Browse content similar to Live Budget 2017. Check below for episodes and series from the same categories and more!
Line | From | To | |
---|---|---|---|
So Prime Minister's Questions
comes to an end and. | 0:00:00 | 0:00:06 | |
Thank you. Border. Dashboard. | 0:00:06 | 0:00:19 | |
Copies of the speech will be
available in the library afterwords. | 0:00:31 | 0:00:39 | |
I now call the Chancellor of the
Exchequer, the right honourable | 0:00:39 | 0:00:43 | |
Philip Hammond.
Mr Deputy Speaker, I report today on | 0:00:43 | 0:00:52 | |
an economy which continues to grow,
continues to create more jobs than | 0:00:52 | 0:00:56 | |
ever before, and continues to
confound those who seek to talk it | 0:00:56 | 0:00:59 | |
down. An economy is set on a path to
a new relationship with our European | 0:00:59 | 0:01:08 | |
neighbours and a new future outside
the European Union. A future that | 0:01:08 | 0:01:17 | |
will be full of change, full of new
challenges and above all, full of | 0:01:17 | 0:01:20 | |
new opportunities. And in this
Budget, we express our resolve to | 0:01:20 | 0:01:24 | |
look forwards, not backwards. To
embrace that change, to meet those | 0:01:24 | 0:01:28 | |
challenges head-on, and to seize
those for Britain. For negotiations | 0:01:28 | 0:01:36 | |
on a relationship with the EU are in
a critical phase. My right | 0:01:36 | 0:01:41 | |
honourable friend the Prime Minister
has been clear we seek a deep and | 0:01:41 | 0:01:44 | |
special partnership based on free
and frictionless trading goods, | 0:01:44 | 0:01:49 | |
close collaboration on security and
strong mutual respect and | 0:01:49 | 0:01:53 | |
friendship. As Chancellor, Mr Deputy
Speaker, I am clear that one of the | 0:01:53 | 0:01:57 | |
biggest boosts we can provide to
businesses and families, one of the | 0:01:57 | 0:02:01 | |
best ways to protect British jobs
and prosperity, as we build that new | 0:02:01 | 0:02:06 | |
future, is to make early progress in
delivering my right honourable | 0:02:06 | 0:02:11 | |
friend's vision. With an
implementation agreement that allows | 0:02:11 | 0:02:14 | |
businesses to plan and invest with
confidence. And this government will | 0:02:14 | 0:02:19 | |
make the pursuit of that progress is
a top priority in the weeks ahead. | 0:02:19 | 0:02:25 | |
But Mr Deputy Speaker, while we work
to achieve this deep and special | 0:02:25 | 0:02:30 | |
partnership, we are determined to
ensure that the country is prepared | 0:02:30 | 0:02:34 | |
for every possible outcome. We have
already invested almost £700 million | 0:02:34 | 0:02:42 | |
in Brexit preparations, and today, I
am setting aside over the next two | 0:02:42 | 0:02:49 | |
years, another £3 billion, and I
stand ready to allocate further sums | 0:02:49 | 0:02:52 | |
if and when needed. Mr Deputy
Speaker, no one should doubt our | 0:02:52 | 0:02:58 | |
resolve. But this Budget is about
much more than Brexit. The world is | 0:02:58 | 0:03:05 | |
on the brink of a technological
revolution, one that will change the | 0:03:05 | 0:03:08 | |
way that we work and live, and
transform our living standards for | 0:03:08 | 0:03:14 | |
generations to come. And we face a
choice. Either we embrace the | 0:03:14 | 0:03:19 | |
future, seize the opportunities that
lie within our grasp, and build on | 0:03:19 | 0:03:25 | |
Britain's great global success
story, or as the party opposite | 0:03:25 | 0:03:29 | |
advocates, rejects change and turn
inwards to the failed and irrelevant | 0:03:29 | 0:03:34 | |
dogmas of the past. Mr Deputy
Speaker, we have no doubt we choose | 0:03:34 | 0:03:42 | |
the future. We choose, we choose to
run towards change, not away from | 0:03:42 | 0:03:52 | |
it. To prepare our people to meet
the challenges ahead, not to hide | 0:03:52 | 0:03:59 | |
from them. And the prize will be
enormous. For the first time in | 0:03:59 | 0:04:05 | |
decades, Britain is genuinely at the
forefront of this technological | 0:04:05 | 0:04:08 | |
revolution. Not just in our
universities and research | 0:04:08 | 0:04:14 | |
institutes, but this time in the
commercial development labs of our | 0:04:14 | 0:04:18 | |
great companies and on factory
floors and business parks across | 0:04:18 | 0:04:21 | |
this land. But we must invest to
secure this bright future for | 0:04:21 | 0:04:27 | |
Britain, and that this Budget, that
is what we choose to do. But Mr | 0:04:27 | 0:04:32 | |
Deputy Speaker, we are listening,
and we understand the frustration of | 0:04:32 | 0:04:37 | |
families where real incomes or under
pressure. So at this Budget we | 0:04:37 | 0:04:42 | |
choose a balanced approach. Yes,
maintaining fiscal responsibility as | 0:04:42 | 0:04:47 | |
we last see our debt Peking.
Continuing to invest in the skills | 0:04:47 | 0:04:54 | |
and infrastructure that will support
the jobs of the future. Building the | 0:04:54 | 0:04:58 | |
homes that will make good on our
promise to the next generation. But | 0:04:58 | 0:05:04 | |
crucially, also helping families to
cope with the cost of living. Mr | 0:05:04 | 0:05:10 | |
Deputy Speaker, as we invest in our
country's future, I have a clear | 0:05:10 | 0:05:14 | |
vision of what that global Britain
looks like. A prosperous and | 0:05:14 | 0:05:18 | |
inclusive economy. Where everybody
has the opportunity to shine. | 0:05:18 | 0:05:23 | |
Wherever in these islands they live,
and whatever their background. Where | 0:05:23 | 0:05:29 | |
talent and hard work are rewarded.
Where the dream of home ownership is | 0:05:29 | 0:05:34 | |
a reality for all generations. A hub
of enterprise and innovation. A | 0:05:34 | 0:05:42 | |
beacon of creativity. A civilised
and tolerant place that cares for | 0:05:42 | 0:05:47 | |
the vulnerable and nurtures the
talented. And outward looking free | 0:05:47 | 0:05:51 | |
trading nation, a full good in the
world. That is the Britain that I | 0:05:51 | 0:06:00 | |
want to leave to my children, Mr
Deputy Speaker. A Britain we can be | 0:06:00 | 0:06:05 | |
proud of. A country fit for the
future. I know we will not build it | 0:06:05 | 0:06:10 | |
overnight, but in this Budget today
we will lay the foundations. I'm | 0:06:10 | 0:06:19 | |
being tempted with something a
little more exotic here, but I will | 0:06:19 | 0:06:22 | |
stick to plain water. I did take the
precaution... I did take the | 0:06:22 | 0:06:37 | |
precaution of asking my right
honourable friend to bring a packet | 0:06:37 | 0:06:39 | |
of cough sweets just in case.
LAUGHTER | 0:06:39 | 0:06:52 | |
Mr Deputy Speaker, Mr Deputy
Speaker... Order, order. I think it | 0:06:52 | 0:07:07 | |
might be a hearing aid we all need
if this continues. Mr Deputy | 0:07:07 | 0:07:15 | |
Speaker, I shall first report to the
House on the economic forecast of | 0:07:15 | 0:07:21 | |
the independent OBR. This is the bit
with the long economic words in it. | 0:07:21 | 0:07:24 | |
LAUGHTER
Once again, I thank Robert Chote and | 0:07:24 | 0:07:35 | |
his team for their hard work over
the last few weeks. I believe | 0:07:35 | 0:07:39 | |
passionately that the best way to
improve the lives of people across | 0:07:39 | 0:07:43 | |
the length and breadth of this
country is to help them get into | 0:07:43 | 0:07:47 | |
work. Mr Deputy Speaker, I am
acutely aware that 1.4 million | 0:07:47 | 0:07:52 | |
people out of work is 1.4 million to
many. So today... Today I welcome | 0:07:52 | 0:08:04 | |
the OBR forecast that there will be
another 600,000 people in work by | 0:08:04 | 0:08:10 | |
2022. And I am immensely proud of
this government's record in having | 0:08:10 | 0:08:17 | |
created over 3 million new jobs
since 2010. | 0:08:17 | 0:08:23 | |
A far cry from the 1.2 million job
losses the right honourable member | 0:08:23 | 0:08:29 | |
for Hayes and Harlington predicted
in 2011 but in no doubt this | 0:08:29 | 0:08:35 | |
government will continue its focus
on getting more people into work, | 0:08:35 | 0:08:38 | |
giving them security and peace of
mind of a regular wage. I want work | 0:08:38 | 0:08:43 | |
to be a good well-paid and
regrettably our productivity | 0:08:43 | 0:08:50 | |
performance continues to disappoint.
The OBR assumed at each of the last | 0:08:50 | 0:08:57 | |
16 fiscal events that productivity
growth would return to its precrisis | 0:08:57 | 0:09:01 | |
trend of about 2% per year, but it
has remained stubbornly flat. Today | 0:09:01 | 0:09:07 | |
they revised down the outlook for
productivity growth, business | 0:09:07 | 0:09:12 | |
investment and GDP growth across the
forecast period. They now expect to | 0:09:12 | 0:09:18 | |
see GDP grow 1.5% in 2017, one .4 in
2018, one .3 in 2019 and 2020, | 0:09:18 | 0:09:28 | |
before picking up to 1.5% and
finally 1.6% in 2022. With inflation | 0:09:28 | 0:09:38 | |
peaking at 3% in this quarter before
falling back to target in the next | 0:09:38 | 0:09:43 | |
year. I reaffirm the remit that the
Monetary Policy Committee and its | 0:09:43 | 0:09:51 | |
inflation target. We took over an
economy with the highest budget | 0:09:51 | 0:09:56 | |
deficit in peacetime history. Since
then, thanks to the hard work of the | 0:09:56 | 0:10:03 | |
British people, that deficit has
been shrinking. Next year, it will | 0:10:03 | 0:10:09 | |
be below 2%. Our debt is still too
high and we need to get it down. Not | 0:10:09 | 0:10:17 | |
for and ideological reason, but
because successive debt undermines | 0:10:17 | 0:10:22 | |
economic security leaving is
vulnerable to shocks. It passes the | 0:10:22 | 0:10:27 | |
burden unfairly to the next
generation. And because it simply | 0:10:27 | 0:10:32 | |
cannot be right to spend more on our
debt interest than on police and | 0:10:32 | 0:10:37 | |
Armed Forces combined. I am pleased
to tell the House OBR expects debt | 0:10:37 | 0:10:42 | |
to peak this year and then gradually
fall as a share of GDP. They turning | 0:10:42 | 0:10:48 | |
point in the recovery. Mr Deputy
Speaker, apparently, not everyone | 0:10:48 | 0:10:59 | |
shares the view that falling debt is
good news. I heard representations | 0:10:59 | 0:11:04 | |
from the party opposite suggesting
increasing the debt by £500 billion. | 0:11:04 | 0:11:10 | |
Taking us back to square one,
wasting an extra £7 billion a year | 0:11:10 | 0:11:16 | |
on debt interest. If they carry on
like that, there will be plenty of | 0:11:16 | 0:11:22 | |
others joining Kezia Dugdale saying,
I'm Labour, get me out of here. Mr | 0:11:22 | 0:11:35 | |
Deputy Speaker, I have rejected
these representations and instead I | 0:11:35 | 0:11:41 | |
reaffirm our pledge of fiscal
responsibility and our commitment to | 0:11:41 | 0:11:45 | |
the fiscal rules set out last
autumn. Now I choose to use some of | 0:11:45 | 0:11:50 | |
the headroom I established then so
that as well as reducing debt, we | 0:11:50 | 0:11:55 | |
can also invest in Britain's future,
support key public services, keep | 0:11:55 | 0:12:02 | |
taxes low and provide a little help
to families and businesses under | 0:12:02 | 0:12:06 | |
pressure. A balanced approach that
will prepare Britain for the future, | 0:12:06 | 0:12:11 | |
not seek to hide from it. Today the
OBR confirmed we are on track to | 0:12:11 | 0:12:18 | |
meet our fiscal rules, borrowing is
forecast to be 49.9 billion this | 0:12:18 | 0:12:23 | |
year, 8.4 billion lower than
forecast at the spring budget. After | 0:12:23 | 0:12:30 | |
taking account of all decisions
since the spring budget, the GDP | 0:12:30 | 0:12:34 | |
revision and measures I will
announce borrowing will fall in | 0:12:34 | 0:12:40 | |
every year of the forecast from 39.5
billion next year, to 25.6 point | 0:12:40 | 0:12:48 | |
6,000,000,020 2-23 to reach its
lowest level in 20 years. As a | 0:12:48 | 0:12:53 | |
percentage of GDP falls from 2.4% to
1.9% next year, then 1.6, 1.5, 1.3 | 0:12:53 | 0:13:01 | |
and finally 1.1% in 22-3. The OBR
forecast the structural deficit to | 0:13:01 | 0:13:10 | |
be 1.3% of GDP in 2021, giving 14.8
billion of headroom against our 2% | 0:13:10 | 0:13:18 | |
target. Debt will peak at 86.5% of
GDP this year and then fall to 86.4, | 0:13:18 | 0:13:30 | |
then 86.1, 83.1, 79.3 and 79.1 in 22
- 23, the first sustained decline in | 0:13:30 | 0:13:39 | |
debt in 17 years. Under Conservative
led governments, the hard work of | 0:13:39 | 0:13:49 | |
the British people is steadily
clearing up the mess left behind by | 0:13:49 | 0:13:53 | |
Labour. At the heart of global
Britain must be a dynamic and | 0:13:53 | 0:14:05 | |
innovative economy. On Monday, the
Prime Minister set out key elements | 0:14:05 | 0:14:10 | |
of our modern industrial strategy,
which will raise productivity and | 0:14:10 | 0:14:14 | |
wages in all parts of the country
and guarantee a brighter future we | 0:14:14 | 0:14:18 | |
have promised to the next
generation. The Business Secretary | 0:14:18 | 0:14:22 | |
will present a White Paper in the
next few days. This is not just an | 0:14:22 | 0:14:28 | |
economic plan. It is a key part of
our vision for a fairer Britain, a | 0:14:28 | 0:14:34 | |
Britain where every one of our
citizens can contribute to and share | 0:14:34 | 0:14:39 | |
in the benefits of prosperity. And
the key to raising the wages of | 0:14:39 | 0:14:43 | |
British workers is raising
investment, public and we are | 0:14:43 | 0:14:49 | |
investing in Britain's future, half
£1 trillion since 2010, the biggest | 0:14:49 | 0:14:55 | |
rail programme since Victorian
times, the largest road-building | 0:14:55 | 0:14:59 | |
programme since the 1970s, the
biggest increase in science and | 0:14:59 | 0:15:04 | |
innovation funding in four decades
and the two largest infrastructure | 0:15:04 | 0:15:09 | |
projects in Europe, Crossrail and
HS2. When I took this job I | 0:15:09 | 0:15:14 | |
committed to make the battle to
raise Britain's productivity and the | 0:15:14 | 0:15:18 | |
nation's pay the central mission of
the Treasury. Last autumn, I | 0:15:18 | 0:15:25 | |
launched the national productivity
investment funds to provide an | 0:15:25 | 0:15:31 | |
additional £23 billion of investment
over five years, to upgrade the | 0:15:31 | 0:15:34 | |
economic infrastructure for the 21st
century. Today I announce I will | 0:15:34 | 0:15:38 | |
extend the fund a further year and
expand it to over £31 billion. | 0:15:38 | 0:15:47 | |
Meaning that public investment under
this government will on average be | 0:15:47 | 0:15:53 | |
£25 billion per year higher in real
terms than under the last Labour | 0:15:53 | 0:15:57 | |
government. We are allocating a
further £2.3 billion for investment | 0:15:57 | 0:16:05 | |
in R&B and will increase the main
RND tax credit to 12% -- R&D. To | 0:16:05 | 0:16:16 | |
drive up investment across the
economy to 2.4% of GDP. Britain is | 0:16:16 | 0:16:24 | |
the world's sixth-largest economy.
London is the number one | 0:16:24 | 0:16:28 | |
international financial services
sector and we have some of the | 0:16:28 | 0:16:32 | |
world's Best companies and a
commanding position in a raft of | 0:16:32 | 0:16:35 | |
tech and digital industries that
will form the backbone of the global | 0:16:35 | 0:16:40 | |
economy. Those who under estimate
Britain do so at their peril. | 0:16:40 | 0:16:46 | |
Because we will harness this
potential and turn it into the | 0:16:46 | 0:16:51 | |
high-paid, high productivity jobs of
tomorrow. Others may choose to | 0:16:51 | 0:16:55 | |
reject the future, we choose to
embrace it. A new tech business is | 0:16:55 | 0:17:01 | |
founded in Britain every hour. I
want that to be every half-hour. | 0:17:01 | 0:17:10 | |
Today, we invest over £500 million
in a range of initiatives from | 0:17:10 | 0:17:13 | |
artificial intelligence to five G
and four fibre broadband and support | 0:17:13 | 0:17:18 | |
regulation with the new Pioneer fund
and a new geospatial data commission | 0:17:18 | 0:17:21 | |
to develop... You should listen. To
develop a strategy for using the | 0:17:21 | 0:17:30 | |
government location data to support
economic growth and to help tech | 0:17:30 | 0:17:35 | |
start-ups reach scale we asked for a
review of availability of capital. | 0:17:35 | 0:17:41 | |
Today we are publishing an action
plan to unlock over £20 billion of | 0:17:41 | 0:17:46 | |
new investment in UK knowledge
intensive scale up businesses | 0:17:46 | 0:17:50 | |
including through a new fund in the
British business bank seeded with | 0:17:50 | 0:17:55 | |
£2.5 billion of public money by
facilitating pension-fund access to | 0:17:55 | 0:18:01 | |
long-term investment sum by doubling
investments limits for knowledge | 0:18:01 | 0:18:08 | |
intensive companies while ensuring
EI S is not used as a shelter for | 0:18:08 | 0:18:12 | |
low risk capital preservation
schemes. We stand ready to step in | 0:18:12 | 0:18:17 | |
to replace European investment fund
lending is necessary. There is | 0:18:17 | 0:18:23 | |
perhaps no technology as symbolic of
the Revolution gathering pace as | 0:18:23 | 0:18:28 | |
driverless vehicles. | 0:18:28 | 0:18:31 | |
They surely do not want me to make
the joke about the Labour Party | 0:18:40 | 0:18:45 | |
again, Mr Deputy Speaker? I know
Jeremy Clarkson does not like them | 0:18:45 | 0:18:49 | |
but there are many other good
reasons to pursue this technology. | 0:18:49 | 0:18:54 | |
Today, we step up support for it.
I'm sorry, Jeremy, definitely not | 0:18:54 | 0:19:00 | |
the first time you have been snubbed
by Hammond and May. Allah future | 0:19:00 | 0:19:09 | |
-- our future vehicles will be
driverless but there they will be | 0:19:14 | 0:19:21 | |
electric first and that is a change
that needs to come as soon as | 0:19:21 | 0:19:25 | |
possible for the planet. We will
establish a £400 million structure | 0:19:25 | 0:19:30 | |
fund and invest an extra hundred
million per plug-in car Grant and | 0:19:30 | 0:19:34 | |
more for R&D. I will clarify the law
so that people who charge electric | 0:19:34 | 0:19:41 | |
vehicles at work will not face a
benefit in kind charge from next | 0:19:41 | 0:19:45 | |
year. The tax system can play an
important role in protecting our | 0:19:45 | 0:19:51 | |
environment. We owe it to our
children the air they breathe is | 0:19:51 | 0:19:55 | |
clean and we published the air
quality plan this year and said then | 0:19:55 | 0:19:59 | |
we would fund it through taxes on
new diesel cars. From April 2018, | 0:19:59 | 0:20:06 | |
the first year rate for diesel cars
that do not meet the latest | 0:20:06 | 0:20:09 | |
standards will go up by £1 and the
existing supplement in company car | 0:20:09 | 0:20:16 | |
tax will increase by one percentage
point and drivers buying a new car | 0:20:16 | 0:20:20 | |
will avoid this charge as soon as
manufacturers bring forward the next | 0:20:20 | 0:20:26 | |
generation of cleaner diesels. We
only apply this measure to cars. | 0:20:26 | 0:20:30 | |
Before the headline writers start to
limber up, let me be clear. No white | 0:20:30 | 0:20:37 | |
van man or woman will be hit by
these measures. This levy will fund | 0:20:37 | 0:20:50 | |
a new £220 million cleaner fund to
provide support for the | 0:20:50 | 0:20:54 | |
implementation of local air quality
plans, improving the quality of air | 0:20:54 | 0:20:59 | |
in cities and towns in the UK. Our
air quality is sadly not our only | 0:20:59 | 0:21:06 | |
environmental challenge. Audiences
in the country glued to Blue Planet | 0:21:06 | 0:21:13 | |
have been reminded of the problems
of plastics pollution. The UK lead | 0:21:13 | 0:21:17 | |
the world on climate change
agreements and pioneers protecting | 0:21:17 | 0:21:21 | |
marine environment and I want us to
be a world leader in tackling the | 0:21:21 | 0:21:26 | |
scourge of plastic littering the
planet and oceans. With my right | 0:21:26 | 0:21:30 | |
honourable friend the Environment
Secretary I will investigate how the | 0:21:30 | 0:21:34 | |
tax system and charges on single use
plastic items can reduce waste. We | 0:21:34 | 0:21:41 | |
cannot keep our promise to the next
generation to build an economy fit | 0:21:41 | 0:21:45 | |
for the future unless we ensure our
planet has a future. Meeting the | 0:21:45 | 0:21:53 | |
challenge of change head on means
giving our people the confidence to | 0:21:53 | 0:21:58 | |
embrace it and the skills to reap
the rewards and we have a plan to do | 0:21:58 | 0:22:02 | |
so. We are delivering 3 million
apprenticeships by 2020 thanks to | 0:22:02 | 0:22:08 | |
the apprenticeship levy and I will
review the flexibility levy payers | 0:22:08 | 0:22:13 | |
have to spend this. We are
introducing T levels and I am | 0:22:13 | 0:22:18 | |
providing £20 million to support
colleges to prepare for them. | 0:22:18 | 0:22:24 | |
Knowledge of maths is key to the
high-tech, cutting edge jobs in our | 0:22:24 | 0:22:29 | |
digital economy. It is useful in
less glamorous roles like front line | 0:22:29 | 0:22:33 | |
politics! We will expand the
teaching for mastery of maths | 0:22:33 | 0:22:41 | |
programme to further 3000 schools
and provide 40 million to train | 0:22:41 | 0:22:47 | |
maths teachers and introduce a £600
maths premium for schools for every | 0:22:47 | 0:22:52 | |
additional people who takes a level
maths and invite proposals for new | 0:22:52 | 0:23:01 | |
maths schools across England so
highly talented young mathematicians | 0:23:01 | 0:23:05 | |
can release their potential wherever
they live and what ever their | 0:23:05 | 0:23:07 | |
background. | 0:23:07 | 0:23:14 | |
More maths for everyone. Don't let
anyone say I don't know how to show | 0:23:14 | 0:23:18 | |
the nation a good time!
Computer science is also at the | 0:23:18 | 0:23:28 | |
heart of this revolution. So we will
ensure every secondary school pupil | 0:23:28 | 0:23:35 | |
can study computing by tripling the
number of trained computer science | 0:23:35 | 0:23:40 | |
teachers to 12,000. And we will work
with industry to create a new | 0:23:40 | 0:23:46 | |
national centre for computing. But
Mr Deputy Speaker, rapid | 0:23:46 | 0:23:49 | |
technological change means we also
need to help people we train during | 0:23:49 | 0:23:54 | |
their working lives, ensuring our | 0:23:54 | 0:23:59 | |
workforce is equipped with the
skills they need for the workplace | 0:23:59 | 0:24:00 | |
of the future. Today, my right
honourable friend the Education | 0:24:00 | 0:24:04 | |
Secretary and I are launching an
historic partnership between | 0:24:04 | 0:24:08 | |
government, the CBI and the TUC to
set the strategic direction for a | 0:24:08 | 0:24:13 | |
national retraining scheme. Its
first priority will be to boost | 0:24:13 | 0:24:18 | |
digital skills and support expansion
of the construction centre. To make | 0:24:18 | 0:24:21 | |
a start immediately, we will invest
£30 million in the development of | 0:24:21 | 0:24:26 | |
digital skills distance learning
courses, so people can learn | 0:24:26 | 0:24:29 | |
wherever they are and whenever they
want. I'm pleased to be able to | 0:24:29 | 0:24:34 | |
accept the representation that I
have | 0:24:34 | 0:24:45 | |
received from the TUC, to continue
to fund union learn which I | 0:24:47 | 0:24:50 | |
recognise as a valuable part of our
support to workplace learning. Mr | 0:24:50 | 0:24:56 | |
Deputy Speaker, I got an e-mail from
Len asking me especially, backing | 0:24:56 | 0:25:07 | |
skills is key to unlocking growth
nationally, but far too much of our | 0:25:07 | 0:25:11 | |
economic strength is concentrated in
our capital city. If we are truly to | 0:25:11 | 0:25:15 | |
build an economy that is fit for the
future, then we have to get all | 0:25:15 | 0:25:19 | |
parts of the UK firing on all
cylinders, and that is what our | 0:25:19 | 0:25:24 | |
modern industrial strategy is all
about. Today, we back the Northern | 0:25:24 | 0:25:30 | |
Powerhouse, the Midlands engine and
elected mayors across the UK. We | 0:25:30 | 0:25:33 | |
back them with a new 1.7 £1.7
billion transforming cities fund, | 0:25:33 | 0:25:40 | |
half of it to be shared with the six
areas with Metro mayors, to give | 0:25:40 | 0:25:45 | |
them power to deal with transport
priorities, and the remainder will | 0:25:45 | 0:25:49 | |
be opened to competition in other
cities in England. We are investing | 0:25:49 | 0:25:56 | |
£300 million to assure HS2
infrastructure will incorporate | 0:25:56 | 0:25:59 | |
Northern Powerhouse and Midland
engine improvements. I am also | 0:25:59 | 0:26:05 | |
providing money to trial digital
solutions on the trans-Pennine | 0:26:05 | 0:26:11 | |
route. We are developing a punch
with Manchester and I'm pleased to | 0:26:11 | 0:26:22 | |
announce a second devolution deal
with Andy Street and we will find | 0:26:22 | 0:26:27 | |
the replacement of the 40 old
rolling stock on the Tyne at where | 0:26:27 | 0:26:32 | |
Metro and a total investment of 337
million pounds. We will invest £123 | 0:26:32 | 0:26:38 | |
million in the Redcar steel
steelwork sites to support the work | 0:26:38 | 0:26:51 | |
of those leading the fight for
prosperity in that area. Mr Deputy | 0:26:51 | 0:26:59 | |
Speaker, we are piloting 100%
business rates retention in London | 0:26:59 | 0:27:03 | |
next year, and continuing to work
with TFL on the funding and | 0:27:03 | 0:27:09 | |
financing of Crossrail two. We will
also make over £1 billion of | 0:27:09 | 0:27:14 | |
discounted lending available to
local authorities across the country | 0:27:14 | 0:27:18 | |
to support high-value infrastructure
projects. A Conservative government | 0:27:18 | 0:27:21 | |
giving power back to the people of
Britain, and driving prosperity and | 0:27:21 | 0:27:29 | |
greater fairness across our United
Kingdom. | 0:27:29 | 0:27:32 | |
The decisions taken in this Budget
also mean £2 billion more for the | 0:27:32 | 0:27:38 | |
Scottish Government, £1.2 billion
more for the Welsh Government, and | 0:27:38 | 0:27:46 | |
156 mg more for the Northern Ireland
Executive. I can confirm today | 0:27:46 | 0:27:51 | |
progress is being made on the city
's deal for Terry and Stirling. I'm | 0:27:51 | 0:27:57 | |
getting used to the experience of
having my ear bent by 13 | 0:27:57 | 0:28:03 | |
Conservatives Scottish colleagues.
Most recently on the issue of | 0:28:03 | 0:28:11 | |
Scottish police and fire VAT. The
SNP knew the rules, they knew the | 0:28:11 | 0:28:19 | |
consequences of introducing these
bodies and they ploughed ahead | 0:28:19 | 0:28:21 | |
anyway. My Scottish Conservative
colleagues have persuaded me that | 0:28:21 | 0:28:32 | |
the Scottish people should not lose
out just because of the obstinacy of | 0:28:32 | 0:28:36 | |
the SNP government. So we will
legislate to allow VAT refunds from | 0:28:36 | 0:28:48 | |
April 20 18. And in response to yet
more representations from my | 0:28:48 | 0:28:53 | |
honourable Scottish friends, aided
and abetted by my honourable friend | 0:28:53 | 0:28:57 | |
for Waverley, from November 2018, we
will introduce agile is there a tax | 0:28:57 | 0:29:02 | |
history for transfers of gas in the
North Sea, an innovative tax policy | 0:29:02 | 0:29:08 | |
which will bring fresh investment to
a base on which still holds up to 20 | 0:29:08 | 0:29:12 | |
billion barrels of oil. We will
begin negotiations towards great | 0:29:12 | 0:29:19 | |
deals the North Wales and mid Wales,
and we will abolish tolls on the | 0:29:19 | 0:29:24 | |
Severn Bridge as promised by the end
of next year. We will deliver on our | 0:29:24 | 0:29:29 | |
commitment to review the effect of
VAT and APD on tourism in Northern | 0:29:29 | 0:29:34 | |
Ireland, reporting on next year's
Budget and we will open negotiations | 0:29:34 | 0:29:39 | |
for a Belfast city deal as part of
our commitment to an ambitious set | 0:29:39 | 0:29:43 | |
of city deals across Northern
Ireland. A Conservative government | 0:29:43 | 0:29:48 | |
delivering for all parts of our
United Kingdom. It is only by | 0:29:48 | 0:29:57 | |
supporting our regions and nations,
dealing with our debts and investing | 0:29:57 | 0:30:01 | |
in skills and infrastructure for the
long term, that we can build an | 0:30:01 | 0:30:05 | |
economy fit for the future. But I
recognise that many people are | 0:30:05 | 0:30:09 | |
feeling pressure on their budgets
now. And because we are all in | 0:30:09 | 0:30:13 | |
politics to make people's lives
better, in the short term as well as | 0:30:13 | 0:30:19 | |
the long-term, we will take further
measures in this Budget to help | 0:30:19 | 0:30:23 | |
families and businesses where we
can. The switch to Universal Credit | 0:30:23 | 0:30:29 | |
is a long overdue and necessary
reform. Replacing Labour's broken | 0:30:29 | 0:30:35 | |
system that discouraged people from
working more than 16 hours a week | 0:30:35 | 0:30:40 | |
and trapped 1.4 million on out of
work benefits for nearly a decade, | 0:30:40 | 0:30:45 | |
Universal Credit delivers a modern
welfare system where work always | 0:30:45 | 0:30:49 | |
pays and people are supported to
earn. But I recognise, Mr Deputy | 0:30:49 | 0:30:58 | |
Speaker, the genuine concerns on
both sides of the House at about the | 0:30:58 | 0:31:01 | |
operational delivery of this
benefit, and today we will act on | 0:31:01 | 0:31:03 | |
those concerns. First, we will
remove the seven-day waiting period | 0:31:03 | 0:31:09 | |
applied at the beginning of a
benefit claim, so that entitlement | 0:31:09 | 0:31:13 | |
to Universal Credit will start on
the day of the claim. To provide | 0:31:13 | 0:31:18 | |
greater support during the waiting
period, we will change the advance | 0:31:18 | 0:31:21 | |
the system to ensure any household
needs it can access a full month's | 0:31:21 | 0:31:26 | |
payment within five days of
applying. We will make it possible | 0:31:26 | 0:31:31 | |
to apply for an advanced online. We
will extend the repayment period for | 0:31:31 | 0:31:37 | |
advances from six months to 12
months, and any new Universal Credit | 0:31:37 | 0:31:42 | |
claimant in receipt of housing
benefit at the time of the claim | 0:31:42 | 0:31:46 | |
will continue to receive that
housing benefit for a further two | 0:31:46 | 0:31:51 | |
weeks, making it easier for them to
pay their rent. This, Mr Deputy | 0:31:51 | 0:31:57 | |
Speaker, is a £1.5 billion package
to address concerns about the | 0:31:57 | 0:32:01 | |
delivery of the benefit. My right
honourable friend the Secretary of | 0:32:01 | 0:32:09 | |
State for Work and Pensions will
give further details in a statement | 0:32:09 | 0:32:11 | |
to the House tomorrow. We also want
to help low income households in | 0:32:11 | 0:32:16 | |
areas where rents have been rising
fastest. In the long run, of course, | 0:32:16 | 0:32:21 | |
the answer lies in increasing the
amount of housing available, a theme | 0:32:21 | 0:32:26 | |
I shall return to. In the meantime,
the best way to help them is by | 0:32:26 | 0:32:30 | |
increasing the rate of support in
those areas where rents are least | 0:32:30 | 0:32:35 | |
affordable. We will increase
targeted affordability funding by | 0:32:35 | 0:32:40 | |
£125 million over the next two
years, benefiting 140,000 people. We | 0:32:40 | 0:32:45 | |
will always listen to genuine
concerns and act where we can to | 0:32:45 | 0:32:51 | |
help. Making work pay is core to the
philosophy of this government. That | 0:32:51 | 0:32:57 | |
is why we introduced the National
Living Wage in 2016. In April, it | 0:32:57 | 0:33:03 | |
will rise by 4.4%, from £7 50 an
hour, to £7 83, handing full-time | 0:33:03 | 0:33:13 | |
workers a further £600 pay increase,
taking their total pay rise since | 0:33:13 | 0:33:18 | |
its introduction to over £2000 a
year. We also accept the low pay | 0:33:18 | 0:33:25 | |
commission's recommendations on
national minimum wage rates, | 0:33:25 | 0:33:29 | |
supporting our young people with the
largest increase in youth rates in | 0:33:29 | 0:33:33 | |
ten years, delivering a pay rise for
over 2 million minimum wage workers | 0:33:33 | 0:33:42 | |
of all ages across the country. The
facts are these. Income inequality | 0:33:42 | 0:33:45 | |
today is at its lowest level in 30
years. The top 1% are paying a | 0:33:45 | 0:33:51 | |
larger share of income taxes than at
any time under the last Labour | 0:33:51 | 0:33:55 | |
government. The poorest 10% in
Britain have seen their real incomes | 0:33:55 | 0:34:01 | |
grow faster than 2010 than the
richest 10%, and the proportion of | 0:34:01 | 0:34:06 | |
full-time jobs that are low paid is
at its lowest level for 20 years. A | 0:34:06 | 0:34:14 | |
Conservative government delivering a
fairer Britain. But as well as | 0:34:14 | 0:34:21 | |
making work pay, we want families to
keep more of the money they earn. | 0:34:21 | 0:34:25 | |
When we came into office, the
personal allowance stood at £6,475 a | 0:34:25 | 0:34:31 | |
year. From April, I will increase
the personal allowance to £11,850, | 0:34:31 | 0:34:38 | |
and the higher rate threshold to
£46,350, making progress towards our | 0:34:38 | 0:34:46 | |
manifesto commitments, which I
reiterate today. The typical basic | 0:34:46 | 0:34:51 | |
rate taxpayer will be £1075 a year
better off than 2010, and a | 0:34:51 | 0:34:56 | |
full-time worker on the National
Living Wage will take home more than | 0:34:56 | 0:35:01 | |
£3800 extra. This Conservative
government delivering for Britain's | 0:35:01 | 0:35:06 | |
workers. Mr Deputy Speaker, I turn
now to duties. The tobacco duty | 0:35:06 | 0:35:16 | |
escalator will continue with an
extra 1% duty on hand-rolling duty | 0:35:16 | 0:35:23 | |
this year and minimum excise duty on
cigarettes will also rise. Excessive | 0:35:23 | 0:35:27 | |
alcohol consumption and the most
vulnerable people is all too often | 0:35:27 | 0:35:32 | |
through cheap high-strength low
quality products, especially | 0:35:32 | 0:35:36 | |
so-called white ciders. I want to
pay tribute to the campaign led by | 0:35:36 | 0:35:40 | |
my honourable friend for Congleton
on this issue, and so following our | 0:35:40 | 0:35:45 | |
recent consultation, we will
legislate to increase duty on these | 0:35:45 | 0:35:50 | |
products from 2019. But recognising
the pressure on household budgets, | 0:35:50 | 0:35:53 | |
and backing our great British pubs,
duties on other sliders, wines, | 0:35:53 | 0:35:58 | |
spirits and on beer will be frozen.
This will mean a bottle of whiskey | 0:35:58 | 0:36:09 | |
will be £1.15 less in 2018 than if
we had continued with Labour's | 0:36:09 | 0:36:14 | |
plans, and a pint of beer 12p less.
So Merry Christmas, Mr Deputy | 0:36:14 | 0:36:20 | |
Speaker. The cost of travel is also
an important factor for families and | 0:36:20 | 0:36:27 | |
businesses. From April 2019, I will
again freeze short-haul air | 0:36:27 | 0:36:31 | |
passenger duty rates, and I will
also frees long-haul economy rates, | 0:36:31 | 0:36:36 | |
paid for by an increase on premium
class tickets and on private jets. | 0:36:36 | 0:36:41 | |
Sorry, Lewis. For those who do not
stretch to a private jet, I can | 0:36:41 | 0:36:48 | |
announce a new Railcard for those
aged 26 to 30, giving 4.5 million | 0:36:48 | 0:36:53 | |
more young people a third of their
rail fares. And I will once again | 0:36:53 | 0:37:01 | |
cancel the fuel duty rise for both
petrol and diesel that is scheduled | 0:37:01 | 0:37:06 | |
for April. Since 2010, we will have
saved the average car driver £850, | 0:37:06 | 0:37:15 | |
and the average van driver over
£2100, compared to Labour's | 0:37:15 | 0:37:21 | |
escalator plans. Fuel duty has now
been frozen for the longest period | 0:37:21 | 0:37:26 | |
in 40 years, at a total cost to the
Exchequer of £46 billion, is since | 0:37:26 | 0:37:34 | |
2010. Mr Deputy Speaker, our NHS is
one of our great institutions. An | 0:37:34 | 0:37:39 | |
essential part of what we are as a
nation. And a source of pride the | 0:37:39 | 0:37:45 | |
length and breadth of the country.
Its values are the values of the | 0:37:45 | 0:37:49 | |
British people, and we will always
back it. Dedicated NHS staff are | 0:37:49 | 0:37:55 | |
handling the challenges of an ageing
population and the rapidly advancing | 0:37:55 | 0:38:00 | |
technology with skill and commitment
and we salute them. Mr Deputy | 0:38:00 | 0:38:04 | |
Speaker, although you would not
think so to listen to the Leader of | 0:38:04 | 0:38:08 | |
the Opposition, as he regularly
talks down the achievements of the | 0:38:08 | 0:38:15 | |
NHS, the number of patients being
treated is at record levels, cancer | 0:38:15 | 0:38:19 | |
survival rates are at the highest
ever level, 17 million people are | 0:38:19 | 0:38:24 | |
now able to access GP appointments
in the evenings and weekends, and | 0:38:24 | 0:38:28 | |
public satisfaction among hospital
inpatients is at its highest level | 0:38:28 | 0:38:33 | |
in more than 20 years. | 0:38:33 | 0:38:38 | |
It is central to this government's
vision everyone has access to the | 0:38:38 | 0:38:43 | |
NHS free at the point of need which
is why we endorsed and funded the | 0:38:43 | 0:38:50 | |
five-year forward view in 2014 but
even with this additional funding we | 0:38:50 | 0:38:53 | |
acknowledge the service remains
under pressure and today we respond. | 0:38:53 | 0:38:57 | |
First, we will deliver an additional
£10 billion package of capital | 0:38:57 | 0:39:03 | |
investment in front line services
over the course of this Parliament, | 0:39:03 | 0:39:08 | |
to support the sustainability and
transformation plans that will make | 0:39:08 | 0:39:13 | |
our NHS more resilient, investing
for an NHS fit for the future. We | 0:39:13 | 0:39:18 | |
also recognise that the NHS is under
pressure right now. I am therefore | 0:39:18 | 0:39:25 | |
exceptionally and outside the
spending review process making an | 0:39:25 | 0:39:28 | |
additional commitment of resource
funding of £2.8 billion to the NHS | 0:39:28 | 0:39:33 | |
in England. £350 million immediately
to allow trusts to plan for this | 0:39:33 | 0:39:41 | |
winter. 1.6 billion in 2018-19 but
the balance in 19-20, taking the | 0:39:41 | 0:39:49 | |
extra resource into the NHS next
year to £3.75 billion in total. | 0:39:49 | 0:39:59 | |
Meaning, Mr Deputy Speaker, our NHS
will receive a £7.5 billion increase | 0:39:59 | 0:40:08 | |
to its resource budget over this
year and next. Our nation's nurses | 0:40:08 | 0:40:15 | |
provide invaluable support to us all
in our time of greatest need and | 0:40:15 | 0:40:21 | |
deserve our deepest gratitude for
their tireless efforts. My right | 0:40:21 | 0:40:25 | |
honourable friend the Health
Secretary has begun discussions with | 0:40:25 | 0:40:29 | |
health unions on pay structure
modernisation for staff to improve | 0:40:29 | 0:40:36 | |
recruitment and retention. He will
submit evidence to the independent | 0:40:36 | 0:40:40 | |
pay review body in due course. I
want to assure NHS staff and | 0:40:40 | 0:40:45 | |
patients and members that if the
Health Secretary's talks bear fruit, | 0:40:45 | 0:40:50 | |
I will protect patient services by
providing additional funding for | 0:40:50 | 0:40:53 | |
such a settlement. Just as our
public services must be fit for the | 0:40:53 | 0:41:03 | |
future, so too must our tax system.
It must remain competitive to | 0:41:03 | 0:41:08 | |
attract the brightest and best to
establish and grow businesses of the | 0:41:08 | 0:41:12 | |
future. It must raise revenue we
need to fund public services and it | 0:41:12 | 0:41:17 | |
must be robust against abuse so it
is fair to all. We have heard talk | 0:41:17 | 0:41:22 | |
recently from the party opposite
about what they would do to crack | 0:41:22 | 0:41:25 | |
down on tax avoidance and evasion,
but the truth is, they did not. It | 0:41:25 | 0:41:33 | |
is this government that has clamped
down on avoidance and evasion, this | 0:41:33 | 0:41:37 | |
government has seen the tax gap cut
by a quarter to a record low and | 0:41:37 | 0:41:42 | |
this government that has raked in an
extra £160 billion over seven years | 0:41:42 | 0:41:49 | |
for our public services by
collecting taxes due so I will take | 0:41:49 | 0:41:52 | |
no lectures, but I will take action
and this budget continues the work | 0:41:52 | 0:42:01 | |
of the last seven years with a
further package of measures that is | 0:42:01 | 0:42:06 | |
forecast to raise £4.8 billion by
2022-3, doing the job Labour failed | 0:42:06 | 0:42:13 | |
to do for 13 years in office. Our
long-term phased reduction of | 0:42:13 | 0:42:22 | |
corporation tax has generated
investment and jobs and raised £20 | 0:42:22 | 0:42:26 | |
billion extra for public services.
We are committed to maintaining | 0:42:26 | 0:42:32 | |
competitive corporation tax rates
that there is a case for removing | 0:42:32 | 0:42:35 | |
the anomaly of the index allowance
for capital gains bringing the | 0:42:35 | 0:42:40 | |
corporate tax system into line with
personal capital gains tax system. I | 0:42:40 | 0:42:45 | |
will freeze this allowance so
companies receive relief for | 0:42:45 | 0:42:49 | |
inflation up to January 2018 but not
thereafter. I am grateful to the | 0:42:49 | 0:42:55 | |
office for tax simplification on
their report on VAT registration | 0:42:55 | 0:43:00 | |
threshold. At £85,000 the UK VAT
threshold is by far the highest in | 0:43:00 | 0:43:07 | |
the OECD, by contrast in Germany it
is £15,600. I note the conclusion | 0:43:07 | 0:43:15 | |
that it distorts competition and
dis- incentivise is business growth | 0:43:15 | 0:43:21 | |
and note the Federation of Small
Businesses concerns about the cliff | 0:43:21 | 0:43:25 | |
edge of the threshold but such a
high threshold has the benefit of | 0:43:25 | 0:43:30 | |
keeping the majority of small
businesses out of VAT altogether so | 0:43:30 | 0:43:35 | |
I am not minded to reduce the
threshold. I will consult on whether | 0:43:35 | 0:43:44 | |
it -- its design could better
incentivise growth and we will | 0:43:44 | 0:43:48 | |
maintain it at the current level for
the next two years. We cannot build | 0:43:48 | 0:43:53 | |
an economy fit for the future
without supporting its backbone, our | 0:43:53 | 0:44:01 | |
5.5 million small businesses, who
are responsible for nearly half our | 0:44:01 | 0:44:05 | |
private sector jobs. They give the
economy its vibrancy and resilience. | 0:44:05 | 0:44:11 | |
I recognise many are feeling under
pressure. I know that it is hard | 0:44:11 | 0:44:17 | |
work to get a business off the
ground and get it to grow, so today | 0:44:17 | 0:44:21 | |
I want to do what we can to ease
that pressure. Business rates | 0:44:21 | 0:44:27 | |
represent a high fixed cost for
small businesses. At budget 2016 we | 0:44:27 | 0:44:33 | |
introduced a package of business
rate relief worth almost £9 billion | 0:44:33 | 0:44:39 | |
with a further £435 million in the
spring budget. Today I go further. | 0:44:39 | 0:44:45 | |
We have listened to concerns about
the potential costs of the annual up | 0:44:45 | 0:44:49 | |
rating of business rates in April.
Today I will accept the | 0:44:49 | 0:44:55 | |
representation of the British
Chambers of Commerce, CBI and others | 0:44:55 | 0:44:59 | |
and bring forward the planned switch
from RPI to CPI by two years to | 0:44:59 | 0:45:06 | |
April 2018, a move that is worth
£2.3 billion to business over the | 0:45:06 | 0:45:11 | |
next five years. I have listened to
businesses affected by the so-called | 0:45:11 | 0:45:17 | |
staircase tax. We will change the
law to ensure where a businesses | 0:45:17 | 0:45:23 | |
impacted by the ruling, it can have
its original bill reinstated if it | 0:45:23 | 0:45:27 | |
chooses and backdated and I hope I
can expect cross-party backing to | 0:45:27 | 0:45:33 | |
speed that measure through
Parliament. Three simple steps to | 0:45:33 | 0:45:39 | |
solve the staircase tax. What do
they expect, it is the tax section? | 0:45:39 | 0:45:46 | |
To support the thousands of small
pubs at the heart of many | 0:45:46 | 0:45:51 | |
communities, we will extend the
£1000 discount with the rateable | 0:45:51 | 0:45:55 | |
value of less than the amount to
March 20 19. I have heard the | 0:45:55 | 0:46:05 | |
concerns about the five-year
reevaluation system and shorter | 0:46:05 | 0:46:08 | |
periods will reduce the size of
changes in valuation that I can | 0:46:08 | 0:46:12 | |
announce after the next revaluation
future revaluation will take place | 0:46:12 | 0:46:17 | |
every three years. This Conservative
government is listening to small | 0:46:17 | 0:46:20 | |
business. There is a wider concern
across this House and in the | 0:46:20 | 0:46:27 | |
business community about the tax
system in the digital age. Along | 0:46:27 | 0:46:31 | |
with innovation and growth it
brings, digitalisation poses | 0:46:31 | 0:46:36 | |
challenges for the sustainability
and fairness of our tax system but | 0:46:36 | 0:46:40 | |
this challenge can only properly be
solved on an international basis and | 0:46:40 | 0:46:45 | |
the UK is leading the charge in the
OECD and G20 to find solutions. | 0:46:45 | 0:46:51 | |
Today we publish a paper on the tax
challenge posed by the digital | 0:46:51 | 0:46:56 | |
economy, setting out emerging
thinking about potential solutions, | 0:46:56 | 0:47:00 | |
but in the meantime we will take
what action we can. Multinational | 0:47:00 | 0:47:07 | |
digital businesses pay billions in
royalties to jurisdictions where | 0:47:07 | 0:47:10 | |
they are not taxed and some of these
royalties relate to UK sales. From | 0:47:10 | 0:47:17 | |
April 2019 and in accordance with
international obligations we will | 0:47:17 | 0:47:21 | |
apply income tax to royalties
relating to UK sales when those | 0:47:21 | 0:47:26 | |
royalties are paid to a low tax
jurisdiction, even if they do not | 0:47:26 | 0:47:31 | |
fall to be taxed in the UK under
current rules. This will raise about | 0:47:31 | 0:47:38 | |
£200 million a year. It does not
solve the problem, but it sends a | 0:47:38 | 0:47:44 | |
signal of our determination and we
will continue to work in the | 0:47:44 | 0:47:48 | |
international arena to find a
sustainable and fair long-term | 0:47:48 | 0:47:52 | |
solution that properly taxes digital
businesses that operate in | 0:47:52 | 0:47:55 | |
cyberspace. Following
representations from a number of | 0:47:55 | 0:48:00 | |
honourable friends we are taking
action to address online VAT fraud | 0:48:00 | 0:48:05 | |
that costs the taxpayer £1.2 billion
per year, by making all online | 0:48:05 | 0:48:11 | |
marketplaces jointly liable with
their sellers for VAT, ensuring | 0:48:11 | 0:48:17 | |
sellers operating through them pay
the right VAT just we expect | 0:48:17 | 0:48:22 | |
retailers on the high street to do.
I want to turn to the challenge of | 0:48:22 | 0:48:28 | |
the housing market. Before I do, I
want to touch on the aftermath of | 0:48:28 | 0:48:33 | |
the appalling events at Grenfell
Tower. We have provided financial | 0:48:33 | 0:48:38 | |
support for victims of this terrible
tragedy and today I announce we will | 0:48:38 | 0:48:43 | |
provide Kensington and Chelsea
Council with a further £28 million | 0:48:43 | 0:48:49 | |
for mental health and counselling
services, the generation support and | 0:48:49 | 0:48:53 | |
to provide a new community space for
residents. This tragedy should never | 0:48:53 | 0:48:59 | |
have happened and we must ensure
nothing like it ever happens again. | 0:48:59 | 0:49:06 | |
All local authorities and housing
associations must carry out any | 0:49:06 | 0:49:11 | |
identified necessary safety work as
soon as possible. If any local | 0:49:11 | 0:49:16 | |
authority cannot access funding to
pay for essential fire safety work, | 0:49:16 | 0:49:20 | |
they should contact us immediately,
and I have said before and will | 0:49:20 | 0:49:25 | |
again today, we will not allow
financial constraints to get in the | 0:49:25 | 0:49:30 | |
way of essential fire safety work. I
want to also address the issue of | 0:49:30 | 0:49:37 | |
empty properties. It cannot be right
to leave property empty when so many | 0:49:37 | 0:49:43 | |
are desperate for a place to live.
We will legislate to give local | 0:49:43 | 0:49:48 | |
authorities the power to charge a
100% council tax premium on empty | 0:49:48 | 0:49:53 | |
properties. We will also launch a
consultation on barriers to longer | 0:49:53 | 0:49:59 | |
tenancies in the private rented
sector and how we might encourage | 0:49:59 | 0:50:02 | |
landlords to offer them to tenants
who want extra security. I want to | 0:50:02 | 0:50:07 | |
say something about rough sleeping.
It is not acceptable in 21st-century | 0:50:07 | 0:50:13 | |
Britain people are sleeping on the
streets. We will invest today £28 | 0:50:13 | 0:50:19 | |
million in three new housing first
pilots in the West Midlands, | 0:50:19 | 0:50:24 | |
Manchester and in Liverpool, and we
will establish a task force as part | 0:50:24 | 0:50:29 | |
of our commitment to halving rough
sleeping by 2022 and eliminating it | 0:50:29 | 0:50:33 | |
by 2027. I would like to thank the
many colleagues who submitted ideas | 0:50:33 | 0:50:41 | |
on how to tackle the challenge of
the housing market, including my | 0:50:41 | 0:50:46 | |
honourable friends for North East
Hampshire, Eastleigh and | 0:50:46 | 0:50:49 | |
Weston-Super-Mare in particular. By
continuing to invest in Britain's | 0:50:49 | 0:50:55 | |
infrastructure, skills and R&D, we
will ensure productivity and | 0:50:55 | 0:51:00 | |
economic growth that is the key to
delivering a stronger, fairer and | 0:51:00 | 0:51:05 | |
more balanced economy and the
assurance to the next generation of | 0:51:05 | 0:51:10 | |
their economic security, but however
successful in that endeavour, there | 0:51:10 | 0:51:13 | |
is an area where young people will
rightly feel concerned about their | 0:51:13 | 0:51:18 | |
future prospects and that is in the
housing market. House prices are | 0:51:18 | 0:51:23 | |
increasingly out of reach. It takes
too long to save for a deposit and | 0:51:23 | 0:51:28 | |
rents absorbed too high a portion of
monthly income. The number of 25-34 | 0:51:28 | 0:51:35 | |
year old is owning their own home
has dropped from 59% to 38% in 13 | 0:51:35 | 0:51:41 | |
years. Put simply, successive
governments over decades have failed | 0:51:41 | 0:51:47 | |
to build enough homes to deliver the
homeowning dream this country has | 0:51:47 | 0:51:52 | |
always been proud of, or indeed to
meet the needs of those who rent. In | 0:51:52 | 0:51:58 | |
Manchester a few weeks ago the Prime
Minister made a pledge to the | 0:51:58 | 0:52:02 | |
younger generation that she would
dedicate her premiership to fixing | 0:52:02 | 0:52:06 | |
this problem and today we take the
next steps to delivering on that | 0:52:06 | 0:52:10 | |
pledge. By choosing to build we send
a message to the next generation | 0:52:10 | 0:52:16 | |
that getting on the housing ladder
is not just a dream of your parents | 0:52:16 | 0:52:23 | |
passed, but a reality for your
future. We have started with schemes | 0:52:23 | 0:52:27 | |
like help to buy that has helped
320,000 people buy a home. We have | 0:52:27 | 0:52:31 | |
increased the supply of homes. By
more than 1.1 billion since 2010. | 0:52:31 | 0:52:42 | |
Including almost 350,000 affordable
homes -- by more than 1.1 million. | 0:52:42 | 0:52:48 | |
The latest figures show that over
217,000 additional homes were added | 0:52:48 | 0:52:56 | |
to the stock last year, that is a
remarkable achievement, but we need | 0:52:56 | 0:53:01 | |
to do better still if we are to see
affordability improved. This is a | 0:53:01 | 0:53:06 | |
complex challenge and there is no
single magic bullet. If we don't | 0:53:06 | 0:53:13 | |
increase the supply of land for new
homes, more money will simply | 0:53:13 | 0:53:17 | |
inflate prices and make matters
worse. If we don't do more to | 0:53:17 | 0:53:22 | |
support the growth of the SMT
house-building sector that was all | 0:53:22 | 0:53:26 | |
but wiped out by Labour's great
recession, we will remain dependent | 0:53:26 | 0:53:33 | |
on the major national house-builders
that dominate the industry. -- | 0:53:33 | 0:53:38 | |
growth of the SME house-building
sector. Solving this challenge will | 0:53:38 | 0:53:46 | |
require money and it will require
planning reform and it will require | 0:53:46 | 0:53:51 | |
intervention. So today we set out an
ambitious plan to tackle the housing | 0:53:51 | 0:53:56 | |
challenge. Over the next five years
we will commit a total of at least | 0:53:56 | 0:54:02 | |
£44 billion of capital funding,
loans and guarantees to support our | 0:54:02 | 0:54:07 | |
housing market, to boost the supply
of skills, resources and building | 0:54:07 | 0:54:11 | |
land and to create the financial
incentives to deliver 300,000 net | 0:54:11 | 0:54:18 | |
additional homes on average by the
mid-20 20s, the biggest annual | 0:54:18 | 0:54:23 | |
increase in housing supply | 0:54:23 | 0:54:28 | |
New money for the fund to get SME
house-building began, a £30 million | 0:54:28 | 0:54:35 | |
fund, a further £2.7 billion to more
than double the housing | 0:54:35 | 0:54:41 | |
infrastructure fund, £400 million
more for a state regeneration, air | 0:54:41 | 0:54:46 | |
£1.1 billion fund to unlock
strategic sites, including new | 0:54:46 | 0:54:50 | |
settlements and urban regeneration
schemes, a listing of H R eight caps | 0:54:50 | 0:54:58 | |
for councils in high demand areas to
get them building again and £8 | 0:54:58 | 0:55:01 | |
billion of new financial guarantees
to support house-building and the | 0:55:01 | 0:55:06 | |
private rented sector. Because we
need a workforce to build these new | 0:55:06 | 0:55:10 | |
homes, we are providing an
additional 30 formally in pounds to | 0:55:10 | 0:55:14 | |
develop construction skills across
the country. Mr Deputy Speaker, | 0:55:14 | 0:55:18 | |
solving the housing challenge takes
more than money, it takes planning | 0:55:18 | 0:55:22 | |
reform. We will focus on the urban
areas where people want to live, and | 0:55:22 | 0:55:27 | |
where most jobs are created, making
best use of our urban land and | 0:55:27 | 0:55:33 | |
continuing the strong protection of
our green belt. In particular, | 0:55:33 | 0:55:41 | |
building high-quality high density
homes in city centres and around | 0:55:41 | 0:55:44 | |
major transport hubs. And to put the
needs of our young people first, we | 0:55:44 | 0:55:50 | |
will insure that councils in high
demand areas permit more homes for | 0:55:50 | 0:55:56 | |
first-time buyers and affordable
renters. The Communities Secretary | 0:55:56 | 0:56:00 | |
will set out more detailed in a
statement to the House in due | 0:56:00 | 0:56:05 | |
course. However, one thing is very
clear, there is a significant gap | 0:56:05 | 0:56:10 | |
between the number of planning
permission is granted, and the | 0:56:10 | 0:56:13 | |
number of homes built. In London
alone, there are 270,000 residential | 0:56:13 | 0:56:22 | |
planning permission is an built. We
need to understand why -- not built. | 0:56:22 | 0:56:30 | |
I'm establishing an urgent review to
look at the gap between planning | 0:56:30 | 0:56:35 | |
permissions and housing starts. It
will be chaired by the member for | 0:56:35 | 0:56:39 | |
West Dorset and will deliver an
interim report in time for the | 0:56:39 | 0:56:47 | |
spring statement next year. And if
that report finds that fighter Lee | 0:56:47 | 0:56:52 | |
needed land is being withheld from
the market for commercial rather | 0:56:52 | 0:56:58 | |
than technical reasons, we will
intervene to change the incentives | 0:56:58 | 0:57:02 | |
to ensure such land is brought
forward for development, using | 0:57:02 | 0:57:07 | |
direct intervention, compulsory
purchase powers as necessary. My | 0:57:07 | 0:57:11 | |
right honourable friend the Prime
Minister has said we will fix this | 0:57:11 | 0:57:16 | |
problem, and no one should doubt the
Government's determination to do so. | 0:57:16 | 0:57:23 | |
But the solution will not deliver
itself. Local authorities will need | 0:57:23 | 0:57:29 | |
help and support. Developers will
need encouragement and persuasion. | 0:57:29 | 0:57:36 | |
Infrastructure to facilitate higher
density development must be funded | 0:57:36 | 0:57:40 | |
undelivered. So the Homes and
Communities Agency will expand to | 0:57:40 | 0:57:45 | |
become homes England bringing
together money, expertise and | 0:57:45 | 0:57:50 | |
planning and compulsory purchase
powers with a clear remit to | 0:57:50 | 0:57:54 | |
facilitate delivery of sufficient
new homes where they are most | 0:57:54 | 0:57:59 | |
needed, to deliver a sustained
improvement in housing | 0:57:59 | 0:58:01 | |
affordability. The battle to achieve
and sustain affordability will be a | 0:58:01 | 0:58:08 | |
long-term one, so we also need to
look beyond this Parliament, to | 0:58:08 | 0:58:13 | |
long-term measures. We will use new
town development corporations to | 0:58:13 | 0:58:17 | |
kick-start five new locally agreed
garden towns in areas of demand | 0:58:17 | 0:58:22 | |
pressure, delivered through
public-private partnerships, | 0:58:22 | 0:58:27 | |
designed to attract long-term
capital investment from around the | 0:58:27 | 0:58:28 | |
world. Last week, the National in
the structure commission published | 0:58:28 | 0:58:35 | |
their report on the Cambridge Milton
Keynes Oxford corridor. Today, we | 0:58:35 | 0:58:39 | |
back their vision and commit to
building up to 1 million homes by | 0:58:39 | 0:58:45 | |
2050, completing the road and rail
infrastructure to support them. As a | 0:58:45 | 0:58:49 | |
down payment on this plan, we have
agreed an ambitious housing deal | 0:58:49 | 0:58:54 | |
with Oxfordshire, to deliver 100,000
homes by 2031. Capitalising on the | 0:58:54 | 0:59:01 | |
global reputations of our two most
famous universities and Britain's | 0:59:01 | 0:59:06 | |
biggest new town, to create a
dynamic new growth corridor for the | 0:59:06 | 0:59:10 | |
21st century. Mr Deputy Speaker,
this is our plan to deliver on the | 0:59:10 | 0:59:16 | |
pledge we have made to the next
generation. That the dream of home | 0:59:16 | 0:59:22 | |
ownership will become a reality in
this country once again. But I also | 0:59:22 | 0:59:27 | |
want to take action today to help
young people who are saving to own a | 0:59:27 | 0:59:32 | |
home. One of the biggest challenges
facing young first-time buyers is | 0:59:32 | 0:59:37 | |
the cash required upfront. We have
put £10 billion more money into Help | 0:59:37 | 0:59:42 | |
to Buy equity loan to help those
saving for a deposit, but I want to | 0:59:42 | 0:59:48 | |
do more still. I have received
representations for a temporary | 0:59:48 | 0:59:51 | |
stamp duty holiday to first-time
buyers, but this would only help | 0:59:51 | 0:59:56 | |
those who are ready to purchase now,
and would offer nothing for the many | 0:59:56 | 1:00:01 | |
who will need to save for years. So
with effect from today, for all | 1:00:01 | 1:00:07 | |
first-time buyer purchases up to
£300,000, I am abolishing stamp duty | 1:00:07 | 1:00:12 | |
altogether. | 1:00:12 | 1:00:21 | |
If you want more, you are going to
have to let the Chancellor finish! | 1:00:37 | 1:00:42 | |
Chancellor of the Exchequer. And Mr
Deputy Speaker, to ensure this | 1:00:42 | 1:00:47 | |
release also helps first-time buyers
in very high-priced areas like | 1:00:47 | 1:00:54 | |
London, it will also be available on
the first £300,000 on the purchase | 1:00:54 | 1:00:58 | |
price of properties up to £500,000.
