Live Budget 2017 Budget


Live Budget 2017

Similar Content

Browse content similar to Live Budget 2017. Check below for episodes and series from the same categories and more!

Transcript


LineFromTo

So Prime Minister's Questions

comes to an end and.

0:00:000:00:06

Thank you. Border. Dashboard.

0:00:060:00:19

Copies of the speech will be

available in the library afterwords.

0:00:310:00:39

I now call the Chancellor of the

Exchequer, the right honourable

0:00:390:00:43

Philip Hammond.

Mr Deputy Speaker, I report today on

0:00:430:00:52

an economy which continues to grow,

continues to create more jobs than

0:00:520:00:56

ever before, and continues to

confound those who seek to talk it

0:00:560:00:59

down. An economy is set on a path to

a new relationship with our European

0:00:590:01:08

neighbours and a new future outside

the European Union. A future that

0:01:080:01:17

will be full of change, full of new

challenges and above all, full of

0:01:170:01:20

new opportunities. And in this

Budget, we express our resolve to

0:01:200:01:24

look forwards, not backwards. To

embrace that change, to meet those

0:01:240:01:28

challenges head-on, and to seize

those for Britain. For negotiations

0:01:280:01:36

on a relationship with the EU are in

a critical phase. My right

0:01:360:01:41

honourable friend the Prime Minister

has been clear we seek a deep and

0:01:410:01:44

special partnership based on free

and frictionless trading goods,

0:01:440:01:49

close collaboration on security and

strong mutual respect and

0:01:490:01:53

friendship. As Chancellor, Mr Deputy

Speaker, I am clear that one of the

0:01:530:01:57

biggest boosts we can provide to

businesses and families, one of the

0:01:570:02:01

best ways to protect British jobs

and prosperity, as we build that new

0:02:010:02:06

future, is to make early progress in

delivering my right honourable

0:02:060:02:11

friend's vision. With an

implementation agreement that allows

0:02:110:02:14

businesses to plan and invest with

confidence. And this government will

0:02:140:02:19

make the pursuit of that progress is

a top priority in the weeks ahead.

0:02:190:02:25

But Mr Deputy Speaker, while we work

to achieve this deep and special

0:02:250:02:30

partnership, we are determined to

ensure that the country is prepared

0:02:300:02:34

for every possible outcome. We have

already invested almost £700 million

0:02:340:02:42

in Brexit preparations, and today, I

am setting aside over the next two

0:02:420:02:49

years, another £3 billion, and I

stand ready to allocate further sums

0:02:490:02:52

if and when needed. Mr Deputy

Speaker, no one should doubt our

0:02:520:02:58

resolve. But this Budget is about

much more than Brexit. The world is

0:02:580:03:05

on the brink of a technological

revolution, one that will change the

0:03:050:03:08

way that we work and live, and

transform our living standards for

0:03:080:03:14

generations to come. And we face a

choice. Either we embrace the

0:03:140:03:19

future, seize the opportunities that

lie within our grasp, and build on

0:03:190:03:25

Britain's great global success

story, or as the party opposite

0:03:250:03:29

advocates, rejects change and turn

inwards to the failed and irrelevant

0:03:290:03:34

dogmas of the past. Mr Deputy

Speaker, we have no doubt we choose

0:03:340:03:42

the future. We choose, we choose to

run towards change, not away from

0:03:420:03:52

it. To prepare our people to meet

the challenges ahead, not to hide

0:03:520:03:59

from them. And the prize will be

enormous. For the first time in

0:03:590:04:05

decades, Britain is genuinely at the

forefront of this technological

0:04:050:04:08

revolution. Not just in our

universities and research

0:04:080:04:14

institutes, but this time in the

commercial development labs of our

0:04:140:04:18

great companies and on factory

floors and business parks across

0:04:180:04:21

this land. But we must invest to

secure this bright future for

0:04:210:04:27

Britain, and that this Budget, that

is what we choose to do. But Mr

0:04:270:04:32

Deputy Speaker, we are listening,

and we understand the frustration of

0:04:320:04:37

families where real incomes or under

pressure. So at this Budget we

0:04:370:04:42

choose a balanced approach. Yes,

maintaining fiscal responsibility as

0:04:420:04:47

we last see our debt Peking.

Continuing to invest in the skills

0:04:470:04:54

and infrastructure that will support

the jobs of the future. Building the

0:04:540:04:58

homes that will make good on our

promise to the next generation. But

0:04:580:05:04

crucially, also helping families to

cope with the cost of living. Mr

0:05:040:05:10

Deputy Speaker, as we invest in our

country's future, I have a clear

0:05:100:05:14

vision of what that global Britain

looks like. A prosperous and

0:05:140:05:18

inclusive economy. Where everybody

has the opportunity to shine.

0:05:180:05:23

Wherever in these islands they live,

and whatever their background. Where

0:05:230:05:29

talent and hard work are rewarded.

Where the dream of home ownership is

0:05:290:05:34

a reality for all generations. A hub

of enterprise and innovation. A

0:05:340:05:42

beacon of creativity. A civilised

and tolerant place that cares for

0:05:420:05:47

the vulnerable and nurtures the

talented. And outward looking free

0:05:470:05:51

trading nation, a full good in the

world. That is the Britain that I

0:05:510:06:00

want to leave to my children, Mr

Deputy Speaker. A Britain we can be

0:06:000:06:05

proud of. A country fit for the

future. I know we will not build it

0:06:050:06:10

overnight, but in this Budget today

we will lay the foundations. I'm

0:06:100:06:19

being tempted with something a

little more exotic here, but I will

0:06:190:06:22

stick to plain water. I did take the

precaution... I did take the

0:06:220:06:37

precaution of asking my right

honourable friend to bring a packet

0:06:370:06:39

of cough sweets just in case.

LAUGHTER

0:06:390:06:52

Mr Deputy Speaker, Mr Deputy

Speaker...

Order, order. I think it

0:06:520:07:07

might be a hearing aid we all need

if this continues.

Mr Deputy

0:07:070:07:15

Speaker, I shall first report to the

House on the economic forecast of

0:07:150:07:21

the independent OBR. This is the bit

with the long economic words in it.

0:07:210:07:24

LAUGHTER

Once again, I thank Robert Chote and

0:07:240:07:35

his team for their hard work over

the last few weeks. I believe

0:07:350:07:39

passionately that the best way to

improve the lives of people across

0:07:390:07:43

the length and breadth of this

country is to help them get into

0:07:430:07:47

work. Mr Deputy Speaker, I am

acutely aware that 1.4 million

0:07:470:07:52

people out of work is 1.4 million to

many. So today... Today I welcome

0:07:520:08:04

the OBR forecast that there will be

another 600,000 people in work by

0:08:040:08:10

2022. And I am immensely proud of

this government's record in having

0:08:100:08:17

created over 3 million new jobs

since 2010.

0:08:170:08:23

A far cry from the 1.2 million job

losses the right honourable member

0:08:230:08:29

for Hayes and Harlington predicted

in 2011 but in no doubt this

0:08:290:08:35

government will continue its focus

on getting more people into work,

0:08:350:08:38

giving them security and peace of

mind of a regular wage. I want work

0:08:380:08:43

to be a good well-paid and

regrettably our productivity

0:08:430:08:50

performance continues to disappoint.

The OBR assumed at each of the last

0:08:500:08:57

16 fiscal events that productivity

growth would return to its precrisis

0:08:570:09:01

trend of about 2% per year, but it

has remained stubbornly flat. Today

0:09:010:09:07

they revised down the outlook for

productivity growth, business

0:09:070:09:12

investment and GDP growth across the

forecast period. They now expect to

0:09:120:09:18

see GDP grow 1.5% in 2017, one .4 in

2018, one .3 in 2019 and 2020,

0:09:180:09:28

before picking up to 1.5% and

finally 1.6% in 2022. With inflation

0:09:280:09:38

peaking at 3% in this quarter before

falling back to target in the next

0:09:380:09:43

year. I reaffirm the remit that the

Monetary Policy Committee and its

0:09:430:09:51

inflation target. We took over an

economy with the highest budget

0:09:510:09:56

deficit in peacetime history. Since

then, thanks to the hard work of the

0:09:560:10:03

British people, that deficit has

been shrinking. Next year, it will

0:10:030:10:09

be below 2%. Our debt is still too

high and we need to get it down. Not

0:10:090:10:17

for and ideological reason, but

because successive debt undermines

0:10:170:10:22

economic security leaving is

vulnerable to shocks. It passes the

0:10:220:10:27

burden unfairly to the next

generation. And because it simply

0:10:270:10:32

cannot be right to spend more on our

debt interest than on police and

0:10:320:10:37

Armed Forces combined. I am pleased

to tell the House OBR expects debt

0:10:370:10:42

to peak this year and then gradually

fall as a share of GDP. They turning

0:10:420:10:48

point in the recovery. Mr Deputy

Speaker, apparently, not everyone

0:10:480:10:59

shares the view that falling debt is

good news. I heard representations

0:10:590:11:04

from the party opposite suggesting

increasing the debt by £500 billion.

0:11:040:11:10

Taking us back to square one,

wasting an extra £7 billion a year

0:11:100:11:16

on debt interest. If they carry on

like that, there will be plenty of

0:11:160:11:22

others joining Kezia Dugdale saying,

I'm Labour, get me out of here. Mr

0:11:220:11:35

Deputy Speaker, I have rejected

these representations and instead I

0:11:350:11:41

reaffirm our pledge of fiscal

responsibility and our commitment to

0:11:410:11:45

the fiscal rules set out last

autumn. Now I choose to use some of

0:11:450:11:50

the headroom I established then so

that as well as reducing debt, we

0:11:500:11:55

can also invest in Britain's future,

support key public services, keep

0:11:550:12:02

taxes low and provide a little help

to families and businesses under

0:12:020:12:06

pressure. A balanced approach that

will prepare Britain for the future,

0:12:060:12:11

not seek to hide from it. Today the

OBR confirmed we are on track to

0:12:110:12:18

meet our fiscal rules, borrowing is

forecast to be 49.9 billion this

0:12:180:12:23

year, 8.4 billion lower than

forecast at the spring budget. After

0:12:230:12:30

taking account of all decisions

since the spring budget, the GDP

0:12:300:12:34

revision and measures I will

announce borrowing will fall in

0:12:340:12:40

every year of the forecast from 39.5

billion next year, to 25.6 point

0:12:400:12:48

6,000,000,020 2-23 to reach its

lowest level in 20 years. As a

0:12:480:12:53

percentage of GDP falls from 2.4% to

1.9% next year, then 1.6, 1.5, 1.3

0:12:530:13:01

and finally 1.1% in 22-3. The OBR

forecast the structural deficit to

0:13:010:13:10

be 1.3% of GDP in 2021, giving 14.8

billion of headroom against our 2%

0:13:100:13:18

target. Debt will peak at 86.5% of

GDP this year and then fall to 86.4,

0:13:180:13:30

then 86.1, 83.1, 79.3 and 79.1 in 22

- 23, the first sustained decline in

0:13:300:13:39

debt in 17 years. Under Conservative

led governments, the hard work of

0:13:390:13:49

the British people is steadily

clearing up the mess left behind by

0:13:490:13:53

Labour. At the heart of global

Britain must be a dynamic and

0:13:530:14:05

innovative economy. On Monday, the

Prime Minister set out key elements

0:14:050:14:10

of our modern industrial strategy,

which will raise productivity and

0:14:100:14:14

wages in all parts of the country

and guarantee a brighter future we

0:14:140:14:18

have promised to the next

generation. The Business Secretary

0:14:180:14:22

will present a White Paper in the

next few days. This is not just an

0:14:220:14:28

economic plan. It is a key part of

our vision for a fairer Britain, a

0:14:280:14:34

Britain where every one of our

citizens can contribute to and share

0:14:340:14:39

in the benefits of prosperity. And

the key to raising the wages of

0:14:390:14:43

British workers is raising

investment, public and we are

0:14:430:14:49

investing in Britain's future, half

£1 trillion since 2010, the biggest

0:14:490:14:55

rail programme since Victorian

times, the largest road-building

0:14:550:14:59

programme since the 1970s, the

biggest increase in science and

0:14:590:15:04

innovation funding in four decades

and the two largest infrastructure

0:15:040:15:09

projects in Europe, Crossrail and

HS2. When I took this job I

0:15:090:15:14

committed to make the battle to

raise Britain's productivity and the

0:15:140:15:18

nation's pay the central mission of

the Treasury. Last autumn, I

0:15:180:15:25

launched the national productivity

investment funds to provide an

0:15:250:15:31

additional £23 billion of investment

over five years, to upgrade the

0:15:310:15:34

economic infrastructure for the 21st

century. Today I announce I will

0:15:340:15:38

extend the fund a further year and

expand it to over £31 billion.

0:15:380:15:47

Meaning that public investment under

this government will on average be

0:15:470:15:53

£25 billion per year higher in real

terms than under the last Labour

0:15:530:15:57

government. We are allocating a

further £2.3 billion for investment

0:15:570:16:05

in R&B and will increase the main

RND tax credit to 12% -- R&D. To

0:16:050:16:16

drive up investment across the

economy to 2.4% of GDP. Britain is

0:16:160:16:24

the world's sixth-largest economy.

London is the number one

0:16:240:16:28

international financial services

sector and we have some of the

0:16:280:16:32

world's Best companies and a

commanding position in a raft of

0:16:320:16:35

tech and digital industries that

will form the backbone of the global

0:16:350:16:40

economy. Those who under estimate

Britain do so at their peril.

0:16:400:16:46

Because we will harness this

potential and turn it into the

0:16:460:16:51

high-paid, high productivity jobs of

tomorrow. Others may choose to

0:16:510:16:55

reject the future, we choose to

embrace it. A new tech business is

0:16:550:17:01

founded in Britain every hour. I

want that to be every half-hour.

0:17:010:17:10

Today, we invest over £500 million

in a range of initiatives from

0:17:100:17:13

artificial intelligence to five G

and four fibre broadband and support

0:17:130:17:18

regulation with the new Pioneer fund

and a new geospatial data commission

0:17:180:17:21

to develop... You should listen. To

develop a strategy for using the

0:17:210:17:30

government location data to support

economic growth and to help tech

0:17:300:17:35

start-ups reach scale we asked for a

review of availability of capital.

0:17:350:17:41

Today we are publishing an action

plan to unlock over £20 billion of

0:17:410:17:46

new investment in UK knowledge

intensive scale up businesses

0:17:460:17:50

including through a new fund in the

British business bank seeded with

0:17:500:17:55

£2.5 billion of public money by

facilitating pension-fund access to

0:17:550:18:01

long-term investment sum by doubling

investments limits for knowledge

0:18:010:18:08

intensive companies while ensuring

EI S is not used as a shelter for

0:18:080:18:12

low risk capital preservation

schemes. We stand ready to step in

0:18:120:18:17

to replace European investment fund

lending is necessary. There is

0:18:170:18:23

perhaps no technology as symbolic of

the Revolution gathering pace as

0:18:230:18:28

driverless vehicles.

0:18:280:18:31

They surely do not want me to make

the joke about the Labour Party

0:18:400:18:45

again, Mr Deputy Speaker? I know

Jeremy Clarkson does not like them

0:18:450:18:49

but there are many other good

reasons to pursue this technology.

0:18:490:18:54

Today, we step up support for it.

I'm sorry, Jeremy, definitely not

0:18:540:19:00

the first time you have been snubbed

by Hammond and May. Allah future

0:19:000:19:09

-- our future vehicles will be

driverless but there they will be

0:19:140:19:21

electric first and that is a change

that needs to come as soon as

0:19:210:19:25

possible for the planet. We will

establish a £400 million structure

0:19:250:19:30

fund and invest an extra hundred

million per plug-in car Grant and

0:19:300:19:34

more for R&D. I will clarify the law

so that people who charge electric

0:19:340:19:41

vehicles at work will not face a

benefit in kind charge from next

0:19:410:19:45

year. The tax system can play an

important role in protecting our

0:19:450:19:51

environment. We owe it to our

children the air they breathe is

0:19:510:19:55

clean and we published the air

quality plan this year and said then

0:19:550:19:59

we would fund it through taxes on

new diesel cars. From April 2018,

0:19:590:20:06

the first year rate for diesel cars

that do not meet the latest

0:20:060:20:09

standards will go up by £1 and the

existing supplement in company car

0:20:090:20:16

tax will increase by one percentage

point and drivers buying a new car

0:20:160:20:20

will avoid this charge as soon as

manufacturers bring forward the next

0:20:200:20:26

generation of cleaner diesels. We

only apply this measure to cars.

0:20:260:20:30

Before the headline writers start to

limber up, let me be clear. No white

0:20:300:20:37

van man or woman will be hit by

these measures. This levy will fund

0:20:370:20:50

a new £220 million cleaner fund to

provide support for the

0:20:500:20:54

implementation of local air quality

plans, improving the quality of air

0:20:540:20:59

in cities and towns in the UK. Our

air quality is sadly not our only

0:20:590:21:06

environmental challenge. Audiences

in the country glued to Blue Planet

0:21:060:21:13

have been reminded of the problems

of plastics pollution. The UK lead

0:21:130:21:17

the world on climate change

agreements and pioneers protecting

0:21:170:21:21

marine environment and I want us to

be a world leader in tackling the

0:21:210:21:26

scourge of plastic littering the

planet and oceans. With my right

0:21:260:21:30

honourable friend the Environment

Secretary I will investigate how the

0:21:300:21:34

tax system and charges on single use

plastic items can reduce waste. We

0:21:340:21:41

cannot keep our promise to the next

generation to build an economy fit

0:21:410:21:45

for the future unless we ensure our

planet has a future. Meeting the

0:21:450:21:53

challenge of change head on means

giving our people the confidence to

0:21:530:21:58

embrace it and the skills to reap

the rewards and we have a plan to do

0:21:580:22:02

so. We are delivering 3 million

apprenticeships by 2020 thanks to

0:22:020:22:08

the apprenticeship levy and I will

review the flexibility levy payers

0:22:080:22:13

have to spend this. We are

introducing T levels and I am

0:22:130:22:18

providing £20 million to support

colleges to prepare for them.

0:22:180:22:24

Knowledge of maths is key to the

high-tech, cutting edge jobs in our

0:22:240:22:29

digital economy. It is useful in

less glamorous roles like front line

0:22:290:22:33

politics! We will expand the

teaching for mastery of maths

0:22:330:22:41

programme to further 3000 schools

and provide 40 million to train

0:22:410:22:47

maths teachers and introduce a £600

maths premium for schools for every

0:22:470:22:52

additional people who takes a level

maths and invite proposals for new

0:22:520:23:01

maths schools across England so

highly talented young mathematicians

0:23:010:23:05

can release their potential wherever

they live and what ever their

0:23:050:23:07

background.

0:23:070:23:14

More maths for everyone. Don't let

anyone say I don't know how to show

0:23:140:23:18

the nation a good time!

Computer science is also at the

0:23:180:23:28

heart of this revolution. So we will

ensure every secondary school pupil

0:23:280:23:35

can study computing by tripling the

number of trained computer science

0:23:350:23:40

teachers to 12,000. And we will work

with industry to create a new

0:23:400:23:46

national centre for computing. But

Mr Deputy Speaker, rapid

0:23:460:23:49

technological change means we also

need to help people we train during

0:23:490:23:54

their working lives, ensuring our

0:23:540:23:59

workforce is equipped with the

skills they need for the workplace

0:23:590:24:00

of the future. Today, my right

honourable friend the Education

0:24:000:24:04

Secretary and I are launching an

historic partnership between

0:24:040:24:08

government, the CBI and the TUC to

set the strategic direction for a

0:24:080:24:13

national retraining scheme. Its

first priority will be to boost

0:24:130:24:18

digital skills and support expansion

of the construction centre. To make

0:24:180:24:21

a start immediately, we will invest

£30 million in the development of

0:24:210:24:26

digital skills distance learning

courses, so people can learn

0:24:260:24:29

wherever they are and whenever they

want. I'm pleased to be able to

0:24:290:24:34

accept the representation that I

have

0:24:340:24:45

received from the TUC, to continue

to fund union learn which I

0:24:470:24:50

recognise as a valuable part of our

support to workplace learning. Mr

0:24:500:24:56

Deputy Speaker, I got an e-mail from

Len asking me especially, backing

0:24:560:25:07

skills is key to unlocking growth

nationally, but far too much of our

0:25:070:25:11

economic strength is concentrated in

our capital city. If we are truly to

0:25:110:25:15

build an economy that is fit for the

future, then we have to get all

0:25:150:25:19

parts of the UK firing on all

cylinders, and that is what our

0:25:190:25:24

modern industrial strategy is all

about. Today, we back the Northern

0:25:240:25:30

Powerhouse, the Midlands engine and

elected mayors across the UK. We

0:25:300:25:33

back them with a new 1.7 £1.7

billion transforming cities fund,

0:25:330:25:40

half of it to be shared with the six

areas with Metro mayors, to give

0:25:400:25:45

them power to deal with transport

priorities, and the remainder will

0:25:450:25:49

be opened to competition in other

cities in England. We are investing

0:25:490:25:56

£300 million to assure HS2

infrastructure will incorporate

0:25:560:25:59

Northern Powerhouse and Midland

engine improvements. I am also

0:25:590:26:05

providing money to trial digital

solutions on the trans-Pennine

0:26:050:26:11

route. We are developing a punch

with Manchester and I'm pleased to

0:26:110:26:22

announce a second devolution deal

with Andy Street and we will find

0:26:220:26:27

the replacement of the 40 old

rolling stock on the Tyne at where

0:26:270:26:32

Metro and a total investment of 337

million pounds. We will invest £123

0:26:320:26:38

million in the Redcar steel

steelwork sites to support the work

0:26:380:26:51

of those leading the fight for

prosperity in that area. Mr Deputy

0:26:510:26:59

Speaker, we are piloting 100%

business rates retention in London

0:26:590:27:03

next year, and continuing to work

with TFL on the funding and

0:27:030:27:09

financing of Crossrail two. We will

also make over £1 billion of

0:27:090:27:14

discounted lending available to

local authorities across the country

0:27:140:27:18

to support high-value infrastructure

projects. A Conservative government

0:27:180:27:21

giving power back to the people of

Britain, and driving prosperity and

0:27:210:27:29

greater fairness across our United

Kingdom.

0:27:290:27:32

The decisions taken in this Budget

also mean £2 billion more for the

0:27:320:27:38

Scottish Government, £1.2 billion

more for the Welsh Government, and

0:27:380:27:46

156 mg more for the Northern Ireland

Executive. I can confirm today

0:27:460:27:51

progress is being made on the city

's deal for Terry and Stirling. I'm

0:27:510:27:57

getting used to the experience of

having my ear bent by 13

0:27:570:28:03

Conservatives Scottish colleagues.

Most recently on the issue of

0:28:030:28:11

Scottish police and fire VAT. The

SNP knew the rules, they knew the

0:28:110:28:19

consequences of introducing these

bodies and they ploughed ahead

0:28:190:28:21

anyway. My Scottish Conservative

colleagues have persuaded me that

0:28:210:28:32

the Scottish people should not lose

out just because of the obstinacy of

0:28:320:28:36

the SNP government. So we will

legislate to allow VAT refunds from

0:28:360:28:48

April 20 18. And in response to yet

more representations from my

0:28:480:28:53

honourable Scottish friends, aided

and abetted by my honourable friend

0:28:530:28:57

for Waverley, from November 2018, we

will introduce agile is there a tax

0:28:570:29:02

history for transfers of gas in the

North Sea, an innovative tax policy

0:29:020:29:08

which will bring fresh investment to

a base on which still holds up to 20

0:29:080:29:12

billion barrels of oil. We will

begin negotiations towards great

0:29:120:29:19

deals the North Wales and mid Wales,

and we will abolish tolls on the

0:29:190:29:24

Severn Bridge as promised by the end

of next year. We will deliver on our

0:29:240:29:29

commitment to review the effect of

VAT and APD on tourism in Northern

0:29:290:29:34

Ireland, reporting on next year's

Budget and we will open negotiations

0:29:340:29:39

for a Belfast city deal as part of

our commitment to an ambitious set

0:29:390:29:43

of city deals across Northern

Ireland. A Conservative government

0:29:430:29:48

delivering for all parts of our

United Kingdom. It is only by

0:29:480:29:57

supporting our regions and nations,

dealing with our debts and investing

0:29:570:30:01

in skills and infrastructure for the

long term, that we can build an

0:30:010:30:05

economy fit for the future. But I

recognise that many people are

0:30:050:30:09

feeling pressure on their budgets

now. And because we are all in

0:30:090:30:13

politics to make people's lives

better, in the short term as well as

0:30:130:30:19

the long-term, we will take further

measures in this Budget to help

0:30:190:30:23

families and businesses where we

can. The switch to Universal Credit

0:30:230:30:29

is a long overdue and necessary

reform. Replacing Labour's broken

0:30:290:30:35

system that discouraged people from

working more than 16 hours a week

0:30:350:30:40

and trapped 1.4 million on out of

work benefits for nearly a decade,

0:30:400:30:45

Universal Credit delivers a modern

welfare system where work always

0:30:450:30:49

pays and people are supported to

earn. But I recognise, Mr Deputy

0:30:490:30:58

Speaker, the genuine concerns on

both sides of the House at about the

0:30:580:31:01

operational delivery of this

benefit, and today we will act on

0:31:010:31:03

those concerns. First, we will

remove the seven-day waiting period

0:31:030:31:09

applied at the beginning of a

benefit claim, so that entitlement

0:31:090:31:13

to Universal Credit will start on

the day of the claim. To provide

0:31:130:31:18

greater support during the waiting

period, we will change the advance

0:31:180:31:21

the system to ensure any household

needs it can access a full month's

0:31:210:31:26

payment within five days of

applying. We will make it possible

0:31:260:31:31

to apply for an advanced online. We

will extend the repayment period for

0:31:310:31:37

advances from six months to 12

months, and any new Universal Credit

0:31:370:31:42

claimant in receipt of housing

benefit at the time of the claim

0:31:420:31:46

will continue to receive that

housing benefit for a further two

0:31:460:31:51

weeks, making it easier for them to

pay their rent. This, Mr Deputy

0:31:510:31:57

Speaker, is a £1.5 billion package

to address concerns about the

0:31:570:32:01

delivery of the benefit. My right

honourable friend the Secretary of

0:32:010:32:09

State for Work and Pensions will

give further details in a statement

0:32:090:32:11

to the House tomorrow. We also want

to help low income households in

0:32:110:32:16

areas where rents have been rising

fastest. In the long run, of course,

0:32:160:32:21

the answer lies in increasing the

amount of housing available, a theme

0:32:210:32:26

I shall return to. In the meantime,

the best way to help them is by

0:32:260:32:30

increasing the rate of support in

those areas where rents are least

0:32:300:32:35

affordable. We will increase

targeted affordability funding by

0:32:350:32:40

£125 million over the next two

years, benefiting 140,000 people. We

0:32:400:32:45

will always listen to genuine

concerns and act where we can to

0:32:450:32:51

help. Making work pay is core to the

philosophy of this government. That

0:32:510:32:57

is why we introduced the National

Living Wage in 2016. In April, it

0:32:570:33:03

will rise by 4.4%, from £7 50 an

hour, to £7 83, handing full-time

0:33:030:33:13

workers a further £600 pay increase,

taking their total pay rise since

0:33:130:33:18

its introduction to over £2000 a

year. We also accept the low pay

0:33:180:33:25

commission's recommendations on

national minimum wage rates,

0:33:250:33:29

supporting our young people with the

largest increase in youth rates in

0:33:290:33:33

ten years, delivering a pay rise for

over 2 million minimum wage workers

0:33:330:33:42

of all ages across the country. The

facts are these. Income inequality

0:33:420:33:45

today is at its lowest level in 30

years. The top 1% are paying a

0:33:450:33:51

larger share of income taxes than at

any time under the last Labour

0:33:510:33:55

government. The poorest 10% in

Britain have seen their real incomes

0:33:550:34:01

grow faster than 2010 than the

richest 10%, and the proportion of

0:34:010:34:06

full-time jobs that are low paid is

at its lowest level for 20 years. A

0:34:060:34:14

Conservative government delivering a

fairer Britain. But as well as

0:34:140:34:21

making work pay, we want families to

keep more of the money they earn.

0:34:210:34:25

When we came into office, the

personal allowance stood at £6,475 a

0:34:250:34:31

year. From April, I will increase

the personal allowance to £11,850,

0:34:310:34:38

and the higher rate threshold to

£46,350, making progress towards our

0:34:380:34:46

manifesto commitments, which I

reiterate today. The typical basic

0:34:460:34:51

rate taxpayer will be £1075 a year

better off than 2010, and a

0:34:510:34:56

full-time worker on the National

Living Wage will take home more than

0:34:560:35:01

£3800 extra. This Conservative

government delivering for Britain's

0:35:010:35:06

workers. Mr Deputy Speaker, I turn

now to duties. The tobacco duty

0:35:060:35:16

escalator will continue with an

extra 1% duty on hand-rolling duty

0:35:160:35:23

this year and minimum excise duty on

cigarettes will also rise. Excessive

0:35:230:35:27

alcohol consumption and the most

vulnerable people is all too often

0:35:270:35:32

through cheap high-strength low

quality products, especially

0:35:320:35:36

so-called white ciders. I want to

pay tribute to the campaign led by

0:35:360:35:40

my honourable friend for Congleton

on this issue, and so following our

0:35:400:35:45

recent consultation, we will

legislate to increase duty on these

0:35:450:35:50

products from 2019. But recognising

the pressure on household budgets,

0:35:500:35:53

and backing our great British pubs,

duties on other sliders, wines,

0:35:530:35:58

spirits and on beer will be frozen.

This will mean a bottle of whiskey

0:35:580:36:09

will be £1.15 less in 2018 than if

we had continued with Labour's

0:36:090:36:14

plans, and a pint of beer 12p less.

So Merry Christmas, Mr Deputy

0:36:140:36:20

Speaker. The cost of travel is also

an important factor for families and

0:36:200:36:27

businesses. From April 2019, I will

again freeze short-haul air

0:36:270:36:31

passenger duty rates, and I will

also frees long-haul economy rates,

0:36:310:36:36

paid for by an increase on premium

class tickets and on private jets.

0:36:360:36:41

Sorry, Lewis. For those who do not

stretch to a private jet, I can

0:36:410:36:48

announce a new Railcard for those

aged 26 to 30, giving 4.5 million

0:36:480:36:53

more young people a third of their

rail fares. And I will once again

0:36:530:37:01

cancel the fuel duty rise for both

petrol and diesel that is scheduled

0:37:010:37:06

for April. Since 2010, we will have

saved the average car driver £850,

0:37:060:37:15

and the average van driver over

£2100, compared to Labour's

0:37:150:37:21

escalator plans. Fuel duty has now

been frozen for the longest period

0:37:210:37:26

in 40 years, at a total cost to the

Exchequer of £46 billion, is since

0:37:260:37:34

2010. Mr Deputy Speaker, our NHS is

one of our great institutions. An

0:37:340:37:39

essential part of what we are as a

nation. And a source of pride the

0:37:390:37:45

length and breadth of the country.

Its values are the values of the

0:37:450:37:49

British people, and we will always

back it. Dedicated NHS staff are

0:37:490:37:55

handling the challenges of an ageing

population and the rapidly advancing

0:37:550:38:00

technology with skill and commitment

and we salute them. Mr Deputy

0:38:000:38:04

Speaker, although you would not

think so to listen to the Leader of

0:38:040:38:08

the Opposition, as he regularly

talks down the achievements of the

0:38:080:38:15

NHS, the number of patients being

treated is at record levels, cancer

0:38:150:38:19

survival rates are at the highest

ever level, 17 million people are

0:38:190:38:24

now able to access GP appointments

in the evenings and weekends, and

0:38:240:38:28

public satisfaction among hospital

inpatients is at its highest level

0:38:280:38:33

in more than 20 years.

0:38:330:38:38

It is central to this government's

vision everyone has access to the

0:38:380:38:43

NHS free at the point of need which

is why we endorsed and funded the

0:38:430:38:50

five-year forward view in 2014 but

even with this additional funding we

0:38:500:38:53

acknowledge the service remains

under pressure and today we respond.

0:38:530:38:57

First, we will deliver an additional

£10 billion package of capital

0:38:570:39:03

investment in front line services

over the course of this Parliament,

0:39:030:39:08

to support the sustainability and

transformation plans that will make

0:39:080:39:13

our NHS more resilient, investing

for an NHS fit for the future. We

0:39:130:39:18

also recognise that the NHS is under

pressure right now. I am therefore

0:39:180:39:25

exceptionally and outside the

spending review process making an

0:39:250:39:28

additional commitment of resource

funding of £2.8 billion to the NHS

0:39:280:39:33

in England. £350 million immediately

to allow trusts to plan for this

0:39:330:39:41

winter. 1.6 billion in 2018-19 but

the balance in 19-20, taking the

0:39:410:39:49

extra resource into the NHS next

year to £3.75 billion in total.

0:39:490:39:59

Meaning, Mr Deputy Speaker, our NHS

will receive a £7.5 billion increase

0:39:590:40:08

to its resource budget over this

year and next. Our nation's nurses

0:40:080:40:15

provide invaluable support to us all

in our time of greatest need and

0:40:150:40:21

deserve our deepest gratitude for

their tireless efforts. My right

0:40:210:40:25

honourable friend the Health

Secretary has begun discussions with

0:40:250:40:29

health unions on pay structure

modernisation for staff to improve

0:40:290:40:36

recruitment and retention. He will

submit evidence to the independent

0:40:360:40:40

pay review body in due course. I

want to assure NHS staff and

0:40:400:40:45

patients and members that if the

Health Secretary's talks bear fruit,

0:40:450:40:50

I will protect patient services by

providing additional funding for

0:40:500:40:53

such a settlement. Just as our

public services must be fit for the

0:40:530:41:03

future, so too must our tax system.

It must remain competitive to

0:41:030:41:08

attract the brightest and best to

establish and grow businesses of the

0:41:080:41:12

future. It must raise revenue we

need to fund public services and it

0:41:120:41:17

must be robust against abuse so it

is fair to all. We have heard talk

0:41:170:41:22

recently from the party opposite

about what they would do to crack

0:41:220:41:25

down on tax avoidance and evasion,

but the truth is, they did not. It

0:41:250:41:33

is this government that has clamped

down on avoidance and evasion, this

0:41:330:41:37

government has seen the tax gap cut

by a quarter to a record low and

0:41:370:41:42

this government that has raked in an

extra £160 billion over seven years

0:41:420:41:49

for our public services by

collecting taxes due so I will take

0:41:490:41:52

no lectures, but I will take action

and this budget continues the work

0:41:520:42:01

of the last seven years with a

further package of measures that is

0:42:010:42:06

forecast to raise £4.8 billion by

2022-3, doing the job Labour failed

0:42:060:42:13

to do for 13 years in office. Our

long-term phased reduction of

0:42:130:42:22

corporation tax has generated

investment and jobs and raised £20

0:42:220:42:26

billion extra for public services.

We are committed to maintaining

0:42:260:42:32

competitive corporation tax rates

that there is a case for removing

0:42:320:42:35

the anomaly of the index allowance

for capital gains bringing the

0:42:350:42:40

corporate tax system into line with

personal capital gains tax system. I

0:42:400:42:45

will freeze this allowance so

companies receive relief for

0:42:450:42:49

inflation up to January 2018 but not

thereafter. I am grateful to the

0:42:490:42:55

office for tax simplification on

their report on VAT registration

0:42:550:43:00

threshold. At £85,000 the UK VAT

threshold is by far the highest in

0:43:000:43:07

the OECD, by contrast in Germany it

is £15,600. I note the conclusion

0:43:070:43:15

that it distorts competition and

dis- incentivise is business growth

0:43:150:43:21

and note the Federation of Small

Businesses concerns about the cliff

0:43:210:43:25

edge of the threshold but such a

high threshold has the benefit of

0:43:250:43:30

keeping the majority of small

businesses out of VAT altogether so

0:43:300:43:35

I am not minded to reduce the

threshold. I will consult on whether

0:43:350:43:44

it -- its design could better

incentivise growth and we will

0:43:440:43:48

maintain it at the current level for

the next two years. We cannot build

0:43:480:43:53

an economy fit for the future

without supporting its backbone, our

0:43:530:44:01

5.5 million small businesses, who

are responsible for nearly half our

0:44:010:44:05

private sector jobs. They give the

economy its vibrancy and resilience.

0:44:050:44:11

I recognise many are feeling under

pressure. I know that it is hard

0:44:110:44:17

work to get a business off the

ground and get it to grow, so today

0:44:170:44:21

I want to do what we can to ease

that pressure. Business rates

0:44:210:44:27

represent a high fixed cost for

small businesses. At budget 2016 we

0:44:270:44:33

introduced a package of business

rate relief worth almost £9 billion

0:44:330:44:39

with a further £435 million in the

spring budget. Today I go further.

0:44:390:44:45

We have listened to concerns about

the potential costs of the annual up

0:44:450:44:49

rating of business rates in April.

Today I will accept the

0:44:490:44:55

representation of the British

Chambers of Commerce, CBI and others

0:44:550:44:59

and bring forward the planned switch

from RPI to CPI by two years to

0:44:590:45:06

April 2018, a move that is worth

£2.3 billion to business over the

0:45:060:45:11

next five years. I have listened to

businesses affected by the so-called

0:45:110:45:17

staircase tax. We will change the

law to ensure where a businesses

0:45:170:45:23

impacted by the ruling, it can have

its original bill reinstated if it

0:45:230:45:27

chooses and backdated and I hope I

can expect cross-party backing to

0:45:270:45:33

speed that measure through

Parliament. Three simple steps to

0:45:330:45:39

solve the staircase tax. What do

they expect, it is the tax section?

0:45:390:45:46

To support the thousands of small

pubs at the heart of many

0:45:460:45:51

communities, we will extend the

£1000 discount with the rateable

0:45:510:45:55

value of less than the amount to

March 20 19. I have heard the

0:45:550:46:05

concerns about the five-year

reevaluation system and shorter

0:46:050:46:08

periods will reduce the size of

changes in valuation that I can

0:46:080:46:12

announce after the next revaluation

future revaluation will take place

0:46:120:46:17

every three years. This Conservative

government is listening to small

0:46:170:46:20

business. There is a wider concern

across this House and in the

0:46:200:46:27

business community about the tax

system in the digital age. Along

0:46:270:46:31

with innovation and growth it

brings, digitalisation poses

0:46:310:46:36

challenges for the sustainability

and fairness of our tax system but

0:46:360:46:40

this challenge can only properly be

solved on an international basis and

0:46:400:46:45

the UK is leading the charge in the

OECD and G20 to find solutions.

0:46:450:46:51

Today we publish a paper on the tax

challenge posed by the digital

0:46:510:46:56

economy, setting out emerging

thinking about potential solutions,

0:46:560:47:00

but in the meantime we will take

what action we can. Multinational

0:47:000:47:07

digital businesses pay billions in

royalties to jurisdictions where

0:47:070:47:10

they are not taxed and some of these

royalties relate to UK sales. From

0:47:100:47:17

April 2019 and in accordance with

international obligations we will

0:47:170:47:21

apply income tax to royalties

relating to UK sales when those

0:47:210:47:26

royalties are paid to a low tax

jurisdiction, even if they do not

0:47:260:47:31

fall to be taxed in the UK under

current rules. This will raise about

0:47:310:47:38

£200 million a year. It does not

solve the problem, but it sends a

0:47:380:47:44

signal of our determination and we

will continue to work in the

0:47:440:47:48

international arena to find a

sustainable and fair long-term

0:47:480:47:52

solution that properly taxes digital

businesses that operate in

0:47:520:47:55

cyberspace. Following

representations from a number of

0:47:550:48:00

honourable friends we are taking

action to address online VAT fraud

0:48:000:48:05

that costs the taxpayer £1.2 billion

per year, by making all online

0:48:050:48:11

marketplaces jointly liable with

their sellers for VAT, ensuring

0:48:110:48:17

sellers operating through them pay

the right VAT just we expect

0:48:170:48:22

retailers on the high street to do.

I want to turn to the challenge of

0:48:220:48:28

the housing market. Before I do, I

want to touch on the aftermath of

0:48:280:48:33

the appalling events at Grenfell

Tower. We have provided financial

0:48:330:48:38

support for victims of this terrible

tragedy and today I announce we will

0:48:380:48:43

provide Kensington and Chelsea

Council with a further £28 million

0:48:430:48:49

for mental health and counselling

services, the generation support and

0:48:490:48:53

to provide a new community space for

residents. This tragedy should never

0:48:530:48:59

have happened and we must ensure

nothing like it ever happens again.

0:48:590:49:06

All local authorities and housing

associations must carry out any

0:49:060:49:11

identified necessary safety work as

soon as possible. If any local

0:49:110:49:16

authority cannot access funding to

pay for essential fire safety work,

0:49:160:49:20

they should contact us immediately,

and I have said before and will

0:49:200:49:25

again today, we will not allow

financial constraints to get in the

0:49:250:49:30

way of essential fire safety work. I

want to also address the issue of

0:49:300:49:37

empty properties. It cannot be right

to leave property empty when so many

0:49:370:49:43

are desperate for a place to live.

We will legislate to give local

0:49:430:49:48

authorities the power to charge a

100% council tax premium on empty

0:49:480:49:53

properties. We will also launch a

consultation on barriers to longer

0:49:530:49:59

tenancies in the private rented

sector and how we might encourage

0:49:590:50:02

landlords to offer them to tenants

who want extra security. I want to

0:50:020:50:07

say something about rough sleeping.

It is not acceptable in 21st-century

0:50:070:50:13

Britain people are sleeping on the

streets. We will invest today £28

0:50:130:50:19

million in three new housing first

pilots in the West Midlands,

0:50:190:50:24

Manchester and in Liverpool, and we

will establish a task force as part

0:50:240:50:29

of our commitment to halving rough

sleeping by 2022 and eliminating it

0:50:290:50:33

by 2027. I would like to thank the

many colleagues who submitted ideas

0:50:330:50:41

on how to tackle the challenge of

the housing market, including my

0:50:410:50:46

honourable friends for North East

Hampshire, Eastleigh and

0:50:460:50:49

Weston-Super-Mare in particular. By

continuing to invest in Britain's

0:50:490:50:55

infrastructure, skills and R&D, we

will ensure productivity and

0:50:550:51:00

economic growth that is the key to

delivering a stronger, fairer and

0:51:000:51:05

more balanced economy and the

assurance to the next generation of

0:51:050:51:10

their economic security, but however

successful in that endeavour, there

0:51:100:51:13

is an area where young people will

rightly feel concerned about their

0:51:130:51:18

future prospects and that is in the

housing market. House prices are

0:51:180:51:23

increasingly out of reach. It takes

too long to save for a deposit and

0:51:230:51:28

rents absorbed too high a portion of

monthly income. The number of 25-34

0:51:280:51:35

year old is owning their own home

has dropped from 59% to 38% in 13

0:51:350:51:41

years. Put simply, successive

governments over decades have failed

0:51:410:51:47

to build enough homes to deliver the

homeowning dream this country has

0:51:470:51:52

always been proud of, or indeed to

meet the needs of those who rent. In

0:51:520:51:58

Manchester a few weeks ago the Prime

Minister made a pledge to the

0:51:580:52:02

younger generation that she would

dedicate her premiership to fixing

0:52:020:52:06

this problem and today we take the

next steps to delivering on that

0:52:060:52:10

pledge. By choosing to build we send

a message to the next generation

0:52:100:52:16

that getting on the housing ladder

is not just a dream of your parents

0:52:160:52:23

passed, but a reality for your

future. We have started with schemes

0:52:230:52:27

like help to buy that has helped

320,000 people buy a home. We have

0:52:270:52:31

increased the supply of homes. By

more than 1.1 billion since 2010.

0:52:310:52:42

Including almost 350,000 affordable

homes -- by more than 1.1 million.

0:52:420:52:48

The latest figures show that over

217,000 additional homes were added

0:52:480:52:56

to the stock last year, that is a

remarkable achievement, but we need

0:52:560:53:01

to do better still if we are to see

affordability improved. This is a

0:53:010:53:06

complex challenge and there is no

single magic bullet. If we don't

0:53:060:53:13

increase the supply of land for new

homes, more money will simply

0:53:130:53:17

inflate prices and make matters

worse. If we don't do more to

0:53:170:53:22

support the growth of the SMT

house-building sector that was all

0:53:220:53:26

but wiped out by Labour's great

recession, we will remain dependent

0:53:260:53:33

on the major national house-builders

that dominate the industry. --

0:53:330:53:38

growth of the SME house-building

sector. Solving this challenge will

0:53:380:53:46

require money and it will require

planning reform and it will require

0:53:460:53:51

intervention. So today we set out an

ambitious plan to tackle the housing

0:53:510:53:56

challenge. Over the next five years

we will commit a total of at least

0:53:560:54:02

£44 billion of capital funding,

loans and guarantees to support our

0:54:020:54:07

housing market, to boost the supply

of skills, resources and building

0:54:070:54:11

land and to create the financial

incentives to deliver 300,000 net

0:54:110:54:18

additional homes on average by the

mid-20 20s, the biggest annual

0:54:180:54:23

increase in housing supply

0:54:230:54:28

New money for the fund to get SME

house-building began, a £30 million

0:54:280:54:35

fund, a further £2.7 billion to more

than double the housing

0:54:350:54:41

infrastructure fund, £400 million

more for a state regeneration, air

0:54:410:54:46

£1.1 billion fund to unlock

strategic sites, including new

0:54:460:54:50

settlements and urban regeneration

schemes, a listing of H R eight caps

0:54:500:54:58

for councils in high demand areas to

get them building again and £8

0:54:580:55:01

billion of new financial guarantees

to support house-building and the

0:55:010:55:06

private rented sector. Because we

need a workforce to build these new

0:55:060:55:10

homes, we are providing an

additional 30 formally in pounds to

0:55:100:55:14

develop construction skills across

the country. Mr Deputy Speaker,

0:55:140:55:18

solving the housing challenge takes

more than money, it takes planning

0:55:180:55:22

reform. We will focus on the urban

areas where people want to live, and

0:55:220:55:27

where most jobs are created, making

best use of our urban land and

0:55:270:55:33

continuing the strong protection of

our green belt. In particular,

0:55:330:55:41

building high-quality high density

homes in city centres and around

0:55:410:55:44

major transport hubs. And to put the

needs of our young people first, we

0:55:440:55:50

will insure that councils in high

demand areas permit more homes for

0:55:500:55:56

first-time buyers and affordable

renters. The Communities Secretary

0:55:560:56:00

will set out more detailed in a

statement to the House in due

0:56:000:56:05

course. However, one thing is very

clear, there is a significant gap

0:56:050:56:10

between the number of planning

permission is granted, and the

0:56:100:56:13

number of homes built. In London

alone, there are 270,000 residential

0:56:130:56:22

planning permission is an built. We

need to understand why -- not built.

