Browse content similar to 01/02/2018. Check below for episodes and series from the same categories and more!
Line | From | To | |
---|---|---|---|
be done, it ought to be done. I am
quite sure the honourable lady's | 0:00:00 | 0:00:00 | |
point will have been noted by the
Treasury bench. There are no further | 0:00:00 | 0:00:05 | |
points of order. We now come to the
backbench motion on baby you'd leave | 0:00:05 | 0:00:13 | |
for Members of Parliament. Harriet
Harman -- baby leave. Can I join in | 0:00:13 | 0:00:22 | |
wishing you a happy birthday? You
honestly do not need to worry about | 0:00:22 | 0:00:26 | |
numbers. I am 67 and I have
discovered that I know a lot more as | 0:00:26 | 0:00:31 | |
I get older that I did not used to
know when I was younger. There is | 0:00:31 | 0:00:35 | |
nothing wrong with getting older. I
would like to thank the honourable | 0:00:35 | 0:00:40 | |
member for Gateshead and the members
of the Backbench Business Committee | 0:00:40 | 0:00:44 | |
which he chairs for agreeing to the
subject of our motion today. As the | 0:00:44 | 0:00:48 | |
backbench business was one of the
things that was introduced when I | 0:00:48 | 0:00:52 | |
was Leader of the House, I was very
glad that when I went before them to | 0:00:52 | 0:00:56 | |
ask for this, they did not turn me
down. I can see the honourable | 0:00:56 | 0:01:01 | |
member for Basingstoke, the right
honourable member, is in her place | 0:01:01 | 0:01:04 | |
and I would like to thank her for
all the work she has done on this | 0:01:04 | 0:01:13 | |
issue. Very much a joint enterprise
between her and me on this. I cannot | 0:01:13 | 0:01:15 | |
speak highly enough about her work
as chair of the very excellent Women | 0:01:15 | 0:01:20 | |
and Equalities Committee and I do
not usually say good things about | 0:01:20 | 0:01:23 | |
people who have been in the Cabinet
in Tory governments but she really | 0:01:23 | 0:01:28 | |
has been... She is very important to
all of us in that role. I would like | 0:01:28 | 0:01:34 | |
to thank the other 52 members from
all parties that supported this | 0:01:34 | 0:01:40 | |
application for this motion, right
honourable and honourable members, | 0:01:40 | 0:01:44 | |
honourable friends, on the side of
the House, many of whom are here | 0:01:44 | 0:01:48 | |
today, thank you for attending, and
members of the Scottish National | 0:01:48 | 0:01:52 | |
Party who have been very active and
supportive and co-workers on this | 0:01:52 | 0:01:59 | |
issue, as have the Liberal
Democrats, and many honourable | 0:01:59 | 0:02:03 | |
members on the Tory benches. This is
very much a cross-party issue. I am | 0:02:03 | 0:02:09 | |
very pleased to see that you, Madam
Deputy Speaker, that the Leader of | 0:02:09 | 0:02:16 | |
the House is in her place and
responding personally to the debate | 0:02:16 | 0:02:20 | |
in a week that has not been an -- in
the week that has been busy, I think | 0:02:20 | 0:02:28 | |
it is testament to the commitment
she has that this issue, along with | 0:02:28 | 0:02:32 | |
the Shadow Leader of the House. This
is something which Mr Speaker's | 0:02:32 | 0:02:38 | |
reference group has also looked at.
This motion, asked the House for | 0:02:38 | 0:02:45 | |
it's in principle agreement to make
arrangements for when a member has a | 0:02:45 | 0:02:49 | |
baby or adopts a child because at
the moment we do not have any such | 0:02:49 | 0:02:54 | |
arrangements. In this House, we set
the rules for parents outside of the | 0:02:54 | 0:03:01 | |
House having babies or adopting a
child and we do that because we | 0:03:01 | 0:03:03 | |
think it is important for the child
and it is important for the parents. | 0:03:03 | 0:03:07 | |
We do it because we do not want new
parents to to have to ask the | 0:03:07 | 0:03:12 | |
favours but to be clear where they
stand, but there is no such system | 0:03:12 | 0:03:16 | |
for members of this House. I thank
my right honourable friend for | 0:03:16 | 0:03:21 | |
giving way and for bringing forward
this important debate. The sheer | 0:03:21 | 0:03:25 | |
agree with me that as we set the
rules for people outside the House | 0:03:25 | 0:03:30 | |
to take maternity, paternity and
shared parental leave, we have a | 0:03:30 | 0:03:33 | |
system that makes this place less
family friendly than most workplaces | 0:03:33 | 0:03:38 | |
in the UK? -- does she agree with
me. She is right. No one wants us to | 0:03:38 | 0:03:48 | |
be given better conditions than
those outside, but we are now | 0:03:48 | 0:03:53 | |
lagging behind and we are in danger
of setting a very bad example. I | 0:03:53 | 0:03:56 | |
give way. I thank my right
honourable friend for giving way. I | 0:03:56 | 0:04:02 | |
pay tribute to her for bringing this
motion to the House but also for her | 0:04:02 | 0:04:06 | |
work over more than 30 years to
advance equality for women in this | 0:04:06 | 0:04:10 | |
place and the wider world. I visited
a girls' secondary school, they | 0:04:10 | 0:04:19 | |
asked me how it is being a woman in
the House of Commons, I mentioned | 0:04:19 | 0:04:22 | |
there was no maternity leave for
women members, there were gasps. | 0:04:22 | 0:04:26 | |
Which you agree with me, we owe it
to a drain oration of young women | 0:04:26 | 0:04:31 | |
now thinking about their future to
make this place somewhere where they | 0:04:31 | 0:04:35 | |
feel welcome and they feel they have
the same rights as every other woman | 0:04:35 | 0:04:39 | |
in workplaces around the country --
we owe it to a generation of young | 0:04:39 | 0:04:43 | |
women. She puts it spot on. Erskine
May, our Parliamentary rules Bible, | 0:04:43 | 0:04:48 | |
says absolutely nothing about
pregnancy. That is no surprise, no | 0:04:48 | 0:04:59 | |
surprise at all.
LAUGHTER | 0:04:59 | 0:05:00 | |
It used to be the case that the
overwhelming majority of members | 0:05:00 | 0:05:04 | |
were men and it was not that the men
were not parents, it was just that | 0:05:04 | 0:05:10 | |
they regarded a baby as the sole
responsibility of their wives. There | 0:05:10 | 0:05:15 | |
were hardly any women in this House,
and mostly they were older women | 0:05:15 | 0:05:22 | |
whose children had either grown-up
or who had no children. That was | 0:05:22 | 0:05:26 | |
certainly the case when I had my
three children as a young member of | 0:05:26 | 0:05:31 | |
this House. Then I was the only
woman in the House at that time | 0:05:31 | 0:05:35 | |
having babies, but now things have
changed and the sight of growing | 0:05:35 | 0:05:39 | |
pregnant bumps in our division
lobbies is commonplace and | 0:05:39 | 0:05:44 | |
celebrated on all sides.
LAUGHTER | 0:05:44 | 0:05:50 | |
Speaking of pregnant bumps... I
thank my honourable friend for | 0:05:50 | 0:05:56 | |
making an excellent contribution and
speech and I declare my interest as | 0:05:56 | 0:05:59 | |
one of those members with a growing
bump. Does she agree with me that | 0:05:59 | 0:06:04 | |
this highlights the urgency is by
which we have to address this issue? | 0:06:04 | 0:06:08 | |
I am not the only member currently
pregnant. We are working to a | 0:06:08 | 0:06:13 | |
deadline because babies, it will not
stay in there forever, which she | 0:06:13 | 0:06:16 | |
agree with me? I certainly do and I
congratulate and I am looking | 0:06:16 | 0:06:21 | |
forward to meeting the new arrival.
The reason why we are proposing this | 0:06:21 | 0:06:25 | |
change now is that the House has
changed, it has changed profoundly | 0:06:25 | 0:06:31 | |
in its attitudes and membership. Now
many men want and expect to play | 0:06:31 | 0:06:37 | |
their part with a new baby. I am
extremely grateful to my right | 0:06:37 | 0:06:44 | |
honourable friend. In 1992 when I
informed the Chief Whip that my wife | 0:06:44 | 0:06:49 | |
was going into hospital and that I
intended to be at the birth, I was | 0:06:49 | 0:06:55 | |
told, that is all right, as long as
you are here on Monday night to vote | 0:06:55 | 0:07:01 | |
on my strict matters. My daughter
was born on the Sunday and I was | 0:07:01 | 0:07:05 | |
able to leave the hospital to stay
until 2:30am but that dilemma | 0:07:05 | 0:07:09 | |
applies to men as well. It really
did and it was an acceptable then | 0:07:09 | 0:07:15 | |
and it is even more unacceptable
now. I will give way. Which you | 0:07:15 | 0:07:21 | |
agree with me that it is a crying
shame that even though the last | 0:07:21 | 0:07:25 | |
Labour government introduce shared
parental leave, only around 5% of | 0:07:25 | 0:07:29 | |
fathers take it and I do not think
there is any provision in this House | 0:07:29 | 0:07:33 | |
for new dads to do that? Absolutely.
One of the things about this is | 0:07:33 | 0:07:40 | |
talking to colleagues on all sides
of the House, it really is something | 0:07:40 | 0:07:44 | |
felt as strongly by fathers in this
House now as well as mothers and | 0:07:44 | 0:07:49 | |
that is a real change. It is
gratifying to me to see younger men | 0:07:49 | 0:07:56 | |
who are determined not only to be
excellent members of this House but | 0:07:56 | 0:08:00 | |
also sharing parents and responsible
fathers who do not see their baby | 0:08:00 | 0:08:06 | |
just ask their wife's business, most
members' wives work and their | 0:08:06 | 0:08:11 | |
husbands in the House want to
support them. I will give way. Sorry | 0:08:11 | 0:08:19 | |
to be able not to stay for long,
partly for this problem. Can I | 0:08:19 | 0:08:26 | |
congratulate her on a motion which
does not talk about men and women, | 0:08:26 | 0:08:29 | |
it talks about members? When my wife
was elected, my younger son was two. | 0:08:29 | 0:08:36 | |
The slippery slope, we ought to talk
about a staircase, and at some | 0:08:36 | 0:08:40 | |
stage, if this goes through, what
about people hospitalised or have to | 0:08:40 | 0:08:44 | |
take time off her elderly parents in
some extreme emergency? Well, that | 0:08:44 | 0:08:51 | |
might well be the case in the
future, but for the moment, we are | 0:08:51 | 0:08:54 | |
talking about maternity, paternity
and adoption. And we should focus on | 0:08:54 | 0:09:01 | |
that. Madam Deputy Speaker, I never
thought I would see the day when the | 0:09:01 | 0:09:06 | |
sons of the women's movement arrived
in the Scouse, but they are here. - | 0:09:06 | 0:09:13 | |
Rucker in this House. They want and
expect to play pop with a new baby | 0:09:13 | 0:09:17 | |
and all credit to them -- in this
House. They want and expect to play | 0:09:17 | 0:09:23 | |
a proper role with the new baby. My
wife and I had my son, Patrick, two | 0:09:23 | 0:09:28 | |
weeks before the general election
last year, a member told me, loved | 0:09:28 | 0:09:32 | |
brother for our daughter who is
three. My wife is and remains a star | 0:09:32 | 0:09:38 | |
who like other MPs' partners has to
put up with so much because of this | 0:09:38 | 0:09:41 | |
job and the need to be away from
home. I wish I could have had some | 0:09:41 | 0:09:47 | |
paternity leave. So that at least
just after he was born, I could have | 0:09:47 | 0:09:51 | |
been a great help than I have been.
My wife has never complained and | 0:09:51 | 0:09:55 | |
like others, she got on with it, but
she deserved more support than I was | 0:09:55 | 0:09:59 | |
able to give her and I hope we can
fix this for other MPs and I hope | 0:09:59 | 0:10:04 | |
that is what we will do. Of course,
there are more women members than | 0:10:04 | 0:10:08 | |
ever before, on all sides of the
house, over 200, and younger women | 0:10:08 | 0:10:14 | |
as well. It is a democratic
imperative that we have women in | 0:10:14 | 0:10:18 | |
this House as well as men, to make
the House representative of this | 0:10:18 | 0:10:24 | |
country. It is a biological
inevitability that young women will | 0:10:24 | 0:10:27 | |
have babies. There have already been
17 babies born to women members | 0:10:27 | 0:10:33 | |
since 2010. I give way. I thank the
right honourable lady for giving way | 0:10:33 | 0:10:39 | |
and I congratulate her on the
amazing work she has done on this | 0:10:39 | 0:10:42 | |
issue and on her speech and will she
agree that given that we are | 0:10:42 | 0:10:47 | |
apparently by definition the gayest
parliament in the world and we have | 0:10:47 | 0:10:50 | |
many LGBT members, there will be
many young gay and female members | 0:10:50 | 0:10:56 | |
who like myself at some point want
to have children and it is important | 0:10:56 | 0:11:00 | |
that this motion supports them as
well? Whether it is adoption or | 0:11:00 | 0:11:06 | |
biological birth. I thank the
honourable lady who has been | 0:11:06 | 0:11:09 | |
unstinting in her support and we
have worked together on this. That | 0:11:09 | 0:11:14 | |
is why I called it baby leave rather
than maternity and paternity leave | 0:11:14 | 0:11:18 | |
and why I talk at about parents and
their children. There have been 17 | 0:11:18 | 0:11:27 | |
babies born to women and countless
pawn to mail Members of Parliament | 0:11:27 | 0:11:30 | |
but which we do not know about. --
countless born at two male Members | 0:11:30 | 0:11:40 | |
of Parliament.
LAUGHTER | 0:11:40 | 0:11:46 | |
Madam Deputy Speaker, in the absence
of any official recognition of these | 0:11:46 | 0:11:50 | |
babies being born to members, the
way things work currently is that | 0:11:50 | 0:11:56 | |
women MPs giving birth or male MPs
who want time with their baby, they | 0:11:56 | 0:12:02 | |
asked the whips, and they make an
arrangement with the whips on the | 0:12:02 | 0:12:06 | |
other side. The situation in
relation to the whips is nothing | 0:12:06 | 0:12:09 | |
like it was when I was having the
first of our three children 34 years | 0:12:09 | 0:12:14 | |
ago, when I had to ask for a few
weeks off from the whips office when | 0:12:14 | 0:12:19 | |
most of them thought that a woman
should not be in the House of | 0:12:19 | 0:12:23 | |
Commons, let alone a pregnant woman.
I know that attitudes in the whips | 0:12:23 | 0:12:28 | |
office are completely different to
what they were before, but it is | 0:12:28 | 0:12:32 | |
still the case that each member
individually has to ask. We would | 0:12:32 | 0:12:36 | |
not agree to that happening in any
other workplace, and it is in the | 0:12:36 | 0:12:40 | |
discretion of not just one whips
office but two to get... Both whips | 0:12:40 | 0:12:50 | |
offices have to agree. I speak as a
whip, SNP work, our party does not | 0:12:50 | 0:12:56 | |
take part in pairings, I commend
what has been brought forward today | 0:12:56 | 0:12:59 | |
because I am uncomfortable with it,
to have to go through a pairing | 0:12:59 | 0:13:03 | |
arrangement. I support what she is
saying. That is a really important | 0:13:03 | 0:13:09 | |
point and I hope we can think of
some arrangements that can be made | 0:13:09 | 0:13:13 | |
until such time as we zoom in this
process through to deal with the | 0:13:13 | 0:13:21 | |
issue of honourable members from the
SNP. Granting or with holding a pair | 0:13:21 | 0:13:25 | |
is an important role for the
opposition whips office and no one | 0:13:25 | 0:13:28 | |
can accuse me of not knowing the
importance of fighting in opposition | 0:13:28 | 0:13:33 | |
because tragically, that is what I
have been doing for 20 years of my | 0:13:33 | 0:13:38 | |
parliamentary life. But a woman
giving birth should not be a matter | 0:13:38 | 0:13:42 | |
of wrangling between whips office is
or an opportunity to take advantage | 0:13:42 | 0:13:47 | |
over the Government, however much
they would deserve it. I give way. | 0:13:47 | 0:13:53 | |
I congratulate you on securing this
debate. Would you agree with me that | 0:13:53 | 0:14:01 | |
the Parliamentary report into six
and 16 says that we must accommodate | 0:14:01 | 0:14:07 | |
facilitate a project member and
co-parent. Particularly of limits, | 0:14:07 | 0:14:15 | |
this change being sorted is really
long overdue. I think the honourable | 0:14:15 | 0:14:20 | |
Lady makes a very good point. That
the good Parliament report also | 0:14:20 | 0:14:24 | |
reports on all the Parliaments
around the world how in their own | 0:14:24 | 0:14:28 | |
way have started to do with this.
This Madam Deputy Speaker is not | 0:14:28 | 0:14:33 | |
just a matter for the wishes of
parents. It is about the rights of | 0:14:33 | 0:14:37 | |
our constituents. When an MP is
paired, it is recorded that they | 0:14:37 | 0:14:43 | |
simply have not voted. I'll give
way. Thank you for giving way. The | 0:14:43 | 0:14:53 | |
negotiation between whips is
important in other circumstances, | 0:14:53 | 0:14:56 | |
but I am sure there are many women
in this House who take time off to | 0:14:56 | 0:14:59 | |
be with their babies during the
first two weeks want to practise | 0:14:59 | 0:15:05 | |
representing their constituencies. I
think she is absolutely right on | 0:15:05 | 0:15:15 | |
this. Why should that constituencies
lose the right for the voting -- for | 0:15:15 | 0:15:22 | |
the vote in their name to be cast
because they're MP is having a baby? | 0:15:22 | 0:15:26 | |
Madam Deputy Speaker, when you are
in a birthing pool, you cannot be | 0:15:26 | 0:15:30 | |
voting. But your constituency has a
right to have its voice heard. I | 0:15:30 | 0:15:40 | |
thank you for giving way. Further to
the important part, mothers and | 0:15:40 | 0:15:47 | |
fathers that aren't able to be here
when they are looking after their | 0:15:47 | 0:15:51 | |
children, I note it registers the
fact that I have just voted... Does | 0:15:51 | 0:16:01 | |
she concur with me that something
should be rectified without websites | 0:16:01 | 0:16:05 | |
reflect best fact that parents
aren't here because they are looking | 0:16:05 | 0:16:09 | |
after the children? I think she
makes a very important point. | 0:16:09 | 0:16:15 | |
Actually, we do need to do this for
defence of reason because people, | 0:16:15 | 0:16:20 | |
women who were off having babies or
men who are off with their newborn | 0:16:20 | 0:16:25 | |
babies, they are criticised and
therefore that is wrong. I think it | 0:16:25 | 0:16:28 | |
is even more important than that. It
is actually our constituencies | 0:16:28 | 0:16:35 | |
should have their voices heard. I
thank you for giving away and all | 0:16:35 | 0:16:43 | |
the work that you have done on these
important issues. I am responsible | 0:16:43 | 0:16:49 | |
for two of the 17 babies that have
been born since 2010. When my first | 0:16:49 | 0:16:55 | |
child was born, almost five years
ago, one of the campaigning | 0:16:55 | 0:17:00 | |
organisations who e-mails
constituencies about votes, e-mailed | 0:17:00 | 0:17:03 | |
my constituents is to say that I
hadn't bothered to turn up to a | 0:17:03 | 0:17:07 | |
vote. I would have liked to have
turned up to vote out all those | 0:17:07 | 0:17:09 | |
issues, but with a very young baby,
that is impossible. And that needs | 0:17:09 | 0:17:14 | |
to be rectified as well. In the
minds of our constituency, we are | 0:17:14 | 0:17:18 | |
not there, we are absent, we are not
representing them. But we are doing | 0:17:18 | 0:17:22 | |
very important work at home. She is
absolutely right on this. It chimes | 0:17:22 | 0:17:27 | |
very much with what another one of
my friend said, she says as a mother | 0:17:27 | 0:17:34 | |
of four, she thinks just because
women are having babies, that should | 0:17:34 | 0:17:42 | |
not mean that their constituents are
not represented by their MP casting | 0:17:42 | 0:17:46 | |
their vote. My honourable friend new
son was only 35 years old when they | 0:17:46 | 0:17:55 | |
had a crucial vote on Brexit and I
know this is an issue for you. | 0:17:55 | 0:18:02 | |
Hours? Did I say Dave? You said
years. Sorry. He was only 35 hours | 0:18:02 | 0:18:12 | |
old when we have the crucial Brexit
vote. His wife, Nicki, had had an | 0:18:12 | 0:18:18 | |
early induction because of her
pregnancy being high risk. He says | 0:18:18 | 0:18:22 | |
that with that vote that he knew was
fixed, coming up, but his wife in | 0:18:22 | 0:18:26 | |
labour, that it actually. It
actually put his fundamental role as | 0:18:26 | 0:18:37 | |
an MP against his fundamental role
as a man, husband and a father. He | 0:18:37 | 0:18:41 | |
it bought brought an edge to the
delivery room when she says is | 0:18:41 | 0:18:48 | |
unhealthy. He says, surely, it is
easier to move Parliament then to | 0:18:48 | 0:18:53 | |
hold back the majestic and
existential forces of the arrival of | 0:18:53 | 0:18:57 | |
new life. Well, let's show that we
can actually manage to move | 0:18:57 | 0:19:00 | |
Parliament. The trouble is that even
as my right honourable friend said, | 0:19:00 | 0:19:06 | |
the trouble is that even when you
are paired, people outside this | 0:19:06 | 0:19:10 | |
House don't understand pairing. They
just see that they're MP has not | 0:19:10 | 0:19:15 | |
voted. Social media campaigns, which
my honourable friend mentioned, | 0:19:15 | 0:19:20 | |
criticised MPs who have not voted on
important issues unaware that they | 0:19:20 | 0:19:23 | |
are paired because of childbirth.
They get criticised in newspapers | 0:19:23 | 0:19:28 | |
who run voting league tables. We all
know that a hyperactive MP in this | 0:19:28 | 0:19:38 | |
House featured at number two in the
sons list of Britain cos laziest | 0:19:38 | 0:19:44 | |
MPs. We cannot go on like this.
Point is that members... I apologise | 0:19:44 | 0:19:51 | |
for intervening yet again. I have
been responsible for the latest of | 0:19:51 | 0:19:58 | |
the children being born. I was
criticised by a Sunday paper, I am | 0:19:58 | 0:20:03 | |
not going to name them, when I ran
up the political editor, he very | 0:20:03 | 0:20:07 | |
kindly took my name off the story.
That rated me as a second-worst MP | 0:20:07 | 0:20:13 | |
in this current Parliament. And they
did not mention that I had been on | 0:20:13 | 0:20:16 | |
maternity leave the election. I
think that what we need is for you | 0:20:16 | 0:20:22 | |
to be able to cast your
constituencies vote by proxy. The | 0:20:22 | 0:20:31 | |
point is, that is what the proposal
before the House will do. What it | 0:20:31 | 0:20:36 | |
puts to the House is that we should
it agree in principle that members | 0:20:36 | 0:20:40 | |
should be allowed to choose another
member to vote by proxy in the | 0:20:40 | 0:20:44 | |
division lobby when they have had a
new baby or adopted a child. If | 0:20:44 | 0:20:47 | |
there is an agreement to this in
principle, there is then many issues | 0:20:47 | 0:20:51 | |
of implementation that would have to
be considered. Other Parliaments, as | 0:20:51 | 0:20:56 | |
the good Parliament a port to Mac
report make clear, made arrangements | 0:20:56 | 0:21:01 | |
for baby leave, but we would need to
do it in a way that fits with our | 0:21:01 | 0:21:04 | |
culture and our processes. Another
member is rightly concerned that any | 0:21:04 | 0:21:09 | |
change might have unintended
consequences. We rightly jealously | 0:21:09 | 0:21:16 | |
guard the rules of our democracy.
Can I just reassure honourable | 0:21:16 | 0:21:20 | |
members on a number of matters? The
resolution before the House today is | 0:21:20 | 0:21:24 | |
not that a member would be required
to apply for a proxy vote, but that | 0:21:24 | 0:21:29 | |
they would be able to do so if they
chose. Those who want to take no | 0:21:29 | 0:21:34 | |
leave or to ask for a beer, would be
perfectly free to do so as they are | 0:21:34 | 0:21:38 | |
now. It would not affect pay, which
is matter for itself who have | 0:21:38 | 0:21:43 | |
assured me in writing that how we
vote in this House is a matter for | 0:21:43 | 0:21:48 | |
us not for them. And they would not
regard any change in voting as a | 0:21:48 | 0:21:52 | |
matter which would affect pay in any
way. That is just not an issue. It | 0:21:52 | 0:21:56 | |
would not be open to abuse because
whether you have had a baby or | 0:21:56 | 0:22:01 | |
adopted a child, is not a question
of subjective judgement. It is a | 0:22:01 | 0:22:05 | |
matter of fact. It will be evident
that I am not moving this motion as | 0:22:05 | 0:22:12 | |
a matter of self interest. It is too
late for that. 30 years too late. My | 0:22:12 | 0:22:19 | |
children are already grown up. But I
want this for the younger members | 0:22:19 | 0:22:24 | |
and the future parents in this
House. I give way. I am grateful for | 0:22:24 | 0:22:31 | |
you to giving away. Also happy
birthday for me. She has talked | 0:22:31 | 0:22:38 | |
about her own experiences and she
was very fortunate to have a good | 0:22:38 | 0:22:44 | |
person by her side. She is also
talked about pairing. In personal | 0:22:44 | 0:22:49 | |
life, not everyone is paired. As the
chair for single-parent families, is | 0:22:49 | 0:22:56 | |
she aware that this is an
increasingly common form? It is 51% | 0:22:56 | 0:23:02 | |
in London constituencies. I think
303,600 in my own constituency. | 0:23:02 | 0:23:08 | |
These problems are exacerbated
further for single-parent and could | 0:23:08 | 0:23:12 | |
she encourage... Just before you
answer. The intervention, I have no | 0:23:12 | 0:23:25 | |
wish what's... Whatsoever to curtail
debate which is an excellent debate | 0:23:25 | 0:23:31 | |
on an important subject. I would
draw to your attention that while | 0:23:31 | 0:23:35 | |
you are absolutely correct, of
course to take that into mentioned, | 0:23:35 | 0:23:38 | |
there is much to be said, I have a
great many people who want to speak | 0:23:38 | 0:23:44 | |
and we don't have a huge amount of
time. I withdraw my comments to a | 0:23:44 | 0:23:50 | |
close. In the centenary year, a
hundred years after women first won | 0:23:50 | 0:23:57 | |
the right to stand for Parliament, I
hope that we will agree this motion | 0:23:57 | 0:24:01 | |
and that the procedure will be
looked expeditiously. We have not | 0:24:01 | 0:24:05 | |
got all the time of the world. At
least two more Parliament. Babies | 0:24:05 | 0:24:10 | |
are in the pipeline. There is one
woman who is on with her second, and | 0:24:10 | 0:24:17 | |
my honourable friend the Member for
Lancaster have just spoken. They are | 0:24:17 | 0:24:22 | |
both expecting. While we tell,
nature is taking its course, so | 0:24:22 | 0:24:26 | |
let's agree this and let's get on
with it. The question is on the | 0:24:26 | 0:24:32 | |
order paper. Thank you, can I echo
the good wishes on your birthday. Of | 0:24:32 | 0:24:39 | |
course, this isn't issue that you
have a lot of first-hand knowledge | 0:24:39 | 0:24:45 | |
about as well. I know you are not
able to participate in the debate | 0:24:45 | 0:24:48 | |
today. I am sure you will be sitting
there thinking fondly of your own | 0:24:48 | 0:24:53 | |
experiences being a pregnant member
of Parliament and your wonderful son | 0:24:53 | 0:24:56 | |
who I have had the pleasure of
meeting on a number of occasions. | 0:24:56 | 0:25:07 | |
She has characterises as joint
enterprise. I am not sure whether it | 0:25:07 | 0:25:10 | |
is the sort of joint enterprise that
we have talked about in the legal | 0:25:10 | 0:25:14 | |
sense. That would be a crime were
more than one person is involved. | 0:25:14 | 0:25:18 | |
But I understand the point that she
is making. This has to be a joint | 0:25:18 | 0:25:23 | |
enterprise. If it is going to be
successful. I sense from the | 0:25:23 | 0:25:26 | |
goodwill that we have already heard
here that that joint enterprise will | 0:25:26 | 0:25:30 | |
be a positive thing. I would like to
pay tribute to her. As mother of the | 0:25:30 | 0:25:40 | |
House who has done so much to set
the tone around these issues over | 0:25:40 | 0:25:43 | |
many, many years. I would also like
to pay tribute to those who perhaps | 0:25:43 | 0:25:49 | |
rolled the pitch on this and made it
easier for us to bring this debate | 0:25:49 | 0:25:53 | |
forward today. Professor Sarah
Charles has already been mentioned | 0:25:53 | 0:25:59 | |
and her work really has been a
foundation in much of the | 0:25:59 | 0:26:02 | |
modernisation we are talking about.
Mr Speaker if he were here, I would | 0:26:02 | 0:26:08 | |
think him as well, again he has set
the tone. But also can I just pay | 0:26:08 | 0:26:13 | |
tribute to my right honourable
friend the Leader of the House? He | 0:26:13 | 0:26:20 | |
is doing a sterling job of making
sure that this place can be a modern | 0:26:20 | 0:26:23 | |
place for us all to work in. And
that is important not just for our | 0:26:23 | 0:26:29 | |
staff but for our members as well.
The select committee that I have the | 0:26:29 | 0:26:35 | |
pleasure you wood pleasure of
sharing and others really been | 0:26:35 | 0:26:39 | |
instrumental in selling the seeds of
change. Of course I will give way. | 0:26:39 | 0:26:47 | |
Thank you for giving way. But to say
how important this debate is. How it | 0:26:47 | 0:27:00 | |
is rooted in room evidence the
importance of bringing this House in | 0:27:00 | 0:27:08 | |
line with policies in other
workplaces were absolutely set the | 0:27:08 | 0:27:13 | |
right tone and precedents for their
future particularly in this week, | 0:27:13 | 0:27:17 | |
when we will be celebrating 100
years since women got the vote. She | 0:27:17 | 0:27:27 | |
is absolutely right. I think we are
uncovering some important ways this | 0:27:27 | 0:27:31 | |
place is changing and I hope we are
identifying ways that need to | 0:27:31 | 0:27:35 | |
continue to change in the future. It
is a great pleasure to work with her | 0:27:35 | 0:27:40 | |
on that. Being a member of
Parliament is a unique position, it | 0:27:40 | 0:27:45 | |
is a unique honour and a unique
responsibility that requires | 0:27:45 | 0:27:49 | |
complete commitment, but that cannot
mean that only those without care | 0:27:49 | 0:27:54 | |
and responsible news can apply.
Indeed, it is that experience that | 0:27:54 | 0:27:58 | |
we can have as carers that can make
us much better members of | 0:27:58 | 0:28:03 | |
Parliament. That is why I
wholeheartedly support this motion | 0:28:03 | 0:28:06 | |
in its own right. | 0:28:06 | 0:28:15 | |
She talks about... I want to raise
another issue in chairing the force | 0:28:15 | 0:28:23 | |
that society looking at
representation of women in local | 0:28:23 | 0:28:26 | |
government and it was shocking to
discover there that only 2% of local | 0:28:26 | 0:28:30 | |
authorities have maternity leave
policies in place. -- the Fawcett | 0:28:30 | 0:28:37 | |
Society. The number of women
councillors in jobs with babies had | 0:28:37 | 0:28:43 | |
been sacked. All of us as
politicians of political parties | 0:28:43 | 0:28:51 | |
ought to engage with colleagues in
local government to secure the | 0:28:51 | 0:28:54 | |
necessary changes there to have
proper representation of women? The | 0:28:54 | 0:28:59 | |
right honourable lady is absolutely
right, we need to have more women at | 0:28:59 | 0:29:03 | |
every level of our democratic
process. In Basingstoke, my | 0:29:03 | 0:29:10 | |
constituency, I have a phenomenal
team of women, nine out of the 14 | 0:29:10 | 0:29:14 | |
councillors are women and I think
that it is even more astonishing | 0:29:14 | 0:29:19 | |
when I see that a number of them are
very young women with very young | 0:29:19 | 0:29:24 | |
children and I think others should
be looking at what is happening in | 0:29:24 | 0:29:28 | |
councils like mine in Basingstoke to
encourage that so that we can see | 0:29:28 | 0:29:32 | |
more young women coming forward and
not seeing this incompatible with | 0:29:32 | 0:29:35 | |
having a young family. Of course,
and then I might make progress. I | 0:29:35 | 0:29:41 | |
thanked the most right honourable
members for bringing this debate and | 0:29:41 | 0:29:45 | |
the honourable member from
Basingstoke makes an important point | 0:29:45 | 0:29:48 | |
about local government. 23 and 25
years ago, I gave birth to my | 0:29:48 | 0:29:53 | |
children. I was a senior councillor
in Hounslow. Although it was | 0:29:53 | 0:29:59 | |
difficult, there are two fundamental
differences between local government | 0:29:59 | 0:30:02 | |
and this place. You are near to home
and the other is the voting, the | 0:30:02 | 0:30:07 | |
times you have to vote and be
recorded as voting, they are | 0:30:07 | 0:30:13 | |
measured and occasional. And this
place is a very different place for | 0:30:13 | 0:30:16 | |
both of those reasons. The right
honourable lady who used to be a | 0:30:16 | 0:30:20 | |
member of my committee and I know
her well and I have worked with her, | 0:30:20 | 0:30:25 | |
she is raising something I will
touch on later in my remarks. Whilst | 0:30:25 | 0:30:28 | |
I think the motion before us today
is really important, there are other | 0:30:28 | 0:30:32 | |
aspects of this place which need to
be thought about again if we are | 0:30:32 | 0:30:35 | |
going to make this work for
everybody, regardless of their | 0:30:35 | 0:30:39 | |
caring responsibilities. I will make
a great deal of progress now so that | 0:30:39 | 0:30:44 | |
you do not have to remind me we are
short on time, Madam Deputy Speaker. | 0:30:44 | 0:30:50 | |
I wholeheartedly support this motion
because a new addition to the family | 0:30:50 | 0:30:53 | |
is a wonderful thing but it is a
huge change. When the rules and | 0:30:53 | 0:30:59 | |
conventions of this place were
established, women had no place | 0:30:59 | 0:31:03 | |
here, men had little or no role in
their children's lives and the rules | 0:31:03 | 0:31:08 | |
and conventions were not established
based on any research or facts, they | 0:31:08 | 0:31:13 | |
were established to reflect the way
men live their lives many years ago. | 0:31:13 | 0:31:19 | |
Men's lives have changed, women's
lives have changed. Women now can | 0:31:19 | 0:31:24 | |
become MPs and our lives have
changed but the demands of having a | 0:31:24 | 0:31:28 | |
child have not changed. Allowing MPs
to take that decision to take some | 0:31:28 | 0:31:33 | |
time away from this place without
disenfranchising their electorate in | 0:31:33 | 0:31:38 | |
the process is an important step in
its own right and I fully support | 0:31:38 | 0:31:43 | |
that. But I would like to say, it is
just one small step. Speaking as a | 0:31:43 | 0:31:49 | |
mum of three kids, when I came here,
my youngest was three, and it was, | 0:31:49 | 0:31:54 | |
for me, a very easy transition. I
had worked full-time before and I | 0:31:54 | 0:31:58 | |
had the best childcare in the world,
grandparents, there to look after my | 0:31:58 | 0:32:04 | |
children. But not every member of
the it has that built in. Not | 0:32:04 | 0:32:09 | |
everyone is as lucky as I was --
every Member of Parliament. One | 0:32:09 | 0:32:14 | |
small step in a workplace culture
change in Parliament that is long | 0:32:14 | 0:32:18 | |
overdue. We recognise the importance
of workplace culture in the people | 0:32:18 | 0:32:25 | |
we represent, whether it is the
culture at the BBC that has allowed | 0:32:25 | 0:32:29 | |
women to be underpaid, the culture
in Hollywood that allows the likes | 0:32:29 | 0:32:33 | |
of Harvey Weinstein to thrive, and
abuse the people around them, when | 0:32:33 | 0:32:38 | |
we scrutinise the effectiveness of
laws, and we often conclude it is | 0:32:38 | 0:32:46 | |
culture that needs to change to make
those laws work better, we have | 0:32:46 | 0:32:51 | |
already heard about the example of
shared parental leave which was | 0:32:51 | 0:32:55 | |
introduced by the coalition
government and also the right to | 0:32:55 | 0:32:58 | |
request flexible working. These are
things people want but when we do | 0:32:58 | 0:33:02 | |
the research, the uptake is low
because the culture in the workplace | 0:33:02 | 0:33:07 | |
has not changed to reflect the
changes in the law. As well as | 0:33:07 | 0:33:11 | |
passing laws, I believe we have a
duty to influence culture as well. | 0:33:11 | 0:33:15 | |
That is why we are bringing, my
right honourable friend, the Leader | 0:33:15 | 0:33:20 | |
of the House, that is why they are
bringing a new disciplinary process | 0:33:20 | 0:33:25 | |
around sexual harassment which is so
important, and that is why we also | 0:33:25 | 0:33:29 | |
need to show we understand that
culture change is important around | 0:33:29 | 0:33:32 | |
families too. Not only MPs with new
children but MPs with all sorts of | 0:33:32 | 0:33:40 | |
wide-ranging caring
responsibilities, for older | 0:33:40 | 0:33:42 | |
children, older members of family,
as I do, or for disabled members of | 0:33:42 | 0:33:49 | |
the family too. As we consider, and
I hope agreed, with this motion | 0:33:49 | 0:33:54 | |
today, I hope it is just a short
small step we are taking forward and | 0:33:54 | 0:33:58 | |
that other steps will follow. I
would just like to give one | 0:33:58 | 0:34:04 | |
particular example. The importance
of predictability in working life. | 0:34:04 | 0:34:08 | |
Before I came to this place, I was a
director of an advertising agency, a | 0:34:08 | 0:34:14 | |
very difficult job, challenging, a
job I could do because I could | 0:34:14 | 0:34:17 | |
determine the way my working life
worked for me. It is very difficult | 0:34:17 | 0:34:21 | |
here to have that level of
predictability around foods in | 0:34:21 | 0:34:25 | |
particular. That is why I would be
advocating following this motion | 0:34:25 | 0:34:29 | |
that we would be looking at issues
like voting power to more | 0:34:29 | 0:34:35 | |
predictability around the way this
place works so that people with | 0:34:35 | 0:34:39 | |
caring responsibilities can better
work those responsibilities around | 0:34:39 | 0:34:43 | |
there overwhelmingly important
responsibilities here. For those who | 0:34:43 | 0:34:48 | |
say introducing baby leave is the
thin end of the wedge, I have to | 0:34:48 | 0:34:52 | |
say, they are right. If it means we
showed compassion to a colleague who | 0:34:52 | 0:34:58 | |
is fighting cancer, show compassion
to a colleague having to attend the | 0:34:58 | 0:35:04 | |
funeral of a close relative, rather
than disenfranchising their | 0:35:04 | 0:35:08 | |
constituents, whilst they are being
human beings, we need to make this | 0:35:08 | 0:35:13 | |
change so that we can actually allow
people to get the balance in their | 0:35:13 | 0:35:19 | |
lives that is so sadly lacking at
some points in the Parliamentary | 0:35:19 | 0:35:23 | |
calendar at the moment. Of course I
give way. I thank her for giving way | 0:35:23 | 0:35:28 | |
and for her very powerful speech and
I absolutely support the motion | 0:35:28 | 0:35:31 | |
before us. I agree that I very much
hope this is the thin end of the | 0:35:31 | 0:35:35 | |
wedge because on the centenary of
the representation of the people | 0:35:35 | 0:35:39 | |
act, we must do more to fix the
pipeline issue around encouraging | 0:35:39 | 0:35:43 | |
more women at a younger age to think
about putting themselves forward to | 0:35:43 | 0:35:49 | |
become Members of Parliament. It is
100 years on since the first woman | 0:35:49 | 0:35:56 | |
sat in this place but it can for
many of us feel like we are still | 0:35:56 | 0:36:01 | |
operating in an 18th-century model
of work. That is something that | 0:36:01 | 0:36:04 | |
really does need to change. I give
way. I am very grateful. I cannot be | 0:36:04 | 0:36:09 | |
alone in being a man in this House
whose partner has an extremely | 0:36:09 | 0:36:15 | |
important job of her own. She sits
as a Supreme Court judge in France. | 0:36:15 | 0:36:21 | |
That takes her away from home and I
therefore have childcare | 0:36:21 | 0:36:26 | |
responsibilities too and I have
one-year-old baby and she does not | 0:36:26 | 0:36:29 | |
look after herself funnily enough. I
wonder whether when we are talking | 0:36:29 | 0:36:35 | |
about equality, absolutely
understand that emphasis on women's | 0:36:35 | 0:36:38 | |
rights, of course, but this is a
human rights, it is about anybody | 0:36:38 | 0:36:42 | |
who has a responsibility to care for
a child or indeed a responsibility | 0:36:42 | 0:36:46 | |
to care for an adult or has
religious obligations that may | 0:36:46 | 0:36:51 | |
indeed keep them away in different
ways. And I think my honourable | 0:36:51 | 0:36:56 | |
friend makes a very powerful point.