Meaning an effective reduction of | 1:00:58 | 1:01:06 | |
£5,000. Mr Deputy Speaker, that is a
stamp duty cut for 95% of all | 1:01:06 | 1:01:13 | |
first-time buyers who pay stamp
duty, and no stamp duty at all of | 1:01:13 | 1:01:19 | |
80% of first-time buyers from today.
When we say we will revive the | 1:01:19 | 1:01:23 | |
homeowning dream in Britain, we mean
it. We do not underestimate the | 1:01:23 | 1:01:28 | |
scale of the challenge, but today we
have made a substantial down | 1:01:28 | 1:01:33 | |
payment. Mr Deputy Speaker, one of
the things that I love most about | 1:01:33 | 1:01:40 | |
this country is its sense of
opportunity. I have always felt it | 1:01:40 | 1:01:45 | |
and I want young people growing up
today to have that same sense of | 1:01:45 | 1:01:50 | |
boundless opportunity. In this
Budget, I have set out a vision for | 1:01:50 | 1:01:55 | |
Britain's future, and a plan for
delivering it. But by getting our | 1:01:55 | 1:02:00 | |
debt down, by supporting British
families and businesses, by | 1:02:00 | 1:02:03 | |
investing in the technologies and
the skills of the future, by | 1:02:03 | 1:02:08 | |
creating the homes and
infrastructure our country needs, we | 1:02:08 | 1:02:11 | |
are at a turning point in our
history, and we resolve to look | 1:02:11 | 1:02:17 | |
forwards, not backwards. To build on
the strengths of the British | 1:02:17 | 1:02:21 | |
economy, to embrace change, not hide
from it. To seize the opportunities | 1:02:21 | 1:02:26 | |
ahead of us, and together, to build
a Britain fit for the future. I | 1:02:26 | 1:02:31 | |
commend this statement to the House.
STUDIO: | 1:02:31 | 1:02:41 | |
Understanding order 51, will the
Chancellor of the Exchequer praise | 1:02:51 | 1:03:00 | |
move formally? The questionnaires to
be sued question five of the | 1:03:00 | 1:03:09 | |
provisional collection of taxes act
1968 will be given to the following | 1:03:09 | 1:03:14 | |
motions. Stamp duty land tax relief
motion number 36. Tobacco products, | 1:03:14 | 1:03:30 | |
rates motion number 40. As many as a
rock that opinion say aye. The ayes | 1:03:30 | 1:03:40 | |
have it. I now call upon the
Chancellor of the Exchequer to move | 1:03:40 | 1:03:50 | |
the motion entitled income tax. It
is intended that this will be put | 1:03:50 | 1:04:09 | |
towards the House on Tuesday 28
November. | 1:04:09 | 1:04:20 | |
The public resolution should have
statutory effect on the provisional | 1:04:22 | 1:04:26 | |
collection of taxes act 1968. I now
call the Leader of the Opposition, | 1:04:26 | 1:04:32 | |
the right honourable Jeremy Corbyn.
Thank you, Mr Speaker. | 1:04:32 | 1:04:47 | |
Test of the Budget is how it affects
the reality of people's lives all | 1:04:47 | 1:04:47 | |
around this country. I would submit
that the reality... If somebody | 1:04:47 | 1:04:55 | |
wants to go for an early cup of tea,
please do so. I am told there are | 1:04:55 | 1:05:01 | |
men despise waiting. But what I will
have is the Leader of the Opposition | 1:05:01 | 1:05:06 | |
listened to and quietly from this
side in the same way I expected the | 1:05:06 | 1:05:11 | |
other side of the House.
Jeremy Corbyn. Thank you, Mr Deputy | 1:05:11 | 1:05:17 | |
Speaker. The reality test of this
Budget has to be how it affects | 1:05:17 | 1:05:22 | |
ordinary people's lives, and I
believe as the days go ahead and | 1:05:22 | 1:05:27 | |
this Budget unravels, the reality
will be a lot of people will be no | 1:05:27 | 1:05:32 | |
better off and the misery many R.N.
Will be continuing. Paid, Mr Speaker | 1:05:32 | 1:05:39 | |
is now lower than it was in 2010 and
wages are now falling again. | 1:05:39 | 1:05:47 | |
Economic growth in the first three
quarters of this year is the lowest | 1:05:47 | 1:05:55 | |
since 2009, and the slowest of the
major economies in the G7. It is a | 1:05:55 | 1:06:01 | |
record of failure with the forecast
of more to come. Economic growth has | 1:06:01 | 1:06:08 | |
been revised down, productivity
growth has been revised down, | 1:06:08 | 1:06:14 | |
business investment revised down,
people's wages and living standards | 1:06:14 | 1:06:17 | |
revised down. What sort of strong
economy is that? What sort of fit | 1:06:17 | 1:06:23 | |
for the future is that? You may
recall, Mr Deputy Speaker, the | 1:06:23 | 1:06:31 | |
deficit was due to be eradicated by
2015. Then that moved to 2016. Then | 1:06:31 | 1:06:43 | |
to 2017. Then 2020 and now we are
looking at 2025. They are missing | 1:06:43 | 1:06:53 | |
their major targets, but the failed
and damaging policy of austerity | 1:06:53 | 1:07:00 | |
remains. The number of people
sleeping rough has doubled since | 1:07:00 | 1:07:08 | |
2010, and this Christmas, this
Christmas 120,000 children will | 1:07:08 | 1:07:16 | |
spend Christmas in temporary
accommodation. Three new pilot | 1:07:16 | 1:07:22 | |
schemes to look at rough sleeping
across the whole country simply | 1:07:22 | 1:07:26 | |
doesn't cut it. We want action now
to help those poor people that | 1:07:26 | 1:07:32 | |
forced to sleep on our streets and
beg... Order. I think the whip know | 1:07:32 | 1:07:38 | |
better. We do not need any more from
you or leave the Chamber. The point | 1:07:38 | 1:07:49 | |
I am making is three new pilot
schemes for rough sleepers simply | 1:07:49 | 1:07:54 | |
doesn't cut it. It is a disaster for
those people sleeping on our | 1:07:54 | 1:07:58 | |
streets, forced to beg for money for
a night shelter. They are looking | 1:07:58 | 1:08:02 | |
for action now from government to
give them a roof over their heads. | 1:08:02 | 1:08:06 | |
In some parts of the country, life
expectancy is actually beginning to | 1:08:06 | 1:08:12 | |
fall. The last Labour government
lifted 1 million children out of | 1:08:12 | 1:08:16 | |
poverty. It was an amazing
achievement. Under this government, | 1:08:16 | 1:08:23 | |
an extra 1 million children will be
plunged into poverty by the end of | 1:08:23 | 1:08:26 | |
this Parliament. | 1:08:26 | 1:08:32 | |
1.9 million pensioners, one in six
of all pensioners living in poverty, | 1:08:32 | 1:08:36 | |
the worst rate anywhere in Western
Europe. It is falling pay, slow | 1:08:36 | 1:08:42 | |
growth, rising poverty and this is
what the Chancellor has the cheek to | 1:08:42 | 1:08:48 | |
call a strong economy. His
predecessor said they would put the | 1:08:48 | 1:08:55 | |
burden on those with the broader
shoulders. How has that turned out? | 1:08:55 | 1:09:02 | |
The poorest tenth of households will
lose 10% of their income by 2022 | 1:09:02 | 1:09:13 | |
while the richest will lose just 1%.
So much for tackling burning | 1:09:13 | 1:09:22 | |
injustices, this is a government
tossing fuel on the fire. Personal | 1:09:22 | 1:09:27 | |
debt levels are rising. 8.3 million
people over indebted. If he wants to | 1:09:27 | 1:09:36 | |
help people out of debt, he should
back Labour's policy for a real | 1:09:36 | 1:09:41 | |
living wage of £10 per hour by 2020.
Working-class young people now | 1:09:41 | 1:09:54 | |
leaving university with £57,000 of
debt because this government, his | 1:09:54 | 1:10:00 | |
government, troubled tuition fees
and the new government policy is to | 1:10:00 | 1:10:03 | |
win over young people by keeping
fees at the same rate per year -- | 1:10:03 | 1:10:17 | |
trebled tuition fees. That is just
one of the multitudes of injustices | 1:10:17 | 1:10:24 | |
presided over by this government and
another is Universal Credit which we | 1:10:24 | 1:10:28 | |
called on ministers to pause and
fix. That is the view of this House | 1:10:28 | 1:10:33 | |
and the verdict of those on the
front line. To shout out, keep | 1:10:33 | 1:10:41 | |
going, he will, but you will be
going out of the chamber. Jeremy | 1:10:41 | 1:10:46 | |
Corbyn. I would rather people staged
to listen, actually, Mr Deputy | 1:10:46 | 1:10:51 | |
Speaker. To the reality. Silence! It
will be in silence. Thank you, Mr | 1:10:51 | 1:11:07 | |
Speaker. Maybe those opposite would
like to listen to Martin's | 1:11:07 | 1:11:13 | |
experience. A full-time worker on a
minimum wage, he said, I get paid | 1:11:13 | 1:11:22 | |
four weekly meeting my pay date is
different each month and because | 1:11:22 | 1:11:27 | |
under the Universal Credit system he
was paid twice in a month and deemed | 1:11:27 | 1:11:31 | |
to have earned too much Universal
Credit was cut off and lead to rent | 1:11:31 | 1:11:37 | |
arrears and he had to use a food
bank for the first time in his life. | 1:11:37 | 1:11:41 | |
That is the humiliation he and many
others have gone through because of | 1:11:41 | 1:11:46 | |
the problems of Universal Credit.
Would it not be better to pause the | 1:11:46 | 1:11:50 | |
whole thing and look at the problems
it has caused? The Chancellor's | 1:11:50 | 1:11:58 | |
solution to a failing system causing
more debt is to offer a loan and the | 1:11:58 | 1:12:03 | |
six-week wait with 20% waiting
longer simply becomes a five-week | 1:12:03 | 1:12:09 | |
wait. This system has been run down
by £3 billion of cuts to work | 1:12:09 | 1:12:17 | |
allowances, the two child limit and
the perverse and appalling clause | 1:12:17 | 1:12:25 | |
that caused evictions because
housing benefit is not paid direct | 1:12:25 | 1:12:28 | |
to the landlord. I say put this
system on hold so it can be fixed | 1:12:28 | 1:12:33 | |
and keep 1 million of our children
out of poverty. For years, we have | 1:12:33 | 1:12:39 | |
had the rhetoric of a long-term
economic plan that never meets its | 1:12:39 | 1:12:45 | |
targets. When all too many are
experiencing long-term economic | 1:12:45 | 1:12:52 | |
pain. And the hardest hit are
disabled people, single parents and | 1:12:52 | 1:12:58 | |
women. It is disappointing the
Chancellor did not back the campaign | 1:12:58 | 1:13:04 | |
by my honourable friend to end
period poverty. He could have done | 1:13:04 | 1:13:11 | |
that. Well done to her on the
campaign, shame on him for not | 1:13:11 | 1:13:17 | |
supporting it. The Conservative
manifesto in the last election | 1:13:17 | 1:13:21 | |
disappeared off its website after
three days, and now some ministers | 1:13:21 | 1:13:26 | |
opposite have put forward some half
decent proposals, conspicuously | 1:13:26 | 1:13:30 | |
borrowed from the Labour manifesto.
Let me tell the Chancellor, as | 1:13:30 | 1:13:38 | |
socialists we are happy to share
ideas. The Communities Secretary is | 1:13:38 | 1:13:43 | |
called the borrowing to invest in
house-building presumably the Prime | 1:13:43 | 1:13:48 | |
Minister slapped him down for
wanting to bankrupt Britain. Where | 1:13:48 | 1:13:52 | |
is the money to fund the pay rise if
he says the pay cap is over? The | 1:13:52 | 1:13:57 | |
Chancellor has not been clear for
NHS workers, police, firefighters, | 1:13:57 | 1:14:05 | |
teachers and assistants, bin
collectors, Armed Forces personnel. | 1:14:05 | 1:14:10 | |
Will the Chancellor listen to
Claire, who says her mum works for | 1:14:10 | 1:14:14 | |
the NHS and she goes above and
beyond for her patients. Why does | 1:14:14 | 1:14:23 | |
the government think it OK to
underpay, over stress and under | 1:14:23 | 1:14:25 | |
appreciate all those who work in the
NHS? The NHS chief executive says | 1:14:25 | 1:14:32 | |
the budget for the NHS next year is
short of what is currently needed. | 1:14:32 | 1:14:37 | |
From what the Chancellor has said,
it is still going to be well short | 1:14:37 | 1:14:42 | |
of what is needed. He said in 2015
they would fund another 5000 GPs. In | 1:14:42 | 1:14:51 | |
the last year, 1200, we have had
1200 fewer GPs and we have lost | 1:14:51 | 1:15:00 | |
community and mental health nurses.
The Chancellor promised | 1:15:00 | 1:15:04 | |
10,000,000,020 15 and delivered 4.5.
If you don't mind, we will wait for | 1:15:04 | 1:15:10 | |
the small print on the announcement
but even what he said falls well | 1:15:10 | 1:15:16 | |
short of the 6 billion Labour would
have delivered from our June | 1:15:16 | 1:15:19 | |
manifesto. Over 1 million of our
elderly are not receiving the care | 1:15:19 | 1:15:25 | |
they need. Over... Over 6 billion
will have been cut from social care | 1:15:25 | 1:15:36 | |
budgets by next March. I hope he
begins to understand what it is like | 1:15:36 | 1:15:41 | |
to wait for social care, stuck in a
hospital bed, with other people | 1:15:41 | 1:15:46 | |
having to give up work to care for
them. The uncaring, uncouth attitude | 1:15:46 | 1:15:56 | |
of certain members... Order. Carry
on. | 1:15:56 | 1:16:09 | |
Mr Speaker, that is why social care
budgets are so important for so many | 1:16:10 | 1:16:19 | |
desperate people in our country. Our
schools will be 5% worse off by | 1:16:19 | 1:16:28 | |
2019, despite the Conservative
manifesto promising no school would | 1:16:28 | 1:16:32 | |
be worse off. 5000 headteachers from
25 counties wrote to the Chancellor | 1:16:32 | 1:16:42 | |
saying, we are simply asking for the
money that has been taken out of the | 1:16:42 | 1:16:45 | |
system to be returned. A senior
science technician wrote to me, | 1:16:45 | 1:16:51 | |
Robert, saying, my pay has been
reduced by over 30%. I have seen | 1:16:51 | 1:16:58 | |
massive cuts at my school, good
teachers and support staff leave. | 1:16:58 | 1:17:03 | |
That is what does for the morale of
both teachers and students. | 1:17:03 | 1:17:10 | |
According to this government, 5000
headteachers are wrong, Robert is | 1:17:10 | 1:17:15 | |
wrong, the IFS is wrong, everybody
is wrong, except the Chancellor. And | 1:17:15 | 1:17:22 | |
if the Chancellor bothered to listen
to what local government is saying, | 1:17:22 | 1:17:27 | |
they have been warning services for
the most vulnerable children are | 1:17:27 | 1:17:32 | |
under more demand than ever. More
children being taken into care, more | 1:17:32 | 1:17:36 | |
in desperate need of help and
support, yet they are labouring with | 1:17:36 | 1:17:43 | |
a 2 billion shortfall in the cost of
dealing with vulnerable children. | 1:17:43 | 1:17:47 | |
Because local councils have lost
80%, will have lost 80% of direct | 1:17:47 | 1:17:56 | |
funding by 2020. The reality of
this, across the country, is | 1:17:56 | 1:18:03 | |
winning's refuges closing, youth
centres and libraries and museums | 1:18:03 | 1:18:09 | |
closing, public facilities
understaffed, under resourced and | 1:18:09 | 1:18:13 | |
underfinanced. It could be so
different, but compassion can cost | 1:18:13 | 1:18:18 | |
very little. Just £10 million is
needed to establish the child | 1:18:18 | 1:18:23 | |
funeral fund, campaigned for
brilliantly by my honourable friend | 1:18:23 | 1:18:29 | |
the member for Swansea East. Why
could not the Chancellor at least | 1:18:29 | 1:18:33 | |
have agreed to fund that? Under this
government there are also 20,000 | 1:18:33 | 1:18:39 | |
fewer police officers and another
6000 community support officers and | 1:18:39 | 1:18:45 | |
11,000 Fire Service staff cut as
well. You cannot keep communities | 1:18:45 | 1:18:48 | |
safe on the cheap. Tammy explains
this. Our police presence has been | 1:18:48 | 1:18:56 | |
taken away from the village, meaning
an increase in crime, as a single | 1:18:56 | 1:19:01 | |
parent I no longer feel safe in the
village where I live, particularly | 1:19:01 | 1:19:04 | |
at night. 5.5 million workers earn
less than living wage, 1 million | 1:19:04 | 1:19:12 | |
more than five years ago. The
Chancellor last Sunday could not | 1:19:12 | 1:19:18 | |
even see 1.4 million people
unemployed in this country. There is | 1:19:18 | 1:19:24 | |
a crisis of low pay and insecure
work affecting one in four women and | 1:19:24 | 1:19:32 | |
one in six men, a record 7.4 million
people in working households living | 1:19:32 | 1:19:39 | |
in poverty. If we want workers
earning better pay, less dependent | 1:19:39 | 1:19:45 | |
on in work benefits, we need strong
trade unions, the most effective way | 1:19:45 | 1:19:50 | |
of boosting workers pay. Instead,
this government weakened trade | 1:19:50 | 1:19:56 | |
unions and introduced employment
Tribunal fees, now scrapped, thanks | 1:19:56 | 1:20:00 | |
to the victory in the courts by
Unison, a trade union representing | 1:20:00 | 1:20:05 | |
members. Why did the Chancellor not
take the opportunity to make two | 1:20:05 | 1:20:11 | |
changes to control debt? First, to
cap credit card debt so nobody pays | 1:20:11 | 1:20:19 | |
back more than they borrowed. And
second, to stop credit card | 1:20:19 | 1:20:24 | |
companies increasing people'scredit
limit without their say-so. Debt is | 1:20:24 | 1:20:29 | |
being racked up because the
government is weak on those who | 1:20:29 | 1:20:33 | |
exploit people such as rail
companies hiking fares above | 1:20:33 | 1:20:38 | |
inflation, and water companies and
energy suppliers. During the general | 1:20:38 | 1:20:43 | |
election he promised an energy cap
to benefit around 17 million | 1:20:43 | 1:20:49 | |
families on standard variable
tariffs. But every bill tells | 1:20:49 | 1:20:53 | |
millions the government has broken
that promise. And with 10 billion in | 1:20:53 | 1:20:59 | |
housing benefit going into the
pockets of private landlords every | 1:20:59 | 1:21:03 | |
year, housing is a key factor in
driving up the welfare bill. Not too | 1:21:03 | 1:21:08 | |
many words from the Chancellor about
excessive levels of rent in the | 1:21:08 | 1:21:13 | |
private rented sector. With this
government delivering the worst rate | 1:21:13 | 1:21:16 | |
of house building since the 20s, and
a quarter... And a quarter of a | 1:21:16 | 1:21:29 | |
million fewer council homes, any
commitment would be welcome. But we | 1:21:29 | 1:21:34 | |
have been here before. The
government promised 200,000 starter | 1:21:34 | 1:21:39 | |
homes, three years ago, and not a
single one has yet been built in | 1:21:39 | 1:21:45 | |
those three years. We need a large
scale publicly funded house-building | 1:21:45 | 1:21:50 | |
programme, not this government's
accounting tricks and empty | 1:21:50 | 1:21:54 | |
promises. We back the abolition of
stamp duty for first-time buyers | 1:21:54 | 1:21:59 | |
because it was another Labour policy
in our manifesto in June, not a Tory | 1:21:59 | 1:22:07 | |
one. This government continues
preference for spin over substance, | 1:22:07 | 1:22:11 | |
that means across this country, in
the words wolf powerhouse and | 1:22:11 | 1:22:17 | |
Midlands engine, now met with
derision. Yorkshire and Humber get | 1:22:17 | 1:22:23 | |
only one tenth of the transport
investment per head given to London. | 1:22:23 | 1:22:29 | |
And government figures show every
region in the of England has seen a | 1:22:29 | 1:22:35 | |
fall in spending on services since
2012. The Midlands, East and west is | 1:22:35 | 1:22:42 | |
receiving less than 8% of total
transport infrastructure investment | 1:22:42 | 1:22:48 | |
compared with 50% going to London.
In the east and West Midlands one in | 1:22:48 | 1:22:54 | |
four workers are paid less than the
living wage, so much for the | 1:22:54 | 1:22:58 | |
Midlands engine. We announced
funding for the trans-Pennine rail | 1:22:58 | 1:23:02 | |
route will not cut it and the other
announcements today will not redress | 1:23:02 | 1:23:09 | |
that balance. Combined with
counter-productive forced Erraid | 1:23:09 | 1:23:12 | |
Davies lack of investment has
consequences in sluggish growth and | 1:23:12 | 1:23:16 | |
shrinking pay packets. Public
investment has virtually halved. | 1:23:16 | 1:23:20 | |
Under this government Britain has
the lowest rate of public investment | 1:23:20 | 1:23:24 | |
in the G7. But it is now investing
in driverless cars. After months of | 1:23:24 | 1:23:32 | |
road testing back-seat driving in
the government. | 1:23:32 | 1:23:40 | |
By moving from RPI to CPI indexes
non-business rates, the Chancellor | 1:23:40 | 1:23:50 | |
has adopted another Labour policy.
But why don't they go further and | 1:23:50 | 1:23:55 | |
adopt Labour's entire business rates
including the annual revaluation of | 1:23:55 | 1:24:03 | |
business rates. Nowhere have their
chaos been more evident than over | 1:24:03 | 1:24:08 | |
Brexit. Following round after round
of fruitless Brexit negotiations, | 1:24:08 | 1:24:12 | |
the Brexit secretary has been
shunted out for the Prime Minister | 1:24:12 | 1:24:15 | |
who has got no further. Every major
business organisation has written to | 1:24:15 | 1:24:20 | |
the Government telling them to pull
their finger out and get on with it. | 1:24:20 | 1:24:25 | |
Businesses are delaying crucial
investment decisions because of this | 1:24:25 | 1:24:28 | |
government doesn't get its act
together soon, they will be taking | 1:24:28 | 1:24:32 | |
relocation decisions. Crashing out
with no deal and turning Britain | 1:24:32 | 1:24:38 | |
into a tax haven would damage
people's jobs and living standards | 1:24:38 | 1:24:44 | |
would serve only a wealthy few. It
is not as if this government isn't | 1:24:44 | 1:24:49 | |
doing its best to protect tax havens
and its clients in the meantime. The | 1:24:49 | 1:24:58 | |
Paradise Papers exposed how a
super-rich elite gets away with | 1:24:58 | 1:25:02 | |
dodging taxes. This government has
opposed measure after measure in | 1:25:02 | 1:25:06 | |
this House and their Tory colleagues
in the European Parliament, to clamp | 1:25:06 | 1:25:11 | |
down on the tax havens that
facilitate this outrageous leaching | 1:25:11 | 1:25:15 | |
from our public purse. Nonpaid tax,
clever reinvestment to get away with | 1:25:15 | 1:25:23 | |
tax, actually, it is hospitals,
schools, housing and it hit the | 1:25:23 | 1:25:27 | |
poorest and most needy in our
society. There is nothing immoral | 1:25:27 | 1:25:31 | |
about dodging tax. There is
everything in moral about evading | 1:25:31 | 1:25:34 | |
it. Mr Speaker, too often it feels
like there is one rule for the | 1:25:34 | 1:25:40 | |
super-rich and another for the rest
of us. The horrors of Grenfell Tower | 1:25:40 | 1:25:47 | |
were a reflection of a system which
puts profits before people, that | 1:25:47 | 1:25:54 | |
failed to listen to working-class
communities. In 2013, the Government | 1:25:54 | 1:25:58 | |
received advice in a krona's report
that sprinklers should be fitted in | 1:25:58 | 1:26:03 | |
all high-rise buildings. Today, once
again, the Government failed to fund | 1:26:03 | 1:26:11 | |
the £1 billion investment needed.
The Chancellor says council should | 1:26:11 | 1:26:13 | |
contact them. But not in house,
Westminster house and they have been | 1:26:13 | 1:26:20 | |
refused. Nothing was offered to
them. We have the privilege to be | 1:26:20 | 1:26:27 | |
members of Parliament, in a building
that is about to be retrofitted with | 1:26:27 | 1:26:32 | |
sprinklers, to protect us. The
message is pretty clear. This | 1:26:32 | 1:26:37 | |
government cares more about what
happens here then happens to people | 1:26:37 | 1:26:42 | |
living in high-rise homes. In effect
saying they matter less. Our | 1:26:42 | 1:26:50 | |
country, Mr Speaker, is marked by
growing inequality and injustice. We | 1:26:50 | 1:26:55 | |
were promised a revolutionary
Budget, the reality is nothing has | 1:26:55 | 1:27:02 | |
changed. People were looking for
help from this Budget and they have | 1:27:02 | 1:27:06 | |
been let down. Let down by a
government, that like the economy be | 1:27:06 | 1:27:11 | |
presided over, is weak and unstable
and in need of urgent change. They | 1:27:11 | 1:27:16 | |
called this a Budget fit for the
future. The reality is, this is a | 1:27:16 | 1:27:22 | |
government no longer fit for office.
Nicky Morgan. | 1:27:22 | 1:27:31 | |
STUDIO: And Jeremy Corbyn sits down
after a long and wide-ranging | 1:27:31 | 1:27:37 | |
response to the Budget. If you wish
to continue to watch what is | 1:27:37 | 1:27:41 | |
happening in the House of Commons,
you can switch to the BBC Parliament | 1:27:41 | 1:27:45 | |
channel and that will tell you what
is going on there. Here, we will go | 1:27:45 | 1:27:50 | |
through | 1:27:50 | 1:27:50 | |
I'm happen to to continue that
tradition. Much of his speech was | 1:28:05 | 1:28:09 | |
pre-written. I suspect he'll want to
look at more of the detail. Today, I | 1:28:09 | 1:28:16 | |
think it is perhaps the Chancellor
who's had the hardest task. More | 1:28:16 | 1:28:24 | |
public spending, rising economic
uncertainty. He has taken a | 1:28:24 | 1:28:28 | |
common-sense approach which will no
doubt displease many on both sides | 1:28:28 | 1:28:32 | |
of the chamber. It is only thanks to
seven years of common-sense, | 1:28:32 | 1:28:37 | |
concerted efforts by Conservative
and Conservative-led Governments to | 1:28:37 | 1:28:41 | |
reduce the deficit and restore
credibility to the public finances | 1:28:41 | 1:28:44 | |
that the UK has the resilience
necessary to face the challenges | 1:28:44 | 1:28:47 | |
ahead. Reclassification of Housing
Association, may have given the | 1:28:47 | 1:28:54 | |
Chancellor some timely room for man
over, it does not alter the | 1:28:54 | 1:28:59 | |
underlying picture. Although the OBR
has made a more negative assessment | 1:28:59 | 1:29:06 | |
of productivity, it is forecasting a
relatively benign breaks the with no | 1:29:06 | 1:29:10 | |
cliff edge in March 2019. But that
can the no be guaranteed. Even | 1:29:10 | 1:29:17 | |
though a transitional arrangement
for a smooth adjustment is in the | 1:29:17 | 1:29:21 | |
interests of both the UK and the EU,
it may not happen. The Treasury | 1:29:21 | 1:29:27 | |
committee will be looking closely at
failing to reach a deal on | 1:29:27 | 1:29:30 | |
transition and expectings to make a
report in the House in the coupling | 1:29:30 | 1:29:34 | |
weeks. Beyond the public finances,
household balance sheets are under | 1:29:34 | 1:29:38 | |
pressure. Rising interest rates,
high inflation, lower wage growth, a | 1:29:38 | 1:29:45 | |
working age benefits freeze, all
these put pressure on ordinary | 1:29:45 | 1:29:49 | |
households. The Chancellor set out
two important principles for | 1:29:49 | 1:29:54 | |
Conservative-led Governments.
Firstly, work should always pay and | 1:29:54 | 1:29:58 | |
secondly, people should keep more of
the money they earn. I'm happy to | 1:29:58 | 1:30:03 | |
subscribe and those on these benches
are happy to support him with those | 1:30:03 | 1:30:08 | |
two principles. Pressures on
household finances which the | 1:30:08 | 1:30:11 | |
committee will be looking at as part
of our inquiry, will be exacerbated, | 1:30:11 | 1:30:18 | |
particularly for the younger again
ration, if action's not taking with | 1:30:18 | 1:30:22 | |
the housing market. I welcome the
measures the chops letter's | 1:30:22 | 1:30:27 | |
announced on housing. It he's
announce add package on land | 1:30:27 | 1:30:33 | |
availability and incentives to get
building. You know there's an issue | 1:30:33 | 1:30:40 | |
when the member for West Dorset is
sent for to solve a particular | 1:30:40 | 1:30:43 | |
problem. He is going to look at the
gap between permissions granted and | 1:30:43 | 1:30:48 | |
those houses being built. Why that
gap exists. I also hugely welcome, | 1:30:48 | 1:30:54 | |
as I think honourable members on
this side of the House will, the | 1:30:54 | 1:30:57 | |
stamp duty cut for first time
buyers. As the Chancellor said, this | 1:30:57 | 1:31:01 | |
will make home ownership a reality
for more young people. The committee | 1:31:01 | 1:31:06 | |
will be intending to hear from
housing experts as part of our | 1:31:06 | 1:31:10 | |
Budget scrutiny and will
investigates whether the rousing war | 1:31:10 | 1:31:14 | |
time rhetoric of my right honourable
friend matches the reality of what | 1:31:14 | 1:31:18 | |
has been announced today. Of course,
the pressure's on the public | 1:31:18 | 1:31:24 | |
finances and households balance
sheet can only be alleviated if | 1:31:24 | 1:31:29 | |
productivity growth improves. I
welcome his further investment in | 1:31:29 | 1:31:33 | |
the national productivity investment
fun. He was right to 'em fast sides | 1:31:33 | 1:31:37 | |
the challenge of productivity which
is the weakest in the G7 in the UK | 1:31:37 | 1:31:41 | |
in his speech. The average UK worker
has to slog from 5 to produce 9- the | 1:31:41 | 1:31:46 | |
same value output as a worker in
Germany produces between the hours | 1:31:46 | 1:31:52 | |
of 9 and 3. I welcome what the
Chancellor said about more | 1:31:52 | 1:31:56 | |
devolution. I don't know where the
Leader of the Opposition has the | 1:31:56 | 1:32:00 | |
idea we don't take seriously the
northern powerhouse or the Midlands | 1:32:00 | 1:32:04 | |
engine on this side of the House. I
can tell him as a Midlands member of | 1:32:04 | 1:32:08 | |
Parliament, we take them very
seriously. This side of the House | 1:32:08 | 1:32:13 | |
believes in devolution. There are no
easy solutions to the UK's weak | 1:32:13 | 1:32:18 | |
productivity performance. We can do
two things to help with the puzzle. | 1:32:18 | 1:32:24 | |
The first is better infrastructure,
including digital infrastructure. | 1:32:24 | 1:32:30 | |
The big political divide in
infrastructure policy is not between | 1:32:30 | 1:32:33 | |
the parties but action and inaction.
The Chancellor must act on the | 1:32:33 | 1:32:38 | |
commission's recommendations when
published. I welcome his commitment | 1:32:38 | 1:32:41 | |
today to implement the commission's
recommendation from the Oxford, | 1:32:41 | 1:32:46 | |
Milton Keynes corridor. And the
discount of lending to local | 1:32:46 | 1:32:49 | |
authorities so they can invest in
infrastructure. The second answer to | 1:32:49 | 1:32:53 | |
productivity is to retain the UK's
historic commitment to openness, | 1:32:53 | 1:32:58 | |
#2r5ied, investment and to
migration. Global Britain must be a | 1:32:58 | 1:33:02 | |
reality and not just a slogan. The
economic case for leaving the EU has | 1:33:02 | 1:33:07 | |
always rested and continues to rest
on openness. We must not allow the | 1:33:07 | 1:33:12 | |
Brexit process to mark the start of
a decent into economic nationalism. | 1:33:12 | 1:33:18 | |
It is only through productivity
growth households can be weaned off | 1:33:18 | 1:33:23 | |
consumer credit without cutting back
consumption and reducing living | 1:33:23 | 1:33:26 | |
standards. It is only through
productivity growth the Chancellor | 1:33:26 | 1:33:33 | |
can Meade things can pries ops bes
NHS, public #1ek9er pay and bricks | 1:33:33 | 1:33:40 | |
the cop tinge Si methods. For the
avoidance of doubt. Let us dismiss | 1:33:40 | 1:33:49 | |
the idea that Brexit induced fiscal
windfall will reduce the pressures | 1:33:49 | 1:33:53 | |
op our health service. There are no
easy choices or a pot of gold under | 1:33:53 | 1:34:02 | |
the Brexit rainbow. At the cost of
long-term damage to trust in | 1:34:02 | 1:34:08 | |
politics. The Chancellor's right to
have identified the technology | 1:34:08 | 1:34:13 | |
revolution and say Britain is at the
forefront of it. He is right to | 1:34:13 | 1:34:17 | |
identify the need for more young
people to learn maths and computer | 1:34:17 | 1:34:21 | |
science to a higher level. We have
to find a way of exciting everyone | 1:34:21 | 1:34:26 | |
in this country, the next generation
and their parents and grandparents | 1:34:26 | 1:34:31 | |
about the technology revolution to
give them the confidence and skills | 1:34:31 | 1:34:34 | |
to meet demand of a fuel or labour
market, not to be frightened by | 1:34:34 | 1:34:39 | |
change in the 21st Century. This is
a key part of our plan for a fairer | 1:34:39 | 1:34:45 | |
Britain I thank the Right Honourable
Member for giving way. Can I just | 1:34:45 | 1:34:49 | |
pick up on The Mount about education
funding. The education proposals, | 1:34:49 | 1:34:56 | |
the Government proposed three
billion of cuts and that was reduced | 1:34:56 | 1:35:01 | |
to justnd £2 billion. There's a gap
of £2 billion education funding cuts | 1:35:01 | 1:35:06 | |
in our system. The Chancellor has
said nothing about how schools will | 1:35:06 | 1:35:09 | |
cope with that. Does she agree with
me we should have had some thinking | 1:35:09 | 1:35:18 | |
and investment in our schools in
order to prevent them reversing the | 1:35:18 | 1:35:24 | |
progress that has been made? I can
say to the honourable lady, who I'm | 1:35:24 | 1:35:29 | |
very pleased to serve on the
Treasury committee with, we have | 1:35:29 | 1:35:34 | |
seen education fanned Ards improve
dramatically in this country over | 1:35:34 | 1:35:37 | |
the last seven years. I don't
recognise the figure she has said. | 1:35:37 | 1:35:42 | |
The Secretary of State for Education
announced an extra £1.3 billion in | 1:35:42 | 1:35:46 | |
July. This Government's spending
more on schools than any Government | 1:35:46 | 1:35:50 | |
has ever spent before. If she's
really concerned, she will want to | 1:35:50 | 1:35:54 | |
address the interest on the debt
this Government is still paying off, | 1:35:54 | 1:35:58 | |
we are spending almost as much on
debt interest as on our schools | 1:35:58 | 1:36:01 | |
budget. Let me turn to tax. The
Chancellor announced a number of new | 1:36:01 | 1:36:06 | |
tax mesh use. He was very pleased he
said our tax system can help protect | 1:36:06 | 1:36:11 | |
our environment. It is an important
signal to send to those concerned | 1:36:11 | 1:36:15 | |
about the environment and to the
next generation. I really want to | 1:36:15 | 1:36:18 | |
welcome... I will, yeah. I'm
grateful to the chair of the | 1:36:18 | 1:36:24 | |
treasury committee for giving way.
On that point, can I we can the | 1:36:24 | 1:36:28 | |
measure in the budget which would
grant an ex-etchings on the zero | 1:36:28 | 1:36:36 | |
emissions. Can I also, through my
honourable friend urge the | 1:36:36 | 1:36:41 | |
Chancellor to bring forward that
measure so it kicks in earlier than | 1:36:41 | 1:36:45 | |
April 2019. Many of those vehicles
will be on the road from next month. | 1:36:45 | 1:36:49 | |
We want drivers to be able to take
advantage of these new zero emission | 1:36:49 | 1:36:55 | |
capable environmentally friendly
taxes. | 1:36:55 | 1:37:01 | |
THE SPEAKER: If we have
interventions, please make them | 1:37:01 | 1:37:03 | |
short. It is a pleasure to serve in
the honourable gentleman on the | 1:37:03 | 1:37:07 | |
Treasury committee. The Chancellor's
heard what he says and is looking | 1:37:07 | 1:37:11 | |
forward to appearing before the
committee on 6th December when we | 1:37:11 | 1:37:15 | |
can ask him those questions
directly. I'll give way believely. | 1:37:15 | 1:37:22 | |
Hidden in the budget book is really
terrible news of no new money for | 1:37:22 | 1:37:28 | |
renewables until 2025 at the same
time the chaps letter' giving away | 1:37:28 | 1:37:32 | |
money, more tax breaks to oil and
gas. How is that compatible with a | 1:37:32 | 1:37:36 | |
forward looking country that is
serious about climate change? I | 1:37:36 | 1:37:40 | |
think this Government's done
incredibly well on supporting | 1:37:40 | 1:37:44 | |
renewables industry. The energy
industry in the Midlands. I can see | 1:37:44 | 1:37:49 | |
a thriving industry. But that's
something again the committee may | 1:37:49 | 1:37:53 | |
well want to take up with the
Chancellor. I want to welcome the | 1:37:53 | 1:37:56 | |
move on business rates. The move
from RPI to CPI is very, very | 1:37:56 | 1:38:00 | |
welcome. I want to welcome the move
on the staircase tax which is | 1:38:00 | 1:38:05 | |
something the Chancellor was asked
about when he appeared before the | 1:38:05 | 1:38:09 | |
committee recently and builds on the
evidence he gave. I hope he's right | 1:38:09 | 1:38:13 | |
about the cross-party support that
he can receive on that measure. | 1:38:13 | 1:38:17 | |
Would my right honourable friend
agree that the changes to business | 1:38:22 | 1:38:25 | |
rates are going to be particularly
valuable for other shops, businesses | 1:38:25 | 1:38:31 | |
and other places in outer London
were they as we could win a bright | 1:38:31 | 1:38:34 | |
lights of London and out-of-town
shopping centres and the Chris | 1:38:34 | 1:38:37 | |
Cusiter business rate is
particularly owners? That is an | 1:38:37 | 1:38:40 | |
excellent point and I would agree
with my honourable friend Matt and I | 1:38:40 | 1:38:43 | |
was going to talk about the
Chancellor's announcement on digital | 1:38:43 | 1:38:48 | |
businesses as well which is
important for bricks and mortar | 1:38:48 | 1:38:51 | |
businesses and perhaps modest, it is
an important printable that has been | 1:38:51 | 1:38:54 | |
established about the tax on digital
businesses doing business here. I | 1:38:54 | 1:38:58 | |
welcome what the Chancellor said
about tax avoidance and evasion | 1:38:58 | 1:39:01 | |
measures. I think you said we were
going to spend £155 billion on | 1:39:01 | 1:39:05 | |
HMRC's collecting ability to collect
£2.3 billion, which sounds | 1:39:05 | 1:39:11 | |
encouraging but the committee will
private estimate. -- 100 £55 | 1:39:11 | 1:39:17 | |
million. I wanted to match my
honourable friend for beginning to | 1:39:17 | 1:39:22 | |
publish the income distribution
analysis showing how different | 1:39:22 | 1:39:24 | |
households are affected by the
budget. That analysis provides an | 1:39:24 | 1:39:28 | |
unprecedented level of transparency
about the consequences of the budget | 1:39:28 | 1:39:30 | |
for ordinary people which only
emerge as a result of pressure by | 1:39:30 | 1:39:35 | |
the Treasury committee in the last
two parliaments. There may be more | 1:39:35 | 1:39:38 | |
work for the committee to doing this
one. What is not included in the | 1:39:38 | 1:39:42 | |
Treasury's analysis yet is an
assessment of the gender impact of | 1:39:42 | 1:39:46 | |
the budget, an analysis of how much
men and women stand to gain or lose | 1:39:46 | 1:39:49 | |
from the Chancellor's decisions. It
will come as no surprise that as the | 1:39:49 | 1:39:53 | |
first female chair of the Treasury
Select Committee, the committee will | 1:39:53 | 1:39:57 | |
be taking gritting evidence
including from the women's budget | 1:39:57 | 1:40:00 | |
group on the merits of such an
analysis. Before concluding, I would | 1:40:00 | 1:40:03 | |
like to remind the house about the
role of the Treasury committee in | 1:40:03 | 1:40:07 | |
scrutinising the OBR and upholding
its independence. I think there is | 1:40:07 | 1:40:10 | |
widespread agreement, Mr Deputy
Speaker, across this house, that the | 1:40:10 | 1:40:13 | |
creation of the OBR as last improved
the credibility and quality of | 1:40:13 | 1:40:18 | |
economic and fiscal forecasting and
empowered members of Parliament to | 1:40:18 | 1:40:21 | |
hold government to account for its
fiscal policy. But in this free bar | 1:40:21 | 1:40:26 | |
political atmosphere, we must member
the OBR is still young. Its hard-won | 1:40:26 | 1:40:30 | |
reputation could be fatally
undermined if the motives and good | 1:40:30 | 1:40:40 | |
faith of its leadership are impugned
by those who disagree with its | 1:40:40 | 1:40:43 | |
finding. The OBR as a powerful line
of accountability to Parliament | 1:40:43 | 1:40:45 | |
thanks to the committee's statutory
veto over the appointment and is the | 1:40:45 | 1:40:47 | |
will of the senior leadership, we
will seek assurances the OBR has | 1:40:47 | 1:40:50 | |
done its work without political
interference. We will subject its | 1:40:50 | 1:40:52 | |
forecast to critical scrutiny as
necessary and defend its integrity. | 1:40:52 | 1:40:54 | |
The committee looks forward to
hearing as I said from the | 1:40:54 | 1:40:57 | |
Chancellor on the measures he has
announced and the economic and | 1:40:57 | 1:41:00 | |
fiscal outlook when he appears
before us in two weeks' time. Mr | 1:41:00 | 1:41:04 | |
Deputy Speaker, the UK faces many
challenges. Brexit hangs over this | 1:41:04 | 1:41:07 | |
place and the UK like a cloud. Some
people think there is a silver | 1:41:07 | 1:41:12 | |
lining. Some people think there will
be more rain and fog. It was | 1:41:12 | 1:41:16 | |
important that today's budget should
show the government's determination | 1:41:16 | 1:41:19 | |
is to do more than just negotiate
our path out of the EU. I believe | 1:41:19 | 1:41:24 | |
the Chancellor has more than
announced that with everything he | 1:41:24 | 1:41:26 | |
has announced today. Ian Black.
Thank you, Mr Deputy Speaker. I | 1:41:26 | 1:41:35 | |
mean, I want to wish the Chancellor
all the best. He talks about | 1:41:35 | 1:41:39 | |
preparing for the future but let's
look at the reality of the figures | 1:41:39 | 1:41:44 | |
contained in the OBR book. What we
are faced with is the United Kingdom | 1:41:44 | 1:41:49 | |
falling to the bottom of growth in
the G7. When we look at GDP per | 1:41:49 | 1:41:57 | |
capita, for the years 2019 and 2020,
what we see is that the OBR have | 1:41:57 | 1:42:06 | |
reduced forecasts from 1.7%, to 0.7%
in 2019, and in 2020, from 1.9%, to | 1:42:06 | 1:42:20 | |
0.7%. Mr Deputy Speaker, that is
what post-Brexit Britain is going to | 1:42:20 | 1:42:26 | |
look like. An absolute shredding of
growth forecasts that the next two | 1:42:26 | 1:42:34 | |
years. The OBR talks about GDP... I
will not because this is the third | 1:42:34 | 1:42:42 | |
party speech and it is the practice
that there is not to be | 1:42:42 | 1:42:45 | |
interventions. The change in GDP
that we will see in the OBR book is | 1:42:45 | 1:42:52 | |
a cut to GDP of 2.7%. That is what
this government is presiding over. | 1:42:52 | 1:43:01 | |
It is a threat to the wages, to the
living standards and to the job | 1:43:01 | 1:43:04 | |
prospects of people up and down the
United Kingdom. Frankly, it is a | 1:43:04 | 1:43:10 | |
government that should be ashamed of
itself. And when you look at the | 1:43:10 | 1:43:16 | |
rhetoric of the budget speech, and I
can see honourable members laughing, | 1:43:16 | 1:43:19 | |
but when you look at the fiscal
loosening that we have in this | 1:43:19 | 1:43:24 | |
budget, it is a fiscal loosening of
0.1%. That does not take into | 1:43:24 | 1:43:29 | |
account the reality of the risks
that the people of the United | 1:43:29 | 1:43:32 | |
Kingdom face. Mr Deputy Speaker, let
me welcome the removal of VAT on | 1:43:32 | 1:43:43 | |
police and Fire Services. But can I
remind the Chancellor of the | 1:43:43 | 1:43:49 | |
Exchequer that together with his
friend, the Secretary of State for | 1:43:49 | 1:43:53 | |
Scotland, that they were given the
opportunity to support an SNP | 1:43:53 | 1:43:57 | |
amendment to the Finance Bill in
2015 that would have removed VAT | 1:43:57 | 1:44:03 | |
from Scotland and I can see the
remarks coming from the benches | 1:44:03 | 1:44:06 | |
opposite but I will remind them that
the Conservative Party in their | 1:44:06 | 1:44:11 | |
manifesto supported the
establishment of police Scotland. It | 1:44:11 | 1:44:15 | |
was the vindictiveness and the nasty
nurse of the Tory government that | 1:44:15 | 1:44:20 | |
imposed VAT on Scotland. That has
ripped £114 million out of our front | 1:44:20 | 1:44:26 | |
line services. And when the
Chancellor of the Exchequer and the | 1:44:26 | 1:44:33 | |
Secretary of State for Scotland were
given the opportunity in the Finance | 1:44:33 | 1:44:39 | |
Bill of 2015, they failed. So it is
a disgrace that we have had 140 | 1:44:39 | 1:44:44 | |
million taken out of front line
spending. Point of order. Mr Debord | 1:44:44 | 1:44:50 | |
is bigger, just a point of
clarification, just to clarify, we | 1:44:50 | 1:44:54 | |
are allowed to intervene on the
honourable member's speech, whether | 1:44:54 | 1:44:57 | |
he takes it or not is something
else. Just a second. Just a moment. | 1:44:57 | 1:45:04 | |
The rules are that it is the
Chancellor of the Exchequer, it is | 1:45:04 | 1:45:09 | |
the Leader of the Opposition, who
are not intervened on but what I | 1:45:09 | 1:45:14 | |
would say is that the courtesies go
to the leader of the SNP, who may | 1:45:14 | 1:45:19 | |
wish not to be intervened, that is
his choice, and what I suggest... | 1:45:19 | 1:45:24 | |
What I suggest... Order, order. What
I will tell you is that he has made | 1:45:24 | 1:45:29 | |
it quite clear that he wants the
same courtesy that has been | 1:45:29 | 1:45:33 | |
established so in which case come he
won't be giving way. It will save us | 1:45:33 | 1:45:36 | |
a lot of time if the bust standing
up. Thank you very much Mr Deputy | 1:45:36 | 1:45:43 | |
Speaker, it is about time the
Scottish Conservatives actually | 1:45:43 | 1:45:46 | |
showed some proper respect, not just
to the SNP year but to the Scottish | 1:45:46 | 1:45:49 | |
Government in Edinburgh. To return
to the point, it is an absolute | 1:45:49 | 1:45:55 | |
disgrace we have had £140 million
taken out of front line spending by | 1:45:55 | 1:46:00 | |
a Tory government ahead of this
announcement. VAT should never have | 1:46:00 | 1:46:04 | |
been charged to Scottish police and
fire and the blame for that, the | 1:46:04 | 1:46:09 | |
sole blame for that lies with the
Conservative government. Mr Deputy | 1:46:09 | 1:46:13 | |
Speaker... Andrew Green order, you
are a normal, gentle person, a man | 1:46:13 | 1:46:20 | |
who normally shows such dignity. I'm
hoping he will show dignity today. | 1:46:20 | 1:46:26 | |
Thank you, Mr Deputy Speaker. The
SNP have spoken out here and in | 1:46:26 | 1:46:31 | |
Holyrood 140 times before the
government finally saw sense. But | 1:46:31 | 1:46:36 | |
what about the 140 million that has
been paid? The Chancellor has | 1:46:36 | 1:46:41 | |
confirmed today what we knew all
along, it was a political choice to | 1:46:41 | 1:46:45 | |
charge VAT on our emergency
services. He has accepted that he | 1:46:45 | 1:46:49 | |
was wrong but I'm calling on the
Chancellor today and his friends | 1:46:49 | 1:46:54 | |
from Scotland on the Tory benches to
make sure that we push for a refund | 1:46:54 | 1:46:59 | |
of the VAT that has been paid over
the course of the last three years. | 1:46:59 | 1:47:05 | |
Mr Deputy Speaker, the Chancellor
has painted a picture of our | 1:47:05 | 1:47:13 | |
economy, ready for the impending
economic disaster Brexit. We all | 1:47:13 | 1:47:18 | |
have to wonder, just exactly what
planet is the Chancellor on Western | 1:47:18 | 1:47:22 | |
Mark most workers are seeing a
decline in their living standards | 1:47:22 | 1:47:25 | |
and have done so since the financial
crisis. We are living through the | 1:47:25 | 1:47:29 | |
worst decade of wage growth for 210
years. Young people are going to be | 1:47:29 | 1:47:36 | |
poorer than their parents. Housing
has become unaffordable for many. | 1:47:36 | 1:47:45 | |
The austerity economic model has
failed millions. The Prime Minister | 1:47:45 | 1:47:48 | |
alluded to this when she talked
about the "Just about managing". Mr | 1:47:48 | 1:47:55 | |
Deputy Speaker, today's budget was
an opportunity to address these | 1:47:55 | 1:47:59 | |
challenges and make this a budget
for people and prosperity. The | 1:47:59 | 1:48:04 | |
reality is, there is nothing in this
budget that deals with the | 1:48:04 | 1:48:07 | |
challenges that we face. We have the
impending UK exit from Europe. We | 1:48:07 | 1:48:12 | |
know the government is preparing for
a no deal. Yet the Chancellor made | 1:48:12 | 1:48:18 | |
no mention of how the economy would
cope with that. The cliff edge is | 1:48:18 | 1:48:25 | |
before us and the Chancellor sits
transfixed, unable or incapable of | 1:48:25 | 1:48:30 | |
rising to the challenge. No doubt
the Chancellor recognises the | 1:48:30 | 1:48:37 | |
economic self harm that comes with
leaving the single market and the | 1:48:37 | 1:48:40 | |
customs union. But has failed to
act. Why? Because the Brexiteers | 1:48:40 | 1:48:48 | |
have set the agenda for this
government and the Chancellor is | 1:48:48 | 1:48:50 | |
without the authority to challenge
the madness. The Chancellor, like | 1:48:50 | 1:48:55 | |
his government, is in office but not
in power. We know that the Prime | 1:48:55 | 1:49:03 | |
Minister has two present a financial
settlement to the EU 27 over the | 1:49:03 | 1:49:07 | |
coming days. Yet there was no
mention of that in this statement, | 1:49:07 | 1:49:10 | |
none at all. This government has to
take its head out of the sand and | 1:49:10 | 1:49:15 | |
except that the future -- accept
that the future indicates the | 1:49:15 | 1:49:21 | |
likelihood of significant economic
self arm. Mr Deputy Speaker, before | 1:49:21 | 1:49:26 | |
the winds of Brexit hit us, the
starting position for millions of | 1:49:26 | 1:49:29 | |
people is that by then, we will have
already been struggling with nine | 1:49:29 | 1:49:32 | |
years austerity. The cuts being
imposed on public services, meaning | 1:49:32 | 1:49:38 | |
that service delivery has been
impacted in public service workers | 1:49:38 | 1:49:42 | |
in particular, are feeling the
squeeze. This is a budget that shows | 1:49:42 | 1:49:47 | |
a Chancellor that is either blind to
what is going on or that he is | 1:49:47 | 1:49:50 | |
behaving like a frightened rabbit
caught in headlights. Either way, | 1:49:50 | 1:49:55 | |
people are going to pay the price
for his lack of leadership. Well, I | 1:49:55 | 1:49:58 | |
can see the Chancellor saying an
extra £2 billion for Scotland. Let | 1:49:58 | 1:50:04 | |
me tell this allows the reality. Let
me tell you the reality. -- this | 1:50:04 | 1:50:10 | |
house. It is a £250 million cut in
real terms. That is what the | 1:50:10 | 1:50:15 | |
government here is delivering to the
people of Scotland. Mr Deputy | 1:50:15 | 1:50:21 | |
Speaker, this government used to
speak of the empty rhetoric of the | 1:50:21 | 1:50:25 | |
long-term economic plan. It has
failed to deliver a vision and has | 1:50:25 | 1:50:30 | |
no plan for delivering prosperity.
The long-term economic plan has | 1:50:30 | 1:50:33 | |
given way to no plan. Scratch the
surface of the economy and you will | 1:50:33 | 1:50:39 | |
see a structure barely coping with
the state of society, a structure | 1:50:39 | 1:50:45 | |
that is so unfairly built in favour
of the wealthy, we have created a | 1:50:45 | 1:50:48 | |
situation where we have the worst
wage growth in 200 years and the IFS | 1:50:48 | 1:50:53 | |
tell us an additional 400,000
children will be in absolute poverty | 1:50:53 | 1:50:57 | |
within six years due to the benefit
cuts that are to come because let's | 1:50:57 | 1:51:02 | |
remind ourselves, there is still £12
billion of cuts to welfare to come | 1:51:02 | 1:51:08 | |
from this Tory government. The case,
Mr Deputy Speaker, is that working | 1:51:08 | 1:51:16 | |
people are paying the price for this
government's ideological accession | 1:51:16 | 1:51:18 | |
with austerity because make no
mistake, it is an ideological | 1:51:18 | 1:51:23 | |
accession. I mean, it is a pity that
people watching and listening to | 1:51:23 | 1:51:30 | |
this cannot see the Tory benches
sitting and laughing when people in | 1:51:30 | 1:51:37 | |
our country are paying the price.