0:56:220:56:30

I'm establishing an urgent review to

look at the gap between planning

0:56:300:56:35

permissions and housing starts. It

will be chaired by the member for

0:56:350:56:39

West Dorset and will deliver an

interim report in time for the

0:56:390:56:47

spring statement next year. And if

that report finds that fighter Lee

0:56:470:56:52

needed land is being withheld from

the market for commercial rather

0:56:520:56:58

than technical reasons, we will

intervene to change the incentives

0:56:580:57:02

to ensure such land is brought

forward for development, using

0:57:020:57:07

direct intervention, compulsory

purchase powers as necessary. My

0:57:070:57:11

right honourable friend the Prime

Minister has said we will fix this

0:57:110:57:16

problem, and no one should doubt the

Government's determination to do so.

0:57:160:57:23

But the solution will not deliver

itself. Local authorities will need

0:57:230:57:29

help and support. Developers will

need encouragement and persuasion.

0:57:290:57:36

Infrastructure to facilitate higher

density development must be funded

0:57:360:57:40

undelivered. So the Homes and

Communities Agency will expand to

0:57:400:57:45

become homes England bringing

together money, expertise and

0:57:450:57:50

planning and compulsory purchase

powers with a clear remit to

0:57:500:57:54

facilitate delivery of sufficient

new homes where they are most

0:57:540:57:59

needed, to deliver a sustained

improvement in housing

0:57:590:58:01

affordability. The battle to achieve

and sustain affordability will be a

0:58:010:58:08

long-term one, so we also need to

look beyond this Parliament, to

0:58:080:58:13

long-term measures. We will use new

town development corporations to

0:58:130:58:17

kick-start five new locally agreed

garden towns in areas of demand

0:58:170:58:22

pressure, delivered through

public-private partnerships,

0:58:220:58:27

designed to attract long-term

capital investment from around the

0:58:270:58:28

world. Last week, the National in

the structure commission published

0:58:280:58:35

their report on the Cambridge Milton

Keynes Oxford corridor. Today, we

0:58:350:58:39

back their vision and commit to

building up to 1 million homes by

0:58:390:58:45

2050, completing the road and rail

infrastructure to support them. As a

0:58:450:58:49

down payment on this plan, we have

agreed an ambitious housing deal

0:58:490:58:54

with Oxfordshire, to deliver 100,000

homes by 2031. Capitalising on the

0:58:540:59:01

global reputations of our two most

famous universities and Britain's

0:59:010:59:06

biggest new town, to create a

dynamic new growth corridor for the

0:59:060:59:10

21st century. Mr Deputy Speaker,

this is our plan to deliver on the

0:59:100:59:16

pledge we have made to the next

generation. That the dream of home

0:59:160:59:22

ownership will become a reality in

this country once again. But I also

0:59:220:59:27

want to take action today to help

young people who are saving to own a

0:59:270:59:32

home. One of the biggest challenges

facing young first-time buyers is

0:59:320:59:37

the cash required upfront. We have

put £10 billion more money into Help

0:59:370:59:42

to Buy equity loan to help those

saving for a deposit, but I want to

0:59:420:59:48

do more still. I have received

representations for a temporary

0:59:480:59:51

stamp duty holiday to first-time

buyers, but this would only help

0:59:510:59:56

those who are ready to purchase now,

and would offer nothing for the many

0:59:561:00:01

who will need to save for years. So

with effect from today, for all

1:00:011:00:07

first-time buyer purchases up to

£300,000, I am abolishing stamp duty

1:00:071:00:12

altogether.

1:00:121:00:21

If you want more, you are going to

have to let the Chancellor finish!

1:00:371:00:42

Chancellor of the Exchequer.

And Mr

Deputy Speaker, to ensure this

1:00:421:00:47

release also helps first-time buyers

in very high-priced areas like

1:00:471:00:54

London, it will also be available on

the first £300,000 on the purchase

1:00:541:00:58

price of properties up to £500,000.

Meaning an effective reduction of

1:00:581:01:06

£5,000. Mr Deputy Speaker, that is a

stamp duty cut for 95% of all

1:01:061:01:13

first-time buyers who pay stamp

duty, and no stamp duty at all of

1:01:131:01:19

80% of first-time buyers from today.

When we say we will revive the

1:01:191:01:23

homeowning dream in Britain, we mean

it. We do not underestimate the

1:01:231:01:28

scale of the challenge, but today we

have made a substantial down

1:01:281:01:33

payment. Mr Deputy Speaker, one of

the things that I love most about

1:01:331:01:40

this country is its sense of

opportunity. I have always felt it

1:01:401:01:45

and I want young people growing up

today to have that same sense of

1:01:451:01:50

boundless opportunity. In this

Budget, I have set out a vision for

1:01:501:01:55

Britain's future, and a plan for

delivering it. But by getting our

1:01:551:02:00

debt down, by supporting British

families and businesses, by

1:02:001:02:03

investing in the technologies and

the skills of the future, by

1:02:031:02:08

creating the homes and

infrastructure our country needs, we

1:02:081:02:11

are at a turning point in our

history, and we resolve to look

1:02:111:02:17

forwards, not backwards. To build on

the strengths of the British

1:02:171:02:21

economy, to embrace change, not hide

from it. To seize the opportunities

1:02:211:02:26

ahead of us, and together, to build

a Britain fit for the future. I

1:02:261:02:31

commend this statement to the House.

STUDIO:

1:02:311:02:41

Understanding order 51, will the

Chancellor of the Exchequer praise

1:02:511:03:00

move formally? The questionnaires to

be sued question five of the

1:03:001:03:09

provisional collection of taxes act

1968 will be given to the following

1:03:091:03:14

motions. Stamp duty land tax relief

motion number 36. Tobacco products,

1:03:141:03:30

rates motion number 40. As many as a

rock that opinion say aye. The ayes

1:03:301:03:40

have it. I now call upon the

Chancellor of the Exchequer to move

1:03:401:03:50

the motion entitled income tax. It

is intended that this will be put

1:03:501:04:09

towards the House on Tuesday 28

November.

1:04:091:04:20

The public resolution should have

statutory effect on the provisional

1:04:221:04:26

collection of taxes act 1968. I now

call the Leader of the Opposition,

1:04:261:04:32

the right honourable Jeremy Corbyn.

Thank you, Mr Speaker.

1:04:321:04:47

Test of the Budget is how it affects

the reality of people's lives all

1:04:471:04:47

around this country. I would submit

that the reality...

If somebody

1:04:471:04:55

wants to go for an early cup of tea,

please do so. I am told there are

1:04:551:05:01

men despise waiting. But what I will

have is the Leader of the Opposition

1:05:011:05:06

listened to and quietly from this

side in the same way I expected the

1:05:061:05:11

other side of the House.

Jeremy Corbyn.

Thank you, Mr Deputy

1:05:111:05:17

Speaker. The reality test of this

Budget has to be how it affects

1:05:171:05:22

ordinary people's lives, and I

believe as the days go ahead and

1:05:221:05:27

this Budget unravels, the reality

will be a lot of people will be no

1:05:271:05:32

better off and the misery many R.N.

Will be continuing. Paid, Mr Speaker

1:05:321:05:39

is now lower than it was in 2010 and

wages are now falling again.

1:05:391:05:47

Economic growth in the first three

quarters of this year is the lowest

1:05:471:05:55

since 2009, and the slowest of the

major economies in the G7. It is a

1:05:551:06:01

record of failure with the forecast

of more to come. Economic growth has

1:06:011:06:08

been revised down, productivity

growth has been revised down,

1:06:081:06:14

business investment revised down,

people's wages and living standards

1:06:141:06:17

revised down. What sort of strong

economy is that? What sort of fit

1:06:171:06:23

for the future is that? You may

recall, Mr Deputy Speaker, the

1:06:231:06:31

deficit was due to be eradicated by

2015. Then that moved to 2016. Then

1:06:311:06:43

to 2017. Then 2020 and now we are

looking at 2025. They are missing

1:06:431:06:53

their major targets, but the failed

and damaging policy of austerity

1:06:531:07:00

remains. The number of people

sleeping rough has doubled since

1:07:001:07:08

2010, and this Christmas, this

Christmas 120,000 children will

1:07:081:07:16

spend Christmas in temporary

accommodation. Three new pilot

1:07:161:07:22

schemes to look at rough sleeping

across the whole country simply

1:07:221:07:26

doesn't cut it. We want action now

to help those poor people that

1:07:261:07:32

forced to sleep on our streets and

beg...

Order. I think the whip know

1:07:321:07:38

better. We do not need any more from

you or leave the Chamber.

The point

1:07:381:07:49

I am making is three new pilot

schemes for rough sleepers simply

1:07:491:07:54

doesn't cut it. It is a disaster for

those people sleeping on our

1:07:541:07:58

streets, forced to beg for money for

a night shelter. They are looking

1:07:581:08:02

for action now from government to

give them a roof over their heads.

1:08:021:08:06

In some parts of the country, life

expectancy is actually beginning to

1:08:061:08:12

fall. The last Labour government

lifted 1 million children out of

1:08:121:08:16

poverty. It was an amazing

achievement. Under this government,

1:08:161:08:23

an extra 1 million children will be

plunged into poverty by the end of

1:08:231:08:26

this Parliament.

1:08:261:08:32

1.9 million pensioners, one in six

of all pensioners living in poverty,

1:08:321:08:36

the worst rate anywhere in Western

Europe. It is falling pay, slow

1:08:361:08:42

growth, rising poverty and this is

what the Chancellor has the cheek to

1:08:421:08:48

call a strong economy. His

predecessor said they would put the

1:08:481:08:55

burden on those with the broader

shoulders. How has that turned out?

1:08:551:09:02

The poorest tenth of households will

lose 10% of their income by 2022

1:09:021:09:13

while the richest will lose just 1%.

So much for tackling burning

1:09:131:09:22

injustices, this is a government

tossing fuel on the fire. Personal

1:09:221:09:27

debt levels are rising. 8.3 million

people over indebted. If he wants to

1:09:271:09:36

help people out of debt, he should

back Labour's policy for a real

1:09:361:09:41

living wage of £10 per hour by 2020.

Working-class young people now

1:09:411:09:54

leaving university with £57,000 of

debt because this government, his

1:09:541:10:00

government, troubled tuition fees

and the new government policy is to

1:10:001:10:03

win over young people by keeping

fees at the same rate per year --

1:10:031:10:17

trebled tuition fees. That is just

one of the multitudes of injustices

1:10:171:10:24

presided over by this government and

another is Universal Credit which we

1:10:241:10:28

called on ministers to pause and

fix. That is the view of this House

1:10:281:10:33

and the verdict of those on the

front line.

To shout out, keep

1:10:331:10:41

going, he will, but you will be

going out of the chamber.

Jeremy

1:10:411:10:46

Corbyn. I would rather people staged

to listen, actually, Mr Deputy

1:10:461:10:51

Speaker. To the reality.

Silence! It

will be in silence.

Thank you, Mr

1:10:511:11:07

Speaker. Maybe those opposite would

like to listen to Martin's

1:11:071:11:13

experience. A full-time worker on a

minimum wage, he said, I get paid

1:11:131:11:22

four weekly meeting my pay date is

different each month and because

1:11:221:11:27

under the Universal Credit system he

was paid twice in a month and deemed

1:11:271:11:31

to have earned too much Universal

Credit was cut off and lead to rent

1:11:311:11:37

arrears and he had to use a food

bank for the first time in his life.

1:11:371:11:41

That is the humiliation he and many

others have gone through because of

1:11:411:11:46

the problems of Universal Credit.

Would it not be better to pause the

1:11:461:11:50

whole thing and look at the problems

it has caused? The Chancellor's

1:11:501:11:58

solution to a failing system causing

more debt is to offer a loan and the

1:11:581:12:03

six-week wait with 20% waiting

longer simply becomes a five-week

1:12:031:12:09

wait. This system has been run down

by £3 billion of cuts to work

1:12:091:12:17

allowances, the two child limit and

the perverse and appalling clause

1:12:171:12:25

that caused evictions because

housing benefit is not paid direct

1:12:251:12:28

to the landlord. I say put this

system on hold so it can be fixed

1:12:281:12:33

and keep 1 million of our children

out of poverty. For years, we have

1:12:331:12:39

had the rhetoric of a long-term

economic plan that never meets its

1:12:391:12:45

targets. When all too many are

experiencing long-term economic

1:12:451:12:52

pain. And the hardest hit are

disabled people, single parents and

1:12:521:12:58

women. It is disappointing the

Chancellor did not back the campaign

1:12:581:13:04

by my honourable friend to end

period poverty. He could have done

1:13:041:13:11

that. Well done to her on the

campaign, shame on him for not

1:13:111:13:17

supporting it. The Conservative

manifesto in the last election

1:13:171:13:21

disappeared off its website after

three days, and now some ministers

1:13:211:13:26

opposite have put forward some half

decent proposals, conspicuously

1:13:261:13:30

borrowed from the Labour manifesto.

Let me tell the Chancellor, as

1:13:301:13:38

socialists we are happy to share

ideas. The Communities Secretary is

1:13:381:13:43

called the borrowing to invest in

house-building presumably the Prime

1:13:431:13:48

Minister slapped him down for

wanting to bankrupt Britain. Where

1:13:481:13:52

is the money to fund the pay rise if

he says the pay cap is over? The

1:13:521:13:57

Chancellor has not been clear for

NHS workers, police, firefighters,

1:13:571:14:05

teachers and assistants, bin

collectors, Armed Forces personnel.

1:14:051:14:10

Will the Chancellor listen to

Claire, who says her mum works for

1:14:101:14:14

the NHS and she goes above and

beyond for her patients. Why does

1:14:141:14:23

the government think it OK to

underpay, over stress and under

1:14:231:14:25

appreciate all those who work in the

NHS? The NHS chief executive says

1:14:251:14:32

the budget for the NHS next year is

short of what is currently needed.

1:14:321:14:37

From what the Chancellor has said,

it is still going to be well short

1:14:371:14:42

of what is needed. He said in 2015

they would fund another 5000 GPs. In

1:14:421:14:51

the last year, 1200, we have had

1200 fewer GPs and we have lost

1:14:511:15:00

community and mental health nurses.

The Chancellor promised

1:15:001:15:04

10,000,000,020 15 and delivered 4.5.

If you don't mind, we will wait for

1:15:041:15:10

the small print on the announcement

but even what he said falls well

1:15:101:15:16

short of the 6 billion Labour would

have delivered from our June

1:15:161:15:19

manifesto. Over 1 million of our

elderly are not receiving the care

1:15:191:15:25

they need. Over... Over 6 billion

will have been cut from social care

1:15:251:15:36

budgets by next March. I hope he

begins to understand what it is like

1:15:361:15:41

to wait for social care, stuck in a

hospital bed, with other people

1:15:411:15:46

having to give up work to care for

them. The uncaring, uncouth attitude

1:15:461:15:56

of certain members...

Order. Carry

on.

1:15:561:16:09

Mr Speaker, that is why social care

budgets are so important for so many

1:16:101:16:19

desperate people in our country. Our

schools will be 5% worse off by

1:16:191:16:28

2019, despite the Conservative

manifesto promising no school would

1:16:281:16:32

be worse off. 5000 headteachers from

25 counties wrote to the Chancellor

1:16:321:16:42

saying, we are simply asking for the

money that has been taken out of the

1:16:421:16:45

system to be returned. A senior

science technician wrote to me,

1:16:451:16:51

Robert, saying, my pay has been

reduced by over 30%. I have seen

1:16:511:16:58

massive cuts at my school, good

teachers and support staff leave.

1:16:581:17:03

That is what does for the morale of

both teachers and students.

1:17:031:17:10

According to this government, 5000

headteachers are wrong, Robert is

1:17:101:17:15

wrong, the IFS is wrong, everybody

is wrong, except the Chancellor. And

1:17:151:17:22

if the Chancellor bothered to listen

to what local government is saying,

1:17:221:17:27

they have been warning services for

the most vulnerable children are

1:17:271:17:32

under more demand than ever. More

children being taken into care, more

1:17:321:17:36

in desperate need of help and

support, yet they are labouring with

1:17:361:17:43

a 2 billion shortfall in the cost of

dealing with vulnerable children.

1:17:431:17:47

Because local councils have lost

80%, will have lost 80% of direct

1:17:471:17:56

funding by 2020. The reality of

this, across the country, is

1:17:561:18:03

winning's refuges closing, youth

centres and libraries and museums

1:18:031:18:09

closing, public facilities

understaffed, under resourced and

1:18:091:18:13

underfinanced. It could be so

different, but compassion can cost

1:18:131:18:18

very little. Just £10 million is

needed to establish the child

1:18:181:18:23

funeral fund, campaigned for

brilliantly by my honourable friend

1:18:231:18:29

the member for Swansea East. Why

could not the Chancellor at least

1:18:291:18:33

have agreed to fund that? Under this

government there are also 20,000

1:18:331:18:39

fewer police officers and another

6000 community support officers and

1:18:391:18:45

11,000 Fire Service staff cut as

well. You cannot keep communities

1:18:451:18:48

safe on the cheap. Tammy explains

this. Our police presence has been

1:18:481:18:56

taken away from the village, meaning

an increase in crime, as a single

1:18:561:19:01

parent I no longer feel safe in the

village where I live, particularly

1:19:011:19:04

at night. 5.5 million workers earn

less than living wage, 1 million

1:19:041:19:12

more than five years ago. The

Chancellor last Sunday could not

1:19:121:19:18

even see 1.4 million people

unemployed in this country. There is

1:19:181:19:24

a crisis of low pay and insecure

work affecting one in four women and

1:19:241:19:32

one in six men, a record 7.4 million

people in working households living

1:19:321:19:39

in poverty. If we want workers

earning better pay, less dependent

1:19:391:19:45

on in work benefits, we need strong

trade unions, the most effective way

1:19:451:19:50

of boosting workers pay. Instead,

this government weakened trade

1:19:501:19:56

unions and introduced employment

Tribunal fees, now scrapped, thanks

1:19:561:20:00

to the victory in the courts by

Unison, a trade union representing

1:20:001:20:05

members. Why did the Chancellor not

take the opportunity to make two

1:20:051:20:11

changes to control debt? First, to

cap credit card debt so nobody pays

1:20:111:20:19

back more than they borrowed. And

second, to stop credit card

1:20:191:20:24

companies increasing people'scredit

limit without their say-so. Debt is

1:20:241:20:29

being racked up because the

government is weak on those who

1:20:291:20:33

exploit people such as rail

companies hiking fares above

1:20:331:20:38

inflation, and water companies and

energy suppliers. During the general

1:20:381:20:43

election he promised an energy cap

to benefit around 17 million

1:20:431:20:49

families on standard variable

tariffs. But every bill tells

1:20:491:20:53

millions the government has broken

that promise. And with 10 billion in

1:20:531:20:59

housing benefit going into the

pockets of private landlords every

1:20:591:21:03

year, housing is a key factor in

driving up the welfare bill. Not too

1:21:031:21:08

many words from the Chancellor about

excessive levels of rent in the

1:21:081:21:13

private rented sector. With this

government delivering the worst rate

1:21:131:21:16

of house building since the 20s, and

a quarter... And a quarter of a

1:21:161:21:29

million fewer council homes, any

commitment would be welcome. But we

1:21:291:21:34

have been here before. The

government promised 200,000 starter

1:21:341:21:39

homes, three years ago, and not a

single one has yet been built in

1:21:391:21:45

those three years. We need a large

scale publicly funded house-building

1:21:451:21:50

programme, not this government's

accounting tricks and empty

1:21:501:21:54

promises. We back the abolition of

stamp duty for first-time buyers

1:21:541:21:59

because it was another Labour policy

in our manifesto in June, not a Tory

1:21:591:22:07

one. This government continues

preference for spin over substance,

1:22:071:22:11

that means across this country, in

the words wolf powerhouse and

1:22:111:22:17

Midlands engine, now met with

derision. Yorkshire and Humber get

1:22:171:22:23

only one tenth of the transport

investment per head given to London.

1:22:231:22:29

And government figures show every

region in the of England has seen a

1:22:291:22:35

fall in spending on services since

2012. The Midlands, East and west is

1:22:351:22:42

receiving less than 8% of total

transport infrastructure investment

1:22:421:22:48

compared with 50% going to London.

In the east and West Midlands one in

1:22:481:22:54

four workers are paid less than the

living wage, so much for the

1:22:541:22:58

Midlands engine. We announced

funding for the trans-Pennine rail

1:22:581:23:02

route will not cut it and the other

announcements today will not redress

1:23:021:23:09

that balance. Combined with

counter-productive forced Erraid

1:23:091:23:12

Davies lack of investment has

consequences in sluggish growth and

1:23:121:23:16

shrinking pay packets. Public

investment has virtually halved.

1:23:161:23:20

Under this government Britain has

the lowest rate of public investment

1:23:201:23:24

in the G7. But it is now investing

in driverless cars. After months of

1:23:241:23:32

road testing back-seat driving in

the government.

1:23:321:23:40

By moving from RPI to CPI indexes

non-business rates, the Chancellor

1:23:401:23:50

has adopted another Labour policy.

But why don't they go further and

1:23:501:23:55

adopt Labour's entire business rates

including the annual revaluation of

1:23:551:24:03

business rates. Nowhere have their

chaos been more evident than over

1:24:031:24:08

Brexit. Following round after round

of fruitless Brexit negotiations,

1:24:081:24:12

the Brexit secretary has been

shunted out for the Prime Minister

1:24:121:24:15

who has got no further. Every major

business organisation has written to

1:24:151:24:20

the Government telling them to pull

their finger out and get on with it.

1:24:201:24:25

Businesses are delaying crucial

investment decisions because of this

1:24:251:24:28

government doesn't get its act

together soon, they will be taking

1:24:281:24:32

relocation decisions. Crashing out

with no deal and turning Britain

1:24:321:24:38

into a tax haven would damage

people's jobs and living standards

1:24:381:24:44

would serve only a wealthy few. It

is not as if this government isn't

1:24:441:24:49

doing its best to protect tax havens

and its clients in the meantime. The

1:24:491:24:58

Paradise Papers exposed how a

super-rich elite gets away with

1:24:581:25:02

dodging taxes. This government has

opposed measure after measure in

1:25:021:25:06

this House and their Tory colleagues

in the European Parliament, to clamp

1:25:061:25:11

down on the tax havens that

facilitate this outrageous leaching

1:25:111:25:15

from our public purse. Nonpaid tax,

clever reinvestment to get away with

1:25:151:25:23

tax, actually, it is hospitals,

schools, housing and it hit the

1:25:231:25:27

poorest and most needy in our

society. There is nothing immoral

1:25:271:25:31

about dodging tax. There is

everything in moral about evading

1:25:311:25:34

it. Mr Speaker, too often it feels

like there is one rule for the

1:25:341:25:40

super-rich and another for the rest

of us. The horrors of Grenfell Tower

1:25:401:25:47

were a reflection of a system which

puts profits before people, that

1:25:471:25:54

failed to listen to working-class

communities. In 2013, the Government

1:25:541:25:58

received advice in a krona's report

that sprinklers should be fitted in

1:25:581:26:03

all high-rise buildings. Today, once

again, the Government failed to fund

1:26:031:26:11

the £1 billion investment needed.

The Chancellor says council should

1:26:111:26:13

contact them. But not in house,

Westminster house and they have been

1:26:131:26:20

refused. Nothing was offered to

them. We have the privilege to be

1:26:201:26:27

members of Parliament, in a building

that is about to be retrofitted with

1:26:271:26:32

sprinklers, to protect us. The

message is pretty clear. This

1:26:321:26:37

government cares more about what

happens here then happens to people

1:26:371:26:42

living in high-rise homes. In effect

saying they matter less. Our

1:26:421:26:50

country, Mr Speaker, is marked by

growing inequality and injustice. We

1:26:501:26:55

were promised a revolutionary

Budget, the reality is nothing has

1:26:551:27:02

changed. People were looking for

help from this Budget and they have

1:27:021:27:06

been let down. Let down by a

government, that like the economy be

1:27:061:27:11

presided over, is weak and unstable

and in need of urgent change. They

1:27:111:27:16

called this a Budget fit for the

future. The reality is, this is a

1:27:161:27:22

government no longer fit for office.

Nicky Morgan.

1:27:221:27:31

STUDIO: And Jeremy Corbyn sits down

after a long and wide-ranging

1:27:311:27:37

response to the Budget. If you wish

to continue to watch what is

1:27:371:27:41

happening in the House of Commons,

you can switch to the BBC Parliament

1:27:411:27:45

channel and that will tell you what

is going on there. Here, we will go

1:27:451:27:50

through

1:27:501:27:50

I'm happen to to continue that

tradition. Much of his speech was

1:28:051:28:09

pre-written. I suspect he'll want to

look at more of the detail. Today, I

1:28:091:28:16

think it is perhaps the Chancellor

who's had the hardest task. More

1:28:161:28:24

public spending, rising economic

uncertainty. He has taken a

1:28:241:28:28

common-sense approach which will no

doubt displease many on both sides

1:28:281:28:32

of the chamber. It is only thanks to

seven years of common-sense,

1:28:321:28:37

concerted efforts by Conservative

and Conservative-led Governments to

1:28:371:28:41

reduce the deficit and restore

credibility to the public finances

1:28:411:28:44

that the UK has the resilience

necessary to face the challenges

1:28:441:28:47

ahead. Reclassification of Housing

Association, may have given the

1:28:471:28:54

Chancellor some timely room for man

over, it does not alter the

1:28:541:28:59

underlying picture. Although the OBR

has made a more negative assessment

1:28:591:29:06

of productivity, it is forecasting a

relatively benign breaks the with no

1:29:061:29:10

cliff edge in March 2019. But that

can the no be guaranteed. Even

1:29:101:29:17

though a transitional arrangement

for a smooth adjustment is in the

1:29:171:29:21

interests of both the UK and the EU,

it may not happen. The Treasury

1:29:211:29:27

committee will be looking closely at

failing to reach a deal on

1:29:271:29:30

transition and expectings to make a

report in the House in the coupling

1:29:301:29:34

weeks. Beyond the public finances,

household balance sheets are under

1:29:341:29:38

pressure. Rising interest rates,

high inflation, lower wage growth, a

1:29:381:29:45

working age benefits freeze, all

these put pressure on ordinary

1:29:451:29:49

households. The Chancellor set out

two important principles for

1:29:491:29:54

Conservative-led Governments.

Firstly, work should always pay and

1:29:541:29:58

secondly, people should keep more of

the money they earn. I'm happy to

1:29:581:30:03

subscribe and those on these benches

are happy to support him with those

1:30:031:30:08

two principles. Pressures on

household finances which the

1:30:081:30:11

committee will be looking at as part

of our inquiry, will be exacerbated,

1:30:111:30:18

particularly for the younger again

ration, if action's not taking with

1:30:181:30:22

the housing market. I welcome the

measures the chops letter's

1:30:221:30:27

announced on housing. It he's

announce add package on land

1:30:271:30:33

availability and incentives to get

building. You know there's an issue

1:30:331:30:40

when the member for West Dorset is

sent for to solve a particular

1:30:401:30:43

problem. He is going to look at the

gap between permissions granted and

1:30:431:30:48

those houses being built. Why that

gap exists. I also hugely welcome,

1:30:481:30:54

as I think honourable members on

this side of the House will, the

1:30:541:30:57

stamp duty cut for first time

buyers. As the Chancellor said, this

1:30:571:31:01

will make home ownership a reality

for more young people. The committee

1:31:011:31:06

will be intending to hear from

housing experts as part of our

1:31:061:31:10

Budget scrutiny and will

investigates whether the rousing war

1:31:101:31:14

time rhetoric of my right honourable

friend matches the reality of what

1:31:141:31:18

has been announced today. Of course,

the pressure's on the public

1:31:181:31:24

finances and households balance

sheet can only be alleviated if

1:31:241:31:29

productivity growth improves. I

welcome his further investment in

1:31:291:31:33

the national productivity investment

fun. He was right to 'em fast sides

1:31:331:31:37

the challenge of productivity which

is the weakest in the G7 in the UK

1:31:371:31:41

in his speech. The average UK worker

has to slog from 5 to produce 9- the

1:31:411:31:46

same value output as a worker in

Germany produces between the hours

1:31:461:31:52

of 9 and 3. I welcome what the

Chancellor said about more

1:31:521:31:56

devolution. I don't know where the

Leader of the Opposition has the

1:31:561:32:00

idea we don't take seriously the

northern powerhouse or the Midlands

1:32:001:32:04

engine on this side of the House. I

can tell him as a Midlands member of

1:32:041:32:08

Parliament, we take them very

seriously. This side of the House

1:32:081:32:13

believes in devolution. There are no

easy solutions to the UK's weak

1:32:131:32:18

productivity performance. We can do

two things to help with the puzzle.

1:32:181:32:24

The first is better infrastructure,

including digital infrastructure.

1:32:241:32:30

The big political divide in

infrastructure policy is not between

1:32:301:32:33

the parties but action and inaction.

The Chancellor must act on the

1:32:331:32:38

commission's recommendations when

published. I welcome his commitment

1:32:381:32:41

today to implement the commission's

recommendation from the Oxford,

1:32:411:32:46

Milton Keynes corridor. And the

discount of lending to local

1:32:461:32:49

authorities so they can invest in

infrastructure. The second answer to

1:32:491:32:53

productivity is to retain the UK's

historic commitment to openness,

1:32:531:32:58

#2r5ied, investment and to

migration. Global Britain must be a

1:32:581:33:02

reality and not just a slogan. The

economic case for leaving the EU has

1:33:021:33:07

always rested and continues to rest

on openness. We must not allow the

1:33:071:33:12

Brexit process to mark the start of

a decent into economic nationalism.

1:33:121:33:18

It is only through productivity

growth households can be weaned off

1:33:181:33:23

consumer credit without cutting back

consumption and reducing living

1:33:231:33:26

standards. It is only through

productivity growth the Chancellor

1:33:261:33:33

can Meade things can pries ops bes

NHS, public #1ek9er pay and bricks

1:33:331:33:40

the cop tinge Si methods. For the

avoidance of doubt. Let us dismiss

1:33:401:33:49

the idea that Brexit induced fiscal

windfall will reduce the pressures

1:33:491:33:53

op our health service. There are no

easy choices or a pot of gold under

1:33:531:34:02

the Brexit rainbow. At the cost of

long-term damage to trust in

1:34:021:34:08

politics. The Chancellor's right to

have identified the technology

1:34:081:34:13

revolution and say Britain is at the

forefront of it. He is right to

1:34:131:34:17

identify the need for more young

people to learn maths and computer

1:34:171:34:21

science to a higher level. We have

to find a way of exciting everyone

1:34:211:34:26

in this country, the next generation

and their parents and grandparents

1:34:261:34:31

about the technology revolution to

give them the confidence and skills

1:34:311:34:34

to meet demand of a fuel or labour

market, not to be frightened by

1:34:341:34:39

change in the 21st Century. This is

a key part of our plan for a fairer

1:34:391:34:45

Britain

I thank the Right Honourable

Member for giving way. Can I just

1:34:451:34:49

pick up on The Mount about education

funding. The education proposals,

1:34:491:34:56

the Government proposed three

billion of cuts and that was reduced

1:34:561:35:01

to justnd £2 billion. There's a gap

of £2 billion education funding cuts

1:35:011:35:06

in our system. The Chancellor has

said nothing about how schools will

1:35:061:35:09

cope with that. Does she agree with

me we should have had some thinking

1:35:091:35:18

and investment in our schools in

order to prevent them reversing the

1:35:181:35:24

progress that has been made?

I can

say to the honourable lady, who I'm

1:35:241:35:29

very pleased to serve on the

Treasury committee with, we have

1:35:291:35:34

seen education fanned Ards improve

dramatically in this country over

1:35:341:35:37

the last seven years. I don't

recognise the figure she has said.

1:35:371:35:42

The Secretary of State for Education

announced an extra £1.3 billion in

1:35:421:35:46

July. This Government's spending

more on schools than any Government

1:35:461:35:50

has ever spent before. If she's

really concerned, she will want to

1:35:501:35:54

address the interest on the debt

this Government is still paying off,

1:35:541:35:58

we are spending almost as much on

debt interest as on our schools

1:35:581:36:01

budget. Let me turn to tax. The

Chancellor announced a number of new

1:36:011:36:06

tax mesh use. He was very pleased he

said our tax system can help protect

1:36:061:36:11

our environment. It is an important

signal to send to those concerned

1:36:111:36:15

about the environment and to the

next generation. I really want to

1:36:151:36:18

welcome... I will, yeah.

I'm

grateful to the chair of the

1:36:181:36:24

treasury committee for giving way.

On that point, can I we can the

1:36:241:36:28

measure in the budget which would

grant an ex-etchings on the zero

1:36:281:36:36

emissions. Can I also, through my

honourable friend urge the

1:36:361:36:41

Chancellor to bring forward that

measure so it kicks in earlier than

1:36:411:36:45

April 2019. Many of those vehicles

will be on the road from next month.

1:36:451:36:49

We want drivers to be able to take

advantage of these new zero emission

1:36:491:36:55

capable environmentally friendly

taxes.

1:36:551:37:01

THE SPEAKER:

If we have

interventions, please make them

1:37:011:37:03

short.

It is a pleasure to serve in

the honourable gentleman on the

1:37:031:37:07

Treasury committee. The Chancellor's

heard what he says and is looking

1:37:071:37:11

forward to appearing before the

committee on 6th December when we

1:37:111:37:15

can ask him those questions

directly. I'll give way believely.

1:37:151:37:22

Hidden in the budget book is really

terrible news of no new money for

1:37:221:37:28

renewables until 2025 at the same

time the chaps letter' giving away

1:37:281:37:32

money, more tax breaks to oil and

gas. How is that compatible with a

1:37:321:37:36

forward looking country that is

serious about climate change?

I

1:37:361:37:40

think this Government's done

incredibly well on supporting

1:37:401:37:44

renewables industry. The energy

industry in the Midlands. I can see

1:37:441:37:49

a thriving industry. But that's

something again the committee may

1:37:491:37:53

well want to take up with the

Chancellor. I want to welcome the

1:37:531:37:56

move on business rates. The move

from RPI to CPI is very, very

1:37:561:38:00

welcome. I want to welcome the move

on the staircase tax which is

1:38:001:38:05

something the Chancellor was asked

about when he appeared before the

1:38:051:38:09

committee recently and builds on the

evidence he gave. I hope he's right

1:38:091:38:13

about the cross-party support that

he can receive on that measure.

1:38:131:38:17

Would my right honourable friend

agree that the changes to business

1:38:221:38:25

rates are going to be particularly

valuable for other shops, businesses

1:38:251:38:31

and other places in outer London

were they as we could win a bright

1:38:311:38:34

lights of London and out-of-town

shopping centres and the Chris

1:38:341:38:37

Cusiter business rate is

particularly owners?

That is an

1:38:371:38:40

excellent point and I would agree

with my honourable friend Matt and I

1:38:401:38:43

was going to talk about the

Chancellor's announcement on digital

1:38:431:38:48

businesses as well which is

important for bricks and mortar

1:38:481:38:51

businesses and perhaps modest, it is

an important printable that has been

1:38:511:38:54

established about the tax on digital

businesses doing business here. I

1:38:541:38:58

welcome what the Chancellor said

about tax avoidance and evasion

1:38:581:39:01

measures. I think you said we were

going to spend £155 billion on

1:39:011:39:05

HMRC's collecting ability to collect

£2.3 billion, which sounds

1:39:051:39:11

encouraging but the committee will

private estimate. -- 100 £55

1:39:111:39:17

million. I wanted to match my

honourable friend for beginning to

1:39:171:39:22

publish the income distribution

analysis showing how different

1:39:221:39:24

households are affected by the

budget. That analysis provides an

1:39:241:39:28

unprecedented level of transparency

about the consequences of the budget

1:39:281:39:30

for ordinary people which only

emerge as a result of pressure by

1:39:301:39:35

the Treasury committee in the last

two parliaments. There may be more

1:39:351:39:38

work for the committee to doing this

one. What is not included in the

1:39:381:39:42

Treasury's analysis yet is an

assessment of the gender impact of

1:39:421:39:46

the budget, an analysis of how much

men and women stand to gain or lose

1:39:461:39:49

from the Chancellor's decisions. It

will come as no surprise that as the

1:39:491:39:53

first female chair of the Treasury

Select Committee, the committee will

1:39:531:39:57

be taking gritting evidence

including from the women's budget

1:39:571:40:00

group on the merits of such an

analysis. Before concluding, I would

1:40:001:40:03

like to remind the house about the

role of the Treasury committee in

1:40:031:40:07

scrutinising the OBR and upholding

its independence. I think there is

1:40:071:40:10

widespread agreement, Mr Deputy

Speaker, across this house, that the

1:40:101:40:13

creation of the OBR as last improved

the credibility and quality of

1:40:131:40:18

economic and fiscal forecasting and

empowered members of Parliament to

1:40:181:40:21

hold government to account for its

fiscal policy. But in this free bar

1:40:211:40:26

political atmosphere, we must member

the OBR is still young. Its hard-won

1:40:261:40:30

reputation could be fatally

undermined if the motives and good

1:40:301:40:40

faith of its leadership are impugned

by those who disagree with its

1:40:401:40:43

finding. The OBR as a powerful line

of accountability to Parliament

1:40:431:40:45

thanks to the committee's statutory

veto over the appointment and is the

1:40:451:40:47

will of the senior leadership, we

will seek assurances the OBR has

1:40:471:40:50

done its work without political

interference. We will subject its

1:40:501:40:52

forecast to critical scrutiny as

necessary and defend its integrity.

1:40:521:40:54

The committee looks forward to

hearing as I said from the

1:40:541:40:57

Chancellor on the measures he has

announced and the economic and

1:40:571:41:00

fiscal outlook when he appears

before us in two weeks' time. Mr

1:41:001:41:04

Deputy Speaker, the UK faces many

challenges. Brexit hangs over this

1:41:041:41:07

place and the UK like a cloud. Some

people think there is a silver

1:41:071:41:12

lining. Some people think there will

be more rain and fog. It was

1:41:121:41:16

important that today's budget should

show the government's determination

1:41:161:41:19

is to do more than just negotiate

our path out of the EU. I believe

1:41:191:41:24

the Chancellor has more than

announced that with everything he

1:41:241:41:26

has announced today.

Ian Black.

Thank you, Mr Deputy Speaker. I

1:41:261:41:35

mean, I want to wish the Chancellor

all the best. He talks about

1:41:351:41:39

preparing for the future but let's

look at the reality of the figures

1:41:391:41:44

contained in the OBR book. What we

are faced with is the United Kingdom

1:41:441:41:49

falling to the bottom of growth in

the G7. When we look at GDP per

1:41:491:41:57

capita, for the years 2019 and 2020,

what we see is that the OBR have

1:41:571:42:06

reduced forecasts from 1.7%, to 0.7%

in 2019, and in 2020, from 1.9%, to

1:42:061:42:20

0.7%. Mr Deputy Speaker, that is

what post-Brexit Britain is going to

1:42:201:42:26

look like. An absolute shredding of

growth forecasts that the next two

1:42:261:42:34

years. The OBR talks about GDP... I

will not because this is the third

1:42:341:42:42

party speech and it is the practice

that there is not to be

1:42:421:42:45

interventions. The change in GDP

that we will see in the OBR book is

1:42:451:42:52

a cut to GDP of 2.7%. That is what

this government is presiding over.

1:42:521:43:01

It is a threat to the wages, to the

living standards and to the job

1:43:011:43:04

prospects of people up and down the

United Kingdom. Frankly, it is a

1:43:041:43:10

government that should be ashamed of

itself. And when you look at the

1:43:101:43:16

rhetoric of the budget speech, and I

can see honourable members laughing,

1:43:161:43:19

but when you look at the fiscal

loosening that we have in this

1:43:191:43:24

budget, it is a fiscal loosening of

0.1%. That does not take into

1:43:241:43:29

account the reality of the risks

that the people of the United

1:43:291:43:32

Kingdom face. Mr Deputy Speaker, let

me welcome the removal of VAT on

1:43:321:43:43

police and Fire Services. But can I

remind the Chancellor of the

1:43:431:43:49

Exchequer that together with his

friend, the Secretary of State for

1:43:491:43:53

Scotland, that they were given the

opportunity to support an SNP

1:43:531:43:57

amendment to the Finance Bill in

2015 that would have removed VAT

1:43:571:44:03

from Scotland and I can see the

remarks coming from the benches

1:44:031:44:06

opposite but I will remind them that

the Conservative Party in their

1:44:061:44:11

manifesto supported the

establishment of police Scotland. It

1:44:111:44:15

was the vindictiveness and the nasty

nurse of the Tory government that

1:44:151:44:20

imposed VAT on Scotland. That has

ripped £114 million out of our front

1:44:201:44:26

line services. And when the

Chancellor of the Exchequer and the

1:44:261:44:33

Secretary of State for Scotland were

given the opportunity in the Finance

1:44:331:44:39

Bill of 2015, they failed. So it is

a disgrace that we have had 140

1:44:391:44:44

million taken out of front line

spending.

Point of order. Mr Debord

1:44:441:44:50

is bigger, just a point of

clarification, just to clarify, we

1:44:501:44:54

are allowed to intervene on the

honourable member's speech, whether

1:44:541:44:57

he takes it or not is something

else.

Just a second. Just a moment.

1:44:571:45:04

The rules are that it is the

Chancellor of the Exchequer, it is

1:45:041:45:09

the Leader of the Opposition, who

are not intervened on but what I

1:45:091:45:14

would say is that the courtesies go

to the leader of the SNP, who may

1:45:141:45:19

wish not to be intervened, that is

his choice, and what I suggest...

1:45:191:45:24

What I suggest... Order, order. What

I will tell you is that he has made

1:45:241:45:29

it quite clear that he wants the

same courtesy that has been

1:45:291:45:33

established so in which case come he

won't be giving way. It will save us

1:45:331:45:36

a lot of time if the bust standing

up.

Thank you very much Mr Deputy

1:45:361:45:43

Speaker, it is about time the

Scottish Conservatives actually

1:45:431:45:46

showed some proper respect, not just

to the SNP year but to the Scottish

1:45:461:45:49

Government in Edinburgh. To return

to the point, it is an absolute

1:45:491:45:55

disgrace we have had £140 million

taken out of front line spending by

1:45:551:46:00

a Tory government ahead of this

announcement. VAT should never have

1:46:001:46:04

been charged to Scottish police and

fire and the blame for that, the

1:46:041:46:09

sole blame for that lies with the

Conservative government. Mr Deputy

1:46:091:46:13

Speaker... Andrew Green order, you

are a normal, gentle person, a man

1:46:131:46:20

who normally shows such dignity.

I'm

hoping he will show dignity today.

1:46:201:46:26

Thank you, Mr Deputy Speaker. The

SNP have spoken out here and in

1:46:261:46:31

Holyrood 140 times before the

government finally saw sense. But

1:46:311:46:36

what about the 140 million that has

been paid? The Chancellor has

1:46:361:46:41

confirmed today what we knew all

along, it was a political choice to

1:46:411:46:45

charge VAT on our emergency

services. He has accepted that he

1:46:451:46:49

was wrong but I'm calling on the

Chancellor today and his friends

1:46:491:46:54

from Scotland on the Tory benches to

make sure that we push for a refund

1:46:541:46:59

of the VAT that has been paid over

the course of the last three years.

1:46:591:47:05

Mr Deputy Speaker, the Chancellor

has painted a picture of our

1:47:051:47:13

economy, ready for the impending

economic disaster Brexit. We all

1:47:131:47:18

have to wonder, just exactly what

planet is the Chancellor on Western

1:47:181:47:22

Mark most workers are seeing a

decline in their living standards

1:47:221:47:25

and have done so since the financial

crisis. We are living through the

1:47:251:47:29

worst decade of wage growth for 210

years. Young people are going to be

1:47:291:47:36

poorer than their parents. Housing

has become unaffordable for many.

1:47:361:47:45

The austerity economic model has

failed millions. The Prime Minister

1:47:451:47:48

alluded to this when she talked

about the "Just about managing". Mr

1:47:481:47:55

Deputy Speaker, today's budget was

an opportunity to address these

1:47:551:47:59

challenges and make this a budget

for people and prosperity. The

1:47:591:48:04

reality is, there is nothing in this

budget that deals with the

1:48:041:48:07

challenges that we face. We have the

impending UK exit from Europe. We

1:48:071:48:12

know the government is preparing for

a no deal. Yet the Chancellor made

1:48:121:48:18

no mention of how the economy would

cope with that. The cliff edge is

1:48:181:48:25

before us and the Chancellor sits

transfixed, unable or incapable of

1:48:251:48:30

rising to the challenge. No doubt

the Chancellor recognises the

1:48:301:48:37

economic self harm that comes with

leaving the single market and the

1:48:371:48:40

customs union. But has failed to

act. Why? Because the Brexiteers

1:48:401:48:48

have set the agenda for this

government and the Chancellor is

1:48:481:48:50

without the authority to challenge

the madness. The Chancellor, like

1:48:501:48:55

his government, is in office but not

in power. We know that the Prime

1:48:551:49:03

Minister has two present a financial

settlement to the EU 27 over the

1:49:031:49:07

coming days. Yet there was no

mention of that in this statement,

1:49:071:49:10

none at all. This government has to

take its head out of the sand and

1:49:101:49:15

except that the future -- accept

that the future indicates the

1:49:151:49:21

likelihood of significant economic

self arm. Mr Deputy Speaker, before

1:49:211:49:26

the winds of Brexit hit us, the

starting position for millions of

1:49:261:49:29

people is that by then, we will have

already been struggling with nine

1:49:291:49:32

years austerity. The cuts being

imposed on public services, meaning

1:49:321:49:38

that service delivery has been

impacted in public service workers

1:49:381:49:42

in particular, are feeling the

squeeze. This is a budget that shows

1:49:421:49:47

a Chancellor that is either blind to

what is going on or that he is

1:49:471:49:50

behaving like a frightened rabbit

caught in headlights. Either way,

1:49:501:49:55

people are going to pay the price

for his lack of leadership. Well, I

1:49:551:49:58

can see the Chancellor saying an

extra £2 billion for Scotland. Let

1:49:581:50:04

me tell this allows the reality. Let

me tell you the reality. -- this

1:50:041:50:10

house. It is a £250 million cut in

real terms. That is what the

1:50:101:50:15

government here is delivering to the

people of Scotland. Mr Deputy

1:50:151:50:21

Speaker, this government used to

speak of the empty rhetoric of the

1:50:211:50:25

long-term economic plan. It has

failed to deliver a vision and has

1:50:251:50:30

no plan for delivering prosperity.

The long-term economic plan has

1:50:301:50:33

given way to no plan. Scratch the

surface of the economy and you will

1:50:331:50:39

see a structure barely coping with

the state of society, a structure

1:50:391:50:45

that is so unfairly built in favour

of the wealthy, we have created a

1:50:451:50:48

situation where we have the worst

wage growth in 200 years and the IFS

1:50:481:50:53

tell us an additional 400,000

children will be in absolute poverty

1:50:531:50:57

within six years due to the benefit

cuts that are to come because let's

1:50:571:51:02

remind ourselves, there is still £12

billion of cuts to welfare to come

1:51:021:51:08

from this Tory government. The case,

Mr Deputy Speaker, is that working

1:51:081:51:16

people are paying the price for this

government's ideological accession

1:51:161:51:18

with austerity because make no

mistake, it is an ideological

1:51:181:51:23

accession. I mean, it is a pity that

people watching and listening to

1:51:231:51:30

this cannot see the Tory benches

sitting and laughing when people in

1:51:301:51:37

our country are paying the price.