It is important to recognise the way | 0:36:56 | 0:37:01 | |
that many family lives have changed
over the years. That is why it was | 0:37:01 | 0:37:05 | |
so important to frame this motion
about MPs, parents, not about men | 0:37:05 | 0:37:10 | |
and women. We can all have those
sorts of caring responsibilities and | 0:37:10 | 0:37:17 | |
they are not the sole preserve of
anyone gender at this point. It | 0:37:17 | 0:37:24 | |
would be remiss of me to not
acknowledge the extraordinary way | 0:37:24 | 0:37:30 | |
that the whips department has
evolved in my time of being in this | 0:37:30 | 0:37:36 | |
place, since 2005. I remember some
of the conversations I had with | 0:37:36 | 0:37:40 | |
whips when I first got here and I
shudder a little because they did | 0:37:40 | 0:37:45 | |
not really reflect my 20 years
working life beforehand. I am | 0:37:45 | 0:37:49 | |
looking particularly admirable
friend and neighbour who was sitting | 0:37:49 | 0:37:52 | |
on the front bench, but also my
other honourable friend, the member | 0:37:52 | 0:37:57 | |
for Bury St Edmunds, both of whom
were also members of my select | 0:37:57 | 0:38:01 | |
committee, and I know that the whips
office is in extraordinarily good | 0:38:01 | 0:38:07 | |
hands, but we cannot just let this
be something which we put to chance | 0:38:07 | 0:38:13 | |
and we do need to have better rules
to give people certainty about what | 0:38:13 | 0:38:17 | |
they can expect. MPs have a duty to
keep our democracy healthy. I do not | 0:38:17 | 0:38:25 | |
believe MPs can never be treated as
employees. Our role demands that we | 0:38:25 | 0:38:30 | |
are never going to really be subject
to a contract. Our contract with the | 0:38:30 | 0:38:39 | |
people we represent and they
demonstrate their views each time | 0:38:39 | 0:38:42 | |
there is an election. What we can do
is modernise the culture of this | 0:38:42 | 0:38:46 | |
place to reflect the 21st century,
not the 18th-century. For our | 0:38:46 | 0:38:51 | |
employees, of course, those who work
for us, but also to those members | 0:38:51 | 0:38:56 | |
sitting here today and for those who
will come after us, to make this an | 0:38:56 | 0:39:01 | |
attractive place for a more diverse
range of people who want to become | 0:39:01 | 0:39:06 | |
Members of Parliament. Today is one
small step, allowing new parents | 0:39:06 | 0:39:11 | |
some time away from this place to
cope with the demands of a new | 0:39:11 | 0:39:14 | |
family member, and it is long
overdue. But following this motion, | 0:39:14 | 0:39:19 | |
we do need to press forward further
with modernisation, particularly | 0:39:19 | 0:39:22 | |
around the scheduling of this place.
I lack of consistency and certainty | 0:39:22 | 0:39:28 | |
is one issue raised with me, not
only because it makes us less | 0:39:28 | 0:39:34 | |
productive, it also makes us less
able to balance our family life too | 0:39:34 | 0:39:39 | |
-- a lack of consistency. I
respectfully disagree with people | 0:39:39 | 0:39:46 | |
who think this change today is
wrong. The health of our democracy | 0:39:46 | 0:39:49 | |
depends on the strength of the House
of Commons and we are strengthened | 0:39:49 | 0:39:53 | |
if we are truly representative of
the community is making up the UK. | 0:39:53 | 0:39:58 | |
Introducing baby leave for members
of Parliament who need it and want | 0:39:58 | 0:40:02 | |
it is just one small step in opening
up membership of this place to more | 0:40:02 | 0:40:05 | |
people. And seeing fewer people
choosing to leave before their time | 0:40:05 | 0:40:11 | |
because life as an MP is
incompatible with the responsibility | 0:40:11 | 0:40:15 | |
of being a parent. I hope this
motion gets the full agreement of | 0:40:15 | 0:40:20 | |
the House today. Above all, I hope
that the procedure committee looks | 0:40:20 | 0:40:24 | |
at it swiftly so that those members
here today with imminent arrivals | 0:40:24 | 0:40:30 | |
can look forward to their
pregnancies and the birth without a | 0:40:30 | 0:40:36 | |
question as to how they will deal
with it with the whips. Order. This | 0:40:36 | 0:40:43 | |
debate has to finish just before
3pm. Therefore, we will have a time | 0:40:43 | 0:40:48 | |
limit now of about eight minutes.
No, not about. The debate has to | 0:40:48 | 0:40:58 | |
finish at about three o'clock. But
the time limit is exactly eight | 0:40:58 | 0:41:05 | |
minutes. Sorry, I had in my mind
there the terror that I felt the day | 0:41:05 | 0:41:09 | |
I told the Chief Whip I was going to
have a baby. | 0:41:09 | 0:41:12 | |
LAUGHTER
It had only happened once before in | 0:41:12 | 0:41:16 | |
the Conservative Party. It was
causing palpitations again. Exactly | 0:41:16 | 0:41:21 | |
eight minutes. Emma Reynolds. Thank
you. I will keep to exactly eight | 0:41:21 | 0:41:28 | |
minutes. I want to thank the right
honourable lady for her contribution | 0:41:28 | 0:41:31 | |
which I found to be incredibly
thoughtful and I agree with every | 0:41:31 | 0:41:35 | |
single word she said. I want to pay
particular special tribute to my | 0:41:35 | 0:41:40 | |
right honourable friend, for
Camberwell in Peckham. Not only for | 0:41:40 | 0:41:45 | |
bringing forward these proposals
today and doing so much work on this | 0:41:45 | 0:41:50 | |
issue, but for all the work she has
done since she joined this House | 0:41:50 | 0:41:54 | |
many years ago, I do not know how
many, but I know she is the mother | 0:41:54 | 0:41:58 | |
of the House, all the work she has
done to make sure we have greater | 0:41:58 | 0:42:04 | |
gender equality in our country and
our Parliament and we have made huge | 0:42:04 | 0:42:07 | |
progress thanks to her work. But as
today's motion demonstrates, we | 0:42:07 | 0:42:12 | |
still have quite some way to go. I
want to just recount what happened | 0:42:12 | 0:42:19 | |
in 2017. My husband and I were
expecting a baby in April. We were | 0:42:19 | 0:42:24 | |
hoping for a quiet year on the work
front, let's say. We thought, this | 0:42:24 | 0:42:32 | |
is great, the bump will be around
three years old at the time of the | 0:42:32 | 0:42:36 | |
next election because it seemed the
Prime Minister was absolutely | 0:42:36 | 0:42:44 | |
determined to really respect the
Fixed-term Parliaments Act. I gave | 0:42:44 | 0:42:47 | |
birth at 2am on Good Friday. As
those of you who have been there | 0:42:47 | 0:42:54 | |
before me know, it is a very
physically demanding and tiring | 0:42:54 | 0:42:58 | |
process. Four days later, I was
lying on my bed at home in the | 0:42:58 | 0:43:04 | |
morning, breast-feeding baby Theo,
and my mother actually used a few | 0:43:04 | 0:43:09 | |
expletives looking at her phone and
I said, what has happened? She said, | 0:43:09 | 0:43:14 | |
the Prime Minister has called an
election. I said, no, that can't be | 0:43:14 | 0:43:19 | |
right. She was adamant she would
not. Unlike some of you here who | 0:43:19 | 0:43:24 | |
were watching the podium and
noticing there were not... There was | 0:43:24 | 0:43:28 | |
not any writing. I did not know she
was making a statement. My husband | 0:43:28 | 0:43:31 | |
came in and my mum said, Richard,
there is going to be an election. He | 0:43:31 | 0:43:38 | |
said, you have to check, I don't
believe it. We were in a state of | 0:43:38 | 0:43:43 | |
disbelief for quite some hours, days
and weeks, actually. We wondered how | 0:43:43 | 0:43:47 | |
on earth we would cope with the
newborn, this brand-new little | 0:43:47 | 0:43:50 | |
person we had in our lives who we've
already struggling to cope with in | 0:43:50 | 0:43:54 | |
the night because he was up most of
the night and we had to do that and | 0:43:54 | 0:43:59 | |
organise an election campaign as
well. | 0:43:59 | 0:44:04 | |
I want to think the vast majority of
my constituents who were so | 0:44:04 | 0:44:12 | |
supportive and I lost can't of the
number of messages and cards and the | 0:44:12 | 0:44:17 | |
number of people who were on the
doorstep or asked about how I was | 0:44:17 | 0:44:20 | |
and how my child was getting on. I
have to say, there were a a small | 0:44:20 | 0:44:27 | |
handful of people who said to me
that once the election was called, | 0:44:27 | 0:44:30 | |
they assumed that I would not stand
again. And I politely said to them, | 0:44:30 | 0:44:34 | |
would you ask the same question if
my husband was the MP? And the | 0:44:34 | 0:44:40 | |
answer did not come back because the
answer was obvious. Of course they | 0:44:40 | 0:44:44 | |
would not. I believe that new mums a
new dads in this place should have | 0:44:44 | 0:44:49 | |
the same rights that we have a
legislative four for men and women | 0:44:49 | 0:44:54 | |
across our country. I cannot believe
we are dragging our feet on this | 0:44:54 | 0:44:59 | |
what the meant when we have made
such market improvement. I enjoyed | 0:44:59 | 0:45:04 | |
listening to her experiences. I've
just gone on to the procedure | 0:45:04 | 0:45:10 | |
committee and attended for the first
time yesterday and it is on our | 0:45:10 | 0:45:13 | |
agenda to have investigated the Mac
investigation and make a report on | 0:45:13 | 0:45:18 | |
this. And I think that I would just
like I wanted to put it on record | 0:45:18 | 0:45:24 | |
that we are going to be looking at
that. I urge them to do it quickly | 0:45:24 | 0:45:29 | |
because there aren't various
colleagues who have a very tight | 0:45:29 | 0:45:33 | |
deadline that you should be working
to that we have already discussed. I | 0:45:33 | 0:45:37 | |
want to put on record my thanks to
my husband's employer because as | 0:45:37 | 0:45:42 | |
members of this House will know, new
dads do have a right to share | 0:45:42 | 0:45:47 | |
parental leave, but they have to
give several weeks notice. And it | 0:45:47 | 0:45:51 | |
happens to be eight weeks notice,
which is about the same time as an | 0:45:51 | 0:45:56 | |
election campaign. Thankfully his
employer agreed to bring his | 0:45:56 | 0:46:00 | |
parental leave forward. Because had
my husband and working full-time at | 0:46:00 | 0:46:04 | |
the same time is me running the
campaign, I am not sure we would | 0:46:04 | 0:46:08 | |
have been able to cope. I am really
grateful to them for doing that. I | 0:46:08 | 0:46:13 | |
would encourage new dads to take up
that right. I do think that only 5% | 0:46:13 | 0:46:20 | |
at the moment to take up that right.
After the election and we did get | 0:46:20 | 0:46:26 | |
through. And I did start... A week
after I gave birth, a whole bunch of | 0:46:26 | 0:46:36 | |
people came to help. And someone in
the Sunday paper came with | 0:46:36 | 0:46:42 | |
photographers. My baby Pete
everywhere. And anyway. Now I an | 0:46:42 | 0:46:56 | |
experienced in it. I was having this
meeting to... They got a photo of me | 0:46:56 | 0:47:05 | |
in the baby and I was very tired and
eggs -- they insisted on driving me | 0:47:05 | 0:47:11 | |
on the campaign trail. I didn't want
to because I was very tired. I | 0:47:11 | 0:47:19 | |
should have gone home, and I did
suffer from it physically. Then I | 0:47:19 | 0:47:26 | |
had a rest. We had all the deadlines
for letters and leaflets and as much | 0:47:26 | 0:47:32 | |
stuff as you can basically get out.
Especially given it was such a short | 0:47:32 | 0:47:37 | |
campaign. I think her for giving
way. What she just said made me feel | 0:47:37 | 0:47:46 | |
so uncomfortable because it is
actually illegal to work for two | 0:47:46 | 0:47:49 | |
weeks after giving birth. The
situation she describes is just | 0:47:49 | 0:47:54 | |
intolerable. We really do have to do
something about this. I admit I | 0:47:54 | 0:47:58 | |
broke the law and I should not have.
I must say the motion before us | 0:47:58 | 0:48:03 | |
today would not have helped me in my
situation and there were other | 0:48:03 | 0:48:08 | |
members here who were in the same
situation. There were three new mums | 0:48:08 | 0:48:12 | |
with election was called. I suspect
there isn't anything that can be | 0:48:12 | 0:48:17 | |
done when this happens. We were very
very unlucky with the timing. I do | 0:48:17 | 0:48:21 | |
think there is something we can do
for after that. That is what I am | 0:48:21 | 0:48:25 | |
coming on too now. We had the
election, I retain my seat, but the | 0:48:25 | 0:48:29 | |
weeks after that, I was required to
come in in swearing or I don't get | 0:48:29 | 0:48:36 | |
paid. I was required to come in and
vote on the Queen's speech. I was | 0:48:36 | 0:48:41 | |
asked to come in to vote on and
select committee chairs which I | 0:48:41 | 0:48:44 | |
really want to do. Because they've
usually indoor for five years, but | 0:48:44 | 0:48:49 | |
let's see what happens. I did not
have a say on that. I infect | 0:48:49 | 0:48:52 | |
e-mailed Mr Speaker cut -- I in fact
e-mailed Mr Speaker but there wasn't | 0:48:52 | 0:49:00 | |
much he could do on this. I think it
is only right that I constituents | 0:49:00 | 0:49:06 | |
are represented in this place and we
should have the choice to appoint a | 0:49:06 | 0:49:12 | |
call into vote on our behalf. I know
that some colleagues are | 0:49:12 | 0:49:16 | |
uncomfortable with this because they
would only want to be the ones | 0:49:16 | 0:49:19 | |
voting and that's why, and I think
the right honourable Lady has taken | 0:49:19 | 0:49:26 | |
this on board, it should be a
choice. If you become a new mum or | 0:49:26 | 0:49:29 | |
dad, you should be able to appoint a
proxy for the time that you are on | 0:49:29 | 0:49:33 | |
leave. I must say I am very hugely
grateful to the web's office. | 0:49:33 | 0:49:39 | |
Particularly my honourable friend
who has been so brilliant and | 0:49:39 | 0:49:43 | |
flexible. Not only after the
election when I gave birth, but when | 0:49:43 | 0:49:49 | |
I was pregnant. It is very tiring
coming to this place when you are | 0:49:49 | 0:49:54 | |
really big. The whip's offices in
all seriousness have made a huge | 0:49:54 | 0:50:02 | |
amount of progress. I have spoken to
many colleagues who have had babies, | 0:50:02 | 0:50:07 | |
ten or 20 years ago and indeed
yourself Mattern Deputy Speaker when | 0:50:07 | 0:50:11 | |
you didn't really have that kind of
leave that we have. But we should | 0:50:11 | 0:50:18 | |
not have to ask for it. This should
be our right. And in other | 0:50:18 | 0:50:22 | |
workplaces you don't have to ask,
you have the right to it. We are | 0:50:22 | 0:50:27 | |
dragging our feet. I just want to
echo what was said earlier by one of | 0:50:27 | 0:50:32 | |
my honourable friends who talked
about a website. I e-mailed them | 0:50:32 | 0:50:40 | |
just before going on maternity leave
to see if they would reflect on | 0:50:40 | 0:50:45 | |
their website the fact that I was
going to be on leave. And they sort | 0:50:45 | 0:50:50 | |
of filed me off. They said we will
look at and they didn't do anything. | 0:50:50 | 0:50:56 | |
And I think they should consider
qualifying things on their website. | 0:50:56 | 0:51:01 | |
Many of us have been criticised by
national newspapers and it is not | 0:51:01 | 0:51:06 | |
right. It damages our reputation,
whether they issue an apology or | 0:51:06 | 0:51:10 | |
not. It is a damage your reputation
and we should not be in that | 0:51:10 | 0:51:13 | |
position. In conclusion, I just want
to pay tribute to all the honourable | 0:51:13 | 0:51:22 | |
members who have gone before me and
I want to single out a few people. | 0:51:22 | 0:51:26 | |
Not only you Madam Deputy Speaker. I
want to also pay tribute and say | 0:51:26 | 0:51:37 | |
things to some other people who
weren't... The First Minister to | 0:51:37 | 0:51:42 | |
give birth in office. I have been
inspired by many other colleagues. | 0:51:42 | 0:51:50 | |
There was one member who had two
babies while she was in the Shadow | 0:51:50 | 0:51:54 | |
Cabinet. Juggling family life and
being an MP. I say to young women | 0:51:54 | 0:52:01 | |
don't be deterred, come in and do
it. Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. | 0:52:01 | 0:52:16 | |
My friend famously fought a by
election whilst having a child. And | 0:52:16 | 0:52:23 | |
she was one of the first MPs having
a child in this House. She was a | 0:52:23 | 0:52:29 | |
real example. I want to congratulate
her for bringing the work. Since | 0:52:29 | 0:52:34 | |
then, we have made steady, but I
think, literally slow progress as to | 0:52:34 | 0:52:40 | |
become a child friendly workplace.
We now have a on-site nursery. I was | 0:52:40 | 0:52:46 | |
in the building when it was
concreted and it was a site where a | 0:52:46 | 0:52:50 | |
bar once existed. I think a much
improved replacement. As we have | 0:52:50 | 0:52:55 | |
heard in this debate, there are so
many more modernising reforms that | 0:52:55 | 0:53:01 | |
are desperately needed. I think we
need more baby friendly spaces, more | 0:53:01 | 0:53:07 | |
spaces for buggies, nappy PINS,
places to breast-feed. Represent -- | 0:53:07 | 0:53:13 | |
the opportunity that it presents for
the diversity of this chamber. The | 0:53:13 | 0:53:20 | |
example that we can set for the rest
of the country. If I can just say, I | 0:53:20 | 0:53:25 | |
think it is fitting that this issue
is discussed today. Since the last | 0:53:25 | 0:53:31 | |
time to talk date, I've had a baby
and as a new mum, I am acutely aware | 0:53:31 | 0:53:36 | |
for new mums and for women to keep a
close eye on their mental health. | 0:53:36 | 0:53:44 | |
Northeast, forgive me... My BB was
just four weeks off when -- my baby | 0:53:44 | 0:53:56 | |
was just four weeks old when the
election was called. It wasn't -- it | 0:53:56 | 0:54:01 | |
was an incredibly stressful.. Many
people will have mental health | 0:54:01 | 0:54:16 | |
issues. There are many diseases that
increase after childbirth. We know | 0:54:16 | 0:54:23 | |
that one of the triggers to mental
health is stress and anxiety in the | 0:54:23 | 0:54:29 | |
workplace. This is especially true
when a mum or dad returns to work | 0:54:29 | 0:54:33 | |
after the birth of their child.
These issues affect people inside | 0:54:33 | 0:54:37 | |
and outside of this House just why
this debate is so important. I have | 0:54:37 | 0:54:48 | |
two polling -- it is a privilege to
stand here for Mike disaster ensues. | 0:54:48 | 0:54:58 | |
While I was able to keep on with the
constituency casework, last June I | 0:54:58 | 0:55:05 | |
had to leave my constituency and
travel to come down to London to | 0:55:05 | 0:55:12 | |
Parliament. First to swear in and
while I am very grateful to the | 0:55:12 | 0:55:18 | |
whips, I was asked to come in and
vote on a couple of occasions. In | 0:55:18 | 0:55:22 | |
June, when my baby was just three
months old and again in September | 0:55:22 | 0:55:27 | |
for some important votes when she
was just five months old. In | 0:55:27 | 0:55:30 | |
September, I was in the team room
with my baby and we were there until | 0:55:30 | 0:55:35 | |
after ten o'clock at night. Arguably
that was not the right place for my | 0:55:35 | 0:55:40 | |
baby at that time of night. As a
breast-feeding mum, all my baby came | 0:55:40 | 0:55:49 | |
in with me. Colleagues will know it
is of huge responsibility looking | 0:55:49 | 0:55:53 | |
after a tiny human. I was a slummy
mummy. It is a challenge some days | 0:55:53 | 0:56:02 | |
just to take a shower. Let alone to
get up and get out of the House, to | 0:56:02 | 0:56:06 | |
get to the station, to change the
baby on the train that is moving at | 0:56:06 | 0:56:12 | |
a miles an hour. The crying. To get
on the tube often using escalator | 0:56:12 | 0:56:21 | |
stairs because there is no lift. For
an important overnight trip which | 0:56:21 | 0:56:28 | |
for some babies will be the first
time they are outside, it can be | 0:56:28 | 0:56:32 | |
quite traumatic for them. I think
the vote on the motion today, proxy | 0:56:32 | 0:56:39 | |
voting, it is a simple means to
count a member's vote without having | 0:56:39 | 0:56:46 | |
them to pass physically through the
voting lobbies. I think that will | 0:56:46 | 0:56:51 | |
mean that the representative role of
any MP can continue without being | 0:56:51 | 0:56:55 | |
disrupted. It is not only an issue
of fairness for the parents, it is a | 0:56:55 | 0:56:59 | |
matter of fairness for our
constituents. As with all the | 0:56:59 | 0:57:04 | |
representation we make in this
House, the work we do on the | 0:57:04 | 0:57:09 | |
campaigns, the contributions we make
for the country, to improve the | 0:57:09 | 0:57:13 | |
first 1001 days of a child's life,
to give children the best start in | 0:57:13 | 0:57:17 | |
life, when we highlight the
importance of attachment, when we | 0:57:17 | 0:57:23 | |
address the breast-feeding rates
that we have in our country, Madam | 0:57:23 | 0:57:28 | |
Deputy Speaker, we need to lead by
example and we need to give | 0:57:28 | 0:57:33 | |
children, the children of MPs the
best start as well. Some people | 0:57:33 | 0:57:38 | |
might say this is a dangerous leap
modernity I have heard that. Proxy | 0:57:38 | 0:57:50 | |
voting was known here. It records
until 1868 lords who were not | 0:57:50 | 0:57:57 | |
present could vote by proxy. Since
then, no attempt has been made to | 0:57:57 | 0:58:01 | |
suspend the laws to allow the
revival of this practise. In the | 0:58:01 | 0:58:11 | |
comments, proxies were allowed in
the mediaeval Parliament. This is | 0:58:11 | 0:58:14 | |
not a leap in the dark, but in
unearthing of a fine old | 0:58:14 | 0:58:18 | |
Parliamentary tradition. | 0:58:18 | 0:58:23 | |
To deny our constituents of voice
because of this House not | 0:58:23 | 0:58:27 | |
modernising, it is an affront.
Providing new parents with the | 0:58:27 | 0:58:33 | |
ability to register a vote by a
ensures our constituents can still | 0:58:33 | 0:58:37 | |
be heard. We know the physical
arrangements are about to undergo | 0:58:37 | 0:58:44 | |
huge changes. Our work continues and
our democracy in June was. I hope | 0:58:44 | 0:58:51 | |
that as we contemplate those
changes, following yesterday's wrote | 0:58:51 | 0:58:55 | |
about the refurbishment of the
Palace of Westminster, we will focus | 0:58:55 | 0:58:59 | |
on ways we can continue to become
more child friendly and welcoming -- | 0:58:59 | 0:59:04 | |
yesterday's vote. The small but
significant changes, so should every | 0:59:04 | 0:59:09 | |
workplace and every factory, office,
there are practical ways to help | 0:59:09 | 0:59:13 | |
people when parents return to work
after having a baby or having | 0:59:13 | 0:59:16 | |
adopted. I think many stressful
situations can be averted through | 0:59:16 | 0:59:22 | |
small changes and if we are serious
about improving the nation's mental | 0:59:22 | 0:59:28 | |
health, it is an important factor.
For over 35 years, the member for | 0:59:28 | 0:59:33 | |
Camberwell and Peckham has fought
for equality and fairness at | 0:59:33 | 0:59:36 | |
Westminster and in the country. I
think proxy voting would be another | 0:59:36 | 0:59:39 | |
valuable part of honouring the
mother of our Parliament's | 0:59:39 | 0:59:44 | |
continuing contribution to our
public life and I sincerely hope the | 0:59:44 | 0:59:48 | |
House approves this measure and the
Speaker will move towards a system | 0:59:48 | 0:59:51 | |
of proxy voting without delay. We
have to reduce the time limit to | 0:59:51 | 0:59:56 | |
seven minutes. Yvette Cooper. Thank
you, Madam Deputy Speaker. You and I | 0:59:56 | 1:00:05 | |
had to work out how to hang --
handle pregnancy and Parliament some | 1:00:05 | 1:00:11 | |
years ago, lovely to have you in the
chair. Can I pay tribute to the | 1:00:11 | 1:00:16 | |
brilliant speeches to my honourable
friends, their speeches alone ought | 1:00:16 | 1:00:22 | |
to persuade everybody, without any
doubt, that this is a motion that | 1:00:22 | 1:00:28 | |
should go through, but also should
be very swiftly dealt with by the | 1:00:28 | 1:00:34 | |
procedure committee? Frankly, it
feels like it is a no-brainer. 100 | 1:00:34 | 1:00:38 | |
years since women got the vote, it
is frankly an embarrassment that we | 1:00:38 | 1:00:43 | |
do not have in Parliament a system
for maternity, paternity and baby | 1:00:43 | 1:00:50 | |
leave, that my right honourable
friend describes, because if other | 1:00:50 | 1:00:55 | |
organisations can do it, why can't
we? If shops and factories and | 1:00:55 | 1:01:01 | |
businesses and doctors surgeries and
police forces, every other | 1:01:01 | 1:01:05 | |
organisation manages to find a way
of doing it, why on earth can't we? | 1:01:05 | 1:01:09 | |
Especially when we are the
organisation that has told so many | 1:01:09 | 1:01:14 | |
of those organisations that they
have to do it, they have to have | 1:01:14 | 1:01:18 | |
arrangements for leave, but we
cannot sort it out for ourselves. I | 1:01:18 | 1:01:22 | |
think maternity arrangements are not
strong enough across the country. I | 1:01:22 | 1:01:26 | |
think there is not enough provision,
the culture changes still need to | 1:01:26 | 1:01:32 | |
take place. There are still too many
difficulties and obstacles put in | 1:01:32 | 1:01:35 | |
people's way and I think there is a
serious problem about maternity | 1:01:35 | 1:01:38 | |
discrimination under way in which
the law is not enforced or arguably | 1:01:38 | 1:01:42 | |
is not strong enough to make sure
women are not ending up finding | 1:01:42 | 1:01:47 | |
themselves made redundant or demoted
or losing responsibilities when they | 1:01:47 | 1:01:52 | |
take maternity leave or at the same
time, for men, feeling that they | 1:01:52 | 1:01:57 | |
cannot take paternity leave for fear
those things will happen. How can we | 1:01:57 | 1:02:02 | |
end this House challenge errant
employers saying, it is too too | 1:02:02 | 1:02:06 | |
difficult, we are two special, we
cannot possibly provide for people | 1:02:06 | 1:02:12 | |
having babies, if we do not sort it
out ourselves customer that is why I | 1:02:12 | 1:02:18 | |
am paying tribute to my right
honourable friend who has pioneered | 1:02:18 | 1:02:22 | |
so many of these debates, led the
way for so many of us to follow, and | 1:02:22 | 1:02:27 | |
I know it was much easier for me to
be able to take maternity leave as | 1:02:27 | 1:02:32 | |
an MP but also as a minister because
of the support I got, personal | 1:02:32 | 1:02:40 | |
support as well as leadership shown,
by my right honourable friend, and | 1:02:40 | 1:02:44 | |
it is hugely important she is doing
the same still for each generation | 1:02:44 | 1:02:50 | |
of women and each generation of men
as well. I pay tribute too to the | 1:02:50 | 1:02:54 | |
right honourable member for
Basingstoke and the work she has | 1:02:54 | 1:02:58 | |
done on the women equality select
committee to support this and | 1:02:58 | 1:03:01 | |
promote this. I agree with her that
there should be wider reforms, | 1:03:01 | 1:03:06 | |
across the country, and I know this
has support from other parties as | 1:03:06 | 1:03:09 | |
well. I think given we all know,
having a baby is normal, it is why | 1:03:09 | 1:03:17 | |
we are all here, and Parliament
ought to be able to cope with what | 1:03:17 | 1:03:22 | |
is normal. Parliament ought to show
the leadership by making it | 1:03:22 | 1:03:28 | |
possible. Of course, it will always
be a challenge and there will always | 1:03:28 | 1:03:33 | |
be chaos that comes. For me, a lot
of that chaos would come from the | 1:03:33 | 1:03:37 | |
travelling to and fro with small
children, not just with a baby, I am | 1:03:37 | 1:03:42 | |
a dab hand at changing nappies on a
fast moving train, but the potty | 1:03:42 | 1:03:47 | |
training was more challenging. A few
sticky moments with a portable potty | 1:03:47 | 1:03:52 | |
with a lid on, putting it up on the
shelf on a fast moving train. There | 1:03:52 | 1:03:59 | |
will always be some complexities in
having small children and being the | 1:03:59 | 1:04:03 | |
Members of Parliament and the honour
that comes from representing | 1:04:03 | 1:04:08 | |
constituents, but it ought to be
made possible to manage both things | 1:04:08 | 1:04:12 | |
in a way that too often it isn't.
Another honourable friend of ours | 1:04:12 | 1:04:16 | |
who has since left who had a baby
and who was asked to come in for | 1:04:16 | 1:04:23 | |
votes when the baby was very small
and she came also at a time when we | 1:04:23 | 1:04:27 | |
were not even allowed to take babies
through the voting lobbies. We ended | 1:04:27 | 1:04:33 | |
up in this baby really, we took it
in turns to vote and carry the baby | 1:04:33 | 1:04:37 | |
while she went through to vote and
we would each hold the baby, great | 1:04:37 | 1:04:41 | |
for us, we got to cuddle a tiny
baby, but neither seen he there the | 1:04:41 | 1:04:45 | |
baby should have been here, but it
was a tight vote -- neither she or | 1:04:45 | 1:04:52 | |
the baby. It should not depend on
favours, not on special deals and | 1:04:52 | 1:04:58 | |
arrangements, on the whips, it
should just be a very sensible, | 1:04:58 | 1:05:01 | |
practical arrangement, it should not
be beyond the wit of this house when | 1:05:01 | 1:05:06 | |
we come up with practical
arrangements for other organisations | 1:05:06 | 1:05:09 | |
across the country to come up with a
practical way of working that works | 1:05:09 | 1:05:13 | |
too. To recognise the truth is for
any working mum, often for working | 1:05:13 | 1:05:20 | |
parents, there is always the sense
of conflicting guilt and | 1:05:20 | 1:05:25 | |
responsibility, guilt towards the
newborn that you are trying to do | 1:05:25 | 1:05:28 | |
your constituency casework at the
same time, guilt towards | 1:05:28 | 1:05:32 | |
constituents but you should be in
Parliament or at a meeting. The | 1:05:32 | 1:05:38 | |
sense of responsibility towards
Parliament, constituents, baby, | 1:05:38 | 1:05:42 | |
family, but also, the sense of
responsibility towards so many other | 1:05:42 | 1:05:45 | |
women who also might be finding it
hard to take maternity leave to show | 1:05:45 | 1:05:49 | |
it is possible and we do not have to
pretend to be superwomen and pretend | 1:05:49 | 1:05:54 | |
to have to be able to do it all at
once otherwise somehow that means | 1:05:54 | 1:05:57 | |
you are not doing your job properly.
We want people in all walks of life | 1:05:57 | 1:06:02 | |
to be able to combine parenthood and
employment because it is normal, | 1:06:02 | 1:06:06 | |
that is what we do, and we should
end the muddling through and put | 1:06:06 | 1:06:11 | |
proper arrangements in place. Final
thought I would ask the ministers | 1:06:11 | 1:06:15 | |
also have another look at the
arrangements for ministerial | 1:06:15 | 1:06:18 | |
maternity leave. When I first took
ministerial maternity leave 16 years | 1:06:18 | 1:06:23 | |
ago, we again were muddling through,
we attempted to put some | 1:06:23 | 1:06:27 | |
arrangements in place after that
that were more formal, but they | 1:06:27 | 1:06:29 | |
disappeared. They need to be revised
as well. 100th anniversary of women | 1:06:29 | 1:06:37 | |
getting the vote, what better time
to get this sorted and get it sorted | 1:06:37 | 1:06:42 | |
really, really fast. So that this
can be about our next step around | 1:06:42 | 1:06:47 | |
not just equality for people in this
House but for us being able to keep | 1:06:47 | 1:06:52 | |
being confident pioneers for
equality across the country as well. | 1:06:52 | 1:06:57 | |
Thank you, Mr Deputy Speaker. A
massive honour to follow all of the | 1:06:57 | 1:07:01 | |
speeches and I feel that honourable
friends across the house today and | 1:07:01 | 1:07:08 | |
in today's debate. I should register
not an interest but a total | 1:07:08 | 1:07:12 | |
disinterest in ever having another
child again. This will not benefit | 1:07:12 | 1:07:18 | |
me, even in the slightest, I could
not be more disinterested. Listening | 1:07:18 | 1:07:24 | |
to the testimony of my friend from
Wolverhampton North East, I found it | 1:07:24 | 1:07:33 | |
to be incredibly moving, pushing the
right back at that moment when I was | 1:07:33 | 1:07:37 | |
22 and a new mum and I was terrified
that I was going to break this | 1:07:37 | 1:07:42 | |
little thing. I have. Expected the
things... I will not put you through | 1:07:42 | 1:07:50 | |
it, Mr Deputy Speaker, but some of
the things that happen to a woman's | 1:07:50 | 1:07:52 | |
body immediately after she has a
baby, they are terrifying, you do | 1:07:52 | 1:07:58 | |
not expect it. I thought my internal
organs were falling out. | 1:07:58 | 1:08:04 | |
LAUGHTER
The thought I would have to get up | 1:08:04 | 1:08:07 | |
and get to the meeting... It is not
me that is worried but I am worried | 1:08:07 | 1:08:14 | |
about the member for Lancaster!
LAUGHTER | 1:08:14 | 1:08:21 | |
Forewarned is forearmed in these
situations. You are not dying, that | 1:08:21 | 1:08:24 | |
is what I would say to my friend
from Lancaster. But we all thought | 1:08:24 | 1:08:29 | |
that we were. The idea I would have
to get up at that moment, terrified, | 1:08:29 | 1:08:34 | |
suffering and fear, real fear for
the first time and have to go to a | 1:08:34 | 1:08:39 | |
constituency member's meeting, it is
absolutely horrifying. The thought | 1:08:39 | 1:08:43 | |
of you doing that at the. Sorry, not
you. The thought of the member for | 1:08:43 | 1:08:51 | |
Wolverhampton North East doing that
is absolutely terrifying to me. -- | 1:08:51 | 1:08:55 | |
the thought of you doing that...
