17/09/2013 Newsnight


17/09/2013

Kirsty Wark is on the England-Scotland border with an audience of Scots to debate the independence referendum.


Similar Content

Browse content similar to 17/09/2013. Check below for episodes and series from the same categories and more!

Transcript


LineFromTo

here at the historic European train bridge

0:00:140:00:14

here at the historic European train bridge over

0:00:140:00:14

here at the historic European train bridge over the

0:00:140:00:15

here at the historic European train bridge over the River

0:00:150:00:15

here at the historic European train bridge over the River Tweed,

0:00:150:00:15

here at the historic European train bridge over the River Tweed, one

0:00:150:00:16

here at the historic European train bridge over the River Tweed, one of

0:00:160:00:16

bridge over the River Tweed, one of the

0:00:160:00:16

bridge over the River Tweed, one of the most

0:00:160:00:17

bridge over the River Tweed, one of the most powerful

0:00:170:00:17

bridge over the River Tweed, one of the most powerful symbols

0:00:170:00:17

bridge over the River Tweed, one of the most powerful symbols of

0:00:170:00:18

bridge over the River Tweed, one of the most powerful symbols of the

0:00:180:00:18

the most powerful symbols of the connection

0:00:180:00:18

the most powerful symbols of the connection between

0:00:180:00:18

the most powerful symbols of the connection between Scotland

0:00:180:00:19

the most powerful symbols of the connection between Scotland and

0:00:190:00:19

connection between Scotland and England.

0:00:190:00:19

connection between Scotland and England. Just

0:00:190:00:20

connection between Scotland and England. Just one

0:00:200:00:20

connection between Scotland and England. Just one year

0:00:200:00:20

connection between Scotland and England. Just one year from

0:00:200:00:21

England. Just one year from now this

0:00:210:00:21

England. Just one year from now this could

0:00:210:00:21

England. Just one year from now this could be

0:00:210:00:22

England. Just one year from now this could be an

0:00:220:00:22

England. Just one year from now this could be an international

0:00:220:00:22

this could be an international border.

0:00:220:00:23

this could be an international border. Tonight

0:00:230:00:23

this could be an international border. Tonight we're

0:00:230:00:24

this could be an international border. Tonight we're asking

0:00:240:00:24

this could be an international border. Tonight we're asking an

0:00:240:00:25

border. Tonight we're asking an audience

0:00:250:00:25

border. Tonight we're asking an audience of

0:00:250:00:26

border. Tonight we're asking an audience of undecided

0:00:260:00:26

border. Tonight we're asking an audience of undecided Scots

0:00:260:00:26

border. Tonight we're asking an audience of undecided Scots should

0:00:260:00:26

audience of undecided Scots should it

0:00:260:00:27

audience of undecided Scots should it be?

0:00:270:00:34

Good

0:00:370:00:37

Good evening,

0:00:370:00:37

Good evening, live

0:00:370:00:38

Good evening, live from

0:00:380:00:38

Good evening, live from the

0:00:380:00:39

Good evening, live from the River

0:00:390:00:39

Good evening, live from the River Tweed,

0:00:390:00:40

Good evening, live from the River Tweed, on

0:00:400:00:41

Good evening, live from the River Tweed, on the

0:00:410:00:41

Good evening, live from the River Tweed, on the great

0:00:410:00:42

Good evening, live from the River Tweed, on the great stone

0:00:420:00:42

Good evening, live from the River Tweed, on the great stone towers

0:00:420:00:42

Tweed, on the great stone towers that

0:00:420:00:42

Tweed, on the great stone towers that stand

0:00:420:00:43

Tweed, on the great stone towers that stand at

0:00:430:00:43

Tweed, on the great stone towers that stand at either

0:00:430:00:43

Tweed, on the great stone towers that stand at either edge

0:00:430:00:43

Tweed, on the great stone towers that stand at either edge of

0:00:430:00:44

Tweed, on the great stone towers that stand at either edge of the

0:00:440:00:44

that stand at either edge of the bridge,

0:00:440:00:45

that stand at either edge of the bridge, there

0:00:450:00:45

that stand at either edge of the bridge, there is

0:00:450:00:46

that stand at either edge of the bridge, there is a

0:00:460:00:46

that stand at either edge of the bridge, there is a Latin

0:00:460:00:47

that stand at either edge of the bridge, there is a Latin motto

0:00:470:00:47

that stand at either edge of the bridge, there is a Latin motto that

0:00:470:00:47

bridge, there is a Latin motto that means

0:00:470:00:48

bridge, there is a Latin motto that means "roughly

0:00:480:00:48

bridge, there is a Latin motto that means "roughly united

0:00:480:00:48

bridge, there is a Latin motto that means "roughly united we

0:00:480:00:49

bridge, there is a Latin motto that means "roughly united we are

0:00:490:00:49

means "roughly united we are stronger".

0:00:490:00:50

means "roughly united we are stronger". It

0:00:500:00:50

means "roughly united we are stronger". It was

0:00:500:00:50

means "roughly united we are stronger". It was put

0:00:500:00:50

means "roughly united we are stronger". It was put there

0:00:500:00:51

means "roughly united we are stronger". It was put there in

0:00:510:00:51

means "roughly united we are stronger". It was put there in 1820.

0:00:510:00:51

stronger". It was put there in 1820. But

0:00:510:00:52

stronger". It was put there in 1820. But one

0:00:520:00:52

stronger". It was put there in 1820. But one year

0:00:520:00:52

stronger". It was put there in 1820. But one year from

0:00:520:00:52

stronger". It was put there in 1820. But one year from now

0:00:520:00:53

stronger". It was put there in 1820. But one year from now will

0:00:530:00:53

stronger". It was put there in 1820. But one year from now will the

0:00:530:00:53

But one year from now will the Scottish

0:00:530:00:53

But one year from now will the Scottish people

0:00:530:00:54

But one year from now will the Scottish people hold

0:00:540:00:54

But one year from now will the Scottish people hold to

0:00:540:00:54

But one year from now will the Scottish people hold to that

0:00:540:00:55

But one year from now will the Scottish people hold to that view

0:00:550:00:55

Scottish people hold to that view and

0:00:550:00:55

Scottish people hold to that view and the

0:00:550:00:55

Scottish people hold to that view and the union

0:00:550:00:56

Scottish people hold to that view and the union or

0:00:560:00:56

Scottish people hold to that view and the union or will

0:00:560:00:56

Scottish people hold to that view and the union or will they

0:00:560:00:57

Scottish people hold to that view and the union or will they vote

0:00:570:00:57

Scottish people hold to that view and the union or will they vote to

0:00:570:00:58

and the union or will they vote to make

0:00:580:00:58

and the union or will they vote to make Scotland

0:00:580:00:58

and the union or will they vote to make Scotland an

0:00:580:00:58

and the union or will they vote to make Scotland an independent

0:00:580:00:59

make Scotland an independent sovereign

0:00:590:00:59

make Scotland an independent sovereign state

0:00:590:00:59

make Scotland an independent sovereign state again,

0:00:590:01:00

make Scotland an independent sovereign state again, and

0:01:000:01:00

make Scotland an independent sovereign state again, and what

0:01:000:01:00

sovereign state again, and what would

0:01:000:01:01

sovereign state again, and what would this

0:01:010:01:01

sovereign state again, and what would this border

0:01:010:01:01

sovereign state again, and what would this border look

0:01:010:01:02

sovereign state again, and what would this border look like

0:01:020:01:02

sovereign state again, and what would this border look like then?

0:01:020:01:03

would this border look like then? We

0:01:030:01:03

would this border look like then? We brought

0:01:030:01:04

would this border look like then? We brought leading

0:01:040:01:06

would this border look like then? We brought leading lights

0:01:060:01:06

would this border look like then? We brought leading lights from

0:01:060:01:07

would this border look like then? We brought leading lights from the

0:01:070:01:07

We brought leading lights from the rival

0:01:070:01:07

We brought leading lights from the rival campaigns

0:01:070:01:07

We brought leading lights from the rival campaigns on

0:01:070:01:08

We brought leading lights from the rival campaigns on to

0:01:080:01:08

We brought leading lights from the rival campaigns on to this

0:01:080:01:08

We brought leading lights from the rival campaigns on to this bridge

0:01:080:01:09

rival campaigns on to this bridge to

0:01:090:01:09

rival campaigns on to this bridge to try

0:01:090:01:09

rival campaigns on to this bridge to try to

0:01:090:01:10

rival campaigns on to this bridge to try to win

0:01:100:01:10

rival campaigns on to this bridge to try to win hearts

0:01:100:01:11

rival campaigns on to this bridge to try to win hearts and

0:01:110:01:11

rival campaigns on to this bridge to try to win hearts and minds

0:01:110:01:11

rival campaigns on to this bridge to try to win hearts and minds of

0:01:110:01:12

to try to win hearts and minds of the

0:01:120:01:12

to try to win hearts and minds of the audience.

0:01:120:01:12

to try to win hearts and minds of the audience. Earlier

0:01:120:01:12

to try to win hearts and minds of the audience. Earlier tonight

0:01:120:01:13

to try to win hearts and minds of the audience. Earlier tonight they

0:01:130:01:13

the audience. Earlier tonight they made

0:01:130:01:14

the audience. Earlier tonight they made their

0:01:140:01:14

the audience. Earlier tonight they made their case,

0:01:140:01:14

the audience. Earlier tonight they made their case, and

0:01:140:01:15

the audience. Earlier tonight they made their case, and later

0:01:150:01:15

the audience. Earlier tonight they made their case, and later our

0:01:150:01:16

made their case, and later our undecided

0:01:160:01:16

made their case, and later our undecided voters

0:01:160:01:16

made their case, and later our undecided voters will

0:01:160:01:16

made their case, and later our undecided voters will be

0:01:160:01:17

made their case, and later our undecided voters will be returning

0:01:170:01:17

undecided voters will be returning to

0:01:170:01:17

undecided voters will be returning to the

0:01:170:01:17

undecided voters will be returning to the bridge

0:01:170:01:17

undecided voters will be returning to the bridge to

0:01:170:01:18

undecided voters will be returning to the bridge to cast

0:01:180:01:18

undecided voters will be returning to the bridge to cast their

0:01:180:01:19

undecided voters will be returning to the bridge to cast their votes

0:01:190:01:19

to the bridge to cast their votes live.

0:01:190:01:20

to the bridge to cast their votes live. Here

0:01:200:01:20

to the bridge to cast their votes live. Here is

0:01:200:01:20

to the bridge to cast their votes live. Here is how

0:01:200:01:20

to the bridge to cast their votes live. Here is how the

0:01:200:01:21

to the bridge to cast their votes live. Here is how the night

0:01:210:01:21

live. Here is how the night unfolded.

0:01:210:01:25

live. Here is how the night unfolded. A

0:01:250:01:25

live. Here is how the night unfolded. A year

0:01:250:01:26

live. Here is how the night unfolded. A year from

0:01:260:01:26

live. Here is how the night unfolded. A year from now

0:01:260:01:26

live. Here is how the night unfolded. A year from now the

0:01:260:01:27

unfolded. A year from now the people

0:01:270:01:27

unfolded. A year from now the people of

0:01:270:01:27

unfolded. A year from now the people of Scotland

0:01:270:01:28

unfolded. A year from now the people of Scotland will

0:01:280:01:28

unfolded. A year from now the people of Scotland will vote,

0:01:280:01:28

unfolded. A year from now the people of Scotland will vote, the

0:01:280:01:30

people of Scotland will vote, the question

0:01:300:01:30

people of Scotland will vote, the question on

0:01:300:01:30

people of Scotland will vote, the question on the

0:01:300:01:30

people of Scotland will vote, the question on the ballot

0:01:300:01:31

people of Scotland will vote, the question on the ballot will

0:01:310:01:32

people of Scotland will vote, the question on the ballot will be

0:01:320:01:33

question on the ballot will be "should

0:01:330:01:33

question on the ballot will be "should Scotland

0:01:330:01:33

question on the ballot will be "should Scotland be

0:01:330:01:34

question on the ballot will be "should Scotland be an

0:01:340:01:34

question on the ballot will be "should Scotland be an independent

0:01:340:01:34

"should Scotland be an independent country?

0:01:340:01:34

"should Scotland be an independent country? Yes

0:01:340:01:36

"should Scotland be an independent country? Yes or

0:01:360:01:36

"should Scotland be an independent country? Yes or no."

0:01:360:01:36

"should Scotland be an independent country? Yes or no." All

0:01:360:01:37

"should Scotland be an independent country? Yes or no." All the

0:01:370:01:38

"should Scotland be an independent country? Yes or no." All the polls

0:01:380:01:38

country? Yes or no." All the polls have

0:01:380:01:39

country? Yes or no." All the polls have said

0:01:390:01:39

country? Yes or no." All the polls have said and

0:01:390:01:40

country? Yes or no." All the polls have said and the

0:01:400:01:40

country? Yes or no." All the polls have said and the undecided

0:01:400:01:40

country? Yes or no." All the polls have said and the undecided of

0:01:400:01:41

country? Yes or no." All the polls have said and the undecided of this

0:01:410:01:41

have said and the undecided of this country

0:01:410:01:41

have said and the undecided of this country will

0:01:410:01:41

have said and the undecided of this country will hold

0:01:410:01:42

have said and the undecided of this country will hold the

0:01:420:01:42

have said and the undecided of this country will hold the future

0:01:420:01:42

have said and the undecided of this country will hold the future of

0:01:420:01:42

have said and the undecided of this country will hold the future of the

0:01:420:01:43

country will hold the future of the country.

0:01:430:01:43

country will hold the future of the country. I

0:01:430:01:43

country will hold the future of the country. I hope

0:01:430:01:44

country will hold the future of the country. I hope to

0:01:440:01:44

country will hold the future of the country. I hope to hear

0:01:440:01:44

country will hold the future of the country. I hope to hear a

0:01:440:01:45

country will hold the future of the country. I hope to hear a lot

0:01:450:01:45

country will hold the future of the country. I hope to hear a lot of

0:01:450:01:45

country. I hope to hear a lot of the

0:01:450:01:45

country. I hope to hear a lot of the economic

0:01:450:01:46

country. I hope to hear a lot of the economic side

0:01:460:01:46

country. I hope to hear a lot of the economic side and

0:01:460:01:47

country. I hope to hear a lot of the economic side and the

0:01:470:01:47

country. I hope to hear a lot of the economic side and the Queen.

0:01:470:01:47

country. I hope to hear a lot of the economic side and the Queen. Oh

0:01:470:01:47

the economic side and the Queen. Oh lots

0:01:470:01:48

the economic side and the Queen. Oh lots of

0:01:480:01:48

the economic side and the Queen. Oh lots of things,

0:01:480:01:49

the economic side and the Queen. Oh lots of things, I'm

0:01:490:01:49

the economic side and the Queen. Oh lots of things, I'm sure

0:01:490:01:49

the economic side and the Queen. Oh lots of things, I'm sure things

0:01:490:01:50

lots of things, I'm sure things will

0:01:500:01:50

lots of things, I'm sure things will come

0:01:500:01:50

lots of things, I'm sure things will come up

0:01:500:01:50

lots of things, I'm sure things will come up that

0:01:500:01:50

lots of things, I'm sure things will come up that I

0:01:500:01:51

lots of things, I'm sure things will come up that I never

0:01:510:01:51

lots of things, I'm sure things will come up that I never thought

0:01:510:01:51

lots of things, I'm sure things will come up that I never thought I

0:01:510:01:51

will come up that I never thought I needed

0:01:510:01:51

will come up that I never thought I needed to

0:01:510:01:52

will come up that I never thought I needed to know

0:01:520:01:53

will come up that I never thought I needed to know about.

0:01:530:01:53

will come up that I never thought I needed to know about. It

0:01:530:01:54

will come up that I never thought I needed to know about. It would

0:01:540:01:54

will come up that I never thought I needed to know about. It would be

0:01:540:01:54

needed to know about. It would be very

0:01:540:01:54

needed to know about. It would be very nice

0:01:540:01:54

needed to know about. It would be very nice to

0:01:540:01:55

needed to know about. It would be very nice to be

0:01:550:01:56

needed to know about. It would be very nice to be a

0:01:560:01:56

needed to know about. It would be very nice to be a bit

0:01:560:01:57

needed to know about. It would be very nice to be a bit more

0:01:570:01:57

needed to know about. It would be very nice to be a bit more informed.

0:01:570:01:57

very nice to be a bit more informed. Our

0:01:570:01:58

very nice to be a bit more informed. Our connection

0:01:580:01:59

very nice to be a bit more informed. Our connection to

0:01:590:01:59

very nice to be a bit more informed. Our connection to Europe,

0:01:590:01:59

very nice to be a bit more informed. Our connection to Europe, the

0:01:590:01:59

very nice to be a bit more informed. Our connection to Europe, the trade,

0:01:590:02:00

Our connection to Europe, the trade, the

0:02:000:02:00

Our connection to Europe, the trade, the involvement

0:02:000:02:01

Our connection to Europe, the trade, the involvement with

0:02:010:02:01

Our connection to Europe, the trade, the involvement with Europe

0:02:010:02:01

Our connection to Europe, the trade, the involvement with Europe and

0:02:010:02:01

Our connection to Europe, the trade, the involvement with Europe and how

0:02:010:02:02

the involvement with Europe and how we

0:02:020:02:02

the involvement with Europe and how we would

0:02:020:02:03

the involvement with Europe and how we would be

0:02:030:02:03

the involvement with Europe and how we would be affected

0:02:030:02:03

the involvement with Europe and how we would be affected by

0:02:030:02:03

the involvement with Europe and how we would be affected by not

0:02:030:02:05

the involvement with Europe and how we would be affected by not being

0:02:050:02:05

we would be affected by not being part

0:02:050:02:05

we would be affected by not being part of

0:02:050:02:07

we would be affected by not being part of Britain

0:02:070:02:07

we would be affected by not being part of Britain essentially

0:02:070:02:07

we would be affected by not being part of Britain essentially divided

0:02:070:02:08

part of Britain essentially divided away

0:02:080:02:08

part of Britain essentially divided away from

0:02:080:02:08

part of Britain essentially divided away from Britain.

0:02:080:02:09

part of Britain essentially divided away from Britain. I

0:02:090:02:11

part of Britain essentially divided away from Britain. I think

0:02:110:02:11

away from Britain. I think especially

0:02:110:02:11

away from Britain. I think especially being

0:02:110:02:12

away from Britain. I think especially being on

0:02:120:02:12

away from Britain. I think especially being on the

0:02:120:02:12

away from Britain. I think especially being on the border,

0:02:120:02:12

away from Britain. I think especially being on the border, it

0:02:120:02:13

especially being on the border, it is

0:02:130:02:13

especially being on the border, it is a

0:02:130:02:13

especially being on the border, it is a big

0:02:130:02:13

especially being on the border, it is a big issue

0:02:130:02:13

especially being on the border, it is a big issue for

0:02:130:02:14

especially being on the border, it is a big issue for us

0:02:140:02:14

especially being on the border, it is a big issue for us where

0:02:140:02:14

especially being on the border, it is a big issue for us where we

0:02:140:02:15

especially being on the border, it is a big issue for us where we live.

0:02:150:02:15

is a big issue for us where we live. The

0:02:150:02:15

is a big issue for us where we live. The latest

0:02:150:02:16

is a big issue for us where we live. The latest polling

0:02:160:02:18

is a big issue for us where we live. The latest polling puts

0:02:180:02:18

is a big issue for us where we live. The latest polling puts better

0:02:180:02:18

The latest polling puts better together

0:02:180:02:19

The latest polling puts better together ahead

0:02:190:02:20

The latest polling puts better together ahead by

0:02:200:02:20

The latest polling puts better together ahead by 10-20%,

0:02:200:02:20

The latest polling puts better together ahead by 10-20%, with

0:02:200:02:21

The latest polling puts better together ahead by 10-20%, with one

0:02:210:02:21

together ahead by 10-20%, with one in

0:02:210:02:22

together ahead by 10-20%, with one in five

0:02:220:02:22

together ahead by 10-20%, with one in five voters

0:02:220:02:22

together ahead by 10-20%, with one in five voters still

0:02:220:02:22

together ahead by 10-20%, with one in five voters still undecided.

0:02:220:02:23

together ahead by 10-20%, with one in five voters still undecided. So

0:02:230:02:24

in five voters still undecided. So the

0:02:240:02:24

in five voters still undecided. So the result

0:02:240:02:24

in five voters still undecided. So the result of

0:02:240:02:25

in five voters still undecided. So the result of next

0:02:250:02:26

in five voters still undecided. So the result of next year's

0:02:260:02:26

the result of next year's referendum

0:02:260:02:26

the result of next year's referendum is

0:02:260:02:27

the result of next year's referendum is still

0:02:270:02:27

the result of next year's referendum is still far

0:02:270:02:27

the result of next year's referendum is still far from

0:02:270:02:28

referendum is still far from certain.

0:02:280:02:28

referendum is still far from certain. It

0:02:280:02:28

referendum is still far from certain. It is

0:02:280:02:29

referendum is still far from certain. It is these

0:02:290:02:29

referendum is still far from certain. It is these men

0:02:290:02:29

referendum is still far from certain. It is these men and

0:02:290:02:30

referendum is still far from certain. It is these men and women

0:02:300:02:30

certain. It is these men and women the

0:02:300:02:31

certain. It is these men and women the campaigns

0:02:310:02:31

certain. It is these men and women the campaigns must

0:02:310:02:31

certain. It is these men and women the campaigns must now

0:02:310:02:31

certain. It is these men and women the campaigns must now convince.

0:02:310:02:36

the campaigns must now convince. Tonight

0:02:360:02:36

the campaigns must now convince. Tonight we

0:02:360:02:36

the campaigns must now convince. Tonight we will

0:02:360:02:37

the campaigns must now convince. Tonight we will be

0:02:370:02:37

the campaigns must now convince. some of

0:02:370:02:37

the campaigns must now convince. some of the

0:02:370:02:38

the campaigns must now convince. some of the big

0:02:380:02:38

the campaigns must now convince. some of the big questions

0:02:380:02:38

the campaigns must now convince. some of the big questions about

0:02:380:02:39

the campaigns must now convince. some of the big questions about the

0:02:390:02:39

some of the big questions about the economics

0:02:390:02:40

some of the big questions about the economics of

0:02:400:02:40

some of the big questions about the economics of independence,

0:02:400:02:40

some of the big questions about the economics of independence, the

0:02:400:02:41

economics of independence, the future

0:02:410:02:42

economics of independence, the future of

0:02:420:02:42

economics of independence, the future of Trident,

0:02:420:02:42

economics of independence, the future of Trident, whether

0:02:420:02:43

economics of independence, the future of Trident, whether an

0:02:430:02:43

future of Trident, whether an independent

0:02:430:02:44

future of Trident, whether an independent Scotland

0:02:440:02:44

future of Trident, whether an independent Scotland would

0:02:440:02:44

future of Trident, whether an independent Scotland would be

0:02:440:02:44

future of Trident, whether an independent Scotland would be in

0:02:440:02:44

independent Scotland would be in NATO?

0:02:440:02:45

independent Scotland would be in NATO? Who

0:02:450:02:45

independent Scotland would be in NATO? Who gets

0:02:450:02:46

independent Scotland would be in NATO? Who gets the

0:02:460:02:46

independent Scotland would be in NATO? Who gets the oil

0:02:460:02:47

independent Scotland would be in NATO? Who gets the oil revenues

0:02:470:02:47

independent Scotland would be in NATO? Who gets the oil revenues if

0:02:470:02:47

NATO? Who gets the oil revenues if Scotland

0:02:470:02:48

NATO? Who gets the oil revenues if Scotland votes

0:02:480:02:48

NATO? Who gets the oil revenues if Scotland votes yes

0:02:480:02:49

NATO? Who gets the oil revenues if Scotland votes yes to

0:02:490:02:49

NATO? Who gets the oil revenues if Scotland votes yes to independence?

0:02:490:02:49

Scotland votes yes to independence? And

0:02:490:02:50

Scotland votes yes to independence? And how

0:02:500:02:50

Scotland votes yes to independence? And how would

0:02:500:02:51

Scotland votes yes to independence? And how would Scotland's

0:02:510:02:51

Scotland votes yes to independence? And how would Scotland's close

0:02:510:02:52

And how would Scotland's close relationship

0:02:520:02:52

And how would Scotland's close relationship to

0:02:520:02:52

And how would Scotland's close relationship to England

0:02:520:02:52

And how would Scotland's close relationship to England would

0:02:520:02:53

relationship to England would change

0:02:530:02:53

relationship to England would change if

0:02:530:02:53

relationship to England would change if Scotland

0:02:530:02:54

relationship to England would change if Scotland was

0:02:540:02:54

relationship to England would change if Scotland was a

0:02:540:02:55

relationship to England would change if Scotland was a sovereign

0:02:550:02:55

change if Scotland was a sovereign state?

0:02:550:02:56

change if Scotland was a sovereign state? On

0:02:560:02:56

change if Scotland was a sovereign state? On the

0:02:560:02:57

change if Scotland was a sovereign state? On the panel

0:02:570:02:57

change if Scotland was a sovereign state? On the panel voting

0:02:570:02:57

change if Scotland was a sovereign state? On the panel voting yes

0:02:570:02:57

change if Scotland was a sovereign state? On the panel voting yes is

0:02:570:02:58

state? On the panel voting yes is Nicola

0:02:580:02:58

state? On the panel voting yes is Nicola Sturgeon,

0:02:580:02:58

state? On the panel voting yes is Nicola Sturgeon, Deputy

0:02:580:02:59

state? On the panel voting yes is Nicola Sturgeon, Deputy First

0:02:590:02:59

Nicola Sturgeon, Deputy First Minister,

0:02:590:03:00

Nicola Sturgeon, Deputy First Minister, and

0:03:000:03:01

Nicola Sturgeon, Deputy First Minister, and Pat

0:03:010:03:01

Nicola Sturgeon, Deputy First Minister, and Pat Caine,

0:03:010:03:02

Nicola Sturgeon, Deputy First Minister, and Pat Caine, cultural

0:03:020:03:02

Minister, and Pat Caine, cultural commentator

0:03:020:03:02

Minister, and Pat Caine, cultural commentator and

0:03:020:03:03

Minister, and Pat Caine, cultural commentator and musician.

0:03:030:03:03

Minister, and Pat Caine, cultural commentator and musician. Voting

0:03:030:03:03

Minister, and Pat Caine, cultural commentator and musician. Voting no

0:03:030:03:03

commentator and musician. Voting no a

0:03:030:03:04

commentator and musician. Voting no a year

0:03:040:03:04

commentator and musician. Voting no a year from

0:03:040:03:04

commentator and musician. Voting no a year from now,

0:03:040:03:05

commentator and musician. Voting no a year from now, Curran

0:03:050:03:05

commentator and musician. Voting no a year from now, Curran cushion

0:03:050:03:06

commentator and musician. Voting no a year from now, Curran cushion the

0:03:060:03:06

commentator and musician. Voting no shadow Secretary of State

0:03:060:03:07

commentator and musician. Voting no shadow Secretary of State for

0:03:070:03:07

shadow Secretary of State for Scotland,

0:03:070:03:07

shadow Secretary of State for Scotland, and

0:03:070:03:07

shadow Secretary of State for Scotland, and the

0:03:070:03:07

shadow Secretary of State for Scotland, and the business

0:03:070:03:08

shadow Secretary of State for Scotland, and the business woman,

0:03:080:03:08

Scotland, and the business woman, Tessa

0:03:080:03:08

Scotland, and the business woman, Tessa Hartman.

0:03:080:03:10

Scotland, and the business woman, Tessa Hartman. APPLAUSE

0:03:100:03:15

Tessa Hartman. APPLAUSE We

0:03:150:03:16

Tessa Hartman. APPLAUSE We are

0:03:160:03:17

Tessa Hartman. APPLAUSE We are going

0:03:170:03:17

Tessa Hartman. APPLAUSE We are going to

0:03:170:03:17

Tessa Hartman. APPLAUSE We are going to kick

0:03:170:03:17

Tessa Hartman. APPLAUSE We are going to kick off

0:03:170:03:18

Tessa Hartman. APPLAUSE We are going to kick off with

0:03:180:03:18

Tessa Hartman. APPLAUSE We are going to kick off with short

0:03:180:03:19

We are going to kick off with short pitches

0:03:190:03:20

We are going to kick off with short pitches from

0:03:200:03:20

We are going to kick off with short pitches from the

0:03:200:03:21

We are going to kick off with short pitches from the main

0:03:210:03:22

We are going to kick off with short pitches from the main protaganists,

0:03:220:03:22

pitches from the main protaganists, Margaret

0:03:220:03:22

pitches from the main protaganists, Margaret Curran

0:03:220:03:22

pitches from the main protaganists, Margaret Curran and

0:03:220:03:23

pitches from the main protaganists, Margaret Curran and Nicola

0:03:230:03:23

pitches from the main protaganists, Margaret Curran and Nicola Sturgeon

0:03:230:03:23

Margaret Curran and Nicola Sturgeon on

0:03:230:03:23

Margaret Curran and Nicola Sturgeon on thes

0:03:230:03:23

Margaret Curran and Nicola Sturgeon on thes to

0:03:230:03:24

Margaret Curran and Nicola Sturgeon on thes to of

0:03:240:03:24

Margaret Curran and Nicola Sturgeon on thes to of the

0:03:240:03:25

Margaret Curran and Nicola Sturgeon on thes to of the coin.

0:03:250:03:25

Margaret Curran and Nicola Sturgeon on thes to of the coin. Which

0:03:250:03:26

on thes to of the coin. Which would you

0:03:260:03:27

on thes to of the coin. Which would you --

0:03:270:03:27

on thes to of the coin. Which would you -- toss

0:03:270:03:27

on thes to of the coin. Which would you -- toss of

0:03:270:03:28

on thes to of the coin. Which would you -- toss of the

0:03:280:03:28

on thes to of the coin. Which would you -- toss of the coin.

0:03:280:03:28

on thes to of the coin. Which would you -- toss of the coin. Which

0:03:280:03:28

you -- toss of the coin. Which would

0:03:280:03:29

you -- toss of the coin. Which would you

0:03:290:03:29

you -- toss of the coin. Which would you like,

0:03:290:03:30

you -- toss of the coin. Which would you like, heads

0:03:300:03:30

you -- toss of the coin. Which would you like, heads or

0:03:300:03:31

you -- toss of the coin. Which would you like, heads or tails?

0:03:310:03:33

would you like, heads or tails? Heads.

0:03:330:03:33

would you like, heads or tails? Heads. Heads

0:03:330:03:34

would you like, heads or tails? Heads. Heads it

0:03:340:03:34

would you like, heads or tails? Heads. Heads it is,

0:03:340:03:34

would you like, heads or tails? Heads. Heads it is, Nicola

0:03:340:03:34

would you like, heads or tails? Heads. Heads it is, Nicola Sturgeon

0:03:340:03:34

Heads. Heads it is, Nicola Sturgeon make

0:03:340:03:35

Heads. Heads it is, Nicola Sturgeon make your

0:03:350:03:35

Heads. Heads it is, Nicola Sturgeon make your pitch

0:03:350:03:36

Heads. Heads it is, Nicola Sturgeon make your pitch for

0:03:360:03:36

Heads. Heads it is, Nicola Sturgeon make your pitch for independence.

0:03:360:03:37

make your pitch for independence. Scotland

0:03:370:03:37

make your pitch for independence. Scotland can

0:03:370:03:37

make your pitch for independence. Scotland can more

0:03:370:03:37

make your pitch for independence. Scotland can more than

0:03:370:03:37

make your pitch for independence. Scotland can more than afford

0:03:370:03:38

make your pitch for independence. Scotland can more than afford to

0:03:380:03:38

make your pitch for independence. Scotland can more than afford to be

0:03:380:03:38

Scotland can more than afford to be independent,

0:03:380:03:38

Scotland can more than afford to be independent, we

0:03:380:03:38

Scotland can more than afford to be independent, we are

0:03:380:03:39

Scotland can more than afford to be independent, we are one

0:03:390:03:39

Scotland can more than afford to be independent, we are one of

0:03:390:03:39

Scotland can more than afford to be independent, we are one of the

0:03:390:03:40

independent, we are one of the wealthiest

0:03:400:03:40

independent, we are one of the wealthiest countries

0:03:400:03:40

independent, we are one of the wealthiest countries in

0:03:400:03:40

independent, we are one of the wealthiest countries in the

0:03:400:03:40

independent, we are one of the wealthiest countries in the world,

0:03:400:03:41

wealthiest countries in the world, we

0:03:410:03:41

wealthiest countries in the world, we more

0:03:410:03:41

wealthiest countries in the world, we more than

0:03:410:03:41

wealthiest countries in the world, we more than pay

0:03:410:03:42

wealthiest countries in the world, we more than pay our

0:03:420:03:42

wealthiest countries in the world, we more than pay our way.

0:03:420:03:43

wealthiest countries in the world, we more than pay our way. In

0:03:430:03:43

wealthiest countries in the world, we more than pay our way. In each

0:03:430:03:43

we more than pay our way. In each of

0:03:430:03:44

we more than pay our way. In each of every

0:03:440:03:44

we more than pay our way. In each of every one

0:03:440:03:44

we more than pay our way. In each of every one of

0:03:440:03:45

we more than pay our way. In each of every one of the

0:03:450:03:45

we more than pay our way. In each of every one of the past

0:03:450:03:45

we more than pay our way. In each of every one of the past 30

0:03:450:03:45

we more than pay our way. In each of every one of the past 30 years

0:03:450:03:46

of every one of the past 30 years when

0:03:460:03:46

of every one of the past 30 years when oil

0:03:460:03:46

of every one of the past 30 years when oil prices

0:03:460:03:46

of every one of the past 30 years when oil prices have

0:03:460:03:47

of every one of the past 30 years when oil prices have been

0:03:470:03:48

of every one of the past 30 years when oil prices have been high

0:03:480:03:49

of every one of the past 30 years when oil prices have been high and

0:03:490:03:49

when oil prices have been high and low,

0:03:490:03:49

when oil prices have been high and low, Scotland

0:03:490:03:50

when oil prices have been high and low, Scotland has

0:03:500:03:50

when oil prices have been high and low, Scotland has generated

0:03:500:03:50

when oil prices have been high and low, Scotland has generated more

0:03:500:03:51

when oil prices have been high and tax per

0:03:510:03:51

when oil prices have been high and tax per head

0:03:510:03:51

when oil prices have been high and tax per head of

0:03:510:03:51

when oil prices have been high and tax per head of population

0:03:510:03:52

when oil prices have been high and tax per head of population than

0:03:520:03:52

when oil prices have been high and tax per head of population than the

0:03:520:03:52

tax per head of population than the UK

0:03:520:03:52

tax per head of population than the UK as

0:03:520:03:53

tax per head of population than the UK as a

0:03:530:03:53

tax per head of population than the UK as a whole.

0:03:530:03:53

tax per head of population than the UK as a whole. There

0:03:530:03:54

tax per head of population than the UK as a whole. There is

0:03:540:03:54

tax per head of population than the UK as a whole. There is no

0:03:540:03:54

tax per head of population than the UK as a whole. There is no question

0:03:540:03:55

UK as a whole. There is no question that

0:03:550:03:55

UK as a whole. There is no question that Scotland

0:03:550:03:55

UK as a whole. There is no question that Scotland can

0:03:550:03:55

UK as a whole. There is no question that Scotland can be

0:03:550:03:56

UK as a whole. There is no question that Scotland can be a

0:03:560:03:56

UK as a whole. There is no question that Scotland can be a successful

0:03:560:03:56

that Scotland can be a successful independent

0:03:560:03:56

that Scotland can be a successful independent country.

0:03:560:03:57

that Scotland can be a successful independent country. The

0:03:570:03:57

that Scotland can be a successful independent country. The question

0:03:570:03:57

independent country. The question is

0:03:570:03:58

independent country. The question is should

0:03:580:03:58

independent country. The question is should we

0:03:580:03:58

independent country. The question is should we be?

0:03:580:03:59

independent country. The question is should we be? My

0:03:590:03:59

independent country. The question is should we be? My argument

0:03:590:03:59

independent country. The question is should we be? My argument is

0:03:590:03:59

is should we be? My argument is that

0:03:590:04:00

is should we be? My argument is that it

0:04:000:04:00

is should we be? My argument is that it is

0:04:000:04:00

is should we be? My argument is that it is better

0:04:000:04:00

is should we be? My argument is that it is better for

0:04:000:04:01

is should we be? My argument is that it is better for all

0:04:010:04:01

is should we be? My argument is that it is better for all of

0:04:010:04:01

is should we be? My argument is that it is better for all of us

0:04:010:04:02

is should we be? My argument is that it is better for all of us if

0:04:020:04:03

that it is better for all of us if decisions

0:04:030:04:03

that it is better for all of us if decisions about

0:04:030:04:04

that it is better for all of us if decisions about Scotland

0:04:040:04:04

that it is better for all of us if decisions about Scotland are

0:04:040:04:04

that it is better for all of us if decisions about Scotland are taken

0:04:040:04:05

decisions about Scotland are taken in

0:04:050:04:05

decisions about Scotland are taken in Scotland.

0:04:050:04:05

decisions about Scotland are taken in Scotland. By

0:04:050:04:05

decisions about Scotland are taken in Scotland. By the

0:04:050:04:05

decisions about Scotland are taken in Scotland. By the people

0:04:050:04:06

decisions about Scotland are taken in Scotland. By the people who

0:04:060:04:06

decisions about Scotland are taken in Scotland. By the people who care

0:04:060:04:06

in Scotland. By the people who care most,

0:04:060:04:06

in Scotland. By the people who care most, those

0:04:060:04:07

in Scotland. By the people who care most, those of

0:04:070:04:07

in Scotland. By the people who care most, those of us

0:04:070:04:07

in Scotland. By the people who care most, those of us who

0:04:070:04:07

in Scotland. By the people who care most, those of us who live

0:04:070:04:08

in Scotland. By the people who care most, those of us who live and

0:04:080:04:08

in Scotland. By the people who care most, those of us who live and work

0:04:080:04:09

most, those of us who live and work here.

0:04:090:04:09

most, those of us who live and work here. We

0:04:090:04:09

most, those of us who live and work here. We have

0:04:090:04:09

most, those of us who live and work here. We have demonstrated

0:04:090:04:10

most, those of us who live and work here. We have demonstrated that

0:04:100:04:11

here. We have demonstrated that with

0:04:110:04:11

here. We have demonstrated that with the

0:04:110:04:11

here. We have demonstrated that with the devolution

0:04:110:04:12

here. We have demonstrated that with the devolution of

0:04:120:04:13

here. We have demonstrated that with the devolution of power

0:04:130:04:13

here. We have demonstrated that with the devolution of power over

0:04:130:04:13

with the devolution of power over health

0:04:130:04:14

with the devolution of power over health and

0:04:140:04:15

with the devolution of power over health and education.

0:04:150:04:15

with the devolution of power over health and education. Independence

0:04:150:04:15

health and education. Independence is

0:04:150:04:16

health and education. Independence is about completing

0:04:160:04:16

health and education. Independence is about completing the

0:04:160:04:16

health and education. Independence is about completing the powers

0:04:160:04:17

health and education. Independence is about completing the powers of

0:04:170:04:17

is about completing the powers of our

0:04:170:04:17

is about completing the powers of our parliament

0:04:170:04:18

is about completing the powers of our parliament to

0:04:180:04:18

is about completing the powers of our parliament to bring

0:04:180:04:18

is about completing the powers of our parliament to bring home

0:04:180:04:20

is about completing the powers of our parliament to bring home powers

0:04:200:04:20

our parliament to bring home powers over

0:04:200:04:20

our parliament to bring home powers over the

0:04:200:04:20

our parliament to bring home powers over the economy

0:04:200:04:21

our parliament to bring home powers over the economy and

0:04:210:04:21

our parliament to bring home powers over the economy and wealth

0:04:210:04:21

our parliament to bring home powers over the economy and wealth there

0:04:210:04:22

over the economy and wealth there as

0:04:220:04:22

over the economy and wealth there as well.

0:04:220:04:23

over the economy and wealth there as well. Scotland's

0:04:230:04:23

over the economy and wealth there as well. Scotland's future

0:04:230:04:24

over the economy and wealth there as well. Scotland's future in

0:04:240:04:25

as well. Scotland's future in Scotland's

0:04:250:04:25

as well. Scotland's future in Scotland's hands

0:04:250:04:25

as well. Scotland's future in Scotland's hands has

0:04:250:04:25

as well. Scotland's future in Scotland's hands has to

0:04:250:04:27

as well. Scotland's future in Scotland's hands has to be

0:04:270:04:27

as well. Scotland's future in Scotland's hands has to be better

0:04:270:04:27

Scotland's hands has to be better than

0:04:270:04:27

Scotland's hands has to be better than leaving

0:04:270:04:28

Scotland's hands has to be better than leaving decisions

0:04:280:04:28

Scotland's hands has to be better than leaving decisions in

0:04:280:04:28

Scotland's hands has to be better than leaving decisions in the

0:04:280:04:28

Scotland's hands has to be better than leaving decisions in the hands

0:04:280:04:29

than leaving decisions in the hands of

0:04:290:04:30

than leaving decisions in the hands of Westminster

0:04:300:04:30

than leaving decisions in the hands of Westminster Governments,

0:04:300:04:31

than leaving decisions in the hands of Westminster Governments, very

0:04:310:04:31

of Westminster Governments, very often

0:04:310:04:32

of Westminster Governments, very often who

0:04:320:04:32

of Westminster Governments, very often who we

0:04:320:04:32

of Westminster Governments, very often who we in

0:04:320:04:32

of Westminster Governments, very often who we in Scotland

0:04:320:04:33

of Westminster Governments, very often who we in Scotland don't

0:04:330:04:33

of Westminster Governments, very often who we in Scotland don't vote

0:04:330:04:33

often who we in Scotland don't vote for.