They should be utterly ashamed of

1:51:371:51:39

themselves. Effective stewardship of

our economy has to recognise the

1:51:391:51:46

importance of fiscal and monetary

policy working in tandem to create

1:51:461:51:50

the circumstances of sustainable and

inclusive economic growth. Any

1:51:501:51:57

disconnect leads to failure to

deliver an economy that works for

1:51:571:52:01

all, which is precisely what is

happening. A failure to deliver a

1:52:011:52:05

budget for prosperity hit all

workers, in particular those in the

1:52:051:52:09

public sector. Mr Deputy Speaker, in

September, the Scottish cosmid

1:52:091:52:13

became the first in the UK to

announce it will scrap the public

1:52:131:52:16

sector pay gap. Our nurses,

teachers, police officers and

1:52:161:52:23

firefighters deserve a fair deal for

the future. Future pay rises will be

1:52:231:52:26

based on the cost of living and

today, the Chancellor betrayed

1:52:261:52:30

public sector workers by refusing to

fund a fair pay rise. But it is not

1:52:301:52:36

just the squeeze on pay which is

leaving low earners are struggling

1:52:361:52:40

to get by. The UK Government's

Social Security cuts are

1:52:401:52:44

specifically designed to remove the

welfare state. The SNP will never

1:52:441:52:49

accept this ideological attack on

the most vulnerable in our society.

1:52:491:52:54

The damaging and destructive

Universal Credit system must be

1:52:541:52:56

halted and fixed. Now, I welcome

some of the things we have heard to

1:52:561:53:02

date but it simply does not go far

enough. We still have cuts to the

1:53:021:53:08

work allowance is taking place and

while young people are pushed into

1:53:081:53:10

poverty, Universal Credit as is, is

not fit for purpose. The Chancellor

1:53:101:53:16

of the Exchequer should call

thoughts today and reform the system

1:53:161:53:19

properly. -- call a halt today. We

also call on the Chancellor to scrap

1:53:191:53:26

the two child policy and immoral...

According to the IFS, the two child

1:53:261:53:35

cap on tax credits will mean around

600,000 families with three children

1:53:351:53:41

lose £2500 per year on average, and

300,000 families with four or more

1:53:411:53:46

children will lose a whopping £7,000

per year on average, and most of

1:53:461:53:50

these families are in work. If you

want to make work pay, then let's

1:53:501:53:54

remove that clause.

1:53:541:53:56

There is nothing in this budget for

Wimborne in the 19 50s, we're seeing

1:54:011:54:08

a rise in pensionable age up to six

years without proper notice.

1:54:081:54:12

Depriving millions of a pension they

paid for, they were entitled to.

1:54:121:54:16

Time and time again, the

Government's been asked to slow down

1:54:161:54:19

the current rate of increase and

women's pensionable age which is

1:54:191:54:23

increasing at three months for each

calendar month. Either the

1:54:231:54:27

Chancellor decides to act now and

deliver fairness to 1950s women or

1:54:271:54:32

he will find Parliament will do it

for him. There is a Private Members

1:54:321:54:38

Bill calling for mitigation to be

put in place for 1950s women. Let me

1:54:381:54:44

say to the Government, recognise the

cross-party nature of this bill and

1:54:441:54:48

actor face defeat. Whilst the Tories

attack on benefits pushing more

1:54:481:54:55

families into poverty, the financial

squeeze on household income

1:54:551:54:58

continues as Brexit bites. Today,

inflation sits at 3%. Prices are

1:54:581:55:04

risings at a faster rate than wages.

The Resolution Foundation calculated

1:55:041:55:09

3% inflation combined with the

benefits freeze will impact 7.3

1:55:091:55:14

million children, 2.4 million

disabled people and 800,000 people

1:55:141:55:17

looking for work. There is no answer

to that for the Chancellor. Nothing

1:55:171:55:22

in this budget. Let me tell the

Chancellor those on the Tory

1:55:221:55:26

benches, what life is like outside

the guilded rooms of Whitehall.

1:55:261:55:32

Electricity bills have increased by

9%. You laugh, you laugh when people

1:55:321:55:37

in Scotland and the rest of the UK

have seen electricity prices rise by

1:55:371:55:43

9%. You should be ashamed of

yourself. I hope your electorate

1:55:431:55:47

holds you to account. That, by the

way, was the so-called honourable

1:55:471:55:53

member for Ayr. Children's clothing

has increased by 6.7% in price.

1:55:531:56:00

Butter has increased by 12% in

price. Travel, bus and coach traffic

1:56:001:56:05

has increased by 13%. Train fairs by

3.4%. Transport insurance up by

1:56:051:56:11

1.6%. Motor vehicle insurance 13%.

Travel insurance 10 rest. That's the

1:56:111:56:20

reality for ordinary working people

in Scotland and the UK. Inflation is

1:56:201:56:24

making the cost of a weekly shop

soar and wages are falling. There is

1:56:241:56:30

nothing in this budget to address

that. The rise in inflation and

1:56:301:56:34

squeeze on wages is creating a

crisis for low income earners.

1:56:341:56:42

Between 2010 sand 201, official GDP

per employee had risen by 3.5% real

1:56:421:56:51

waging are 1.2% -- 1.1% lower. If

inflation is calculated to include

1:56:511:56:59

housings costs, real wages are down

by 7.2%. That's the economic record

1:56:591:57:03

of the Tory Government. The collapse

of UK productivity growth has driven

1:57:031:57:09

low growth and stagnant wages. But

whilst many of my constituencients

1:57:091:57:13

and families across the UK rely on

credit cards to put forward on the

1:57:131:57:18

table, a different story is

unfolding in the city. Under this

1:57:181:57:25

Tory Government, boardroom pay has

soared. From 2010-1016 the average

1:57:251:57:34

ewe numeration for CEOs almost

doubled. From 1.5-3.1 million. Mr

1:57:341:57:43

Deputy Speaker, the inequality goes

much deeper. European Commission

1:57:431:57:47

figures revealed the UK had the

biggest increase in the EU's gender

1:57:471:57:52

pay gap in 2015. The difference in

average hourly pay for male and

1:57:521:57:59

female workers jumped from 19.7% in

2014 to 70.8% in 2015. That means in

1:57:591:58:07

event women are working unpaid for

more than two months a year in

1:58:071:58:12

comparison to men. This Government

has not only driven thousands into

1:58:121:58:17

poverty, it has completely failed to

investment in building an inclusive

1:58:171:58:23

economy fit for future generations.

Legacy this Chancellor leaves is an

1:58:231:58:28

economy which only works for the

rich and reckless. We need tad fifty

1:58:281:58:34

to create circumstances to include

sustainable economic growth with

1:58:341:58:39

unthat would encourage investment

strive up productivity and living

1:58:391:58:44

standards, which recognises monetary

and fiscal policy have to work in

1:58:441:58:48

UNISON. What we've had is a focus on

monetary policy that's given up

1:58:481:58:53

house prices, stocks and shares but

failed to drive investment in the

1:58:531:58:56

real economy. Back in 2009

quantitative easing was an obvious

1:58:561:59:03

choice to be part of restoring

confidence in growth provided it was

1:59:031:59:07

matched with fiscal measures.

Particularly in vestings in

1:59:071:59:13

infrastructure and building capacity

in our economy. A chance to invest

1:59:131:59:16

in the economy to kick-start growth

and productivity. But under the

1:59:161:59:21

steer of this Government it was

invested to benefit the wealthy and,

1:59:211:59:25

in the end, has done nothing but

exacerbate the gap between rich and

1:59:251:59:29

poor. The Bank of England recognise

the negative effect caused by this

1:59:291:59:33

policy. In 2012, they said although

quantitative easing had increased as

1:59:331:59:41

set prices this had

disproportionately benefitted the

1:59:411:59:44

top 5% of the households. I can see

the Chancellor waiving his hands.

1:59:441:59:49

This is something which is

important. Something that he

1:59:491:59:54

ultimately has to take

responsibility for. Mr Deputy

1:59:541:59:59

Speaker, last year inflating as set

prices had exacerbated the gap

1:59:592:00:04

between rich and poor. They found

the 10% wreathiest of households

2:00:042:00:10

held 56% of net financial as sets in

2015. By 2014, the proportion of the

2:00:102:00:17

nation's welts had increased to 6 a

%. It is easy to see why the Tories

2:00:172:00:21

don't want to change this policy.

Reducing inequality has never been

2:00:212:00:25

one of their aims. The #e6ed is

stark. Quantitative easing has

2:00:252:00:31

mostly benefitted those who started

with considerable wealth. The FTSE

2:00:312:00:36

100 was sitting at 3,805 on 18th

March 2009 ahead of the QE programme

2:00:362:00:45

being launched. Last night, there

was a growth of 95% in just over

2:00:452:00:52

eight years. The Government has

stuffed cash into the pockets of the

2:00:522:00:58

wealthy whilst ordinary folk have

paid the price for austerity. The

2:00:582:01:03

cry, there's no money, flies in the

face of the Government's own agenda.

2:01:032:01:07

A further £70 billion was invested

in QE after the Brexit vote taking

2:01:072:01:13

the programme to £435 billion. That

is £435 billion on to our debt with

2:01:132:01:20

no plan, no plan as to how this will

be repaid. We could have invested in

2:01:202:01:27

our infrastructure, in housing,

dealing with the demand for housing

2:01:272:01:30

and dampening the rise in house

prices to affordable level as one

2:01:302:01:34

example. Investing in connectivity,

transport and digital, to allow our

2:01:342:01:40

citizens and businesses compete

effectively and not caught in the

2:01:402:01:43

slow lane of transport snarl-ups and

fighting to get decent broadband or

2:01:432:01:48

mobile connectivity. This investment

would have grown the economy, tax

2:01:482:01:52

receipts and allowed us to cut the

deficit. There would have been a pay

2:01:522:01:55

pack. That could have supported

businesses at the same time as

2:01:552:02:00

supporting people. Don't tell us

there's no money when you can invest

2:02:002:02:06

an additional £70 billion in QE at

the drop of a hat. Take proper

2:02:062:02:11

responsibility for creating the

circumstances for inclusive growth

2:02:112:02:14

and prosperity. Of course, taking

responsibility is not something that

2:02:142:02:19

this Government does. £6.9 billion

is lost to our schools and 4079s

2:02:192:02:27

every year because this Government

I'm calling on the Government to

2:02:272:02:33

take tough new action to ensure the

richest in society and the biggest

2:02:332:02:37

corporations pay the taxes they owe

in full. They have chosen to cut

2:02:372:02:42

public spending while protects the

super rich. Of course, the Tories

2:02:422:02:46

are the party of the super rich. If

they won't take the ass required,

2:02:462:02:51

devolve the powers needed to canle

the issue to the Scottish

2:02:512:02:54

Parliament. For I ask the Chancellor

last month on any assessment he has

2:02:542:03:00

made on the inter relationship

between monetary and fiscal policy,

2:03:002:03:03

the answer I got was that monetary

responsibility was the

2:03:032:03:08

responsibility of the bang Bank of

England. There was no regard for a

2:03:082:03:11

link between the two. It is left to

the Bank of England to shine the

2:03:112:03:17

light on the failure the Chancellor

to engaged and joined up thinking.

2:03:172:03:22

The Bank of England #5ed mitted the

steep rises in house prices in the

2:03:222:03:26

decade proceeding the crisis

together the with a fall in

2:03:262:03:29

long-term interest rates has led to

a sharp rise in inter generational

2:03:292:03:34

dis-Persian of wealth benefitting in

particular older people who had

2:03:342:03:37

already entered the market before

prices began to rise. This

2:03:372:03:43

Government has avoided every

opportunity to invest in young

2:03:432:03:45

people. What hope... The Chancellor

says rubbish. I'm giving facts from

2:03:452:03:54

respected institutions, not least

the Bank of England. Is the

2:03:542:03:56

Chancellor really saying 9 bank of

the Bank of England is wrong as

2:03:562:04:01

well? I think they might have

something to say. What hope it

2:04:012:04:05

Millenials have to cling on to?

Robbed of their housing allowance.

2:04:052:04:10

Lumbered with chronic student debt,

this Government's gone out of its

2:04:102:04:14

way to avoid investing in young

people. The inter generational

2:04:142:04:17

wealth and fairness is creating the

perfect storm for future

2:04:172:04:21

generations. Research from the

Resolution Foundation shows today's

2:04:212:04:26

27-year-olds are earning the same

amount 27-year-olds did a quarter of

2:04:262:04:33

a century ago. A typical millennial

has earned £8,000 less in their

2:04:332:04:39

twenty than those in the proceeding

generation. We've missed chance

2:04:392:04:42

after chance to invest in inclusive

growth opportunities. The Government

2:04:422:04:48

has been the proverbial one club

golfer relying on monetary measures

2:04:482:04:52

in a vacuum. Even the IFS warned the

Chancellor on his calculations.

2:04:522:04:57

First of all, we had George Osborne

pro claim he wanted to balance the

2:04:572:05:03

books by 2015. That didn't happen.

Now the current Chancellor wants to

2:05:032:05:09

eliminate borrowing by 2020. Even

the IFS called on him to abandon his

2:05:092:05:15

fanciful fiscal targets. There is

more uncertainty on forecast now

2:05:152:05:20

than ever before. The Chancellor

himself told the Treasury committee

2:05:202:05:25

a cloud of uncertainty is acting as

a temporary dampner and we need to

2:05:252:05:29

remove it as soon as possible. Well,

there was nothing in that budget

2:05:292:05:34

today to remove it. But, I'm in a

giving mood. I'll give the

2:05:342:05:41

Chancellor a bit of fundamental

economic advice. End the suicidal

2:05:412:05:47

flirtation with a no deal scenario.

Give business something to invest in

2:05:472:05:51

and work on keeping the UK in the

single market. The stupidity and

2:05:512:05:56

recklessness of some on front bench

who rode around on a famous red bus

2:05:562:06:00

has been the most damaging economic

pledge in modern history. £350

2:06:002:06:05

million a week, they said for the

NHS. Well, they're silent on that

2:06:052:06:09

now. The Foreign Secretary and the

Environment Secretary should listen

2:06:092:06:13

up. Here are some home truths about

the mess they've created. The Bank

2:06:132:06:19

of England confirmed 75,000 jobs are

at risk in the financial sector due

2:06:192:06:24

to Brexit. The LSE revealed

Scotland's towns and cities could

2:06:242:06:28

lose up to £340 billion over five

years. Brexit would cost Scotland up

2:06:282:06:34

to 80,000 jobs and see camings fall

by £2,000 a head per year. Now the

2:06:342:06:40

Chancellor is planning for a no

deal. A complete catastrophe. That's

2:06:402:06:47

unfolding under his watch. He knows

how devastating such a math would be

2:06:472:06:52

for the UK economy. He's given

departments £250 million to carry

2:06:522:06:57

out work in preparation. To put this

in contest, that would pay for

2:06:572:07:06

11,553 new starter nurses, teachers

or police officers. It is not just

2:07:062:07:10

the funding Brexit that's costing

commune. Leaving the EU will cut off

2:07:102:07:14

the financial social funds we've

benefitted from for so long. This

2:07:142:07:17

will be devastating for communities

where poverty and destitution at the

2:07:172:07:22

hands of the Tories have vene

volunteers pick up the pieces. As

2:07:222:07:28

the UK haemorrhages EU funding and

the Chancellor pro claims austerity

2:07:282:07:33

is essential he managed to find £1

billion for the DUP. Quite

2:07:332:07:37

remarkable. The Chancellor found £1

billion for devolved areas in the

2:07:372:07:43

Northern Ireland executive to spend

but no additional funds provided for

2:07:432:07:48

Scotland or any other part of the

you can. Cash for votes, not very

2:07:482:07:51

honourable at all. What use are

they? The Scottish Conservative

2:07:512:07:56

benches who pledge to work as a

block to protect Scotland's

2:07:562:08:01

interests that was your chance to

shine. A golden opportunity to show

2:08:012:08:07

they were prepared to put politics

aside and stand up for Scotland. But

2:08:072:08:13

no, party loyalty prevailed and

Scotland is being overlooked in this

2:08:132:08:16

dodgy deal. This money cannot be

post Tested until the discussions

2:08:162:08:20

have concluded on the

appropriateness and the way in which

2:08:202:08:23

the UK Government decided to provide

the addition financial support. The

2:08:232:08:30

Barnet rules mean Scotland, Wales

and Northern Ireland are entitled to

2:08:302:08:35

an extra £2.9 billion as a result of

deal. Where the Scottish Tories

2:08:352:08:39

standing can up for that £2.9

billion Scotland he is defshs? Gone

2:08:392:08:45

are the calls for the Scottish

Tories, UK Government to match the

2:08:452:08:49

deal for Northern Ireland. They've

been found wanting. Year after year,

2:08:492:08:54

the UK Government continues to let

down our world-class oil and gas

2:08:542:08:58

industry in the north-east of

Scotland.

2:08:582:09:03

Two years ago, Mr Deputy Speaker,

the Conservatives boasted about the

2:09:032:09:07

creation of a new oil and gas

ambassador. It would promote the

2:09:072:09:11

North Sea around the world and boost

investment. How embarrassing, then,

2:09:112:09:15

for the Chancellor that the role,

two years later, has yet to be

2:09:152:09:21

built. It seems that the Chancellor

and his cabinet colleagues have

2:09:212:09:24

simply forgotten about our North Sea

industry once again. Despite the

2:09:242:09:28

Chancellor's tight grip restraining

skull and's economic potential, the

2:09:282:09:34

SNP in Scotland have delivered our

people.

Anna Soubry.

Mr Deputy

2:09:342:09:42

Speaker, is it in order for

honourable members to make speeches

2:09:422:09:46

where they completely ignore the

contents of the budget that the

2:09:462:09:51

Chancellor has just delivered?

Order, order. There's two good

2:09:512:09:57

things, isn't there? We've got a

slight break. One, it was definitely

2:09:572:10:01

not a point of order and you know it

wasn't, completely not a point of

2:10:012:10:05

order. The fact is, we've had a

running commentary from you all the

2:10:052:10:08

way through. I think I've heard more

than enough from the time being and

2:10:082:10:12

I certainly want to get to the end

of the leader of the SNP.

Thank you,

2:10:122:10:19

Mr Deputy Speaker. In Scotland,

international exports are up 41%

2:10:192:10:24

between 2007-2015, the latest on

imported figures show that Scotland

2:10:242:10:29

has higher unemployment rate and

lower implement rates with UK and

2:10:292:10:34

use and continues to outperform UK.

The Scottish Government the filled

2:10:342:10:37

its commitment to reduce youth

unemployment for years ahead of

2:10:372:10:40

schedule, that is how you make

visible targets, it is not just

2:10:402:10:43

about the ability of the Scottish

Government to deliver an inclusive

2:10:432:10:46

society that works for all, it is

our vision for an economy that

2:10:462:10:49

benefits all and the UK Government

chose the break clause, the Scottish

2:10:492:10:57

Government chose the baby box. When

the UK Government tripled tuition

2:10:572:11:01

fees, the Scottish Government

maintained a Brisbane Roar free

2:11:012:11:03

tuition for all. When the

Conservatives pushed for a dementia

2:11:032:11:06

tax, the Scottish Government stood

by free personal care for the

2:11:062:11:09

elderly. We know that an economy is

not just a tool for inclusive growth

2:11:092:11:14

but it is central to the social

fabric of the society which we grow

2:11:142:11:18

up. It is time for an economy that

benefits all. And damaging austerity

2:11:182:11:25

agenda and stop the catastrophic

ideological obsession with a Brexit

2:11:252:11:28

no deal.

Just, order. Just to say,

we are going over to ten minute

2:11:282:11:38

speeches and it will be ten minutes

from when we start but I have a

2:11:382:11:42

point of order.

Mr Deputy Speaker,

this morning in Cabinet questions,

2:11:422:11:47

the first Secretary of State claimed

the consultation on the contaminated

2:11:472:11:50

blood scandal had been extended

until the end of October this year

2:11:502:11:54

at the request of the APPG, this was

not correct and in fact the APPG had

2:11:542:11:59

asked for an extension of the

original date of the consultation

2:11:592:12:02

which was in August 2000 17. Many

people have contacted me you are

2:12:022:12:06

concerned that this is now being

made on the announcement of the

2:12:062:12:12

chair and terms of reference and I

wondered if there is a way of

2:12:122:12:15

correcting the record?

I think you

have achieved that I do have

2:12:152:12:20

corrected the record and put it on

the record for now. Right, let's

2:12:202:12:23

continue with a ten minute remit,

Nadim Zahawi 's.

Thank you Mr Deputy

2:12:232:12:29

Speaker and it is a relief to rise

after the previous speech from the

2:12:292:12:35

SNP spokesman. It was actually

longer than the official opposition

2:12:352:12:40

response, and it was riveting. Mr

Deputy Speaker, the budget

2:12:402:12:47

resolutions always tend to be about

figures and statements which can be

2:12:472:12:54

quite dry and are very often leaked

before the actual budget speech

2:12:542:12:58

itself. I was delighted today,

absolutely delighted, that of the

2:12:582:13:04

headline measures in this speech,

the removal of the 300,000... Sorry,

2:13:042:13:10

removal of stamp duty on properties

up to £300,000 was to be scrapped.

2:13:102:13:15

-- the stamp duty on properties. I'm

delighted that measure was not

2:13:152:13:19

leaked and was an exciting moment,

and one of the are many measures...

2:13:192:13:25

I thank my honourable friend were

giving way, something the benches

2:13:252:13:28

opposite were not prepared to do for

whatever reason. Does my honourable

2:13:282:13:32

friend really believe that the

policy announced by the Chancellor

2:13:322:13:36

in respect of stamp duty presents an

almighty challenge to the Scottish

2:13:362:13:39

Government? Their land buildings and

transaction tax has been an

2:13:392:13:44

unmitigated disaster. Does she think

that the leader of the SNP should be

2:13:442:13:49

going to the First Minister and

suggesting that the policy is

2:13:492:13:52

followed in Scotland?

I'm very sure

that they have had the honourable

2:13:522:13:57

member's point and will be taking at

Ford, I imagine tomorrow. -- they

2:13:572:14:02

have heard. Mr Deputy Speaker, one

of the issues about homeownership in

2:14:022:14:05

the UK is it is very close to my

heart, it is actually the reason I

2:14:052:14:09

became a Conservative MP in the

first base. We are seeing now in

2:14:092:14:14

these measures today one of the

biggest and most... It's a

2:14:142:14:19

revolution in house-building in the

UK, 300,000 homes per year, plus the

2:14:192:14:25

establishment of homes England which

will bring together all of the

2:14:252:14:28

strands that we need to make this

target possible. Taking, looking at

2:14:282:14:35

those... The planning applications,

the training of skilled Artisans and

2:14:352:14:42

workmen to build those homes. Homes

England is going to be an authority

2:14:422:14:45

that will be required to drive

forward to that degree of

2:14:452:14:49

homeownership but it is sometimes

very easy to forget what

2:14:492:14:51

homeownership means to so many

people. We haven't seen measures

2:14:512:14:57

like this introduced in the UK since

the 1970s. And I think that probably

2:14:572:15:03

in this house, I may be one of the

members who understands the value of

2:15:032:15:06

homeownership more than most. I was,

I lived in a council house until I

2:15:062:15:12

was in my late 20s. And I was

reminded of this in 2017 when I was

2:15:122:15:20

canvassing in a constituency which

is not mine, in Luton, in Stockley

2:15:202:15:27

Ward. When I knocked at the Lady's

door, she said, "I know you, you are

2:15:272:15:32

not standing here but I wouldn't

vote for you anyway because you

2:15:322:15:37

support homeownership". And I found

this quite remarkable because I was

2:15:372:15:42

on a private, well appointed home.

-- I was at a private. She told me,

2:15:422:15:48

we had a discussion which was a

similar moment for me. She says,

2:15:482:15:52

"The thing is, I'm a trade unionist

and I don't want, I bore Right To

2:15:522:16:00

Buy, I abhor homeownership because

people who have mortgages to pay

2:16:002:16:02

won't strike"

2:16:022:16:04

people who have mortgages to pay

won't strike". We went on to have a

2:16:042:16:08

discussion about how people, when

they buy their own homes, regard

2:16:082:16:13

their own private capital over and

above social capital and she was a

2:16:132:16:18

very principled lady, I believed.

She had very strong points of view

2:16:182:16:22

and I never want to diminish zombie

's's point of view, it is just as

2:16:222:16:27

relevant as mine. She can ball

homeownership to the same extent

2:16:272:16:31

that I adore homeownership. -- she

can a poor homeownership. But we had

2:16:312:16:35

an sting last sentence when she told

me it was her own home, not private

2:16:352:16:42

rented accommodation. That was an

interesting moment but I took a

2:16:422:16:45

points on board. But I tried to

explain to her the reason why,

2:16:452:16:50

because she said to me, "You

shouldn't be a conservative, you

2:16:502:16:54

should be a Labour politician, you

have come from a council estate I

2:16:542:16:57

know your background"

2:16:572:16:59

have come from a council estate I

know your background". It was really

2:16:592:17:00

interesting because I did, and I

witnessed what happens to people

2:17:002:17:05

when they are given the opportunity

to buy their own home. I will try to

2:17:052:17:10

give a description of what it is

like to not own your own house

2:17:102:17:15

because so many people are in that

position right now. On the estate I

2:17:152:17:18

lived in, every door was painted the

same colour. It was painted by the

2:17:182:17:21

council. The gardens on the ground

floors were divided by packing cases

2:17:212:17:28

and palettes, wooden pallets. There

were no flowers and what were

2:17:282:17:32

gardens had become patches of mud.

Life was pretty great and people

2:17:322:17:38

worked at Ford and nobody had any

particular aspiration to do anything

2:17:382:17:42

else. But when people began to own

those council houses, it was as

2:17:422:17:47

though it changed overnight. People

started to paint their own front

2:17:472:17:51

doors, their own colours, expressing

their individuality. The packing

2:17:512:17:55

cases were ripped up and painted

fences were put in their place.

2:17:552:17:59

Flowers were planted in the gardens.

People started working overtime. The

2:17:592:18:05

very first car was bought and

arrived in our road. My mother, who

2:18:052:18:08

was a teacher, was almost giving

knightly class to people knocking on

2:18:082:18:13

the door and wanting to have lessons

because they wanted to go out, women

2:18:132:18:17

who wanted to go out to work. I

regarded homeownership at that time

2:18:172:18:22

as a driver for equality for women

because women and almost a reason to

2:18:222:18:27

break free on the kitchen sink and

get out to work. -- from the kitchen

2:18:272:18:34

sink. I saw a transformation happen

on the estate I lived because of

2:18:342:18:37

homeownership. It is about family

stability also because people who

2:18:372:18:45

don't own their own homes, rent,

families rent and that is the most

2:18:452:18:48

unstable position for a family to

live in, you are facing may be

2:18:482:18:52

having to move every six months, you

are facing not the kind of

2:18:522:18:55

properties you want to live in, not

the areas you want to live in which

2:18:552:18:59

is why people being able to buy

their own homes, decide where they

2:18:592:19:03

live, where they send their children

to school... I will give way.

I

2:19:032:19:07

thank my honourable friend for

giving way, making a typically

2:19:072:19:11

powerful argument and is she aware

that this drives people to aspire to

2:19:112:19:16

own their own home, so 80% of people

who read want to own?

Absolutely and

2:19:162:19:21

that is exactly the point I'm coming

on to. I have spoken to a number of

2:19:212:19:26

people who actually work here, our

staff. One of the most startling

2:19:262:19:31

facts about our staff who work here

is that they have to wait until they

2:19:312:19:35

are in at least their mid-30s before

they can even think of putting

2:19:352:19:41

effort on the property ladder and

what I hope these measures that have

2:19:412:19:45

been announced today will do is help

those people, the abolition of the

2:19:452:19:48

stamp duty and all the measures that

we putting in place to become

2:19:482:19:51

homeowners. Of course.

I'm listening

carefully to what she says and I've

2:19:512:19:58

been a long-standing supporter and

champion of people being able to own

2:19:582:20:02

their own homes but has she read

what the OBR says about the stamp

2:20:022:20:07

duty, that in fact, it won't help

first-time buyers, it will push up

2:20:072:20:12

prices by far more than they would

actually save?

I thank my honourable

2:20:122:20:19

friend for that contribution and

that is exactly what the point the

2:20:192:20:23

Chancellor made during his speech,

he made the point that other

2:20:232:20:26

measures also needed to be made in

conjunction with the abolition of

2:20:262:20:29

the stamp duty, which is the

investment had a lot I will give way

2:20:292:20:32

once more because it only ten

minutes.

The desire to purchase your

2:20:322:20:39

own them and I have a niece who

lived in a council flat until three

2:20:392:20:42

years ago and she chose to purchase

the flat before the Scottish

2:20:422:20:45

Government banned the sale of houses

and would have denied her ownership

2:20:452:20:52

and in purchasing have flat, she

saved £150 per month.

I thank the

2:20:522:20:58

honourable gentleman for that

statement and it is another

2:20:582:21:00

illustration of how important it is

for people to be able to purchase

2:21:002:21:03

their own homes. In response to the

honourable lady, I can go through

2:21:032:21:08

the list, abolishing stamp duty,

investing an additional 15 billion

2:21:082:21:15

for house building, taking £44

billion, the total, for this

2:21:152:21:19

parliament, it is the other measures

along with stamp duty. People can't

2:21:192:21:23

own their own homes, though, if

there are not people to build those

2:21:232:21:27

homes. I welcome the review into

looking at, just in London alone,

2:21:272:21:34

the 270,000 planning permissions, I

welcome the review into looking at

2:21:342:21:36

why those homes have not been built.

It is not just in London but in my

2:21:362:21:41

constituency and all across the

country. Measures have been put in

2:21:412:21:44

place to help councils build more,

it is vitally important we have more

2:21:442:21:48

council homes, authorities need to

be able to have the powers and

2:21:482:21:51

ability to do that. We need those

targets, Brown, urban sites,

2:21:512:21:56

brownfield sites which have laid

dormant. We all know the areas

2:21:562:22:04

around Heathrow and those areas in

outer London. People work in London

2:22:042:22:07

and they want to live in London and

be able to afford to buy in London,

2:22:072:22:10

not have to travel two hours commute

into London to be able to work. I

2:22:102:22:13

believe all this is being looked at

which will enable so many young

2:22:132:22:16

people in this capital, who want to

be able to buy their home and simply

2:22:162:22:20

have not been able to do so but not

just in the capital, in my

2:22:202:22:24

constituency in mid-Bedfordshire.

One of the complaints I hear more

2:22:242:22:28

often than any other in my mailbox

is young people who want to stay and

2:22:282:22:32

live in mid-Bedfordshire and buy

their home in mid-Bedfordshire but

2:22:322:22:35

simply are unable to do so and are

forced out. You know, not everybody

2:22:352:22:40

in my constituency will work on my

words that I want to see more

2:22:402:22:44

house-building but I absolutely do

because we have to accept now is the

2:22:442:22:47

time, when we have got to the

position where we need to build more

2:22:472:22:52

homes and I have been distressed for

the last 12 years that the entire

2:22:522:22:56

time I have been here, there has

been little emphasis on the need, on

2:22:562:23:00

the understanding, of the psyche of

people and the desire people have to

2:23:002:23:05

live in their own homes and to

purchase their own homes. I am

2:23:052:23:09

delighted today, relieved that that

is finally being addressed. I think

2:23:092:23:15

I would like to finish, Mr Deputy

Speaker, by saying that the

2:23:152:23:20

Chancellor also mentioned in his

speech today, in the budget

2:23:202:23:25

resolution, the East-West Ark, the

Varsity arc, the Cambridge to Oxford

2:23:252:23:29

arc which is going to have road and

rail investment. That will go right

2:23:292:23:34

past my constituency in

mid-Bedfordshire. I am delighted

2:23:342:23:39

that it will bring high-tech jobs,

it will build skills and

2:23:392:23:42

infrastructure and will drive growth

forward. As the Chancellor said,

2:23:422:23:45

that is going to be embracing

innovation, embracing the future and

2:23:452:23:50

change, it is what we are going to

need in a post-Brexit Britain. We

2:23:502:23:55

need those high-tech jobs. We need

those gross corridors as winners in

2:23:552:23:59

the Midlands, the West and East Link

has been needed for so long but

2:23:592:24:03

never been addressed. It is vital

and important and it is essential

2:24:032:24:07

for post-Brexit growth, when I think

we are going to become an island of

2:24:072:24:14

opportunity, an island of

development, an island of investment

2:24:142:24:16

and growth and the announcements

that have been made today, as well

2:24:162:24:21

as the financial measures put in for

Brexit and the preparation for

2:24:212:24:24

Brexit, I think we are going to be

ready to embrace that post-Brexit

2:24:242:24:29

world, with the East-West corridor,

the Midlands grows, the Northern

2:24:292:24:32

Powerhouse and all the other

measures that have been mentioned

2:24:322:24:35

today which I wholly welcome.

2:24:352:24:37

It is a privilege to follow the

honourable lady for Mid

2:24:412:24:47

Bedfordshire. A fear the budget

today delivers more of the say and

2:24:472:24:50

does very little to help people in

the every day economy struggling to

2:24:502:24:53

get by, to get a foot on the housing

ladder, to grow their business or to

2:24:532:24:58

get security in work. I'm going to

focus on two particular aspects of

2:24:582:25:03

budget in my remarks. First that

will be on GDP and productivity and

2:25:032:25:09

secondly, as the honourable lady for

mid-Behred Ford shire, on the issue

2:25:092:25:14

of housing supply and house prices.

First of all on GDP and

2:25:142:25:21

productivity, the biggest influence

on our standard of living, whether

2:25:212:25:24

we can afford to pay the bills. How

we're doing. Whether our families

2:25:242:25:28

can get on and do better than the

generation before is how fast the

2:25:282:25:33

economy's growing. From that most

important metric, I think, today, we

2:25:332:25:38

can only regard the budget as a

failure in Government economic

2:25:382:25:41

policy. In every single year of the

forecast period, economic growth's

2:25:412:25:48

revised downwards. That is not from

particularly high levels in the

2:25:482:25:51

first place. But this is a further

downward revision since just March

2:25:512:25:55

of this year. I think that is very

worrying for many families all

2:25:552:26:00

across our country in all of cower

constituencies. By 2022, believe GDP

2:26:002:26:10

will be 7% low enthan it was

predicted in March. About 80% of

2:26:102:26:15

that downgrade in the level of our

GDP is because of lower productivity

2:26:152:26:22

in that period. It is expected to be

27% lower than it would have been if

2:26:222:26:27

it had carried on growing at its

pre-crisis levels. This is

2:26:272:26:31

incredibly worrying. If we are going

to compete with countries all around

2:26:312:26:35

the world outside of the European

Union we need to boost our product

2:26:352:26:41

specificity, research, development,

business investment, investment in

2:26:412:26:45

infrastructure and all the numbers

from budget of responsibility today

2:26:452:26:50

suggest we're doing the opposite.

Going in the wrong direction in

2:26:502:26:54

those most important economic

numbers on GDP and on productivity.

2:26:542:26:58

We are already, as you know, 20%

behind the United States, Japan and

2:26:582:27:06

ge any Germany in terms of

productivity. We cannot afford to

2:27:062:27:11

have further downgrades in

productivity. They have a real

2:27:112:27:15

effect on Government borrowing and

Government debt. Over the forecast

2:27:152:27:18

period, over the next five years,

this downgrade to productivity adds

2:27:182:27:25

a staggering £90 billion to our

borrowing trajectory. Worrying for

2:27:252:27:30

standards of living but in terms of

the public finances. We are not able

2:27:302:27:33

to put the money we need into

Universal Credit, infrastructure,

2:27:332:27:40

National Health Service, our schools

because we are not delivering on

2:27:402:27:44

those productive, well paid jobs.

The Government have to take

2:27:442:27:48

responsibility for that. I look

forward to the industrial strategy

2:27:482:27:53

White Paper being published next

week. But I have to say to the

2:27:532:27:57

Government, it has to be a lot

better than the Green Paper we saw

2:27:572:28:02

alar this year which was incredibly

disappointing and simply won't

2:28:022:28:05

deliver the types of prod you can

I've tiffity and performance we

2:28:052:28:08

need. It is 18 months since the

Government's productivity strategy.

2:28:082:28:12

Since then, every estimate of

productivity has been downwards and

2:28:122:28:16

not upwards. What a failed

opportunity and what a failed

2:28:162:28:19

strategy. I will give way.

She's

making in extremely powerful speech.

2:28:192:28:26

Will she agree prod you can tiff I

will never increase while we exclude

2:28:262:28:30

important parts of society. The

industrial strategy didn't mention

2:28:302:28:35

disabled people neither did the

Chancellor today. The budget is

2:28:352:28:38

simply not inclusive. That

That is a

very good point. To ensure everybody

2:28:382:28:44

benefits from a growing economy,

we've just about got growth but not

2:28:442:28:47

very much of it, to ensure everyone

benefits, we need to have an

2:28:472:28:52

incluesive economy and economic

strategy that works for everybody in

2:28:522:28:54

all of our communities. The

Government might respond by saying

2:28:542:29:00

it's OK, Labour members, there's a

productivity investment fund worth

2:29:002:29:04

£7 billion. But the money doesn't

start until 2022/23. Five years we

2:29:042:29:10

have to wait for a productivity

investment fund. Why is that? We all

2:29:102:29:16

recognise there is a desperate need

to improve productivity why wait

2:29:162:29:20

five years before we put money and

support into doing that? I thought

2:29:202:29:23

that would have been an urgent

priority at this budget not

2:29:232:29:26

something that can be kicked down

the road and we put into place in

2:29:262:29:32

five years' time. I want to come to

the issue of housing. I'm afraid I'm

2:29:322:29:37

much less optimistic about the

Government's plans today compared

2:29:372:29:42

with the honourable member for Mid

Bedfordshire. Over the last hour or

2:29:422:29:48

so, I've been looking at the Office

for Budget Responsibility's economic

2:29:482:29:53

and fiscal outlook. The truth is, if

you read this, I know not everybody

2:29:532:29:57

likes to listen to experts, I'm one

of those people who still thinks

2:29:572:30:01

they are worth listening to. If you

believe what the experts at the

2:30:012:30:09

office Office for Budget

Responsibility are saying, they say,

2:30:092:30:12

the measures taken in totality, not

just the stamp duty measure but the

2:30:122:30:15

whole lot of measures on housing in

this budget will increase house

2:30:152:30:21

prices by 0.3% and there will be no

change in the supply of housing

2:30:212:30:26

compared with the budget in March.

So, despite all the fanfare today,

2:30:262:30:31

the verdict of the Office for Budget

Responsibility, on page 53 of their

2:30:312:30:39

document, says impact no change in

supply and an increase in house

2:30:392:30:42

prices. The opposite of what we need

if we want to ensure more young

2:30:422:30:46

people and families can get on the

housing ladder. Something we all

2:30:462:30:51

share as an objective but not set by

the measures today.

I can understand

2:30:512:30:57

the honourable lady interpreting

that report and having concerns. For

2:30:572:31:01

an area like St Albans where the

average house price is over

2:31:012:31:06

£500,000, the previous Chancellor

helped young people on to the ladder

2:31:062:31:09

and this Chancellor will help them

save money towards house prices. It

2:31:092:31:13

will be welcomed by many high house

price areas. Surely she must accept

2:31:132:31:18

the stamp duty is a welcome measure.

I'm not making my own forecast, it

2:31:182:31:23

is from the Office for Budget

Responsibility. What people in St

2:31:232:31:29

Albans, Mid Bedfordshire and Leeds

West is affordable housing, to be

2:31:292:31:32

able to get on to the housing

ladder. For that, we need stable

2:31:322:31:39

house prices and an increase in

supply. But there will be no

2:31:392:31:43

improvement in housing supply on the

basis of the measures today and that

2:31:432:31:47

also house prices will be 0.3%

higher than they would otherwise

2:31:472:31:51

have been. So, it's not going to

have the desired effect. I

2:31:512:31:56

understand the honourable lady wants

her constituents to get those

2:31:562:32:02

opportunities. The measures her

Chancellor's taken today doesn't

2:32:022:32:05

sound like it will achieve. In fact,

I would say it will have the

2:32:052:32:10

opposite affect. I'll make a little

more progress. In a north box they

2:32:102:32:21

say on the basis of their analysis,

post the changes to stamp duty, the

2:32:212:32:27

prices paid by first time buyers

would be higher with the relief than

2:32:272:32:31

without it. And thus, they argue,

the main gainers from the policy on

2:32:312:32:36

stamp duty today are people who

already own their property not the

2:32:362:32:40

first time buyers themselves. I

would say, I think that's a terrible

2:32:402:32:45

indictment of the policies on

housing. If that was supposed to be

2:32:452:32:50

the fanfare of the budget today, I'm

afraid it ends up a bit of a damp

2:32:502:32:54

squib. I'll give way to my

honourable friend.

Doesn't my

2:32:542:33:02

honourable friend think it is absurd

to have a stamp duty limit for first

2:33:022:33:07

time buyers of 500,000 which implies

an income of £150,000.

If you look

2:33:072:33:16

at the earnings forecast, it is

another impediment for people

2:33:162:33:19

getting on the housing ladder. You

need incomes keeping pace with the

2:33:192:33:24

rising cost of living and house

prices and forecast for average

2:33:242:33:28

earnings suggest it will be harder

still for many people to get on the

2:33:282:33:30

housing ladder. I'll take a short

intervention.

Would she accept and

2:33:302:33:37

agree with me an injection of

300,000 homes per year, if that

2:33:372:33:42

target's reached will have an affect

of stabilising the price of homes at

2:33:422:33:47

the very least because the supply

will be increased in a way it's

2:33:472:33:51

never been since the 1970s?

Isle

I'll say this argument is not with

2:33:512:33:57

me, it is for the budge the of

responsibility. They say these

2:33:572:34:02

measures will benefit existing house

owners rather than those trying to

2:34:022:34:05

get on the housing leaded ladder.

That's disappointing. The additional

2:34:052:34:10

300,000 homes a year is like the

productivity investment fund. They

2:34:102:34:13

are not set to be delivered until

the mid-2020s. The honourable lady

2:34:132:34:19

and all honourable members across

the house will recognise we need to

2:34:192:34:22

be building the houses now. We don't

have seven or eight years to wait.

2:34:222:34:28

People need those homes today. I

will finish my speech with a couple

2:34:282:34:34

of remarks about Europe. The truth

is, the biggest economic

2:34:342:34:41

announcements, really, for the rest

of this year will be the decisions

2:34:412:34:44

made in the middle of December about

whether or not to move the talks on

2:34:442:34:48

between the European Commission and

the UK Government on to trade and

2:34:482:34:54

the final agreement between the UK

and EU about future trading

2:34:542:34:59

relationships. While the Chancellor

makes these announcements today, the

2:34:592:35:05

most important announces for our

constituents will be made in just a

2:35:052:35:09

fee weeks' time. I would urge the

Government in that time to reflect

2:35:092:35:12

on some of the evidence heard by my

select committee in the last couple

2:35:122:35:16

of weeks. Honda gave evidence to our

select committee saying the cost of

2:35:162:35:21

exporting a car would be about

£1,800 more than it is today. That

2:35:212:35:28

amount far outweighs their profit

margins risking investment and jobs

2:35:282:35:31

in this country. We also heard

evidence from Aston Martin who said

2:35:312:35:37

if they cannot get their vehicles

certificated by the agency in this

2:35:372:35:42

country they'd have to stop

production whilst they seek that

2:35:422:35:46

authorisation from the European

Union. Yesterday, we took evidence

2:35:462:35:50

from the Aerospace sector from

Airbus. Airbus said there are

2:35:502:35:53

country knocking on their doors

asking to build the wings of

2:35:532:35:57

aeroplanes in their country. The

risks of friction in trade will have

2:35:572:36:03

very real implications for their

businesses and very many others. I

2:36:032:36:06

would just end by urging the

Government, in the next fee walks,

2:36:062:36:11

to do everything -- weeks, to do

everything they can to move talks on

2:36:112:36:15

to the next level in Europe. If they

don't issues about prod you can I've

2:36:152:36:21

tiffity, housing, earnings, will be

pretty meaningless if those jobs

2:36:212:36:26

move overseas and we can't have that

free trade and frictionless trade we

2:36:262:36:33

benefit so much from today.

I remind

the House of the business interests

2:36:332:36:38

I declared in the register. A few

weeks Alling, I strongly criticised

2:36:382:36:43

for some for daring to say we wanted

realistically optimistic forecasts.

2:36:432:36:49

I'm delighted the latest set of

official forecasts are more

2:36:492:36:53

realistically optimistic than the

forecasts immediately after the

2:36:532:36:56

referendum vote. We were told we'd

plunge into recession, the British

2:36:562:37:01

economy would be badly damaged. I

thought that was completely wrong at

2:37:012:37:05

the time, I'm pleased to have been

on the winning side. It is welcome

2:37:052:37:09

today to see a more realistic set of

forecasts. I think they're still a

2:37:092:37:14

tad pessimistic for next year and

the year after but are broadly in

2:37:142:37:18

the right direction. The reason

they've been downgraded in the way

2:37:182:37:22

some on the Labour side are

objecting, is the OBR now doesn't

2:37:222:37:26

think we can get back the rate of

productivity growth we had before

2:37:262:37:30

the crash because the rate of

productivity growth has been very

2:37:302:37:33

disappointed around the world. I now

find I'm facing extremely distorted

2:37:332:37:39

interpretations of something I wrote

more recently. I would like to

2:37:392:37:44

absolutely sure the House then, as

now, I'm extremely confident about

2:37:442:37:48

the prospects for the British

economy. There's been a lot of

2:37:482:37:53

inward investment into the UK

economy. Those inward involvement

2:37:532:37:56

people are very wise. I think the

UK's a great place for people who

2:37:562:38:00

want to set up a factory, expand a

business, take on commercial space,

2:38:002:38:06

hire a good workforce. I see they

think it is ridiculous. That Haas

2:38:062:38:10

always been my view. Anyone who

suggests that is not my view is

2:38:102:38:14

making it up. I would like to get

that very firmly on the record. They

2:38:142:38:19

should read the whole article and

understand the point I was making

2:38:192:38:23

but clearly they weren't able to.

Can we get productivity up? The

2:38:232:38:28

Chancellor's made some very good

proposals in his budget. But it will

2:38:282:38:32

take time. What it really comes down

to is education, mentoring,

2:38:322:38:37

training, it is about taking our

economy on that next part of the

2:38:372:38:40

journey. The recovery since the

crash of 2009 has been gradual but

2:38:402:38:47

progressive. The Government rightly

takes pride in the success that many

2:38:472:38:51

British businesses and people to

generate three million extra jobs

2:38:512:38:55

and get many more people into work.

The next part of the journey is to

2:38:552:38:59

try and get people into better paid

work. That is about the Government

2:38:592:39:04

and the FE colleges and the

universities and schools working

2:39:042:39:07

with young people and with people

already in work on training

2:39:072:39:11

programmes so they get the extra

skills they can adapt and improve.