They should be utterly ashamed of | 1:51:37 | 1:51:39 | |
themselves. Effective stewardship of
our economy has to recognise the | 1:51:39 | 1:51:46 | |
importance of fiscal and monetary
policy working in tandem to create | 1:51:46 | 1:51:50 | |
the circumstances of sustainable and
inclusive economic growth. Any | 1:51:50 | 1:51:57 | |
disconnect leads to failure to
deliver an economy that works for | 1:51:57 | 1:52:01 | |
all, which is precisely what is
happening. A failure to deliver a | 1:52:01 | 1:52:05 | |
budget for prosperity hit all
workers, in particular those in the | 1:52:05 | 1:52:09 | |
public sector. Mr Deputy Speaker, in
September, the Scottish cosmid | 1:52:09 | 1:52:13 | |
became the first in the UK to
announce it will scrap the public | 1:52:13 | 1:52:16 | |
sector pay gap. Our nurses,
teachers, police officers and | 1:52:16 | 1:52:23 | |
firefighters deserve a fair deal for
the future. Future pay rises will be | 1:52:23 | 1:52:26 | |
based on the cost of living and
today, the Chancellor betrayed | 1:52:26 | 1:52:30 | |
public sector workers by refusing to
fund a fair pay rise. But it is not | 1:52:30 | 1:52:36 | |
just the squeeze on pay which is
leaving low earners are struggling | 1:52:36 | 1:52:40 | |
to get by. The UK Government's
Social Security cuts are | 1:52:40 | 1:52:44 | |
specifically designed to remove the
welfare state. The SNP will never | 1:52:44 | 1:52:49 | |
accept this ideological attack on
the most vulnerable in our society. | 1:52:49 | 1:52:54 | |
The damaging and destructive
Universal Credit system must be | 1:52:54 | 1:52:56 | |
halted and fixed. Now, I welcome
some of the things we have heard to | 1:52:56 | 1:53:02 | |
date but it simply does not go far
enough. We still have cuts to the | 1:53:02 | 1:53:08 | |
work allowance is taking place and
while young people are pushed into | 1:53:08 | 1:53:10 | |
poverty, Universal Credit as is, is
not fit for purpose. The Chancellor | 1:53:10 | 1:53:16 | |
of the Exchequer should call
thoughts today and reform the system | 1:53:16 | 1:53:19 | |
properly. -- call a halt today. We
also call on the Chancellor to scrap | 1:53:19 | 1:53:26 | |
the two child policy and immoral...
According to the IFS, the two child | 1:53:26 | 1:53:35 | |
cap on tax credits will mean around
600,000 families with three children | 1:53:35 | 1:53:41 | |
lose £2500 per year on average, and
300,000 families with four or more | 1:53:41 | 1:53:46 | |
children will lose a whopping £7,000
per year on average, and most of | 1:53:46 | 1:53:50 | |
these families are in work. If you
want to make work pay, then let's | 1:53:50 | 1:53:54 | |
remove that clause. | 1:53:54 | 1:53:56 | |
There is nothing in this budget for
Wimborne in the 19 50s, we're seeing | 1:54:01 | 1:54:08 | |
a rise in pensionable age up to six
years without proper notice. | 1:54:08 | 1:54:12 | |
Depriving millions of a pension they
paid for, they were entitled to. | 1:54:12 | 1:54:16 | |
Time and time again, the
Government's been asked to slow down | 1:54:16 | 1:54:19 | |
the current rate of increase and
women's pensionable age which is | 1:54:19 | 1:54:23 | |
increasing at three months for each
calendar month. Either the | 1:54:23 | 1:54:27 | |
Chancellor decides to act now and
deliver fairness to 1950s women or | 1:54:27 | 1:54:32 | |
he will find Parliament will do it
for him. There is a Private Members | 1:54:32 | 1:54:38 | |
Bill calling for mitigation to be
put in place for 1950s women. Let me | 1:54:38 | 1:54:44 | |
say to the Government, recognise the
cross-party nature of this bill and | 1:54:44 | 1:54:48 | |
actor face defeat. Whilst the Tories
attack on benefits pushing more | 1:54:48 | 1:54:55 | |
families into poverty, the financial
squeeze on household income | 1:54:55 | 1:54:58 | |
continues as Brexit bites. Today,
inflation sits at 3%. Prices are | 1:54:58 | 1:55:04 | |
risings at a faster rate than wages.
The Resolution Foundation calculated | 1:55:04 | 1:55:09 | |
3% inflation combined with the
benefits freeze will impact 7.3 | 1:55:09 | 1:55:14 | |
million children, 2.4 million
disabled people and 800,000 people | 1:55:14 | 1:55:17 | |
looking for work. There is no answer
to that for the Chancellor. Nothing | 1:55:17 | 1:55:22 | |
in this budget. Let me tell the
Chancellor those on the Tory | 1:55:22 | 1:55:26 | |
benches, what life is like outside
the guilded rooms of Whitehall. | 1:55:26 | 1:55:32 | |
Electricity bills have increased by
9%. You laugh, you laugh when people | 1:55:32 | 1:55:37 | |
in Scotland and the rest of the UK
have seen electricity prices rise by | 1:55:37 | 1:55:43 | |
9%. You should be ashamed of
yourself. I hope your electorate | 1:55:43 | 1:55:47 | |
holds you to account. That, by the
way, was the so-called honourable | 1:55:47 | 1:55:53 | |
member for Ayr. Children's clothing
has increased by 6.7% in price. | 1:55:53 | 1:56:00 | |
Butter has increased by 12% in
price. Travel, bus and coach traffic | 1:56:00 | 1:56:05 | |
has increased by 13%. Train fairs by
3.4%. Transport insurance up by | 1:56:05 | 1:56:11 | |
1.6%. Motor vehicle insurance 13%.
Travel insurance 10 rest. That's the | 1:56:11 | 1:56:20 | |
reality for ordinary working people
in Scotland and the UK. Inflation is | 1:56:20 | 1:56:24 | |
making the cost of a weekly shop
soar and wages are falling. There is | 1:56:24 | 1:56:30 | |
nothing in this budget to address
that. The rise in inflation and | 1:56:30 | 1:56:34 | |
squeeze on wages is creating a
crisis for low income earners. | 1:56:34 | 1:56:42 | |
Between 2010 sand 201, official GDP
per employee had risen by 3.5% real | 1:56:42 | 1:56:51 | |
waging are 1.2% -- 1.1% lower. If
inflation is calculated to include | 1:56:51 | 1:56:59 | |
housings costs, real wages are down
by 7.2%. That's the economic record | 1:56:59 | 1:57:03 | |
of the Tory Government. The collapse
of UK productivity growth has driven | 1:57:03 | 1:57:09 | |
low growth and stagnant wages. But
whilst many of my constituencients | 1:57:09 | 1:57:13 | |
and families across the UK rely on
credit cards to put forward on the | 1:57:13 | 1:57:18 | |
table, a different story is
unfolding in the city. Under this | 1:57:18 | 1:57:25 | |
Tory Government, boardroom pay has
soared. From 2010-1016 the average | 1:57:25 | 1:57:34 | |
ewe numeration for CEOs almost
doubled. From 1.5-3.1 million. Mr | 1:57:34 | 1:57:43 | |
Deputy Speaker, the inequality goes
much deeper. European Commission | 1:57:43 | 1:57:47 | |
figures revealed the UK had the
biggest increase in the EU's gender | 1:57:47 | 1:57:52 | |
pay gap in 2015. The difference in
average hourly pay for male and | 1:57:52 | 1:57:59 | |
female workers jumped from 19.7% in
2014 to 70.8% in 2015. That means in | 1:57:59 | 1:58:07 | |
event women are working unpaid for
more than two months a year in | 1:58:07 | 1:58:12 | |
comparison to men. This Government
has not only driven thousands into | 1:58:12 | 1:58:17 | |
poverty, it has completely failed to
investment in building an inclusive | 1:58:17 | 1:58:23 | |
economy fit for future generations.
Legacy this Chancellor leaves is an | 1:58:23 | 1:58:28 | |
economy which only works for the
rich and reckless. We need tad fifty | 1:58:28 | 1:58:34 | |
to create circumstances to include
sustainable economic growth with | 1:58:34 | 1:58:39 | |
unthat would encourage investment
strive up productivity and living | 1:58:39 | 1:58:44 | |
standards, which recognises monetary
and fiscal policy have to work in | 1:58:44 | 1:58:48 | |
UNISON. What we've had is a focus on
monetary policy that's given up | 1:58:48 | 1:58:53 | |
house prices, stocks and shares but
failed to drive investment in the | 1:58:53 | 1:58:56 | |
real economy. Back in 2009
quantitative easing was an obvious | 1:58:56 | 1:59:03 | |
choice to be part of restoring
confidence in growth provided it was | 1:59:03 | 1:59:07 | |
matched with fiscal measures.
Particularly in vestings in | 1:59:07 | 1:59:13 | |
infrastructure and building capacity
in our economy. A chance to invest | 1:59:13 | 1:59:16 | |
in the economy to kick-start growth
and productivity. But under the | 1:59:16 | 1:59:21 | |
steer of this Government it was
invested to benefit the wealthy and, | 1:59:21 | 1:59:25 | |
in the end, has done nothing but
exacerbate the gap between rich and | 1:59:25 | 1:59:29 | |
poor. The Bank of England recognise
the negative effect caused by this | 1:59:29 | 1:59:33 | |
policy. In 2012, they said although
quantitative easing had increased as | 1:59:33 | 1:59:41 | |
set prices this had
disproportionately benefitted the | 1:59:41 | 1:59:44 | |
top 5% of the households. I can see
the Chancellor waiving his hands. | 1:59:44 | 1:59:49 | |
This is something which is
important. Something that he | 1:59:49 | 1:59:54 | |
ultimately has to take
responsibility for. Mr Deputy | 1:59:54 | 1:59:59 | |
Speaker, last year inflating as set
prices had exacerbated the gap | 1:59:59 | 2:00:04 | |
between rich and poor. They found
the 10% wreathiest of households | 2:00:04 | 2:00:10 | |
held 56% of net financial as sets in
2015. By 2014, the proportion of the | 2:00:10 | 2:00:17 | |
nation's welts had increased to 6 a
%. It is easy to see why the Tories | 2:00:17 | 2:00:21 | |
don't want to change this policy.
Reducing inequality has never been | 2:00:21 | 2:00:25 | |
one of their aims. The #e6ed is
stark. Quantitative easing has | 2:00:25 | 2:00:31 | |
mostly benefitted those who started
with considerable wealth. The FTSE | 2:00:31 | 2:00:36 | |
100 was sitting at 3,805 on 18th
March 2009 ahead of the QE programme | 2:00:36 | 2:00:45 | |
being launched. Last night, there
was a growth of 95% in just over | 2:00:45 | 2:00:52 | |
eight years. The Government has
stuffed cash into the pockets of the | 2:00:52 | 2:00:58 | |
wealthy whilst ordinary folk have
paid the price for austerity. The | 2:00:58 | 2:01:03 | |
cry, there's no money, flies in the
face of the Government's own agenda. | 2:01:03 | 2:01:07 | |
A further £70 billion was invested
in QE after the Brexit vote taking | 2:01:07 | 2:01:13 | |
the programme to £435 billion. That
is £435 billion on to our debt with | 2:01:13 | 2:01:20 | |
no plan, no plan as to how this will
be repaid. We could have invested in | 2:01:20 | 2:01:27 | |
our infrastructure, in housing,
dealing with the demand for housing | 2:01:27 | 2:01:30 | |
and dampening the rise in house
prices to affordable level as one | 2:01:30 | 2:01:34 | |
example. Investing in connectivity,
transport and digital, to allow our | 2:01:34 | 2:01:40 | |
citizens and businesses compete
effectively and not caught in the | 2:01:40 | 2:01:43 | |
slow lane of transport snarl-ups and
fighting to get decent broadband or | 2:01:43 | 2:01:48 | |
mobile connectivity. This investment
would have grown the economy, tax | 2:01:48 | 2:01:52 | |
receipts and allowed us to cut the
deficit. There would have been a pay | 2:01:52 | 2:01:55 | |
pack. That could have supported
businesses at the same time as | 2:01:55 | 2:02:00 | |
supporting people. Don't tell us
there's no money when you can invest | 2:02:00 | 2:02:06 | |
an additional £70 billion in QE at
the drop of a hat. Take proper | 2:02:06 | 2:02:11 | |
responsibility for creating the
circumstances for inclusive growth | 2:02:11 | 2:02:14 | |
and prosperity. Of course, taking
responsibility is not something that | 2:02:14 | 2:02:19 | |
this Government does. £6.9 billion
is lost to our schools and 4079s | 2:02:19 | 2:02:27 | |
every year because this Government
I'm calling on the Government to | 2:02:27 | 2:02:33 | |
take tough new action to ensure the
richest in society and the biggest | 2:02:33 | 2:02:37 | |
corporations pay the taxes they owe
in full. They have chosen to cut | 2:02:37 | 2:02:42 | |
public spending while protects the
super rich. Of course, the Tories | 2:02:42 | 2:02:46 | |
are the party of the super rich. If
they won't take the ass required, | 2:02:46 | 2:02:51 | |
devolve the powers needed to canle
the issue to the Scottish | 2:02:51 | 2:02:54 | |
Parliament. For I ask the Chancellor
last month on any assessment he has | 2:02:54 | 2:03:00 | |
made on the inter relationship
between monetary and fiscal policy, | 2:03:00 | 2:03:03 | |
the answer I got was that monetary
responsibility was the | 2:03:03 | 2:03:08 | |
responsibility of the bang Bank of
England. There was no regard for a | 2:03:08 | 2:03:11 | |
link between the two. It is left to
the Bank of England to shine the | 2:03:11 | 2:03:17 | |
light on the failure the Chancellor
to engaged and joined up thinking. | 2:03:17 | 2:03:22 | |
The Bank of England #5ed mitted the
steep rises in house prices in the | 2:03:22 | 2:03:26 | |
decade proceeding the crisis
together the with a fall in | 2:03:26 | 2:03:29 | |
long-term interest rates has led to
a sharp rise in inter generational | 2:03:29 | 2:03:34 | |
dis-Persian of wealth benefitting in
particular older people who had | 2:03:34 | 2:03:37 | |
already entered the market before
prices began to rise. This | 2:03:37 | 2:03:43 | |
Government has avoided every
opportunity to invest in young | 2:03:43 | 2:03:45 | |
people. What hope... The Chancellor
says rubbish. I'm giving facts from | 2:03:45 | 2:03:54 | |
respected institutions, not least
the Bank of England. Is the | 2:03:54 | 2:03:56 | |
Chancellor really saying 9 bank of
the Bank of England is wrong as | 2:03:56 | 2:04:01 | |
well? I think they might have
something to say. What hope it | 2:04:01 | 2:04:05 | |
Millenials have to cling on to?
Robbed of their housing allowance. | 2:04:05 | 2:04:10 | |
Lumbered with chronic student debt,
this Government's gone out of its | 2:04:10 | 2:04:14 | |
way to avoid investing in young
people. The inter generational | 2:04:14 | 2:04:17 | |
wealth and fairness is creating the
perfect storm for future | 2:04:17 | 2:04:21 | |
generations. Research from the
Resolution Foundation shows today's | 2:04:21 | 2:04:26 | |
27-year-olds are earning the same
amount 27-year-olds did a quarter of | 2:04:26 | 2:04:33 | |
a century ago. A typical millennial
has earned £8,000 less in their | 2:04:33 | 2:04:39 | |
twenty than those in the proceeding
generation. We've missed chance | 2:04:39 | 2:04:42 | |
after chance to invest in inclusive
growth opportunities. The Government | 2:04:42 | 2:04:48 | |
has been the proverbial one club
golfer relying on monetary measures | 2:04:48 | 2:04:52 | |
in a vacuum. Even the IFS warned the
Chancellor on his calculations. | 2:04:52 | 2:04:57 | |
First of all, we had George Osborne
pro claim he wanted to balance the | 2:04:57 | 2:05:03 | |
books by 2015. That didn't happen.
Now the current Chancellor wants to | 2:05:03 | 2:05:09 | |
eliminate borrowing by 2020. Even
the IFS called on him to abandon his | 2:05:09 | 2:05:15 | |
fanciful fiscal targets. There is
more uncertainty on forecast now | 2:05:15 | 2:05:20 | |
than ever before. The Chancellor
himself told the Treasury committee | 2:05:20 | 2:05:25 | |
a cloud of uncertainty is acting as
a temporary dampner and we need to | 2:05:25 | 2:05:29 | |
remove it as soon as possible. Well,
there was nothing in that budget | 2:05:29 | 2:05:34 | |
today to remove it. But, I'm in a
giving mood. I'll give the | 2:05:34 | 2:05:41 | |
Chancellor a bit of fundamental
economic advice. End the suicidal | 2:05:41 | 2:05:47 | |
flirtation with a no deal scenario.
Give business something to invest in | 2:05:47 | 2:05:51 | |
and work on keeping the UK in the
single market. The stupidity and | 2:05:51 | 2:05:56 | |
recklessness of some on front bench
who rode around on a famous red bus | 2:05:56 | 2:06:00 | |
has been the most damaging economic
pledge in modern history. £350 | 2:06:00 | 2:06:05 | |
million a week, they said for the
NHS. Well, they're silent on that | 2:06:05 | 2:06:09 | |
now. The Foreign Secretary and the
Environment Secretary should listen | 2:06:09 | 2:06:13 | |
up. Here are some home truths about
the mess they've created. The Bank | 2:06:13 | 2:06:19 | |
of England confirmed 75,000 jobs are
at risk in the financial sector due | 2:06:19 | 2:06:24 | |
to Brexit. The LSE revealed
Scotland's towns and cities could | 2:06:24 | 2:06:28 | |
lose up to £340 billion over five
years. Brexit would cost Scotland up | 2:06:28 | 2:06:34 | |
to 80,000 jobs and see camings fall
by £2,000 a head per year. Now the | 2:06:34 | 2:06:40 | |
Chancellor is planning for a no
deal. A complete catastrophe. That's | 2:06:40 | 2:06:47 | |
unfolding under his watch. He knows
how devastating such a math would be | 2:06:47 | 2:06:52 | |
for the UK economy. He's given
departments £250 million to carry | 2:06:52 | 2:06:57 | |
out work in preparation. To put this
in contest, that would pay for | 2:06:57 | 2:07:06 | |
11,553 new starter nurses, teachers
or police officers. It is not just | 2:07:06 | 2:07:10 | |
the funding Brexit that's costing
commune. Leaving the EU will cut off | 2:07:10 | 2:07:14 | |
the financial social funds we've
benefitted from for so long. This | 2:07:14 | 2:07:17 | |
will be devastating for communities
where poverty and destitution at the | 2:07:17 | 2:07:22 | |
hands of the Tories have vene
volunteers pick up the pieces. As | 2:07:22 | 2:07:28 | |
the UK haemorrhages EU funding and
the Chancellor pro claims austerity | 2:07:28 | 2:07:33 | |
is essential he managed to find £1
billion for the DUP. Quite | 2:07:33 | 2:07:37 | |
remarkable. The Chancellor found £1
billion for devolved areas in the | 2:07:37 | 2:07:43 | |
Northern Ireland executive to spend
but no additional funds provided for | 2:07:43 | 2:07:48 | |
Scotland or any other part of the
you can. Cash for votes, not very | 2:07:48 | 2:07:51 | |
honourable at all. What use are
they? The Scottish Conservative | 2:07:51 | 2:07:56 | |
benches who pledge to work as a
block to protect Scotland's | 2:07:56 | 2:08:01 | |
interests that was your chance to
shine. A golden opportunity to show | 2:08:01 | 2:08:07 | |
they were prepared to put politics
aside and stand up for Scotland. But | 2:08:07 | 2:08:13 | |
no, party loyalty prevailed and
Scotland is being overlooked in this | 2:08:13 | 2:08:16 | |
dodgy deal. This money cannot be
post Tested until the discussions | 2:08:16 | 2:08:20 | |
have concluded on the
appropriateness and the way in which | 2:08:20 | 2:08:23 | |
the UK Government decided to provide
the addition financial support. The | 2:08:23 | 2:08:30 | |
Barnet rules mean Scotland, Wales
and Northern Ireland are entitled to | 2:08:30 | 2:08:35 | |
an extra £2.9 billion as a result of
deal. Where the Scottish Tories | 2:08:35 | 2:08:39 | |
standing can up for that £2.9
billion Scotland he is defshs? Gone | 2:08:39 | 2:08:45 | |
are the calls for the Scottish
Tories, UK Government to match the | 2:08:45 | 2:08:49 | |
deal for Northern Ireland. They've
been found wanting. Year after year, | 2:08:49 | 2:08:54 | |
the UK Government continues to let
down our world-class oil and gas | 2:08:54 | 2:08:58 | |
industry in the north-east of
Scotland. | 2:08:58 | 2:09:03 | |
Two years ago, Mr Deputy Speaker,
the Conservatives boasted about the | 2:09:03 | 2:09:07 | |
creation of a new oil and gas
ambassador. It would promote the | 2:09:07 | 2:09:11 | |
North Sea around the world and boost
investment. How embarrassing, then, | 2:09:11 | 2:09:15 | |
for the Chancellor that the role,
two years later, has yet to be | 2:09:15 | 2:09:21 | |
built. It seems that the Chancellor
and his cabinet colleagues have | 2:09:21 | 2:09:24 | |
simply forgotten about our North Sea
industry once again. Despite the | 2:09:24 | 2:09:28 | |
Chancellor's tight grip restraining
skull and's economic potential, the | 2:09:28 | 2:09:34 | |
SNP in Scotland have delivered our
people. Anna Soubry. Mr Deputy | 2:09:34 | 2:09:42 | |
Speaker, is it in order for
honourable members to make speeches | 2:09:42 | 2:09:46 | |
where they completely ignore the
contents of the budget that the | 2:09:46 | 2:09:51 | |
Chancellor has just delivered?
Order, order. There's two good | 2:09:51 | 2:09:57 | |
things, isn't there? We've got a
slight break. One, it was definitely | 2:09:57 | 2:10:01 | |
not a point of order and you know it
wasn't, completely not a point of | 2:10:01 | 2:10:05 | |
order. The fact is, we've had a
running commentary from you all the | 2:10:05 | 2:10:08 | |
way through. I think I've heard more
than enough from the time being and | 2:10:08 | 2:10:12 | |
I certainly want to get to the end
of the leader of the SNP. Thank you, | 2:10:12 | 2:10:19 | |
Mr Deputy Speaker. In Scotland,
international exports are up 41% | 2:10:19 | 2:10:24 | |
between 2007-2015, the latest on
imported figures show that Scotland | 2:10:24 | 2:10:29 | |
has higher unemployment rate and
lower implement rates with UK and | 2:10:29 | 2:10:34 | |
use and continues to outperform UK.
The Scottish Government the filled | 2:10:34 | 2:10:37 | |
its commitment to reduce youth
unemployment for years ahead of | 2:10:37 | 2:10:40 | |
schedule, that is how you make
visible targets, it is not just | 2:10:40 | 2:10:43 | |
about the ability of the Scottish
Government to deliver an inclusive | 2:10:43 | 2:10:46 | |
society that works for all, it is
our vision for an economy that | 2:10:46 | 2:10:49 | |
benefits all and the UK Government
chose the break clause, the Scottish | 2:10:49 | 2:10:57 | |
Government chose the baby box. When
the UK Government tripled tuition | 2:10:57 | 2:11:01 | |
fees, the Scottish Government
maintained a Brisbane Roar free | 2:11:01 | 2:11:03 | |
tuition for all. When the
Conservatives pushed for a dementia | 2:11:03 | 2:11:06 | |
tax, the Scottish Government stood
by free personal care for the | 2:11:06 | 2:11:09 | |
elderly. We know that an economy is
not just a tool for inclusive growth | 2:11:09 | 2:11:14 | |
but it is central to the social
fabric of the society which we grow | 2:11:14 | 2:11:18 | |
up. It is time for an economy that
benefits all. And damaging austerity | 2:11:18 | 2:11:25 | |
agenda and stop the catastrophic
ideological obsession with a Brexit | 2:11:25 | 2:11:28 | |
no deal. Just, order. Just to say,
we are going over to ten minute | 2:11:28 | 2:11:38 | |
speeches and it will be ten minutes
from when we start but I have a | 2:11:38 | 2:11:42 | |
point of order. Mr Deputy Speaker,
this morning in Cabinet questions, | 2:11:42 | 2:11:47 | |
the first Secretary of State claimed
the consultation on the contaminated | 2:11:47 | 2:11:50 | |
blood scandal had been extended
until the end of October this year | 2:11:50 | 2:11:54 | |
at the request of the APPG, this was
not correct and in fact the APPG had | 2:11:54 | 2:11:59 | |
asked for an extension of the
original date of the consultation | 2:11:59 | 2:12:02 | |
which was in August 2000 17. Many
people have contacted me you are | 2:12:02 | 2:12:06 | |
concerned that this is now being
made on the announcement of the | 2:12:06 | 2:12:12 | |
chair and terms of reference and I
wondered if there is a way of | 2:12:12 | 2:12:15 | |
correcting the record? I think you
have achieved that I do have | 2:12:15 | 2:12:20 | |
corrected the record and put it on
the record for now. Right, let's | 2:12:20 | 2:12:23 | |
continue with a ten minute remit,
Nadim Zahawi 's. Thank you Mr Deputy | 2:12:23 | 2:12:29 | |
Speaker and it is a relief to rise
after the previous speech from the | 2:12:29 | 2:12:35 | |
SNP spokesman. It was actually
longer than the official opposition | 2:12:35 | 2:12:40 | |
response, and it was riveting. Mr
Deputy Speaker, the budget | 2:12:40 | 2:12:47 | |
resolutions always tend to be about
figures and statements which can be | 2:12:47 | 2:12:54 | |
quite dry and are very often leaked
before the actual budget speech | 2:12:54 | 2:12:58 | |
itself. I was delighted today,
absolutely delighted, that of the | 2:12:58 | 2:13:04 | |
headline measures in this speech,
the removal of the 300,000... Sorry, | 2:13:04 | 2:13:10 | |
removal of stamp duty on properties
up to £300,000 was to be scrapped. | 2:13:10 | 2:13:15 | |
-- the stamp duty on properties. I'm
delighted that measure was not | 2:13:15 | 2:13:19 | |
leaked and was an exciting moment,
and one of the are many measures... | 2:13:19 | 2:13:25 | |
I thank my honourable friend were
giving way, something the benches | 2:13:25 | 2:13:28 | |
opposite were not prepared to do for
whatever reason. Does my honourable | 2:13:28 | 2:13:32 | |
friend really believe that the
policy announced by the Chancellor | 2:13:32 | 2:13:36 | |
in respect of stamp duty presents an
almighty challenge to the Scottish | 2:13:36 | 2:13:39 | |
Government? Their land buildings and
transaction tax has been an | 2:13:39 | 2:13:44 | |
unmitigated disaster. Does she think
that the leader of the SNP should be | 2:13:44 | 2:13:49 | |
going to the First Minister and
suggesting that the policy is | 2:13:49 | 2:13:52 | |
followed in Scotland? I'm very sure
that they have had the honourable | 2:13:52 | 2:13:57 | |
member's point and will be taking at
Ford, I imagine tomorrow. -- they | 2:13:57 | 2:14:02 | |
have heard. Mr Deputy Speaker, one
of the issues about homeownership in | 2:14:02 | 2:14:05 | |
the UK is it is very close to my
heart, it is actually the reason I | 2:14:05 | 2:14:09 | |
became a Conservative MP in the
first base. We are seeing now in | 2:14:09 | 2:14:14 | |
these measures today one of the
biggest and most... It's a | 2:14:14 | 2:14:19 | |
revolution in house-building in the
UK, 300,000 homes per year, plus the | 2:14:19 | 2:14:25 | |
establishment of homes England which
will bring together all of the | 2:14:25 | 2:14:28 | |
strands that we need to make this
target possible. Taking, looking at | 2:14:28 | 2:14:35 | |
those... The planning applications,
the training of skilled Artisans and | 2:14:35 | 2:14:42 | |
workmen to build those homes. Homes
England is going to be an authority | 2:14:42 | 2:14:45 | |
that will be required to drive
forward to that degree of | 2:14:45 | 2:14:49 | |
homeownership but it is sometimes
very easy to forget what | 2:14:49 | 2:14:51 | |
homeownership means to so many
people. We haven't seen measures | 2:14:51 | 2:14:57 | |
like this introduced in the UK since
the 1970s. And I think that probably | 2:14:57 | 2:15:03 | |
in this house, I may be one of the
members who understands the value of | 2:15:03 | 2:15:06 | |
homeownership more than most. I was,
I lived in a council house until I | 2:15:06 | 2:15:12 | |
was in my late 20s. And I was
reminded of this in 2017 when I was | 2:15:12 | 2:15:20 | |
canvassing in a constituency which
is not mine, in Luton, in Stockley | 2:15:20 | 2:15:27 | |
Ward. When I knocked at the Lady's
door, she said, "I know you, you are | 2:15:27 | 2:15:32 | |
not standing here but I wouldn't
vote for you anyway because you | 2:15:32 | 2:15:37 | |
support homeownership". And I found
this quite remarkable because I was | 2:15:37 | 2:15:42 | |
on a private, well appointed home.
-- I was at a private. She told me, | 2:15:42 | 2:15:48 | |
we had a discussion which was a
similar moment for me. She says, | 2:15:48 | 2:15:52 | |
"The thing is, I'm a trade unionist
and I don't want, I bore Right To | 2:15:52 | 2:16:00 | |
Buy, I abhor homeownership because
people who have mortgages to pay | 2:16:00 | 2:16:02 | |
won't strike" | 2:16:02 | 2:16:04 | |
people who have mortgages to pay
won't strike". We went on to have a | 2:16:04 | 2:16:08 | |
discussion about how people, when
they buy their own homes, regard | 2:16:08 | 2:16:13 | |
their own private capital over and
above social capital and she was a | 2:16:13 | 2:16:18 | |
very principled lady, I believed.
She had very strong points of view | 2:16:18 | 2:16:22 | |
and I never want to diminish zombie
's's point of view, it is just as | 2:16:22 | 2:16:27 | |
relevant as mine. She can ball
homeownership to the same extent | 2:16:27 | 2:16:31 | |
that I adore homeownership. -- she
can a poor homeownership. But we had | 2:16:31 | 2:16:35 | |
an sting last sentence when she told
me it was her own home, not private | 2:16:35 | 2:16:42 | |
rented accommodation. That was an
interesting moment but I took a | 2:16:42 | 2:16:45 | |
points on board. But I tried to
explain to her the reason why, | 2:16:45 | 2:16:50 | |
because she said to me, "You
shouldn't be a conservative, you | 2:16:50 | 2:16:54 | |
should be a Labour politician, you
have come from a council estate I | 2:16:54 | 2:16:57 | |
know your background" | 2:16:57 | 2:16:59 | |
have come from a council estate I
know your background". It was really | 2:16:59 | 2:17:00 | |
interesting because I did, and I
witnessed what happens to people | 2:17:00 | 2:17:05 | |
when they are given the opportunity
to buy their own home. I will try to | 2:17:05 | 2:17:10 | |
give a description of what it is
like to not own your own house | 2:17:10 | 2:17:15 | |
because so many people are in that
position right now. On the estate I | 2:17:15 | 2:17:18 | |
lived in, every door was painted the
same colour. It was painted by the | 2:17:18 | 2:17:21 | |
council. The gardens on the ground
floors were divided by packing cases | 2:17:21 | 2:17:28 | |
and palettes, wooden pallets. There
were no flowers and what were | 2:17:28 | 2:17:32 | |
gardens had become patches of mud.
Life was pretty great and people | 2:17:32 | 2:17:38 | |
worked at Ford and nobody had any
particular aspiration to do anything | 2:17:38 | 2:17:42 | |
else. But when people began to own
those council houses, it was as | 2:17:42 | 2:17:47 | |
though it changed overnight. People
started to paint their own front | 2:17:47 | 2:17:51 | |
doors, their own colours, expressing
their individuality. The packing | 2:17:51 | 2:17:55 | |
cases were ripped up and painted
fences were put in their place. | 2:17:55 | 2:17:59 | |
Flowers were planted in the gardens.
People started working overtime. The | 2:17:59 | 2:18:05 | |
very first car was bought and
arrived in our road. My mother, who | 2:18:05 | 2:18:08 | |
was a teacher, was almost giving
knightly class to people knocking on | 2:18:08 | 2:18:13 | |
the door and wanting to have lessons
because they wanted to go out, women | 2:18:13 | 2:18:17 | |
who wanted to go out to work. I
regarded homeownership at that time | 2:18:17 | 2:18:22 | |
as a driver for equality for women
because women and almost a reason to | 2:18:22 | 2:18:27 | |
break free on the kitchen sink and
get out to work. -- from the kitchen | 2:18:27 | 2:18:34 | |
sink. I saw a transformation happen
on the estate I lived because of | 2:18:34 | 2:18:37 | |
homeownership. It is about family
stability also because people who | 2:18:37 | 2:18:45 | |
don't own their own homes, rent,
families rent and that is the most | 2:18:45 | 2:18:48 | |
unstable position for a family to
live in, you are facing may be | 2:18:48 | 2:18:52 | |
having to move every six months, you
are facing not the kind of | 2:18:52 | 2:18:55 | |
properties you want to live in, not
the areas you want to live in which | 2:18:55 | 2:18:59 | |
is why people being able to buy
their own homes, decide where they | 2:18:59 | 2:19:03 | |
live, where they send their children
to school... I will give way. I | 2:19:03 | 2:19:07 | |
thank my honourable friend for
giving way, making a typically | 2:19:07 | 2:19:11 | |
powerful argument and is she aware
that this drives people to aspire to | 2:19:11 | 2:19:16 | |
own their own home, so 80% of people
who read want to own? Absolutely and | 2:19:16 | 2:19:21 | |
that is exactly the point I'm coming
on to. I have spoken to a number of | 2:19:21 | 2:19:26 | |
people who actually work here, our
staff. One of the most startling | 2:19:26 | 2:19:31 | |
facts about our staff who work here
is that they have to wait until they | 2:19:31 | 2:19:35 | |
are in at least their mid-30s before
they can even think of putting | 2:19:35 | 2:19:41 | |
effort on the property ladder and
what I hope these measures that have | 2:19:41 | 2:19:45 | |
been announced today will do is help
those people, the abolition of the | 2:19:45 | 2:19:48 | |
stamp duty and all the measures that
we putting in place to become | 2:19:48 | 2:19:51 | |
homeowners. Of course. I'm listening
carefully to what she says and I've | 2:19:51 | 2:19:58 | |
been a long-standing supporter and
champion of people being able to own | 2:19:58 | 2:20:02 | |
their own homes but has she read
what the OBR says about the stamp | 2:20:02 | 2:20:07 | |
duty, that in fact, it won't help
first-time buyers, it will push up | 2:20:07 | 2:20:12 | |
prices by far more than they would
actually save? I thank my honourable | 2:20:12 | 2:20:19 | |
friend for that contribution and
that is exactly what the point the | 2:20:19 | 2:20:23 | |
Chancellor made during his speech,
he made the point that other | 2:20:23 | 2:20:26 | |
measures also needed to be made in
conjunction with the abolition of | 2:20:26 | 2:20:29 | |
the stamp duty, which is the
investment had a lot I will give way | 2:20:29 | 2:20:32 | |
once more because it only ten
minutes. The desire to purchase your | 2:20:32 | 2:20:39 | |
own them and I have a niece who
lived in a council flat until three | 2:20:39 | 2:20:42 | |
years ago and she chose to purchase
the flat before the Scottish | 2:20:42 | 2:20:45 | |
Government banned the sale of houses
and would have denied her ownership | 2:20:45 | 2:20:52 | |
and in purchasing have flat, she
saved £150 per month. I thank the | 2:20:52 | 2:20:58 | |
honourable gentleman for that
statement and it is another | 2:20:58 | 2:21:00 | |
illustration of how important it is
for people to be able to purchase | 2:21:00 | 2:21:03 | |
their own homes. In response to the
honourable lady, I can go through | 2:21:03 | 2:21:08 | |
the list, abolishing stamp duty,
investing an additional 15 billion | 2:21:08 | 2:21:15 | |
for house building, taking £44
billion, the total, for this | 2:21:15 | 2:21:19 | |
parliament, it is the other measures
along with stamp duty. People can't | 2:21:19 | 2:21:23 | |
own their own homes, though, if
there are not people to build those | 2:21:23 | 2:21:27 | |
homes. I welcome the review into
looking at, just in London alone, | 2:21:27 | 2:21:34 | |
the 270,000 planning permissions, I
welcome the review into looking at | 2:21:34 | 2:21:36 | |
why those homes have not been built.
It is not just in London but in my | 2:21:36 | 2:21:41 | |
constituency and all across the
country. Measures have been put in | 2:21:41 | 2:21:44 | |
place to help councils build more,
it is vitally important we have more | 2:21:44 | 2:21:48 | |
council homes, authorities need to
be able to have the powers and | 2:21:48 | 2:21:51 | |
ability to do that. We need those
targets, Brown, urban sites, | 2:21:51 | 2:21:56 | |
brownfield sites which have laid
dormant. We all know the areas | 2:21:56 | 2:22:04 | |
around Heathrow and those areas in
outer London. People work in London | 2:22:04 | 2:22:07 | |
and they want to live in London and
be able to afford to buy in London, | 2:22:07 | 2:22:10 | |
not have to travel two hours commute
into London to be able to work. I | 2:22:10 | 2:22:13 | |
believe all this is being looked at
which will enable so many young | 2:22:13 | 2:22:16 | |
people in this capital, who want to
be able to buy their home and simply | 2:22:16 | 2:22:20 | |
have not been able to do so but not
just in the capital, in my | 2:22:20 | 2:22:24 | |
constituency in mid-Bedfordshire.
One of the complaints I hear more | 2:22:24 | 2:22:28 | |
often than any other in my mailbox
is young people who want to stay and | 2:22:28 | 2:22:32 | |
live in mid-Bedfordshire and buy
their home in mid-Bedfordshire but | 2:22:32 | 2:22:35 | |
simply are unable to do so and are
forced out. You know, not everybody | 2:22:35 | 2:22:40 | |
in my constituency will work on my
words that I want to see more | 2:22:40 | 2:22:44 | |
house-building but I absolutely do
because we have to accept now is the | 2:22:44 | 2:22:47 | |
time, when we have got to the
position where we need to build more | 2:22:47 | 2:22:52 | |
homes and I have been distressed for
the last 12 years that the entire | 2:22:52 | 2:22:56 | |
time I have been here, there has
been little emphasis on the need, on | 2:22:56 | 2:23:00 | |
the understanding, of the psyche of
people and the desire people have to | 2:23:00 | 2:23:05 | |
live in their own homes and to
purchase their own homes. I am | 2:23:05 | 2:23:09 | |
delighted today, relieved that that
is finally being addressed. I think | 2:23:09 | 2:23:15 | |
I would like to finish, Mr Deputy
Speaker, by saying that the | 2:23:15 | 2:23:20 | |
Chancellor also mentioned in his
speech today, in the budget | 2:23:20 | 2:23:25 | |
resolution, the East-West Ark, the
Varsity arc, the Cambridge to Oxford | 2:23:25 | 2:23:29 | |
arc which is going to have road and
rail investment. That will go right | 2:23:29 | 2:23:34 | |
past my constituency in
mid-Bedfordshire. I am delighted | 2:23:34 | 2:23:39 | |
that it will bring high-tech jobs,
it will build skills and | 2:23:39 | 2:23:42 | |
infrastructure and will drive growth
forward. As the Chancellor said, | 2:23:42 | 2:23:45 | |
that is going to be embracing
innovation, embracing the future and | 2:23:45 | 2:23:50 | |
change, it is what we are going to
need in a post-Brexit Britain. We | 2:23:50 | 2:23:55 | |
need those high-tech jobs. We need
those gross corridors as winners in | 2:23:55 | 2:23:59 | |
the Midlands, the West and East Link
has been needed for so long but | 2:23:59 | 2:24:03 | |
never been addressed. It is vital
and important and it is essential | 2:24:03 | 2:24:07 | |
for post-Brexit growth, when I think
we are going to become an island of | 2:24:07 | 2:24:14 | |
opportunity, an island of
development, an island of investment | 2:24:14 | 2:24:16 | |
and growth and the announcements
that have been made today, as well | 2:24:16 | 2:24:21 | |
as the financial measures put in for
Brexit and the preparation for | 2:24:21 | 2:24:24 | |
Brexit, I think we are going to be
ready to embrace that post-Brexit | 2:24:24 | 2:24:29 | |
world, with the East-West corridor,
the Midlands grows, the Northern | 2:24:29 | 2:24:32 | |
Powerhouse and all the other
measures that have been mentioned | 2:24:32 | 2:24:35 | |
today which I wholly welcome. | 2:24:35 | 2:24:37 | |
It is a privilege to follow the
honourable lady for Mid | 2:24:41 | 2:24:47 | |
Bedfordshire. A fear the budget
today delivers more of the say and | 2:24:47 | 2:24:50 | |
does very little to help people in
the every day economy struggling to | 2:24:50 | 2:24:53 | |
get by, to get a foot on the housing
ladder, to grow their business or to | 2:24:53 | 2:24:58 | |
get security in work. I'm going to
focus on two particular aspects of | 2:24:58 | 2:25:03 | |
budget in my remarks. First that
will be on GDP and productivity and | 2:25:03 | 2:25:09 | |
secondly, as the honourable lady for
mid-Behred Ford shire, on the issue | 2:25:09 | 2:25:14 | |
of housing supply and house prices.
First of all on GDP and | 2:25:14 | 2:25:21 | |
productivity, the biggest influence
on our standard of living, whether | 2:25:21 | 2:25:24 | |
we can afford to pay the bills. How
we're doing. Whether our families | 2:25:24 | 2:25:28 | |
can get on and do better than the
generation before is how fast the | 2:25:28 | 2:25:33 | |
economy's growing. From that most
important metric, I think, today, we | 2:25:33 | 2:25:38 | |
can only regard the budget as a
failure in Government economic | 2:25:38 | 2:25:41 | |
policy. In every single year of the
forecast period, economic growth's | 2:25:41 | 2:25:48 | |
revised downwards. That is not from
particularly high levels in the | 2:25:48 | 2:25:51 | |
first place. But this is a further
downward revision since just March | 2:25:51 | 2:25:55 | |
of this year. I think that is very
worrying for many families all | 2:25:55 | 2:26:00 | |
across our country in all of cower
constituencies. By 2022, believe GDP | 2:26:00 | 2:26:10 | |
will be 7% low enthan it was
predicted in March. About 80% of | 2:26:10 | 2:26:15 | |
that downgrade in the level of our
GDP is because of lower productivity | 2:26:15 | 2:26:22 | |
in that period. It is expected to be
27% lower than it would have been if | 2:26:22 | 2:26:27 | |
it had carried on growing at its
pre-crisis levels. This is | 2:26:27 | 2:26:31 | |
incredibly worrying. If we are going
to compete with countries all around | 2:26:31 | 2:26:35 | |
the world outside of the European
Union we need to boost our product | 2:26:35 | 2:26:41 | |
specificity, research, development,
business investment, investment in | 2:26:41 | 2:26:45 | |
infrastructure and all the numbers
from budget of responsibility today | 2:26:45 | 2:26:50 | |
suggest we're doing the opposite.
Going in the wrong direction in | 2:26:50 | 2:26:54 | |
those most important economic
numbers on GDP and on productivity. | 2:26:54 | 2:26:58 | |
We are already, as you know, 20%
behind the United States, Japan and | 2:26:58 | 2:27:06 | |
ge any Germany in terms of
productivity. We cannot afford to | 2:27:06 | 2:27:11 | |
have further downgrades in
productivity. They have a real | 2:27:11 | 2:27:15 | |
effect on Government borrowing and
Government debt. Over the forecast | 2:27:15 | 2:27:18 | |
period, over the next five years,
this downgrade to productivity adds | 2:27:18 | 2:27:25 | |
a staggering £90 billion to our
borrowing trajectory. Worrying for | 2:27:25 | 2:27:30 | |
standards of living but in terms of
the public finances. We are not able | 2:27:30 | 2:27:33 | |
to put the money we need into
Universal Credit, infrastructure, | 2:27:33 | 2:27:40 | |
National Health Service, our schools
because we are not delivering on | 2:27:40 | 2:27:44 | |
those productive, well paid jobs.
The Government have to take | 2:27:44 | 2:27:48 | |
responsibility for that. I look
forward to the industrial strategy | 2:27:48 | 2:27:53 | |
White Paper being published next
week. But I have to say to the | 2:27:53 | 2:27:57 | |
Government, it has to be a lot
better than the Green Paper we saw | 2:27:57 | 2:28:02 | |
alar this year which was incredibly
disappointing and simply won't | 2:28:02 | 2:28:05 | |
deliver the types of prod you can
I've tiffity and performance we | 2:28:05 | 2:28:08 | |
need. It is 18 months since the
Government's productivity strategy. | 2:28:08 | 2:28:12 | |
Since then, every estimate of
productivity has been downwards and | 2:28:12 | 2:28:16 | |
not upwards. What a failed
opportunity and what a failed | 2:28:16 | 2:28:19 | |
strategy. I will give way. She's
making in extremely powerful speech. | 2:28:19 | 2:28:26 | |
Will she agree prod you can tiff I
will never increase while we exclude | 2:28:26 | 2:28:30 | |
important parts of society. The
industrial strategy didn't mention | 2:28:30 | 2:28:35 | |
disabled people neither did the
Chancellor today. The budget is | 2:28:35 | 2:28:38 | |
simply not inclusive. That That is a
very good point. To ensure everybody | 2:28:38 | 2:28:44 | |
benefits from a growing economy,
we've just about got growth but not | 2:28:44 | 2:28:47 | |
very much of it, to ensure everyone
benefits, we need to have an | 2:28:47 | 2:28:52 | |
incluesive economy and economic
strategy that works for everybody in | 2:28:52 | 2:28:54 | |
all of our communities. The
Government might respond by saying | 2:28:54 | 2:29:00 | |
it's OK, Labour members, there's a
productivity investment fund worth | 2:29:00 | 2:29:04 | |
£7 billion. But the money doesn't
start until 2022/23. Five years we | 2:29:04 | 2:29:10 | |
have to wait for a productivity
investment fund. Why is that? We all | 2:29:10 | 2:29:16 | |
recognise there is a desperate need
to improve productivity why wait | 2:29:16 | 2:29:20 | |
five years before we put money and
support into doing that? I thought | 2:29:20 | 2:29:23 | |
that would have been an urgent
priority at this budget not | 2:29:23 | 2:29:26 | |
something that can be kicked down
the road and we put into place in | 2:29:26 | 2:29:32 | |
five years' time. I want to come to
the issue of housing. I'm afraid I'm | 2:29:32 | 2:29:37 | |
much less optimistic about the
Government's plans today compared | 2:29:37 | 2:29:42 | |
with the honourable member for Mid
Bedfordshire. Over the last hour or | 2:29:42 | 2:29:48 | |
so, I've been looking at the Office
for Budget Responsibility's economic | 2:29:48 | 2:29:53 | |
and fiscal outlook. The truth is, if
you read this, I know not everybody | 2:29:53 | 2:29:57 | |
likes to listen to experts, I'm one
of those people who still thinks | 2:29:57 | 2:30:01 | |
they are worth listening to. If you
believe what the experts at the | 2:30:01 | 2:30:09 | |
office Office for Budget
Responsibility are saying, they say, | 2:30:09 | 2:30:12 | |
the measures taken in totality, not
just the stamp duty measure but the | 2:30:12 | 2:30:15 | |
whole lot of measures on housing in
this budget will increase house | 2:30:15 | 2:30:21 | |
prices by 0.3% and there will be no
change in the supply of housing | 2:30:21 | 2:30:26 | |
compared with the budget in March.
So, despite all the fanfare today, | 2:30:26 | 2:30:31 | |
the verdict of the Office for Budget
Responsibility, on page 53 of their | 2:30:31 | 2:30:39 | |
document, says impact no change in
supply and an increase in house | 2:30:39 | 2:30:42 | |
prices. The opposite of what we need
if we want to ensure more young | 2:30:42 | 2:30:46 | |
people and families can get on the
housing ladder. Something we all | 2:30:46 | 2:30:51 | |
share as an objective but not set by
the measures today. I can understand | 2:30:51 | 2:30:57 | |
the honourable lady interpreting
that report and having concerns. For | 2:30:57 | 2:31:01 | |
an area like St Albans where the
average house price is over | 2:31:01 | 2:31:06 | |
£500,000, the previous Chancellor
helped young people on to the ladder | 2:31:06 | 2:31:09 | |
and this Chancellor will help them
save money towards house prices. It | 2:31:09 | 2:31:13 | |
will be welcomed by many high house
price areas. Surely she must accept | 2:31:13 | 2:31:18 | |
the stamp duty is a welcome measure.
I'm not making my own forecast, it | 2:31:18 | 2:31:23 | |
is from the Office for Budget
Responsibility. What people in St | 2:31:23 | 2:31:29 | |
Albans, Mid Bedfordshire and Leeds
West is affordable housing, to be | 2:31:29 | 2:31:32 | |
able to get on to the housing
ladder. For that, we need stable | 2:31:32 | 2:31:39 | |
house prices and an increase in
supply. But there will be no | 2:31:39 | 2:31:43 | |
improvement in housing supply on the
basis of the measures today and that | 2:31:43 | 2:31:47 | |
also house prices will be 0.3%
higher than they would otherwise | 2:31:47 | 2:31:51 | |
have been. So, it's not going to
have the desired effect. I | 2:31:51 | 2:31:56 | |
understand the honourable lady wants
her constituents to get those | 2:31:56 | 2:32:02 | |
opportunities. The measures her
Chancellor's taken today doesn't | 2:32:02 | 2:32:05 | |
sound like it will achieve. In fact,
I would say it will have the | 2:32:05 | 2:32:10 | |
opposite affect. I'll make a little
more progress. In a north box they | 2:32:10 | 2:32:21 | |
say on the basis of their analysis,
post the changes to stamp duty, the | 2:32:21 | 2:32:27 | |
prices paid by first time buyers
would be higher with the relief than | 2:32:27 | 2:32:31 | |
without it. And thus, they argue,
the main gainers from the policy on | 2:32:31 | 2:32:36 | |
stamp duty today are people who
already own their property not the | 2:32:36 | 2:32:40 | |
first time buyers themselves. I
would say, I think that's a terrible | 2:32:40 | 2:32:45 | |
indictment of the policies on
housing. If that was supposed to be | 2:32:45 | 2:32:50 | |
the fanfare of the budget today, I'm
afraid it ends up a bit of a damp | 2:32:50 | 2:32:54 | |
squib. I'll give way to my
honourable friend. Doesn't my | 2:32:54 | 2:33:02 | |
honourable friend think it is absurd
to have a stamp duty limit for first | 2:33:02 | 2:33:07 | |
time buyers of 500,000 which implies
an income of £150,000. If you look | 2:33:07 | 2:33:16 | |
at the earnings forecast, it is
another impediment for people | 2:33:16 | 2:33:19 | |
getting on the housing ladder. You
need incomes keeping pace with the | 2:33:19 | 2:33:24 | |
rising cost of living and house
prices and forecast for average | 2:33:24 | 2:33:28 | |
earnings suggest it will be harder
still for many people to get on the | 2:33:28 | 2:33:30 | |
housing ladder. I'll take a short
intervention. Would she accept and | 2:33:30 | 2:33:37 | |
agree with me an injection of
300,000 homes per year, if that | 2:33:37 | 2:33:42 | |
target's reached will have an affect
of stabilising the price of homes at | 2:33:42 | 2:33:47 | |
the very least because the supply
will be increased in a way it's | 2:33:47 | 2:33:51 | |
never been since the 1970s? Isle
I'll say this argument is not with | 2:33:51 | 2:33:57 | |
me, it is for the budge the of
responsibility. They say these | 2:33:57 | 2:34:02 | |
measures will benefit existing house
owners rather than those trying to | 2:34:02 | 2:34:05 | |
get on the housing leaded ladder.
That's disappointing. The additional | 2:34:05 | 2:34:10 | |
300,000 homes a year is like the
productivity investment fund. They | 2:34:10 | 2:34:13 | |
are not set to be delivered until
the mid-2020s. The honourable lady | 2:34:13 | 2:34:19 | |
and all honourable members across
the house will recognise we need to | 2:34:19 | 2:34:22 | |
be building the houses now. We don't
have seven or eight years to wait. | 2:34:22 | 2:34:28 | |
People need those homes today. I
will finish my speech with a couple | 2:34:28 | 2:34:34 | |
of remarks about Europe. The truth
is, the biggest economic | 2:34:34 | 2:34:41 | |
announcements, really, for the rest
of this year will be the decisions | 2:34:41 | 2:34:44 | |
made in the middle of December about
whether or not to move the talks on | 2:34:44 | 2:34:48 | |
between the European Commission and
the UK Government on to trade and | 2:34:48 | 2:34:54 | |
the final agreement between the UK
and EU about future trading | 2:34:54 | 2:34:59 | |
relationships. While the Chancellor
makes these announcements today, the | 2:34:59 | 2:35:05 | |
most important announces for our
constituents will be made in just a | 2:35:05 | 2:35:09 | |
fee weeks' time. I would urge the
Government in that time to reflect | 2:35:09 | 2:35:12 | |
on some of the evidence heard by my
select committee in the last couple | 2:35:12 | 2:35:16 | |
of weeks. Honda gave evidence to our
select committee saying the cost of | 2:35:16 | 2:35:21 | |
exporting a car would be about
£1,800 more than it is today. That | 2:35:21 | 2:35:28 | |
amount far outweighs their profit
margins risking investment and jobs | 2:35:28 | 2:35:31 | |
in this country. We also heard
evidence from Aston Martin who said | 2:35:31 | 2:35:37 | |
if they cannot get their vehicles
certificated by the agency in this | 2:35:37 | 2:35:42 | |
country they'd have to stop
production whilst they seek that | 2:35:42 | 2:35:46 | |
authorisation from the European
Union. Yesterday, we took evidence | 2:35:46 | 2:35:50 | |
from the Aerospace sector from
Airbus. Airbus said there are | 2:35:50 | 2:35:53 | |
country knocking on their doors
asking to build the wings of | 2:35:53 | 2:35:57 | |
aeroplanes in their country. The
risks of friction in trade will have | 2:35:57 | 2:36:03 | |
very real implications for their
businesses and very many others. I | 2:36:03 | 2:36:06 | |
would just end by urging the
Government, in the next fee walks, | 2:36:06 | 2:36:11 | |
to do everything -- weeks, to do
everything they can to move talks on | 2:36:11 | 2:36:15 | |
to the next level in Europe. If they
don't issues about prod you can I've | 2:36:15 | 2:36:21 | |
tiffity, housing, earnings, will be
pretty meaningless if those jobs | 2:36:21 | 2:36:26 | |
move overseas and we can't have that
free trade and frictionless trade we | 2:36:26 | 2:36:33 | |
benefit so much from today. I remind
the House of the business interests | 2:36:33 | 2:36:38 | |
I declared in the register. A few
weeks Alling, I strongly criticised | 2:36:38 | 2:36:43 | |
for some for daring to say we wanted
realistically optimistic forecasts. | 2:36:43 | 2:36:49 | |
I'm delighted the latest set of
official forecasts are more | 2:36:49 | 2:36:53 | |
realistically optimistic than the
forecasts immediately after the | 2:36:53 | 2:36:56 | |
referendum vote. We were told we'd
plunge into recession, the British | 2:36:56 | 2:37:01 | |
economy would be badly damaged. I
thought that was completely wrong at | 2:37:01 | 2:37:05 | |
the time, I'm pleased to have been
on the winning side. It is welcome | 2:37:05 | 2:37:09 | |
today to see a more realistic set of
forecasts. I think they're still a | 2:37:09 | 2:37:14 | |
tad pessimistic for next year and
the year after but are broadly in | 2:37:14 | 2:37:18 | |
the right direction. The reason
they've been downgraded in the way | 2:37:18 | 2:37:22 | |
some on the Labour side are
objecting, is the OBR now doesn't | 2:37:22 | 2:37:26 | |
think we can get back the rate of
productivity growth we had before | 2:37:26 | 2:37:30 | |
the crash because the rate of
productivity growth has been very | 2:37:30 | 2:37:33 | |
disappointed around the world. I now
find I'm facing extremely distorted | 2:37:33 | 2:37:39 | |
interpretations of something I wrote
more recently. I would like to | 2:37:39 | 2:37:44 | |
absolutely sure the House then, as
now, I'm extremely confident about | 2:37:44 | 2:37:48 | |
the prospects for the British
economy. There's been a lot of | 2:37:48 | 2:37:53 | |
inward investment into the UK
economy. Those inward involvement | 2:37:53 | 2:37:56 | |
people are very wise. I think the
UK's a great place for people who | 2:37:56 | 2:38:00 | |
want to set up a factory, expand a
business, take on commercial space, | 2:38:00 | 2:38:06 | |
hire a good workforce. I see they
think it is ridiculous. That Haas | 2:38:06 | 2:38:10 | |
always been my view. Anyone who
suggests that is not my view is | 2:38:10 | 2:38:14 | |
making it up. I would like to get
that very firmly on the record. They | 2:38:14 | 2:38:19 | |
should read the whole article and
understand the point I was making | 2:38:19 | 2:38:23 | |
but clearly they weren't able to.
Can we get productivity up? The | 2:38:23 | 2:38:28 | |
Chancellor's made some very good
proposals in his budget. But it will | 2:38:28 | 2:38:32 | |
take time. What it really comes down
to is education, mentoring, | 2:38:32 | 2:38:37 | |
training, it is about taking our
economy on that next part of the | 2:38:37 | 2:38:40 | |
journey. The recovery since the
crash of 2009 has been gradual but | 2:38:40 | 2:38:47 | |
progressive. The Government rightly
takes pride in the success that many | 2:38:47 | 2:38:51 | |
British businesses and people to
generate three million extra jobs | 2:38:51 | 2:38:55 | |
and get many more people into work.
The next part of the journey is to | 2:38:55 | 2:38:59 | |
try and get people into better paid
work. That is about the Government | 2:38:59 | 2:39:04 | |
and the FE colleges and the
universities and schools working | 2:39:04 | 2:39:07 | |
with young people and with people
already in work on training | 2:39:07 | 2:39:11 | |
programmes so they get the extra
skills they can adapt and improve. | 2:39:11 | 2:39:14 | |
It is easier to get a better paid
job from a job than to get one from | 2:39:14 | 2:39:19 | |
unemployment. | 2:39:19 | 2:39:26 | |
And also building on the
apprenticeship scheme which has been | 2:39:26 | 2:39:32 | |
doing such a good job in getting
young people forward on a different | 2:39:32 | 2:39:35 | |
route. Yes, indeed and I hope the
public sector will take this on | 2:39:35 | 2:39:40 | |
board as well as the private sector.