0:04:330:04:34

often who we in Scotland don't vote for. Margaret Curran?

0:04:340:04:35

often who we in Scotland don't vote for. Margaret Curran? The

0:04:350:04:35

often who we in Scotland don't vote for. Margaret Curran? The debate

0:04:350:04:35

often who we in Scotland don't vote for. Margaret Curran? The debate in

0:04:350:04:35

for. Margaret Curran? The debate in Scotland

0:04:350:04:35

for. Margaret Curran? The debate in Scotland and

0:04:350:04:36

for. Margaret Curran? The debate in Scotland and tonight

0:04:360:04:36

for. Margaret Curran? The debate in Scotland and tonight is

0:04:360:04:36

for. Margaret Curran? The debate in Scotland and tonight is not

0:04:360:04:37

for. Margaret Curran? The debate in Scotland and tonight is not a

0:04:370:04:37

Scotland and tonight is not a question

0:04:370:04:37

Scotland and tonight is not a question of

0:04:370:04:37

Scotland and tonight is not a question of whether

0:04:370:04:38

Scotland and tonight is not a question of whether Scotland

0:04:380:04:38

Scotland and tonight is not a question of whether Scotland could

0:04:380:04:38

question of whether Scotland could be

0:04:380:04:38

question of whether Scotland could be independent,

0:04:380:04:38

question of whether Scotland could be independent, it

0:04:380:04:39

question of whether Scotland could be independent, it is

0:04:390:04:39

question of whether Scotland could be independent, it is a

0:04:390:04:39

question of whether Scotland could be independent, it is a question

0:04:390:04:39

question of whether Scotland could be independent, it is a question of

0:04:390:04:40

be independent, it is a question of whether

0:04:400:04:41

be independent, it is a question of whether Scotland should

0:04:410:04:41

be independent, it is a question of whether Scotland should be

0:04:410:04:41

whether Scotland should be independent.

0:04:410:04:45

whether Scotland should be independent. We

0:04:450:04:45

whether Scotland should be independent. We make

0:04:450:04:45

whether Scotland should be independent. We make real

0:04:450:04:46

whether Scotland should be independent. We make real decisions

0:04:460:04:46

independent. We make real decisions in

0:04:460:04:46

independent. We make real decisions in Scotland

0:04:460:04:46

independent. We make real decisions in Scotland about

0:04:460:04:47

independent. We make real decisions in Scotland about real

0:04:470:04:47

independent. We make real decisions in Scotland about real issues

0:04:470:04:48

independent. We make real decisions in Scotland about real issues that

0:04:480:04:48

in Scotland about real issues that matter,

0:04:480:04:48

in Scotland about real issues that matter, health,

0:04:480:04:49

in Scotland about real issues that matter, health, education

0:04:490:04:49

in Scotland about real issues that matter, health, education and

0:04:490:04:49

matter, health, education and housing,

0:04:490:04:50

matter, health, education and housing, but

0:04:500:04:50

matter, health, education and housing, but I

0:04:500:04:50

matter, health, education and housing, but I also

0:04:500:04:51

matter, health, education and housing, but I also think

0:04:510:04:51

matter, health, education and housing, but I also think we

0:04:510:04:51

housing, but I also think we benefit

0:04:510:04:51

housing, but I also think we benefit being

0:04:510:04:52

housing, but I also think we benefit being part

0:04:520:04:52

housing, but I also think we benefit being part of

0:04:520:04:53

housing, but I also think we benefit being part of that

0:04:530:04:54

housing, but I also think we benefit being part of that broader

0:04:540:04:54

benefit being part of that broader partnership

0:04:540:04:54

benefit being part of that broader partnership that

0:04:540:04:54

benefit being part of that broader partnership that is

0:04:540:04:55

benefit being part of that broader partnership that is the

0:04:550:04:55

benefit being part of that broader partnership that is the United

0:04:550:04:55

partnership that is the United Kingdom.

0:04:550:06:43

the market, it is thought to be £56 billion

0:06:430:06:43

the market, it is thought to be £56 billion over

0:06:430:06:44

the market, it is thought to be £56 billion over 20-odd

0:06:440:06:44

the market, it is thought to be £56 billion over 20-odd years.

0:06:440:06:44

the market, it is thought to be £56 billion over 20-odd years. What

0:06:440:06:44

billion over 20-odd years. What would

0:06:440:06:45

billion over 20-odd years. What would independent

0:06:450:06:45

billion over 20-odd years. What would independent mean

0:06:450:06:45

billion over 20-odd years. What would independent mean for

0:06:450:06:45

would independent mean for businesses

0:06:450:06:46

would independent mean for businesses operating

0:06:460:06:46

would independent mean for businesses operating on

0:06:460:06:46

would independent mean for businesses operating on both

0:06:460:06:47

would independent mean for businesses operating on both sides

0:06:470:06:47

businesses operating on both sides of

0:06:470:06:47

businesses operating on both sides of the

0:06:470:06:48

businesses operating on both sides of the border,

0:06:480:06:48

businesses operating on both sides of the border, could

0:06:480:06:48

businesses operating on both sides of the border, could the

0:06:480:06:48

businesses operating on both sides of the border, could the Scottish

0:06:480:06:48

of the border, could the Scottish Government

0:06:480:06:49

of the border, could the Scottish Government continue

0:06:490:06:49

of the border, could the Scottish Government continue to

0:06:490:06:50

of the border, could the Scottish Government continue to spend

0:06:500:06:50

of the border, could the Scottish Government continue to spend in

0:06:500:06:50

of the border, could the Scottish Government continue to spend in the

0:06:500:06:52

of the border, could the Scottish same way.

0:06:520:06:53

of the border, could the Scottish same way. Scotland

0:06:530:06:53

of the border, could the Scottish same way. Scotland is

0:06:530:06:54

of the border, could the Scottish same way. Scotland is spending

0:06:540:06:54

same way. Scotland is spending about

0:06:540:06:54

same way. Scotland is spending about £20

0:06:540:06:54

same way. Scotland is spending about £20 billion

0:06:540:06:55

same way. Scotland is spending about £20 billion more

0:06:550:06:55

same way. Scotland is spending about £20 billion more than

0:06:550:06:55

same way. Scotland is spending about £20 billion more than it

0:06:550:06:56

same way. Scotland is spending about £20 billion more than it is

0:06:560:06:56

about £20 billion more than it is raising

0:06:560:06:56

about £20 billion more than it is raising each

0:06:560:06:57

about £20 billion more than it is raising each year.

0:06:570:06:57

about £20 billion more than it is raising each year. Public

0:06:570:06:58

about £20 billion more than it is raising each year. Public spending

0:06:580:06:58

raising each year. Public spending is

0:06:580:06:58

raising each year. Public spending is reckoned

0:06:580:06:58

raising each year. Public spending is reckoned to

0:06:580:06:59

raising each year. Public spending is reckoned to be

0:06:590:07:00

raising each year. Public spending is reckoned to be 10%

0:07:000:07:00

raising each year. Public spending is reckoned to be 10% higher

0:07:000:07:00

raising each year. Public spending is reckoned to be 10% higher north

0:07:000:07:00

is reckoned to be 10% higher north of

0:07:000:07:02

is reckoned to be 10% higher north of the

0:07:020:07:02

is reckoned to be 10% higher north of the border.

0:07:020:07:02

is reckoned to be 10% higher north of the border. Then

0:07:020:07:03

is reckoned to be 10% higher north of the border. Then there

0:07:030:07:03

is reckoned to be 10% higher north of the border. Then there is

0:07:030:07:03

is reckoned to be 10% higher north of the border. Then there is the

0:07:030:07:04

of the border. Then there is the gigantic

0:07:040:07:04

of the border. Then there is the gigantic issue

0:07:040:07:04

of the border. Then there is the gigantic issue of

0:07:040:07:04

of the border. Then there is the gigantic issue of debt.

0:07:040:07:05

of the border. Then there is the gigantic issue of debt. What

0:07:050:07:05

of the border. Then there is the gigantic issue of debt. What share

0:07:050:07:06

gigantic issue of debt. What share of

0:07:060:07:07

gigantic issue of debt. What share of the

0:07:070:07:07

gigantic issue of debt. What share of the UK's

0:07:070:07:07

gigantic issue of debt. What share of the UK's more

0:07:070:07:07

gigantic issue of debt. What share of the UK's more than

0:07:070:07:08

gigantic issue of debt. What share of the UK's more than a

0:07:080:07:08

gigantic issue of debt. What share of the UK's more than a trillion

0:07:080:07:08

of the UK's more than a trillion pound

0:07:080:07:09

of the UK's more than a trillion pound worth

0:07:090:07:09

of the UK's more than a trillion pound worth of

0:07:090:07:09

of the UK's more than a trillion pound worth of public

0:07:090:07:09

of the UK's more than a trillion pound worth of public debt

0:07:090:07:10

of the UK's more than a trillion pound worth of public debt would

0:07:100:07:10

pound worth of public debt would Edinburgh

0:07:100:07:10

pound worth of public debt would Edinburgh have

0:07:100:07:11

pound worth of public debt would Edinburgh have to

0:07:110:07:11

pound worth of public debt would Edinburgh have to take

0:07:110:07:12

pound worth of public debt would Edinburgh have to take on.

0:07:120:07:12

pound worth of public debt would Edinburgh have to take on. Don't

0:07:120:07:12

pound worth of public debt would forget the

0:07:120:07:13

pound worth of public debt would forget the issue

0:07:130:07:13

pound worth of public debt would forget the issue of

0:07:130:07:13

pound worth of public debt would forget the issue of the

0:07:130:07:13

pound worth of public debt would forget the issue of the RBS

0:07:130:07:14

pound worth of public debt would forget the issue of the RBS bail

0:07:140:07:14

forget the issue of the RBS bail out,

0:07:140:07:14

forget the issue of the RBS bail out, should

0:07:140:07:14

forget the issue of the RBS bail out, should that

0:07:140:07:15

forget the issue of the RBS bail out, should that all

0:07:150:07:15

forget the issue of the RBS bail out, should that all be

0:07:150:07:16

forget the issue of the RBS bail out, should that all be dumped

0:07:160:07:16

forget the issue of the RBS bail out, should that all be dumped on

0:07:160:07:16

out, should that all be dumped on Scotland,

0:07:160:07:17

out, should that all be dumped on Scotland, or

0:07:170:07:17

out, should that all be dumped on Scotland, or is

0:07:170:07:17

out, should that all be dumped on Scotland, or is it

0:07:170:07:17

out, should that all be dumped on Scotland, or is it a

0:07:170:07:18

out, should that all be dumped on Scotland, or is it a Westminster

0:07:180:07:19

Scotland, or is it a Westminster problem.

0:07:190:07:19

problem. A

0:07:190:07:19

problem. A poll

0:07:190:07:20

problem. A poll today

0:07:200:07:20

problem. A poll today says

0:07:200:07:21

problem. A poll today says that Scots

0:07:210:07:21

problem. A poll today says that Scots would

0:07:210:07:21

A poll today says that Scots would be

0:07:210:07:22

A poll today says that Scots would be £500

0:07:220:07:22

A poll today says that Scots would be £500 better

0:07:220:07:22

A poll today says that Scots would be £500 better off

0:07:220:07:22

A poll today says that Scots would be £500 better off and

0:07:220:07:23

A poll today says that Scots would be £500 better off and that

0:07:230:07:23

A poll today says that Scots would be £500 better off and that would

0:07:230:07:23

be £500 better off and that would make

0:07:230:07:23

be £500 better off and that would make a

0:07:230:07:23

be £500 better off and that would make a difference

0:07:230:07:24

be £500 better off and that would make a difference to

0:07:240:07:24

be £500 better off and that would make a difference to them.

0:07:240:07:24

be £500 better off and that would make a difference to them. That

0:07:240:07:24

make a difference to them. That would

0:07:240:07:24

make a difference to them. That would be

0:07:240:07:25

make a difference to them. That would be one

0:07:250:07:25

make a difference to them. That would be one of

0:07:250:07:25

make a difference to them. That would be one of the

0:07:250:07:25

make a difference to them. That would be one of the big

0:07:250:07:26

make a difference to them. That would be one of the big things

0:07:260:07:26

make a difference to them. That would be one of the big things that

0:07:260:07:26

would be one of the big things that would

0:07:260:07:26

would be one of the big things that would make

0:07:260:07:26

would be one of the big things that would make their

0:07:260:07:27

would be one of the big things that would make their minds

0:07:270:07:27

would be one of the big things that would make their minds up.

0:07:270:07:28

would be one of the big things that would make their minds up. The

0:07:280:07:28

would be one of the big things that would make their minds up. The SNP

0:07:280:07:28

would make their minds up. The SNP says

0:07:280:07:29

would make their minds up. The SNP says it

0:07:290:07:30

would make their minds up. The SNP says it is

0:07:300:07:31

would make their minds up. The SNP says it is £800

0:07:310:07:31

would make their minds up. The SNP says it is £800 a

0:07:310:07:31

would make their minds up. The SNP says it is £800 a head

0:07:310:07:34

would make their minds up. The SNP says it is £800 a head per

0:07:340:07:34

would make their minds up. The SNP says it is £800 a head per better -

0:07:340:07:37

says it is £800 a head per better - -

0:07:370:07:41

says it is £800 a head per better - - better

0:07:410:07:41

says it is £800 a head per better - - better above.

0:07:410:07:42

says it is £800 a head per better - - better above. I

0:07:420:07:43

says it is £800 a head per better - - better above. I think

0:07:430:07:44

says it is £800 a head per better - - better above. I think we

0:07:440:07:44

- better above. I think we challenge

0:07:440:07:44

- better above. I think we challenge the

0:07:440:07:44

- better above. I think we challenge the figures

0:07:440:07:45

- better above. I think we challenge the figures that

0:07:450:07:45

- better above. I think we challenge the figures that say

0:07:450:07:45

challenge the figures that say Scotland

0:07:450:07:46

challenge the figures that say Scotland pays

0:07:460:07:46

challenge the figures that say Scotland pays in

0:07:460:07:46

challenge the figures that say Scotland pays in more

0:07:460:07:46

challenge the figures that say Scotland pays in more than

0:07:460:07:47

challenge the figures that say Scotland pays in more than it

0:07:470:07:48

Scotland pays in more than it gets out.

0:07:480:07:49

Scotland pays in more than it gets out. The

0:07:490:07:49

Scotland pays in more than it gets out. The Institute

0:07:490:07:49

Scotland pays in more than it gets out. The Institute of

0:07:490:07:49

Scotland pays in more than it gets out. The Institute of Fiscal

0:07:490:07:50

Scotland pays in more than it gets Studies and

0:07:500:07:50

Scotland pays in more than it gets Studies and other

0:07:500:07:50

Scotland pays in more than it gets Studies and other commentators

0:07:500:07:50

Scotland pays in more than it gets Studies and other commentators have

0:07:500:07:51

Studies and other commentators have said

0:07:510:07:51

Studies and other commentators have said that

0:07:510:07:51

Studies and other commentators have said that more

0:07:510:07:52

Studies and other commentators have said that more is spent

0:07:520:07:52

Studies and other commentators have said that more is spent in

0:07:520:07:52

Studies and other commentators have said that more is spent in Scotland

0:07:520:07:52

said that more is spent in Scotland than

0:07:520:07:53

said that more is spent in Scotland than we

0:07:530:07:53

said that more is spent in Scotland than we give

0:07:530:07:53

said that more is spent in Scotland than we give back.

0:07:530:07:53

said that more is spent in Scotland than we give back. I

0:07:530:07:54

said that more is spent in Scotland than we give back. I think

0:07:540:07:54

said that more is spent in Scotland than we give back. I think that

0:07:540:07:54

said that more is spent in Scotland than we give back. I think that is

0:07:540:07:54

than we give back. I think that is right,

0:07:540:07:54

than we give back. I think that is right, we

0:07:540:07:55

than we give back. I think that is right, we deserve

0:07:550:07:55

than we give back. I think that is right, we deserve that,

0:07:550:07:56

than we give back. I think that is right, we deserve that, it

0:07:560:07:56

than we give back. I think that is right, we deserve that, it should

0:07:560:07:56

right, we deserve that, it should be

0:07:560:07:56

right, we deserve that, it should be based

0:07:560:07:56

right, we deserve that, it should be based on

0:07:560:07:57

right, we deserve that, it should be based on need

0:07:570:07:57

right, we deserve that, it should be based on need not

0:07:570:07:57

right, we deserve that, it should be based on need not nationalty.

0:07:570:07:57

right, we deserve that, it should be based on need not nationalty. I

0:07:570:07:58

be based on need not nationalty. I think

0:07:580:07:58

be based on need not nationalty. I think the

0:07:580:07:58

be based on need not nationalty. I think the union

0:07:580:07:59

be based on need not nationalty. I think the union works

0:07:590:07:59

be based on need not nationalty. I think the union works for

0:07:590:07:59

be based on need not nationalty. I think the union works for Scotland.

0:07:590:07:59

think the union works for Scotland. I

0:07:590:08:00

think the union works for Scotland. I think

0:08:000:08:00

think the union works for Scotland. I think that is

0:08:000:08:00

think the union works for Scotland. I think that is the

0:08:000:08:01

think the union works for Scotland. I think that is the best

0:08:010:08:01

think the union works for Scotland. I think that is the best way

0:08:010:08:01

think the union works for Scotland. I think that is the best way to

0:08:010:08:02

I think that is the best way to move

0:08:020:08:02

I think that is the best way to move forward.

0:08:020:08:02

I think that is the best way to move forward. Better

0:08:020:08:03

I think that is the best way to move forward. Better off

0:08:030:08:03

I think that is the best way to move forward. Better off or

0:08:030:08:04

I think that is the best way to move forward. Better off or worse

0:08:040:08:04

move forward. Better off or worse off?

0:08:040:08:04

move forward. Better off or worse off? In

0:08:040:08:05

move forward. Better off or worse off? In independence,

0:08:050:08:05

move forward. Better off or worse off? In independence, on

0:08:050:08:05

move forward. Better off or worse off? In independence, on the

0:08:050:08:06

move forward. Better off or worse off? In independence, on the basis

0:08:060:08:06

off? In independence, on the basis of

0:08:060:08:06

off? In independence, on the basis of that

0:08:060:08:06

off? In independence, on the basis of that we

0:08:060:08:06

off? In independence, on the basis of that we would

0:08:060:08:07

off? In independence, on the basis of that we would be

0:08:070:08:07

off? In independence, on the basis of that we would be worse

0:08:070:08:08

off? In independence, on the basis of that we would be worse off.

0:08:080:08:08

of that we would be worse off. Economically

0:08:080:08:08

of that we would be worse off. Economically I

0:08:080:08:08

of that we would be worse off. Economically I don't

0:08:080:08:08

of that we would be worse off. Economically I don't think

0:08:080:08:09

of that we would be worse off. Economically I don't think that

0:08:090:08:09

Economically I don't think that would

0:08:090:08:09

Economically I don't think that would help

0:08:090:08:09

Economically I don't think that would help us,

0:08:090:08:10

Economically I don't think that would help us, because

0:08:100:08:10

Economically I don't think that would help us, because England

0:08:100:08:11

would help us, because England is our

0:08:110:08:12

would help us, because England is our biggest

0:08:120:08:12

would help us, because England is our biggest exporter,

0:08:120:08:13

would help us, because England is our biggest exporter, why

0:08:130:08:13

would help us, because England is our biggest exporter, why would

0:08:130:08:13

would help us, because England is our biggest exporter, why would we

0:08:130:08:14

our biggest exporter, why would we turn

0:08:140:08:14

our biggest exporter, why would we turn our

0:08:140:08:15

our biggest exporter, why would we turn our biggest

0:08:150:08:15

our biggest exporter, why would we turn our biggest exporter

0:08:150:08:15

our biggest exporter, why would we turn our biggest exporter into

0:08:150:08:15

our biggest exporter, why would we turn our biggest exporter into a

0:08:150:08:15

turn our biggest exporter into a competitor

0:08:150:08:16

turn our biggest exporter into a competitor not

0:08:160:08:16

turn our biggest exporter into a competitor not a

0:08:160:08:17

turn our biggest exporter into a competitor not a partner,

0:08:170:08:18

turn our biggest exporter into a competitor not a partner, when

0:08:180:08:18

turn our biggest exporter into a competitor not a partner, when it

0:08:180:08:18

competitor not a partner, when it can

0:08:180:08:18

competitor not a partner, when it can work

0:08:180:08:18

competitor not a partner, when it can work to

0:08:180:08:19

competitor not a partner, when it can work to our

0:08:190:08:20

competitor not a partner, when it can work to our dual

0:08:200:08:20

competitor not a partner, when it can work to our dual advantage

0:08:200:08:21

competitor not a partner, when it can work to our dual advantage to

0:08:210:08:22

can work to our dual advantage to work

0:08:220:08:22

can work to our dual advantage to work together.

0:08:220:08:23

can work to our dual advantage to work together. The

0:08:230:08:24

can work to our dual advantage to work together. The idea

0:08:240:08:24

can work to our dual advantage to work together. The idea is

0:08:240:08:24

work together. The idea is according

0:08:240:08:24

work together. The idea is according toe

0:08:240:08:26

work together. The idea is according toe the

0:08:260:08:27

work together. The idea is according toe the Scottish --

0:08:270:08:27

according toe the Scottish -- according

0:08:270:08:28

according toe the Scottish -- according to

0:08:280:08:28

according toe the Scottish -- according to the

0:08:280:08:29

according toe the Scottish -- according to the Scottish

0:08:290:08:29

according to the Scottish Government

0:08:290:08:29

according to the Scottish Government we

0:08:290:08:30

according to the Scottish Government we get

0:08:300:08:31

according to the Scottish Government we get more

0:08:310:08:31

according to the Scottish Government we get more per

0:08:310:08:32

according to the Scottish Government we get more per capita,

0:08:320:08:32

Government we get more per capita, 20%,

0:08:320:08:33

Government we get more per capita, 20%, 40%,

0:08:330:08:33

Government we get more per capita, 20%, 40%, how

0:08:330:08:33

Government we get more per capita, 20%, 40%, how will

0:08:330:08:33

Government we get more per capita, 20%, 40%, how will you

0:08:330:08:34

Government we get more per capita, 20%, 40%, how will you pay

0:08:340:08:34

Government we get more per capita, 20%, 40%, how will you pay for

0:08:340:08:34

20%, 40%, how will you pay for these

0:08:340:08:35

20%, 40%, how will you pay for these things

0:08:350:08:35

20%, 40%, how will you pay for these things n

0:08:350:08:35

20%, 40%, how will you pay for these things n an

0:08:350:08:37

20%, 40%, how will you pay for these things n an independent

0:08:370:08:38

these things n an independent Scotland,

0:08:380:08:38

these things n an independent Scotland, paying

0:08:380:08:39

these things n an independent Scotland, paying for

0:08:390:08:39

these things n an independent Scotland, paying for free

0:08:390:08:39

Scotland, paying for free prescriptions,

0:08:390:08:40

Scotland, paying for free prescriptions, free

0:08:400:08:41

Scotland, paying for free prescriptions, free personal

0:08:410:08:41

Scotland, paying for free prescriptions, free personal care,

0:08:410:08:41

prescriptions, free personal care, no

0:08:410:08:42

prescriptions, free personal care, no tuition

0:08:420:08:42

prescriptions, free personal care, no tuition fees,

0:08:420:08:42

prescriptions, free personal care, no tuition fees, the

0:08:420:08:42

prescriptions, free personal care, no tuition fees, the benefit

0:08:420:08:43

prescriptions, free personal care, no tuition fees, the benefit to

0:08:430:08:43

no tuition fees, the benefit to spare

0:08:430:08:43

no tuition fees, the benefit to spare rooms

0:08:430:08:44

no tuition fees, the benefit to spare rooms will

0:08:440:08:44

no tuition fees, the benefit to spare rooms will not

0:08:440:08:45

no tuition fees, the benefit to spare rooms will not be

0:08:450:08:45

spare rooms will not be independented

0:08:450:08:46

spare rooms will not be independented in

0:08:460:08:50

spare rooms will not be independented in an

0:08:500:08:50

spare rooms will not be independented in an allowed

0:08:500:08:50

spare rooms will not be independented in an allowed in

0:08:500:08:50

spare rooms will not be independented in an allowed in an

0:08:500:08:51

independented in an allowed in an independent

0:08:510:08:51

independented in an allowed in an independent Scotland?

0:08:510:08:51

independented in an allowed in an independent Scotland? We

0:08:510:08:52

independented in an allowed in an independent Scotland? We pay

0:08:520:08:52

independented in an allowed in an independent Scotland? We pay for

0:08:520:08:53

independent Scotland? We pay for all

0:08:530:08:53

independent Scotland? We pay for all these

0:08:530:08:53

independent Scotland? We pay for all these things

0:08:530:08:53

independent Scotland? We pay for all these things in

0:08:530:08:54

independent Scotland? We pay for all these things in a

0:08:540:08:54

independent Scotland? We pay for all these things in a balanced

0:08:540:08:54

all these things in a balanced budget.

0:08:540:08:54

all these things in a balanced budget. I

0:08:540:08:55

all these things in a balanced budget. I believe

0:08:550:08:55

all these things in a balanced budget. I believe Scotland

0:08:550:08:56

all these things in a balanced budget. I believe Scotland is

0:08:560:08:56

budget. I believe Scotland is better

0:08:560:08:56

budget. I believe Scotland is better off

0:08:560:08:56

budget. I believe Scotland is better off as

0:08:560:08:56

budget. I believe Scotland is better off as an

0:08:560:08:57

budget. I believe Scotland is better off as an independent

0:08:570:08:57

better off as an independent country,

0:08:570:08:57

better off as an independent country, because

0:08:570:08:57

better off as an independent country, because it

0:08:570:08:57

better off as an independent country, because it is

0:08:570:08:58

better off as an independent country, because it is better

0:08:580:08:58

better off as an independent country, because it is better we

0:08:580:08:59

country, because it is better we take

0:08:590:08:59

country, because it is better we take decisions

0:08:590:08:59

country, because it is better we take decisions about

0:08:590:09:00

country, because it is better we take decisions about our

0:09:000:09:00

country, because it is better we take decisions about our own

0:09:000:09:00

country, because it is better we take decisions about our own future

0:09:000:09:00

take decisions about our own future ourselves.

0:09:000:09:01

take decisions about our own future ourselves. I

0:09:010:09:01

take decisions about our own future ourselves. I believe

0:09:010:09:01

take decisions about our own future ourselves. I believe we

0:09:010:09:01

take decisions about our own future ourselves. I believe we will

0:09:010:09:02

take decisions about our own future ourselves. I believe we will be

0:09:020:09:02

ourselves. I believe we will be economically

0:09:020:09:03

ourselves. I believe we will be economically better

0:09:030:09:04

ourselves. I believe we will be economically better off.

0:09:040:09:04

ourselves. I believe we will be economically better off. Margaret

0:09:040:09:04

economically better off. Margaret says

0:09:040:09:04

economically better off. Margaret says we

0:09:040:09:05

economically better off. Margaret says we have

0:09:050:09:05

economically better off. Margaret says we have higher

0:09:050:09:05

economically better off. Margaret says we have higher spending,

0:09:050:09:06

economically better off. Margaret says we have higher spending, the

0:09:060:09:06

says we have higher spending, the last

0:09:060:09:06

says we have higher spending, the last year

0:09:060:09:07

says we have higher spending, the last year we

0:09:070:09:07

says we have higher spending, the last year we have

0:09:070:09:07

says we have higher spending, the last year we have figures

0:09:070:09:08

says we have higher spending, the last year we have figures available

0:09:080:09:08

last year we have figures available for,

0:09:080:09:09

last year we have figures available for, 2011/12,

0:09:090:09:11

last year we have figures available for, 2011/12, spending

0:09:110:09:11

last year we have figures available for, 2011/12, spending on

0:09:110:09:12

last year we have figures available for, 2011/12, spending on benefits

0:09:120:09:13

for, 2011/12, spending on benefits was

0:09:130:09:13

for, 2011/12, spending on benefits was £50

0:09:130:09:14

for, 2011/12, spending on benefits was £50 a

0:09:140:09:14

for, 2011/12, spending on benefits was £50 a head

0:09:140:09:14

for, 2011/12, spending on benefits was £50 a head higher

0:09:140:09:15

for, 2011/12, spending on benefits was £50 a head higher in

0:09:150:09:15

for, 2011/12, spending on benefits was £50 a head higher in Scotland,

0:09:150:09:16

was £50 a head higher in Scotland, in

0:09:160:09:16

was £50 a head higher in Scotland, in that

0:09:160:09:16

was £50 a head higher in Scotland, in that same

0:09:160:09:17

was £50 a head higher in Scotland, in that same year

0:09:170:09:17

was £50 a head higher in Scotland, in that same year we

0:09:170:09:18

was £50 a head higher in Scotland, in that same year we contributed

0:09:180:09:18

in that same year we contributed £1700

0:09:180:09:19

in that same year we contributed £1700 more

0:09:190:09:19

in that same year we contributed £1700 more in

0:09:190:09:19

in that same year we contributed £1700 more in tax

0:09:190:09:19

in that same year we contributed £1700 more in tax per

0:09:190:09:19

in that same year we contributed £1700 more in tax per head

0:09:190:09:20

in that same year we contributed £1700 more in tax per head than

0:09:200:09:20

in that same year we contributed £1700 more in tax per head than the

0:09:200:09:20

£1700 more in tax per head than the UK

0:09:200:09:20

£1700 more in tax per head than the UK as

0:09:200:09:21

£1700 more in tax per head than the UK as a

0:09:210:09:21

£1700 more in tax per head than the UK as a whole.

0:09:210:09:22

£1700 more in tax per head than the UK as a whole. Let's

0:09:220:09:22

£1700 more in tax per head than the UK as a whole. Let's have

0:09:220:09:22

£1700 more in tax per head than the UK as a whole. Let's have no

0:09:220:09:22

UK as a whole. Let's have no nonsense

0:09:220:09:23

UK as a whole. Let's have no nonsense about

0:09:230:09:24

UK as a whole. Let's have no nonsense about Scotland

0:09:240:09:24

UK as a whole. Let's have no nonsense about Scotland not

0:09:240:09:24

UK as a whole. Let's have no nonsense about Scotland not being

0:09:240:09:25

nonsense about Scotland not being able

0:09:250:09:25

nonsense about Scotland not being able to

0:09:250:09:25

nonsense about Scotland not being able to afford

0:09:250:09:26

nonsense about Scotland not being able to afford being

0:09:260:09:26

nonsense about Scotland not being able to afford being independent.

0:09:260:09:26

able to afford being independent. We

0:09:260:09:26

able to afford being independent. We can

0:09:260:09:27

able to afford being independent. We can afford

0:09:270:09:27

able to afford being independent. We can afford it.

0:09:270:09:27

able to afford being independent. We can afford it. The

0:09:270:09:28

able to afford being independent. We can afford it. The question

0:09:280:09:28

able to afford being independent. We can afford it. The question is

0:09:280:09:29

We can afford it. The question is where

0:09:290:09:29

We can afford it. The question is where is

0:09:290:09:29

We can afford it. The question is where is it

0:09:290:09:29

We can afford it. The question is where is it best

0:09:290:09:30

We can afford it. The question is where is it best to

0:09:300:09:30

We can afford it. The question is where is it best to have

0:09:300:09:30

We can afford it. The question is where is it best to have decisions

0:09:300:09:30

where is it best to have decisions take,

0:09:300:09:31

where is it best to have decisions take, here

0:09:310:09:31

where is it best to have decisions take, here in

0:09:310:09:31

where is it best to have decisions take, here in Scotland

0:09:310:09:32

where is it best to have decisions take, here in Scotland or

0:09:320:09:32

where is it best to have decisions take, here in Scotland or Tory

0:09:320:09:32

take, here in Scotland or Tory Governments

0:09:320:09:33

take, here in Scotland or Tory Governments in

0:09:330:09:34

take, here in Scotland or Tory Governments in Westminster

0:09:340:09:34

take, here in Scotland or Tory Governments in Westminster that

0:09:340:09:34

Governments in Westminster that very

0:09:340:09:34

Governments in Westminster that very often

0:09:340:09:35

Governments in Westminster that very often we

0:09:350:09:35

Governments in Westminster that very often we don't

0:09:350:09:35

Governments in Westminster that very often we don't vote

0:09:350:09:35

Governments in Westminster that very often we don't vote for,

0:09:350:09:36

Governments in Westminster that very often we don't vote for, that

0:09:360:09:36

very often we don't vote for, that is

0:09:360:09:36

very often we don't vote for, that is the

0:09:360:09:36

very often we don't vote for, that is the heart

0:09:360:09:36

very often we don't vote for, that is the heart of

0:09:360:09:37

very often we don't vote for, that is the heart of this

0:09:370:09:37

very often we don't vote for, that is the heart of this argument.

0:09:370:09:37

very often we don't vote for, that is the heart of this argument. What

0:09:370:09:38

is the heart of this argument. What do

0:09:380:09:38

is the heart of this argument. What do people

0:09:380:09:38

is the heart of this argument. What do people in

0:09:380:09:38

is the heart of this argument. What do people in the

0:09:380:09:39

is the heart of this argument. What do people in the audience

0:09:390:09:39

is the heart of this argument. What do people in the audience think,

0:09:390:09:39

do people in the audience think, would

0:09:390:09:40

do people in the audience think, would it

0:09:400:09:40

do people in the audience think, would it make

0:09:400:09:40

do people in the audience think, would it make a

0:09:400:09:40

do people in the audience think, would it make a difference

0:09:400:09:41

do people in the audience think, would it make a difference if

0:09:410:09:41

would it make a difference if you thought

0:09:410:09:41

would it make a difference if you thought you

0:09:410:09:41

would it make a difference if you thought you were

0:09:410:09:42

would it make a difference if you thought you were going

0:09:420:09:42

would it make a difference if you thought you were going to

0:09:420:09:43

would it make a difference if you thought you were going to be

0:09:430:09:43

would it make a difference if you thought you were going to be £500

0:09:430:09:43

thought you were going to be £500 better

0:09:430:09:44

thought you were going to be £500 better off

0:09:440:09:44

thought you were going to be £500 better off or worse

0:09:440:09:44

thought you were going to be £500 better off or worse off,

0:09:440:09:45

thought you were going to be £500 better off or worse off, would

0:09:450:09:45

thought you were going to be £500 better off or worse off, would that

0:09:450:09:46

better off or worse off, would that make

0:09:460:09:46

better off or worse off, would that make a

0:09:460:09:46

better off or worse off, would that make a difference

0:09:460:09:46

better off or worse off, would that make a difference to

0:09:460:09:47

better off or worse off, would that make a difference to you?

0:09:470:09:47

better off or worse off, would that make a difference to you? The

0:09:470:09:47

make a difference to you? The gentleman

0:09:470:09:48

make a difference to you? The gentleman there

0:09:480:09:48

make a difference to you? The gentleman there in

0:09:480:09:48

make a difference to you? The gentleman there in the

0:09:480:09:48

make a difference to you? The gentleman there in the check

0:09:480:09:49

make a difference to you? The gentleman there in the check shirt,

0:09:490:09:49

gentleman there in the check shirt, tell

0:09:490:09:49

gentleman there in the check shirt, tell me

0:09:490:09:50

gentleman there in the check shirt, tell me about

0:09:500:09:50

gentleman there in the check shirt, tell me about that

0:09:500:09:51

gentleman there in the check shirt, tell me about that for

0:09:510:09:51

gentleman there in the check shirt, tell me about that for you?

0:09:510:09:51

gentleman there in the check shirt, tell me about that for you? I

0:09:510:09:51

gentleman there in the check shirt, tell me about that for you? I think

0:09:510:09:52

tell me about that for you? I think if

0:09:520:09:52

tell me about that for you? I think if we

0:09:520:09:52

tell me about that for you? I think if we were

0:09:520:09:52

tell me about that for you? I think if we were going

0:09:520:09:52

tell me about that for you? I think if we were going to

0:09:520:09:53

tell me about that for you? I think if we were going to be

0:09:530:09:53

tell me about that for you? I think if we were going to be £500

0:09:530:09:54

tell me about that for you? I think if we were going to be £500 better

0:09:540:09:54

if we were going to be £500 better off

0:09:540:09:54

if we were going to be £500 better off in

0:09:540:09:54

if we were going to be £500 better off in an

0:09:540:09:56

if we were going to be £500 better off in an independent

0:09:560:09:56

if we were going to be £500 better off in an independent Scotland,

0:09:560:09:57

off in an independent Scotland, that

0:09:570:09:57

off in an independent Scotland, that would

0:09:570:09:58

off in an independent Scotland, that would obviously

0:09:580:09:58

off in an independent Scotland, that would obviously give

0:09:580:09:59

off in an independent Scotland, that would obviously give credence

0:09:590:09:59

that would obviously give credence to

0:09:590:09:59

that would obviously give credence to the

0:09:590:10:00

that would obviously give credence to the argument

0:10:000:10:00

that would obviously give credence to the argument about

0:10:000:10:00

that would obviously give credence to the argument about Scotland

0:10:000:10:00

to the argument about Scotland being

0:10:000:10:01

to the argument about Scotland being better

0:10:010:10:01

to the argument about Scotland being better off

0:10:010:10:01

to the argument about Scotland being better off as

0:10:010:10:02

to the argument about Scotland being better off as a

0:10:020:10:02

to the argument about Scotland being better off as a whole.

0:10:020:10:03

to the argument about Scotland being better off as a whole. But

0:10:030:10:03

to the argument about Scotland being better off as a whole. But I

0:10:030:10:05

being better off as a whole. But I suppose

0:10:050:10:06

being better off as a whole. But I suppose I'm

0:10:060:10:06

being better off as a whole. But I suppose I'm slightly

0:10:060:10:06

being better off as a whole. But I suppose I'm slightly sceptical

0:10:060:10:09

suppose I'm slightly sceptical because

0:10:090:10:09

suppose I'm slightly sceptical because we

0:10:090:10:10

suppose I'm slightly sceptical because we just

0:10:100:10:10

suppose I'm slightly sceptical because we just don't

0:10:100:10:10

suppose I'm slightly sceptical because we just don't know

0:10:100:10:10

suppose I'm slightly sceptical because we just don't know at

0:10:100:10:11

suppose I'm slightly sceptical because we just don't know at this

0:10:110:10:11

because we just don't know at this point,

0:10:110:10:11

because we just don't know at this point, we

0:10:110:10:11

because we just don't know at this point, we are

0:10:110:10:12

because we just don't know at this point, we are being

0:10:120:10:12

because we just don't know at this point, we are being told

0:10:120:10:12

because we just don't know at this point, we are being told obviously

0:10:120:10:12

point, we are being told obviously that

0:10:120:10:13

point, we are being told obviously that we

0:10:130:10:13

point, we are being told obviously that we will

0:10:130:10:13

point, we are being told obviously that we will be

0:10:130:10:13

point, we are being told obviously that we will be better

0:10:130:10:14

point, we are being told obviously that we will be better off

0:10:140:10:14

point, we are being told obviously that we will be better off by

0:10:140:10:14

point, we are being told obviously that we will be better off by the

0:10:140:10:15

that we will be better off by the yes

0:10:150:10:15

that we will be better off by the yes campaign,

0:10:150:10:16

that we will be better off by the yes campaign, and

0:10:160:10:16

that we will be better off by the yes campaign, and we

0:10:160:10:16

that we will be better off by the yes campaign, and we are

0:10:160:10:16

that we will be better off by the yes campaign, and we are hearing

0:10:160:10:17

yes campaign, and we are hearing the

0:10:170:10:17

yes campaign, and we are hearing the opposite

0:10:170:10:17

yes campaign, and we are hearing the opposite story

0:10:170:10:18

yes campaign, and we are hearing the opposite story from

0:10:180:10:19

yes campaign, and we are hearing the opposite story from the

0:10:190:10:20

yes campaign, and we are hearing the opposite story from the no

0:10:200:10:20

the opposite story from the no campaign.

0:10:200:10:21

the opposite story from the no campaign. Jim

0:10:210:10:21

the opposite story from the no campaign. Jim kal

0:10:210:10:22

the opposite story from the no campaign. Jim kal her

0:10:220:10:22

the opposite story from the no campaign. Jim kal her coming

0:10:220:10:22

the opposite story from the no campaign. Jim kal her coming to

0:10:220:10:22

the opposite story from the no campaign. Jim kal her coming to you,

0:10:220:10:23

campaign. Jim kal her coming to you, the

0:10:230:10:24

campaign. Jim kal her coming to you, the problem

0:10:240:10:24

campaign. Jim kal her coming to you, the problem --

0:10:240:10:24

campaign. Jim kal her coming to you, the problem -- Gallagher,

0:10:240:10:25

campaign. Jim kal her coming to you, the problem -- Gallagher, coming

0:10:250:10:25

campaign. Jim kal her coming to you, the problem -- Gallagher, coming to

0:10:250:10:25

the problem -- Gallagher, coming to you

0:10:250:10:26

the problem -- Gallagher, coming to you here,

0:10:260:10:26

the problem -- Gallagher, coming to you here, people

0:10:260:10:26

the problem -- Gallagher, coming to you here, people in

0:10:260:10:26

the problem -- Gallagher, coming to you here, people in Scotland

0:10:260:10:26

the problem -- Gallagher, coming to you here, people in Scotland don't

0:10:260:10:27

you here, people in Scotland don't know

0:10:270:10:27

you here, people in Scotland don't know the

0:10:270:10:27

you here, people in Scotland don't know the true

0:10:270:10:28

you here, people in Scotland don't know the true figures

0:10:280:10:28

you here, people in Scotland don't know the true figures do

0:10:280:10:28

you here, people in Scotland don't know the true figures do they?