Sorry, not you. Massive credit to | 1:08:55 | 1:09:01 | |
all of the women here who have had
babies. I want to, because I quite | 1:09:01 | 1:09:06 | |
like a row, to head off at the pass
some of the things I have heard in | 1:09:06 | 1:09:10 | |
this place about why this could not
happen. We're pretty much all here | 1:09:10 | 1:09:14 | |
to support it today, largely, but I
have heard quite a lot of | 1:09:14 | 1:09:19 | |
mutterings, they are mutterings,
they sound like this... Amazing... I | 1:09:19 | 1:09:27 | |
have heard an awful lot of that and
I want to address some of them. Some | 1:09:27 | 1:09:30 | |
of them from women in this House, I
have heard squeamishness about | 1:09:30 | 1:09:35 | |
wanting to ask for a right because
MPs, we are criticised for talking | 1:09:35 | 1:09:40 | |
about ourselves, very insular, we
all know those fake news on the | 1:09:40 | 1:09:45 | |
internet where they show a really
busy Chamber when we are talking | 1:09:45 | 1:09:49 | |
about our salary and an empty
Chamber when we are talking about | 1:09:49 | 1:09:52 | |
something else, just for the public
outside, a total lie. The idea we | 1:09:52 | 1:09:59 | |
should be asking for something for
ourselves, the rightful people here, | 1:09:59 | 1:10:03 | |
it is totally and utterly
acceptable. I have had to talk to | 1:10:03 | 1:10:07 | |
women in the Labour Party and as the
chair of the women's Parliamentary | 1:10:07 | 1:10:12 | |
Labour Party, to say, I am not going
to feel afraid about asking for | 1:10:12 | 1:10:16 | |
something for you, writes for the
people in this building, because if | 1:10:16 | 1:10:21 | |
I worked... When I worked at Woman's
Age, I fought for them to have | 1:10:21 | 1:10:27 | |
better maternity services for
parental leave, no matter where I | 1:10:27 | 1:10:31 | |
worked, I would be fighting for the
women to have better rights and we | 1:10:31 | 1:10:35 | |
should not be embarrassed about
fighting for them here either. I | 1:10:35 | 1:10:39 | |
want to put that to bed, the idea it
is somehow selfish. It isn't, it is | 1:10:39 | 1:10:43 | |
a right we should be entitled to.
The other chuntering I have heard | 1:10:43 | 1:10:49 | |
some people have mentioned, the thin
end of the wedge, where will this | 1:10:49 | 1:10:55 | |
lead? It will lead to being exactly
like every other employer in the | 1:10:55 | 1:11:00 | |
country. The idea of the thin end of
the wedge, as the right honourable | 1:11:00 | 1:11:05 | |
member for Basingstoke said, the
thin end of the wedge where we are | 1:11:05 | 1:11:09 | |
kind and nice employers, the big end
of the wedge is decency and | 1:11:09 | 1:11:13 | |
humanity, I am more all right with
that. We are asking for something a | 1:11:13 | 1:11:20 | |
very specific reason and when people
do not... They say, you cannot have | 1:11:20 | 1:11:25 | |
other people voting for you, as if
they have the divine right of kings | 1:11:25 | 1:11:30 | |
when we come into this place, our
vote is handed to us by God and it | 1:11:30 | 1:11:35 | |
is so special, nobody else could say
how I might feel about fisheries | 1:11:35 | 1:11:41 | |
industries, it is frankly
ridiculous. The idea that people | 1:11:41 | 1:11:46 | |
feel that they are so special that
nobody could ever cast their vote | 1:11:46 | 1:11:53 | |
for them, I assume they have never
followed the whip and deciding | 1:11:53 | 1:11:59 | |
always exactly what they will vote
for all by their little selves, I | 1:11:59 | 1:12:03 | |
find that highly unlikely. I think
Caroline Lucas, the member for | 1:12:03 | 1:12:09 | |
Brighton Pavilion, she might be the
only person who could say that. I | 1:12:09 | 1:12:14 | |
thank my honourable friend for
giving way and making this | 1:12:14 | 1:12:17 | |
incredibly powerful speech. Would
she agreed that the thin end of the | 1:12:17 | 1:12:20 | |
wedge is not the thin end of erosion
of our democracy but a thin end of | 1:12:20 | 1:12:25 | |
how we balance work and family life
when circumstances might be | 1:12:25 | 1:12:30 | |
unpredictable? Two months ago, my
mother had a stroke and while she is | 1:12:30 | 1:12:35 | |
a lot better now, I was in a
position of having to put in place | 1:12:35 | 1:12:40 | |
with my sisters and brother 24-hour
care for someone who we were used to | 1:12:40 | 1:12:45 | |
caring for us and whilst I know and
understand the issues that there | 1:12:45 | 1:12:50 | |
will be with parents, to have to be
in that position and to then | 1:12:50 | 1:12:57 | |
struggle for the flexibility to
manage that alongside being a Member | 1:12:57 | 1:13:00 | |
of Parliament, it is something that
I would want to see us change and | 1:13:00 | 1:13:03 | |
have the courage to change. I
couldn't agree more, as somebody who | 1:13:03 | 1:13:10 | |
has similarly cared for my own
mother when she was dying, the | 1:13:10 | 1:13:15 | |
amount of pressure that gets put on
and I have to say it is largely the | 1:13:15 | 1:13:19 | |
women in society when you are in the
middle and you are caring for | 1:13:19 | 1:13:24 | |
children and you are also caring for
dying relatives or very sick | 1:13:24 | 1:13:30 | |
relatives, we have got to, as a
nation, get better at dealing with | 1:13:30 | 1:13:34 | |
that, and why not start here? The
other issue, I went for lunch with a | 1:13:34 | 1:13:40 | |
gentleman yesterday, with my husband
-- my husband's listening, it wasn't | 1:13:40 | 1:13:47 | |
him. He talked about how he had
hoped to intend to take shared | 1:13:47 | 1:13:54 | |
parental leave other colleagues has
spoken about and he said, as soon as | 1:13:54 | 1:13:58 | |
I said, OK, I will take three months
off, it started to creep in, what if | 1:13:58 | 1:14:03 | |
my clients get given to somebody
else? What if people judge me for | 1:14:03 | 1:14:10 | |
leaving? I thought, my heart bleeds
for you, my tiny violin, that is | 1:14:10 | 1:14:13 | |
what we have to put up with for
ever. | 1:14:13 | 1:14:20 | |
Because I have lived that life. The
truth of the matter is is that we | 1:14:20 | 1:14:28 | |
have got to make sure that when we
make these changes that it is not | 1:14:28 | 1:14:32 | |
only the women in this building that
take this leave. And that the man in | 1:14:32 | 1:14:39 | |
this building take it as well.
Frankly, I think some of the men in | 1:14:39 | 1:14:44 | |
this building and some of the
backtalk that I have heard when I | 1:14:44 | 1:14:49 | |
have talked about this should be
ashamed of bragging about being here | 1:14:49 | 1:14:57 | |
moments when their baby were born.
For standing up and saying and | 1:14:57 | 1:15:01 | |
committees, point of order, my wife
just had a baby. Point of order, I | 1:15:01 | 1:15:09 | |
divorce you if you are my husband.
There is one plays a man should be | 1:15:09 | 1:15:12 | |
when their baby is born and that is
by the side of their partner. And | 1:15:12 | 1:15:20 | |
that, I think, in this place, we
have got to say, this is not about | 1:15:20 | 1:15:24 | |
the women getting something better.
This is about the parents getting | 1:15:24 | 1:15:28 | |
something better. Because we have
got to lead by example. And I know | 1:15:28 | 1:15:32 | |
just not for the Member for
Wolverhampton from Northeast. There | 1:15:32 | 1:15:37 | |
are husbands in this building who
are starting to take that leaves and | 1:15:37 | 1:15:41 | |
we have got to stand as an example
to that. So, basically when this | 1:15:41 | 1:15:45 | |
comes in, I am coming in for you. To
the men in his house to take it. | 1:15:45 | 1:15:55 | |
Thank you for calling this important
debate. It is very important for me | 1:15:55 | 1:16:03 | |
to be here because I did have a baby
a year and a half ago. As a sitting | 1:16:03 | 1:16:08 | |
MP. While I will not go into detail
about what happened to my insides... | 1:16:08 | 1:16:13 | |
LAUGHTER
I do want to talk a little bit about | 1:16:13 | 1:16:18 | |
the impact of the pregnancy and the
birth on me. I won't go into | 1:16:18 | 1:16:23 | |
details, but I did say -- I would
say I had a 40 hour long labour | 1:16:23 | 1:16:28 | |
which resulted in an emergency
C-section. After that, I got an | 1:16:28 | 1:16:33 | |
infection and so did the baby. I was
looked after for nine days, even | 1:16:33 | 1:16:41 | |
when I was on the hospital bed, I
had to do e-mails and I had to sign | 1:16:41 | 1:16:46 | |
things offer my office simply
because there was no one else to do | 1:16:46 | 1:16:49 | |
it and I could not really nominate
someone to take care of crucial | 1:16:49 | 1:16:52 | |
matters. And there were some crucial
matters which I will elaborate in a | 1:16:52 | 1:16:57 | |
moment. I am not describing this
details because I want sympathy I'm | 1:16:57 | 1:17:04 | |
doing it because before I had a
child, I did not quite realise the | 1:17:04 | 1:17:07 | |
physical impact childbirth has on
your body. I have been around | 1:17:07 | 1:17:14 | |
children and babies, but I still did
not realise quite what would happen | 1:17:14 | 1:17:17 | |
to your body when you went through a
40 hour ordeal in the way that I did | 1:17:17 | 1:17:23 | |
and after the emergency C-section
where I physically could not move | 1:17:23 | 1:17:25 | |
from the bed and I had to ask
everyone for help which is not easy | 1:17:25 | 1:17:29 | |
when I'm used to doing for myself.
It was not easy, but because I was | 1:17:29 | 1:17:36 | |
in a seat that had been a very
marginal seat, the lady that I had | 1:17:36 | 1:17:40 | |
taken over from only one deceived by
42 votes, I had only won it by just | 1:17:40 | 1:17:45 | |
over a thousand votes. I did not
feel like I could look like my | 1:17:45 | 1:17:49 | |
constituents. I came back to work
very quickly afterwards. As a result | 1:17:49 | 1:17:52 | |
because my body did not recover, I
developed a very terrible infection. | 1:17:52 | 1:17:59 | |
And anyone who has had disinfection
knows what it does to your body. I | 1:17:59 | 1:18:05 | |
went to my GP and I told him that I
was overworked and had come back to | 1:18:05 | 1:18:09 | |
work very early. In my sleep
deprived state I knew I had to do | 1:18:09 | 1:18:13 | |
something. I tabled an early day
motion asking if we could change the | 1:18:13 | 1:18:16 | |
way the voting system worked. Even I
was getting e-mails saying why have | 1:18:16 | 1:18:21 | |
you not turned up for this vote? In
the six weeks, I was being asked why | 1:18:21 | 1:18:26 | |
I had not turned up for a certain
meeting. And if you know our | 1:18:26 | 1:18:35 | |
constituencies, they look up your
your voting record. I wanted to make | 1:18:35 | 1:18:41 | |
it clear that we have got to change
the voting system. This is the time | 1:18:41 | 1:18:45 | |
to do it where there are more women
than ever before. Having children in | 1:18:45 | 1:18:49 | |
Parliament. I wanted to point out
how our position here in Parliament | 1:18:49 | 1:18:54 | |
lags behind in other countries. In
Sweden, Denmark and Slovenia, | 1:18:54 | 1:19:00 | |
members of Parliament may be granted
leave of 12 ones in case of child | 1:19:00 | 1:19:05 | |
birth, pregnancy or adoption. This
is the same in Estonia Finland and | 1:19:05 | 1:19:08 | |
Luke Latvia. In the Netherlands,
there are no formal maternity leave, | 1:19:08 | 1:19:17 | |
but they can be replaced by another
MP from the same political group so | 1:19:17 | 1:19:21 | |
they are not penalised for their
absence. The fact that we are behind | 1:19:21 | 1:19:25 | |
these countries with our attitudes
to parental leave is compounded with | 1:19:25 | 1:19:32 | |
her attitude with our Parliamentary
voting system. Scotland, he India | 1:19:32 | 1:19:38 | |
and Ireland and the European Union
are all have electronic voting. I | 1:19:38 | 1:19:48 | |
just want to say to my friend making
an incredibly powerful speech, would | 1:19:48 | 1:19:53 | |
she agree with me by the time we are
done with this, we should match or | 1:19:53 | 1:19:57 | |
better the best Parliaments in the
world. And also just to say | 1:19:57 | 1:20:01 | |
physically, having the second is
harder. | 1:20:01 | 1:20:04 | |
LAUGHTER. I would like to thank my
honourable friend for the note of | 1:20:04 | 1:20:12 | |
confidence, but I absolutely agree
with what she is saying. If we want | 1:20:12 | 1:20:15 | |
to make Parliament a welcoming place
for female representatives and if we | 1:20:15 | 1:20:19 | |
want to act in the way that my
constituency Labour Party did when | 1:20:19 | 1:20:23 | |
they categorically said one after
another we want more people not | 1:20:23 | 1:20:29 | |
women in Parliament, that is what we
should all be encouraging in the | 1:20:29 | 1:20:36 | |
House of Commons where we sit. I
thank you for giving way and an | 1:20:36 | 1:20:44 | |
excellent speech. She mentioned
Scotland, so I could not miss the | 1:20:44 | 1:20:47 | |
opportunity to jump in. We have been
in debates on this motion before. | 1:20:47 | 1:20:51 | |
She mentioned electronic voting and
she will know as well as I do that | 1:20:51 | 1:20:56 | |
some of the arguments against proxy
and electronic voting is that this | 1:20:56 | 1:21:03 | |
chamber does not fit half of the
members of this House. We all have | 1:21:03 | 1:21:08 | |
modern technology we can all watch
at home, there is a reason not to do | 1:21:08 | 1:21:11 | |
this. We have had discussions about
this and we do feel that Parliament | 1:21:11 | 1:21:18 | |
needs to become more modern and we
need to encourage more things like | 1:21:18 | 1:21:23 | |
electronic voting. Maybe that will
be next on the agenda. I wanted to | 1:21:23 | 1:21:27 | |
touch on the fact that I have a lot
of support for my constituency | 1:21:27 | 1:21:31 | |
Labour Party when I ran to be an MP.
When I was a young woman, they | 1:21:31 | 1:21:35 | |
thought I would have children and
there were questions raised about | 1:21:35 | 1:21:40 | |
it. One person said what is the
problem is MPs have children? It's | 1:21:40 | 1:21:48 | |
good for their constituency. He also
pointed out that apparently | 1:21:48 | 1:21:51 | |
politicians with children get more
votes, I do not know if that is | 1:21:51 | 1:21:55 | |
true. I just want to talk a little
bit about the support I received in | 1:21:55 | 1:22:01 | |
Parliament. The staff at the nursery
were really fantastic when I first | 1:22:01 | 1:22:04 | |
took my child. I want to pay tribute
to them. The member who was sitting | 1:22:04 | 1:22:11 | |
here earlier on is my neighbouring
MP and right at the beginning when I | 1:22:11 | 1:22:16 | |
had morning sickness, he was the
first to ring and say if there are | 1:22:16 | 1:22:18 | |
any meetings that you would like me
to cover for you, I am happy to go. | 1:22:18 | 1:22:22 | |
Because his wife had gone through
the same thing. Another member on a | 1:22:22 | 1:22:26 | |
trip to Paris carried my suitcase up
and down the stairs when I | 1:22:26 | 1:22:34 | |
physically could not lift the
suitcase. And on the same trip to | 1:22:34 | 1:22:38 | |
Paris to explore how we tackle
anti-Semitism, the former MP for... | 1:22:38 | 1:22:43 | |
I'm trying to think, for Brentwood
said to me he is happy to be the | 1:22:43 | 1:22:47 | |
godfather for my child and whether I
wanted to name my daughter Erica | 1:22:47 | 1:22:52 | |
after him which I declined. Another
MP gave me a wristband to monitor | 1:22:52 | 1:22:58 | |
the number time my babies kicked.
There was a sense of real spirit | 1:22:58 | 1:23:05 | |
among members of the other side who
I would talk to. About what we did | 1:23:05 | 1:23:09 | |
as young women who had children but
also wanted to be good MPs. When my | 1:23:09 | 1:23:18 | |
ever-growing bomb, and when you are
four foot 11, your bob really does | 1:23:18 | 1:23:22 | |
stand out also -- when your bump
really stands out when you are four | 1:23:22 | 1:23:30 | |
foot 11. Perhaps the memory that
most stands out was when right after | 1:23:30 | 1:23:40 | |
I had the baby, I got an urgent call
from my office, the result man whose | 1:23:40 | 1:23:46 | |
wife had been in a Ron who was
detained with her small child. I had | 1:23:46 | 1:23:52 | |
just had my baby obviously when my
office called, I had to meet with | 1:23:52 | 1:23:56 | |
them because there was no one I
could delegate that responsibility | 1:23:56 | 1:24:00 | |
to when I spoke to him on the phone
he said why don't you come over to | 1:24:00 | 1:24:03 | |
my house and I said that is a good
idea. And he said is there any idea | 1:24:03 | 1:24:08 | |
that the leader of the Labour Party
could also meet me? I ran and I said | 1:24:08 | 1:24:12 | |
I just had a baby but there is a
really urgent Kates and we need to | 1:24:12 | 1:24:16 | |
meet near my flat because I'm
breast-feeding. And he said why | 1:24:16 | 1:24:21 | |
don't I come over to your flat and
we will have a meeting there? So are | 1:24:21 | 1:24:26 | |
in the meeting and I had a tiny baby
in my arm, the man whose wife had | 1:24:26 | 1:24:31 | |
been detained and why breast-feed,
we discussed the Iranian authorities | 1:24:31 | 1:24:35 | |
and talked about how to get my
constituent back into the country. | 1:24:35 | 1:24:39 | |
At one point my baby was very
unsettled and I had to take some | 1:24:39 | 1:24:44 | |
notes so I said to the member, could
you hold the baby for bid why write | 1:24:44 | 1:24:49 | |
notes? Now the baby had been quite
unsettled, but for some reason as | 1:24:49 | 1:24:53 | |
soon as I handed her over, she
settled down and went to sleep. | 1:24:53 | 1:24:59 | |
LAUGHTER. I don't want to say but
there may be a point about kinder | 1:24:59 | 1:25:10 | |
gentler cuddling. I wanted to tell
people in the chamber is that that | 1:25:10 | 1:25:14 | |
was a real defining moment for me.
Both men in that room demonstrated | 1:25:14 | 1:25:19 | |
serious comrade Rees. For me. Taking
time to come to my house because I | 1:25:19 | 1:25:23 | |
did not feel like I could leave. Not
batting an eyelid when I breast-fed. | 1:25:23 | 1:25:28 | |
I think that is the tiny ethos we
need to bring into this House. If | 1:25:28 | 1:25:32 | |
you are an MP and you have an urgent
case and you still want to fulfil | 1:25:32 | 1:25:36 | |
your duties, there are ways to do
it. If you can do in my flat in | 1:25:36 | 1:25:41 | |
North London, we can do it here as
well. I sit on a committee where we | 1:25:41 | 1:25:47 | |
scrutinise legislation around other
people's maternity and if we cannot | 1:25:47 | 1:25:51 | |
lead by example, we should not be
sitting here. I commend this motion. | 1:25:51 | 1:25:58 | |
Thank you, Mr Deputy Speaker, but
I'm not sure how I'm going to | 1:25:58 | 1:26:01 | |
follow. It is an honour to take part
in this debate. I would like to pay | 1:26:01 | 1:26:07 | |
tribute to the right honourable
members for securing it today. And | 1:26:07 | 1:26:10 | |
say that for me it is actually what
we like to say at home and little | 1:26:10 | 1:26:16 | |
treat. Around 20 years ago, we were
able -- a few years ago I was able | 1:26:16 | 1:26:21 | |
to interview a member about how she
planned to change the working | 1:26:21 | 1:26:28 | |
landscape for families in this
country. I actually had just | 1:26:28 | 1:26:34 | |
finished my maternity leave at the
BBC at the time and I have to say | 1:26:34 | 1:26:42 | |
that she was right even back in
those dark distant days of the past, | 1:26:42 | 1:26:45 | |
the BBC words you -- were able to
put out news bulletins even though I | 1:26:45 | 1:26:52 | |
was not there. Employers find a way.
I have to say the landscape for | 1:26:52 | 1:26:57 | |
families has changed dramatically.
Children who were born back then and | 1:26:57 | 1:27:03 | |
are becoming parents now benefit
from a whole raft of legislation | 1:27:03 | 1:27:08 | |
which makes it easier for them to be
with their partner and their child | 1:27:08 | 1:27:12 | |
to bond as a family immediately
after the child is born except of | 1:27:12 | 1:27:16 | |
course unless they are a member of
Parliament. It seems ridiculous that | 1:27:16 | 1:27:20 | |
we in this place should be so far
behind the very people that we are | 1:27:20 | 1:27:27 | |
here to represent and to help. I
have to say also I have no intention | 1:27:27 | 1:27:36 | |
of having another child and although
I have found that this debate at | 1:27:36 | 1:27:40 | |
times moving and entertaining, it is
also been frankly horrifying. If | 1:27:40 | 1:27:45 | |
there had been any doubt I would not
be having another child now. The | 1:27:45 | 1:27:52 | |
gender bias of this House has also
changed completely since I've been | 1:27:52 | 1:27:56 | |
here. There are now 200 women many
of them young enough to be starting | 1:27:56 | 1:28:01 | |
or expanding their families. And
many of the male colleagues are as | 1:28:01 | 1:28:04 | |
well. I think we have to bear in
mind that for many of us who have | 1:28:04 | 1:28:11 | |
constituencies, many hundreds of
miles away, that will not mean being | 1:28:11 | 1:28:15 | |
home late at night for an hour or a
couple of hours or travelling | 1:28:15 | 1:28:19 | |
although that must be difficult to
high-speed train with a small child. | 1:28:19 | 1:28:23 | |
It will mean being away for a week
at a time. | 1:28:23 | 1:28:31 | |
Separated from them at the most
important time in a child's life, | 1:28:31 | 1:28:35 | |
not helping our partners through the
sorts of ordeals we have heard about | 1:28:35 | 1:28:39 | |
from other members, and we know that
some of the younger male members of | 1:28:39 | 1:28:42 | |
this house have already had to do.
We should not be asking parents to | 1:28:42 | 1:28:49 | |
choose between voting and providing
that support. Not when an | 1:28:49 | 1:28:58 | |
alternative is already there. It was
there in the 19th century, we have | 1:28:58 | 1:29:02 | |
heard today. It is there every time
we go to the ballot box. You can | 1:29:02 | 1:29:06 | |
have a proxy vote. You can have
someone to go to exercise democratic | 1:29:06 | 1:29:10 | |
right. We should not be excluding
ourselves from that possibility. One | 1:29:10 | 1:29:16 | |
other thing, all of the changes
which have come about in the last | 1:29:16 | 1:29:25 | |
20-30 years, maternity and parental
leave act, working families act, the | 1:29:25 | 1:29:30 | |
Children and Families Act, the
Equalities Act, they all aimed at | 1:29:30 | 1:29:33 | |
creating a level playing field so
that when young women went in for a | 1:29:33 | 1:29:37 | |
job, they were not judged on whether
they might be leaving to have | 1:29:37 | 1:29:41 | |
maternity leave and a young man who
came in would not present the same | 1:29:41 | 1:29:45 | |
problem, he would also be taking
baby leave. And yet, we do not seem | 1:29:45 | 1:29:50 | |
to have taken it into account that
when selecting members for this | 1:29:50 | 1:29:55 | |
House, selecting candidates, perhaps
local parties would be faced with | 1:29:55 | 1:30:00 | |
the same dilemma. If they choose the
young woman, married, maybe about to | 1:30:00 | 1:30:06 | |
start a family, they are going to
lose her from the House. If they | 1:30:06 | 1:30:10 | |
choose to young man, they might
think they would not. So we are | 1:30:10 | 1:30:16 | |
making it difficult for ourselves to
pursue that stated goal of making | 1:30:16 | 1:30:20 | |
this place more representative of
the country that we seek to | 1:30:20 | 1:30:24 | |
represent. We need more young women
and more young men, we need more | 1:30:24 | 1:30:31 | |
people from every section of
society, and by making this simple | 1:30:31 | 1:30:36 | |
difference, this simple change, we
can make it easier to encourage | 1:30:36 | 1:30:42 | |
young people who are about to start
families to think, you know, it | 1:30:42 | 1:30:48 | |
might just be possible, I might just
be able to go and continue to | 1:30:48 | 1:30:52 | |
represent the people I want to
represent when I have my child, I | 1:30:52 | 1:30:56 | |
can have someone else vote for me,
when we adopt a child, someone else | 1:30:56 | 1:31:00 | |
can do it, it is the simplest thing
possible. And yet we have not done | 1:31:00 | 1:31:06 | |
it. If we are going to be truly
representative, then we have is to | 1:31:06 | 1:31:17 | |
represent all of our constituents.
We are falling short on that in this | 1:31:17 | 1:31:20 | |
and all I would say today is we have
the opportunity to put that last | 1:31:20 | 1:31:25 | |
piece of the jigsaw in place, to
make it possible to vote, it seems | 1:31:25 | 1:31:32 | |
ridiculous that they could do it in
the 19th century, and in the 21st, | 1:31:32 | 1:31:36 | |
we are even asking the question.
Thank you. I congratulate my right | 1:31:36 | 1:31:42 | |
honourable friend for securing this
important debate. I also thank other | 1:31:42 | 1:31:49 | |
honourable and right honourable
members and Deputy Speaker, making | 1:31:49 | 1:31:56 | |
good progress over the last few
years on this issue. As a new | 1:31:56 | 1:32:00 | |
member, I had no idea the day
nursery used to be a wine bar. The | 1:32:00 | 1:32:05 | |
day nursery being there seems normal
and that is good progress. I declare | 1:32:05 | 1:32:08 | |
my interest as the father of an
eight-week-old and husband to my | 1:32:08 | 1:32:13 | |
wife, Lucy. Ophelia was able to join
me here last week to vote for the | 1:32:13 | 1:32:19 | |
first time against the third reading
of the EU withdrawal bill and for | 1:32:19 | 1:32:23 | |
those that have shared concern about
bringing babies into the voting | 1:32:23 | 1:32:29 | |
lobby, let me pay tribute to the
clerks who very astutely did not | 1:32:29 | 1:32:34 | |
count her vote when I walked through
and quite rightly, I have no ideas | 1:32:34 | 1:32:38 | |
what her views are on the
Government's Brexit strategy. I | 1:32:38 | 1:32:41 | |
support this important motion today
because from my own experience of | 1:32:41 | 1:32:46 | |
going on paternity leave a little
earlier than expected in the run-up | 1:32:46 | 1:32:50 | |
to Christmas, I was a book as a
backbench MP to clear my diary | 1:32:50 | 1:32:55 | |
easily and my constituents were very
supportive but I needed to be and | 1:32:55 | 1:33:04 | |
there were important votes I wanted
to vote on, but the ability to use | 1:33:04 | 1:33:07 | |
proxy voting or I can see the clerks
use and iPad, maybe there is an app | 1:33:07 | 1:33:11 | |
we could access. It would be welcome
progress. In the early days, as | 1:33:11 | 1:33:16 | |
other honourable friends have said,
my duty as a husband and father is | 1:33:16 | 1:33:20 | |
to be there to help in any way I can
at home and having to leave for | 1:33:20 | 1:33:24 | |
sometimes many hours to vote when I
could do it from home or by a proxy, | 1:33:24 | 1:33:29 | |
it would be very helpful.
Formalising the process would be | 1:33:29 | 1:33:34 | |
helpful too. The whips were very
helpful but there was a presumption | 1:33:34 | 1:33:36 | |
I would be here apart from those I
negotiated not to be here for. I | 1:33:36 | 1:33:41 | |
would argue it was the other way
round. French reds, the Brexit ones, | 1:33:41 | 1:33:47 | |
I'm sure Ophelia would have said
that she wanted me to be here -- on | 1:33:47 | 1:33:51 | |
the crunch ones. The assumption
needs switching. In the short amount | 1:33:51 | 1:33:56 | |
of time I have, it is important we
set the tone in this place, it is | 1:33:56 | 1:34:02 | |
right, as others have said, we
should be doing the same as what we | 1:34:02 | 1:34:06 | |
have legislated for in the country,
that seems perfectly sensible. It is | 1:34:06 | 1:34:10 | |
right to set the tone for what we
wish to see. Parenting should not be | 1:34:10 | 1:34:15 | |
a gender issue and I am of the firm
view a family friendly and gender | 1:34:15 | 1:34:19 | |
balanced economy is not just the
right thing to do but would be good | 1:34:19 | 1:34:22 | |
for economic growth and well-being
as well. The House may not be | 1:34:22 | 1:34:26 | |
surprised to hear that I think my
wife is a remarkable and talented | 1:34:26 | 1:34:35 | |
woman and I say that not least
because in the snap election went at | 1:34:35 | 1:34:38 | |
that stage we were two months
pregnant, I made it clear I stood no | 1:34:38 | 1:34:43 | |
chance of winning the election
whatsoever and that I would be able | 1:34:43 | 1:34:47 | |
to apply for shared parental leave
in my previous job as a lawyer. To | 1:34:47 | 1:34:51 | |
make it worse, having actually won
when I said I would not, although I | 1:34:51 | 1:34:55 | |
am very honoured to be here of
course, the local BBC News, they | 1:34:55 | 1:35:00 | |
noticed a slight bump, they
announced our pregnancy to 1.3 | 1:35:00 | 1:35:04 | |
million people in the region without
checking first, so we had text | 1:35:04 | 1:35:09 | |
messages saying, congratulations. We
thought it was about the election | 1:35:09 | 1:35:11 | |
and we realised it was about
Ophelia, we had not had the three | 1:35:11 | 1:35:15 | |
months can, how does everyone know?
My wife had a bumpy process in | 1:35:15 | 1:35:21 | |
becoming a mum involved with a
parliamentarian and my wife is also | 1:35:21 | 1:35:24 | |
my constituent and she has said it
is OK for me to say that it has been | 1:35:24 | 1:35:36 | |
quite distressing and it has been
quite difficult because my wife as | 1:35:36 | 1:35:44 | |
director of public policy at an
energy company receiving government | 1:35:44 | 1:35:48 | |
funding in a senior role, doing very
well, and after the announcement of | 1:35:48 | 1:35:52 | |
her pregnancy, she was made
redundant and told her role was no | 1:35:52 | 1:35:55 | |
longer needed. Very distressing to
her. Having worked so hard to | 1:35:55 | 1:36:00 | |
achieve what she had. But my wife is
also a formidable woman, she took | 1:36:00 | 1:36:05 | |
them to the employment tribunal. As
a litigant in person, whilst | 1:36:05 | 1:36:09 | |
pregnant, cross-examined her former
employers, in front of a judge, who | 1:36:09 | 1:36:14 | |
said that since the Supreme Court
had decided the fees were illegal | 1:36:14 | 1:36:20 | |
for employment tribunal cases, his
time was increasingly being taken up | 1:36:20 | 1:36:23 | |
by these types of cases. The
atmosphere and environment, can you | 1:36:23 | 1:36:27 | |
imagine, as one of only two women of
ten in the tribunal room, without | 1:36:27 | 1:36:32 | |
gender balance unemployment tribunal
's, it was clearly very distressing | 1:36:32 | 1:36:38 | |
and I take that issue up now with
the president of the employment | 1:36:38 | 1:36:43 | |
tribunal... The fact of the matter
is, I should say, my wife sadly lost | 1:36:43 | 1:36:46 | |
that case and perhaps we should have
the debate about the application of | 1:36:46 | 1:36:52 | |
burden of proof rules in this
country where it is up to women to | 1:36:52 | 1:36:55 | |
establish the burden of proof that
discrimination could have taken | 1:36:55 | 1:36:58 | |
place before employers have to bring
forward witnesses and documents to | 1:36:58 | 1:37:01 | |
show it did not take place at a time
when they said the documents did not | 1:37:01 | 1:37:05 | |
exist, it makes it very difficult
for women bringing those claims. The | 1:37:05 | 1:37:09 | |
fact is that as a father and a
husband, I think it is perfectly | 1:37:09 | 1:37:14 | |
sensible and normal for me to want
to lean in, for dads to | 1:37:14 | 1:37:28 | |
lean my wife to achieve her
aspirations and together we want to | 1:37:30 | 1:37:33 | |
give the best upbringing to our
children so I support this motion | 1:37:33 | 1:37:35 | |
not just because Parliament should
be in line with what is happening in | 1:37:35 | 1:37:38 | |
the rest of the country but it gives
us the opportunity to set the tone | 1:37:38 | 1:37:41 | |
of what we expect in a modern
Britain and I hope that through | 1:37:41 | 1:37:43 | |
reforming Parliament, looking at
companies that receive public money | 1:37:43 | 1:37:45 | |
who have these issues, we may also
look at reforming rules in the | 1:37:45 | 1:37:48 | |
judiciary, maybe even having gender
balance and hopefully achieving | 1:37:48 | 1:37:49 | |
change in the wider economy too. I
commend this motion to the House and | 1:37:49 | 1:37:54 | |
I look forward to supporting it in
any way I can. Extremely grateful, | 1:37:54 | 1:38:00 | |
Mr Deputy Speaker. I am really glad
to see you in your seat in this | 1:38:00 | 1:38:03 | |
debate which I guess maybe on some
levels bittersweet but reminds us | 1:38:03 | 1:38:07 | |
very strongly there are fantastic
parents here in Parliament and I | 1:38:07 | 1:38:10 | |
have to say in all honesty that
those of us who have grappled with | 1:38:10 | 1:38:16 | |
the experience of being the
custodians of a child, being a | 1:38:16 | 1:38:22 | |
parent, and I have met few finer
examples than those people I work | 1:38:22 | 1:38:27 | |
alongside here in Westminster, you
have heard some of those stories | 1:38:27 | 1:38:30 | |
here today were ready, I will not
rehearse the points already made but | 1:38:30 | 1:38:33 | |
I want to pay tribute to the members
for Peckham and Basingstoke for | 1:38:33 | 1:38:37 | |
bringing this forward. It has been
something we have been discussing | 1:38:37 | 1:38:40 | |
for a period of time. As one small
change that might make life a little | 1:38:40 | 1:38:45 | |
bit easier it what is an incredibly
difficult hard and job and I wanted | 1:38:45 | 1:38:49 | |
to say as well I do not believe we
should be exempt or we should not | 1:38:49 | 1:38:56 | |
acknowledge the freedom and
flexibility to do a job for which we | 1:38:56 | 1:38:59 | |
are well paid and for which we love
the opportunity to do so, it should | 1:38:59 | 1:39:03 | |
be hard, it should cost us
something, but if we can make small | 1:39:03 | 1:39:08 | |
incremental improvements that
improve the lives of people here as | 1:39:08 | 1:39:12 | |
well, I do not think it is just as
that will benefit, it is the whole | 1:39:12 | 1:39:16 | |
of society. In a week in which we
discussed last night the renewal of | 1:39:16 | 1:39:22 | |
this Parliament and today our own
arrangements, it can perhaps seem | 1:39:22 | 1:39:27 | |
indulgent for parliamentarians to
spend their time talking about | 1:39:27 | 1:39:29 | |
themselves, but I would simply point
out we are the only ones that can | 1:39:29 | 1:39:34 | |
have this conversation, we are the
ones that determine our working | 1:39:34 | 1:39:37 | |
practices and rightly so. My
honourable friend for Birmingham | 1:39:37 | 1:39:42 | |
Yardley referred to the famous
internet meme when MPs are packed in | 1:39:42 | 1:39:50 | |
when talking about the own
conditions and absolutely absent | 1:39:50 | 1:39:55 | |
when some important issue is being
talked about, that is absolutely | 1:39:55 | 1:39:59 | |
untrue. It would be good for them to
talk about this, we are relatively | 1:39:59 | 1:40:04 | |
sparse here today, everyone is
taking one position, but I have | 1:40:04 | 1:40:09 | |
spoken to many young fathers, they
have said to me that they really do | 1:40:09 | 1:40:15 | |
want this change. They really do. My
honourable friend from the committee | 1:40:15 | 1:40:20 | |
says that we are voicing one view
here today. He is right. But surely | 1:40:20 | 1:40:27 | |
if anyone had a view that differed,
they would be here? I couldn't agree | 1:40:27 | 1:40:33 | |
more and that is why I feel
confident that this motion be | 1:40:33 | 1:40:37 | |
brought forward and moved forward
and I feel we should take confidence | 1:40:37 | 1:40:41 | |
than that -- from that and
encouraged the procedure committee | 1:40:41 | 1:40:44 | |
to look at it swiftly, I know they
have done preliminary work on how | 1:40:44 | 1:40:48 | |
such a system could work. The model
of caring for a child in that first | 1:40:48 | 1:40:54 | |
year of the child's life, the split
between two different parents, it | 1:40:54 | 1:40:59 | |
sets the pattern of child rearing
right the way through the child's | 1:40:59 | 1:41:03 | |
life, all of the studies seem to
show that. Therefore, if we want | 1:41:03 | 1:41:15 | |
people to live up to the expectation
of being present for their children, | 1:41:15 | 1:41:17 | |
we should try to reflect that here
in our practice as well. I have | 1:41:17 | 1:41:20 | |
for-year-old daughter and I have
always juggled life in this | 1:41:20 | 1:41:22 | |
Parliament and I have made the most
of the flexibility offered around | 1:41:22 | 1:41:25 | |
floats to try to be present in her
life -- around votes. We make it | 1:41:25 | 1:41:32 | |
work, whatever way of life we are
in, whether it means using time on | 1:41:32 | 1:41:36 | |
Monday, getting back for the school
run on Thursday, shifting days | 1:41:36 | 1:41:40 | |
around at the weekend, being able to
take a day out in the middle but | 1:41:40 | 1:41:44 | |
turn up the votes later, I would
just say, I have never had a formal | 1:41:44 | 1:41:48 | |
conversation with my whips office to
talk about the indications of me | 1:41:48 | 1:41:52 | |
having a child, I have never said,
here is my working pattern, I have | 1:41:52 | 1:41:55 | |
really broadcast up until now what
that looks like. Two fears, probably | 1:41:55 | 1:42:03 | |
play on the minds of young fathers
as well as young mothers, the first | 1:42:03 | 1:42:07 | |
being what if it leaves you open to
criticism that you are not hard at | 1:42:07 | 1:42:12 | |
work? I have to say, when I headed
up my first year in Parliament, I | 1:42:12 | 1:42:17 | |
did that exercise, excluding the
commuting, I worked out at 70-80 | 1:42:17 | 1:42:22 | |
hour week in that job, and it has
eased off as I have got better at | 1:42:22 | 1:42:26 | |
it, frankly, but that is not a
concern that should be legitimate. | 1:42:26 | 1:42:31 | |
There is no shortage of work and we
are all doing it and when we are | 1:42:31 | 1:42:35 | |
not, it is fairly obvious... I will
give way. Apologies for not being | 1:42:35 | 1:42:41 | |
here for the full debate and
interrupting now. Can I thank the | 1:42:41 | 1:42:44 | |
honourable member for allowing the
back row allowing me to spend more | 1:42:44 | 1:42:47 | |
time with my children by winning the
seat in 2010 and leaving me another | 1:42:47 | 1:42:52 | |
five years before I personally got
into Parliament? Making a really | 1:42:52 | 1:42:56 | |
important point about constituents
expecting this to work very hard but | 1:42:56 | 1:42:59 | |
at the same time we have to put
process in place so it is not | 1:42:59 | 1:43:03 | |
unnecessarily difficult and I think
that is what we have at the moment, | 1:43:03 | 1:43:07 | |
ridiculous processes making it
unnecessarily difficult, whereas the | 1:43:07 | 1:43:10 | |
rest of the country has moved on.