2:39:112:39:14

It is easier to get a better paid

job from a job than to get one from

2:39:142:39:19

unemployment.

2:39:192:39:26

And also building on the

apprenticeship scheme which has been

2:39:262:39:32

doing such a good job in getting

young people forward on a different

2:39:322:39:35

route.

Yes, indeed and I hope the

public sector will take this on

2:39:352:39:40

board as well as the private sector.

We are going to face a very major

2:39:402:39:55

revolution, as the Chancellor has

been indicating, from robots,

2:39:552:40:00

artificial intelligence, all kinds

of applications of the digital

2:40:002:40:03

economy. We see how great companies

are making huge changes and having a

2:40:032:40:08

big knock-on effect on more

traditional businesses. So, we need

2:40:082:40:12

to put all our weight behind a

government which wishes to

2:40:122:40:16

understand that revolution and to

try and make sure that more people

2:40:162:40:19

are winners from it, by changing

jobs

2:40:192:40:22

are winners from it, by changing

jobs, developing new skills, so that

2:40:222:40:27

their career can respond. Quite

rightly the attention in this budget

2:40:272:40:32

is on whether there will be enough

money to do a decent job for public

2:40:322:40:36

services. I also want to make sure

that my local schools have enough

2:40:362:40:41

money to pay good features and to

have enough teachers. And I want to

2:40:412:40:46

make sure that my local hospital and

surgeries have enough financial

2:40:462:40:49

support to do a good job. And I see

from this particular budget that

2:40:492:40:55

there is a £6 billion overall fiscal

relaxation in 2018-19 and £10

2:40:552:41:04

billion the following year. I'm sure

from what the Chancellor said that

2:41:042:41:08

as some relaxation of the pay

agreements occurs, when we will see

2:41:082:41:15

money coming forward in order to

meet those bills. It is very

2:41:152:41:19

important that the Health Service

and schools have the money to be

2:41:192:41:22

able to meet those particular

requirements. I think a very modest

2:41:222:41:28

fiscal relaxation like that is

eminently affordable, I don't think

2:41:282:41:31

the current levels of debt or

deficit are alarming. I'm very

2:41:312:41:35

pleased to see the government thinks

the level of debt as a percentage of

2:41:352:41:38

GDP will be coming down very

shortly. But I think we also need to

2:41:382:41:43

take into account the fact that the

state owns quite a lot of the debt

2:41:432:41:48

itself now, which I think does make

a bit of a difference. And when we

2:41:482:41:52

look at what the United States of

America is doing, they are now

2:41:522:41:55

embarking on a programme of actually

cancelling and reducing debts,

2:41:552:42:00

because it controls both sides of

that balance sheet through the

2:42:002:42:03

Federal reserve board. I want to

concentrate a little more on

2:42:032:42:07

house-building and housing, because

I'm very pleased that the government

2:42:072:42:12

is going to have a speedy and I hope

some interesting and into the issue

2:42:122:42:15

of how existing learning permissions

can be better used and translated

2:42:152:42:20

into more homes more quickly. This

is a problem that is very much a big

2:42:202:42:28

issue in the Wokingham Borough part

of my constituency, where the

2:42:282:42:31

borough has issued around 11,000

planning permissions for individual

2:42:312:42:37

homes, more than enough you would

think to have a fast build rate, as

2:42:372:42:43

is required under the agreements in

the local plan is. But there has

2:42:432:42:47

been considerable delay in bringing

forward some of those houses. And

2:42:472:42:51

then there is a wish by others to

try and get planning permissions

2:42:512:42:54

elsewhere and build outside the

areas where the plan would prefer

2:42:542:42:59

the building to go. There is a lot

to be said for concentrating the

2:42:592:43:03

areas of building, because then the

monies can be applied to the

2:43:032:43:07

surgeries, the primary schools and

extra road capacity that is needed

2:43:072:43:12

in a planned and predictable way,

whereas if inspectors, because of a

2:43:122:43:18

slow build rate, grant permissions

in a variety of different places

2:43:182:43:23

around the borough, then we would

need far more capital to keep up

2:43:232:43:26

with the demands, because distance

becomes an issue for people getting

2:43:262:43:30

to those particular facilities.

Looking at the national feature on

2:43:302:43:35

house-building, I welcome the idea

that we should be able to have five

2:43:352:43:40

new garden cities. I think the

garden town movement was a very fine

2:43:402:43:45

one many years ago Edu there were

some great successes with new towns

2:43:452:43:50

and cities in our country. I am not

going to start choosing places where

2:43:502:43:54

they should go, because none of them

will be my constituency, because we

2:43:542:43:59

already have an awful lot of and

development going on.

Can the

2:43:592:44:05

honourable member confirm that the

Chancellor never mentioned homes for

2:44:052:44:11

social went? Can he confirm that he

also never heard the Chancellor

2:44:112:44:16

mentioning homes for social went?

I

think the honourable lady is wrong,

2:44:162:44:21

I think he did and I think it is

clearly part of the government's

2:44:212:44:24

plan. Homes for rent and homes for

purchase. But I would like to see

2:44:242:44:30

new settlements, where a suitable

location can be found and I am

2:44:302:44:35

pleased to hear that there is

already some agreement over the

2:44:352:44:40

university arc from Cambridge

through to Oxford via Milton Keynes,

2:44:402:44:43

where there are all sorts of

exciting opportunities. One of the

2:44:432:44:47

good things about the UK economy now

is the momentum that is clearly

2:44:472:44:50

gathering pace in technology,

investment and technology business

2:44:502:44:55

setup, and it's obviously easier to

do that close to great centres of

2:44:552:45:01

learning and where there is very

extremely good workforce to recruit,

2:45:012:45:06

who may well be some of the

entrepreneurs as well. So, I think

2:45:062:45:10

it is excellent that we reinforce

success and see that as a very major

2:45:102:45:13

part of the country. I agree with my

honourable friend who said that

2:45:132:45:18

within the housing issue, it is very

important to promote homeownership.

2:45:182:45:25

There is clearly a great yearning

for homeownership and I do think it

2:45:252:45:31

is one of the big social problems of

our day, that people under the age

2:45:312:45:35

of 35 in many cases are unable to

afford a first home, and I welcome

2:45:352:45:39

anything that would make the gap a

bit more Bridget.

2:45:392:45:53

-- a bit more Bridget will.

In my

fast and remote constituency,

2:45:582:46:02

first-time buyers welcomed abolition

of stamped duty. Will here agree

2:46:022:46:06

with his colleague who has now left

the Chamber that it would be high

2:46:062:46:10

time that the Scottish Government

followed suit and abolished the same

2:46:102:46:13

stamp duty, because we don't want to

marry inequality disadvantage in

2:46:132:46:17

Scots.

That is fine by me, I have no

problem with that but nor do I have

2:46:172:46:24

any constituency interest in it. It

is interesting how the SNP have not

2:46:242:46:28

staged to follow that through.

There

is one!

But yes, it is a sensible

2:46:282:46:41

proposal and I think it is very

welcome. Those who say that allowing

2:46:412:46:45

some remission of stamp duty right

up to 500,000 is unrealistic, I

2:46:452:46:50

think the earnings multiples now

being applied are rather greater

2:46:502:46:53

than the one the honourable lady was

suggesting. And I do think some

2:46:532:46:57

relief for people struggling to buy

in London is as necessary as

2:46:572:47:01

elsewhere in the country, and you do

need to take into account the much

2:47:012:47:05

higher prices in London. In summary,

I welcome the new forecast. I think

2:47:052:47:18

the UK is a great place to invest

in, I think the growth should fairly

2:47:182:47:22

steady from here, the productivity

plans need rolling out and

2:47:222:47:27

developing much more. It's going to

have to be done, because they are

2:47:272:47:33

about influencing behaviour and

opportunity in thousands of

2:47:332:47:35

companies around the country, and

working with the educational and

2:47:352:47:38

training establishments to achieve

what we need to bring about. And it

2:47:382:47:44

is above all I think about

government being open and conscious

2:47:442:47:47

of the need for it to adapt itself

very quickly to the huge changes

2:47:472:47:54

that technology is producing. I

would welcome experiments within the

2:47:542:47:56

public sector on how we can greatly

improve public sector productivity.

2:47:562:48:04

And in a positive way, by wanting to

ensure that people keep their jobs,

2:48:042:48:10

the but the jobs are enriched and

more rewarding, and I think it would

2:48:102:48:14

be really good to have some

pioneering examples in parts of the

2:48:142:48:19

public sector, and if the public

sector is good at it, when it might

2:48:192:48:23

be demonstrated to the private

sector. I wish the government every

2:48:232:48:27

success with this. The House has

wanted to be in a very fractious

2:48:272:48:36

mood today but we live in hope that

in due course people will see that

2:48:362:48:39

this country is on a very exciting

journey and that joint work to crack

2:48:392:48:44

the productivity problem would be

very welcome.

It is a pleasure to

2:48:442:48:49

follow the member for working. The

OBR forecast which was published

2:48:492:48:53

today has really demonstrated that

we're in a downgraded economy. --

2:48:532:49:00

the member for Wokingham. Real wages

are down. Business investment is

2:49:002:49:04

down. Productivity is downgraded now

and far into the future. So, no

2:49:042:49:09

wonder, Madame Deputy Speaker, that

the growth is down from the

2:49:092:49:14

Chancellor's modest forecast in

March of this year. He's presented

2:49:142:49:18

news today of a slowing economy for

the next three years, an economy

2:49:182:49:22

which is forecast to be six to £5

billion smaller in 2020 from what

2:49:222:49:28

they expected only last year. Aside

from setting apart £3 billion to

2:49:282:49:36

plan for Brexit, which is more than

he gave to the NHS, he made no

2:49:362:49:40

mention of the £40 billion or so

divorce payment which is presumably

2:49:402:49:46

going to be agreed with the EU soon.

And he used head room and some

2:49:462:49:52

reclassification of housing

association debt to announce some

2:49:522:49:57

tinkering, but fundamentally, to use

a phrase, Madame Deputy Speaker,

2:49:572:50:02

nothing has changed with this

budget. It's a eighth, or austerity

2:50:022:50:07

budget in a row. And it's taking

place against a backdrop of an

2:50:072:50:12

economy in the doldrums. We were

told by George Osborne in his first

2:50:122:50:18

austerity budget that we all had to

make sacrifices to eliminate a

2:50:182:50:23

deficit caused by the global

financial crisis. Entirely

2:50:232:50:28

predictably, that five-year plan

failed. So, the pain was extended

2:50:282:50:32

for another five years. And now

we're told that the second five-year

2:50:322:50:36

plan has failed, too. And so this

Chancellor is extending it for

2:50:362:50:40

another five years, until 2025. That

is already a 10-year delay on what

2:50:402:50:46

was meant to be a five-year recovery

plan. It's 15 years of austerity,

2:50:462:50:53

cut after cut, pressure on public

services year in, year out which no

2:50:532:50:59

end in sight. And this austerity

policy has huge human cost, which we

2:50:592:51:04

on this side of the House siege

daily in our advice surgeries.

2:51:042:51:09

Homelessness and destitution on the

rise, food bank use soaring, a and

2:51:092:51:14

if its system failing most of those

who have to rely on it through no

2:51:142:51:17

fault of their own. Now, the

Conservative Party is enthralled to

2:51:172:51:24

a right-wing libertarian ideology.

They want to shrink the size of the

2:51:242:51:28

state as a deliberate political aim.

They want state expenditure to be as

2:51:282:51:33

low as a percentage of GDP as

possible, despite be increasing

2:51:332:51:37

demands of an ageing population and

the need to make our economy fit for

2:51:372:51:42

the future in rapidly changing

times. They expect people to sink or

2:51:422:51:46

swim, and they aren't that concerned

about providing them with any

2:51:462:51:50

lifeboats. They saw an

opportunity... Well, the right

2:51:502:51:56

honourable gentleman has just

spoken. He can go off and advise his

2:51:562:52:01

clients on investing their money

abroad. Madame Deputy Speaker, they

2:52:012:52:05

saw an opportunity to pursue this

minimal state agenda in the

2:52:052:52:12

aftermath of the global financial

crash, and they've done so at great

2:52:122:52:16

cost too many. They made a

deliberate choice that cuts to

2:52:162:52:20

public spending would bear 80% of

the cost of eliminating the deficit,

2:52:202:52:24

with only 20% being accounted for by

tax changes. And we now know that

2:52:242:52:30

these cuts have fallen

disproportionately on the most

2:52:302:52:32

vulnerable and least able to look

after themselves. The Chancellor's

2:52:322:52:38

predecessor liked to claim that we

were all in this together, but he

2:52:382:52:41

cut the top rate of tax for his

super-rich friends at the same time

2:52:412:52:45

as ensuring that public sector

workers what a decade of pay freezes

2:52:452:52:50

and falling living standards.

Meanwhile this government has

2:52:502:52:54

systematically reduced the social

safety net to tatters for some of

2:52:542:52:57

the most vulnerable people in our

society. By 2021 my local authority

2:52:572:53:02

in Wirral will have had its funding

cut by 40% since 2010. Efficiency

2:53:022:53:09

savings, Madame Deputy Speaker, are

not cover cuts on this scale, and it

2:53:092:53:15

is no surprise that this level of

cuts decimates council services such

2:53:152:53:19

as adult social care, which wasn't

mentioned in the budget for a second

2:53:192:53:23

time and has seen a 26% cut between

2011 and 2016. This means that

2:53:232:53:32

essential care for the elderly is

not available and people in dire

2:53:322:53:36

need are being left with little or

no help. In education cuts have led

2:53:362:53:40

to a loss of £149 per pupil and 29

teachers in Wallasey alone. Will and

2:53:402:53:47

Cheshire NHS is being told to cut £1

billion in the next five years.

2:53:472:53:52

Merseyside Fire Brigade used to have

40 fire engines to save lives check

2:53:522:53:56

if they now have 28.

2:53:562:54:03

I do welcome the VAT announcement

today for the Scottish fire rescue

2:54:032:54:07

and police service. But does my

honourable friend not agree with me

2:54:072:54:13

that the reinstatement of VAT

exemption is far too late and his

2:54:132:54:18

led for years and yeared of added

deduction in the fire and police

2:54:182:54:22

service?

That's right. Merseyside

Police will have suffered cuts of

2:54:222:54:28

£183 million by 2021. 1,000 officers

and 700 support staff down. Little

2:54:282:54:34

wonder crime levels are now the

highest in a decade. I could go on

2:54:342:54:40

but I think you get the point.

Austerity has extracted a brutal

2:54:402:54:45

cost from the most vulnerable. This

budget takes place against a

2:54:452:54:50

backdrop of unparalleled uncertainty

and danger for our country. This is

2:54:502:54:53

a Government paralysed by its own

disagreements over Brexit. It is a

2:54:532:54:57

Government unable to resolve its own

internal contradictions around the

2:54:572:55:02

Cabinet table, let alone chart the

path to a successful conclusion of

2:55:022:55:06

the Article 50 negotiation in the

Brussels. We have a Prime Minister

2:55:062:55:09

who puts the interests of her party

above those of the country. And a

2:55:092:55:15

Tory Party, half of whom would

rather us crash out of the EU

2:55:152:55:19

without any deal than stay in a

moment longer. Go on!

Does she not

2:55:192:55:27

acknowledge that preparing for no

deal is an essential ingredient of

2:55:272:55:31

securing a good deal. Has she ever

bought a second-hand car? Did she go

2:55:312:55:36

in and tell the salesman she had to

leave with a car and yet expect a

2:55:362:55:39

discount?

I have to say, I would

certainly buy a second-hand car from

2:55:392:55:45

the honourable gentleman! The

Chancellor, who is regarded with the

2:55:452:55:52

utmost suspicion by the Brexit

extremists on his own side was

2:55:522:55:55

warned he had to produce a game

changer of a budget or his career

2:55:552:55:59

would be over. They want rid of him.

They don't think he's eurosceptic

2:55:592:56:04

enough. The Prime Minister's already

shown her faith in him by make can

2:56:042:56:08

him disappear for the entire length

of recent general election campaign.

2:56:082:56:13

After his outing on the Sunday

Politics show at the weekend when he

2:56:132:56:16

claimed no-one in Britain was

unemployed you can see what they're

2:56:162:56:20

worried about. No wonder he declined

to get in that driverless car they

2:56:202:56:25

were going to put him in for a

pre-budget hi-tech photo op. The

2:56:252:56:30

party opposite is responsible for

the slowest recovery from recession

2:56:302:56:35

since the Napoleonic War and the

largest squeeze on living standards

2:56:352:56:39

since Victorian times. Their

presiding over record levels of

2:56:392:56:44

wealth inequality. This is not a

record to be proud of. This budget

2:56:442:56:49

has done nothing to address these

abject and fundamental failures.

2:56:492:56:55

Since the crash, Gross Domestic

Product per head has increased by

2:56:552:56:58

2.4%. During the 19900 recession the

comparticle figure was 21%. Driven

2:56:582:57:06

by the significant decline in the

value of the pound in the referendum

2:57:062:57:13

vote inflation roseto 3% double the

rate in the eurozone and growth in

2:57:132:57:18

the UK is anaemic by our historic

trend. And as the off the BR said,

2:57:182:57:24

is on a downward path. Wages are

lower now than in 2010. The living

2:57:242:57:30

standard squeeze has returned as

prices are outstripping wage

2:57:302:57:34

increases once more. In the public

sector, there's been a decade of

2:57:342:57:38

falling wages which is causing real

hardship. The TUC calculated as a

2:57:382:57:43

result of the public sector pay

freeze paramedics and die Tests are

2:57:432:57:50

worse off. Firefighters are £2,900

lower down and Crown Prosecution

2:57:502:57:57

Service in our courts, 4,500 worse

off a year. Their polling shows 15%

2:57:572:58:03

of staff in our public services have

skipped meals to make ends meet.

2:58:032:58:08

Meanwhile, in Tory Britain, workers

are not only struggling with

2:58:082:58:11

stagnant or falling pay levels,

they're experiencing a huge increase

2:58:112:58:15

in job insecurity. One in ten of the

workforce, had an is 3.2 million

2:58:152:58:21

people, now face insecurity at work,

including 800,000 on zero hours

2:58:212:58:28

contracts, 760,000 on nonstandard

forms of temporary work, including

2:58:282:58:32

agency and casual work and 1.7

million who are in low paid

2:58:322:58:37

self-employment earning below the

Government's modest so-called living

2:58:372:58:40

wage. Little wonder that tax

receipts have fallen as employers

2:58:402:58:47

take advantage of tax structures

which innocent vies less secure

2:58:472:58:51

forms of employment. Little wonder

the Bank of England figures show

2:58:512:58:58

household levels of unsecured

consumer debt are rising at the

2:58:582:59:01

fastest rate since the global FM

crass. Up over 10% last year and now

2:59:012:59:05

higher than it was in 2008. The

budget had nothing in it to address

2:59:052:59:11

any of these important issues. There

are a few people who are doing

2:59:112:59:15

really well out of the current

system. Pay ratios between FTSE 100

2:59:152:59:21

CEOs and the rest continue to wide

when. They're now paid at a

2:59:212:59:26

staggering 160 times more than the

average worker. This means they made

2:59:262:59:30

more money by the first Wednesday of

2017 than the average worker could

2:59:302:59:36

earn for working all year. 5% of

households now earn 40% of all the

2:59:362:59:42

wealth in Britain. Is this really

the kind of society we wish to

2:59:422:59:46

create? Boosting productivity is the

key to economic growth and pay

2:59:462:59:51

increases. Yet, in the last decade.

The UK's productivity performance

2:59:512:59:56

has the the worst of any G7 country.

Since 2010, the Government's failure

2:59:563:00:02

to invest in infrastructure and

skills has seen our productivity

3:00:023:00:05

flat line. We're 15% lower than the

G7 average. So bad has been this

3:00:053:00:11

Government's record on productivity

that the OBR's revised down its

3:00:113:00:18

assumptions on productivity growth.

We've the lowest levels of

3:00:183:00:22

investment in the G7 driven by the

the Government's failure to invest

3:00:223:00:27

in businesses. This is nowhere near

enough to retool our economy and

3:00:273:00:31

make it fit for the future. Yet,

addressing this problem must be at

3:00:313:00:36

the heart of any Government's

industrial strategy. This budget

3:00:363:00:42

might have been the time when the

Chancellor decided to tackle the

3:00:423:00:47

regional disparity in economic

performance. When he took the

3:00:473:00:51

opportunity to invest in our

infrastructure and skills base. When

3:00:513:00:54

he finally gave Britain the pay rise

it so badly needs. But he didn't.

3:00:543:00:59

This is a budget of missed

opportunities. Once more, nothing on

3:00:593:01:04

social care. A bits and pieces

budget that fails to rise to the

3:01:043:01:10

huge challenges that this country

faces.

Thank you very much. I'm

3:01:103:01:18

pleased to follow the honourable

lady for Wallasey. But what her

3:01:183:01:23

speech showed is that the party

opposite has not learnt anything

3:01:233:01:27

about how to run a successful,

modern economy. The Chancellor in

3:01:273:01:32

his speech used the figure of the

party opposite increasing our

3:01:323:01:38

national debt by £500 billion. The

easiest thing in the world is to

3:01:383:01:43

spend more money and borrow more

money, which is precisely the

3:01:433:01:48

situation the party opposite left us

in 2010. That's why we've had to

3:01:483:01:52

have the austerity budgets we've had

in the last few years. Indeed, I

3:01:523:01:55

went to a lunch recently and I met

one of our major director of one of

3:01:553:02:02

our major banks, the party opposite

should listen to this. He said our

3:02:023:02:05

focus of attention has changed from

Brexit. We'll cope with whatever the

3:02:053:02:10

politicians dloe at us for Brexit.

Our focus of attention has changed

3:02:103:02:15

to political risk, the risk of a

Labour Government ruining this

3:02:153:02:18

economy. In contrast to that, what

we saw today was my right honourable

3:02:183:02:24

friend's budget. It was a prudent

budget, a fiscal loosening budget,

3:02:243:02:30

but, at the same time, we've been

able to stabilise our national debt,

3:02:303:02:35

put more money into our public

services, particularly into NH

3:02:353:02:39

skchlt and education. More moon into

infrastructure and deal with some of

3:02:393:02:43

the tax evasion. I'm particularly

pleased to see the PAC

3:02:433:02:47

recommendations on which I sit on

the PAC, the recommendations on VAT,

3:02:473:02:53

fraud, have been closed. I pay

tribute to my honourable friend for

3:02:533:03:00

their hard work on doing that. I'd

like to say something about housing.

3:03:003:03:03

The recent Government White Paper

said the UK needs to build 250,000

3:03:033:03:07

new houses a year. It certainly

does. If in a high housing price

3:03:073:03:13

area like the Cotswolds, if you ask

any of our teachers or nurses where

3:03:133:03:17

they live, nine times out of ten,

they will not live in the cots

3:03:173:03:22

Wolds. Cotswolds. Anything that can

be done to produce housing for lower

3:03:223:03:28

paid people must be a good thing.

In

my parliamentary division, the

3:03:283:03:33

difficulty is private builders will

not address that portion of the

3:03:333:03:37

market where the need is greatest.

The bottom and mid-market. Equally,

3:03:373:03:41

such is the increase in supply that

is required to drive down the price,

3:03:413:03:47

it's questionable as to whether it

would be in the interests of

3:03:473:03:52

independent builders to secure such

a reduction in price. The greatest

3:03:523:04:00

increase in the market was achieved

through building through the public

3:04:003:04:03

sector. Does he see that as a

possibility?

I'm grateful for my

3:04:033:04:09

honourable friend's intervention.

The need to build more houses is

3:04:093:04:14

about providing houses for those

that can't afford to buy on the

3:04:143:04:17

housing ladder. There are lots of

way in the affordable housing

3:04:173:04:20

sectors to do that. Affordable rent

to buy, staircasing, that is what we

3:04:203:04:26

need to pay attention to. I want to

say something about the planning

3:04:263:04:29

system in a minute. The structure of

house ownership has changed in the

3:04:293:04:33

last ten years. There is a statistic

in the last ten years, the number of

3:04:333:04:40

under-45-year-olds who own their own

houses has dropped by a million.

3:04:403:04:43

That I think is something we need to

address. That ask why I find it

3:04:433:04:48

extraordinary the party opposite

should be carping about the very

3:04:483:04:53

welcome announcedments by the

Chancellor today on the stamp duty

3:04:533:04:59

exemption for first time buyers for

300,000 and 500,000 limit in London.

3:04:593:05:05

They carp about how it will increase

the market for first time buyers.

3:05:053:05:09

But a cut in stamp duty is likely to

excite any increase in the house

3:05:093:05:14

prices by that. I think we should

welcome that. I think we should

3:05:143:05:19

welcome the measures the Government

are introducing to build more

3:05:193:05:23

houses. The use of new town

development corporation. It was used

3:05:233:05:28

successfully by the Conservative

Government in the 1980s and created

3:05:283:05:32

whole new towns like Milton Keynes.

What it does is, it is a partnership

3:05:323:05:38

of the Government, local authorities

and of the private sector and the

3:05:383:05:43

social housing sector to build more

houses. It worked in the 1980s. We

3:05:433:05:48

should do it again and make sure

those new town corporations are able

3:05:483:05:52

to get access to Morland. I have a

suggestion of two ways on how to

3:05:523:05:57

alter the planning system. We need

to alter the planning system in the

3:05:573:06:02

material start system so when

builders get planning permission

3:06:023:06:05

always it should only be for three

years. It should have to build out a

3:06:053:06:10

site in its entirety for services.

That would stop house builders

3:06:103:06:14

sitting on land banking for an

unacceptable peered and stop the

3:06:143:06:20

current system where they use a

vacant site to gain planning

3:06:203:06:25

permissions on other sites they want

to get. That, I think I, would be an

3:06:253:06:29

important improvement. I'd like to

go on to talk about the Brexit deaf

3:06:293:06:35

others bill which the honourable

lady, to be fair, did touch on. This

3:06:353:06:39

is the biggest liability this

country faces for the next few

3:06:393:06:42

years. It has been rumoured that

we'll pay £38 billion which, of

3:06:423:06:49

course, includes obligations for

outstanding contribution, overseas

3:06:493:06:56

aid and decommissions liabilities.

But, effort nevertheless, in a

3:06:563:07:02

negotiation for a second-hand car,

you don't go in and pay an excessive

3:07:023:07:06

price. The clever negotiator pays

the right price. The minimum price

3:07:063:07:11

they can get away with. I think

that's what we should be doing with

3:07:113:07:14

the EU. To put this £38 billion into

perspective. It is isn't just £38

3:07:143:07:22

billion, it is the additional two

years, an additional £8 billion a

3:07:223:07:26

year. An additional £16 billion, so

up to some £56 billion. It is more

3:07:263:07:35

than our entire transport budget and

almost as much as our entire defence

3:07:353:07:39

budget. This is what we've to think

about with these very large figures.

3:07:393:07:44

I contrast that with the fact in

1945, the USA loaned us £2.2 billion

3:07:443:07:52

as war rap arations, that's £87

billion adjusted in today's money.

3:07:523:07:57

It took us over 50 years to pay it

off. I hope, at the very least,

3:07:573:08:01

we'll do two things with this

payment if we actually agree to it

3:08:013:08:05

with the EU. One it is it should be

paid over a significant number of

3:08:053:08:08

years. And, secondly, it should be

linked to our ability to earn money

3:08:083:08:15

from it, trade deals and other deals

that will help us eastern it and

3:08:153:08:18

therefore pay it off. I'd like to go

on to technology. Technology is

3:08:183:08:24

really important. It's really

important to this country to remain

3:08:243:08:30

competitive with our foreign

competitors and our productivity is

3:08:303:08:34

to increase. We, thankfully in this

country, seen a huge growth in

3:08:343:08:40

digital innovation. However, we have

a shortfall of around 40,000 people

3:08:403:08:45

with the necessary stem skills to

meet the demands of our economy. I'm

3:08:453:08:50

delighted to learn now maths is our

most pop lair subject. I see my

3:08:503:08:54

honourable friend for higher

education is here. Maths is our most

3:08:543:08:58

popular subject in schools. I'm

delighted with the extra money

3:08:583:09:06

encouraging children to take maths

at A-level. That our national inflay

3:09:063:09:11

structure fund is rising from 23

billion to 33 million. And the R&D

3:09:113:09:18

to invest in more infrastructure

will be main taped. It was an

3:09:183:09:23

amazing figure the Chancellor

mentioned that every hour a new

3:09:233:09:28

hi-tech company is emerging. He

wants to up that to half an hour.

3:09:283:09:35

Finally, I'd like to talk about

education.

3:09:353:09:45

Funding for our primary and

secondary schools was to be

3:09:453:09:48

maintained so that every jar in this

country gets a budget which is

3:09:483:09:51

increasing in real terms every year

and also that every child in this

3:09:513:09:56

country, their budget in secondary

schools should move up to £4800.

3:09:563:10:10

And that announcement, an extra £1.3

billion in our manifesto and

3:10:153:10:22

committed to spending that money,

has made a difference in Cotswold

3:10:223:10:26

schools of £450,000. And that is a

really welcome boost. Finally,

3:10:263:10:35

Madame Deputy Speaker, I would just

like to talk about small businesses.

3:10:353:10:38

The Chancellor had some very, very

welcome announcements for small

3:10:383:10:43

businesses in the budget. There

after all 5.5 million small

3:10:433:10:47

businesses in this country, as

e-mail clear, they are the engine of

3:10:473:10:53

growth, jobs and growth, in this

country, and therefore we need to

3:10:533:10:57

make sure that they prosper. And I

welcome the fact that is contrary to

3:10:573:11:02

the leaks about the budget, which

thank goodness are often wrong, that

3:11:023:11:06

we're not going to reduce the VA

Taper showed, because that would not

3:11:063:11:10

only produce more bureaucracy for

small businesses, it would also

3:11:103:11:13

bring them within the business

digital threshold as well, which

3:11:133:11:17

would produce even more bureaucracy.

-- reduce the VAT threshold. On the

3:11:173:11:27

subject of bureaucracy for small

businesses, doesn't he agree that

3:11:273:11:30

one of the biggest generators of

bureaucracy is if new arrangements

3:11:303:11:33

are introduced in terms of customs?

As he knows, the Public Accounts

3:11:333:11:41

Committee have done a lot of work on

customs and I'm hopeful that with

3:11:413:11:46

new IT and with the new introduction

of the customs declaration service

3:11:463:11:50

replacing the existing IT service,

airing in mind that customs are

3:11:503:11:54

great to have a huge increase in the

number of VAT declarations when we

3:11:543:11:59

leave the EU, customs have a really

difficult job to police goods which

3:11:593:12:04

are wrongly coming into this

country. So I think customs really

3:12:043:12:07

need to take that into account. But

I've almost come to the end of what

3:12:073:12:11

I wanted to say. Bureaucracy for

small businesses, and it is

3:12:113:12:15

essential that we try and keep it

down and we try and help small

3:12:153:12:20

businesses wherever possible. I was

especially pleased, and I'm sure

3:12:203:12:24

businesses in the Cotswold will be

pleased to see that we're

3:12:243:12:27

maintaining the small business rate

relief. For small businesses often

3:12:273:12:32

with a premises, where they're

paying quite high rent and rates in

3:12:323:12:37

an area like the Cotswolds, rates

can become a real burden. Those who

3:12:373:12:42

have been able to be taken out of

the rates gambit altogether by this

3:12:423:12:45

will be glad to hear that they're

not going to be brought back into it

3:12:453:12:49

this coming year, which is what they

feared. Residents and businesses in

3:12:493:12:55

a large rural area like mine, the

Cotswolds, will be glad to see the

3:12:553:12:59

freeze on fuel duty for yet another

year. Incidentally I'm sure

3:12:593:13:03

individuals in the Cotswolds and

indeed the entire country, will be

3:13:033:13:08

really pleased to see the freeze on

wine and spirits and cider. I'm sure

3:13:083:13:13

that will be particularly welcome.

To sum up, I think this has been a

3:13:133:13:18

prudent budget, it is nothing more

than I would expect from my right

3:13:183:13:21

honourable friend. I think he is

doing the great job for this country

3:13:213:13:25

in terms of his economic

stewardship. I'm sure that our

3:13:253:13:28

economy will go from strength to

strength, our education we will get

3:13:283:13:32

better, we will have more high-tech

jobs, we will continue in to employ

3:13:323:13:38

a record number of jobs. And if the

party opposite had anything to cheer

3:13:383:13:42

about, it would surely be that we

are employing a record number of

3:13:423:13:46

people in this country. And I would

have thought they would be

3:13:463:13:49

particularly pleased with the

Chancellor's announcement that

3:13:493:13:52

poverty is reducing in this country,

and child poverty has reduced by

3:13:523:13:56

over a million in the last ten

years. That is what the Chancellor

3:13:563:13:59

said. I know the party opposite

would not like these figures, but

3:13:593:14:06

the fact is that this is what's

happening. Thank you, Madame Deputy

3:14:063:14:09

Speaker. Thank you, Madame Deputy

Speaker. It is a pleasure to follow

3:14:093:14:15

the honourable gentleman from the

Cotswolds. Here's a great

3:14:153:14:20

parliamentarian and serves with

distinction along with me on the

3:14:203:14:23

Public Accounts Committee. For those

of us who have been in this House

3:14:233:14:27

for a number of years, we feel it is

like groundhog day. We have seen it

3:14:273:14:31

all before. The difference in this

budget is that usually after a

3:14:313:14:36

general election, the Chancellor has

two dole out the medicine and the

3:14:363:14:40

British public ridge just voted the

government in, have to take it. The

3:14:403:14:45

difficulty this Chancellor faces is,

he has to please all people of all

3:14:453:14:49

persuasions. I've no doubt, when he

fetched to the media that he wanted

3:14:493:14:54

to reduce the VAT threshold for

businesses, he was put off when he

3:14:543:14:58

looked towards his Irish colleagues.

I'm sure the freeze did not come out

3:14:583:15:03

of economic prudence but political

this city. But I have to say, this

3:15:033:15:08

speech is no different to any that

we've heard before. It begins with a

3:15:083:15:12

number of lame jokes, which I'm

sorry, the Chancellor is no

3:15:123:15:16

comedian. Who did not see that joke

about cough sweets coming a mile

3:15:163:15:23

off? I'm sorry, but it's no laughing

matter. The elephant in the room for

3:15:233:15:28

this budget, and the previous one

has been Brexit. In the previous

3:15:283:15:34

budget, the Chancellor only

dedicated a few lines to China. This

3:15:343:15:37

is the most seminal moment in

post-war British history. We are

3:15:373:15:42

leaving the European Union. Now, the

Chancellor said early on in his

3:15:423:15:48

speech that the Prime Minister has

set out a clear vision. Well, I must

3:15:483:15:51

be the only one who does not know

what this vision looks like.

3:15:513:15:58

Actually, all we have seen is the

Chancellor saying they're putting £3

3:15:583:16:02

billion towards any consequences of

what could happen in Brexit. Does he

3:16:023:16:09

not agree with me that in fact the

simplest thing that the Chancellor

3:16:093:16:13

could have done to support business

would have been to announce here at

3:16:133:16:16

the dispatch box that he's going to

keep the United Kingdom in the

3:16:163:16:20

single market and Customs union?

Well, at least I would have liked to

3:16:203:16:24

hear some sort of plan about the

single market and Customs union. And

3:16:243:16:27

I will say this, and I will divert

if you will allow me, Madame Deputy

3:16:273:16:33

Speaker, those of us who are

concerned about Brexit and about

3:16:333:16:35

getting the best possible deal, have

been attacked unfairly by opponents

3:16:353:16:43

as remote as, when simply we want to

get the best deal for this country

3:16:433:16:46

in Brexit. We see £3 billion put

aside for Brexit but we have heard

3:16:463:16:53

nothing from the Chancellor about

the £350 million a week for the NHS.

3:16:533:17:00

Perhaps the Chancellor wants to drag

the Foreign Secretary here to talk

3:17:003:17:03

about where that £350 million is.

Because I haven't seen it. And when

3:17:033:17:08

he's doing that perhaps he wants to

talk to the nurses. I give way.

I'm

3:17:083:17:12

very grateful. Buttrick Minford has

worked out that if we move to free

3:17:123:17:19

trade, that £350 million WILL be

available for the NHS, but only

3:17:193:17:23

after we've left the European Union,

which hasn't happened yet.

I respect

3:17:233:17:28

the honourable gentleman as a

parliamentarian but I believe he is

3:17:283:17:31

wrong on this. He knows that was a

false statement made by the Leave

3:17:313:17:35

side to try to con people into

voting that way. And he knows that.

3:17:353:17:39

And there is no point in standing by

that any more. But the one thing is,

3:17:393:17:44

we hear nothing about Brexit. All we

heard is, this is not going to be a

3:17:443:17:48

budget of unaided by Brexit. Well,

I'm afraid the Chancellor is wrong.

3:17:483:17:52

Every budget from here on in will be

dominated by the consequences of

3:17:523:17:56

leaving the European Union. And so

the budget went on and on and on. We

3:17:563:18:03

heard terms which the Tories would

love - a strong government, we will

3:18:033:18:07

be resolute in our determination to

bring about a strong economy... But

3:18:073:18:13

it took eight pages before we got to

the real story of this budget. Quite

3:18:133:18:16

simply, productivity growth is down,

and it has continued to fall. This

3:18:163:18:22

is the first Chancellor who has

stood before that dispatch box and

3:18:223:18:26

has said that growth will be below

2% since World War II. That's

3:18:263:18:31

something they should be proud of.

It gets worse. 1.5% in 2017, 1.4%

3:18:313:18:38

the year after and 1.3% in the next

two years, and hopefully picking up

3:18:383:18:47

to 1.5% and finally 1.6% in 2022. At

the same point, debt will be at its

3:18:473:18:54

highest level ever. And right the

government is being overoptimistic.

3:18:543:19:00

And if we're not going to talk about

Brexit, at least talk about the

3:19:003:19:05

fundamental weakness in our economy.

It is productivity. Productivity has

3:19:053:19:09

failed to return to pre-crash

levels, and it doesn't look like

3:19:093:19:14

it's going to happen any time soon.

The OBR has revised its estimates of

3:19:143:19:20

long-term productivity and economic

growth. They say it means the

3:19:203:19:23

economy will not bounce back from

the financial crisis and output per

3:19:233:19:27

worker probably will not recover to

its pre-rices rate of 2.1%. The

3:19:273:19:33

productivity prices will mean larger

budget deficits in future years and

3:19:333:19:38

depressed earnings, which will mean

future tax revenues will take a

3:19:383:19:41

serious long-term hit. The downgrade

creates a £20 billion black hole in

3:19:413:19:48

the UK's public finances according

to the Institute for Fiscal Studies.

3:19:483:19:54

We cannot hide this problem any

more. Now, if the government wasn't

3:19:543:19:59

so timid and scared of its friends

from Ireland, I'm sure we would need

3:19:593:20:04

radical solutions. Things have not

worked, we can all go on all the

3:20:043:20:09

time with this rhetoric that things

are going to improve. We have to

3:20:093:20:13

take action, and that action must be

taken now. For me, the most

3:20:133:20:17

fundamental error that this

government has made since it came

3:20:173:20:20

into power is its failure to get to

grips with the banking system. We

3:20:203:20:28

need to boost business investment

through a network of regional banks.

3:20:283:20:31

Germany has thousands of banks,

including state run and co-operative

3:20:313:20:38

is, many focused on lending

specifically to small and

3:20:383:20:41

medium-sized businesses. In Britain,

just five banks own 85% of all

3:20:413:20:47

current accounts of. The Chancellor

could learn from the German modelled

3:20:473:20:51

by enabling a new generation of

mutually owned building societies

3:20:513:20:55

and saving banks to focus on

long-term investment rather than

3:20:553:20:58

short-term dividends for the

shareholders.

Might the Chancellor

3:20:583:21:03

not also rethink the future of the

World Bank of Scotland hammered at

3:21:033:21:09

the moment the government is

committed to privatising back at

3:21:093:21:11

some future point, but surely taking

the opportunity to set a future for

3:21:113:21:22

RBS as a mutual, perhaps the royal

building society of Scotland, might

3:21:223:21:27

be a better way to encourage

competition in the banking market?

I

3:21:273:21:31

think my honourable friend speaks

from experience and here is

3:21:313:21:36

absolutely right. We need a thriving

co-operative sector in this country.

3:21:363:21:40

And again, if we want to talk about

the past and talk about the reason

3:21:403:21:45

we haven't got a strong mutual

sector in this country is because of

3:21:453:21:49

what the Tory has allowed on many of

our banks, the most famous of which

3:21:493:21:55

is Bradford & Bingley, allowing

people to become members and then

3:21:553:21:59

turning them to plc is.

Does he

agree with me that one of the worst

3:21:593:22:07

decisions of the Conservatives in

the night in 80s was the destruction

3:22:073:22:11

of the great regional institutions

that were building societies, so

3:22:113:22:18

that institutions like the Halifax

building society which created

3:22:183:22:21

wealth and retained it in the

regions were destroyed?

I agree with

3:22:213:22:25

my honourable friend. If ever there

was something tearing into the

3:22:253:22:30

fabric of British society, that was

it. It is terrible when you walk

3:22:303:22:33

down the street and so many of the

famous building societies are no

3:22:333:22:37

longer there. That needs to change

and we need to start talking about

3:22:373:22:40

alternative corporative models. We

need to talk about more mutual in

3:22:403:22:47

our society and business, including

employees share ownership schemes

3:22:473:22:52

and other things. But I think as

well it is time now to talk about

3:22:523:22:58

the NHS. Our nurses do a fantastic

job. They're at the front line. When

3:22:583:23:03

someone is in need, they are there.

But very often, this government has

3:23:033:23:08

not been there for them. And still

today, instead of giving the nurses

3:23:083:23:13

a pay rise, which I think all of us

agree they deserve, what we got was

3:23:133:23:17

a very vague statement about

maybe...

3:23:173:23:28

I also think about all those people

on Universal Credit. Again, this is

3:23:313:23:35

all about a sop to those who are in

need. There should have been an

3:23:353:23:41

announcement today to pause it and

look at it and eventually change it.

3:23:413:23:45

It is no good plunging the most

vulnerable people we have into

3:23:453:23:48

abject poverty. But this is what

this government is about. This

3:23:483:23:55

government I feel is very good at

warm words. Of course every

3:23:553:23:59

Chancellor's speech has to end with

a flourish, and resorted there. The

3:23:593:24:03

wedding of the paper as the

Chancellor stood up and in his

3:24:033:24:08

uninspiring tones announced that he

was going to abolish stamp duty for

3:24:083:24:14

those with houses up to 300,000.

3:24:143:24:21

Straightaway, minutes after, which

happens after all of his speeches.

3:24:213:24:25

It happened last time with national

insurance contributions, we get the

3:24:253:24:28

real story. Hidden on page 154 of

the report, it states clearly that

3:24:283:24:33

the temporary holiday on stamp duty

will increase house prices by 0.3%.

3:24:333:24:41

The honourable gentleman is shouting

at me... Judging by the ability of

3:24:413:24:48

the OBR to predict the future, does

it honestly think they are only

3:24:483:24:52

going to go up by 0.3%? It might

come down. Hopefully the honourable

3:24:523:24:57

gentleman. The point the Chancellor

is missing, many of these people

3:24:573:25:02

can't afford a deposit to buy a

house. So really he should have been

3:25:023:25:07

looking, as well as reducing stamp

duty, something people can save to

3:25:073:25:12

buy a house. We've heard about the

home-buyers I said, many people

3:25:123:25:17

didn't take it up. It's those kind

of things we need. In closing, I've

3:25:173:25:20

spoken for a long time, taking a lot

of interventions. I will say this,

3:25:203:25:24

this was a speech where the

Chancellor was boxed in. He held up

3:25:243:25:29

his red box that was a symbol of how

he was boxed in. Boxed in by his

3:25:293:25:35

government, in by the aquatic Ulster

Unionists and boxed in by his party

3:25:353:25:40

as well.

3:25:403:25:44

In terms of Brexit and the

productivity problems we have in

3:25:453:25:48

this country, we needed radical

reform. That government can't

3:25:483:25:51

provide it any more. I say to them,

stop clinging onto power and let's

3:25:513:25:55

go back to the country.

Andrew

Mitchell.

It's a pleasure to follow

3:25:553:26:03

the honourable gentleman. I fear my

speech will take a slightly

3:26:033:26:07

different view from his. I draw to

the house's attention my interests

3:26:073:26:13

that are registered in the House of

Commons register. I want, if I may,

3:26:133:26:17

to start by saying I think the

Chancellor faced a pretty difficult

3:26:173:26:22

task today. He was said to be

between a rock and a hard place. But

3:26:223:26:27

I think this is a sensible and

pragmatic budget. The Chancellor

3:26:273:26:33

will be well content with that

analysis. Madam Deputy Speaker I

3:26:333:26:36

want to start with the Midlands

because that is the area, part of

3:26:363:26:42

the area, which I represent. Very

pleased indeed to see we now have

3:26:423:26:48

the second devolution deal. I think

the support, and you will understand

3:26:483:26:51

how much this matters in the West

Midlands for the automobile

3:26:513:26:57

industry, for driverless cars, for

electric cars, is enormously

3:26:573:27:01

important. The Midlands is the

centre of this. We are leaders in

3:27:013:27:06

technology, design and production.

Internationally we very much welcome

3:27:063:27:10

that support. More of which is to be

announced later this week. Secondly,

3:27:103:27:17

the £200 million we received for

cleaning up Brownfield land is

3:27:173:27:22

thanks to the vigour and vision of

Andy Street, our mayor. He's doing a

3:27:223:27:28

very good job. I hope the Treasury

will consider providing more funding

3:27:283:27:31

when that £200 million has been

used. The importance of spending

3:27:313:27:39

money cleaning up Brownfield land is

immense because it means we then

3:27:393:27:43

don't have to build on green belt.

We should only ever do that as last

3:27:433:27:48

resort. I would also like to say we

are delighted that we are to be part

3:27:483:27:55

of a national pilot of housing

first. This is a particular priority

3:27:553:28:00

of Andy Street, our mayor's

programme. This pilot will allow us

3:28:003:28:05

to address rough sleeping across the

West Midlands in a decisive way. We

3:28:053:28:11

are very determined to do that.

Fourthly, from today 's

3:28:113:28:16

announcement, I want to express my

gratitude to the government for the

3:28:163:28:19

announcement on Birmingham

Children's Hospital where resources

3:28:193:28:23

will now be made available for

children's emergency medicine and

3:28:233:28:28

paediatric care centre. Many of us

have been campaigning for this and

3:28:283:28:33

the news is excellent. I give way to

my honourable friend.

If I can take

3:28:333:28:37

him back to housing for a moment,

does he agree the budget needs to be

3:28:373:28:41

seen in the round-up of government

announcements and opportunities in

3:28:413:28:48

the White Paper for local

authorities to build once again?