0:10:280:10:29

know the true figures do they? First

0:10:290:10:29

know the true figures do they? First of

0:10:290:10:29

know the true figures do they? First of all,

0:10:290:10:30

know the true figures do they? First of all, I

0:10:300:10:30

know the true figures do they? First of all, I don't

0:10:300:10:30

know the true figures do they? First of all, I don't think

0:10:300:10:30

know the true figures do they? First of all, I don't think I

0:10:300:10:30

know the true figures do they? First of all, I don't think I would

0:10:300:10:31

First of all, I don't think I would buy

0:10:310:10:31

First of all, I don't think I would buy and

0:10:310:10:32

First of all, I don't think I would buy and sell

0:10:320:10:32

First of all, I don't think I would buy and sell my

0:10:320:10:32

First of all, I don't think I would buy and sell my country

0:10:320:10:33

First of all, I don't think I would buy and sell my country for

0:10:330:10:33

First of all, I don't think I would buy and sell my country for £500,

0:10:330:10:34

First of all, I don't think I would buy and sell my country for £500, I

0:10:340:10:34

buy and sell my country for £500, I hope

0:10:340:10:34

buy and sell my country for £500, I hope nobody

0:10:340:10:35

buy and sell my country for £500, I hope nobody else

0:10:350:10:35

buy and sell my country for £500, I hope nobody else would.

0:10:350:10:35

buy and sell my country for £500, I hope nobody else would. Let's

0:10:350:10:35

hope nobody else would. Let's understand

0:10:350:10:36

hope nobody else would. Let's understand first

0:10:360:10:36

hope nobody else would. Let's understand first of

0:10:360:10:36

hope nobody else would. Let's understand first of all

0:10:360:10:36

hope nobody else would. Let's understand first of all what

0:10:360:10:36

hope nobody else would. Let's understand first of all what kind

0:10:360:10:37

understand first of all what kind of

0:10:370:10:37

understand first of all what kind of figure

0:10:370:10:37

understand first of all what kind of figure we

0:10:370:10:37

understand first of all what kind of figure we are

0:10:370:10:38

understand first of all what kind of figure we are talking

0:10:380:10:38

understand first of all what kind of figure we are talking about.

0:10:380:10:38

of figure we are talking about. What

0:10:380:10:38

of figure we are talking about. What Nicola

0:10:380:10:39

of figure we are talking about. What Nicola is

0:10:390:10:39

of figure we are talking about. What Nicola is talking

0:10:390:10:40

of figure we are talking about. What Nicola is talking about

0:10:400:10:40

of figure we are talking about. What Nicola is talking about is

0:10:400:10:40

What Nicola is talking about is public

0:10:400:10:40

What Nicola is talking about is public spending

0:10:400:10:41

What Nicola is talking about is public spending and

0:10:410:10:41

What Nicola is talking about is public spending and taxation.

0:10:410:10:41

What Nicola is talking about is public spending and taxation. It

0:10:410:10:42

What Nicola is talking about is public spending and taxation. It is

0:10:420:10:42

public spending and taxation. It is easy

0:10:420:10:42

public spending and taxation. It is easy to understand

0:10:420:10:42

public spending and taxation. It is easy to understand what

0:10:420:10:43

public spending and taxation. It is easy to understand what that

0:10:430:10:44

easy to understand what that actually

0:10:440:10:44

easy to understand what that actually is.

0:10:440:10:44

easy to understand what that actually is. You

0:10:440:10:45

easy to understand what that actually is. You being

0:10:450:10:46

easy to understand what that actually is. You being a

0:10:460:10:46

easy to understand what that actually is. You being a former

0:10:460:10:46

actually is. You being a former senior

0:10:460:10:47

actually is. You being a former senior civil

0:10:470:10:47

actually is. You being a former senior civil servant

0:10:470:10:47

actually is. You being a former senior civil servant you

0:10:470:10:48

actually is. You being a former senior civil servant you understand

0:10:480:10:48

senior civil servant you understand this

0:10:480:10:48

senior civil servant you understand this too?

0:10:480:10:48

senior civil servant you understand this too? I

0:10:480:10:49

senior civil servant you understand this too? I spent

0:10:490:10:49

senior civil servant you understand this too? I spent a

0:10:490:10:49

senior civil servant you understand this too? I spent a lot

0:10:490:10:49

senior civil servant you understand this too? I spent a lot of

0:10:490:10:49

senior civil servant you understand this too? I spent a lot of time

0:10:490:10:50

this too? I spent a lot of time adding

0:10:500:10:50

this too? I spent a lot of time adding up

0:10:500:10:51

this too? I spent a lot of time adding up the

0:10:510:10:51

this too? I spent a lot of time adding up the sums.

0:10:510:10:52

this too? I spent a lot of time adding up the sums. Straight

0:10:520:10:53

adding up the sums. Straight forwardedly

0:10:530:10:53

adding up the sums. Straight forwardedly Scotland

0:10:530:10:53

adding up the sums. Straight forwardedly Scotland on

0:10:530:10:54

adding up the sums. Straight forwardedly Scotland on shore,

0:10:540:10:54

forwardedly Scotland on shore, leaving

0:10:540:10:55

forwardedly Scotland on shore, leaving aside oil

0:10:550:10:55

forwardedly Scotland on shore, leaving aside oil at

0:10:550:10:55

forwardedly Scotland on shore, leaving aside oil at the

0:10:550:10:55

forwardedly Scotland on shore, leaving aside oil at the moment,

0:10:550:10:56

leaving aside oil at the moment, raises

0:10:560:10:57

leaving aside oil at the moment, raises about

0:10:570:10:57

leaving aside oil at the moment, raises about 1%

0:10:570:10:58

leaving aside oil at the moment, raises about 1% less

0:10:580:10:58

leaving aside oil at the moment, raises about 1% less every

0:10:580:10:58

leaving aside oil at the moment, raises about 1% less every year

0:10:580:10:58

leaving aside oil at the moment, raises about 1% less every year per

0:10:580:10:59

leaving aside oil at the moment, head in

0:10:590:10:59

leaving aside oil at the moment, head in tax

0:10:590:10:59

leaving aside oil at the moment, head in tax than

0:10:590:11:00

leaving aside oil at the moment, head in tax than the

0:11:000:11:01

leaving aside oil at the moment, head in tax than the UK.

0:11:010:11:02

leaving aside oil at the moment, head in tax than the UK. Scotland

0:11:020:11:02

head in tax than the UK. Scotland spends

0:11:020:11:03

head in tax than the UK. Scotland spends on

0:11:030:11:03

head in tax than the UK. Scotland spends on shore

0:11:030:11:04

head in tax than the UK. Scotland spends on shore about

0:11:040:11:04

head in tax than the UK. Scotland spends on shore about 11%

0:11:040:11:05

head in tax than the UK. Scotland spends on shore about 11% more

0:11:050:11:05

head in tax than the UK. Scotland spends on shore about 11% more than

0:11:050:11:06

spends on shore about 11% more than the

0:11:060:11:06

spends on shore about 11% more than the UK.

0:11:060:11:06

spends on shore about 11% more than the UK. If

0:11:060:11:06

spends on shore about 11% more than the UK. If that

0:11:060:11:07

spends on shore about 11% more than the UK. If that was all

0:11:070:11:07

spends on shore about 11% more than the UK. If that was all there

0:11:070:11:08

spends on shore about 11% more than the UK. If that was all there was

0:11:080:11:08

the UK. If that was all there was to

0:11:080:11:08

the UK. If that was all there was to it

0:11:080:11:08

the UK. If that was all there was to it Scotland

0:11:080:11:08

the UK. If that was all there was to it Scotland would

0:11:080:11:09

the UK. If that was all there was to it Scotland would be

0:11:090:11:09

the UK. If that was all there was to it Scotland would be in

0:11:090:11:09

the UK. If that was all there was to it Scotland would be in big

0:11:090:11:09

to it Scotland would be in big trouble.

0:11:090:11:10

to it Scotland would be in big trouble. But

0:11:100:11:10

to it Scotland would be in big trouble. But of

0:11:100:11:10

to it Scotland would be in big trouble. But of course

0:11:100:11:11

to it Scotland would be in big trouble. But of course an

0:11:110:11:11

trouble. But of course an independent

0:11:110:11:12

trouble. But of course an independent Scotland

0:11:120:11:12

trouble. But of course an independent Scotland would

0:11:120:11:12

trouble. But of course an independent Scotland would have

0:11:120:11:12

trouble. But of course an independent Scotland would have the

0:11:120:11:13

independent Scotland would have the oil.

0:11:130:11:13

independent Scotland would have the oil. The

0:11:130:11:13

independent Scotland would have the oil. The oil

0:11:130:11:14

independent Scotland would have the oil. The oil almost

0:11:140:11:14

independent Scotland would have the oil. The oil almost makes

0:11:140:11:14

independent Scotland would have the oil. The oil almost makes up

0:11:140:11:15

oil. The oil almost makes up the difference,

0:11:150:11:16

oil. The oil almost makes up the difference, and

0:11:160:11:16

oil. The oil almost makes up the difference, and the

0:11:160:11:17

oil. The oil almost makes up the difference, and the problem

0:11:170:11:17

oil. The oil almost makes up the difference, and the problem for

0:11:170:11:18

oil. The oil almost makes up the difference, and the problem for an

0:11:180:11:18

difference, and the problem for an independent

0:11:180:11:18

difference, and the problem for an independent Scotland

0:11:180:11:18

difference, and the problem for an independent Scotland however

0:11:180:11:19

difference, and the problem for an independent Scotland however was

0:11:190:11:19

difference, and the problem for an independent Scotland however was if

0:11:190:11:19

independent Scotland however was if it

0:11:190:11:19

independent Scotland however was if it spent

0:11:190:11:20

independent Scotland however was if it spent all the

0:11:200:11:20

independent Scotland however was if it spent all the oil

0:11:200:11:20

independent Scotland however was if it spent all the oil it

0:11:200:11:21

independent Scotland however was if it spent all the oil it couldn't

0:11:210:11:21

it spent all the oil it couldn't save

0:11:210:11:21

it spent all the oil it couldn't save it

0:11:210:11:22

it spent all the oil it couldn't save it as

0:11:220:11:22

it spent all the oil it couldn't save it as well.

0:11:220:11:22

it spent all the oil it couldn't save it as well. And

0:11:220:11:23

it spent all the oil it couldn't save it as well. And if

0:11:230:11:23

it spent all the oil it couldn't save it as well. And if you're

0:11:230:11:23

save it as well. And if you're going

0:11:230:11:24

save it as well. And if you're going to

0:11:240:11:24

save it as well. And if you're going to have

0:11:240:11:24

save it as well. And if you're going to have oil,

0:11:240:11:24

save it as well. And if you're going to have oil, one

0:11:240:11:24

save it as well. And if you're going to have oil, one of

0:11:240:11:25

save it as well. And if you're going to have oil, one of the

0:11:250:11:25

going to have oil, one of the things

0:11:250:11:25

going to have oil, one of the things you

0:11:250:11:25

going to have oil, one of the things you should

0:11:250:11:25

going to have oil, one of the things you should do

0:11:250:11:26

going to have oil, one of the things you should do is

0:11:260:11:27

going to have oil, one of the things you should do is save

0:11:270:11:27

going to have oil, one of the things you should do is save it,

0:11:270:11:27

things you should do is save it, because

0:11:270:11:28

things you should do is save it, because you

0:11:280:11:28

things you should do is save it, because you can't

0:11:280:11:28

things you should do is save it, because you can't both

0:11:280:11:28

things you should do is save it, because you can't both save

0:11:280:11:28

things you should do is save it, because you can't both save it

0:11:280:11:29

things you should do is save it, because you can't both save it and

0:11:290:11:29

because you can't both save it and spend

0:11:290:11:30

because you can't both save it and spend it.

0:11:300:11:30

because you can't both save it and spend it. You

0:11:300:11:31

because you can't both save it and spend it. You are

0:11:310:11:31

because you can't both save it and spend it. You are a

0:11:310:11:32

because you can't both save it and spend it. You are a businessman

0:11:320:11:32

because you can't both save it and spend it. You are a businessman who

0:11:320:11:32

spend it. You are a businessman who supports

0:11:320:11:33

spend it. You are a businessman who supports independence

0:11:330:11:33

spend it. You are a businessman who supports independence you

0:11:330:11:33

spend it. You are a businessman who supports independence you are

0:11:330:11:33

supports independence you are shaking

0:11:330:11:34

supports independence you are shaking your

0:11:340:11:35

supports independence you are shaking your head

0:11:350:11:35

supports independence you are shaking your head violently?

0:11:350:11:36

supports independence you are shaking your head violently? I

0:11:360:11:36

shaking your head violently? I think

0:11:360:11:36

shaking your head violently? I think that

0:11:360:11:36

shaking your head violently? I think that is

0:11:360:11:37

shaking your head violently? I think that is being

0:11:370:11:37

shaking your head violently? I think that is being disingenious

0:11:370:11:37

think that is being disingenious with

0:11:370:11:38

think that is being disingenious with the

0:11:380:11:38

think that is being disingenious with the numbers.

0:11:380:11:39

think that is being disingenious with the numbers. I'm

0:11:390:11:40

think that is being disingenious with the numbers. I'm not

0:11:400:11:40

think that is being disingenious with the numbers. I'm not blessed

0:11:400:11:40

with the numbers. I'm not blessed with

0:11:400:11:41

with the numbers. I'm not blessed with a

0:11:410:11:41

with the numbers. I'm not blessed with a career

0:11:410:11:41

with the numbers. I'm not blessed with a career in

0:11:410:11:41

with the numbers. I'm not blessed with a career in the

0:11:410:11:42

with the numbers. I'm not blessed with a career in the Civil

0:11:420:11:42

with the numbers. I'm not blessed with a career in the Civil Service,

0:11:420:11:42

with a career in the Civil Service, I

0:11:420:11:42

with a career in the Civil Service, I buy

0:11:420:11:43

with a career in the Civil Service, I buy and

0:11:430:11:43

with a career in the Civil Service, I buy and sell

0:11:430:11:43

with a career in the Civil Service, I buy and sell companies

0:11:430:11:43

with a career in the Civil Service, I buy and sell companies and

0:11:430:11:44

with a career in the Civil Service, I buy and sell companies and add

0:11:440:11:44

with a career in the Civil Service, I buy and sell companies and add up

0:11:440:11:45

I buy and sell companies and add up numbers

0:11:450:11:45

I buy and sell companies and add up numbers as

0:11:450:11:45

I buy and sell companies and add up numbers as well.

0:11:450:11:45

I buy and sell companies and add up numbers as well. I

0:11:450:11:46

I buy and sell companies and add up numbers as well. I was

0:11:460:11:46

I buy and sell companies and add up numbers as well. I was sceptical

0:11:460:11:46

numbers as well. I was sceptical about

0:11:460:11:46

numbers as well. I was sceptical about the

0:11:460:11:47

numbers as well. I was sceptical about the numbers

0:11:470:11:47

numbers as well. I was sceptical about the numbers last

0:11:470:11:47

numbers as well. I was sceptical about the numbers last yeeark

0:11:470:11:47

numbers as well. I was sceptical about the numbers last yeeark I

0:11:470:11:47

numbers as well. I was sceptical about the numbers last yeeark I had

0:11:470:11:48

about the numbers last yeeark I had a

0:11:480:11:48

about the numbers last yeeark I had a good

0:11:480:11:48

about the numbers last yeeark I had a good look

0:11:480:11:48

about the numbers last yeeark I had a good look at

0:11:480:11:48

about the numbers last yeeark I had a good look at them,

0:11:480:11:49

about the numbers last yeeark I had a good look at them, as

0:11:490:11:49

about the numbers last yeeark I had a good look at them, as if

0:11:490:11:49

about the numbers last yeeark I had a good look at them, as if I

0:11:490:11:50

about the numbers last yeeark I had a good look at them, as if I would

0:11:500:11:50

a good look at them, as if I would do

0:11:500:11:50

a good look at them, as if I would do if

0:11:500:11:50

a good look at them, as if I would do if I

0:11:500:11:51

a good look at them, as if I would do if I was

0:11:510:11:51

a good look at them, as if I would do if I was buying

0:11:510:11:51

a good look at them, as if I would do if I was buying a

0:11:510:11:51

a good look at them, as if I would do if I was buying a company.

0:11:510:11:52

a good look at them, as if I would do if I was buying a company. I

0:11:520:11:52

do if I was buying a company. I have

0:11:520:11:52

do if I was buying a company. I have been

0:11:520:11:53

do if I was buying a company. I have been right

0:11:530:11:53

do if I was buying a company. I have been right through

0:11:530:11:53

do if I was buying a company. I have been right through the

0:11:530:11:53

do if I was buying a company. I have been right through the number,

0:11:530:11:54

have been right through the number, they

0:11:540:11:54

have been right through the number, they are

0:11:540:11:54

have been right through the number, they are available

0:11:540:11:54

have been right through the number, they are available on

0:11:540:11:55

have been right through the number, they are available on the

0:11:550:11:55

have been right through the number, they are available on the Internet

0:11:550:11:55

they are available on the Internet if

0:11:550:11:55

they are available on the Internet if you

0:11:550:11:55

they are available on the Internet if you want

0:11:550:11:56

they are available on the Internet if you want to

0:11:560:11:56

they are available on the Internet if you want to use

0:11:560:11:56

they are available on the Internet if you want to use them.

0:11:560:11:57

they are available on the Internet if you want to use them. What

0:11:570:11:57

they are available on the Internet if you want to use them. What they

0:11:570:11:58

if you want to use them. What they say

0:11:580:11:58

if you want to use them. What they say is

0:11:580:11:59

if you want to use them. What they say is what

0:11:590:11:59

if you want to use them. What they say is what Nicola

0:11:590:11:59

if you want to use them. What they say is what Nicola said.

0:11:590:12:00

if you want to use them. What they say is what Nicola said. Scotland

0:12:000:12:00

say is what Nicola said. Scotland raises

0:12:000:12:01

say is what Nicola said. Scotland raises £1700

0:12:010:12:01

say is what Nicola said. Scotland raises £1700 more

0:12:010:12:01

say is what Nicola said. Scotland raises £1700 more than

0:12:010:12:01

say is what Nicola said. Scotland raises £1700 more than the

0:12:010:12:02

say is what Nicola said. Scotland raises £1700 more than the UK

0:12:020:12:02

raises £1700 more than the UK average,

0:12:020:12:03

raises £1700 more than the UK average, spends

0:12:030:12:03

raises £1700 more than the UK average, spends more

0:12:030:12:05

raises £1700 more than the UK average, spends more than

0:12:050:12:05

raises £1700 more than the UK average, spends more than £1200

0:12:050:12:06

average, spends more than £1200 than

0:12:060:12:06

average, spends more than £1200 than the

0:12:060:12:07

average, spends more than £1200 than the UK

0:12:070:12:07

average, spends more than £1200 than the UK average.

0:12:070:12:07

average, spends more than £1200 than the UK average. The

0:12:070:12:07

average, spends more than £1200 than the UK average. The finances

0:12:070:12:08

than the UK average. The finances are

0:12:080:12:08

than the UK average. The finances are extremely

0:12:080:12:08

than the UK average. The finances are extremely strong

0:12:080:12:08

than the UK average. The finances are extremely strong in

0:12:080:12:09

than the UK average. The finances are extremely strong in the

0:12:090:12:09

than the UK average. The finances are extremely strong in the context,

0:12:090:12:09

are extremely strong in the context, there

0:12:090:12:09

are extremely strong in the context, there is

0:12:090:12:10

are extremely strong in the context, there is no

0:12:100:12:10

are extremely strong in the context, there is no debate

0:12:100:12:10

are extremely strong in the context, there is no debate about

0:12:100:12:11

are extremely strong in the context, there is no debate about it,

0:12:110:12:11

are extremely strong in the context, there is no debate about it, it

0:12:110:12:11

are extremely strong in the context, there is no debate about it, it is

0:12:110:12:12

there is no debate about it, it is a

0:12:120:12:12

there is no debate about it, it is a fact.

0:12:120:12:12

there is no debate about it, it is a fact. Let's

0:12:120:12:12

there is no debate about it, it is a fact. Let's look

0:12:120:12:13

there is no debate about it, it is a fact. Let's look at

0:12:130:12:14

there is no debate about it, it is a fact. Let's look at the

0:12:140:12:14

there is no debate about it, it is a fact. Let's look at the question

0:12:140:12:14

a fact. Let's look at the question of

0:12:140:12:14

a fact. Let's look at the question of oil,

0:12:140:12:16

a fact. Let's look at the question of oil, where

0:12:160:12:16

a fact. Let's look at the question of oil, where do

0:12:160:12:16

a fact. Let's look at the question of oil, where do we

0:12:160:12:16

a fact. Let's look at the question of oil, where do we stand

0:12:160:12:17

a fact. Let's look at the question of oil, where do we stand on

0:12:170:12:17

a fact. Let's look at the question of oil, where do we stand on oil?

0:12:170:12:18

of oil, where do we stand on oil? Because

0:12:180:12:18

of oil, where do we stand on oil? Because of

0:12:180:12:19

of oil, where do we stand on oil? Because of course

0:12:190:12:19

of oil, where do we stand on oil? Because of course the

0:12:190:12:19

of oil, where do we stand on oil? Because of course the oil

0:12:190:12:20

of oil, where do we stand on oil? Because of course the oil price

0:12:200:12:20

of oil, where do we stand on oil? Because of course the oil price is

0:12:200:12:21

Because of course the oil price is volatile.

0:12:210:12:21

Because of course the oil price is volatile. For

0:12:210:12:21

Because of course the oil price is volatile. For the

0:12:210:12:21

Because of course the oil price is volatile. For the nationalists

0:12:210:12:22

Because of course the oil price is volatile. For the nationalists to

0:12:220:12:22

volatile. For the nationalists to say

0:12:220:12:22

volatile. For the nationalists to say a

0:12:220:12:23

volatile. For the nationalists to say a lot

0:12:230:12:23

volatile. For the nationalists to say a lot of

0:12:230:12:23

volatile. For the nationalists to say a lot of their

0:12:230:12:24

volatile. For the nationalists to say a lot of their spending

0:12:240:12:24

volatile. For the nationalists to say a lot of their spending is

0:12:240:12:24

say a lot of their spending is predicated

0:12:240:12:25

say a lot of their spending is predicated on

0:12:250:12:26

say a lot of their spending is predicated on the

0:12:260:12:26

say a lot of their spending is predicated on the oil price

0:12:260:12:26

say a lot of their spending is predicated on the oil price is

0:12:260:12:26

predicated on the oil price is tricky,

0:12:260:12:27

predicated on the oil price is tricky, because

0:12:270:12:27

predicated on the oil price is tricky, because we

0:12:270:12:27

predicated on the oil price is tricky, because we don't

0:12:270:12:28

predicated on the oil price is tricky, because we don't know

0:12:280:12:28

predicated on the oil price is tricky, because we don't know in

0:12:280:12:28

tricky, because we don't know in the

0:12:280:12:29

tricky, because we don't know in the UK

0:12:290:12:29

tricky, because we don't know in the UK whose

0:12:290:12:30

tricky, because we don't know in the UK whose revenues

0:12:300:12:30

tricky, because we don't know in the UK whose revenues are

0:12:300:12:31

tricky, because we don't know in the UK whose revenues are who's

0:12:310:12:31

tricky, because we don't know in the UK whose revenues are who's in

0:12:310:12:31

the UK whose revenues are who's in the

0:12:310:12:31

the UK whose revenues are who's in the oil?

0:12:310:12:32

the UK whose revenues are who's in the oil? Oil

0:12:320:12:32

the UK whose revenues are who's in the oil? Oil is

0:12:320:12:32

the UK whose revenues are who's in the oil? Oil is a

0:12:320:12:32

the UK whose revenues are who's in the oil? Oil is a huge

0:12:320:12:33

the UK whose revenues are who's in the oil? Oil is a huge resource

0:12:330:12:33

the UK whose revenues are who's in the oil? Oil is a huge resource and

0:12:330:12:33

the oil? Oil is a huge resource and much

0:12:330:12:34

the oil? Oil is a huge resource and much of

0:12:340:12:34

the oil? Oil is a huge resource and much of it

0:12:340:12:34

the oil? Oil is a huge resource and much of it would

0:12:340:12:35

the oil? Oil is a huge resource and much of it would accrue

0:12:350:12:35

the oil? Oil is a huge resource and much of it would accrue to

0:12:350:12:35

the oil? Oil is a huge resource and much of it would accrue to Scotland

0:12:350:12:35

much of it would accrue to Scotland it

0:12:350:12:35

much of it would accrue to Scotland it is

0:12:350:12:36

much of it would accrue to Scotland it is assumed

0:12:360:12:36

much of it would accrue to Scotland it is assumed in

0:12:360:12:37

much of it would accrue to Scotland it is assumed in the

0:12:370:12:37

much of it would accrue to Scotland it is assumed in the event

0:12:370:12:37

much of it would accrue to Scotland it is assumed in the event of

0:12:370:12:37

it is assumed in the event of independent.

0:12:370:12:38

it is assumed in the event of independent. As

0:12:380:12:38

it is assumed in the event of independent. As you

0:12:380:12:38

it is assumed in the event of independent. As you say

0:12:380:12:39

it is assumed in the event of independent. As you say the value

0:12:390:12:39

independent. As you say the value of

0:12:390:12:39

independent. As you say the value of oil

0:12:390:12:39

independent. As you say the value of oil goes

0:12:390:12:40

independent. As you say the value of oil goes up

0:12:400:12:40

independent. As you say the value of oil goes up and

0:12:400:12:40

independent. As you say the value of oil goes up and down,

0:12:400:12:40

independent. As you say the value of oil goes up and down, what

0:12:400:12:41

independent. As you say the value of oil goes up and down, what the

0:12:410:12:41

of oil goes up and down, what the SNP

0:12:410:12:41

of oil goes up and down, what the SNP would

0:12:410:12:42

of oil goes up and down, what the SNP would hope

0:12:420:12:42

of oil goes up and down, what the SNP would hope to

0:12:420:12:42

of oil goes up and down, what the SNP would hope to do

0:12:420:12:42

of oil goes up and down, what the SNP would hope to do is

0:12:420:12:43

of oil goes up and down, what the SNP would hope to do is to

0:12:430:12:43

of oil goes up and down, what the SNP would hope to do is to TUC

0:12:430:12:44

of oil goes up and down, what the SNP would hope to do is to TUC away

0:12:440:12:44

SNP would hope to do is to TUC away some

0:12:440:12:44

SNP would hope to do is to TUC away some of

0:12:440:12:44

SNP would hope to do is to TUC away some of that

0:12:440:12:44

SNP would hope to do is to TUC away some of that money

0:12:440:12:45

SNP would hope to do is to TUC away some of that money --

0:12:450:12:45

SNP would hope to do is to TUC away some of that money -- tuck

0:12:450:12:45

SNP would hope to do is to TUC away some of that money -- tuck away

0:12:450:12:45

some of that money -- tuck away some

0:12:450:12:46

some of that money -- tuck away some of

0:12:460:12:46

some of that money -- tuck away some of that

0:12:460:12:46

some of that money -- tuck away some of that money

0:12:460:12:47

some of that money -- tuck away some of that money and

0:12:470:12:47

some of that money -- tuck away some of that money and save

0:12:470:12:47

some of that money -- tuck away some of that money and save it,

0:12:470:12:48

some of that money -- tuck away some of that money and save it, as

0:12:480:12:48

some of that money and save it, as Norway

0:12:480:12:48

some of that money and save it, as Norway has,

0:12:480:12:48

some of that money and save it, as Norway has, to

0:12:480:12:49

some of that money and save it, as Norway has, to invest

0:12:490:12:49

some of that money and save it, as Norway has, to invest in

0:12:490:12:49

some of that money and save it, as Norway has, to invest in the

0:12:490:12:50

some of that money and save it, as Norway has, to invest in the future

0:12:500:12:50

Norway has, to invest in the future and

0:12:500:12:50

Norway has, to invest in the future and times

0:12:500:12:50

Norway has, to invest in the future and times when

0:12:500:12:50

Norway has, to invest in the future and times when things

0:12:500:12:51

Norway has, to invest in the future and times when things are

0:12:510:12:51

Norway has, to invest in the future and times when things are tougher.

0:12:510:12:52

and times when things are tougher. The

0:12:520:12:52

and times when things are tougher. The question

0:12:520:12:53

and times when things are tougher. The question that

0:12:530:12:53

and times when things are tougher. The question that was

0:12:530:12:54

and times when things are tougher. The question that was raised

0:12:540:12:54

and times when things are tougher. The question that was raised a

0:12:540:12:54

The question that was raised a moment

0:12:540:12:55

The question that was raised a moment or

0:12:550:12:55

The question that was raised a moment or too ago

0:12:550:12:56

The question that was raised a moment or too ago by

0:12:560:12:56

The question that was raised a moment or too ago by Jim

0:12:560:12:56

The question that was raised a moment or too ago by Jim Gallagher

0:12:560:12:57

moment or too ago by Jim Gallagher is

0:12:570:12:57

moment or too ago by Jim Gallagher is at

0:12:570:12:57

moment or too ago by Jim Gallagher is at what

0:12:570:12:57

moment or too ago by Jim Gallagher is at what point would

0:12:570:12:58

moment or too ago by Jim Gallagher is at what point would they

0:12:580:12:58

moment or too ago by Jim Gallagher is at what point would they be

0:12:580:12:58

moment or too ago by Jim Gallagher is at what point would they be able

0:12:580:12:58

is at what point would they be able to

0:12:580:12:58

is at what point would they be able to do

0:12:580:12:59

is at what point would they be able to do that

0:12:590:12:59

is at what point would they be able to do that if

0:12:590:13:00

is at what point would they be able to do that if on

0:13:000:13:00

is at what point would they be able to do that if on day

0:13:000:13:00

is at what point would they be able to do that if on day one

0:13:000:13:00

is at what point would they be able to do that if on day one much

0:13:000:13:00

is at what point would they be able to do that if on day one much of

0:13:000:13:01

to do that if on day one much of the

0:13:010:13:01

to do that if on day one much of the money

0:13:010:13:01

to do that if on day one much of the money was

0:13:010:13:01

to do that if on day one much of the money was already

0:13:010:13:02

to do that if on day one much of the money was already allocated

0:13:020:13:02

to do that if on day one much of the money was already allocated to

0:13:020:13:03

the money was already allocated to other

0:13:030:13:03

the money was already allocated to other things.

0:13:030:13:03

the money was already allocated to other things. One

0:13:030:13:03

the money was already allocated to other things. One of

0:13:030:13:04

the money was already allocated to other things. One of the things

0:13:040:13:04

the money was already allocated to other things. One of the things is

0:13:040:13:04

other things. One of the things is that

0:13:040:13:04

other things. One of the things is that we

0:13:040:13:05

other things. One of the things is that we don't

0:13:050:13:05

other things. One of the things is that we don't hear

0:13:050:13:06

other things. One of the things is that we don't hear very

0:13:060:13:06

other things. One of the things is that we don't hear very much

0:13:060:13:06

other things. One of the things is that we don't hear very much about

0:13:060:13:06

that we don't hear very much about an

0:13:060:13:06

that we don't hear very much about an oil

0:13:060:13:06

that we don't hear very much about an oil fund

0:13:060:13:07

that we don't hear very much about an oil fund from

0:13:070:13:08

that we don't hear very much about an oil fund from John

0:13:080:13:08

that we don't hear very much about an oil fund from John Swinny

0:13:080:13:09

that we don't hear very much about an oil fund from John Swinny any

0:13:090:13:09

an oil fund from John Swinny any more,

0:13:090:13:10

an oil fund from John Swinny any more, he's

0:13:100:13:10

an oil fund from John Swinny any more, he's a

0:13:100:13:10

an oil fund from John Swinny any more, he's a realist

0:13:100:13:10

an oil fund from John Swinny any more, he's a realist and

0:13:100:13:11

an oil fund from John Swinny any more, he's a realist and on

0:13:110:13:11

an oil fund from John Swinny any more, he's a realist and on current

0:13:110:13:11

more, he's a realist and on current projections

0:13:110:13:11

more, he's a realist and on current projections there

0:13:110:13:12

more, he's a realist and on current projections there isn't

0:13:120:13:12

more, he's a realist and on current projections there isn't the

0:13:120:13:12

more, he's a realist and on current projections there isn't the money

0:13:120:13:12

projections there isn't the money for

0:13:120:13:13

projections there isn't the money for an

0:13:130:13:13

projections there isn't the money for an oil

0:13:130:13:13

projections there isn't the money for an oil fund

0:13:130:13:13

projections there isn't the money for an oil fund and

0:13:130:13:14

projections there isn't the money for an oil fund and the

0:13:140:13:14

projections there isn't the money for an oil fund and the spending

0:13:140:13:14

for an oil fund and the spending commitments

0:13:140:13:16

for an oil fund and the spending commitments that the SNP have

0:13:160:13:16

commitments that the SNP have currently

0:13:160:13:17

commitments that the SNP have currently made

0:13:170:13:17

commitments that the SNP have currently made for

0:13:170:13:17

commitments that the SNP have currently made for future

0:13:170:13:17

commitments that the SNP have currently made for future of

0:13:170:13:17

commitments that the SNP have currently made for future of an

0:13:170:13:18

commitments that the SNP have independent Scotland.

0:13:180:13:18

commitments that the SNP have independent Scotland. One

0:13:180:13:18

commitments that the SNP have independent Scotland. One of

0:13:180:13:19

commitments that the SNP have independent Scotland. One of the

0:13:190:13:19

independent Scotland. One of the things

0:13:190:13:19

independent Scotland. One of the things we

0:13:190:13:19

independent Scotland. One of the things we also

0:13:190:13:20

independent Scotland. One of the things we also see

0:13:200:13:20

independent Scotland. One of the things we also see is

0:13:200:13:21

independent Scotland. One of the things we also see is according

0:13:210:13:21

independent Scotland. One of the things we also see is according to

0:13:210:13:22

independent Scotland. One of the recent polls

0:13:220:13:23

independent Scotland. One of the recent polls something

0:13:230:13:24

independent Scotland. One of the recent polls something like

0:13:240:13:24

independent Scotland. One of the recent polls something like 59% of

0:13:240:13:25

recent polls something like 59% of Scots

0:13:250:13:25

recent polls something like 59% of Scots expect

0:13:250:13:25

recent polls something like 59% of Scots expect taxes

0:13:250:13:26

recent polls something like 59% of Scots expect taxes to

0:13:260:13:26

recent polls something like 59% of Scots expect taxes to go

0:13:260:13:26

recent polls something like 59% of Scots expect taxes to go up

0:13:260:13:27

recent polls something like 59% of Scots expect taxes to go up after

0:13:270:13:27

Scots expect taxes to go up after independent.

0:13:270:13:27

Scots expect taxes to go up after independent. It

0:13:270:13:28

Scots expect taxes to go up after independent. It is

0:13:280:13:28

Scots expect taxes to go up after independent. It is not

0:13:280:13:28

Scots expect taxes to go up after independent. It is not difficult

0:13:280:13:29

independent. It is not difficult but

0:13:290:13:29

independent. It is not difficult but only

0:13:290:13:29

independent. It is not difficult but only 29%

0:13:290:13:30

independent. It is not difficult but only 29% think

0:13:300:13:30

independent. It is not difficult but only 29% think public

0:13:300:13:30

independent. It is not difficult but only 29% think public services

0:13:300:13:31

but only 29% think public services would

0:13:310:13:31

but only 29% think public services would improve.

0:13:310:13:31

but only 29% think public services would improve. And

0:13:310:13:32

but only 29% think public services would improve. And it

0:13:320:13:32

but only 29% think public services would improve. And it is

0:13:320:13:32

but only 29% think public services would improve. And it is not

0:13:320:13:33

would improve. And it is not difficult

0:13:330:13:33

would improve. And it is not difficult to

0:13:330:13:33

would improve. And it is not difficult to imagine

0:13:330:13:33

would improve. And it is not difficult to imagine that

0:13:330:13:34

would improve. And it is not difficult to imagine that this

0:13:340:13:34

would improve. And it is not difficult to imagine that this puts

0:13:340:13:35

difficult to imagine that this puts something

0:13:350:13:35

difficult to imagine that this puts something of

0:13:350:13:35

difficult to imagine that this puts something of a

0:13:350:13:35

difficult to imagine that this puts something of a brake

0:13:350:13:36

difficult to imagine that this puts something of a brake upon

0:13:360:13:37

difficult to imagine that this puts something of a brake upon people's

0:13:370:13:37

something of a brake upon people's enthusiasm

0:13:370:13:37

something of a brake upon people's enthusiasm for

0:13:370:13:38

something of a brake upon people's enthusiasm for independent.

0:13:380:13:39

something of a brake upon people's enthusiasm for independent. People

0:13:390:13:39

enthusiasm for independent. People used

0:13:390:13:39

enthusiasm for independent. People used to

0:13:390:13:39

enthusiasm for independent. People used to use

0:13:390:13:40

enthusiasm for independent. People used to use these

0:13:400:13:41

enthusiasm for independent. People used to use these self-same

0:13:410:13:41

used to use these self-same arguments

0:13:410:13:42

used to use these self-same arguments before

0:13:420:13:42

used to use these self-same arguments before the

0:13:420:13:42

used to use these self-same arguments before the Scottish

0:13:420:13:42

arguments before the Scottish Parliament

0:13:420:13:43

arguments before the Scottish Parliament was

0:13:430:13:43

arguments before the Scottish Parliament was in

0:13:430:13:43

arguments before the Scottish Parliament was in existence.

0:13:430:13:44

arguments before the Scottish Parliament was in existence. People

0:13:440:13:44

Parliament was in existence. People were

0:13:440:13:45

Parliament was in existence. People were saying

0:13:450:13:45

Parliament was in existence. People were saying business

0:13:450:13:45

Parliament was in existence. People were saying business will

0:13:450:13:46

Parliament was in existence. People were saying business will leave,

0:13:460:13:47

were saying business will leave, taxes

0:13:470:13:47

were saying business will leave, taxes will

0:13:470:13:47

were saying business will leave, taxes will go

0:13:470:13:47

were saying business will leave, taxes will go up

0:13:470:13:47

were saying business will leave, taxes will go up and

0:13:470:13:48

were saying business will leave, taxes will go up and public

0:13:480:13:48

taxes will go up and public services

0:13:480:13:49

taxes will go up and public services will

0:13:490:13:49

taxes will go up and public services will deteriorate.

0:13:490:13:49

taxes will go up and public services will deteriorate. On

0:13:490:13:49

taxes will go up and public services will deteriorate. On the

0:13:490:13:50

services will deteriorate. On the contrary

0:13:500:13:50

services will deteriorate. On the contrary public

0:13:500:13:50

services will deteriorate. On the contrary public services

0:13:500:13:51

services will deteriorate. On the contrary public services have

0:13:510:13:51

contrary public services have strengthened

0:13:510:13:52

contrary public services have strengthened in

0:13:520:13:52

contrary public services have strengthened in Scotland.

0:13:520:13:52

contrary public services have strengthened in Scotland. We

0:13:520:13:52

contrary public services have strengthened in Scotland. We have

0:13:520:13:52

strengthened in Scotland. We have not

0:13:520:13:53

strengthened in Scotland. We have not seen

0:13:530:13:53

strengthened in Scotland. We have not seen taxes

0:13:530:13:53

strengthened in Scotland. We have not seen taxes go

0:13:530:13:53

strengthened in Scotland. We have not seen taxes go up.

0:13:530:13:54

strengthened in Scotland. We have not seen taxes go up. Scotland

0:13:540:13:54

strengthened in Scotland. We have not seen taxes go up. Scotland is

0:13:540:13:55

not seen taxes go up. Scotland is doing

0:13:550:13:55

not seen taxes go up. Scotland is doing well,

0:13:550:13:56

not seen taxes go up. Scotland is doing well, not

0:13:560:13:56

not seen taxes go up. Scotland is doing well, not without

0:13:560:13:56

not seen taxes go up. Scotland is doing well, not without its

0:13:560:13:56

doing well, not without its challenges

0:13:560:13:57

doing well, not without its challenges with

0:13:570:13:57

doing well, not without its challenges with the

0:13:570:13:57

doing well, not without its challenges with the Scottish

0:13:570:13:57

challenges with the Scottish Parliament.

0:13:570:13:58

challenges with the Scottish Parliament. What

0:13:580:13:58

challenges with the Scottish Parliament. What we

0:13:580:13:58

challenges with the Scottish Parliament. What we want

0:13:580:13:58

challenges with the Scottish Parliament. What we want to

0:13:580:13:58

challenges with the Scottish Parliament. What we want to do

0:13:580:13:59

challenges with the Scottish Parliament. What we want to do is

0:13:590:13:59

Parliament. What we want to do is complete

0:13:590:13:59

Parliament. What we want to do is complete the powers

0:13:590:13:59

Parliament. What we want to do is complete the powers of

0:13:590:14:00

complete the powers of the parliament

0:14:000:14:00

complete the powers of the parliament and

0:14:000:14:00

complete the powers of the parliament and take

0:14:000:14:01

complete the powers of the parliament and take it

0:14:010:14:01

complete the powers of the parliament and take it to

0:14:010:14:01

complete the powers of the parliament and take it to its

0:14:010:14:02

parliament and take it to its logical

0:14:020:14:02

parliament and take it to its logical conclusion.

0:14:020:14:02

parliament and take it to its logical conclusion. Living

0:14:020:14:02

logical conclusion. Living standards

0:14:020:14:02

logical conclusion. Living standards in

0:14:020:14:03

logical conclusion. Living standards in the

0:14:030:14:03

logical conclusion. Living standards in the UK

0:14:030:14:03

logical conclusion. Living standards in the UK right

0:14:030:14:03

logical conclusion. Living standards in the UK right now

0:14:030:14:05

logical conclusion. Living standards in the UK right now are

0:14:050:14:05

standards in the UK right now are falling.