Generous to me in 2010 and generous | 1:43:10 | 1:43:14 | |
to me now. The second reason why I
have never sat down and had a formal | 1:43:14 | 1:43:23 | |
conversation is we worry that
sometimes it looks like a lack of | 1:43:23 | 1:43:26 | |
professionalism, a lack of hunger to
get on, and actually, it is true, it | 1:43:26 | 1:43:31 | |
is much harder to have sharp elbows
in this place and force your way to | 1:43:31 | 1:43:34 | |
the front if you make choices about
supporting your own family. I am | 1:43:34 | 1:43:39 | |
fortunate to structure my own work
time to be present around my | 1:43:39 | 1:43:43 | |
daughter but most people's
experience of having children and | 1:43:43 | 1:43:46 | |
being in this place is completely
frazzled all of the time. Trying to | 1:43:46 | 1:43:49 | |
find a way to make it work. | 1:43:49 | 1:43:56 | |
Very sadly my own relationship with
my daughter's mum broke down and I | 1:43:56 | 1:44:01 | |
want to take full responsibility for
that, but equally we need to be | 1:44:01 | 1:44:04 | |
honest about the working practises
of this place and the implications | 1:44:04 | 1:44:07 | |
that there are. I was told that
between my intake of 20 ten and | 1:44:07 | 1:44:16 | |
2015, a quarter of marriages broke
down during that term. And we have | 1:44:16 | 1:44:21 | |
to be honest about the implications
of this place. And the effect that | 1:44:21 | 1:44:24 | |
it has. There are real issues. For
example shared parental leave is not | 1:44:24 | 1:44:34 | |
only difficult, it is impossible
because we don't have that formal | 1:44:34 | 1:44:40 | |
employment relationship. Secondly
just to make the point we make | 1:44:40 | 1:44:44 | |
reasonable accommodations in all
sorts of ways for other members's | 1:44:44 | 1:44:48 | |
issues. I do not believe that we
should dial down our parenthood to | 1:44:48 | 1:44:53 | |
be representatives in this place I
think we should amplify it. I think | 1:44:53 | 1:44:56 | |
we should talk about it, we should
normalise it. I think by doing so we | 1:44:56 | 1:45:01 | |
might be able to get to a fairer
society and close the gender pay | 1:45:01 | 1:45:08 | |
gap. We can also approach other
issues in a different lens. I want | 1:45:08 | 1:45:18 | |
to make one final point, Mr Deputy
Speaker, it is actually a procedural | 1:45:18 | 1:45:22 | |
one. At the moment, the procedures
invest to make exist that we work | 1:45:22 | 1:45:29 | |
with the whips office in my case two
weeks after the birth of my | 1:45:29 | 1:45:38 | |
daughter, you know longer. -- longer
amounts of time. I just want to say | 1:45:38 | 1:45:47 | |
that our pairing arrangements we
know that there are some members who | 1:45:47 | 1:45:55 | |
are not going to be around for a lot
of time. For example, select | 1:45:55 | 1:46:02 | |
committee visit which cannot go
ahead because we have already pared | 1:46:02 | 1:46:06 | |
out what we can do on the basis of
illness or on the basis of child | 1:46:06 | 1:46:10 | |
care. I, myself, have never, it is
not a brag, I have never made a | 1:46:10 | 1:46:16 | |
request to be let off the whip for
personal circumstances. I've | 1:46:16 | 1:46:19 | |
actually never missed a vote because
I've been ill, I've always been | 1:46:19 | 1:46:25 | |
present. I do not think people abuse
that system, but there are | 1:46:25 | 1:46:29 | |
restrictions that are put in place
and I do not actually believe this | 1:46:29 | 1:46:31 | |
would take power away or give power
to the whips offices. Whenever | 1:46:31 | 1:46:37 | |
you're particular... It were
actually professionalize it and make | 1:46:37 | 1:46:43 | |
it much easier. In my own party
standing orders requiring me if I | 1:46:43 | 1:46:52 | |
were to take paternity leave for
example, baby care, to sign over my | 1:46:52 | 1:46:59 | |
proxy vote to the Chiefs. I am
comfortable with that. There are | 1:46:59 | 1:47:03 | |
ways around this. This should not be
something that should be... Overall, | 1:47:03 | 1:47:09 | |
this is a change which is required.
It is a change that will have a | 1:47:09 | 1:47:13 | |
profound impact on how we work here.
It is the T one to -- thin end of | 1:47:13 | 1:47:20 | |
the wedge. We need to become better
at looking after ourselves on the | 1:47:20 | 1:47:27 | |
basis that we don't want to put
unnecessary strain. This job should | 1:47:27 | 1:47:33 | |
be hard. Public leadership and
sacrifice should be that | 1:47:33 | 1:47:36 | |
sacrificial. Putting in place
artificial barriers will not just | 1:47:36 | 1:47:41 | |
hold that women in this place, but
met as well. It is a pleasure to | 1:47:41 | 1:47:47 | |
speak in this debate. Because I'm
leaving for the S&P, my name had to | 1:47:47 | 1:47:57 | |
come off the motion. I pay a tribute
to the honourable Lady for ringing | 1:47:57 | 1:48:04 | |
this debate. They are two women in
this place that I hold in highest | 1:48:04 | 1:48:10 | |
regard. I think that the debate
today has been completely consensual | 1:48:10 | 1:48:14 | |
as it should be on this issue. Not
just in this place, but across | 1:48:14 | 1:48:18 | |
society. I moved to say the words
we're here not in our efforts to be | 1:48:18 | 1:48:26 | |
lawbreakers, but in our efforts to
be to get to speak today and to be | 1:48:26 | 1:48:31 | |
part of what hopefully will come
forward is very important weird | 1:48:31 | 1:48:41 | |
because as the owner member said you
know we have to reflect society but | 1:48:41 | 1:48:50 | |
we also have to lead society. And I
think 100 years on from women | 1:48:50 | 1:48:54 | |
getting the vote that is hugely
important. When I was thinking about | 1:48:54 | 1:48:59 | |
standing for election, it was
something I thought very carefully | 1:48:59 | 1:49:01 | |
about whether I could do for two
reasons. One, I knew I needed to | 1:49:01 | 1:49:06 | |
come out and do with my sexuality
and secondly I wanted to have | 1:49:06 | 1:49:09 | |
children. -- deal with my sexuality.
Nonetheless regardless of that being | 1:49:09 | 1:49:24 | |
able to know that there are members
across this place that support this | 1:49:24 | 1:49:28 | |
process means that hopefully the
next generation of parliamentarians, | 1:49:28 | 1:49:33 | |
whether they are male, female
whenever disability, whatever their | 1:49:33 | 1:49:38 | |
sexuality is, they will look at this
place and other Parliaments across | 1:49:38 | 1:49:41 | |
the UK and think that is something
that I can and want to be a part of. | 1:49:41 | 1:49:47 | |
I think it has been an incredible
debate. As we look across the world, | 1:49:47 | 1:49:52 | |
we have the Prime Minister of New
Zealand who was about to have a baby | 1:49:52 | 1:49:58 | |
with her partner. We are taking
steps forward and the testimonies | 1:49:58 | 1:50:04 | |
that were read out mentioned. I
would also like to refer to my | 1:50:04 | 1:50:17 | |
honourable friend from Glasgow
Central who got an interesting | 1:50:17 | 1:50:23 | |
e-mail during the 2015 election. I'm
just going to read out the question | 1:50:23 | 1:50:28 | |
and the answer because I think it
typifies the debate. It just shows | 1:50:28 | 1:50:34 | |
how far we have to go. Dear Alison,
I am in favour in the back of many | 1:50:34 | 1:50:41 | |
of the S&P's Parliament to make
policies. But I am very worried to | 1:50:41 | 1:50:47 | |
find out that you are a mother of a
very young family. It would help to | 1:50:47 | 1:50:54 | |
know your solution... Your solution
peer to me it is quite incredible | 1:50:54 | 1:51:01 | |
that anybody would write to a
potential candidate and saying that | 1:51:01 | 1:51:05 | |
the fact that -- having children
would be a problem. It is spoken | 1:51:05 | 1:51:18 | |
that we let me read you the
response. Thank you very much for | 1:51:18 | 1:51:27 | |
your e-mail. I apologise for the
delayed playback late reply. I am | 1:51:27 | 1:51:37 | |
not alone amongst male and female
candidates who have been lucky | 1:51:37 | 1:51:41 | |
enough to have a family. Indeed, the
mail Parliament member has a family. | 1:51:41 | 1:51:50 | |
The average age of MP were 50, more
than 62% of the MPs are white men | 1:51:50 | 1:51:57 | |
aged over 40, I think Westminster
out to be more representative of the | 1:51:57 | 1:52:04 | |
people it serves without more women.
Inequality affects policy and | 1:52:04 | 1:52:08 | |
governance. I believe with the poor
gender balance they have made poor | 1:52:08 | 1:52:18 | |
decisions in things with families.
Making the law the right to | 1:52:18 | 1:52:33 | |
breast-feed. Over the last five
years... She goes on to talk about | 1:52:33 | 1:52:36 | |
being a councillor. There was
another person who is a councillor | 1:52:36 | 1:52:45 | |
in Aberdeen with very small
children. I will cross whatever | 1:52:45 | 1:52:48 | |
other bridges are necessary when the
votes are cast. I think I is an | 1:52:48 | 1:52:54 | |
excellent response. I thank you for
giving way. I welcome the | 1:52:54 | 1:53:02 | |
contributions that making. She is
talking about what candidates might | 1:53:02 | 1:53:11 | |
face when they are a new parent. I
want to reflect on the abuse that I | 1:53:11 | 1:53:17 | |
received. This person took to
Twitter to criticise me for not | 1:53:17 | 1:53:24 | |
attending a debate in the evening.
He accused me of being timid for my | 1:53:24 | 1:53:29 | |
refusal to attend an election
debate. And I told that candidate | 1:53:29 | 1:53:33 | |
that I did not refuse to do any
debates, but with a newborn baby, | 1:53:33 | 1:53:38 | |
evening events would be impossible
and that I would gladly take on any | 1:53:38 | 1:53:42 | |
day. He responded to say that he
didn't realise that we were still | 1:53:42 | 1:53:46 | |
1950s when only a woman can look
after a child. He said he thought | 1:53:46 | 1:53:51 | |
the Labour Party believed in shared
paternity. And I told him that we do | 1:53:51 | 1:53:57 | |
and we champion it. To remind him
that I wasn't expecting a general | 1:53:57 | 1:54:06 | |
election and also he didn't know my
personal circumstances and that as | 1:54:06 | 1:54:09 | |
far as I was aware men still could
not breast-feed. I suggested that he | 1:54:09 | 1:54:15 | |
might want to stop digging. But I
wanted to share this because the | 1:54:15 | 1:54:24 | |
point that the honourable member
makes at what happens at election | 1:54:24 | 1:54:28 | |
time and how candidates treat other
candidate shows back in 2017 we | 1:54:28 | 1:54:32 | |
still have an issue to address. I
completely agree. This vote on this | 1:54:32 | 1:54:40 | |
issue is just not about a
technicality of how we cast our | 1:54:40 | 1:54:43 | |
votes. It is very important and my
honourable friend has highlighted to | 1:54:43 | 1:54:50 | |
me the importance the thin end of
the wedge and I agree on that. It is | 1:54:50 | 1:54:58 | |
proximity. Also with weather and
geography. It's about the discourse | 1:54:58 | 1:55:07 | |
and the narrative that we have in
politics with each other, that the | 1:55:07 | 1:55:10 | |
press has with us. And the digital
environment how all the systems and | 1:55:10 | 1:55:20 | |
processes that are around politics
and around how we do politics need | 1:55:20 | 1:55:24 | |
to be more transparent, need to be
more reflective. If we have the | 1:55:24 | 1:55:28 | |
positive system then it will be much
more positive. I just want to prefer | 1:55:28 | 1:55:37 | |
briefly and paid tribute to my
honourable friend in the Scottish | 1:55:37 | 1:55:45 | |
Parliament, and a gender balance
Cabinet secretaries. They have had | 1:55:45 | 1:55:51 | |
children in office and they for me
have paved the way inspired me to | 1:55:51 | 1:55:57 | |
stand. But the Scottish Parliament
made clear from the outset. It was | 1:55:57 | 1:56:06 | |
said there is a seed for everyone.
Voting only takes a few seconds. And | 1:56:06 | 1:56:11 | |
in the best practises phase things
were drawn up to make sure that we | 1:56:11 | 1:56:22 | |
can learn from our mistakes. We have
a crush in the Scottish Parliament. | 1:56:22 | 1:56:35 | |
We have child care in the Scottish
permit. Some of the challenges of | 1:56:35 | 1:56:47 | |
bringing children to this place
where the family room is sometimes | 1:56:47 | 1:56:50 | |
misused by other members or for
meetings. He has had a great deal of | 1:56:50 | 1:56:56 | |
support in that, but we do need to
look at that as well. And there are | 1:56:56 | 1:57:03 | |
many inclusive practises how
business is done, so finishing at | 1:57:03 | 1:57:09 | |
five o'clock. I do not want to talk
too much about it. The Other Place I | 1:57:09 | 1:57:12 | |
want to focus. My honourable friend
from Aberdeen North talks about how | 1:57:12 | 1:57:20 | |
she travels to Westminster biplane.
And most don't let people 36 weeks | 1:57:20 | 1:57:28 | |
pregnant fly. Also after having a
baby you cannot fly for a week | 1:57:28 | 1:57:33 | |
probably more like a fortnight. So,
if she had a baby and she did say | 1:57:33 | 1:57:41 | |
that she did not have any intentions
of having more, she may have put | 1:57:41 | 1:57:50 | |
women off having children. I have to
say I remain undeterred. She says | 1:57:50 | 1:57:56 | |
being away from Westminster. Because
she could not travel gear would be | 1:57:56 | 1:58:00 | |
very unfair to her constituents and
would mean they would be | 1:58:00 | 1:58:02 | |
unrepresented. | 1:58:02 | 1:58:12 | |
He has fantastic staff ensuring
everything was covered in the | 1:58:12 | 1:58:16 | |
constituency but these matters need
to be formalised. It seems | 1:58:16 | 1:58:21 | |
incredible that 100 years after
women got the vote, we are debating | 1:58:21 | 1:58:25 | |
the fact they cannot take part fully
for their constituents and fully in | 1:58:25 | 1:58:30 | |
debates. We know Parliamentary work
is not just about walking through | 1:58:30 | 1:58:34 | |
the voting lobbies, it is about
being in your constituency, but | 1:58:34 | 1:58:37 | |
having an open Parliament will make
sure that people from whatever walk | 1:58:37 | 1:58:43 | |
of life, particularly women and
aspiring parents and parents, they | 1:58:43 | 1:58:49 | |
will think they can be part of
democracy, stand for election, and | 1:58:49 | 1:58:54 | |
it will make those women
particularly who are going to have | 1:58:54 | 1:58:59 | |
children very soon,
parliamentarians, it will make their | 1:58:59 | 1:59:02 | |
lives significantly easier. I hope
the House and the public are | 1:59:02 | 1:59:05 | |
listening carefully to the testimony
from today. Thank you. Can I | 1:59:05 | 1:59:11 | |
associate myself with the remarks
made by my noble friend for Luton | 1:59:11 | 1:59:14 | |
South? Good to see you in your
place. I say to the honourable | 1:59:14 | 1:59:18 | |
friend from Luton South, that is
what a feminist looks like. Can I | 1:59:18 | 1:59:22 | |
thank the right honourable a --
right honourable lady? She was a | 1:59:22 | 1:59:32 | |
formidable role model when she was
pregnant and stood in the election, | 1:59:32 | 1:59:35 | |
I think it was Harry at the time, it
is fitting that mother of the house | 1:59:35 | 1:59:41 | |
should bring forward this debate and
it is right for members to debate | 1:59:41 | 1:59:44 | |
this and for the backbench committee
to have allowed this debate. The | 1:59:44 | 1:59:49 | |
honourable member for Basingstoke is
always, as co-sponsor of this | 1:59:49 | 1:59:54 | |
debate, raising important equality
issues on her committee and I am | 1:59:54 | 1:59:59 | |
sure she will monitor, together with
other members, what the procedure | 1:59:59 | 2:00:06 | |
committee comes up with. Honourable
members will remember when the | 2:00:06 | 2:00:11 | |
former Prime Minister and the Deputy
Prime Minister took paternity leave, | 2:00:11 | 2:00:14 | |
they were celebrated, but as the
honourable members for Liverpool, | 2:00:14 | 2:00:20 | |
Wolverhampton North East, when they
have been maternity leave, they have | 2:00:20 | 2:00:24 | |
suffered abuse. The honourable
member, she was a minister, | 2:00:24 | 2:00:32 | |
surrounded by gurgles and red boxes,
they are all formidable campaigners. | 2:00:32 | 2:00:38 | |
The fat women have suffered abuse
and accusations of being lazy is | 2:00:38 | 2:00:43 | |
unacceptable -- the fact that women
have suffered abuse. We want women | 2:00:43 | 2:00:50 | |
to be Members of Parliament, there
are no implications for play, women | 2:00:50 | 2:00:54 | |
are not away, they want to cast
their vote on behalf of their | 2:00:54 | 2:00:57 | |
constituents -- implications for
pay. It is right we should look at | 2:00:57 | 2:01:02 | |
this, the edition of nodding through
in certain circumstances. Ophelia is | 2:01:02 | 2:01:10 | |
lucky to have a hands-on band, in
the constituency member Bristol | 2:01:10 | 2:01:14 | |
West. It is not compulsory to
request this, but in my view, it is | 2:01:14 | 2:01:20 | |
a compelling case. Proxy voting will
have to be in line with party policy | 2:01:20 | 2:01:24 | |
and proxy voting does not equate to
a free vote. This motion does not | 2:01:24 | 2:01:30 | |
ask to widen proxy voting to other
circumstances, just this specific | 2:01:30 | 2:01:35 | |
one where the member cannot attend
the vote because of caring | 2:01:35 | 2:01:38 | |
responsibilities. All this motion
does is enable women MPs to balance | 2:01:38 | 2:01:43 | |
giving birth, looking after a baby,
with their work as an MP, and all my | 2:01:43 | 2:01:48 | |
honourable friends who have given
birth while they have been MPs have | 2:01:48 | 2:01:51 | |
carried on with their work in the
constituency and in the house and as | 2:01:51 | 2:01:59 | |
honourable members have pointed out,
they know in the 21st-century they | 2:01:59 | 2:02:02 | |
have to respond to e-mails and they
do so all the time. The honourable | 2:02:02 | 2:02:08 | |
member from Birmingham Yardley, she
says she doesn't want to have any | 2:02:08 | 2:02:11 | |
more children, but I want to break
it to her, she will be a month | 2:02:11 | 2:02:15 | |
forever, even when are older, and
they have children of their own. -- | 2:02:15 | 2:02:21 | |
a mum for ever. The clerk of the
house we submitted a memorandum on | 2:02:21 | 2:02:29 | |
proxy voting identify members with
caring responsibilities limited to | 2:02:29 | 2:02:32 | |
mothers of young infants as a
category of member who might qualify | 2:02:32 | 2:02:36 | |
for proxy voting. The honourable
member is right that matters should | 2:02:36 | 2:02:39 | |
be looked at by the appropriate
committee, the honourable member for | 2:02:39 | 2:02:44 | |
Peckham and Camberwell, and more
work should be done following the | 2:02:44 | 2:02:48 | |
motion together with their work by
Sarah Charles and her report. It is | 2:02:48 | 2:02:52 | |
going to be more of an issue as
women members take their place and | 2:02:52 | 2:02:56 | |
we move towards parity of MPs. And
it is a lovely way to celebrate the | 2:02:56 | 2:03:02 | |
representation of the people act
1918 giving 6 million women the | 2:03:02 | 2:03:06 | |
right over the age of 30, first, the
right to vote and debating this | 2:03:06 | 2:03:12 | |
issue as women take our rightful
place in the House. The honourable | 2:03:12 | 2:03:17 | |
member for Camberwell and Peckham
and Basingstoke, co-sponsors, all | 2:03:17 | 2:03:23 | |
the members speaking in the debate,
they are wonderful role models, | 2:03:23 | 2:03:27 | |
Ophelia, Emilio, Theo and Ruby, the
wonderful babies born to members in | 2:03:27 | 2:03:34 | |
the time I have been in the house,
your parents and every single | 2:03:34 | 2:03:38 | |
honourable member has pushed back
the boundaries today towards a good | 2:03:38 | 2:03:42 | |
and more equal Parliament. Thank
you, Mr Deputy Speaker. Can I say | 2:03:42 | 2:03:52 | |
what a huge pleasure it is to see
you in your place today? There have | 2:03:52 | 2:03:56 | |
been some excellent and very
personal speeches and I think they | 2:03:56 | 2:04:01 | |
have been so informative and they
take me back to the horrors of those | 2:04:01 | 2:04:06 | |
early days and also, Mr Deputy
Speaker, I have to reflect that | 2:04:06 | 2:04:10 | |
following the debate yesterday where
I opened by saying this is a debate | 2:04:10 | 2:04:12 | |
that should have taken place 40
years ago, this is a debate that | 2:04:12 | 2:04:17 | |
should have taken place 40 years ago
too. Let me start by paying tribute | 2:04:17 | 2:04:22 | |
to the right honourable member for
Camberwell and Peckham for the way | 2:04:22 | 2:04:25 | |
in which she opened today's debate,
a consistent champion of these | 2:04:25 | 2:04:29 | |
issues throughout her career and it
is certainly fitting she is mother | 2:04:29 | 2:04:34 | |
of the House has secured this debate
today. I want to recognise the total | 2:04:34 | 2:04:45 | |
commitment of my right honourable
friend for Basingstoke as chairman | 2:04:45 | 2:04:47 | |
of the women and equality select
committee who has supported and | 2:04:47 | 2:04:50 | |
promoted so many issues affecting
women and equality is in this house. | 2:04:50 | 2:04:52 | |
I absolutely agree with all members
here that it is essential we address | 2:04:52 | 2:04:58 | |
and deal with the issue of baby
leaves. Mr Deputy Speaker, the | 2:04:58 | 2:05:03 | |
motion before the House today
presents two issues for | 2:05:03 | 2:05:07 | |
consideration, the first is the need
for Members of Parliament to be able | 2:05:07 | 2:05:10 | |
to take baby leave, I think we can
all agree new parents must spend | 2:05:10 | 2:05:14 | |
time with their babies, they must be
enabled to do that. The second issue | 2:05:14 | 2:05:20 | |
concerns how we reconcile this with
the question of how and whether | 2:05:20 | 2:05:24 | |
members should be able to vote in
the House of Commons during any such | 2:05:24 | 2:05:28 | |
leave. I want to thank the all-party
Parliamentary group for women, until | 2:05:28 | 2:05:34 | |
recently chaired by my honourable
friend for Eastleigh and now by my | 2:05:34 | 2:05:37 | |
honourable friend for Redditch for
their hard work promoting equality | 2:05:37 | 2:05:42 | |
for women and also the Commons
reference group on representation | 2:05:42 | 2:05:45 | |
and inclusion which is chaired by Mr
Speaker and it is tasked with | 2:05:45 | 2:05:50 | |
following and implementing where
possible the recommendations made in | 2:05:50 | 2:05:58 | |
the Good Parliament report. I want
to say thanks for the important work | 2:05:58 | 2:06:02 | |
of these groups. As the House may be
aware, I have championed the vital | 2:06:02 | 2:06:07 | |
importance of secure early
attachment for many years and I have | 2:06:07 | 2:06:10 | |
worked with a number of charities on
this vital issue and I was chairman | 2:06:10 | 2:06:14 | |
and trustee of a charity than nine
years, helping parents who are | 2:06:14 | 2:06:18 | |
struggling to form a secure bond
with their babies. When I became MP | 2:06:18 | 2:06:23 | |
for South Northamptonshire, I set up
a Northamptonshire parent and infant | 2:06:23 | 2:06:27 | |
partnership to provide help to all
those new parents struggling across | 2:06:27 | 2:06:32 | |
the county and even persuaded my
honourable friend, the member for | 2:06:32 | 2:06:36 | |
Banbury, to become a founding
trustee. Now through the national | 2:06:36 | 2:06:41 | |
charity I set up, there are five
further parenting for partnerships | 2:06:41 | 2:06:45 | |
across the country and I am
delighted more families are unable | 2:06:45 | 2:06:49 | |
to seek support for the earliest
relationships which is probably the | 2:06:49 | 2:06:53 | |
most important relationship we ever
have because the baby's lifelong | 2:06:53 | 2:06:59 | |
emotional health is profoundly
impacted by his or her earliest | 2:06:59 | 2:07:06 | |
experiences in the 1001 critical
days of the perinatal period and I | 2:07:06 | 2:07:11 | |
was proud to hear the honourable
lady, the member for Liverpool way | 2:07:11 | 2:07:16 | |
victory, mention the cross-party
1001 critical days campaign is set | 2:07:16 | 2:07:20 | |
up in 2011 and it does command
support from across the House. I | 2:07:20 | 2:07:26 | |
absolutely agree that the mental
health white paper published just | 2:07:26 | 2:07:33 | |
before Christmas does include the
need to commission further research | 2:07:33 | 2:07:37 | |
into interventions that support
better attachment and improve the | 2:07:37 | 2:07:40 | |
understanding amongst professionals
of the importance of low stress, | 2:07:40 | 2:07:46 | |
healthy pregnancies and secure
attachment. Like the two right | 2:07:46 | 2:07:51 | |
honourable ladies, my own children
are a bit older than babies, my | 2:07:51 | 2:07:55 | |
eldest is 22, but that excellent
speeches take me back to my early | 2:07:55 | 2:07:59 | |
experiences when I was not in this
place and I had a 46 hour delivery, | 2:07:59 | 2:08:04 | |
I think, and a good dose, having
just been promoted to a senior | 2:08:04 | 2:08:08 | |
executive in the bank I was working
in, they required me back after 11 | 2:08:08 | 2:08:12 | |
weeks. I had a good dose of
postnatal depression to deal with | 2:08:12 | 2:08:16 | |
following that. I totally empathise
with all of those members who talk | 2:08:16 | 2:08:21 | |
about their own experiences here and
very committed to ensuring those who | 2:08:21 | 2:08:24 | |
come after us do not have to suffer
those same problems. I would just | 2:08:24 | 2:08:28 | |
draw attention to my honourable
friend for Worcester who sat next to | 2:08:28 | 2:08:32 | |
me in the first part of the debate
who was telling me his brother who | 2:08:32 | 2:08:35 | |
works for the civil service is
looking forward to six months shared | 2:08:35 | 2:08:39 | |
parental leave next February and he
himself is expecting a baby with his | 2:08:39 | 2:08:43 | |
wife and he is asking nicely for two
weeks. How is that? Today's debate | 2:08:43 | 2:08:50 | |
is timely. I wonder if she remembers
the first time we met she was | 2:08:50 | 2:08:58 | |
pregnant? A few years ago now. Does
she... We were on the selection | 2:08:58 | 2:09:03 | |
trail as well. Does she agree with
me that this is as important as it | 2:09:03 | 2:09:08 | |
is a first step in trying to make
this place and much easier place to | 2:09:08 | 2:09:15 | |
not just be a parent but actually to
be somebody who cares for their | 2:09:15 | 2:09:19 | |
broader family as well? Of course,
my right honourable friend is | 2:09:19 | 2:09:25 | |
exactly right, there is a lot more
to life than this place. It may seem | 2:09:25 | 2:09:29 | |
extraordinary to all of us but we
are all human beings, we are | 2:09:29 | 2:09:33 | |
parents, daughters and sons, we have
responsibilities. Today's debate is | 2:09:33 | 2:09:37 | |
timely as we continue to break down
the barriers that could discourage | 2:09:37 | 2:09:43 | |
women and men from pursuing a career
in Parliament. The motion today | 2:09:43 | 2:09:49 | |
suggest a way to resolve the issue
of baby leave is with the | 2:09:49 | 2:09:53 | |
introduction of proxy voting, whilst
I absolutely support the need to | 2:09:53 | 2:09:57 | |
make this house more accessible for
new parents, it is also important we | 2:09:57 | 2:10:02 | |
recognise the possible consequences
of any reforms, so with that in | 2:10:02 | 2:10:06 | |
mind, I wrote to my honourable
friend, the member for Broxbourne, | 2:10:06 | 2:10:08 | |
the chair of the procedure committee
in November, copying my right | 2:10:08 | 2:10:13 | |
honourable friend, the chair of the
women and | 2:10:13 | 2:10:26 | |
equality is asked the committee to
consider the matter of baby leave | 2:10:29 | 2:10:31 | |
and proxy voting and for that
committee to set out its views to | 2:10:31 | 2:10:34 | |
the House. I also wrote to every
member of the Cabinet and I can say | 2:10:34 | 2:10:37 | |
that my right honourable friend the
Prime Minister replied to me and | 2:10:37 | 2:10:39 | |
agrees this is an important matter.
She wrote, I quote, being a member | 2:10:39 | 2:10:42 | |
of the and is a demanding job and it
is important we give due | 2:10:42 | 2:10:45 | |
consideration to the impact this can
have on work life balance, childcare | 2:10:45 | 2:10:47 | |
and they believe -- a member of the
in. She has made clear her support. | 2:10:47 | 2:10:50 | |
Following my letter to the procedure
committee, my honourable friend has | 2:10:50 | 2:10:54 | |
said should the motion be agreed
today, the committee will undertake | 2:10:54 | 2:10:58 | |
an inquiry into proxy voting. I
welcome this as it is clear from | 2:10:58 | 2:11:02 | |
this debate there are a number of
important questions that need to be | 2:11:02 | 2:11:06 | |
considered. Some of which I will set
out briefly now. Giving Members of | 2:11:06 | 2:11:10 | |
Parliament the right to baby leave
raises a number of potential | 2:11:10 | 2:11:14 | |
questions around the duties of
Members of Parliament and the rules | 2:11:14 | 2:11:17 | |
by which they are regulated. As
colleagues will know, Members of | 2:11:17 | 2:11:23 | |
Parliament are appointed
representatives of their | 2:11:23 | 2:11:29 | |
constituencies and they are not
regulated by the same employment | 2:11:29 | 2:11:31 | |
rules applying to other members of
the workforce. Introducing baby | 2:11:31 | 2:11:33 | |
leave might lead some to suggest MPs
should be treated as employees which | 2:11:33 | 2:11:37 | |
could have wider implications that
we need to look at. The introduction | 2:11:37 | 2:11:41 | |
of proxy voting would mark a
departure from conventional voting | 2:11:41 | 2:11:46 | |
practices in the House. For example,
when members vote in a division, it | 2:11:46 | 2:11:50 | |
is expected they do so having had
the opportunity to attend the | 2:11:50 | 2:11:53 | |
Chamber. I think we can all agree
that television and 24-hour | 2:11:53 | 2:11:58 | |
reporting, let alone Twitter and
everything else, it gives members | 2:11:58 | 2:12:04 | |
the opportunity to follow business
from further afield, but any change | 2:12:04 | 2:12:07 | |
will need to be carefully
considered, including who would act | 2:12:07 | 2:12:11 | |
as a proxy and how this would be
regulated. It is also important to | 2:12:11 | 2:12:17 | |
note Members of Parliament are
elected by their constituents as | 2:12:17 | 2:12:21 | |
individuals and it is implied upon
election that their votes cannot be | 2:12:21 | 2:12:26 | |
transferred to another empty so
appointing a proxy voter could be | 2:12:26 | 2:12:31 | |
perceived as reducing personal
accountability. Any changes will | 2:12:31 | 2:12:33 | |
need to ensure that personal
accountability is maintained. In | 2:12:33 | 2:12:39 | |
addition to these questions, and as
I said in my letter to the procedure | 2:12:39 | 2:12:43 | |
committee, a number of alternative
suggestions have been made, aimed at | 2:12:43 | 2:12:48 | |
addressing the needs of new parents
undertaking the duties of an MP | 2:12:48 | 2:12:52 | |
while also making sure their
constituents have adequate | 2:12:52 | 2:12:56 | |
representation in parliament. One
such example is that all political | 2:12:56 | 2:13:00 | |
parties represented in the House
could agree a memorandum of | 2:13:00 | 2:13:04 | |
understanding agreeing to the same
terms which would allow their MPs to | 2:13:04 | 2:13:08 | |
take parental leave and to formalise
pairing arrangements across all | 2:13:08 | 2:13:12 | |
parties. I am grateful. I appreciate
the thoughtful way in which she is | 2:13:12 | 2:13:19 | |
approaching this from first
principles and laying out some of | 2:13:19 | 2:13:22 | |
the issues mentioned by other
members. I would just like her to go | 2:13:22 | 2:13:29 | |
slightly further and acknowledge
that there is a reputational issues | 2:13:29 | 2:13:32 | |
around Members of Parliament not
being present to vote and being | 2:13:32 | 2:13:37 | |
reported as being absent when
actually they are taking up | 2:13:37 | 2:13:41 | |
responsibilities she herself has
said a vitally important. | 2:13:41 | 2:13:48 | |
I am not advocating one group over
another. I am merely pointing out to | 2:13:48 | 2:13:53 | |
the House that these issues need
careful consideration, which is why | 2:13:53 | 2:13:56 | |
I wrote to the procedure committee
and why I'm delighted that they will | 2:13:56 | 2:14:02 | |
have an inquiry. In addition, a
helpful memorandum has been created | 2:14:02 | 2:14:09 | |
and is available on the website. I
encourage members to read it. It | 2:14:09 | 2:14:15 | |
talks about very important issues
including other approaches in other | 2:14:15 | 2:14:19 | |
Parliament. Also alluding to our
mediaeval tradition of voting by | 2:14:19 | 2:14:25 | |
proxy. I am sure there were not very
many pregnant women there in those | 2:14:25 | 2:14:29 | |
days, but nevertheless they found a
way. So Mr Deputy Speaker, should an | 2:14:29 | 2:14:35 | |
inquiry be launched, I would inquire
your colleagues to submit their own | 2:14:35 | 2:14:39 | |
views. I have no doubt that the many
insightful contributions made here | 2:14:39 | 2:14:44 | |
will be great value to the
committee. This is an important | 2:14:44 | 2:14:49 | |
debate which has really caught the
attention of Parliament. As Leader | 2:14:49 | 2:14:52 | |
of the House, I want to make it
absolutely clear that if we can | 2:14:52 | 2:14:56 | |
agree on a way forward on they
believe, I will drive that forward | 2:14:56 | 2:15:00 | |
with my total commitment. Thank you.
Thank you very much Mr Deputy | 2:15:00 | 2:15:06 | |
Speaker and I welcome you back to
the chair. It is great to see you | 2:15:06 | 2:15:10 | |
here with us. I think this has been
a really important debate and I | 2:15:10 | 2:15:14 | |
think all members who've contributed
from all sides. People who have | 2:15:14 | 2:15:18 | |
spoken in deeply personal team to
wood terms. They have shown a | 2:15:18 | 2:15:23 | |
passion for their family and their
constituents. Nobody has actually | 2:15:23 | 2:15:29 | |
spoken against it. I think this has
been a very important debate to | 2:15:29 | 2:15:33 | |
shape the proceedings of the
procedure committee. The committee | 2:15:33 | 2:15:38 | |
needs to take it forward with some
focus and with some clarity and wit | 2:15:38 | 2:15:42 | |
some expedition. We do not want
after debate such as we have had to | 2:15:42 | 2:15:47 | |
date for it to go wrestling into the
long grass. That will not be | 2:15:47 | 2:15:51 | |
acceptable. I would like to conclude
by thanking everyone who spoke in | 2:15:51 | 2:15:56 | |
this debate. And say we must all be
in alliance for progress on this. | 2:15:56 | 2:16:00 | |
All of us here must make sure that
this actually happens and does not | 2:16:00 | 2:16:06 | |
disappear for more decades. I'm sure
that we can have that purpose and | 2:16:06 | 2:16:10 | |
intent. I would also like to say,
that I apologise for the fact for | 2:16:10 | 2:16:15 | |
not inking about the situation of
SNP members who don't even have | 2:16:15 | 2:16:20 | |
pairing. I feel sort of embarrassed
about that. I feel as such time, | 2:16:20 | 2:16:27 | |
when the committee comes out how we
do proxy voting, we need to make | 2:16:27 | 2:16:31 | |
some arrangements which reflect the
situation for the S&P right away. | 2:16:31 | 2:16:34 | |
Thank you Mr Speaker. The question
on the order papers are many of that | 2:16:34 | 2:16:41 | |
opinion say ayes. The ayes have it.