We are going to face a very major | 2:39:40 | 2:39:55 | |
revolution, as the Chancellor has
been indicating, from robots, | 2:39:55 | 2:40:00 | |
artificial intelligence, all kinds
of applications of the digital | 2:40:00 | 2:40:03 | |
economy. We see how great companies
are making huge changes and having a | 2:40:03 | 2:40:08 | |
big knock-on effect on more
traditional businesses. So, we need | 2:40:08 | 2:40:12 | |
to put all our weight behind a
government which wishes to | 2:40:12 | 2:40:16 | |
understand that revolution and to
try and make sure that more people | 2:40:16 | 2:40:19 | |
are winners from it, by changing
jobs | 2:40:19 | 2:40:22 | |
are winners from it, by changing
jobs, developing new skills, so that | 2:40:22 | 2:40:27 | |
their career can respond. Quite
rightly the attention in this budget | 2:40:27 | 2:40:32 | |
is on whether there will be enough
money to do a decent job for public | 2:40:32 | 2:40:36 | |
services. I also want to make sure
that my local schools have enough | 2:40:36 | 2:40:41 | |
money to pay good features and to
have enough teachers. And I want to | 2:40:41 | 2:40:46 | |
make sure that my local hospital and
surgeries have enough financial | 2:40:46 | 2:40:49 | |
support to do a good job. And I see
from this particular budget that | 2:40:49 | 2:40:55 | |
there is a £6 billion overall fiscal
relaxation in 2018-19 and £10 | 2:40:55 | 2:41:04 | |
billion the following year. I'm sure
from what the Chancellor said that | 2:41:04 | 2:41:08 | |
as some relaxation of the pay
agreements occurs, when we will see | 2:41:08 | 2:41:15 | |
money coming forward in order to
meet those bills. It is very | 2:41:15 | 2:41:19 | |
important that the Health Service
and schools have the money to be | 2:41:19 | 2:41:22 | |
able to meet those particular
requirements. I think a very modest | 2:41:22 | 2:41:28 | |
fiscal relaxation like that is
eminently affordable, I don't think | 2:41:28 | 2:41:31 | |
the current levels of debt or
deficit are alarming. I'm very | 2:41:31 | 2:41:35 | |
pleased to see the government thinks
the level of debt as a percentage of | 2:41:35 | 2:41:38 | |
GDP will be coming down very
shortly. But I think we also need to | 2:41:38 | 2:41:43 | |
take into account the fact that the
state owns quite a lot of the debt | 2:41:43 | 2:41:48 | |
itself now, which I think does make
a bit of a difference. And when we | 2:41:48 | 2:41:52 | |
look at what the United States of
America is doing, they are now | 2:41:52 | 2:41:55 | |
embarking on a programme of actually
cancelling and reducing debts, | 2:41:55 | 2:42:00 | |
because it controls both sides of
that balance sheet through the | 2:42:00 | 2:42:03 | |
Federal reserve board. I want to
concentrate a little more on | 2:42:03 | 2:42:07 | |
house-building and housing, because
I'm very pleased that the government | 2:42:07 | 2:42:12 | |
is going to have a speedy and I hope
some interesting and into the issue | 2:42:12 | 2:42:15 | |
of how existing learning permissions
can be better used and translated | 2:42:15 | 2:42:20 | |
into more homes more quickly. This
is a problem that is very much a big | 2:42:20 | 2:42:28 | |
issue in the Wokingham Borough part
of my constituency, where the | 2:42:28 | 2:42:31 | |
borough has issued around 11,000
planning permissions for individual | 2:42:31 | 2:42:37 | |
homes, more than enough you would
think to have a fast build rate, as | 2:42:37 | 2:42:43 | |
is required under the agreements in
the local plan is. But there has | 2:42:43 | 2:42:47 | |
been considerable delay in bringing
forward some of those houses. And | 2:42:47 | 2:42:51 | |
then there is a wish by others to
try and get planning permissions | 2:42:51 | 2:42:54 | |
elsewhere and build outside the
areas where the plan would prefer | 2:42:54 | 2:42:59 | |
the building to go. There is a lot
to be said for concentrating the | 2:42:59 | 2:43:03 | |
areas of building, because then the
monies can be applied to the | 2:43:03 | 2:43:07 | |
surgeries, the primary schools and
extra road capacity that is needed | 2:43:07 | 2:43:12 | |
in a planned and predictable way,
whereas if inspectors, because of a | 2:43:12 | 2:43:18 | |
slow build rate, grant permissions
in a variety of different places | 2:43:18 | 2:43:23 | |
around the borough, then we would
need far more capital to keep up | 2:43:23 | 2:43:26 | |
with the demands, because distance
becomes an issue for people getting | 2:43:26 | 2:43:30 | |
to those particular facilities.
Looking at the national feature on | 2:43:30 | 2:43:35 | |
house-building, I welcome the idea
that we should be able to have five | 2:43:35 | 2:43:40 | |
new garden cities. I think the
garden town movement was a very fine | 2:43:40 | 2:43:45 | |
one many years ago Edu there were
some great successes with new towns | 2:43:45 | 2:43:50 | |
and cities in our country. I am not
going to start choosing places where | 2:43:50 | 2:43:54 | |
they should go, because none of them
will be my constituency, because we | 2:43:54 | 2:43:59 | |
already have an awful lot of and
development going on. Can the | 2:43:59 | 2:44:05 | |
honourable member confirm that the
Chancellor never mentioned homes for | 2:44:05 | 2:44:11 | |
social went? Can he confirm that he
also never heard the Chancellor | 2:44:11 | 2:44:16 | |
mentioning homes for social went? I
think the honourable lady is wrong, | 2:44:16 | 2:44:21 | |
I think he did and I think it is
clearly part of the government's | 2:44:21 | 2:44:24 | |
plan. Homes for rent and homes for
purchase. But I would like to see | 2:44:24 | 2:44:30 | |
new settlements, where a suitable
location can be found and I am | 2:44:30 | 2:44:35 | |
pleased to hear that there is
already some agreement over the | 2:44:35 | 2:44:40 | |
university arc from Cambridge
through to Oxford via Milton Keynes, | 2:44:40 | 2:44:43 | |
where there are all sorts of
exciting opportunities. One of the | 2:44:43 | 2:44:47 | |
good things about the UK economy now
is the momentum that is clearly | 2:44:47 | 2:44:50 | |
gathering pace in technology,
investment and technology business | 2:44:50 | 2:44:55 | |
setup, and it's obviously easier to
do that close to great centres of | 2:44:55 | 2:45:01 | |
learning and where there is very
extremely good workforce to recruit, | 2:45:01 | 2:45:06 | |
who may well be some of the
entrepreneurs as well. So, I think | 2:45:06 | 2:45:10 | |
it is excellent that we reinforce
success and see that as a very major | 2:45:10 | 2:45:13 | |
part of the country. I agree with my
honourable friend who said that | 2:45:13 | 2:45:18 | |
within the housing issue, it is very
important to promote homeownership. | 2:45:18 | 2:45:25 | |
There is clearly a great yearning
for homeownership and I do think it | 2:45:25 | 2:45:31 | |
is one of the big social problems of
our day, that people under the age | 2:45:31 | 2:45:35 | |
of 35 in many cases are unable to
afford a first home, and I welcome | 2:45:35 | 2:45:39 | |
anything that would make the gap a
bit more Bridget. | 2:45:39 | 2:45:53 | |
-- a bit more Bridget will. In my
fast and remote constituency, | 2:45:58 | 2:46:02 | |
first-time buyers welcomed abolition
of stamped duty. Will here agree | 2:46:02 | 2:46:06 | |
with his colleague who has now left
the Chamber that it would be high | 2:46:06 | 2:46:10 | |
time that the Scottish Government
followed suit and abolished the same | 2:46:10 | 2:46:13 | |
stamp duty, because we don't want to
marry inequality disadvantage in | 2:46:13 | 2:46:17 | |
Scots. That is fine by me, I have no
problem with that but nor do I have | 2:46:17 | 2:46:24 | |
any constituency interest in it. It
is interesting how the SNP have not | 2:46:24 | 2:46:28 | |
staged to follow that through. There
is one! But yes, it is a sensible | 2:46:28 | 2:46:41 | |
proposal and I think it is very
welcome. Those who say that allowing | 2:46:41 | 2:46:45 | |
some remission of stamp duty right
up to 500,000 is unrealistic, I | 2:46:45 | 2:46:50 | |
think the earnings multiples now
being applied are rather greater | 2:46:50 | 2:46:53 | |
than the one the honourable lady was
suggesting. And I do think some | 2:46:53 | 2:46:57 | |
relief for people struggling to buy
in London is as necessary as | 2:46:57 | 2:47:01 | |
elsewhere in the country, and you do
need to take into account the much | 2:47:01 | 2:47:05 | |
higher prices in London. In summary,
I welcome the new forecast. I think | 2:47:05 | 2:47:18 | |
the UK is a great place to invest
in, I think the growth should fairly | 2:47:18 | 2:47:22 | |
steady from here, the productivity
plans need rolling out and | 2:47:22 | 2:47:27 | |
developing much more. It's going to
have to be done, because they are | 2:47:27 | 2:47:33 | |
about influencing behaviour and
opportunity in thousands of | 2:47:33 | 2:47:35 | |
companies around the country, and
working with the educational and | 2:47:35 | 2:47:38 | |
training establishments to achieve
what we need to bring about. And it | 2:47:38 | 2:47:44 | |
is above all I think about
government being open and conscious | 2:47:44 | 2:47:47 | |
of the need for it to adapt itself
very quickly to the huge changes | 2:47:47 | 2:47:54 | |
that technology is producing. I
would welcome experiments within the | 2:47:54 | 2:47:56 | |
public sector on how we can greatly
improve public sector productivity. | 2:47:56 | 2:48:04 | |
And in a positive way, by wanting to
ensure that people keep their jobs, | 2:48:04 | 2:48:10 | |
the but the jobs are enriched and
more rewarding, and I think it would | 2:48:10 | 2:48:14 | |
be really good to have some
pioneering examples in parts of the | 2:48:14 | 2:48:19 | |
public sector, and if the public
sector is good at it, when it might | 2:48:19 | 2:48:23 | |
be demonstrated to the private
sector. I wish the government every | 2:48:23 | 2:48:27 | |
success with this. The House has
wanted to be in a very fractious | 2:48:27 | 2:48:36 | |
mood today but we live in hope that
in due course people will see that | 2:48:36 | 2:48:39 | |
this country is on a very exciting
journey and that joint work to crack | 2:48:39 | 2:48:44 | |
the productivity problem would be
very welcome. It is a pleasure to | 2:48:44 | 2:48:49 | |
follow the member for working. The
OBR forecast which was published | 2:48:49 | 2:48:53 | |
today has really demonstrated that
we're in a downgraded economy. -- | 2:48:53 | 2:49:00 | |
the member for Wokingham. Real wages
are down. Business investment is | 2:49:00 | 2:49:04 | |
down. Productivity is downgraded now
and far into the future. So, no | 2:49:04 | 2:49:09 | |
wonder, Madame Deputy Speaker, that
the growth is down from the | 2:49:09 | 2:49:14 | |
Chancellor's modest forecast in
March of this year. He's presented | 2:49:14 | 2:49:18 | |
news today of a slowing economy for
the next three years, an economy | 2:49:18 | 2:49:22 | |
which is forecast to be six to £5
billion smaller in 2020 from what | 2:49:22 | 2:49:28 | |
they expected only last year. Aside
from setting apart £3 billion to | 2:49:28 | 2:49:36 | |
plan for Brexit, which is more than
he gave to the NHS, he made no | 2:49:36 | 2:49:40 | |
mention of the £40 billion or so
divorce payment which is presumably | 2:49:40 | 2:49:46 | |
going to be agreed with the EU soon.
And he used head room and some | 2:49:46 | 2:49:52 | |
reclassification of housing
association debt to announce some | 2:49:52 | 2:49:57 | |
tinkering, but fundamentally, to use
a phrase, Madame Deputy Speaker, | 2:49:57 | 2:50:02 | |
nothing has changed with this
budget. It's a eighth, or austerity | 2:50:02 | 2:50:07 | |
budget in a row. And it's taking
place against a backdrop of an | 2:50:07 | 2:50:12 | |
economy in the doldrums. We were
told by George Osborne in his first | 2:50:12 | 2:50:18 | |
austerity budget that we all had to
make sacrifices to eliminate a | 2:50:18 | 2:50:23 | |
deficit caused by the global
financial crisis. Entirely | 2:50:23 | 2:50:28 | |
predictably, that five-year plan
failed. So, the pain was extended | 2:50:28 | 2:50:32 | |
for another five years. And now
we're told that the second five-year | 2:50:32 | 2:50:36 | |
plan has failed, too. And so this
Chancellor is extending it for | 2:50:36 | 2:50:40 | |
another five years, until 2025. That
is already a 10-year delay on what | 2:50:40 | 2:50:46 | |
was meant to be a five-year recovery
plan. It's 15 years of austerity, | 2:50:46 | 2:50:53 | |
cut after cut, pressure on public
services year in, year out which no | 2:50:53 | 2:50:59 | |
end in sight. And this austerity
policy has huge human cost, which we | 2:50:59 | 2:51:04 | |
on this side of the House siege
daily in our advice surgeries. | 2:51:04 | 2:51:09 | |
Homelessness and destitution on the
rise, food bank use soaring, a and | 2:51:09 | 2:51:14 | |
if its system failing most of those
who have to rely on it through no | 2:51:14 | 2:51:17 | |
fault of their own. Now, the
Conservative Party is enthralled to | 2:51:17 | 2:51:24 | |
a right-wing libertarian ideology.
They want to shrink the size of the | 2:51:24 | 2:51:28 | |
state as a deliberate political aim.
They want state expenditure to be as | 2:51:28 | 2:51:33 | |
low as a percentage of GDP as
possible, despite be increasing | 2:51:33 | 2:51:37 | |
demands of an ageing population and
the need to make our economy fit for | 2:51:37 | 2:51:42 | |
the future in rapidly changing
times. They expect people to sink or | 2:51:42 | 2:51:46 | |
swim, and they aren't that concerned
about providing them with any | 2:51:46 | 2:51:50 | |
lifeboats. They saw an
opportunity... Well, the right | 2:51:50 | 2:51:56 | |
honourable gentleman has just
spoken. He can go off and advise his | 2:51:56 | 2:52:01 | |
clients on investing their money
abroad. Madame Deputy Speaker, they | 2:52:01 | 2:52:05 | |
saw an opportunity to pursue this
minimal state agenda in the | 2:52:05 | 2:52:12 | |
aftermath of the global financial
crash, and they've done so at great | 2:52:12 | 2:52:16 | |
cost too many. They made a
deliberate choice that cuts to | 2:52:16 | 2:52:20 | |
public spending would bear 80% of
the cost of eliminating the deficit, | 2:52:20 | 2:52:24 | |
with only 20% being accounted for by
tax changes. And we now know that | 2:52:24 | 2:52:30 | |
these cuts have fallen
disproportionately on the most | 2:52:30 | 2:52:32 | |
vulnerable and least able to look
after themselves. The Chancellor's | 2:52:32 | 2:52:38 | |
predecessor liked to claim that we
were all in this together, but he | 2:52:38 | 2:52:41 | |
cut the top rate of tax for his
super-rich friends at the same time | 2:52:41 | 2:52:45 | |
as ensuring that public sector
workers what a decade of pay freezes | 2:52:45 | 2:52:50 | |
and falling living standards.
Meanwhile this government has | 2:52:50 | 2:52:54 | |
systematically reduced the social
safety net to tatters for some of | 2:52:54 | 2:52:57 | |
the most vulnerable people in our
society. By 2021 my local authority | 2:52:57 | 2:53:02 | |
in Wirral will have had its funding
cut by 40% since 2010. Efficiency | 2:53:02 | 2:53:09 | |
savings, Madame Deputy Speaker, are
not cover cuts on this scale, and it | 2:53:09 | 2:53:15 | |
is no surprise that this level of
cuts decimates council services such | 2:53:15 | 2:53:19 | |
as adult social care, which wasn't
mentioned in the budget for a second | 2:53:19 | 2:53:23 | |
time and has seen a 26% cut between
2011 and 2016. This means that | 2:53:23 | 2:53:32 | |
essential care for the elderly is
not available and people in dire | 2:53:32 | 2:53:36 | |
need are being left with little or
no help. In education cuts have led | 2:53:36 | 2:53:40 | |
to a loss of £149 per pupil and 29
teachers in Wallasey alone. Will and | 2:53:40 | 2:53:47 | |
Cheshire NHS is being told to cut £1
billion in the next five years. | 2:53:47 | 2:53:52 | |
Merseyside Fire Brigade used to have
40 fire engines to save lives check | 2:53:52 | 2:53:56 | |
if they now have 28. | 2:53:56 | 2:54:03 | |
I do welcome the VAT announcement
today for the Scottish fire rescue | 2:54:03 | 2:54:07 | |
and police service. But does my
honourable friend not agree with me | 2:54:07 | 2:54:13 | |
that the reinstatement of VAT
exemption is far too late and his | 2:54:13 | 2:54:18 | |
led for years and yeared of added
deduction in the fire and police | 2:54:18 | 2:54:22 | |
service? That's right. Merseyside
Police will have suffered cuts of | 2:54:22 | 2:54:28 | |
£183 million by 2021. 1,000 officers
and 700 support staff down. Little | 2:54:28 | 2:54:34 | |
wonder crime levels are now the
highest in a decade. I could go on | 2:54:34 | 2:54:40 | |
but I think you get the point.
Austerity has extracted a brutal | 2:54:40 | 2:54:45 | |
cost from the most vulnerable. This
budget takes place against a | 2:54:45 | 2:54:50 | |
backdrop of unparalleled uncertainty
and danger for our country. This is | 2:54:50 | 2:54:53 | |
a Government paralysed by its own
disagreements over Brexit. It is a | 2:54:53 | 2:54:57 | |
Government unable to resolve its own
internal contradictions around the | 2:54:57 | 2:55:02 | |
Cabinet table, let alone chart the
path to a successful conclusion of | 2:55:02 | 2:55:06 | |
the Article 50 negotiation in the
Brussels. We have a Prime Minister | 2:55:06 | 2:55:09 | |
who puts the interests of her party
above those of the country. And a | 2:55:09 | 2:55:15 | |
Tory Party, half of whom would
rather us crash out of the EU | 2:55:15 | 2:55:19 | |
without any deal than stay in a
moment longer. Go on! Does she not | 2:55:19 | 2:55:27 | |
acknowledge that preparing for no
deal is an essential ingredient of | 2:55:27 | 2:55:31 | |
securing a good deal. Has she ever
bought a second-hand car? Did she go | 2:55:31 | 2:55:36 | |
in and tell the salesman she had to
leave with a car and yet expect a | 2:55:36 | 2:55:39 | |
discount? I have to say, I would
certainly buy a second-hand car from | 2:55:39 | 2:55:45 | |
the honourable gentleman! The
Chancellor, who is regarded with the | 2:55:45 | 2:55:52 | |
utmost suspicion by the Brexit
extremists on his own side was | 2:55:52 | 2:55:55 | |
warned he had to produce a game
changer of a budget or his career | 2:55:55 | 2:55:59 | |
would be over. They want rid of him.
They don't think he's eurosceptic | 2:55:59 | 2:56:04 | |
enough. The Prime Minister's already
shown her faith in him by make can | 2:56:04 | 2:56:08 | |
him disappear for the entire length
of recent general election campaign. | 2:56:08 | 2:56:13 | |
After his outing on the Sunday
Politics show at the weekend when he | 2:56:13 | 2:56:16 | |
claimed no-one in Britain was
unemployed you can see what they're | 2:56:16 | 2:56:20 | |
worried about. No wonder he declined
to get in that driverless car they | 2:56:20 | 2:56:25 | |
were going to put him in for a
pre-budget hi-tech photo op. The | 2:56:25 | 2:56:30 | |
party opposite is responsible for
the slowest recovery from recession | 2:56:30 | 2:56:35 | |
since the Napoleonic War and the
largest squeeze on living standards | 2:56:35 | 2:56:39 | |
since Victorian times. Their
presiding over record levels of | 2:56:39 | 2:56:44 | |
wealth inequality. This is not a
record to be proud of. This budget | 2:56:44 | 2:56:49 | |
has done nothing to address these
abject and fundamental failures. | 2:56:49 | 2:56:55 | |
Since the crash, Gross Domestic
Product per head has increased by | 2:56:55 | 2:56:58 | |
2.4%. During the 19900 recession the
comparticle figure was 21%. Driven | 2:56:58 | 2:57:06 | |
by the significant decline in the
value of the pound in the referendum | 2:57:06 | 2:57:13 | |
vote inflation roseto 3% double the
rate in the eurozone and growth in | 2:57:13 | 2:57:18 | |
the UK is anaemic by our historic
trend. And as the off the BR said, | 2:57:18 | 2:57:24 | |
is on a downward path. Wages are
lower now than in 2010. The living | 2:57:24 | 2:57:30 | |
standard squeeze has returned as
prices are outstripping wage | 2:57:30 | 2:57:34 | |
increases once more. In the public
sector, there's been a decade of | 2:57:34 | 2:57:38 | |
falling wages which is causing real
hardship. The TUC calculated as a | 2:57:38 | 2:57:43 | |
result of the public sector pay
freeze paramedics and die Tests are | 2:57:43 | 2:57:50 | |
worse off. Firefighters are £2,900
lower down and Crown Prosecution | 2:57:50 | 2:57:57 | |
Service in our courts, 4,500 worse
off a year. Their polling shows 15% | 2:57:57 | 2:58:03 | |
of staff in our public services have
skipped meals to make ends meet. | 2:58:03 | 2:58:08 | |
Meanwhile, in Tory Britain, workers
are not only struggling with | 2:58:08 | 2:58:11 | |
stagnant or falling pay levels,
they're experiencing a huge increase | 2:58:11 | 2:58:15 | |
in job insecurity. One in ten of the
workforce, had an is 3.2 million | 2:58:15 | 2:58:21 | |
people, now face insecurity at work,
including 800,000 on zero hours | 2:58:21 | 2:58:28 | |
contracts, 760,000 on nonstandard
forms of temporary work, including | 2:58:28 | 2:58:32 | |
agency and casual work and 1.7
million who are in low paid | 2:58:32 | 2:58:37 | |
self-employment earning below the
Government's modest so-called living | 2:58:37 | 2:58:40 | |
wage. Little wonder that tax
receipts have fallen as employers | 2:58:40 | 2:58:47 | |
take advantage of tax structures
which innocent vies less secure | 2:58:47 | 2:58:51 | |
forms of employment. Little wonder
the Bank of England figures show | 2:58:51 | 2:58:58 | |
household levels of unsecured
consumer debt are rising at the | 2:58:58 | 2:59:01 | |
fastest rate since the global FM
crass. Up over 10% last year and now | 2:59:01 | 2:59:05 | |
higher than it was in 2008. The
budget had nothing in it to address | 2:59:05 | 2:59:11 | |
any of these important issues. There
are a few people who are doing | 2:59:11 | 2:59:15 | |
really well out of the current
system. Pay ratios between FTSE 100 | 2:59:15 | 2:59:21 | |
CEOs and the rest continue to wide
when. They're now paid at a | 2:59:21 | 2:59:26 | |
staggering 160 times more than the
average worker. This means they made | 2:59:26 | 2:59:30 | |
more money by the first Wednesday of
2017 than the average worker could | 2:59:30 | 2:59:36 | |
earn for working all year. 5% of
households now earn 40% of all the | 2:59:36 | 2:59:42 | |
wealth in Britain. Is this really
the kind of society we wish to | 2:59:42 | 2:59:46 | |
create? Boosting productivity is the
key to economic growth and pay | 2:59:46 | 2:59:51 | |
increases. Yet, in the last decade.
The UK's productivity performance | 2:59:51 | 2:59:56 | |
has the the worst of any G7 country.
Since 2010, the Government's failure | 2:59:56 | 3:00:02 | |
to invest in infrastructure and
skills has seen our productivity | 3:00:02 | 3:00:05 | |
flat line. We're 15% lower than the
G7 average. So bad has been this | 3:00:05 | 3:00:11 | |
Government's record on productivity
that the OBR's revised down its | 3:00:11 | 3:00:18 | |
assumptions on productivity growth.
We've the lowest levels of | 3:00:18 | 3:00:22 | |
investment in the G7 driven by the
the Government's failure to invest | 3:00:22 | 3:00:27 | |
in businesses. This is nowhere near
enough to retool our economy and | 3:00:27 | 3:00:31 | |
make it fit for the future. Yet,
addressing this problem must be at | 3:00:31 | 3:00:36 | |
the heart of any Government's
industrial strategy. This budget | 3:00:36 | 3:00:42 | |
might have been the time when the
Chancellor decided to tackle the | 3:00:42 | 3:00:47 | |
regional disparity in economic
performance. When he took the | 3:00:47 | 3:00:51 | |
opportunity to invest in our
infrastructure and skills base. When | 3:00:51 | 3:00:54 | |
he finally gave Britain the pay rise
it so badly needs. But he didn't. | 3:00:54 | 3:00:59 | |
This is a budget of missed
opportunities. Once more, nothing on | 3:00:59 | 3:01:04 | |
social care. A bits and pieces
budget that fails to rise to the | 3:01:04 | 3:01:10 | |
huge challenges that this country
faces. Thank you very much. I'm | 3:01:10 | 3:01:18 | |
pleased to follow the honourable
lady for Wallasey. But what her | 3:01:18 | 3:01:23 | |
speech showed is that the party
opposite has not learnt anything | 3:01:23 | 3:01:27 | |
about how to run a successful,
modern economy. The Chancellor in | 3:01:27 | 3:01:32 | |
his speech used the figure of the
party opposite increasing our | 3:01:32 | 3:01:38 | |
national debt by £500 billion. The
easiest thing in the world is to | 3:01:38 | 3:01:43 | |
spend more money and borrow more
money, which is precisely the | 3:01:43 | 3:01:48 | |
situation the party opposite left us
in 2010. That's why we've had to | 3:01:48 | 3:01:52 | |
have the austerity budgets we've had
in the last few years. Indeed, I | 3:01:52 | 3:01:55 | |
went to a lunch recently and I met
one of our major director of one of | 3:01:55 | 3:02:02 | |
our major banks, the party opposite
should listen to this. He said our | 3:02:02 | 3:02:05 | |
focus of attention has changed from
Brexit. We'll cope with whatever the | 3:02:05 | 3:02:10 | |
politicians dloe at us for Brexit.
Our focus of attention has changed | 3:02:10 | 3:02:15 | |
to political risk, the risk of a
Labour Government ruining this | 3:02:15 | 3:02:18 | |
economy. In contrast to that, what
we saw today was my right honourable | 3:02:18 | 3:02:24 | |
friend's budget. It was a prudent
budget, a fiscal loosening budget, | 3:02:24 | 3:02:30 | |
but, at the same time, we've been
able to stabilise our national debt, | 3:02:30 | 3:02:35 | |
put more money into our public
services, particularly into NH | 3:02:35 | 3:02:39 | |
skchlt and education. More moon into
infrastructure and deal with some of | 3:02:39 | 3:02:43 | |
the tax evasion. I'm particularly
pleased to see the PAC | 3:02:43 | 3:02:47 | |
recommendations on which I sit on
the PAC, the recommendations on VAT, | 3:02:47 | 3:02:53 | |
fraud, have been closed. I pay
tribute to my honourable friend for | 3:02:53 | 3:03:00 | |
their hard work on doing that. I'd
like to say something about housing. | 3:03:00 | 3:03:03 | |
The recent Government White Paper
said the UK needs to build 250,000 | 3:03:03 | 3:03:07 | |
new houses a year. It certainly
does. If in a high housing price | 3:03:07 | 3:03:13 | |
area like the Cotswolds, if you ask
any of our teachers or nurses where | 3:03:13 | 3:03:17 | |
they live, nine times out of ten,
they will not live in the cots | 3:03:17 | 3:03:22 | |
Wolds. Cotswolds. Anything that can
be done to produce housing for lower | 3:03:22 | 3:03:28 | |
paid people must be a good thing. In
my parliamentary division, the | 3:03:28 | 3:03:33 | |
difficulty is private builders will
not address that portion of the | 3:03:33 | 3:03:37 | |
market where the need is greatest.
The bottom and mid-market. Equally, | 3:03:37 | 3:03:41 | |
such is the increase in supply that
is required to drive down the price, | 3:03:41 | 3:03:47 | |
it's questionable as to whether it
would be in the interests of | 3:03:47 | 3:03:52 | |
independent builders to secure such
a reduction in price. The greatest | 3:03:52 | 3:04:00 | |
increase in the market was achieved
through building through the public | 3:04:00 | 3:04:03 | |
sector. Does he see that as a
possibility? I'm grateful for my | 3:04:03 | 3:04:09 | |
honourable friend's intervention.
The need to build more houses is | 3:04:09 | 3:04:14 | |
about providing houses for those
that can't afford to buy on the | 3:04:14 | 3:04:17 | |
housing ladder. There are lots of
way in the affordable housing | 3:04:17 | 3:04:20 | |
sectors to do that. Affordable rent
to buy, staircasing, that is what we | 3:04:20 | 3:04:26 | |
need to pay attention to. I want to
say something about the planning | 3:04:26 | 3:04:29 | |
system in a minute. The structure of
house ownership has changed in the | 3:04:29 | 3:04:33 | |
last ten years. There is a statistic
in the last ten years, the number of | 3:04:33 | 3:04:40 | |
under-45-year-olds who own their own
houses has dropped by a million. | 3:04:40 | 3:04:43 | |
That I think is something we need to
address. That ask why I find it | 3:04:43 | 3:04:48 | |
extraordinary the party opposite
should be carping about the very | 3:04:48 | 3:04:53 | |
welcome announcedments by the
Chancellor today on the stamp duty | 3:04:53 | 3:04:59 | |
exemption for first time buyers for
300,000 and 500,000 limit in London. | 3:04:59 | 3:05:05 | |
They carp about how it will increase
the market for first time buyers. | 3:05:05 | 3:05:09 | |
But a cut in stamp duty is likely to
excite any increase in the house | 3:05:09 | 3:05:14 | |
prices by that. I think we should
welcome that. I think we should | 3:05:14 | 3:05:19 | |
welcome the measures the Government
are introducing to build more | 3:05:19 | 3:05:23 | |
houses. The use of new town
development corporation. It was used | 3:05:23 | 3:05:28 | |
successfully by the Conservative
Government in the 1980s and created | 3:05:28 | 3:05:32 | |
whole new towns like Milton Keynes.
What it does is, it is a partnership | 3:05:32 | 3:05:38 | |
of the Government, local authorities
and of the private sector and the | 3:05:38 | 3:05:43 | |
social housing sector to build more
houses. It worked in the 1980s. We | 3:05:43 | 3:05:48 | |
should do it again and make sure
those new town corporations are able | 3:05:48 | 3:05:52 | |
to get access to Morland. I have a
suggestion of two ways on how to | 3:05:52 | 3:05:57 | |
alter the planning system. We need
to alter the planning system in the | 3:05:57 | 3:06:02 | |
material start system so when
builders get planning permission | 3:06:02 | 3:06:05 | |
always it should only be for three
years. It should have to build out a | 3:06:05 | 3:06:10 | |
site in its entirety for services.
That would stop house builders | 3:06:10 | 3:06:14 | |
sitting on land banking for an
unacceptable peered and stop the | 3:06:14 | 3:06:20 | |
current system where they use a
vacant site to gain planning | 3:06:20 | 3:06:25 | |
permissions on other sites they want
to get. That, I think I, would be an | 3:06:25 | 3:06:29 | |
important improvement. I'd like to
go on to talk about the Brexit deaf | 3:06:29 | 3:06:35 | |
others bill which the honourable
lady, to be fair, did touch on. This | 3:06:35 | 3:06:39 | |
is the biggest liability this
country faces for the next few | 3:06:39 | 3:06:42 | |
years. It has been rumoured that
we'll pay £38 billion which, of | 3:06:42 | 3:06:49 | |
course, includes obligations for
outstanding contribution, overseas | 3:06:49 | 3:06:56 | |
aid and decommissions liabilities.
But, effort nevertheless, in a | 3:06:56 | 3:07:02 | |
negotiation for a second-hand car,
you don't go in and pay an excessive | 3:07:02 | 3:07:06 | |
price. The clever negotiator pays
the right price. The minimum price | 3:07:06 | 3:07:11 | |
they can get away with. I think
that's what we should be doing with | 3:07:11 | 3:07:14 | |
the EU. To put this £38 billion into
perspective. It is isn't just £38 | 3:07:14 | 3:07:22 | |
billion, it is the additional two
years, an additional £8 billion a | 3:07:22 | 3:07:26 | |
year. An additional £16 billion, so
up to some £56 billion. It is more | 3:07:26 | 3:07:35 | |
than our entire transport budget and
almost as much as our entire defence | 3:07:35 | 3:07:39 | |
budget. This is what we've to think
about with these very large figures. | 3:07:39 | 3:07:44 | |
I contrast that with the fact in
1945, the USA loaned us £2.2 billion | 3:07:44 | 3:07:52 | |
as war rap arations, that's £87
billion adjusted in today's money. | 3:07:52 | 3:07:57 | |
It took us over 50 years to pay it
off. I hope, at the very least, | 3:07:57 | 3:08:01 | |
we'll do two things with this
payment if we actually agree to it | 3:08:01 | 3:08:05 | |
with the EU. One it is it should be
paid over a significant number of | 3:08:05 | 3:08:08 | |
years. And, secondly, it should be
linked to our ability to earn money | 3:08:08 | 3:08:15 | |
from it, trade deals and other deals
that will help us eastern it and | 3:08:15 | 3:08:18 | |
therefore pay it off. I'd like to go
on to technology. Technology is | 3:08:18 | 3:08:24 | |
really important. It's really
important to this country to remain | 3:08:24 | 3:08:30 | |
competitive with our foreign
competitors and our productivity is | 3:08:30 | 3:08:34 | |
to increase. We, thankfully in this
country, seen a huge growth in | 3:08:34 | 3:08:40 | |
digital innovation. However, we have
a shortfall of around 40,000 people | 3:08:40 | 3:08:45 | |
with the necessary stem skills to
meet the demands of our economy. I'm | 3:08:45 | 3:08:50 | |
delighted to learn now maths is our
most pop lair subject. I see my | 3:08:50 | 3:08:54 | |
honourable friend for higher
education is here. Maths is our most | 3:08:54 | 3:08:58 | |
popular subject in schools. I'm
delighted with the extra money | 3:08:58 | 3:09:06 | |
encouraging children to take maths
at A-level. That our national inflay | 3:09:06 | 3:09:11 | |
structure fund is rising from 23
billion to 33 million. And the R&D | 3:09:11 | 3:09:18 | |
to invest in more infrastructure
will be main taped. It was an | 3:09:18 | 3:09:23 | |
amazing figure the Chancellor
mentioned that every hour a new | 3:09:23 | 3:09:28 | |
hi-tech company is emerging. He
wants to up that to half an hour. | 3:09:28 | 3:09:35 | |
Finally, I'd like to talk about
education. | 3:09:35 | 3:09:45 | |
Funding for our primary and
secondary schools was to be | 3:09:45 | 3:09:48 | |
maintained so that every jar in this
country gets a budget which is | 3:09:48 | 3:09:51 | |
increasing in real terms every year
and also that every child in this | 3:09:51 | 3:09:56 | |
country, their budget in secondary
schools should move up to £4800. | 3:09:56 | 3:10:10 | |
And that announcement, an extra £1.3
billion in our manifesto and | 3:10:15 | 3:10:22 | |
committed to spending that money,
has made a difference in Cotswold | 3:10:22 | 3:10:26 | |
schools of £450,000. And that is a
really welcome boost. Finally, | 3:10:26 | 3:10:35 | |
Madame Deputy Speaker, I would just
like to talk about small businesses. | 3:10:35 | 3:10:38 | |
The Chancellor had some very, very
welcome announcements for small | 3:10:38 | 3:10:43 | |
businesses in the budget. There
after all 5.5 million small | 3:10:43 | 3:10:47 | |
businesses in this country, as
e-mail clear, they are the engine of | 3:10:47 | 3:10:53 | |
growth, jobs and growth, in this
country, and therefore we need to | 3:10:53 | 3:10:57 | |
make sure that they prosper. And I
welcome the fact that is contrary to | 3:10:57 | 3:11:02 | |
the leaks about the budget, which
thank goodness are often wrong, that | 3:11:02 | 3:11:06 | |
we're not going to reduce the VA
Taper showed, because that would not | 3:11:06 | 3:11:10 | |
only produce more bureaucracy for
small businesses, it would also | 3:11:10 | 3:11:13 | |
bring them within the business
digital threshold as well, which | 3:11:13 | 3:11:17 | |
would produce even more bureaucracy.
-- reduce the VAT threshold. On the | 3:11:17 | 3:11:27 | |
subject of bureaucracy for small
businesses, doesn't he agree that | 3:11:27 | 3:11:30 | |
one of the biggest generators of
bureaucracy is if new arrangements | 3:11:30 | 3:11:33 | |
are introduced in terms of customs?
As he knows, the Public Accounts | 3:11:33 | 3:11:41 | |
Committee have done a lot of work on
customs and I'm hopeful that with | 3:11:41 | 3:11:46 | |
new IT and with the new introduction
of the customs declaration service | 3:11:46 | 3:11:50 | |
replacing the existing IT service,
airing in mind that customs are | 3:11:50 | 3:11:54 | |
great to have a huge increase in the
number of VAT declarations when we | 3:11:54 | 3:11:59 | |
leave the EU, customs have a really
difficult job to police goods which | 3:11:59 | 3:12:04 | |
are wrongly coming into this
country. So I think customs really | 3:12:04 | 3:12:07 | |
need to take that into account. But
I've almost come to the end of what | 3:12:07 | 3:12:11 | |
I wanted to say. Bureaucracy for
small businesses, and it is | 3:12:11 | 3:12:15 | |
essential that we try and keep it
down and we try and help small | 3:12:15 | 3:12:20 | |
businesses wherever possible. I was
especially pleased, and I'm sure | 3:12:20 | 3:12:24 | |
businesses in the Cotswold will be
pleased to see that we're | 3:12:24 | 3:12:27 | |
maintaining the small business rate
relief. For small businesses often | 3:12:27 | 3:12:32 | |
with a premises, where they're
paying quite high rent and rates in | 3:12:32 | 3:12:37 | |
an area like the Cotswolds, rates
can become a real burden. Those who | 3:12:37 | 3:12:42 | |
have been able to be taken out of
the rates gambit altogether by this | 3:12:42 | 3:12:45 | |
will be glad to hear that they're
not going to be brought back into it | 3:12:45 | 3:12:49 | |
this coming year, which is what they
feared. Residents and businesses in | 3:12:49 | 3:12:55 | |
a large rural area like mine, the
Cotswolds, will be glad to see the | 3:12:55 | 3:12:59 | |
freeze on fuel duty for yet another
year. Incidentally I'm sure | 3:12:59 | 3:13:03 | |
individuals in the Cotswolds and
indeed the entire country, will be | 3:13:03 | 3:13:08 | |
really pleased to see the freeze on
wine and spirits and cider. I'm sure | 3:13:08 | 3:13:13 | |
that will be particularly welcome.
To sum up, I think this has been a | 3:13:13 | 3:13:18 | |
prudent budget, it is nothing more
than I would expect from my right | 3:13:18 | 3:13:21 | |
honourable friend. I think he is
doing the great job for this country | 3:13:21 | 3:13:25 | |
in terms of his economic
stewardship. I'm sure that our | 3:13:25 | 3:13:28 | |
economy will go from strength to
strength, our education we will get | 3:13:28 | 3:13:32 | |
better, we will have more high-tech
jobs, we will continue in to employ | 3:13:32 | 3:13:38 | |
a record number of jobs. And if the
party opposite had anything to cheer | 3:13:38 | 3:13:42 | |
about, it would surely be that we
are employing a record number of | 3:13:42 | 3:13:46 | |
people in this country. And I would
have thought they would be | 3:13:46 | 3:13:49 | |
particularly pleased with the
Chancellor's announcement that | 3:13:49 | 3:13:52 | |
poverty is reducing in this country,
and child poverty has reduced by | 3:13:52 | 3:13:56 | |
over a million in the last ten
years. That is what the Chancellor | 3:13:56 | 3:13:59 | |
said. I know the party opposite
would not like these figures, but | 3:13:59 | 3:14:06 | |
the fact is that this is what's
happening. Thank you, Madame Deputy | 3:14:06 | 3:14:09 | |
Speaker. Thank you, Madame Deputy
Speaker. It is a pleasure to follow | 3:14:09 | 3:14:15 | |
the honourable gentleman from the
Cotswolds. Here's a great | 3:14:15 | 3:14:20 | |
parliamentarian and serves with
distinction along with me on the | 3:14:20 | 3:14:23 | |
Public Accounts Committee. For those
of us who have been in this House | 3:14:23 | 3:14:27 | |
for a number of years, we feel it is
like groundhog day. We have seen it | 3:14:27 | 3:14:31 | |
all before. The difference in this
budget is that usually after a | 3:14:31 | 3:14:36 | |
general election, the Chancellor has
two dole out the medicine and the | 3:14:36 | 3:14:40 | |
British public ridge just voted the
government in, have to take it. The | 3:14:40 | 3:14:45 | |
difficulty this Chancellor faces is,
he has to please all people of all | 3:14:45 | 3:14:49 | |
persuasions. I've no doubt, when he
fetched to the media that he wanted | 3:14:49 | 3:14:54 | |
to reduce the VAT threshold for
businesses, he was put off when he | 3:14:54 | 3:14:58 | |
looked towards his Irish colleagues.
I'm sure the freeze did not come out | 3:14:58 | 3:15:03 | |
of economic prudence but political
this city. But I have to say, this | 3:15:03 | 3:15:08 | |
speech is no different to any that
we've heard before. It begins with a | 3:15:08 | 3:15:12 | |
number of lame jokes, which I'm
sorry, the Chancellor is no | 3:15:12 | 3:15:16 | |
comedian. Who did not see that joke
about cough sweets coming a mile | 3:15:16 | 3:15:23 | |
off? I'm sorry, but it's no laughing
matter. The elephant in the room for | 3:15:23 | 3:15:28 | |
this budget, and the previous one
has been Brexit. In the previous | 3:15:28 | 3:15:34 | |
budget, the Chancellor only
dedicated a few lines to China. This | 3:15:34 | 3:15:37 | |
is the most seminal moment in
post-war British history. We are | 3:15:37 | 3:15:42 | |
leaving the European Union. Now, the
Chancellor said early on in his | 3:15:42 | 3:15:48 | |
speech that the Prime Minister has
set out a clear vision. Well, I must | 3:15:48 | 3:15:51 | |
be the only one who does not know
what this vision looks like. | 3:15:51 | 3:15:58 | |
Actually, all we have seen is the
Chancellor saying they're putting £3 | 3:15:58 | 3:16:02 | |
billion towards any consequences of
what could happen in Brexit. Does he | 3:16:02 | 3:16:09 | |
not agree with me that in fact the
simplest thing that the Chancellor | 3:16:09 | 3:16:13 | |
could have done to support business
would have been to announce here at | 3:16:13 | 3:16:16 | |
the dispatch box that he's going to
keep the United Kingdom in the | 3:16:16 | 3:16:20 | |
single market and Customs union?
Well, at least I would have liked to | 3:16:20 | 3:16:24 | |
hear some sort of plan about the
single market and Customs union. And | 3:16:24 | 3:16:27 | |
I will say this, and I will divert
if you will allow me, Madame Deputy | 3:16:27 | 3:16:33 | |
Speaker, those of us who are
concerned about Brexit and about | 3:16:33 | 3:16:35 | |
getting the best possible deal, have
been attacked unfairly by opponents | 3:16:35 | 3:16:43 | |
as remote as, when simply we want to
get the best deal for this country | 3:16:43 | 3:16:46 | |
in Brexit. We see £3 billion put
aside for Brexit but we have heard | 3:16:46 | 3:16:53 | |
nothing from the Chancellor about
the £350 million a week for the NHS. | 3:16:53 | 3:17:00 | |
Perhaps the Chancellor wants to drag
the Foreign Secretary here to talk | 3:17:00 | 3:17:03 | |
about where that £350 million is.
Because I haven't seen it. And when | 3:17:03 | 3:17:08 | |
he's doing that perhaps he wants to
talk to the nurses. I give way. I'm | 3:17:08 | 3:17:12 | |
very grateful. Buttrick Minford has
worked out that if we move to free | 3:17:12 | 3:17:19 | |
trade, that £350 million WILL be
available for the NHS, but only | 3:17:19 | 3:17:23 | |
after we've left the European Union,
which hasn't happened yet. I respect | 3:17:23 | 3:17:28 | |
the honourable gentleman as a
parliamentarian but I believe he is | 3:17:28 | 3:17:31 | |
wrong on this. He knows that was a
false statement made by the Leave | 3:17:31 | 3:17:35 | |
side to try to con people into
voting that way. And he knows that. | 3:17:35 | 3:17:39 | |
And there is no point in standing by
that any more. But the one thing is, | 3:17:39 | 3:17:44 | |
we hear nothing about Brexit. All we
heard is, this is not going to be a | 3:17:44 | 3:17:48 | |
budget of unaided by Brexit. Well,
I'm afraid the Chancellor is wrong. | 3:17:48 | 3:17:52 | |
Every budget from here on in will be
dominated by the consequences of | 3:17:52 | 3:17:56 | |
leaving the European Union. And so
the budget went on and on and on. We | 3:17:56 | 3:18:03 | |
heard terms which the Tories would
love - a strong government, we will | 3:18:03 | 3:18:07 | |
be resolute in our determination to
bring about a strong economy... But | 3:18:07 | 3:18:13 | |
it took eight pages before we got to
the real story of this budget. Quite | 3:18:13 | 3:18:16 | |
simply, productivity growth is down,
and it has continued to fall. This | 3:18:16 | 3:18:22 | |
is the first Chancellor who has
stood before that dispatch box and | 3:18:22 | 3:18:26 | |
has said that growth will be below
2% since World War II. That's | 3:18:26 | 3:18:31 | |
something they should be proud of.
It gets worse. 1.5% in 2017, 1.4% | 3:18:31 | 3:18:38 | |
the year after and 1.3% in the next
two years, and hopefully picking up | 3:18:38 | 3:18:47 | |
to 1.5% and finally 1.6% in 2022. At
the same point, debt will be at its | 3:18:47 | 3:18:54 | |
highest level ever. And right the
government is being overoptimistic. | 3:18:54 | 3:19:00 | |
And if we're not going to talk about
Brexit, at least talk about the | 3:19:00 | 3:19:05 | |
fundamental weakness in our economy.
It is productivity. Productivity has | 3:19:05 | 3:19:09 | |
failed to return to pre-crash
levels, and it doesn't look like | 3:19:09 | 3:19:14 | |
it's going to happen any time soon.
The OBR has revised its estimates of | 3:19:14 | 3:19:20 | |
long-term productivity and economic
growth. They say it means the | 3:19:20 | 3:19:23 | |
economy will not bounce back from
the financial crisis and output per | 3:19:23 | 3:19:27 | |
worker probably will not recover to
its pre-rices rate of 2.1%. The | 3:19:27 | 3:19:33 | |
productivity prices will mean larger
budget deficits in future years and | 3:19:33 | 3:19:38 | |
depressed earnings, which will mean
future tax revenues will take a | 3:19:38 | 3:19:41 | |
serious long-term hit. The downgrade
creates a £20 billion black hole in | 3:19:41 | 3:19:48 | |
the UK's public finances according
to the Institute for Fiscal Studies. | 3:19:48 | 3:19:54 | |
We cannot hide this problem any
more. Now, if the government wasn't | 3:19:54 | 3:19:59 | |
so timid and scared of its friends
from Ireland, I'm sure we would need | 3:19:59 | 3:20:04 | |
radical solutions. Things have not
worked, we can all go on all the | 3:20:04 | 3:20:09 | |
time with this rhetoric that things
are going to improve. We have to | 3:20:09 | 3:20:13 | |
take action, and that action must be
taken now. For me, the most | 3:20:13 | 3:20:17 | |
fundamental error that this
government has made since it came | 3:20:17 | 3:20:20 | |
into power is its failure to get to
grips with the banking system. We | 3:20:20 | 3:20:28 | |
need to boost business investment
through a network of regional banks. | 3:20:28 | 3:20:31 | |
Germany has thousands of banks,
including state run and co-operative | 3:20:31 | 3:20:38 | |
is, many focused on lending
specifically to small and | 3:20:38 | 3:20:41 | |
medium-sized businesses. In Britain,
just five banks own 85% of all | 3:20:41 | 3:20:47 | |
current accounts of. The Chancellor
could learn from the German modelled | 3:20:47 | 3:20:51 | |
by enabling a new generation of
mutually owned building societies | 3:20:51 | 3:20:55 | |
and saving banks to focus on
long-term investment rather than | 3:20:55 | 3:20:58 | |
short-term dividends for the
shareholders. Might the Chancellor | 3:20:58 | 3:21:03 | |
not also rethink the future of the
World Bank of Scotland hammered at | 3:21:03 | 3:21:09 | |
the moment the government is
committed to privatising back at | 3:21:09 | 3:21:11 | |
some future point, but surely taking
the opportunity to set a future for | 3:21:11 | 3:21:22 | |
RBS as a mutual, perhaps the royal
building society of Scotland, might | 3:21:22 | 3:21:27 | |
be a better way to encourage
competition in the banking market? I | 3:21:27 | 3:21:31 | |
think my honourable friend speaks
from experience and here is | 3:21:31 | 3:21:36 | |
absolutely right. We need a thriving
co-operative sector in this country. | 3:21:36 | 3:21:40 | |
And again, if we want to talk about
the past and talk about the reason | 3:21:40 | 3:21:45 | |
we haven't got a strong mutual
sector in this country is because of | 3:21:45 | 3:21:49 | |
what the Tory has allowed on many of
our banks, the most famous of which | 3:21:49 | 3:21:55 | |
is Bradford & Bingley, allowing
people to become members and then | 3:21:55 | 3:21:59 | |
turning them to plc is. Does he
agree with me that one of the worst | 3:21:59 | 3:22:07 | |
decisions of the Conservatives in
the night in 80s was the destruction | 3:22:07 | 3:22:11 | |
of the great regional institutions
that were building societies, so | 3:22:11 | 3:22:18 | |
that institutions like the Halifax
building society which created | 3:22:18 | 3:22:21 | |
wealth and retained it in the
regions were destroyed? I agree with | 3:22:21 | 3:22:25 | |
my honourable friend. If ever there
was something tearing into the | 3:22:25 | 3:22:30 | |
fabric of British society, that was
it. It is terrible when you walk | 3:22:30 | 3:22:33 | |
down the street and so many of the
famous building societies are no | 3:22:33 | 3:22:37 | |
longer there. That needs to change
and we need to start talking about | 3:22:37 | 3:22:40 | |
alternative corporative models. We
need to talk about more mutual in | 3:22:40 | 3:22:47 | |
our society and business, including
employees share ownership schemes | 3:22:47 | 3:22:52 | |
and other things. But I think as
well it is time now to talk about | 3:22:52 | 3:22:58 | |
the NHS. Our nurses do a fantastic
job. They're at the front line. When | 3:22:58 | 3:23:03 | |
someone is in need, they are there.
But very often, this government has | 3:23:03 | 3:23:08 | |
not been there for them. And still
today, instead of giving the nurses | 3:23:08 | 3:23:13 | |
a pay rise, which I think all of us
agree they deserve, what we got was | 3:23:13 | 3:23:17 | |
a very vague statement about
maybe... | 3:23:17 | 3:23:28 | |
I also think about all those people
on Universal Credit. Again, this is | 3:23:31 | 3:23:35 | |
all about a sop to those who are in
need. There should have been an | 3:23:35 | 3:23:41 | |
announcement today to pause it and
look at it and eventually change it. | 3:23:41 | 3:23:45 | |
It is no good plunging the most
vulnerable people we have into | 3:23:45 | 3:23:48 | |
abject poverty. But this is what
this government is about. This | 3:23:48 | 3:23:55 | |
government I feel is very good at
warm words. Of course every | 3:23:55 | 3:23:59 | |
Chancellor's speech has to end with
a flourish, and resorted there. The | 3:23:59 | 3:24:03 | |
wedding of the paper as the
Chancellor stood up and in his | 3:24:03 | 3:24:08 | |
uninspiring tones announced that he
was going to abolish stamp duty for | 3:24:08 | 3:24:14 | |
those with houses up to 300,000. | 3:24:14 | 3:24:21 | |
Straightaway, minutes after, which
happens after all of his speeches. | 3:24:21 | 3:24:25 | |
It happened last time with national
insurance contributions, we get the | 3:24:25 | 3:24:28 | |
real story. Hidden on page 154 of
the report, it states clearly that | 3:24:28 | 3:24:33 | |
the temporary holiday on stamp duty
will increase house prices by 0.3%. | 3:24:33 | 3:24:41 | |
The honourable gentleman is shouting
at me... Judging by the ability of | 3:24:41 | 3:24:48 | |
the OBR to predict the future, does
it honestly think they are only | 3:24:48 | 3:24:52 | |
going to go up by 0.3%? It might
come down. Hopefully the honourable | 3:24:52 | 3:24:57 | |
gentleman. The point the Chancellor
is missing, many of these people | 3:24:57 | 3:25:02 | |
can't afford a deposit to buy a
house. So really he should have been | 3:25:02 | 3:25:07 | |
looking, as well as reducing stamp
duty, something people can save to | 3:25:07 | 3:25:12 | |
buy a house. We've heard about the
home-buyers I said, many people | 3:25:12 | 3:25:17 | |
didn't take it up. It's those kind
of things we need. In closing, I've | 3:25:17 | 3:25:20 | |
spoken for a long time, taking a lot
of interventions. I will say this, | 3:25:20 | 3:25:24 | |
this was a speech where the
Chancellor was boxed in. He held up | 3:25:24 | 3:25:29 | |
his red box that was a symbol of how
he was boxed in. Boxed in by his | 3:25:29 | 3:25:35 | |
government, in by the aquatic Ulster
Unionists and boxed in by his party | 3:25:35 | 3:25:40 | |
as well. | 3:25:40 | 3:25:44 | |
In terms of Brexit and the
productivity problems we have in | 3:25:45 | 3:25:48 | |
this country, we needed radical
reform. That government can't | 3:25:48 | 3:25:51 | |
provide it any more. I say to them,
stop clinging onto power and let's | 3:25:51 | 3:25:55 | |
go back to the country. Andrew
Mitchell. It's a pleasure to follow | 3:25:55 | 3:26:03 | |
the honourable gentleman. I fear my
speech will take a slightly | 3:26:03 | 3:26:07 | |
different view from his. I draw to
the house's attention my interests | 3:26:07 | 3:26:13 | |
that are registered in the House of
Commons register. I want, if I may, | 3:26:13 | 3:26:17 | |
to start by saying I think the
Chancellor faced a pretty difficult | 3:26:17 | 3:26:22 | |
task today. He was said to be
between a rock and a hard place. But | 3:26:22 | 3:26:27 | |
I think this is a sensible and
pragmatic budget. The Chancellor | 3:26:27 | 3:26:33 | |
will be well content with that
analysis. Madam Deputy Speaker I | 3:26:33 | 3:26:36 | |
want to start with the Midlands
because that is the area, part of | 3:26:36 | 3:26:42 | |
the area, which I represent. Very
pleased indeed to see we now have | 3:26:42 | 3:26:48 | |
the second devolution deal. I think
the support, and you will understand | 3:26:48 | 3:26:51 | |
how much this matters in the West
Midlands for the automobile | 3:26:51 | 3:26:57 | |
industry, for driverless cars, for
electric cars, is enormously | 3:26:57 | 3:27:01 | |
important. The Midlands is the
centre of this. We are leaders in | 3:27:01 | 3:27:06 | |
technology, design and production.
Internationally we very much welcome | 3:27:06 | 3:27:10 | |
that support. More of which is to be
announced later this week. Secondly, | 3:27:10 | 3:27:17 | |
the £200 million we received for
cleaning up Brownfield land is | 3:27:17 | 3:27:22 | |
thanks to the vigour and vision of
Andy Street, our mayor. He's doing a | 3:27:22 | 3:27:28 | |
very good job. I hope the Treasury
will consider providing more funding | 3:27:28 | 3:27:31 | |
when that £200 million has been
used. The importance of spending | 3:27:31 | 3:27:39 | |
money cleaning up Brownfield land is
immense because it means we then | 3:27:39 | 3:27:43 | |
don't have to build on green belt.
We should only ever do that as last | 3:27:43 | 3:27:48 | |
resort. I would also like to say we
are delighted that we are to be part | 3:27:48 | 3:27:55 | |
of a national pilot of housing
first. This is a particular priority | 3:27:55 | 3:28:00 | |
of Andy Street, our mayor's
programme. This pilot will allow us | 3:28:00 | 3:28:05 | |
to address rough sleeping across the
West Midlands in a decisive way. We | 3:28:05 | 3:28:11 | |
are very determined to do that.