0:14:050:14:05

standards in the UK right now are falling. The

0:14:050:14:05

standards in the UK right now are falling. The power

0:14:050:14:05

standards in the UK right now are falling. The power of

0:14:050:14:06

standards in the UK right now are falling. The power of independence

0:14:060:14:06

falling. The power of independence is

0:14:060:14:06

falling. The power of independence is getting

0:14:060:14:06

falling. The power of independence is getting your

0:14:060:14:07

falling. The power of independence is getting your hands

0:14:070:14:07

falling. The power of independence is getting your hands on

0:14:070:14:07

falling. The power of independence is getting your hands on the

0:14:070:14:07

falling. The power of independence is getting your hands on the levers

0:14:070:14:08

is getting your hands on the levers of

0:14:080:14:08

is getting your hands on the levers of the

0:14:080:14:08

is getting your hands on the levers of the economy

0:14:080:14:08

is getting your hands on the levers of the economy to

0:14:080:14:08

is getting your hands on the levers of the economy to grow

0:14:080:14:09

is getting your hands on the levers of the economy to grow the

0:14:090:14:09

is getting your hands on the levers of the economy to grow the economy

0:14:090:14:10

of the economy to grow the economy faster

0:14:100:14:11

of the economy to grow the economy faster and

0:14:110:14:11

of the economy to grow the economy faster and make

0:14:110:14:12

of the economy to grow the economy faster and make people better.

0:14:120:14:12

of the economy to grow the economy faster and make people better. We

0:14:120:14:12

faster and make people better. We will

0:14:120:14:13

faster and make people better. We will talk

0:14:130:14:13

faster and make people better. We will talk about

0:14:130:14:13

faster and make people better. We will talk about getting

0:14:130:14:13

faster and make people better. We will talk about getting your

0:14:130:14:14

faster and make people better. We will talk about getting your hands

0:14:140:14:14

will talk about getting your hands on

0:14:140:14:14

will talk about getting your hands on the

0:14:140:14:14

will talk about getting your hands on the lever

0:14:140:14:14

will talk about getting your hands on the lever of

0:14:140:14:15

will talk about getting your hands on the lever of the

0:14:150:14:15

will talk about getting your hands on the lever of the economy

0:14:150:14:15

will talk about getting your hands on the lever of the economy and

0:14:150:14:16

on the lever of the economy and talking

0:14:160:14:16

on the lever of the economy and talking about

0:14:160:14:16

on the lever of the economy and talking about the

0:14:160:14:16

on the lever of the economy and talking about the debt

0:14:160:14:17

on the lever of the economy and talking about the debt and

0:14:170:14:17

on the lever of the economy and talking about the debt and so

0:14:170:14:17

on the lever of the economy and talking about the debt and so forth.

0:14:170:14:17

talking about the debt and so forth. We

0:14:170:14:18

talking about the debt and so forth. We have

0:14:180:14:18

talking about the debt and so forth. We have a

0:14:180:14:18

talking about the debt and so forth. We have a young

0:14:180:14:18

talking about the debt and so forth. We have a young woman

0:14:180:14:19

talking about the debt and so forth. We have a young woman in

0:14:190:14:19

talking about the debt and so forth. We have a young woman in the

0:14:190:14:20

We have a young woman in the audience

0:14:200:14:20

We have a young woman in the audience wanting

0:14:200:14:20

We have a young woman in the audience wanting to

0:14:200:14:21

We have a young woman in the audience wanting to come

0:14:210:14:21

We have a young woman in the audience wanting to come in?

0:14:210:14:22

We have a young woman in the audience wanting to come in? My

0:14:220:14:22

audience wanting to come in? My question

0:14:220:14:22

audience wanting to come in? My question was

0:14:220:14:23

audience wanting to come in? My question was about

0:14:230:14:23

audience wanting to come in? My question was about the

0:14:230:14:23

question was about the affordability

0:14:230:14:24

question was about the affordability and

0:14:240:14:24

question was about the affordability and the

0:14:240:14:24

question was about the affordability and the difference

0:14:240:14:25

question was about the affordability and the difference it

0:14:250:14:25

affordability and the difference it would

0:14:250:14:25

affordability and the difference it would make

0:14:250:14:25

affordability and the difference it would make in

0:14:250:14:25

affordability and the difference it would make in terms

0:14:250:14:26

affordability and the difference it would make in terms of

0:14:260:14:26

affordability and the difference it would make in terms of every

0:14:260:14:26

affordability and the difference it would make in terms of every day

0:14:260:14:26

would make in terms of every day lives

0:14:260:14:27

would make in terms of every day lives and

0:14:270:14:27

would make in terms of every day lives and finances.

0:14:270:14:27

would make in terms of every day lives and finances. There is

0:14:270:14:28

would make in terms of every day lives and finances. There is a

0:14:280:14:28

would make in terms of every day lives and finances. There is a lot

0:14:280:14:28

lives and finances. There is a lot of

0:14:280:14:29

lives and finances. There is a lot of changes in

0:14:290:14:29

lives and finances. There is a lot of changes in public

0:14:290:14:30

lives and finances. There is a lot of changes in public services

0:14:300:14:30

lives and finances. There is a lot of changes in public services and

0:14:300:14:30

of changes in public services and integration,

0:14:300:14:31

of changes in public services and integration, health

0:14:310:14:31

of changes in public services and integration, health and

0:14:310:14:32

of changes in public services and integration, health and social

0:14:320:14:32

of changes in public services and integration, health and social care

0:14:320:14:32

integration, health and social care for

0:14:320:14:32

integration, health and social care for example,

0:14:320:14:33

integration, health and social care for example, all

0:14:330:14:33

integration, health and social care for example, all these

0:14:330:14:33

integration, health and social care for example, all these huge

0:14:330:14:34

integration, health and social care for example, all these huge change

0:14:340:14:35

for example, all these huge change processes,

0:14:350:14:35

for example, all these huge change processes, I

0:14:350:14:35

for example, all these huge change processes, I wondered

0:14:350:14:35

for example, all these huge change processes, I wondered what

0:14:350:14:36

for example, all these huge change processes, I wondered what you

0:14:360:14:36

for example, all these huge change processes, I wondered what you see

0:14:360:14:36

processes, I wondered what you see as

0:14:360:14:37

processes, I wondered what you see as the

0:14:370:14:38

processes, I wondered what you see as the affordability

0:14:380:14:38

processes, I wondered what you see as the affordability and

0:14:380:14:39

processes, I wondered what you see as the affordability and cost

0:14:390:14:40

processes, I wondered what you see as the affordability and cost of

0:14:400:14:41

as the affordability and cost of those

0:14:410:14:41

as the affordability and cost of those processes,

0:14:410:14:41

as the affordability and cost of those processes, aside

0:14:410:14:42

as the affordability and cost of those processes, aside from

0:14:420:14:42

as the affordability and cost of those processes, aside from the

0:14:420:14:42

those processes, aside from the actual

0:14:420:14:43

those processes, aside from the actual real

0:14:430:14:43

those processes, aside from the actual real benefit

0:14:430:14:43

those processes, aside from the actual real benefit you see

0:14:430:14:43

those processes, aside from the actual real benefit you see and

0:14:430:14:44

actual real benefit you see and difference

0:14:440:14:45

actual real benefit you see and difference in

0:14:450:14:45

actual real benefit you see and difference in finances.

0:14:450:14:45

actual real benefit you see and difference in finances. We

0:14:450:14:45

actual real benefit you see and difference in finances. We have an

0:14:450:14:46

difference in finances. We have an ageing

0:14:460:14:46

difference in finances. We have an ageing population,

0:14:460:14:46

difference in finances. We have an ageing population, the

0:14:460:14:46

difference in finances. We have an ageing population, the idea

0:14:460:14:47

difference in finances. We have an ageing population, the idea of

0:14:470:14:47

difference in finances. We have an ageing population, the idea of free

0:14:470:14:48

ageing population, the idea of free personal

0:14:480:14:48

ageing population, the idea of free personal care,

0:14:480:14:48

ageing population, the idea of free personal care, the

0:14:480:14:48

ageing population, the idea of free personal care, the need

0:14:480:14:49

ageing population, the idea of free personal care, the need for

0:14:490:14:50

ageing population, the idea of free personal care, the need for that

0:14:500:14:50

ageing population, the idea of free personal care, the need for that is

0:14:500:14:50

personal care, the need for that is going

0:14:500:14:52

personal care, the need for that is going to

0:14:520:14:53

personal care, the need for that is going to grow

0:14:530:14:53

personal care, the need for that is going to grow exponentialally,

0:14:530:14:54

going to grow exponentialally, interestingly

0:14:540:14:54

going to grow exponentialally, interestingly on

0:14:540:14:54

going to grow exponentialally, interestingly on the

0:14:540:14:54

going to grow exponentialally, interestingly on the English

0:14:540:14:55

going to grow exponentialally, interestingly on the English side

0:14:550:14:56

interestingly on the English side of

0:14:560:14:56

interestingly on the English side of this

0:14:560:14:56

interestingly on the English side of this bridge

0:14:560:14:56

interestingly on the English side of this bridge there

0:14:560:14:57

interestingly on the English side of this bridge there is

0:14:570:14:57

interestingly on the English side of this bridge there is no

0:14:570:14:58

of this bridge there is no free personal

0:14:580:14:58

of this bridge there is no free personal care

0:14:580:14:58

of this bridge there is no free personal care and

0:14:580:14:58

of this bridge there is no free personal care and on

0:14:580:14:59

of this bridge there is no free personal care and on the

0:14:590:14:59

of this bridge there is no free personal care and on the Scottish

0:14:590:14:59

personal care and on the Scottish side

0:14:590:15:00

personal care and on the Scottish side there

0:15:000:15:01

personal care and on the Scottish side there is.

0:15:010:15:01

personal care and on the Scottish side there is. Tessa

0:15:010:15:01

personal care and on the Scottish side there is. Tessa Hartman

0:15:010:15:01

personal care and on the Scottish side there is. Tessa Hartman how

0:15:010:15:02

personal care and on the Scottish side there is. Tessa Hartman how do

0:15:020:15:03

side there is. Tessa Hartman how do you

0:15:030:15:03

side there is. Tessa Hartman how do you think

0:15:030:15:03

side there is. Tessa Hartman how do you think people

0:15:030:15:03

side there is. Tessa Hartman how do you think people view

0:15:030:15:04

side there is. Tessa Hartman how do you think people view in

0:15:040:15:05

side there is. Tessa Hartman how do you think people view in England

0:15:050:15:05

side there is. Tessa Hartman how do you think people view in England as

0:15:050:15:05

you think people view in England as it

0:15:050:15:05

you think people view in England as it were

0:15:050:15:06

you think people view in England as it were the

0:15:060:15:06

you think people view in England as it were the bounty

0:15:060:15:07

you think people view in England as it were the bounty that

0:15:070:15:07

you think people view in England as it were the bounty that comes

0:15:070:15:08

you think people view in England as it were the bounty that comes to

0:15:080:15:08

it were the bounty that comes to Scotland

0:15:080:15:08

it were the bounty that comes to Scotland in

0:15:080:15:09

it were the bounty that comes to Scotland in terms

0:15:090:15:09

it were the bounty that comes to Scotland in terms of

0:15:090:15:09

it were the bounty that comes to Scotland in terms of free

0:15:090:15:10

it were the bounty that comes to Scotland in terms of free personal

0:15:100:15:10

Scotland in terms of free personal care

0:15:100:15:10

Scotland in terms of free personal care and

0:15:100:15:10

Scotland in terms of free personal care and no

0:15:100:15:11

Scotland in terms of free personal care and no tuition

0:15:110:15:11

Scotland in terms of free personal care and no tuition fees?

0:15:110:15:12

Scotland in terms of free personal care and no tuition fees? I

0:15:120:15:12

Scotland in terms of free personal care and no tuition fees? I think

0:15:120:15:12

care and no tuition fees? I think they

0:15:120:15:12

care and no tuition fees? I think they are

0:15:120:15:12

care and no tuition fees? I think they are jealous.

0:15:120:15:13

care and no tuition fees? I think they are jealous. It

0:15:130:15:13

care and no tuition fees? I think they are jealous. It is

0:15:130:15:13

care and no tuition fees? I think they are jealous. It is interesting,

0:15:130:15:13

they are jealous. It is interesting, I

0:15:130:15:14

they are jealous. It is interesting, I sit

0:15:140:15:14

they are jealous. It is interesting, I sit here

0:15:140:15:14

they are jealous. It is interesting, I sit here as

0:15:140:15:14

they are jealous. It is interesting, I sit here as a

0:15:140:15:14

they are jealous. It is interesting, I sit here as a small

0:15:140:15:15

they are jealous. It is interesting, I sit here as a small business

0:15:150:15:15

I sit here as a small business owner,

0:15:150:15:16

I sit here as a small business owner, but

0:15:160:15:16

I sit here as a small business owner, but also

0:15:160:15:16

I sit here as a small business owner, but also a

0:15:160:15:16

I sit here as a small business owner, but also a mother

0:15:160:15:17

I sit here as a small business owner, but also a mother of

0:15:170:15:17

I sit here as a small business owner, but also a mother of four.

0:15:170:15:17

I sit here as a small business owner, but also a mother of four. A

0:15:170:15:18

owner, but also a mother of four. A lot

0:15:180:15:18

owner, but also a mother of four. A lot of these

0:15:180:15:18

owner, but also a mother of four. A lot of these questions

0:15:180:15:18

owner, but also a mother of four. A lot of these questions are,

0:15:180:15:19

owner, but also a mother of four. A lot of these questions are, you

0:15:190:15:19

lot of these questions are, you read

0:15:190:15:19

lot of these questions are, you read about

0:15:190:15:19

lot of these questions are, you read about them

0:15:190:15:19

lot of these questions are, you read about them all

0:15:190:15:20

lot of these questions are, you read about them all the

0:15:200:15:20

lot of these questions are, you read about them all the time,

0:15:200:15:20

lot of these questions are, you read about them all the time, yet

0:15:200:15:20

lot of these questions are, you read about them all the time, yet I

0:15:200:15:21

read about them all the time, yet I sit

0:15:210:15:21

read about them all the time, yet I sit here

0:15:210:15:21

read about them all the time, yet I sit here still

0:15:210:15:21

read about them all the time, yet I sit here still in

0:15:210:15:21

read about them all the time, yet I sit here still in so

0:15:210:15:22

read about them all the time, yet I sit here still in so much

0:15:220:15:22

read about them all the time, yet I sit here still in so much confusion,

0:15:220:15:22

sit here still in so much confusion, because

0:15:220:15:23

sit here still in so much confusion, because they

0:15:230:15:23

sit here still in so much confusion, because they are

0:15:230:15:23

sit here still in so much confusion, because they are asking

0:15:230:15:23

sit here still in so much confusion, because they are asking us

0:15:230:15:24

sit here still in so much confusion, because they are asking us to

0:15:240:15:24

sit here still in so much confusion, because they are asking us to make

0:15:240:15:24

because they are asking us to make a

0:15:240:15:25

because they are asking us to make a huge,

0:15:250:15:26

because they are asking us to make a huge, to

0:15:260:15:26

because they are asking us to make a huge, to sign

0:15:260:15:26

because they are asking us to make a huge, to sign on

0:15:260:15:27

because they are asking us to make a huge, to sign on the

0:15:270:15:27

because they are asking us to make a huge, to sign on the dotted

0:15:270:15:27

because they are asking us to make a huge, to sign on the dotted line,

0:15:270:15:28

a huge, to sign on the dotted line, to

0:15:280:15:28

a huge, to sign on the dotted line, to divorce

0:15:280:15:29

a huge, to sign on the dotted line, to divorce essentially

0:15:290:15:29

a huge, to sign on the dotted line, to divorce essentially from

0:15:290:15:29

to divorce essentially from Scotland

0:15:290:15:29

to divorce essentially from Scotland without

0:15:290:15:30

to divorce essentially from Scotland without actually

0:15:300:15:30

to divorce essentially from Scotland without actually thinking

0:15:300:15:30

Scotland without actually thinking about

0:15:300:15:31

Scotland without actually thinking about what

0:15:310:15:31

Scotland without actually thinking about what the

0:15:310:15:31

Scotland without actually thinking about what the terms

0:15:310:15:31

Scotland without actually thinking about what the terms of

0:15:310:15:31

Scotland without actually thinking about what the terms of the

0:15:310:15:32

about what the terms of the contract

0:15:320:15:32

about what the terms of the contract are.

0:15:320:15:32

about what the terms of the contract are. Me

0:15:320:15:33

about what the terms of the contract are. Me as

0:15:330:15:33

about what the terms of the contract are. Me as a

0:15:330:15:33

about what the terms of the contract are. Me as a mother

0:15:330:15:34

about what the terms of the contract are. Me as a mother how

0:15:340:15:35

contract are. Me as a mother how are

0:15:350:15:35

contract are. Me as a mother how are we

0:15:350:15:35

contract are. Me as a mother how are we actually

0:15:350:15:36

contract are. Me as a mother how are we actually going

0:15:360:15:36

contract are. Me as a mother how are we actually going to,

0:15:360:15:36

contract are. Me as a mother how are we actually going to, what

0:15:360:15:37

contract are. Me as a mother how are we actually going to, what are

0:15:370:15:37

are we actually going to, what are the

0:15:370:15:37

are we actually going to, what are the tax

0:15:370:15:37

are we actually going to, what are the tax rates

0:15:370:15:38

are we actually going to, what are the tax rates going

0:15:380:15:38

are we actually going to, what are the tax rates going to

0:15:380:15:39

are we actually going to, what are the tax rates going to be,

0:15:390:15:39

are we actually going to, what are the tax rates going to be, I

0:15:390:15:39

are we actually going to, what are the tax rates going to be, I have

0:15:390:15:39

the tax rates going to be, I have read

0:15:390:15:40

the tax rates going to be, I have read so

0:15:400:15:40

the tax rates going to be, I have read so many

0:15:400:15:41

the tax rates going to be, I have read so many places

0:15:410:15:41

the tax rates going to be, I have read so many places about

0:15:410:15:41

the tax rates going to be, I have read so many places about the

0:15:410:15:41

the tax rates going to be, I have read so many places about the tax

0:15:410:15:41

read so many places about the tax going

0:15:410:15:42

read so many places about the tax going through

0:15:420:15:42

read so many places about the tax going through the

0:15:420:15:43

read so many places about the tax going through the roof.

0:15:430:15:44

read so many places about the tax going through the roof. My

0:15:440:15:44

read so many places about the tax going through the roof. My biggest

0:15:440:15:44

going through the roof. My biggest customer

0:15:440:15:45

going through the roof. My biggest customer and

0:15:450:15:45

going through the roof. My biggest customer and the

0:15:450:15:45

going through the roof. My biggest customer and the entire

0:15:450:15:46

going through the roof. My biggest customer and the entire high

0:15:460:15:46

going through the roof. My biggest customer and the entire high street

0:15:460:15:46

customer and the entire high street retail

0:15:460:15:46

customer and the entire high street retail are

0:15:460:15:47

customer and the entire high street retail are in

0:15:470:15:47

customer and the entire high street retail are in England.

0:15:470:15:47

customer and the entire high street retail are in England. Our

0:15:470:15:48

customer and the entire high street retail are in England. Our Scottish

0:15:480:15:48

retail are in England. Our Scottish high

0:15:480:15:49

retail are in England. Our Scottish high streets

0:15:490:15:49

retail are in England. Our Scottish high streets are

0:15:490:15:50

retail are in England. Our Scottish high streets are made

0:15:500:15:50

retail are in England. Our Scottish high streets are made up

0:15:500:15:50

retail are in England. Our Scottish high streets are made up of

0:15:500:15:51

high streets are made up of businesses

0:15:510:15:51

high streets are made up of businesses with

0:15:510:15:51

high streets are made up of businesses with Scottish

0:15:510:15:52

high streets are made up of businesses with Scottish businesses

0:15:520:15:53

businesses with Scottish businesses in

0:15:530:15:53

businesses with Scottish businesses in England.

0:15:530:15:53

businesses with Scottish businesses in England. The

0:15:530:15:53

businesses with Scottish businesses in England. The first

0:15:530:15:54

businesses with Scottish businesses in England. The first time

0:15:540:15:54

businesses with Scottish businesses in England. The first time we talk

0:15:540:15:54

in England. The first time we talk about

0:15:540:15:55

in England. The first time we talk about economic

0:15:550:15:55

in England. The first time we talk about economic crisis

0:15:550:15:55

in England. The first time we talk about economic crisis we

0:15:550:15:56

in England. The first time we talk about economic crisis we refer

0:15:560:15:56

in England. The first time we talk about economic crisis we refer to

0:15:560:15:57

about economic crisis we refer to consumer

0:15:570:15:57

about economic crisis we refer to consumer spend.

0:15:570:15:57

about economic crisis we refer to consumer spend. I'm

0:15:570:15:58

about economic crisis we refer to consumer spend. I'm seeing

0:15:580:15:58

about economic crisis we refer to consumer spend. I'm seeing for

0:15:580:15:59

about economic crisis we refer to consumer spend. I'm seeing for sure

0:15:590:15:59

consumer spend. I'm seeing for sure budgets

0:15:590:15:59

consumer spend. I'm seeing for sure budgets that

0:15:590:15:59

consumer spend. I'm seeing for sure budgets that are

0:15:590:16:00

consumer spend. I'm seeing for sure budgets that are being

0:16:000:16:00

consumer spend. I'm seeing for sure budgets that are being taken

0:16:000:16:00

consumer spend. I'm seeing for sure budgets that are being taken away

0:16:000:16:01

budgets that are being taken away because

0:16:010:16:01

budgets that are being taken away because of

0:16:010:16:01

budgets that are being taken away because of the

0:16:010:16:01

budgets that are being taken away because of the uncertainty,

0:16:010:16:02

budgets that are being taken away because of the uncertainty, the

0:16:020:16:03

because of the uncertainty, the unknown.

0:16:030:16:03

because of the uncertainty, the unknown. The

0:16:030:16:03

because of the uncertainty, the unknown. The questions

0:16:030:16:04

because of the uncertainty, the unknown. The questions that

0:16:040:16:04

because of the uncertainty, the unknown. The questions that yet

0:16:040:16:04

because of the uncertainty, the can't seem

0:16:040:16:05

because of the uncertainty, the can't seem to

0:16:050:16:05

because of the uncertainty, the can't seem to be

0:16:050:16:05

because of the uncertainty, the can't seem to be answered.

0:16:050:16:06

because of the uncertainty, the can't seem to be answered. Although

0:16:060:16:06

can't seem to be answered. Although many

0:16:060:16:06

can't seem to be answered. Although many people

0:16:060:16:08

can't seem to be answered. Although many people might

0:16:080:16:08

can't seem to be answered. Although many people might be...In

0:16:080:16:09

can't seem to be answered. Although many people might be...In Scotland

0:16:090:16:09

many people might be...In Scotland businesses

0:16:090:16:09

many people might be...In Scotland businesses thrive

0:16:090:16:09

many people might be...In Scotland businesses thrive own

0:16:090:16:10

many people might be...In Scotland businesses thrive own a

0:16:100:16:10

many people might be...In Scotland businesses thrive own a global

0:16:100:16:10

businesses thrive own a global economy,

0:16:100:16:11

businesses thrive own a global economy, a lot

0:16:110:16:11

businesses thrive own a global economy, a lot of

0:16:110:16:11

businesses thrive own a global economy, a lot of businesses

0:16:110:16:11

businesses thrive own a global economy, a lot of businesses do

0:16:110:16:12

economy, a lot of businesses do well

0:16:120:16:13

economy, a lot of businesses do well on

0:16:130:16:13

economy, a lot of businesses do well on export?

0:16:130:16:13

economy, a lot of businesses do well on export? They

0:16:130:16:13

economy, a lot of businesses do well on export? They absolutely

0:16:130:16:13

economy, a lot of businesses do well on export? They absolutely do.

0:16:130:16:14

well on export? They absolutely do. Our

0:16:140:16:14

well on export? They absolutely do. Our job

0:16:140:16:14

well on export? They absolutely do. Our job is

0:16:140:16:15

well on export? They absolutely do. Our job is to

0:16:150:16:15

well on export? They absolutely do. Our job is to compete

0:16:150:16:15

well on export? They absolutely do. Our job is to compete against

0:16:150:16:15

well on export? They absolutely do. Our job is to compete against the

0:16:150:16:15

Our job is to compete against the European,

0:16:150:16:16

Our job is to compete against the European, the

0:16:160:16:16

Our job is to compete against the European, the French

0:16:160:16:16

Our job is to compete against the European, the French and

0:16:160:16:16

Our job is to compete against the European, the French and the

0:16:160:16:16

Our job is to compete against the European, the French and the it

0:16:160:16:18

Our job is to compete against the European, the French and the it at

0:16:180:16:18

European, the French and the it at thatalens

0:16:180:16:19

European, the French and the it at thatalens everybody.

0:16:190:16:20

European, the French and the it at thatalens everybody. It

0:16:200:16:20

European, the French and the it at thatalens everybody. It --

0:16:200:16:21

European, the French and the it at thatalens everybody. It -- The

0:16:210:16:22

thatalens everybody. It -- The Italians.

0:16:220:16:23

thatalens everybody. It -- The Italians. All

0:16:230:16:23

thatalens everybody. It -- The Italians. All this

0:16:230:16:24

thatalens everybody. It -- The Italians. All this natural

0:16:240:16:24

thatalens everybody. It -- The Italians. All this natural resource,

0:16:240:16:24

Italians. All this natural resource, all

0:16:240:16:24

Italians. All this natural resource, all these

0:16:240:16:25

Italians. All this natural resource, all these world

0:16:250:16:25

Italians. All this natural resource, all these world class

0:16:250:16:25

Italians. All this natural resource, all these world class universities

0:16:250:16:26

all these world class universities and

0:16:260:16:26

all these world class universities and thrusting

0:16:260:16:26

all these world class universities and thrusting companies

0:16:260:16:27

all these world class universities and thrusting companies with

0:16:270:16:27

all these world class universities and thrusting companies with their

0:16:270:16:28

and thrusting companies with their high-technology

0:16:280:16:28

and thrusting companies with their high-technology and

0:16:280:16:28

and thrusting companies with their high-technology and expertise,

0:16:280:16:28

and thrusting companies with their high-technology and expertise, we

0:16:280:16:29

high-technology and expertise, we are

0:16:290:16:29

high-technology and expertise, we are really

0:16:290:16:29

high-technology and expertise, we are really in

0:16:290:16:30

high-technology and expertise, we are really in trouble!

0:16:300:16:30

high-technology and expertise, we are really in trouble! That

0:16:300:16:30

high-technology and expertise, we are really in trouble! That funding

0:16:300:16:31

high-technology and expertise, we comes from

0:16:310:16:32

high-technology and expertise, we comes from the

0:16:320:16:32

high-technology and expertise, we comes from the UK

0:16:320:16:32

high-technology and expertise, we comes from the UK Government.

0:16:320:16:34

high-technology and expertise, we comes from the UK Government. To

0:16:340:16:34

comes from the UK Government. To finish

0:16:340:16:35

comes from the UK Government. To finish the

0:16:350:16:35

comes from the UK Government. To finish the point,

0:16:350:16:35

comes from the UK Government. To finish the point, the

0:16:350:16:35

comes from the UK Government. To finish the point, the point

0:16:350:16:36

comes from the UK Government. To finish the point, the point about

0:16:360:16:36

finish the point, the point about completing

0:16:360:16:36

finish the point, the point about completing the

0:16:360:16:36

finish the point, the point about completing the powers

0:16:360:16:36

finish the point, the point about completing the powers of

0:16:360:16:37

finish the point, the point about completing the powers of the

0:16:370:16:37

completing the powers of the parliament,

0:16:370:16:37

completing the powers of the parliament, we

0:16:370:16:38

completing the powers of the parliament, we should

0:16:380:16:38

completing the powers of the parliament, we should have

0:16:380:16:38

completing the powers of the parliament, we should have a

0:16:380:16:38

parliament, we should have a perspective

0:16:380:16:38

parliament, we should have a perspective on

0:16:380:16:39

parliament, we should have a perspective on Scottish

0:16:390:16:39

parliament, we should have a perspective on Scottish growth,

0:16:390:16:40

parliament, we should have a perspective on Scottish growth, if

0:16:400:16:40

perspective on Scottish growth, if we

0:16:400:16:40

perspective on Scottish growth, if we have

0:16:400:16:40

perspective on Scottish growth, if we have a

0:16:400:16:40

perspective on Scottish growth, if we have a problem

0:16:400:16:40

perspective on Scottish growth, if we have a problem with

0:16:400:16:41

perspective on Scottish growth, if we have a problem with revenue

0:16:410:16:41

perspective on Scottish growth, if we have a problem with revenue we

0:16:410:16:41

we have a problem with revenue we should

0:16:410:16:41

we have a problem with revenue we should be

0:16:410:16:42

we have a problem with revenue we should be planning the

0:16:420:16:42

we have a problem with revenue we should be planning the country

0:16:420:16:42

we have a problem with revenue we should be planning the country to

0:16:420:16:43

should be planning the country to grow

0:16:430:16:43

should be planning the country to grow economies,

0:16:430:16:44

should be planning the country to grow economies, to

0:16:440:16:45

should be planning the country to grow economies, to grow

0:16:450:16:45

should be planning the country to grow economies, to grow prosperity,

0:16:450:16:45

grow economies, to grow prosperity, to

0:16:450:16:45

grow economies, to grow prosperity, to grow

0:16:450:16:46

grow economies, to grow prosperity, to grow skill

0:16:460:16:46

grow economies, to grow prosperity, to grow skill and

0:16:460:16:46

grow economies, to grow prosperity, to grow skill and talent

0:16:460:16:46

grow economies, to grow prosperity, to grow skill and talent in

0:16:460:16:49

grow economies, to grow prosperity, to grow skill and talent in the

0:16:490:16:49

to grow skill and talent in the country.

0:16:490:16:50

to grow skill and talent in the country. The

0:16:500:16:50

to grow skill and talent in the country. The gentleman

0:16:500:16:50

to grow skill and talent in the country. The gentleman at

0:16:500:16:50

to grow skill and talent in the country. The gentleman at the

0:16:500:16:51

to grow skill and talent in the country. The gentleman at the back?

0:16:510:16:51

country. The gentleman at the back? Interesting

0:16:510:16:51

country. The gentleman at the back? Interesting to

0:16:510:16:52

country. The gentleman at the back? Interesting to hear

0:16:520:16:52

country. The gentleman at the back? Interesting to hear about

0:16:520:16:53

country. The gentleman at the back? Interesting to hear about Scottish

0:16:530:16:53

Interesting to hear about Scottish growth,

0:16:530:16:53

Interesting to hear about Scottish growth, I'm

0:16:530:16:53

Interesting to hear about Scottish growth, I'm part

0:16:530:16:54

Interesting to hear about Scottish growth, I'm part of

0:16:540:16:54

Interesting to hear about Scottish growth, I'm part of the

0:16:540:16:54

growth, I'm part of the education industry,

0:16:540:16:54

growth, I'm part of the education industry, if

0:16:540:16:55

growth, I'm part of the education industry, if you

0:16:550:16:55

growth, I'm part of the education industry, if you like

0:16:550:16:55

growth, I'm part of the education industry, if you like at

0:16:550:16:55

growth, I'm part of the education industry, if you like at the

0:16:550:16:56

growth, I'm part of the education industry, if you like at the moment,

0:16:560:16:56

industry, if you like at the moment, and

0:16:560:16:56

industry, if you like at the moment, and all

0:16:560:16:57

industry, if you like at the moment, and all I'm

0:16:570:16:57

industry, if you like at the moment, and all I'm seeing

0:16:570:16:58

industry, if you like at the moment, and all I'm seeing is

0:16:580:16:58

industry, if you like at the moment, and all I'm seeing is cutback,

0:16:580:16:58

and all I'm seeing is cutback, cutback,

0:16:580:16:58

and all I'm seeing is cutback, cutback, cutback.

0:16:580:16:59

and all I'm seeing is cutback, cutback, cutback. I

0:16:590:16:59

and all I'm seeing is cutback, cutback, cutback. I would

0:16:590:16:59

and all I'm seeing is cutback, cutback, cutback. I would like

0:16:590:16:59

and all I'm seeing is cutback, cutback, cutback. I would like to

0:16:590:17:00

cutback, cutback. I would like to know

0:17:000:17:00

cutback, cutback. I would like to know exactly

0:17:000:17:01

cutback, cutback. I would like to know exactly how

0:17:010:17:01

cutback, cutback. I would like to know exactly how much

0:17:010:17:01

cutback, cutback. I would like to know exactly how much of

0:17:010:17:02

cutback, cutback. I would like to know exactly how much of that

0:17:020:17:02

cutback, cutback. I would like to know exactly how much of that £500

0:17:020:17:03

know exactly how much of that £500 per

0:17:030:17:03

know exactly how much of that £500 per person

0:17:030:17:03

know exactly how much of that £500 per person would

0:17:030:17:03

know exactly how much of that £500 per person would be

0:17:030:17:03

know exactly how much of that £500 per person would be scaled

0:17:030:17:03

know exactly how much of that £500 per person would be scaled up

0:17:030:17:04

know exactly how much of that £500 per person would be scaled up to

0:17:040:17:04

per person would be scaled up to look

0:17:040:17:04

per person would be scaled up to look after

0:17:040:17:05

per person would be scaled up to look after the

0:17:050:17:05

per person would be scaled up to look after the education

0:17:050:17:05

per person would be scaled up to look after the education system.

0:17:050:17:07

look after the education system. Because

0:17:070:17:07

look after the education system. Because we're

0:17:070:17:07

look after the education system. Because we're implementing

0:17:070:17:08

look after the education system. Because we're implementing at

0:17:080:17:08

look after the education system. Because we're implementing at the

0:17:080:17:08

Because we're implementing at the moment

0:17:080:17:08

Because we're implementing at the moment the

0:17:080:17:09

Because we're implementing at the moment the curriculum

0:17:090:17:09

Because we're implementing at the moment the curriculum for

0:17:090:17:09

moment the curriculum for excellence

0:17:090:17:09

moment the curriculum for excellence and

0:17:090:17:09

moment the curriculum for excellence and there

0:17:090:17:10

moment the curriculum for excellence and there is

0:17:100:17:10

moment the curriculum for excellence and there is no

0:17:100:17:10

moment the curriculum for excellence and there is no money

0:17:100:17:10

excellence and there is no money behind

0:17:100:17:11

excellence and there is no money behind it

0:17:110:17:11

excellence and there is no money behind it as

0:17:110:17:11

excellence and there is no money behind it as far

0:17:110:17:11

excellence and there is no money behind it as far as

0:17:110:17:12

excellence and there is no money behind it as far as I

0:17:120:17:12

excellence and there is no money behind it as far as I can

0:17:120:17:12

excellence and there is no money behind it as far as I can see.

0:17:120:17:12

excellence and there is no money behind it as far as I can see. It

0:17:120:17:12

behind it as far as I can see. It is

0:17:120:17:12

behind it as far as I can see. It is you

0:17:120:17:13

behind it as far as I can see. It is you have

0:17:130:17:13

behind it as far as I can see. It is you have to

0:17:130:17:13

behind it as far as I can see. It is you have to cut

0:17:130:17:14

behind it as far as I can see. It is you have to cut here

0:17:140:17:15

behind it as far as I can see. It is you have to cut here and

0:17:150:17:16

behind it as far as I can see. It is you have to cut here and there?

0:17:160:17:16

is you have to cut here and there? Would

0:17:160:17:16

is you have to cut here and there? Would there

0:17:160:17:18

is you have to cut here and there? Would there be

0:17:180:17:18

is you have to cut here and there? Would there be an

0:17:180:17:18

is you have to cut here and there? Would there be an exponential

0:17:180:17:19

Would there be an exponential increase

0:17:190:17:20

Would there be an exponential increase for

0:17:200:17:20

Would there be an exponential increase for education

0:17:200:17:20

Would there be an exponential increase for education in

0:17:200:17:20

Would there be an exponential increase for education in Scotland?

0:17:200:17:21

increase for education in Scotland? It

0:17:210:17:22

increase for education in Scotland? It was

0:17:220:17:22

increase for education in Scotland? It was asked

0:17:220:17:22

increase for education in Scotland? It was asked for

0:17:220:17:22

increase for education in Scotland? It was asked for the

0:17:220:17:23

increase for education in Scotland? It was asked for the tax

0:17:230:17:23

increase for education in Scotland? It was asked for the tax rate,

0:17:230:17:23

increase for education in Scotland? It was asked for the tax rate, you

0:17:230:17:23

It was asked for the tax rate, you couldn't

0:17:230:17:24

It was asked for the tax rate, you couldn't tell

0:17:240:17:24

It was asked for the tax rate, you couldn't tell you

0:17:240:17:24

It was asked for the tax rate, you couldn't tell you the

0:17:240:17:24

It was asked for the tax rate, you couldn't tell you the tax

0:17:240:17:25

It was asked for the tax rate, you couldn't tell you the tax rate

0:17:250:17:25

It was asked for the tax rate, you couldn't tell you the tax rate in

0:17:250:17:25

couldn't tell you the tax rate in five

0:17:250:17:25

couldn't tell you the tax rate in five years

0:17:250:17:25

couldn't tell you the tax rate in five years in

0:17:250:17:27

couldn't tell you the tax rate in five years in the

0:17:270:17:27

couldn't tell you the tax rate in five years in the UK.

0:17:270:17:27

couldn't tell you the tax rate in five years in the UK. These

0:17:270:17:28

couldn't tell you the tax rate in five years in the UK. These are

0:17:280:17:28

five years in the UK. These are made

0:17:280:17:28

five years in the UK. These are made by

0:17:280:17:28

five years in the UK. These are made by elected

0:17:280:17:29

five years in the UK. These are made by elected Governments

0:17:290:17:29

five years in the UK. These are made by elected Governments and

0:17:290:17:29

made by elected Governments and budgets

0:17:290:17:30

made by elected Governments and budgets across

0:17:300:17:30

made by elected Governments and budgets across the

0:17:300:17:30

made by elected Governments and budgets across the world.

0:17:300:17:31

made by elected Governments and budgets across the world. The

0:17:310:17:31

budgets across the world. The benefit

0:17:310:17:32

budgets across the world. The benefit in

0:17:320:17:32

budgets across the world. The benefit in terms

0:17:320:17:34

budgets across the world. The benefit in terms of

0:17:340:17:34

budgets across the world. The benefit in terms of the

0:17:340:17:35

budgets across the world. The benefit in terms of the gentleman's

0:17:350:17:35

benefit in terms of the gentleman's questions,

0:17:350:17:35

benefit in terms of the gentleman's questions, the

0:17:350:17:35

benefit in terms of the gentleman's questions, the situation

0:17:350:17:35

benefit in terms of the gentleman's questions, the situation we

0:17:350:17:36

benefit in terms of the gentleman's questions, the situation we have

0:17:360:17:36

questions, the situation we have now

0:17:360:17:36

questions, the situation we have now is

0:17:360:17:36

questions, the situation we have now is we

0:17:360:17:37

questions, the situation we have now is we pay

0:17:370:17:37

questions, the situation we have now is we pay the

0:17:370:17:37

questions, the situation we have now is we pay the taxes

0:17:370:17:37

questions, the situation we have now is we pay the taxes and

0:17:370:17:38

questions, the situation we have now is we pay the taxes and the

0:17:380:17:38

now is we pay the taxes and the London

0:17:380:17:39

now is we pay the taxes and the London Treasury

0:17:390:17:39

now is we pay the taxes and the London Treasury give

0:17:390:17:40

now is we pay the taxes and the London Treasury give us

0:17:400:17:40

now is we pay the taxes and the London Treasury give us a

0:17:400:17:40

now is we pay the taxes and the London Treasury give us a block

0:17:400:17:41

London Treasury give us a block bank

0:17:410:17:41

London Treasury give us a block bank back,

0:17:410:17:41

London Treasury give us a block bank back, we

0:17:410:17:41

London Treasury give us a block bank back, we keep

0:17:410:17:41

London Treasury give us a block bank back, we keep the

0:17:410:17:42

London Treasury give us a block bank back, we keep the taxes

0:17:420:17:42

London Treasury give us a block bank back, we keep the taxes here

0:17:420:17:42

bank back, we keep the taxes here and

0:17:420:17:43

bank back, we keep the taxes here and make

0:17:430:17:43

bank back, we keep the taxes here and make decisions

0:17:430:17:43

bank back, we keep the taxes here and make decisions ourselves

0:17:430:17:44

bank back, we keep the taxes here and make decisions ourselves about

0:17:440:17:44

and make decisions ourselves about how

0:17:440:17:44

and make decisions ourselves about how to

0:17:440:17:44

and make decisions ourselves about how to allocate

0:17:440:17:45

and make decisions ourselves about how to allocate the

0:17:450:17:45

and make decisions ourselves about how to allocate the money.

0:17:450:17:46

and make decisions ourselves about how to allocate the money. Surely

0:17:460:17:46

and make decisions ourselves about it is

0:17:460:17:47

and make decisions ourselves about it is like

0:17:470:17:47

and make decisions ourselves about it is like your

0:17:470:17:47

and make decisions ourselves about it is like your coin,

0:17:470:17:48

and make decisions ourselves about it is like your coin, Kirsty,

0:17:480:17:48

and make decisions ourselves about it is like your coin, Kirsty, there

0:17:480:17:48

and make decisions ourselves about is two

0:17:480:17:48

and make decisions ourselves about is two sides

0:17:480:17:49

and make decisions ourselves about is two sides to

0:17:490:17:49

and make decisions ourselves about is two sides to it.

0:17:490:17:50

and make decisions ourselves about is two sides to it. Can

0:17:500:17:51

and make decisions ourselves about is two sides to it. Can we

0:17:510:17:51

and make decisions ourselves about is two sides to it. Can we afford,

0:17:510:17:52

is two sides to it. Can we afford, can

0:17:520:17:52

is two sides to it. Can we afford, can Scotland

0:17:520:17:53

is two sides to it. Can we afford, can Scotland afford

0:17:530:17:53

is two sides to it. Can we afford, can Scotland afford independence?