We now come to the backbench motion | 2:16:41 | 2:16:53 | |
on Hospital car parking charges.
Thank you. I beg to move that we | 2:16:53 | 2:17:03 | |
move to take consultation to
identify the most effective means | 2:17:03 | 2:17:10 | |
for Hospital parking. And provide a
time step treatment timescale for | 2:17:10 | 2:17:17 | |
the application. I think the bench
batch committee for excepting this | 2:17:17 | 2:17:20 | |
debate. I think my colleagues who
supported me in the debate. | 2:17:20 | 2:17:37 | |
I also think the various
organisations that have been | 2:17:40 | 2:17:46 | |
actively supporting this campaign
through their own research and on | 2:17:46 | 2:17:49 | |
social media. Other organisations
representing drivers. They are just | 2:17:49 | 2:17:59 | |
a few of the bodies were offering
their help and support to bring an | 2:17:59 | 2:18:03 | |
end to the extortion of car park
charging. We all know that being a | 2:18:03 | 2:18:10 | |
patient or visitor can be a
stressful and emotional time. The | 2:18:10 | 2:18:14 | |
last thing anyone should be worrying
about is whether they have change | 2:18:14 | 2:18:17 | |
for the car park or if they can
afford the rates that are charged. I | 2:18:17 | 2:18:22 | |
started this campaign in 2014 after
finding out that hospitals in | 2:18:22 | 2:18:29 | |
England were charging staff and
visitors up to £500 a week to use | 2:18:29 | 2:18:34 | |
on-site parking facilities. As a
result, in that year, we published | 2:18:34 | 2:18:45 | |
guidance urging them to cut their
fees. Caps or cuts should be | 2:18:45 | 2:18:54 | |
available for staff and others.
While some of these charges have | 2:18:54 | 2:19:01 | |
fallen since 2014, I was shocked to
discover that last year when we | 2:19:01 | 2:19:04 | |
carried out further research that
47% of hospitals have actually | 2:19:04 | 2:19:09 | |
increased the parking charges and
almost have charge blue badge people | 2:19:09 | 2:19:16 | |
to park. The average is £53. And
people on average paid £1 98. I'm | 2:19:16 | 2:19:30 | |
grateful for him giving way. And I
congratulate him for bringing this | 2:19:30 | 2:19:35 | |
issue to the House of Commons. It
has been announced with no | 2:19:35 | 2:19:42 | |
consultation, that they air opposing
parking charges on blue badge | 2:19:42 | 2:19:47 | |
holders and a site that people are
doing it everywhere else in the NHS. | 2:19:47 | 2:19:51 | |
It is an NHS wide issue. Does he
therefore not agree with me that it | 2:19:51 | 2:19:58 | |
needs to be looked at to get rid of
Lou badge holders Chargers? Many of | 2:19:58 | 2:20:05 | |
these charges are done without any
consultation or fair consultation. I | 2:20:05 | 2:20:11 | |
completely agree with him. Of
course, because of what the Speaker | 2:20:11 | 2:20:18 | |
said to me, I won't take too many
interruptions. Thank you for giving | 2:20:18 | 2:20:23 | |
way. I agree with the member who
just spoke. A lot of the hospital | 2:20:23 | 2:20:33 | |
charges are part of the PFI. I think
this should be looked at you could | 2:20:33 | 2:20:41 | |
argue it is a tax. That is the sad
thing that many private companies | 2:20:41 | 2:20:48 | |
are making profit out of the
taxpayers. And the most vulnerable | 2:20:48 | 2:20:55 | |
people of our society. This has got
to stop. This has happy to -- | 2:20:55 | 2:21:02 | |
happened under both governments. Now
there is still a lottery with | 2:21:02 | 2:21:16 | |
different hospitals charging wildly
different fees. The goal of the NHS | 2:21:16 | 2:21:22 | |
is to provide free health care for
all, but the charges are a stealth | 2:21:22 | 2:21:26 | |
tax. The parking charges are the
bane of people's lives. No one goes | 2:21:26 | 2:21:32 | |
to hospital out of choice. They go
because they have to. No one chooses | 2:21:32 | 2:21:38 | |
to be ill. You rely on doctors and
nurses to look after us. And I urge | 2:21:38 | 2:21:42 | |
the Health Secretary and the
Minister who was here today to take | 2:21:42 | 2:21:45 | |
urgent action to end this. And to
introduce substantial legislation to | 2:21:45 | 2:21:52 | |
ensure hospitals scrap their parking
charges. Thank you for giving way. | 2:21:52 | 2:21:59 | |
You have been most generous. I have
tremendous sympathy with my | 2:21:59 | 2:22:07 | |
honourable friend in this respect.
And I have campaigned hard on | 2:22:07 | 2:22:11 | |
charges my cell. The one difficulty
that I do have is the fact that my | 2:22:11 | 2:22:16 | |
hospital is located right in the
town centre and the difference we | 2:22:16 | 2:22:18 | |
have is that people use it because
it's free to go off and go shopping | 2:22:18 | 2:22:23 | |
pair that has happened in the past.
I'm just looking for suggestions and | 2:22:23 | 2:22:27 | |
solutions in that area. I am very
proud to work with you on that. What | 2:22:27 | 2:22:36 | |
he said is a very important point
and I hope that you would just wait | 2:22:36 | 2:22:41 | |
a few minutes I hope I will be able
to answer the concerns that he has | 2:22:41 | 2:22:44 | |
expressed. I mentioned Mr Deputy
Speaker, earlier that in 2014 | 2:22:44 | 2:22:52 | |
guidelines on concession for
patients and visitors peered this | 2:22:52 | 2:22:55 | |
was welcome. I welcome it. It was a
sign that the Government was aware | 2:22:55 | 2:22:59 | |
of the extortion costs facing
hospital users. But the problem with | 2:22:59 | 2:23:04 | |
the guidance is that none of that is
mandatory. In fact the guidance | 2:23:04 | 2:23:10 | |
encourages the postcode lottery. The
guideline states that charges should | 2:23:10 | 2:23:12 | |
be reasonable for the area. Trusts
are free to set their own fees. It | 2:23:12 | 2:23:19 | |
means people working in South London
or charge the most. I asked what is | 2:23:19 | 2:23:27 | |
a reasonable charge and I'm
consistently told, first hospital | 2:23:27 | 2:23:34 | |
car parks charges are for local NHS
hospital., they are supposed to | 2:23:34 | 2:23:42 | |
follow published guidance and the
Department of Health has discussed | 2:23:42 | 2:23:49 | |
car park charges with local trusts.
I gave away the last time because I | 2:23:49 | 2:23:55 | |
want to be fair to what the Deputy
Speaker has asked me before the | 2:23:55 | 2:23:58 | |
debate. Thank you. Do you accept
that the national health service is | 2:23:58 | 2:24:07 | |
not best place for ministry in car
parks at all? And that if we take | 2:24:07 | 2:24:11 | |
car parking charges away, we should
also take the whole provision of car | 2:24:11 | 2:24:15 | |
park away from the national health
service and make sure they don't | 2:24:15 | 2:24:19 | |
lose out financially? The crucial
thing is that the NHS does not lose | 2:24:19 | 2:24:26 | |
out financially. I think that is the
substance of what he is saying. The | 2:24:26 | 2:24:30 | |
guidance is that the superficial. I
have been unable to work out what is | 2:24:30 | 2:24:35 | |
a reasonable charge. The Government
isn't able or willing to keep trusts | 2:24:35 | 2:24:40 | |
in check. Since 2013, the campaign
to scrap car park charges has | 2:24:40 | 2:24:50 | |
actually gained speed. Now more and
more leading UK charities in its | 2:24:50 | 2:24:54 | |
associations representing drivers
carrying out research into the | 2:24:54 | 2:24:57 | |
negative effects of this on patients
and drivers. This sick and | 2:24:57 | 2:25:07 | |
vulnerable are disproportionately
hit, particularly those with | 2:25:07 | 2:25:08 | |
long-term or severe illnesses that
require lengthy stays in the | 2:25:08 | 2:25:13 | |
hospital. Research has shown that
cancer patients and patients of | 2:25:13 | 2:25:17 | |
premature babies face the greatest
financial of the glances. There is a | 2:25:17 | 2:25:26 | |
wonderful charity supporting and
people with cancer found that | 2:25:26 | 2:25:30 | |
families were paying about £37 a
month. Some families paying up to | 2:25:30 | 2:25:37 | |
£10 per day. They also say that one
in four parents,, over that, 29%... | 2:25:37 | 2:25:50 | |
The sentiment is mirrored. It is
said that patients in England are | 2:25:50 | 2:25:57 | |
paying extortionist card charges.
There are some babies who only stay | 2:25:57 | 2:26:08 | |
in the neonatal unit for a few days,
some parents have to pay up to £250 | 2:26:08 | 2:26:12 | |
at their babies stays for eight
weeks. And some, they say, many | 2:26:12 | 2:26:17 | |
parents are cannot even afford to go
and see their baby because of the | 2:26:17 | 2:26:24 | |
car park charges. Let me just quote
another charity, which I think sums | 2:26:24 | 2:26:31 | |
up the whole debate. They say
recently, they do a lot of work in | 2:26:31 | 2:26:42 | |
terms of brain injured see to
injury. We support a family that's | 2:26:42 | 2:26:48 | |
been more than £1500 in parking
charges in 15 weeks. They needed to | 2:26:48 | 2:26:53 | |
be at the bedside of their son who
was frightened after sustaining | 2:26:53 | 2:26:57 | |
brain surgery. What parent would not
want to be there day and I? Yet they | 2:26:57 | 2:27:03 | |
were faced with a huge appeal to the
next Bill. This is putting people | 2:27:03 | 2:27:10 | |
into huge debt at a time when they
already have enough to cope with. | 2:27:10 | 2:27:17 | |
Another charity say that dialysis
patients who have to go three times | 2:27:17 | 2:27:20 | |
a week and that takes four hours
suggests that the average cost of | 2:27:20 | 2:27:28 | |
parking for that time is £3 .28. You
can imagine how the costs stack up. | 2:27:28 | 2:27:39 | |
It is extraordinary that despite the
Government guidance almost half the | 2:27:39 | 2:27:45 | |
hospitals charge disabled drivers.
They don't go out of choice. It is | 2:27:45 | 2:27:51 | |
hard for them to use public
transport. Yet they have to pay | 2:27:51 | 2:27:56 | |
significant charges. Even the ones
that allow free parking have a lot | 2:27:56 | 2:27:59 | |
of conditions attached. The scope --
scope, a charity, support the | 2:27:59 | 2:28:09 | |
sentiment. It is not just charities
that do valuable work. The RAC do | 2:28:09 | 2:28:26 | |
support this as well. I have worked
with a person for a number of years | 2:28:26 | 2:28:32 | |
from this organisation. | 2:28:32 | 2:28:45 | |
95% of respondents want hospital
parking fees scrapped or set at a | 2:28:45 | 2:28:52 | |
maximum fee of £1. The RAC carried
out a survey. Two thirds named | 2:28:52 | 2:29:03 | |
hospitals as one of the places they
dislike paying for parking the most. | 2:29:03 | 2:29:08 | |
The campaign is growing. Charities
represent the most vulnerable. Two | 2:29:08 | 2:29:21 | |
main motoring organisations
representing motorists in the UK. We | 2:29:21 | 2:29:29 | |
must not forget our incredibly
hard-working NHS staff. Some of whom | 2:29:29 | 2:29:33 | |
are charged to go to work. Other
public sector workers, police | 2:29:33 | 2:29:38 | |
officers and teachers are right with
the most part able to park for free | 2:29:38 | 2:29:43 | |
on their premises, whether it is a
police station or school. The | 2:29:43 | 2:29:51 | |
guidance from the government
suggests concessions should be | 2:29:51 | 2:29:52 | |
available for all hospital staff
working shifts that make public | 2:29:52 | 2:29:58 | |
transport use difficult. But so much
of the USDAW workforce cannot reply | 2:29:58 | 2:30:07 | |
on public transport to get to work.
Hospital porter would have to spend | 2:30:07 | 2:30:19 | |
over an hour on two buses to get to
work. Many work anti-social hours in | 2:30:19 | 2:30:27 | |
the health service. We have no
choice but to use hospital car | 2:30:27 | 2:30:30 | |
parks. Of hospitals seem to offer
discounted parking scheme based on | 2:30:30 | 2:30:36 | |
pay band or salary, or by allocating
a limited number of discounted staff | 2:30:36 | 2:30:43 | |
spaces, NHS staff are charged to
work anti-social hours. My noble | 2:30:43 | 2:30:51 | |
friend was told that they cannot
afford the parking charges of the | 2:30:51 | 2:30:59 | |
half to park on nearby unlit streets
which leaves them vulnerable. I was | 2:30:59 | 2:31:08 | |
contacted recently by a resident who
was delighted to hear of the | 2:31:08 | 2:31:13 | |
campaign but came from a different
angle. Southpark in the residential | 2:31:13 | 2:31:16 | |
roads around hospital to avoid being
charged to go to work. The influx of | 2:31:16 | 2:31:24 | |
cars everyday game in their
driveways are blocked, there is more | 2:31:24 | 2:31:27 | |
traffic on the road and residents
are only able to go about their | 2:31:27 | 2:31:32 | |
daily business. I realise that
hospital parking charges can be a | 2:31:32 | 2:31:36 | |
source of income for hospitals.
They're certainly a gold mine for | 2:31:36 | 2:31:40 | |
some private companies. But the
government has previously stated, | 2:31:40 | 2:31:44 | |
and I quote, providing free parking
at NHS hospitals would result in 200 | 2:31:44 | 2:31:51 | |
million per year taken from clinical
care budgets to make up the | 2:31:51 | 2:31:56 | |
shortfall. When considered in terms
of the 120 billion plus to be spent | 2:31:56 | 2:32:04 | |
in the running of the NHS, that 200
million figure is to be put in | 2:32:04 | 2:32:10 | |
perspective. And going on the
assumption that free hospital | 2:32:10 | 2:32:13 | |
parking would cost 200 million per
year, I think there are a number of | 2:32:13 | 2:32:18 | |
funding options which would mean
hospitals were not left out of | 2:32:18 | 2:32:21 | |
pocket and clinical care budgets
were not affected. The government | 2:32:21 | 2:32:27 | |
have said that with better
procurement in the NHS they would | 2:32:27 | 2:32:32 | |
bring in over 1 billion per year,
and I just asking for 200 million | 2:32:32 | 2:32:36 | |
from that. The Department of Health
financial accounts for 2016 suggests | 2:32:36 | 2:32:44 | |
they underspent their revenue budget
by 0.5%. Could some of that money | 2:32:44 | 2:32:52 | |
not go towards covering parking
costs for patients and staff? It | 2:32:52 | 2:32:56 | |
might be time to look at other areas
of government where we spend a | 2:32:56 | 2:33:00 | |
significant amount of money and
perhaps look at reallocating a very | 2:33:00 | 2:33:04 | |
small amount of that money. The 200
million of the take in order to | 2:33:04 | 2:33:11 | |
scrap hospital car parking charges.
Another concern is that free parking | 2:33:11 | 2:33:18 | |
in hospitals would be exploited by
shoppers. This could be easily | 2:33:18 | 2:33:24 | |
solved using parking tokens
validated by ward staff. Some NHS | 2:33:24 | 2:33:30 | |
hospitals in England provide free
parking, including the | 2:33:30 | 2:33:36 | |
Northamptonshire NHS Trusts and the
Leicestershire partnership trust. It | 2:33:36 | 2:33:40 | |
shows it is possible to deliver free
parking for patients, visitors and | 2:33:40 | 2:33:46 | |
staff, and discourage abuse of the
system with tokens are barriers. | 2:33:46 | 2:33:50 | |
Having contacted hospitals in
Scotland and Wales directly, I know | 2:33:50 | 2:33:55 | |
there are numerous parking solutions
in order to ensure that free parking | 2:33:55 | 2:34:00 | |
is not exploited. Alongside the
abolition of hospital car parking | 2:34:00 | 2:34:04 | |
charges, a system could be
introduced whereby the ticket or | 2:34:04 | 2:34:09 | |
presented to staff at the beginning
and is validated at the end. In | 2:34:09 | 2:34:18 | |
conclusion, because I see the look.
It is time to end the hospital car | 2:34:18 | 2:34:29 | |
parking problems once and for all.
The NHS is supposed to be free at | 2:34:29 | 2:34:33 | |
the point of access. It was never
envisaged that people with cars | 2:34:33 | 2:34:37 | |
would have to pay on top of taxation
for the National Health Service. | 2:34:37 | 2:34:42 | |
Instead, patients and staff are
charged access for vital services. | 2:34:42 | 2:34:49 | |
Patients with sick children,
patients suffering from long-term | 2:34:49 | 2:34:56 | |
illnesses. The cause of major social
injustice and clearly the government | 2:34:56 | 2:35:01 | |
guidance is not working. I urge the
government to look into the most | 2:35:01 | 2:35:04 | |
efficient way to scrap hospital car
parking charges and bring an end to | 2:35:04 | 2:35:09 | |
the stealth tax on drivers once and
for all. Can I bring in an eight | 2:35:09 | 2:35:17 | |
minute limit? Thank you. I'm very
grateful to be part of this | 2:35:17 | 2:35:24 | |
important debate and I congratulate
the Member for Havel and others. The | 2:35:24 | 2:35:38 | |
Diana Princess of Wales Hospital
site in Great Grimsby provides a | 2:35:38 | 2:35:41 | |
whole range of health and well-being
services. Everything from A&E to | 2:35:41 | 2:35:48 | |
child development, mercenary, eating
disorder unit and health education | 2:35:48 | 2:35:54 | |
spaces. The site covers such a huge
range of different services that | 2:35:54 | 2:35:59 | |
deliver to a very wide community. As
part of this debate, there are two | 2:35:59 | 2:36:05 | |
main areas I want to try and
address. The first is the | 2:36:05 | 2:36:08 | |
difficulties for patients and the
challenges of ever-increasing | 2:36:08 | 2:36:12 | |
parking tariffs, and also the issues
for staff around car parking, which | 2:36:12 | 2:36:16 | |
has been raised with me on a number
of occasions. In Grimsby, I know I | 2:36:16 | 2:36:23 | |
can go and park in the Iceland car
park for £1 per hour in the centre | 2:36:23 | 2:36:28 | |
of our town. If I need to park for
over two hours, I might park in the | 2:36:28 | 2:36:35 | |
multistorey and I might pay £3 50
for the privilege of four hours | 2:36:35 | 2:36:40 | |
parking. Having worked in places
like Yorkie, I know I should be | 2:36:40 | 2:36:43 | |
grateful for the seemingly small
amounts that it costs to park in the | 2:36:43 | 2:36:49 | |
centre of our town, but when these
smaller amounts are set against what | 2:36:49 | 2:36:53 | |
people are expected to be in
hospital parking charges, it feels | 2:36:53 | 2:36:58 | |
very much to my constituents that
the NHS is over inflating the | 2:36:58 | 2:37:03 | |
expense and adding an unnecessary
burden to patients and families. Its | 2:37:03 | 2:37:07 | |
recently increased to £2 ten for one
hour's parking at the Diana Princess | 2:37:07 | 2:37:13 | |
of Wales Hospital. Double what it is
in the centre of town. On a good | 2:37:13 | 2:37:25 | |
day, it might take just a few
minutes to collect a prescription. | 2:37:25 | 2:37:29 | |
On top of those costs, I'm paying
another £2 ten to collect my | 2:37:29 | 2:37:40 | |
prescription. Last week I went in to
get a blood test. This is not to | 2:37:40 | 2:37:52 | |
bemoan the cost to my personal
pocket. I know I can afford this, | 2:37:52 | 2:37:56 | |
but there are many and my
constituency who cannot. It is | 2:37:56 | 2:38:01 | |
prohibitive. And happy to give way.
I thank my noble friend for giving | 2:38:01 | 2:38:06 | |
way. Does she agree with me that the
example she races shows the | 2:38:06 | 2:38:16 | |
opportunity for greater flexibility.
Some leisure centres have free | 2:38:16 | 2:38:26 | |
parking for half an hour.
Recognising the need to be | 2:38:26 | 2:38:30 | |
proportionate. She raises an
important point. There is room for | 2:38:30 | 2:38:37 | |
flexibility and all trusts should be
looking at what they can do to make | 2:38:37 | 2:38:40 | |
parking less prohibitive for people
and not put them all. It is galling | 2:38:40 | 2:38:44 | |
for my constituents to know that in
other parts of town the parking fees | 2:38:44 | 2:38:49 | |
are lower, and they all have the
issue of maintenance and lighting | 2:38:49 | 2:38:56 | |
but are still not charging the high
rate, so does feel like profiteering | 2:38:56 | 2:39:00 | |
off the back of people have no
choice but to be at hospital for | 2:39:00 | 2:39:05 | |
themselves, friends or relatives.
There are concessions the trust | 2:39:05 | 2:39:09 | |
offers. Lower costs for blue badge
holders, although not exempt | 2:39:09 | 2:39:13 | |
charges. Parent staying overnight
with Pirelli children or those | 2:39:13 | 2:39:17 | |
having cancer treatment. When the
justification for charging is it | 2:39:17 | 2:39:26 | |
pays for the maintenance of the
site, it doesn't seem to stack up | 2:39:26 | 2:39:32 | |
compared to other parking sites. We
have recently had the new automated | 2:39:32 | 2:39:35 | |
numberplate recognition system
installed. This led to even more | 2:39:35 | 2:39:42 | |
frustration for constituents because
while this fantastic new system was | 2:39:42 | 2:39:47 | |
supposed to make things quicker and
easier, all it did was cause an | 2:39:47 | 2:39:52 | |
additional delays and cost for
people because people try to pay | 2:39:52 | 2:39:58 | |
further parking and it caused havoc.
There were cheers going around the | 2:39:58 | 2:40:04 | |
block with people tripping over into
the next pay band and paying even | 2:40:04 | 2:40:09 | |
more. It caused an extraordinary
amount of frustration and reflected | 2:40:09 | 2:40:14 | |
very pearly on the trust, which is a
real shame. The knock-on effect of | 2:40:14 | 2:40:21 | |
the charges as I think the
surrounding streets, all residential | 2:40:21 | 2:40:27 | |
streets with limited on street
parking, get filled with cars of | 2:40:27 | 2:40:36 | |
those attending hospital. I know
there is nothing illegal about that. | 2:40:36 | 2:40:41 | |
But it really irritates residents,
if it crosses a dropped curb or | 2:40:41 | 2:40:48 | |
impinges on people's driveways, it
is an incredible frustration, and is | 2:40:48 | 2:40:52 | |
also giving rise to increasing
concerns about road safety, | 2:40:52 | 2:40:58 | |
particularly around school hours. A
broader point is that we now that | 2:40:58 | 2:41:03 | |
people with disabilities or
long-term illnesses are generally | 2:41:03 | 2:41:09 | |
financially worse off than the rest
of the population. That additional | 2:41:09 | 2:41:17 | |
costs really represents significant
inconvenience and potential hardship | 2:41:17 | 2:41:20 | |
put on people who can least afford
it. Briefly, turning to the issues | 2:41:20 | 2:41:24 | |
that staff face because it has been
an increasing issue that staff have | 2:41:24 | 2:41:28 | |
been talking to me about,
particularly on this side, there | 2:41:28 | 2:41:33 | |
have been discussions with staff
about increasing the amount they | 2:41:33 | 2:41:36 | |
already pay in order to go to work.
That has been postponed for now, but | 2:41:36 | 2:41:41 | |
the opportunity for that to be
brought back next year understand is | 2:41:41 | 2:41:45 | |
very much on the table and they
would see significant increases | 2:41:45 | 2:41:48 | |
going forward. As the honourable
member for Harlow has indicated, | 2:41:48 | 2:41:55 | |
where not just talking about
consultants who might be earning a | 2:41:55 | 2:41:58 | |
very good wage or senior executives,
we're talking about porters and | 2:41:58 | 2:42:03 | |
health care assistants, medical
secretaries, people behind the | 2:42:03 | 2:42:05 | |
scenes to keep the hospital going,
expected to pay even more. The | 2:42:05 | 2:42:09 | |
frustrations that has brought about
from staff are immense because they | 2:42:09 | 2:42:13 | |
already say they struggle to get a
parking space as it is, not least | 2:42:13 | 2:42:17 | |
because of the shifts run over, the
idea you might do an eight-hour | 2:42:17 | 2:42:21 | |
shift in | 2:42:21 | 2:42:32 | |
the NHS is negligible because most
people through their own goodwill by | 2:42:47 | 2:42:49 | |
giving more to the NHS and working
beyond their shift, they don't want | 2:42:49 | 2:42:52 | |
to leave their patients in the
middle of an incident. And saw the | 2:42:52 | 2:42:54 | |
number of parking spaces available
for people is reduced. People are | 2:42:54 | 2:42:56 | |
leaving home and off a lot earlier,
an hour or an hour and a half | 2:42:56 | 2:42:59 | |
earlier than their shift starts, so
increasing their working day in many | 2:42:59 | 2:43:02 | |
slaves. Most of it is not just about
travel time. It is about people in | 2:43:02 | 2:43:05 | |
the car parks driving around trying
to find a space. It is incredibly | 2:43:05 | 2:43:07 | |
frustrating people are paying for a
space to go to work, they can't get | 2:43:07 | 2:43:10 | |
a space and sometimes it is making
them late to go into work. I'm happy | 2:43:10 | 2:43:13 | |
to give way. | 2:43:13 | 2:43:17 | |
You make a good point about people
trying to find parking spaces and | 2:43:17 | 2:43:21 | |
they're not being enough, could be
compromised and that hospitals | 2:43:21 | 2:43:25 | |
charge a reasonable flat rate rather
than abolishing completely? By | 2:43:25 | 2:43:30 | |
abolishing charges completely with
that exacerbate the very thing that | 2:43:30 | 2:43:33 | |
the honourable lady is talking
about? Hello Mac I thank the | 2:43:33 | 2:43:36 | |
honourable gentleman for that
intervention and I think that is | 2:43:36 | 2:43:42 | |
worth looking at. What we need is a
system where it does not put people | 2:43:42 | 2:43:46 | |
off either attending their
appointments and does not inhibit | 2:43:46 | 2:43:48 | |
people who are going to work and
causing them to arrive late at work, | 2:43:48 | 2:43:54 | |
so any suggestions are very welcome
to reach a sensible solution. And | 2:43:54 | 2:44:01 | |
finally, just to conclude, to raise
the issue that all of this, the car | 2:44:01 | 2:44:06 | |
parking charges are set in the
context of a long-term | 2:44:06 | 2:44:09 | |
transportation plan including Park
and ride systems, increasing | 2:44:09 | 2:44:14 | |
people's ability to use public
transport, cycles and everything | 2:44:14 | 2:44:16 | |
else. The reality is that not enough
has been done on any of those things | 2:44:16 | 2:44:22 | |
to enable people to use alternative
methods of transport to access work | 2:44:22 | 2:44:26 | |
at the time they need it or access
appointments at the time they needed | 2:44:26 | 2:44:29 | |
and so it is all for nothing and
that is why the charges are so | 2:44:29 | 2:44:33 | |
incredibly prohibitive when there
are no other methods of easy | 2:44:33 | 2:44:36 | |
transport on a regular basis to suit
patients and staff. It is a great | 2:44:36 | 2:44:43 | |
pleasure to follow the honourable
member from Grimsby who has given a | 2:44:43 | 2:44:47 | |
very thoughtful and engaging speech
on this very important issue. I am | 2:44:47 | 2:44:51 | |
glad so many members are able to be
here this afternoon to take part in | 2:44:51 | 2:44:55 | |
this debate. I would like to
congratulate the Right Honourable | 2:44:55 | 2:44:59 | |
member from Harlow for championing
this important issue in Parliament | 2:44:59 | 2:45:03 | |
over many years. He is much admired
right across the house taking up | 2:45:03 | 2:45:07 | |
issues that not everyone chooses to
champion and these are the issues | 2:45:07 | 2:45:10 | |
that so often make the lives of the
people he represents, the people I | 2:45:10 | 2:45:14 | |
represent, so much better so I thank
him for that. I was inspired by his | 2:45:14 | 2:45:19 | |
efforts in this area before they
became an MP and I was actually | 2:45:19 | 2:45:23 | |
campaigning in my constituency of
Telford and the whole issue of | 2:45:23 | 2:45:26 | |
parking charges when at the Princess
Royal Hospital the charges went up | 2:45:26 | 2:45:33 | |
by 75% and created the deal of local
upset. My constituents raised their | 2:45:33 | 2:45:41 | |
concerns on this issue frequently,
and in the time I have campaigned on | 2:45:41 | 2:45:44 | |
this issue I have received over 5000
letters and I see letters, not | 2:45:44 | 2:45:49 | |
e-mails, on this specific issue. In
Telford we really care about this | 2:45:49 | 2:45:53 | |
and that is why I am here today
because I was supposed to be at the | 2:45:53 | 2:45:57 | |
school giving a speech on the --
giving a speech to the ethical | 2:45:57 | 2:46:02 | |
debating society which I have to
cancel to be here because it matters | 2:46:02 | 2:46:05 | |
so much, and I apologise to the
students. I was told by my hospital | 2:46:05 | 2:46:10 | |
trust in 2014 that due to the
long-term nature of the legally | 2:46:10 | 2:46:15 | |
binding contract the hospital trust
had entered into that it was not | 2:46:15 | 2:46:20 | |
possible to change the existing
arrangement that they had. Clearly, | 2:46:20 | 2:46:24 | |
even political season long-term
contracts eventually expire so we | 2:46:24 | 2:46:28 | |
must be looking forward to what we
can put in place when the contracts | 2:46:28 | 2:46:33 | |
do. It is not acceptable for those
who can effect change to simply | 2:46:33 | 2:46:37 | |
stand back and wait for orders
contracts with public contractors to | 2:46:37 | 2:46:41 | |
be renewed. I thank my honourable
friend forgiving way. As she says | 2:46:41 | 2:46:47 | |
part of the problem is that so many
hospital trusts are locked into a | 2:46:47 | 2:46:53 | |
long-term contract, many of which
were negotiated in the late 90s, and | 2:46:53 | 2:46:58 | |
to thousands. But which will shortly
be coming up for renewal on | 2:46:58 | 2:47:05 | |
expiring. There she had been at now
is the time to be looking on what | 2:47:05 | 2:47:08 | |
provisions we can put in place to
make sure that as they are of | 2:47:08 | 2:47:13 | |
renewed the do not contain these
exploitative provisions that allow | 2:47:13 | 2:47:16 | |
hospital trusts to take patients and
their families and visitors for | 2:47:16 | 2:47:23 | |
remarks by overcharging them for
parking? My honourable friend makes | 2:47:23 | 2:47:30 | |
an important point and makes it
eloquently. This is a timely debate | 2:47:30 | 2:47:34 | |
and that is why it is so important
that we are are here to make the | 2:47:34 | 2:47:37 | |
case. Sadly, my local hospital trust
has gone on increasing the price of | 2:47:37 | 2:47:46 | |
hospital parking charges in a way
that some do feel is faultless and | 2:47:46 | 2:47:50 | |
has been described to me as a
cavalier manner. Following rises in | 2:47:50 | 2:47:55 | |
2017 it is now cheaper to park near
my local shopping centre in Telford | 2:47:55 | 2:48:01 | |
than it is to go to hospital to
visit a sick relative so there is | 2:48:01 | 2:48:05 | |
clearly something wrong with the
model that operate in this way | 2:48:05 | 2:48:09 | |
because as many other members have
mentioned no one chooses to go to | 2:48:09 | 2:48:15 | |
hospital. Telford is a new town much
like my right honourable friend's | 2:48:15 | 2:48:21 | |
constituency of Harlow and like many
new towns that are problems around | 2:48:21 | 2:48:23 | |
the way they are designed because
right or wrong way it is all about | 2:48:23 | 2:48:27 | |
road users as together with major
roads and read about systems -- | 2:48:27 | 2:48:32 | |
roundabout systems which are much
loved in Telford, everything is | 2:48:32 | 2:48:36 | |
focused on the car. It was never
intended that the pedestrian be able | 2:48:36 | 2:48:40 | |
to walk from A to B and this is one
of the problems that make it such an | 2:48:40 | 2:48:46 | |
important issue locally. We do not
have good public transport and we | 2:48:46 | 2:48:49 | |
can just hop on a bus or hop on a
chip or as I see a walk to the local | 2:48:49 | 2:48:53 | |
hospital as you might do in many
other areas. We have to take several | 2:48:53 | 2:48:58 | |
buses and so many people find
themselves being driven to hospital | 2:48:58 | 2:49:01 | |
or driving themselves and having to
pay. Some of the reasons my trust | 2:49:01 | 2:49:06 | |
gave to me about the increase in
charges was they said that the | 2:49:06 | 2:49:11 | |
charges are lower elsewhere in the
country which I did not think how | 2:49:11 | 2:49:14 | |
much teeth to it because London is a
very different environment to | 2:49:14 | 2:49:18 | |
Telford both in terms of income and
accessibility of transport so there | 2:49:18 | 2:49:23 | |
is a real need to take into
consideration local factors when | 2:49:23 | 2:49:26 | |
trusts are setting these charges,
and offering concessions is good, | 2:49:26 | 2:49:30 | |
and there are concessions at the
Princess Royal in Telford but they | 2:49:30 | 2:49:35 | |
are very contributed to administer
and operate and if you you must | 2:49:35 | 2:49:39 | |
prove you are on benefits and have
had your appointment and pretty | 2:49:39 | 2:49:41 | |
pager charges and all the time
health care staff are having to | 2:49:41 | 2:49:45 | |
administer this, having to cancel
charges and operate a refund of | 2:49:45 | 2:49:50 | |
devout concessions and that is not
what they are there for. It is no | 2:49:50 | 2:49:53 | |
good saying either that if there was
more money for hospitals they would | 2:49:53 | 2:49:56 | |
not need to charge because I think
we all know and understand that in | 2:49:56 | 2:50:00 | |
many cases and seven in my local
hospital 50% of the revenue goes to | 2:50:00 | 2:50:06 | |
the parking contractor and that must
be wrong. The other argument we have | 2:50:06 | 2:50:10 | |
here advanced year-to-date is that
if there were no parking charges | 2:50:10 | 2:50:15 | |
then there would be nowhere for
people to park, as anyone who wished | 2:50:15 | 2:50:18 | |
to produce the hospital car park.
Charges it is argued in a | 2:50:18 | 2:50:25 | |
disincentive to parking and without
charges my local hospital trust | 2:50:25 | 2:50:27 | |
people might stay all day in the
hospital cafe is having the | 2:50:27 | 2:50:31 | |
refreshments rather than leaving the
site. Clearly this is complete | 2:50:31 | 2:50:36 | |
nonsense, first of all because even
with charging incredibly high | 2:50:36 | 2:50:40 | |
charges there is nowhere to park.