Fourthly, from today 's | 3:28:11 | 3:28:16 | |
announcement, I want to express my
gratitude to the government for the | 3:28:16 | 3:28:19 | |
announcement on Birmingham
Children's Hospital where resources | 3:28:19 | 3:28:23 | |
will now be made available for
children's emergency medicine and | 3:28:23 | 3:28:28 | |
paediatric care centre. Many of us
have been campaigning for this and | 3:28:28 | 3:28:33 | |
the news is excellent. I give way to
my honourable friend. If I can take | 3:28:33 | 3:28:37 | |
him back to housing for a moment,
does he agree the budget needs to be | 3:28:37 | 3:28:41 | |
seen in the round-up of government
announcements and opportunities in | 3:28:41 | 3:28:48 | |
the White Paper for local
authorities to build once again? My | 3:28:48 | 3:28:54 | |
right honourable friend makes his
point exceedingly eloquently. Madam | 3:28:54 | 3:28:58 | |
Deputy Speaker, the second point I
wanted to make was really to | 3:28:58 | 3:29:01 | |
underline to the house that free
enterprise, open markets has been | 3:29:01 | 3:29:07 | |
and is the greatest engine of social
and economic advancement known to | 3:29:07 | 3:29:10 | |
man. I think we need to stand up for
these more than we perhaps have in | 3:29:10 | 3:29:15 | |
the recent past against the opposing
views espoused by the Shadow | 3:29:15 | 3:29:21 | |
Chancellor and large numbers of
young people who were not around to | 3:29:21 | 3:29:24 | |
learn some of the pretty basic
economic troops many of us learned | 3:29:24 | 3:29:29 | |
in the 1970s and 1980s. Having said
that, capitalism has always required | 3:29:29 | 3:29:37 | |
governments and regulators to set
boundaries to human activity and, | 3:29:37 | 3:29:42 | |
inevitably commit human greed. That
chimes in very well with the | 3:29:42 | 3:29:48 | |
activist views our Prime Minister
has expressed since she took up that | 3:29:48 | 3:29:52 | |
job. I want to point to three areas
briefly, by way of example, where I | 3:29:52 | 3:29:58 | |
think this regulation of capitalism
is the most important. The first is | 3:29:58 | 3:30:03 | |
that the debates that have taken
place across the house an open | 3:30:03 | 3:30:07 | |
ownership registers, in particular
for the British embassy's | 3:30:07 | 3:30:11 | |
territories, this was an initiative
of the Cameron government. We've | 3:30:11 | 3:30:15 | |
imposed upon ourselves in Britain
this transparency and we need to do | 3:30:15 | 3:30:21 | |
it on the overseas territories as
well. Many in this house care deeply | 3:30:21 | 3:30:25 | |
about this. My honourable friend for
Staffordshire for Amber Valley, the | 3:30:25 | 3:30:30 | |
right honourable ladies for Barking
and Don Valley. It is important the | 3:30:30 | 3:30:34 | |
Treasury recognises this point in
the Finance Bill. I very much hope | 3:30:34 | 3:30:39 | |
they will. Second become in terms of
energy prices, the government is | 3:30:39 | 3:30:44 | |
absolutely right to pursue this.
There is a monopolistic situation | 3:30:44 | 3:30:48 | |
which is working against the
interests of consumers. Regulation | 3:30:48 | 3:30:52 | |
is absolutely the right way to deal
with this rather than | 3:30:52 | 3:30:56 | |
renationalisation, which because of
the regulatory regime is entirely | 3:30:56 | 3:31:01 | |
necessary. Thirdly, this point has
been raised in this debate already, | 3:31:01 | 3:31:04 | |
but I make it again. A recent study
of the annual reports of the FTSE | 3:31:04 | 3:31:09 | |
100 companies shows the average pay
for chief executives has risen from | 3:31:09 | 3:31:17 | |
£5 million ahead in 2014 to five and
half million pounds in 2015. What I | 3:31:17 | 3:31:27 | |
believe is offensive and totally
unjustifiable with this, that is 140 | 3:31:27 | 3:31:30 | |
times the average salary of their
employees. It is noteworthy Madam | 3:31:30 | 3:31:37 | |
Deputy Speaker that only a quarter
of FTSE 100 companies pay the | 3:31:37 | 3:31:40 | |
voluntary living wage to their
employers. Now the scale of this | 3:31:40 | 3:31:47 | |
inequality, vastly greater than
previously, gives capitalism a bad | 3:31:47 | 3:31:51 | |
name. At a time when inequality more
generally has been falling, with | 3:31:51 | 3:31:57 | |
income inequality currently at its
lowest rate for 30 years, this is | 3:31:57 | 3:32:00 | |
something the government needs to
address through regulation. I will | 3:32:00 | 3:32:04 | |
give way. The honourable member will
come I'm sure, be aware the OECD | 3:32:04 | 3:32:11 | |
found there was a relationship
between inequality and growth, | 3:32:11 | 3:32:14 | |
namely more inequality means less
growth. Is also what when you | 3:32:14 | 3:32:22 | |
analyse the genie coefficients, the
normal way of evaluating inequality, | 3:32:22 | 3:32:26 | |
the UK is the highest and fastest
growing inequality in Europe. I | 3:32:26 | 3:32:31 | |
don't agree with the last point, but
the honourable gentleman makes. I | 3:32:31 | 3:32:35 | |
will rest on the recently published
statistics that the income | 3:32:35 | 3:32:40 | |
inequality is now at a 30 year low
in Britain. My third and final point | 3:32:40 | 3:32:45 | |
is a point that has also been raised
generally today about | 3:32:45 | 3:32:51 | |
intergenerational fairness. Of
course it's absolutely right that | 3:32:51 | 3:32:54 | |
housing inequality is right at the
top of the list. We want future | 3:32:54 | 3:33:02 | |
generations to have the
opportunities that our generations | 3:33:02 | 3:33:04 | |
have had in terms of ownership. Not
only in ownership. It is also in | 3:33:04 | 3:33:09 | |
part ownership and rental. The
importance, I think of the decisions | 3:33:09 | 3:33:15 | |
that were announced today in the
budget is that they give a real | 3:33:15 | 3:33:20 | |
boost to the creative use of space
Maria Lenk a regiment to using the | 3:33:20 | 3:33:25 | |
Brownfield land I spoke about. Quite
right to attack the issue of the | 3:33:25 | 3:33:33 | |
misuse of land banks. And be
creative in terms of building new | 3:33:33 | 3:33:36 | |
communities. We need far more
imagination. I would like to see the | 3:33:36 | 3:33:41 | |
government committing to 1 million
new housing starts over the next | 3:33:41 | 3:33:46 | |
three years. Slightly further than
the government has gone today. I | 3:33:46 | 3:33:49 | |
think we need to recognise that this
is absolutely at the top of | 3:33:49 | 3:33:54 | |
everyone's agenda. Building new
communities, focusing on | 3:33:54 | 3:33:59 | |
infrastructure, looking at Garden
cities. I think many people will be | 3:33:59 | 3:34:03 | |
delighted to see what the government
has said today. In the Midlands we | 3:34:03 | 3:34:06 | |
want to see the Black Country garden
city developed, so far an idea | 3:34:06 | 3:34:13 | |
without much flesh on the bones. We
need to see far more flesh added to | 3:34:13 | 3:34:16 | |
the bones. But we must build in the
right places and progress will | 3:34:16 | 3:34:23 | |
become ever more bogged down if we
start to attack the green belt. In | 3:34:23 | 3:34:27 | |
my view it's very important the
government doesn't do that. This | 3:34:27 | 3:34:30 | |
should be the top priority. I want
to end my remarks, Madam Deputy | 3:34:30 | 3:34:35 | |
Speaker, making this point. When it
comes to intergenerational fairness, | 3:34:35 | 3:34:40 | |
everyone agrees this is a vital
topic. Do not let us forget that | 3:34:40 | 3:34:44 | |
excessive borrowing makes it worse.
The last six months, Germany had a | 3:34:44 | 3:34:49 | |
public spending surplus of £8
billion. Ours was a deficit of | 3:34:49 | 3:34:53 | |
something like 26 billion. This will
have to be repaid. It is a cruel and | 3:34:53 | 3:34:58 | |
unfair deception on the next
generation if we do not make it | 3:34:58 | 3:35:01 | |
clear that if our generation does
not repay it, their generation will | 3:35:01 | 3:35:06 | |
have two. Austerity is not optional,
it is not a Tory vice, Madam Deputy | 3:35:06 | 3:35:12 | |
Speaker, it is fiscal
responsibility. We have to return to | 3:35:12 | 3:35:16 | |
living within our means. The final
point I want to make on into general | 3:35:16 | 3:35:23 | |
fairness is, one of the best
investment in future generations is | 3:35:23 | 3:35:27 | |
Britain's contribution to
international development. The work | 3:35:27 | 3:35:29 | |
Britain is doing, the commitment
which we make across the house to | 3:35:29 | 3:35:36 | |
the .7 drives real change in the
world, does a huge amount to help | 3:35:36 | 3:35:39 | |
some of the poorest in the world
today. It contributes directly to | 3:35:39 | 3:35:46 | |
making the world a safer and more
prosperous place for future | 3:35:46 | 3:35:52 | |
generations. It tackles directly the
international dangers from climate | 3:35:52 | 3:35:55 | |
change, migration, Terra, pandemics
and protectionism. The government | 3:35:55 | 3:35:59 | |
should make more of this. This is
something the government of which I | 3:35:59 | 3:36:04 | |
was proud to be apart some five
years ago has done an immense | 3:36:04 | 3:36:08 | |
amount. It is very important in
addressing intergenerational | 3:36:08 | 3:36:12 | |
inequity. And also in making more of
it, the government will note it is | 3:36:12 | 3:36:19 | |
very strongly supported by people
across our country under the age of | 3:36:19 | 3:36:22 | |
35. A cohort suspect during sleep
absent from Tory voters at the last | 3:36:22 | 3:36:28 | |
election. I end by saying how
pleased I am too the government has | 3:36:28 | 3:36:37 | |
given a body that does good work in
Zimbabwe amongst elderly people £1.3 | 3:36:37 | 3:36:43 | |
million from the libel finds. On
behalf of all those involved, I'd | 3:36:43 | 3:36:48 | |
like to express my gratitude to the
Treasury and Chancellor of the | 3:36:48 | 3:36:52 | |
Exchequer for making that very wise
decision. It would be obvious to the | 3:36:52 | 3:36:57 | |
house a great many people still wish
to take part in today's debate and | 3:36:57 | 3:37:01 | |
there is limited time, so I have to
reduce the time limit to eight | 3:37:01 | 3:37:04 | |
minutes. Jo Swinson. Thank you very
much indeed Madam Deputy Speaker. | 3:37:04 | 3:37:11 | |
The British economy today faces
three key challenges. We have, | 3:37:11 | 3:37:17 | |
firstly, low productivity, with the
associated wage stagnation that | 3:37:17 | 3:37:19 | |
comes with that. And of course the
reduced tax receipts. We have high | 3:37:19 | 3:37:23 | |
public sector debt, and we must
recognise the constraints that | 3:37:23 | 3:37:27 | |
places on what is possible
economically. We have to be honest | 3:37:27 | 3:37:31 | |
about some of the hard choices that
need to be made. Thirdly, there is | 3:37:31 | 3:37:35 | |
Brexit. As has already been called
the elephant in the room. The | 3:37:35 | 3:37:40 | |
uncertainty it is creating for
businesses and investment in the | 3:37:40 | 3:37:43 | |
country, the impact on our economy.
Indeed also the opportunity cost of | 3:37:43 | 3:37:47 | |
all of the energy and money being
spent on preparing for Brexit that | 3:37:47 | 3:37:51 | |
could otherwise be directed
elsewhere. Now the Chancellor is a | 3:37:51 | 3:37:55 | |
serious man. We had our differences
in coalition by significant | 3:37:55 | 3:38:01 | |
differences, but in recent months he
has appeared to be one of the few | 3:38:01 | 3:38:05 | |
voices of reason in the Cabinet on
Brexit. He has the unenviable task | 3:38:05 | 3:38:09 | |
coming to the house today in a
picture where there is higher | 3:38:09 | 3:38:12 | |
inflation, lower growth, lower
productivity and higher levels of | 3:38:12 | 3:38:18 | |
debt. It really is bleak, the
economy will be £45 billion smaller | 3:38:18 | 3:38:23 | |
in 2021 than had been projected in
March this year. So I'm afraid his | 3:38:23 | 3:38:28 | |
attempts to paint a cheerful vision
of the future were rather less | 3:38:28 | 3:38:32 | |
successful than his jokes. The truth
is, as the Chancellor knows, this | 3:38:32 | 3:38:38 | |
budget and the next budget, and the
budget after that, and all future | 3:38:38 | 3:38:42 | |
budgets, are made all the more
difficult because of Brexit. And | 3:38:42 | 3:38:46 | |
because of the extreme approach to
Brexit that this government is | 3:38:46 | 3:38:48 | |
pursuing. You making clear that an
exit from the Single Market and the | 3:38:48 | 3:38:56 | |
customs union is a red line for the
government, aided and abetted by the | 3:38:56 | 3:39:00 | |
front bench of the Labour Party,
this in peril is the future of the | 3:39:00 | 3:39:04 | |
UK economy and the Chancellor knows
it. The honourable member for | 3:39:04 | 3:39:08 | |
Loughborough said there was no pot
of gold at the end of the Brexit | 3:39:08 | 3:39:12 | |
rainbow, she is right but I think
the metaphor of a thunderstorm is | 3:39:12 | 3:39:17 | |
better. The cost of reparations, not
just the 700 million already | 3:39:17 | 3:39:23 | |
allocated but a further £3 billion,
more than could be found for the | 3:39:23 | 3:39:27 | |
NHS, which tells its own story. You
add on top of that the exit bill | 3:39:27 | 3:39:33 | |
which may be 20, 30, £40 billion and
the hits to the economy which the | 3:39:33 | 3:39:38 | |
OECD has said could be £40 billion.
No surprise these figures were not | 3:39:38 | 3:39:43 | |
on the side of a bus in the
referendum campaign. To promote the | 3:39:43 | 3:39:49 | |
health of the economy we have long
needed to use the advantage of low | 3:39:49 | 3:39:53 | |
borrowing rates to increase
investment in the economy so I | 3:39:53 | 3:39:57 | |
welcome the measures to unlock new
house-building but it isn't | 3:39:57 | 3:39:59 | |
ambitious enough. As ever the budget
is in the detail. The headline | 3:39:59 | 3:40:05 | |
figure touted was 44 billion. Only
15 billion was actually new and just | 3:40:05 | 3:40:11 | |
6 billion was extra for increasing
housing supply. As the honourable | 3:40:11 | 3:40:14 | |
member for Bath dead, next to no
money for social housing which is | 3:40:14 | 3:40:22 | |
badly needed -- the member for Bath
said. The Chancellor's response does | 3:40:22 | 3:40:28 | |
not come close. The new revenue
peaks at 1.9 billion next year and | 3:40:28 | 3:40:34 | |
then drops to 1.1 billion. We
appreciate that hard choices need to | 3:40:34 | 3:40:39 | |
be made and if we want to resource
the NHS and social care properly we | 3:40:39 | 3:40:43 | |
need to look at how to find the
funds which is why we propose an | 3:40:43 | 3:40:48 | |
increase in income tax of 1p in the
pound specifically for the NHS and | 3:40:48 | 3:40:52 | |
social care. Social care is
something the Chancellor did not | 3:40:52 | 3:40:56 | |
even think was worth mentioning in
his remarks. I think the lady for | 3:40:56 | 3:41:01 | |
giving way. I wonder if she has done
the calculation on what £350 million | 3:41:01 | 3:41:06 | |
a week for the NHS over a year would
amount to. I think it is 18 billion. | 3:41:06 | 3:41:12 | |
How much is the Chancellor offering?
Next year, 1.9 billion, falling | 3:41:12 | 3:41:17 | |
significantly short of that. I'm
sure the Foreign Secretary will be | 3:41:17 | 3:41:22 | |
beating a path to his door to try
and make that happen or perhaps not. | 3:41:22 | 3:41:27 | |
On social care we need serious
responses and cross-party work to | 3:41:27 | 3:41:33 | |
find long-term solutions is that of
the half baked policies put up in | 3:41:33 | 3:41:37 | |
secret that the government offered
in the last election. On taxation in | 3:41:37 | 3:41:42 | |
addition to that increase in income
tax that my party has suggested to | 3:41:42 | 3:41:46 | |
find the NHS there was a missed
opportunity to increase capital | 3:41:46 | 3:41:52 | |
gains tax, corporate gains tax.
Instead of a race to the bottom to | 3:41:52 | 3:41:55 | |
get to 17% we keep it at a
competitive rate of 20% and get the | 3:41:55 | 3:42:01 | |
additional funds it generates. The
Chancellor was right to say that | 3:42:01 | 3:42:05 | |
international action is needed to
create fairer taxation but he failed | 3:42:05 | 3:42:08 | |
to address the role of the overseas
territories. We should require them | 3:42:08 | 3:42:14 | |
to comply with UK standards on
transparency or be prevented from | 3:42:14 | 3:42:16 | |
doing business in the UK. In the
spirit of being transparent, my | 3:42:16 | 3:42:24 | |
husband works for transparency
International UK. In the concept of | 3:42:24 | 3:42:30 | |
rocketing executive pay it is
impossible to escape the contrasts | 3:42:30 | 3:42:32 | |
between the rich who can hide their
assets and avoid tax, those on | 3:42:32 | 3:42:38 | |
middle incomes who are facing real
terms JCats and De Paula, many of | 3:42:38 | 3:42:43 | |
whom, working or not, rely on
benefits to make ends meet -- real | 3:42:43 | 3:42:49 | |
terms pay cut. There is a £12
billion cut to benefits to come, | 3:42:49 | 3:42:57 | |
that the Lib Dems blocked in
coalition. The rise in the income | 3:42:57 | 3:43:02 | |
tax threshold is welcome but
benefits are being frozen. That was | 3:43:02 | 3:43:07 | |
bad enough last year and the year
before but in the face of a 3% | 3:43:07 | 3:43:13 | |
inflation level it is going to cause
real hardship. We see some changes | 3:43:13 | 3:43:18 | |
to Universal Credit but wider
problems are ignored, not least £3 | 3:43:18 | 3:43:22 | |
billion of cuts introduced in 2015.
Universal Credit should be paused | 3:43:22 | 3:43:27 | |
while the problems are ironed out.
There is merit to the simple | 3:43:27 | 3:43:31 | |
assistant but using it to make cuts
undermines the principles underlying | 3:43:31 | 3:43:36 | |
Universal Credit. On the environment
welcome the consideration of new | 3:43:36 | 3:43:42 | |
charges on single use plastics, a
Lib Dem idea but there was precious | 3:43:42 | 3:43:44 | |
little else to show that the
government appreciates the scale of | 3:43:44 | 3:43:48 | |
the threat. They cut subsidies for
solar and renewable heat, | 3:43:48 | 3:43:54 | |
privatising the investment bank and
scrapping the Department for energy | 3:43:54 | 3:43:57 | |
and climate change. Today we saw no
new resources for tidal, carbon | 3:43:57 | 3:44:02 | |
capture and storage, they don't have
a strong record on the environment. | 3:44:02 | 3:44:05 | |
On a positive note, I welcome a
couple of things in the budget. | 3:44:05 | 3:44:12 | |
Investment in technology come in a
eye, driverless cars and geospatial | 3:44:12 | 3:44:16 | |
data. And ethics must be at the
heart of how we proceed. Whether we | 3:44:16 | 3:44:22 | |
can do something is not the same as
whether we should do. I was | 3:44:22 | 3:44:27 | |
delighted to read on page 45 of the
red book that the government intends | 3:44:27 | 3:44:30 | |
to establish a state of -- a centre
for data ethics which is urgently | 3:44:30 | 3:44:36 | |
needed and we should be leading the
way on the issue. On that I say well | 3:44:36 | 3:44:41 | |
done to the government and I look
forward to exploring those issues. I | 3:44:41 | 3:44:46 | |
welcome the national retraining
scheme, especially the partnership | 3:44:46 | 3:44:48 | |
with the CPI and the TUC to make it
work with a focus on digital and | 3:44:48 | 3:44:52 | |
construction skills in the first
instance. I would also save | 3:44:52 | 3:44:57 | |
particularly in the context of the
automation challenge we face to our | 3:44:57 | 3:45:02 | |
workforce, we should be looking more
at the care sector. There are | 3:45:02 | 3:45:06 | |
certain things that robots cannot do
in the future and caring and human | 3:45:06 | 3:45:12 | |
empathy is one of those things. We
face a demographic time bomb so we | 3:45:12 | 3:45:16 | |
should be investing in the care
sector to change it from a low | 3:45:16 | 3:45:20 | |
status profession to one that we
should recognise is high skilled and | 3:45:20 | 3:45:24 | |
we should ensure there is proper
resource. In conclusion, our country | 3:45:24 | 3:45:30 | |
faces big challenges and
opportunities. There is a bleak | 3:45:30 | 3:45:32 | |
economic outlook, low productivity,
effect of climate change, the pace | 3:45:32 | 3:45:38 | |
of technology change and the impact
of automation. These challenges are | 3:45:38 | 3:45:42 | |
enough to give any government awake
at night. They need attention, | 3:45:42 | 3:45:47 | |
innovation and new ideas. Instead we
have a government obsessed and | 3:45:47 | 3:45:52 | |
consumed by Brexit. It isn't even
doing that competently. The economic | 3:45:52 | 3:45:58 | |
picture outlined by the Chancellor
today makes it clearer than ever | 3:45:58 | 3:46:01 | |
that we need an exit from Brexit.
Priti Patel. Thank you madam Deputy | 3:46:01 | 3:46:10 | |
Speaker. It is a pleasure to follow
the honourable lady. It is the first | 3:46:10 | 3:46:16 | |
time in a while that we have debated
together. I want to commend my | 3:46:16 | 3:46:20 | |
friend the Chancellor on the budget
and especially because I know from | 3:46:20 | 3:46:26 | |
my own time in the Treasury during
my apprenticeship three years ago, I | 3:46:26 | 3:46:29 | |
recall the great efforts that the
Chancellor took to bring the budget | 3:46:29 | 3:46:36 | |
together especially as ministers are
lobbied constantly by a range of | 3:46:36 | 3:46:41 | |
interests and of course it is a
challenge to balance the needs with | 3:46:41 | 3:46:45 | |
the responsibility to keep the
public finances in sound order. The | 3:46:45 | 3:46:50 | |
Treasury should be commended for
navigating those pressures and | 3:46:50 | 3:46:55 | |
continuing to put the stability at
the core of the budget. Economic | 3:46:55 | 3:47:00 | |
stability should rightly stand at
the core of every budget and it's | 3:47:00 | 3:47:04 | |
worth reminding members, especially
those opposite, of the progress that | 3:47:04 | 3:47:07 | |
has been made in putting the public
finances back in order from the | 3:47:07 | 3:47:12 | |
appalling situation in 2010. Back
then the deficit was exceeding £150 | 3:47:12 | 3:47:19 | |
billion, more than we were spending
on health, education, police and the | 3:47:19 | 3:47:23 | |
Armed Forces, a level of spending
financed by borrowing that was | 3:47:23 | 3:47:26 | |
unsustainable. We know that the
party opposite never want to take | 3:47:26 | 3:47:32 | |
responsibility for how it mishandled
public finances and loves pointing | 3:47:32 | 3:47:35 | |
the finger of blame elsewhere. It is
a fact that before the financial | 3:47:35 | 3:47:39 | |
crisis the then Labour government
wrapped up an eye watering about of | 3:47:39 | 3:47:43 | |
debt. I will give way. In 2010 the
Conservative government said it was | 3:47:43 | 3:47:50 | |
very to eliminate the deficit by
2015. They were aware of the deficit | 3:47:50 | 3:47:55 | |
at that stage. Why have they failed?
I think the answer is the scale of | 3:47:55 | 3:48:01 | |
Labour's economic mismanagement. In
2008, the budget is planned for was | 3:48:01 | 3:48:07 | |
a £43 billion deficit, more than all
the revenues raised in excise duties | 3:48:07 | 3:48:12 | |
so it says everything we need to
know about financial management by | 3:48:12 | 3:48:16 | |
Labour. I thank my friend for giving
way. Does she think that the | 3:48:16 | 3:48:24 | |
opposition have the brass neck to
intervene in that way, having on the | 3:48:24 | 3:48:29 | |
one hand in the chamber criticised
the government for not cutting the | 3:48:29 | 3:48:33 | |
deficit fast enough and yet on every
occasion they've been invited to | 3:48:33 | 3:48:37 | |
support the deficit cutting strategy
they've voted against it. My right | 3:48:37 | 3:48:42 | |
honourable friend is absolutely
right and of course there are many | 3:48:42 | 3:48:45 | |
occasions since 2010 when the party
opposite have not only not supported | 3:48:45 | 3:48:50 | |
the government approach on deficit
reduction but have failed to vote | 3:48:50 | 3:48:54 | |
and support policies as well that
support the reduction of deficit and | 3:48:54 | 3:48:59 | |
also bring in sound financial
economic management back into the | 3:48:59 | 3:49:02 | |
public finances. We have come a long
way when it comes to bringing the | 3:49:02 | 3:49:07 | |
deficit down but also understanding
the reasons as to why it sound | 3:49:07 | 3:49:11 | |
financial management matters. Of
course that is because we need the | 3:49:11 | 3:49:16 | |
money available to invest in our
public services and to have an | 3:49:16 | 3:49:19 | |
economy that embraces enterprise and
can bring the tax receipts needed to | 3:49:19 | 3:49:24 | |
pay for hospitals, schools, police
and Armed Forces. Today's budget | 3:49:24 | 3:49:29 | |
recognises that and touches on this
fundamental issue. While we heard | 3:49:29 | 3:49:33 | |
criticism in the debate earlier on
about the NHS, our NHS of course is | 3:49:33 | 3:49:38 | |
a great is the Jewish in and it's
right that the Chancellor today has | 3:49:38 | 3:49:41 | |
committed more public funds into the
NHS -- great institution. I'm | 3:49:41 | 3:49:49 | |
delighted to see new support,
capital investment coming into the | 3:49:49 | 3:49:56 | |
NHS because for 30 years under
Labour, there was underfunding. I | 3:49:56 | 3:50:01 | |
speak again and make the point that
my friend did, the party opposite | 3:50:01 | 3:50:07 | |
have a brass neck to criticise the
work we've done and the investments | 3:50:07 | 3:50:10 | |
that have been made. One of the
great successes we've had since 2010 | 3:50:10 | 3:50:15 | |
has been record levels of job
creation in the economy. I like many | 3:50:15 | 3:50:23 | |
honourable friends recall sitting in
these debates from 2010 onwards | 3:50:23 | 3:50:26 | |
hearing the doom and gloom and
scaremongering from the party | 3:50:26 | 3:50:29 | |
opposite about unemployment and
recession. As we know, their | 3:50:29 | 3:50:36 | |
predictions have proven wrong. The
point now is in the budget today | 3:50:36 | 3:50:40 | |
we've heard about greater
investment, in key sectors going | 3:50:40 | 3:50:46 | |
forward where we know we have to
think about the future of the Labour | 3:50:46 | 3:50:50 | |
market, where automation will be
coming in and also looking at how we | 3:50:50 | 3:50:55 | |
can invest in construction and key
services. I will give way. Doesn't | 3:50:55 | 3:51:04 | |
she recognise that under the Labour
government the economy grew by 40% | 3:51:04 | 3:51:11 | |
in ten years to 2008, that the
government doubled debt from 45% in | 3:51:11 | 3:51:20 | |
90% of the economy and now we have
the lowest growth in the G7. Surely | 3:51:20 | 3:51:25 | |
that isn't a success. In my
constituency we have seen the | 3:51:25 | 3:51:30 | |
claimant count falling from 70% from
under its peak under Gordon Brown | 3:51:30 | 3:51:35 | |
and there has been growth in small
enterprises, more jobs in Essex, and | 3:51:35 | 3:51:42 | |
we should be welcoming that. I will
give way. Her speech reminds me to | 3:51:42 | 3:51:48 | |
ask this question, can she recall an
occasion when the party opposite has | 3:51:48 | 3:51:51 | |
talked up the economy? It seems they
are always about more spending and | 3:51:51 | 3:51:56 | |
borrowing, more debt and benefits.
My honourable friend is absolutely | 3:51:56 | 3:52:02 | |
right, we have 32 million people in
work, an opposition party that talks | 3:52:02 | 3:52:07 | |
our economy down. They seem to hold
a pathological hatred of enterprise | 3:52:07 | 3:52:14 | |
aspiration free markets, calling for
higher tax on businesses to serve | 3:52:14 | 3:52:18 | |
their agenda to tighten controls on
free markets, to stifle innovation | 3:52:18 | 3:52:22 | |
and style businesses from
succeeding. As we know that would | 3:52:22 | 3:52:26 | |
harm the economy in the long-running
-- stop businesses from succeeding. | 3:52:26 | 3:52:31 | |
As we've seen in the budget, great
Conservative budgets of sport | 3:52:31 | 3:52:37 | |
aspiration and opportunity and
freedom and this is why this party | 3:52:37 | 3:52:40 | |
has been on the side of people who
work hard and want to get on and own | 3:52:40 | 3:52:44 | |
their own homes. We've seen the
budget making welcome changes to | 3:52:44 | 3:52:48 | |
stamp duty to help people get on the
property ladder with 95% of | 3:52:48 | 3:52:54 | |
first-time buyers benefiting and 80%
paying no stamp duty. There is the | 3:52:54 | 3:52:59 | |
right action that will support
homeownership and increase supply | 3:52:59 | 3:53:02 | |
through the investment that has been
now announced today in the budget. I | 3:53:02 | 3:53:05 | |
want to stress to my honourable
friends on the front bench the | 3:53:05 | 3:53:11 | |
importance of ensuring there is
investment in infrastructure with | 3:53:11 | 3:53:15 | |
new housing from five it as well as
public sources. In Essex in | 3:53:15 | 3:53:20 | |
particular we've been working
assiduously to secure investment | 3:53:20 | 3:53:22 | |
with the government, the rail route
north of Witton, upgrading the a | 3:53:22 | 3:53:30 | |
120, critical investments that will
support house-building in that part | 3:53:30 | 3:53:34 | |
of Essex but also we are working to
ensure greater public funding, not | 3:53:34 | 3:53:38 | |
just private funding, but innovative
financial products to reduce the | 3:53:38 | 3:53:45 | |
risk to the public purse and
increase private contributions to | 3:53:45 | 3:53:51 | |
see the increase in construction.
Deputy Speaker, it was right that we | 3:53:51 | 3:54:01 | |
saw the budget setting us on a
course to be able to make the most | 3:54:01 | 3:54:05 | |
out of the new long-term
opportunities that Britain has. Of | 3:54:05 | 3:54:07 | |
course that means a global beacon
for free trade, a place that | 3:54:07 | 3:54:13 | |
welcomes investment from overseas,
more enterprise. But also finding | 3:54:13 | 3:54:17 | |
ways in which we unlock the talent
of this country. Again I welcome the | 3:54:17 | 3:54:22 | |
new investment we've heard today
from my right honourable friend the | 3:54:22 | 3:54:24 | |
Chancellor when it comes to skills,
critical sectors and investing in | 3:54:24 | 3:54:28 | |
people. There are fantastic
opportunity is not just for the City | 3:54:28 | 3:54:33 | |
of London but for our country. There
are plenty of reasons not just to be | 3:54:33 | 3:54:37 | |
optimistic, but looking at how we
can trade with the world and grow | 3:54:37 | 3:54:40 | |
our economy. Looking outwards rather
than inwards. A budget will | 3:54:40 | 3:54:49 | |
facilitate a positive international
vision for Britain. I believe that | 3:54:49 | 3:54:52 | |
is how it would be judged in years
that ahead. This budget stands in | 3:54:52 | 3:54:56 | |
marked contrast to the policies of
the party opposite you want to tax | 3:54:56 | 3:55:00 | |
more, harm our country and economy,
but importantly this budget lays a | 3:55:00 | 3:55:05 | |
foundation for a Britain that be fit
for the future. Gareth Thomas. A | 3:55:05 | 3:55:15 | |
pleasure to follow the right
honourable lady for Witham, shall | 3:55:15 | 3:55:18 | |
not be surprised I take a slightly
different view about the decisions | 3:55:18 | 3:55:21 | |
our country has made on Brexit. I
thought she nevertheless gave an | 3:55:21 | 3:55:27 | |
interesting speech. I was also
interested in the comments by her | 3:55:27 | 3:55:33 | |
colleague, the right honourable
gentleman for, if you'll forgive me, | 3:55:33 | 3:55:36 | |
somewhere in the Midlands. About
the... Sutton Coldfield, thank you | 3:55:36 | 3:55:41 | |
very much. To reform capitalism. I
thought his proposals were rather | 3:55:41 | 3:55:48 | |
timid. They were a star in terms of
recognising how corporate culture | 3:55:48 | 3:55:53 | |
needs to change. I would encourage
and there are forms of public | 3:55:53 | 3:55:58 | |
ownership that he should look at
with more enthusiasm than his | 3:55:58 | 3:56:01 | |
remarks today suggested he might do.
If I have time I hope to pick some | 3:56:01 | 3:56:09 | |
of those up. Today the most striking
feature of the budget thus far has | 3:56:09 | 3:56:16 | |
been the revelations about the cost
of Brexit. The downgrade by the OBR | 3:56:16 | 3:56:22 | |
in growth forecasts means for the
first time in modern history | 3:56:22 | 3:56:27 | |
official UK GDP growth forecast for
every single year over the period | 3:56:27 | 3:56:32 | |
being forecast are under 2%. The
setting aside of an extra £3 billion | 3:56:32 | 3:56:41 | |
to fund the cost of Brexit is quite
extraordinary. I don't remember any | 3:56:41 | 3:56:47 | |
of the Leave campaign mentioning or
even hinting at such costs. Earlier | 3:56:47 | 3:56:56 | |
this month the Bank of England
governor gave his verdict on the | 3:56:56 | 3:57:01 | |
economy and said Britain, in his
words, would be moving if it was not | 3:57:01 | 3:57:07 | |
for the Brexit effect. With
favourable conditions and stronger | 3:57:07 | 3:57:10 | |
growth in other parts of the world,
sadly, notably, in the Eurozone, | 3:57:10 | 3:57:15 | |
Britain has fallen from the top to
the bottom of the league of G-7 | 3:57:15 | 3:57:19 | |
leading economies in the year since
the Brexit vote. Perhaps most | 3:57:19 | 3:57:24 | |
strikingly, foreign investment in
Britain is 20% lower than the Bank | 3:57:24 | 3:57:28 | |
of England were forecasting before
the referendum result. So it's easy, | 3:57:28 | 3:57:34 | |
I think, to be concerned even more
than we might have been about the | 3:57:34 | 3:57:39 | |
cost of Brexit. But the evidence
that businesses are beginning to | 3:57:39 | 3:57:44 | |
come forward with it to explain why
they are holding back on investment | 3:57:44 | 3:57:50 | |
decisions is perhaps not surprising
when the Cabinet themselves cannot | 3:57:50 | 3:57:55 | |
decide what kind of trading
relationship they want with our | 3:57:55 | 3:57:58 | |
European partners. The truth is
ordinary households are paying the | 3:57:58 | 3:58:03 | |
price of that situation. A report
published this month by the Centre | 3:58:03 | 3:58:08 | |
for economic performance found the
impact of inflation and the weaker | 3:58:08 | 3:58:15 | |
pound since the referendum means the
average worker had experienced a | 3:58:15 | 3:58:18 | |
real term cut of almost £450 in
annual pay, the equivalent of a | 3:58:18 | 3:58:24 | |
weak's salary. Sadly the government
marches on, insisting we'll leave | 3:58:24 | 3:58:28 | |
the customs union and single market,
and that no deal may well be an | 3:58:28 | 3:58:33 | |
acceptable outcome. Either striking
the evidence we've heard recently | 3:58:33 | 3:58:37 | |
from car manufacturers such as Honda
about the potential cost of leaving | 3:58:37 | 3:58:45 | |
the customs union. Up to £850,000
for some manufacturers every year. | 3:58:45 | 3:58:50 | |
Underestimate it would take their 18
month to set up the warehouses and | 3:58:50 | 3:58:55 | |
procedures they would need if
Britain left the customs union. | 3:58:55 | 3:58:59 | |
Something the government insists
will happen in 17 months' time. | 3:58:59 | 3:59:06 | |
Genuinely worrying for the future of
jobs in this country. The general | 3:59:06 | 3:59:11 | |
election confirmed there is no
mandate for a hard Brexit so even at | 3:59:11 | 3:59:15 | |
this late stage I urge the Minister
's opposite, and indeed if I may do | 3:59:15 | 3:59:19 | |
so generally, my own front bench, to
again explore soft Brexit options. | 3:59:19 | 3:59:24 | |
Such as EEA membership. Which allow
potentially new arrangements on | 3:59:24 | 3:59:28 | |
issues of concern to the British
people such as judicial authority | 3:59:28 | 3:59:32 | |
and freedom of movement, but which
would crucially give significant | 3:59:32 | 3:59:34 | |
economic certainty going forward.
The second area I wanted to touch on | 3:59:34 | 3:59:42 | |
was the failure of this budget to
tackle the crisis in funding for | 3:59:42 | 3:59:45 | |
public services. I thought it was
striking the Chancellor, given the | 3:59:45 | 3:59:48 | |
terrorist attacks our country has
had this year, made absolutely no | 3:59:48 | 3:59:54 | |
mention of additional funding for
the police or indeed additional | 3:59:54 | 3:59:58 | |
funding to invest in tackling the
threat, the ongoing threat of | 3:59:58 | 4:00:06 | |
terrorism in this country. For
Harrow we've lost 173 police | 4:00:06 | 4:00:13 | |
officers since 2010. Violent crime,
particularly crime involving a | 4:00:13 | 4:00:18 | |
knife, is up by 60% in Harrow. There
are stabbings, stabbings in South | 4:00:18 | 4:00:28 | |
Harrow and Harrow town centre.
Something my constituency has not | 4:00:28 | 4:00:33 | |
experienced for a considerable
period of time. The fear of crime is | 4:00:33 | 4:00:36 | |
therefore stand Julie on the
increase. I'll give way to my | 4:00:36 | 4:00:40 | |
honourable friend. He mentioned the
police numbers and crime rising, | 4:00:40 | 4:00:48 | |
knife crime. The West Midlands has
lost over 2000 policeman, how will | 4:00:48 | 4:00:51 | |
you tackle knife crime when you are
reducing the police force and other | 4:00:51 | 4:00:55 | |
crimes for that matter. When we talk
about public services, instead of | 4:00:55 | 4:01:00 | |
the government telling public
services the police and fire brigade | 4:01:00 | 4:01:04 | |
and medical profession, why don't
they give them a decent wage? It's | 4:01:04 | 4:01:07 | |
the best way to thank them for the
service they give us. I strongly | 4:01:07 | 4:01:11 | |
support my honourable friend's
point. I worry that the government | 4:01:11 | 4:01:18 | |
has chosen to do nothing about the
threat, the real threat in funding | 4:01:18 | 4:01:26 | |
terms, of a further loss of 3-4000
police officers. Which the | 4:01:26 | 4:01:31 | |
commission of the Metropolitan
Police, Cressida Dick, outlined what | 4:01:31 | 4:01:33 | |
would happen if there was no
increase in the Metropolitan | 4:01:33 | 4:01:38 | |
Police's budget going forward. The
consequences of that lack of funding | 4:01:38 | 4:01:44 | |
mean Harrow will be merged with
Barnet and Brent. Barnett increased | 4:01:44 | 4:01:51 | |
burglary rates, Brent a significant
gang problem. Many of my | 4:01:51 | 4:01:56 | |
constituents fear the police will be
taken out of our borough to tackle | 4:01:56 | 4:01:59 | |
problems in those two other
borrowers. And that crime in Harrow | 4:01:59 | 4:02:06 | |
will not be tackled in a way that
they might have hoped. On the | 4:02:06 | 4:02:11 | |
National Health Service it is
significant, I think, that the extra | 4:02:11 | 4:02:16 | |
resources which the Kings fund and
of the NHS said were necessary have | 4:02:16 | 4:02:20 | |
not been met. There have been some
increases and uplift and I welcome | 4:02:20 | 4:02:27 | |
that. It is striking that just last
year there were two and a half | 4:02:27 | 4:02:31 | |
million people waiting longer than
four hours in accident and emergency | 4:02:31 | 4:02:35 | |
compared to the 350,000 when we left
office. 4 million people at the | 4:02:35 | 4:02:39 | |
moment on a waiting list for
treatment in an English hospital. In | 4:02:39 | 4:02:44 | |
terms of Norfolk Park which serves
my constituency, it is the second | 4:02:44 | 4:02:49 | |
busiest trust in London following
the government's decision to close | 4:02:49 | 4:02:54 | |
the accident and emergency
department at Hammersmith and | 4:02:54 | 4:02:56 | |
Central Middlesex. We in my
constituency worry that Ealing | 4:02:56 | 4:03:01 | |
Hospital accident and emergency
department is due to close as well. | 4:03:01 | 4:03:05 | |
When one considers that our trust
has entered the last financial year | 4:03:05 | 4:03:10 | |
some £60 million in deficit with an
underlying deficit of almost 100 | 4:03:10 | 4:03:15 | |
million, and is expected to make
savings of 50 million in the current | 4:03:15 | 4:03:21 | |
financial year, which the leadership
of the trust is an unprecedented | 4:03:21 | 4:03:24 | |
challenge, and one I think you can
understand why my constituents, I | 4:03:24 | 4:03:29 | |
think, will be deeply worried about
the implications of this budget for | 4:03:29 | 4:03:31 | |
the hospital going. Many of my
schools are under considerable | 4:03:31 | 4:03:37 | |
financial pressure. Having to see
teaching assistants, vacancies not | 4:03:37 | 4:03:44 | |
being filled, experienced staff when
they are leaving replaced by newly | 4:03:44 | 4:03:49 | |
qualified teachers. Again, this
budget does nothing to address those | 4:03:49 | 4:03:53 | |
particular problems. Nothing on
adult social care and the financial | 4:03:53 | 4:03:59 | |
prices. Nothing on the increasing
crisis in children's services. Going | 4:03:59 | 4:04:05 | |
forward. Lack of time prevents me
picking up the challenge the | 4:04:05 | 4:04:10 | |
honourable gentleman for Sutton
Coldfield laid down about a debate | 4:04:10 | 4:04:13 | |
on how one reforms capitalism going
forward, but I do think a series of | 4:04:13 | 4:04:18 | |
cooperative and mutual solutions
might offer a potential for that. | 4:04:18 | 4:04:22 | |
There needs to be an increase in
cooperative housing. The Royal Bank | 4:04:22 | 4:04:27 | |
of Scotland should be converted into
a building society going forward. | 4:04:27 | 4:04:30 | |
And far more needs to be done to
encourage an increase in energy | 4:04:30 | 4:04:37 | |
cooperatives to challenge the
dominance of the big six players at | 4:04:37 | 4:04:40 | |
the moment. It's a pleasure to
follow the honourable gentleman for | 4:04:40 | 4:04:45 | |
Harrow West. I agree with his
remarks at the end about the role of | 4:04:45 | 4:04:50 | |
cooperatives in financial services
and other parts of our economy, he | 4:04:50 | 4:04:53 | |
and I spoke about that previously.
This was a budget fit for the | 4:04:53 | 4:04:58 | |
future. Said the Chancellor. In many
ways all budgets are fit for the | 4:04:58 | 4:05:02 | |
future because it's the future we
face. Some, like many the previous | 4:05:02 | 4:05:07 | |
Chancellor had to deal with, had to
cure the ills of the past, today we | 4:05:07 | 4:05:10 | |
see some of that pressure and pain
this economy has had to take the | 4:05:10 | 4:05:16 | |
input right. Some of these benefits
coming forward in a number of ways. | 4:05:16 | 4:05:22 | |
My right honourable friend for
Sutton Coldfield was right, much is | 4:05:22 | 4:05:25 | |
spoken about intergenerational
issues. The worst intergenerational | 4:05:25 | 4:05:30 | |
burden you can leave is to load the
next generation with the debt from | 4:05:30 | 4:05:39 | |
your reckless spending. When the
Leader of the Opposition said in his | 4:05:39 | 4:05:42 | |
speech today how different it could
all have been, so right he was. A | 4:05:42 | 4:05:46 | |
deficit denied not more money spent,
more tax raised. Little benefit. The | 4:05:46 | 4:05:55 | |
reality is our constituents are
bearing the brunt of that. Madam | 4:05:55 | 4:05:59 | |
Deputy Speaker, the Chancellor was
right to point out the OBR is | 4:05:59 | 4:06:02 | |
independent and also it gives a view
on the best economic forecasting | 4:06:02 | 4:06:08 | |
available. All forecasting bears
risks. If you had a look at the OBR | 4:06:08 | 4:06:19 | |
book, it brings out interesting
things. The honourable gentleman | 4:06:19 | 4:06:23 | |
opposite made the point several
times about productivity and his | 4:06:23 | 4:06:26 | |
right to make that, it is the
central challenge of this economy. | 4:06:26 | 4:06:28 | |
The honourable lady for the Liberal
Democrats made the same point. It's | 4:06:28 | 4:06:34 | |
fascinating to note, because of
course as an economic historian of | 4:06:34 | 4:06:39 | |
relatively modern times, it's worth
remembering of course the previous | 4:06:39 | 4:06:43 | |
Administration had to redefine
productivity because it was falling | 4:06:43 | 4:06:47 | |
so fast under their watch. It is
right to say that the OBR is making | 4:06:47 | 4:06:51 | |
the point and it is a disappointment
that although it is picking up its | 4:06:51 | 4:06:56 | |
not reaching precrisis levels. Which
is why it should be welcoming inside | 4:06:56 | 4:07:02 | |
the detail of the red book today the
schemes that are for retraining | 4:07:02 | 4:07:07 | |
older people as much as the skills
given to new people. If you look | 4:07:07 | 4:07:13 | |
inside the OBR one of the biggest
problems being highlighted is the | 4:07:13 | 4:07:17 | |
participation rate, as we have an
increasingly elderly population | 4:07:17 | 4:07:25 | |
without the skills to tackle some of
the new industries that are so | 4:07:25 | 4:07:30 | |
obviously going to be there. I
particularly welcome the retraining | 4:07:30 | 4:07:34 | |
partnership skills we'll be putting
there. The Chancellor was right in | 4:07:34 | 4:07:38 | |
that he was saying there is much to
be done in terms of maths and | 4:07:38 | 4:07:43 | |
computing. So the welcome to
continue there, so we can take the | 4:07:43 | 4:07:50 | |
challenge of the future... The other
thing that is clearly evident... | 4:07:50 | 4:07:54 | |
There is an awful lot in this book
in terms of the detail of this | 4:07:54 | 4:07:59 | |
budget. Often Chancellor 's hope
you'll pick a rabbit out of the hat, | 4:07:59 | 4:08:06 | |
the headline will be there, you
won't be looking at the detail. Much | 4:08:06 | 4:08:08 | |
of the good stuff is in the detail.
One thing worth mentioning is that | 4:08:08 | 4:08:13 | |
the Universal Credit announcements
today showed the Chancellor was | 4:08:13 | 4:08:19 | |
listening. He has to be right, it
has to be a modern welfare system. | 4:08:19 | 4:08:22 | |
So that work is always encouraging.
What is really interesting today, | 4:08:22 | 4:08:28 | |
already, one of the real experts,
David Orr, chief executive of the | 4:08:28 | 4:08:33 | |
National Housing foundation, which
owns most of the housing | 4:08:33 | 4:08:38 | |
associations, says we welcome the
changes to Universal Credit | 4:08:38 | 4:08:41 | |
including advance payments, it'll
make a direct and positive impact on | 4:08:41 | 4:08:45 | |
the lives of Housing association
tenants. I will give way. | 4:08:45 | 4:08:51 | |
I thank the member for giving way.
Whatever the motive behind Universal | 4:08:52 | 4:08:58 | |
Credit, in my wide reaching
constituency the lack of Internet | 4:08:58 | 4:09:05 | |
axis is there, it is an immovable
obstacle and it cuts against the | 4:09:05 | 4:09:09 | |
best intentions of government. Does
the government front bench recognise | 4:09:09 | 4:09:13 | |
this massive problem? The gentleman
is right, it is a problem alongside | 4:09:13 | 4:09:22 | |
infrastructure. You will have noted
a number of infrastructure | 4:09:22 | 4:09:25 | |
announcements today, that the
roll-out of broadband is being | 4:09:25 | 4:09:29 | |
accelerated. I'm pleased the front
bench is doing something about it. | 4:09:29 | 4:09:37 | |
At a constituency level can two
things, the announcement of the | 4:09:37 | 4:09:41 | |
Meyler review, and some money going
to Saint Georges mental health | 4:09:41 | 4:09:46 | |
trust, which will welcome, as will
the announcement that Crossrail two | 4:09:46 | 4:09:52 | |
is proceeding although at a pace
most of us would like to see faster | 4:09:52 | 4:09:55 | |
than the trains, we hope. I think
the key announcements around | 4:09:55 | 4:10:03 | |
infrastructure, what was
particularly interesting was the | 4:10:03 | 4:10:06 | |
amount of money government is giving
to transforming cities to provide | 4:10:06 | 4:10:09 | |
local transport and give cities and
may is the flexibility to express | 4:10:09 | 4:10:16 | |
the new urban design in terms of
incorporating new industries of the | 4:10:16 | 4:10:21 | |
future -- cities and mayors.
Especially local councils to have | 4:10:21 | 4:10:28 | |
discounted lending, for high-value
infrastructure projects that they | 4:10:28 | 4:10:36 | |
think will bring extra facilities to
local people. It is key. By not ring | 4:10:36 | 4:10:42 | |
fencing the money for any particular
project but allowing it to be | 4:10:42 | 4:10:48 | |
brought forward so some of the new
urban design ideas coming forward | 4:10:48 | 4:10:51 | |
can be utilised. I've been
particularly keen recently to | 4:10:51 | 4:10:57 | |
contribute to the housing and
finance institute's recent papers on | 4:10:57 | 4:11:00 | |
how you make sure you bring sites
forward in a way that brings the | 4:11:00 | 4:11:07 | |
housing and services that come with
it. Often what frustrates major and | 4:11:07 | 4:11:13 | |
sometimes small applications is the
fact that it isn't just the roads | 4:11:13 | 4:11:17 | |
and rail, it's the atrocity, water
and whatever. The recent report by | 4:11:17 | 4:11:21 | |
was part of landed on the
Chancellor's desk. -- it's the | 4:11:21 | 4:11:28 | |
electricity. It has made an impact
because I can see that he's | 4:11:28 | 4:11:34 | |
establishing Homes England. It may
have been missed by many. By | 4:11:34 | 4:11:38 | |
widening the scope and allowing the
government's major house-building | 4:11:38 | 4:11:44 | |
directive for infrastructure to have
a wide and encompassing remit will | 4:11:44 | 4:11:50 | |
be, I suspect, bringing forward a
number of projects more quickly, | 4:11:50 | 4:11:53 | |
especially a view combine that with
some measures that the Chancellor | 4:11:53 | 4:11:56 | |
has mentioned in the red book today.
The strategic sites fund is steadily | 4:11:56 | 4:12:03 | |
to be welcomed if you combine it
with the announcement of Homes | 4:12:03 | 4:12:06 | |
England. It seems there is some
grown-up and connected thinking in | 4:12:06 | 4:12:11 | |
the Treasury and I welcome it. My
friend on the front bench smiles but | 4:12:11 | 4:12:16 | |
he was always guilty of that even if
not always evident to everybody | 4:12:16 | 4:12:21 | |
else. Two other things have been
noticeable, clearly the problem with | 4:12:21 | 4:12:30 | |
housing market is supply, everyone
talks about it, and clearly the big | 4:12:30 | 4:12:35 | |
projects. If you look across your
constituencies there will be numbers | 4:12:35 | 4:12:39 | |
of small sites that aren't being
brought forward and that's the | 4:12:39 | 4:12:43 | |
reason we've seen the decline of the
small builder. The extension of the | 4:12:43 | 4:12:47 | |
house-building fund, small sites and
most importantly the loan guarantee | 4:12:47 | 4:12:53 | |
to small builders, is likely to
bring forward more sites and it may | 4:12:53 | 4:12:58 | |
be at an incremental level, it may
not mean, every ten, 25 and up and I | 4:12:58 | 4:13:05 | |
think it is particular welcome. Also
particularly welcome from a regional | 4:13:05 | 4:13:11 | |
basis, the first time there has been
some regional accept that house | 4:13:11 | 4:13:14 | |
prices are not the same everywhere
in the country and the announcement | 4:13:14 | 4:13:18 | |
on stamp duty I think will be
particularly welcome inside London. | 4:13:18 | 4:13:25 | |
The patient capital review. Often
the structures in the past that have | 4:13:25 | 4:13:31 | |
been put in place did not recognise
the need to have the emphasis on | 4:13:31 | 4:13:35 | |
high risk and high growth. It's
right that if you're going to get | 4:13:35 | 4:13:39 | |
these funds and advantages they
should be for high-growth, high | 4:13:39 | 4:13:41 | |
risk. It is a benefit to see the
announcement from the Chancellor, | 4:13:41 | 4:13:47 | |
especially if it works alongside
private industry to bring forward | 4:13:47 | 4:13:51 | |
7.5 million into the in screws of
the future. There is much to welcome | 4:13:51 | 4:13:56 | |
in the budget -- into the industries
of the future. The devil is in the | 4:13:56 | 4:14:00 | |
details and I commend it. It is a
pleasure to follow the honourable | 4:14:00 | 4:14:06 | |
member for Wimbledon although I'm
uncertain that we'll find a great | 4:14:06 | 4:14:09 | |
deal of agreement. In the run-up to
the budget, during the Chancellor's | 4:14:09 | 4:14:15 | |
speech today, we've heard a lot
about building a Briton fit for the | 4:14:15 | 4:14:19 | |
future. But many of my constituents
do not share his confidence in that | 4:14:19 | 4:14:27 | |
the government's proposals will
achieve such a vision. I've always | 4:14:27 | 4:14:32 | |
considered Enfield a fantastic place
to live, I've been there over 20 | 4:14:32 | 4:14:36 | |
years, and a great place to raise a
family. But for far too many Enfield | 4:14:36 | 4:14:43 | |
North residents now, especially
hard-working and hard-pressed | 4:14:43 | 4:14:45 | |
families, the last in years of Tory
austerity have led to greater | 4:14:45 | 4:14:52 | |
insecurity, poorer public services
and in some cases abject poverty. | 4:14:52 | 4:14:56 | |
Child poverty has risen to its
highest level since 2010. I | 4:14:56 | 4:15:01 | |
mentioned this earlier to the Prime
Minister in Prime Minister's | 4:15:01 | 4:15:04 | |
Questions when I pointed out that
these to Jude for fiscal studies and | 4:15:04 | 4:15:08 | |
the Joseph Rowntree foundation are
predicting an additional 1.2 million | 4:15:08 | 4:15:14 | |
children will be pushed into poverty
by 2021 on top of the four million | 4:15:14 | 4:15:18 | |
in 2015-60 -- the Institute for
Fiscal Studies. It is a moral issue | 4:15:18 | 4:15:27 | |
facing the country and this
government. Enfield is the worst | 4:15:27 | 4:15:31 | |
affected are in London with almost
one third of our children living in | 4:15:31 | 4:15:35 | |
poverty. And the Chancellor seems to
be emphatic that this was being | 4:15:35 | 4:15:41 | |
dealt with. Let me tell the house,
the comment on today's budget, the | 4:15:41 | 4:15:47 | |
Chief Executive of the child poverty
action group Alison Graham said this | 4:15:47 | 4:15:50 | |
should have been the budget that
ushered in much-needed structural | 4:15:50 | 4:15:55 | |
reform of Universal Credit to revise
the promised to strengthen the | 4:15:55 | 4:15:58 | |
rewards from work. That didn't
happen. She went on to say that our | 4:15:58 | 4:16:04 | |
new analysis finds that while
effective tax rates may have been | 4:16:04 | 4:16:08 | |
fruitful for some families, big
falls in family income caused by | 4:16:08 | 4:16:12 | |
cuts and changes to Universal Credit
have left many worse off overall, | 4:16:12 | 4:16:19 | |
overwhelming any gains from
increases in the National Living | 4:16:19 | 4:16:21 | |
Wage, personal tax allowances and
help for childcare. Families on | 4:16:21 | 4:16:26 | |
Universal Credit who want to get
better off through earnings gain | 4:16:26 | 4:16:31 | |
little from today's budget." I'm
more inclined to accept what the | 4:16:31 | 4:16:36 | |
Chief Executive of the child poverty
action group as to say then I am the | 4:16:36 | 4:16:40 | |
empty words of the Chancellor. I'm
very grateful to the honourable lady | 4:16:40 | 4:16:47 | |
for giving way. She is making a very
interesting point. I think when | 4:16:47 | 4:16:53 | |
she's had another Trinity to study
the impact on households, the | 4:16:53 | 4:16:56 | |
distribution of analysis
accompanying the budget, I'm sure | 4:16:56 | 4:16:59 | |
she'd want to welcome the analysis
showing that since 2010, households | 4:16:59 | 4:17:04 | |
across all income areas have seen
growth in their disposable incomes | 4:17:04 | 4:17:10 | |
on average. I think that is good
news and I'm sure she'd want to | 4:17:10 | 4:17:13 | |
welcome it. Well I think if the
honourable lady sat in my surgery | 4:17:13 | 4:17:22 | |
and listen to what families in
Enfield, over one third of children | 4:17:22 | 4:17:28 | |
living in poverty, I think she'd
find that disposable income is a | 4:17:28 | 4:17:30 | |
major problem and that most families
feel that the rising costs and | 4:17:30 | 4:17:36 | |
particularly in rentals have hugely
wiped out any possible gain. Nearly | 4:17:36 | 4:17:44 | |
six in ten Londoners in poverty live
in a working family. So the picture | 4:17:44 | 4:17:50 | |
of poverty has changed. These aren't
people who are what others sometimes | 4:17:50 | 4:17:54 | |
referred to as grounders, they are
working people trying to get on in | 4:17:54 | 4:17:59 | |
life. -- with referred to as
scroungers. The government failure | 4:17:59 | 4:18:09 | |
to address these issues has meant
that many families are unable to | 4:18:09 | 4:18:14 | |
just about manage today, let alone
build for tomorrow. Enfield is the | 4:18:14 | 4:18:19 | |
fourth highest borough in London for
food bank usage. Last year 5970 | 4:18:19 | 4:18:27 | |
43-day emergency food supplies were
provided to people in Enfield, of | 4:18:27 | 4:18:32 | |
which 2434 were given to children.
The roll-out of Universal Credit in | 4:18:32 | 4:18:38 | |
Enfield starting this month will
make a bad situation even worse. The | 4:18:38 | 4:18:41 | |
Trussell trust has said that
emergency food parcels is 30% higher | 4:18:41 | 4:18:49 | |
in areas where Universal Credit is
being implemented. Every week I see | 4:18:49 | 4:18:55 | |
so many hard-working families in my
constituency surgery who are living | 4:18:55 | 4:18:59 | |
on or below the breadline. I'd like
to say a few words about housing. A | 4:18:59 | 4:19:07 | |
great many people who have come to
see me, my constituents, see me | 4:19:07 | 4:19:11 | |
about problems with their housing or
problems related in some way to | 4:19:11 | 4:19:14 | |
their housing, especially those
living in the insecure private | 4:19:14 | 4:19:18 | |
rental sector. The risk of falling
into rent arrears and the risk of | 4:19:18 | 4:19:26 | |
eviction and debt because of
Universal Credit has only added to | 4:19:26 | 4:19:30 | |
their concerns. Stagnant wages, fast
rising rents and a crisis in the | 4:19:30 | 4:19:38 | |
housing supply have created a
perfect storm in Enfield. We have | 4:19:38 | 4:19:42 | |
the highest infection rates in the
capital. Levels of homelessness | 4:19:42 | 4:19:46 | |
accept and zis have risen by 82% in
the last two years alone. Enfield | 4:19:46 | 4:19:53 | |
has the second-highest number of
temporary accommodation placements | 4:19:53 | 4:19:56 | |
in London putting even more pressure
on an already strained housing | 4:19:56 | 4:19:59 | |
market. Again this isn't a record of
which the Chancellor can be proud. | 4:19:59 | 4:20:06 | |
And to referred to some of what he
said today, he said house prices are | 4:20:06 | 4:20:10 | |
increasingly out of reach for many.