0:17:530:17:54

can Scotland afford independence? And

0:17:540:17:55

can Scotland afford independence? And can

0:17:550:17:55

can Scotland afford independence? And can Scotland

0:17:550:17:55

can Scotland afford independence? And can Scotland afford

0:17:550:17:55

can Scotland afford independence? And can Scotland afford to

0:17:550:17:56

can Scotland afford independence? And can Scotland afford to stay

0:17:560:17:56

And can Scotland afford to stay under

0:17:560:17:56

And can Scotland afford to stay under Westminster?

0:17:560:17:58

And can Scotland afford to stay under Westminster? There

0:17:580:17:58

And can Scotland afford to stay under Westminster? There is

0:17:580:17:59

And can Scotland afford to stay under Westminster? There is a

0:17:590:17:59

And can Scotland afford to stay under Westminster? There is a great

0:17:590:17:59

under Westminster? There is a great statistic

0:17:590:17:59

under Westminster? There is a great statistic I

0:17:590:18:00

under Westminster? There is a great statistic I heard

0:18:000:18:00

under Westminster? There is a great statistic I heard the

0:18:000:18:01

under Westminster? There is a great statistic I heard the other

0:18:010:18:01

under Westminster? There is a great statistic I heard the other day.

0:18:010:18:01

statistic I heard the other day. Margaret

0:18:010:18:02

statistic I heard the other day. Margaret Curran

0:18:020:18:02

statistic I heard the other day. Margaret Curran hasn't

0:18:020:18:03

statistic I heard the other day. Margaret Curran hasn't said?

0:18:030:18:03

statistic I heard the other day. Margaret Curran hasn't said? I

0:18:030:18:03

statistic I heard the other day. Margaret Curran hasn't said? I have

0:18:030:18:03

Margaret Curran hasn't said? I have been

0:18:030:18:03

Margaret Curran hasn't said? I have been trying

0:18:030:18:04

Margaret Curran hasn't said? I have been trying to

0:18:040:18:04

Margaret Curran hasn't said? I have been trying to get

0:18:040:18:04

Margaret Curran hasn't said? I have been trying to get in

0:18:040:18:04

Margaret Curran hasn't said? I have been trying to get in tole

0:18:040:18:05

been trying to get in tole challenge

0:18:050:18:05

been trying to get in tole challenge the

0:18:050:18:05

been trying to get in tole challenge the facts

0:18:050:18:05

been trying to get in tole challenge the facts and

0:18:050:18:06

been trying to get in tole challenge the facts and figures.

0:18:060:18:06

been trying to get in tole challenge the facts and figures. I

0:18:060:18:07

challenge the facts and figures. I would

0:18:070:18:07

challenge the facts and figures. I would imagine

0:18:070:18:07

challenge the facts and figures. I would imagine it

0:18:070:18:08

challenge the facts and figures. I would imagine it is

0:18:080:18:08

challenge the facts and figures. I would imagine it is frustrating

0:18:080:18:08

challenge the facts and figures. I would imagine it is frustrating if

0:18:080:18:08

would imagine it is frustrating if you

0:18:080:18:08

would imagine it is frustrating if you are

0:18:080:18:09

would imagine it is frustrating if you are not

0:18:090:18:09

would imagine it is frustrating if you are not involved

0:18:090:18:09

would imagine it is frustrating if you are not involved in

0:18:090:18:09

would imagine it is frustrating if you are not involved in politics

0:18:090:18:10

would imagine it is frustrating if you are not involved in politics to

0:18:100:18:10

you are not involved in politics to hear

0:18:100:18:11

you are not involved in politics to hear two

0:18:110:18:11

you are not involved in politics to hear two politicians

0:18:110:18:11

you are not involved in politics to hear two politicians each

0:18:110:18:11

you are not involved in politics to hear two politicians each saying

0:18:110:18:11

hear two politicians each saying this

0:18:110:18:12

hear two politicians each saying this and

0:18:120:18:12

hear two politicians each saying this and that

0:18:120:18:12

hear two politicians each saying this and that figure

0:18:120:18:12

hear two politicians each saying this and that figure is

0:18:120:18:13

hear two politicians each saying this and that figure is right.

0:18:130:18:13

hear two politicians each saying this and that figure is right. I

0:18:130:18:14

this and that figure is right. I appreciate

0:18:140:18:14

this and that figure is right. I appreciate that,

0:18:140:18:14

this and that figure is right. I appreciate that, but

0:18:140:18:14

this and that figure is right. I appreciate that, but it

0:18:140:18:15

this and that figure is right. I appreciate that, but it is

0:18:150:18:15

this and that figure is right. I appreciate that, but it is an

0:18:150:18:16

appreciate that, but it is an absolute

0:18:160:18:16

appreciate that, but it is an absolute fact

0:18:160:18:16

appreciate that, but it is an absolute fact that

0:18:160:18:17

appreciate that, but it is an absolute fact that more

0:18:170:18:18

appreciate that, but it is an absolute fact that more is

0:18:180:18:18

appreciate that, but it is an absolute fact that more is spent

0:18:180:18:18

appreciate that, but it is an absolute fact that more is spent on

0:18:180:18:19

absolute fact that more is spent on public

0:18:190:18:19

absolute fact that more is spent on public expenditure,

0:18:190:18:20

absolute fact that more is spent on public expenditure, £1200

0:18:200:18:20

absolute fact that more is spent on public expenditure, £1200 more,

0:18:200:18:20

public expenditure, £1200 more, than

0:18:200:18:21

public expenditure, £1200 more, than it

0:18:210:18:21

public expenditure, £1200 more, than it is

0:18:210:18:21

public expenditure, £1200 more, than it is in

0:18:210:18:21

public expenditure, £1200 more, than it is in the

0:18:210:18:21

public expenditure, £1200 more, than it is in the rest

0:18:210:18:22

public expenditure, £1200 more, than it is in the rest of

0:18:220:18:22

public expenditure, £1200 more, than it is in the rest of the

0:18:220:18:22

public expenditure, £1200 more, than it is in the rest of the UK.

0:18:220:18:24

than it is in the rest of the UK. Let's

0:18:240:18:24

than it is in the rest of the UK. Let's turn

0:18:240:18:25

than it is in the rest of the UK. Let's turn now

0:18:250:18:25

than it is in the rest of the UK. Let's turn now to

0:18:250:18:25

than it is in the rest of the UK. Let's turn now to how

0:18:250:18:26

than it is in the rest of the UK. Let's turn now to how an

0:18:260:18:26

Let's turn now to how an independent

0:18:260:18:26

Let's turn now to how an independent would

0:18:260:18:27

Let's turn now to how an independent would actually

0:18:270:18:27

Let's turn now to how an independent would actually operate,

0:18:270:18:28

independent would actually operate, what

0:18:280:18:28

independent would actually operate, what it

0:18:280:18:28

independent would actually operate, what it would

0:18:280:18:28

independent would actually operate, what it would look

0:18:280:18:28

independent would actually operate, what it would look and

0:18:280:18:29

independent would actually operate, what it would look and feel

0:18:290:18:29

independent would actually operate, what it would look and feel like.

0:18:290:18:37

what it would look and feel like. Let's

0:18:370:18:37

what it would look and feel like. Let's start

0:18:370:18:38

what it would look and feel like. Let's start with

0:18:380:18:38

what it would look and feel like. Let's start with the

0:18:380:18:38

what it would look and feel like. Let's start with the currency,

0:18:380:18:39

what it would look and feel like. Let's start with the currency, what

0:18:390:18:39

Let's start with the currency, what would

0:18:390:18:39

Let's start with the currency, what would the

0:18:390:18:40

Let's start with the currency, what would the change

0:18:400:18:41

Let's start with the currency, what would the change in

0:18:410:18:41

Let's start with the currency, what would the change in your

0:18:410:18:41

Let's start with the currency, what would the change in your pocket

0:18:410:18:41

Let's start with the currency, what would the change in your pocket be?

0:18:410:18:43

would the change in your pocket be? Alex

0:18:430:18:43

would the change in your pocket be? Alex Salmond

0:18:430:18:43

would the change in your pocket be? Alex Salmond wants

0:18:430:18:43

would the change in your pocket be? Alex Salmond wants to

0:18:430:18:44

would the change in your pocket be? Alex Salmond wants to stick

0:18:440:18:44

would the change in your pocket be? Alex Salmond wants to stick with

0:18:440:18:44

would the change in your pocket be? the pound

0:18:440:18:45

would the change in your pocket be? the pound and

0:18:450:18:45

would the change in your pocket be? the pound and create

0:18:450:18:45

would the change in your pocket be? the pound and create a

0:18:450:18:45

would the change in your pocket be? the pound and create a sterling

0:18:450:18:46

the pound and create a sterling zone.

0:18:460:18:46

the pound and create a sterling zone. Would

0:18:460:18:46

the pound and create a sterling zone. Would that

0:18:460:18:47

the pound and create a sterling zone. Would that be

0:18:470:18:47

the pound and create a sterling zone. Would that be the

0:18:470:18:47

the pound and create a sterling zone. Would that be the Treasury's

0:18:470:18:48

zone. Would that be the Treasury's call?

0:18:480:18:48

zone. Would that be the Treasury's call? The

0:18:480:18:48

zone. Would that be the Treasury's call? The Chancellor

0:18:480:18:48

zone. Would that be the Treasury's call? The Chancellor has

0:18:480:18:49

zone. Would that be the Treasury's call? The Chancellor has already

0:18:490:18:50

call? The Chancellor has already said

0:18:500:18:50

call? The Chancellor has already said he's

0:18:500:18:50

call? The Chancellor has already said he's worried

0:18:500:18:50

call? The Chancellor has already said he's worried to

0:18:500:18:52

call? The Chancellor has already said he's worried to be

0:18:520:18:52

call? The Chancellor has already said he's worried to be tied

0:18:520:18:52

call? The Chancellor has already said he's worried to be tied to

0:18:520:18:53

call? The Chancellor has already said he's worried to be tied to an

0:18:530:18:55

said he's worried to be tied to an economy

0:18:550:18:56

said he's worried to be tied to an economy dependant

0:18:560:18:56

said he's worried to be tied to an economy dependant on

0:18:560:18:57

said he's worried to be tied to an economy dependant on oil

0:18:570:18:57

said he's worried to be tied to an economy dependant on oil and

0:18:570:18:57

economy dependant on oil and services

0:18:570:18:57

economy dependant on oil and services without

0:18:570:18:58

economy dependant on oil and services without having

0:18:580:18:58

economy dependant on oil and services without having national

0:18:580:18:59

services without having national control.

0:18:590:18:59

services without having national control. Would

0:18:590:18:59

services without having national control. Would Scotland

0:18:590:18:59

services without having national control. Would Scotland have

0:18:590:19:00

services without having national control. Would Scotland have to

0:19:000:19:00

control. Would Scotland have to create

0:19:000:19:00

control. Would Scotland have to create a

0:19:000:19:01

control. Would Scotland have to create a new

0:19:010:19:01

control. Would Scotland have to create a new currency?

0:19:010:19:01

control. Would Scotland have to create a new currency? Or

0:19:010:19:02

control. Would Scotland have to create a new currency? Or join

0:19:020:19:02

control. Would Scotland have to create a new currency? Or join the

0:19:020:19:02

create a new currency? Or join the euro.

0:19:020:19:02

create a new currency? Or join the euro. But

0:19:020:19:03

create a new currency? Or join the euro. But that

0:19:030:19:03

create a new currency? Or join the euro. But that gets

0:19:030:19:04

create a new currency? Or join the euro. But that gets us

0:19:040:19:04

create a new currency? Or join the euro. But that gets us to

0:19:040:19:05

euro. But that gets us to the thorny

0:19:050:19:05

euro. But that gets us to the thorny issue

0:19:050:19:06

euro. But that gets us to the thorny issue of

0:19:060:19:06

euro. But that gets us to the thorny issue of European

0:19:060:19:06

euro. But that gets us to the thorny issue of European membership.

0:19:060:19:07

thorny issue of European membership. As

0:19:070:19:07

thorny issue of European membership. As a

0:19:070:19:07

thorny issue of European membership. As a new

0:19:070:19:08

thorny issue of European membership. As a new country

0:19:080:19:08

thorny issue of European membership. As a new country would

0:19:080:19:08

thorny issue of European membership. As a new country would Scotland

0:19:080:19:08

As a new country would Scotland have

0:19:080:19:09

As a new country would Scotland have to

0:19:090:19:09

As a new country would Scotland have to apply

0:19:090:19:09

As a new country would Scotland have to apply for

0:19:090:19:10

As a new country would Scotland have to apply for membership

0:19:100:19:10

As a new country would Scotland have to apply for membership and

0:19:100:19:10

have to apply for membership and then

0:19:100:19:10

have to apply for membership and then join

0:19:100:19:11

have to apply for membership and then join the

0:19:110:19:11

have to apply for membership and then join the currency?

0:19:110:19:11

have to apply for membership and then join the currency? A

0:19:110:19:12

have to apply for membership and then join the currency? A process

0:19:120:19:13

then join the currency? A process that

0:19:130:19:13

then join the currency? A process that could

0:19:130:19:13

then join the currency? A process that could take years.

0:19:130:19:14

then join the currency? A process that could take years. And

0:19:140:19:14

then join the currency? A process that could take years. And would

0:19:140:19:14

then join the currency? A process that could take years. And would it

0:19:140:19:15

that could take years. And would it be

0:19:150:19:15

that could take years. And would it be the

0:19:150:19:16

that could take years. And would it be the same for

0:19:160:19:16

that could take years. And would it be the same for NATO

0:19:160:19:16

that could take years. And would it be the same for NATO membership

0:19:160:19:17

that could take years. And would it be the same for NATO membership and

0:19:170:19:17

be the same for NATO membership and the

0:19:170:19:17

be the same for NATO membership and the issue

0:19:170:19:18

be the same for NATO membership and the issue of

0:19:180:19:18

be the same for NATO membership and the issue of defence?

0:19:180:19:19

be the same for NATO membership and the issue of defence? The

0:19:190:19:20

be the same for NATO membership and the issue of defence? The SNP

0:19:200:19:20

be the same for NATO membership and the issue of defence? The SNP said

0:19:200:19:20

the issue of defence? The SNP said it

0:19:200:19:20

the issue of defence? The SNP said it would

0:19:200:19:20

the issue of defence? The SNP said it would build

0:19:200:19:21

the issue of defence? The SNP said it would build the

0:19:210:19:21

the issue of defence? The SNP said it would build the own

0:19:210:19:21

the issue of defence? The SNP said it would build the own army

0:19:210:19:22

the issue of defence? The SNP said it would build the own army of

0:19:220:19:23

it would build the own army of 15,000

0:19:230:19:23

it would build the own army of 15,000 soldiers,

0:19:230:19:24

it would build the own army of 15,000 soldiers, restore

0:19:240:19:25

it would build the own army of 15,000 soldiers, restore historic

0:19:250:19:26

15,000 soldiers, restore historic regiments

0:19:260:19:26

15,000 soldiers, restore historic regiments and

0:19:260:19:27

15,000 soldiers, restore historic regiments and replace

0:19:270:19:27

15,000 soldiers, restore historic regiments and replace the

0:19:270:19:29

regiments and replace the intelligence

0:19:290:19:29

regiments and replace the intelligence agencies.

0:19:290:19:29

regiments and replace the intelligence agencies. Cause

0:19:290:19:30

regiments and replace the intelligence agencies. Cause for

0:19:300:19:31

intelligence agencies. Cause for £2.5

0:19:310:19:31

intelligence agencies. Cause for £2.5 billion.

0:19:310:19:31

intelligence agencies. Cause for £2.5 billion. While

0:19:310:19:32

intelligence agencies. Cause for £2.5 billion. While we

0:19:320:19:32

intelligence agencies. Cause for £2.5 billion. While we are

0:19:320:19:32

intelligence agencies. Cause for £2.5 billion. While we are on

0:19:320:19:33

£2.5 billion. While we are on instraightjacketable

0:19:330:19:33

£2.5 billion. While we are on instraightjacketable problems,

0:19:330:19:34

£2.5 billion. While we are on instraightjacketable problems, with

0:19:340:19:34

instraightjacketable problems, with what

0:19:340:19:34

instraightjacketable problems, with what about Trident,

0:19:340:19:35

instraightjacketable problems, with what about Trident, the

0:19:350:19:36

instraightjacketable problems, with what about Trident, the SNP

0:19:360:19:36

instraightjacketable problems, with country without

0:19:360:19:36

instraightjacketable problems, with country without nuke

0:19:360:19:37

instraightjacketable problems, with country without nuke clear

0:19:370:19:37

instraightjacketable problems, with country without nuke clear weapons,

0:19:370:19:38

country without nuke clear weapons, but

0:19:380:19:38

country without nuke clear weapons, but the

0:19:380:19:40

country without nuke clear weapons, but the UK's

0:19:400:19:40

country without nuke clear weapons, but the UK's nuclear

0:19:400:19:41

country without nuke clear weapons, but the UK's nuclear deterrent

0:19:410:19:41

country without nuke clear weapons, but the UK's nuclear deterrent is

0:19:410:19:42

but the UK's nuclear deterrent is based

0:19:420:19:42

but the UK's nuclear deterrent is based here.

0:19:420:19:43

but the UK's nuclear deterrent is based here. To

0:19:430:19:43

but the UK's nuclear deterrent is based here. To relocate

0:19:430:19:43

but the UK's nuclear deterrent is based here. To relocate would

0:19:430:19:45

based here. To relocate would cost billions,

0:19:450:19:46

based here. To relocate would cost billions, so

0:19:460:19:46

based here. To relocate would cost billions, so the

0:19:460:19:46

based here. To relocate would cost billions, so the Ministry

0:19:460:19:46

based here. To relocate would cost billions, so the Ministry of

0:19:460:19:46

billions, so the Ministry of Defence

0:19:460:19:47

billions, so the Ministry of Defence is

0:19:470:19:47

billions, so the Ministry of Defence is said

0:19:470:19:47

billions, so the Ministry of Defence is said to

0:19:470:19:48

billions, so the Ministry of Defence is said to be

0:19:480:19:49

billions, so the Ministry of Defence is said to be looking

0:19:490:19:49

billions, so the Ministry of Defence is said to be looking at

0:19:490:19:49

Defence is said to be looking at designating

0:19:490:19:49

Defence is said to be looking at designating the

0:19:490:19:50

Defence is said to be looking at designating the area

0:19:500:19:51

Defence is said to be looking at designating the area sovereign

0:19:510:19:52

Defence is said to be looking at designating the area sovereign UK

0:19:520:19:52

designating the area sovereign UK territory.

0:19:520:19:52

designating the area sovereign UK territory. What

0:19:520:19:52

designating the area sovereign UK territory. What about

0:19:520:19:52

designating the area sovereign UK territory. What about Balmoral.

0:19:520:19:55

territory. What about Balmoral. Alex

0:19:550:19:55

territory. What about Balmoral. Alex Salmond

0:19:550:19:55

territory. What about Balmoral. Alex Salmond wants

0:19:550:19:56

territory. What about Balmoral. Alex Salmond wants the

0:19:560:19:56

territory. What about Balmoral. Alex Salmond wants the Queen

0:19:560:19:56

territory. What about Balmoral. Alex Salmond wants the Queen to

0:19:560:19:56

Alex Salmond wants the Queen to remain

0:19:560:19:56

Alex Salmond wants the Queen to remain head

0:19:560:19:57

Alex Salmond wants the Queen to remain head of

0:19:570:19:57

Alex Salmond wants the Queen to remain head of state,

0:19:570:19:57

Alex Salmond wants the Queen to remain head of state, a

0:19:570:19:58

Alex Salmond wants the Queen to remain head of state, a view

0:19:580:19:58

Alex Salmond wants the Queen to remain head of state, a view shared

0:19:580:19:58

remain head of state, a view shared by

0:19:580:19:59

remain head of state, a view shared by most

0:19:590:19:59

remain head of state, a view shared by most of

0:19:590:19:59

remain head of state, a view shared by most of the

0:19:590:19:59

remain head of state, a view shared by most of the Scottish

0:19:590:19:59

remain head of state, a view shared by most of the Scottish public.

0:19:590:20:00

by most of the Scottish public. Others

0:20:000:20:00

by most of the Scottish public. Others in

0:20:000:20:01

by most of the Scottish public. Others in the

0:20:010:20:01

by most of the Scottish public. Others in the independence

0:20:010:20:01

by most of the Scottish public. Others in the independence campaign

0:20:010:20:01

Others in the independence campaign have

0:20:010:20:02

Others in the independence campaign have mooted

0:20:020:20:02

Others in the independence campaign have mooted the

0:20:020:20:02

Others in the independence campaign have mooted the idea

0:20:020:20:02

Others in the independence campaign have mooted the idea of

0:20:020:20:03

Others in the independence campaign have mooted the idea of a

0:20:030:20:04

Others in the independence campaign have mooted the idea of a Republic.

0:20:040:20:05

have mooted the idea of a Republic. Right

0:20:050:20:05

have mooted the idea of a Republic. Right at

0:20:050:20:05

have mooted the idea of a Republic. Right at the

0:20:050:20:05

have mooted the idea of a Republic. Right at the very

0:20:050:20:06

have mooted the idea of a Republic. Right at the very beginning

0:20:060:20:06

have mooted the idea of a Republic. Right at the very beginning of

0:20:060:20:06

have mooted the idea of a Republic. Right at the very beginning of this

0:20:060:20:06

Right at the very beginning of this he

0:20:060:20:06

Right at the very beginning of this he d

0:20:060:20:07

Right at the very beginning of this he d bait,

0:20:070:20:07

Right at the very beginning of this he d bait, in

0:20:070:20:07

Right at the very beginning of this he d bait, in your

0:20:070:20:08

Right at the very beginning of this he d bait, in your opening

0:20:080:20:08

Right at the very beginning of this he d bait, in your opening pitch,

0:20:080:20:08

he d bait, in your opening pitch, you

0:20:080:20:08

he d bait, in your opening pitch, you said,

0:20:080:20:09

he d bait, in your opening pitch, you said, in

0:20:090:20:09

he d bait, in your opening pitch, you said, in fact

0:20:090:20:10

he d bait, in your opening pitch, you said, in fact I

0:20:100:20:11

he d bait, in your opening pitch, you said, in fact I think

0:20:110:20:11

he d bait, in your opening pitch, you said, in fact I think the

0:20:110:20:11

he d bait, in your opening pitch, you said, in fact I think the words

0:20:110:20:11

you said, in fact I think the words were

0:20:110:20:12

you said, in fact I think the words were what

0:20:120:20:12

you said, in fact I think the words were what you

0:20:120:20:12

you said, in fact I think the words were what you wanted

0:20:120:20:13

you said, in fact I think the words were what you wanted was

0:20:130:20:14

were what you wanted was Scottish decisions

0:20:140:20:14

were what you wanted was Scottish decisions about

0:20:140:20:14

were what you wanted was Scottish decisions about Scotland,

0:20:140:20:14

were what you wanted was Scottish decisions about Scotland, made

0:20:140:20:15

were what you wanted was Scottish decisions about Scotland, made in

0:20:150:20:15

decisions about Scotland, made in Scotland.

0:20:150:20:16

decisions about Scotland, made in Scotland. But

0:20:160:20:17

decisions about Scotland, made in Scotland. But the

0:20:170:20:17

decisions about Scotland, made in Scotland. But the way

0:20:170:20:18

decisions about Scotland, made in Scotland. But the way that

0:20:180:20:18

decisions about Scotland, made in Scotland. But the way that you

0:20:180:20:18

Scotland. But the way that you characterise

0:20:180:20:19

Scotland. But the way that you characterise the

0:20:190:20:19

Scotland. But the way that you characterise the debate

0:20:190:20:19

Scotland. But the way that you characterise the debate on

0:20:190:20:19

characterise the debate on independence

0:20:190:20:20

characterise the debate on independence means

0:20:200:20:20

characterise the debate on independence means that

0:20:200:20:20

characterise the debate on independence means that what

0:20:200:20:21

characterise the debate on independence means that what you

0:20:210:20:21

independence means that what you want

0:20:210:20:21

independence means that what you want to

0:20:210:20:21

independence means that what you want to have

0:20:210:20:22

independence means that what you want to have is

0:20:220:20:23

independence means that what you want to have is you

0:20:230:20:23

independence means that what you want to have is you want

0:20:230:20:23

independence means that what you want to have is you want to

0:20:230:20:23

independence means that what you want to have is you want to have

0:20:230:20:24

want to have is you want to have the

0:20:240:20:24

want to have is you want to have the sterling,

0:20:240:20:24

want to have is you want to have the sterling, you

0:20:240:20:25

want to have is you want to have the sterling, you want

0:20:250:20:25

want to have is you want to have the sterling, you want sterling,

0:20:250:20:26

the sterling, you want sterling, you

0:20:260:20:26

the sterling, you want sterling, you want

0:20:260:20:27

the sterling, you want sterling, you want to

0:20:270:20:27

the sterling, you want sterling, you want to be

0:20:270:20:27

the sterling, you want sterling, you want to be possibly

0:20:270:20:27

the sterling, you want sterling, you want to be possibly part

0:20:270:20:30

the sterling, you want sterling, you want to be possibly part of

0:20:300:20:31

you want to be possibly part of having

0:20:310:20:31

you want to be possibly part of having different

0:20:310:20:31

you want to be possibly part of having different defence

0:20:310:20:31

you want to be possibly part of having different defence positions,

0:20:310:20:32

having different defence positions, the

0:20:320:20:33

having different defence positions, the monarchy,

0:20:330:20:33

having different defence positions, the monarchy, you

0:20:330:20:33

having different defence positions, the monarchy, you want

0:20:330:20:33

having different defence positions, the monarchy, you want financial

0:20:330:20:34

the monarchy, you want financial institutions

0:20:340:20:34

the monarchy, you want financial institutions to

0:20:340:20:34

the monarchy, you want financial institutions to still

0:20:340:20:34

the monarchy, you want financial institutions to still be

0:20:340:20:35

the monarchy, you want financial institutions to still be the

0:20:350:20:35

the monarchy, you want financial institutions to still be the same.

0:20:350:20:36

institutions to still be the same. These

0:20:360:20:36

institutions to still be the same. These decisions

0:20:360:20:36

institutions to still be the same. These decisions won't

0:20:360:20:37

institutions to still be the same. These decisions won't be

0:20:370:20:37

institutions to still be the same. These decisions won't be within

0:20:370:20:37

These decisions won't be within your

0:20:370:20:37

These decisions won't be within your grasp.

0:20:370:20:38

These decisions won't be within your grasp. If

0:20:380:20:38

These decisions won't be within your grasp. If you

0:20:380:20:38

These decisions won't be within your grasp. If you want

0:20:380:20:38

These decisions won't be within your grasp. If you want to

0:20:380:20:39

These decisions won't be within your grasp. If you want to stick

0:20:390:20:39

These decisions won't be within your grasp. If you want to stick to

0:20:390:20:39

your grasp. If you want to stick to sterling

0:20:390:20:39

your grasp. If you want to stick to sterling you

0:20:390:20:40

your grasp. If you want to stick to sterling you will

0:20:400:20:40

your grasp. If you want to stick to sterling you will be

0:20:400:20:41

your grasp. If you want to stick to sterling you will be in

0:20:410:20:41

your grasp. If you want to stick to sterling you will be in hock

0:20:410:20:41

your grasp. If you want to stick to sterling you will be in hock other

0:20:410:20:41

sterling you will be in hock other thral

0:20:410:20:42

sterling you will be in hock other thral to

0:20:420:20:43

sterling you will be in hock other thral to Treasury

0:20:430:20:43

sterling you will be in hock other thral to Treasury decisions

0:20:430:20:44

sterling you will be in hock other thral to Treasury decisions in

0:20:440:20:45

thral to Treasury decisions in London?

0:20:450:20:45

thral to Treasury decisions in London? Interest

0:20:450:20:45

thral to Treasury decisions in London? Interest rates

0:20:450:20:45

thral to Treasury decisions in London? Interest rates are

0:20:450:20:46

thral to Treasury decisions in London? Interest rates are not

0:20:460:20:46

thral to Treasury decisions in London? Interest rates are not set

0:20:460:20:46

London? Interest rates are not set by

0:20:460:20:46

London? Interest rates are not set by the

0:20:460:20:46

London? Interest rates are not set by the Treasury

0:20:460:20:47

London? Interest rates are not set by the Treasury but

0:20:470:20:47

London? Interest rates are not set by the Treasury but independently

0:20:470:20:48

by the Treasury but independently by

0:20:480:20:48

by the Treasury but independently by the Bank of

0:20:480:20:48

by the Treasury but independently by the Bank of England.

0:20:480:20:48

by the Treasury but independently by the Bank of England. We

0:20:480:20:48

by the Treasury but independently by the Bank of England. We want

0:20:480:20:48

by the Treasury but independently by the Bank of England. We want to

0:20:480:20:49

by the Bank of England. We want to keep

0:20:490:20:49

by the Bank of England. We want to keep our

0:20:490:20:49

by the Bank of England. We want to keep our pound,

0:20:490:20:49

by the Bank of England. We want to keep our pound, it

0:20:490:20:50

by the Bank of England. We want to keep our pound, it is

0:20:500:20:50

by the Bank of England. We want to keep our pound, it is as

0:20:500:20:50

by the Bank of England. We want to keep our pound, it is as much

0:20:500:20:51

keep our pound, it is as much Scotland's

0:20:510:20:51

keep our pound, it is as much Scotland's pound as

0:20:510:20:51

keep our pound, it is as much Scotland's pound as it

0:20:510:20:52

keep our pound, it is as much Scotland's pound as it is

0:20:520:20:52

keep our pound, it is as much Scotland's pound as it is the

0:20:520:20:52

keep our pound, it is as much Scotland's pound as it is the pound

0:20:520:20:52

Scotland's pound as it is the pound of

0:20:520:20:53

Scotland's pound as it is the pound of the

0:20:530:20:54

Scotland's pound as it is the pound of the UK.

0:20:540:20:54

Scotland's pound as it is the pound of the UK. Independence

0:20:540:20:55

Scotland's pound as it is the pound of the UK. Independence gives

0:20:550:20:55

Scotland's pound as it is the pound of the UK. Independence gives us

0:20:550:20:56

of the UK. Independence gives us fiscal

0:20:560:20:56

of the UK. Independence gives us fiscal powers

0:20:560:20:56

of the UK. Independence gives us fiscal powers and

0:20:560:20:56

of the UK. Independence gives us fiscal powers and powers

0:20:560:20:58

of the UK. Independence gives us fiscal powers and powers over

0:20:580:20:58

of the UK. Independence gives us fiscal powers and powers over tax

0:20:580:20:58

fiscal powers and powers over tax and

0:20:580:20:58

fiscal powers and powers over tax and the

0:20:580:20:58

fiscal powers and powers over tax and the welfare

0:20:580:20:59

fiscal powers and powers over tax and the welfare state

0:20:590:20:59

fiscal powers and powers over tax and the welfare state to

0:20:590:20:59

fiscal powers and powers over tax and the welfare state to do

0:20:590:20:59

fiscal powers and powers over tax and the welfare state to do what

0:20:590:21:00

fiscal powers and powers over tax and the welfare state to do what we

0:21:000:21:00

and the welfare state to do what we have

0:21:000:21:00

and the welfare state to do what we have been

0:21:000:21:00

and the welfare state to do what we have been talking

0:21:000:21:01

and the welfare state to do what we have been talking about,

0:21:010:21:01

and the welfare state to do what we have been talking about, get

0:21:010:21:01

and the welfare state to do what we have been talking about, get the

0:21:010:21:01

have been talking about, get the economy

0:21:010:21:02

have been talking about, get the economy growing,

0:21:020:21:02

have been talking about, get the economy growing, create

0:21:020:21:02

have been talking about, get the economy growing, create jobs

0:21:020:21:03

have been talking about, get the economy growing, create jobs and

0:21:030:21:03

economy growing, create jobs and the

0:21:030:21:03

economy growing, create jobs and the public

0:21:030:21:04

economy growing, create jobs and the public services

0:21:040:21:04

economy growing, create jobs and the public services we

0:21:040:21:04

economy growing, create jobs and the public services we want

0:21:040:21:04

economy growing, create jobs and the public services we want with

0:21:040:21:04

the public services we want with the

0:21:040:21:05

the public services we want with the wealth

0:21:050:21:06

the public services we want with the wealth it

0:21:060:21:06

the public services we want with the wealth it create.

0:21:060:21:06

the public services we want with the wealth it create. Do

0:21:060:21:07

the public services we want with the wealth it create. Do you

0:21:070:21:07

the public services we want with the wealth it create. Do you think

0:21:070:21:07

the wealth it create. Do you think it

0:21:070:21:07

the wealth it create. Do you think it will

0:21:070:21:08

the wealth it create. Do you think it will be

0:21:080:21:08

the wealth it create. Do you think it will be necessarily

0:21:080:21:08

the wealth it create. Do you think it will be necessarily in

0:21:080:21:09

the wealth it create. Do you think it will be necessarily in Nicola

0:21:090:21:09

it will be necessarily in Nicola Sturgeon's

0:21:090:21:10

it will be necessarily in Nicola Sturgeon's gift

0:21:100:21:10

it will be necessarily in Nicola Sturgeon's gift if

0:21:100:21:11

it will be necessarily in Nicola Sturgeon's gift if Scotland

0:21:110:21:11

it will be necessarily in Nicola Sturgeon's gift if Scotland was

0:21:110:21:11

it will be necessarily in Nicola Sturgeon's gift if Scotland was to

0:21:110:21:11

Sturgeon's gift if Scotland was to vote

0:21:110:21:11

Sturgeon's gift if Scotland was to vote yes

0:21:110:21:12

Sturgeon's gift if Scotland was to vote yes for

0:21:120:21:12

Sturgeon's gift if Scotland was to vote yes for Scotland

0:21:120:21:12

Sturgeon's gift if Scotland was to vote yes for Scotland to

0:21:120:21:13

Sturgeon's gift if Scotland was to vote yes for Scotland to keep

0:21:130:21:13

Sturgeon's gift if Scotland was to vote yes for Scotland to keep the

0:21:130:21:14

vote yes for Scotland to keep the pound?

0:21:140:21:14

vote yes for Scotland to keep the pound? That

0:21:140:21:14

vote yes for Scotland to keep the pound? That is

0:21:140:21:15

vote yes for Scotland to keep the pound? That is hard

0:21:150:21:15

vote yes for Scotland to keep the pound? That is hard to

0:21:150:21:15

vote yes for Scotland to keep the pound? That is hard to predict

0:21:150:21:15

vote yes for Scotland to keep the pound? That is hard to predict with

0:21:150:21:16

pound? That is hard to predict with any

0:21:160:21:16

pound? That is hard to predict with any certainty,

0:21:160:21:17

pound? That is hard to predict with any certainty, we

0:21:170:21:17

pound? That is hard to predict with any certainty, we can

0:21:170:21:17

pound? That is hard to predict with any certainty, we can say

0:21:170:21:18

any certainty, we can say everything

0:21:180:21:18

any certainty, we can say everything Nicola

0:21:180:21:18

any certainty, we can say everything Nicola has

0:21:180:21:18

any certainty, we can say everything Nicola has said

0:21:180:21:19

any certainty, we can say everything Nicola has said about

0:21:190:21:19

everything Nicola has said about the

0:21:190:21:19

everything Nicola has said about the advantages

0:21:190:21:19

everything Nicola has said about the advantages of

0:21:190:21:20

everything Nicola has said about the advantages of a

0:21:200:21:20

everything Nicola has said about the advantages of a sterling

0:21:200:21:20

everything Nicola has said about the advantages of a sterling union

0:21:200:21:21

the advantages of a sterling union is

0:21:210:21:21

the advantages of a sterling union is what

0:21:210:21:21

the advantages of a sterling union is what she

0:21:210:21:21

the advantages of a sterling union is what she and

0:21:210:21:22

the advantages of a sterling union is what she and other

0:21:220:21:22

the advantages of a sterling union is what she and other senior

0:21:220:21:22

is what she and other senior members

0:21:220:21:22

is what she and other senior members of

0:21:220:21:23

is what she and other senior members of the

0:21:230:21:23

is what she and other senior members of the SNP

0:21:230:21:24

is what she and other senior members of the SNP said

0:21:240:21:24

is what she and other senior members of the SNP said until

0:21:240:21:25

is what she and other senior members of the SNP said until very

0:21:250:21:25

members of the SNP said until very recently

0:21:250:21:25

members of the SNP said until very recently about

0:21:250:21:26

members of the SNP said until very recently about membership

0:21:260:21:26

members of the SNP said until very recently about membership of

0:21:260:21:26

members of the SNP said until very recently about membership of the

0:21:260:21:26

recently about membership of the euro.

0:21:260:21:27

recently about membership of the euro. That

0:21:270:21:27

recently about membership of the euro. That would

0:21:270:21:27

recently about membership of the euro. That would bring

0:21:270:21:28

recently about membership of the euro. That would bring up

0:21:280:21:28

recently about membership of the euro. That would bring up many

0:21:280:21:28

recently about membership of the euro. That would bring up many of

0:21:280:21:29

euro. That would bring up many of the

0:21:290:21:29

euro. That would bring up many of the same

0:21:290:21:29

euro. That would bring up many of the same problems

0:21:290:21:29

euro. That would bring up many of the same problems as

0:21:290:21:30

euro. That would bring up many of the same problems as a

0:21:300:21:30

euro. That would bring up many of the same problems as a sterling

0:21:300:21:30

the same problems as a sterling union

0:21:300:21:31

the same problems as a sterling union within

0:21:310:21:31

the same problems as a sterling union within the

0:21:310:21:31

the same problems as a sterling union within the UK.

0:21:310:21:32

the same problems as a sterling union within the UK. The

0:21:320:21:33

the same problems as a sterling union within the UK. The SNP's

0:21:330:21:33

union within the UK. The SNP's currency

0:21:330:21:33

union within the UK. The SNP's currency position

0:21:330:21:34

union within the UK. The SNP's currency position is

0:21:340:21:34

union within the UK. The SNP's currency position is one

0:21:340:21:34

union within the UK. The SNP's currency position is one of

0:21:340:21:35

currency position is one of convience

0:21:350:21:35

currency position is one of convience and

0:21:350:21:35

currency position is one of convience and political

0:21:350:21:35

currency position is one of convience and political opportunism

0:21:350:21:36

convience and political opportunism as

0:21:360:21:36

convience and political opportunism as much

0:21:360:21:36

convience and political opportunism as much as

0:21:360:21:36

convience and political opportunism as much as it

0:21:360:21:37

convience and political opportunism as much as it is

0:21:370:21:37

convience and political opportunism as much as it is a

0:21:370:21:37

convience and political opportunism as much as it is a principle.

0:21:370:21:38

convience and political opportunism as much as it is a principle. That

0:21:380:21:38

as much as it is a principle. That is

0:21:380:21:38

as much as it is a principle. That is absolutely

0:21:380:21:38

as much as it is a principle. That is absolutely fine,

0:21:380:21:39

as much as it is a principle. That is absolutely fine, but

0:21:390:21:39

as much as it is a principle. That is absolutely fine, but it

0:21:390:21:39

as much as it is a principle. That is absolutely fine, but it is

0:21:390:21:40

is absolutely fine, but it is designed

0:21:400:21:40

is absolutely fine, but it is designed to

0:21:400:21:41

is absolutely fine, but it is designed to eliminate

0:21:410:21:41

is absolutely fine, but it is designed to eliminate uncertainty,

0:21:410:21:41

designed to eliminate uncertainty, it

0:21:410:21:41

designed to eliminate uncertainty, it is

0:21:410:21:42

designed to eliminate uncertainty, it is not

0:21:420:21:42

designed to eliminate uncertainty, it is not because

0:21:420:21:42

designed to eliminate uncertainty, it is not because they

0:21:420:21:43

designed to eliminate uncertainty, it is not because they have

0:21:430:21:43

it is not because they have suddenly

0:21:430:21:43

it is not because they have suddenly realised

0:21:430:21:43

it is not because they have suddenly realised that

0:21:430:21:43

it is not because they have suddenly realised that sterling

0:21:430:21:44

it is not because they have suddenly realised that sterling is

0:21:440:21:44

suddenly realised that sterling is the

0:21:440:21:44

suddenly realised that sterling is the best

0:21:440:21:45

suddenly realised that sterling is the best answer

0:21:450:21:46

suddenly realised that sterling is the best answer for

0:21:460:21:46

suddenly realised that sterling is the best answer for Scotland.

0:21:460:21:46

suddenly realised that sterling is the best answer for Scotland. It

0:21:460:21:46

suddenly realised that sterling is the best answer for Scotland. It is

0:21:460:21:47

suddenly realised that sterling is their third

0:21:470:34:55

I'm not suggesting people whinge at Westminster

0:34:550:34:55

I'm not suggesting people whinge at Westminster but

0:34:550:34:55

I'm not suggesting people whinge at Westminster but wouldn't

0:34:550:34:56

I'm not suggesting people whinge at Westminster but wouldn't be

0:34:560:34:57

I'm not suggesting people whinge at Westminster but wouldn't be able

0:34:570:34:57

I'm not suggesting people whinge at Westminster but wouldn't be able to

0:34:570:34:57

Westminster but wouldn't be able to blame

0:34:570:34:57

Westminster but wouldn't be able to blame Westminster

0:34:570:34:58

Westminster but wouldn't be able to blame Westminster for

0:34:580:34:58

Westminster but wouldn't be able to blame Westminster for the

0:34:580:34:59

Westminster but wouldn't be able to blame Westminster for the nation's

0:34:590:35:00

blame Westminster for the nation's ills?