All of the spaces are filled, the | 2:50:40 | 2:50:45 | |
grass is filled, the concrete is
filled, so the argument that | 2:50:45 | 2:50:48 | |
everyone is sitting in a cafe is
beyond my contravention. And I do | 2:50:48 | 2:50:53 | |
think this is an issue that needs to
be addressed with careful thought | 2:50:53 | 2:50:56 | |
rather than just seeing charges as
an instant panacea to a problem when | 2:50:56 | 2:51:00 | |
it clearly is not. Bizarrely my
hospital trust even tried to justify | 2:51:00 | 2:51:06 | |
the increase by talking to residents
about the number of nurses the | 2:51:06 | 2:51:11 | |
parking revenue pays for. I don't
like that as an argument because | 2:51:11 | 2:51:14 | |
nurses are paid for by taxpayers to
government funding and not the | 2:51:14 | 2:51:17 | |
parking charges, he increased the
Internet it was in fact in the | 2:51:17 | 2:51:21 | |
contractual agreement and nothing to
do with the number of nurses that | 2:51:21 | 2:51:24 | |
they were employing. So I do worry
when hospital managers think that | 2:51:24 | 2:51:30 | |
this is a charge that is not a big
deal because it is cheaper somewhere | 2:51:30 | 2:51:33 | |
else in the transport is not really
their problem, and if they are | 2:51:33 | 2:51:37 | |
spending too long in cafes then they
must live them on by using charges, | 2:51:37 | 2:51:41 | |
the shoes that they probably did not
understand as well as they should | 2:51:41 | 2:51:44 | |
the people they serve. And if you
dig a little bit deeper you find | 2:51:44 | 2:51:47 | |
that the Princess Royal that the
reason it is not possible to park is | 2:51:47 | 2:51:51 | |
there has been a huge increase in
the number of staff working on site | 2:51:51 | 2:51:56 | |
and parking in the car park and we
do need to look at ways of helping | 2:51:56 | 2:51:59 | |
staff reduced car park use, as this
would free up many spaces for | 2:51:59 | 2:52:05 | |
patients to use throughout the day
and we need to think imaginatively | 2:52:05 | 2:52:07 | |
on how this might be done, perhaps a
park-and-ride scheme specifically | 2:52:07 | 2:52:12 | |
tailored to shift times could help
and I think this is something that | 2:52:12 | 2:52:17 | |
hospitals are looking at. We have
heard today that this is a tax on | 2:52:17 | 2:52:21 | |
the sick and most taxes take account
of people's ability to pay and that | 2:52:21 | 2:52:25 | |
is absolutely right, yet hospital
managers and porters pay the same to | 2:52:25 | 2:52:30 | |
park and it is often the least well
off who are hit hardest. If you want | 2:52:30 | 2:52:34 | |
to tax people and give half of that
tax to a car park in company then do | 2:52:34 | 2:52:39 | |
it to PAYE, it is a bit senseless
but do not break nurses and other | 2:52:39 | 2:52:42 | |
health care staff be involved in
enforcement and its is completely | 2:52:42 | 2:52:47 | |
inefficient to operate it in the way
it is being operated. Others have | 2:52:47 | 2:52:50 | |
talked on the issue of the rigmarole
that those of paying for parking, | 2:52:50 | 2:52:54 | |
whether it is coins are typing in
your number plate being video going | 2:52:54 | 2:52:57 | |
in and out, there is a whole
punitive element to this that when | 2:52:57 | 2:53:01 | |
you are rushing to see someone who
is ill or indeed waiting for an | 2:53:01 | 2:53:05 | |
appointment at -- and the consultant
is running over time it had to the | 2:53:05 | 2:53:08 | |
anxiety and I think in this
particular context it is completely | 2:53:08 | 2:53:13 | |
inappropriate. This is an issue that
no one wants to own and so we will | 2:53:13 | 2:53:17 | |
end up accepting it rather than
solving it and too many people see | 2:53:17 | 2:53:21 | |
it is not our problem and too
difficult to fix and it is not that | 2:53:21 | 2:53:24 | |
important because it is only £8 per
day. Too often those in power look | 2:53:24 | 2:53:28 | |
at the world through their own eyes
and not through the eyes of those | 2:53:28 | 2:53:31 | |
whom they serve. There is little
appetite amongst hospital management | 2:53:31 | 2:53:34 | |
to deal with this. It is not a
big-ticket issue, it is not exciting | 2:53:34 | 2:53:40 | |
or a shiny new hospital, it does not
cost £300 million, which is | 2:53:40 | 2:53:43 | |
something that we spend a lot of
time talking about in Telford, | 2:53:43 | 2:53:46 | |
earlier emergency units that why I
am here today, I want to see | 2:53:46 | 2:53:52 | |
government and hospital managers sit
up and take notice of this issue. | 2:53:52 | 2:53:55 | |
Don't rush it off as at an issue, it
is not. By NCH through the eyes of | 2:53:55 | 2:54:00 | |
others and tackle the issue that
faces the everyday users of our | 2:54:00 | 2:54:06 | |
hospitals. It is something that can
be fixed and will make a difference | 2:54:06 | 2:54:09 | |
to the lives of those who most need
hospital services and for that | 2:54:09 | 2:54:12 | |
reason we should all care about its
all for the Right Honourable member | 2:54:12 | 2:54:15 | |
of Harlow, it is a great service to
his constituents and I thank him for | 2:54:15 | 2:54:20 | |
bringing forward this debate and I
support him entirely. It is a | 2:54:20 | 2:54:24 | |
pleasure to follow the Honourable
member from Telford. We all know | 2:54:24 | 2:54:28 | |
that the NHS is underfunded and the
hospital trust in my constituency | 2:54:28 | 2:54:33 | |
received over £1.5 million in car
parking charges in 2016-17 according | 2:54:33 | 2:54:39 | |
to data released by Freedom of
information request, so it might | 2:54:39 | 2:54:45 | |
seem unusual for me to be calling
for the abolition of car parking | 2:54:45 | 2:54:48 | |
charges when we know that they can
provide an income for hospitals | 2:54:48 | 2:54:52 | |
however I agree with the Honourable
member from Telford that much of the | 2:54:52 | 2:54:55 | |
money does not actually go to the
hospital, it often goes to the | 2:54:55 | 2:54:59 | |
private operator of that car park. I
also think that it is the | 2:54:59 | 2:55:04 | |
government's responsibility to
ensure our NHS has the money needs, | 2:55:04 | 2:55:08 | |
not the patient's not staff and not
visitors. We should not expect | 2:55:08 | 2:55:13 | |
vulnerable people to pay a sickness
taxi parking charges. And I also | 2:55:13 | 2:55:18 | |
agree with my honourable friend's
comment from Great Grimsby about the | 2:55:18 | 2:55:22 | |
impact it has on other residents
living in the local area. In the | 2:55:22 | 2:55:25 | |
street opposite my hospital in
Walker Street they have had to issue | 2:55:25 | 2:55:32 | |
resident permits to stop other
people parking on the street so in | 2:55:32 | 2:55:36 | |
effect the residents that live there
have to pay to park their cars | 2:55:36 | 2:55:40 | |
because staff are parking their cars
where they left because staff cannot | 2:55:40 | 2:55:43 | |
afford to use the car park. The
whole system is completely nonsense. | 2:55:43 | 2:55:47 | |
And of course I am incredibly proud
that our Labour Party manifesto | 2:55:47 | 2:55:53 | |
pledge to strap car parking charges
at her suggestion was that any loss | 2:55:53 | 2:55:57 | |
of income could come from a tax on
private health care and insurance | 2:55:57 | 2:56:01 | |
which would meet the £162 million
cost of free parking on all NHS | 2:56:01 | 2:56:06 | |
hospitals across England. The
unfairness of the sickness tax by | 2:56:06 | 2:56:12 | |
having car parking charges must be
felt in context, and I want to tell | 2:56:12 | 2:56:16 | |
you about a dear friend of mine, a
man called Dermot. He has been in | 2:56:16 | 2:56:22 | |
hospital now for well over 20 days
and I am not sure if you are all | 2:56:22 | 2:56:26 | |
aware but a particularly cruel and
unfair consequence of being in | 2:56:26 | 2:56:29 | |
hospital over 28 days if the ending
of his payments for disability | 2:56:29 | 2:56:32 | |
living allowance and attendance
allowance. And if he had been | 2:56:32 | 2:56:39 | |
receiving PIP instead of the LA that
would have been stopped as well. His | 2:56:39 | 2:56:41 | |
wife's income has been affected as
well because she is his carer and he | 2:56:41 | 2:56:46 | |
has stopped receiving her allowance
because Dermot has lost his | 2:56:46 | 2:56:49 | |
disability living allowance. The
nice bits to this study is that | 2:56:49 | 2:56:54 | |
friends have rallied round and
organised fundraising concert for | 2:56:54 | 2:56:56 | |
their friend and I have to make sure
I pronounce this carefully, it was | 2:56:56 | 2:57:03 | |
cold funk the 28 day rule, which was
used to raise money to support | 2:57:03 | 2:57:11 | |
Dermot. Friends should not have to
raise money to compensate our health | 2:57:11 | 2:57:15 | |
care's system failure to support
people. The dramatic fall in his | 2:57:15 | 2:57:20 | |
family's income makes the added
travel at car parking costs | 2:57:20 | 2:57:23 | |
particularly cruel and they are not
the only family facing this but | 2:57:23 | 2:57:26 | |
their story highlights the
unfairness that many families face | 2:57:26 | 2:57:30 | |
of having to park every day to visit
loved ones at a time when their | 2:57:30 | 2:57:34 | |
income might have dramatically
fallen. We all hate to think what | 2:57:34 | 2:57:38 | |
would happen if one of our loved
ones ended up staying in hospital | 2:57:38 | 2:57:42 | |
for a long time. One of the saddest
examples of the sickness tax is what | 2:57:42 | 2:57:48 | |
the Honourable member for Harlow
mention that that is for parents of | 2:57:48 | 2:57:50 | |
premature sick babies. We know that
premature and sick babies, to have | 2:57:50 | 2:57:56 | |
the best possible outcome, they need
hands-on care every day, the daily | 2:57:56 | 2:58:01 | |
cost of travelling to hospital can
be a barrier to parents being with | 2:58:01 | 2:58:05 | |
the baby. The charity Bliss states
that parents spent 32p per week on | 2:58:05 | 2:58:13 | |
average on car parking charges to
visit their baby. -- £32 per week. | 2:58:13 | 2:58:20 | |
This is an unacceptable cost. All of
our new precious babies have the | 2:58:20 | 2:58:23 | |
right to be with their parents, not
just the parents who can afford to | 2:58:23 | 2:58:26 | |
pay to park their cars there. | 2:58:26 | 2:58:33 | |
I lady for giving way. I think it is
grossly unacceptable for people | 2:58:33 | 2:58:42 | |
visiting sick babies, or a husband
or man with his partner waiting for | 2:58:42 | 2:58:49 | |
her to give birth, how often does
happen that you have paid for three | 2:58:49 | 2:58:59 | |
hours parking and you require much
more? You are stuck. You're required | 2:58:59 | 2:59:03 | |
to stay with the woman, but you're
worried about paying for the | 2:59:03 | 2:59:07 | |
flipping parking charge. This is
wrong. There must be a way around | 2:59:07 | 2:59:15 | |
this. I completely agree. I know
from being with my parents when a go | 2:59:15 | 2:59:19 | |
in for hospital appointments, my mum
sits there with the alarm on her | 2:59:19 | 2:59:25 | |
phone. It is not what you want to be
thinking about when you visit | 2:59:25 | 2:59:30 | |
hospital. This unfair cost is not
just felt by visitors and patients, | 2:59:30 | 2:59:34 | |
but by staff as well. During my
local big conversation event, I | 2:59:34 | 2:59:38 | |
became aware of the difficulties
facing local nurses and other NHS | 2:59:38 | 2:59:43 | |
professionals in my local hospital.
The financial squeeze that NHS | 2:59:43 | 2:59:50 | |
professionals are facing has been
well-documented. For example, | 2:59:50 | 2:59:52 | |
midwives have lost on average £6,000
per year in real terms since 2010. | 2:59:52 | 2:59:58 | |
The additional cost of parking their
cars seems particularly unfair. An | 2:59:58 | 3:00:04 | |
investigation by the union Unison
found some medics were having to | 3:00:04 | 3:00:09 | |
rush out in between appointments to
move their car to avoid a fine. A | 3:00:09 | 3:00:13 | |
situation which is ridiculous. Our
hospitals are open 24 hours a day, | 3:00:13 | 3:00:22 | |
every day of the year. Star finish
work at different times. We have a | 3:00:22 | 3:00:28 | |
duty to keep them safe, after they
have spent their shift caring for | 3:00:28 | 3:00:32 | |
others. They should not be having to
return to cars parked on dark and | 3:00:32 | 3:00:36 | |
isolated streets because they can't
afford the hospital car park. I urge | 3:00:36 | 3:00:41 | |
the Minister to take this motion
forward and take action. This issue, | 3:00:41 | 3:00:46 | |
as you can hear, has cross-party
support and it would make a real | 3:00:46 | 3:00:51 | |
difference, a real positive
difference to so many people slides. | 3:00:51 | 3:01:00 | |
It's a pleasure to follow the
honourable lady who represents the | 3:01:00 | 3:01:04 | |
other side of the Humber Bridge. And
a pleasure to support the honourable | 3:01:04 | 3:01:10 | |
member for Harlow. His campaigning
skills on issues such as this on the | 3:01:10 | 3:01:16 | |
backbenches are very welcome.
Hopefully we can have success, as we | 3:01:16 | 3:01:27 | |
have done in the past with
campaigns. It's a pleasure to speak | 3:01:27 | 3:01:34 | |
following the honourable member for
Great Grimsby. On this occasion, I | 3:01:34 | 3:01:41 | |
can't say that I agree with every
word said in this House by my member | 3:01:41 | 3:01:46 | |
of Parliament. It is about getting
the balance right. Diluted initial | 3:01:46 | 3:01:56 | |
burden on patients and their
families, particularly at a time | 3:01:56 | 3:01:59 | |
when they are particularly stressed
and perhaps in great distress? Or | 3:01:59 | 3:02:06 | |
should we put the burden on any
limited NHS resources our hospitals | 3:02:06 | 3:02:14 | |
are having to manage? There is a
balance to be achieved, I'm quite | 3:02:14 | 3:02:18 | |
sure. The reality is that some
patients and families can afford to | 3:02:18 | 3:02:26 | |
pay, as has been mentioned already.
But even those in those | 3:02:26 | 3:02:29 | |
circumstances or perhaps visiting a
parent who is coming to the end of | 3:02:29 | 3:02:38 | |
their life and they suffer just as
much distress, whatever their | 3:02:38 | 3:02:41 | |
financial circumstances. The
hospital trust that serves my | 3:02:41 | 3:02:54 | |
constituency has an income of £2.8
million from car parking last year. | 3:02:54 | 3:02:59 | |
They told me there was a surplus of
three quarters of £1 million spent | 3:02:59 | 3:03:06 | |
on patient care. That is good news
in the sense that that is money they | 3:03:06 | 3:03:12 | |
desperately need, but it has come
out of the pockets of people | 3:03:12 | 3:03:15 | |
visiting the hospital at difficult
times. It is a real burden on many | 3:03:15 | 3:03:30 | |
hard-working families. I would
detain the House is a great deal of | 3:03:30 | 3:03:41 | |
time if I were to read the 64 page
guidance the local trust produces | 3:03:41 | 3:03:46 | |
for parking on hospital site. It is
an appalling burden we place on all | 3:03:46 | 3:03:56 | |
organisations, be they in the public
or private sector, when he have to | 3:03:56 | 3:04:00 | |
go to such trouble to produce 64
pages guidance on how they operate | 3:04:00 | 3:04:06 | |
their car park. It is madness. I
draw attention to the fact that | 3:04:06 | 3:04:14 | |
patients in my constituency and the
neighbouring areas in many cases | 3:04:14 | 3:04:22 | |
half to travel much further, many
times over the river to Hull. Public | 3:04:22 | 3:04:36 | |
transport is almost nonexistent from
many of the rural villages in my | 3:04:36 | 3:04:40 | |
constituency and in the wider area
served by Grimsby's hospital. I will | 3:04:40 | 3:04:47 | |
happily give way. He is making a
very good point and that is that the | 3:04:47 | 3:04:53 | |
cost is disproportionate on those
who live in rural areas. I thank my | 3:04:53 | 3:04:58 | |
honourable friend from that point.
He rammed his eye sees the point I | 3:04:58 | 3:05:03 | |
am making. Many patients travel 15
or 20 miles before the actually get | 3:05:03 | 3:05:08 | |
to the hospital. It is an additional
burden they can well do without. My | 3:05:08 | 3:05:15 | |
honourable friend from Grimsby
mentioned the fact that there was a | 3:05:15 | 3:05:19 | |
problem with management. She
mentioned parking in neighbouring | 3:05:19 | 3:05:22 | |
streets. When all those streets very
well. When I was a councillor for | 3:05:22 | 3:05:32 | |
that area, they used to complain
about people blocking their streets | 3:05:32 | 3:05:36 | |
and I'm sure they complain to their
member of Parliament today. It is a | 3:05:36 | 3:05:41 | |
problem I recognise. There is a
problem with commuter parking which | 3:05:41 | 3:05:45 | |
has to be dealt with, tokens have
already been mentioned, simple time | 3:05:45 | 3:05:51 | |
limits of a couple of hours before
charges kicked in might be another | 3:05:51 | 3:05:55 | |
alternative, as well as the flat
charge my honourable friend from | 3:05:55 | 3:06:00 | |
Southampton mentioned. I urge the
government to tackle this. It needs | 3:06:00 | 3:06:07 | |
government action. It is
unreasonable to expect a trust, | 3:06:07 | 3:06:14 | |
particularly those like Northern
Lincolnshire and cool, in special | 3:06:14 | 3:06:17 | |
measures, with various challenges of
their own. In needs government | 3:06:17 | 3:06:24 | |
action to resolve it. Savings can be
made through better procurement | 3:06:24 | 3:06:32 | |
procedure is. That is one possible
route. I'm sure every member in the | 3:06:32 | 3:06:37 | |
House could identify one particular
saving they could identify in order | 3:06:37 | 3:06:41 | |
to provide this particular -- meet
the cost of the 200 million the NHS | 3:06:41 | 3:06:51 | |
would have to find. It is a major
problem, it's a burden on our | 3:06:51 | 3:06:56 | |
constituents, one could so easily be
resolved and I urge the government | 3:06:56 | 3:06:59 | |
to get on with it and resolve it
pretty quickly. Thank you. I would | 3:06:59 | 3:07:08 | |
also like to thank the Right
honourable member for Harlow for | 3:07:08 | 3:07:10 | |
securing this important debate. If I
parked at the hospital car park in | 3:07:10 | 3:07:24 | |
my constituency, it would cost me a
third more than if I parked in a | 3:07:24 | 3:07:28 | |
council owned car park. How is that
acceptable? Is this not NHS Trusts | 3:07:28 | 3:07:34 | |
profiteering from the sick and
vulnerable? When you're in a rush, | 3:07:34 | 3:07:37 | |
taking a sick friend or relative to
the hospital, you won't necessarily | 3:07:37 | 3:07:42 | |
consider where is cheaper to park.
Unho Park in the closest car park | 3:07:42 | 3:07:47 | |
and sort it out later. If you're
having to attend hospital on a | 3:07:47 | 3:07:51 | |
regular occasion, you'll get free
parking. At Huddersfield Royal | 3:07:51 | 3:07:57 | |
Infirmary, a 2.5 hour stay three
times a week every week of the year | 3:07:57 | 3:08:01 | |
will cost you needy pounds. That is
700 needy pounds to support someone | 3:08:01 | 3:08:07 | |
receiving medical treatment. Even
for some who are disabled blue badge | 3:08:07 | 3:08:15 | |
holders, £780. I thank the
honourable lady for giving way. I | 3:08:15 | 3:08:25 | |
think I speak on behalf of all of
us, but I find it in equities that | 3:08:25 | 3:08:29 | |
anyone with a blue badge should have
to pay a penny when they go to | 3:08:29 | 3:08:35 | |
hospital. I am in complete agreement
with you. How am I constituents | 3:08:35 | 3:08:43 | |
meant to afford these excessive
costs? Hard-working nurse, doctor, | 3:08:43 | 3:08:48 | |
Porter, cleaner, receptionists, they
all go to work to help people. They | 3:08:48 | 3:08:54 | |
are paying 1000 pounds -- £1600 per
year to work 12 hour shift to for | 3:08:54 | 3:09:07 | |
people. Paying to save lives. How is
this acceptable by anyone's | 3:09:07 | 3:09:15 | |
standards? How does anyone think it
is right that these hard-working | 3:09:15 | 3:09:18 | |
professionals are paying nearly
£2000 a year to help people and cure | 3:09:18 | 3:09:23 | |
for people? I can tell you, it
isn't. I appreciate that trusts are | 3:09:23 | 3:09:34 | |
following national guidelines, but
patients and staff feel like they | 3:09:34 | 3:09:37 | |
are being treated just like cash
cows by NHS Trusts. My local trust | 3:09:37 | 3:09:45 | |
remains nearly £15 million in
deficit from last year. In the | 3:09:45 | 3:09:52 | |
annual reports, the trust recorded
1.4 million income from car parking. | 3:09:52 | 3:09:59 | |
In 2016, this rose to 2.7 million.
The extra money the trust makes | 3:09:59 | 3:10:07 | |
helps plug the hole from the
underfunded from the government, but | 3:10:07 | 3:10:10 | |
it shouldn't have to. Our NHS should
be fully funded, not depending on | 3:10:10 | 3:10:16 | |
car parking fees. I urge the
government to consider the comments | 3:10:16 | 3:10:19 | |
being made today by members from
across this House and act swiftly to | 3:10:19 | 3:10:25 | |
resolve this issue. It takes me back
a long way to when I was shadow | 3:10:25 | 3:10:38 | |
Health Minister back in 2006. This
issue with car parking charges was | 3:10:38 | 3:10:44 | |
around then. Successive governments
have talks about addressing this, | 3:10:44 | 3:10:51 | |
but it is a regressive tax. It is a
tax on everybody that needs the NHS, | 3:10:51 | 3:10:57 | |
that's why the earlier. And for the
staff to be taxed even more, to be | 3:10:57 | 3:11:03 | |
able to go to work in a very
difficult shift pattern is even more | 3:11:03 | 3:11:12 | |
of a regressive tax for them. It is
frankly unacceptable. I've raised | 3:11:12 | 3:11:16 | |
this issue many times before.
Members of the House might remember | 3:11:16 | 3:11:20 | |
I used to be a firefighter.
Firefighters don't pay to park in | 3:11:20 | 3:11:25 | |
the yard of the fire station. The
Ambulance Service doesn't pay, the | 3:11:25 | 3:11:33 | |
drive to work, they go to the depot
to pick up the ambulance and go to | 3:11:33 | 3:11:38 | |
work. So why another emergency
worker to be charged in this way is | 3:11:38 | 3:11:48 | |
something fundamentally wrong, it's
been going back and forth across | 3:11:48 | 3:11:54 | |
this House the matter who is in
government. Contracts were signed by | 3:11:54 | 3:11:59 | |
this government and previous ones,
hugely expensive ones, particularly | 3:11:59 | 3:12:03 | |
the PFI once. We need to do
something about that. Thank you. It | 3:12:03 | 3:12:13 | |
seems to me again that you have a
staff car park and you should have a | 3:12:13 | 3:12:19 | |
setup where staff have a separate
parking arrangement so that staff do | 3:12:19 | 3:12:24 | |
not block the public going in and
staff have a guaranteed slot, so | 3:12:24 | 3:12:30 | |
they are not late further shift. In
some parts of the world, in Luton | 3:12:30 | 3:12:40 | |
and Dunstable, that's what they do.
I went to visit someone in | 3:12:40 | 3:12:46 | |
palliative care. I didn't know how
long I was going to be seeing them. | 3:12:46 | 3:12:59 | |
I parked and paid where I thought I
was in a public car park. I was in | 3:13:00 | 3:13:05 | |
the staff car park. So when I went
to try and get out, the barrier | 3:13:05 | 3:13:09 | |
wouldn't go up. I pressed the button
and the said I had parked illegally. | 3:13:09 | 3:13:14 | |
I said I have got a ticket.
Fortunately they had no idea who I | 3:13:14 | 3:13:21 | |
was. Eventually I said, if you're
going to find me, finally. I will | 3:13:21 | 3:13:33 | |
see you in court. I had paid in an
NHS car park that you have | 3:13:33 | 3:13:40 | |
designated. Eventually they just
said, go our way. I have been | 3:13:40 | 3:13:43 | |
waiting for the fine to come
through. It probably will now and I | 3:13:43 | 3:13:47 | |
will see them in court. We have
heard quite rightly about maternity. | 3:13:47 | 3:14:02 | |
Babies come out when they want to,
not when we want them to and not | 3:14:02 | 3:14:08 | |
based on how much time you have in
the car park. People are getting | 3:14:08 | 3:14:13 | |
signed every day in this country
because they have overrun their time | 3:14:13 | 3:14:17 | |
in the car park. How can the right? | 3:14:17 | 3:14:24 | |
I was told by a member who cannot be
here today, volunteer drivers, what | 3:14:24 | 3:14:28 | |
would we do without them? They are
fantastic. They pay to be in | 3:14:28 | 3:14:35 | |
hospital car parks to take patients
home. Because the annual service is | 3:14:35 | 3:14:40 | |
struggling so much. What is
happening in some parts of the | 3:14:40 | 3:14:42 | |
country and I know this is happening
in my part, is because the car | 3:14:42 | 3:14:46 | |
parking facilities are so bad people
are saying I want the patient | 3:14:46 | 3:14:51 | |
transport. Putting more of a burden
on patient transport because they | 3:14:51 | 3:14:55 | |
can't find a parking space and will
be with her that appointment. If | 3:14:55 | 3:14:59 | |
they are they for the appointment
because of the patient transport | 3:14:59 | 3:15:01 | |
that is OK but if you can't find the
parking space to pay then you are a | 3:15:01 | 3:15:05 | |
bad person. We have heard of people
parking outside. Blue badge holders | 3:15:05 | 3:15:09 | |
being charged in a car park when
they can park for free on the road | 3:15:09 | 3:15:13 | |
which is what they do. We know that
is what is happening and that is | 3:15:13 | 3:15:18 | |
where it is very wrong. I know when
the minister stands up and he is a | 3:15:18 | 3:15:25 | |
good man and an honourable man but
he will almost certainly say this is | 3:15:25 | 3:15:29 | |
devolved to NHS trusts and it is for
them to decide how they run their | 3:15:29 | 3:15:32 | |
facilities. For those of us who are
members of Parliament the NHS trusts | 3:15:32 | 3:15:37 | |
are completely unaccountable. We can
go and moan about this and they will | 3:15:37 | 3:15:41 | |
not listen in the slightest. They
will be looking at whether they can | 3:15:41 | 3:15:46 | |
get away with it and how much they
can raise. It is not just about | 3:15:46 | 3:15:51 | |
money, it is about space. For
instance we have heard already that | 3:15:51 | 3:15:55 | |
if we do not charge it will be full
of people from the town centre. My | 3:15:55 | 3:16:00 | |
hospital was closed, the excellent
Hemel Hampstead hospital and we said | 3:16:00 | 3:16:05 | |
if you move all of the acute care to
Watford in the middle of Watford | 3:16:05 | 3:16:09 | |
town centre next to a football
stadium, apparently Watford play | 3:16:09 | 3:16:12 | |
there. My constituents will be very
upset when the Jamie being | 3:16:12 | 3:16:17 | |
derogatory about Watford but they
have huge fans and on one occasion I | 3:16:17 | 3:16:21 | |
went to Watford Hospital on Saturday
morning to visit a constituent of | 3:16:21 | 3:16:25 | |
mine. I parked and paid. When I came
out there was a group of parking | 3:16:25 | 3:16:32 | |
people who clearly wanted to give me
a ticket. I had paid in the football | 3:16:32 | 3:16:35 | |
pitch. That was designated to
Watford football club when playing | 3:16:35 | 3:16:40 | |
at home. What does that have to do
with going to see and look after our | 3:16:40 | 3:16:44 | |
call to a hospital, an NHS hospital?
Unfortunately Madam Deputy Speaker | 3:16:44 | 3:16:50 | |
they didn't recognise the other very
apologetic, but I don't think that | 3:16:50 | 3:16:54 | |
is right. If they had no dry was the
ticket was coming. How on earth | 3:16:54 | 3:16:59 | |
Madam Deputy Speaker can you have a
feel Acute Hospital in the middle of | 3:16:59 | 3:17:04 | |
a town as big as Watford next to a
football stadium and call it a | 3:17:04 | 3:17:10 | |
modern NHS hospital? The parking
facilities for staff and patients is | 3:17:10 | 3:17:15 | |
frankly almost nonexistent not least
because lots of it has been carved | 3:17:15 | 3:17:17 | |
for the football club. I want
Watford to be very successful but | 3:17:17 | 3:17:22 | |
what I want on her part of the world
is a brand-new hospital, Greenfield | 3:17:22 | 3:17:27 | |
hospital with proper parking
facilities away from the town centre | 3:17:27 | 3:17:31 | |
so we don't have any of these
concerns about whether or not people | 3:17:31 | 3:17:34 | |
will go shopping or stay there all
day. But at the moment I don't have | 3:17:34 | 3:17:38 | |
that, I have Watford as an Acute
Hospital, it has come out of special | 3:17:38 | 3:17:42 | |
measures and wish them well, and
Hemel Hempstead Hospital which is | 3:17:42 | 3:17:46 | |
basically a clinic these days, and
they charge the staff Madam Deputy | 3:17:46 | 3:17:52 | |
Speaker and the patients to park
there. It is empty. There is hardly | 3:17:52 | 3:17:59 | |
anybody parked there because there's
nothing on the site any more. But | 3:17:59 | 3:18:03 | |
they still insist on charging. That
pushes the patient outside so we | 3:18:03 | 3:18:07 | |
have restricted parking outside
which is an issue for the town | 3:18:07 | 3:18:12 | |
centre. Is it cheaper to park in the
town centre and the council car park | 3:18:12 | 3:18:18 | |
or they go to an empty car park
literally empty car park because | 3:18:18 | 3:18:21 | |
there are so few facilities there.
This has to be sorted out from | 3:18:21 | 3:18:28 | |
central government. Central
government guidelines have to be | 3:18:28 | 3:18:30 | |
enforceable. We can issue as many
notices from the Department, if you | 3:18:30 | 3:18:37 | |
do not actually come out with the
stick, nothing will happen. Could | 3:18:37 | 3:18:44 | |
the money be raised other ways?
Could there be savings in the NHS? | 3:18:44 | 3:18:48 | |
We have already heard about the
amount of money in the pot of things | 3:18:48 | 3:18:52 | |
is peanuts and if we wanted to save
some money instantly one of the more | 3:18:52 | 3:18:57 | |
recent chief executives of my very
small acute trust was on a package | 3:18:57 | 3:19:00 | |
of over £300,000 per year. Take a
look at the salaries of the top | 3:19:00 | 3:19:07 | |
people in the NHS. Look after the
people at the bottom and do not | 3:19:07 | 3:19:12 | |
charge them to park when they go to
work. Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker | 3:19:12 | 3:19:17 | |
and it is a pleasure to speak in
this debate and to follow the | 3:19:17 | 3:19:21 | |
honourable member for Hemel
Hampstead. Much of what he has said | 3:19:21 | 3:19:27 | |
echoes the complaints that have come
to my constituency office. I also | 3:19:27 | 3:19:32 | |
want to thank the honourable member
for Harlow for bringing this debate. | 3:19:32 | 3:19:36 | |
This is a subject very close to my
heart because I used to work for the | 3:19:36 | 3:19:40 | |
NHS and I remember very well be time
when car parking charges were | 3:19:40 | 3:19:45 | |
actually introduced for patients,
carers, visitors and staff. In a | 3:19:45 | 3:19:51 | |
member the controversies cost at the
time and it still causes that | 3:19:51 | 3:19:55 | |
controversy now. This issue has not
gone away. I work for the NHS as a | 3:19:55 | 3:20:03 | |
political scientists but I was a
workplace red Ford Unite, the trade | 3:20:03 | 3:20:07 | |
union. And I remember the resistance
that all of the health union split | 3:20:07 | 3:20:14 | |
up towards the introduction of car
parking charges which we saw then | 3:20:14 | 3:20:17 | |
and still see now as a tax on staff
coming to work, attacks on patients, | 3:20:17 | 3:20:26 | |
on visitors and carers. The practice
of charging for car parking in my | 3:20:26 | 3:20:32 | |
area was started by Central
Manchester hospital and the reason | 3:20:32 | 3:20:36 | |
that Mac the issue that has been
referred to of people using the free | 3:20:36 | 3:20:42 | |
parking at hospital and going
somewhere else was the reason why | 3:20:42 | 3:20:44 | |
they introduced those charges, but
once the debt that all of the other | 3:20:44 | 3:20:49 | |
hospitals in greater Manchester
followed suit. The hospital I worked | 3:20:49 | 3:20:54 | |
at, North Manchester General, the
only reason anyone would go there | 3:20:54 | 3:20:58 | |
was because they worked there, or
there getting treatment there or | 3:20:58 | 3:21:02 | |
they were visiting India capacity as
either a friend relative or a carer, | 3:21:02 | 3:21:07 | |
there was no other reason for
someone to be visiting the hospital, | 3:21:07 | 3:21:10 | |
so there was no real reason to start
to charge people to park there. But | 3:21:10 | 3:21:17 | |
the trust claimed that the money
taken would be put towards improving | 3:21:17 | 3:21:22 | |
the car parking facilities which I
have to admit at the time were | 3:21:22 | 3:21:28 | |
absolutely dire, we used to park one
answer that potholed areas and at | 3:21:28 | 3:21:31 | |
least eventually they will improve
once the car parking system, the | 3:21:31 | 3:21:36 | |
charging system had become embedded,
so that was one positive thing that | 3:21:36 | 3:21:40 | |
came out of it. And I do remember
initially that the hospital trust | 3:21:40 | 3:21:47 | |
purchased some wheel clamps and
friends and those who did not pay | 3:21:47 | 3:21:50 | |
with clamping. I did work with some
interesting people in the NHS and | 3:21:50 | 3:21:54 | |
one colleague of mine decided he was
going to buy his own personal wheel | 3:21:54 | 3:21:59 | |
clamp, he attached it to his car
when he parked in the morning, which | 3:21:59 | 3:22:05 | |
served two purposes because it was
not the muscle that areas, it | 3:22:05 | 3:22:09 | |
immobilises Karin kept secure and it
also gave the impression that he had | 3:22:09 | 3:22:12 | |
been penalised for not being able to
park and within a few weeks his | 3:22:12 | 3:22:16 | |
wheel clan had paid for itself.
However, not everyone was that | 3:22:16 | 3:22:23 | |
inventors, and gradually the idea of
paying to park at a hospital became | 3:22:23 | 3:22:29 | |
commonplace if not accepted,
although the trade unions always | 3:22:29 | 3:22:32 | |
strongly opposed the practice. And
the wheel clamps were actually very | 3:22:32 | 3:22:36 | |
quickly phased out, rumour had it
that the trust had been successfully | 3:22:36 | 3:22:41 | |
sued over we can never find out the
full facts of that but the trust | 3:22:41 | 3:22:44 | |
then began to impose fines on those
deemed to have breached the rules. | 3:22:44 | 3:22:51 | |
The whole issue of car parking fees
and fines, it generated a huge | 3:22:51 | 3:22:57 | |
amount of controversy, discussion
and debate. Not to mention a huge | 3:22:57 | 3:23:02 | |
sum of visits, phone calls and
e-mails to the trading in office. | 3:23:02 | 3:23:07 | |
And anyone who might question the
need to give trading in rats | 3:23:07 | 3:23:10 | |
facility time to do their job might
like to reflect upon the massive | 3:23:10 | 3:23:14 | |
pressure put upon them by issues
like this. When I left the trust | 3:23:14 | 3:23:20 | |
when I was elected to this place I
was paying £20 per month in car | 3:23:20 | 3:23:26 | |
parking charges, which was taken
directly out of my salary. And that | 3:23:26 | 3:23:32 | |
staff three is now £22.10, which
might not sound a lot but it is an | 3:23:32 | 3:23:38 | |
increase of over 10% over the last
three years, and that pays scant | 3:23:38 | 3:23:43 | |
regard to the fact that NHS staff
have had their pay either frozen or | 3:23:43 | 3:23:48 | |
capped to a maximum of just 1%. It
is completely disproportionate. As | 3:23:48 | 3:23:53 | |
an NPI have held many constituents
who have been sent a demand for car | 3:23:53 | 3:23:58 | |
parking fines by a company called
civil enforcement Ltd, who are | 3:23:58 | 3:24:03 | |
contracted by my local hospital
trusts, Pennine acute, to pursue | 3:24:03 | 3:24:07 | |
those who are deemed to have
breached car parking regulations. I | 3:24:07 | 3:24:13 | |
have had constituents aggressively
chased by -- aggressively chased for | 3:24:13 | 3:24:18 | |
payment when they have inadvertently
parked in the staff parking space by | 3:24:18 | 3:24:21 | |
mistake. The practices of this
company do seem to lack the human | 3:24:21 | 3:24:26 | |
touch, most people attending
hospital usually have more important | 3:24:26 | 3:24:31 | |
matters on their mind and could be
forgiven for being slightly | 3:24:31 | 3:24:35 | |
distracted while trying to work out
the myriad instructions posted on | 3:24:35 | 3:24:38 | |
the hospital car park prior to
visiting sick relatives are going | 3:24:38 | 3:24:42 | |
for treatment themselves. The
charges can be prohibitive, £1 for | 3:24:42 | 3:24:49 | |
one hour, £4 for eight hours, £8 for
up to 24 hours. As many members have | 3:24:49 | 3:24:54 | |
pointed out, most of the time the
patient, the visitor does not know | 3:24:54 | 3:24:59 | |
how long they are going to be in the
hospital for and most people here on | 3:24:59 | 3:25:02 | |
the side of caution and pay more
than they should. The ticket | 3:25:02 | 3:25:06 | |
machines do not take banknotes, when
I worked at the hospital I was | 3:25:06 | 3:25:10 | |
regularly asked for change by
patients and visitors struggling to | 3:25:10 | 3:25:14 | |
feed these machines. And I'm sure
that all those people have more | 3:25:14 | 3:25:18 | |
important things to deal with and
could have done without additional | 3:25:18 | 3:25:22 | |
stress. I accept that my local trust
will provide a ticket for £15 and | 3:25:22 | 3:25:28 | |
will make arrangements for those
with long-term illness, but this is | 3:25:28 | 3:25:32 | |
not immediately clear to patients
and visitors and requires action on | 3:25:32 | 3:25:35 | |
their part at an already stressful
time. The motion calls upon the | 3:25:35 | 3:25:41 | |
government to provide a need whereby
car park in charges may be abolished | 3:25:41 | 3:25:46 | |
and I fully support that but
hand-in-hand with that must be an | 3:25:46 | 3:25:50 | |
improved public transport system so
that staff, patients, carers and | 3:25:50 | 3:25:54 | |
visitors are not as reliant on
private cars. Sadly in my | 3:25:54 | 3:25:59 | |
constituency we have just had a bus
service between Rochdale, Middleton | 3:25:59 | 3:26:03 | |
and North Manchester General
Hospital withdrawn. Retrograde steps | 3:26:03 | 3:26:07 | |
like this do nothing to reduce the
demand on hospital car parks, and we | 3:26:07 | 3:26:13 | |
absolutely need a comprehensive
public transport policy to support | 3:26:13 | 3:26:17 | |
the abolition of Hospital car
parking charges. And the other step | 3:26:17 | 3:26:21 | |
we need to take is to reduce the
dependence of NHS trusts upon income | 3:26:21 | 3:26:26 | |
from car parking. The Department of
Health guidelines used to stipulate | 3:26:26 | 3:26:31 | |
that income earned from car parking
should only be spent upon the | 3:26:31 | 3:26:34 | |
maintenance and running of the car
parks, however these guidelines now | 3:26:34 | 3:26:38 | |
appear to have been relaxed and
cash-strapped trust are using that | 3:26:38 | 3:26:44 | |
income for patient care. In fact
when I visited North Manchester | 3:26:44 | 3:26:47 | |
recently I was disappointed to see
our staff car park which had been in | 3:26:47 | 3:26:51 | |
a very first aid and I worked there
many years ago had been allowed to | 3:26:51 | 3:26:55 | |
deteriorate even further and clearly
not income had been spent there on | 3:26:55 | 3:26:58 | |
improving conditions for staff.