My

3:28:483:28:54

right honourable friend makes his

point exceedingly eloquently. Madam

3:28:543:28:58

Deputy Speaker, the second point I

wanted to make was really to

3:28:583:29:01

underline to the house that free

enterprise, open markets has been

3:29:013:29:07

and is the greatest engine of social

and economic advancement known to

3:29:073:29:10

man. I think we need to stand up for

these more than we perhaps have in

3:29:103:29:15

the recent past against the opposing

views espoused by the Shadow

3:29:153:29:21

Chancellor and large numbers of

young people who were not around to

3:29:213:29:24

learn some of the pretty basic

economic troops many of us learned

3:29:243:29:29

in the 1970s and 1980s. Having said

that, capitalism has always required

3:29:293:29:37

governments and regulators to set

boundaries to human activity and,

3:29:373:29:42

inevitably commit human greed. That

chimes in very well with the

3:29:423:29:48

activist views our Prime Minister

has expressed since she took up that

3:29:483:29:52

job. I want to point to three areas

briefly, by way of example, where I

3:29:523:29:58

think this regulation of capitalism

is the most important. The first is

3:29:583:30:03

that the debates that have taken

place across the house an open

3:30:033:30:07

ownership registers, in particular

for the British embassy's

3:30:073:30:11

territories, this was an initiative

of the Cameron government. We've

3:30:113:30:15

imposed upon ourselves in Britain

this transparency and we need to do

3:30:153:30:21

it on the overseas territories as

well. Many in this house care deeply

3:30:213:30:25

about this. My honourable friend for

Staffordshire for Amber Valley, the

3:30:253:30:30

right honourable ladies for Barking

and Don Valley. It is important the

3:30:303:30:34

Treasury recognises this point in

the Finance Bill. I very much hope

3:30:343:30:39

they will. Second become in terms of

energy prices, the government is

3:30:393:30:44

absolutely right to pursue this.

There is a monopolistic situation

3:30:443:30:48

which is working against the

interests of consumers. Regulation

3:30:483:30:52

is absolutely the right way to deal

with this rather than

3:30:523:30:56

renationalisation, which because of

the regulatory regime is entirely

3:30:563:31:01

necessary. Thirdly, this point has

been raised in this debate already,

3:31:013:31:04

but I make it again. A recent study

of the annual reports of the FTSE

3:31:043:31:09

100 companies shows the average pay

for chief executives has risen from

3:31:093:31:17

£5 million ahead in 2014 to five and

half million pounds in 2015. What I

3:31:173:31:27

believe is offensive and totally

unjustifiable with this, that is 140

3:31:273:31:30

times the average salary of their

employees. It is noteworthy Madam

3:31:303:31:37

Deputy Speaker that only a quarter

of FTSE 100 companies pay the

3:31:373:31:40

voluntary living wage to their

employers. Now the scale of this

3:31:403:31:47

inequality, vastly greater than

previously, gives capitalism a bad

3:31:473:31:51

name. At a time when inequality more

generally has been falling, with

3:31:513:31:57

income inequality currently at its

lowest rate for 30 years, this is

3:31:573:32:00

something the government needs to

address through regulation. I will

3:32:003:32:04

give way.

The honourable member will

come I'm sure, be aware the OECD

3:32:043:32:11

found there was a relationship

between inequality and growth,

3:32:113:32:14

namely more inequality means less

growth. Is also what when you

3:32:143:32:22

analyse the genie coefficients, the

normal way of evaluating inequality,

3:32:223:32:26

the UK is the highest and fastest

growing inequality in Europe.

I

3:32:263:32:31

don't agree with the last point, but

the honourable gentleman makes. I

3:32:313:32:35

will rest on the recently published

statistics that the income

3:32:353:32:40

inequality is now at a 30 year low

in Britain. My third and final point

3:32:403:32:45

is a point that has also been raised

generally today about

3:32:453:32:51

intergenerational fairness. Of

course it's absolutely right that

3:32:513:32:54

housing inequality is right at the

top of the list. We want future

3:32:543:33:02

generations to have the

opportunities that our generations

3:33:023:33:04

have had in terms of ownership. Not

only in ownership. It is also in

3:33:043:33:09

part ownership and rental. The

importance, I think of the decisions

3:33:093:33:15

that were announced today in the

budget is that they give a real

3:33:153:33:20

boost to the creative use of space

Maria Lenk a regiment to using the

3:33:203:33:25

Brownfield land I spoke about. Quite

right to attack the issue of the

3:33:253:33:33

misuse of land banks. And be

creative in terms of building new

3:33:333:33:36

communities. We need far more

imagination. I would like to see the

3:33:363:33:41

government committing to 1 million

new housing starts over the next

3:33:413:33:46

three years. Slightly further than

the government has gone today. I

3:33:463:33:49

think we need to recognise that this

is absolutely at the top of

3:33:493:33:54

everyone's agenda. Building new

communities, focusing on

3:33:543:33:59

infrastructure, looking at Garden

cities. I think many people will be

3:33:593:34:03

delighted to see what the government

has said today. In the Midlands we

3:34:033:34:06

want to see the Black Country garden

city developed, so far an idea

3:34:063:34:13

without much flesh on the bones. We

need to see far more flesh added to

3:34:133:34:16

the bones. But we must build in the

right places and progress will

3:34:163:34:23

become ever more bogged down if we

start to attack the green belt. In

3:34:233:34:27

my view it's very important the

government doesn't do that. This

3:34:273:34:30

should be the top priority. I want

to end my remarks, Madam Deputy

3:34:303:34:35

Speaker, making this point. When it

comes to intergenerational fairness,

3:34:353:34:40

everyone agrees this is a vital

topic. Do not let us forget that

3:34:403:34:44

excessive borrowing makes it worse.

The last six months, Germany had a

3:34:443:34:49

public spending surplus of £8

billion. Ours was a deficit of

3:34:493:34:53

something like 26 billion. This will

have to be repaid. It is a cruel and

3:34:533:34:58

unfair deception on the next

generation if we do not make it

3:34:583:35:01

clear that if our generation does

not repay it, their generation will

3:35:013:35:06

have two. Austerity is not optional,

it is not a Tory vice, Madam Deputy

3:35:063:35:12

Speaker, it is fiscal

responsibility. We have to return to

3:35:123:35:16

living within our means. The final

point I want to make on into general

3:35:163:35:23

fairness is, one of the best

investment in future generations is

3:35:233:35:27

Britain's contribution to

international development. The work

3:35:273:35:29

Britain is doing, the commitment

which we make across the house to

3:35:293:35:36

the .7 drives real change in the

world, does a huge amount to help

3:35:363:35:39

some of the poorest in the world

today. It contributes directly to

3:35:393:35:46

making the world a safer and more

prosperous place for future

3:35:463:35:52

generations. It tackles directly the

international dangers from climate

3:35:523:35:55

change, migration, Terra, pandemics

and protectionism. The government

3:35:553:35:59

should make more of this. This is

something the government of which I

3:35:593:36:04

was proud to be apart some five

years ago has done an immense

3:36:043:36:08

amount. It is very important in

addressing intergenerational

3:36:083:36:12

inequity. And also in making more of

it, the government will note it is

3:36:123:36:19

very strongly supported by people

across our country under the age of

3:36:193:36:22

35. A cohort suspect during sleep

absent from Tory voters at the last

3:36:223:36:28

election. I end by saying how

pleased I am too the government has

3:36:283:36:37

given a body that does good work in

Zimbabwe amongst elderly people £1.3

3:36:373:36:43

million from the libel finds. On

behalf of all those involved, I'd

3:36:433:36:48

like to express my gratitude to the

Treasury and Chancellor of the

3:36:483:36:52

Exchequer for making that very wise

decision.

It would be obvious to the

3:36:523:36:57

house a great many people still wish

to take part in today's debate and

3:36:573:37:01

there is limited time, so I have to

reduce the time limit to eight

3:37:013:37:04

minutes. Jo Swinson.

Thank you very

much indeed Madam Deputy Speaker.

3:37:043:37:11

The British economy today faces

three key challenges. We have,

3:37:113:37:17

firstly, low productivity, with the

associated wage stagnation that

3:37:173:37:19

comes with that. And of course the

reduced tax receipts. We have high

3:37:193:37:23

public sector debt, and we must

recognise the constraints that

3:37:233:37:27

places on what is possible

economically. We have to be honest

3:37:273:37:31

about some of the hard choices that

need to be made. Thirdly, there is

3:37:313:37:35

Brexit. As has already been called

the elephant in the room. The

3:37:353:37:40

uncertainty it is creating for

businesses and investment in the

3:37:403:37:43

country, the impact on our economy.

Indeed also the opportunity cost of

3:37:433:37:47

all of the energy and money being

spent on preparing for Brexit that

3:37:473:37:51

could otherwise be directed

elsewhere. Now the Chancellor is a

3:37:513:37:55

serious man. We had our differences

in coalition by significant

3:37:553:38:01

differences, but in recent months he

has appeared to be one of the few

3:38:013:38:05

voices of reason in the Cabinet on

Brexit. He has the unenviable task

3:38:053:38:09

coming to the house today in a

picture where there is higher

3:38:093:38:12

inflation, lower growth, lower

productivity and higher levels of

3:38:123:38:18

debt. It really is bleak, the

economy will be £45 billion smaller

3:38:183:38:23

in 2021 than had been projected in

March this year. So I'm afraid his

3:38:233:38:28

attempts to paint a cheerful vision

of the future were rather less

3:38:283:38:32

successful than his jokes. The truth

is, as the Chancellor knows, this

3:38:323:38:38

budget and the next budget, and the

budget after that, and all future

3:38:383:38:42

budgets, are made all the more

difficult because of Brexit. And

3:38:423:38:46

because of the extreme approach to

Brexit that this government is

3:38:463:38:48

pursuing. You making clear that an

exit from the Single Market and the

3:38:483:38:56

customs union is a red line for the

government, aided and abetted by the

3:38:563:39:00

front bench of the Labour Party,

this in peril is the future of the

3:39:003:39:04

UK economy and the Chancellor knows

it. The honourable member for

3:39:043:39:08

Loughborough said there was no pot

of gold at the end of the Brexit

3:39:083:39:12

rainbow, she is right but I think

the metaphor of a thunderstorm is

3:39:123:39:17

better. The cost of reparations, not

just the 700 million already

3:39:173:39:23

allocated but a further £3 billion,

more than could be found for the

3:39:233:39:27

NHS, which tells its own story. You

add on top of that the exit bill

3:39:273:39:33

which may be 20, 30, £40 billion and

the hits to the economy which the

3:39:333:39:38

OECD has said could be £40 billion.

No surprise these figures were not

3:39:383:39:43

on the side of a bus in the

referendum campaign. To promote the

3:39:433:39:49

health of the economy we have long

needed to use the advantage of low

3:39:493:39:53

borrowing rates to increase

investment in the economy so I

3:39:533:39:57

welcome the measures to unlock new

house-building but it isn't

3:39:573:39:59

ambitious enough. As ever the budget

is in the detail. The headline

3:39:593:40:05

figure touted was 44 billion. Only

15 billion was actually new and just

3:40:053:40:11

6 billion was extra for increasing

housing supply. As the honourable

3:40:113:40:14

member for Bath dead, next to no

money for social housing which is

3:40:143:40:22

badly needed -- the member for Bath

said. The Chancellor's response does

3:40:223:40:28

not come close. The new revenue

peaks at 1.9 billion next year and

3:40:283:40:34

then drops to 1.1 billion. We

appreciate that hard choices need to

3:40:343:40:39

be made and if we want to resource

the NHS and social care properly we

3:40:393:40:43

need to look at how to find the

funds which is why we propose an

3:40:433:40:48

increase in income tax of 1p in the

pound specifically for the NHS and

3:40:483:40:52

social care. Social care is

something the Chancellor did not

3:40:523:40:56

even think was worth mentioning in

his remarks.

I think the lady for

3:40:563:41:01

giving way. I wonder if she has done

the calculation on what £350 million

3:41:013:41:06

a week for the NHS over a year would

amount to. I think it is 18 billion.

3:41:063:41:12

How much is the Chancellor offering?

Next year, 1.9 billion, falling

3:41:123:41:17

significantly short of that. I'm

sure the Foreign Secretary will be

3:41:173:41:22

beating a path to his door to try

and make that happen or perhaps not.

3:41:223:41:27

On social care we need serious

responses and cross-party work to

3:41:273:41:33

find long-term solutions is that of

the half baked policies put up in

3:41:333:41:37

secret that the government offered

in the last election. On taxation in

3:41:373:41:42

addition to that increase in income

tax that my party has suggested to

3:41:423:41:46

find the NHS there was a missed

opportunity to increase capital

3:41:463:41:52

gains tax, corporate gains tax.

Instead of a race to the bottom to

3:41:523:41:55

get to 17% we keep it at a

competitive rate of 20% and get the

3:41:553:42:01

additional funds it generates. The

Chancellor was right to say that

3:42:013:42:05

international action is needed to

create fairer taxation but he failed

3:42:053:42:08

to address the role of the overseas

territories. We should require them

3:42:083:42:14

to comply with UK standards on

transparency or be prevented from

3:42:143:42:16

doing business in the UK. In the

spirit of being transparent, my

3:42:163:42:24

husband works for transparency

International UK. In the concept of

3:42:243:42:30

rocketing executive pay it is

impossible to escape the contrasts

3:42:303:42:32

between the rich who can hide their

assets and avoid tax, those on

3:42:323:42:38

middle incomes who are facing real

terms JCats and De Paula, many of

3:42:383:42:43

whom, working or not, rely on

benefits to make ends meet -- real

3:42:433:42:49

terms pay cut. There is a £12

billion cut to benefits to come,

3:42:493:42:57

that the Lib Dems blocked in

coalition. The rise in the income

3:42:573:43:02

tax threshold is welcome but

benefits are being frozen. That was

3:43:023:43:07

bad enough last year and the year

before but in the face of a 3%

3:43:073:43:13

inflation level it is going to cause

real hardship. We see some changes

3:43:133:43:18

to Universal Credit but wider

problems are ignored, not least £3

3:43:183:43:22

billion of cuts introduced in 2015.

Universal Credit should be paused

3:43:223:43:27

while the problems are ironed out.

There is merit to the simple

3:43:273:43:31

assistant but using it to make cuts

undermines the principles underlying

3:43:313:43:36

Universal Credit. On the environment

welcome the consideration of new

3:43:363:43:42

charges on single use plastics, a

Lib Dem idea but there was precious

3:43:423:43:44

little else to show that the

government appreciates the scale of

3:43:443:43:48

the threat. They cut subsidies for

solar and renewable heat,

3:43:483:43:54

privatising the investment bank and

scrapping the Department for energy

3:43:543:43:57

and climate change. Today we saw no

new resources for tidal, carbon

3:43:573:44:02

capture and storage, they don't have

a strong record on the environment.

3:44:023:44:05

On a positive note, I welcome a

couple of things in the budget.

3:44:053:44:12

Investment in technology come in a

eye, driverless cars and geospatial

3:44:123:44:16

data. And ethics must be at the

heart of how we proceed. Whether we

3:44:163:44:22

can do something is not the same as

whether we should do. I was

3:44:223:44:27

delighted to read on page 45 of the

red book that the government intends

3:44:273:44:30

to establish a state of -- a centre

for data ethics which is urgently

3:44:303:44:36

needed and we should be leading the

way on the issue. On that I say well

3:44:363:44:41

done to the government and I look

forward to exploring those issues. I

3:44:413:44:46

welcome the national retraining

scheme, especially the partnership

3:44:463:44:48

with the CPI and the TUC to make it

work with a focus on digital and

3:44:483:44:52

construction skills in the first

instance. I would also save

3:44:523:44:57

particularly in the context of the

automation challenge we face to our

3:44:573:45:02

workforce, we should be looking more

at the care sector. There are

3:45:023:45:06

certain things that robots cannot do

in the future and caring and human

3:45:063:45:12

empathy is one of those things. We

face a demographic time bomb so we

3:45:123:45:16

should be investing in the care

sector to change it from a low

3:45:163:45:20

status profession to one that we

should recognise is high skilled and

3:45:203:45:24

we should ensure there is proper

resource. In conclusion, our country

3:45:243:45:30

faces big challenges and

opportunities. There is a bleak

3:45:303:45:32

economic outlook, low productivity,

effect of climate change, the pace

3:45:323:45:38

of technology change and the impact

of automation. These challenges are

3:45:383:45:42

enough to give any government awake

at night. They need attention,

3:45:423:45:47

innovation and new ideas. Instead we

have a government obsessed and

3:45:473:45:52

consumed by Brexit. It isn't even

doing that competently. The economic

3:45:523:45:58

picture outlined by the Chancellor

today makes it clearer than ever

3:45:583:46:01

that we need an exit from Brexit.

Priti Patel.

Thank you madam Deputy

3:46:013:46:10

Speaker. It is a pleasure to follow

the honourable lady. It is the first

3:46:103:46:16

time in a while that we have debated

together. I want to commend my

3:46:163:46:20

friend the Chancellor on the budget

and especially because I know from

3:46:203:46:26

my own time in the Treasury during

my apprenticeship three years ago, I

3:46:263:46:29

recall the great efforts that the

Chancellor took to bring the budget

3:46:293:46:36

together especially as ministers are

lobbied constantly by a range of

3:46:363:46:41

interests and of course it is a

challenge to balance the needs with

3:46:413:46:45

the responsibility to keep the

public finances in sound order. The

3:46:453:46:50

Treasury should be commended for

navigating those pressures and

3:46:503:46:55

continuing to put the stability at

the core of the budget. Economic

3:46:553:47:00

stability should rightly stand at

the core of every budget and it's

3:47:003:47:04

worth reminding members, especially

those opposite, of the progress that

3:47:043:47:07

has been made in putting the public

finances back in order from the

3:47:073:47:12

appalling situation in 2010. Back

then the deficit was exceeding £150

3:47:123:47:19

billion, more than we were spending

on health, education, police and the

3:47:193:47:23

Armed Forces, a level of spending

financed by borrowing that was

3:47:233:47:26

unsustainable. We know that the

party opposite never want to take

3:47:263:47:32

responsibility for how it mishandled

public finances and loves pointing

3:47:323:47:35

the finger of blame elsewhere. It is

a fact that before the financial

3:47:353:47:39

crisis the then Labour government

wrapped up an eye watering about of

3:47:393:47:43

debt. I will give way.

In 2010 the

Conservative government said it was

3:47:433:47:50

very to eliminate the deficit by

2015. They were aware of the deficit

3:47:503:47:55

at that stage. Why have they failed?

I think the answer is the scale of

3:47:553:48:01

Labour's economic mismanagement. In

2008, the budget is planned for was

3:48:013:48:07

a £43 billion deficit, more than all

the revenues raised in excise duties

3:48:073:48:12

so it says everything we need to

know about financial management by

3:48:123:48:16

Labour.

I thank my friend for giving

way. Does she think that the

3:48:163:48:24

opposition have the brass neck to

intervene in that way, having on the

3:48:243:48:29

one hand in the chamber criticised

the government for not cutting the

3:48:293:48:33

deficit fast enough and yet on every

occasion they've been invited to

3:48:333:48:37

support the deficit cutting strategy

they've voted against it.

My right

3:48:373:48:42

honourable friend is absolutely

right and of course there are many

3:48:423:48:45

occasions since 2010 when the party

opposite have not only not supported

3:48:453:48:50

the government approach on deficit

reduction but have failed to vote

3:48:503:48:54

and support policies as well that

support the reduction of deficit and

3:48:543:48:59

also bring in sound financial

economic management back into the

3:48:593:49:02

public finances. We have come a long

way when it comes to bringing the

3:49:023:49:07

deficit down but also understanding

the reasons as to why it sound

3:49:073:49:11

financial management matters. Of

course that is because we need the

3:49:113:49:16

money available to invest in our

public services and to have an

3:49:163:49:19

economy that embraces enterprise and

can bring the tax receipts needed to

3:49:193:49:24

pay for hospitals, schools, police

and Armed Forces. Today's budget

3:49:243:49:29

recognises that and touches on this

fundamental issue. While we heard

3:49:293:49:33

criticism in the debate earlier on

about the NHS, our NHS of course is

3:49:333:49:38

a great is the Jewish in and it's

right that the Chancellor today has

3:49:383:49:41

committed more public funds into the

NHS -- great institution. I'm

3:49:413:49:49

delighted to see new support,

capital investment coming into the

3:49:493:49:56

NHS because for 30 years under

Labour, there was underfunding. I

3:49:563:50:01

speak again and make the point that

my friend did, the party opposite

3:50:013:50:07

have a brass neck to criticise the

work we've done and the investments

3:50:073:50:10

that have been made. One of the

great successes we've had since 2010

3:50:103:50:15

has been record levels of job

creation in the economy. I like many

3:50:153:50:23

honourable friends recall sitting in

these debates from 2010 onwards

3:50:233:50:26

hearing the doom and gloom and

scaremongering from the party

3:50:263:50:29

opposite about unemployment and

recession. As we know, their

3:50:293:50:36

predictions have proven wrong. The

point now is in the budget today

3:50:363:50:40

we've heard about greater

investment, in key sectors going

3:50:403:50:46

forward where we know we have to

think about the future of the Labour

3:50:463:50:50

market, where automation will be

coming in and also looking at how we

3:50:503:50:55

can invest in construction and key

services. I will give way.

Doesn't

3:50:553:51:04

she recognise that under the Labour

government the economy grew by 40%

3:51:043:51:11

in ten years to 2008, that the

government doubled debt from 45% in

3:51:113:51:20

90% of the economy and now we have

the lowest growth in the G7. Surely

3:51:203:51:25

that isn't a success.

In my

constituency we have seen the

3:51:253:51:30

claimant count falling from 70% from

under its peak under Gordon Brown

3:51:303:51:35

and there has been growth in small

enterprises, more jobs in Essex, and

3:51:353:51:42

we should be welcoming that. I will

give way.

Her speech reminds me to

3:51:423:51:48

ask this question, can she recall an

occasion when the party opposite has

3:51:483:51:51

talked up the economy? It seems they

are always about more spending and

3:51:513:51:56

borrowing, more debt and benefits.

My honourable friend is absolutely

3:51:563:52:02

right, we have 32 million people in

work, an opposition party that talks

3:52:023:52:07

our economy down. They seem to hold

a pathological hatred of enterprise

3:52:073:52:14

aspiration free markets, calling for

higher tax on businesses to serve

3:52:143:52:18

their agenda to tighten controls on

free markets, to stifle innovation

3:52:183:52:22

and style businesses from

succeeding. As we know that would

3:52:223:52:26

harm the economy in the long-running

-- stop businesses from succeeding.

3:52:263:52:31

As we've seen in the budget, great

Conservative budgets of sport

3:52:313:52:37

aspiration and opportunity and

freedom and this is why this party

3:52:373:52:40

has been on the side of people who

work hard and want to get on and own

3:52:403:52:44

their own homes. We've seen the

budget making welcome changes to

3:52:443:52:48

stamp duty to help people get on the

property ladder with 95% of

3:52:483:52:54

first-time buyers benefiting and 80%

paying no stamp duty. There is the

3:52:543:52:59

right action that will support

homeownership and increase supply

3:52:593:53:02

through the investment that has been

now announced today in the budget. I

3:53:023:53:05

want to stress to my honourable

friends on the front bench the

3:53:053:53:11

importance of ensuring there is

investment in infrastructure with

3:53:113:53:15

new housing from five it as well as

public sources. In Essex in

3:53:153:53:20

particular we've been working

assiduously to secure investment

3:53:203:53:22

with the government, the rail route

north of Witton, upgrading the a

3:53:223:53:30

120, critical investments that will

support house-building in that part

3:53:303:53:34

of Essex but also we are working to

ensure greater public funding, not

3:53:343:53:38

just private funding, but innovative

financial products to reduce the

3:53:383:53:45

risk to the public purse and

increase private contributions to

3:53:453:53:51

see the increase in construction.

Deputy Speaker, it was right that we

3:53:513:54:01

saw the budget setting us on a

course to be able to make the most

3:54:013:54:05

out of the new long-term

opportunities that Britain has. Of

3:54:053:54:07

course that means a global beacon

for free trade, a place that

3:54:073:54:13

welcomes investment from overseas,

more enterprise. But also finding

3:54:133:54:17

ways in which we unlock the talent

of this country. Again I welcome the

3:54:173:54:22

new investment we've heard today

from my right honourable friend the

3:54:223:54:24

Chancellor when it comes to skills,

critical sectors and investing in

3:54:243:54:28

people. There are fantastic

opportunity is not just for the City

3:54:283:54:33

of London but for our country. There

are plenty of reasons not just to be

3:54:333:54:37

optimistic, but looking at how we

can trade with the world and grow

3:54:373:54:40

our economy. Looking outwards rather

than inwards. A budget will

3:54:403:54:49

facilitate a positive international

vision for Britain. I believe that

3:54:493:54:52

is how it would be judged in years

that ahead. This budget stands in

3:54:523:54:56

marked contrast to the policies of

the party opposite you want to tax

3:54:563:55:00

more, harm our country and economy,

but importantly this budget lays a

3:55:003:55:05

foundation for a Britain that be fit

for the future.

Gareth Thomas.

A

3:55:053:55:15

pleasure to follow the right

honourable lady for Witham, shall

3:55:153:55:18

not be surprised I take a slightly

different view about the decisions

3:55:183:55:21

our country has made on Brexit. I

thought she nevertheless gave an

3:55:213:55:27

interesting speech. I was also

interested in the comments by her

3:55:273:55:33

colleague, the right honourable

gentleman for, if you'll forgive me,

3:55:333:55:36

somewhere in the Midlands. About

the... Sutton Coldfield, thank you

3:55:363:55:41

very much. To reform capitalism. I

thought his proposals were rather

3:55:413:55:48

timid. They were a star in terms of

recognising how corporate culture

3:55:483:55:53

needs to change. I would encourage

and there are forms of public

3:55:533:55:58

ownership that he should look at

with more enthusiasm than his

3:55:583:56:01

remarks today suggested he might do.

If I have time I hope to pick some

3:56:013:56:09

of those up. Today the most striking

feature of the budget thus far has

3:56:093:56:16

been the revelations about the cost

of Brexit. The downgrade by the OBR

3:56:163:56:22

in growth forecasts means for the

first time in modern history

3:56:223:56:27

official UK GDP growth forecast for

every single year over the period

3:56:273:56:32

being forecast are under 2%. The

setting aside of an extra £3 billion

3:56:323:56:41

to fund the cost of Brexit is quite

extraordinary. I don't remember any

3:56:413:56:47

of the Leave campaign mentioning or

even hinting at such costs. Earlier

3:56:473:56:56

this month the Bank of England

governor gave his verdict on the

3:56:563:57:01

economy and said Britain, in his

words, would be moving if it was not

3:57:013:57:07

for the Brexit effect. With

favourable conditions and stronger

3:57:073:57:10

growth in other parts of the world,

sadly, notably, in the Eurozone,

3:57:103:57:15

Britain has fallen from the top to

the bottom of the league of G-7

3:57:153:57:19

leading economies in the year since

the Brexit vote. Perhaps most

3:57:193:57:24

strikingly, foreign investment in

Britain is 20% lower than the Bank

3:57:243:57:28

of England were forecasting before

the referendum result. So it's easy,

3:57:283:57:34

I think, to be concerned even more

than we might have been about the

3:57:343:57:39

cost of Brexit. But the evidence

that businesses are beginning to

3:57:393:57:44

come forward with it to explain why

they are holding back on investment

3:57:443:57:50

decisions is perhaps not surprising

when the Cabinet themselves cannot

3:57:503:57:55

decide what kind of trading

relationship they want with our

3:57:553:57:58

European partners. The truth is

ordinary households are paying the

3:57:583:58:03

price of that situation. A report

published this month by the Centre

3:58:033:58:08

for economic performance found the

impact of inflation and the weaker

3:58:083:58:15

pound since the referendum means the

average worker had experienced a

3:58:153:58:18

real term cut of almost £450 in

annual pay, the equivalent of a

3:58:183:58:24

weak's salary. Sadly the government

marches on, insisting we'll leave

3:58:243:58:28

the customs union and single market,

and that no deal may well be an

3:58:283:58:33

acceptable outcome. Either striking

the evidence we've heard recently

3:58:333:58:37

from car manufacturers such as Honda

about the potential cost of leaving

3:58:373:58:45

the customs union. Up to £850,000

for some manufacturers every year.

3:58:453:58:50

Underestimate it would take their 18

month to set up the warehouses and

3:58:503:58:55

procedures they would need if

Britain left the customs union.

3:58:553:58:59

Something the government insists

will happen in 17 months' time.

3:58:593:59:06

Genuinely worrying for the future of

jobs in this country. The general

3:59:063:59:11

election confirmed there is no

mandate for a hard Brexit so even at

3:59:113:59:15

this late stage I urge the Minister

's opposite, and indeed if I may do

3:59:153:59:19

so generally, my own front bench, to

again explore soft Brexit options.

3:59:193:59:24

Such as EEA membership. Which allow

potentially new arrangements on

3:59:243:59:28

issues of concern to the British

people such as judicial authority

3:59:283:59:32

and freedom of movement, but which

would crucially give significant

3:59:323:59:34

economic certainty going forward.

The second area I wanted to touch on

3:59:343:59:42

was the failure of this budget to

tackle the crisis in funding for

3:59:423:59:45

public services. I thought it was

striking the Chancellor, given the

3:59:453:59:48

terrorist attacks our country has

had this year, made absolutely no

3:59:483:59:54

mention of additional funding for

the police or indeed additional

3:59:543:59:58

funding to invest in tackling the

threat, the ongoing threat of

3:59:584:00:06

terrorism in this country. For

Harrow we've lost 173 police

4:00:064:00:13

officers since 2010. Violent crime,

particularly crime involving a

4:00:134:00:18

knife, is up by 60% in Harrow. There

are stabbings, stabbings in South

4:00:184:00:28

Harrow and Harrow town centre.

Something my constituency has not

4:00:284:00:33

experienced for a considerable

period of time. The fear of crime is

4:00:334:00:36

therefore stand Julie on the

increase. I'll give way to my

4:00:364:00:40

honourable friend.

He mentioned the

police numbers and crime rising,

4:00:404:00:48

knife crime. The West Midlands has

lost over 2000 policeman, how will

4:00:484:00:51

you tackle knife crime when you are

reducing the police force and other

4:00:514:00:55

crimes for that matter. When we talk

about public services, instead of

4:00:554:01:00

the government telling public

services the police and fire brigade

4:01:004:01:04

and medical profession, why don't

they give them a decent wage? It's

4:01:044:01:07

the best way to thank them for the

service they give us.

I strongly

4:01:074:01:11

support my honourable friend's

point. I worry that the government

4:01:114:01:18

has chosen to do nothing about the

threat, the real threat in funding

4:01:184:01:26

terms, of a further loss of 3-4000

police officers. Which the

4:01:264:01:31

commission of the Metropolitan

Police, Cressida Dick, outlined what

4:01:314:01:33

would happen if there was no

increase in the Metropolitan

4:01:334:01:38

Police's budget going forward. The

consequences of that lack of funding

4:01:384:01:44

mean Harrow will be merged with

Barnet and Brent. Barnett increased

4:01:444:01:51

burglary rates, Brent a significant

gang problem. Many of my

4:01:514:01:56

constituents fear the police will be

taken out of our borough to tackle

4:01:564:01:59

problems in those two other

borrowers. And that crime in Harrow

4:01:594:02:06

will not be tackled in a way that

they might have hoped. On the

4:02:064:02:11

National Health Service it is

significant, I think, that the extra

4:02:114:02:16

resources which the Kings fund and

of the NHS said were necessary have

4:02:164:02:20

not been met. There have been some

increases and uplift and I welcome

4:02:204:02:27

that. It is striking that just last

year there were two and a half

4:02:274:02:31

million people waiting longer than

four hours in accident and emergency

4:02:314:02:35

compared to the 350,000 when we left

office. 4 million people at the

4:02:354:02:39

moment on a waiting list for

treatment in an English hospital. In

4:02:394:02:44

terms of Norfolk Park which serves

my constituency, it is the second

4:02:444:02:49

busiest trust in London following

the government's decision to close

4:02:494:02:54

the accident and emergency

department at Hammersmith and

4:02:544:02:56

Central Middlesex. We in my

constituency worry that Ealing

4:02:564:03:01

Hospital accident and emergency

department is due to close as well.

4:03:014:03:05

When one considers that our trust

has entered the last financial year

4:03:054:03:10

some £60 million in deficit with an

underlying deficit of almost 100

4:03:104:03:15

million, and is expected to make

savings of 50 million in the current

4:03:154:03:21

financial year, which the leadership

of the trust is an unprecedented

4:03:214:03:24

challenge, and one I think you can

understand why my constituents, I

4:03:244:03:29

think, will be deeply worried about

the implications of this budget for

4:03:294:03:31

the hospital going. Many of my

schools are under considerable

4:03:314:03:37

financial pressure. Having to see

teaching assistants, vacancies not

4:03:374:03:44

being filled, experienced staff when

they are leaving replaced by newly

4:03:444:03:49

qualified teachers. Again, this

budget does nothing to address those

4:03:494:03:53

particular problems. Nothing on

adult social care and the financial

4:03:534:03:59

prices. Nothing on the increasing

crisis in children's services. Going

4:03:594:04:05

forward. Lack of time prevents me

picking up the challenge the

4:04:054:04:10

honourable gentleman for Sutton

Coldfield laid down about a debate

4:04:104:04:13

on how one reforms capitalism going

forward, but I do think a series of

4:04:134:04:18

cooperative and mutual solutions

might offer a potential for that.

4:04:184:04:22

There needs to be an increase in

cooperative housing. The Royal Bank

4:04:224:04:27

of Scotland should be converted into

a building society going forward.

4:04:274:04:30

And far more needs to be done to

encourage an increase in energy

4:04:304:04:37

cooperatives to challenge the

dominance of the big six players at

4:04:374:04:40

the moment.

It's a pleasure to

follow the honourable gentleman for

4:04:404:04:45

Harrow West. I agree with his

remarks at the end about the role of

4:04:454:04:50

cooperatives in financial services

and other parts of our economy, he

4:04:504:04:53

and I spoke about that previously.

This was a budget fit for the

4:04:534:04:58

future. Said the Chancellor. In many

ways all budgets are fit for the

4:04:584:05:02

future because it's the future we

face. Some, like many the previous

4:05:024:05:07

Chancellor had to deal with, had to

cure the ills of the past, today we

4:05:074:05:10

see some of that pressure and pain

this economy has had to take the

4:05:104:05:16

input right. Some of these benefits

coming forward in a number of ways.

4:05:164:05:22

My right honourable friend for

Sutton Coldfield was right, much is

4:05:224:05:25

spoken about intergenerational

issues. The worst intergenerational

4:05:254:05:30

burden you can leave is to load the

next generation with the debt from

4:05:304:05:39

your reckless spending. When the

Leader of the Opposition said in his

4:05:394:05:42

speech today how different it could

all have been, so right he was. A

4:05:424:05:46

deficit denied not more money spent,

more tax raised. Little benefit. The

4:05:464:05:55

reality is our constituents are

bearing the brunt of that. Madam

4:05:554:05:59

Deputy Speaker, the Chancellor was

right to point out the OBR is

4:05:594:06:02

independent and also it gives a view

on the best economic forecasting

4:06:024:06:08

available. All forecasting bears

risks. If you had a look at the OBR

4:06:084:06:19

book, it brings out interesting

things. The honourable gentleman

4:06:194:06:23

opposite made the point several

times about productivity and his

4:06:234:06:26

right to make that, it is the

central challenge of this economy.

4:06:264:06:28

The honourable lady for the Liberal

Democrats made the same point. It's

4:06:284:06:34

fascinating to note, because of

course as an economic historian of

4:06:344:06:39

relatively modern times, it's worth

remembering of course the previous

4:06:394:06:43

Administration had to redefine

productivity because it was falling

4:06:434:06:47

so fast under their watch. It is

right to say that the OBR is making

4:06:474:06:51

the point and it is a disappointment

that although it is picking up its

4:06:514:06:56

not reaching precrisis levels. Which

is why it should be welcoming inside

4:06:564:07:02

the detail of the red book today the

schemes that are for retraining

4:07:024:07:07

older people as much as the skills

given to new people. If you look

4:07:074:07:13

inside the OBR one of the biggest

problems being highlighted is the

4:07:134:07:17

participation rate, as we have an

increasingly elderly population

4:07:174:07:25

without the skills to tackle some of

the new industries that are so

4:07:254:07:30

obviously going to be there. I

particularly welcome the retraining

4:07:304:07:34

partnership skills we'll be putting

there. The Chancellor was right in

4:07:344:07:38

that he was saying there is much to

be done in terms of maths and

4:07:384:07:43

computing. So the welcome to

continue there, so we can take the

4:07:434:07:50

challenge of the future... The other

thing that is clearly evident...

4:07:504:07:54

There is an awful lot in this book

in terms of the detail of this

4:07:544:07:59

budget. Often Chancellor 's hope

you'll pick a rabbit out of the hat,

4:07:594:08:06

the headline will be there, you

won't be looking at the detail. Much

4:08:064:08:08

of the good stuff is in the detail.

One thing worth mentioning is that

4:08:084:08:13

the Universal Credit announcements

today showed the Chancellor was

4:08:134:08:19

listening. He has to be right, it

has to be a modern welfare system.

4:08:194:08:22

So that work is always encouraging.

What is really interesting today,

4:08:224:08:28

already, one of the real experts,

David Orr, chief executive of the

4:08:284:08:33

National Housing foundation, which

owns most of the housing

4:08:334:08:38

associations, says we welcome the

changes to Universal Credit

4:08:384:08:41

including advance payments, it'll

make a direct and positive impact on

4:08:414:08:45

the lives of Housing association

tenants. I will give way.

4:08:454:08:51

I thank the member for giving way.

Whatever the motive behind Universal

4:08:524:08:58

Credit, in my wide reaching

constituency the lack of Internet

4:08:584:09:05

axis is there, it is an immovable

obstacle and it cuts against the

4:09:054:09:09

best intentions of government. Does

the government front bench recognise

4:09:094:09:13

this massive problem?

The gentleman

is right, it is a problem alongside

4:09:134:09:22

infrastructure. You will have noted

a number of infrastructure

4:09:224:09:25

announcements today, that the

roll-out of broadband is being

4:09:254:09:29

accelerated. I'm pleased the front

bench is doing something about it.

4:09:294:09:37

At a constituency level can two

things, the announcement of the

4:09:374:09:41

Meyler review, and some money going

to Saint Georges mental health

4:09:414:09:46

trust, which will welcome, as will

the announcement that Crossrail two

4:09:464:09:52

is proceeding although at a pace

most of us would like to see faster

4:09:524:09:55

than the trains, we hope. I think

the key announcements around

4:09:554:10:03

infrastructure, what was

particularly interesting was the

4:10:034:10:06

amount of money government is giving

to transforming cities to provide

4:10:064:10:09

local transport and give cities and

may is the flexibility to express

4:10:094:10:16

the new urban design in terms of

incorporating new industries of the

4:10:164:10:21

future -- cities and mayors.

Especially local councils to have

4:10:214:10:28

discounted lending, for high-value

infrastructure projects that they

4:10:284:10:36

think will bring extra facilities to

local people. It is key. By not ring

4:10:364:10:42

fencing the money for any particular

project but allowing it to be

4:10:424:10:48

brought forward so some of the new

urban design ideas coming forward

4:10:484:10:51

can be utilised. I've been

particularly keen recently to

4:10:514:10:57

contribute to the housing and

finance institute's recent papers on

4:10:574:11:00

how you make sure you bring sites

forward in a way that brings the

4:11:004:11:07

housing and services that come with

it. Often what frustrates major and

4:11:074:11:13

sometimes small applications is the

fact that it isn't just the roads

4:11:134:11:17

and rail, it's the atrocity, water

and whatever. The recent report by

4:11:174:11:21

was part of landed on the

Chancellor's desk. -- it's the

4:11:214:11:28

electricity. It has made an impact

because I can see that he's

4:11:284:11:34

establishing Homes England. It may

have been missed by many. By

4:11:344:11:38

widening the scope and allowing the

government's major house-building

4:11:384:11:44

directive for infrastructure to have

a wide and encompassing remit will

4:11:444:11:50

be, I suspect, bringing forward a

number of projects more quickly,

4:11:504:11:53

especially a view combine that with

some measures that the Chancellor

4:11:534:11:56

has mentioned in the red book today.

The strategic sites fund is steadily

4:11:564:12:03

to be welcomed if you combine it

with the announcement of Homes

4:12:034:12:06

England. It seems there is some

grown-up and connected thinking in

4:12:064:12:11

the Treasury and I welcome it. My

friend on the front bench smiles but

4:12:114:12:16

he was always guilty of that even if

not always evident to everybody

4:12:164:12:21

else. Two other things have been

noticeable, clearly the problem with

4:12:214:12:30

housing market is supply, everyone

talks about it, and clearly the big

4:12:304:12:35

projects. If you look across your

constituencies there will be numbers

4:12:354:12:39

of small sites that aren't being

brought forward and that's the

4:12:394:12:43

reason we've seen the decline of the

small builder. The extension of the

4:12:434:12:47

house-building fund, small sites and

most importantly the loan guarantee

4:12:474:12:53

to small builders, is likely to

bring forward more sites and it may

4:12:534:12:58

be at an incremental level, it may

not mean, every ten, 25 and up and I

4:12:584:13:05

think it is particular welcome. Also

particularly welcome from a regional

4:13:054:13:11

basis, the first time there has been

some regional accept that house

4:13:114:13:14

prices are not the same everywhere

in the country and the announcement

4:13:144:13:18

on stamp duty I think will be

particularly welcome inside London.

4:13:184:13:25

The patient capital review. Often

the structures in the past that have

4:13:254:13:31

been put in place did not recognise

the need to have the emphasis on

4:13:314:13:35

high risk and high growth. It's

right that if you're going to get

4:13:354:13:39

these funds and advantages they

should be for high-growth, high

4:13:394:13:41

risk. It is a benefit to see the

announcement from the Chancellor,

4:13:414:13:47

especially if it works alongside

private industry to bring forward

4:13:474:13:51

7.5 million into the in screws of

the future. There is much to welcome

4:13:514:13:56

in the budget -- into the industries

of the future. The devil is in the

4:13:564:14:00

details and I commend it.

It is a

pleasure to follow the honourable

4:14:004:14:06

member for Wimbledon although I'm

uncertain that we'll find a great

4:14:064:14:09

deal of agreement. In the run-up to

the budget, during the Chancellor's

4:14:094:14:15

speech today, we've heard a lot

about building a Briton fit for the

4:14:154:14:19

future. But many of my constituents

do not share his confidence in that

4:14:194:14:27

the government's proposals will

achieve such a vision. I've always

4:14:274:14:32

considered Enfield a fantastic place

to live, I've been there over 20

4:14:324:14:36

years, and a great place to raise a

family. But for far too many Enfield

4:14:364:14:43

North residents now, especially

hard-working and hard-pressed

4:14:434:14:45

families, the last in years of Tory

austerity have led to greater

4:14:454:14:52

insecurity, poorer public services

and in some cases abject poverty.

4:14:524:14:56

Child poverty has risen to its

highest level since 2010. I

4:14:564:15:01

mentioned this earlier to the Prime

Minister in Prime Minister's

4:15:014:15:04

Questions when I pointed out that

these to Jude for fiscal studies and

4:15:044:15:08

the Joseph Rowntree foundation are

predicting an additional 1.2 million

4:15:084:15:14

children will be pushed into poverty

by 2021 on top of the four million

4:15:144:15:18

in 2015-60 -- the Institute for

Fiscal Studies. It is a moral issue

4:15:184:15:27

facing the country and this

government. Enfield is the worst

4:15:274:15:31

affected are in London with almost

one third of our children living in

4:15:314:15:35

poverty. And the Chancellor seems to

be emphatic that this was being

4:15:354:15:41

dealt with. Let me tell the house,

the comment on today's budget, the

4:15:414:15:47

Chief Executive of the child poverty

action group Alison Graham said this

4:15:474:15:50

should have been the budget that

ushered in much-needed structural

4:15:504:15:55

reform of Universal Credit to revise

the promised to strengthen the

4:15:554:15:58

rewards from work. That didn't

happen. She went on to say that our

4:15:584:16:04

new analysis finds that while

effective tax rates may have been

4:16:044:16:08

fruitful for some families, big

falls in family income caused by

4:16:084:16:12

cuts and changes to Universal Credit

have left many worse off overall,

4:16:124:16:19

overwhelming any gains from

increases in the National Living

4:16:194:16:21

Wage, personal tax allowances and

help for childcare. Families on

4:16:214:16:26

Universal Credit who want to get

better off through earnings gain

4:16:264:16:31

little from today's budget." I'm

more inclined to accept what the

4:16:314:16:36

Chief Executive of the child poverty

action group as to say then I am the

4:16:364:16:40

empty words of the Chancellor.

I'm

very grateful to the honourable lady

4:16:404:16:47

for giving way. She is making a very

interesting point. I think when

4:16:474:16:53

she's had another Trinity to study

the impact on households, the

4:16:534:16:56

distribution of analysis

accompanying the budget, I'm sure

4:16:564:16:59

she'd want to welcome the analysis

showing that since 2010, households

4:16:594:17:04

across all income areas have seen

growth in their disposable incomes

4:17:044:17:10

on average. I think that is good

news and I'm sure she'd want to

4:17:104:17:13

welcome it.

Well I think if the

honourable lady sat in my surgery

4:17:134:17:22

and listen to what families in

Enfield, over one third of children

4:17:224:17:28

living in poverty, I think she'd

find that disposable income is a

4:17:284:17:30

major problem and that most families

feel that the rising costs and

4:17:304:17:36

particularly in rentals have hugely

wiped out any possible gain. Nearly

4:17:364:17:44

six in ten Londoners in poverty live

in a working family. So the picture

4:17:444:17:50

of poverty has changed. These aren't

people who are what others sometimes

4:17:504:17:54

referred to as grounders, they are

working people trying to get on in

4:17:544:17:59

life. -- with referred to as

scroungers. The government failure

4:17:594:18:09

to address these issues has meant

that many families are unable to

4:18:094:18:14

just about manage today, let alone

build for tomorrow. Enfield is the

4:18:144:18:19

fourth highest borough in London for

food bank usage. Last year 5970

4:18:194:18:27

43-day emergency food supplies were

provided to people in Enfield, of

4:18:274:18:32

which 2434 were given to children.

The roll-out of Universal Credit in

4:18:324:18:38

Enfield starting this month will

make a bad situation even worse. The

4:18:384:18:41

Trussell trust has said that

emergency food parcels is 30% higher

4:18:414:18:49

in areas where Universal Credit is

being implemented. Every week I see

4:18:494:18:55

so many hard-working families in my

constituency surgery who are living

4:18:554:18:59

on or below the breadline. I'd like

to say a few words about housing. A

4:18:594:19:07

great many people who have come to

see me, my constituents, see me

4:19:074:19:11

about problems with their housing or

problems related in some way to

4:19:114:19:14

their housing, especially those

living in the insecure private

4:19:144:19:18

rental sector. The risk of falling

into rent arrears and the risk of

4:19:184:19:26

eviction and debt because of

Universal Credit has only added to

4:19:264:19:30

their concerns. Stagnant wages, fast

rising rents and a crisis in the

4:19:304:19:38

housing supply have created a

perfect storm in Enfield. We have

4:19:384:19:42

the highest infection rates in the

capital. Levels of homelessness

4:19:424:19:46

accept and zis have risen by 82% in

the last two years alone. Enfield

4:19:464:19:53

has the second-highest number of

temporary accommodation placements

4:19:534:19:56

in London putting even more pressure

on an already strained housing

4:19:564:19:59

market. Again this isn't a record of

which the Chancellor can be proud.