0:35:000:35:00

blame Westminster for the nation's ills? We

0:35:000:35:00

blame Westminster for the nation's ills? We have

0:35:000:35:00

blame Westminster for the nation's ills? We have to

0:35:000:35:00

blame Westminster for the nation's ills? We have to distinguish

0:35:000:35:01

ills? We have to distinguish between

0:35:010:35:01

ills? We have to distinguish between it,

0:35:010:35:02

ills? We have to distinguish between it, we

0:35:020:35:02

ills? We have to distinguish between it, we talk

0:35:020:35:03

ills? We have to distinguish between it, we talk about

0:35:030:35:03

between it, we talk about ideology. That

0:35:030:35:03

between it, we talk about ideology. That is

0:35:030:35:04

between it, we talk about ideology. That is not

0:35:040:35:04

between it, we talk about ideology. That is not reality.

0:35:040:35:04

between it, we talk about ideology. That is not reality. There

0:35:040:35:04

between it, we talk about ideology. That is not reality. There are

0:35:040:35:04

That is not reality. There are loads

0:35:040:35:05

That is not reality. There are loads of

0:35:050:35:05

That is not reality. There are loads of things

0:35:050:35:05

That is not reality. There are loads of things I

0:35:050:35:05

That is not reality. There are loads of things I would

0:35:050:35:05

That is not reality. There are loads of things I would love

0:35:050:35:06

That is not reality. There are loads of things I would love to

0:35:060:35:06

That is not reality. There are loads of things I would love to do

0:35:060:35:06

loads of things I would love to do that

0:35:060:35:06

loads of things I would love to do that aren't

0:35:060:35:06

loads of things I would love to do that aren't the

0:35:060:35:07

loads of things I would love to do that aren't the right

0:35:070:35:07

loads of things I would love to do that aren't the right thing

0:35:070:35:07

loads of things I would love to do that aren't the right thing to

0:35:070:35:07

loads of things I would love to do that aren't the right thing to do.

0:35:070:35:08

that aren't the right thing to do. What

0:35:080:35:08

that aren't the right thing to do. What I

0:35:080:35:08

that aren't the right thing to do. What I can

0:35:080:35:08

that aren't the right thing to do. What I can tell

0:35:080:35:09

that aren't the right thing to do. What I can tell you

0:35:090:35:09

that aren't the right thing to do. What I can tell you we

0:35:090:35:09

that aren't the right thing to do. What I can tell you we are

0:35:090:35:10

that aren't the right thing to do. What I can tell you we are talking

0:35:100:35:10

What I can tell you we are talking about

0:35:100:35:11

What I can tell you we are talking about my

0:35:110:35:11

What I can tell you we are talking about my sector,

0:35:110:35:11

What I can tell you we are talking about my sector, now

0:35:110:35:12

What I can tell you we are talking about my sector, now we're

0:35:120:35:12

about my sector, now we're struggling

0:35:120:35:12

about my sector, now we're struggling in

0:35:120:35:13

about my sector, now we're struggling in a

0:35:130:35:13

about my sector, now we're struggling in a retail

0:35:130:35:14

about my sector, now we're struggling in a retail environment

0:35:140:35:15

struggling in a retail environment with

0:35:150:35:15

struggling in a retail environment with supporting

0:35:150:35:16

struggling in a retail environment with supporting new

0:35:160:35:16

struggling in a retail environment with supporting new industry,

0:35:160:35:17

with supporting new industry, textiles.

0:35:170:35:18

with supporting new industry, textiles. All

0:35:180:35:18

with supporting new industry, textiles. All the

0:35:180:35:18

with supporting new industry, textiles. All the best

0:35:180:35:18

with supporting new industry, textiles. All the best of

0:35:180:35:19

with supporting new industry, textiles. All the best of British

0:35:190:35:20

textiles. All the best of British designers

0:35:200:35:20

textiles. All the best of British designers right

0:35:200:35:20

textiles. All the best of British designers right now

0:35:200:35:20

textiles. All the best of British designers right now at

0:35:200:35:20

textiles. All the best of British designers right now at the

0:35:200:35:21

textiles. All the best of British designers right now at the top

0:35:210:35:21

textiles. All the best of British designers right now at the top of

0:35:210:35:21

designers right now at the top of their

0:35:210:35:21

designers right now at the top of their game

0:35:210:35:22

designers right now at the top of their game trading all

0:35:220:35:22

designers right now at the top of their game trading all across

0:35:220:35:22

designers right now at the top of their game trading all across the

0:35:220:35:23

their game trading all across the world

0:35:230:35:23

their game trading all across the world are

0:35:230:35:23

their game trading all across the world are Scottish.

0:35:230:35:23

their game trading all across the world are Scottish. How

0:35:230:35:24

their game trading all across the world are Scottish. How did

0:35:240:35:24

their game trading all across the world are Scottish. How did they

0:35:240:35:25

world are Scottish. How did they get

0:35:250:35:25

world are Scottish. How did they get there? From

0:35:250:35:25

world are Scottish. How did they get there? From the

0:35:250:35:25

world are Scottish. How did they get there? From the support

0:35:250:35:26

world are Scottish. How did they get there? From the support and

0:35:260:35:26

get there? From the support and grants

0:35:260:35:27

get there? From the support and grants from

0:35:270:35:27

get there? From the support and grants from the

0:35:270:35:27

get there? From the support and grants from the British

0:35:270:35:27

get there? From the support and grants from the British Fashion

0:35:270:35:27

grants from the British Fashion Council,

0:35:270:35:28

grants from the British Fashion Council, and

0:35:280:35:29

grants from the British Fashion Council, and the

0:35:290:35:29

grants from the British Fashion Council, and the British

0:35:290:35:29

grants from the British Fashion Council, and the British Trade

0:35:290:35:29

grants from the British Fashion Council, and the British Trade and

0:35:290:35:30

Council, and the British Trade and Industry

0:35:300:35:31

Council, and the British Trade and Industry sector,

0:35:310:35:31

Council, and the British Trade and Industry sector, not

0:35:310:35:31

Council, and the British Trade and Industry sector, not Scotland.

0:35:310:35:34

Council, and the British Trade and Industry sector, not Scotland. Now

0:35:340:35:35

Industry sector, not Scotland. Now they

0:35:350:35:35

Industry sector, not Scotland. Now they are

0:35:350:35:35

Industry sector, not Scotland. Now they are so

0:35:350:35:36

Industry sector, not Scotland. Now they are so proud

0:35:360:35:36

Industry sector, not Scotland. Now they are so proud to

0:35:360:35:36

Industry sector, not Scotland. Now they are so proud to be

0:35:360:35:36

Industry sector, not Scotland. Now they are so proud to be Scottish

0:35:360:35:37

they are so proud to be Scottish and

0:35:370:35:37

they are so proud to be Scottish and incredibly

0:35:370:35:37

they are so proud to be Scottish and incredibly proud

0:35:370:35:37

they are so proud to be Scottish and incredibly proud to

0:35:370:35:37

they are so proud to be Scottish and incredibly proud to be

0:35:370:35:38

they are so proud to be Scottish and incredibly proud to be British,

0:35:380:35:38

and incredibly proud to be British, the

0:35:380:35:38

and incredibly proud to be British, the reality

0:35:380:35:38

and incredibly proud to be British, the reality is

0:35:380:35:39

and incredibly proud to be British, the reality is they

0:35:390:35:39

and incredibly proud to be British, the reality is they wouldn't

0:35:390:35:39

and incredibly proud to be British, the reality is they wouldn't be

0:35:390:35:39

the reality is they wouldn't be there

0:35:390:35:40

the reality is they wouldn't be there without

0:35:400:35:40

the reality is they wouldn't be there without the

0:35:400:35:40

the reality is they wouldn't be there without the support

0:35:400:35:42

the reality is they wouldn't be there without the support of

0:35:420:35:42

there without the support of England.

0:35:420:35:42

there without the support of England. Do

0:35:420:35:42

there without the support of England. Do you

0:35:420:35:43

there without the support of England. Do you feel,

0:35:430:35:43

there without the support of England. Do you feel, Margaret

0:35:430:35:43

England. Do you feel, Margaret Curran,

0:35:430:35:43

England. Do you feel, Margaret Curran, here

0:35:430:35:44

England. Do you feel, Margaret Curran, here we

0:35:440:35:44

England. Do you feel, Margaret Curran, here we are

0:35:440:35:44

England. Do you feel, Margaret Curran, here we are on

0:35:440:35:44

England. Do you feel, Margaret Curran, here we are on the

0:35:440:35:45

England. Do you feel, Margaret Curran, here we are on the border,

0:35:450:35:45

Curran, here we are on the border, do

0:35:450:35:45

Curran, here we are on the border, do you

0:35:450:35:45

Curran, here we are on the border, do you think

0:35:450:35:46

Curran, here we are on the border, do you think that

0:35:460:35:46

Curran, here we are on the border, do you think that the

0:35:460:35:46

Curran, here we are on the border, do you think that the border

0:35:460:35:47

Curran, here we are on the border, do you think that the border would

0:35:470:35:47

do you think that the border would be

0:35:470:35:47

do you think that the border would be open

0:35:470:35:48

do you think that the border would be open or

0:35:480:35:48

do you think that the border would be open or closed,

0:35:480:35:49

do you think that the border would be open or closed, not

0:35:490:35:49

do you think that the border would be open or closed, not closed,

0:35:490:35:50

do you think that the border would be open or closed, not closed, but

0:35:500:35:50

be open or closed, not closed, but there

0:35:500:35:50

be open or closed, not closed, but there would

0:35:500:35:50

be open or closed, not closed, but there would be

0:35:500:35:50

be open or closed, not closed, but there would be border

0:35:500:35:51

be open or closed, not closed, but there would be border controls

0:35:510:35:51

there would be border controls between

0:35:510:35:51

there would be border controls between England

0:35:510:35:52

there would be border controls between England and

0:35:520:35:52

there would be border controls between England and Scotland?

0:35:520:35:52

there would be border controls between England and Scotland? That

0:35:520:35:53

between England and Scotland? That would

0:35:530:35:53

between England and Scotland? That would depend

0:35:530:35:54

between England and Scotland? That would depend on

0:35:540:35:55

between England and Scotland? That would depend on what

0:35:550:35:55

between England and Scotland? That would depend on what arrange.Ments,

0:35:550:35:58

would depend on what arrange.Ments, but

0:35:580:35:59

would depend on what arrange.Ments, but part...You

0:35:590:36:00

would depend on what arrange.Ments, but part...You Can't

0:36:000:36:00

would depend on what arrange.Ments, but part...You Can't go

0:36:000:36:00

would depend on what arrange.Ments, but part...You Can't go on

0:36:000:36:00

would depend on what arrange.Ments, but part...You Can't go on about

0:36:000:36:01

but part...You Can't go on about crossing

0:36:010:36:01

but part...You Can't go on about crossing borders.

0:36:010:36:02

but part...You Can't go on about crossing borders. One

0:36:020:36:02

but part...You Can't go on about crossing borders. One of

0:36:020:36:02

but part...You Can't go on about crossing borders. One of the

0:36:020:36:03

crossing borders. One of the reasons

0:36:030:36:03

crossing borders. One of the reasons I

0:36:030:36:03

crossing borders. One of the reasons I emphasise

0:36:030:36:03

crossing borders. One of the reasons I emphasise my

0:36:030:36:04

crossing borders. One of the reasons I emphasise my Scottishness

0:36:040:36:04

reasons I emphasise my Scottishness is

0:36:040:36:04

reasons I emphasise my Scottishness is I

0:36:040:36:04

reasons I emphasise my Scottishness is I have

0:36:040:36:05

reasons I emphasise my Scottishness is I have to

0:36:050:36:05

reasons I emphasise my Scottishness is I have to say

0:36:050:36:05

reasons I emphasise my Scottishness is I have to say people

0:36:050:36:05

reasons I emphasise my Scottishness is I have to say people who

0:36:050:36:06

reasons I emphasise my Scottishness is I have to say people who are

0:36:060:36:06

reasons I emphasise my Scottishness is I have to say people who are on

0:36:060:36:07

is I have to say people who are on my

0:36:070:36:07

is I have to say people who are on my side

0:36:070:36:07

is I have to say people who are on my side of

0:36:070:36:08

is I have to say people who are on my side of the

0:36:080:36:08

is I have to say people who are on my side of the argument

0:36:080:36:08

is I have to say people who are on my side of the argument have

0:36:080:36:08

is I have to say people who are on my side of the argument have been

0:36:080:36:09

my side of the argument have been accused

0:36:090:36:10

my side of the argument have been accused of

0:36:100:36:13

my side of the argument have been accused of being

0:36:130:36:13

my side of the argument have been accused of being anti-Scottish.

0:36:130:36:13

my side of the argument have been accused of being anti-Scottish. I'm

0:36:130:36:13

accused of being anti-Scottish. I'm sure

0:36:130:36:14

accused of being anti-Scottish. I'm sure Nicola

0:36:140:36:14

accused of being anti-Scottish. I'm sure Nicola and

0:36:140:36:14

accused of being anti-Scottish. I'm sure Nicola and Pat

0:36:140:36:15

accused of being anti-Scottish. I'm sure Nicola and Pat would

0:36:150:36:15

accused of being anti-Scottish. I'm sure Nicola and Pat would disavow

0:36:150:36:15

sure Nicola and Pat would disavow that.

0:36:150:36:16

sure Nicola and Pat would disavow that. It

0:36:160:36:16

sure Nicola and Pat would disavow that. It is

0:36:160:36:16

sure Nicola and Pat would disavow that. It is important

0:36:160:36:16

sure Nicola and Pat would disavow that. It is important in

0:36:160:36:17

sure Nicola and Pat would disavow that. It is important in this

0:36:170:36:17

that. It is important in this debate.

0:36:170:36:17

that. It is important in this debate. It

0:36:170:36:17

that. It is important in this debate. It is

0:36:170:36:18

that. It is important in this debate. It is a

0:36:180:36:18

that. It is important in this debate. It is a favoured

0:36:180:36:19

that. It is important in this debate. It is a favoured debate

0:36:190:36:19

debate. It is a favoured debate already,

0:36:190:36:19

debate. It is a favoured debate already, I

0:36:190:36:20

debate. It is a favoured debate already, I can

0:36:200:36:20

debate. It is a favoured debate already, I can imagine it

0:36:200:36:20

debate. It is a favoured debate already, I can imagine it will

0:36:200:36:21

debate. It is a favoured debate already, I can imagine it will get

0:36:210:36:21

already, I can imagine it will get more

0:36:210:36:21

already, I can imagine it will get more as

0:36:210:36:21

already, I can imagine it will get more as the

0:36:210:36:21

already, I can imagine it will get more as the year

0:36:210:36:22

already, I can imagine it will get more as the year goes

0:36:220:36:22

already, I can imagine it will get more as the year goes on.

0:36:220:36:22

already, I can imagine it will get more as the year goes on. It

0:36:220:36:22

already, I can imagine it will get more as the year goes on. It is

0:36:220:36:23

more as the year goes on. It is important

0:36:230:36:23

more as the year goes on. It is important that

0:36:230:36:23

more as the year goes on. It is important that those

0:36:230:36:23

more as the year goes on. It is important that those on

0:36:230:36:24

more as the year goes on. It is important that those on my

0:36:240:36:24

more as the year goes on. It is important that those on my side

0:36:240:36:25

more as the year goes on. It is important that those on my side who

0:36:250:36:25

important that those on my side who do

0:36:250:36:25

important that those on my side who do see

0:36:250:36:25

important that those on my side who do see that

0:36:250:36:25

important that those on my side who do see that Scotland

0:36:250:36:26

important that those on my side who do see that Scotland gets

0:36:260:36:26

important that those on my side who do see that Scotland gets advantage,

0:36:260:36:27

do see that Scotland gets advantage, not

0:36:270:36:27

do see that Scotland gets advantage, not that

0:36:270:36:27

do see that Scotland gets advantage, not that it

0:36:270:36:27

do see that Scotland gets advantage, not that it is

0:36:270:36:28

do see that Scotland gets advantage, not that it is good

0:36:280:36:28

do see that Scotland gets advantage, not that it is good to

0:36:280:36:28

do see that Scotland gets advantage, not that it is good to be

0:36:280:36:28

do see that Scotland gets advantage, not that it is good to be nice

0:36:280:36:29

do see that Scotland gets advantage, not that it is good to be nice to

0:36:290:36:29

not that it is good to be nice to your

0:36:290:36:29

not that it is good to be nice to your neighbours

0:36:290:36:30

not that it is good to be nice to your neighbours but

0:36:300:36:31

not that it is good to be nice to your neighbours but we

0:36:310:36:31

not that it is good to be nice to your neighbours but we get

0:36:310:36:32

your neighbours but we get advantages

0:36:320:36:33

your neighbours but we get advantages through sport,

0:36:330:36:33

your neighbours but we get advantages through sport, athletes,

0:36:330:36:34

advantages through sport, athletes, fashion

0:36:340:36:34

advantages through sport, athletes, fashion designers

0:36:340:36:35

advantages through sport, athletes, fashion designers getting

0:36:350:36:35

advantages through sport, athletes, fashion designers getting advantage

0:36:350:36:35

fashion designers getting advantage to

0:36:350:36:35

fashion designers getting advantage to that.

0:36:350:36:35

fashion designers getting advantage to that. That

0:36:350:36:36

fashion designers getting advantage to that. That would

0:36:360:36:36

fashion designers getting advantage to that. That would be

0:36:360:36:36

fashion designers getting advantage to that. That would be a

0:36:360:36:37

fashion designers getting advantage to that. That would be a loss

0:36:370:36:37

fashion designers getting advantage to that. That would be a loss to

0:36:370:36:37

to that. That would be a loss to Scotland

0:36:370:36:37

to that. That would be a loss to Scotland if

0:36:370:36:38

to that. That would be a loss to Scotland if we

0:36:380:36:38

to that. That would be a loss to Scotland if we became

0:36:380:36:39

to that. That would be a loss to Scotland if we became independent.

0:36:390:36:39

Scotland if we became independent. That

0:36:390:36:39

Scotland if we became independent. That is

0:36:390:36:39

Scotland if we became independent. That is a

0:36:390:36:39

Scotland if we became independent. That is a genuine

0:36:390:36:40

Scotland if we became independent. That is a genuine argument

0:36:400:36:40

Scotland if we became independent. That is a genuine argument that

0:36:400:36:40

That is a genuine argument that should

0:36:400:36:41

That is a genuine argument that should be

0:36:410:36:42

That is a genuine argument that should be respected.

0:36:420:36:42

That is a genuine argument that should be respected. When

0:36:420:36:42

That is a genuine argument that should be respected. When you

0:36:420:36:42

That is a genuine argument that should be respected. When you are

0:36:420:36:43

should be respected. When you are up

0:36:430:36:43

should be respected. When you are up and

0:36:430:36:43

should be respected. When you are up and down

0:36:430:36:43

should be respected. When you are up and down to

0:36:430:36:44

should be respected. When you are up and down to London

0:36:440:36:44

should be respected. When you are up and down to London have

0:36:440:36:44

should be respected. When you are up and down to London have you

0:36:440:36:44

up and down to London have you concerns

0:36:440:36:45

up and down to London have you concerns about

0:36:450:36:45

up and down to London have you concerns about the

0:36:450:36:45

up and down to London have you concerns about the border?

0:36:450:36:45

up and down to London have you concerns about the border? I

0:36:450:36:46

up and down to London have you concerns about the border? I do,

0:36:460:36:46

up and down to London have you concerns about the border? I do, if

0:36:460:36:46

concerns about the border? I do, if I'm

0:36:460:36:46

concerns about the border? I do, if I'm going

0:36:460:36:47

concerns about the border? I do, if I'm going to

0:36:470:36:47

concerns about the border? I do, if I'm going to have

0:36:470:36:48

concerns about the border? I do, if I'm going to have to

0:36:480:36:48

concerns about the border? I do, if I'm going to have to stand

0:36:480:36:48

concerns about the border? I do, if I'm going to have to stand in

0:36:480:36:49

concerns about the border? I do, if I'm going to have to stand in the

0:36:490:36:49

I'm going to have to stand in the queue

0:36:490:36:49

I'm going to have to stand in the queue to

0:36:490:36:49

I'm going to have to stand in the queue to make

0:36:490:36:50

I'm going to have to stand in the queue to make a

0:36:500:36:50

I'm going to have to stand in the queue to make a commercial

0:36:500:36:51

I'm going to have to stand in the queue to make a commercial trip

0:36:510:36:51

I'm going to have to stand in the queue to make a commercial trip to

0:36:510:36:51

queue to make a commercial trip to business

0:36:510:36:52

queue to make a commercial trip to business in

0:36:520:36:52

queue to make a commercial trip to business in London

0:36:520:36:52

queue to make a commercial trip to business in London and

0:36:520:36:53

queue to make a commercial trip to business in London and it

0:36:530:36:53

queue to make a commercial trip to business in London and it will

0:36:530:36:53

queue to make a commercial trip to business in London and it will take

0:36:530:36:54

business in London and it will take hours

0:36:540:36:54

business in London and it will take hours that

0:36:540:36:54

business in London and it will take hours that will

0:36:540:36:55

business in London and it will take hours that will have

0:36:550:36:55

business in London and it will take hours that will have an

0:36:550:36:55

business in London and it will take hours that will have an impact

0:36:550:36:55

business in London and it will take hours that will have an impact on

0:36:550:36:59

hours that will have an impact on the

0:36:590:36:59

hours that will have an impact on the day.

0:36:590:37:00

hours that will have an impact on the day. Why

0:37:000:37:00

hours that will have an impact on the day. Why hours?

0:37:000:37:01

hours that will have an impact on the day. Why hours? Because

0:37:010:37:01

hours that will have an impact on the day. Why hours? Because the

0:37:010:37:02

the day. Why hours? Because the British

0:37:020:37:02

the day. Why hours? Because the British Government

0:37:020:37:02

the day. Why hours? Because the British Government will

0:37:020:37:02

the day. Why hours? Because the British Government will have

0:37:020:37:04

the day. Why hours? Because the British Government will have to

0:37:040:37:04

the day. Why hours? Because the British Government will have to put

0:37:040:37:04

British Government will have to put that

0:37:040:37:04

British Government will have to put that in

0:37:040:37:05

British Government will have to put that in border

0:37:050:37:05

British Government will have to put that in border controls.

0:37:050:37:05

British Government will have to put that in border controls. You

0:37:050:37:06

British Government will have to put that in border controls. You want

0:37:060:37:06

that in border controls. You want this,

0:37:060:37:07

that in border controls. You want this, why

0:37:070:37:07

that in border controls. You want this, why are

0:37:070:37:07

that in border controls. You want this, why are you

0:37:070:37:08

that in border controls. You want this, why are you so offended

0:37:080:37:09

that in border controls. You want this, why are you so offended that

0:37:090:37:09

this, why are you so offended that the

0:37:090:37:09

this, why are you so offended that the border

0:37:090:37:09

this, why are you so offended that the border will

0:37:090:37:10

this, why are you so offended that the border will have

0:37:100:37:10

this, why are you so offended that the border will have to

0:37:100:37:11

this, why are you so offended that the border will have to be

0:37:110:37:11

this, why are you so offended that the border will have to be police.

0:37:110:37:11

the border will have to be police. Scotland

0:37:110:37:11

the border will have to be police. Scotland will

0:37:110:37:11

the border will have to be police. Scotland will be

0:37:110:37:12

the border will have to be police. Scotland will be in

0:37:120:37:12

the border will have to be police. Scotland will be in the

0:37:120:37:12

the border will have to be police. Scotland will be in the common

0:37:120:37:12

Scotland will be in the common travel

0:37:120:37:12

Scotland will be in the common travel area

0:37:120:37:13

Scotland will be in the common travel area and

0:37:130:37:13

Scotland will be in the common travel area and the

0:37:130:37:13

Scotland will be in the common travel area and the rest

0:37:130:37:13

Scotland will be in the common travel area and the rest of

0:37:130:37:14

Scotland will be in the common travel area and the rest of the

0:37:140:37:14

Scotland will be in the common travel area and the rest of the UK

0:37:140:37:14

travel area and the rest of the UK in

0:37:140:37:14

travel area and the rest of the UK in Ireland.

0:37:140:37:14

travel area and the rest of the UK in Ireland. You

0:37:140:37:15

travel area and the rest of the UK in Ireland. You can't

0:37:150:37:15

travel area and the rest of the UK in Ireland. You can't answer

0:37:150:37:15

travel area and the rest of the UK in Ireland. You can't answer that,

0:37:150:37:15

in Ireland. You can't answer that, that

0:37:150:37:16

in Ireland. You can't answer that, that is

0:37:160:37:16

in Ireland. You can't answer that, that is not

0:37:160:37:16

in Ireland. You can't answer that, that is not a

0:37:160:37:16

in Ireland. You can't answer that, that is not a fact.

0:37:160:37:17

in Ireland. You can't answer that, that is not a fact. We

0:37:170:37:17

in Ireland. You can't answer that, that is not a fact. We are

0:37:170:37:17

in Ireland. You can't answer that, that is not a fact. We are all

0:37:170:37:18

that is not a fact. We are all going

0:37:180:37:18

that is not a fact. We are all going to

0:37:180:37:18

that is not a fact. We are all going to hear

0:37:180:37:18

that is not a fact. We are all going to hear competing

0:37:180:37:19

that is not a fact. We are all going to hear competing claims

0:37:190:37:19

that is not a fact. We are all going to hear competing claims in

0:37:190:37:20

going to hear competing claims in this

0:37:200:37:20

going to hear competing claims in this debate,

0:37:200:37:20

going to hear competing claims in this debate, we

0:37:200:37:20

going to hear competing claims in this debate, we have

0:37:200:37:20

going to hear competing claims in this debate, we have to

0:37:200:37:21

going to hear competing claims in this debate, we have to apply

0:37:210:37:21

this debate, we have to apply common

0:37:210:37:21

this debate, we have to apply common sense.

0:37:210:37:22

this debate, we have to apply common sense. For

0:37:220:37:22

this debate, we have to apply common sense. For the

0:37:220:37:22

this debate, we have to apply common sense. For the UK

0:37:220:37:22

this debate, we have to apply common sense. For the UK to

0:37:220:37:23

this debate, we have to apply common sense. For the UK to force

0:37:230:37:23

common sense. For the UK to force Scotland

0:37:230:37:23

common sense. For the UK to force Scotland out

0:37:230:37:23

common sense. For the UK to force Scotland out of

0:37:230:37:24

common sense. For the UK to force Scotland out of the

0:37:240:37:24

common sense. For the UK to force Scotland out of the common

0:37:240:37:25

common sense. For the UK to force Scotland out of the common travel

0:37:250:37:25

Scotland out of the common travel area,

0:37:250:37:26

Scotland out of the common travel area, or

0:37:260:37:27

Scotland out of the common travel area, or to

0:37:270:37:27

Scotland out of the common travel area, or to force

0:37:270:37:27

Scotland out of the common travel area, or to force us

0:37:270:37:27

Scotland out of the common travel area, or to force us out

0:37:270:37:28

Scotland out of the common travel area, or to force us out of

0:37:280:37:28

area, or to force us out of sterling

0:37:280:37:28

area, or to force us out of sterling wouldn't

0:37:280:37:29

area, or to force us out of sterling wouldn't mean

0:37:290:37:29

area, or to force us out of sterling wouldn't mean that

0:37:290:37:29

area, or to force us out of sterling wouldn't mean that the

0:37:290:37:29

area, or to force us out of sterling wouldn't mean that the UK

0:37:290:37:30

sterling wouldn't mean that the UK was

0:37:300:37:30

sterling wouldn't mean that the UK was acting

0:37:300:37:31

sterling wouldn't mean that the UK was acting against

0:37:310:37:31

sterling wouldn't mean that the UK was acting against Scotland's

0:37:310:37:32

was acting against Scotland's interests

0:37:320:37:33

was acting against Scotland's interests but

0:37:330:37:33

was acting against Scotland's interests but England's

0:37:330:37:33

was acting against Scotland's interests but England's interests

0:37:330:37:34

interests but England's interests as

0:37:340:37:34

interests but England's interests as well.

0:37:340:37:34

interests but England's interests as well. Would

0:37:340:37:35

interests but England's interests as well. Would a

0:37:350:37:35

interests but England's interests as well. Would a Labour

0:37:350:37:35

interests but England's interests as well. Would a Labour Government

0:37:350:37:36

as well. Would a Labour Government in

0:37:360:37:36

as well. Would a Labour Government in Westminster

0:37:360:37:36

as well. Would a Labour Government in Westminster institute

0:37:360:37:37

as well. Would a Labour Government in Westminster institute border

0:37:370:37:37

in Westminster institute border controls?

0:37:370:37:37

in Westminster institute border controls? I

0:37:370:37:38

in Westminster institute border controls? I don't

0:37:380:37:38

in Westminster institute border controls? I don't think

0:37:380:37:38

in Westminster institute border controls? I don't think we

0:37:380:37:38

in Westminster institute border controls? I don't think we would

0:37:380:37:39

controls? I don't think we would want

0:37:390:37:39

controls? I don't think we would want border

0:37:390:37:39

controls? I don't think we would want border controls,

0:37:390:37:39

controls? I don't think we would want border controls, the

0:37:390:37:40

controls? I don't think we would want border controls, the key

0:37:400:37:41

controls? I don't think we would want border controls, the key rests

0:37:410:37:41

want border controls, the key rests on

0:37:410:37:41

want border controls, the key rests on if

0:37:410:37:41

want border controls, the key rests on if for

0:37:410:37:42

want border controls, the key rests on if for example

0:37:420:37:42

want border controls, the key rests on if for example Scotland

0:37:420:37:42

want border controls, the key rests on if for example Scotland decided

0:37:420:37:43

on if for example Scotland decided it

0:37:430:37:43

on if for example Scotland decided it wanted

0:37:430:37:44

on if for example Scotland decided it wanted a

0:37:440:37:46

on if for example Scotland decided it wanted a different

0:37:460:37:47

on if for example Scotland decided it wanted a different immigration

0:37:470:37:47

it wanted a different immigration policy.

0:37:470:37:47

it wanted a different immigration policy. If

0:37:470:37:48

it wanted a different immigration policy. If Scotland

0:37:480:37:48

it wanted a different immigration policy. If Scotland wanted

0:37:480:37:49

it wanted a different immigration policy. If Scotland wanted a

0:37:490:37:49

policy. If Scotland wanted a different

0:37:490:37:50

policy. If Scotland wanted a different immigration

0:37:500:37:50

policy. If Scotland wanted a different immigration policy,

0:37:500:37:50

policy. If Scotland wanted a different immigration policy, which

0:37:500:37:51

different immigration policy, which had

0:37:510:37:51

different immigration policy, which had direct

0:37:510:37:52

different immigration policy, which had direct implications

0:37:520:37:52

different immigration policy, which had direct implications for

0:37:520:37:52

different immigration policy, which had direct implications for England

0:37:520:37:52

had direct implications for England then

0:37:520:37:52

had direct implications for England then people

0:37:520:37:52

had direct implications for England then people may

0:37:520:37:53

had direct implications for England then people may have

0:37:530:37:53

had direct implications for England then people may have to

0:37:530:37:54

had direct implications for England then people may have to say,

0:37:540:37:54

had direct implications for England then people may have to say, not

0:37:540:37:54

then people may have to say, not maybe

0:37:540:37:55

then people may have to say, not maybe through

0:37:550:37:55

then people may have to say, not maybe through poll,

0:37:550:37:55

then people may have to say, not maybe through poll, but

0:37:550:37:56

then people may have to say, not maybe through poll, but they

0:37:560:37:56

then people may have to say, not maybe through poll, but they may

0:37:560:37:56

maybe through poll, but they may have

0:37:560:37:56

maybe through poll, but they may have to

0:37:560:37:57

maybe through poll, but they may have to police

0:37:570:37:57

maybe through poll, but they may have to police it

0:37:570:37:58

maybe through poll, but they may have to police it differently.

0:37:580:37:58

maybe through poll, but they may have to police it differently. The

0:37:580:37:58

have to police it differently. The issue

0:37:580:37:59

have to police it differently. The issue is

0:37:590:37:59

have to police it differently. The issue is Nicola

0:37:590:37:59

have to police it differently. The issue is Nicola can't

0:37:590:38:00

have to police it differently. The issue is Nicola can't guarantee

0:38:000:38:00

issue is Nicola can't guarantee that

0:38:000:38:00

issue is Nicola can't guarantee that in

0:38:000:38:00

issue is Nicola can't guarantee that in an

0:38:000:38:01

issue is Nicola can't guarantee that in an independent

0:38:010:38:01

issue is Nicola can't guarantee that in an independent Scotland.

0:38:010:38:01

issue is Nicola can't guarantee that in an independent Scotland. It

0:38:010:38:02

that in an independent Scotland. It may

0:38:020:38:02

that in an independent Scotland. It may or

0:38:020:38:02

that in an independent Scotland. It may or may

0:38:020:38:02

that in an independent Scotland. It may or may not

0:38:020:38:02

that in an independent Scotland. It may or may not happen,

0:38:020:38:03

that in an independent Scotland. It may or may not happen, depending

0:38:030:38:05

that in an independent Scotland. It may or may not happen, depending on

0:38:050:38:05

may or may not happen, depending on the

0:38:050:38:06

may or may not happen, depending on the policies

0:38:060:38:07

may or may not happen, depending on the policies implemented.

0:38:070:38:07

may or may not happen, depending on the policies implemented. You

0:38:070:38:07

may or may not happen, depending on the policies implemented. You spend

0:38:070:38:08

the policies implemented. You spend 50%

0:38:080:38:08

the policies implemented. You spend 50% of

0:38:080:38:08

the policies implemented. You spend 50% of your

0:38:080:38:09

the policies implemented. You spend 50% of your time

0:38:090:38:09

the policies implemented. You spend 50% of your time in

0:38:090:38:09

the policies implemented. You spend 50% of your time in London

0:38:090:38:09

the policies implemented. You spend 50% of your time in London and

0:38:090:38:10

50% of your time in London and Glasgow,

0:38:100:38:10

50% of your time in London and Glasgow, you

0:38:100:38:10

50% of your time in London and Glasgow, you may

0:38:100:38:10

50% of your time in London and Glasgow, you may have

0:38:100:38:10

50% of your time in London and Glasgow, you may have to

0:38:100:38:11

50% of your time in London and Glasgow, you may have to stop

0:38:110:38:11

50% of your time in London and Glasgow, you may have to stop at

0:38:110:38:11

Glasgow, you may have to stop at the

0:38:110:38:11

Glasgow, you may have to stop at the border?

0:38:110:38:11

Glasgow, you may have to stop at the border? It

0:38:110:38:12

Glasgow, you may have to stop at the border? It has

0:38:120:38:12

Glasgow, you may have to stop at the border? It has to

0:38:120:38:12

Glasgow, you may have to stop at the border? It has to work

0:38:120:38:12

Glasgow, you may have to stop at the border? It has to work for

0:38:120:38:12

Glasgow, you may have to stop at the border? It has to work for me,

0:38:120:38:13

the border? It has to work for me, I

0:38:130:38:13

the border? It has to work for me, I live

0:38:130:38:13

the border? It has to work for me, I live and

0:38:130:38:13

the border? It has to work for me, I live and work

0:38:130:38:14

the border? It has to work for me, I live and work on

0:38:140:38:14

the border? It has to work for me, I live and work on both

0:38:140:38:14

the border? It has to work for me, I live and work on both sides.

0:38:140:38:14

the border? It has to work for me, I live and work on both sides. I

0:38:140:38:15

I live and work on both sides. I have

0:38:150:38:15

I live and work on both sides. I have access

0:38:150:38:16

I live and work on both sides. I have access to

0:38:160:38:16

I live and work on both sides. I have access to a

0:38:160:38:17

I live and work on both sides. I have access to a world

0:38:170:38:17

I live and work on both sides. I have access to a world city

0:38:170:38:18

I live and work on both sides. I have access to a world city called

0:38:180:38:18

have access to a world city called London,

0:38:180:38:19

have access to a world city called London, it

0:38:190:38:19

have access to a world city called London, it could

0:38:190:38:20

have access to a world city called London, it could easily

0:38:200:38:20

have access to a world city called London, it could easily be

0:38:200:38:20

London, it could easily be Stuttgart,

0:38:200:38:22

London, it could easily be Stuttgart, New

0:38:220:38:22

London, it could easily be Stuttgart, New York,

0:38:220:38:22

London, it could easily be Stuttgart, New York, Munich.

0:38:220:38:22

London, it could easily be Stuttgart, New York, Munich. We

0:38:220:38:23

London, it could easily be Stuttgart, New York, Munich. We are

0:38:230:38:23

Stuttgart, New York, Munich. We are all

0:38:230:38:23

Stuttgart, New York, Munich. We are all Europeans

0:38:230:38:23

Stuttgart, New York, Munich. We are all Europeans and

0:38:230:38:24

Stuttgart, New York, Munich. We are all Europeans and on

0:38:240:38:24

Stuttgart, New York, Munich. We are all Europeans and on the

0:38:240:38:24

Stuttgart, New York, Munich. We are all Europeans and on the island

0:38:240:38:24

Stuttgart, New York, Munich. We are all Europeans and on the island of

0:38:240:38:25

all Europeans and on the island of the

0:38:250:38:25

all Europeans and on the island of the UK,

0:38:250:38:25

all Europeans and on the island of the UK, we

0:38:250:38:25

all Europeans and on the island of the UK, we will

0:38:250:38:25

all Europeans and on the island of the UK, we will all

0:38:250:38:26

all Europeans and on the island of the UK, we will all be

0:38:260:38:26

all Europeans and on the island of the UK, we will all be able

0:38:260:38:27

all Europeans and on the island of the UK, we will all be able to

0:38:270:38:27

all Europeans and on the island of the UK, we will all be able to move

0:38:270:38:28

the UK, we will all be able to move around

0:38:280:38:28

the UK, we will all be able to move around very

0:38:280:38:28

the UK, we will all be able to move around very easily,

0:38:280:38:29

the UK, we will all be able to move around very easily, it

0:38:290:38:29

the UK, we will all be able to move around very easily, it is the

0:38:290:38:29

the UK, we will all be able to move around very easily, it is the most

0:38:290:38:29

around very easily, it is the most sensible

0:38:290:38:29

around very easily, it is the most sensible thing

0:38:290:38:30

around very easily, it is the most sensible thing toe

0:38:300:38:31

around very easily, it is the most sensible thing toe do.

0:38:310:38:31

around very easily, it is the most sensible thing toe do. Thank

0:38:310:38:31

around very easily, it is the most sensible thing toe do. Thank you

0:38:310:38:31

sensible thing toe do. Thank you very

0:38:310:38:31

sensible thing toe do. Thank you very much,

0:38:310:38:32

sensible thing toe do. Thank you very much, I'm

0:38:320:38:32

sensible thing toe do. Thank you very much, I'm just

0:38:320:38:32

sensible thing toe do. Thank you very much, I'm just going

0:38:320:38:32

sensible thing toe do. Thank you very much, I'm just going to

0:38:320:38:32

sensible thing toe do. Thank you very much, I'm just going to ask

0:38:320:38:33

sensible thing toe do. Thank you very much, I'm just going to ask a

0:38:330:38:33

very much, I'm just going to ask a final

0:38:330:38:34

very much, I'm just going to ask a final question

0:38:340:38:35

very much, I'm just going to ask a final question of

0:38:350:38:35

very much, I'm just going to ask a final question of Nicola

0:38:350:38:35

very much, I'm just going to ask a final question of Nicola about

0:38:350:38:35

final question of Nicola about identity.

0:38:350:38:39

final question of Nicola about identity. Is

0:38:390:38:40

final question of Nicola about identity. Is this

0:38:400:38:40

final question of Nicola about identity. Is this debate

0:38:400:38:40

final question of Nicola about identity. Is this debate being

0:38:400:38:41

identity. Is this debate being characterised

0:38:410:38:41

identity. Is this debate being characterised by

0:38:410:38:42

identity. Is this debate being characterised by economic

0:38:420:38:42

identity. Is this debate being characterised by economic questions,

0:38:420:38:43

characterised by economic questions, cultural

0:38:430:38:43

characterised by economic questions, cultural questions,

0:38:430:38:44

characterised by economic questions, cultural questions, political

0:38:440:38:44

cultural questions, political questions.

0:38:440:38:44

cultural questions, political questions. What

0:38:440:38:44

cultural questions, political questions. What is

0:38:440:38:44

cultural questions, political questions. What is this

0:38:440:38:45

cultural questions, political questions. What is this debate

0:38:450:38:45

questions. What is this debate going

0:38:450:38:45

questions. What is this debate going to

0:38:450:38:45

questions. What is this debate going to be

0:38:450:38:46

questions. What is this debate going to be about

0:38:460:38:46

questions. What is this debate going to be about in

0:38:460:38:46

questions. What is this debate going to be about in the

0:38:460:38:46

questions. What is this debate going to be about in the next

0:38:460:38:46

questions. What is this debate going to be about in the next year?

0:38:460:38:47

going to be about in the next year? It

0:38:470:38:47

going to be about in the next year? It will

0:38:470:38:47

going to be about in the next year? It will be

0:38:470:38:47

going to be about in the next year? It will be a

0:38:470:38:48

going to be about in the next year? It will be a mixture of

0:38:480:38:48

going to be about in the next year? It will be a mixture of all

0:38:480:38:48

going to be about in the next year? It will be a mixture of all of

0:38:480:38:48

It will be a mixture of all of those

0:38:480:38:49

It will be a mixture of all of those thingsment

0:38:490:38:49

It will be a mixture of all of those thingsment for

0:38:490:38:50

It will be a mixture of all of those thingsment for me

0:38:500:38:50

It will be a mixture of all of those thingsment for me it

0:38:500:38:50

It will be a mixture of all of those thingsment for me it is

0:38:500:38:50

It will be a mixture of all of those thingsment for me it is not

0:38:500:38:51

those thingsment for me it is not about

0:38:510:38:51

those thingsment for me it is not about identity

0:38:510:38:52

those thingsment for me it is not about identity --

0:38:520:38:52

those thingsment for me it is not about identity -- things. For

0:38:520:38:52

those thingsment for me it is not about identity -- things. For me

0:38:520:38:52

those thingsment for me it is not about identity -- things. For me it

0:38:520:38:52

about identity -- things. For me it is

0:38:520:38:53

about identity -- things. For me it is not

0:38:530:38:53

about identity -- things. For me it is not about

0:38:530:38:53

about identity -- things. For me it is not about why

0:38:530:38:54

about identity -- things. For me it is not about why theity

0:38:540:38:54

about identity -- things. For me it is not about why theity and

0:38:540:38:55

about identity -- things. For me it is not about why theity and those

0:38:550:38:55

is not about why theity and those things.