Pennine acute trust alone made £3 | 3:26:58 | 3:27:05 | |
million from car parking charges
last year, the NHS underfunding | 3:27:05 | 3:27:09 | |
issue must be addressed in any
consideration of the abolition of | 3:27:09 | 3:27:12 | |
car parking charges. Thank you very
much Madam Deputy Speaker. I would | 3:27:12 | 3:27:21 | |
like to first of all thank the
honourable member from Harlow for | 3:27:21 | 3:27:24 | |
having secured and initiated such an
important debate which affects so | 3:27:24 | 3:27:28 | |
many within my constituency and
indeed across our country. For many, | 3:27:28 | 3:27:34 | |
attending hospital is a vulnerable
time, whether seeking treatment for | 3:27:34 | 3:27:40 | |
ourselves or a loved one. Our
hospitals are indeed underfunded and | 3:27:40 | 3:27:44 | |
overstretched but it is not for sick
patients, anxious relatives and | 3:27:44 | 3:27:49 | |
already hard-pressed NHS staff to be
filling the funding gaps. We have | 3:27:49 | 3:27:54 | |
heard that hospital car parking
charges raise funds, however many | 3:27:54 | 3:28:00 | |
hospital trusts up and down the
country have increased their charges | 3:28:00 | 3:28:04 | |
without public consultation. The
very people they are there for. Some | 3:28:04 | 3:28:10 | |
trusts allow private contractors to
manage car parking sites leading to | 3:28:10 | 3:28:14 | |
penalties and points as we have
already heard in this important | 3:28:14 | 3:28:16 | |
debate, for patients and visitors.
At a time when the cost of living is | 3:28:16 | 3:28:24 | |
increasing and those who work in the
public sector have had their pay | 3:28:24 | 3:28:26 | |
capped, the rising cost of hospital
car parking increases increases the | 3:28:26 | 3:28:34 | |
financial burden on many in our
constituencies. Madam Deputy Speaker | 3:28:34 | 3:28:37 | |
it is not just the patients that are
deterred by high charges, family and | 3:28:37 | 3:28:43 | |
friends might be discouraged from
visiting patients at her bedside, | 3:28:43 | 3:28:47 | |
which must surely have a negative
impact on the mental well-being of | 3:28:47 | 3:28:50 | |
the patient. We -- and would
increase pressure on nursing staff. | 3:28:50 | 3:28:57 | |
From personal experience in that
many patients rely on relatives and | 3:28:57 | 3:29:00 | |
friends to act as interpreters or
advocates, such elements are | 3:29:00 | 3:29:05 | |
seemingly overlooked when surveys
and reports are undertaken, but | 3:29:05 | 3:29:10 | |
patient care can really be impacted
where high charges deter people from | 3:29:10 | 3:29:15 | |
providing this kind of crucial
systems. | 3:29:15 | 3:29:23 | |
Thank you I wanted to reflect on the
fact we have heard a lot about | 3:29:24 | 3:29:30 | |
staff, patients and families, we did
hear a reference about volunteers. | 3:29:30 | 3:29:35 | |
You are talking about the importance
of support for patients. Would you | 3:29:35 | 3:29:39 | |
agree with me it is therefore
particularly short-sighted that any | 3:29:39 | 3:29:44 | |
hospital trust should charge
volunteers to pay to park their car | 3:29:44 | 3:29:51 | |
when you're giving up their free
time? I couldn't agree more. We've | 3:29:51 | 3:29:58 | |
heard previously about volunteer
drivers. It is just not fair and | 3:29:58 | 3:30:04 | |
nonsensical to be asking them to dig
further into the pockets. When it | 3:30:04 | 3:30:11 | |
comes to hard-working staff who have
gone for years without a decent pay | 3:30:11 | 3:30:16 | |
rise, they also face this is unfair
and unnecessary burden. Some | 3:30:16 | 3:30:21 | |
hospitals offer free or discounted
parking, in relation to specific | 3:30:21 | 3:30:26 | |
kinds of treatment or four people in
receipt of specific benefits. There | 3:30:26 | 3:30:31 | |
are significant variations in fees
across trusts in the same region. | 3:30:31 | 3:30:36 | |
Wrexham Park hospital in my
constituency has some of the highest | 3:30:36 | 3:30:41 | |
parking charges in the region. £3
after the first 30 minutes and an | 3:30:41 | 3:30:50 | |
increase to £8 for five hours. That
trust is only doing what is being | 3:30:50 | 3:30:56 | |
done by all other trusts within
government guidelines. What I do not | 3:30:56 | 3:31:02 | |
want is for older and vulnerable
patients to be deterred from | 3:31:02 | 3:31:06 | |
attending hospital. We should be
able to get their appointment and | 3:31:06 | 3:31:09 | |
are comfortable, dignified and
affordable manner, and within a | 3:31:09 | 3:31:14 | |
reasonable time. Most NHS car
parking charges have been abolished | 3:31:14 | 3:31:18 | |
in Scotland and Wales. And I know
the government has issued guidance | 3:31:18 | 3:31:24 | |
to NHS Trusts on the implementation
of car parking charges, including | 3:31:24 | 3:31:29 | |
the provision of discounted or free
parking. These guidelines are not | 3:31:29 | 3:31:36 | |
based on legislation and appear to
have had little effect. The Labour | 3:31:36 | 3:31:42 | |
government in 2010 left fully costed
plans to phase out the charges in | 3:31:42 | 3:31:48 | |
patients and their visitors. In
2015, a Private Members' Bill gained | 3:31:48 | 3:31:54 | |
cross-party support published
October. Clearly, many across the | 3:31:54 | 3:31:59 | |
country in the House want to see an
end to hospital parking charges. | 3:31:59 | 3:32:04 | |
Let's send a clear message today
that there is another way for word. | 3:32:04 | 3:32:10 | |
And this tax on the vulnerable must
end. Thank you. Thank you. It's a | 3:32:10 | 3:32:20 | |
pleasure to follow the honourable
member for Slough and also can I | 3:32:20 | 3:32:24 | |
commend the Member for Harlow on his
extremely powerful speech and for | 3:32:24 | 3:32:29 | |
raising this very important issue?
Congratulations. My daughter started | 3:32:29 | 3:32:39 | |
to show signs of acute appendicitis.
We could quickly bundled our | 3:32:39 | 3:32:45 | |
daughter in agony into the car,
drove to the hospital, not a calm | 3:32:45 | 3:32:50 | |
journey, and I'm sure there are many
members of the House have had some | 3:32:50 | 3:32:53 | |
sort of experience along those
lines. Panicking, we were scrambling | 3:32:53 | 3:32:58 | |
for change, taking it in turns to
move the car or top of the ticket. | 3:32:58 | 3:33:08 | |
Obviously this was a one off and
bearable. Sadly for many it is not a | 3:33:08 | 3:33:12 | |
one-off experience Andrew to chronic
illness they are forced to take | 3:33:12 | 3:33:17 | |
several trips a week. People going
through the worst of times. This | 3:33:17 | 3:33:21 | |
cynical approach of charging them to
park is unacceptable. Being ill is | 3:33:21 | 3:33:26 | |
not anyone's choice and should not
be exploited. New figures show money | 3:33:26 | 3:33:32 | |
brought in from NHS car park run by
private firms has increased by half | 3:33:32 | 3:33:39 | |
£1 million everyday. It is
equivalent to 0.0001% of NHS | 3:33:39 | 3:33:55 | |
spending but private companies
pocket most of the benefits. Past | 3:33:55 | 3:34:09 | |
NHS parking staff get parking
charges deducted from their wages, | 3:34:09 | 3:34:16 | |
sometimes when they can't find a
space in the correct pay, they get | 3:34:16 | 3:34:21 | |
fined for parking in the wrong way.
In my constituency, the bus that | 3:34:21 | 3:34:26 | |
used to connect our local hospital
has been cancelled, forcing more | 3:34:26 | 3:34:34 | |
people to use car, incurring parking
costs. My own hospital charges after | 3:34:34 | 3:34:46 | |
20 minutes. There is a reduction on
blue badge holders, but we still | 3:34:46 | 3:34:49 | |
have to pay. There is a stress
inducing pay on exit system and it | 3:34:49 | 3:34:56 | |
is quite a complex process to get
car parking concessions approved by | 3:34:56 | 3:35:01 | |
hospital staff on the day. Not an
ideal situation. I will give way. | 3:35:01 | 3:35:09 | |
Does she agree with me that in the
21st-century means testing at the | 3:35:09 | 3:35:14 | |
point of delivery, which is what we
are talking about here, is morally | 3:35:14 | 3:35:19 | |
unacceptable in an NHS that we
should be proud of? I'm so glad he | 3:35:19 | 3:35:25 | |
raced that. This concession is only
available to the patient and not to | 3:35:25 | 3:35:28 | |
the low paid and might have driven
that patient there are. So whilst | 3:35:28 | 3:35:32 | |
you are the probably person, you're
the one who has to go and get the | 3:35:32 | 3:35:40 | |
concession for the car parking. It's
unfair. After a Freedom of | 3:35:40 | 3:35:44 | |
information request by Unison, it
was revealed that some people are | 3:35:44 | 3:35:49 | |
being charged up to £100 per month.
Costs for parking impact on | 3:35:49 | 3:35:59 | |
surrounding streets. I have been
contacted by local residents | 3:35:59 | 3:36:03 | |
complaining that those who cannot
afford car parking charges are think | 3:36:03 | 3:36:07 | |
he might have to stay for several
hours are parking on the residential | 3:36:07 | 3:36:12 | |
streets, blocking their driveways
and making it difficult to park | 3:36:12 | 3:36:15 | |
outside their own homes. Free
hospital parking would end this. | 3:36:15 | 3:36:21 | |
Whilst we now trusts are struggling
to balance the books after years of | 3:36:21 | 3:36:27 | |
underfunding by this government, we
must ensure they are not forced to | 3:36:27 | 3:36:31 | |
fill this gap by charging sick and
pearly patients, their visitors and | 3:36:31 | 3:36:36 | |
relatives and hard-pressed NHS
staff. Car parking charges are an | 3:36:36 | 3:36:44 | |
attack on serious illness. Labour
would raise insurance tax on private | 3:36:44 | 3:36:50 | |
health care to 20% to meet the £162
million worth of parking charges at | 3:36:50 | 3:36:58 | |
NHS hospitals across England.
Charities, trade unions and the | 3:36:58 | 3:37:06 | |
public are all Colin out for this
government to please listen. In | 3:37:06 | 3:37:12 | |
Scotland and Wales, they have
appointed -- abolished car parking | 3:37:12 | 3:37:17 | |
charges in all but a handful of
hospitals. We should show some | 3:37:17 | 3:37:24 | |
humanity and do the same. I support
this motion. I congratulate the | 3:37:24 | 3:37:30 | |
Member for Harlow for securing this
important debate. It is clear from | 3:37:30 | 3:37:36 | |
speakers that the scandal of
hospital parking charges must come | 3:37:36 | 3:37:40 | |
to an end. Gravely ill people or
people visiting relatives must not | 3:37:40 | 3:37:45 | |
be treated as cash cows by hospital
parking operators. Last year, half | 3:37:45 | 3:37:52 | |
of all trusts charge disabled people
for parking in some or all of their | 3:37:52 | 3:37:57 | |
disabled parking spaces. Winning to
redress this ridiculous | 3:37:57 | 3:38:01 | |
inconsistency of the situation that
in Wales and Scotland hospital | 3:38:01 | 3:38:06 | |
parking is mainly free, but in
Northern Ireland and England, trusts | 3:38:06 | 3:38:11 | |
charge for parking. It's time that
all hospitals abolished parking fees | 3:38:11 | 3:38:15 | |
and drivers must not be punished for
being sick, visiting loved ones or | 3:38:15 | 3:38:21 | |
attending appointments. People don't
choose to be ill and should not be | 3:38:21 | 3:38:25 | |
asked to pay for a hospital visit.
In my constituency, I've been | 3:38:25 | 3:38:29 | |
approached by many constituents over
this issue. Mother contacted me to | 3:38:29 | 3:38:34 | |
say that after her husband took
their son to accident and emergency | 3:38:34 | 3:38:38 | |
with breathing difficulties in the
middle of the night, he was later | 3:38:38 | 3:38:41 | |
presented with a parking charge
notice. I don't believe people | 3:38:41 | 3:38:47 | |
rushing to hospital with gravely ill
children should be put in the | 3:38:47 | 3:38:50 | |
position of having to worry about
such matters. Imagine if my | 3:38:50 | 3:38:54 | |
constituent had spent extra precious
moments scrambling for change for | 3:38:54 | 3:38:59 | |
parking while his son struggle to
breathe. With that have been | 3:38:59 | 3:39:03 | |
sensible or responsible thing for a
parent of a seriously ill child to | 3:39:03 | 3:39:07 | |
do? Of course not. If that reason
why we must get rid of these | 3:39:07 | 3:39:15 | |
charges. Been contacted by a father
who had to take his young daughter | 3:39:15 | 3:39:17 | |
to the emergency department. He had
to leave and return to his daughter | 3:39:17 | 3:39:23 | |
throughout the night in order to
feed more money into the car park | 3:39:23 | 3:39:26 | |
metre. She was being kept in for a
long period of time. My constituent | 3:39:26 | 3:39:30 | |
kept paying at the machines, which
failed to give him the seats when | 3:39:30 | 3:39:36 | |
requested. He was unsure of the
times he had left. He reported that | 3:39:36 | 3:39:42 | |
seeing other people in various
states of distress walking around | 3:39:42 | 3:39:45 | |
the car park, they all seemed unsure
of what to do. Two weeks later, he | 3:39:45 | 3:39:51 | |
received the parking notice, telling
him he had not paid for all the time | 3:39:51 | 3:39:54 | |
he had been in the car park. We must
ask, is this an appropriate way to | 3:39:54 | 3:39:59 | |
treat the parents of very ill
children? We've heard in the press | 3:39:59 | 3:40:05 | |
about desperately ill patients
forced to quit work are left with | 3:40:05 | 3:40:09 | |
bills for hundreds of pounds due to
frequent hospital visits. Then there | 3:40:09 | 3:40:13 | |
are hugely unfair cases of NHS staff
who have had parking charges | 3:40:13 | 3:40:19 | |
deducted from their wages but have
been unable to get a space and have | 3:40:19 | 3:40:22 | |
been fined for parking in the wrong
way. I've been contacted by several | 3:40:22 | 3:40:30 | |
elderly patients about this issue.
This Sunday is world cancer day. I'm | 3:40:30 | 3:40:36 | |
sure many of us know people who've
had treatment for cancer. Anyone | 3:40:36 | 3:40:44 | |
knows the effects of chemotherapy
and how debilitating treatment can | 3:40:44 | 3:40:48 | |
be. They will often need a carer
with them to make the journey home. | 3:40:48 | 3:40:53 | |
Considering the frequency of
treatments for cancer and other | 3:40:53 | 3:40:56 | |
illnesses, surely car parking
charges are nothing more than a tax | 3:40:56 | 3:41:04 | |
on the sick? Many people have no
choice but to drive to the local | 3:41:04 | 3:41:08 | |
hospital, due to the infrequency of
public transport. Thank you for | 3:41:08 | 3:41:13 | |
giving way. He has spoken about the
difficulty of travel. Does he agree | 3:41:13 | 3:41:17 | |
with me that the reduction in bus
services in many areas have cost to | 3:41:17 | 3:41:21 | |
be no alternative to parking on
hospital car parks? In a | 3:41:21 | 3:41:29 | |
constituency like mine, it means
frequent journeys for people who | 3:41:29 | 3:41:34 | |
require treatment. She makes an
excellent point. People in rural | 3:41:34 | 3:41:39 | |
areas or areas far away from a local
hospital, they are unfairly affected | 3:41:39 | 3:41:45 | |
by the situation of having transport
networks, to ferry them to hospital. | 3:41:45 | 3:41:50 | |
So they have no choice but to by
car. The Right honourable member for | 3:41:50 | 3:41:56 | |
Hemel Hempstead net a valid point
about other emergency workers not | 3:41:56 | 3:42:01 | |
been required to pay for parking at
police or fire stations. In | 3:42:01 | 3:42:06 | |
addition, hospital staff are
reducing the number of spaces for | 3:42:06 | 3:42:11 | |
patients and visitors. NHS staff
should be able to park free, but we | 3:42:11 | 3:42:17 | |
should also be able to afford to
live nearer to the hospital. It's | 3:42:17 | 3:42:23 | |
therefore ironic wearing a situation
whereby NHS Trust are forced to sell | 3:42:23 | 3:42:27 | |
land they could have been used to
house NHS staff locally. Another | 3:42:27 | 3:42:32 | |
pressure on my local hospital has
been the fact that as the A&E | 3:42:32 | 3:42:39 | |
department at another hospital has
been closed, it has resulted in more | 3:42:39 | 3:42:44 | |
visitors to the A&E department at
North Middlesex. Between Christmas | 3:42:44 | 3:42:49 | |
and New Year, the hospital ran out
of acute beds. One can only imagine | 3:42:49 | 3:42:54 | |
how busy the car park was during
that period. It is time these unfair | 3:42:54 | 3:43:04 | |
charges were scrapped and the NHS
was properly funded. For the sake of | 3:43:04 | 3:43:10 | |
NHS staff, parents and visitors. I
asked the Minister to bring forward | 3:43:10 | 3:43:16 | |
measures to scrap car parking
charges as soon as possible. | 3:43:16 | 3:43:23 | |
Many thanks, it is an honour to
speak in this debate and indeed any | 3:43:23 | 3:43:28 | |
debate where the NHS is at the heart
of what we are discussing. I would | 3:43:28 | 3:43:32 | |
like to thank the honourable member
for Harlow for bringing the debate, | 3:43:32 | 3:43:36 | |
it is extremely important as has
already been discussed, it is | 3:43:36 | 3:43:41 | |
important to patients, charities,
emergency workers, to our volunteers | 3:43:41 | 3:43:46 | |
and carers and our NHS staff so it
is a credit to the honourable member | 3:43:46 | 3:43:50 | |
that he has brought this debate. He
set out his case elegantly and | 3:43:50 | 3:43:55 | |
offensively. The SNP Scottish
Government as has already been | 3:43:55 | 3:43:59 | |
mentioned scrapped hospital car
parking charges approximately ten | 3:43:59 | 3:44:02 | |
years ago in all car parks and by
the NHS is all I would urge the UK | 3:44:02 | 3:44:06 | |
Government to follow both this
principle and policy. As an NHS | 3:44:06 | 3:44:12 | |
employee for over 20 years I must
declare an interest. I was part of | 3:44:12 | 3:44:17 | |
the campaign all those many years
ago to scrap the NHS parking charges | 3:44:17 | 3:44:23 | |
as at Unite grep and I was so
pleased when we succeeded because it | 3:44:23 | 3:44:27 | |
has made a great difference to so
many people and has saved some of | 3:44:27 | 3:44:31 | |
the most vulnerable from spending
money on parking when they are | 3:44:31 | 3:44:35 | |
already facing so many difficulties
financially. She has kindly been | 3:44:35 | 3:44:43 | |
generous in giving way and I thank
her for her remarks. Would you not | 3:44:43 | 3:44:46 | |
agree that actively given that the
hospital parking charges for the | 3:44:46 | 3:44:51 | |
most part have been scrapped in
Scotland you have been able to do | 3:44:51 | 3:44:54 | |
with the problems of people possibly
misusing the car parks for shopping | 3:44:54 | 3:44:57 | |
and whatever the needy? I thank the
honourable member and indeed | 3:44:57 | 3:45:05 | |
whenever there is a welfare is away
with this one. It can happen and can | 3:45:05 | 3:45:08 | |
be done and it is a matter of
prioritising it in terms of making | 3:45:08 | 3:45:12 | |
it happen and that is something that
we can raise a point with the | 3:45:12 | 3:45:18 | |
Minister today. As we have heard,
the changes, the charges in the | 3:45:18 | 3:45:26 | |
hospital prior to the changes hit
the most vulnerable people in our | 3:45:26 | 3:45:31 | |
society and disabled people, those
were chronically ill and those who | 3:45:31 | 3:45:33 | |
act cannily ill including families
caring for terminally ill children, | 3:45:33 | 3:45:40 | |
those who require repeat
appointments and mentally hospital | 3:45:40 | 3:45:42 | |
stays. Like one of the other members
who raised the issue earlier I also | 3:45:42 | 3:45:47 | |
heard of families have their cars
impounded because they were in the | 3:45:47 | 3:45:51 | |
maternity unit, and their partner
was giving birth and it did not go | 3:45:51 | 3:45:56 | |
quite to time as these things often
don't do, Madam Deputy Speaker, and | 3:45:56 | 3:46:00 | |
they were unable to feed the meter.
So at a time of utmost family | 3:46:00 | 3:46:05 | |
importance that is one of the last
things that you want to have on your | 3:46:05 | 3:46:08 | |
mind. NHS staff, particularly those
on community-based shifts are often | 3:46:08 | 3:46:15 | |
penalised and often have no choice
but to use their cars from hospital | 3:46:15 | 3:46:19 | |
to community visits and therefore
cannot travel by public transport to | 3:46:19 | 3:46:22 | |
the hospital-based. There is
fundamentally something wrong with | 3:46:22 | 3:46:27 | |
charging our valued NHS staff to get
to their work saving lives when | 3:46:27 | 3:46:32 | |
their pay has already been affected
for so many years by caps. The SNP | 3:46:32 | 3:46:38 | |
are clear that the founding
principle of the NHS is to have | 3:46:38 | 3:46:42 | |
services that are free for everyone,
services that are not out for | 3:46:42 | 3:46:46 | |
profit, and we have heard today from
honourable members that sometimes it | 3:46:46 | 3:46:49 | |
has even been cheaper to park town
centres Andrew Parker hospitals, | 3:46:49 | 3:46:53 | |
that cannot be right. So by 2015 we
understand that getting rid of | 3:46:53 | 3:47:03 | |
hospital charges has saved staff in
hospital over £25 million. Parking | 3:47:03 | 3:47:07 | |
charges are basically a tax on NHS
treatment and it cannot be allowed | 3:47:07 | 3:47:12 | |
to go on. As chair of the all-party
Parliamentary group for disability | 3:47:12 | 3:47:17 | |
and protect -- I am particularly
concerned that people with | 3:47:17 | 3:47:20 | |
disabilities who we know are more
likely to speed poverty are being | 3:47:20 | 3:47:23 | |
doubly financially penalised if they
require medical treatment and having | 3:47:23 | 3:47:28 | |
in England to pay for hospital
parking. The honourable member for | 3:47:28 | 3:47:34 | |
Harlow is correct, there are
pragmatic ways to address the issue. | 3:47:34 | 3:47:39 | |
The issues that are raised which are
set to repeat and prevent this | 3:47:39 | 3:47:44 | |
coming about can be overcome. We
discussed tokens and other such | 3:47:44 | 3:47:49 | |
ideas and these are all pragmatic
and can be put in place and can | 3:47:49 | 3:47:52 | |
work. We have made it work, we have
made it a success and it can happen | 3:47:52 | 3:47:57 | |
with the will. I would like to take
a brief moment if I need to extend | 3:47:57 | 3:48:02 | |
the issue from hospital parking
charges to also address parking for | 3:48:02 | 3:48:06 | |
NHS staff in health centres. All are
free I believe in my own | 3:48:06 | 3:48:12 | |
constituency, aside from the new
Hunter health centre of the story | 3:48:12 | 3:48:15 | |
car park. I have been in somewhat
intransigent negotiations with NHS | 3:48:15 | 3:48:22 | |
Lanarkshire for over a year now as
only a limited amount of permanent | 3:48:22 | 3:48:26 | |
parking has been made available for
staff. This has unfortunately meant | 3:48:26 | 3:48:30 | |
that some staff often in lower pay
bands such as administration staff | 3:48:30 | 3:48:37 | |
have extortionate weekly charges for
getting to work. I believe it is | 3:48:37 | 3:48:41 | |
unprincipled, it is also unfair and
why should we penalised staff who | 3:48:41 | 3:48:45 | |
work in a particular health centre?
I have taken on my Friday, Madam | 3:48:45 | 3:48:52 | |
Deputy Speaker, to monitoring the
free spaces on the car park and I | 3:48:52 | 3:48:57 | |
can assure the house that it is half
empty every single Friday, it is an | 3:48:57 | 3:49:02 | |
extremely busy day usually elsewhere
for car parks so there are enough | 3:49:02 | 3:49:07 | |
spaces for staff. I would urge the
NHS Chief Executive once again to | 3:49:07 | 3:49:14 | |
reverse the decision and ensure that
permits for staff as requested are | 3:49:14 | 3:49:21 | |
restored and that this principle
step is taken. Again I am writing to | 3:49:21 | 3:49:26 | |
him after this debate which I'm sure
he will look forward to the ways | 3:49:26 | 3:49:32 | |
does and I will let him know that he
has been mentioned in the House of | 3:49:32 | 3:49:36 | |
Commons once again. So I would like
to just some of my thank you to all | 3:49:36 | 3:49:44 | |
of the honourable members have taken
part from all sides of a house in | 3:49:44 | 3:49:48 | |
today's debate, the honourable
member for Great Grimsby and great | 3:49:48 | 3:49:51 | |
Telfer, the honourable member for
Kingston-upon-Hull, from Cleethorpes | 3:49:51 | 3:49:54 | |
who actually raised important issues
about people in rural areas being | 3:49:54 | 3:50:00 | |
badly affected, the honourable
member for the coal Valley, the law | 3:50:00 | 3:50:04 | |
member from Hemel Hempstead who
spoke about volunteer drivers which | 3:50:04 | 3:50:07 | |
I think is an extremely pertinent
point. The honourable member for | 3:50:07 | 3:50:10 | |
Hayward and Middleton who worked
with NHS as a fellow Unite grep in | 3:50:10 | 3:50:16 | |
my time at who has done great work
in her years for the NHS. The | 3:50:16 | 3:50:20 | |
honourable member for Slough and
spent her for Enfield Southgate. | 3:50:20 | 3:50:28 | |
Everyone who has spoken has urged
the government to act. We do not | 3:50:28 | 3:50:32 | |
need any superficial metric but we
do need action. So I would ask the | 3:50:32 | 3:50:37 | |
Minister and the government to act
by putting NHS patients, staff, | 3:50:37 | 3:50:42 | |
carers and relatives and volunteers
first. Our emergency workers and | 3:50:42 | 3:50:47 | |
those who care about NHS are all
request in change and this must be | 3:50:47 | 3:50:53 | |
taken forward and I trust that the
Minister will do so. Thank you. I am | 3:50:53 | 3:51:04 | |
really pleased to have the
opportunity to reply in this debate | 3:51:04 | 3:51:06 | |
on this very important subject. I am
grateful to the honourable member | 3:51:06 | 3:51:11 | |
for Harlow for bringing this subject
forward. I know that he and I agree | 3:51:11 | 3:51:20 | |
on most aspects of the subject. I am
grateful to members on all sides of | 3:51:20 | 3:51:28 | |
the house, it seems that there is
much agreement you today and it is | 3:51:28 | 3:51:31 | |
heartening to see members raising
the issues of the impact and | 3:51:31 | 3:51:36 | |
understanding of the impact of -- on
patients and carers and NHS staff. | 3:51:36 | 3:51:42 | |
The member for Great Grimsby also
made the point of the effect on | 3:51:42 | 3:51:48 | |
greater transportation system and
how that ought to be impacted. | 3:51:48 | 3:51:53 | |
Powerful speeches were made from the
member from Telford and Cleethorpes | 3:51:53 | 3:51:56 | |
in the com ballet, accused the
system of being one of profiteering. | 3:51:56 | 3:52:01 | |
A very important point made an heavy
stuff here from Middleton and the | 3:52:01 | 3:52:06 | |
member for how Hamstead on the
burden of having to pay for going to | 3:52:06 | 3:52:11 | |
work. Raising the issues of personal
family issues where people are taken | 3:52:11 | 3:52:20 | |
away from a Sikh family member's bed
to replenish parking meters. I would | 3:52:20 | 3:52:27 | |
like to say no one likes to pay to
park, to pay to park at a hospital | 3:52:27 | 3:52:32 | |
really does add insult to injury. We
are not talking about a luxury | 3:52:32 | 3:52:38 | |
experience, a shopping trip or fun
night out. We are talking about | 3:52:38 | 3:52:41 | |
paying to visit a hospital where
people are not queueing up to go to | 3:52:41 | 3:52:47 | |
the hospital cafe as people pointed
out. No one goes to the hospital | 3:52:47 | 3:52:50 | |
because they want to, they go
because they are sick. They go for | 3:52:50 | 3:52:55 | |
treatment, surged, chemotherapy,
dialysis, and they go to visit loved | 3:52:55 | 3:52:58 | |
ones. Hospitals are not destinations
of choice. People go because they | 3:52:58 | 3:53:04 | |
must and I am quite shocked that it
is free to park at the local | 3:53:04 | 3:53:09 | |
shopping centre but I must pay to
park at my local hospital. During | 3:53:09 | 3:53:14 | |
the last three years I have spent
hours and hours visiting my mother | 3:53:14 | 3:53:18 | |
in hospital. I have often gone
backwards or forwards to three times | 3:53:18 | 3:53:23 | |
a day sitting in hospital visits
roadwork and other commitments and I | 3:53:23 | 3:53:25 | |
must say it is all very distressing.
And as I leave the hospital each | 3:53:25 | 3:53:29 | |
night worried, wondering what
tomorrow will bring, the last thing | 3:53:29 | 3:53:34 | |
I want to do is stand outside in the
cold queueing to pay for my parking. | 3:53:34 | 3:53:40 | |
This burden is of course in addition
to the actual cost. Some car parks | 3:53:40 | 3:53:46 | |
demand payment in advance as we have
heard tonight and this brings its | 3:53:46 | 3:53:49 | |
own set of problems where patients
and visitors must judge how long | 3:53:49 | 3:53:52 | |
each hospital visit the last and
then have to leave the water and | 3:53:52 | 3:53:56 | |
treatment room to feed the ever
hungry parking machine. Of course | 3:53:56 | 3:54:00 | |
running to and from the car park
when hooked onto dialysis machine. | 3:54:00 | 3:54:07 | |
Many dialysis patients suffer from
multiple conditions and so paying to | 3:54:07 | 3:54:11 | |
park the times a week for dialysis
sessions each lasting 4-5 hours is a | 3:54:11 | 3:54:16 | |
real financial burden for them and
their carers. People in my | 3:54:16 | 3:54:23 | |
constituency are on a weekly Carer's
Allowance and say they are forced to | 3:54:23 | 3:54:28 | |
give up work to provide
round-the-clock care for her husband | 3:54:28 | 3:54:30 | |
who suffered a stroke. He has been
in hospital. She has been in | 3:54:30 | 3:54:36 | |
hospital for two or three hours a
day to comfort her husband. This | 3:54:36 | 3:54:41 | |
cost £20 per week at the time she
has paid for petrol have for | 3:54:41 | 3:54:44 | |
allowances gone. We have a National
Health Service that was set up to be | 3:54:44 | 3:54:49 | |
free at the point of delivery,
established in 1948 to make health | 3:54:49 | 3:54:52 | |
care are right for all. That is not
what is happening. Even though | 3:54:52 | 3:54:56 | |
hospital car parking is free in
Scotland and Wales during England | 3:54:56 | 3:55:00 | |
hospital users are forced to pay off
an extortionate rates, charges | 3:55:00 | 3:55:04 | |
varying from £1 50 per hour to £4
per hour. We are charging the | 3:55:04 | 3:55:10 | |
chronically ill, the terminally ill,
their carers and visitors over half | 3:55:10 | 3:55:15 | |
of those aged over 76 years have
conditions that require regular | 3:55:15 | 3:55:20 | |
hospital appointments. Hospital car
parking charges are an extra burden | 3:55:20 | 3:55:22 | |
for them and their families. The
Alzheimer Society report that their | 3:55:22 | 3:55:26 | |
patients with dementia stay 5-7
times longer in hospital than other | 3:55:26 | 3:55:31 | |
patients aged over 65 and hospitals
can be frightening places for those | 3:55:31 | 3:55:35 | |
with these conditions. Rely on
family and carers visiting to give | 3:55:35 | 3:55:39 | |
them support. Parking charges are an
extra burden that these families | 3:55:39 | 3:55:44 | |
could do without. The Patients'
Association commented that for | 3:55:44 | 3:55:48 | |
patients parking charges and
genetics of charge for being ill, | 3:55:48 | 3:55:52 | |
appointment of delayed last longer
than the expected to sort even if | 3:55:52 | 3:55:54 | |
you're paying for parking you could
end up being fined when you click it | 3:55:54 | 3:55:58 | |
runs out. Visiting hospital is
stressful enough. But Cancer | 3:55:58 | 3:56:05 | |
support, the corporate blogs NHS is
to provide key health -- free health | 3:56:05 | 3:56:10 | |
care for all of the point of access.
But many are paying extortionate car | 3:56:10 | 3:56:14 | |
parking charges in order to access
treatment for life-threatening | 3:56:14 | 3:56:17 | |
diseases. Bliss, the charity for
babies born prematurely or sick said | 3:56:17 | 3:56:25 | |
that the very real cost having a
premature or sick baby can | 3:56:25 | 3:56:28 | |
contribute to the financial burden
many families face when their babies | 3:56:28 | 3:56:31 | |
need neo-natal care. In the midst of
this misery the average hospital | 3:56:31 | 3:56:37 | |
clusters making £1 million of profit
from car parking charges, and | 3:56:37 | 3:56:41 | |
several hospitals the length and
breadth of the country report | 3:56:41 | 3:56:43 | |
profits of over £3 million. Last
year NHS hospitals made a record 100 | 3:56:43 | 3:56:50 | |
and some did for million from
charging patients visitors and | 3:56:50 | 3:56:53 | |
staff. -- 174 million. Some people
point out that public transport is | 3:56:53 | 3:56:59 | |
an option that avoid parking charges
in me say this, public transport | 3:56:59 | 3:57:03 | |
provision has been reduced in
response to funding cuts but even | 3:57:03 | 3:57:06 | |
where it exists there are many
further this is not an option. Some | 3:57:06 | 3:57:12 | |
patients are too unwell or frail to
travel on a bus and others including | 3:57:12 | 3:57:16 | |
cancer patients attending for
chemotherapy have reduced in unity | 3:57:16 | 3:57:20 | |
and must avoid contact with the
general public. You are making a | 3:57:20 | 3:57:26 | |
compelling case like most have here
today. Public transport has its | 3:57:26 | 3:57:30 | |
place for outpatients and things
like that where it is available. | 3:57:30 | 3:57:32 | |
Imagine going into labour and think
and I wait for the number two bus, | 3:57:32 | 3:57:38 | |
please? This is farcical. We need
car parks to be there for people | 3:57:38 | 3:57:42 | |
when we need them other than as a
cash cow. Thank you I entirely agree | 3:57:42 | 3:57:46 | |
with the honourable gentleman.
Further to this I would say there | 3:57:46 | 3:57:52 | |
are other people, patients and
carers who are often balancing work | 3:57:52 | 3:57:56 | |
and other commitments who have time
-- tight time schedule is that | 3:57:56 | 3:58:02 | |
preclude public transport. I have
spoken to parents of a terminally | 3:58:02 | 3:58:08 | |
ill child who only left their
child's bedside to tend to the needs | 3:58:08 | 3:58:11 | |
of the other children. There has
been no discussion of cause of | 3:58:11 | 3:58:16 | |
hospital car parking charges that
would be complete without | 3:58:16 | 3:58:19 | |
consideration of the impact on NHS
staff as has been mentioned earlier. | 3:58:19 | 3:58:25 | |
Staff who pay to go to work and who
are not guaranteed a space. Some | 3:58:25 | 3:58:33 | |
hospital staff his chef overruns
because attending to the needs of | 3:58:33 | 3:58:38 | |
patients face fines for overstaying
their parking time. This is clearly | 3:58:38 | 3:58:41 | |
no way to treat health
professionals, no wonder we face a | 3:58:41 | 3:58:47 | |
crisis in retention. Governor action
has been limited to a series of | 3:58:47 | 3:58:52 | |
recommendations in relation to
hospital car parking. The government | 3:58:52 | 3:58:55 | |
recommends that the hospital car
parking charges should not be | 3:58:55 | 3:58:57 | |
applied to blue badge holders,
carers, visitors with relatives who | 3:58:57 | 3:59:01 | |
are gravely ill and patients are
frequent outpatient appointments. In | 3:59:01 | 3:59:06 | |
reality these recommendations came
for very little and in fact the | 3:59:06 | 3:59:09 | |
trend is to increase car parking
charges and to reduce the number of | 3:59:09 | 3:59:12 | |
those who are exempt. Many hospital
trusts have even begun to charge | 3:59:12 | 3:59:15 | |
without all this. It is not good
enough for the government to | 3:59:15 | 3:59:20 | |
abdicate response ability. This is a
matter of principle. Scandalously, | 3:59:20 | 3:59:24 | |
Conservative members have argued in
this chamber on previous occasions | 3:59:24 | 3:59:28 | |
that the NHS needs the income from
car parking. I have no doubt that | 3:59:28 | 3:59:34 | |
the NHS needs this revenue, it is
common knowledge that since 2010 the | 3:59:34 | 3:59:38 | |
service has been starved of funding.
I would ask, is it right that we | 3:59:38 | 3:59:42 | |
fund our health service by taxing
sick? | 3:59:42 | 3:59:50 | |
We on the Labour benches while none
of this. I'm proud of the next | 3:59:50 | 3:59:53 | |
Labour government will ensure a red
-- our NHS is properly funded and we | 3:59:53 | 4:00:01 | |
will abolish all parking charges at
hospitals. No hospital will lose | 4:00:01 | 4:00:07 | |
funding as a result of our policy.