4:19:594:20:06

And to referred to some of what he

said today, he said house prices are

4:20:064:20:10

increasingly out of reach for many.

They are, it takes too long to save

4:20:104:20:15

for a deposit, it does, if you can

do that at all. And rents absorb too

4:20:154:20:22

high a proportion of monthly income.

We've heard how the Office for

4:20:224:20:28

Budget Responsibility report makes

it clear that house prices will

4:20:284:20:31

actually rise because of the

measures today. And the member from

4:20:314:20:35

along the benches earlier asked

about whether anything was said

4:20:354:20:41

about houses for social rent. And

the member for Woking insisted that

4:20:414:20:49

it had been referred to. I'd look

through the speech and I could see

4:20:494:20:53

nothing that says that and I have

heard nothing. It does say,

4:20:534:20:57

including nearly 350,000 affordable

homes. The question is, affordable

4:20:574:21:02

for whom? There's nothing in here

about houses at a social rent and I

4:21:024:21:08

think that's a disgrace and

completely ignores the very

4:21:084:21:11

desperate need...

We heard opposite

earlier that the amendment referring

4:21:114:21:18

to how bad it was in the 1970s and

learning lessons from there, the

4:21:184:21:24

lesson is that if I was brought up

in a council house in the 1970s,

4:21:244:21:30

which was a tremendous base for me

in my life, we should be proud of

4:21:304:21:33

that. Those opposite should learn

from that and treat them with some

4:21:334:21:38

respect.

I completely agree with my

friend, I was also brought up in a

4:21:384:21:43

council house and we were proud of

our home and considered it the next

4:21:434:21:46

best thing to owning your own home.

We hardly drew a distinction on that

4:21:464:21:51

basis. That is the case today and

being able to offer anybody a

4:21:514:21:56

council house is becoming any

possibility. I want to make a bit of

4:21:564:22:01

progress. I want to say a few words

about public services, hard-working

4:22:014:22:09

families rely on our public services

but the veneers of austerity have

4:22:094:22:14

stretched the services to breaking

point. Enfield Council have tried

4:22:144:22:20

their best to protect families from

the immense pressures that they are

4:22:204:22:23

under. But given that their

government grant has been reduced by

4:22:234:22:30

£93 million, what they are able to

do is so much less and the level of

4:22:304:22:35

cuts local authorities are taking is

unsustainable. I noticed that when

4:22:354:22:40

we talk about social care, when we

talk about the environment, we talk

4:22:404:22:46

about policing, every time, the

answer we get from government is,

4:22:464:22:51

local authorities, local

authorities. They are slashing their

4:22:514:22:54

budgets on one hand and pushing all

their responsibilities to local

4:22:544:22:58

authorities on the other hand. They

know that this is a circle that

4:22:584:23:03

can't be squared, it's an impossible

task. They are undermining our

4:23:034:23:08

public services and local councils.

In education, our schools in

4:23:084:23:14

Enfield, primary and secondary, are

due to lose one third of £50 million

4:23:144:23:21

by 2020, heads will have to cut more

teaching posts, affecting every

4:23:214:23:25

child's ability to reach their best.

In health, my constituents deserve

4:23:254:23:30

good quality services but we've seen

Tory government closing the accident

4:23:304:23:37

and emergency and maternity unit and

cutting the number of beds by more

4:23:374:23:40

than 400. North Middlesex Hospital,

the other one that we now use and

4:23:404:23:45

rely on has been placed under

increasing pressure and constantly

4:23:454:23:50

faces a crisis as a result. The

Royal College of General

4:23:504:23:55

practitioners and says that Enfield

needs a deformed more general

4:23:554:23:59

practitioners by 2020 and I have

little confidence that the

4:23:594:24:01

government will provide that. In

terms of policing we've seen a 70%

4:24:014:24:07

increase in Enfield over the last

seven years in rising violent crime

4:24:074:24:12

and we've seen huge cuts in a number

of uniformed officers on our

4:24:124:24:16

streets. There is a relationship

between them. The government is

4:24:164:24:21

behaving in such a way, no mention

today of this, no mention

4:24:214:24:27

whatsoever... Sadiq Khan, the Mayor

of London, has done everything he

4:24:274:24:31

can to protect front-line policing.

The Chancellor failed to commit or

4:24:314:24:36

even mention additional funding for

London's police force. We're in a

4:24:364:24:41

situation where this government is

making London less safe for

4:24:414:24:46

Londoners, tourists and everybody

who lives in it. This is in a year

4:24:464:24:50

when we've seen five major terrorist

attacks. London is less safe under

4:24:504:24:54

the Tories. This budget helps

nobody.

4:24:544:25:21

This is a budget that ensures we

prepare for Brexit, prepare for the

4:25:214:25:26

future of this country. And to make

sure we embrace that future and get

4:25:264:25:29

the best of that future for our

children and grandchildren. I want

4:25:294:25:35

to commend the Chancellor for the

level of thought and consideration

4:25:354:25:39

he put into it and indeed, his

excellent budget speech and

4:25:394:25:43

presentation today. I think the

Chancellor did a brilliant job and

4:25:434:25:47

has brought forward a really

positive budget. I want to welcome

4:25:474:25:50

in particular the measures to ensure

there is an allegation of up to £3

4:25:504:25:59

billion for preparations for Brexit.

This matters, as we know, the Dover

4:25:594:26:03

front line and Channel ports, to

make sure we have a smooth

4:26:034:26:08

transition and to make sure there

are no hold backs, no gridlock, no

4:26:084:26:11

queues. Now, I know some honourable

members in this house quite like the

4:26:114:26:18

idea of queues at the Channel ports,

they look forward to it being a

4:26:184:26:22

disaster on Brexit. Not this side of

the house. I'm glad to see this

4:26:224:26:27

Chancellor is making sure the

investment and money is available to

4:26:274:26:31

make sure we can avoid that

eventuality. Gridlock at Dover will

4:26:314:26:36

mean gridlock for the entire British

economy. If the Midlands engine

4:26:364:26:40

cannot get essential component it'll

come out. If the Northern Powerhouse

4:26:404:26:46

doesn't get the supplies it needs it

will cease to work. That is why it

4:26:464:26:49

is so important for each and every

one of us to do all we can to ensure

4:26:494:26:54

Brexit is a success and ensure we

get the investment we need and the

4:26:544:26:58

preparations we need to make sure we

undock seamlessly from the European

4:26:584:27:04

Union and go out into the world to

make a success for the future of

4:27:044:27:10

Britain. It really can be success.

Let's remember what's coming down

4:27:104:27:14

the tracks, so well placed for the

next revolution of automation, so

4:27:144:27:18

well-placed for autonomous vehicles,

for the fourth Industrial

4:27:184:27:22

Revolution. I know even the

opposition doesn't share my view, he

4:27:224:27:27

wants to tax innovation and put a

stop to all this, this idea that it

4:27:274:27:31

might create a transition in our

economy. That he is scared of this

4:27:314:27:35

prospect. But I would simply say

that is commonly the case whenever

4:27:354:27:39

there is change and evolution and

innovation in our economy, people

4:27:394:27:44

are scared. The Luddites were very

scared. People were scared at the

4:27:444:27:49

Industrial Revolution, people were

scared in the 1980s with the

4:27:494:27:51

revolution in our economy. Each time

we saw a leap forward, a massive

4:27:514:27:58

jump in productivity, each time we

saw our economy move ahead and

4:27:584:28:01

Britain become stronger, more

successful, leading in the world.

4:28:014:28:07

That is why the Chancellor is

absolutely right to set up such a

4:28:074:28:11

positive vision in this budget and

reject the Luddite frontbencher view

4:28:114:28:16

opposite. A Luddite view that I know

most of the backbenchers, who ought

4:28:164:28:20

to be on the front benches opposite,

reject as well. Even know their Dan

4:28:204:28:24

Lobb say it for fear of deselection,

for fear the Labour front bench will

4:28:244:28:30

mobilise membership and gain

momentum to sweep them away. Can I

4:28:304:28:35

say how much I welcome the

innovations made to help the least

4:28:354:28:40

well off? We've created 3 million

jobs since 2010. We've seen massive

4:28:404:28:47

increase in the personal allowance,

nearly at £12,000. We sing the

4:28:474:28:51

national living wage, which also

makes a huge difference. Close to my

4:28:514:28:56

heart, we're also seeing the fuel

duty frees, for years and years, so

4:28:564:29:01

since 2010 hard hard-working

motorists and white van drivers,

4:29:014:29:06

hauliers, are seeing a massive

reduction in the effective costs of

4:29:064:29:10

duty. Each car owner benefits to the

tune of £850 a year. For a person on

4:29:104:29:18

average wages it makes a massive

difference and for a person who has

4:29:184:29:21

to drive in remote areas such as

Scotland, as a member of the SNP

4:29:214:29:26

kindly decided to remain present to

our deliberations, I should mention

4:29:264:29:30

Scotland and I welcome the fact he's

in the house. In that area it makes

4:29:304:29:35

a huge difference to people who have

to drive much further to much more

4:29:354:29:40

about areas. I welcome the fact it

has made such a difference to

4:29:404:29:43

hard-working people. I also welcome

the fact we're taking firmer action

4:29:434:29:48

against large businesses which are

too often given to industrial tax

4:29:484:29:54

avoidance, which is an acceptable. I

want to welcome the work taken,

4:29:544:30:01

joint liability for online platforms

like Amazon, if enabled overseas

4:30:014:30:07

retailers to gain our VAT system,

get competitive advantage, against

4:30:074:30:11

smaller businesses in this country.

Put them out of business and not

4:30:114:30:15

paid their fair share of taxes. A

campaign cross-party with the Public

4:30:154:30:20

Accounts Committee members, many of

us have fought for a long time. I

4:30:204:30:23

really welcome the measures taken

today to bring justice and fairness

4:30:234:30:28

and a contested if playing field to

the tax system. Service competitive

4:30:284:30:34

playing field. The Chancellor is to

be commended for doing the right

4:30:344:30:37

thing, making sure we get revenues

as well. So we have extra cash for

4:30:374:30:42

schools and hospitals. I really want

to finish with one thing. I think we

4:30:424:30:47

do need to go further with these

multinationals. I think there is a

4:30:474:30:52

problem we have. Too many

multinationals think they are not

4:30:524:30:55

subject to the rule of law of this

country. They behave like they are

4:30:554:30:59

over mighty medieval barons that

laws don't apply to in some way. I

4:30:594:31:04

say this house should call time on

that viewpoint. We need to make sure

4:31:044:31:09

Amazon, Facebook, all the rest of

them, pay a fair share of taxes in

4:31:094:31:16

this country, that they should be

subject to the rule of law in this

4:31:164:31:19

country. That these social media

outfits should also be subject to

4:31:194:31:23

our laws of libel and laws against

terrorism. Laws that exist for the

4:31:234:31:31

protection of people and the fair

dealing and fair treatment of

4:31:314:31:33

people. I think we need to take a

stronger and firmer measure. They

4:31:334:31:37

will say, but we're in America, you

is. I say we're leaving the EU, we

4:31:374:31:45

can take back control of Internet

access and trade policy. We need to

4:31:454:31:49

think along those lines. I give way.

Would he therefore also like to

4:31:494:31:55

welcome the online VAT fraud

extending the powers to overseas

4:31:554:32:00

businesses which I think is a really

important part of bringing these

4:32:004:32:05

multinationals in the modern trading

areas into line. I think it's a very

4:32:054:32:08

good move.

My right honourable

friend makes a powerful point, she

4:32:084:32:12

is absolutely right. There are

various areas where we need to look

4:32:124:32:16

to making sure social media outfits

in general. Generally technology

4:32:164:32:21

companies are subject to rules of

law on libel, an identity of who

4:32:214:32:25

they are rather than fake accounts

which bully people, mistreat people.

4:32:254:32:30

It is not acceptable. We should not

ever tolerate it. They should pay

4:32:304:32:35

their fair share of tax, be tougher

on terror, as we are, and seek to

4:32:354:32:40

join the government and support the

authorities in this country in

4:32:404:32:43

cracking down on terror. Cracking

down on crime and mistreatment of

4:32:434:32:50

our fellow people. They need to

respect our laws and values as a

4:32:504:32:53

country if they are trading year.

They need to respect that.

Does the

4:32:534:32:58

honourable gentleman agree with me

there has been a significant rise in

4:32:584:33:01

anti-Semitism through social media?

And anti-Semitic abuse? This is a

4:33:014:33:09

disgraceful form of abuse and one we

should do something about

4:33:094:33:12

immediately. And the government

should act immediately.

I completely

4:33:124:33:17

agree with the honourable lady,

she's absolutely right. The

4:33:174:33:20

disgusting and vile abuse we've

seen, anti-Semitism, racism, all of

4:33:204:33:27

those mistreatment of people, all of

it has got to stop. We need to have

4:33:274:33:31

a culture of respect on the

Internet. We need to not tolerate

4:33:314:33:34

those who will not show fair respect

and fair treatment on the Internet.

4:33:344:33:39

It's gone on too long, it's

unacceptable. It's got to stop. That

4:33:394:33:44

is why I say it's time to bring the

rule of law, the rule of law in this

4:33:444:33:49

house, this Parliament, this

country, to those on social media

4:33:494:33:51

and those multinationals not

currently playing by the rules as

4:33:514:33:56

they should.

Catherine McIlorum.

4:33:564:33:58

I've been inundated with

correspondence about what they did

4:34:034:34:05

or didn't want to see in this budget

from concerns on beer duty, business

4:34:054:34:10

rates, fuel duty, green belt

protection, Equitable Life and

4:34:104:34:15

proposals to make the private rented

sector more secure and affordable. I

4:34:154:34:18

have diligently raised every issue

that I've been contacted about a

4:34:184:34:23

head of this budget. I'm quite sure

the Chancellor and his team may have

4:34:234:34:26

been concerned they gained a new pen

pal in the process. However, I think

4:34:264:34:32

most people would confess that they

did not have high hopes for this

4:34:324:34:36

budget. And the Chancellor in this

regard hasn't fallen short. This is

4:34:364:34:43

a budget that has its head buried in

the sand. When it comes to the

4:34:434:34:46

enormity of the challenges facing

our economy. The downgrading of our

4:34:464:34:50

growth productivity and investment

protections, and the imprecations

4:34:504:34:56

this will have flawed and airy

households up and down the country

4:34:564:34:58

as they continue to face the misery

of this cost of living squeeze. Not

4:34:584:35:03

to mention, the Brexit uncertainty

and its implications that loom

4:35:034:35:09

ahead. However, I wanted to focus

today on a number of issues of

4:35:094:35:14

particular interest to the

north-east. We finally received in

4:35:144:35:20

the budget today confirmation that

the government is minded to devolve

4:35:204:35:24

funding and power to the north of

time areas, ending months of

4:35:244:35:28

uncertainty around this issue. I

look forward to seeing the details

4:35:284:35:31

in the days and weeks ahead. I also

welcome the long-awaited

4:35:314:35:38

announcement of the funding to

replace the Tyne and Wear Metro's

4:35:384:35:40

rolling stock over a year after the

government received a full business

4:35:404:35:44

case from the region for this

investment. About 40 million

4:35:444:35:48

passengers use the Metro every year

but the poor reliability of the

4:35:484:35:52

system has been causing problems for

constituents on a daily basis and we

4:35:524:35:55

must have that investment in new

trains by 2021 if the Metro is not

4:35:554:35:59

to grind to a halt. I'd be grateful

if the Minister could confirm that

4:35:594:36:04

Nexus will be able to go to market

this year in order to meet the time

4:36:044:36:09

scale necessary given the first

tranche of funding won't be made

4:36:094:36:11

available until 2020. Despite clear

commitments from the former Prime

4:36:114:36:20

Minister and Chancellor, that

further devolution to Scotland

4:36:204:36:26

wouldn't be allowed to economically

disadvantaged parts of the UK, we

4:36:264:36:28

are still to receive from the

current Chancellor a commitment as

4:36:284:36:32

to how he intends to mitigate the

impact of devolving air passenger

4:36:324:36:35

duty to the Scottish Government and

English regional airports. Newcastle

4:36:354:36:41

International Airport is in my

constituency, it supports 19,000

4:36:414:36:44

jobs across the north-east. It'll be

most affected, according to the

4:36:444:36:49

government own assessment, by the

Scottish devolution plans to cut

4:36:494:36:53

passenger duty. I believe, I first

raised this issue in Parliament

4:36:534:37:00

February 2016 and still haven't had

an answer. Wait and see isn't good

4:37:004:37:05

enough on this key, vital

infrastructure issue. Of course we

4:37:054:37:08

know the government is struggling to

make a decision on anything at the

4:37:084:37:11

moment. Trapped as it is within this

post Brexit election...

4:37:114:37:17

Post-election quagmire of its own

making.

I'll give way. I thank the

4:37:174:37:21

honourable member for giving way.

Would she perhaps agree with me that

4:37:214:37:25

really the ideal solution to avoid

this, I speak as a Scottish MP, is

4:37:254:37:30

to get rid of the air duty

altogether across the UK?

It's

4:37:304:37:35

incumbent on the government to come

up with a solution but I'm sure they

4:37:354:37:39

will take on board the honourable

gentleman's suggestion. Combined

4:37:394:37:44

with the continued uncertainty about

the Prime Minister's ability to

4:37:444:37:47

deliver a deal that won't have a

devastating impact on the UK economy

4:37:474:37:52

on investment, an jobs, I fear this

zombie government threatens to set

4:37:524:37:58

our economy back decades. If it

doesn't rapidly get a grip.

4:37:584:38:03

Particularly for net exporting

regions like the north-east. How can

4:38:034:38:06

we possibly compete for business on

a post Brexit global stage if we

4:38:064:38:10

struggle to make infrastructure

decisions that have been dragging on

4:38:104:38:14

for years in this country? Like on

Heathrow? And, finally, on Tyne &

4:38:144:38:19

Wear Metro. How can the government

be serious about rebalancing the

4:38:194:38:24

economy and creating a Northern

Powerhouse when countless businesses

4:38:244:38:26

are still none the wiser as to what

is actually being meant. Just last

4:38:264:38:32

week the north-east chair of the

Federation of small business said

4:38:324:38:35

three years on from the first

mention of the Northern Powerhouse,

4:38:354:38:38

it is still hard to find concrete

manifestations of it. With a week to

4:38:384:38:42

go until the budget, we'd like to

see the Chancellor takes a

4:38:424:38:44

meaningful steps towards getting the

show on the road. He also said, we

4:38:444:38:49

need cast-iron guarantees about EU

funding, post Brexit. Firms across

4:38:494:38:54

the north-east are benefiting from

EU support to the tune of millions

4:38:544:38:57

every year. One thing is for sure,

we won't have a Northern Powerhouse

4:38:574:39:01

unless that money is replaced. Yet

again, though, this budget does not

4:39:014:39:05

give the answer is that those

businesses need.

4:39:054:39:13

If we are to achieve our full

potential we need a Chancellor who

4:39:134:39:17

is on our side, who is prepared to

genuinely rebalance investment to

4:39:174:39:21

support sustainable economic growth

and one that can give businesses

4:39:214:39:26

confidence to invest. In

highlighting the pre-budget demands

4:39:264:39:32

the Northeast chamber of commerce

said that if the government is

4:39:324:39:34

serious about securing closing the

gap between London and the regions

4:39:344:39:39

there is a major work needed to

change the distribution of public

4:39:394:39:44

and private investment bank Canna

activity in the UK. This trend has

4:39:444:39:47

built up over decades. Listening to

the voice of businesses in our

4:39:474:39:53

region is essential to achieving

that. It is increasingly clear that

4:39:534:39:58

the challenges we face in reducing

unemployment in regions like the

4:39:584:40:03

Northeast that we must also solve

this productivity crisis, to tackle

4:40:034:40:10

the epidemic of low paid and

insecure work now affecting our

4:40:104:40:13

communities. Research published this

year by the TUC highlighted that the

4:40:134:40:19

Northeast has become the UK capital

of insecure work. With the

4:40:194:40:24

equivalent of two thirds of jobs

created in the region over the last

4:40:244:40:27

five years without guaranteed pay.

People's wages are lower now than in

4:40:274:40:32

real terms than they were in 2010

and it is little wonder that we are

4:40:324:40:36

seeing household debt rising and

more and more children living in

4:40:364:40:40

poverty. In conclusion, there is a

raft of issues we could have covered

4:40:404:40:47

today, many of which I have raised

countless times before and of which

4:40:474:40:50

we still have not seen any

meaningful solution in the budget.

4:40:504:40:57

Hundreds of families in Newcastle

suffered misery after the Universal

4:40:574:41:00

Credit roll-out. We've seen some

announcements but they don't go far

4:41:004:41:06

enough. Many in financial difficulty

as a result of this discrimination

4:41:064:41:11

against women. Local schools are

struggling to balance books because

4:41:114:41:15

of the government's real: budget

cuts. We have the NHS and social

4:41:154:41:20

care system on its knees with

services deteriorating because

4:41:204:41:24

funding has not been ring fenced.

They are overstretched and

4:41:244:41:30

undervalued, public sector workers

have seen a significant fall in

4:41:304:41:32

living standards as a result of this

long-standing 1% pay cap. It

4:41:324:41:41

includes constituents who are now

feeling the brunt of the £221

4:41:414:41:44

million of cuts in Newcastle City

Council since 2010 and the £124

4:41:444:41:52

million of cuts imposed on

Northumbria Police over the same

4:41:524:41:54

period with more to come. All of

which could have been addressed by

4:41:544:42:00

the Chancellor today if the

government were serious about

4:42:004:42:01

tackling tax avoidance and dealing

with the cost of living crisis. All

4:42:014:42:07

of which risks falling down further

down the government agenda as the

4:42:074:42:11

Chancellor sets aside £3 billion to

cover the anticipated costs of the

4:42:114:42:16

Prime Minister's potential failure

to secure a Brexit deal. All of

4:42:164:42:20

which are further away from being

addressed than ever before with

4:42:204:42:25

growth, business investment and

productivity forecasts all

4:42:254:42:27

dramatically downgraded. Once again

my constituents in Newcastle, and in

4:42:274:42:34

the north-east have been failed by

this budget and it has succeeded

4:42:344:42:38

only in living up to the

expectations of not being up to the

4:42:384:42:42

job.

It is a pleasure to follow the

lady for Newcastle upon Tyne who

4:42:424:42:50

speaks so passionately about her

university town. I hope that there

4:42:504:42:57

will be some businesses and people

in her town who will benefit from

4:42:574:43:00

the measures in the budget,

particularly for example the changes

4:43:004:43:04

that have been made on Universal

Credit because I feel the Chancellor

4:43:044:43:08

has listened and I'm sure he would

welcome feedback. I think this has

4:43:084:43:14

been a budget for change and I would

particularly like to welcome some

4:43:144:43:19

changes. For example, the additional

money that has come in for the

4:43:194:43:26

Brexit preparations, that is a major

change for this country. £700

4:43:264:43:31

million for the immediate

preparations with £3 billion

4:43:314:43:37

promised for the future, very

important because we must try and

4:43:374:43:41

create an environment where we don't

have uncertainty about the economic

4:43:414:43:44

impact. The money will go towards

providing more certainty in that

4:43:444:43:51

area. Can I welcome the ONS report

accompanying the budget today which

4:43:514:43:55

said that the public finances have

performed better than expected. I

4:43:554:44:00

think that was a welcome relief for

the Chancellor. I think that the

4:44:004:44:05

forecast for jobs was also to be

welcomed because they estimate that

4:44:054:44:10

employment will increase from 31.7

million in 2016, two dirty to buy 7

4:44:104:44:17

million in 2022 -- to 2.7 million.

£7 million for further education

4:44:174:44:26

ologies and the increase in computer

science teachers and the maths

4:44:264:44:30

uplift and schools building on

apprenticeships, which will help to

4:44:304:44:36

equip young people for those jobs so

they can take advantage of the

4:44:364:44:40

growth in business. I also think

that the announcement of research

4:44:404:44:46

and develop that for business,

especially in driverless cars will

4:44:464:44:49

be of great use, not only to people

who are early adopters of new

4:44:494:44:56

technology but also of those people

who are disabled and getting on in

4:44:564:45:00

our society. I think that they will

bring great innovations which will

4:45:004:45:05

assist them. I mentioned in an

intervention from my friend the

4:45:054:45:09

member for Dover, and I welcome the

vat number display provisions that

4:45:094:45:19

were mentioned in the red book. I

commend my constituent Richard Allen

4:45:194:45:24

who I know has played a major part

in providing information to the

4:45:244:45:29

Treasury and assisting and improving

and tightening up the law in this

4:45:294:45:35

area so that people who owe money to

the Exchequer are held to account.

4:45:354:45:41

The National Health Service is very

important in my area and I was

4:45:414:45:48

pleased to see there was more money

for that health service. Can I in

4:45:484:45:52

particular welcome that the Chilton

and Aylesbury Vale CCG bid for eight

4:45:524:45:57

private community care homes I

believe has been accept it and that

4:45:574:46:02

will be a welcome addition to the

health of my constituency. But it is

4:46:024:46:12

change that worries me in this

budget and therefore I have two

4:46:124:46:17

turned to the national

infrastructure commission report on

4:46:174:46:22

Cambridge: Milton Keynes and the

Oxford corridor which identifies a

4:46:224:46:27

lack of housing activity putting

future success at risk. The report

4:46:274:46:31

emphasises a joint apology required

in infrastructure and homes and

4:46:314:46:35

recommends the construction of an

east-west rail project, an Oxford

4:46:354:46:43

Cambridge Expressway, accompanied by

a massive house-building programme

4:46:434:46:45

which could see as many as 150,000

houses coming into Buckinghamshire.

4:46:454:46:51

I acknowledge the desperate need for

affordable housing, we've all had

4:46:514:46:54

people in our surgeries saying that

children can't get houses in their

4:46:544:46:58

area. We know that we need more and

I support connectivity but the

4:46:584:47:05

government should step back and see

what's happening in Buckinghamshire

4:47:054:47:08

so we can have a cohesive approach

to the area. Admin eja Tivoli we are

4:47:084:47:13

facing a potential Wii organisation

of local government --

4:47:134:47:18

administratively. Something may be

announced before Christmas which

4:47:184:47:22

means any changes would be limited

before the May 2020 elections which

4:47:224:47:28

would take a lot of time and effort

-- would be implemented. At the same

4:47:284:47:33

time there is the added burdens

placed on them by HS2, which is not

4:47:334:47:39

a minor project. It is causing,

using up a lot of resources in the

4:47:394:47:47

county. Local Enterprise

Partnerships are not exactly

4:47:474:47:51

streamlined, we have two. Although

one has done sterling work on the

4:47:514:47:59

economic plan, they are going to

find that they will have to make

4:47:594:48:04

some changes if the infrastructure

commission's plans is accepted and

4:48:044:48:10

put into action. The environment is

also a very fragile in the Chilterns

4:48:104:48:16

and the new proposals are for

£150,000 150,000 -- 150,000 houses

4:48:164:48:28

which looks to be bigger than Milton

Keynes already as well as doubling

4:48:284:48:31

the size of Milton Keynes. Our

environment in Buckinghamshire is of

4:48:314:48:36

great importance to residents and

provides many people who come to the

4:48:364:48:40

area of outstanding national beauty

with an away since of natural beauty

4:48:404:48:44

and the fact that it has received a

national designation should mean it

4:48:444:48:48

has been highest level of

protection. The report emphasises

4:48:484:48:52

connectivity and this was one of the

reasons for HS2 but there is no

4:48:524:48:57

connection proposed between the

east-west rail link and HS2. I think

4:48:574:49:01

there should be an immediate review

of whether it is desirable to link

4:49:014:49:05

these railways and if so, what

changes would be required for HS2.

4:49:054:49:12

Had the proposed route through

Milton Keynes been accepted, it

4:49:124:49:18

would have reduced the environmental

damage in Buckinghamshire. Change

4:49:184:49:21

needs to be managed and there are

currently too many changes and

4:49:214:49:26

initiatives coming down the track

which will impact in a major way on

4:49:264:49:30

the Co-op Buckinghamshire. Unless

matters are coordinated I think we

4:49:304:49:35

may face unsustainable burdens that

do the reverse of what was intended

4:49:354:49:40

by some of the welcome announcements

today. I'd be grateful if the

4:49:404:49:45

Chancellor could meet with me and

other members of Parliament in

4:49:454:49:48

Buckinghamshire to look at how we

can maximise the opportunities that

4:49:484:49:52

he's providing for the country and

county in this budget rather than

4:49:524:49:58

the local resources being swamped by

a change. This is a budget for

4:49:584:50:02

change but it must be managed

effectively to achieve the

4:50:024:50:05

beneficial outcomes that we would

all like to see.

Thank you for the

4:50:054:50:14

opportunity to contribute to this

important debate today. Although I

4:50:144:50:19

think across the benches on this

side of the house we have heard

4:50:194:50:22

considerable pessimism, there is --

I rise to welcome the statement from

4:50:224:50:29

the Chancellor today and in

particular the increased investment

4:50:294:50:32

across the United Kingdom which will

bring an additional £660 million of

4:50:324:50:39

benefit to Northern Ireland. This is

much needed. It has been a difficult

4:50:394:50:45

number of years. Significant budget

pressures across all departments in

4:50:454:50:51

Northern Ireland combined with a

constructed or limited real term

4:50:514:50:57

budget growth every year has led to

significant challenges. Hard and

4:50:574:51:01

difficult decisions have to be made

and it was people and services in

4:51:014:51:09

Northern Ireland that suffered. I

support the principle of fiscal

4:51:094:51:12

responsibility but austerity did

feel punishing too many. This was

4:51:124:51:19

especially acute in Northern Ireland

because we were still struggling to

4:51:194:51:22

emerge from decades of

underinvestment due to a long period

4:51:224:51:26

of violence. We were still trying to

rebalance our too public sector

4:51:264:51:36

reliant economy. I welcome the

fiscal loosening that was outlined

4:51:364:51:39

today in the budget. We would like

to see further loosening in relation

4:51:394:51:44

to the years ahead, especially in

reference to the plight of the Waspy

4:51:444:51:54

women in relation to pensions.

Additional pay sector award funds

4:51:544:52:02

should not come from within budgets

and put pressure on front line

4:52:024:52:04

services. In relation to this

specific budget there is an emphasis

4:52:044:52:11

in relation to the capital and in

Northern Ireland we have huge

4:52:114:52:14

pressures, especially in relation to

education and health which requires

4:52:144:52:18

revenue resource investment along

with capital. I acknowledge that

4:52:184:52:25

capital is very important in terms

of growing the economy and investing

4:52:254:52:28

in the infrastructure but it is the

resource pressures that often impact

4:52:284:52:33

on front line services and I hope

that in the years ahead we'll

4:52:334:52:36

continue to have very positive

conversations in relation to easing

4:52:364:52:41

on those matters. Public services,

especially health, need significant

4:52:414:52:48

investment to transform and become

truly fit for purpose. Northern

4:52:484:52:54

Ireland is in a slightly different

situation to some others across the

4:52:544:52:58

house in that we will have a Barnett

consequential from the budget so

4:52:584:53:03

there will be less ability in

relation to be prioritised Asian of

4:53:034:53:08

those funds and that £660 million --

prioritisation. An aspect of the

4:53:084:53:16

budget will benefit Northern Ireland

in a positive way, for example

4:53:164:53:20

Northern Ireland is ready to play

its part in the technological

4:53:204:53:26

revolution to make the UK the true

world leader in this area. This is

4:53:264:53:30

indeed the future.

4:53:304:53:35

We have very highly skilled base,

and employment base, we have low

4:53:354:53:41

staff turnover and we have much

innovation. Our universities, such

4:53:414:53:46

as Queens University in my own

constituency of south Belfast, are

4:53:464:53:50

prepared and determine to play a

full part in this digital and tech

4:53:504:53:55

revolution. I also welcome that the

Budget goes some way in

4:53:554:53:59

acknowledging the difficulty of the

way the last two years have been in

4:53:594:54:06

Northern Ireland. The addition of

the pay cap and I welcome in

4:54:064:54:12

relation to nurses' pay. The stamp

duty exemption and increase in

4:54:124:54:19

personal allowance will bring much

support to those who are genuinely

4:54:194:54:22

is struggling. These will apply

directly in Northern Ireland. In

4:54:224:54:26

conclusion, I just want to touch on

the issue about the Barnett

4:54:264:54:31

consequential and the decisions

which need to be made in Northern

4:54:314:54:34

Ireland in relation to the Budget.

It grieves me that there is no

4:54:344:54:39

executive in place to examine the

proposals today and make those

4:54:394:54:42

decisions. We need an executive to

look at what is coming forward from

4:54:424:54:49

this Budget, to listen to the people

on the ground in Northern Ireland,

4:54:494:54:54

organisations, those who benefit

from public services, those whose

4:54:544:54:58

businesses need to grow. We need

somebody to listen and to prioritise

4:54:584:55:05

into our own Northern Ireland

Budget. We in the Democratic

4:55:054:55:09

Unionist Party I doing everything we

can to bring government back to

4:55:094:55:13

Northern Ireland. But we will not

and cannot be held to ransom by

4:55:134:55:20

narrow and divisive cultural

identity politics. This is a

4:55:204:55:23

terrible situation in Northern

Ireland. Although that has been much

4:55:234:55:27

talk in the House today about the

impact of wrecks it, in Northern

4:55:274:55:31

Ireland, we are in the twilight

zone. We have a senior civil

4:55:314:55:35

servants in charge of departments,

with no accountability, because we

4:55:354:55:40

neither have direct rule ministers

or local ministers. There is no

4:55:404:55:46

constitutional democratic

accountability in Northern Ireland

4:55:464:55:48

for public spend and there hasn't

been for ten months. This is an

4:55:484:55:53

appalling situation, and I urge the

Government to step in and do

4:55:534:55:58

everything you can to either support

the Executive in terms of getting

4:55:584:56:02

re-established, or bring in direct

rule ministers, because this

4:56:024:56:06

democratic accountability cannot

continue.

4:56:064:56:13

Which she perhaps agree with some

suggestions that may be the MLAs pay

4:56:134:56:19

should be suspended until they

managed to get together and form the

4:56:194:56:21

Executive?

I have only three minutes

left so I will not get into that

4:56:214:56:27

specific issue. Only to say that

many MLAs across Northern Ireland

4:56:274:56:32

are working hard to try and restore

government in Northern Ireland, and

4:56:324:56:36

to work to deliver to people in

very, very difficult circumstances.

4:56:364:56:41

The entire of Northern Ireland are

being held to ransom. It is health

4:56:414:56:46

and education which is being held to

ransom. This is all the more

4:56:464:56:50

important in relation to Brexit. I

welcome the investment in terms of

4:56:504:56:54

the Budget today, in terms of

ensuring a sensible and positive

4:56:544:56:58

Brexit. That will require

investment. That is particularly

4:56:584:57:03

important in Northern Ireland.

However, again, because of the lack

4:57:034:57:07

of a Northern Ireland Executive, it

is incredibly difficult to be making

4:57:074:57:10

our case and ensuring we get the

best possible position to Northern

4:57:104:57:17

Ireland. There has been a lot of

nonsense spoken about this issue in

4:57:174:57:19

recent days, and in fact, in the

Republic of Ireland, almost hysteria

4:57:194:57:24

has been whipped up in relation to

this. It is vitally important in

4:57:244:57:28

terms of the economy, and in terms

of the report today, things will be

4:57:284:57:33

challenging in terms of growth,

things will be challenging in terms

4:57:334:57:37

of productivity, but we are

absolutely keen, we are absolutely

4:57:374:57:41

there to fight the Northern Ireland

through all of this and get the best

4:57:414:57:45

possible deal in relation to Brexit.

In conclusion, it is a disgrace that

4:57:454:57:51

there is no finance committee

sitting in place to examine this

4:57:514:57:55

Budget. It is a disgrace that there

are no ministers to make decisions.

4:57:554:57:59

It is the people on the ground who

are suffering and they are suffering

4:57:594:58:02

because Sinn Fein are refusing to go

back into government. Today, and I

4:58:024:58:09

was astounded by this, our finance

minister, who is currently not in

4:58:094:58:13

place, instead of examining this

Budget, instead of bringing forward

4:58:134:58:16

proposals, and we should have at

this time in Northern Ireland, a

4:58:164:58:20

Budget being brought forward for the

Northern Ireland Assembly for next

4:58:204:58:23

year, instead of doing that, what is

he doing today? He is standing

4:58:234:58:32

outside Queens University at a

student protest. That is a disgrace.

4:58:324:58:35

People are suffering. I welcome the

Budget statement today. We will

4:58:354:58:44

continue to work in Northern Ireland

to ensure there is the best deal.

4:58:444:58:48

This is a bad solution. The

Government needs to work with us to

4:58:484:58:52

find solutions and deliver across

all communities in Northern Ireland.

4:58:524:58:58

Thank you, Mr Speaker. It is a

particular pleasure to follow the

4:58:584:59:02

honourable member for Belfast South.

Michael, I want to see a devolved

4:59:024:59:06

government making decisions again

and then examined around Northern

4:59:064:59:12

Ireland -- like her, I want to see a

devolved government. It is

4:59:124:59:19

unacceptable and it is right to be

moved forward. She is right to make

4:59:194:59:23

our observations about the roles one

or two other parties have made who

4:59:234:59:30

are not here. With that, I go on to

welcoming the Budget, and also the

4:59:304:59:41

general tenet that it set going out.

I want to look at particularly what

4:59:414:59:46

it means for those living in my own

constituency. That means starting

4:59:464:59:50

with the impact that raising the

basic allowance will have for many

4:59:504:59:54

families. It is hard to think that

not that long ago, someone earning

4:59:544:59:59

less than £7,000 the year would be

deemed to be earning enough to pay

4:59:595:00:03

income tax. Now the threshold is

heading up to £11,800, it means

5:00:035:00:08

those on low pay keeping more of

what they are earning. And also the

5:00:085:00:16

freezing fuel duty as well, that

makes a difference for those on low

5:00:165:00:20

incomes for him transport will be an

increasing cost. It is not just

5:00:205:00:24

those who are car drivers, it is

those who use all forms of transport

5:00:245:00:29

which rely on fuel. It is very

welcome to see this. I am conscious,

5:00:295:00:36

given my PPS role, I have to

restrict some of what I say around

5:00:365:00:39

the housing element, but it is

absolutely right that we welcome the

5:00:395:00:42

huge amount that has been done and

has been announced today. Certainly

5:00:425:00:47

getting towards 300,000 homes a year

would be a great achievement and

5:00:475:00:50

would make a real difference.

Certainly, it is they welcome to see

5:00:505:00:54

some of the reviews that will be

launched particularly looking at

5:00:545:01:02

some of the issues in the planning

system. And I certainly welcome the

5:01:025:01:04

change on stamp duty. That tax

change will make it easier for many

5:01:045:01:07

first-time buyers. When I bought my

first home, one of the nasty

5:01:075:01:11

surprises you get is you think you

have got the money together to

5:01:115:01:14

purchase the property, you have your

deposit and then you are presented

5:01:145:01:18

with a lovely bill of several

thousand pounds which you have to

5:01:185:01:22

pay almost immediately, putting

instant pressure on those who have

5:01:225:01:24

already had to save for a higher

deposit. I have heard some of the

5:01:245:01:29

complaints from those opposite. If

they feel that way there will be a

5:01:295:01:41

chance to divide the House and a

chance for them to tell the

5:01:415:01:44

constituents why they have opposed

this change, why they will tell

5:01:445:01:46

first-time buyers that they do not

think it is the right idea. It is a

5:01:465:01:49

bit strange to spend the afternoon

in the House of Commons complaining

5:01:495:01:52

about something and then to go away

and support it. It will make a

5:01:525:01:54

difference to first-time buyers in

Torbay. Given the age demographic of

5:01:545:01:59

the population in the bay it is

welcome to hear about funding and

5:01:595:02:03

the extra money for winter

pressures. I hope that can be used

5:02:035:02:08

particularly around parts of A&E and

also looking at some of the

5:02:085:02:12

pressures in each area which are

created by its demographics. Torbay

5:02:125:02:16

is very much driven by an older

population. Other areas will have

5:02:165:02:20

different challenges which require

funding to be put in. There is an

5:02:205:02:24

ongoing discussion about social

care, but I think it is right to say

5:02:245:02:27

that will never be resolved in just

one Budget. That is something which

5:02:275:02:31

needs to be part of a long-term

discussion, probably on a

5:02:315:02:35

cross-party basis to provide a

solution, as it is something that no

5:02:355:02:38

one parliament will be able to

5:02:385:02:49

resolve in a way that will give

confidence to the public going

5:02:515:02:54

forward. The effort is an -- the

effort to increase productivity is

5:02:545:02:56

welcome. I can see that the

investment on the link road has

5:02:565:02:59

helped people getting between the

Newton Abbot and Torquay. It shows

5:02:595:03:02

the difference in the structure

investment can have I hope we will

5:03:025:03:05

see more of that, particularly with

the 8 billion productivity

5:03:055:03:08

investment fund being announced.

Would he not share my disappointment

5:03:085:03:17

at the paltry recognition of the

south-west that we're seeing today's

5:03:175:03:20

Budget? It does not even warrant a

headline in the red book. What does

5:03:205:03:25

this say about this government's

hole approach to the economy?

I

5:03:255:03:35

thank the member for Bristol South's

intervention. I can just say two

5:03:355:03:43

words: Stonehenge tunnel. Decades

have been wasted on that. I will be

5:03:435:03:50

judging this government on what it

does, not what it spends. Moving

5:03:505:03:54

back to the point, I also welcome

the 2.3 billion which will be going

5:03:545:03:58

into research and development and I

hope that will include in the long

5:03:585:04:02

run, having ended is to to to

technology based around the South

5:04:025:04:07

Devon College in Paignton,

delivering some of the highest

5:04:075:04:09

levels of skills training in our

local community. Torbay is famous

5:04:095:04:14

for its beaches and tourism

industry, but also has a vibrant the

5:04:145:04:20

tonics industry which needs more

people with skills and also knowing

5:04:205:04:24

that their training will be the high

scale will make it more likely that

5:04:245:04:27

they would wish to come and invest

in our area and grow and expand and

5:04:275:04:32

give local people those

opportunities. I know it is a baby

5:04:325:04:36

that is going in, literally as we

speak, and I think it very welcome.

5:04:365:04:42

Turning to other issues in the bay,

there are some problems when it

5:04:425:04:47

comes around alcohol and substance

abuse. Therefore it is welcome to

5:04:475:04:51

hear the Chancellor's comments

around certain super-strength

5:04:515:04:55

ciders. Certainly, there are issues

on preloading which affect our

5:04:555:04:59

night-time economy, and many of

those are connected to side which is

5:04:595:05:03

cheaper than mineral water but has a

strength far stronger than most

5:05:035:05:07

other things on the market. I think

it is right, they approach the

5:05:075:05:11

Chancellor is making on it. It will

be interesting to see what comes out

5:05:115:05:16

of Scotland and what happens there.

I have to say I'm not at the moment

5:05:165:05:20

persuaded by the arguments on

minimum pricing but it will be

5:05:205:05:23

interesting to see the difference

that is made in Scotland, and

5:05:235:05:26

something that can be learned from

in future. It is it works, we'll

5:05:265:05:30

have an example, and if it doesn't,

the other way round, we will have an

5:05:305:05:35

example. Also welcomed the

announcement is around Universal

5:05:355:05:37

Credit and the changes being made

there. It will be lamented in Torbay

5:05:375:05:41

and rolled out a full service in May

2018 and some of the changes being

5:05:415:05:46

made a very welcome. I will look

forward to hearing the statement

5:05:465:05:49

tomorrow to get some more detail on

that, but I think again it is good

5:05:495:05:53

to know that the Government has

listened, particularly to some of

5:05:535:06:03

the comments that were made in last

Thursday's debate in the Chamber.

5:06:035:06:05

Torbay is famous as well for many

small businesses and therefore, no

5:06:055:06:08

change to the VAT threshold is

something that people will welcome,

5:06:085:06:10

and keeps many small businesses

going and I also welcome the action

5:06:105:06:17

to crack down on online tax

avoidance. That is a key issue

5:06:175:06:22

because it does not make any sense

that you can avoid tax if you have a

5:06:225:06:26

very large website. If you have a

small business based in a shopping

5:06:265:06:30

centre in Torbay, there is little

you can do to avoid it. Again, it is

5:06:305:06:35

welcome. And given some of the

comments we have had today, if some

5:06:355:06:38

of these things were so easy to deal

with, why weren't they in the past?

5:06:385:06:49

It is welcome to see the change. It

was a cross-party spirit in the

5:06:495:06:52

Public Accounts Committee, and some

of the rhetoric we are hearing in

5:06:525:06:54

this chamber does not really fit

with some people's records in terms

5:06:545:06:57

of dealing with these areas. A final

one, having spent the weekend

5:06:575:07:02

talking with Daniel Maddox who is

campaigning around the issue of

5:07:025:07:07

potholes, it is always good to see

the reference in the red book to the

5:07:075:07:12

45 million to dealing with them.

Although it might be minor compared

5:07:125:07:16

with building a new tunnel around

Stonehenge or delivering a major

5:07:165:07:20

piece of infrastructure, but it is

the sort of thing that annoys those

5:07:205:07:23

who pay their taxes and want to see

a service in return. I do think this

5:07:235:07:28

is a welcome Budget. It will help

people which their aspirations. It

5:07:285:07:32

will help people buy their home and

it is a Budget which will help

5:07:325:07:36

Britain move forward and have

technology industries and a vibrant

5:07:365:07:39

private sector as we approach

Brexit.

5:07:395:07:51

That is a welcome Budget. It is a

Budget which will make Britain fit

5:08:025:08:04

for the future and it should be

supported by this House.

Before I

5:08:045:08:07

start I want to pay tribute to a

working-class hero whose funeral is

5:08:075:08:10

place today, Derek Robinson who said

I can sleep sound at night because I

5:08:105:08:12

never betray workers. Mr Speaker,

Cabinet source is quoted as saying

5:08:125:08:17

this Budget had the worst build-up

in history. I don't think he was

5:08:175:08:22

wrong. Members on the opposite bench

have gone bananas about the Budget

5:08:225:08:26

ahead of today. What is clear to me

if this Budget caps off seven years

5:08:265:08:30

of abject failure, first by the

coalition and now by the

5:08:305:08:34

Conservative minority government.

5:08:345:08:41

Contrary to the warm words we have

heard from the opposite benches,

5:08:415:08:45

this budget has proved that the

Government is out of touch, has no

5:08:455:08:49

idea about the lives of ordinary

people and certainly no plans of

5:08:495:08:53

improvement. What we are seeing here

is an irrational ideology, actually

5:08:535:08:59

tromping plain common sense.