They are, it takes too long to save | 4:20:10 | 4:20:15 | |
for a deposit, it does, if you can
do that at all. And rents absorb too | 4:20:15 | 4:20:22 | |
high a proportion of monthly income.
We've heard how the Office for | 4:20:22 | 4:20:28 | |
Budget Responsibility report makes
it clear that house prices will | 4:20:28 | 4:20:31 | |
actually rise because of the
measures today. And the member from | 4:20:31 | 4:20:35 | |
along the benches earlier asked
about whether anything was said | 4:20:35 | 4:20:41 | |
about houses for social rent. And
the member for Woking insisted that | 4:20:41 | 4:20:49 | |
it had been referred to. I'd look
through the speech and I could see | 4:20:49 | 4:20:53 | |
nothing that says that and I have
heard nothing. It does say, | 4:20:53 | 4:20:57 | |
including nearly 350,000 affordable
homes. The question is, affordable | 4:20:57 | 4:21:02 | |
for whom? There's nothing in here
about houses at a social rent and I | 4:21:02 | 4:21:08 | |
think that's a disgrace and
completely ignores the very | 4:21:08 | 4:21:11 | |
desperate need... We heard opposite
earlier that the amendment referring | 4:21:11 | 4:21:18 | |
to how bad it was in the 1970s and
learning lessons from there, the | 4:21:18 | 4:21:24 | |
lesson is that if I was brought up
in a council house in the 1970s, | 4:21:24 | 4:21:30 | |
which was a tremendous base for me
in my life, we should be proud of | 4:21:30 | 4:21:33 | |
that. Those opposite should learn
from that and treat them with some | 4:21:33 | 4:21:38 | |
respect. I completely agree with my
friend, I was also brought up in a | 4:21:38 | 4:21:43 | |
council house and we were proud of
our home and considered it the next | 4:21:43 | 4:21:46 | |
best thing to owning your own home.
We hardly drew a distinction on that | 4:21:46 | 4:21:51 | |
basis. That is the case today and
being able to offer anybody a | 4:21:51 | 4:21:56 | |
council house is becoming any
possibility. I want to make a bit of | 4:21:56 | 4:22:01 | |
progress. I want to say a few words
about public services, hard-working | 4:22:01 | 4:22:09 | |
families rely on our public services
but the veneers of austerity have | 4:22:09 | 4:22:14 | |
stretched the services to breaking
point. Enfield Council have tried | 4:22:14 | 4:22:20 | |
their best to protect families from
the immense pressures that they are | 4:22:20 | 4:22:23 | |
under. But given that their
government grant has been reduced by | 4:22:23 | 4:22:30 | |
£93 million, what they are able to
do is so much less and the level of | 4:22:30 | 4:22:35 | |
cuts local authorities are taking is
unsustainable. I noticed that when | 4:22:35 | 4:22:40 | |
we talk about social care, when we
talk about the environment, we talk | 4:22:40 | 4:22:46 | |
about policing, every time, the
answer we get from government is, | 4:22:46 | 4:22:51 | |
local authorities, local
authorities. They are slashing their | 4:22:51 | 4:22:54 | |
budgets on one hand and pushing all
their responsibilities to local | 4:22:54 | 4:22:58 | |
authorities on the other hand. They
know that this is a circle that | 4:22:58 | 4:23:03 | |
can't be squared, it's an impossible
task. They are undermining our | 4:23:03 | 4:23:08 | |
public services and local councils.
In education, our schools in | 4:23:08 | 4:23:14 | |
Enfield, primary and secondary, are
due to lose one third of £50 million | 4:23:14 | 4:23:21 | |
by 2020, heads will have to cut more
teaching posts, affecting every | 4:23:21 | 4:23:25 | |
child's ability to reach their best.
In health, my constituents deserve | 4:23:25 | 4:23:30 | |
good quality services but we've seen
Tory government closing the accident | 4:23:30 | 4:23:37 | |
and emergency and maternity unit and
cutting the number of beds by more | 4:23:37 | 4:23:40 | |
than 400. North Middlesex Hospital,
the other one that we now use and | 4:23:40 | 4:23:45 | |
rely on has been placed under
increasing pressure and constantly | 4:23:45 | 4:23:50 | |
faces a crisis as a result. The
Royal College of General | 4:23:50 | 4:23:55 | |
practitioners and says that Enfield
needs a deformed more general | 4:23:55 | 4:23:59 | |
practitioners by 2020 and I have
little confidence that the | 4:23:59 | 4:24:01 | |
government will provide that. In
terms of policing we've seen a 70% | 4:24:01 | 4:24:07 | |
increase in Enfield over the last
seven years in rising violent crime | 4:24:07 | 4:24:12 | |
and we've seen huge cuts in a number
of uniformed officers on our | 4:24:12 | 4:24:16 | |
streets. There is a relationship
between them. The government is | 4:24:16 | 4:24:21 | |
behaving in such a way, no mention
today of this, no mention | 4:24:21 | 4:24:27 | |
whatsoever... Sadiq Khan, the Mayor
of London, has done everything he | 4:24:27 | 4:24:31 | |
can to protect front-line policing.
The Chancellor failed to commit or | 4:24:31 | 4:24:36 | |
even mention additional funding for
London's police force. We're in a | 4:24:36 | 4:24:41 | |
situation where this government is
making London less safe for | 4:24:41 | 4:24:46 | |
Londoners, tourists and everybody
who lives in it. This is in a year | 4:24:46 | 4:24:50 | |
when we've seen five major terrorist
attacks. London is less safe under | 4:24:50 | 4:24:54 | |
the Tories. This budget helps
nobody. | 4:24:54 | 4:25:21 | |
This is a budget that ensures we
prepare for Brexit, prepare for the | 4:25:21 | 4:25:26 | |
future of this country. And to make
sure we embrace that future and get | 4:25:26 | 4:25:29 | |
the best of that future for our
children and grandchildren. I want | 4:25:29 | 4:25:35 | |
to commend the Chancellor for the
level of thought and consideration | 4:25:35 | 4:25:39 | |
he put into it and indeed, his
excellent budget speech and | 4:25:39 | 4:25:43 | |
presentation today. I think the
Chancellor did a brilliant job and | 4:25:43 | 4:25:47 | |
has brought forward a really
positive budget. I want to welcome | 4:25:47 | 4:25:50 | |
in particular the measures to ensure
there is an allegation of up to £3 | 4:25:50 | 4:25:59 | |
billion for preparations for Brexit.
This matters, as we know, the Dover | 4:25:59 | 4:26:03 | |
front line and Channel ports, to
make sure we have a smooth | 4:26:03 | 4:26:08 | |
transition and to make sure there
are no hold backs, no gridlock, no | 4:26:08 | 4:26:11 | |
queues. Now, I know some honourable
members in this house quite like the | 4:26:11 | 4:26:18 | |
idea of queues at the Channel ports,
they look forward to it being a | 4:26:18 | 4:26:22 | |
disaster on Brexit. Not this side of
the house. I'm glad to see this | 4:26:22 | 4:26:27 | |
Chancellor is making sure the
investment and money is available to | 4:26:27 | 4:26:31 | |
make sure we can avoid that
eventuality. Gridlock at Dover will | 4:26:31 | 4:26:36 | |
mean gridlock for the entire British
economy. If the Midlands engine | 4:26:36 | 4:26:40 | |
cannot get essential component it'll
come out. If the Northern Powerhouse | 4:26:40 | 4:26:46 | |
doesn't get the supplies it needs it
will cease to work. That is why it | 4:26:46 | 4:26:49 | |
is so important for each and every
one of us to do all we can to ensure | 4:26:49 | 4:26:54 | |
Brexit is a success and ensure we
get the investment we need and the | 4:26:54 | 4:26:58 | |
preparations we need to make sure we
undock seamlessly from the European | 4:26:58 | 4:27:04 | |
Union and go out into the world to
make a success for the future of | 4:27:04 | 4:27:10 | |
Britain. It really can be success.
Let's remember what's coming down | 4:27:10 | 4:27:14 | |
the tracks, so well placed for the
next revolution of automation, so | 4:27:14 | 4:27:18 | |
well-placed for autonomous vehicles,
for the fourth Industrial | 4:27:18 | 4:27:22 | |
Revolution. I know even the
opposition doesn't share my view, he | 4:27:22 | 4:27:27 | |
wants to tax innovation and put a
stop to all this, this idea that it | 4:27:27 | 4:27:31 | |
might create a transition in our
economy. That he is scared of this | 4:27:31 | 4:27:35 | |
prospect. But I would simply say
that is commonly the case whenever | 4:27:35 | 4:27:39 | |
there is change and evolution and
innovation in our economy, people | 4:27:39 | 4:27:44 | |
are scared. The Luddites were very
scared. People were scared at the | 4:27:44 | 4:27:49 | |
Industrial Revolution, people were
scared in the 1980s with the | 4:27:49 | 4:27:51 | |
revolution in our economy. Each time
we saw a leap forward, a massive | 4:27:51 | 4:27:58 | |
jump in productivity, each time we
saw our economy move ahead and | 4:27:58 | 4:28:01 | |
Britain become stronger, more
successful, leading in the world. | 4:28:01 | 4:28:07 | |
That is why the Chancellor is
absolutely right to set up such a | 4:28:07 | 4:28:11 | |
positive vision in this budget and
reject the Luddite frontbencher view | 4:28:11 | 4:28:16 | |
opposite. A Luddite view that I know
most of the backbenchers, who ought | 4:28:16 | 4:28:20 | |
to be on the front benches opposite,
reject as well. Even know their Dan | 4:28:20 | 4:28:24 | |
Lobb say it for fear of deselection,
for fear the Labour front bench will | 4:28:24 | 4:28:30 | |
mobilise membership and gain
momentum to sweep them away. Can I | 4:28:30 | 4:28:35 | |
say how much I welcome the
innovations made to help the least | 4:28:35 | 4:28:40 | |
well off? We've created 3 million
jobs since 2010. We've seen massive | 4:28:40 | 4:28:47 | |
increase in the personal allowance,
nearly at £12,000. We sing the | 4:28:47 | 4:28:51 | |
national living wage, which also
makes a huge difference. Close to my | 4:28:51 | 4:28:56 | |
heart, we're also seeing the fuel
duty frees, for years and years, so | 4:28:56 | 4:29:01 | |
since 2010 hard hard-working
motorists and white van drivers, | 4:29:01 | 4:29:06 | |
hauliers, are seeing a massive
reduction in the effective costs of | 4:29:06 | 4:29:10 | |
duty. Each car owner benefits to the
tune of £850 a year. For a person on | 4:29:10 | 4:29:18 | |
average wages it makes a massive
difference and for a person who has | 4:29:18 | 4:29:21 | |
to drive in remote areas such as
Scotland, as a member of the SNP | 4:29:21 | 4:29:26 | |
kindly decided to remain present to
our deliberations, I should mention | 4:29:26 | 4:29:30 | |
Scotland and I welcome the fact he's
in the house. In that area it makes | 4:29:30 | 4:29:35 | |
a huge difference to people who have
to drive much further to much more | 4:29:35 | 4:29:40 | |
about areas. I welcome the fact it
has made such a difference to | 4:29:40 | 4:29:43 | |
hard-working people. I also welcome
the fact we're taking firmer action | 4:29:43 | 4:29:48 | |
against large businesses which are
too often given to industrial tax | 4:29:48 | 4:29:54 | |
avoidance, which is an acceptable. I
want to welcome the work taken, | 4:29:54 | 4:30:01 | |
joint liability for online platforms
like Amazon, if enabled overseas | 4:30:01 | 4:30:07 | |
retailers to gain our VAT system,
get competitive advantage, against | 4:30:07 | 4:30:11 | |
smaller businesses in this country.
Put them out of business and not | 4:30:11 | 4:30:15 | |
paid their fair share of taxes. A
campaign cross-party with the Public | 4:30:15 | 4:30:20 | |
Accounts Committee members, many of
us have fought for a long time. I | 4:30:20 | 4:30:23 | |
really welcome the measures taken
today to bring justice and fairness | 4:30:23 | 4:30:28 | |
and a contested if playing field to
the tax system. Service competitive | 4:30:28 | 4:30:34 | |
playing field. The Chancellor is to
be commended for doing the right | 4:30:34 | 4:30:37 | |
thing, making sure we get revenues
as well. So we have extra cash for | 4:30:37 | 4:30:42 | |
schools and hospitals. I really want
to finish with one thing. I think we | 4:30:42 | 4:30:47 | |
do need to go further with these
multinationals. I think there is a | 4:30:47 | 4:30:52 | |
problem we have. Too many
multinationals think they are not | 4:30:52 | 4:30:55 | |
subject to the rule of law of this
country. They behave like they are | 4:30:55 | 4:30:59 | |
over mighty medieval barons that
laws don't apply to in some way. I | 4:30:59 | 4:31:04 | |
say this house should call time on
that viewpoint. We need to make sure | 4:31:04 | 4:31:09 | |
Amazon, Facebook, all the rest of
them, pay a fair share of taxes in | 4:31:09 | 4:31:16 | |
this country, that they should be
subject to the rule of law in this | 4:31:16 | 4:31:19 | |
country. That these social media
outfits should also be subject to | 4:31:19 | 4:31:23 | |
our laws of libel and laws against
terrorism. Laws that exist for the | 4:31:23 | 4:31:31 | |
protection of people and the fair
dealing and fair treatment of | 4:31:31 | 4:31:33 | |
people. I think we need to take a
stronger and firmer measure. They | 4:31:33 | 4:31:37 | |
will say, but we're in America, you
is. I say we're leaving the EU, we | 4:31:37 | 4:31:45 | |
can take back control of Internet
access and trade policy. We need to | 4:31:45 | 4:31:49 | |
think along those lines. I give way.
Would he therefore also like to | 4:31:49 | 4:31:55 | |
welcome the online VAT fraud
extending the powers to overseas | 4:31:55 | 4:32:00 | |
businesses which I think is a really
important part of bringing these | 4:32:00 | 4:32:05 | |
multinationals in the modern trading
areas into line. I think it's a very | 4:32:05 | 4:32:08 | |
good move. My right honourable
friend makes a powerful point, she | 4:32:08 | 4:32:12 | |
is absolutely right. There are
various areas where we need to look | 4:32:12 | 4:32:16 | |
to making sure social media outfits
in general. Generally technology | 4:32:16 | 4:32:21 | |
companies are subject to rules of
law on libel, an identity of who | 4:32:21 | 4:32:25 | |
they are rather than fake accounts
which bully people, mistreat people. | 4:32:25 | 4:32:30 | |
It is not acceptable. We should not
ever tolerate it. They should pay | 4:32:30 | 4:32:35 | |
their fair share of tax, be tougher
on terror, as we are, and seek to | 4:32:35 | 4:32:40 | |
join the government and support the
authorities in this country in | 4:32:40 | 4:32:43 | |
cracking down on terror. Cracking
down on crime and mistreatment of | 4:32:43 | 4:32:50 | |
our fellow people. They need to
respect our laws and values as a | 4:32:50 | 4:32:53 | |
country if they are trading year.
They need to respect that. Does the | 4:32:53 | 4:32:58 | |
honourable gentleman agree with me
there has been a significant rise in | 4:32:58 | 4:33:01 | |
anti-Semitism through social media?
And anti-Semitic abuse? This is a | 4:33:01 | 4:33:09 | |
disgraceful form of abuse and one we
should do something about | 4:33:09 | 4:33:12 | |
immediately. And the government
should act immediately. I completely | 4:33:12 | 4:33:17 | |
agree with the honourable lady,
she's absolutely right. The | 4:33:17 | 4:33:20 | |
disgusting and vile abuse we've
seen, anti-Semitism, racism, all of | 4:33:20 | 4:33:27 | |
those mistreatment of people, all of
it has got to stop. We need to have | 4:33:27 | 4:33:31 | |
a culture of respect on the
Internet. We need to not tolerate | 4:33:31 | 4:33:34 | |
those who will not show fair respect
and fair treatment on the Internet. | 4:33:34 | 4:33:39 | |
It's gone on too long, it's
unacceptable. It's got to stop. That | 4:33:39 | 4:33:44 | |
is why I say it's time to bring the
rule of law, the rule of law in this | 4:33:44 | 4:33:49 | |
house, this Parliament, this
country, to those on social media | 4:33:49 | 4:33:51 | |
and those multinationals not
currently playing by the rules as | 4:33:51 | 4:33:56 | |
they should. Catherine McIlorum. | 4:33:56 | 4:33:58 | |
I've been inundated with
correspondence about what they did | 4:34:03 | 4:34:05 | |
or didn't want to see in this budget
from concerns on beer duty, business | 4:34:05 | 4:34:10 | |
rates, fuel duty, green belt
protection, Equitable Life and | 4:34:10 | 4:34:15 | |
proposals to make the private rented
sector more secure and affordable. I | 4:34:15 | 4:34:18 | |
have diligently raised every issue
that I've been contacted about a | 4:34:18 | 4:34:23 | |
head of this budget. I'm quite sure
the Chancellor and his team may have | 4:34:23 | 4:34:26 | |
been concerned they gained a new pen
pal in the process. However, I think | 4:34:26 | 4:34:32 | |
most people would confess that they
did not have high hopes for this | 4:34:32 | 4:34:36 | |
budget. And the Chancellor in this
regard hasn't fallen short. This is | 4:34:36 | 4:34:43 | |
a budget that has its head buried in
the sand. When it comes to the | 4:34:43 | 4:34:46 | |
enormity of the challenges facing
our economy. The downgrading of our | 4:34:46 | 4:34:50 | |
growth productivity and investment
protections, and the imprecations | 4:34:50 | 4:34:56 | |
this will have flawed and airy
households up and down the country | 4:34:56 | 4:34:58 | |
as they continue to face the misery
of this cost of living squeeze. Not | 4:34:58 | 4:35:03 | |
to mention, the Brexit uncertainty
and its implications that loom | 4:35:03 | 4:35:09 | |
ahead. However, I wanted to focus
today on a number of issues of | 4:35:09 | 4:35:14 | |
particular interest to the
north-east. We finally received in | 4:35:14 | 4:35:20 | |
the budget today confirmation that
the government is minded to devolve | 4:35:20 | 4:35:24 | |
funding and power to the north of
time areas, ending months of | 4:35:24 | 4:35:28 | |
uncertainty around this issue. I
look forward to seeing the details | 4:35:28 | 4:35:31 | |
in the days and weeks ahead. I also
welcome the long-awaited | 4:35:31 | 4:35:38 | |
announcement of the funding to
replace the Tyne and Wear Metro's | 4:35:38 | 4:35:40 | |
rolling stock over a year after the
government received a full business | 4:35:40 | 4:35:44 | |
case from the region for this
investment. About 40 million | 4:35:44 | 4:35:48 | |
passengers use the Metro every year
but the poor reliability of the | 4:35:48 | 4:35:52 | |
system has been causing problems for
constituents on a daily basis and we | 4:35:52 | 4:35:55 | |
must have that investment in new
trains by 2021 if the Metro is not | 4:35:55 | 4:35:59 | |
to grind to a halt. I'd be grateful
if the Minister could confirm that | 4:35:59 | 4:36:04 | |
Nexus will be able to go to market
this year in order to meet the time | 4:36:04 | 4:36:09 | |
scale necessary given the first
tranche of funding won't be made | 4:36:09 | 4:36:11 | |
available until 2020. Despite clear
commitments from the former Prime | 4:36:11 | 4:36:20 | |
Minister and Chancellor, that
further devolution to Scotland | 4:36:20 | 4:36:26 | |
wouldn't be allowed to economically
disadvantaged parts of the UK, we | 4:36:26 | 4:36:28 | |
are still to receive from the
current Chancellor a commitment as | 4:36:28 | 4:36:32 | |
to how he intends to mitigate the
impact of devolving air passenger | 4:36:32 | 4:36:35 | |
duty to the Scottish Government and
English regional airports. Newcastle | 4:36:35 | 4:36:41 | |
International Airport is in my
constituency, it supports 19,000 | 4:36:41 | 4:36:44 | |
jobs across the north-east. It'll be
most affected, according to the | 4:36:44 | 4:36:49 | |
government own assessment, by the
Scottish devolution plans to cut | 4:36:49 | 4:36:53 | |
passenger duty. I believe, I first
raised this issue in Parliament | 4:36:53 | 4:37:00 | |
February 2016 and still haven't had
an answer. Wait and see isn't good | 4:37:00 | 4:37:05 | |
enough on this key, vital
infrastructure issue. Of course we | 4:37:05 | 4:37:08 | |
know the government is struggling to
make a decision on anything at the | 4:37:08 | 4:37:11 | |
moment. Trapped as it is within this
post Brexit election... | 4:37:11 | 4:37:17 | |
Post-election quagmire of its own
making. I'll give way. I thank the | 4:37:17 | 4:37:21 | |
honourable member for giving way.
Would she perhaps agree with me that | 4:37:21 | 4:37:25 | |
really the ideal solution to avoid
this, I speak as a Scottish MP, is | 4:37:25 | 4:37:30 | |
to get rid of the air duty
altogether across the UK? It's | 4:37:30 | 4:37:35 | |
incumbent on the government to come
up with a solution but I'm sure they | 4:37:35 | 4:37:39 | |
will take on board the honourable
gentleman's suggestion. Combined | 4:37:39 | 4:37:44 | |
with the continued uncertainty about
the Prime Minister's ability to | 4:37:44 | 4:37:47 | |
deliver a deal that won't have a
devastating impact on the UK economy | 4:37:47 | 4:37:52 | |
on investment, an jobs, I fear this
zombie government threatens to set | 4:37:52 | 4:37:58 | |
our economy back decades. If it
doesn't rapidly get a grip. | 4:37:58 | 4:38:03 | |
Particularly for net exporting
regions like the north-east. How can | 4:38:03 | 4:38:06 | |
we possibly compete for business on
a post Brexit global stage if we | 4:38:06 | 4:38:10 | |
struggle to make infrastructure
decisions that have been dragging on | 4:38:10 | 4:38:14 | |
for years in this country? Like on
Heathrow? And, finally, on Tyne & | 4:38:14 | 4:38:19 | |
Wear Metro. How can the government
be serious about rebalancing the | 4:38:19 | 4:38:24 | |
economy and creating a Northern
Powerhouse when countless businesses | 4:38:24 | 4:38:26 | |
are still none the wiser as to what
is actually being meant. Just last | 4:38:26 | 4:38:32 | |
week the north-east chair of the
Federation of small business said | 4:38:32 | 4:38:35 | |
three years on from the first
mention of the Northern Powerhouse, | 4:38:35 | 4:38:38 | |
it is still hard to find concrete
manifestations of it. With a week to | 4:38:38 | 4:38:42 | |
go until the budget, we'd like to
see the Chancellor takes a | 4:38:42 | 4:38:44 | |
meaningful steps towards getting the
show on the road. He also said, we | 4:38:44 | 4:38:49 | |
need cast-iron guarantees about EU
funding, post Brexit. Firms across | 4:38:49 | 4:38:54 | |
the north-east are benefiting from
EU support to the tune of millions | 4:38:54 | 4:38:57 | |
every year. One thing is for sure,
we won't have a Northern Powerhouse | 4:38:57 | 4:39:01 | |
unless that money is replaced. Yet
again, though, this budget does not | 4:39:01 | 4:39:05 | |
give the answer is that those
businesses need. | 4:39:05 | 4:39:13 | |
If we are to achieve our full
potential we need a Chancellor who | 4:39:13 | 4:39:17 | |
is on our side, who is prepared to
genuinely rebalance investment to | 4:39:17 | 4:39:21 | |
support sustainable economic growth
and one that can give businesses | 4:39:21 | 4:39:26 | |
confidence to invest. In
highlighting the pre-budget demands | 4:39:26 | 4:39:32 | |
the Northeast chamber of commerce
said that if the government is | 4:39:32 | 4:39:34 | |
serious about securing closing the
gap between London and the regions | 4:39:34 | 4:39:39 | |
there is a major work needed to
change the distribution of public | 4:39:39 | 4:39:44 | |
and private investment bank Canna
activity in the UK. This trend has | 4:39:44 | 4:39:47 | |
built up over decades. Listening to
the voice of businesses in our | 4:39:47 | 4:39:53 | |
region is essential to achieving
that. It is increasingly clear that | 4:39:53 | 4:39:58 | |
the challenges we face in reducing
unemployment in regions like the | 4:39:58 | 4:40:03 | |
Northeast that we must also solve
this productivity crisis, to tackle | 4:40:03 | 4:40:10 | |
the epidemic of low paid and
insecure work now affecting our | 4:40:10 | 4:40:13 | |
communities. Research published this
year by the TUC highlighted that the | 4:40:13 | 4:40:19 | |
Northeast has become the UK capital
of insecure work. With the | 4:40:19 | 4:40:24 | |
equivalent of two thirds of jobs
created in the region over the last | 4:40:24 | 4:40:27 | |
five years without guaranteed pay.
People's wages are lower now than in | 4:40:27 | 4:40:32 | |
real terms than they were in 2010
and it is little wonder that we are | 4:40:32 | 4:40:36 | |
seeing household debt rising and
more and more children living in | 4:40:36 | 4:40:40 | |
poverty. In conclusion, there is a
raft of issues we could have covered | 4:40:40 | 4:40:47 | |
today, many of which I have raised
countless times before and of which | 4:40:47 | 4:40:50 | |
we still have not seen any
meaningful solution in the budget. | 4:40:50 | 4:40:57 | |
Hundreds of families in Newcastle
suffered misery after the Universal | 4:40:57 | 4:41:00 | |
Credit roll-out. We've seen some
announcements but they don't go far | 4:41:00 | 4:41:06 | |
enough. Many in financial difficulty
as a result of this discrimination | 4:41:06 | 4:41:11 | |
against women. Local schools are
struggling to balance books because | 4:41:11 | 4:41:15 | |
of the government's real: budget
cuts. We have the NHS and social | 4:41:15 | 4:41:20 | |
care system on its knees with
services deteriorating because | 4:41:20 | 4:41:24 | |
funding has not been ring fenced.
They are overstretched and | 4:41:24 | 4:41:30 | |
undervalued, public sector workers
have seen a significant fall in | 4:41:30 | 4:41:32 | |
living standards as a result of this
long-standing 1% pay cap. It | 4:41:32 | 4:41:41 | |
includes constituents who are now
feeling the brunt of the £221 | 4:41:41 | 4:41:44 | |
million of cuts in Newcastle City
Council since 2010 and the £124 | 4:41:44 | 4:41:52 | |
million of cuts imposed on
Northumbria Police over the same | 4:41:52 | 4:41:54 | |
period with more to come. All of
which could have been addressed by | 4:41:54 | 4:42:00 | |
the Chancellor today if the
government were serious about | 4:42:00 | 4:42:01 | |
tackling tax avoidance and dealing
with the cost of living crisis. All | 4:42:01 | 4:42:07 | |
of which risks falling down further
down the government agenda as the | 4:42:07 | 4:42:11 | |
Chancellor sets aside £3 billion to
cover the anticipated costs of the | 4:42:11 | 4:42:16 | |
Prime Minister's potential failure
to secure a Brexit deal. All of | 4:42:16 | 4:42:20 | |
which are further away from being
addressed than ever before with | 4:42:20 | 4:42:25 | |
growth, business investment and
productivity forecasts all | 4:42:25 | 4:42:27 | |
dramatically downgraded. Once again
my constituents in Newcastle, and in | 4:42:27 | 4:42:34 | |
the north-east have been failed by
this budget and it has succeeded | 4:42:34 | 4:42:38 | |
only in living up to the
expectations of not being up to the | 4:42:38 | 4:42:42 | |
job. It is a pleasure to follow the
lady for Newcastle upon Tyne who | 4:42:42 | 4:42:50 | |
speaks so passionately about her
university town. I hope that there | 4:42:50 | 4:42:57 | |
will be some businesses and people
in her town who will benefit from | 4:42:57 | 4:43:00 | |
the measures in the budget,
particularly for example the changes | 4:43:00 | 4:43:04 | |
that have been made on Universal
Credit because I feel the Chancellor | 4:43:04 | 4:43:08 | |
has listened and I'm sure he would
welcome feedback. I think this has | 4:43:08 | 4:43:14 | |
been a budget for change and I would
particularly like to welcome some | 4:43:14 | 4:43:19 | |
changes. For example, the additional
money that has come in for the | 4:43:19 | 4:43:26 | |
Brexit preparations, that is a major
change for this country. £700 | 4:43:26 | 4:43:31 | |
million for the immediate
preparations with £3 billion | 4:43:31 | 4:43:37 | |
promised for the future, very
important because we must try and | 4:43:37 | 4:43:41 | |
create an environment where we don't
have uncertainty about the economic | 4:43:41 | 4:43:44 | |
impact. The money will go towards
providing more certainty in that | 4:43:44 | 4:43:51 | |
area. Can I welcome the ONS report
accompanying the budget today which | 4:43:51 | 4:43:55 | |
said that the public finances have
performed better than expected. I | 4:43:55 | 4:44:00 | |
think that was a welcome relief for
the Chancellor. I think that the | 4:44:00 | 4:44:05 | |
forecast for jobs was also to be
welcomed because they estimate that | 4:44:05 | 4:44:10 | |
employment will increase from 31.7
million in 2016, two dirty to buy 7 | 4:44:10 | 4:44:17 | |
million in 2022 -- to 2.7 million.
£7 million for further education | 4:44:17 | 4:44:26 | |
ologies and the increase in computer
science teachers and the maths | 4:44:26 | 4:44:30 | |
uplift and schools building on
apprenticeships, which will help to | 4:44:30 | 4:44:36 | |
equip young people for those jobs so
they can take advantage of the | 4:44:36 | 4:44:40 | |
growth in business. I also think
that the announcement of research | 4:44:40 | 4:44:46 | |
and develop that for business,
especially in driverless cars will | 4:44:46 | 4:44:49 | |
be of great use, not only to people
who are early adopters of new | 4:44:49 | 4:44:56 | |
technology but also of those people
who are disabled and getting on in | 4:44:56 | 4:45:00 | |
our society. I think that they will
bring great innovations which will | 4:45:00 | 4:45:05 | |
assist them. I mentioned in an
intervention from my friend the | 4:45:05 | 4:45:09 | |
member for Dover, and I welcome the
vat number display provisions that | 4:45:09 | 4:45:19 | |
were mentioned in the red book. I
commend my constituent Richard Allen | 4:45:19 | 4:45:24 | |
who I know has played a major part
in providing information to the | 4:45:24 | 4:45:29 | |
Treasury and assisting and improving
and tightening up the law in this | 4:45:29 | 4:45:35 | |
area so that people who owe money to
the Exchequer are held to account. | 4:45:35 | 4:45:41 | |
The National Health Service is very
important in my area and I was | 4:45:41 | 4:45:48 | |
pleased to see there was more money
for that health service. Can I in | 4:45:48 | 4:45:52 | |
particular welcome that the Chilton
and Aylesbury Vale CCG bid for eight | 4:45:52 | 4:45:57 | |
private community care homes I
believe has been accept it and that | 4:45:57 | 4:46:02 | |
will be a welcome addition to the
health of my constituency. But it is | 4:46:02 | 4:46:12 | |
change that worries me in this
budget and therefore I have two | 4:46:12 | 4:46:17 | |
turned to the national
infrastructure commission report on | 4:46:17 | 4:46:22 | |
Cambridge: Milton Keynes and the
Oxford corridor which identifies a | 4:46:22 | 4:46:27 | |
lack of housing activity putting
future success at risk. The report | 4:46:27 | 4:46:31 | |
emphasises a joint apology required
in infrastructure and homes and | 4:46:31 | 4:46:35 | |
recommends the construction of an
east-west rail project, an Oxford | 4:46:35 | 4:46:43 | |
Cambridge Expressway, accompanied by
a massive house-building programme | 4:46:43 | 4:46:45 | |
which could see as many as 150,000
houses coming into Buckinghamshire. | 4:46:45 | 4:46:51 | |
I acknowledge the desperate need for
affordable housing, we've all had | 4:46:51 | 4:46:54 | |
people in our surgeries saying that
children can't get houses in their | 4:46:54 | 4:46:58 | |
area. We know that we need more and
I support connectivity but the | 4:46:58 | 4:47:05 | |
government should step back and see
what's happening in Buckinghamshire | 4:47:05 | 4:47:08 | |
so we can have a cohesive approach
to the area. Admin eja Tivoli we are | 4:47:08 | 4:47:13 | |
facing a potential Wii organisation
of local government -- | 4:47:13 | 4:47:18 | |
administratively. Something may be
announced before Christmas which | 4:47:18 | 4:47:22 | |
means any changes would be limited
before the May 2020 elections which | 4:47:22 | 4:47:28 | |
would take a lot of time and effort
-- would be implemented. At the same | 4:47:28 | 4:47:33 | |
time there is the added burdens
placed on them by HS2, which is not | 4:47:33 | 4:47:39 | |
a minor project. It is causing,
using up a lot of resources in the | 4:47:39 | 4:47:47 | |
county. Local Enterprise
Partnerships are not exactly | 4:47:47 | 4:47:51 | |
streamlined, we have two. Although
one has done sterling work on the | 4:47:51 | 4:47:59 | |
economic plan, they are going to
find that they will have to make | 4:47:59 | 4:48:04 | |
some changes if the infrastructure
commission's plans is accepted and | 4:48:04 | 4:48:10 | |
put into action. The environment is
also a very fragile in the Chilterns | 4:48:10 | 4:48:16 | |
and the new proposals are for
£150,000 150,000 -- 150,000 houses | 4:48:16 | 4:48:28 | |
which looks to be bigger than Milton
Keynes already as well as doubling | 4:48:28 | 4:48:31 | |
the size of Milton Keynes. Our
environment in Buckinghamshire is of | 4:48:31 | 4:48:36 | |
great importance to residents and
provides many people who come to the | 4:48:36 | 4:48:40 | |
area of outstanding national beauty
with an away since of natural beauty | 4:48:40 | 4:48:44 | |
and the fact that it has received a
national designation should mean it | 4:48:44 | 4:48:48 | |
has been highest level of
protection. The report emphasises | 4:48:48 | 4:48:52 | |
connectivity and this was one of the
reasons for HS2 but there is no | 4:48:52 | 4:48:57 | |
connection proposed between the
east-west rail link and HS2. I think | 4:48:57 | 4:49:01 | |
there should be an immediate review
of whether it is desirable to link | 4:49:01 | 4:49:05 | |
these railways and if so, what
changes would be required for HS2. | 4:49:05 | 4:49:12 | |
Had the proposed route through
Milton Keynes been accepted, it | 4:49:12 | 4:49:18 | |
would have reduced the environmental
damage in Buckinghamshire. Change | 4:49:18 | 4:49:21 | |
needs to be managed and there are
currently too many changes and | 4:49:21 | 4:49:26 | |
initiatives coming down the track
which will impact in a major way on | 4:49:26 | 4:49:30 | |
the Co-op Buckinghamshire. Unless
matters are coordinated I think we | 4:49:30 | 4:49:35 | |
may face unsustainable burdens that
do the reverse of what was intended | 4:49:35 | 4:49:40 | |
by some of the welcome announcements
today. I'd be grateful if the | 4:49:40 | 4:49:45 | |
Chancellor could meet with me and
other members of Parliament in | 4:49:45 | 4:49:48 | |
Buckinghamshire to look at how we
can maximise the opportunities that | 4:49:48 | 4:49:52 | |
he's providing for the country and
county in this budget rather than | 4:49:52 | 4:49:58 | |
the local resources being swamped by
a change. This is a budget for | 4:49:58 | 4:50:02 | |
change but it must be managed
effectively to achieve the | 4:50:02 | 4:50:05 | |
beneficial outcomes that we would
all like to see. Thank you for the | 4:50:05 | 4:50:14 | |
opportunity to contribute to this
important debate today. Although I | 4:50:14 | 4:50:19 | |
think across the benches on this
side of the house we have heard | 4:50:19 | 4:50:22 | |
considerable pessimism, there is --
I rise to welcome the statement from | 4:50:22 | 4:50:29 | |
the Chancellor today and in
particular the increased investment | 4:50:29 | 4:50:32 | |
across the United Kingdom which will
bring an additional £660 million of | 4:50:32 | 4:50:39 | |
benefit to Northern Ireland. This is
much needed. It has been a difficult | 4:50:39 | 4:50:45 | |
number of years. Significant budget
pressures across all departments in | 4:50:45 | 4:50:51 | |
Northern Ireland combined with a
constructed or limited real term | 4:50:51 | 4:50:57 | |
budget growth every year has led to
significant challenges. Hard and | 4:50:57 | 4:51:01 | |
difficult decisions have to be made
and it was people and services in | 4:51:01 | 4:51:09 | |
Northern Ireland that suffered. I
support the principle of fiscal | 4:51:09 | 4:51:12 | |
responsibility but austerity did
feel punishing too many. This was | 4:51:12 | 4:51:19 | |
especially acute in Northern Ireland
because we were still struggling to | 4:51:19 | 4:51:22 | |
emerge from decades of
underinvestment due to a long period | 4:51:22 | 4:51:26 | |
of violence. We were still trying to
rebalance our too public sector | 4:51:26 | 4:51:36 | |
reliant economy. I welcome the
fiscal loosening that was outlined | 4:51:36 | 4:51:39 | |
today in the budget. We would like
to see further loosening in relation | 4:51:39 | 4:51:44 | |
to the years ahead, especially in
reference to the plight of the Waspy | 4:51:44 | 4:51:54 | |
women in relation to pensions.
Additional pay sector award funds | 4:51:54 | 4:52:02 | |
should not come from within budgets
and put pressure on front line | 4:52:02 | 4:52:04 | |
services. In relation to this
specific budget there is an emphasis | 4:52:04 | 4:52:11 | |
in relation to the capital and in
Northern Ireland we have huge | 4:52:11 | 4:52:14 | |
pressures, especially in relation to
education and health which requires | 4:52:14 | 4:52:18 | |
revenue resource investment along
with capital. I acknowledge that | 4:52:18 | 4:52:25 | |
capital is very important in terms
of growing the economy and investing | 4:52:25 | 4:52:28 | |
in the infrastructure but it is the
resource pressures that often impact | 4:52:28 | 4:52:33 | |
on front line services and I hope
that in the years ahead we'll | 4:52:33 | 4:52:36 | |
continue to have very positive
conversations in relation to easing | 4:52:36 | 4:52:41 | |
on those matters. Public services,
especially health, need significant | 4:52:41 | 4:52:48 | |
investment to transform and become
truly fit for purpose. Northern | 4:52:48 | 4:52:54 | |
Ireland is in a slightly different
situation to some others across the | 4:52:54 | 4:52:58 | |
house in that we will have a Barnett
consequential from the budget so | 4:52:58 | 4:53:03 | |
there will be less ability in
relation to be prioritised Asian of | 4:53:03 | 4:53:08 | |
those funds and that £660 million --
prioritisation. An aspect of the | 4:53:08 | 4:53:16 | |
budget will benefit Northern Ireland
in a positive way, for example | 4:53:16 | 4:53:20 | |
Northern Ireland is ready to play
its part in the technological | 4:53:20 | 4:53:26 | |
revolution to make the UK the true
world leader in this area. This is | 4:53:26 | 4:53:30 | |
indeed the future. | 4:53:30 | 4:53:35 | |
We have very highly skilled base,
and employment base, we have low | 4:53:35 | 4:53:41 | |
staff turnover and we have much
innovation. Our universities, such | 4:53:41 | 4:53:46 | |
as Queens University in my own
constituency of south Belfast, are | 4:53:46 | 4:53:50 | |
prepared and determine to play a
full part in this digital and tech | 4:53:50 | 4:53:55 | |
revolution. I also welcome that the
Budget goes some way in | 4:53:55 | 4:53:59 | |
acknowledging the difficulty of the
way the last two years have been in | 4:53:59 | 4:54:06 | |
Northern Ireland. The addition of
the pay cap and I welcome in | 4:54:06 | 4:54:12 | |
relation to nurses' pay. The stamp
duty exemption and increase in | 4:54:12 | 4:54:19 | |
personal allowance will bring much
support to those who are genuinely | 4:54:19 | 4:54:22 | |
is struggling. These will apply
directly in Northern Ireland. In | 4:54:22 | 4:54:26 | |
conclusion, I just want to touch on
the issue about the Barnett | 4:54:26 | 4:54:31 | |
consequential and the decisions
which need to be made in Northern | 4:54:31 | 4:54:34 | |
Ireland in relation to the Budget.
It grieves me that there is no | 4:54:34 | 4:54:39 | |
executive in place to examine the
proposals today and make those | 4:54:39 | 4:54:42 | |
decisions. We need an executive to
look at what is coming forward from | 4:54:42 | 4:54:49 | |
this Budget, to listen to the people
on the ground in Northern Ireland, | 4:54:49 | 4:54:54 | |
organisations, those who benefit
from public services, those whose | 4:54:54 | 4:54:58 | |
businesses need to grow. We need
somebody to listen and to prioritise | 4:54:58 | 4:55:05 | |
into our own Northern Ireland
Budget. We in the Democratic | 4:55:05 | 4:55:09 | |
Unionist Party I doing everything we
can to bring government back to | 4:55:09 | 4:55:13 | |
Northern Ireland. But we will not
and cannot be held to ransom by | 4:55:13 | 4:55:20 | |
narrow and divisive cultural
identity politics. This is a | 4:55:20 | 4:55:23 | |
terrible situation in Northern
Ireland. Although that has been much | 4:55:23 | 4:55:27 | |
talk in the House today about the
impact of wrecks it, in Northern | 4:55:27 | 4:55:31 | |
Ireland, we are in the twilight
zone. We have a senior civil | 4:55:31 | 4:55:35 | |
servants in charge of departments,
with no accountability, because we | 4:55:35 | 4:55:40 | |
neither have direct rule ministers
or local ministers. There is no | 4:55:40 | 4:55:46 | |
constitutional democratic
accountability in Northern Ireland | 4:55:46 | 4:55:48 | |
for public spend and there hasn't
been for ten months. This is an | 4:55:48 | 4:55:53 | |
appalling situation, and I urge the
Government to step in and do | 4:55:53 | 4:55:58 | |
everything you can to either support
the Executive in terms of getting | 4:55:58 | 4:56:02 | |
re-established, or bring in direct
rule ministers, because this | 4:56:02 | 4:56:06 | |
democratic accountability cannot
continue. | 4:56:06 | 4:56:13 | |
Which she perhaps agree with some
suggestions that may be the MLAs pay | 4:56:13 | 4:56:19 | |
should be suspended until they
managed to get together and form the | 4:56:19 | 4:56:21 | |
Executive? I have only three minutes
left so I will not get into that | 4:56:21 | 4:56:27 | |
specific issue. Only to say that
many MLAs across Northern Ireland | 4:56:27 | 4:56:32 | |
are working hard to try and restore
government in Northern Ireland, and | 4:56:32 | 4:56:36 | |
to work to deliver to people in
very, very difficult circumstances. | 4:56:36 | 4:56:41 | |
The entire of Northern Ireland are
being held to ransom. It is health | 4:56:41 | 4:56:46 | |
and education which is being held to
ransom. This is all the more | 4:56:46 | 4:56:50 | |
important in relation to Brexit. I
welcome the investment in terms of | 4:56:50 | 4:56:54 | |
the Budget today, in terms of
ensuring a sensible and positive | 4:56:54 | 4:56:58 | |
Brexit. That will require
investment. That is particularly | 4:56:58 | 4:57:03 | |
important in Northern Ireland.
However, again, because of the lack | 4:57:03 | 4:57:07 | |
of a Northern Ireland Executive, it
is incredibly difficult to be making | 4:57:07 | 4:57:10 | |
our case and ensuring we get the
best possible position to Northern | 4:57:10 | 4:57:17 | |
Ireland. There has been a lot of
nonsense spoken about this issue in | 4:57:17 | 4:57:19 | |
recent days, and in fact, in the
Republic of Ireland, almost hysteria | 4:57:19 | 4:57:24 | |
has been whipped up in relation to
this. It is vitally important in | 4:57:24 | 4:57:28 | |
terms of the economy, and in terms
of the report today, things will be | 4:57:28 | 4:57:33 | |
challenging in terms of growth,
things will be challenging in terms | 4:57:33 | 4:57:37 | |
of productivity, but we are
absolutely keen, we are absolutely | 4:57:37 | 4:57:41 | |
there to fight the Northern Ireland
through all of this and get the best | 4:57:41 | 4:57:45 | |
possible deal in relation to Brexit.
In conclusion, it is a disgrace that | 4:57:45 | 4:57:51 | |
there is no finance committee
sitting in place to examine this | 4:57:51 | 4:57:55 | |
Budget. It is a disgrace that there
are no ministers to make decisions. | 4:57:55 | 4:57:59 | |
It is the people on the ground who
are suffering and they are suffering | 4:57:59 | 4:58:02 | |
because Sinn Fein are refusing to go
back into government. Today, and I | 4:58:02 | 4:58:09 | |
was astounded by this, our finance
minister, who is currently not in | 4:58:09 | 4:58:13 | |
place, instead of examining this
Budget, instead of bringing forward | 4:58:13 | 4:58:16 | |
proposals, and we should have at
this time in Northern Ireland, a | 4:58:16 | 4:58:20 | |
Budget being brought forward for the
Northern Ireland Assembly for next | 4:58:20 | 4:58:23 | |
year, instead of doing that, what is
he doing today? He is standing | 4:58:23 | 4:58:32 | |
outside Queens University at a
student protest. That is a disgrace. | 4:58:32 | 4:58:35 | |
People are suffering. I welcome the
Budget statement today. We will | 4:58:35 | 4:58:44 | |
continue to work in Northern Ireland
to ensure there is the best deal. | 4:58:44 | 4:58:48 | |
This is a bad solution. The
Government needs to work with us to | 4:58:48 | 4:58:52 | |
find solutions and deliver across
all communities in Northern Ireland. | 4:58:52 | 4:58:58 | |
Thank you, Mr Speaker. It is a
particular pleasure to follow the | 4:58:58 | 4:59:02 | |
honourable member for Belfast South.
Michael, I want to see a devolved | 4:59:02 | 4:59:06 | |
government making decisions again
and then examined around Northern | 4:59:06 | 4:59:12 | |
Ireland -- like her, I want to see a
devolved government. It is | 4:59:12 | 4:59:19 | |
unacceptable and it is right to be
moved forward. She is right to make | 4:59:19 | 4:59:23 | |
our observations about the roles one
or two other parties have made who | 4:59:23 | 4:59:30 | |
are not here. With that, I go on to
welcoming the Budget, and also the | 4:59:30 | 4:59:41 | |
general tenet that it set going out.
I want to look at particularly what | 4:59:41 | 4:59:46 | |
it means for those living in my own
constituency. That means starting | 4:59:46 | 4:59:50 | |
with the impact that raising the
basic allowance will have for many | 4:59:50 | 4:59:54 | |
families. It is hard to think that
not that long ago, someone earning | 4:59:54 | 4:59:59 | |
less than £7,000 the year would be
deemed to be earning enough to pay | 4:59:59 | 5:00:03 | |
income tax. Now the threshold is
heading up to £11,800, it means | 5:00:03 | 5:00:08 | |
those on low pay keeping more of
what they are earning. And also the | 5:00:08 | 5:00:16 | |
freezing fuel duty as well, that
makes a difference for those on low | 5:00:16 | 5:00:20 | |
incomes for him transport will be an
increasing cost. It is not just | 5:00:20 | 5:00:24 | |
those who are car drivers, it is
those who use all forms of transport | 5:00:24 | 5:00:29 | |
which rely on fuel. It is very
welcome to see this. I am conscious, | 5:00:29 | 5:00:36 | |
given my PPS role, I have to
restrict some of what I say around | 5:00:36 | 5:00:39 | |
the housing element, but it is
absolutely right that we welcome the | 5:00:39 | 5:00:42 | |
huge amount that has been done and
has been announced today. Certainly | 5:00:42 | 5:00:47 | |
getting towards 300,000 homes a year
would be a great achievement and | 5:00:47 | 5:00:50 | |
would make a real difference.
Certainly, it is they welcome to see | 5:00:50 | 5:00:54 | |
some of the reviews that will be
launched particularly looking at | 5:00:54 | 5:01:02 | |
some of the issues in the planning
system. And I certainly welcome the | 5:01:02 | 5:01:04 | |
change on stamp duty. That tax
change will make it easier for many | 5:01:04 | 5:01:07 | |
first-time buyers. When I bought my
first home, one of the nasty | 5:01:07 | 5:01:11 | |
surprises you get is you think you
have got the money together to | 5:01:11 | 5:01:14 | |
purchase the property, you have your
deposit and then you are presented | 5:01:14 | 5:01:18 | |
with a lovely bill of several
thousand pounds which you have to | 5:01:18 | 5:01:22 | |
pay almost immediately, putting
instant pressure on those who have | 5:01:22 | 5:01:24 | |
already had to save for a higher
deposit. I have heard some of the | 5:01:24 | 5:01:29 | |
complaints from those opposite. If
they feel that way there will be a | 5:01:29 | 5:01:41 | |
chance to divide the House and a
chance for them to tell the | 5:01:41 | 5:01:44 | |
constituents why they have opposed
this change, why they will tell | 5:01:44 | 5:01:46 | |
first-time buyers that they do not
think it is the right idea. It is a | 5:01:46 | 5:01:49 | |
bit strange to spend the afternoon
in the House of Commons complaining | 5:01:49 | 5:01:52 | |
about something and then to go away
and support it. It will make a | 5:01:52 | 5:01:54 | |
difference to first-time buyers in
Torbay. Given the age demographic of | 5:01:54 | 5:01:59 | |
the population in the bay it is
welcome to hear about funding and | 5:01:59 | 5:02:03 | |
the extra money for winter
pressures. I hope that can be used | 5:02:03 | 5:02:08 | |
particularly around parts of A&E and
also looking at some of the | 5:02:08 | 5:02:12 | |
pressures in each area which are
created by its demographics. Torbay | 5:02:12 | 5:02:16 | |
is very much driven by an older
population. Other areas will have | 5:02:16 | 5:02:20 | |
different challenges which require
funding to be put in. There is an | 5:02:20 | 5:02:24 | |
ongoing discussion about social
care, but I think it is right to say | 5:02:24 | 5:02:27 | |
that will never be resolved in just
one Budget. That is something which | 5:02:27 | 5:02:31 | |
needs to be part of a long-term
discussion, probably on a | 5:02:31 | 5:02:35 | |
cross-party basis to provide a
solution, as it is something that no | 5:02:35 | 5:02:38 | |
one parliament will be able to | 5:02:38 | 5:02:49 | |
resolve in a way that will give
confidence to the public going | 5:02:51 | 5:02:54 | |
forward. The effort is an -- the
effort to increase productivity is | 5:02:54 | 5:02:56 | |
welcome. I can see that the
investment on the link road has | 5:02:56 | 5:02:59 | |
helped people getting between the
Newton Abbot and Torquay. It shows | 5:02:59 | 5:03:02 | |
the difference in the structure
investment can have I hope we will | 5:03:02 | 5:03:05 | |
see more of that, particularly with
the 8 billion productivity | 5:03:05 | 5:03:08 | |
investment fund being announced.
Would he not share my disappointment | 5:03:08 | 5:03:17 | |
at the paltry recognition of the
south-west that we're seeing today's | 5:03:17 | 5:03:20 | |
Budget? It does not even warrant a
headline in the red book. What does | 5:03:20 | 5:03:25 | |
this say about this government's
hole approach to the economy? I | 5:03:25 | 5:03:35 | |
thank the member for Bristol South's
intervention. I can just say two | 5:03:35 | 5:03:43 | |
words: Stonehenge tunnel. Decades
have been wasted on that. I will be | 5:03:43 | 5:03:50 | |
judging this government on what it
does, not what it spends. Moving | 5:03:50 | 5:03:54 | |
back to the point, I also welcome
the 2.3 billion which will be going | 5:03:54 | 5:03:58 | |
into research and development and I
hope that will include in the long | 5:03:58 | 5:04:02 | |
run, having ended is to to to
technology based around the South | 5:04:02 | 5:04:07 | |
Devon College in Paignton,
delivering some of the highest | 5:04:07 | 5:04:09 | |
levels of skills training in our
local community. Torbay is famous | 5:04:09 | 5:04:14 | |
for its beaches and tourism
industry, but also has a vibrant the | 5:04:14 | 5:04:20 | |
tonics industry which needs more
people with skills and also knowing | 5:04:20 | 5:04:24 | |
that their training will be the high
scale will make it more likely that | 5:04:24 | 5:04:27 | |
they would wish to come and invest
in our area and grow and expand and | 5:04:27 | 5:04:32 | |
give local people those
opportunities. I know it is a baby | 5:04:32 | 5:04:36 | |
that is going in, literally as we
speak, and I think it very welcome. | 5:04:36 | 5:04:42 | |
Turning to other issues in the bay,
there are some problems when it | 5:04:42 | 5:04:47 | |
comes around alcohol and substance
abuse. Therefore it is welcome to | 5:04:47 | 5:04:51 | |
hear the Chancellor's comments
around certain super-strength | 5:04:51 | 5:04:55 | |
ciders. Certainly, there are issues
on preloading which affect our | 5:04:55 | 5:04:59 | |
night-time economy, and many of
those are connected to side which is | 5:04:59 | 5:05:03 | |
cheaper than mineral water but has a
strength far stronger than most | 5:05:03 | 5:05:07 | |
other things on the market. I think
it is right, they approach the | 5:05:07 | 5:05:11 | |
Chancellor is making on it. It will
be interesting to see what comes out | 5:05:11 | 5:05:16 | |
of Scotland and what happens there.
I have to say I'm not at the moment | 5:05:16 | 5:05:20 | |
persuaded by the arguments on
minimum pricing but it will be | 5:05:20 | 5:05:23 | |
interesting to see the difference
that is made in Scotland, and | 5:05:23 | 5:05:26 | |
something that can be learned from
in future. It is it works, we'll | 5:05:26 | 5:05:30 | |
have an example, and if it doesn't,
the other way round, we will have an | 5:05:30 | 5:05:35 | |
example. Also welcomed the
announcement is around Universal | 5:05:35 | 5:05:37 | |
Credit and the changes being made
there. It will be lamented in Torbay | 5:05:37 | 5:05:41 | |
and rolled out a full service in May
2018 and some of the changes being | 5:05:41 | 5:05:46 | |
made a very welcome. I will look
forward to hearing the statement | 5:05:46 | 5:05:49 | |
tomorrow to get some more detail on
that, but I think again it is good | 5:05:49 | 5:05:53 | |
to know that the Government has
listened, particularly to some of | 5:05:53 | 5:06:03 | |
the comments that were made in last
Thursday's debate in the Chamber. | 5:06:03 | 5:06:05 | |
Torbay is famous as well for many
small businesses and therefore, no | 5:06:05 | 5:06:08 | |
change to the VAT threshold is
something that people will welcome, | 5:06:08 | 5:06:10 | |
and keeps many small businesses
going and I also welcome the action | 5:06:10 | 5:06:17 | |
to crack down on online tax
avoidance. That is a key issue | 5:06:17 | 5:06:22 | |
because it does not make any sense
that you can avoid tax if you have a | 5:06:22 | 5:06:26 | |
very large website. If you have a
small business based in a shopping | 5:06:26 | 5:06:30 | |
centre in Torbay, there is little
you can do to avoid it. Again, it is | 5:06:30 | 5:06:35 | |
welcome. And given some of the
comments we have had today, if some | 5:06:35 | 5:06:38 | |
of these things were so easy to deal
with, why weren't they in the past? | 5:06:38 | 5:06:49 | |
It is welcome to see the change. It
was a cross-party spirit in the | 5:06:49 | 5:06:52 | |
Public Accounts Committee, and some
of the rhetoric we are hearing in | 5:06:52 | 5:06:54 | |
this chamber does not really fit
with some people's records in terms | 5:06:54 | 5:06:57 | |
of dealing with these areas. A final
one, having spent the weekend | 5:06:57 | 5:07:02 | |
talking with Daniel Maddox who is
campaigning around the issue of | 5:07:02 | 5:07:07 | |
potholes, it is always good to see
the reference in the red book to the | 5:07:07 | 5:07:12 | |
45 million to dealing with them.
Although it might be minor compared | 5:07:12 | 5:07:16 | |
with building a new tunnel around
Stonehenge or delivering a major | 5:07:16 | 5:07:20 | |
piece of infrastructure, but it is
the sort of thing that annoys those | 5:07:20 | 5:07:23 | |
who pay their taxes and want to see
a service in return. I do think this | 5:07:23 | 5:07:28 | |
is a welcome Budget. It will help
people which their aspirations. It | 5:07:28 | 5:07:32 | |
will help people buy their home and
it is a Budget which will help | 5:07:32 | 5:07:36 | |
Britain move forward and have
technology industries and a vibrant | 5:07:36 | 5:07:39 | |
private sector as we approach
Brexit. | 5:07:39 | 5:07:51 | |
That is a welcome Budget. It is a
Budget which will make Britain fit | 5:08:02 | 5:08:04 | |
for the future and it should be
supported by this House. Before I | 5:08:04 | 5:08:07 | |
start I want to pay tribute to a
working-class hero whose funeral is | 5:08:07 | 5:08:10 | |
place today, Derek Robinson who said
I can sleep sound at night because I | 5:08:10 | 5:08:12 | |
never betray workers. Mr Speaker,
Cabinet source is quoted as saying | 5:08:12 | 5:08:17 | |
this Budget had the worst build-up
in history. I don't think he was | 5:08:17 | 5:08:22 | |
wrong. Members on the opposite bench
have gone bananas about the Budget | 5:08:22 | 5:08:26 | |
ahead of today. What is clear to me
if this Budget caps off seven years | 5:08:26 | 5:08:30 | |
of abject failure, first by the
coalition and now by the | 5:08:30 | 5:08:34 | |
Conservative minority government. | 5:08:34 | 5:08:41 | |
Contrary to the warm words we have
heard from the opposite benches, | 5:08:41 | 5:08:45 | |
this budget has proved that the
Government is out of touch, has no | 5:08:45 | 5:08:49 | |
idea about the lives of ordinary
people and certainly no plans of | 5:08:49 | 5:08:53 | |
improvement. What we are seeing here
is an irrational ideology, actually | 5:08:53 | 5:08:59 | |
tromping plain common sense. They
are driven by a neoliberal ideology | 5:08:59 | 5:09:04 | |
which has proven that they are
certainly not a Government for the | 5:09:04 | 5:09:08 | |
many. I have to say, Mr Speaker,
where the help of world War paid | 5:09:08 | 5:09:14 | |
workers. The measures that the
Chancellor is announced on the | 5:09:14 | 5:09:18 | |
Universal Credit were absolutely
pathetic and it's also worth noting | 5:09:18 | 5:09:21 | |
that the don't come into effect
before Christmas either, so people | 5:09:21 | 5:09:25 | |
will be left penniless over the
Christmas period. Will is the | 5:09:25 | 5:09:29 | |
support for public sector workers?