0:38:550:38:56

is not about why theity and those things. I'm

0:38:560:38:56

is not about why theity and those things. I'm the

0:38:560:38:56

is not about why theity and those things. I'm the daughter

0:38:560:38:57

is not about why theity and those things. I'm the daughter of

0:38:570:38:58

is not about why theity and those things. I'm the daughter of an

0:38:580:38:58

things. I'm the daughter of an Englishman,

0:38:580:38:58

things. I'm the daughter of an Englishman, if

0:38:580:38:58

things. I'm the daughter of an Englishman, if I

0:38:580:38:59

things. I'm the daughter of an Englishman, if I was

0:38:590:38:59

things. I'm the daughter of an Englishman, if I was asked

0:38:590:38:59

things. I'm the daughter of an Englishman, if I was asked the

0:38:590:38:59

Englishman, if I was asked the nationality

0:38:590:39:00

Englishman, if I was asked the nationality of

0:39:000:39:00

Englishman, if I was asked the nationality of many

0:39:000:39:01

Englishman, if I was asked the nationality of many people

0:39:010:39:01

Englishman, if I was asked the nationality of many people in

0:39:010:39:01

nationality of many people in Scotland

0:39:010:39:02

nationality of many people in Scotland they

0:39:020:39:02

nationality of many people in Scotland they would

0:39:020:39:03

nationality of many people in Scotland they would say

0:39:030:39:03

nationality of many people in Scotland they would say Pakistani,

0:39:030:39:04

Scotland they would say Pakistani, they

0:39:040:39:04

Scotland they would say Pakistani, they wouldn't

0:39:040:39:06

Scotland they would say Pakistani, they wouldn't say

0:39:060:39:07

Scotland they would say Pakistani, they wouldn't say English.

0:39:070:39:07

Scotland they would say Pakistani, they wouldn't say English. The

0:39:070:39:07

Scotland they would say Pakistani, they wouldn't say English. The best

0:39:070:39:07

they wouldn't say English. The best comment

0:39:070:39:07

they wouldn't say English. The best comment I

0:39:070:39:08

they wouldn't say English. The best comment I have

0:39:080:39:08

they wouldn't say English. The best comment I have heard

0:39:080:39:08

they wouldn't say English. The best comment I have heard tonight

0:39:080:39:08

they wouldn't say English. The best comment I have heard tonight is

0:39:080:39:09

they wouldn't say English. The best comment I have heard tonight is the

0:39:090:39:09

comment I have heard tonight is the laid

0:39:090:39:09

comment I have heard tonight is the laid Yeates

0:39:090:39:09

comment I have heard tonight is the laid Yeates here,

0:39:090:39:10

comment I have heard tonight is the laid Yeates here, you

0:39:100:39:10

comment I have heard tonight is the laid Yeates here, you know

0:39:100:39:12

comment I have heard tonight is the laid Yeates here, you know let's

0:39:120:39:12

laid Yeates here, you know let's start

0:39:120:39:12

laid Yeates here, you know let's start --

0:39:120:39:12

laid Yeates here, you know let's start -- ladies

0:39:120:39:12

laid Yeates here, you know let's start -- ladies here.

0:39:120:39:16

laid Yeates here, you know let's start -- ladies here. Let's

0:39:160:39:17

laid Yeates here, you know let's start -- ladies here. Let's accept

0:39:170:39:17

start -- ladies here. Let's accept that

0:39:170:39:17

start -- ladies here. Let's accept that comment

0:39:170:39:17

start -- ladies here. Let's accept that comment that

0:39:170:39:18

start -- ladies here. Let's accept that comment that we

0:39:180:39:18

start -- ladies here. Let's accept that comment that we don't

0:39:180:39:18

start -- ladies here. Let's accept that comment that we don't doubt

0:39:180:39:18

start -- ladies here. Let's accept that comment that we don't doubt it

0:39:180:39:18

that comment that we don't doubt it can

0:39:180:39:19

that comment that we don't doubt it can be

0:39:190:39:19

that comment that we don't doubt it can be independent,

0:39:190:39:19

that comment that we don't doubt it can be independent, let's

0:39:190:39:20

that comment that we don't doubt it can be independent, let's focus

0:39:200:39:20

that comment that we don't doubt it can be independent, let's focus on

0:39:200:39:20

can be independent, let's focus on the

0:39:200:39:20

can be independent, let's focus on the country

0:39:200:39:21

can be independent, let's focus on the country we

0:39:210:39:21

can be independent, let's focus on the country we want

0:39:210:39:21

can be independent, let's focus on the country we want to

0:39:210:39:21

can be independent, let's focus on the country we want to be

0:39:210:39:21

can be independent, let's focus on the country we want to be and

0:39:210:39:22

can be independent, let's focus on the country we want to be and how

0:39:220:39:22

the country we want to be and how we

0:39:220:39:22

the country we want to be and how we will

0:39:220:39:22

the country we want to be and how we will build

0:39:220:39:23

the country we want to be and how we will build that

0:39:230:39:23

the country we want to be and how we will build that country.

0:39:230:39:23

the country we want to be and how we will build that country. You

0:39:230:39:23

we will build that country. You have

0:39:230:39:23

we will build that country. You have heard

0:39:230:39:24

we will build that country. You have heard the

0:39:240:39:24

we will build that country. You have heard the panel

0:39:240:39:24

we will build that country. You have heard the panel and

0:39:240:39:24

we will build that country. You have heard the panel and you

0:39:240:39:25

we will build that country. You have heard the panel and you have

0:39:250:39:26

have heard the panel and you have quizzed

0:39:260:39:26

have heard the panel and you have quizzed them.

0:39:260:39:26

have heard the panel and you have quizzed them. Now

0:39:260:39:26

have heard the panel and you have quizzed them. Now it

0:39:260:39:27

have heard the panel and you have quizzed them. Now it is

0:39:270:39:27

have heard the panel and you have quizzed them. Now it is time

0:39:270:39:27

have heard the panel and you have quizzed them. Now it is time to

0:39:270:39:28

quizzed them. Now it is time to rumate

0:39:280:39:29

quizzed them. Now it is time to rumate before

0:39:290:39:29

quizzed them. Now it is time to rumate before you

0:39:290:39:29

quizzed them. Now it is time to rumate before you vote

0:39:290:39:29

quizzed them. Now it is time to rumate before you vote live

0:39:290:39:30

quizzed them. Now it is time to rumate before you vote live on

0:39:300:39:30

rumate before you vote live on Newsnight

0:39:300:39:30

rumate before you vote live on Newsnight tonight.

0:39:300:39:33

Newsnight tonight. So

0:39:330:39:33

Newsnight tonight. So they

0:39:330:39:34

Newsnight tonight. So they heard

0:39:340:39:35

Newsnight tonight. So they heard the

0:39:350:39:35

Newsnight tonight. So they heard the arguments and

0:39:350:39:36

Newsnight tonight. So they heard the arguments and the

0:39:360:39:36

So they heard the arguments and the audience

0:39:360:39:36

So they heard the arguments and the audience have

0:39:360:39:37

So they heard the arguments and the audience have been

0:39:370:39:37

So they heard the arguments and the audience have been thinking

0:39:370:39:37

So they heard the arguments and the audience have been thinking hard

0:39:370:39:38

audience have been thinking hard about

0:39:380:39:38

audience have been thinking hard about how

0:39:380:39:38

audience have been thinking hard about how to

0:39:380:39:38

audience have been thinking hard about how to cast

0:39:380:39:39

audience have been thinking hard about how to cast the

0:39:390:39:39

audience have been thinking hard about how to cast the vote

0:39:390:39:40

audience have been thinking hard about how to cast the vote as

0:39:400:39:40

audience have been thinking hard about how to cast the vote as they

0:39:400:39:41

about how to cast the vote as they wander

0:39:410:39:42

about how to cast the vote as they wander around

0:39:420:39:42

about how to cast the vote as they wander around the

0:39:420:39:42

about how to cast the vote as they wander around the spectacular

0:39:420:39:42

wander around the spectacular setting

0:39:420:39:43

wander around the spectacular setting on

0:39:430:39:43

wander around the spectacular setting on the

0:39:430:39:44

wander around the spectacular setting on the border

0:39:440:39:44

wander around the spectacular setting on the border between

0:39:440:39:44

setting on the border between England

0:39:440:39:45

setting on the border between England and

0:39:450:39:45

setting on the border between England and Scotland.

0:39:450:39:45

setting on the border between England and Scotland. It

0:39:450:39:45

setting on the border between England and Scotland. It could

0:39:450:39:46

setting on the border between England and Scotland. It could be

0:39:460:39:46

England and Scotland. It could be an

0:39:460:39:46

England and Scotland. It could be an international

0:39:460:39:46

England and Scotland. It could be an international crossing

0:39:460:39:47

England and Scotland. It could be an international crossing point

0:39:470:39:47

England and Scotland. It could be an international crossing point a

0:39:470:39:47

an international crossing point a year

0:39:470:39:47

an international crossing point a year from

0:39:470:39:48

an international crossing point a year from now.

0:39:480:39:48

an international crossing point a year from now. These

0:39:480:39:48

an international crossing point a year from now. These men

0:39:480:39:49

an international crossing point a year from now. These men and

0:39:490:39:49

an international crossing point a year from now. These men and women,

0:39:490:39:50

year from now. These men and women, the

0:39:500:39:50

year from now. These men and women, the undecided

0:39:500:39:50

year from now. These men and women, the undecided hold

0:39:500:39:51

year from now. These men and women, the undecided hold the

0:39:510:39:51

year from now. These men and women, the undecided hold the future of

0:39:510:39:51

the undecided hold the future of Scotland

0:39:510:39:52

the undecided hold the future of Scotland and

0:39:520:39:52

the undecided hold the future of Scotland and the

0:39:520:39:52

the undecided hold the future of Scotland and the qu.

0:39:520:39:53

the undecided hold the future of Scotland and the qu. In

0:39:530:39:53

the undecided hold the future of Scotland and the qu. In their

0:39:530:39:54

the undecided hold the future of Scotland and the qu. In their hand

0:39:540:39:54

Scotland and the qu. In their hand on

0:39:540:39:54

Scotland and the qu. In their hand on Newsnight

0:39:540:39:56

Scotland and the qu. In their hand on Newsnight at

0:39:560:39:56

Scotland and the qu. In their hand on Newsnight at least.

0:39:560:39:56

Scotland and the qu. In their hand on Newsnight at least. I

0:39:560:39:57

Scotland and the qu. In their hand on Newsnight at least. I have

0:39:570:39:57

Scotland and the qu. In their hand on Newsnight at least. I have two

0:39:570:39:58

on Newsnight at least. I have two ballot

0:39:580:39:58

on Newsnight at least. I have two ballot boxes

0:39:580:39:58

on Newsnight at least. I have two ballot boxes here

0:39:580:39:59

on Newsnight at least. I have two ballot boxes here and

0:39:590:39:59

on Newsnight at least. I have two ballot boxes here and we

0:39:590:39:59

on Newsnight at least. I have two ballot boxes here and we will

0:39:590:39:59

on Newsnight at least. I have two ballot boxes here and we will count

0:39:590:40:00

ballot boxes here and we will count live

0:40:000:40:00

ballot boxes here and we will count live as

0:40:000:40:01

ballot boxes here and we will count live as people

0:40:010:40:02

ballot boxes here and we will count live as people decide

0:40:020:40:02

ballot boxes here and we will count live as people decide should

0:40:020:40:02

live as people decide should Scotland

0:40:020:40:03

live as people decide should Scotland be

0:40:030:40:03

live as people decide should Scotland be an

0:40:030:40:03

live as people decide should Scotland be an independent

0:40:030:40:03

live as people decide should Scotland be an independent country,

0:40:030:40:04

Scotland be an independent country, yes

0:40:040:40:05

Scotland be an independent country, yes or

0:40:050:40:05

Scotland be an independent country, yes or no.

0:40:050:40:05

Scotland be an independent country, yes or no. Tessa

0:40:050:40:05

Scotland be an independent country, yes or no. Tessa Hartman,

0:40:050:40:06

yes or no. Tessa Hartman, businessman

0:40:060:40:07

yes or no. Tessa Hartman, businessman and

0:40:070:40:07

yes or no. Tessa Hartman, businessman and unionist

0:40:070:40:07

yes or no. Tessa Hartman, businessman and unionist is

0:40:070:40:08

yes or no. Tessa Hartman, businessman and unionist is here,

0:40:080:40:11

businessman and unionist is here, and

0:40:110:40:11

businessman and unionist is here, and pro-independence

0:40:110:40:11

businessman and unionist is here, and pro-independence campaigner,

0:40:110:40:12

and pro-independence campaigner, Pat

0:40:120:40:12

and pro-independence campaigner, Pat Caine,

0:40:120:40:13

and pro-independence campaigner, Pat Caine, the

0:40:130:40:13

and pro-independence campaigner, Pat Caine, the time

0:40:130:40:14

and pro-independence campaigner, Pat Caine, the time for

0:40:140:40:14

and pro-independence campaigner, Pat Caine, the time for talking

0:40:140:40:14

and pro-independence campaigner, Pat Caine, the time for talking is

0:40:140:40:14

Pat Caine, the time for talking is over.

0:40:140:40:15

Pat Caine, the time for talking is over. Let's

0:40:150:40:15

Pat Caine, the time for talking is over. Let's start

0:40:150:40:15

Pat Caine, the time for talking is over. Let's start the

0:40:150:40:16

Pat Caine, the time for talking is over. Let's start the vote,

0:40:160:40:16

Pat Caine, the time for talking is over. Let's start the vote, bring

0:40:160:40:16

over. Let's start the vote, bring it

0:40:160:40:16

over. Let's start the vote, bring it on.

0:40:160:40:44

it on. During

0:40:440:40:44

it on. During the

0:40:440:40:45

it on. During the debate

0:40:450:40:45

it on. During the debate wasn't

0:40:450:40:46

it on. During the debate wasn't it

0:40:460:40:46

During the debate wasn't it extraordinary,

0:40:460:40:46

During the debate wasn't it extraordinary, the

0:40:460:40:46

During the debate wasn't it extraordinary, the woman

0:40:460:40:47

During the debate wasn't it extraordinary, the woman who

0:40:470:40:47

During the debate wasn't it extraordinary, the woman who said

0:40:470:40:47

extraordinary, the woman who said the

0:40:470:40:47

extraordinary, the woman who said the first

0:40:470:40:48

extraordinary, the woman who said the first time she

0:40:480:40:48

extraordinary, the woman who said the first time she had

0:40:480:40:49

extraordinary, the woman who said the first time she had felt

0:40:490:40:49

extraordinary, the woman who said the first time she had felt engaged

0:40:490:40:49

the first time she had felt engaged is

0:40:490:40:49

the first time she had felt engaged is when

0:40:490:40:49

the first time she had felt engaged is when we

0:40:490:40:50

the first time she had felt engaged is when we started

0:40:500:40:50

the first time she had felt engaged is when we started talking

0:40:500:40:51

the first time she had felt engaged is when we started talking about

0:40:510:40:51

is when we started talking about what

0:40:510:40:51

is when we started talking about what it

0:40:510:40:51

is when we started talking about what it felt

0:40:510:40:51

is when we started talking about what it felt like

0:40:510:40:52

is when we started talking about what it felt like to

0:40:520:40:52

is when we started talking about what it felt like to be

0:40:520:40:52

is when we started talking about what it felt like to be Scottish.

0:40:520:40:52

is when we started talking about what it felt like to be Scottish. A

0:40:520:40:52

what it felt like to be Scottish. A lot

0:40:520:40:53

what it felt like to be Scottish. A lot of

0:40:530:40:53

what it felt like to be Scottish. A lot of it

0:40:530:40:53

what it felt like to be Scottish. A lot of it will

0:40:530:40:54

what it felt like to be Scottish. A lot of it will come

0:40:540:40:54

what it felt like to be Scottish. A lot of it will come down

0:40:540:40:54

what it felt like to be Scottish. A lot of it will come down to

0:40:540:40:54

what it felt like to be Scottish. A lot of it will come down to that

0:40:540:40:54

lot of it will come down to that Pat

0:40:540:40:55

lot of it will come down to that Pat Caine?

0:40:550:40:55

lot of it will come down to that Pat Caine? Whether

0:40:550:40:55

lot of it will come down to that Pat Caine? Whether you

0:40:550:40:55

lot of it will come down to that Pat Caine? Whether you like

0:40:550:40:56

lot of it will come down to that Pat Caine? Whether you like it

0:40:560:40:57

lot of it will come down to that Pat Caine? Whether you like it or

0:40:570:40:57

Pat Caine? Whether you like it or not?

0:40:570:40:57

Pat Caine? Whether you like it or not? It

0:40:570:40:58

Pat Caine? Whether you like it or not? It is

0:40:580:40:58

Pat Caine? Whether you like it or not? It is a

0:40:580:40:59

Pat Caine? Whether you like it or not? It is a necessary

0:40:590:40:59

Pat Caine? Whether you like it or not? It is a necessary act

0:40:590:41:00

Pat Caine? Whether you like it or not? It is a necessary act fact.

0:41:000:41:00

Pat Caine? Whether you like it or not? It is a necessary act fact. It

0:41:000:41:00

not? It is a necessary act fact. It is

0:41:000:41:00

not? It is a necessary act fact. It is a

0:41:000:41:02

not? It is a necessary act fact. It is a grown

0:41:020:41:03

not? It is a necessary act fact. It is a grown up

0:41:030:41:03

not? It is a necessary act fact. It is a grown up thing

0:41:030:41:03

not? It is a necessary act fact. It is a grown up thing to

0:41:030:41:04

not? It is a necessary act fact. It is a grown up thing to try

0:41:040:41:05

not? It is a necessary act fact. It is a grown up thing to try to

0:41:050:41:05

not? It is a necessary act fact. It is a grown up thing to try to find

0:41:050:41:05

is a grown up thing to try to find out

0:41:050:41:05

is a grown up thing to try to find out about

0:41:050:41:06

is a grown up thing to try to find out about owning

0:41:060:41:06

is a grown up thing to try to find out about owning your

0:41:060:41:06

is a grown up thing to try to find out about owning your country.

0:41:060:41:06

is a grown up thing to try to find out about owning your country. It

0:41:060:41:07

out about owning your country. It is

0:41:070:41:07

out about owning your country. It is a

0:41:070:41:08

out about owning your country. It is a demanding

0:41:080:41:08

out about owning your country. It is a demanding thing.

0:41:080:41:08

out about owning your country. It is a demanding thing. Do

0:41:080:41:08

out about owning your country. It is a demanding thing. Do you

0:41:080:41:09

out about owning your country. It is a demanding thing. Do you think

0:41:090:41:09

is a demanding thing. Do you think it

0:41:090:41:09

is a demanding thing. Do you think it will

0:41:090:41:09

is a demanding thing. Do you think it will be

0:41:090:41:09

is a demanding thing. Do you think it will be about

0:41:090:41:10

is a demanding thing. Do you think it will be about head

0:41:100:41:10

is a demanding thing. Do you think it will be about head or

0:41:100:41:10

is a demanding thing. Do you think it will be about head or heart?

0:41:100:41:10

is a demanding thing. Do you think it will be about head or heart? A

0:41:100:41:11

it will be about head or heart? A mixture

0:41:110:41:11

it will be about head or heart? A mixture of

0:41:110:41:11

it will be about head or heart? A mixture of both.

0:41:110:41:12

it will be about head or heart? A mixture of both. It

0:41:120:41:12

it will be about head or heart? A mixture of both. It programmes

0:41:120:41:13

it will be about head or heart? A mixture of both. It programmes like

0:41:130:41:13

mixture of both. It programmes like these

0:41:130:41:13

mixture of both. It programmes like these where

0:41:130:41:13

mixture of both. It programmes like these where people

0:41:130:41:14

mixture of both. It programmes like these where people can

0:41:140:41:14

mixture of both. It programmes like these where people can get

0:41:140:41:14

mixture of both. It programmes like these where people can get to

0:41:140:41:14

these where people can get to debate

0:41:140:41:15

these where people can get to debate and

0:41:150:41:15

these where people can get to debate and fire

0:41:150:41:15

these where people can get to debate and fire and

0:41:150:41:16

these where people can get to debate and fire and argue

0:41:160:41:16

these where people can get to debate and fire and argue and

0:41:160:41:16

debate and fire and argue and almost

0:41:160:41:16

debate and fire and argue and almost educate

0:41:160:41:17

debate and fire and argue and almost educate themselves

0:41:170:41:17

debate and fire and argue and almost educate themselves into

0:41:170:41:17

almost educate themselves into where

0:41:170:41:18

almost educate themselves into where they

0:41:180:41:18

almost educate themselves into where they see

0:41:180:41:19

almost educate themselves into where they see it

0:41:190:41:19

almost educate themselves into where they see it going.

0:41:190:41:20

almost educate themselves into where they see it going. There

0:41:200:41:20

almost educate themselves into where they see it going. There is

0:41:200:41:20

almost educate themselves into where they see it going. There is a

0:41:200:41:20

where they see it going. There is a big

0:41:200:41:21

where they see it going. There is a big expansion

0:41:210:41:21

where they see it going. There is a big expansion going

0:41:210:41:21

where they see it going. There is a big expansion going on

0:41:210:41:21

where they see it going. There is a big expansion going on in

0:41:210:41:22

where they see it going. There is a big expansion going on in head

0:41:220:41:22

where they see it going. There is a big expansion going on in head and

0:41:220:41:22

big expansion going on in head and heart.

0:41:220:41:23

big expansion going on in head and heart. It

0:41:230:41:23

big expansion going on in head and heart. It is

0:41:230:41:23

big expansion going on in head and heart. It is basically

0:41:230:41:23

big expansion going on in head and heart. It is basically a

0:41:230:41:24

big expansion going on in head and heart. It is basically a good

0:41:240:41:24

big expansion going on in head and heart. It is basically a good thing.

0:41:240:41:24

heart. It is basically a good thing. How

0:41:240:41:24

heart. It is basically a good thing. How did

0:41:240:41:25

heart. It is basically a good thing. How did you

0:41:250:41:25

heart. It is basically a good thing. How did you vote?

0:41:250:41:26

heart. It is basically a good thing. How did you vote? Yes.

0:41:260:41:28

heart. It is basically a good thing. How did you vote? Yes. Why?

0:41:280:41:28

heart. It is basically a good thing. How did you vote? Yes. Why? Because

0:41:280:41:28

How did you vote? Yes. Why? Because you

0:41:280:41:29

How did you vote? Yes. Why? Because you were

0:41:290:41:29

How did you vote? Yes. Why? Because you were undecided?

0:41:290:41:30

How did you vote? Yes. Why? Because you were undecided? Well

0:41:300:41:30

How did you vote? Yes. Why? Because you were undecided? Well I

0:41:300:41:30

How did you vote? Yes. Why? Because you were undecided? Well I was

0:41:300:41:30

you were undecided? Well I was undecided

0:41:300:41:31

you were undecided? Well I was undecided before

0:41:310:41:31

you were undecided? Well I was undecided before but

0:41:310:41:31

you were undecided? Well I was undecided before but I

0:41:310:41:31

you were undecided? Well I was undecided before but I think

0:41:310:41:32

you were undecided? Well I was undecided before but I think the

0:41:320:41:33

undecided before but I think the delivery

0:41:330:41:33

undecided before but I think the delivery and

0:41:330:41:33

undecided before but I think the delivery and the

0:41:330:41:33

undecided before but I think the delivery and the oratory

0:41:330:41:35

undecided before but I think the delivery and the oratory was

0:41:350:41:35

delivery and the oratory was definitely

0:41:350:41:35

delivery and the oratory was definitely there

0:41:350:41:36

delivery and the oratory was definitely there for

0:41:360:41:36

delivery and the oratory was definitely there for the

0:41:360:41:36

delivery and the oratory was definitely there for the yes

0:41:360:41:36

definitely there for the yes campaign,

0:41:360:41:37

definitely there for the yes campaign, there

0:41:370:41:37

definitely there for the yes campaign, there is

0:41:370:41:37

definitely there for the yes campaign, there is a

0:41:370:41:38

definitely there for the yes campaign, there is a lot

0:41:380:41:38

definitely there for the yes campaign, there is a lot of

0:41:380:41:38

definitely there for the yes campaign, there is a lot of content

0:41:380:41:38

campaign, there is a lot of content and

0:41:380:41:38

campaign, there is a lot of content and answers

0:41:380:41:39

campaign, there is a lot of content and answers that

0:41:390:41:39

campaign, there is a lot of content and answers that are

0:41:390:41:39

campaign, there is a lot of content and answers that are still

0:41:390:41:40

campaign, there is a lot of content and answers that are still required

0:41:400:41:40

and answers that are still required for

0:41:400:41:40

and answers that are still required for so.

0:41:400:41:40

and answers that are still required for so. Questions

0:41:400:41:41

and answers that are still required for so. Questions raised

0:41:410:41:41

and answers that are still required for so. Questions raised tonight.

0:41:410:41:42

for so. Questions raised tonight. But

0:41:420:41:43

for so. Questions raised tonight. But definitely

0:41:430:41:43

for so. Questions raised tonight. But definitely more

0:41:430:41:43

for so. Questions raised tonight. But definitely more on

0:41:430:41:43

for so. Questions raised tonight. But definitely more on the

0:41:430:41:44

for so. Questions raised tonight. But definitely more on the yes

0:41:440:41:44

for so. Questions raised tonight. But definitely more on the yes side

0:41:440:41:45

But definitely more on the yes side now.

0:41:450:41:47

now. Tell

0:41:470:41:47

now. Tell me,

0:41:470:41:48

now. Tell me, you

0:41:480:41:48

now. Tell me, you have

0:41:480:41:48

now. Tell me, you have just

0:41:480:41:49

now. Tell me, you have just voted

0:41:490:41:49

now. Tell me, you have just voted no,

0:41:490:41:50

now. Tell me, you have just voted no, so

0:41:500:41:50

Tell me, you have just voted no, so what

0:41:500:41:50

Tell me, you have just voted no, so what was

0:41:500:41:50

Tell me, you have just voted no, so what was about

0:41:500:41:50

Tell me, you have just voted no, so what was about it

0:41:500:41:51

Tell me, you have just voted no, so what was about it the

0:41:510:41:51

Tell me, you have just voted no, so what was about it the debate

0:41:510:41:52

Tell me, you have just voted no, so what was about it the debate that

0:41:520:41:52

what was about it the debate that influenced

0:41:520:41:53

what was about it the debate that influenced you

0:41:530:41:53

what was about it the debate that influenced you tonight?

0:41:530:41:53

what was about it the debate that influenced you tonight? There

0:41:530:41:53

what was about it the debate that influenced you tonight? There was

0:41:530:41:54

influenced you tonight? There was nothing

0:41:540:41:54

influenced you tonight? There was nothing in

0:41:540:41:54

influenced you tonight? There was nothing in the

0:41:540:41:55

influenced you tonight? There was nothing in the debate tonight

0:41:550:41:55

influenced you tonight? There was nothing in the debate tonight or

0:41:550:41:55

nothing in the debate tonight or anything

0:41:550:41:56

nothing in the debate tonight or anything up

0:41:560:41:56

nothing in the debate tonight or anything up to

0:41:560:41:56

nothing in the debate tonight or anything up to this

0:41:560:41:58

nothing in the debate tonight or anything up to this point

0:41:580:41:58

nothing in the debate tonight or anything up to this point that

0:41:580:41:58

nothing in the debate tonight or anything up to this point that has

0:41:580:41:58

anything up to this point that has convinced

0:41:580:41:59

anything up to this point that has convinced me

0:41:590:42:00

anything up to this point that has convinced me that

0:42:000:42:01

anything up to this point that has convinced me that moving

0:42:010:42:01

anything up to this point that has convinced me that moving towards

0:42:010:42:01

convinced me that moving towards independence

0:42:010:42:02

convinced me that moving towards independence would

0:42:020:42:02

convinced me that moving towards independence would be

0:42:020:42:02

convinced me that moving towards independence would be any

0:42:020:42:03

convinced me that moving towards independence would be any benefit

0:42:030:42:03

independence would be any benefit of

0:42:030:42:03

independence would be any benefit of anyone

0:42:030:42:04

independence would be any benefit of anyone in

0:42:040:42:04

independence would be any benefit of anyone in Scotland.

0:42:040:42:04

independence would be any benefit of anyone in Scotland. Are

0:42:040:42:04

independence would be any benefit of anyone in Scotland. Are you

0:42:040:42:05

independence would be any benefit of anyone in Scotland. Are you a

0:42:050:42:05

of anyone in Scotland. Are you a businessman?

0:42:050:42:06

of anyone in Scotland. Are you a businessman? I'm

0:42:060:42:06

of anyone in Scotland. Are you a businessman? I'm a

0:42:060:42:07

of anyone in Scotland. Are you a businessman? I'm a fire

0:42:070:42:07

of anyone in Scotland. Are you a businessman? I'm a fire officer,

0:42:070:42:07

of anyone in Scotland. Are you a businessman? I'm a fire officer, I

0:42:070:42:07

businessman? I'm a fire officer, I have

0:42:070:42:07

businessman? I'm a fire officer, I have been

0:42:070:42:08

businessman? I'm a fire officer, I have been a

0:42:080:42:09

businessman? I'm a fire officer, I have been a number

0:42:090:42:09

businessman? I'm a fire officer, I have been a number of

0:42:090:42:09

businessman? I'm a fire officer, I have been a number of years,

0:42:090:42:12

businessman? I'm a fire officer, I have been a number of years, and

0:42:120:42:12

have been a number of years, and I'm

0:42:120:42:12

have been a number of years, and I'm happy

0:42:120:42:12

have been a number of years, and I'm happy with

0:42:120:42:13

have been a number of years, and I'm happy with the

0:42:130:42:13

have been a number of years, and I'm happy with the Governments

0:42:130:42:13

have been a number of years, and I'm happy with the Governments we

0:42:130:42:13

I'm happy with the Governments we have.

0:42:130:42:14

have. Thank

0:42:140:42:14

have. Thank you

0:42:140:42:14

have. Thank you very

0:42:140:42:15

have. Thank you very much

0:42:150:42:15

have. Thank you very much indeed.

0:42:150:42:17

Thank you very much indeed. The

0:42:170:42:19

Thank you very much indeed. The arguments

0:42:190:42:19

Thank you very much indeed. The arguments though

0:42:190:42:19

Thank you very much indeed. The arguments though about

0:42:190:42:20

Thank you very much indeed. The arguments though about whether

0:42:200:42:20

The arguments though about whether it

0:42:200:42:20

The arguments though about whether it is

0:42:200:42:20

The arguments though about whether it is politician

0:42:200:42:20

The arguments though about whether it is politician or

0:42:200:42:21

The arguments though about whether it is politician or whether

0:42:210:42:21

The arguments though about whether it is politician or whether it

0:42:210:42:22

The arguments though about whether it is politician or whether it is

0:42:220:42:22

it is politician or whether it is lawyers,

0:42:220:42:22

it is politician or whether it is lawyers, economists,

0:42:220:42:23

it is politician or whether it is lawyers, economists, whatever,

0:42:230:42:25

it is politician or whether it is lawyers, economists, whatever, the

0:42:250:42:25

lawyers, economists, whatever, the point

0:42:250:42:25

lawyers, economists, whatever, the point is

0:42:250:42:26

lawyers, economists, whatever, the point is there has

0:42:260:42:26

lawyers, economists, whatever, the point is there has not

0:42:260:42:26

lawyers, economists, whatever, the point is there has not been

0:42:260:42:26

lawyers, economists, whatever, the point is there has not been a

0:42:260:42:27

point is there has not been a settled

0:42:270:42:27

point is there has not been a settled position,

0:42:270:42:28

point is there has not been a settled position, there

0:42:280:42:28

point is there has not been a settled position, there will

0:42:280:42:28

point is there has not been a settled position, there will always

0:42:280:42:29

settled position, there will always be

0:42:290:42:29

settled position, there will always be different

0:42:290:42:29

settled position, there will always be different positions

0:42:290:42:29

settled position, there will always be different positions and

0:42:290:42:30

be different positions and different

0:42:300:42:30

be different positions and different figures,

0:42:300:42:30

be different positions and different figures, so

0:42:300:42:30

be different positions and different figures, so therefore

0:42:300:42:30

be different positions and different figures, so therefore it

0:42:300:42:31

different figures, so therefore it is

0:42:310:42:31

different figures, so therefore it is going

0:42:310:42:31

different figures, so therefore it is going to

0:42:310:42:32

different figures, so therefore it is going to be

0:42:320:42:32

different figures, so therefore it is going to be very

0:42:320:42:32

different figures, so therefore it is going to be very difficult

0:42:320:42:32

different figures, so therefore it is going to be very difficult for

0:42:320:42:33

is going to be very difficult for people

0:42:330:42:33

is going to be very difficult for people to

0:42:330:42:33

is going to be very difficult for people to make,

0:42:330:42:34

is going to be very difficult for people to make, they

0:42:340:42:34

is going to be very difficult for people to make, they are

0:42:340:42:34

is going to be very difficult for people to make, they are making

0:42:340:42:34

people to make, they are making informed

0:42:340:42:35

people to make, they are making informed decisions

0:42:350:42:35

people to make, they are making informed decisions maybe,

0:42:350:42:36

people to make, they are making informed decisions maybe, but

0:42:360:42:36

people to make, they are making informed decisions maybe, but it

0:42:360:42:36

informed decisions maybe, but it will

0:42:360:42:36

informed decisions maybe, but it will have

0:42:360:42:37

informed decisions maybe, but it will have to

0:42:370:42:37

informed decisions maybe, but it will have to be

0:42:370:42:37

informed decisions maybe, but it will have to be on

0:42:370:42:37

informed decisions maybe, but it will have to be on hunches

0:42:370:42:38

informed decisions maybe, but it will have to be on hunches as

0:42:380:42:38

informed decisions maybe, but it will have to be on hunches as well?

0:42:380:42:38

will have to be on hunches as well? It

0:42:380:42:38

will have to be on hunches as well? It will

0:42:380:42:38

will have to be on hunches as well? It will have

0:42:380:42:39

will have to be on hunches as well? It will have to

0:42:390:42:39

will have to be on hunches as well? It will have to be

0:42:390:42:39

will have to be on hunches as well? It will have to be on

0:42:390:42:39

will have to be on hunches as well? It will have to be on hunches

0:42:390:42:39

will have to be on hunches as well? It will have to be on hunches as

0:42:390:42:40

It will have to be on hunches as well.

0:42:400:42:40

It will have to be on hunches as well. It

0:42:400:42:40

It will have to be on hunches as well. It also

0:42:400:42:40

It will have to be on hunches as well. It also has

0:42:400:42:41

It will have to be on hunches as well. It also has to

0:42:410:42:41

It will have to be on hunches as well. It also has to be

0:42:410:42:41

It will have to be on hunches as well. It also has to be about

0:42:410:42:41

well. It also has to be about looking

0:42:410:42:42

well. It also has to be about looking around

0:42:420:42:42

well. It also has to be about looking around you

0:42:420:42:42

well. It also has to be about looking around you in

0:42:420:42:42

well. It also has to be about looking around you in the

0:42:420:42:43

well. It also has to be about looking around you in the world

0:42:430:42:43

well. It also has to be about looking around you in the world and

0:42:430:42:43

looking around you in the world and seeing

0:42:430:42:44

looking around you in the world and seeing what

0:42:440:42:44

looking around you in the world and seeing what small

0:42:440:42:44

looking around you in the world and seeing what small nations

0:42:440:42:45

looking around you in the world and seeing what small nations are

0:42:450:42:45

seeing what small nations are rapable

0:42:450:42:45

seeing what small nations are rapable of

0:42:450:42:45

seeing what small nations are rapable of and

0:42:450:42:46

seeing what small nations are rapable of and can

0:42:460:42:47

seeing what small nations are rapable of and can do.

0:42:470:42:47

seeing what small nations are rapable of and can do. One

0:42:470:42:47

seeing what small nations are rapable of and can do. One of

0:42:470:42:47

seeing what small nations are rapable of and can do. One of the

0:42:470:42:47

rapable of and can do. One of the things

0:42:470:42:48

rapable of and can do. One of the things --

0:42:480:42:48

rapable of and can do. One of the things -- capable

0:42:480:42:48

rapable of and can do. One of the things -- capable of

0:42:480:42:48

rapable of and can do. One of the things -- capable of and

0:42:480:42:49

rapable of and can do. One of the things -- capable of and can

0:42:490:42:49

rapable of and can do. One of the things -- capable of and can do.

0:42:490:42:49

things -- capable of and can do. Are

0:42:490:42:50

things -- capable of and can do. Are we

0:42:500:42:50

things -- capable of and can do. Are we confident,

0:42:500:42:51

things -- capable of and can do. Are we confident, we

0:42:510:42:51

things -- capable of and can do. Are we confident, we are

0:42:510:42:51

things -- capable of and can do. Are we confident, we are totally

0:42:510:42:51

Are we confident, we are totally capable

0:42:510:42:51

Are we confident, we are totally capable and

0:42:510:42:52

Are we confident, we are totally capable and resourced

0:42:520:42:52

Are we confident, we are totally capable and resourced to

0:42:520:42:53

Are we confident, we are totally capable and resourced to do

0:42:530:42:53

Are we confident, we are totally capable and resourced to do it,

0:42:530:42:53

Are we confident, we are totally capable and resourced to do it, it

0:42:530:42:53

capable and resourced to do it, it is

0:42:530:42:53

capable and resourced to do it, it is the

0:42:530:42:53

capable and resourced to do it, it is the wee

0:42:530:42:54

capable and resourced to do it, it is the wee step

0:42:540:42:54

capable and resourced to do it, it is the wee step which

0:42:540:42:54

capable and resourced to do it, it is the wee step which I

0:42:540:42:54

capable and resourced to do it, it is the wee step which I think

0:42:540:42:55

capable and resourced to do it, it is the wee step which I think Scots

0:42:550:42:55

is the wee step which I think Scots go

0:42:550:42:55

is the wee step which I think Scots go over

0:42:550:42:55

is the wee step which I think Scots go over the

0:42:550:42:56

is the wee step which I think Scots go over the line

0:42:560:42:56

is the wee step which I think Scots go over the line about

0:42:560:42:56

is the wee step which I think Scots go over the line about being

0:42:560:42:57

go over the line about being confident

0:42:570:42:57

go over the line about being confident to

0:42:570:42:57

go over the line about being confident to do

0:42:570:42:57

go over the line about being confident to do it.

0:42:570:42:57

go over the line about being confident to do it. All

0:42:570:42:58

go over the line about being confident to do it. All the

0:42:580:42:58

go over the line about being confident to do it. All the other

0:42:580:42:58

confident to do it. All the other countries

0:42:580:42:59

confident to do it. All the other countries that

0:42:590:42:59

confident to do it. All the other countries that we

0:42:590:43:00

confident to do it. All the other countries that we might

0:43:000:43:00

confident to do it. All the other countries that we might measure

0:43:000:43:00

countries that we might measure ourselves

0:43:000:43:00

countries that we might measure ourselves against

0:43:000:43:01

countries that we might measure ourselves against have

0:43:010:43:01

countries that we might measure ourselves against have had

0:43:010:43:01

countries that we might measure ourselves against have had the

0:43:010:43:02

ourselves against have had the national

0:43:020:43:02

ourselves against have had the national revolutions

0:43:020:43:02

ourselves against have had the national revolutions at

0:43:020:43:02

ourselves against have had the national revolutions at the

0:43:020:43:02

ourselves against have had the national revolutions at the turn

0:43:020:43:03

ourselves against have had the national revolutions at the turn of

0:43:030:43:03

national revolutions at the turn of the

0:43:030:43:03

national revolutions at the turn of the century. They

0:43:030:43:03

national revolutions at the turn of the century. They got

0:43:030:43:04

national revolutions at the turn of the century. They got their

0:43:040:43:04

the century. They got their independence.

0:43:040:43:04

the century. They got their independence. We

0:43:040:43:05

the century. They got their independence. We are

0:43:050:43:05

the century. They got their independence. We are a

0:43:050:43:05

the century. They got their independence. We are a bit late

0:43:050:43:05

the century. They got their independence. We are a bit late to

0:43:050:43:06

independence. We are a bit late to the

0:43:060:43:06

independence. We are a bit late to the game,

0:43:060:43:06

independence. We are a bit late to the game, we

0:43:060:43:06

independence. We are a bit late to the game, we can

0:43:060:43:07

independence. We are a bit late to the game, we can get

0:43:070:43:07

independence. We are a bit late to the game, we can get there.

