition and today courting

controversy after its members voted against allowing women to join. We

have been through a thorough process with a very high turnout so I think

we must respect the result of the ballot. It doesn't look good, does

it? That is for others to judge. It is what it is. The East Lothian club

has hosted the open on 16 occasions. Through the years, some of the most

famous names in golf have competed here and one but not any longer

after it was said it would not be staged at a venue that does not

admit women as members. It is indefensible. Muirfield is a private

club in charge of its own rules and regulations and I accept that but

this is 2016. Scotland has female leaders in every walk of life,

politics and business and everywhere else, and I think the decision is

wrong. Others agree including these women golfers that other courses

along the Gulf Coast. I wonder whether there is any logical reason

and I am quite surprised that can happen in Europe. I think it is

absolutely terrible and 2016, to be honest. The views of those on the

green at Muirfield are more mixed. If that's what the members decided

to vote I think it should be respected. I know a lot of women

will be disappointed but the members have chosen. Women will still be

admitted to Muirfield as visitors but the vote to continue excluding

them as members may prove costly to the reputation of this

world-renowned club. Tennis's French Open

starts on Sunday. This is quite a story, he has not

missed a grand slam for a very long time.

On his website he said, I have been making steady progress

with my overall fitness, but I am still not 100% and feel

I might be taking an unnecessary risk by playing in this event before

Last time Federer didn't play a Slam there were over a billion fewer

people in the world and MySpace had just launched.

Let's bring in John Watson from the BBC sports Centre. When was it,

1999? That's right, 1989 was the last time Roger Federer mistake

grand slam tennis tournament. An incredible run of 65 consecutive

grand slams. Incredible and a huge disappointment he will not be

playing at the French Open for tennis fans around the world not

least because he is the world number three. He is one of the greatest

tennis players ever to grace the game and to see that his run of

grand slams is coming to an end is a real shame. 1999 was the last time

he failed to reach the tournament proper when he went out on

qualifying, but as we know he has been struggling with injuries and

had surgery on his knee, the first time in his career, early this year.

Rather unfortunate, injuring his knee while running a bath for his

daughters. He also ruled out of the Rome Masters Eire where this month

having problems with his back, and ongoing fitness problem, and that

will keep him out of the French Open, but for any tennis fans

wondering is this the end of Roger Federer? Write him off at your peril

because the statement that read up on his Facebook said, ID mane

motivated and excited as ever and my plan is to achieve the highest level

of fitness before returning for the upcoming grass court season. We know

he loves Wimbledon and has won seven times before. I am sorry to my fans

in Paris but I look forward to returning in 2017. He is certainly

not planning to retire at any time soon and as we know, very good at

Wimbledon, he won seven times and reached the final the last two

years, but we hope and suspect he will be back for Wimbledon. We wish

him a speedy recovery. A memorial service has been held

in London for Sir Nicholas Winton who rescued hundreds of children

from the Holocaust in the months He did so by organising

the 'Kindertransport' - in which more than 600,

mostly Jewish, children came to Britain by train

from Czechoslovakia in 1939. A mother kisses her child

goodbye, knowing she may Prague station, early 1939,

and young boys and girls head to Britain, to avoid the Nazi

invasion of Czechoslovakia and the subsequent persecution of Jewish

and other minority communities. Today, those children now

elderly men and women, gathered to celebrate the life

of the man who gave them a future. Sir Nicholas Winton was 28,

a young stockbroker in London when he organised trains to take

Jewish children to safety His Kindertransport operation saved

669 children, but for many years he harboured an overriding regret

that he couldn't have rescued more. He kept quiet about what he had

done, until his wife Back here, you will see is the list

of all the children. Finally in 1988, Esther Rantzen

publicised what he did on her TV I should tell you you are sitting

next to Sir Nicholas Winton. Is there anyone in our audience

tonight who owes their life to him? Anyone who owes their life,

would you stand up please? 28 years later, it's estimated

between five and 7000 people do. One of them is this man who still

remembers the train journey. He went on to become

a Spitfire pilot. I owe everything to him and so does

the rest of the family Without him, I wouldn't have been

in the air force, I wouldn't Today, they remembered a modest hero

and celebrated a life that was proof one individual can make

an incredible difference. This and the report ends this

edition of outside source, thank you and see you next week.

Much of me so far has been very changeable in terms of fluctuating

temperatures, some heavy rain and dry weather and the story continues

to end the week. We will see outbreaks of rain heading in from