They

are driven by a neoliberal ideology

5:08:595:09:04

which has proven that they are

certainly not a Government for the

5:09:045:09:08

many. I have to say, Mr Speaker,

where the help of world War paid

5:09:085:09:14

workers. The measures that the

Chancellor is announced on the

5:09:145:09:18

Universal Credit were absolutely

pathetic and it's also worth noting

5:09:185:09:21

that the don't come into effect

before Christmas either, so people

5:09:215:09:25

will be left penniless over the

Christmas period. Will is the

5:09:255:09:29

support for public sector workers?

Public sector workers, the defending

5:09:295:09:35

a decent society. I didn't hear any

Member -- mention of support for

5:09:355:09:39

them. Wood is the significant

support for the infrastructure this

5:09:395:09:45

country desperately needs. Where is

the best for health and education

5:09:455:09:49

and local Government? Social care is

an absolute crisis. Support for

5:09:495:09:54

vulnerable children is another area

and dictators. We have the

5:09:545:09:57

Chancellor say he is good to make

money available for fire safety, but

5:09:575:10:01

when local authorities have

approached the Government for

5:10:015:10:05

support with installing,

retrofitting sprinklers, that

5:10:055:10:09

support has been refused. The IMS

have estimated that local Government

5:10:095:10:14

funding will fall by 79% by 2020.

Ahead of this budget, the NHS chief

5:10:145:10:23

executive warned that without

funding, waiting lists will claim

5:10:235:10:28

further, the 5 million, and the 18

week target will be scrapped. The

5:10:285:10:33

key targets such as 62 day cancer

treatment targets, will be missed

5:10:335:10:40

and the extra money that has been

announced will not tackle that

5:10:405:10:42

crisis. Last year, we saw 40%, a 40%

cut in the adult skills budget.

5:10:425:10:51

Meaning that 1.3 million less adult

learners as a consequence of that.

5:10:515:10:57

We said that the -- we have the

chance see he said he wanted the two

5:10:575:11:02

make the dream of home ownership a

reality. With a cynical punter will

5:11:025:11:05

all mimic -- working-class people to

buy their own home? Where's the

5:11:055:11:12

house-building programme? The former

Chancellor promised that austerity

5:11:125:11:15

would wipe out the deficit, well, we

certainly haven't achieved that. The

5:11:155:11:21

failure to do that means that

hostility has permitted to nothing

5:11:215:11:25

more than conscious cruelty. They

have failed to eliminate the debt as

5:11:255:11:30

well and this Chancellor today said

that it is peaking. It seems to me

5:11:305:11:35

that all he is doing is fiddling

while Britain burns. Fiddling around

5:11:355:11:41

with the housing association, taking

that off the balance sheet, that is

5:11:415:11:45

nothing more than the tragedy. We

have seen a spectacular failure by

5:11:455:11:50

this Government on any measure in

relation to the debts and the

5:11:505:11:53

deficit. It's a case of rearranging

the deck chairs in the range to the

5:11:535:11:59

debt. I wonder whether the

Chancellor made to have a new job as

5:11:595:12:03

a deckchair attendant on debating

beach when he sacked from this

5:12:035:12:08

place. He has gone on to say that

there are more jobs than ever but

5:12:085:12:12

the problem is that after seven

years of hostility, probable --

5:12:125:12:20

productivity, the productivity

forecast has been wrong and causing

5:12:205:12:26

them to significantly downgraded

protections. -- projections.

5:12:265:12:30

Businesses are simply not investing

because they lack confidence in the

5:12:305:12:34

economy. The Tory ideology is wrong,

the doctrine that Daniel Lubbers --

5:12:345:12:39

neoliberalism says that the state

should be rolled back but it is

5:12:395:12:42

clear we need an entrepreneurial

state. I wonder if my colleagues the

5:12:425:12:51

lies that the Government has been

indulging in wilful sabotaging of

5:12:515:12:55

the economy, the adult skills budget

last year. That has resulted in an

5:12:555:13:05

1.23 million fewer adult learners.

Little wonder that the forecasts are

5:13:055:13:10

so anaemic for the dues: forward.

The previous Chancellor also said

5:13:105:13:18

that he wouldn't balance the books

on the backs of the power but that

5:13:185:13:21

is precisely what the Government has

done, with £12 billion more in

5:13:215:13:25

social security cuts for working age

people in the pipeline. The NHS

5:13:255:13:30

waiting lists, as we've heard, are

going to increase and the extra

5:13:305:13:35

funding for the NHS will simply not

actually tank all that very real

5:13:355:13:40

problem. We've also seen a skewed

level of investment and a different

5:13:405:13:46

region, we have the wooded spectacle

of investment on real in my region

5:13:465:13:50

of the East Midlands running at £91

per head, whereas in London is

5:13:505:13:56

running at £746 per head. We need a

different approach. It doesn't have

5:13:565:14:00

to be like this, Mr Speaker. Labour

would operate a different approach.

5:14:005:14:03

We would enter public sector

pick-up, pause fixing of the

5:14:035:14:09

Universal Credit to and he was a

real weapon which, bring in an

5:14:095:14:13

energy price cap, bring forward

infrastructure development in every

5:14:135:14:18

place in the country, studying ways

to -- large-scale house-building

5:14:185:14:24

programme and also have controls

over rent, scrap tuition fees and

5:14:245:14:29

stop penalising people for getting a

higher education, reverse the tax

5:14:295:14:32

cuts tip corporations and the

super-rich and content on the

5:14:325:14:37

disgraceful industrial scale tax

avoidance that takes place in this

5:14:375:14:41

country and rejected the toady's

Brexit cliff edge and the race to

5:14:415:14:44

the bottom that will turn Britain

into a deregulated tax haven. The

5:14:445:14:50

Chancellor claimed that he was

embracing the future but the truth

5:14:505:14:53

is this Government is stuck in a

Thatcherite past. Its dogmatic in

5:14:535:14:59

its commitment to neoliberalism,

despite the fact that it is not

5:14:595:15:02

working. Government administered

will remember, no doubt, from the

5:15:025:15:06

ideological training in the public

schools and elite universities that

5:15:065:15:10

the market is supposed to treat

wealth as an invisible hand, it's as

5:15:105:15:15

if the Tories believe in ghosts.

This budget shows that they still

5:15:155:15:19

believe in the invisible hand of the

market, but in reality no such thing

5:15:195:15:24

exists. They are deluding

themselves, pointy by ideology. What

5:15:245:15:30

Britain needs is a stealing hand of

an entrepreneurial state. What

5:15:305:15:33

Britain needs can Mr Speaker, as a

Labour Government that will provide

5:15:335:15:37

it. Rachel McLean.

Thank you very

much Mr Speaker and it's a great

5:15:375:15:46

privilege to fall all of the

Honourable members. As the Member of

5:15:465:15:50

-- I will take issue with the Member

for Derby North, on red Robbo, who

5:15:505:15:59

know from my campaigning. I was sure

the Honourable Member that a number

5:15:595:16:07

of supporters swore that he would --

they would never support level again

5:16:075:16:12

after what he said about destroying

the industry. It's a great privilege

5:16:125:16:17

for me to speak in this budget

debate is a new Member of Parliament

5:16:175:16:20

for the very first time and I really

do welcome this budget Mr Speaker --

5:16:205:16:25

and welcome this budget, Mr Speaker.

We on the site are always aware it

5:16:255:16:29

is not Government money that is

being spent, it is people's money.

5:16:295:16:34

Taxes must be raised and the

question is how. We have just heard

5:16:345:16:39

from the Honourable Member op. Cit.,

who is flooding the Communist party

5:16:395:16:44

plans. It's a stark choice. I did

not hear the Leader of the

5:16:445:16:50

Opposition, in his response to my

Right Honourable Friend the

5:16:505:16:52

Chancellor explain how he would fund

anything that he proposes. Our

5:16:525:16:57

plans, in contrast, are well thought

out. We understand the business is

5:16:575:17:02

and what is needed to support them.

That is why the Federation of Small

5:17:025:17:08

Businesses welcomes the budget

announced today and we made a choice

5:17:085:17:10

today between raising taxes on

private jets, which we are doing and

5:17:105:17:19

rewarding them for young people try

to buy their first House. I was an

5:17:195:17:24

entrepreneur for a 25 years before I

came into this place and, as my

5:17:245:17:30

Right Honourable Friend says, the

understand how difficult it is to

5:17:305:17:32

get a small buses off the ground. I

understand that, I have lived and

5:17:325:17:37

produced it. I am delighted to see

measures which are backing

5:17:375:17:42

entrepreneurial activity in this

country. Measures have already

5:17:425:17:47

created 197,000 jobs in our area

since 2010. In my constituency of

5:17:475:17:52

Redditch, we have seen 275 new

businesses being created, testament

5:17:525:17:56

to the spirit, the innovative spirit

of the people in my constituency.

5:17:565:18:03

Until it also that we have seen 6310

new apprenticeships and these are

5:18:035:18:09

good jobs. We are on the side of

working people and the Chancellor

5:18:095:18:13

today is going further by bringing

an Apis for ordinary working people

5:18:135:18:19

on the basic rate of tax of £1075.

This makes people better off. I

5:18:195:18:28

welcome this budget. This is a

budget which advances country and

5:18:285:18:33

does not proceed as the members op.

Cit., some of them, would want to

5:18:335:18:36

do. In the words of Robert Peel, he

talked about we must make a choice

5:18:365:18:42

between advancing or receding. He

understood the trade and that is

5:18:425:18:45

where we are going on the side of

the House. What we have seen, Mr

5:18:455:18:51

Speaker, we have seen corporation

tax receipts up by 20 billion since

5:18:515:18:55

2010. We have seen 5.5 million more

small businesses and think how many

5:18:555:19:02

more schools and hospitals can be

funded by this type of tax receipt

5:19:025:19:06

that is coming into the tragedy.

These are the business rates, that

5:19:065:19:10

is why I welcome the announcement

today from the Chancellor to remove

5:19:105:19:14

staircase tax and reform of business

rates relief. What they would do is

5:19:145:19:19

borrow more and they totally lacked

any coherent narrative. What we have

5:19:195:19:25

done as we saw borrowing, when we

came into Government that 73.2

5:19:255:19:31

6,000,000,020 ten. That was 3.8% of

GDP. Now it's ten to 49 billion,

5:19:315:19:39

which is 2.4% of GDP and the

Chancellor has said that how it will

5:19:395:19:42

fall further. My constituency and

Redditch will welcome that sensible

5:19:425:19:48

approach to managing the economy. We

know that boardroom war does not

5:19:485:19:52

work. We have already tried that

experiment. It crashed the

5:19:525:19:56

experiment and it was order working

people like my constituents in

5:19:565:19:59

Redditch that paid the price. I

welcome the Chancellor 's focus on

5:19:595:20:05

the Midlands engine and as a

Midlands MP myself, I have seen for

5:20:055:20:10

myself the higher work -- hard work

that went into the devolution deal

5:20:105:20:14

which will benefit others in

Redditch as well. Make no mistake, I

5:20:145:20:18

will also be bending the Chancellor

's year of further to make sure that

5:20:185:20:22

Redditch benefits from this, with

measures like an Institute of

5:20:225:20:25

technology for Redditch to harness

the skills and make a Redditch call

5:20:255:20:29

further and also an express train

from the Redditch to Birmingham. I

5:20:295:20:36

recognise that the restore

productivity gap between diligent in

5:20:365:20:38

our country and between cities and

towns outside and inside our cities,

5:20:385:20:41

for example, Redditch. That is why I

welcome the productivity fund and

5:20:415:20:45

the increase in RND and that has

been welcomed by the Royal Society

5:20:455:20:50

as well who say that this shows the

Government is focused on the UK's

5:20:505:20:54

technological future and the crucial

pipeline of skills necessary to make

5:20:545:20:58

sure we are at the forefront of the

technological revolution. And so I

5:20:585:21:02

am delighted also that we have seen

more technical business started, and

5:21:025:21:11

the Chancellor wants to see more,

more every hour, and as a former

5:21:115:21:17

tech business myself, I will welcome

this. I mention the taxes that we

5:21:175:21:24

have already raised in this

Government and we will continue to

5:21:245:21:27

lose through the budget measures. I

am very delighted to see that the

5:21:275:21:31

taxes are going into our hospitals.

£10 billion for the NHS and of

5:21:315:21:36

course the Chancellor will not be

supplied that I will be lobbying him

5:21:365:21:40

and his Right Honourable Friend the

Secretary of State for Health for

5:21:405:21:43

more money to the hospital in my

constituency. We have seen funds

5:21:435:21:47

pledged the old lady and I am guided

to see that underpinned the day. I

5:21:475:21:51

want to see that also going to fund

the winter pressures and I have been

5:21:515:22:02

award being quite strenuously for

that. Young families in Redditch

5:22:025:22:04

will welcome the measures on

housing. I have received an e-mail

5:22:045:22:06

from a constituent, Mr Andrew Bolt,

who is currently buying a small

5:22:065:22:09

House. He is due to save 200 and

80p, handy just before Christmas.

5:22:095:22:15

Some people are absolutely delighted

about the measures, so I am quite

5:22:155:22:19

shocked by some of the negativity I

have heard on the other side. We

5:22:195:22:23

should be getting an outward looking

vision of country from beyond the

5:22:235:22:28

four walls of this House to the

outside world and so I will just

5:22:285:22:32

finished, again, when I was

listening to the words of my Right

5:22:325:22:36

Honourable Friend to deliver his

budget, I was struck once again by

5:22:365:22:39

the presence of the world dislike

the words of Robert Peel, we face a

5:22:395:22:44

choice between shaping the future or

retreating into the past. The choice

5:22:445:22:47

between an open and innovative

society or a closed, narrowed one.

5:22:475:22:54

We -- me on these benches make our

choice. A country welcoming change,

5:22:545:22:58

welcoming the future and so

therefore I welcome this budget.

5:22:585:23:01

I always think it is worth trying to

find a few small mercies at the

5:23:065:23:11

beginning of a Budget analysis. The

Chancellor has gone to the trouble

5:23:115:23:14

of an hour-long speech and there

have got to be a few things. There

5:23:145:23:21

are some mitigating changes for the

impact of Universal Credit but there

5:23:215:23:26

are still many worries for our

constituents and the impact on the

5:23:265:23:32

severely disabled, for example. I'm

glad there were some changes that

5:23:325:23:36

might help with housing, although

talking to my City Council in

5:23:365:23:40

Nottingham, they have concerns that

many of the announcements are to be

5:23:405:23:45

competitively bid for funds that the

housing revenue account cap

5:23:455:23:49

relaxation may be only for areas of

high demand, so it is not clear that

5:23:495:23:53

will necessarily help cities outside

London. And of course we remain with

5:23:535:24:00

a 70% discount on council house

sales, so even if they do build more

5:24:005:24:04

stock, there is of course the

opportunity that it will be depleted

5:24:045:24:08

very quickly. I was particularly

disappointed the Chancellor didn't

5:24:085:24:13

mention social care at all in his

speech. It beggars belief, really,

5:24:135:24:19

that we had some discussion about

the NHS, but the big issue that is

5:24:195:24:25

strategically a block for many of

the problems we have within the NHS,

5:24:255:24:30

social -- social care was just

disregarded and I believe we need to

5:24:305:24:34

mention that in future days. If I

was to step back and think

5:24:345:24:38

strategically, what is the story of

this Budget, I think it is the very

5:24:385:24:43

start and depressing statistics in

the figures contained in the

5:24:435:24:47

Treasury Redbook. An enormous

downgrade of economic growth.

5:24:475:24:52

Dreadful figures from all over the

years from here on in. We're waving

5:24:525:24:58

goodbye to 2% levels of growth

because it is below those levels now

5:24:585:25:02

henceforth. A big downgrade in

productivity, the biggest, in fact,

5:25:025:25:07

since the office of the budget

responsibility was created. And a

5:25:075:25:12

big broken promise when it comes to

the deficit. Stretching now, as it

5:25:125:25:17

does, until 2022 and beyond. The

promise of that budget surplus seems

5:25:175:25:23

to have gone. Why is this the case?

It is fundamentally because the dark

5:25:235:25:28

clouds and the cold wind of Brexit

are looming large, and they are

5:25:285:25:34

already being felt. And any analysis

of our economic outlook or our

5:25:345:25:40

fiscal prospects cannot possibly

ignore this Brexit question. As I

5:25:405:25:47

say, I think the impact is being

felt on business investment because

5:25:475:25:53

the uncertainty about trade and

tariffs is holding back firms from

5:25:535:25:58

putting money into things that would

otherwise help create productivity.

5:25:585:26:03

And that lack of productivity has

fed into this growth downgrade,

5:26:035:26:08

which in turn has created a big hole

in forecasts of Treasury revenues,

5:26:085:26:15

which we vitally need to pay for

schools, hospitals and transport

5:26:155:26:19

schemes, all of those vital public

services that we have. When the Bank

5:26:195:26:24

of England surveys on their decision

panel further prospects of

5:26:245:26:30

investment, they are getting worse

and worse quarter after quarter, of

5:26:305:26:34

the quarter, looking into the

future, we can see the negative

5:26:345:26:38

effect that the clouds of Brexit are

having on our business investment

5:26:385:26:41

and productivity. When you look at

the impact of the devaluation of

5:26:415:26:46

sterling compared to the exchange

rate index, 17.5% lower than its

5:26:465:26:55

peak in 2015, that has hit all of

our constituents in their pockets to

5:26:555:26:58

a significant degree. It is

estimated around £600 per household

5:26:585:27:05

already now hitting households in

terms of reduction in real available

5:27:055:27:10

income that they have at their

disposal. We still have no idea

5:27:105:27:15

about a transitional status for what

might happen after that fabled cliff

5:27:155:27:20

edge in 2019, and therefore the

impact of uncertainty is likely to

5:27:205:27:26

cast that shadow for very many years

to come. Hopefully we will have some

5:27:265:27:31

resolution at the European Council

meeting before Christmas. But it

5:27:315:27:35

seems to be quite a tall order. And

when you look at perhaps the biggest

5:27:355:27:40

issue, the money, the fiscal impact,

the £3 billion committed for Brexit

5:27:405:27:48

preparations, what a waste of

resources when this is money that

5:27:485:27:50

should have been invested in the

health service, in our schools and

5:27:505:27:54

in our public services. In fact, in

2019 more money is committed to

5:27:545:27:59

Brexit preparations than was

committed for extra result of the

5:27:595:28:03

NHS. I think that if anything sums

up the dysfunction of this whole

5:28:035:28:07

scenario that we are faced with and

I think that statistic does that.

5:28:075:28:13

This is all before the massive

divorce bill, of course, that is

5:28:135:28:17

supposed to come. It wasn't the 350

pounds a week on the side of the

5:28:175:28:24

bus. For the NHS! That is long on!

Potentially £67 billion of a divorce

5:28:245:28:30

Bill. -- that is long gone. That is

two years of a budget deficit bill.

5:28:305:28:40

It is on page 17 of the Treasury's

Redbook, where I think we really get

5:28:405:28:47

that triple whammy, that real kick

about the impact Brexit will be

5:28:475:28:50

having on our public services,

because it is an enormous downgrade

5:28:505:28:55

in revenues. If you look at that

table, Mr Speaker, you will see that

5:28:555:29:02

in 2019, eight billion fewer

receipts forecast in 2020, in 2021

5:29:025:29:13

even more. These are enormous

figures and they really ought to be

5:29:135:29:17

a wake-up call for all Members of

Parliament, certainly for the

5:29:175:29:20

government, but for all members,

because this is a fate that does not

5:29:205:29:24

need to be set in stone. This is a

situation that can still be avoided.

5:29:245:29:30

We know, of course, that the people

who were in voting leave saying,

5:29:305:29:37

this is all done and dusted, Brexit

will take us over the cliff, there

5:29:375:29:42

are choices that we in Britain can

make, and I would say to my

5:29:425:29:46

honourable friends, as much to the

Government, it is our responsibility

5:29:465:29:52

to avoid the Brexit austerity that

is likely to cast a shadow over the

5:29:525:29:56

decade ahead, because this austerity

is something that will be the

5:29:565:29:59

responsibility of all of us unless

we opt to remain in the single

5:29:595:30:05

market and remain in the customs

union, to retain that tariff-free

5:30:055:30:09

trade that we have with our nearest

neighbours in order to avoid these

5:30:095:30:13

problems. I give way.

I've just

looked at page 17 of the Redbook and

5:30:135:30:21

the table he refers to. 1.2. That

shows the deficit going down from

5:30:215:30:26

58.3 billion to... That is the

receipts forecast, not indicating a

5:30:265:30:39

reduction because of Brexit.

It is a

reduction in receipts. He will see

5:30:395:30:44

the budget deficit was forecast in

spring to be £16 billion in 2021. In

5:30:445:30:51

this Budget it is predicted to be

33. The level of borrowing is

5:30:515:30:57

predicted to go up very

significantly, largely driven by the

5:30:575:31:00

fall in that 20 billion of receipts.

I think the figures are quite clear.

5:31:005:31:08

The government might say, well, we

don't need to take it from public

5:31:085:31:12

services now, we will add it to

borrowing, but that will be added

5:31:125:31:15

onto the debt interest and have to

be paid. But my suspicion is that

5:31:155:31:20

this will involve more fiscal

tightening and more austerity

5:31:205:31:23

towards the tail end of these years

ahead. And when you add up the

5:31:235:31:27

wasted money on Brexit preparation,

when you add the extra money of the

5:31:275:31:32

divorce Bill, when you look at the

level of receipts that are falling,

5:31:325:31:37

because of low productivity, because

of lower growth forecasts, which in

5:31:375:31:40

turn are driven by that dark cloud

of Brexit, this is the real story of

5:31:405:31:46

the Budget. It needn't be the fate

of this country, though, if we take

5:31:465:31:51

decisions, and I urge all honourable

members - let's not be responsible

5:31:515:31:56

for this level of austerity in the

future. We need a different fate and

5:31:565:32:00

we need to make sure we intervene

and retain that single market and

5:32:005:32:04

Customs union membership.

I'm sorry

I haven't been in for the whole of

5:32:045:32:10

the debate. I've been at the exiting

the European Union Select Committee

5:32:105:32:14

debating one of our reports, and we

have been firmly exercising split

5:32:145:32:20

infinitive and making sure

apostrophes are in the right place,

5:32:205:32:24

and all those important matters, but

it took me away from the chamber. It

5:32:245:32:28

is a pleasure to follow the

honourable member, the council of

5:32:285:32:34

Dublin East. But we often disagree

quite firmly. -- of Nottingham East.

5:32:345:32:41

In the context of Brexit we are

always told the end of the world is

5:32:415:32:48

nigh, it will all be terrible, and

yet when we look at the Redbook, we

5:32:485:32:52

know the figures we've had so far

are better in spite of the Treasury

5:32:525:32:56

and others saying it would all be a

disaster. So borrowing in 2017-18 is

5:32:565:33:04

49.9, 8 billion lower than forecast,

why? Because receipts are higher.

5:33:045:33:10

More money is coming in and that is

indicative of the economy

5:33:105:33:14

strengthening. On the page following

it indicates spending decisions and

5:33:145:33:18

tax decisions that have been taken

in the Budget. But I do have a

5:33:185:33:25

specific question for the Treasury

bench which may have been raised by

5:33:255:33:29

my honourable friend, the member for

Dover. On page 82, and it is copied

5:33:295:33:36

from page 142 -- 114 of the OBR

book, in 2022-23, it is said there

5:33:365:33:44

will be a £3.5 billion a resources

contribution to the EU. I cannot

5:33:445:33:50

believe those white figures could

have made a schoolboy error of

5:33:505:33:55

assuming money paid out in one year

would be so indefinitely. But it is

5:33:555:33:59

missing the point that by then we

will have left the EU, the

5:33:595:34:04

implementation period will have

ended, the whole concept of own

5:34:045:34:07

resources will have ceased to exist,

and this is rather like spotting an

5:34:075:34:12

error in the Rag'n'Bone Man. It is

where to do and I think we will

5:34:125:34:21

discover this is not intended. --

Anette error in the cricketers'

5:34:215:34:28

book. The error assumes we are still

members so I think there is an error

5:34:285:34:36

there. But I do think this ties in

with the points made very elegantly

5:34:365:34:40

earlier on by the honourable

gentleman that the key to this

5:34:405:34:47

Budget has to be Brexit. That what

we are doing currently is in the

5:34:475:34:52

context of Europe leaving the

European Union. Of course I give

5:34:525:34:55

way.

I would very much like to

respond to the point he has just

5:34:555:35:01

made on the subject of the forecast.

Those forecasts were made by the

5:35:015:35:05

OBR. They were provided with the

Prime Minister's Florence speech,

5:35:055:35:13

the basis on which we are

negotiating with the EU, and it is

5:35:135:35:17

up to them to make their own

independent forecasts. My

5:35:175:35:20

understanding is that you will have

to speak directly to the OBR about

5:35:205:35:26

that, but they have used an average

of other independent forecasts that

5:35:265:35:30

have been prepared.

I am grateful

but I don't think it works for the

5:35:305:35:36

resources figure because they have

made assumptions about our net

5:35:365:35:40

contribution to the EU and they have

assumed those monies will be spent

5:35:405:35:44

domestically in the UK, and

therefore there is no fiscal

5:35:445:35:47

advantage, but there is still a £3.5

million negative income from own

5:35:475:35:51

resources. It is hard to think the

OBR would have taken that from other

5:35:515:35:57

forecasters because that is a matter

directly understandable from the

5:35:575:36:01

Treasury, that the Treasury can give

an authoritative view on, and it

5:36:015:36:04

would be very odd if they hadn't

explained that own resources will

5:36:045:36:08

end at the point that we leave the

EU. It has two. Only member states

5:36:085:36:13

of the EU can make own resources

contribution is the very obvious

5:36:135:36:18

reasons. Though I've always disliked

the term own resources. I've always

5:36:185:36:22

been with Margaret Thatcher that it

is our money and we would quite like

5:36:225:36:25

to keep it, thank you very much! But

I would like to go back to the

5:36:255:36:30

original point that the Budget is

inevitably encompassed by Brexit and

5:36:305:36:34

productivity. And I think this is

where the challenge is. The OBR has

5:36:345:36:39

very gloomy forecasts on

productivity, and these lead to a

5:36:395:36:43

reduction in potential output in

2021-20 two by 3%. -- 2021-22. The

5:36:435:36:56

question is, how do they make Brexit

work to ensure we get a productivity

5:36:565:37:00

boost, and this is where I was so

encouraged by what the Chancellor to

5:37:005:37:04

stay, because he said this would be

a free trade government and this is

5:37:045:37:09

the real opportunity that comes from

Brexit. It is to open up our markets

5:37:095:37:13

to the rest of the world freely. We

have to remember that the customs

5:37:135:37:17

union, which the honourable

gentleman is so keen to stay in, is

5:37:175:37:23

actually a protectionist union that

stops people in the UK buying the

5:37:235:37:26

cheapest available goods, and by and

large, protect industry that the UK

5:37:265:37:31

does not have. The overwhelming

majority of the protection and the

5:37:315:37:37

customs union is for things like

German coffee processors or Spanish

5:37:375:37:43

orange growers. Those types of

things that we are not doing. Our

5:37:435:37:47

industries receive very marginal

protection from the customs union

5:37:475:37:52

but it is a very high cost to

British consumers. It is thought

5:37:525:37:56

that the cost of food is 20%, and

the next highest level of tariffs

5:37:565:38:01

comes on clothing and footwear. And

the opportunity here for the poorest

5:38:015:38:06

in our society to see their standard

of living boosted and their wages

5:38:065:38:10

rise is really quite fundamental,

that it will mean that their weekly,

5:38:105:38:16

monthly, annual expenditure will be

reduced, their real income will

5:38:165:38:20

rise, and this will make available

funds for other expenditures or

5:38:205:38:24

indeed the saving and reinvestment

in British industry. But equally, it

5:38:245:38:29

will mean that because we lose the

cosy protectionism, we cease to

5:38:295:38:36

subsidise continental inefficient

businesses and we also ensure we

5:38:365:38:39

concentrate on what we are best but,

and that ought to leave off itself

5:38:395:38:43

to a boost in productivity, and

indeed this is the lesson of

5:38:435:38:47

history. When you move to free

trade, and the removal not only

5:38:475:38:51

formal tariffs but also nontariff

barriers, and this, if things go

5:38:515:38:57

correctly and the correct policies

are adopted, is whether £350 million

5:38:575:39:02

a week can ultimately be provided

for the National Health Service. The

5:39:025:39:04

figures produced by Sir Patrick

Minford and his very distinguished

5:39:045:39:10

team at Cardiff University indicate

that there will be a boon of £135

5:39:105:39:15

billion between 2020 and 2025 and

£40 billion a year after, which will

5:39:155:39:22

be possible to have both tax cuts

and make it possible to fund the

5:39:225:39:27

health service. And it is very

encouraging to see that the

5:39:275:39:31

Chancellor has already begun this

process and is making more money

5:39:315:39:34

available for the health service at

this stage, because I think it is

5:39:345:39:39

important that politicians deliver

on the spirit of their promises as

5:39:395:39:41

well is on the detailed nit-picking

small print element of their

5:39:415:39:49

policies. So I think it is right

that that should be made possible,

5:39:495:39:54

and having a free-trade developer

and of economic policy is going to

5:39:545:39:58

be crucial to that and it is very

welcome the Chancellor has put this

5:39:585:40:02

in his Budget speech today.

5:40:025:40:10

The other issue important to our

voters is the issue of housing and

5:40:105:40:15

here I would encourage the

Chancellor to call further. I think

5:40:155:40:18

it is absolutely right that we have

more house-building. It is

5:40:185:40:22

absolutely right that the Government

is supporting that but the key to

5:40:225:40:26

that is going to be reform of the

planning system. The thing that

5:40:265:40:30

makes housing so expensive in this

country is that suppliers

5:40:305:40:33

controlled. As the Chancellor

rightly said in his budget speech,

5:40:335:40:37

actions to help demand are likely to

put prices up and what we need to

5:40:375:40:43

see as prices, at least in relation

to incomes, called down and that

5:40:435:40:48

means increasing supply and to

increase supply in a way that people

5:40:485:40:52

want to live. The one question I

would raise on the budget, Mr

5:40:525:40:59

Speaker, as when the Chancellor said

the ruble to ensure that housing was

5:40:595:41:03

primarily in an urban setting, but

actually when you ask people what

5:41:035:41:06

housing they want to 11, the, 80% of

people say they want to live in

5:41:065:41:12

houses with gardens and this means

we're going to have to build on the

5:41:125:41:16

green fields and it would be wise to

review the green belt, because there

5:41:165:41:20

are some areas of it which are not

actually essential to life and the

5:41:205:41:25

pursuit of happiness. What we really

want, Mr Speaker as a whole

5:41:255:41:32

succession of places around the

country, because that's what people

5:41:325:41:35

want to live in.

Liz Kendall. Thank

you Mr Speaker, and as always, it is

5:41:355:41:45

a pleasure to follow the comparable

gentleman. Mr Speaker, the challenge

5:41:455:41:50

facing any Government and any budget

is to boost her strengths, tackle

5:41:505:41:55

our weaknesses and prepare the

Government -- the country for the

5:41:555:41:59

future. I am afraid the Government

has failed to rise to these

5:41:595:42:03

challenges, not least in its

inadequate budget, but in its

5:42:035:42:07

damaging approach to Brexit and I

wanted to take each of these point

5:42:075:42:10

entirely. First, our economic

strengths. We are rightly proud of

5:42:105:42:17

our world leading car manufacturers,

pharmaceutical and Aerosmith

5:42:175:42:22

countries, creative industries and

universities and financial services.

5:42:225:42:25

We want and need these to expand and

thrive to create more good quality

5:42:255:42:31

jobs and help 's fund our vital

public services. But all of these

5:42:315:42:35

facing huge uncertainties because of

the Government 's determination to

5:42:355:42:41

boot is out -- Bill was out of the

single market and Customs union and

5:42:415:42:45

because of not just the acceptance

but the active desire of some

5:42:455:42:50

members opposite, to leave the EU

with no ordeal and fall back on WTO

5:42:505:42:55

rules. The risk of new tariffs and

custom barriers, or financial

5:42:555:43:00

services losing their passport

ingrates and restrictions on trade

5:43:005:43:04

with the largest market of 500

million consumers on our doorstep,

5:43:045:43:10

is a major cause of the war than

expected levels of business

5:43:105:43:15

investment and

5:43:155:43:25

productivity and growth figures that

we have heard in today's budget. The

5:43:285:43:31

Government cannot escape that, no

matter how much they want to sweep

5:43:315:43:33

it under the carpet. But it is not

just that the Government approach to

5:43:335:43:36

Brexit is risking our economic or

strengths, they are also failing to

5:43:365:43:38

address our underlying economic

weaknesses. I want to be clear here,

5:43:385:43:40

many of these existed before Brexit

and indeed before the financial

5:43:405:43:46

crisis, which I fear the Government

approach to Brexit will make far

5:43:465:43:50

worse. The fundamental problem we

have is that the Dove -- British

5:43:505:43:55

economy is no longer delivering the

rising earnings for the majority of

5:43:555:44:00

the population. We are in the

longest proceeded -- period of waste

5:44:005:44:05

-- the longest period of wage

stagnation for 150 years. While I

5:44:055:44:09

welcome our high levels of

employment, many of the jobs are

5:44:095:44:14

insecure and low paid and Child

poverty is arising. Britain is also

5:44:145:44:19

one of the most geographical and

balanced economies in Europe. 40% of

5:44:195:44:25

our economic output comes from

London and the south-east. Indeed,

5:44:255:44:28

these are the only two regions in

the country that has seen the

5:44:285:44:32

economies get back to precrisis

levels and we are also one of the

5:44:325:44:37

most unequal, not just in terms of

income inequality but wealth

5:44:375:44:42

inequality, which, as the IMF says,

really, really matters because more

5:44:425:44:47

unequal countries have shorter and

weaker periods of growth and, Mr

5:44:475:44:52

Speaker, for far too long our

economy has been plagued by shot

5:44:525:44:57

terrorism, pure productivity --

power productivity and a low-level

5:44:575:45:01

supple public and private

investment. I am afraid that nothing

5:45:015:45:05

the Chancellor said today indicates

that the Government understands the

5:45:055:45:10

sheer scale of this problem or has a

plan for reforming our economy, for

5:45:105:45:17

reforming capitalism so it works for

the majority of people in every

5:45:175:45:20

single part of the country. And this

leaves me, Mr Speaker, to my final

5:45:205:45:27

point about preparing the cobbler --

the country for the future. We face

5:45:275:45:32

a big, big challenges alongside that

of Brexit. Deeper globalisation as

5:45:325:45:37

emerging economies to the east and

this is increasingly compete on

5:45:375:45:41

high-value products and services,

not just the basic manufacturing.

5:45:415:45:46

Our ageing population and the

implications this has for

5:45:465:45:59

pensions, the NHS and social care.

Technological change, which is

5:46:015:46:03

opening up huge opportunities for

some but the risks leaving those

5:46:035:46:05

without the skills they need behind

and, the continuing need to check

5:46:055:46:08

all -- to chuckle climate change. I

am glad the Chancellor announced

5:46:085:46:10

measures to that encourage more

young people to take A-level

5:46:105:46:12

mathematics and invest in driverless

car a spot where was the plan to

5:46:125:46:15

transform the skills in this

country? Where was the plan to

5:46:155:46:19

invest in the early years so every

child starts ready to learn? Where

5:46:195:46:24

children from the previous parts of

my constituency start school 20

5:46:245:46:28

months behind with these should be,

they play catch up for the rest of

5:46:285:46:31

their lives. Where was the plan to

help the 5 million adults without

5:46:315:46:36

basic skills who will never cope

with the changes technology and

5:46:365:46:51

globalisation £2.8 billion extra in

the next few years but the NHS, said

5:46:525:46:55

the Chancellor. That is pathetically

inadequate and unless the £3 billion

5:46:555:46:57

on preparing for Brexit -- less than

£3 billion preparing for Brexit and

5:46:575:47:00

nothing in the budget for social

care to get older and disabled

5:47:005:47:03

people and their families, who are

desperately to cope, the health and

5:47:035:47:07

support they need. That, Mr Speaker,

brings me back to Brexit. The single

5:47:075:47:13

most important thing we want in this

budget is that there will be slower

5:47:135:47:16

growth every year for five years.

That means £65 billion less to spend

5:47:165:47:25

on transforming this country and the

life chances of the people we

5:47:255:47:28

represent than we thought it just

one year ago. On any economic test,

5:47:285:47:34

these forecasts are a disaster and

the Government only has itself to

5:47:345:47:39

blame.

Can I just advise the House

in the situation we find ourselves.

5:47:395:47:46

One Honourable Member has offered to

speak on another day. Others are

5:47:465:47:51

surely seized on the importance of

them speaking today. I completely

5:47:515:47:55

understand that but the fact is that

eight people wish to speak and deaf

5:47:555:47:58

ear to do so by seven o'clock, they

can do the arithmetic for

5:47:585:48:03

themselves. That is the reality.

There is no good reporting --

5:48:035:48:08

complaining to the whip. Have two

recognise the responsibility they

5:48:085:48:13

have. There were lots of

interventions and that the

5:48:135:48:16

situation.

I will try to tailor my

remarks with that in mind. It is a

5:48:165:48:24

pleasure to follow the Honourable

Lady from Leicester West and with

5:48:245:48:32

what she says, but she speaks with

passion and verve and I have to say,

5:48:325:48:37

don't want to embarrass horror or

her Honourable Friend but I can that

5:48:375:48:41

with what I heard from the Leader of

Opposition earlier, a lot of noise

5:48:415:48:48

and colour but not necessarily any

discernible theme that I could pick

5:48:485:48:51

up. Everyone on both sides of this

House wants to see good public

5:48:515:48:56

services. They want to see them well

supported, delivering for our

5:48:565:49:01

constituents. I welcome, as the

Honourable Lady from the DUP said

5:49:015:49:05

earlier, the slight fiscal loosening

of the next two or three years as a

5:49:055:49:09

recognition of need other public

sector and perhaps Independent paid

5:49:095:49:15

reviews will give us some leeway in

that direction as well. That is

5:49:155:49:19

right and appropriate but it is also

great it is executed in the context

5:49:195:49:23

of a broader plan in which our

national debt is being brought under

5:49:235:49:26

control we will over this forecast,

from my back of the envelope

5:49:265:49:32

register deaths at the level it was

an 2001 when the Honourable

5:49:325:49:37

gentlemen and ladies opposite were

running the Government, as far as I

5:49:375:49:40

recall, back in 2001, that was the

last year which load very sensibly,

5:49:405:49:45

the fiscal envelope be dictated by

merit Honourable Friend, the number

5:49:455:49:50

for Rushcliffe. The next year, our

total debt as a percentage of the

5:49:505:49:54

East -- DGP will decline by a single

point. Fiscal hole of historic

5:49:545:50:03

proportions that we inherited.

Reducing the deficit is not

5:50:035:50:07

glamorous or popular but it is

necessary. The businesses in the up

5:50:075:50:11

the resilience for future shocks. It

is necessary on the grounds of

5:50:115:50:19

simple fairness to our generations

but to maintain that process of debt

5:50:195:50:23

reduction and sustain her investment

in public services, the Chancellor

5:50:235:50:29

is absolutely right to focus on

productivity puzzle. I respected the

5:50:295:50:35

APR, I respect the economic forecast

that have been referred difficultly

5:50:355:50:38

this afternoon. I personally feel

more optimistic as the pace of

5:50:385:50:42

growth goes, but they are forecasts,

the Co-op, they go down and that is

5:50:425:50:47

the nature of forecast. As they will

be our itself says, the outlook for

5:50:475:50:52

potential productivity growth is the

most important yet uncertain element

5:50:525:50:58

predicting growth. They are right on

both counts. Which is why I applaud

5:50:585:51:05

the Chancellor in embracing new

technologies. We have an excellent

5:51:055:51:12

record on unemployment. Bob then my

constituency and nationally, what a

5:51:125:51:17

thousand jobs today being treated as

2010. The challenge as a country and

5:51:175:51:20

not just this country but there are

challenges to make sure that our

5:51:205:51:28

employees received the investment,

the education, the infrastructure

5:51:285:51:31

and the support two hours to drive

up productivity and enhance further

5:51:315:51:36

growth. I welcome the measures in

this budget directly aimed at

5:51:365:51:39

long-term improvement in

productivity. A further 2.3 billion

5:51:395:51:46

in art indeed, enhancement to the

R&D tax credit, the website and the

5:51:465:51:51

investment target of 2.4% of GDP. As

someone who sees the UK as a liberal

5:51:515:51:56

country open to the world, I am

delighted at the approach is laid

5:51:565:52:01

out in the red book to attract the

best scientific talent anywhere in

5:52:015:52:04

the world to work and flourish here

in the UK. On education, which was

5:52:045:52:09

referred to as the Honourable Lady

from Leicester West, eye on them --

5:52:095:52:13

-- I welcome the new approaches to

education. Schools that plays a huge

5:52:135:52:19

important on Stem subjects, such as

Horsham who provide extra resources

5:52:195:52:26

for students who want to embrace

these new technology.

I just want to

5:52:265:52:29

enter up to say that I know the

Honourable Gentleman extremely well

5:52:295:52:33

and he speaks in his mellifluous

tone with great eloquence and he is

5:52:335:52:37

correct is right capable of doing so

at any length, short or long and now

5:52:375:52:40

that he will want to have regard to

the simmering temperature of the

5:52:405:52:45

Honourable Gentleman for Wrexham,

who is to follow him and other

5:52:455:52:48

colleagues who also wish to

contribute and therefore I speak of

5:52:485:52:50

some confidence and seeing his time

is nigh.

Mr Speaker, I promised I

5:52:505:52:58

would be brief and there will be

belief. Education, I welcome it and

5:52:585:53:01

the infrastructure, more housing, I

welcome it. This is a wide budget

5:53:015:53:07

with a lot to commend it. At the

problems of the past were sitting at

5:53:075:53:12

the foundations for the future. I am

sorry and not able to entertain the

5:53:125:53:16

House at any greater length but that

is powerful it clear that others

5:53:165:53:19

should have the shed and with that I

commend

5:53:195:53:21

Thank you. I am grateful for him at

allowing us to speak as he has been

5:53:275:53:34

here since 11:30am today. I want to

talk about regional policy. I have

5:53:345:53:39

obviously restricted the amount I am

going to speak today but I want to

5:53:395:53:44

raise one particular issue relating

to the HMRC in my constituency in

5:53:445:53:48

Wrexham. It is directly connected to

regional policy. There was a time

5:53:485:53:53

when the party opposite talked about

rebalancing the economy. There was a

5:53:535:53:58

time when there seemed to be a

commitment to something called the

5:53:585:54:01

northern powerhouse. I recall a

committee that I attended a couple

5:54:015:54:07

of years ago with the then

Chancellor of the ex-Jack -- the

5:54:075:54:14

Chancellor of the Exchequer, when

they talked about the investment in

5:54:145:54:16

the north of England. I have had

some time to read the Redbook today.

5:54:165:54:22

There is quite a large section about

investment in the Cambridge, Milton

5:54:225:54:29

Keynes, Oxford corridor. One of the

most affluent places in the United

5:54:295:54:33

Kingdom. I believe in an economy

that serves the whole of this

5:54:335:54:37

country. What I want to tell the

Honourable secretary of the Treasury

5:54:375:54:45

is another corridor that exists

between Manchester and Holyhead and

5:54:455:54:50

contains some of the world leading

companies in the UK - Airbuses, JVC

5:54:505:54:58

- and that is an area of the country

that the private sector is investing

5:54:585:55:06

in. In Wrexham, Virgin Media is

investing in superfast broadband

5:55:065:55:11

networks, and had a company

announced last week they will move

5:55:115:55:15

into Wrexham with the creation of

250 jobs. They have confidence in

5:55:155:55:20

the area. Unfortunately, the

Government is moving away the local

5:55:205:55:24

HMRC office in Wrexham, unbelievably

to central Cardiff! So that the only

5:55:245:55:35

office of the HMRC in Wales that

will exist is going to be in the

5:55:355:55:38

city centre in Cardiff, which is the

most expensive place in the country.

5:55:385:55:44

How any sane government can pursue a

regional policy of that type is

5:55:445:55:48

completely beyond me. Because not

only is it wrong in terms of

5:55:485:55:53

regional policy, it is taking away

wealth from another part of Wales.

5:55:535:55:59

And any sensible government would

actually be doing exactly the

5:55:595:56:02

opposite. Because a sensible

government, the Welsh government, is

5:56:025:56:08

setting up a development plan for

Wales in Wrexham as opposed to

5:56:085:56:11

Cardiff. I would like the Chief

Secretary to go away and to rethink.

5:56:115:56:22

To rethink what I think is the worst

decision and most incomprehensible

5:56:225:56:26

decision that any government

department has made in the time I've

5:56:265:56:29

been in this House. I think this

Government will you need to reflect

5:56:295:56:34

on whether it really believes in the

United Kingdom, about whether it

5:56:345:56:38

really believes in investment in our

regions and our nations, because

5:56:385:56:44

every indication that I've seen from

what we've seen today is that they

5:56:445:56:48

don't support investment in

infrastructure in the regions and

5:56:485:56:55

nations of the United Kingdom. In

North Wales we've had three separate

5:56:555:57:00

Budgets where we've been told that

plans for North Wales growth deal

5:57:005:57:05

are in hand. This is the hat-trick.

This is the hat-trick budget. We are

5:57:055:57:12

yet to see a penny piece of

investment in North Wales from the

5:57:125:57:16

UK Government. In our transport

infrastructure. We are yet to see a

5:57:165:57:24

penny invested in our rail network

for which this Government has

5:57:245:57:30

responsibility since 2010. They

ought to be ashamed. It is about

5:57:305:57:33

time they put their finger out and

do things differently.

Thank you. So

5:57:335:57:44

much for the fudge it Budget.

Virtually no mention of Brexit, and

5:57:445:57:54

we know there are 58 sector reports

that he will be in contempt if he

5:57:545:57:58

doesn't reveal them to this House

and he didn't reveal them at all in

5:57:585:58:03

his Budget speech. Even before

Budget, we saw the government

5:58:035:58:06

increase debt as a proportion of GDP

from 45 to 95%, doubled since 2010.

5:58:065:58:13

Our debt is now 1.8 trillion, 30,000

per person. Under Labour we saw

5:58:135:58:21

growth of 40% over ten years up to

2008 before the banking crisis, so

5:58:215:58:27

that sets the context of how

appalling things have been under the

5:58:275:58:33

Tories. We've seen hopeless

productivity and growth. With senior

5:58:335:58:39

policy of quantitative easing, which

basically pumped money in, inflated

5:58:395:58:43

assets, and anybody with assets like

houses would be richer, and those

5:58:435:58:47

without them would be poorer. We

know from the OECD that growth is

5:58:475:58:52

related to inequality. There is more

inequality and less growth. We know

5:58:525:58:56

from the European studies using the

normal methodology is that the level

5:58:565:59:02

of inequality has grown fastest and

at the highest level in the UK. And

5:59:025:59:06

we know from the United Nations that

the cuts have hit the disabled

5:59:065:59:10

harder than anyone else,

disproportionately and grotesquely,

5:59:105:59:15

so their rights have been abused,

and the UN has asked the way we

5:59:155:59:19

change the way we deliver Universal

Credit. It is appalling. Turning to

5:59:195:59:24

Brexit itself, nobody on the other

side has mentioned the £40 billion

5:59:245:59:32

divorce Bill, the lender being in

the region of £1000 per person.