Public sector workers, the defending | 5:09:29 | 5:09:35 | |
a decent society. I didn't hear any
Member -- mention of support for | 5:09:35 | 5:09:39 | |
them. Wood is the significant
support for the infrastructure this | 5:09:39 | 5:09:45 | |
country desperately needs. Where is
the best for health and education | 5:09:45 | 5:09:49 | |
and local Government? Social care is
an absolute crisis. Support for | 5:09:49 | 5:09:54 | |
vulnerable children is another area
and dictators. We have the | 5:09:54 | 5:09:57 | |
Chancellor say he is good to make
money available for fire safety, but | 5:09:57 | 5:10:01 | |
when local authorities have
approached the Government for | 5:10:01 | 5:10:05 | |
support with installing,
retrofitting sprinklers, that | 5:10:05 | 5:10:09 | |
support has been refused. The IMS
have estimated that local Government | 5:10:09 | 5:10:14 | |
funding will fall by 79% by 2020.
Ahead of this budget, the NHS chief | 5:10:14 | 5:10:23 | |
executive warned that without
funding, waiting lists will claim | 5:10:23 | 5:10:28 | |
further, the 5 million, and the 18
week target will be scrapped. The | 5:10:28 | 5:10:33 | |
key targets such as 62 day cancer
treatment targets, will be missed | 5:10:33 | 5:10:40 | |
and the extra money that has been
announced will not tackle that | 5:10:40 | 5:10:42 | |
crisis. Last year, we saw 40%, a 40%
cut in the adult skills budget. | 5:10:42 | 5:10:51 | |
Meaning that 1.3 million less adult
learners as a consequence of that. | 5:10:51 | 5:10:57 | |
We said that the -- we have the
chance see he said he wanted the two | 5:10:57 | 5:11:02 | |
make the dream of home ownership a
reality. With a cynical punter will | 5:11:02 | 5:11:05 | |
all mimic -- working-class people to
buy their own home? Where's the | 5:11:05 | 5:11:12 | |
house-building programme? The former
Chancellor promised that austerity | 5:11:12 | 5:11:15 | |
would wipe out the deficit, well, we
certainly haven't achieved that. The | 5:11:15 | 5:11:21 | |
failure to do that means that
hostility has permitted to nothing | 5:11:21 | 5:11:25 | |
more than conscious cruelty. They
have failed to eliminate the debt as | 5:11:25 | 5:11:30 | |
well and this Chancellor today said
that it is peaking. It seems to me | 5:11:30 | 5:11:35 | |
that all he is doing is fiddling
while Britain burns. Fiddling around | 5:11:35 | 5:11:41 | |
with the housing association, taking
that off the balance sheet, that is | 5:11:41 | 5:11:45 | |
nothing more than the tragedy. We
have seen a spectacular failure by | 5:11:45 | 5:11:50 | |
this Government on any measure in
relation to the debts and the | 5:11:50 | 5:11:53 | |
deficit. It's a case of rearranging
the deck chairs in the range to the | 5:11:53 | 5:11:59 | |
debt. I wonder whether the
Chancellor made to have a new job as | 5:11:59 | 5:12:03 | |
a deckchair attendant on debating
beach when he sacked from this | 5:12:03 | 5:12:08 | |
place. He has gone on to say that
there are more jobs than ever but | 5:12:08 | 5:12:12 | |
the problem is that after seven
years of hostility, probable -- | 5:12:12 | 5:12:20 | |
productivity, the productivity
forecast has been wrong and causing | 5:12:20 | 5:12:26 | |
them to significantly downgraded
protections. -- projections. | 5:12:26 | 5:12:30 | |
Businesses are simply not investing
because they lack confidence in the | 5:12:30 | 5:12:34 | |
economy. The Tory ideology is wrong,
the doctrine that Daniel Lubbers -- | 5:12:34 | 5:12:39 | |
neoliberalism says that the state
should be rolled back but it is | 5:12:39 | 5:12:42 | |
clear we need an entrepreneurial
state. I wonder if my colleagues the | 5:12:42 | 5:12:51 | |
lies that the Government has been
indulging in wilful sabotaging of | 5:12:51 | 5:12:55 | |
the economy, the adult skills budget
last year. That has resulted in an | 5:12:55 | 5:13:05 | |
1.23 million fewer adult learners.
Little wonder that the forecasts are | 5:13:05 | 5:13:10 | |
so anaemic for the dues: forward.
The previous Chancellor also said | 5:13:10 | 5:13:18 | |
that he wouldn't balance the books
on the backs of the power but that | 5:13:18 | 5:13:21 | |
is precisely what the Government has
done, with £12 billion more in | 5:13:21 | 5:13:25 | |
social security cuts for working age
people in the pipeline. The NHS | 5:13:25 | 5:13:30 | |
waiting lists, as we've heard, are
going to increase and the extra | 5:13:30 | 5:13:35 | |
funding for the NHS will simply not
actually tank all that very real | 5:13:35 | 5:13:40 | |
problem. We've also seen a skewed
level of investment and a different | 5:13:40 | 5:13:46 | |
region, we have the wooded spectacle
of investment on real in my region | 5:13:46 | 5:13:50 | |
of the East Midlands running at £91
per head, whereas in London is | 5:13:50 | 5:13:56 | |
running at £746 per head. We need a
different approach. It doesn't have | 5:13:56 | 5:14:00 | |
to be like this, Mr Speaker. Labour
would operate a different approach. | 5:14:00 | 5:14:03 | |
We would enter public sector
pick-up, pause fixing of the | 5:14:03 | 5:14:09 | |
Universal Credit to and he was a
real weapon which, bring in an | 5:14:09 | 5:14:13 | |
energy price cap, bring forward
infrastructure development in every | 5:14:13 | 5:14:18 | |
place in the country, studying ways
to -- large-scale house-building | 5:14:18 | 5:14:24 | |
programme and also have controls
over rent, scrap tuition fees and | 5:14:24 | 5:14:29 | |
stop penalising people for getting a
higher education, reverse the tax | 5:14:29 | 5:14:32 | |
cuts tip corporations and the
super-rich and content on the | 5:14:32 | 5:14:37 | |
disgraceful industrial scale tax
avoidance that takes place in this | 5:14:37 | 5:14:41 | |
country and rejected the toady's
Brexit cliff edge and the race to | 5:14:41 | 5:14:44 | |
the bottom that will turn Britain
into a deregulated tax haven. The | 5:14:44 | 5:14:50 | |
Chancellor claimed that he was
embracing the future but the truth | 5:14:50 | 5:14:53 | |
is this Government is stuck in a
Thatcherite past. Its dogmatic in | 5:14:53 | 5:14:59 | |
its commitment to neoliberalism,
despite the fact that it is not | 5:14:59 | 5:15:02 | |
working. Government administered
will remember, no doubt, from the | 5:15:02 | 5:15:06 | |
ideological training in the public
schools and elite universities that | 5:15:06 | 5:15:10 | |
the market is supposed to treat
wealth as an invisible hand, it's as | 5:15:10 | 5:15:15 | |
if the Tories believe in ghosts.
This budget shows that they still | 5:15:15 | 5:15:19 | |
believe in the invisible hand of the
market, but in reality no such thing | 5:15:19 | 5:15:24 | |
exists. They are deluding
themselves, pointy by ideology. What | 5:15:24 | 5:15:30 | |
Britain needs is a stealing hand of
an entrepreneurial state. What | 5:15:30 | 5:15:33 | |
Britain needs can Mr Speaker, as a
Labour Government that will provide | 5:15:33 | 5:15:37 | |
it. Rachel McLean. Thank you very
much Mr Speaker and it's a great | 5:15:37 | 5:15:46 | |
privilege to fall all of the
Honourable members. As the Member of | 5:15:46 | 5:15:50 | |
-- I will take issue with the Member
for Derby North, on red Robbo, who | 5:15:50 | 5:15:59 | |
know from my campaigning. I was sure
the Honourable Member that a number | 5:15:59 | 5:16:07 | |
of supporters swore that he would --
they would never support level again | 5:16:07 | 5:16:12 | |
after what he said about destroying
the industry. It's a great privilege | 5:16:12 | 5:16:17 | |
for me to speak in this budget
debate is a new Member of Parliament | 5:16:17 | 5:16:20 | |
for the very first time and I really
do welcome this budget Mr Speaker -- | 5:16:20 | 5:16:25 | |
and welcome this budget, Mr Speaker.
We on the site are always aware it | 5:16:25 | 5:16:29 | |
is not Government money that is
being spent, it is people's money. | 5:16:29 | 5:16:34 | |
Taxes must be raised and the
question is how. We have just heard | 5:16:34 | 5:16:39 | |
from the Honourable Member op. Cit.,
who is flooding the Communist party | 5:16:39 | 5:16:44 | |
plans. It's a stark choice. I did
not hear the Leader of the | 5:16:44 | 5:16:50 | |
Opposition, in his response to my
Right Honourable Friend the | 5:16:50 | 5:16:52 | |
Chancellor explain how he would fund
anything that he proposes. Our | 5:16:52 | 5:16:57 | |
plans, in contrast, are well thought
out. We understand the business is | 5:16:57 | 5:17:02 | |
and what is needed to support them.
That is why the Federation of Small | 5:17:02 | 5:17:08 | |
Businesses welcomes the budget
announced today and we made a choice | 5:17:08 | 5:17:10 | |
today between raising taxes on
private jets, which we are doing and | 5:17:10 | 5:17:19 | |
rewarding them for young people try
to buy their first House. I was an | 5:17:19 | 5:17:24 | |
entrepreneur for a 25 years before I
came into this place and, as my | 5:17:24 | 5:17:30 | |
Right Honourable Friend says, the
understand how difficult it is to | 5:17:30 | 5:17:32 | |
get a small buses off the ground. I
understand that, I have lived and | 5:17:32 | 5:17:37 | |
produced it. I am delighted to see
measures which are backing | 5:17:37 | 5:17:42 | |
entrepreneurial activity in this
country. Measures have already | 5:17:42 | 5:17:47 | |
created 197,000 jobs in our area
since 2010. In my constituency of | 5:17:47 | 5:17:52 | |
Redditch, we have seen 275 new
businesses being created, testament | 5:17:52 | 5:17:56 | |
to the spirit, the innovative spirit
of the people in my constituency. | 5:17:56 | 5:18:03 | |
Until it also that we have seen 6310
new apprenticeships and these are | 5:18:03 | 5:18:09 | |
good jobs. We are on the side of
working people and the Chancellor | 5:18:09 | 5:18:13 | |
today is going further by bringing
an Apis for ordinary working people | 5:18:13 | 5:18:19 | |
on the basic rate of tax of £1075.
This makes people better off. I | 5:18:19 | 5:18:28 | |
welcome this budget. This is a
budget which advances country and | 5:18:28 | 5:18:33 | |
does not proceed as the members op.
Cit., some of them, would want to | 5:18:33 | 5:18:36 | |
do. In the words of Robert Peel, he
talked about we must make a choice | 5:18:36 | 5:18:42 | |
between advancing or receding. He
understood the trade and that is | 5:18:42 | 5:18:45 | |
where we are going on the side of
the House. What we have seen, Mr | 5:18:45 | 5:18:51 | |
Speaker, we have seen corporation
tax receipts up by 20 billion since | 5:18:51 | 5:18:55 | |
2010. We have seen 5.5 million more
small businesses and think how many | 5:18:55 | 5:19:02 | |
more schools and hospitals can be
funded by this type of tax receipt | 5:19:02 | 5:19:06 | |
that is coming into the tragedy.
These are the business rates, that | 5:19:06 | 5:19:10 | |
is why I welcome the announcement
today from the Chancellor to remove | 5:19:10 | 5:19:14 | |
staircase tax and reform of business
rates relief. What they would do is | 5:19:14 | 5:19:19 | |
borrow more and they totally lacked
any coherent narrative. What we have | 5:19:19 | 5:19:25 | |
done as we saw borrowing, when we
came into Government that 73.2 | 5:19:25 | 5:19:31 | |
6,000,000,020 ten. That was 3.8% of
GDP. Now it's ten to 49 billion, | 5:19:31 | 5:19:39 | |
which is 2.4% of GDP and the
Chancellor has said that how it will | 5:19:39 | 5:19:42 | |
fall further. My constituency and
Redditch will welcome that sensible | 5:19:42 | 5:19:48 | |
approach to managing the economy. We
know that boardroom war does not | 5:19:48 | 5:19:52 | |
work. We have already tried that
experiment. It crashed the | 5:19:52 | 5:19:56 | |
experiment and it was order working
people like my constituents in | 5:19:56 | 5:19:59 | |
Redditch that paid the price. I
welcome the Chancellor 's focus on | 5:19:59 | 5:20:05 | |
the Midlands engine and as a
Midlands MP myself, I have seen for | 5:20:05 | 5:20:10 | |
myself the higher work -- hard work
that went into the devolution deal | 5:20:10 | 5:20:14 | |
which will benefit others in
Redditch as well. Make no mistake, I | 5:20:14 | 5:20:18 | |
will also be bending the Chancellor
's year of further to make sure that | 5:20:18 | 5:20:22 | |
Redditch benefits from this, with
measures like an Institute of | 5:20:22 | 5:20:25 | |
technology for Redditch to harness
the skills and make a Redditch call | 5:20:25 | 5:20:29 | |
further and also an express train
from the Redditch to Birmingham. I | 5:20:29 | 5:20:36 | |
recognise that the restore
productivity gap between diligent in | 5:20:36 | 5:20:38 | |
our country and between cities and
towns outside and inside our cities, | 5:20:38 | 5:20:41 | |
for example, Redditch. That is why I
welcome the productivity fund and | 5:20:41 | 5:20:45 | |
the increase in RND and that has
been welcomed by the Royal Society | 5:20:45 | 5:20:50 | |
as well who say that this shows the
Government is focused on the UK's | 5:20:50 | 5:20:54 | |
technological future and the crucial
pipeline of skills necessary to make | 5:20:54 | 5:20:58 | |
sure we are at the forefront of the
technological revolution. And so I | 5:20:58 | 5:21:02 | |
am delighted also that we have seen
more technical business started, and | 5:21:02 | 5:21:11 | |
the Chancellor wants to see more,
more every hour, and as a former | 5:21:11 | 5:21:17 | |
tech business myself, I will welcome
this. I mention the taxes that we | 5:21:17 | 5:21:24 | |
have already raised in this
Government and we will continue to | 5:21:24 | 5:21:27 | |
lose through the budget measures. I
am very delighted to see that the | 5:21:27 | 5:21:31 | |
taxes are going into our hospitals.
£10 billion for the NHS and of | 5:21:31 | 5:21:36 | |
course the Chancellor will not be
supplied that I will be lobbying him | 5:21:36 | 5:21:40 | |
and his Right Honourable Friend the
Secretary of State for Health for | 5:21:40 | 5:21:43 | |
more money to the hospital in my
constituency. We have seen funds | 5:21:43 | 5:21:47 | |
pledged the old lady and I am guided
to see that underpinned the day. I | 5:21:47 | 5:21:51 | |
want to see that also going to fund
the winter pressures and I have been | 5:21:51 | 5:22:02 | |
award being quite strenuously for
that. Young families in Redditch | 5:22:02 | 5:22:04 | |
will welcome the measures on
housing. I have received an e-mail | 5:22:04 | 5:22:06 | |
from a constituent, Mr Andrew Bolt,
who is currently buying a small | 5:22:06 | 5:22:09 | |
House. He is due to save 200 and
80p, handy just before Christmas. | 5:22:09 | 5:22:15 | |
Some people are absolutely delighted
about the measures, so I am quite | 5:22:15 | 5:22:19 | |
shocked by some of the negativity I
have heard on the other side. We | 5:22:19 | 5:22:23 | |
should be getting an outward looking
vision of country from beyond the | 5:22:23 | 5:22:28 | |
four walls of this House to the
outside world and so I will just | 5:22:28 | 5:22:32 | |
finished, again, when I was
listening to the words of my Right | 5:22:32 | 5:22:36 | |
Honourable Friend to deliver his
budget, I was struck once again by | 5:22:36 | 5:22:39 | |
the presence of the world dislike
the words of Robert Peel, we face a | 5:22:39 | 5:22:44 | |
choice between shaping the future or
retreating into the past. The choice | 5:22:44 | 5:22:47 | |
between an open and innovative
society or a closed, narrowed one. | 5:22:47 | 5:22:54 | |
We -- me on these benches make our
choice. A country welcoming change, | 5:22:54 | 5:22:58 | |
welcoming the future and so
therefore I welcome this budget. | 5:22:58 | 5:23:01 | |
I always think it is worth trying to
find a few small mercies at the | 5:23:06 | 5:23:11 | |
beginning of a Budget analysis. The
Chancellor has gone to the trouble | 5:23:11 | 5:23:14 | |
of an hour-long speech and there
have got to be a few things. There | 5:23:14 | 5:23:21 | |
are some mitigating changes for the
impact of Universal Credit but there | 5:23:21 | 5:23:26 | |
are still many worries for our
constituents and the impact on the | 5:23:26 | 5:23:32 | |
severely disabled, for example. I'm
glad there were some changes that | 5:23:32 | 5:23:36 | |
might help with housing, although
talking to my City Council in | 5:23:36 | 5:23:40 | |
Nottingham, they have concerns that
many of the announcements are to be | 5:23:40 | 5:23:45 | |
competitively bid for funds that the
housing revenue account cap | 5:23:45 | 5:23:49 | |
relaxation may be only for areas of
high demand, so it is not clear that | 5:23:49 | 5:23:53 | |
will necessarily help cities outside
London. And of course we remain with | 5:23:53 | 5:24:00 | |
a 70% discount on council house
sales, so even if they do build more | 5:24:00 | 5:24:04 | |
stock, there is of course the
opportunity that it will be depleted | 5:24:04 | 5:24:08 | |
very quickly. I was particularly
disappointed the Chancellor didn't | 5:24:08 | 5:24:13 | |
mention social care at all in his
speech. It beggars belief, really, | 5:24:13 | 5:24:19 | |
that we had some discussion about
the NHS, but the big issue that is | 5:24:19 | 5:24:25 | |
strategically a block for many of
the problems we have within the NHS, | 5:24:25 | 5:24:30 | |
social -- social care was just
disregarded and I believe we need to | 5:24:30 | 5:24:34 | |
mention that in future days. If I
was to step back and think | 5:24:34 | 5:24:38 | |
strategically, what is the story of
this Budget, I think it is the very | 5:24:38 | 5:24:43 | |
start and depressing statistics in
the figures contained in the | 5:24:43 | 5:24:47 | |
Treasury Redbook. An enormous
downgrade of economic growth. | 5:24:47 | 5:24:52 | |
Dreadful figures from all over the
years from here on in. We're waving | 5:24:52 | 5:24:58 | |
goodbye to 2% levels of growth
because it is below those levels now | 5:24:58 | 5:25:02 | |
henceforth. A big downgrade in
productivity, the biggest, in fact, | 5:25:02 | 5:25:07 | |
since the office of the budget
responsibility was created. And a | 5:25:07 | 5:25:12 | |
big broken promise when it comes to
the deficit. Stretching now, as it | 5:25:12 | 5:25:17 | |
does, until 2022 and beyond. The
promise of that budget surplus seems | 5:25:17 | 5:25:23 | |
to have gone. Why is this the case?
It is fundamentally because the dark | 5:25:23 | 5:25:28 | |
clouds and the cold wind of Brexit
are looming large, and they are | 5:25:28 | 5:25:34 | |
already being felt. And any analysis
of our economic outlook or our | 5:25:34 | 5:25:40 | |
fiscal prospects cannot possibly
ignore this Brexit question. As I | 5:25:40 | 5:25:47 | |
say, I think the impact is being
felt on business investment because | 5:25:47 | 5:25:53 | |
the uncertainty about trade and
tariffs is holding back firms from | 5:25:53 | 5:25:58 | |
putting money into things that would
otherwise help create productivity. | 5:25:58 | 5:26:03 | |
And that lack of productivity has
fed into this growth downgrade, | 5:26:03 | 5:26:08 | |
which in turn has created a big hole
in forecasts of Treasury revenues, | 5:26:08 | 5:26:15 | |
which we vitally need to pay for
schools, hospitals and transport | 5:26:15 | 5:26:19 | |
schemes, all of those vital public
services that we have. When the Bank | 5:26:19 | 5:26:24 | |
of England surveys on their decision
panel further prospects of | 5:26:24 | 5:26:30 | |
investment, they are getting worse
and worse quarter after quarter, of | 5:26:30 | 5:26:34 | |
the quarter, looking into the
future, we can see the negative | 5:26:34 | 5:26:38 | |
effect that the clouds of Brexit are
having on our business investment | 5:26:38 | 5:26:41 | |
and productivity. When you look at
the impact of the devaluation of | 5:26:41 | 5:26:46 | |
sterling compared to the exchange
rate index, 17.5% lower than its | 5:26:46 | 5:26:55 | |
peak in 2015, that has hit all of
our constituents in their pockets to | 5:26:55 | 5:26:58 | |
a significant degree. It is
estimated around £600 per household | 5:26:58 | 5:27:05 | |
already now hitting households in
terms of reduction in real available | 5:27:05 | 5:27:10 | |
income that they have at their
disposal. We still have no idea | 5:27:10 | 5:27:15 | |
about a transitional status for what
might happen after that fabled cliff | 5:27:15 | 5:27:20 | |
edge in 2019, and therefore the
impact of uncertainty is likely to | 5:27:20 | 5:27:26 | |
cast that shadow for very many years
to come. Hopefully we will have some | 5:27:26 | 5:27:31 | |
resolution at the European Council
meeting before Christmas. But it | 5:27:31 | 5:27:35 | |
seems to be quite a tall order. And
when you look at perhaps the biggest | 5:27:35 | 5:27:40 | |
issue, the money, the fiscal impact,
the £3 billion committed for Brexit | 5:27:40 | 5:27:48 | |
preparations, what a waste of
resources when this is money that | 5:27:48 | 5:27:50 | |
should have been invested in the
health service, in our schools and | 5:27:50 | 5:27:54 | |
in our public services. In fact, in
2019 more money is committed to | 5:27:54 | 5:27:59 | |
Brexit preparations than was
committed for extra result of the | 5:27:59 | 5:28:03 | |
NHS. I think that if anything sums
up the dysfunction of this whole | 5:28:03 | 5:28:07 | |
scenario that we are faced with and
I think that statistic does that. | 5:28:07 | 5:28:13 | |
This is all before the massive
divorce bill, of course, that is | 5:28:13 | 5:28:17 | |
supposed to come. It wasn't the 350
pounds a week on the side of the | 5:28:17 | 5:28:24 | |
bus. For the NHS! That is long on!
Potentially £67 billion of a divorce | 5:28:24 | 5:28:30 | |
Bill. -- that is long gone. That is
two years of a budget deficit bill. | 5:28:30 | 5:28:40 | |
It is on page 17 of the Treasury's
Redbook, where I think we really get | 5:28:40 | 5:28:47 | |
that triple whammy, that real kick
about the impact Brexit will be | 5:28:47 | 5:28:50 | |
having on our public services,
because it is an enormous downgrade | 5:28:50 | 5:28:55 | |
in revenues. If you look at that
table, Mr Speaker, you will see that | 5:28:55 | 5:29:02 | |
in 2019, eight billion fewer
receipts forecast in 2020, in 2021 | 5:29:02 | 5:29:13 | |
even more. These are enormous
figures and they really ought to be | 5:29:13 | 5:29:17 | |
a wake-up call for all Members of
Parliament, certainly for the | 5:29:17 | 5:29:20 | |
government, but for all members,
because this is a fate that does not | 5:29:20 | 5:29:24 | |
need to be set in stone. This is a
situation that can still be avoided. | 5:29:24 | 5:29:30 | |
We know, of course, that the people
who were in voting leave saying, | 5:29:30 | 5:29:37 | |
this is all done and dusted, Brexit
will take us over the cliff, there | 5:29:37 | 5:29:42 | |
are choices that we in Britain can
make, and I would say to my | 5:29:42 | 5:29:46 | |
honourable friends, as much to the
Government, it is our responsibility | 5:29:46 | 5:29:52 | |
to avoid the Brexit austerity that
is likely to cast a shadow over the | 5:29:52 | 5:29:56 | |
decade ahead, because this austerity
is something that will be the | 5:29:56 | 5:29:59 | |
responsibility of all of us unless
we opt to remain in the single | 5:29:59 | 5:30:05 | |
market and remain in the customs
union, to retain that tariff-free | 5:30:05 | 5:30:09 | |
trade that we have with our nearest
neighbours in order to avoid these | 5:30:09 | 5:30:13 | |
problems. I give way. I've just
looked at page 17 of the Redbook and | 5:30:13 | 5:30:21 | |
the table he refers to. 1.2. That
shows the deficit going down from | 5:30:21 | 5:30:26 | |
58.3 billion to... That is the
receipts forecast, not indicating a | 5:30:26 | 5:30:39 | |
reduction because of Brexit. It is a
reduction in receipts. He will see | 5:30:39 | 5:30:44 | |
the budget deficit was forecast in
spring to be £16 billion in 2021. In | 5:30:44 | 5:30:51 | |
this Budget it is predicted to be
33. The level of borrowing is | 5:30:51 | 5:30:57 | |
predicted to go up very
significantly, largely driven by the | 5:30:57 | 5:31:00 | |
fall in that 20 billion of receipts.
I think the figures are quite clear. | 5:31:00 | 5:31:08 | |
The government might say, well, we
don't need to take it from public | 5:31:08 | 5:31:12 | |
services now, we will add it to
borrowing, but that will be added | 5:31:12 | 5:31:15 | |
onto the debt interest and have to
be paid. But my suspicion is that | 5:31:15 | 5:31:20 | |
this will involve more fiscal
tightening and more austerity | 5:31:20 | 5:31:23 | |
towards the tail end of these years
ahead. And when you add up the | 5:31:23 | 5:31:27 | |
wasted money on Brexit preparation,
when you add the extra money of the | 5:31:27 | 5:31:32 | |
divorce Bill, when you look at the
level of receipts that are falling, | 5:31:32 | 5:31:37 | |
because of low productivity, because
of lower growth forecasts, which in | 5:31:37 | 5:31:40 | |
turn are driven by that dark cloud
of Brexit, this is the real story of | 5:31:40 | 5:31:46 | |
the Budget. It needn't be the fate
of this country, though, if we take | 5:31:46 | 5:31:51 | |
decisions, and I urge all honourable
members - let's not be responsible | 5:31:51 | 5:31:56 | |
for this level of austerity in the
future. We need a different fate and | 5:31:56 | 5:32:00 | |
we need to make sure we intervene
and retain that single market and | 5:32:00 | 5:32:04 | |
Customs union membership. I'm sorry
I haven't been in for the whole of | 5:32:04 | 5:32:10 | |
the debate. I've been at the exiting
the European Union Select Committee | 5:32:10 | 5:32:14 | |
debating one of our reports, and we
have been firmly exercising split | 5:32:14 | 5:32:20 | |
infinitive and making sure
apostrophes are in the right place, | 5:32:20 | 5:32:24 | |
and all those important matters, but
it took me away from the chamber. It | 5:32:24 | 5:32:28 | |
is a pleasure to follow the
honourable member, the council of | 5:32:28 | 5:32:34 | |
Dublin East. But we often disagree
quite firmly. -- of Nottingham East. | 5:32:34 | 5:32:41 | |
In the context of Brexit we are
always told the end of the world is | 5:32:41 | 5:32:48 | |
nigh, it will all be terrible, and
yet when we look at the Redbook, we | 5:32:48 | 5:32:52 | |
know the figures we've had so far
are better in spite of the Treasury | 5:32:52 | 5:32:56 | |
and others saying it would all be a
disaster. So borrowing in 2017-18 is | 5:32:56 | 5:33:04 | |
49.9, 8 billion lower than forecast,
why? Because receipts are higher. | 5:33:04 | 5:33:10 | |
More money is coming in and that is
indicative of the economy | 5:33:10 | 5:33:14 | |
strengthening. On the page following
it indicates spending decisions and | 5:33:14 | 5:33:18 | |
tax decisions that have been taken
in the Budget. But I do have a | 5:33:18 | 5:33:25 | |
specific question for the Treasury
bench which may have been raised by | 5:33:25 | 5:33:29 | |
my honourable friend, the member for
Dover. On page 82, and it is copied | 5:33:29 | 5:33:36 | |
from page 142 -- 114 of the OBR
book, in 2022-23, it is said there | 5:33:36 | 5:33:44 | |
will be a £3.5 billion a resources
contribution to the EU. I cannot | 5:33:44 | 5:33:50 | |
believe those white figures could
have made a schoolboy error of | 5:33:50 | 5:33:55 | |
assuming money paid out in one year
would be so indefinitely. But it is | 5:33:55 | 5:33:59 | |
missing the point that by then we
will have left the EU, the | 5:33:59 | 5:34:04 | |
implementation period will have
ended, the whole concept of own | 5:34:04 | 5:34:07 | |
resources will have ceased to exist,
and this is rather like spotting an | 5:34:07 | 5:34:12 | |
error in the Rag'n'Bone Man. It is
where to do and I think we will | 5:34:12 | 5:34:21 | |
discover this is not intended. --
Anette error in the cricketers' | 5:34:21 | 5:34:28 | |
book. The error assumes we are still
members so I think there is an error | 5:34:28 | 5:34:36 | |
there. But I do think this ties in
with the points made very elegantly | 5:34:36 | 5:34:40 | |
earlier on by the honourable
gentleman that the key to this | 5:34:40 | 5:34:47 | |
Budget has to be Brexit. That what
we are doing currently is in the | 5:34:47 | 5:34:52 | |
context of Europe leaving the
European Union. Of course I give | 5:34:52 | 5:34:55 | |
way. I would very much like to
respond to the point he has just | 5:34:55 | 5:35:01 | |
made on the subject of the forecast.
Those forecasts were made by the | 5:35:01 | 5:35:05 | |
OBR. They were provided with the
Prime Minister's Florence speech, | 5:35:05 | 5:35:13 | |
the basis on which we are
negotiating with the EU, and it is | 5:35:13 | 5:35:17 | |
up to them to make their own
independent forecasts. My | 5:35:17 | 5:35:20 | |
understanding is that you will have
to speak directly to the OBR about | 5:35:20 | 5:35:26 | |
that, but they have used an average
of other independent forecasts that | 5:35:26 | 5:35:30 | |
have been prepared. I am grateful
but I don't think it works for the | 5:35:30 | 5:35:36 | |
resources figure because they have
made assumptions about our net | 5:35:36 | 5:35:40 | |
contribution to the EU and they have
assumed those monies will be spent | 5:35:40 | 5:35:44 | |
domestically in the UK, and
therefore there is no fiscal | 5:35:44 | 5:35:47 | |
advantage, but there is still a £3.5
million negative income from own | 5:35:47 | 5:35:51 | |
resources. It is hard to think the
OBR would have taken that from other | 5:35:51 | 5:35:57 | |
forecasters because that is a matter
directly understandable from the | 5:35:57 | 5:36:01 | |
Treasury, that the Treasury can give
an authoritative view on, and it | 5:36:01 | 5:36:04 | |
would be very odd if they hadn't
explained that own resources will | 5:36:04 | 5:36:08 | |
end at the point that we leave the
EU. It has two. Only member states | 5:36:08 | 5:36:13 | |
of the EU can make own resources
contribution is the very obvious | 5:36:13 | 5:36:18 | |
reasons. Though I've always disliked
the term own resources. I've always | 5:36:18 | 5:36:22 | |
been with Margaret Thatcher that it
is our money and we would quite like | 5:36:22 | 5:36:25 | |
to keep it, thank you very much! But
I would like to go back to the | 5:36:25 | 5:36:30 | |
original point that the Budget is
inevitably encompassed by Brexit and | 5:36:30 | 5:36:34 | |
productivity. And I think this is
where the challenge is. The OBR has | 5:36:34 | 5:36:39 | |
very gloomy forecasts on
productivity, and these lead to a | 5:36:39 | 5:36:43 | |
reduction in potential output in
2021-20 two by 3%. -- 2021-22. The | 5:36:43 | 5:36:56 | |
question is, how do they make Brexit
work to ensure we get a productivity | 5:36:56 | 5:37:00 | |
boost, and this is where I was so
encouraged by what the Chancellor to | 5:37:00 | 5:37:04 | |
stay, because he said this would be
a free trade government and this is | 5:37:04 | 5:37:09 | |
the real opportunity that comes from
Brexit. It is to open up our markets | 5:37:09 | 5:37:13 | |
to the rest of the world freely. We
have to remember that the customs | 5:37:13 | 5:37:17 | |
union, which the honourable
gentleman is so keen to stay in, is | 5:37:17 | 5:37:23 | |
actually a protectionist union that
stops people in the UK buying the | 5:37:23 | 5:37:26 | |
cheapest available goods, and by and
large, protect industry that the UK | 5:37:26 | 5:37:31 | |
does not have. The overwhelming
majority of the protection and the | 5:37:31 | 5:37:37 | |
customs union is for things like
German coffee processors or Spanish | 5:37:37 | 5:37:43 | |
orange growers. Those types of
things that we are not doing. Our | 5:37:43 | 5:37:47 | |
industries receive very marginal
protection from the customs union | 5:37:47 | 5:37:52 | |
but it is a very high cost to
British consumers. It is thought | 5:37:52 | 5:37:56 | |
that the cost of food is 20%, and
the next highest level of tariffs | 5:37:56 | 5:38:01 | |
comes on clothing and footwear. And
the opportunity here for the poorest | 5:38:01 | 5:38:06 | |
in our society to see their standard
of living boosted and their wages | 5:38:06 | 5:38:10 | |
rise is really quite fundamental,
that it will mean that their weekly, | 5:38:10 | 5:38:16 | |
monthly, annual expenditure will be
reduced, their real income will | 5:38:16 | 5:38:20 | |
rise, and this will make available
funds for other expenditures or | 5:38:20 | 5:38:24 | |
indeed the saving and reinvestment
in British industry. But equally, it | 5:38:24 | 5:38:29 | |
will mean that because we lose the
cosy protectionism, we cease to | 5:38:29 | 5:38:36 | |
subsidise continental inefficient
businesses and we also ensure we | 5:38:36 | 5:38:39 | |
concentrate on what we are best but,
and that ought to leave off itself | 5:38:39 | 5:38:43 | |
to a boost in productivity, and
indeed this is the lesson of | 5:38:43 | 5:38:47 | |
history. When you move to free
trade, and the removal not only | 5:38:47 | 5:38:51 | |
formal tariffs but also nontariff
barriers, and this, if things go | 5:38:51 | 5:38:57 | |
correctly and the correct policies
are adopted, is whether £350 million | 5:38:57 | 5:39:02 | |
a week can ultimately be provided
for the National Health Service. The | 5:39:02 | 5:39:04 | |
figures produced by Sir Patrick
Minford and his very distinguished | 5:39:04 | 5:39:10 | |
team at Cardiff University indicate
that there will be a boon of £135 | 5:39:10 | 5:39:15 | |
billion between 2020 and 2025 and
£40 billion a year after, which will | 5:39:15 | 5:39:22 | |
be possible to have both tax cuts
and make it possible to fund the | 5:39:22 | 5:39:27 | |
health service. And it is very
encouraging to see that the | 5:39:27 | 5:39:31 | |
Chancellor has already begun this
process and is making more money | 5:39:31 | 5:39:34 | |
available for the health service at
this stage, because I think it is | 5:39:34 | 5:39:39 | |
important that politicians deliver
on the spirit of their promises as | 5:39:39 | 5:39:41 | |
well is on the detailed nit-picking
small print element of their | 5:39:41 | 5:39:49 | |
policies. So I think it is right
that that should be made possible, | 5:39:49 | 5:39:54 | |
and having a free-trade developer
and of economic policy is going to | 5:39:54 | 5:39:58 | |
be crucial to that and it is very
welcome the Chancellor has put this | 5:39:58 | 5:40:02 | |
in his Budget speech today. | 5:40:02 | 5:40:10 | |
The other issue important to our
voters is the issue of housing and | 5:40:10 | 5:40:15 | |
here I would encourage the
Chancellor to call further. I think | 5:40:15 | 5:40:18 | |
it is absolutely right that we have
more house-building. It is | 5:40:18 | 5:40:22 | |
absolutely right that the Government
is supporting that but the key to | 5:40:22 | 5:40:26 | |
that is going to be reform of the
planning system. The thing that | 5:40:26 | 5:40:30 | |
makes housing so expensive in this
country is that suppliers | 5:40:30 | 5:40:33 | |
controlled. As the Chancellor
rightly said in his budget speech, | 5:40:33 | 5:40:37 | |
actions to help demand are likely to
put prices up and what we need to | 5:40:37 | 5:40:43 | |
see as prices, at least in relation
to incomes, called down and that | 5:40:43 | 5:40:48 | |
means increasing supply and to
increase supply in a way that people | 5:40:48 | 5:40:52 | |
want to live. The one question I
would raise on the budget, Mr | 5:40:52 | 5:40:59 | |
Speaker, as when the Chancellor said
the ruble to ensure that housing was | 5:40:59 | 5:41:03 | |
primarily in an urban setting, but
actually when you ask people what | 5:41:03 | 5:41:06 | |
housing they want to 11, the, 80% of
people say they want to live in | 5:41:06 | 5:41:12 | |
houses with gardens and this means
we're going to have to build on the | 5:41:12 | 5:41:16 | |
green fields and it would be wise to
review the green belt, because there | 5:41:16 | 5:41:20 | |
are some areas of it which are not
actually essential to life and the | 5:41:20 | 5:41:25 | |
pursuit of happiness. What we really
want, Mr Speaker as a whole | 5:41:25 | 5:41:32 | |
succession of places around the
country, because that's what people | 5:41:32 | 5:41:35 | |
want to live in. Liz Kendall. Thank
you Mr Speaker, and as always, it is | 5:41:35 | 5:41:45 | |
a pleasure to follow the comparable
gentleman. Mr Speaker, the challenge | 5:41:45 | 5:41:50 | |
facing any Government and any budget
is to boost her strengths, tackle | 5:41:50 | 5:41:55 | |
our weaknesses and prepare the
Government -- the country for the | 5:41:55 | 5:41:59 | |
future. I am afraid the Government
has failed to rise to these | 5:41:59 | 5:42:03 | |
challenges, not least in its
inadequate budget, but in its | 5:42:03 | 5:42:07 | |
damaging approach to Brexit and I
wanted to take each of these point | 5:42:07 | 5:42:10 | |
entirely. First, our economic
strengths. We are rightly proud of | 5:42:10 | 5:42:17 | |
our world leading car manufacturers,
pharmaceutical and Aerosmith | 5:42:17 | 5:42:22 | |
countries, creative industries and
universities and financial services. | 5:42:22 | 5:42:25 | |
We want and need these to expand and
thrive to create more good quality | 5:42:25 | 5:42:31 | |
jobs and help 's fund our vital
public services. But all of these | 5:42:31 | 5:42:35 | |
facing huge uncertainties because of
the Government 's determination to | 5:42:35 | 5:42:41 | |
boot is out -- Bill was out of the
single market and Customs union and | 5:42:41 | 5:42:45 | |
because of not just the acceptance
but the active desire of some | 5:42:45 | 5:42:50 | |
members opposite, to leave the EU
with no ordeal and fall back on WTO | 5:42:50 | 5:42:55 | |
rules. The risk of new tariffs and
custom barriers, or financial | 5:42:55 | 5:43:00 | |
services losing their passport
ingrates and restrictions on trade | 5:43:00 | 5:43:04 | |
with the largest market of 500
million consumers on our doorstep, | 5:43:04 | 5:43:10 | |
is a major cause of the war than
expected levels of business | 5:43:10 | 5:43:15 | |
investment and | 5:43:15 | 5:43:25 | |
productivity and growth figures that
we have heard in today's budget. The | 5:43:28 | 5:43:31 | |
Government cannot escape that, no
matter how much they want to sweep | 5:43:31 | 5:43:33 | |
it under the carpet. But it is not
just that the Government approach to | 5:43:33 | 5:43:36 | |
Brexit is risking our economic or
strengths, they are also failing to | 5:43:36 | 5:43:38 | |
address our underlying economic
weaknesses. I want to be clear here, | 5:43:38 | 5:43:40 | |
many of these existed before Brexit
and indeed before the financial | 5:43:40 | 5:43:46 | |
crisis, which I fear the Government
approach to Brexit will make far | 5:43:46 | 5:43:50 | |
worse. The fundamental problem we
have is that the Dove -- British | 5:43:50 | 5:43:55 | |
economy is no longer delivering the
rising earnings for the majority of | 5:43:55 | 5:44:00 | |
the population. We are in the
longest proceeded -- period of waste | 5:44:00 | 5:44:05 | |
-- the longest period of wage
stagnation for 150 years. While I | 5:44:05 | 5:44:09 | |
welcome our high levels of
employment, many of the jobs are | 5:44:09 | 5:44:14 | |
insecure and low paid and Child
poverty is arising. Britain is also | 5:44:14 | 5:44:19 | |
one of the most geographical and
balanced economies in Europe. 40% of | 5:44:19 | 5:44:25 | |
our economic output comes from
London and the south-east. Indeed, | 5:44:25 | 5:44:28 | |
these are the only two regions in
the country that has seen the | 5:44:28 | 5:44:32 | |
economies get back to precrisis
levels and we are also one of the | 5:44:32 | 5:44:37 | |
most unequal, not just in terms of
income inequality but wealth | 5:44:37 | 5:44:42 | |
inequality, which, as the IMF says,
really, really matters because more | 5:44:42 | 5:44:47 | |
unequal countries have shorter and
weaker periods of growth and, Mr | 5:44:47 | 5:44:52 | |
Speaker, for far too long our
economy has been plagued by shot | 5:44:52 | 5:44:57 | |
terrorism, pure productivity --
power productivity and a low-level | 5:44:57 | 5:45:01 | |
supple public and private
investment. I am afraid that nothing | 5:45:01 | 5:45:05 | |
the Chancellor said today indicates
that the Government understands the | 5:45:05 | 5:45:10 | |
sheer scale of this problem or has a
plan for reforming our economy, for | 5:45:10 | 5:45:17 | |
reforming capitalism so it works for
the majority of people in every | 5:45:17 | 5:45:20 | |
single part of the country. And this
leaves me, Mr Speaker, to my final | 5:45:20 | 5:45:27 | |
point about preparing the cobbler --
the country for the future. We face | 5:45:27 | 5:45:32 | |
a big, big challenges alongside that
of Brexit. Deeper globalisation as | 5:45:32 | 5:45:37 | |
emerging economies to the east and
this is increasingly compete on | 5:45:37 | 5:45:41 | |
high-value products and services,
not just the basic manufacturing. | 5:45:41 | 5:45:46 | |
Our ageing population and the
implications this has for | 5:45:46 | 5:45:59 | |
pensions, the NHS and social care.
Technological change, which is | 5:46:01 | 5:46:03 | |
opening up huge opportunities for
some but the risks leaving those | 5:46:03 | 5:46:05 | |
without the skills they need behind
and, the continuing need to check | 5:46:05 | 5:46:08 | |
all -- to chuckle climate change. I
am glad the Chancellor announced | 5:46:08 | 5:46:10 | |
measures to that encourage more
young people to take A-level | 5:46:10 | 5:46:12 | |
mathematics and invest in driverless
car a spot where was the plan to | 5:46:12 | 5:46:15 | |
transform the skills in this
country? Where was the plan to | 5:46:15 | 5:46:19 | |
invest in the early years so every
child starts ready to learn? Where | 5:46:19 | 5:46:24 | |
children from the previous parts of
my constituency start school 20 | 5:46:24 | 5:46:28 | |
months behind with these should be,
they play catch up for the rest of | 5:46:28 | 5:46:31 | |
their lives. Where was the plan to
help the 5 million adults without | 5:46:31 | 5:46:36 | |
basic skills who will never cope
with the changes technology and | 5:46:36 | 5:46:51 | |
globalisation £2.8 billion extra in
the next few years but the NHS, said | 5:46:52 | 5:46:55 | |
the Chancellor. That is pathetically
inadequate and unless the £3 billion | 5:46:55 | 5:46:57 | |
on preparing for Brexit -- less than
£3 billion preparing for Brexit and | 5:46:57 | 5:47:00 | |
nothing in the budget for social
care to get older and disabled | 5:47:00 | 5:47:03 | |
people and their families, who are
desperately to cope, the health and | 5:47:03 | 5:47:07 | |
support they need. That, Mr Speaker,
brings me back to Brexit. The single | 5:47:07 | 5:47:13 | |
most important thing we want in this
budget is that there will be slower | 5:47:13 | 5:47:16 | |
growth every year for five years.
That means £65 billion less to spend | 5:47:16 | 5:47:25 | |
on transforming this country and the
life chances of the people we | 5:47:25 | 5:47:28 | |
represent than we thought it just
one year ago. On any economic test, | 5:47:28 | 5:47:34 | |
these forecasts are a disaster and
the Government only has itself to | 5:47:34 | 5:47:39 | |
blame. Can I just advise the House
in the situation we find ourselves. | 5:47:39 | 5:47:46 | |
One Honourable Member has offered to
speak on another day. Others are | 5:47:46 | 5:47:51 | |
surely seized on the importance of
them speaking today. I completely | 5:47:51 | 5:47:55 | |
understand that but the fact is that
eight people wish to speak and deaf | 5:47:55 | 5:47:58 | |
ear to do so by seven o'clock, they
can do the arithmetic for | 5:47:58 | 5:48:03 | |
themselves. That is the reality.
There is no good reporting -- | 5:48:03 | 5:48:08 | |
complaining to the whip. Have two
recognise the responsibility they | 5:48:08 | 5:48:13 | |
have. There were lots of
interventions and that the | 5:48:13 | 5:48:16 | |
situation. I will try to tailor my
remarks with that in mind. It is a | 5:48:16 | 5:48:24 | |
pleasure to follow the Honourable
Lady from Leicester West and with | 5:48:24 | 5:48:32 | |
what she says, but she speaks with
passion and verve and I have to say, | 5:48:32 | 5:48:37 | |
don't want to embarrass horror or
her Honourable Friend but I can that | 5:48:37 | 5:48:41 | |
with what I heard from the Leader of
Opposition earlier, a lot of noise | 5:48:41 | 5:48:48 | |
and colour but not necessarily any
discernible theme that I could pick | 5:48:48 | 5:48:51 | |
up. Everyone on both sides of this
House wants to see good public | 5:48:51 | 5:48:56 | |
services. They want to see them well
supported, delivering for our | 5:48:56 | 5:49:01 | |
constituents. I welcome, as the
Honourable Lady from the DUP said | 5:49:01 | 5:49:05 | |
earlier, the slight fiscal loosening
of the next two or three years as a | 5:49:05 | 5:49:09 | |
recognition of need other public
sector and perhaps Independent paid | 5:49:09 | 5:49:15 | |
reviews will give us some leeway in
that direction as well. That is | 5:49:15 | 5:49:19 | |
right and appropriate but it is also
great it is executed in the context | 5:49:19 | 5:49:23 | |
of a broader plan in which our
national debt is being brought under | 5:49:23 | 5:49:26 | |
control we will over this forecast,
from my back of the envelope | 5:49:26 | 5:49:32 | |
register deaths at the level it was
an 2001 when the Honourable | 5:49:32 | 5:49:37 | |
gentlemen and ladies opposite were
running the Government, as far as I | 5:49:37 | 5:49:40 | |
recall, back in 2001, that was the
last year which load very sensibly, | 5:49:40 | 5:49:45 | |
the fiscal envelope be dictated by
merit Honourable Friend, the number | 5:49:45 | 5:49:50 | |
for Rushcliffe. The next year, our
total debt as a percentage of the | 5:49:50 | 5:49:54 | |
East -- DGP will decline by a single
point. Fiscal hole of historic | 5:49:54 | 5:50:03 | |
proportions that we inherited.
Reducing the deficit is not | 5:50:03 | 5:50:07 | |
glamorous or popular but it is
necessary. The businesses in the up | 5:50:07 | 5:50:11 | |
the resilience for future shocks. It
is necessary on the grounds of | 5:50:11 | 5:50:19 | |
simple fairness to our generations
but to maintain that process of debt | 5:50:19 | 5:50:23 | |
reduction and sustain her investment
in public services, the Chancellor | 5:50:23 | 5:50:29 | |
is absolutely right to focus on
productivity puzzle. I respected the | 5:50:29 | 5:50:35 | |
APR, I respect the economic forecast
that have been referred difficultly | 5:50:35 | 5:50:38 | |
this afternoon. I personally feel
more optimistic as the pace of | 5:50:38 | 5:50:42 | |
growth goes, but they are forecasts,
the Co-op, they go down and that is | 5:50:42 | 5:50:47 | |
the nature of forecast. As they will
be our itself says, the outlook for | 5:50:47 | 5:50:52 | |
potential productivity growth is the
most important yet uncertain element | 5:50:52 | 5:50:58 | |
predicting growth. They are right on
both counts. Which is why I applaud | 5:50:58 | 5:51:05 | |
the Chancellor in embracing new
technologies. We have an excellent | 5:51:05 | 5:51:12 | |
record on unemployment. Bob then my
constituency and nationally, what a | 5:51:12 | 5:51:17 | |
thousand jobs today being treated as
2010. The challenge as a country and | 5:51:17 | 5:51:20 | |
not just this country but there are
challenges to make sure that our | 5:51:20 | 5:51:28 | |
employees received the investment,
the education, the infrastructure | 5:51:28 | 5:51:31 | |
and the support two hours to drive
up productivity and enhance further | 5:51:31 | 5:51:36 | |
growth. I welcome the measures in
this budget directly aimed at | 5:51:36 | 5:51:39 | |
long-term improvement in
productivity. A further 2.3 billion | 5:51:39 | 5:51:46 | |
in art indeed, enhancement to the
R&D tax credit, the website and the | 5:51:46 | 5:51:51 | |
investment target of 2.4% of GDP. As
someone who sees the UK as a liberal | 5:51:51 | 5:51:56 | |
country open to the world, I am
delighted at the approach is laid | 5:51:56 | 5:52:01 | |
out in the red book to attract the
best scientific talent anywhere in | 5:52:01 | 5:52:04 | |
the world to work and flourish here
in the UK. On education, which was | 5:52:04 | 5:52:09 | |
referred to as the Honourable Lady
from Leicester West, eye on them -- | 5:52:09 | 5:52:13 | |
-- I welcome the new approaches to
education. Schools that plays a huge | 5:52:13 | 5:52:19 | |
important on Stem subjects, such as
Horsham who provide extra resources | 5:52:19 | 5:52:26 | |
for students who want to embrace
these new technology. I just want to | 5:52:26 | 5:52:29 | |
enter up to say that I know the
Honourable Gentleman extremely well | 5:52:29 | 5:52:33 | |
and he speaks in his mellifluous
tone with great eloquence and he is | 5:52:33 | 5:52:37 | |
correct is right capable of doing so
at any length, short or long and now | 5:52:37 | 5:52:40 | |
that he will want to have regard to
the simmering temperature of the | 5:52:40 | 5:52:45 | |
Honourable Gentleman for Wrexham,
who is to follow him and other | 5:52:45 | 5:52:48 | |
colleagues who also wish to
contribute and therefore I speak of | 5:52:48 | 5:52:50 | |
some confidence and seeing his time
is nigh. Mr Speaker, I promised I | 5:52:50 | 5:52:58 | |
would be brief and there will be
belief. Education, I welcome it and | 5:52:58 | 5:53:01 | |
the infrastructure, more housing, I
welcome it. This is a wide budget | 5:53:01 | 5:53:07 | |
with a lot to commend it. At the
problems of the past were sitting at | 5:53:07 | 5:53:12 | |
the foundations for the future. I am
sorry and not able to entertain the | 5:53:12 | 5:53:16 | |
House at any greater length but that
is powerful it clear that others | 5:53:16 | 5:53:19 | |
should have the shed and with that I
commend | 5:53:19 | 5:53:21 | |
Thank you. I am grateful for him at
allowing us to speak as he has been | 5:53:27 | 5:53:34 | |
here since 11:30am today. I want to
talk about regional policy. I have | 5:53:34 | 5:53:39 | |
obviously restricted the amount I am
going to speak today but I want to | 5:53:39 | 5:53:44 | |
raise one particular issue relating
to the HMRC in my constituency in | 5:53:44 | 5:53:48 | |
Wrexham. It is directly connected to
regional policy. There was a time | 5:53:48 | 5:53:53 | |
when the party opposite talked about
rebalancing the economy. There was a | 5:53:53 | 5:53:58 | |
time when there seemed to be a
commitment to something called the | 5:53:58 | 5:54:01 | |
northern powerhouse. I recall a
committee that I attended a couple | 5:54:01 | 5:54:07 | |
of years ago with the then
Chancellor of the ex-Jack -- the | 5:54:07 | 5:54:14 | |
Chancellor of the Exchequer, when
they talked about the investment in | 5:54:14 | 5:54:16 | |
the north of England. I have had
some time to read the Redbook today. | 5:54:16 | 5:54:22 | |
There is quite a large section about
investment in the Cambridge, Milton | 5:54:22 | 5:54:29 | |
Keynes, Oxford corridor. One of the
most affluent places in the United | 5:54:29 | 5:54:33 | |
Kingdom. I believe in an economy
that serves the whole of this | 5:54:33 | 5:54:37 | |
country. What I want to tell the
Honourable secretary of the Treasury | 5:54:37 | 5:54:45 | |
is another corridor that exists
between Manchester and Holyhead and | 5:54:45 | 5:54:50 | |
contains some of the world leading
companies in the UK - Airbuses, JVC | 5:54:50 | 5:54:58 | |
- and that is an area of the country
that the private sector is investing | 5:54:58 | 5:55:06 | |
in. In Wrexham, Virgin Media is
investing in superfast broadband | 5:55:06 | 5:55:11 | |
networks, and had a company
announced last week they will move | 5:55:11 | 5:55:15 | |
into Wrexham with the creation of
250 jobs. They have confidence in | 5:55:15 | 5:55:20 | |
the area. Unfortunately, the
Government is moving away the local | 5:55:20 | 5:55:24 | |
HMRC office in Wrexham, unbelievably
to central Cardiff! So that the only | 5:55:24 | 5:55:35 | |
office of the HMRC in Wales that
will exist is going to be in the | 5:55:35 | 5:55:38 | |
city centre in Cardiff, which is the
most expensive place in the country. | 5:55:38 | 5:55:44 | |
How any sane government can pursue a
regional policy of that type is | 5:55:44 | 5:55:48 | |
completely beyond me. Because not
only is it wrong in terms of | 5:55:48 | 5:55:53 | |
regional policy, it is taking away
wealth from another part of Wales. | 5:55:53 | 5:55:59 | |
And any sensible government would
actually be doing exactly the | 5:55:59 | 5:56:02 | |
opposite. Because a sensible
government, the Welsh government, is | 5:56:02 | 5:56:08 | |
setting up a development plan for
Wales in Wrexham as opposed to | 5:56:08 | 5:56:11 | |
Cardiff. I would like the Chief
Secretary to go away and to rethink. | 5:56:11 | 5:56:22 | |
To rethink what I think is the worst
decision and most incomprehensible | 5:56:22 | 5:56:26 | |
decision that any government
department has made in the time I've | 5:56:26 | 5:56:29 | |
been in this House. I think this
Government will you need to reflect | 5:56:29 | 5:56:34 | |
on whether it really believes in the
United Kingdom, about whether it | 5:56:34 | 5:56:38 | |
really believes in investment in our
regions and our nations, because | 5:56:38 | 5:56:44 | |
every indication that I've seen from
what we've seen today is that they | 5:56:44 | 5:56:48 | |
don't support investment in
infrastructure in the regions and | 5:56:48 | 5:56:55 | |
nations of the United Kingdom. In
North Wales we've had three separate | 5:56:55 | 5:57:00 | |
Budgets where we've been told that
plans for North Wales growth deal | 5:57:00 | 5:57:05 | |
are in hand. This is the hat-trick.
This is the hat-trick budget. We are | 5:57:05 | 5:57:12 | |
yet to see a penny piece of
investment in North Wales from the | 5:57:12 | 5:57:16 | |
UK Government. In our transport
infrastructure. We are yet to see a | 5:57:16 | 5:57:24 | |
penny invested in our rail network
for which this Government has | 5:57:24 | 5:57:30 | |
responsibility since 2010. They
ought to be ashamed. It is about | 5:57:30 | 5:57:33 | |
time they put their finger out and
do things differently. Thank you. So | 5:57:33 | 5:57:44 | |
much for the fudge it Budget.
Virtually no mention of Brexit, and | 5:57:44 | 5:57:54 | |
we know there are 58 sector reports
that he will be in contempt if he | 5:57:54 | 5:57:58 | |
doesn't reveal them to this House
and he didn't reveal them at all in | 5:57:58 | 5:58:03 | |
his Budget speech. Even before
Budget, we saw the government | 5:58:03 | 5:58:06 | |
increase debt as a proportion of GDP
from 45 to 95%, doubled since 2010. | 5:58:06 | 5:58:13 | |
Our debt is now 1.8 trillion, 30,000
per person. Under Labour we saw | 5:58:13 | 5:58:21 | |
growth of 40% over ten years up to
2008 before the banking crisis, so | 5:58:21 | 5:58:27 | |
that sets the context of how
appalling things have been under the | 5:58:27 | 5:58:33 | |
Tories. We've seen hopeless
productivity and growth. With senior | 5:58:33 | 5:58:39 | |
policy of quantitative easing, which
basically pumped money in, inflated | 5:58:39 | 5:58:43 | |
assets, and anybody with assets like
houses would be richer, and those | 5:58:43 | 5:58:47 | |
without them would be poorer. We
know from the OECD that growth is | 5:58:47 | 5:58:52 | |
related to inequality. There is more
inequality and less growth. We know | 5:58:52 | 5:58:56 | |
from the European studies using the
normal methodology is that the level | 5:58:56 | 5:59:02 | |
of inequality has grown fastest and
at the highest level in the UK. And | 5:59:02 | 5:59:06 | |
we know from the United Nations that
the cuts have hit the disabled | 5:59:06 | 5:59:10 | |
harder than anyone else,
disproportionately and grotesquely, | 5:59:10 | 5:59:15 | |
so their rights have been abused,
and the UN has asked the way we | 5:59:15 | 5:59:19 | |
change the way we deliver Universal
Credit. It is appalling. Turning to | 5:59:19 | 5:59:24 | |
Brexit itself, nobody on the other
side has mentioned the £40 billion | 5:59:24 | 5:59:32 | |
divorce Bill, the lender being in
the region of £1000 per person. | 5:59:32 | 5:59:37 | |
People have talked about free trade.