0:43:070:43:07

independence. We are a bit late to the game, we can get there. It

0:43:070:43:07

independence. We are a bit late to the game, we can get there. It is

0:43:070:43:07

independence. We are a bit late to the game, we can get there. It is a

0:43:070:43:08

the game, we can get there. It is a different

0:43:080:43:08

the game, we can get there. It is a different kind

0:43:080:43:09

the game, we can get there. It is a different kind of

0:43:090:43:09

the game, we can get there. It is a different kind of conversation,

0:43:090:43:09

different kind of conversation, this

0:43:090:43:09

different kind of conversation, this is

0:43:090:43:10

different kind of conversation, this is not

0:43:100:43:10

different kind of conversation, this is not about

0:43:100:43:10

different kind of conversation, this is not about being

0:43:100:43:11

different kind of conversation, this is not about being out

0:43:110:43:11

different kind of conversation, this is not about being out on

0:43:110:43:11

different kind of conversation, this is not about being out on the

0:43:110:43:12

this is not about being out on the streets

0:43:120:43:12

this is not about being out on the streets like

0:43:120:43:12

this is not about being out on the streets like Catalonia,

0:43:120:43:12

this is not about being out on the streets like Catalonia, it

0:43:120:43:13

this is not about being out on the streets like Catalonia, it is

0:43:130:43:13

streets like Catalonia, it is nothing

0:43:130:43:13

streets like Catalonia, it is nothing like

0:43:130:43:14

streets like Catalonia, it is nothing like that.

0:43:140:43:14

streets like Catalonia, it is nothing like that. It

0:43:140:43:14

streets like Catalonia, it is nothing like that. It is

0:43:140:43:14

streets like Catalonia, it is nothing like that. It is a

0:43:140:43:14

streets like Catalonia, it is nothing like that. It is a much

0:43:140:43:15

nothing like that. It is a much more

0:43:150:43:16

nothing like that. It is a much more pressured

0:43:160:43:16

nothing like that. It is a much more pressured thing?

0:43:160:43:16

nothing like that. It is a much more pressured thing? It

0:43:160:43:16

nothing like that. It is a much more pressured thing? It is

0:43:160:43:17

nothing like that. It is a much more pressured thing? It is a

0:43:170:43:17

more pressured thing? It is a reduced

0:43:170:43:17

more pressured thing? It is a reduced conversation

0:43:170:43:17

more pressured thing? It is a reduced conversation as

0:43:170:43:18

more pressured thing? It is a reduced conversation as you

0:43:180:43:18

more pressured thing? It is a reduced conversation as you know.

0:43:180:43:19

reduced conversation as you know. It

0:43:190:43:19

reduced conversation as you know. It will

0:43:190:43:20

reduced conversation as you know. It will also

0:43:200:43:20

reduced conversation as you know. It will also be

0:43:200:43:20

reduced conversation as you know. It will also be the

0:43:200:43:20

reduced conversation as you know. It will also be the case

0:43:200:43:20

reduced conversation as you know. It will also be the case for

0:43:200:43:21

reduced conversation as you know. It will also be the case for a

0:43:210:43:21

reduced conversation as you know. It will also be the case for a lot

0:43:210:43:21

It will also be the case for a lot of

0:43:210:43:22

It will also be the case for a lot of Scots

0:43:220:43:22

It will also be the case for a lot of Scots they

0:43:220:43:22

It will also be the case for a lot of Scots they won't

0:43:220:43:22

It will also be the case for a lot of Scots they won't publicly

0:43:220:43:23

It will also be the case for a lot of Scots they won't publicly say

0:43:230:43:23

of Scots they won't publicly say what

0:43:230:43:23

of Scots they won't publicly say what they

0:43:230:43:24

of Scots they won't publicly say what they think

0:43:240:43:24

of Scots they won't publicly say what they think towards

0:43:240:43:25

of Scots they won't publicly say what they think towards the

0:43:250:43:25

of Scots they won't publicly say what they think towards the end

0:43:250:43:25

what they think towards the end because

0:43:250:43:25

what they think towards the end because people

0:43:250:43:26

what they think towards the end because people are

0:43:260:43:26

what they think towards the end because people are reticent?

0:43:260:43:27

what they think towards the end because people are reticent? That

0:43:270:43:27

because people are reticent? That is

0:43:270:43:27

because people are reticent? That is where

0:43:270:43:27

because people are reticent? That is where we

0:43:270:43:27

because people are reticent? That is where we all

0:43:270:43:28

because people are reticent? That is where we all have

0:43:280:43:28

because people are reticent? That is where we all have to

0:43:280:43:28

because people are reticent? That is where we all have to speak

0:43:280:43:29

because people are reticent? That is where we all have to speak up

0:43:290:43:29

is where we all have to speak up and

0:43:290:43:29

is where we all have to speak up and inform

0:43:290:43:30

is where we all have to speak up and inform each

0:43:300:43:30

is where we all have to speak up and inform each other.

0:43:300:43:30

is where we all have to speak up and inform each other. It

0:43:300:43:30

is where we all have to speak up and inform each other. It means

0:43:300:43:30

is where we all have to speak up and inform each other. It means so

0:43:300:43:31

and inform each other. It means so many

0:43:310:43:31

and inform each other. It means so many different

0:43:310:43:31

and inform each other. It means so many different things

0:43:310:43:31

and inform each other. It means so many different things to

0:43:310:43:32

and inform each other. It means so many different things to different

0:43:320:43:32

many different things to different people.

0:43:320:43:32

many different things to different people. That

0:43:320:43:32

many different things to different people. That is

0:43:320:43:32

many different things to different people. That is interesting

0:43:320:43:33

many different things to different people. That is interesting about

0:43:330:43:33

people. That is interesting about tonight,

0:43:330:43:33

people. That is interesting about tonight, it

0:43:330:43:33

people. That is interesting about tonight, it is

0:43:330:43:34

people. That is interesting about tonight, it is not

0:43:340:43:34

people. That is interesting about tonight, it is not really

0:43:340:43:34

people. That is interesting about tonight, it is not really about

0:43:340:43:34

people. That is interesting about what the

0:43:340:43:34

people. That is interesting about what the politicians

0:43:340:43:35

people. That is interesting about what the politicians think

0:43:350:43:35

people. That is interesting about what the politicians think any

0:43:350:43:36

people. That is interesting about what the politicians think any more,

0:43:360:43:36

what the politicians think any more, it

0:43:360:43:36

what the politicians think any more, it is

0:43:360:43:36

what the politicians think any more, it is about

0:43:360:43:36

what the politicians think any more, it is about what

0:43:360:43:37

what the politicians think any more, it is about what it

0:43:370:43:37

what the politicians think any more, it is about what it means

0:43:370:43:37

what the politicians think any more, it is about what it means for

0:43:370:43:37

what the politicians think any more, it is about what it means for me

0:43:370:43:37

what the politicians think any more, it is about what it means for me as

0:43:370:43:38

it is about what it means for me as a

0:43:380:43:38

it is about what it means for me as a mother

0:43:380:43:38

it is about what it means for me as a mother and

0:43:380:43:39

it is about what it means for me as a mother and wife

0:43:390:43:39

it is about what it means for me as a mother and wife as

0:43:390:43:39

it is about what it means for me as a mother and wife as a

0:43:390:43:40

it is about what it means for me as a mother and wife as a small

0:43:400:43:40

a mother and wife as a small business

0:43:400:43:40

a mother and wife as a small business person.

0:43:400:43:41

a mother and wife as a small business person. It

0:43:410:43:41

a mother and wife as a small business person. It has

0:43:410:43:43

a mother and wife as a small business person. It has so

0:43:430:43:43

a mother and wife as a small business person. It has so many

0:43:430:43:43

business person. It has so many ramifications

0:43:430:43:43

business person. It has so many ramifications for

0:43:430:43:43

business person. It has so many ramifications for just

0:43:430:43:44

business person. It has so many ramifications for just everybody

0:43:440:43:44

business person. It has so many ramifications for just everybody it

0:43:440:43:45

business person. It has so many has to

0:43:450:43:45

business person. It has so many has to be

0:43:450:43:45

business person. It has so many has to be a

0:43:450:43:46

business person. It has so many has to be a personal

0:43:460:43:46

business person. It has so many has to be a personal and

0:43:460:43:46

business person. It has so many has to be a personal and heart

0:43:460:43:46

has to be a personal and heart decision

0:43:460:43:47

has to be a personal and heart decision as

0:43:470:43:47

has to be a personal and heart decision as well.

0:43:470:43:48

has to be a personal and heart decision as well. Let

0:43:480:43:48

has to be a personal and heart decision as well. Let me

0:43:480:43:48

has to be a personal and heart decision as well. Let me speak

0:43:480:43:49

decision as well. Let me speak to someone

0:43:490:43:49

decision as well. Let me speak to someone he

0:43:490:43:49

decision as well. Let me speak to someone he will.

0:43:490:43:50

decision as well. Let me speak to someone he will. You

0:43:500:43:50

decision as well. Let me speak to someone he will. You have

0:43:500:43:51

decision as well. Let me speak to someone he will. You have voted

0:43:510:43:51

decision as well. Let me speak to someone he will. You have voted yes,

0:43:510:43:52

someone he will. You have voted yes, so

0:43:520:43:52

someone he will. You have voted yes, so what's

0:43:520:43:53

someone he will. You have voted yes, so what's your

0:43:530:43:53

someone he will. You have voted yes, so what's your reasoning?

0:43:530:43:53

someone he will. You have voted yes, so what's your reasoning? I

0:43:530:43:53

someone he will. You have voted yes, so what's your reasoning? I think

0:43:530:43:54

so what's your reasoning? I think you

0:43:540:43:54

so what's your reasoning? I think you have

0:43:540:43:54

so what's your reasoning? I think you have to

0:43:540:43:55

so what's your reasoning? I think you have to weigh up

0:43:550:43:56

so what's your reasoning? I think you have to weigh up the

0:43:560:43:56

so what's your reasoning? I think you have to weigh up the long-term

0:43:560:43:57

you have to weigh up the long-term benefits

0:43:570:43:57

you have to weigh up the long-term benefits against the

0:43:570:43:58

you have to weigh up the long-term benefits against the short-term

0:43:580:43:58

benefits against the short-term risk

0:43:580:43:59

benefits against the short-term risk and

0:43:590:43:59

benefits against the short-term risk and uncertainties.

0:43:590:44:01

benefits against the short-term risk and uncertainties. I

0:44:010:44:01

benefits against the short-term risk and uncertainties. I think

0:44:010:44:01

benefits against the short-term risk and uncertainties. I think you

0:44:010:44:01

risk and uncertainties. I think you have

0:44:010:44:03

risk and uncertainties. I think you have to

0:44:030:44:03

risk and uncertainties. I think you have to hopefully

0:44:030:44:03

risk and uncertainties. I think you have to hopefully believe

0:44:030:44:03

risk and uncertainties. I think you have to hopefully believe those

0:44:030:44:04

have to hopefully believe those short-term

0:44:040:44:04

have to hopefully believe those short-term risks

0:44:040:44:05

have to hopefully believe those short-term risks are

0:44:050:44:05

have to hopefully believe those short-term risks are manageable.

0:44:050:44:06

have to hopefully believe those Basically what

0:44:060:44:06

have to hopefully believe those Basically what you

0:44:060:44:06

have to hopefully believe those Basically what you are

0:44:060:44:06

have to hopefully believe those Basically what you are doing

0:44:060:44:06

have to hopefully believe those Basically what you are doing is

0:44:060:44:07

have to hopefully believe those Basically what you are doing is not

0:44:070:44:07

Basically what you are doing is not looking

0:44:070:44:07

Basically what you are doing is not looking at

0:44:070:44:07

Basically what you are doing is not looking at the

0:44:070:44:08

Basically what you are doing is not looking at the next

0:44:080:44:08

Basically what you are doing is not looking at the next two

0:44:080:44:08

Basically what you are doing is not looking at the next two or

0:44:080:44:09

Basically what you are doing is not looking at the next two or three

0:44:090:44:09

looking at the next two or three years.

0:44:090:44:10

looking at the next two or three years. You

0:44:100:44:10

looking at the next two or three years. You are

0:44:100:44:10

looking at the next two or three years. You are saying

0:44:100:44:10

looking at the next two or three years. You are saying this

0:44:100:44:12

looking at the next two or three years. You are saying this is

0:44:120:44:12

looking at the next two or three years. You are saying this is not

0:44:120:44:12

years. You are saying this is not just

0:44:120:44:12

years. You are saying this is not just for

0:44:120:44:13

years. You are saying this is not just for Christmas,

0:44:130:44:13

years. You are saying this is not just for Christmas, but

0:44:130:44:13

years. You are saying this is not just for Christmas, but for

0:44:130:44:13

years. You are saying this is not just for Christmas, but for the

0:44:130:44:14

just for Christmas, but for the next

0:44:140:44:15

just for Christmas, but for the next generation?

0:44:150:44:15

just for Christmas, but for the next generation? And

0:44:150:44:15

just for Christmas, but for the next generation? And the

0:44:150:44:15

just for Christmas, but for the next generation? And the next

0:44:150:44:15

next generation? And the next generation

0:44:150:44:16

next generation? And the next generation after

0:44:160:44:16

next generation? And the next generation after that.

0:44:160:44:16

next generation? And the next generation after that. You

0:44:160:44:17

next generation? And the next generation after that. You have

0:44:170:44:17

next generation? And the next generation after that. You have to

0:44:170:44:17

generation after that. You have to hope

0:44:170:44:17

generation after that. You have to hope that

0:44:170:44:19

generation after that. You have to hope that Scotland

0:44:190:44:19

generation after that. You have to hope that Scotland standing

0:44:190:44:19

generation after that. You have to hope that Scotland standing on

0:44:190:44:21

generation after that. You have to hope that Scotland standing on its

0:44:210:44:21

hope that Scotland standing on its own

0:44:210:44:21

hope that Scotland standing on its own can

0:44:210:44:22

hope that Scotland standing on its own can sort

0:44:220:44:22

hope that Scotland standing on its own can sort these

0:44:220:44:22

hope that Scotland standing on its own can sort these problems.

0:44:220:44:23

hope that Scotland standing on its own can sort these problems. I

0:44:230:44:23

own can sort these problems. I think

0:44:230:44:24

own can sort these problems. I think all

0:44:240:44:24

own can sort these problems. I think all the

0:44:240:44:24

own can sort these problems. I think all the short-term

0:44:240:44:25

own can sort these problems. I think all the short-term risks

0:44:250:44:25

own can sort these problems. I think all the short-term risks are

0:44:250:44:25

think all the short-term risks are manageable,

0:44:250:44:26

think all the short-term risks are manageable, let's

0:44:260:44:26

think all the short-term risks are manageable, let's go

0:44:260:44:27

think all the short-term risks are manageable, let's go for

0:44:270:44:27

think all the short-term risks are manageable, let's go for it.

0:44:270:44:27

think all the short-term risks are manageable, let's go for it. Let's

0:44:270:44:28

manageable, let's go for it. Let's see

0:44:280:44:28

manageable, let's go for it. Let's see now,

0:44:280:44:28

manageable, let's go for it. Let's see now, we

0:44:280:44:28

manageable, let's go for it. Let's see now, we have

0:44:280:44:29

manageable, let's go for it. Let's see now, we have a

0:44:290:44:29

manageable, let's go for it. Let's see now, we have a few

0:44:290:44:29

manageable, let's go for it. Let's see now, we have a few more

0:44:290:44:30

manageable, let's go for it. Let's see now, we have a few more coming

0:44:300:44:31

manageable, let's go for it. Let's through still.

0:44:310:44:31

manageable, let's go for it. Let's through still. But

0:44:310:44:33

manageable, let's go for it. Let's through still. But the

0:44:330:44:33

manageable, let's go for it. Let's through still. But the idea,

0:44:330:44:33

manageable, let's go for it. Let's through still. But the idea, the

0:44:330:44:36

through still. But the idea, the idea

0:44:360:44:36

through still. But the idea, the idea that

0:44:360:44:36

through still. But the idea, the idea that there

0:44:360:44:37

through still. But the idea, the idea that there is

0:44:370:44:37

through still. But the idea, the idea that there is going

0:44:370:44:37

through still. But the idea, the idea that there is going to

0:44:370:44:37

through still. But the idea, the idea that there is going to be

0:44:370:44:37

through still. But the idea, the idea that there is going to be some

0:44:370:44:38

idea that there is going to be some sort

0:44:380:44:38

idea that there is going to be some sort of

0:44:380:44:38

idea that there is going to be some sort of different

0:44:380:44:38

idea that there is going to be some sort of different relationship

0:44:380:44:39

idea that there is going to be some sort of different relationship with

0:44:390:44:39

sort of different relationship with England

0:44:390:44:40

sort of different relationship with England if

0:44:400:44:40

sort of different relationship with England if there

0:44:400:44:40

sort of different relationship with England if there is

0:44:400:44:41

sort of different relationship with England if there is a

0:44:410:44:41

sort of different relationship with England if there is a yes

0:44:410:44:41

sort of different relationship with England if there is a yes vote

0:44:410:44:42

sort of different relationship with England if there is a yes vote is

0:44:420:44:42

England if there is a yes vote is absolutely

0:44:420:44:42

England if there is a yes vote is absolutely true,

0:44:420:44:43

England if there is a yes vote is absolutely true, it

0:44:430:44:43

England if there is a yes vote is absolutely true, it is

0:44:430:44:43

England if there is a yes vote is absolutely true, it is bound

0:44:430:44:43

England if there is a yes vote is absolutely true, it is bound to

0:44:430:44:44

England if there is a yes vote is absolutely true, it is bound to be?

0:44:440:44:44

absolutely true, it is bound to be? It

0:44:440:44:44

absolutely true, it is bound to be? It is

0:44:440:44:45

absolutely true, it is bound to be? It is a

0:44:450:44:46

absolutely true, it is bound to be? It is a separate

0:44:460:44:46

absolutely true, it is bound to be? It is a separate state,

0:44:460:44:46

absolutely true, it is bound to be? It is a separate state, so

0:44:460:44:46

absolutely true, it is bound to be? It is a separate state, so it

0:44:460:44:47

absolutely true, it is bound to be? It is a separate state, so it has

0:44:470:44:47

It is a separate state, so it has to

0:44:470:44:47

It is a separate state, so it has to function

0:44:470:44:47

It is a separate state, so it has to function as

0:44:470:44:48

It is a separate state, so it has to function as a

0:44:480:44:49

It is a separate state, so it has to function as a separate

0:44:490:44:49

It is a separate state, so it has to function as a separate entity.

0:44:490:44:49

to function as a separate entity. You

0:44:490:44:49

to function as a separate entity. You have

0:44:490:44:50

to function as a separate entity. You have put

0:44:500:44:51

to function as a separate entity. You have put up

0:44:510:44:51

to function as a separate entity. You have put up a

0:44:510:44:51

to function as a separate entity. You have put up a border,

0:44:510:44:52

to function as a separate entity. You have put up a border, your

0:44:520:44:52

You have put up a border, your biggest

0:44:520:44:52

You have put up a border, your biggest trading

0:44:520:44:53

You have put up a border, your biggest trading partner

0:44:530:44:53

You have put up a border, your biggest trading partner is

0:44:530:44:53

You have put up a border, your biggest trading partner is now

0:44:530:44:53

You have put up a border, your biggest trading partner is now not

0:44:530:44:54

biggest trading partner is now not that

0:44:540:44:54

biggest trading partner is now not that partner,

0:44:540:44:55

biggest trading partner is now not that partner, you

0:44:550:44:55

biggest trading partner is now not that partner, you are

0:44:550:44:55

biggest trading partner is now not that partner, you are a

0:44:550:44:55

that partner, you are a separate independent

0:44:550:44:56

that partner, you are a separate independent nation

0:44:560:44:56

that partner, you are a separate independent nation working

0:44:560:44:56

that partner, you are a separate independent nation working with

0:44:560:44:57

independent nation working with your

0:44:570:44:57

independent nation working with your own

0:44:570:45:00

independent nation working with your own financial

0:45:000:45:00

independent nation working with your own financial situations.

0:45:000:45:00

your own financial situations. Let's

0:45:000:45:00

your own financial situations. Let's cut

0:45:000:45:01

your own financial situations. Let's cut to

0:45:010:45:02

your own financial situations. Let's cut to the

0:45:020:45:02

your own financial situations. Let's cut to the chase,

0:45:020:45:02

your own financial situations. Let's cut to the chase, the

0:45:020:45:02

your own financial situations. Let's cut to the chase, the reason

0:45:020:45:03

Let's cut to the chase, the reason why

0:45:030:45:03

Let's cut to the chase, the reason why the

0:45:030:45:03

Let's cut to the chase, the reason why the Scottish

0:45:030:45:03

Let's cut to the chase, the reason why the Scottish Parliament

0:45:030:45:04

Let's cut to the chase, the reason why the Scottish Parliament had

0:45:040:45:04

Let's cut to the chase, the reason why the Scottish Parliament had to

0:45:040:45:04

why the Scottish Parliament had to exist

0:45:040:45:04

why the Scottish Parliament had to exist is

0:45:040:45:05

why the Scottish Parliament had to exist is because

0:45:050:45:06

why the Scottish Parliament had to exist is because we

0:45:060:45:06

why the Scottish Parliament had to exist is because we had

0:45:060:45:06

why the Scottish Parliament had to exist is because we had a

0:45:060:45:06

why the Scottish Parliament had to exist is because we had a consensus

0:45:060:45:07

exist is because we had a consensus of

0:45:070:45:07

exist is because we had a consensus of values

0:45:070:45:08

exist is because we had a consensus of values we

0:45:080:45:08

exist is because we had a consensus of values we wanted

0:45:080:45:08

exist is because we had a consensus of values we wanted to

0:45:080:45:08

exist is because we had a consensus of values we wanted to go

0:45:080:45:08

exist is because we had a consensus of values we wanted to go in

0:45:080:45:09

exist is because we had a consensus of values we wanted to go in a

0:45:090:45:09

of values we wanted to go in a different

0:45:090:45:09

of values we wanted to go in a different direction.

0:45:090:45:10

of values we wanted to go in a different direction. That

0:45:100:45:10

of values we wanted to go in a different direction. That has

0:45:100:45:10

different direction. That has increased

0:45:100:45:11

different direction. That has increased since

0:45:110:45:11

different direction. That has increased since the

0:45:110:45:11

different direction. That has increased since the time

0:45:110:45:11

different direction. That has increased since the time of

0:45:110:45:11

different direction. That has increased since the time of the

0:45:110:45:12

increased since the time of the Scottish

0:45:120:45:12

increased since the time of the Scottish Parliament,

0:45:120:45:12

increased since the time of the Scottish Parliament, at

0:45:120:45:12

increased since the time of the Scottish Parliament, at some

0:45:120:45:12

increased since the time of the Scottish Parliament, at some point

0:45:120:45:13

Scottish Parliament, at some point we

0:45:130:45:13

Scottish Parliament, at some point we have

0:45:130:45:13

Scottish Parliament, at some point we have to

0:45:130:45:14

Scottish Parliament, at some point we have to act

0:45:140:45:14

Scottish Parliament, at some point we have to act on

0:45:140:45:14

Scottish Parliament, at some point we have to act on that

0:45:140:45:15

Scottish Parliament, at some point we have to act on that consensus

0:45:150:45:15

Scottish Parliament, at some point we have to act on that consensus of

0:45:150:45:16

we have to act on that consensus of values,

0:45:160:45:16

we have to act on that consensus of values, independence

0:45:160:45:16

we have to act on that consensus of values, independence allows

0:45:160:45:16

we have to act on that consensus of values, independence allows us

0:45:160:45:16

we have to act on that consensus of values, independence allows us to

0:45:160:45:17

values, independence allows us to do

0:45:170:45:17

values, independence allows us to do that.

0:45:170:45:17

values, independence allows us to do that. It

0:45:170:45:18

values, independence allows us to do that. It is

0:45:180:45:18

values, independence allows us to do that. It is the

0:45:180:45:18

values, independence allows us to do that. It is the Israelisation

0:45:180:45:19

values, independence allows us to do that. It is the Israelisation of

0:45:190:45:19

do that. It is the Israelisation of a

0:45:190:45:19

do that. It is the Israelisation of a process

0:45:190:45:20

do that. It is the Israelisation of a process whereby

0:45:200:45:20

do that. It is the Israelisation of a process whereby you

0:45:200:45:20

do that. It is the Israelisation of a process whereby you restore

0:45:200:45:21

do that. It is the Israelisation of a process whereby you restore a

0:45:210:45:21

a process whereby you restore a parliament,

0:45:210:45:22

a process whereby you restore a parliament, you

0:45:220:45:22

a process whereby you restore a parliament, you --

0:45:220:45:24

a process whereby you restore a parliament, you -- a

0:45:240:45:24

a process whereby you restore a parliament, you -- a realisation

0:45:240:45:25

a process whereby you restore a parliament, you -- a realisation of

0:45:250:45:25

parliament, you -- a realisation of a

0:45:250:45:25

parliament, you -- a realisation of a process

0:45:250:45:26

parliament, you -- a realisation of a process where

0:45:260:45:26

parliament, you -- a realisation of a process where you

0:45:260:45:27

parliament, you -- a realisation of a process where you restore

0:45:270:45:27

parliament, you -- a realisation of a process where you restore the

0:45:270:45:27

a process where you restore the parliament.

0:45:270:45:28

a process where you restore the parliament. It

0:45:280:45:28

a process where you restore the parliament. It is

0:45:280:45:28

a process where you restore the parliament. It is a

0:45:280:45:29

a process where you restore the parliament. It is a positive

0:45:290:45:29

a process where you restore the parliament. It is a positive act.

0:45:290:45:29

parliament. It is a positive act. We

0:45:290:45:29

parliament. It is a positive act. We have

0:45:290:45:29

parliament. It is a positive act. We have our

0:45:290:45:30

parliament. It is a positive act. We have our vote

0:45:300:45:30

parliament. It is a positive act. We have our vote here,

0:45:300:45:30

parliament. It is a positive act. We have our vote here, and

0:45:300:45:30

parliament. It is a positive act. We have our vote here, and the

0:45:300:45:31

We have our vote here, and the number

0:45:310:45:31

We have our vote here, and the number who

0:45:310:45:32

We have our vote here, and the number who are

0:45:320:45:32

We have our vote here, and the number who are going

0:45:320:45:33

We have our vote here, and the number who are going to

0:45:330:45:34

We have our vote here, and the number who are going to vote

0:45:340:45:34

We have our vote here, and the number who are going to vote yes

0:45:340:45:34

number who are going to vote yes for

0:45:340:45:34

number who are going to vote yes for independence

0:45:340:45:35

number who are going to vote yes for independence is

0:45:350:45:36

number who are going to vote yes for independence is 30

0:45:360:45:36

number who are going to vote yes for independence is 30 and

0:45:360:45:36

number who are going to vote yes for independence is 30 and the

0:45:360:45:36

for independence is 30 and the number

0:45:360:45:36

for independence is 30 and the number who

0:45:360:45:37

for independence is 30 and the number who are

0:45:370:45:37

for independence is 30 and the number who are going to

0:45:370:45:37

for independence is 30 and the number who are going to vote

0:45:370:45:38

for independence is 30 and the number who are going to vote no,

0:45:380:45:38

number who are going to vote no, they

0:45:380:45:38

number who are going to vote no, they wish

0:45:380:45:39

number who are going to vote no, they wish to

0:45:390:45:39

number who are going to vote no, they wish to stay

0:45:390:45:39

number who are going to vote no, they wish to stay in

0:45:390:45:40

number who are going to vote no, they wish to stay in the

0:45:400:45:40

number who are going to vote no, they wish to stay in the union

0:45:400:45:40

number who are going to vote no, they wish to stay in the union is

0:45:400:45:41

they wish to stay in the union is 18.

0:45:410:45:41

they wish to stay in the union is 18. Oh

0:45:410:45:42

they wish to stay in the union is 18. Oh wow.

0:45:420:45:42

they wish to stay in the union is 18. Oh wow. So

0:45:420:45:42

they wish to stay in the union is 18. Oh wow. So first

0:45:420:45:43

they wish to stay in the union is 18. Oh wow. So first reaction

0:45:430:45:43

they wish to stay in the union is 18. Oh wow. So first reaction to

0:45:430:45:44

18. Oh wow. So first reaction to that?

0:45:440:45:44

18. Oh wow. So first reaction to that? Well

0:45:440:45:45

18. Oh wow. So first reaction to that? Well done

0:45:450:45:45

18. Oh wow. So first reaction to that? Well done everyone.

0:45:450:45:46

18. Oh wow. So first reaction to that? Well done everyone. Does

0:45:460:45:46

18. Oh wow. So first reaction to that? Well done everyone. Does that

0:45:460:45:47

that? Well done everyone. Does that surprise

0:45:470:45:47

that? Well done everyone. Does that surprise you,

0:45:470:45:47

that? Well done everyone. Does that surprise you, given

0:45:470:45:47

that? Well done everyone. Does that surprise you, given that

0:45:470:45:49

that? Well done everyone. Does that surprise you, given that the

0:45:490:45:49

that? Well done everyone. Does that surprise you, given that the polls,

0:45:490:45:49

surprise you, given that the polls, what

0:45:490:45:49

surprise you, given that the polls, what we

0:45:490:45:50

surprise you, given that the polls, what we have

0:45:500:45:50

surprise you, given that the polls, what we have been

0:45:500:45:50

surprise you, given that the polls, what we have been hearing

0:45:500:45:50

surprise you, given that the polls, what we have been hearing and

0:45:500:45:51

what we have been hearing and seeing

0:45:510:45:51

what we have been hearing and seeing in

0:45:510:45:52

what we have been hearing and seeing in opinion

0:45:520:45:52

what we have been hearing and seeing in opinion polls?

0:45:520:45:54

what we have been hearing and seeing in opinion polls? Well

0:45:540:45:54

what we have been hearing and seeing in opinion polls? Well the

0:45:540:45:54

seeing in opinion polls? Well the theory

0:45:540:45:54

seeing in opinion polls? Well the theory that

0:45:540:45:54

seeing in opinion polls? Well the theory that we

0:45:540:45:55

seeing in opinion polls? Well the theory that we have

0:45:550:45:55

seeing in opinion polls? Well the theory that we have in

0:45:550:45:55

seeing in opinion polls? Well the theory that we have in Yes

0:45:550:45:56

seeing in opinion polls? Well the theory that we have in Yes Scotland

0:45:560:45:56

theory that we have in Yes Scotland is

0:45:560:45:56

theory that we have in Yes Scotland is the

0:45:560:45:57

theory that we have in Yes Scotland is the more

0:45:570:45:57

theory that we have in Yes Scotland is the more people

0:45:570:45:57

theory that we have in Yes Scotland is the more people engage

0:45:570:45:58

theory that we have in Yes Scotland is the more people engage with

0:45:580:45:58

theory that we have in Yes Scotland is the more people engage with the

0:45:580:45:58

is the more people engage with the issues

0:45:580:45:59

is the more people engage with the issues the

0:45:590:45:59

is the more people engage with the issues the more

0:45:590:45:59

is the more people engage with the issues the more likely

0:45:590:45:59

is the more people engage with the issues the more likely they

0:45:590:46:00

is the more people engage with the issues the more likely they are

0:46:000:46:00

is the more people engage with the issues the more likely they are to

0:46:000:46:01

issues the more likely they are to drift

0:46:010:46:01

issues the more likely they are to drift to

0:46:010:46:01

issues the more likely they are to drift to yes.

0:46:010:46:01

issues the more likely they are to drift to yes. But

0:46:010:46:02

issues the more likely they are to drift to yes. But the

0:46:020:46:02

issues the more likely they are to drift to yes. But the point

0:46:020:46:02

issues the more likely they are to drift to yes. But the point about

0:46:020:46:02

drift to yes. But the point about the

0:46:020:46:03

drift to yes. But the point about the process

0:46:030:46:03

drift to yes. But the point about the process is

0:46:030:46:03

drift to yes. But the point about the process is it

0:46:030:46:03

drift to yes. But the point about the process is it is

0:46:030:46:04

drift to yes. But the point about the process is it is an

0:46:040:46:04

drift to yes. But the point about the process is it is an enlarging

0:46:040:46:04

the process is it is an enlarging process,

0:46:040:46:05

the process is it is an enlarging process, it

0:46:050:46:05

the process is it is an enlarging process, it is

0:46:050:46:05

the process is it is an enlarging process, it is about

0:46:050:46:05

the process is it is an enlarging process, it is about connecting

0:46:050:46:06

the process is it is an enlarging process, it is about connecting up

0:46:060:46:06

process, it is about connecting up your

0:46:060:46:06

process, it is about connecting up your head

0:46:060:46:06

process, it is about connecting up your head and

0:46:060:46:07

process, it is about connecting up your head and heart,

0:46:070:46:07

process, it is about connecting up your head and heart, it is about

0:46:070:46:09

your head and heart, it is about dealing

0:46:090:46:09

your head and heart, it is about dealing with

0:46:090:46:09

your head and heart, it is about dealing with facts

0:46:090:46:09

your head and heart, it is about dealing with facts and

0:46:090:46:09

your head and heart, it is about dealing with facts and aspirations

0:46:090:46:10

dealing with facts and aspirations and

0:46:100:46:10

dealing with facts and aspirations and joins

0:46:100:46:10

dealing with facts and aspirations and joins it

0:46:100:46:11

dealing with facts and aspirations and joins it all

0:46:110:46:11

dealing with facts and aspirations and joins it all together.

0:46:110:46:11

dealing with facts and aspirations and joins it all together. Your

0:46:110:46:12

and joins it all together. Your reaction

0:46:120:46:14

and joins it all together. Your reaction to

0:46:140:46:14

and joins it all together. Your reaction to that?

0:46:140:46:14

and joins it all together. Your reaction to that? I

0:46:140:46:14

and joins it all together. Your reaction to that? I am

0:46:140:46:15

and joins it all together. Your reaction to that? I am surprised,

0:46:150:46:15

reaction to that? I am surprised, what

0:46:150:46:15

reaction to that? I am surprised, what is

0:46:150:46:15

reaction to that? I am surprised, what is interesting

0:46:150:46:16

reaction to that? I am surprised, what is interesting is

0:46:160:46:16

reaction to that? I am surprised, what is interesting is so

0:46:160:46:16

reaction to that? I am surprised, what is interesting is so many

0:46:160:46:16

what is interesting is so many people

0:46:160:46:17

what is interesting is so many people are

0:46:170:46:17

what is interesting is so many people are putting

0:46:170:46:17

what is interesting is so many people are putting the

0:46:170:46:18

what is interesting is so many people are putting the fate

0:46:180:46:18

what is interesting is so many people are putting the fate that

0:46:180:46:18

people are putting the fate that the

0:46:180:46:18

people are putting the fate that the Scottish

0:46:180:46:19

people are putting the fate that the Scottish Government

0:46:190:46:19

people are putting the fate that the Scottish Government can

0:46:190:46:19

people are putting the fate that the Scottish Government can deliver

0:46:190:46:20

the Scottish Government can deliver all

0:46:200:46:20

the Scottish Government can deliver all the

0:46:200:46:21

the Scottish Government can deliver all the promises.

0:46:210:46:21

the Scottish Government can deliver all the promises. The

0:46:210:46:22

the Scottish Government can deliver all the promises. The reality

0:46:220:46:22

the Scottish Government can deliver all the promises. The reality is

0:46:220:46:26

all the promises. The reality is that

0:46:260:46:27

all the promises. The reality is that is

0:46:270:46:27

all the promises. The reality is that is there,

0:46:270:46:27

all the promises. The reality is that is there, and

0:46:270:46:28

all the promises. The reality is that is there, and they

0:46:280:46:29

all the promises. The reality is that is there, and they don't

0:46:290:46:29

all the promises. The reality is that is there, and they don't know

0:46:290:46:29

that is there, and they don't know that

0:46:290:46:29

that is there, and they don't know that but

0:46:290:46:30

that is there, and they don't know that but they

0:46:300:46:30

that is there, and they don't know that but they will

0:46:300:46:30

that is there, and they don't know that but they will still

0:46:300:46:30

that is there, and they don't know that but they will still vote

0:46:300:46:31

that is there, and they don't know that but they will still vote yes.

0:46:310:46:31

that but they will still vote yes. That

0:46:310:46:31

that but they will still vote yes. That is

0:46:310:46:31

that but they will still vote yes. That is a big

0:46:310:46:31

that but they will still vote yes. That is a big gamble.

0:46:310:46:32

that but they will still vote yes. That is a big gamble. I

0:46:320:46:32

that but they will still vote yes. That is a big gamble. I hope

0:46:320:46:33

that but they will still vote yes. That is a big gamble. I hope that

0:46:330:46:33

That is a big gamble. I hope that pays

0:46:330:46:33

That is a big gamble. I hope that pays off.

0:46:330:46:34

That is a big gamble. I hope that pays off. I'm

0:46:340:46:34

That is a big gamble. I hope that pays off. I'm still

0:46:340:46:35

That is a big gamble. I hope that pays off. I'm still 100%

0:46:350:46:36

That is a big gamble. I hope that pays off. I'm still 100% against

0:46:360:46:36

That is a big gamble. I hope that pays off. I'm still 100% against it.

0:46:360:46:36

pays off. I'm still 100% against it. Come

0:46:360:46:37

pays off. I'm still 100% against it. Come on

0:46:370:46:37

pays off. I'm still 100% against it. Come on you.

0:46:370:46:37

pays off. I'm still 100% against it. Come on you. No.

0:46:370:46:39

pays off. I'm still 100% against it. Come on you. No. No.

0:46:390:46:39

pays off. I'm still 100% against it. Come on you. No. No. Thank

0:46:390:46:39

pays off. I'm still 100% against it. Come on you. No. No. Thank you

0:46:390:46:40

pays off. I'm still 100% against it. Come on you. No. No. Thank you very

0:46:400:46:40

Come on you. No. No. Thank you very much,

0:46:400:46:40

Come on you. No. No. Thank you very much, that

0:46:400:46:40

Come on you. No. No. Thank you very much, that was

0:46:400:46:41

Come on you. No. No. Thank you very much, that was completely

0:46:410:46:41

much, that was completely unscientific.

0:46:410:46:42

much, that was completely unscientific. But

0:46:420:46:42

much, that was completely unscientific. But debates

0:46:420:46:42

much, that was completely unscientific. But debates like

0:46:420:46:42

unscientific. But debates like these

0:46:420:46:43

unscientific. But debates like these will

0:46:430:46:43

unscientific. But debates like these will be

0:46:430:46:43

unscientific. But debates like these will be happening

0:46:430:46:44

unscientific. But debates like these will be happening all

0:46:440:46:44

unscientific. But debates like these will be happening all over

0:46:440:46:44

these will be happening all over Scotland

0:46:440:46:45

these will be happening all over Scotland between

0:46:450:46:46

these will be happening all over Scotland between now

0:46:460:46:46

these will be happening all over Scotland between now and

0:46:460:46:47

these will be happening all over Scotland between now and September

0:46:470:46:47

Scotland between now and September 18th201.

0:46:470:46:47

Scotland between now and September 18th201. Tonight

0:46:470:46:48

Scotland between now and September 18th201. Tonight is

0:46:480:46:48

Scotland between now and September 18th201. Tonight is just

0:46:480:46:49

Scotland between now and September 18th201. Tonight is just the

0:46:490:46:49

Scotland between now and September 18th201. Tonight is just the start.

0:46:490:46:49

18th201. Tonight is just the start. If

0:46:490:46:50

18th201. Tonight is just the start. If you

0:46:500:46:50

18th201. Tonight is just the start. If you want

0:46:500:46:51

18th201. Tonight is just the start. If you want to

0:46:510:46:51

18th201. Tonight is just the start. If you want to --

0:46:510:46:51

18th201. Tonight is just the start. If you want to -- 2014.

0:46:510:46:51

18th201. Tonight is just the start. If you want to -- 2014. Tonight

0:46:510:46:51

18th201. Tonight is just the start. If you want to -- 2014. Tonight is

0:46:510:46:52

If you want to -- 2014. Tonight is just

0:46:520:46:52

If you want to -- 2014. Tonight is just the

0:46:520:46:52

If you want to -- 2014. Tonight is just the start.

0:46:520:46:52

If you want to -- 2014. Tonight is just the start. If

0:46:520:46:53

If you want to -- 2014. Tonight is just the start. If you

0:46:530:46:53

If you want to -- 2014. Tonight is just the start. If you want

0:46:530:46:54

If you want to -- 2014. Tonight is just the start. If you want to

0:46:540:46:54

just the start. If you want to catch

0:46:540:46:54

just the start. If you want to catch up

0:46:540:46:55

just the start. If you want to catch up on

0:46:550:46:56

just the start. If you want to catch up on the

0:46:560:46:56

just the start. If you want to catch up on the Lib

0:46:560:46:56

just the start. If you want to catch up on the Lib Dem

0:46:560:46:57

just the start. If you want to catch up on the Lib Dem conference

0:46:570:46:57

catch up on the Lib Dem conference the

0:46:570:46:57

catch up on the Lib Dem conference the highlights

0:46:570:46:58

catch up on the Lib Dem conference the highlights are

0:46:580:46:58

catch up on the Lib Dem conference the highlights are immediately

0:46:580:46:59

the highlights are immediately after

0:46:590:46:59

the highlights are immediately after this

0:46:590:46:59

the highlights are immediately after this programme.

0:46:590:47:00

the highlights are immediately after this programme. Between

0:47:000:47:02

the highlights are immediately after this programme. Between the

0:47:020:47:03

after this programme. Between the beautiful

0:47:030:47:03

after this programme. Between the beautiful border

0:47:030:47:04

after this programme. Between the beautiful border of

0:47:040:47:04

after this programme. Between the beautiful border of England

0:47:040:47:04

after this programme. Between the beautiful border of England and

0:47:040:47:05

beautiful border of England and Scotland

0:47:050:47:05

beautiful border of England and Scotland over

0:47:050:47:05

beautiful border of England and Scotland over the

0:47:050:47:06

beautiful border of England and Scotland over the River

0:47:060:47:06

beautiful border of England and Scotland over the River Tweed,

0:47:060:47:06

beautiful border of England and Scotland over the River Tweed, a

0:47:060:47:06

Scotland over the River Tweed, a very

0:47:060:47:06

Scotland over the River Tweed, a very good

0:47:060:47:07

Scotland over the River Tweed, a very good night.

0:47:070:48:02

Download Subtitles

SRT

ASS