5:59:325:59:37

People have talked about free trade.

This is the biggest withdrawal from

5:59:375:59:42

free trade in UK history. We are

turning our back on the biggest and

5:59:425:59:46

most established marketplace in the

world and we hope to have a

5:59:465:59:51

relationship with other markets, but

they are coalescing in their own

5:59:515:59:54

trade agreements. We are likely to

pay massive tariffs to the EU and

5:59:546:00:00

the WTO, and given most of the

exports are services, even more to

6:00:006:00:04

those. We have seen depreciation

produce of a stroke everybody's

6:00:046:00:09

assets and wages by ten and 15% and

we have got inflation eating away at

6:00:096:00:16

people'shousehold incomes, whether

it is in terms of food or energy. We

6:00:166:00:21

have seen growth at the bottom of

the G7 and we are now seeing skills

6:00:216:00:25

leaving the country, going back to

parts of Europe and Poland, as we

6:00:256:00:31

are gaining restricted market access

and disinvestment. So the prospects

6:00:316:00:35

for Britain are appalling. Obviously

I welcome a few things. The clean

6:00:356:00:42

air bill today, many years after

Tony Benn. So I welcome some of the

6:00:426:00:50

things about clean air, but there is

no increase in diesel duty. That

6:00:506:00:57

could be hypothecated to pay for

electric buses in our city centres.

6:00:576:01:02

I welcome the initiative on taxes. I

would have liked to see the Swansea

6:01:026:01:10

clean air focused in here because

they cannot be exploited if we are

6:01:106:01:17

not to see climate change. And I

would like to see a Swansea Metro

6:01:176:01:23

for my constituents. Unfortunately,

we have a future now whereby we will

6:01:236:01:27

be forced into the grabbing hands of

Donald Trump and the trade

6:01:276:01:32

relationships where we will be on

the back foot, and we will have to

6:01:326:01:36

accept what we are given. I do fear

for the future and I solemnly

6:01:366:01:40

believe that the British people on

the margin, when they were given a

6:01:406:01:47

mandatory reason for leaving Europe,

that they should be given the final

6:01:476:01:50

say in 2018 as to whether what they

are getting now represents what they

6:01:506:01:56

understood they would get in 2016. I

will leave my remarks there.

I would

6:01:566:02:03

like to start by reminding the House

that the Bristol economy is a net

6:02:036:02:10

contributor of about £10 billion

annually and I ask, what do we get

6:02:106:02:13

for it? I have looked in the red

book and it's not there. A few

6:02:136:02:17

paltry comments. Once again we have

been short-changed by this

6:02:176:02:20

Government. In Bristol the reality

of low-paid jobs is masked. Young

6:02:206:02:28

people are least likely in the

country to go to university and our

6:02:286:02:35

people are least likely to end up on

apprenticeships. We have 20% of our

6:02:356:02:39

people living with a life affecting

visibility. This is a scandalous

6:02:396:02:44

loss of people. I welcome the

Chancellor's commitment to

6:02:446:02:50

house-building as this is crucial

for my constituency but with house

6:02:506:02:54

inflation at 14% in Bristol, the cut

in stamp duty will not be of much

6:02:546:02:58

help. And I look forward to hearing

whether the council will be able to

6:02:586:03:04

borrow more to build much-needed

council houses to rent in the

6:03:046:03:08

future. We have young people in

Bristol ready to build these houses

6:03:086:03:13

to feed the supply chain but we

desperately need an opportunity to

6:03:136:03:16

train them. The wage differential

for housing construction

6:03:166:03:20

apprenticeships is good compared to

others but most of our young people

6:03:206:03:24

don't get on good apprenticeships.

Last November the city of Bristol

6:03:246:03:29

College was awarded pipeline status

to get a construction centre built

6:03:296:03:32

in my constituency. The previous

member visited with me earlier this

6:03:326:03:37

year and I pointed out to him the

site where it can be built, but

6:03:376:03:41

still the Local Enterprise

Partnership have not invested the

6:03:416:03:44

money. There was no coherence in the

Department for Education at the

6:03:446:03:48

moment for capital money and

investment and the Chancellor needs

6:03:486:03:50

to stop wasting that money and

invest where it is needed. We have

6:03:506:03:54

also heard a lot this week about

apprenticeships, about the pledge of

6:03:546:04:00

driverless cars and other sectors

the Government believes a priority.

6:04:006:04:06

Contrast that with the money for

technical qualifications. I have

6:04:066:04:11

supported apprenticeship schemes in

this House for a long time but

6:04:116:04:16

focusing on new starts means

quantity over quality. May I remind

6:04:166:04:24

the Chancellor of the 61% levy and

the target will not be meant. Isn't

6:04:246:04:31

good enough today to refer to the

levy he will keep. I also welcome

6:04:316:04:36

the commitment to technical

education as part of an attempt to

6:04:366:04:40

fill the skills gap. But again there

is no money in this further

6:04:406:04:43

education. A mere £20 million.

Another group -- acutely aware that

6:04:436:04:48

have been huge delays in rolling out

this programme. We are losing

6:04:486:04:53

critical time. If the issues stem

from a lack of funding than I would

6:04:536:04:58

it expect to see something more in

this budget. Instead, my local

6:04:586:05:02

college is facing cuts since 2030

and participation rates have halved.

6:05:026:05:11

More than 2000 adults failed to be

eligible, more wasted potential. We

6:05:116:05:20

also have the lowest attainment

rates for higher education in the

6:05:206:05:23

country. Disadvantage starts in

early years and in schools. There

6:05:236:05:28

are £1.9 million of cuts coming to

schools in Bristol and the lower

6:05:286:05:31

inflation funding formula will

represent a funding decrease. And on

6:05:316:05:38

health, on the Public Accounts

Committee last year, we nailed the

6:05:386:05:43

lie that the NHS got to ask for lost

time. That's not get into this again

6:05:436:05:47

next time. Of course you bunny is

welcome but it is not sufficient to

6:05:476:05:50

do the job that the government have

asked the NHS to do. -- of course

6:05:506:05:56

the money is welcome. And we have

heard about the silent misery of

6:05:566:06:02

families living in the social care

crisis. I've not heard a single Tory

6:06:026:06:07

defend those reforms. The

destruction of that act is apparent

6:06:076:06:11

to us all. Nobody in charge locally

to do anything about it.

It is a

6:06:116:06:17

real pleasure to follow the member

for Bristol South. And to speak in

6:06:176:06:23

this Budget debate. The outlook for

the economy is bleak. The worst

6:06:236:06:27

five-year forecast of GDP since the

office the budget responsibility was

6:06:276:06:31

set up. Against the backdrop of the

drop in sterling and the increase in

6:06:316:06:35

inflation. As the Chancellor stood

up to speak, the cost of Brexit was

6:06:356:06:41

clear. In excess of £3 billion.

Let's put that on the side of a bus.

6:06:416:06:49

My constituency has been starved of

funding for the last seven years and

6:06:496:06:53

the capacity for us to educate and

care for our citizens as well as

6:06:536:06:58

keep them safe has deteriorated and

will fall further. While London

6:06:586:07:02

remains seemingly a vibrant economy,

there is a yawning gap between the

6:07:026:07:07

haves and have-nots. Earlier in the

debate, the honourable member for

6:07:076:07:11

Wrexham spoke of his region and his

concerns about his region. But there

6:07:116:07:15

is inequality within a region as

well. Because often in London, we

6:07:156:07:20

walked the same streets but inhabit

different worlds. Wages are flat,

6:07:206:07:27

household debt is up, transport and

infrastructure continue to stall,

6:07:276:07:30

having negative effect on industry

and workers alike. Housing across

6:07:306:07:34

the three housing ten years either

hoping to buy, private-sector

6:07:346:07:38

renters and those languishing on

housing lists are all in desperate

6:07:386:07:43

housing need. -- the three housing

groups. Disappointingly, the rough

6:07:436:07:49

sleeping initiative in the speech

did not include tackling rough

6:07:496:07:52

sleeping in the capital. I think we

all noticed as we went to our

6:07:526:07:57

meetings and the Budget debate this

morning that there were two homeless

6:07:576:08:01

men sleep outside the door of the

House of Commons. I think that is

6:08:016:08:05

what we would like to tackle here as

Labour members, and sadly, I fear

6:08:056:08:10

that when we come to do this next

year, there may even be more

6:08:106:08:15

homeless people lying in sleeping

bags outside the doors of the House

6:08:156:08:19

of Commons. While London remains one

of the top destinations for business

6:08:196:08:24

and international talent, transport

and infrastructure continue to

6:08:246:08:29

stall, and it's time we all woke up

to that. The borough of Haringey has

6:08:296:08:34

seen a 40% real terms reduction in

funding since 2010, resulting in

6:08:346:08:41

£160 million of savings, affecting

disabled people, basic municipal

6:08:416:08:46

services, children with special

educational needs and generally

6:08:466:08:49

having a depressing effect on the

local economy. This worrying trend

6:08:496:08:54

is set to continue, with 20 million

more to be found in one London

6:08:546:08:58

Borough's finances. A dangerous

cocktail of growing demand, cost and

6:08:586:09:04

inflation combined with funding cuts

is putting unsustainable pressure on

6:09:046:09:07

local government finances. Core

funding from central government is

6:09:076:09:12

set to have fallen 63% in real terms

over the decade 2019-20. I tell the

6:09:126:09:19

children when I go into schools, it

is like your mum gives you £1 and

6:09:196:09:24

then the next day, 30p, and that is

what it is like the council 's these

6:09:246:09:29

days. People in Hornsey and Wood

Green know this well. There is a

6:09:296:09:33

desperate shortage of housing but

also issues with health and we are

6:09:336:09:37

very concerned that so many

trusts...

She will want to introduce

6:09:376:09:44

some balance in her speech because

she is fair-minded. What does she

6:09:446:09:48

welcome, the investment in housing,

transport or the cut in stamp duty?

6:09:486:10:00

What I would like to see, rather

than the millions wasted on the

6:10:006:10:05

Brexit shambles is more than a

billion for the NHS, it is under

6:10:056:10:09

what she is saying that we need. In

the 37 out of 37 schools having the

6:10:096:10:15

budget tool between 20 1516 and

201920, teaching assistants are all

6:10:156:10:25

calling for desperately needed

change. English and is well to

6:10:256:10:29

police funding cuts which are barely

got a mention, that looks like the

6:10:296:10:32

Home Office is swept -- said to have

to swallow the 400 million cut to

6:10:326:10:36

the police. In the affluent suburb

of Highgate, I was out on Monday

6:10:366:10:40

morning speaking the terrified

mothers who had things are stolen by

6:10:406:10:49

mopeds driving youngster to head

smashed in the wonders of the cafe,

6:10:496:10:53

it has happened four times as they

moved into the high street. We are

6:10:536:10:56

facing a claim with London and it

does need to be addressed. Finally,

6:10:566:11:00

I would like to briefly mention the

797 million or £410 cut per person

6:11:006:11:09

in the North Central London area.

Many members will be aware that

6:11:096:11:15

there are huge pressures,

particularly on mental health and

6:11:156:11:18

use shorts of cups, £510 per person

will have a huge cut -- a huge

6:11:186:11:25

impact on people with serious mental

health problems. Just finally, can I

6:11:256:11:29

just say that I do welcome element

of the changes to small business

6:11:296:11:34

approaches within taxation but I

also think that we must go further

6:11:346:11:37

on that. As our population continues

to call and people work in different

6:11:376:11:42

ways, including in small business,

we need to be ever made of

6:11:426:11:46

supporting them. Thank you Madam

Deputy Speaker.

Thank you Madam

6:11:466:11:52

Deputy Speaker, will try to rush

through this as quickly as I

6:11:526:11:55

possibly can. We in the SNP called

for a budget to keep the drag the

6:11:556:11:59

people and prosperity at its heart.

I'm afraid we have not seen that.

6:11:596:12:07

There was nothing today on renewable

energy. Despite the warm words for

6:12:076:12:12

ministers just reaching -- years on

from the betrayal that might the

6:12:126:12:17

betrayal by George Osborne over

Peterhead, there is nothing on

6:12:176:12:19

carbon capture and storage, the call

to what we need for the future. Very

6:12:196:12:24

little on oil and gas holder we

welcome at long last the

6:12:246:12:29

transitional tax as to the move.

Nowhere to be seen as the oil and

6:12:296:12:33

gas ambassador that was promised.

This phantom appointment two years

6:12:336:12:37

in the waiting, when it could have

been doing good for the North Sea

6:12:376:12:42

industry. No acknowledgement of the

monumental error of judgment that is

6:12:426:12:47

frankly see nuclear investment.

Where a public appearance committee

6:12:476:12:51

said today there were grave

strategic errors over this and they

6:12:516:12:55

had given no thoughts to consumers

before walking into a 35 year deal

6:12:556:13:00

and it falls the National Audit

Office publicity and expensive

6:13:006:13:05

judgment twice the price of new

offshore, consumers paying the

6:13:056:13:10

price. The committee said the poor I

had the hardest. This is not a

6:13:106:13:13

budget for people, like the one for

posterity. -- prosperity. We find

6:13:136:13:20

there would be 3.5 billion spent on

the Brexit users. Web as spend that

6:13:206:13:26

on the edge and stash by the NHS

instead. We could have heard support

6:13:266:13:32

for our farmers, or gently, who need

a clear explanation of the nature

6:13:326:13:36

and timetable for the guarantee of

all European Union funding

6:13:366:13:40

programmes, not at 2020 but for the

period beyond. The thing to do with

6:13:406:13:45

the skills and Labour shortages now

being caused by the Brexit shambles

6:13:456:13:48

and uncertainty. Nothing about the

traces that has been caused for NHS

6:13:486:13:57

fish processing, tourism sectors, to

name just a few. The fact that is

6:13:576:14:03

that we don't know what is happening

it for EU nationals and we are

6:14:036:14:07

seeing people leaving the industry.

Much was made earlier about it

6:14:076:14:11

technology and yet nothing about

broadband, no increase in ambition

6:14:116:14:15

has been shown in this budget, to

match the 100% coverage promised by

6:14:156:14:21

Scotland. If it was left to the UK

Government and the Highlands, only

6:14:216:14:28

21% of the India would have access

to fibre. It has taken the Scottish

6:14:286:14:33

Government stepping up with a £400

billion to bring it to 84% and on

6:14:336:14:38

track to 100%. Where we are on

Scotland, Madam Deputy Speaker, the

6:14:386:14:43

£2.9 billion cut that we have seen

is not matched. 1.1 billion of this

6:14:436:14:51

is in financial attractions which

has two B depict the UK Treasury and

6:14:516:14:55

it has over three years. Edin Dzeko

term cut of £32 million. Where was

6:14:556:15:02

the movement won a wasp in? These

women have been waiting far too long

6:15:026:15:07

to get something from the Chancellor

to sort them out. He said the -- you

6:15:076:15:11

said earlier we are all in politics

to make people's lives better. We

6:15:116:15:14

had a big opportunity to do that

today but she missed it. He could

6:15:146:15:20

have halted it and fix the Universal

Credit. After four years since the

6:15:206:15:24

pilot then my constituency in 2013,

we have been telling the UK

6:15:246:15:28

Government things they could do to

sort this. I will steps, but let's

6:15:286:15:38

not get dazzled. This is not going

to change much. The £1.5 billion

6:15:386:15:40

invention announce sounds good but

if you look at the blue book, it is

6:15:406:15:44

£21 million today and goes up to

2023. That is less confusing alcohol

6:15:446:15:51

duty. The one-week production to

five weeks is also welcome and it's

6:15:516:15:59

something but again, it will be of

little help to many. 25% of Clement

6:15:596:16:05

are already waiting longer and the

cuts are pushing people further into

6:16:056:16:08

crisis. They could help by

decoupling the housing benefit. That

6:16:086:16:18

would help enormously. It could have

helped ease burdens as a woman's

6:16:186:16:22

budget could have pointed out, by

April 2021, employed individuals

6:16:226:16:28

claiming Universal Credit will be

£1200 a year worse off and 57% of

6:16:286:16:33

that is due to be a cut work

allowance. His failure to hold

6:16:336:16:38

Universal Credit means that he is

doing nothing to help families

6:16:386:16:43

waiting for months without payment.

Nothing to sort the systemic failure

6:16:436:16:47

systemic failure -- failure is

6:16:476:16:58

nothing to the disabled, no help or

guarantees to those facing eviction

6:16:586:17:00

or facing having no money this

Christmas. No attempt to remove,

6:17:006:17:03

finally, the cruellest features, the

wait for a cancer patient or the

6:17:036:17:05

terminally ill. He could have done

something that costs absolutely

6:17:056:17:07

nothing today, Madam Deputy Speaker,

he could have removed the new

6:17:076:17:13

requirement for Universal Credit for

self certification of those people

6:17:136:17:16

facing terminal illness. This is not

the budget for people or facility.

6:17:166:17:28

Thank you very much Madam Deputy

Speaker. I am please to fold

6:17:286:17:32

Honourable Member for Inverness and

to take part in the budget debate

6:17:326:17:34

today. The British economy has

basically got to problems. It has a

6:17:346:17:38

low productivity growth, a worker in

France or Germany can go home on a

6:17:386:17:44

first in eight, having produced

except a number of things. The

6:17:446:17:48

British worker has to continue until

Friday night to have made the same

6:17:486:17:52

amount of staff. The second problem

we have in this economy at the

6:17:526:17:57

moment is a high level of

uncertainty and I think Honourable

6:17:576:18:02

Member is probably now the pound

fell again after the Chancellor

6:18:026:18:06

stood down. Now, the forecast shows

that this is not getting better GDP

6:18:066:18:11

growth is down productivity growth

is down. In June one, there is no

6:18:116:18:21

productivity growth. The amount of

money that we will have will be £40

6:18:216:18:26

billion less to spend and do or have

tax cuts at the end of the forecast

6:18:266:18:30

period, than we thought at this time

last year. As a consequence, the

6:18:306:18:37

forecast also is showing average

earnings are fallen. What the

6:18:376:18:42

Chancellor do to tackle this

productivity problem. This is a

6:18:426:18:47

long-running problem, obviously

there aren't instant solutions.

6:18:476:18:50

Nobody would be foolish enough to

think that. One thing that I think

6:18:506:18:54

it's worth noting is that the

productivity problem has original

6:18:546:18:59

dimensions. The IPPR have found that

productivity outside the south-east

6:18:596:19:04

is 44% award than elsewhere. So,

when Honourable Member stalk about

6:19:046:19:09

investing in the regions, this is

not just a matter of social justice,

6:19:096:19:13

it is also a matter of economic

efficiency. At the moment, the

6:19:136:19:18

north-east gets 200 per head spent

on transport, well London gets 1940.

6:19:186:19:26

Almost ten times as much. Why

doesn't the Government reorder its

6:19:266:19:32

investment projects and do HSP,

linking Newcastle to Liverpool,

6:19:326:19:37

before it does a chest to. Let's

take a look at what was in the

6:19:376:19:42

budget for the north-east. Tiny sums

of money. The north of Tyne

6:19:426:19:47

devolution deal, £20 million a year.

Time and we are metal, the money

6:19:476:19:53

would be released until 2022. That

is five years from now. Redcar

6:19:536:19:58

steelworks, the only new money was

£5 million. Tees Valley, they are

6:19:586:20:03

being offered something that has no

price tag at all, they are being

6:20:036:20:06

invited to enter discussions and

it's not just the north-east.

6:20:066:20:11

Midland connect is getting £6

million. But the London business

6:20:116:20:17

rate retention which is being

piloted is going to give London £7.5

6:20:176:20:23

billion and, with the stamp duty cut

in my constituency, the average

6:20:236:20:27

House price is a. People want to

benefit this might not gone to

6:20:276:20:32

benefit from it at all. The second

aspect of this is obviously skills.

6:20:326:20:43

In my constituency, there is an

excellent further education college.

6:20:436:20:51

It plays a vital role. Between 2009

and 2015, further education has been

6:20:516:21:00

cut by 27%. Adult education has been

cut by 50%. The Chancellor announced

6:21:006:21:04

extra money. £60 million. It is 2%

more, tiny percent -- tiny compared

6:21:046:21:12

to the massive cuts. We must start

investing more in our skills. The

6:21:126:21:21

original disparities here as well.

Of course it is true that people

6:21:216:21:25

don't have jobs for life but if we

want to help them through this

6:21:256:21:28

transition, we need to do more for

adult education. I thought the

6:21:286:21:36

manifesto had some very sensible

things in it. Instead we should

6:21:366:21:39

spend another £200 on 16 to

19-year-olds, it said we should

6:21:396:21:43

extend child benefits to people who

are doing A-levels. And they said we

6:21:436:21:52

should spend money on public

transport for young people. In my

6:21:526:21:57

constituency, young person on the

young savers ticket, going from the

6:21:576:22:01

field to Bishop Auckland has a

weekly Bill of £31 a week. The young

6:22:016:22:10

person going from Bishopton from

Arlington has a higher Bill. These

6:22:106:22:14

are substantial numbers. The most

disappointing thing is that the

6:22:146:22:19

Chancellor has not won more battles

on the Brexit. And that he has not

6:22:196:22:25

been able to see of those people who

want a cliff edge from the 1st of

6:22:256:22:32

April 2019. We all thought when the

premise to meet our love -- Forum

6:22:326:22:38

speech that the Chancellor had won

this argument. We were all extremely

6:22:386:22:42

pleased by this on the side of the

House. It seems that this was not

6:22:426:22:47

so. Businesses want certainty now.

It is nearly Christmas. Ministers to

6:22:476:22:52

get skates on.

The question is that

the debate be now adjourned. As many

6:22:526:23:02

are of that opinion see eye. I think

the ayes have it. The debate is to

6:23:026:23:11

be resilient on what day? Tomorrow.

The model. Now, with the Leader of

6:23:116:23:18

the House, I would like to take

motions to 27 together. Motions to

6:23:186:23:27

and seven on international

development, the Minister to move? I

6:23:276:23:29

make the move. The question is as on

the order paper, as many are that

6:23:296:23:35

opinion see high. On the contrary

now. The ayes have it. Petition

6:23:356:23:42

Kevin Foster.

6:23:426:23:42

I rise to present the petition from

the residents of Torbay around bus

6:23:486:23:55

services. I would particularly like

to pay tribute to the work of

6:23:556:23:59

Rosemary Shaw, who has collected the

signatures of thousands of people,

6:23:596:24:06

both in person and online. The bus

service being cancelled or have a

6:24:066:24:16

detrimental effect on residents and

particularly elderly residents.

6:24:166:24:21

Would they commit to reinstating the

service of the number 32 for local

6:24:216:24:26

residents as soon as is the? -- as

possible?

6:24:266:24:32

Petition to local bus services in

Torbay.

The question is that this

6:24:396:24:47

House do now adjourn.

Thank you. I

am grateful for the opportunity to

6:24:476:24:56

raise the important issue of the

future of safety critical guards on

6:24:566:25:00

Merseyrail trains in this chamber

this evening. All of us value the

6:25:006:25:04

work of the people who keep our

country moving, be it guards,

6:25:046:25:09

drivers, signal workers, track

workers, ticket office workers,

6:25:096:25:12

cleaners and station staff. I

represent my home city in This Place

6:25:126:25:17

and it is a privilege to be able to

speak up for my constituents and

6:25:176:25:21

working people, and it is worth

rendering that when workers want to

6:25:216:25:25

raise issues as important as public

safety and protecting decent jobs

6:25:256:25:31

for the future, they are all too

often have to take industrial

6:25:316:25:34

action, putting their own

livelihoods at risk, something I

6:25:346:25:37

don't have to do making this speech

tonight.

I'm very grateful to him.

6:25:376:25:44

On that very point about nobody

wanting this to happen, he will have

6:25:446:25:50

seen the letter from the city region

by the six council leaders on the

6:25:506:26:01

16th of November, which they called

for, both parties in the dispute, to

6:26:016:26:08

agree to engage in a process of

independent reconciliation, starting

6:26:086:26:13

with no preconditions, with the

intent of finding a negotiated

6:26:136:26:17

settlement. Doesn't he think that is

a reasonable suggestion?

I thank my

6:26:176:26:23

honourable friend for his

intervention and I will lay out my

6:26:236:26:27

arguments, including comments on

that issue as I continue. I want to

6:26:276:26:33

use the debate outline why guards

are so important for safety,

6:26:336:26:39

security, service and accessibility,

and highlight the level of public

6:26:396:26:42

support for retaining guards on

trains. They are a safety critical

6:26:426:26:47

function and they are valuable,

protecting the personal safety of

6:26:476:26:51

all passengers. Over the last 30

years there has been a creeping

6:26:516:26:55

introduction of driver only

operation. DOI oh is opposed by the

6:26:556:26:59

rail unions and is unpopular with

the public. Since January 2011 there

6:26:596:27:04

have been at least ten serious

incidents of passenger-train

6:27:046:27:08

interface. Eight of these involved

DOO, operating without a safety

6:27:086:27:17

critical member on the train. It is

now proposed to move all of

6:27:176:27:27

Merseyrail's 207 guards. This

decision comes after a 30 year £460

6:27:276:27:32

million contract from new rolling

stock was signed by the transport

6:27:326:27:35

authority.

Will he give way? I thank

him for that. Does he welcome this

6:27:356:27:44

new rolling stock, which will have

the best accessibility for disabled

6:27:446:27:48

people in the whole of the country?

Does he therefore think that

6:27:486:27:53

negotiations to resolve industrial

issues are a matter of urgency so

6:27:536:27:56

the people of Merseyside can join

these new trains when they arrive?

6:27:566:28:01

Of course negotiations are critical

to resolving this dispute and I

6:28:016:28:07

welcome the new trains. They are

long overdue and they are something

6:28:076:28:10

the unions have also campaigned for.

And they will be publicly owned by

6:28:106:28:15

the people of the Liverpool city

region, forecast to be 30% cheaper

6:28:156:28:19

for the taxpayer then using the

failed Roscoe releasing model. The

6:28:196:28:25

latter are like the loan sharks of

the railway and it is right that

6:28:256:28:28

they are rejected in Liverpool, and

perhaps the minister might like to

6:28:286:28:31

say a few words on why his

department persists in using them

6:28:316:28:35

across the rest of the rail network.

However, there is not a choice

6:28:356:28:40

between having new trains and

keeping a fully staffed service. The

6:28:406:28:45

two are not mutually exclusive. In

fact, these new carriage list trains

6:28:456:28:49

with a more open feature allow the

guard to pass more easily down the

6:28:496:28:53

length of the train. Mersey travel

originally said they wanted both

6:28:536:28:57

when the new train contract was

first announced and Liam Robinson

6:28:576:29:03

said, in an ideal world, we would

like to have a second member of

6:29:036:29:06

staff on every train but we don't

have the resources to do that. I'm

6:29:066:29:11

grateful to him this assistance in

the lead up this debate. The pitiful

6:29:116:29:19

investment in public infrastructure

in the North has rightly been spoken

6:29:196:29:22

about. Tory cuts to local councils

and grant in the city region,

6:29:226:29:29

because of these, the local levy has

been cut by £32 million in real

6:29:296:29:33

terms, which represents a third of

the transport budget locally being

6:29:336:29:37

lost. Faced with these cuts, we must

defend and maintain the standards we

6:29:376:29:42

have, protect jobs and passenger

safety and expose unjustifiable

6:29:426:29:47

profiteering from the travelling

public. Our return to the role of

6:29:476:29:52

local representatives, the transport

authority and government later in my

6:29:526:29:56

remarks, but first let me set out

where the first step is to agree the

6:29:566:30:01

principle that keeping the guards on

the train is essential so we can

6:30:016:30:05

move to a more constructive debate

which looks at solutions. -- I will

6:30:056:30:10

return to the role of local

representatives. There are four

6:30:106:30:15

railway stations in my constituency.

The loss of policemen from the

6:30:156:30:21

budget is having a devastating

impact on our communities and the

6:30:216:30:24

ability of the police to protect the

public. Data released by the British

6:30:246:30:29

Transport Police shows the number of

violent attacks on mainline and

6:30:296:30:34

underground trains has increased by

12.5% in the last year, including

6:30:346:30:40

the spike in hate crime. Reported

sexual offences on trains have more

6:30:406:30:45

than doubled in the past five years

and figures obtained under a Freedom

6:30:456:30:51

of Information request submitted by

the RMT has found that in the last

6:30:516:30:53

five years there were over 1200

on-train crimes on Merseyrail. The

6:30:536:30:59

figures also show that almost 900,

or 72% of crimes, took place before

6:30:596:31:07

8am, the time when Merseyrail have

indicated they would seek to retain

6:31:076:31:14

a second person on the train, which

begs the question, if Merseyrail

6:31:146:31:18

acknowledge the need for a second

person on the train after 8pm, why

6:31:186:31:21

not before? And just as when you cut

police numbers you make the public

6:31:216:31:28

more vulnerable to crime, when you

remove front line rail staff you

6:31:286:31:33

almost jeopardise passenger safety.

A report produced for Mersey travel

6:31:336:31:38

by Passenger Focus in April 2014,

the future Merseyrail rolling stock,

6:31:386:31:45

what passengers wanted was clear.

The fact that emerged us by far the

6:31:456:31:51

most important to improve from a

passenger perspective was personal

6:31:516:31:55

security on the train. It showed

passenger satisfaction with personal

6:31:556:32:02

security was high, at 86%, and the

report said that this aspect is a

6:32:026:32:07

strength upon which it is important

to maintain focus and development.

6:32:076:32:10

It went on to state that the

importance of this messenger --

6:32:106:32:15

measure to passengers suggests that

if satisfaction with personal

6:32:156:32:18

security were to decrease in future,

this would have a severe negative

6:32:186:32:26

effect on overall satisfaction with

the service as a whole. Subsequent

6:32:266:32:31

polling found that among women

passengers, 84% said they would feel

6:32:316:32:35

less safe without a guard. And for

people over 55, 80 5% said they

6:32:356:32:41

would feel less safe without guards.

-- 85%. Perhaps the best

6:32:416:32:48

demonstration of how God is our

valued with a recent petition which

6:32:486:32:55

gained thousands of persistent --

thousands of signatures. -- of how

6:32:556:32:58

guards are valued. The guards took

extra steps to make her and other

6:32:586:33:06

female passengers are secure in a

situation she and others faced. Too

6:33:066:33:11

much of the debate has focused on

issues like who will operate the

6:33:116:33:14

doors and whether the DOO can lead

to conditions. Neither government --

6:33:146:33:23

neither the government nor the

regulators have made any assessment

6:33:236:33:26

of the additional risks to

passengers. Risks to passengers once

6:33:266:33:31

the train has left the platform with

or without a guard on the train. How

6:33:316:33:36

can any decision claim to take

passenger safety seriously before

6:33:366:33:40

these assessments have even been

made? Duties include protecting the

6:33:406:33:48

train, safely securing the doors and

dealing with emergencies such as

6:33:486:33:52

derailments, evacuation, fires and

capacity, and if there is a failure

6:33:526:33:58

of train systems. Following a

collision between a train and a road

6:33:586:34:01

vehicle in Merseyrail in August

2016, the guard played -- placed

6:34:016:34:10

isolating equipment on the track and

evacuated passengers while the

6:34:106:34:17

driver remained in his cab leading

communications. Without this,

6:34:176:34:25

incidents would be dealt with by

intercom to passengers from a place

6:34:256:34:31

miles away. It cannot be deemed that

this is safer. There are many more

6:34:316:34:36

stories like this but as I'm pushed

for time I will carry on. Disabled

6:34:366:34:41

passengers, people with a visual or

hearing impairment, or those with

6:34:416:34:46

anxiety, rely on the practical

assistance and reassurance of staff

6:34:466:34:50

on platforms and on trains. The

disabled protection policy says

6:34:506:34:59

people on platforms and on trains

are designed to help you. In the

6:34:596:35:04

2017 report they talked about the

future of accessible travel. I

6:35:046:35:12

believe it is worth fighting to keep

good jobs for the future. Losing

6:35:126:35:22

over 200 Rob is in no way

progressive. The public still

6:35:226:35:27

overwhelmingly backed the guards.

Recent polling shows 87% oppose the

6:35:276:35:34

removal of these guards from

Merseyrail. Labour Party policy is

6:35:346:35:40

clear - to oppose any extension of

driver only operation. The Welsh

6:35:406:35:46

government has now guaranteed a

guard on every train for future

6:35:466:35:49

franchises and Scotland has made

similar long-term arrangements. The

6:35:496:35:53

Secretary of State wrote last week

telling them a labour government

6:35:536:35:58

would hold any plans to extend

driver only operation. Mersey

6:35:586:36:01

travel's former chair remains

opposed to removing the guards,

6:36:016:36:07

saying common sense should prevail.

It has never been clearer that we

6:36:076:36:11

need a new structure for our

railways. Labour would take back

6:36:116:36:15

control by bringing back our rail

network into public ownership. By

6:36:156:36:19

reinvesting the revenues that are

currently disappearing into the

6:36:196:36:24

pockets of shareholders, a Labour

government would ensure affordable

6:36:246:36:28

fares, state-of-the-art trains, safe

staffing levels and an end to DOO.

6:36:286:36:35

We would preserve safety along with

jobs. This Government doesn't have a

6:36:356:36:39

plan for our rail network. It is

writing job cuts into rail contract

6:36:396:36:43

and it stands by when private

companies mismanage services while

6:36:436:36:46

making eye watering profits. Almost

a quarter of Merseyrail income from

6:36:466:36:53

passengers is swallowed up in

profits. Merseyrail's owners Seb Coe

6:36:536:36:58

and a billion can expect to see

average dividends of £6.7 million

6:36:586:37:08

each. It cannot be right that our

money funds but why our loan --

6:37:086:37:16

while our network pays the price. Is

it too much to ask that they take a

6:37:166:37:23

smaller slice of the profit in order

to ask that their passengers, who

6:37:236:37:27

fronted their profits, might get a

safe and secure service?

I'm

6:37:276:37:35

grateful. Does he know that, or is

he aware that in Holland, the

6:37:356:37:42

state-owned operator actually has

guards on the train, yet they are

6:37:426:37:49

proposing on their Mersey franchise

to run the service without?

I do

6:37:496:37:55

find it incredible and I think it's

not good enough. It's not good

6:37:556:37:59

enough for the people of Merseyside

to go without guards and that the

6:37:596:38:04

people of countries who are

profiting from the money from their

6:38:046:38:07

tickets to benefit from guards. The

government could make safety

6:38:076:38:15

critical guards non-negotiable for

all rail franchises. Better still

6:38:156:38:19

would be to scrap the legislation

that says only the private sector

6:38:196:38:25

can run passenger train services.

Some if the minister wants to argue

6:38:256:38:28

this is a devolved issue, he must

explain why Mersey travel are

6:38:286:38:31

prohibited to run their trains in

the public sector. I went because I

6:38:316:38:36

am just pushed for time.

6:38:366:38:43

I believe that the basis of any

resolution has to be the principle

6:38:436:38:47

of keeping the guard on the train.

Merseyrail last week has appointed a

6:38:476:38:52

new managing director and perhaps

this is an opportunity for fresh

6:38:526:38:56

thinking. We have seen the same

issues resolved elsewhere. They RMT

6:38:566:39:00

has exceeded new deals with a number

of new companies -- other companies,

6:39:006:39:04

including time Pennine express and

also ScotRail. In the case of

6:39:046:39:10

ScotRail, BR, later Merseyrail, born

to buy at the allele. F at Balliol

6:39:106:39:18

and Scotland can agree to keep the

card on the chin, why can't a

6:39:186:39:21

Balliol in the Merseyside? --

Abelio. I want to see this through

6:39:216:39:32

-- dispute resolved as quickly as

possible. The basis of this is to be

6:39:326:39:38

the agreement of the principle of

keeping the guard on the train. I

6:39:386:39:43

hope that the representatives in the

Liverpool region will appreciate the

6:39:436:39:46

points made in the debate today that

in the face of the cuts by the

6:39:466:39:51

Government and transport authority,

private -- privateering out of

6:39:516:39:56

control and failed Tory ideology

that runs right through our rail

6:39:566:40:00

network, it's inevitable that we end

up in a situation where we have

6:40:006:40:03

given for his choice -- we have the

false choice between embracing new

6:40:036:40:07

technology and protecting secure and

public safety.

Minister Paul

6:40:076:40:13

Maynard. Thank you. Can I can

graduate the Honourable Member for a

6:40:136:40:20

Liverpool Walton on prosecuting the

office that ideal opportunity for

6:40:206:40:25

this debate today but for delivering

his thoughts so well-balanced.

6:40:256:40:31

Members from both sides of Mersey

and indeed beyond the Mersey, I

6:40:316:40:35

think it demonstrates the

importance, I know that so many in

6:40:356:40:41

the Merseyside area attached to this

issue. I am sure many more will be

6:40:416:40:50

paying attention to it in the city

region. I am sure all members and

6:40:506:40:55

all that debates are worthwhile

opportunities to raise worthwhile

6:40:556:41:00

constituency matters -- matters.

6:41:006:41:10

Since 2003, matters concerning the

Merseyrail have been entirely

6:41:166:41:20

devolved and are at the of the

transport authority, Mersey travel

6:41:206:41:25

and the chain of -- operators

themselves. Those that prevent him

6:41:256:41:30

from commenting directly on many of

the points he has raised today, I

6:41:306:41:32

will try to do my best to give him a

worthwhile contribution that looks

6:41:326:41:36

at the wider issues he is seeking to

raise and as tempted as I am too try

6:41:366:41:41

to engage on his points and Labour

Party policy, sadly, time it

6:41:416:41:46

probably doesn't permit me to fully

engage with why I think the idea of

6:41:466:41:52

a state monopoly should fill every

single passenger had nothing but

6:41:526:41:55

tread at the thought of that. Given

the lack of time available at is

6:41:556:42:00

only fair that after our

interventions, they can choose the

6:42:006:42:08

moment to launch themselves in my

collection because I suspect

6:42:086:42:12

interventions will grow as my speech

echoes. Merseyside in particular has

6:42:126:42:19

seen the reminiscence of an

passenger rail service driven

6:42:196:42:24

something to 96. Before we see more

about Merseyrail in particular, I

6:42:246:42:27

would like to take a moment to look

at the bigger picture as a whole.

6:42:276:42:30

Just a few weeks ago, Weise

published our real spend commitments

6:42:306:42:34

until 2024. 34 billion investment in

the region, 30.2 billion from

6:42:346:42:42

private sources, including network

charges and fears. This carries

6:42:426:42:46

another decade, the greatest

investment in the the way since the

6:42:466:42:50

time of Queen Victoria, to deliver

the improvement in punctuality and

6:42:506:42:54

reliability for passengers as well

as supporting thousands of jobs in

6:42:546:42:57

the supply chain and the wider

economy. Why are we making this

6:42:576:43:02

money available? It's quite a simple

reason. It's because of

6:43:026:43:06

privatisation of Railways has

succeeded and I will never apologise

6:43:066:43:10

for repeating the statistics.

Passenger the Tories have doubled

6:43:106:43:20

since 1995. We now have the most

improved the way in Europe and the

6:43:206:43:23

safest major railway as well.

Because Merseyrail is a devolved

6:43:236:43:27

concession, decisions are made at

the local level. Merseyrail holds a

6:43:276:43:33

25 year concession which commenced

in 2003, with reviews undertaken

6:43:336:43:41

every five years. The terms and

conditions of contract devolved from

6:43:416:43:52

the DFP back in 2003. Indeed, the

Merseyrail concession is different

6:43:526:43:56

from most train franchise contracts

which are rewarded by the Department

6:43:566:44:00

for Transport. The only other

franchise which is even remotely

6:44:006:44:04

similar is the London Underground

network and this local concession

6:44:046:44:09

agreement is that both Mersey travel

and Merseyrail work closely together

6:44:096:44:13

to respond to local demands and

needs and ultimately the greatest

6:44:136:44:18

beneficiaries are of the passengers.

The concession of 25 years

6:44:186:44:22

distinguishes Merseyrail from many

other train operating companies

6:44:226:44:26

which contracts are added seven and

ten years. This reason Merseyrail

6:44:266:44:30

and Mersey travel are in the

enviable position of being able to

6:44:306:44:33

take a longer-term perspective on

investment and development in the

6:44:336:44:39

services. It's an arrangement that

means the control of the concession

6:44:396:44:43

rests wholly in the city region.

Would show with a strong local focus

6:44:436:44:57

the nature of the concession sees

Mersey travel working in close the

6:44:576:45:06

indication for the ultimate benefit

of passengers. In the previous

6:45:066:45:11

franchise ended in back in 2003,

local politicians wanted quickly

6:45:116:45:15

right to respond to the needs of

local rail users much better. And

6:45:156:45:20

implement changes that would improve

the network for the benefit of

6:45:206:45:25

passengers and for a growth of the

region 's economy. They wanted a

6:45:256:45:29

longer term partnership approach

with the operator to allow ongoing

6:45:296:45:34

investment programmes to continue

with risks being shared. Following a

6:45:346:45:43

robust procurement process back in

2000 the, the transfer of

6:45:436:45:48

responsibility for the heavy rail

franchise from what was then the

6:45:486:45:53

strategic rail authority to Mersey

travel.

I will happily give way.

I

6:45:536:45:59

thank the Minister for giving way

and then my speech I congratulated

6:45:596:46:03

Mersey travel on the ability to

secure provision of these trends in

6:46:036:46:08

the public sector, which means that

they will be 30% cheaper than if

6:46:086:46:12

they were bought through private

means and through private loans. But

6:46:126:46:18

the one thing we cannot do is have a

publicly run Neil -- rail network

6:46:186:46:25

across Merseyside, because the

legislation of the UK Government. It

6:46:256:46:28

is OK for a Dutch rail lease, Dutch

public railways and poker with other

6:46:286:46:35

countries to come and our Railways,

but does the Minister not think that

6:46:356:46:40

has Government might like to run the

railway system at some point?

I

6:46:406:46:47

heard his point earlier and my

response to that is that is not

6:46:476:46:50

Government policy nor do I ever see

it being Government policy will my

6:46:506:46:55

party remains in power. I do not

think that the opportunity to have a

6:46:556:46:59

public monopoly on our Railways is

in the passengers interests. It may

6:46:596:47:02

be in the interest of the party

opposite. It's not in the interest

6:47:026:47:07

of passengers. The agreement that we

have with Mersey travel is worth

6:47:076:47:11

hundreds of millions of pounds.

Indeed -- indeed, in 2017 it's close

6:47:116:47:22

to plan major long-term investment

and that is why into 2000 -- sense

6:47:226:47:27

to those in the quality of train

stations and the running of the

6:47:276:47:32

network has been transformed.

Merseyrail has to be seen as an

6:47:326:47:39

exemplar, local decision-making with

it is practical to do so. On the day

6:47:396:47:43

of devolution, Mersey travel greatly

stated its ambition was to shed the

6:47:436:47:48

label of misery rail by pitting

passengers first and within a year,

6:47:486:47:53

the transformation was apparent.

Customer satisfaction, particularly

6:47:536:47:58

with punctuality. By autumn, 2004,

Miller said it was top of the

6:47:586:48:04

National customer satisfaction week,

for the first time in its history.

6:48:046:48:10

Since 2000 date, satisfaction has

never dropped below 90%, a major

6:48:106:48:13

contribution to this has been the

club partnership in the operator and

6:48:136:48:17

Mersey travel. But the concession

agreement that says the demanding

6:48:176:48:23

specifications, flexibility of local

control allowing both parties to

6:48:236:48:28

allow a stream of initiatives to

increase capacity, tether fears and

6:48:286:48:33

services to local markets and

stations being improved. I will

6:48:336:48:41

happily give way although I know

that time is short.

I hope you will

6:48:416:48:47

respond to my Honourable Member --

my Honourable Friend pots point

6:48:476:48:53

about the cut in funding that this

forcing Mersey travel to make

6:48:536:48:56

decisions that they wouldn't want to

make the hand of -- they had funds

6:48:566:49:01

available.

We have committed £82

million in this current year. That

6:49:016:49:05

gives them the confidence to make

the investment and rolling stock

6:49:056:49:08

which they are then choosing how the

invested. I think members opposite

6:49:086:49:14

will be deeply disappointed, indeed

apoplectic, I was to start

6:49:146:49:19

questioning the decisions of the

elected both said the Mere of

6:49:196:49:22

Liverpool and the city region Amir.

The point of devolution that local

6:49:226:49:28

people, through their

representatives, have to take these

6:49:286:49:30

decisions and that is what they are

doing. The investment we have made

6:49:306:49:38

has facilitated the implementation

of longer trained in 2000 date,

6:49:386:49:44

doubling the Senate -- the services

from Chester to Liverpool in 2013.

6:49:446:49:49

All of that, to me, as an example of

investment are cutting in

6:49:496:49:54

Merseyrail. Indeed, regularly, they

have jointly funded extra weekday

6:49:546:49:59

trains during special events. The

approach has been a great success.

6:49:596:50:07

Passenger demand has consistently

exceeded targets, 27 million a year

6:50:076:50:16

ago 12/25 -- 35 million now.

Enclosing, I hope I have been able

6:50:166:50:29

to demonstrate how the public and

private partnership to Mersey travel

6:50:296:50:33

and Merseyrail has helped transform

the real services in Liverpool over

6:50:336:50:38

the past 14 years and that there is

no reason to suspect that local

6:50:386:50:41

politicians and Liverpool are not

able to take positions in the

6:50:416:50:45

interests of the city region, given

I have a short time with it would be

6:50:456:50:48

churlish of me not to give way.

The

Minister isn't at all addressing the

6:50:486:50:54

issue of a second safety critical

person on the train. This isn't only

6:50:546:50:58

a position in the Merseyrail, it's a

position in the franchises around

6:50:586:51:03

the country. Clearly, the Minister

should have a position on a second

6:51:036:51:09

safety critical person on the

exchange.

As you will be aware,

6:51:096:51:18

sufficiently discussed it is the

issue of cards and Merseyrail

6:51:186:51:21

trains. As Honourable Member 's

obstacle now the complicity of local

6:51:216:51:28

Labour politicians they can be

discussing this with. All of them

6:51:286:51:33

have stood behind this decision. If

we truly believe in devolving and

6:51:336:51:39

transport powers, we have to respect

those decisions that are taken. Let

6:51:396:51:46

me just to restate once again, the

congratulating him on the kid in the

6:51:466:51:51

debate and I am sure he has had a

ready audience across America said

6:51:516:51:55

for his comment and I am sure that

that was not the intended audience

6:51:556:52:00

for what he -- I am sure that was

the intended audience for what he

6:52:006:52:03

had to say. I'm sure the

conversation will continue and I

6:52:036:52:07

will watch with interest what

occurs.

The question is that this

6:52:076:52:13

House do now adjourned. As many are

of that opinion that the eye. The

6:52:136:52:17

ayes have it. Order, order.

6:52:176:52:19

Download Subtitles

SRT

ASS