This is the biggest withdrawal from | 5:59:37 | 5:59:42 | |
free trade in UK history. We are
turning our back on the biggest and | 5:59:42 | 5:59:46 | |
most established marketplace in the
world and we hope to have a | 5:59:46 | 5:59:51 | |
relationship with other markets, but
they are coalescing in their own | 5:59:51 | 5:59:54 | |
trade agreements. We are likely to
pay massive tariffs to the EU and | 5:59:54 | 6:00:00 | |
the WTO, and given most of the
exports are services, even more to | 6:00:00 | 6:00:04 | |
those. We have seen depreciation
produce of a stroke everybody's | 6:00:04 | 6:00:09 | |
assets and wages by ten and 15% and
we have got inflation eating away at | 6:00:09 | 6:00:16 | |
people'shousehold incomes, whether
it is in terms of food or energy. We | 6:00:16 | 6:00:21 | |
have seen growth at the bottom of
the G7 and we are now seeing skills | 6:00:21 | 6:00:25 | |
leaving the country, going back to
parts of Europe and Poland, as we | 6:00:25 | 6:00:31 | |
are gaining restricted market access
and disinvestment. So the prospects | 6:00:31 | 6:00:35 | |
for Britain are appalling. Obviously
I welcome a few things. The clean | 6:00:35 | 6:00:42 | |
air bill today, many years after
Tony Benn. So I welcome some of the | 6:00:42 | 6:00:50 | |
things about clean air, but there is
no increase in diesel duty. That | 6:00:50 | 6:00:57 | |
could be hypothecated to pay for
electric buses in our city centres. | 6:00:57 | 6:01:02 | |
I welcome the initiative on taxes. I
would have liked to see the Swansea | 6:01:02 | 6:01:10 | |
clean air focused in here because
they cannot be exploited if we are | 6:01:10 | 6:01:17 | |
not to see climate change. And I
would like to see a Swansea Metro | 6:01:17 | 6:01:23 | |
for my constituents. Unfortunately,
we have a future now whereby we will | 6:01:23 | 6:01:27 | |
be forced into the grabbing hands of
Donald Trump and the trade | 6:01:27 | 6:01:32 | |
relationships where we will be on
the back foot, and we will have to | 6:01:32 | 6:01:36 | |
accept what we are given. I do fear
for the future and I solemnly | 6:01:36 | 6:01:40 | |
believe that the British people on
the margin, when they were given a | 6:01:40 | 6:01:47 | |
mandatory reason for leaving Europe,
that they should be given the final | 6:01:47 | 6:01:50 | |
say in 2018 as to whether what they
are getting now represents what they | 6:01:50 | 6:01:56 | |
understood they would get in 2016. I
will leave my remarks there. I would | 6:01:56 | 6:02:03 | |
like to start by reminding the House
that the Bristol economy is a net | 6:02:03 | 6:02:10 | |
contributor of about £10 billion
annually and I ask, what do we get | 6:02:10 | 6:02:13 | |
for it? I have looked in the red
book and it's not there. A few | 6:02:13 | 6:02:17 | |
paltry comments. Once again we have
been short-changed by this | 6:02:17 | 6:02:20 | |
Government. In Bristol the reality
of low-paid jobs is masked. Young | 6:02:20 | 6:02:28 | |
people are least likely in the
country to go to university and our | 6:02:28 | 6:02:35 | |
people are least likely to end up on
apprenticeships. We have 20% of our | 6:02:35 | 6:02:39 | |
people living with a life affecting
visibility. This is a scandalous | 6:02:39 | 6:02:44 | |
loss of people. I welcome the
Chancellor's commitment to | 6:02:44 | 6:02:50 | |
house-building as this is crucial
for my constituency but with house | 6:02:50 | 6:02:54 | |
inflation at 14% in Bristol, the cut
in stamp duty will not be of much | 6:02:54 | 6:02:58 | |
help. And I look forward to hearing
whether the council will be able to | 6:02:58 | 6:03:04 | |
borrow more to build much-needed
council houses to rent in the | 6:03:04 | 6:03:08 | |
future. We have young people in
Bristol ready to build these houses | 6:03:08 | 6:03:13 | |
to feed the supply chain but we
desperately need an opportunity to | 6:03:13 | 6:03:16 | |
train them. The wage differential
for housing construction | 6:03:16 | 6:03:20 | |
apprenticeships is good compared to
others but most of our young people | 6:03:20 | 6:03:24 | |
don't get on good apprenticeships.
Last November the city of Bristol | 6:03:24 | 6:03:29 | |
College was awarded pipeline status
to get a construction centre built | 6:03:29 | 6:03:32 | |
in my constituency. The previous
member visited with me earlier this | 6:03:32 | 6:03:37 | |
year and I pointed out to him the
site where it can be built, but | 6:03:37 | 6:03:41 | |
still the Local Enterprise
Partnership have not invested the | 6:03:41 | 6:03:44 | |
money. There was no coherence in the
Department for Education at the | 6:03:44 | 6:03:48 | |
moment for capital money and
investment and the Chancellor needs | 6:03:48 | 6:03:50 | |
to stop wasting that money and
invest where it is needed. We have | 6:03:50 | 6:03:54 | |
also heard a lot this week about
apprenticeships, about the pledge of | 6:03:54 | 6:04:00 | |
driverless cars and other sectors
the Government believes a priority. | 6:04:00 | 6:04:06 | |
Contrast that with the money for
technical qualifications. I have | 6:04:06 | 6:04:11 | |
supported apprenticeship schemes in
this House for a long time but | 6:04:11 | 6:04:16 | |
focusing on new starts means
quantity over quality. May I remind | 6:04:16 | 6:04:24 | |
the Chancellor of the 61% levy and
the target will not be meant. Isn't | 6:04:24 | 6:04:31 | |
good enough today to refer to the
levy he will keep. I also welcome | 6:04:31 | 6:04:36 | |
the commitment to technical
education as part of an attempt to | 6:04:36 | 6:04:40 | |
fill the skills gap. But again there
is no money in this further | 6:04:40 | 6:04:43 | |
education. A mere £20 million.
Another group -- acutely aware that | 6:04:43 | 6:04:48 | |
have been huge delays in rolling out
this programme. We are losing | 6:04:48 | 6:04:53 | |
critical time. If the issues stem
from a lack of funding than I would | 6:04:53 | 6:04:58 | |
it expect to see something more in
this budget. Instead, my local | 6:04:58 | 6:05:02 | |
college is facing cuts since 2030
and participation rates have halved. | 6:05:02 | 6:05:11 | |
More than 2000 adults failed to be
eligible, more wasted potential. We | 6:05:11 | 6:05:20 | |
also have the lowest attainment
rates for higher education in the | 6:05:20 | 6:05:23 | |
country. Disadvantage starts in
early years and in schools. There | 6:05:23 | 6:05:28 | |
are £1.9 million of cuts coming to
schools in Bristol and the lower | 6:05:28 | 6:05:31 | |
inflation funding formula will
represent a funding decrease. And on | 6:05:31 | 6:05:38 | |
health, on the Public Accounts
Committee last year, we nailed the | 6:05:38 | 6:05:43 | |
lie that the NHS got to ask for lost
time. That's not get into this again | 6:05:43 | 6:05:47 | |
next time. Of course you bunny is
welcome but it is not sufficient to | 6:05:47 | 6:05:50 | |
do the job that the government have
asked the NHS to do. -- of course | 6:05:50 | 6:05:56 | |
the money is welcome. And we have
heard about the silent misery of | 6:05:56 | 6:06:02 | |
families living in the social care
crisis. I've not heard a single Tory | 6:06:02 | 6:06:07 | |
defend those reforms. The
destruction of that act is apparent | 6:06:07 | 6:06:11 | |
to us all. Nobody in charge locally
to do anything about it. It is a | 6:06:11 | 6:06:17 | |
real pleasure to follow the member
for Bristol South. And to speak in | 6:06:17 | 6:06:23 | |
this Budget debate. The outlook for
the economy is bleak. The worst | 6:06:23 | 6:06:27 | |
five-year forecast of GDP since the
office the budget responsibility was | 6:06:27 | 6:06:31 | |
set up. Against the backdrop of the
drop in sterling and the increase in | 6:06:31 | 6:06:35 | |
inflation. As the Chancellor stood
up to speak, the cost of Brexit was | 6:06:35 | 6:06:41 | |
clear. In excess of £3 billion.
Let's put that on the side of a bus. | 6:06:41 | 6:06:49 | |
My constituency has been starved of
funding for the last seven years and | 6:06:49 | 6:06:53 | |
the capacity for us to educate and
care for our citizens as well as | 6:06:53 | 6:06:58 | |
keep them safe has deteriorated and
will fall further. While London | 6:06:58 | 6:07:02 | |
remains seemingly a vibrant economy,
there is a yawning gap between the | 6:07:02 | 6:07:07 | |
haves and have-nots. Earlier in the
debate, the honourable member for | 6:07:07 | 6:07:11 | |
Wrexham spoke of his region and his
concerns about his region. But there | 6:07:11 | 6:07:15 | |
is inequality within a region as
well. Because often in London, we | 6:07:15 | 6:07:20 | |
walked the same streets but inhabit
different worlds. Wages are flat, | 6:07:20 | 6:07:27 | |
household debt is up, transport and
infrastructure continue to stall, | 6:07:27 | 6:07:30 | |
having negative effect on industry
and workers alike. Housing across | 6:07:30 | 6:07:34 | |
the three housing ten years either
hoping to buy, private-sector | 6:07:34 | 6:07:38 | |
renters and those languishing on
housing lists are all in desperate | 6:07:38 | 6:07:43 | |
housing need. -- the three housing
groups. Disappointingly, the rough | 6:07:43 | 6:07:49 | |
sleeping initiative in the speech
did not include tackling rough | 6:07:49 | 6:07:52 | |
sleeping in the capital. I think we
all noticed as we went to our | 6:07:52 | 6:07:57 | |
meetings and the Budget debate this
morning that there were two homeless | 6:07:57 | 6:08:01 | |
men sleep outside the door of the
House of Commons. I think that is | 6:08:01 | 6:08:05 | |
what we would like to tackle here as
Labour members, and sadly, I fear | 6:08:05 | 6:08:10 | |
that when we come to do this next
year, there may even be more | 6:08:10 | 6:08:15 | |
homeless people lying in sleeping
bags outside the doors of the House | 6:08:15 | 6:08:19 | |
of Commons. While London remains one
of the top destinations for business | 6:08:19 | 6:08:24 | |
and international talent, transport
and infrastructure continue to | 6:08:24 | 6:08:29 | |
stall, and it's time we all woke up
to that. The borough of Haringey has | 6:08:29 | 6:08:34 | |
seen a 40% real terms reduction in
funding since 2010, resulting in | 6:08:34 | 6:08:41 | |
£160 million of savings, affecting
disabled people, basic municipal | 6:08:41 | 6:08:46 | |
services, children with special
educational needs and generally | 6:08:46 | 6:08:49 | |
having a depressing effect on the
local economy. This worrying trend | 6:08:49 | 6:08:54 | |
is set to continue, with 20 million
more to be found in one London | 6:08:54 | 6:08:58 | |
Borough's finances. A dangerous
cocktail of growing demand, cost and | 6:08:58 | 6:09:04 | |
inflation combined with funding cuts
is putting unsustainable pressure on | 6:09:04 | 6:09:07 | |
local government finances. Core
funding from central government is | 6:09:07 | 6:09:12 | |
set to have fallen 63% in real terms
over the decade 2019-20. I tell the | 6:09:12 | 6:09:19 | |
children when I go into schools, it
is like your mum gives you £1 and | 6:09:19 | 6:09:24 | |
then the next day, 30p, and that is
what it is like the council 's these | 6:09:24 | 6:09:29 | |
days. People in Hornsey and Wood
Green know this well. There is a | 6:09:29 | 6:09:33 | |
desperate shortage of housing but
also issues with health and we are | 6:09:33 | 6:09:37 | |
very concerned that so many
trusts... She will want to introduce | 6:09:37 | 6:09:44 | |
some balance in her speech because
she is fair-minded. What does she | 6:09:44 | 6:09:48 | |
welcome, the investment in housing,
transport or the cut in stamp duty? | 6:09:48 | 6:10:00 | |
What I would like to see, rather
than the millions wasted on the | 6:10:00 | 6:10:05 | |
Brexit shambles is more than a
billion for the NHS, it is under | 6:10:05 | 6:10:09 | |
what she is saying that we need. In
the 37 out of 37 schools having the | 6:10:09 | 6:10:15 | |
budget tool between 20 1516 and
201920, teaching assistants are all | 6:10:15 | 6:10:25 | |
calling for desperately needed
change. English and is well to | 6:10:25 | 6:10:29 | |
police funding cuts which are barely
got a mention, that looks like the | 6:10:29 | 6:10:32 | |
Home Office is swept -- said to have
to swallow the 400 million cut to | 6:10:32 | 6:10:36 | |
the police. In the affluent suburb
of Highgate, I was out on Monday | 6:10:36 | 6:10:40 | |
morning speaking the terrified
mothers who had things are stolen by | 6:10:40 | 6:10:49 | |
mopeds driving youngster to head
smashed in the wonders of the cafe, | 6:10:49 | 6:10:53 | |
it has happened four times as they
moved into the high street. We are | 6:10:53 | 6:10:56 | |
facing a claim with London and it
does need to be addressed. Finally, | 6:10:56 | 6:11:00 | |
I would like to briefly mention the
797 million or £410 cut per person | 6:11:00 | 6:11:09 | |
in the North Central London area.
Many members will be aware that | 6:11:09 | 6:11:15 | |
there are huge pressures,
particularly on mental health and | 6:11:15 | 6:11:18 | |
use shorts of cups, £510 per person
will have a huge cut -- a huge | 6:11:18 | 6:11:25 | |
impact on people with serious mental
health problems. Just finally, can I | 6:11:25 | 6:11:29 | |
just say that I do welcome element
of the changes to small business | 6:11:29 | 6:11:34 | |
approaches within taxation but I
also think that we must go further | 6:11:34 | 6:11:37 | |
on that. As our population continues
to call and people work in different | 6:11:37 | 6:11:42 | |
ways, including in small business,
we need to be ever made of | 6:11:42 | 6:11:46 | |
supporting them. Thank you Madam
Deputy Speaker. Thank you Madam | 6:11:46 | 6:11:52 | |
Deputy Speaker, will try to rush
through this as quickly as I | 6:11:52 | 6:11:55 | |
possibly can. We in the SNP called
for a budget to keep the drag the | 6:11:55 | 6:11:59 | |
people and prosperity at its heart.
I'm afraid we have not seen that. | 6:11:59 | 6:12:07 | |
There was nothing today on renewable
energy. Despite the warm words for | 6:12:07 | 6:12:12 | |
ministers just reaching -- years on
from the betrayal that might the | 6:12:12 | 6:12:17 | |
betrayal by George Osborne over
Peterhead, there is nothing on | 6:12:17 | 6:12:19 | |
carbon capture and storage, the call
to what we need for the future. Very | 6:12:19 | 6:12:24 | |
little on oil and gas holder we
welcome at long last the | 6:12:24 | 6:12:29 | |
transitional tax as to the move.
Nowhere to be seen as the oil and | 6:12:29 | 6:12:33 | |
gas ambassador that was promised.
This phantom appointment two years | 6:12:33 | 6:12:37 | |
in the waiting, when it could have
been doing good for the North Sea | 6:12:37 | 6:12:42 | |
industry. No acknowledgement of the
monumental error of judgment that is | 6:12:42 | 6:12:47 | |
frankly see nuclear investment.
Where a public appearance committee | 6:12:47 | 6:12:51 | |
said today there were grave
strategic errors over this and they | 6:12:51 | 6:12:55 | |
had given no thoughts to consumers
before walking into a 35 year deal | 6:12:55 | 6:13:00 | |
and it falls the National Audit
Office publicity and expensive | 6:13:00 | 6:13:05 | |
judgment twice the price of new
offshore, consumers paying the | 6:13:05 | 6:13:10 | |
price. The committee said the poor I
had the hardest. This is not a | 6:13:10 | 6:13:13 | |
budget for people, like the one for
posterity. -- prosperity. We find | 6:13:13 | 6:13:20 | |
there would be 3.5 billion spent on
the Brexit users. Web as spend that | 6:13:20 | 6:13:26 | |
on the edge and stash by the NHS
instead. We could have heard support | 6:13:26 | 6:13:32 | |
for our farmers, or gently, who need
a clear explanation of the nature | 6:13:32 | 6:13:36 | |
and timetable for the guarantee of
all European Union funding | 6:13:36 | 6:13:40 | |
programmes, not at 2020 but for the
period beyond. The thing to do with | 6:13:40 | 6:13:45 | |
the skills and Labour shortages now
being caused by the Brexit shambles | 6:13:45 | 6:13:48 | |
and uncertainty. Nothing about the
traces that has been caused for NHS | 6:13:48 | 6:13:57 | |
fish processing, tourism sectors, to
name just a few. The fact that is | 6:13:57 | 6:14:03 | |
that we don't know what is happening
it for EU nationals and we are | 6:14:03 | 6:14:07 | |
seeing people leaving the industry.
Much was made earlier about it | 6:14:07 | 6:14:11 | |
technology and yet nothing about
broadband, no increase in ambition | 6:14:11 | 6:14:15 | |
has been shown in this budget, to
match the 100% coverage promised by | 6:14:15 | 6:14:21 | |
Scotland. If it was left to the UK
Government and the Highlands, only | 6:14:21 | 6:14:28 | |
21% of the India would have access
to fibre. It has taken the Scottish | 6:14:28 | 6:14:33 | |
Government stepping up with a £400
billion to bring it to 84% and on | 6:14:33 | 6:14:38 | |
track to 100%. Where we are on
Scotland, Madam Deputy Speaker, the | 6:14:38 | 6:14:43 | |
£2.9 billion cut that we have seen
is not matched. 1.1 billion of this | 6:14:43 | 6:14:51 | |
is in financial attractions which
has two B depict the UK Treasury and | 6:14:51 | 6:14:55 | |
it has over three years. Edin Dzeko
term cut of £32 million. Where was | 6:14:55 | 6:15:02 | |
the movement won a wasp in? These
women have been waiting far too long | 6:15:02 | 6:15:07 | |
to get something from the Chancellor
to sort them out. He said the -- you | 6:15:07 | 6:15:11 | |
said earlier we are all in politics
to make people's lives better. We | 6:15:11 | 6:15:14 | |
had a big opportunity to do that
today but she missed it. He could | 6:15:14 | 6:15:20 | |
have halted it and fix the Universal
Credit. After four years since the | 6:15:20 | 6:15:24 | |
pilot then my constituency in 2013,
we have been telling the UK | 6:15:24 | 6:15:28 | |
Government things they could do to
sort this. I will steps, but let's | 6:15:28 | 6:15:38 | |
not get dazzled. This is not going
to change much. The £1.5 billion | 6:15:38 | 6:15:40 | |
invention announce sounds good but
if you look at the blue book, it is | 6:15:40 | 6:15:44 | |
£21 million today and goes up to
2023. That is less confusing alcohol | 6:15:44 | 6:15:51 | |
duty. The one-week production to
five weeks is also welcome and it's | 6:15:51 | 6:15:59 | |
something but again, it will be of
little help to many. 25% of Clement | 6:15:59 | 6:16:05 | |
are already waiting longer and the
cuts are pushing people further into | 6:16:05 | 6:16:08 | |
crisis. They could help by
decoupling the housing benefit. That | 6:16:08 | 6:16:18 | |
would help enormously. It could have
helped ease burdens as a woman's | 6:16:18 | 6:16:22 | |
budget could have pointed out, by
April 2021, employed individuals | 6:16:22 | 6:16:28 | |
claiming Universal Credit will be
£1200 a year worse off and 57% of | 6:16:28 | 6:16:33 | |
that is due to be a cut work
allowance. His failure to hold | 6:16:33 | 6:16:38 | |
Universal Credit means that he is
doing nothing to help families | 6:16:38 | 6:16:43 | |
waiting for months without payment.
Nothing to sort the systemic failure | 6:16:43 | 6:16:47 | |
systemic failure -- failure is | 6:16:47 | 6:16:58 | |
nothing to the disabled, no help or
guarantees to those facing eviction | 6:16:58 | 6:17:00 | |
or facing having no money this
Christmas. No attempt to remove, | 6:17:00 | 6:17:03 | |
finally, the cruellest features, the
wait for a cancer patient or the | 6:17:03 | 6:17:05 | |
terminally ill. He could have done
something that costs absolutely | 6:17:05 | 6:17:07 | |
nothing today, Madam Deputy Speaker,
he could have removed the new | 6:17:07 | 6:17:13 | |
requirement for Universal Credit for
self certification of those people | 6:17:13 | 6:17:16 | |
facing terminal illness. This is not
the budget for people or facility. | 6:17:16 | 6:17:28 | |
Thank you very much Madam Deputy
Speaker. I am please to fold | 6:17:28 | 6:17:32 | |
Honourable Member for Inverness and
to take part in the budget debate | 6:17:32 | 6:17:34 | |
today. The British economy has
basically got to problems. It has a | 6:17:34 | 6:17:38 | |
low productivity growth, a worker in
France or Germany can go home on a | 6:17:38 | 6:17:44 | |
first in eight, having produced
except a number of things. The | 6:17:44 | 6:17:48 | |
British worker has to continue until
Friday night to have made the same | 6:17:48 | 6:17:52 | |
amount of staff. The second problem
we have in this economy at the | 6:17:52 | 6:17:57 | |
moment is a high level of
uncertainty and I think Honourable | 6:17:57 | 6:18:02 | |
Member is probably now the pound
fell again after the Chancellor | 6:18:02 | 6:18:06 | |
stood down. Now, the forecast shows
that this is not getting better GDP | 6:18:06 | 6:18:11 | |
growth is down productivity growth
is down. In June one, there is no | 6:18:11 | 6:18:21 | |
productivity growth. The amount of
money that we will have will be £40 | 6:18:21 | 6:18:26 | |
billion less to spend and do or have
tax cuts at the end of the forecast | 6:18:26 | 6:18:30 | |
period, than we thought at this time
last year. As a consequence, the | 6:18:30 | 6:18:37 | |
forecast also is showing average
earnings are fallen. What the | 6:18:37 | 6:18:42 | |
Chancellor do to tackle this
productivity problem. This is a | 6:18:42 | 6:18:47 | |
long-running problem, obviously
there aren't instant solutions. | 6:18:47 | 6:18:50 | |
Nobody would be foolish enough to
think that. One thing that I think | 6:18:50 | 6:18:54 | |
it's worth noting is that the
productivity problem has original | 6:18:54 | 6:18:59 | |
dimensions. The IPPR have found that
productivity outside the south-east | 6:18:59 | 6:19:04 | |
is 44% award than elsewhere. So,
when Honourable Member stalk about | 6:19:04 | 6:19:09 | |
investing in the regions, this is
not just a matter of social justice, | 6:19:09 | 6:19:13 | |
it is also a matter of economic
efficiency. At the moment, the | 6:19:13 | 6:19:18 | |
north-east gets 200 per head spent
on transport, well London gets 1940. | 6:19:18 | 6:19:26 | |
Almost ten times as much. Why
doesn't the Government reorder its | 6:19:26 | 6:19:32 | |
investment projects and do HSP,
linking Newcastle to Liverpool, | 6:19:32 | 6:19:37 | |
before it does a chest to. Let's
take a look at what was in the | 6:19:37 | 6:19:42 | |
budget for the north-east. Tiny sums
of money. The north of Tyne | 6:19:42 | 6:19:47 | |
devolution deal, £20 million a year.
Time and we are metal, the money | 6:19:47 | 6:19:53 | |
would be released until 2022. That
is five years from now. Redcar | 6:19:53 | 6:19:58 | |
steelworks, the only new money was
£5 million. Tees Valley, they are | 6:19:58 | 6:20:03 | |
being offered something that has no
price tag at all, they are being | 6:20:03 | 6:20:06 | |
invited to enter discussions and
it's not just the north-east. | 6:20:06 | 6:20:11 | |
Midland connect is getting £6
million. But the London business | 6:20:11 | 6:20:17 | |
rate retention which is being
piloted is going to give London £7.5 | 6:20:17 | 6:20:23 | |
billion and, with the stamp duty cut
in my constituency, the average | 6:20:23 | 6:20:27 | |
House price is a. People want to
benefit this might not gone to | 6:20:27 | 6:20:32 | |
benefit from it at all. The second
aspect of this is obviously skills. | 6:20:32 | 6:20:43 | |
In my constituency, there is an
excellent further education college. | 6:20:43 | 6:20:51 | |
It plays a vital role. Between 2009
and 2015, further education has been | 6:20:51 | 6:21:00 | |
cut by 27%. Adult education has been
cut by 50%. The Chancellor announced | 6:21:00 | 6:21:04 | |
extra money. £60 million. It is 2%
more, tiny percent -- tiny compared | 6:21:04 | 6:21:12 | |
to the massive cuts. We must start
investing more in our skills. The | 6:21:12 | 6:21:21 | |
original disparities here as well.
Of course it is true that people | 6:21:21 | 6:21:25 | |
don't have jobs for life but if we
want to help them through this | 6:21:25 | 6:21:28 | |
transition, we need to do more for
adult education. I thought the | 6:21:28 | 6:21:36 | |
manifesto had some very sensible
things in it. Instead we should | 6:21:36 | 6:21:39 | |
spend another £200 on 16 to
19-year-olds, it said we should | 6:21:39 | 6:21:43 | |
extend child benefits to people who
are doing A-levels. And they said we | 6:21:43 | 6:21:52 | |
should spend money on public
transport for young people. In my | 6:21:52 | 6:21:57 | |
constituency, young person on the
young savers ticket, going from the | 6:21:57 | 6:22:01 | |
field to Bishop Auckland has a
weekly Bill of £31 a week. The young | 6:22:01 | 6:22:10 | |
person going from Bishopton from
Arlington has a higher Bill. These | 6:22:10 | 6:22:14 | |
are substantial numbers. The most
disappointing thing is that the | 6:22:14 | 6:22:19 | |
Chancellor has not won more battles
on the Brexit. And that he has not | 6:22:19 | 6:22:25 | |
been able to see of those people who
want a cliff edge from the 1st of | 6:22:25 | 6:22:32 | |
April 2019. We all thought when the
premise to meet our love -- Forum | 6:22:32 | 6:22:38 | |
speech that the Chancellor had won
this argument. We were all extremely | 6:22:38 | 6:22:42 | |
pleased by this on the side of the
House. It seems that this was not | 6:22:42 | 6:22:47 | |
so. Businesses want certainty now.
It is nearly Christmas. Ministers to | 6:22:47 | 6:22:52 | |
get skates on. The question is that
the debate be now adjourned. As many | 6:22:52 | 6:23:02 | |
are of that opinion see eye. I think
the ayes have it. The debate is to | 6:23:02 | 6:23:11 | |
be resilient on what day? Tomorrow.
The model. Now, with the Leader of | 6:23:11 | 6:23:18 | |
the House, I would like to take
motions to 27 together. Motions to | 6:23:18 | 6:23:27 | |
and seven on international
development, the Minister to move? I | 6:23:27 | 6:23:29 | |
make the move. The question is as on
the order paper, as many are that | 6:23:29 | 6:23:35 | |
opinion see high. On the contrary
now. The ayes have it. Petition | 6:23:35 | 6:23:42 | |
Kevin Foster. | 6:23:42 | 6:23:42 | |
I rise to present the petition from
the residents of Torbay around bus | 6:23:48 | 6:23:55 | |
services. I would particularly like
to pay tribute to the work of | 6:23:55 | 6:23:59 | |
Rosemary Shaw, who has collected the
signatures of thousands of people, | 6:23:59 | 6:24:06 | |
both in person and online. The bus
service being cancelled or have a | 6:24:06 | 6:24:16 | |
detrimental effect on residents and
particularly elderly residents. | 6:24:16 | 6:24:21 | |
Would they commit to reinstating the
service of the number 32 for local | 6:24:21 | 6:24:26 | |
residents as soon as is the? -- as
possible? | 6:24:26 | 6:24:32 | |
Petition to local bus services in
Torbay. The question is that this | 6:24:39 | 6:24:47 | |
House do now adjourn. Thank you. I
am grateful for the opportunity to | 6:24:47 | 6:24:56 | |
raise the important issue of the
future of safety critical guards on | 6:24:56 | 6:25:00 | |
Merseyrail trains in this chamber
this evening. All of us value the | 6:25:00 | 6:25:04 | |
work of the people who keep our
country moving, be it guards, | 6:25:04 | 6:25:09 | |
drivers, signal workers, track
workers, ticket office workers, | 6:25:09 | 6:25:12 | |
cleaners and station staff. I
represent my home city in This Place | 6:25:12 | 6:25:17 | |
and it is a privilege to be able to
speak up for my constituents and | 6:25:17 | 6:25:21 | |
working people, and it is worth
rendering that when workers want to | 6:25:21 | 6:25:25 | |
raise issues as important as public
safety and protecting decent jobs | 6:25:25 | 6:25:31 | |
for the future, they are all too
often have to take industrial | 6:25:31 | 6:25:34 | |
action, putting their own
livelihoods at risk, something I | 6:25:34 | 6:25:37 | |
don't have to do making this speech
tonight. I'm very grateful to him. | 6:25:37 | 6:25:44 | |
On that very point about nobody
wanting this to happen, he will have | 6:25:44 | 6:25:50 | |
seen the letter from the city region
by the six council leaders on the | 6:25:50 | 6:26:01 | |
16th of November, which they called
for, both parties in the dispute, to | 6:26:01 | 6:26:08 | |
agree to engage in a process of
independent reconciliation, starting | 6:26:08 | 6:26:13 | |
with no preconditions, with the
intent of finding a negotiated | 6:26:13 | 6:26:17 | |
settlement. Doesn't he think that is
a reasonable suggestion? I thank my | 6:26:17 | 6:26:23 | |
honourable friend for his
intervention and I will lay out my | 6:26:23 | 6:26:27 | |
arguments, including comments on
that issue as I continue. I want to | 6:26:27 | 6:26:33 | |
use the debate outline why guards
are so important for safety, | 6:26:33 | 6:26:39 | |
security, service and accessibility,
and highlight the level of public | 6:26:39 | 6:26:42 | |
support for retaining guards on
trains. They are a safety critical | 6:26:42 | 6:26:47 | |
function and they are valuable,
protecting the personal safety of | 6:26:47 | 6:26:51 | |
all passengers. Over the last 30
years there has been a creeping | 6:26:51 | 6:26:55 | |
introduction of driver only
operation. DOI oh is opposed by the | 6:26:55 | 6:26:59 | |
rail unions and is unpopular with
the public. Since January 2011 there | 6:26:59 | 6:27:04 | |
have been at least ten serious
incidents of passenger-train | 6:27:04 | 6:27:08 | |
interface. Eight of these involved
DOO, operating without a safety | 6:27:08 | 6:27:17 | |
critical member on the train. It is
now proposed to move all of | 6:27:17 | 6:27:27 | |
Merseyrail's 207 guards. This
decision comes after a 30 year £460 | 6:27:27 | 6:27:32 | |
million contract from new rolling
stock was signed by the transport | 6:27:32 | 6:27:35 | |
authority. Will he give way? I thank
him for that. Does he welcome this | 6:27:35 | 6:27:44 | |
new rolling stock, which will have
the best accessibility for disabled | 6:27:44 | 6:27:48 | |
people in the whole of the country?
Does he therefore think that | 6:27:48 | 6:27:53 | |
negotiations to resolve industrial
issues are a matter of urgency so | 6:27:53 | 6:27:56 | |
the people of Merseyside can join
these new trains when they arrive? | 6:27:56 | 6:28:01 | |
Of course negotiations are critical
to resolving this dispute and I | 6:28:01 | 6:28:07 | |
welcome the new trains. They are
long overdue and they are something | 6:28:07 | 6:28:10 | |
the unions have also campaigned for.
And they will be publicly owned by | 6:28:10 | 6:28:15 | |
the people of the Liverpool city
region, forecast to be 30% cheaper | 6:28:15 | 6:28:19 | |
for the taxpayer then using the
failed Roscoe releasing model. The | 6:28:19 | 6:28:25 | |
latter are like the loan sharks of
the railway and it is right that | 6:28:25 | 6:28:28 | |
they are rejected in Liverpool, and
perhaps the minister might like to | 6:28:28 | 6:28:31 | |
say a few words on why his
department persists in using them | 6:28:31 | 6:28:35 | |
across the rest of the rail network.
However, there is not a choice | 6:28:35 | 6:28:40 | |
between having new trains and
keeping a fully staffed service. The | 6:28:40 | 6:28:45 | |
two are not mutually exclusive. In
fact, these new carriage list trains | 6:28:45 | 6:28:49 | |
with a more open feature allow the
guard to pass more easily down the | 6:28:49 | 6:28:53 | |
length of the train. Mersey travel
originally said they wanted both | 6:28:53 | 6:28:57 | |
when the new train contract was
first announced and Liam Robinson | 6:28:57 | 6:29:03 | |
said, in an ideal world, we would
like to have a second member of | 6:29:03 | 6:29:06 | |
staff on every train but we don't
have the resources to do that. I'm | 6:29:06 | 6:29:11 | |
grateful to him this assistance in
the lead up this debate. The pitiful | 6:29:11 | 6:29:19 | |
investment in public infrastructure
in the North has rightly been spoken | 6:29:19 | 6:29:22 | |
about. Tory cuts to local councils
and grant in the city region, | 6:29:22 | 6:29:29 | |
because of these, the local levy has
been cut by £32 million in real | 6:29:29 | 6:29:33 | |
terms, which represents a third of
the transport budget locally being | 6:29:33 | 6:29:37 | |
lost. Faced with these cuts, we must
defend and maintain the standards we | 6:29:37 | 6:29:42 | |
have, protect jobs and passenger
safety and expose unjustifiable | 6:29:42 | 6:29:47 | |
profiteering from the travelling
public. Our return to the role of | 6:29:47 | 6:29:52 | |
local representatives, the transport
authority and government later in my | 6:29:52 | 6:29:56 | |
remarks, but first let me set out
where the first step is to agree the | 6:29:56 | 6:30:01 | |
principle that keeping the guards on
the train is essential so we can | 6:30:01 | 6:30:05 | |
move to a more constructive debate
which looks at solutions. -- I will | 6:30:05 | 6:30:10 | |
return to the role of local
representatives. There are four | 6:30:10 | 6:30:15 | |
railway stations in my constituency.
The loss of policemen from the | 6:30:15 | 6:30:21 | |
budget is having a devastating
impact on our communities and the | 6:30:21 | 6:30:24 | |
ability of the police to protect the
public. Data released by the British | 6:30:24 | 6:30:29 | |
Transport Police shows the number of
violent attacks on mainline and | 6:30:29 | 6:30:34 | |
underground trains has increased by
12.5% in the last year, including | 6:30:34 | 6:30:40 | |
the spike in hate crime. Reported
sexual offences on trains have more | 6:30:40 | 6:30:45 | |
than doubled in the past five years
and figures obtained under a Freedom | 6:30:45 | 6:30:51 | |
of Information request submitted by
the RMT has found that in the last | 6:30:51 | 6:30:53 | |
five years there were over 1200
on-train crimes on Merseyrail. The | 6:30:53 | 6:30:59 | |
figures also show that almost 900,
or 72% of crimes, took place before | 6:30:59 | 6:31:07 | |
8am, the time when Merseyrail have
indicated they would seek to retain | 6:31:07 | 6:31:14 | |
a second person on the train, which
begs the question, if Merseyrail | 6:31:14 | 6:31:18 | |
acknowledge the need for a second
person on the train after 8pm, why | 6:31:18 | 6:31:21 | |
not before? And just as when you cut
police numbers you make the public | 6:31:21 | 6:31:28 | |
more vulnerable to crime, when you
remove front line rail staff you | 6:31:28 | 6:31:33 | |
almost jeopardise passenger safety.
A report produced for Mersey travel | 6:31:33 | 6:31:38 | |
by Passenger Focus in April 2014,
the future Merseyrail rolling stock, | 6:31:38 | 6:31:45 | |
what passengers wanted was clear.
The fact that emerged us by far the | 6:31:45 | 6:31:51 | |
most important to improve from a
passenger perspective was personal | 6:31:51 | 6:31:55 | |
security on the train. It showed
passenger satisfaction with personal | 6:31:55 | 6:32:02 | |
security was high, at 86%, and the
report said that this aspect is a | 6:32:02 | 6:32:07 | |
strength upon which it is important
to maintain focus and development. | 6:32:07 | 6:32:10 | |
It went on to state that the
importance of this messenger -- | 6:32:10 | 6:32:15 | |
measure to passengers suggests that
if satisfaction with personal | 6:32:15 | 6:32:18 | |
security were to decrease in future,
this would have a severe negative | 6:32:18 | 6:32:26 | |
effect on overall satisfaction with
the service as a whole. Subsequent | 6:32:26 | 6:32:31 | |
polling found that among women
passengers, 84% said they would feel | 6:32:31 | 6:32:35 | |
less safe without a guard. And for
people over 55, 80 5% said they | 6:32:35 | 6:32:41 | |
would feel less safe without guards.
-- 85%. Perhaps the best | 6:32:41 | 6:32:48 | |
demonstration of how God is our
valued with a recent petition which | 6:32:48 | 6:32:55 | |
gained thousands of persistent --
thousands of signatures. -- of how | 6:32:55 | 6:32:58 | |
guards are valued. The guards took
extra steps to make her and other | 6:32:58 | 6:33:06 | |
female passengers are secure in a
situation she and others faced. Too | 6:33:06 | 6:33:11 | |
much of the debate has focused on
issues like who will operate the | 6:33:11 | 6:33:14 | |
doors and whether the DOO can lead
to conditions. Neither government -- | 6:33:14 | 6:33:23 | |
neither the government nor the
regulators have made any assessment | 6:33:23 | 6:33:26 | |
of the additional risks to
passengers. Risks to passengers once | 6:33:26 | 6:33:31 | |
the train has left the platform with
or without a guard on the train. How | 6:33:31 | 6:33:36 | |
can any decision claim to take
passenger safety seriously before | 6:33:36 | 6:33:40 | |
these assessments have even been
made? Duties include protecting the | 6:33:40 | 6:33:48 | |
train, safely securing the doors and
dealing with emergencies such as | 6:33:48 | 6:33:52 | |
derailments, evacuation, fires and
capacity, and if there is a failure | 6:33:52 | 6:33:58 | |
of train systems. Following a
collision between a train and a road | 6:33:58 | 6:34:01 | |
vehicle in Merseyrail in August
2016, the guard played -- placed | 6:34:01 | 6:34:10 | |
isolating equipment on the track and
evacuated passengers while the | 6:34:10 | 6:34:17 | |
driver remained in his cab leading
communications. Without this, | 6:34:17 | 6:34:25 | |
incidents would be dealt with by
intercom to passengers from a place | 6:34:25 | 6:34:31 | |
miles away. It cannot be deemed that
this is safer. There are many more | 6:34:31 | 6:34:36 | |
stories like this but as I'm pushed
for time I will carry on. Disabled | 6:34:36 | 6:34:41 | |
passengers, people with a visual or
hearing impairment, or those with | 6:34:41 | 6:34:46 | |
anxiety, rely on the practical
assistance and reassurance of staff | 6:34:46 | 6:34:50 | |
on platforms and on trains. The
disabled protection policy says | 6:34:50 | 6:34:59 | |
people on platforms and on trains
are designed to help you. In the | 6:34:59 | 6:35:04 | |
2017 report they talked about the
future of accessible travel. I | 6:35:04 | 6:35:12 | |
believe it is worth fighting to keep
good jobs for the future. Losing | 6:35:12 | 6:35:22 | |
over 200 Rob is in no way
progressive. The public still | 6:35:22 | 6:35:27 | |
overwhelmingly backed the guards.
Recent polling shows 87% oppose the | 6:35:27 | 6:35:34 | |
removal of these guards from
Merseyrail. Labour Party policy is | 6:35:34 | 6:35:40 | |
clear - to oppose any extension of
driver only operation. The Welsh | 6:35:40 | 6:35:46 | |
government has now guaranteed a
guard on every train for future | 6:35:46 | 6:35:49 | |
franchises and Scotland has made
similar long-term arrangements. The | 6:35:49 | 6:35:53 | |
Secretary of State wrote last week
telling them a labour government | 6:35:53 | 6:35:58 | |
would hold any plans to extend
driver only operation. Mersey | 6:35:58 | 6:36:01 | |
travel's former chair remains
opposed to removing the guards, | 6:36:01 | 6:36:07 | |
saying common sense should prevail.
It has never been clearer that we | 6:36:07 | 6:36:11 | |
need a new structure for our
railways. Labour would take back | 6:36:11 | 6:36:15 | |
control by bringing back our rail
network into public ownership. By | 6:36:15 | 6:36:19 | |
reinvesting the revenues that are
currently disappearing into the | 6:36:19 | 6:36:24 | |
pockets of shareholders, a Labour
government would ensure affordable | 6:36:24 | 6:36:28 | |
fares, state-of-the-art trains, safe
staffing levels and an end to DOO. | 6:36:28 | 6:36:35 | |
We would preserve safety along with
jobs. This Government doesn't have a | 6:36:35 | 6:36:39 | |
plan for our rail network. It is
writing job cuts into rail contract | 6:36:39 | 6:36:43 | |
and it stands by when private
companies mismanage services while | 6:36:43 | 6:36:46 | |
making eye watering profits. Almost
a quarter of Merseyrail income from | 6:36:46 | 6:36:53 | |
passengers is swallowed up in
profits. Merseyrail's owners Seb Coe | 6:36:53 | 6:36:58 | |
and a billion can expect to see
average dividends of £6.7 million | 6:36:58 | 6:37:08 | |
each. It cannot be right that our
money funds but why our loan -- | 6:37:08 | 6:37:16 | |
while our network pays the price. Is
it too much to ask that they take a | 6:37:16 | 6:37:23 | |
smaller slice of the profit in order
to ask that their passengers, who | 6:37:23 | 6:37:27 | |
fronted their profits, might get a
safe and secure service? I'm | 6:37:27 | 6:37:35 | |
grateful. Does he know that, or is
he aware that in Holland, the | 6:37:35 | 6:37:42 | |
state-owned operator actually has
guards on the train, yet they are | 6:37:42 | 6:37:49 | |
proposing on their Mersey franchise
to run the service without? I do | 6:37:49 | 6:37:55 | |
find it incredible and I think it's
not good enough. It's not good | 6:37:55 | 6:37:59 | |
enough for the people of Merseyside
to go without guards and that the | 6:37:59 | 6:38:04 | |
people of countries who are
profiting from the money from their | 6:38:04 | 6:38:07 | |
tickets to benefit from guards. The
government could make safety | 6:38:07 | 6:38:15 | |
critical guards non-negotiable for
all rail franchises. Better still | 6:38:15 | 6:38:19 | |
would be to scrap the legislation
that says only the private sector | 6:38:19 | 6:38:25 | |
can run passenger train services.
Some if the minister wants to argue | 6:38:25 | 6:38:28 | |
this is a devolved issue, he must
explain why Mersey travel are | 6:38:28 | 6:38:31 | |
prohibited to run their trains in
the public sector. I went because I | 6:38:31 | 6:38:36 | |
am just pushed for time. | 6:38:36 | 6:38:43 | |
I believe that the basis of any
resolution has to be the principle | 6:38:43 | 6:38:47 | |
of keeping the guard on the train.
Merseyrail last week has appointed a | 6:38:47 | 6:38:52 | |
new managing director and perhaps
this is an opportunity for fresh | 6:38:52 | 6:38:56 | |
thinking. We have seen the same
issues resolved elsewhere. They RMT | 6:38:56 | 6:39:00 | |
has exceeded new deals with a number
of new companies -- other companies, | 6:39:00 | 6:39:04 | |
including time Pennine express and
also ScotRail. In the case of | 6:39:04 | 6:39:10 | |
ScotRail, BR, later Merseyrail, born
to buy at the allele. F at Balliol | 6:39:10 | 6:39:18 | |
and Scotland can agree to keep the
card on the chin, why can't a | 6:39:18 | 6:39:21 | |
Balliol in the Merseyside? --
Abelio. I want to see this through | 6:39:21 | 6:39:32 | |
-- dispute resolved as quickly as
possible. The basis of this is to be | 6:39:32 | 6:39:38 | |
the agreement of the principle of
keeping the guard on the train. I | 6:39:38 | 6:39:43 | |
hope that the representatives in the
Liverpool region will appreciate the | 6:39:43 | 6:39:46 | |
points made in the debate today that
in the face of the cuts by the | 6:39:46 | 6:39:51 | |
Government and transport authority,
private -- privateering out of | 6:39:51 | 6:39:56 | |
control and failed Tory ideology
that runs right through our rail | 6:39:56 | 6:40:00 | |
network, it's inevitable that we end
up in a situation where we have | 6:40:00 | 6:40:03 | |
given for his choice -- we have the
false choice between embracing new | 6:40:03 | 6:40:07 | |
technology and protecting secure and
public safety. Minister Paul | 6:40:07 | 6:40:13 | |
Maynard. Thank you. Can I can
graduate the Honourable Member for a | 6:40:13 | 6:40:20 | |
Liverpool Walton on prosecuting the
office that ideal opportunity for | 6:40:20 | 6:40:25 | |
this debate today but for delivering
his thoughts so well-balanced. | 6:40:25 | 6:40:31 | |
Members from both sides of Mersey
and indeed beyond the Mersey, I | 6:40:31 | 6:40:35 | |
think it demonstrates the
importance, I know that so many in | 6:40:35 | 6:40:41 | |
the Merseyside area attached to this
issue. I am sure many more will be | 6:40:41 | 6:40:50 | |
paying attention to it in the city
region. I am sure all members and | 6:40:50 | 6:40:55 | |
all that debates are worthwhile
opportunities to raise worthwhile | 6:40:55 | 6:41:00 | |
constituency matters -- matters. | 6:41:00 | 6:41:10 | |
Since 2003, matters concerning the
Merseyrail have been entirely | 6:41:16 | 6:41:20 | |
devolved and are at the of the
transport authority, Mersey travel | 6:41:20 | 6:41:25 | |
and the chain of -- operators
themselves. Those that prevent him | 6:41:25 | 6:41:30 | |
from commenting directly on many of
the points he has raised today, I | 6:41:30 | 6:41:32 | |
will try to do my best to give him a
worthwhile contribution that looks | 6:41:32 | 6:41:36 | |
at the wider issues he is seeking to
raise and as tempted as I am too try | 6:41:36 | 6:41:41 | |
to engage on his points and Labour
Party policy, sadly, time it | 6:41:41 | 6:41:46 | |
probably doesn't permit me to fully
engage with why I think the idea of | 6:41:46 | 6:41:52 | |
a state monopoly should fill every
single passenger had nothing but | 6:41:52 | 6:41:55 | |
tread at the thought of that. Given
the lack of time available at is | 6:41:55 | 6:42:00 | |
only fair that after our
interventions, they can choose the | 6:42:00 | 6:42:08 | |
moment to launch themselves in my
collection because I suspect | 6:42:08 | 6:42:12 | |
interventions will grow as my speech
echoes. Merseyside in particular has | 6:42:12 | 6:42:19 | |
seen the reminiscence of an
passenger rail service driven | 6:42:19 | 6:42:24 | |
something to 96. Before we see more
about Merseyrail in particular, I | 6:42:24 | 6:42:27 | |
would like to take a moment to look
at the bigger picture as a whole. | 6:42:27 | 6:42:30 | |
Just a few weeks ago, Weise
published our real spend commitments | 6:42:30 | 6:42:34 | |
until 2024. 34 billion investment in
the region, 30.2 billion from | 6:42:34 | 6:42:42 | |
private sources, including network
charges and fears. This carries | 6:42:42 | 6:42:46 | |
another decade, the greatest
investment in the the way since the | 6:42:46 | 6:42:50 | |
time of Queen Victoria, to deliver
the improvement in punctuality and | 6:42:50 | 6:42:54 | |
reliability for passengers as well
as supporting thousands of jobs in | 6:42:54 | 6:42:57 | |
the supply chain and the wider
economy. Why are we making this | 6:42:57 | 6:43:02 | |
money available? It's quite a simple
reason. It's because of | 6:43:02 | 6:43:06 | |
privatisation of Railways has
succeeded and I will never apologise | 6:43:06 | 6:43:10 | |
for repeating the statistics.
Passenger the Tories have doubled | 6:43:10 | 6:43:20 | |
since 1995. We now have the most
improved the way in Europe and the | 6:43:20 | 6:43:23 | |
safest major railway as well.
Because Merseyrail is a devolved | 6:43:23 | 6:43:27 | |
concession, decisions are made at
the local level. Merseyrail holds a | 6:43:27 | 6:43:33 | |
25 year concession which commenced
in 2003, with reviews undertaken | 6:43:33 | 6:43:41 | |
every five years. The terms and
conditions of contract devolved from | 6:43:41 | 6:43:52 | |
the DFP back in 2003. Indeed, the
Merseyrail concession is different | 6:43:52 | 6:43:56 | |
from most train franchise contracts
which are rewarded by the Department | 6:43:56 | 6:44:00 | |
for Transport. The only other
franchise which is even remotely | 6:44:00 | 6:44:04 | |
similar is the London Underground
network and this local concession | 6:44:04 | 6:44:09 | |
agreement is that both Mersey travel
and Merseyrail work closely together | 6:44:09 | 6:44:13 | |
to respond to local demands and
needs and ultimately the greatest | 6:44:13 | 6:44:18 | |
beneficiaries are of the passengers.
The concession of 25 years | 6:44:18 | 6:44:22 | |
distinguishes Merseyrail from many
other train operating companies | 6:44:22 | 6:44:26 | |
which contracts are added seven and
ten years. This reason Merseyrail | 6:44:26 | 6:44:30 | |
and Mersey travel are in the
enviable position of being able to | 6:44:30 | 6:44:33 | |
take a longer-term perspective on
investment and development in the | 6:44:33 | 6:44:39 | |
services. It's an arrangement that
means the control of the concession | 6:44:39 | 6:44:43 | |
rests wholly in the city region.
Would show with a strong local focus | 6:44:43 | 6:44:57 | |
the nature of the concession sees
Mersey travel working in close the | 6:44:57 | 6:45:06 | |
indication for the ultimate benefit
of passengers. In the previous | 6:45:06 | 6:45:11 | |
franchise ended in back in 2003,
local politicians wanted quickly | 6:45:11 | 6:45:15 | |
right to respond to the needs of
local rail users much better. And | 6:45:15 | 6:45:20 | |
implement changes that would improve
the network for the benefit of | 6:45:20 | 6:45:25 | |
passengers and for a growth of the
region 's economy. They wanted a | 6:45:25 | 6:45:29 | |
longer term partnership approach
with the operator to allow ongoing | 6:45:29 | 6:45:34 | |
investment programmes to continue
with risks being shared. Following a | 6:45:34 | 6:45:43 | |
robust procurement process back in
2000 the, the transfer of | 6:45:43 | 6:45:48 | |
responsibility for the heavy rail
franchise from what was then the | 6:45:48 | 6:45:53 | |
strategic rail authority to Mersey
travel. I will happily give way. I | 6:45:53 | 6:45:59 | |
thank the Minister for giving way
and then my speech I congratulated | 6:45:59 | 6:46:03 | |
Mersey travel on the ability to
secure provision of these trends in | 6:46:03 | 6:46:08 | |
the public sector, which means that
they will be 30% cheaper than if | 6:46:08 | 6:46:12 | |
they were bought through private
means and through private loans. But | 6:46:12 | 6:46:18 | |
the one thing we cannot do is have a
publicly run Neil -- rail network | 6:46:18 | 6:46:25 | |
across Merseyside, because the
legislation of the UK Government. It | 6:46:25 | 6:46:28 | |
is OK for a Dutch rail lease, Dutch
public railways and poker with other | 6:46:28 | 6:46:35 | |
countries to come and our Railways,
but does the Minister not think that | 6:46:35 | 6:46:40 | |
has Government might like to run the
railway system at some point? I | 6:46:40 | 6:46:47 | |
heard his point earlier and my
response to that is that is not | 6:46:47 | 6:46:50 | |
Government policy nor do I ever see
it being Government policy will my | 6:46:50 | 6:46:55 | |
party remains in power. I do not
think that the opportunity to have a | 6:46:55 | 6:46:59 | |
public monopoly on our Railways is
in the passengers interests. It may | 6:46:59 | 6:47:02 | |
be in the interest of the party
opposite. It's not in the interest | 6:47:02 | 6:47:07 | |
of passengers. The agreement that we
have with Mersey travel is worth | 6:47:07 | 6:47:11 | |
hundreds of millions of pounds.
Indeed -- indeed, in 2017 it's close | 6:47:11 | 6:47:22 | |
to plan major long-term investment
and that is why into 2000 -- sense | 6:47:22 | 6:47:27 | |
to those in the quality of train
stations and the running of the | 6:47:27 | 6:47:32 | |
network has been transformed.
Merseyrail has to be seen as an | 6:47:32 | 6:47:39 | |
exemplar, local decision-making with
it is practical to do so. On the day | 6:47:39 | 6:47:43 | |
of devolution, Mersey travel greatly
stated its ambition was to shed the | 6:47:43 | 6:47:48 | |
label of misery rail by pitting
passengers first and within a year, | 6:47:48 | 6:47:53 | |
the transformation was apparent.
Customer satisfaction, particularly | 6:47:53 | 6:47:58 | |
with punctuality. By autumn, 2004,
Miller said it was top of the | 6:47:58 | 6:48:04 | |
National customer satisfaction week,
for the first time in its history. | 6:48:04 | 6:48:10 | |
Since 2000 date, satisfaction has
never dropped below 90%, a major | 6:48:10 | 6:48:13 | |
contribution to this has been the
club partnership in the operator and | 6:48:13 | 6:48:17 | |
Mersey travel. But the concession
agreement that says the demanding | 6:48:17 | 6:48:23 | |
specifications, flexibility of local
control allowing both parties to | 6:48:23 | 6:48:28 | |
allow a stream of initiatives to
increase capacity, tether fears and | 6:48:28 | 6:48:33 | |
services to local markets and
stations being improved. I will | 6:48:33 | 6:48:41 | |
happily give way although I know
that time is short. I hope you will | 6:48:41 | 6:48:47 | |
respond to my Honourable Member --
my Honourable Friend pots point | 6:48:47 | 6:48:53 | |
about the cut in funding that this
forcing Mersey travel to make | 6:48:53 | 6:48:56 | |
decisions that they wouldn't want to
make the hand of -- they had funds | 6:48:56 | 6:49:01 | |
available. We have committed £82
million in this current year. That | 6:49:01 | 6:49:05 | |
gives them the confidence to make
the investment and rolling stock | 6:49:05 | 6:49:08 | |
which they are then choosing how the
invested. I think members opposite | 6:49:08 | 6:49:14 | |
will be deeply disappointed, indeed
apoplectic, I was to start | 6:49:14 | 6:49:19 | |
questioning the decisions of the
elected both said the Mere of | 6:49:19 | 6:49:22 | |
Liverpool and the city region Amir.
The point of devolution that local | 6:49:22 | 6:49:28 | |
people, through their
representatives, have to take these | 6:49:28 | 6:49:30 | |
decisions and that is what they are
doing. The investment we have made | 6:49:30 | 6:49:38 | |
has facilitated the implementation
of longer trained in 2000 date, | 6:49:38 | 6:49:44 | |
doubling the Senate -- the services
from Chester to Liverpool in 2013. | 6:49:44 | 6:49:49 | |
All of that, to me, as an example of
investment are cutting in | 6:49:49 | 6:49:54 | |
Merseyrail. Indeed, regularly, they
have jointly funded extra weekday | 6:49:54 | 6:49:59 | |
trains during special events. The
approach has been a great success. | 6:49:59 | 6:50:07 | |
Passenger demand has consistently
exceeded targets, 27 million a year | 6:50:07 | 6:50:16 | |
ago 12/25 -- 35 million now.
Enclosing, I hope I have been able | 6:50:16 | 6:50:29 | |
to demonstrate how the public and
private partnership to Mersey travel | 6:50:29 | 6:50:33 | |
and Merseyrail has helped transform
the real services in Liverpool over | 6:50:33 | 6:50:38 | |
the past 14 years and that there is
no reason to suspect that local | 6:50:38 | 6:50:41 | |
politicians and Liverpool are not
able to take positions in the | 6:50:41 | 6:50:45 | |
interests of the city region, given
I have a short time with it would be | 6:50:45 | 6:50:48 | |
churlish of me not to give way. The
Minister isn't at all addressing the | 6:50:48 | 6:50:54 | |
issue of a second safety critical
person on the train. This isn't only | 6:50:54 | 6:50:58 | |
a position in the Merseyrail, it's a
position in the franchises around | 6:50:58 | 6:51:03 | |
the country. Clearly, the Minister
should have a position on a second | 6:51:03 | 6:51:09 | |
safety critical person on the
exchange. As you will be aware, | 6:51:09 | 6:51:18 | |
sufficiently discussed it is the
issue of cards and Merseyrail | 6:51:18 | 6:51:21 | |
trains. As Honourable Member 's
obstacle now the complicity of local | 6:51:21 | 6:51:28 | |
Labour politicians they can be
discussing this with. All of them | 6:51:28 | 6:51:33 | |
have stood behind this decision. If
we truly believe in devolving and | 6:51:33 | 6:51:39 | |
transport powers, we have to respect
those decisions that are taken. Let | 6:51:39 | 6:51:46 | |
me just to restate once again, the
congratulating him on the kid in the | 6:51:46 | 6:51:51 | |
debate and I am sure he has had a
ready audience across America said | 6:51:51 | 6:51:55 | |
for his comment and I am sure that
that was not the intended audience | 6:51:55 | 6:52:00 | |
for what he -- I am sure that was
the intended audience for what he | 6:52:00 | 6:52:03 | |
had to say. I'm sure the
conversation will continue and I | 6:52:03 | 6:52:07 | |
will watch with interest what
occurs. The question is that this | 6:52:07 | 6:52:13 | |
House do now adjourned. As many are
of that opinion that the eye. The | 6:52:13 | 6:52:17 | |
ayes have it. Order, order. | 6:52:17 | 6:52:19 |