In 2015, I asked the government to | 4:00:07 | 4:00:14 | |
exempt carers from hospital car
parking charges. At that time, that | 4:00:14 | 4:00:19 | |
relatively modest proposal was met
with derision from the government | 4:00:19 | 4:00:23 | |
benches. My attempt to help to
remove this financial burden was | 4:00:23 | 4:00:27 | |
dismissed as a worthy aim but not
worthy enough for the government to | 4:00:27 | 4:00:33 | |
support. Conservative members went
to great lengths to top the bill out | 4:00:33 | 4:00:36 | |
of time. I hope times have changed.
Today I'm asking along with the | 4:00:36 | 4:00:42 | |
honourable member for Harlow that
the government move to remove all | 4:00:42 | 4:00:47 | |
car parking charges at NHS
hospitals. Today we ask the | 4:00:47 | 4:00:51 | |
government to do the decent thing,
to remove this tax on the sick and | 4:00:51 | 4:00:56 | |
take action to ensure we truly have
an NHS free at the point of access. | 4:00:56 | 4:01:04 | |
Thank you. Me I begin by commending
the Member for Harlow on securing | 4:01:04 | 4:01:10 | |
this debate. It is an issue on which
I think members across the House | 4:01:10 | 4:01:17 | |
recognise Yes campaign and for some
time. And an issue on which he has | 4:01:17 | 4:01:24 | |
already had some success, as
reflected in government guidelines | 4:01:24 | 4:01:29 | |
issued in 2004. And I think it's
right in light of the concerns | 4:01:29 | 4:01:32 | |
raised across the House that this
issue is revisited. And I think | 4:01:32 | 4:01:37 | |
that's been reflected in what has
been a constructive debate on behalf | 4:01:37 | 4:01:41 | |
of the backbench committee and a
member or members of the House who | 4:01:41 | 4:01:45 | |
have contributed and informed the
House through their experience of | 4:01:45 | 4:01:49 | |
what is happening in their own
constituencies. I don't think there | 4:01:49 | 4:01:53 | |
is any issue anywhere in the House
on the desirability of scrapping car | 4:01:53 | 4:02:00 | |
parking charges. I think all of us
as English members of Parliament, I | 4:02:00 | 4:02:07 | |
know amongst SNP colleagues it will
be different, but the Member for | 4:02:07 | 4:02:11 | |
Great Grimsby said we pay these
charges and we know they are | 4:02:11 | 4:02:21 | |
unpopular with constituents. They
are a concern for staff working hard | 4:02:21 | 4:02:26 | |
within the NHS. As the Member for
Hemel Hempstead highlighted, they | 4:02:26 | 4:02:33 | |
also predate this government. This
has been an issue that has long been | 4:02:33 | 4:02:38 | |
debated on the House and has been
debated with the parties on | 4:02:38 | 4:02:42 | |
respective sides of the House. I
don't think the issue is the | 4:02:42 | 4:02:47 | |
desirability of what is shot by the
Member for Harlow, the issue is the | 4:02:47 | 4:02:53 | |
execution. How would that be done in
a way that does not cause unintended | 4:02:53 | 4:02:56 | |
consequences? And how might that be
mitigated if their were to be the | 4:02:56 | 4:03:02 | |
case? I think we got a flavour of
some of those unintended | 4:03:02 | 4:03:09 | |
consequences from contributions from
members constructively across the | 4:03:09 | 4:03:11 | |
House. Implicit in the motion is
that car parking charges are applied | 4:03:11 | 4:03:18 | |
to all NHS hospitals, or the
impression from the debate. As you | 4:03:18 | 4:03:28 | |
will be well aware, 67% of NHS sites
don't charge at all at present. So | 4:03:28 | 4:03:34 | |
we are talking about a sub sect
within the NHS where charges apply. | 4:03:34 | 4:03:41 | |
Albeit that is concentrated amongst
the acute sector. For example, | 4:03:41 | 4:03:49 | |
mental health patients are often the
most vulnerable constituents seeking | 4:03:49 | 4:03:56 | |
support do not face charges because
those parking facilities are not | 4:03:56 | 4:04:00 | |
charged. So this tends to be an
issue within the acute sector. I | 4:04:00 | 4:04:06 | |
thank him for his kind words but I
have to say I disagree with what he | 4:04:06 | 4:04:10 | |
has just set. Hospital car parking
charges in England are widespread. | 4:04:10 | 4:04:15 | |
You have to go from one hospital to
another. 50% of hospitals are | 4:04:15 | 4:04:24 | |
charging the disabled, for example.
It is a statement of fact confirmed | 4:04:24 | 4:04:31 | |
by my officials that 67% of NHS
sites do not charged. The definition | 4:04:31 | 4:04:37 | |
of hospitals covers more than acute
hospitals, but the point I was | 4:04:37 | 4:04:45 | |
seeking to make was that this is an
issue concentrated in acute | 4:04:45 | 4:04:52 | |
hospitals and this is the issue that
is before us today. The Member for | 4:04:52 | 4:04:56 | |
Great Grimsby recognise that the
thin trusts there is considerable | 4:04:56 | 4:05:01 | |
room for flexibility. One of the key
issues from the debate was the | 4:05:01 | 4:05:06 | |
distinction between charges that are
covering the maintenance of car | 4:05:06 | 4:05:10 | |
parks and how a reduction in the
facilities would be affected. There | 4:05:10 | 4:05:27 | |
was a concern raised on
profiteering, going beyond the cost | 4:05:27 | 4:05:30 | |
of maintenance. I add that into
place with the current guidelines in | 4:05:30 | 4:05:36 | |
place. And we heard highlighted the
charges from the hospital compared | 4:05:36 | 4:05:48 | |
with the local authority. Concerns
were raised regarding blue badge | 4:05:48 | 4:05:57 | |
holders. You could have an affluent
blue badge holder being spared a | 4:05:57 | 4:06:06 | |
charge and the less affluent other
visitor to our hospital being | 4:06:06 | 4:06:10 | |
charged, but again the transparency
as to how the guidance is being | 4:06:10 | 4:06:14 | |
applied as a factor within that.
Blue badge is quite rightly or not | 4:06:14 | 4:06:24 | |
means tested. It is to do with
ability to access. It doesn't matter | 4:06:24 | 4:06:29 | |
how much money they have in the
bank. If they hospital and have a | 4:06:29 | 4:06:35 | |
blue badge, surely it should be free
and as close to the point of access | 4:06:35 | 4:06:41 | |
as possible? That is part of what
the guidance points to. Am very | 4:06:41 | 4:06:51 | |
happy to look at the reason why it
is 164 pages. It speaks to how | 4:06:51 | 4:07:02 | |
concessions and guidance... I have
huge respect for my honourable | 4:07:02 | 4:07:10 | |
friend, but the fact is the
guidelines are not working. Up to | 4:07:10 | 4:07:17 | |
50% of hospitals according to the
Freedom of information request are | 4:07:17 | 4:07:21 | |
still charging disabled people to
park. Was no point in talking about | 4:07:21 | 4:07:25 | |
the guidelines if people with
disabilities are still being charged | 4:07:25 | 4:07:29 | |
to park in hospitals in England. The
point I was saying to my honourable | 4:07:29 | 4:07:36 | |
friend is to firstly look at cases
and speak to trusts to better | 4:07:36 | 4:07:42 | |
understand that. Part of the
complexity is simply deducing the | 4:07:42 | 4:07:47 | |
charges and how that is managed.
Every worker at the example of | 4:07:47 | 4:07:53 | |
Inverness where the hospital car
park is being used by people for the | 4:07:53 | 4:08:04 | |
airport. That makes access more
difficult. That's why some of these | 4:08:04 | 4:08:14 | |
issues have a local flavour in terms
of how they are applied. That was | 4:08:14 | 4:08:22 | |
recognised by the Member for Hayward
and Middleton when he spoke of the | 4:08:22 | 4:08:28 | |
distinction between the North
Manchester site where visitors are | 4:08:28 | 4:08:39 | |
not using your store car park. So
the point is that there are local | 4:08:39 | 4:08:46 | |
factors, just as there are with
legacy PFI contracts, including in | 4:08:46 | 4:08:52 | |
Scotland and Wales when there are
contracts going back to 2008 which | 4:08:52 | 4:08:58 | |
are still charging. With the
Minister accept that people being | 4:08:58 | 4:09:01 | |
ill and suffering distress at
hospitals is not a local issue, it's | 4:09:01 | 4:09:08 | |
a national issue. The burden of
hospital car parking charges | 4:09:08 | 4:09:13 | |
wherever they occur to be a concern
of the government. Of course, but | 4:09:13 | 4:09:20 | |
the point the honourable Lady must
equally recognise is that for | 4:09:20 | 4:09:24 | |
example if you had a PFI agreement
put in place by the previous | 4:09:24 | 4:09:28 | |
government in 2008 with the Saudis
are still being applied, back does | 4:09:28 | 4:09:34 | |
seem that there are often
complexities in what can be done in | 4:09:34 | 4:09:38 | |
different factors. That is why a
trusts have local discretion. We | 4:09:38 | 4:09:48 | |
need to understand the transparency
around that and how that is being | 4:09:48 | 4:09:51 | |
applied. | 4:09:51 | 4:10:01 | |
I'm sure we have time for this
important issue. He raises the issue | 4:10:02 | 4:10:08 | |
of complexity. Some would be easier
to do than others and I accept that. | 4:10:08 | 4:10:17 | |
Some of these ludicrous PFIs that in
place before the previous | 4:10:17 | 4:10:24 | |
administration and some since. To
the easy ones first. That's the | 4:10:24 | 4:10:27 | |
answer. That's what Scotland did.
But ruling out changing anything at | 4:10:27 | 4:10:33 | |
all because there are some difficult
issues surely is not the way to go | 4:10:33 | 4:10:38 | |
forward. Again, one comes to some of
the issues there are, so again | 4:10:38 | 4:10:43 | |
turning to one of the points raised
was in terms of whether free parking | 4:10:43 | 4:10:48 | |
could address through tokens and
barriers. The concern raised from | 4:10:48 | 4:10:57 | |
colleagues within the NHS would be
the burden on staff. We heard | 4:10:57 | 4:11:01 | |
examples where frequent users of
hospitals are able to access | 4:11:01 | 4:11:09 | |
concessionary schemes, but those
visiting hospitals for a one-off | 4:11:09 | 4:11:13 | |
would be any potential impact on
them in terms of how they might be | 4:11:13 | 4:11:17 | |
expected to assist in the
administration of that. Another | 4:11:17 | 4:11:21 | |
point raised was the impact on staff
members. That was an issue raised by | 4:11:21 | 4:11:29 | |
members across the House. I have
been visited recently by the Royal | 4:11:29 | 4:11:36 | |
College of Nursing regarding wider
pay discussions. It's very helpful | 4:11:36 | 4:11:46 | |
to have the contributions of the
House in terms of this understanding | 4:11:46 | 4:11:51 | |
some of the benefits and pressures
and issues before them, as part of | 4:11:51 | 4:11:55 | |
this debate. There is no question I
think across the House as reflected | 4:11:55 | 4:12:02 | |
by the Member for Harlow on the
desirability in addressing | 4:12:02 | 4:12:09 | |
iniquities variants and scope to
ensure that compliance with the | 4:12:09 | 4:12:15 | |
guidelines is followed. But at the
same time we do need to be mindful | 4:12:15 | 4:12:19 | |
that we don't have unintended
consequences, particularly in | 4:12:19 | 4:12:24 | |
constraining the available car
parking available for those that | 4:12:24 | 4:12:27 | |
need it. I'm happy to continue
discussions with my honourable | 4:12:27 | 4:12:32 | |
friend in terms of this policy and I
commend him and other colleagues | 4:12:32 | 4:12:36 | |
from what has been a very
constructive debate. Thank you. I'd | 4:12:36 | 4:12:45 | |
like to thank the honourable members
have spoken from both sides of the | 4:12:45 | 4:12:48 | |
House. I think the Minister who has
heard about the madness of the | 4:12:48 | 4:12:54 | |
guidelines not working and the
problems with public transport and | 4:12:54 | 4:13:00 | |
parking being given over to football
club supporters, about the moving | 4:13:00 | 4:13:08 | |
stories of families and the problems
people with severe illness have had | 4:13:08 | 4:13:12 | |
to face. I have to say, I'm
incredibly disappointed with his | 4:13:12 | 4:13:18 | |
response today. I gave him my speech
in advance because I wanted him to | 4:13:18 | 4:13:23 | |
look at this seriously. I think a
lot of what he has read is very much | 4:13:23 | 4:13:28 | |
what officials might want -- would
be what you think would come from | 4:13:28 | 4:13:37 | |
officials. I think this is a great
disappointment. Europe and this | 4:13:37 | 4:13:41 | |
saying he believes in the
desirability of this and men did not | 4:13:41 | 4:13:45 | |
give any indication of how. It is
not beyond the wit of man to develop | 4:13:45 | 4:13:57 | |
a number plate recognition system to
deal with the problems of people | 4:13:57 | 4:14:00 | |
misusing hospital car parking. I
think that my feeling is he has said | 4:14:00 | 4:14:09 | |
we will try and make sure the
guidelines work. Even if the | 4:14:09 | 4:14:12 | |
guidelines were working, they would
still mean many hospitals would | 4:14:12 | 4:14:17 | |
charge millions of patients and
visitors. On both sides of the | 4:14:17 | 4:14:22 | |
House, we constantly talk about
billions being spent on the NHS, the | 4:14:22 | 4:14:35 | |
fact is it is hard to understand
from most members of the public but | 4:14:35 | 4:14:39 | |
when there is something real that
affects millions of people, when | 4:14:39 | 4:14:42 | |
they go to hospital on a regular
basis, as has been said again and | 4:14:42 | 4:14:46 | |
again today, not out of choice but
because they have to do, this is | 4:14:46 | 4:14:51 | |
something real and substantive and
does not cost a huge amount of money | 4:14:51 | 4:14:55 | |
in terms of the overall NHS budget.
There are different solutions in | 4:14:55 | 4:14:59 | |
which to pay for that, so the NHS is
not harmed. I just urge him strongly | 4:14:59 | 4:15:04 | |
to look at this issue again and
realise there is a cross-party | 4:15:04 | 4:15:11 | |
consensus in this House. | 4:15:11 | 4:15:17 | |
There are many members on our side
of the house that one is changed and | 4:15:17 | 4:15:21 | |
they returned that when this comes
back, have a more substantive | 4:15:21 | 4:15:26 | |
solution to scrap hospital car park
charges. The question is as on the | 4:15:26 | 4:15:30 | |
order paper, as many are others that
opinion say aye, to the contrary | 4:15:30 | 4:15:34 | |
now. I think the ayes have it, the
ayes have it. Petition, Kate Green. | 4:15:34 | 4:15:45 | |
Thank you very much. I rise to
present the petition on behalf of my | 4:15:45 | 4:15:51 | |
constituents, which has 356
signatures from people seeking to | 4:15:51 | 4:15:57 | |
see an end to the violence and
persecution of the raw anger Muslim | 4:15:57 | 4:16:00 | |
community in the Armagh and the
addition questions that the House of | 4:16:00 | 4:16:09 | |
Commons makes representation to the
government of my Armagh to cease all | 4:16:09 | 4:16:12 | |
violence, and further to call for
further aids to Myanmar and for | 4:16:12 | 4:16:23 | |
others to no longer supply metal
very training or eight. And we must | 4:16:23 | 4:16:29 | |
ensure that the perpetrators are
brought to the International Court | 4:16:29 | 4:16:32 | |
of Justice to be tried for crimes
against the malady. -- crimes | 4:16:32 | 4:16:40 | |
against humanity. | 4:16:40 | 4:16:42 | |
Petition, ten the Mac's Muslim
ethnic minority. -- Myanmar's Muslim | 4:16:49 | 4:16:59 | |
ethnic minority. The question is
that this house do now adjourn. I am | 4:16:59 | 4:17:07 | |
grateful to you Mr Speaker for
granting me this debate and I want | 4:17:07 | 4:17:10 | |
to welcome my honourable friend the
Minister to his role and to the | 4:17:10 | 4:17:16 | |
opportunity to hear about my
constituency. My constituency covers | 4:17:16 | 4:17:21 | |
the lower tiers of local planning
authorities, and Essex County | 4:17:21 | 4:17:25 | |
Council with responsibility for
waste and minerals, which explains | 4:17:25 | 4:17:29 | |
bad and deputy speaker in part why
the honourable Minister's department | 4:17:29 | 4:17:33 | |
hold such a high volume of
correspondence from me on the half | 4:17:33 | 4:17:36 | |
of my constituents. If the Minister
visits my constituency and he is | 4:17:36 | 4:17:41 | |
very welcome to do so, he will see
at first hand the boundless economic | 4:17:41 | 4:17:48 | |
potential of this part of Essex and
indeed the entire county. He will | 4:17:48 | 4:17:52 | |
also see appetite amongst the local
communities to take a positive and | 4:17:52 | 4:17:55 | |
practical approach to housing,
planning and infrastructure. Many | 4:17:55 | 4:18:00 | |
parishes are working on
neighbourhood development plans and | 4:18:00 | 4:18:02 | |
watch to deliver the localism agenda
advocated by our government. They | 4:18:02 | 4:18:07 | |
want to use the powers that their
disposal to allocate preferred site | 4:18:07 | 4:18:11 | |
for housing business use and
protection and we want to deliver | 4:18:11 | 4:18:15 | |
ambitious plans to support economic
growth and bring more local homes to | 4:18:15 | 4:18:19 | |
our local communities. We want and
need new infrastructure to support | 4:18:19 | 4:18:24 | |
growth including the widening of a
12, upgrading the A1 20 and | 4:18:24 | 4:18:29 | |
investment in the great eastern
mainline. I welcome the announcement | 4:18:29 | 4:18:32 | |
today of over £7 million at the
Heybridge flood alleviation and | 4:18:32 | 4:18:38 | |
regeneration screen -- scheme just
outside my constituency and I hope | 4:18:38 | 4:18:42 | |
that more investment can come
through in future to support | 4:18:42 | 4:18:46 | |
planning and development. We also
recognise that development brings | 4:18:46 | 4:18:49 | |
with it implement opportunities,
investment in infrastructure, new | 4:18:49 | 4:18:51 | |
public services and GP services. But
that does not mean housing at any | 4:18:51 | 4:18:57 | |
cost and in any location. So I want
to use this debate to draw the | 4:18:57 | 4:19:02 | |
Minister's attention to some of the
issues and cases of concern were | 4:19:02 | 4:19:05 | |
localism is being undermined and
were opportunities to deliver | 4:19:05 | 4:19:09 | |
locally led planning are being
missed. And I fully appreciate and | 4:19:09 | 4:19:13 | |
respect that the Minister cannot
give detailed responses on specific | 4:19:13 | 4:19:15 | |
planning cases that are currently
alive and under consideration but I | 4:19:15 | 4:19:20 | |
do hope that he and his department
can reflect upon them. First of all | 4:19:20 | 4:19:23 | |
the Minister will be aware that the
Secretary of State decided to call | 4:19:23 | 4:19:27 | |
in planning applications for two
sites in Hatfield, stone Park | 4:19:27 | 4:19:31 | |
Meadows in Gleneagles way for up to
260 new dwellings. A hearing took | 4:19:31 | 4:19:36 | |
place in December and I would like
to pay tribute Madam Deputy Speaker | 4:19:36 | 4:19:39 | |
to my local residents and our parish
council who came together to oppose | 4:19:39 | 4:19:45 | |
these unwelcome developments. Their
dedication to the local community | 4:19:45 | 4:19:51 | |
has been outstanding and what we
have seen here at -- is that both | 4:19:51 | 4:19:56 | |
sites outside of the settlement
boundary and emerging neighbourhood | 4:19:56 | 4:19:59 | |
plan because these would be
detrimental to the countryside. It | 4:19:59 | 4:20:02 | |
would also place unacceptable
pressure is already on the GP | 4:20:02 | 4:20:08 | |
practices was no guarantees of
financial contributions being | 4:20:08 | 4:20:10 | |
offered to ensure that they can be
enhanced. Our local schools are | 4:20:10 | 4:20:15 | |
full, but no cogitations are being
sought because of the silk filling | 4:20:15 | 4:20:20 | |
restrictions and the applicants
think that it is acceptable for | 4:20:20 | 4:20:23 | |
primary school pupils, for children
to be forced to walk over two miles | 4:20:23 | 4:20:26 | |
along the busy a 12 to a school in
Wootton. As for secondary school | 4:20:26 | 4:20:34 | |
pupils axing the number 72 but it
that connects happened to two | 4:20:34 | 4:20:40 | |
academies and so there will be no
direct bus for pupils in the village | 4:20:40 | 4:20:44 | |
to use. We are not opposed to
housing, quite the opposite, the | 4:20:44 | 4:20:50 | |
wonderful village is already set to
accommodate new housing in the | 4:20:50 | 4:20:52 | |
American local plan, focused
everywhere in the village and a | 4:20:52 | 4:20:56 | |
conference we develop that any
covering land between a 12 and | 4:20:56 | 4:21:00 | |
Eastern mainline and that is some
250 new dwellings already going | 4:21:00 | 4:21:05 | |
through. The village has taken its
fair share of new housing and cannot | 4:21:05 | 4:21:09 | |
take any more. There are many other
reasons why these two applications | 4:21:09 | 4:21:13 | |
are totally unsuitable for
development. So I trust that the | 4:21:13 | 4:21:17 | |
Minister and the Secretary of State
will consider these points in the | 4:21:17 | 4:21:21 | |
strong objections when he gets the
report of the findings. Although the | 4:21:21 | 4:21:28 | |
Minister cannot comment on the
specifics of the application that | 4:21:28 | 4:21:30 | |
are wider issues that have arisen
when I would welcome this | 4:21:30 | 4:21:34 | |
classification. Firstly councils
like Braintree died in the process | 4:21:34 | 4:21:40 | |
of putting in a local plan sent
neighbourhood plans are embracing | 4:21:40 | 4:21:43 | |
the principles of localism but they
are being undermined by planning | 4:21:43 | 4:21:48 | |
applications and on many occasions
-- many cases undermining the | 4:21:48 | 4:21:54 | |
democratic processes. These
communities need protecting. And | 4:21:54 | 4:21:59 | |
they need the government to allow
them time to get their plans in | 4:21:59 | 4:22:02 | |
place. Secondly the issue of the
five-year land supply deliverable | 4:22:02 | 4:22:07 | |
sites, speculative and predatory
developers are seeking to exploit | 4:22:07 | 4:22:13 | |
the council's claim that it has a
five-year land supply. The main | 4:22:13 | 4:22:18 | |
reason for Braintree having an
identified surprise shortfall is due | 4:22:18 | 4:22:23 | |
to the failure of the last Labour
government's regional spatial | 4:22:23 | 4:22:27 | |
strategy with housing targets lower
than those with assessed housing | 4:22:27 | 4:22:34 | |
need research. I hope the Minister
can ensure local communities in the | 4:22:34 | 4:22:37 | |
district that they will not be
punished because of the last Labour | 4:22:37 | 4:22:40 | |
government's failure in the
decision-makers can exercise | 4:22:40 | 4:22:45 | |
discretion over the housing supply
figures. Councils do need | 4:22:45 | 4:22:49 | |
flexibility on this issue and that
includes being able to use a | 4:22:49 | 4:22:52 | |
Liverpool method very best suits,
including sites in draft | 4:22:52 | 4:22:56 | |
allocations. I hope the Minister and
speak to this and give assurances | 4:22:56 | 4:22:59 | |
that, too. The third point is the
issue of effectiveness on the | 4:22:59 | 4:23:05 | |
pre-consultation issue. In my region
one applicant issued a consultation | 4:23:05 | 4:23:11 | |
which contained false information
about health provision which the | 4:23:11 | 4:23:14 | |
applicant had not bothered to check
in such to frighten my residence. | 4:23:14 | 4:23:19 | |
The also put in a planning
application within a few weeks of | 4:23:19 | 4:23:22 | |
securing rights from landowners to
promote the site and less than two | 4:23:22 | 4:23:26 | |
working days after holding a
pre-application discussion with | 4:23:26 | 4:23:28 | |
council officers that is now time to
take account of local comment at | 4:23:28 | 4:23:33 | |
all. And when the council and local
community were taken to resolve | 4:23:33 | 4:23:38 | |
issues that have been raised as a
result of the applicants failure, | 4:23:38 | 4:23:41 | |
such as the impact on schools and
NHS and landscape, the applicant had | 4:23:41 | 4:23:47 | |
the audacity to threaten to take the
application to the planning | 4:23:47 | 4:23:50 | |
Inspectorate. For other sites in the
district such as referrals and | 4:23:50 | 4:23:55 | |
planning inspectorate to deliver
decision-making, this is abuse of | 4:23:55 | 4:24:00 | |
the -- this abuse of the planning
system must stop. There are good | 4:24:00 | 4:24:08 | |
examples of positive engagement in
local amenities and we must make | 4:24:08 | 4:24:11 | |
sure that one of this happens and
those who fiddle consultations and | 4:24:11 | 4:24:13 | |
circumvent the application
engagement should be sanctioned for | 4:24:13 | 4:24:16 | |
doing so. Madam Deputy Speaker,
another major development issue | 4:24:16 | 4:24:21 | |
affecting my constituency is the
proposed garden settlement for | 4:24:21 | 4:24:24 | |
Colchester Borough and the border.
This proposal has the deliver -- | 4:24:24 | 4:24:30 | |
this proposal has the potential to
deliver thousands of new homes in | 4:24:30 | 4:24:34 | |
infrastructure upgrades and public
is. The government agonised this and | 4:24:34 | 4:24:37 | |
has provided over £1.3 million to
Colchester Borough Council's work on | 4:24:37 | 4:24:43 | |
this project. However, a number of
questions and concerns have been | 4:24:43 | 4:24:46 | |
raised about the proposals. Whenever
you leave usually to infrastructure | 4:24:46 | 4:24:51 | |
and public services, residents want
to be assured that if the project | 4:24:51 | 4:24:54 | |
gets the green light there will be
significant new infrastructure and | 4:24:54 | 4:24:58 | |
public services put in place to meet
demand. There is no point in putting | 4:24:58 | 4:25:02 | |
the infrastructure and services into
one of the developments until the | 4:25:02 | 4:25:05 | |
development are being occupied. The
needed in advance and a clear | 4:25:05 | 4:25:09 | |
timetable. And that means that the
Department for Transport, the | 4:25:09 | 4:25:14 | |
tragedy, local councils and the
private sector needs to come | 4:25:14 | 4:25:17 | |
together to ensure that funding is
in place to upgrade a 120, increase | 4:25:17 | 4:25:23 | |
capacity on the great Eastern
mainline with a passing grade as | 4:25:23 | 4:25:26 | |
well as providing for new GP
surgeries and schools. There have | 4:25:26 | 4:25:30 | |
also been questions raised about the
delivery vehicle, local engagement, | 4:25:30 | 4:25:34 | |
availability of implement
opportunities and how the councils | 4:25:34 | 4:25:38 | |
have spent the money provided to
them by the government. The garden | 4:25:38 | 4:25:42 | |
settlement proposals are currently
in the process of being examined as | 4:25:42 | 4:25:45 | |
part of the local plan process but I
urge the Minister and Secretary of | 4:25:45 | 4:25:49 | |
State to be careful of these
matters. Some residents are opposed | 4:25:49 | 4:25:53 | |
to this project, others are in
favour, however, it is essential | 4:25:53 | 4:25:56 | |
that this major project goes ahead
it is done correctly and in the | 4:25:56 | 4:25:59 | |
right way. One of other reasons why
there are concerns about garden | 4:25:59 | 4:26:04 | |
settlement is because of the
appalling record of Colchester | 4:26:04 | 4:26:07 | |
Borough Council. An planning matters
as Lib Dem and Labour run council is | 4:26:07 | 4:26:11 | |
rotten to the corner. The Minister
has the background and will know | 4:26:11 | 4:26:15 | |
that last year the Secretary of
State granted planning permission | 4:26:15 | 4:26:18 | |
for a new leisure and retail
development known as Tollgate | 4:26:18 | 4:26:21 | |
Village. This development was
supported by overwhelming majority | 4:26:21 | 4:26:23 | |
of local people and to transform
derelict site into a developer | 4:26:23 | 4:26:30 | |
creating hundreds of new local jobs
and tens of millions of pounds of | 4:26:30 | 4:26:34 | |
inward investment. However, the
council tried everything to block | 4:26:34 | 4:26:36 | |
it. They claimed it would be a loss
of land and even though there was no | 4:26:36 | 4:26:41 | |
interest in using the site in this
way they try to put doggy relativist | 4:26:41 | 4:26:45 | |
Colchester town centre and the even
tried to smear me by making up a | 4:26:45 | 4:26:49 | |
false claim that my representations
were somehow improper. They behaved | 4:26:49 | 4:26:55 | |
disgracefully and not a single
officer or political figure has | 4:26:55 | 4:27:00 | |
taken responsibility. They blocked
the creation of jobs, prevented | 4:27:00 | 4:27:02 | |
investment in waste of public money.
Close to this site a council has | 4:27:02 | 4:27:08 | |
behaved in a similar way on a scheme
called Stein Park, the private | 4:27:08 | 4:27:12 | |
investment project which they
blocked but which was granted | 4:27:12 | 4:27:16 | |
consent on appeal. Also in Stanway
on the Lakeland housing developer to | 4:27:16 | 4:27:19 | |
the council completely neglected and
ignored residents, causing the loss | 4:27:19 | 4:27:22 | |
of green space in an area of land
known as a parcel SR six. Is area of | 4:27:22 | 4:27:32 | |
land should have been landscaped and
it was not and the council failed to | 4:27:32 | 4:27:35 | |
enforce a planning condition. It was
then designated for protection as | 4:27:35 | 4:27:38 | |
open space in the council's local
plan but behind closed doors and | 4:27:38 | 4:27:44 | |
without any consultation the council
allowed a new master plan to be | 4:27:44 | 4:27:47 | |
approved and designated that site
for intensive housing. Residents | 4:27:47 | 4:27:50 | |
were only made aware of this when he
reserved matters application was | 4:27:50 | 4:27:55 | |
made in 2015, despite complaints and
concerns about the process the | 4:27:55 | 4:27:58 | |
council approved the construction of
27 new dwellings and a lot of the | 4:27:58 | 4:28:03 | |
space in 2016. This matter has been
with the local government must win | 4:28:03 | 4:28:07 | |
for over a year and due to the
complexity of the issues involved | 4:28:07 | 4:28:11 | |
but it shows once again that
Colchester council is problematic | 4:28:11 | 4:28:13 | |
and not fit for purpose, they
allowed an area which should have | 4:28:13 | 4:28:16 | |
been a green open space to be lost
without any consultation and they | 4:28:16 | 4:28:20 | |
kept local resident in the dark for
years on this particular matter. | 4:28:20 | 4:28:28 | |
I beg to move that this House do now
adjourned. Continue. Thousands of my | 4:28:28 | 4:28:43 | |
constituents and residents across
Essex and beyond are deeply | 4:28:43 | 4:28:54 | |
concerned about an incinerator which
was given planning permission by the | 4:28:54 | 4:28:57 | |
last Labour government weeks before
the general election in 2010. Since | 4:28:57 | 4:29:02 | |
then, the applicants have paid a
number of changes to the site. The | 4:29:02 | 4:29:08 | |
recycling capacity has been reduced.
Incineration capacity has been | 4:29:08 | 4:29:14 | |
increased from 65%. Another planning
application is being considered. | 4:29:14 | 4:29:27 | |
Given concerns with the incinerator,
the impact on the environment, the | 4:29:27 | 4:29:31 | |
new proposals put forward on waste
from the government, the incinerator | 4:29:31 | 4:29:35 | |
is not only unwelcome, it is out of
date. It has no energy recovery | 4:29:35 | 4:29:45 | |
methods. I trust the Minister will
convey this message to the Secretary | 4:29:45 | 4:29:53 | |
of State and look at all the
submissions that will be coming his | 4:29:53 | 4:29:56 | |
way. My constituent John Patrick has
a long chain of correspondence and | 4:29:56 | 4:30:02 | |
representation with my honourable
friend's Department and is well | 4:30:02 | 4:30:06 | |
known to them. He runs a rural
nursery business growing plants. | 4:30:06 | 4:30:10 | |
When he moved there, it was living
accommodation on site. A long and | 4:30:10 | 4:30:17 | |
protracted planning dispute has
taken place with the local planning | 4:30:17 | 4:30:24 | |
authority. He feels planning
policies justify him being able to | 4:30:24 | 4:30:27 | |
operate his business on the site. I
ask the Minister to review the case | 4:30:27 | 4:30:32 | |
and learn the lessons from it.
Finally, the last case I want to | 4:30:32 | 4:30:41 | |
highlight involves the development
outside by constituency. The | 4:30:41 | 4:30:49 | |
developer is involved in the
development of a site in archers | 4:30:49 | 4:30:54 | |
field District Council. This company
could be prevented from providing | 4:30:54 | 4:31:04 | |
much-needed social housing. As the
Minister can see, my constituency | 4:31:04 | 4:31:13 | |
has arrays -- a wide range of
planning and development issues. | 4:31:13 | 4:31:20 | |
There are many more that time has
prevented me from raising with. I | 4:31:20 | 4:31:24 | |
want to leave him with this message
from my constituency. Were needed | 4:31:24 | 4:31:29 | |
new minister of housing, planning
and local government to deliver | 4:31:29 | 4:31:34 | |
sustainable developments and the
housing we need, prevent unwelcome | 4:31:34 | 4:31:38 | |
developments and abuses in the
planning system, make sure that | 4:31:38 | 4:31:42 | |
intervention takes place in the
cases listed, and ensures that local | 4:31:42 | 4:31:50 | |
people can be supported with
infrastructure and public transport. | 4:31:50 | 4:31:59 | |
Can I start by congratulating my
right honourable friend for securing | 4:31:59 | 4:32:03 | |
this debate about housing, planning
and infrastructure in Essex. It was | 4:32:03 | 4:32:08 | |
great to see her supported in the
chamber by her county colleagues. My | 4:32:08 | 4:32:16 | |
honourable friend is a strong
campaigner for her constituency. I | 4:32:16 | 4:32:19 | |
can tell the House the sheer volume
of cases and correspondence from her | 4:32:19 | 4:32:26 | |
held by the Ministry is a testament
to lead diligent way she pursues | 4:32:26 | 4:32:29 | |
these issues. I thank her very much
for the opportunity to discuss these | 4:32:29 | 4:32:36 | |
very important topics. As she can be
acknowledged in her remarks, I am | 4:32:36 | 4:32:47 | |
not in a position to comment in
detail on the planning applications | 4:32:47 | 4:32:55 | |
that are ongoing. The case she
referred to in the village is being | 4:32:55 | 4:32:59 | |
considered by a planning inspector
who will provide the Secretary of | 4:32:59 | 4:33:02 | |
State of the report friend to
consider in due course. All material | 4:33:02 | 4:33:08 | |
matters associated with these
proposals will be considered as part | 4:33:08 | 4:33:11 | |
of the process and my right
honourable friend can be assured | 4:33:11 | 4:33:15 | |
that the comments she has made will
no doubt be noted. In respect of the | 4:33:15 | 4:33:21 | |
applications related to the waste
management facility for the former | 4:33:21 | 4:33:26 | |
airfield, she has provided some of
the background. The current planning | 4:33:26 | 4:33:30 | |
applications submitted are a matter
for Essex County Council, as the | 4:33:30 | 4:33:35 | |
relevant planning authority, to
consider. However, the ministry is | 4:33:35 | 4:33:40 | |
aware of the requests made for these
applications to be called in and | 4:33:40 | 4:33:43 | |
these requests will be considered in
the appropriate way. Turning next to | 4:33:43 | 4:33:50 | |
John Patrick and the points you
raised about his case, I can assure | 4:33:50 | 4:33:54 | |
my right all the friend that we will
carefully consider and reply to Mr | 4:33:54 | 4:34:01 | |
Patrick's correspondence. As an
aside, representing a highly rural | 4:34:01 | 4:34:07 | |
constituency myself, like her, I
fully recognise the importance of | 4:34:07 | 4:34:11 | |
rural enterprise in driving
prosperity. I was interested to hear | 4:34:11 | 4:34:16 | |
about the case mentioned involving
the District Council. I'm not in a | 4:34:16 | 4:34:23 | |
position to comment on current
planning application, but on the | 4:34:23 | 4:34:28 | |
general point on the provision of
affordable housing, we are keen to | 4:34:28 | 4:34:32 | |
see approach is taken to deliver
more affordable housing and as set | 4:34:32 | 4:34:36 | |
out in the housing paper the
government is keen to promote more | 4:34:36 | 4:34:40 | |
opportunities for small and
medium-sized developers to deliver | 4:34:40 | 4:34:43 | |
that housing. My right honourable
friend made reference to her | 4:34:43 | 4:34:48 | |
concerns with Colchester Borough
Council. The case she had referred | 4:34:48 | 4:34:53 | |
to on the Lakeland site is currently
with the local government ombudsman | 4:34:53 | 4:34:56 | |
and we will take note of the outcome
of their enquiries, but as she knows | 4:34:56 | 4:35:02 | |
we cannot intervene directly in that
process. In relation to the village | 4:35:02 | 4:35:08 | |
project, an inspector conducting the
appeal enquiry produced a report | 4:35:08 | 4:35:14 | |
which the Secretary of State
carefully considered before | 4:35:14 | 4:35:15 | |
accepting the recommendation to be
grant planning permission. We are | 4:35:15 | 4:35:19 | |
aware of the council's position and
my right honourable friend's | 4:35:19 | 4:35:26 | |
concerns with the cancel's reply. As
for every single local authority, | 4:35:26 | 4:35:34 | |
ultimate accountability comes
through the ballot box. I know | 4:35:34 | 4:35:37 | |
first-hand that my right honourable
friend is a top rate campaigner. She | 4:35:37 | 4:35:45 | |
touched in her speech about the
North Essex garden communities. This | 4:35:45 | 4:35:48 | |
is one of 24 new locally led garden
cities, towns and villages the | 4:35:48 | 4:35:54 | |
government is currently supporting.
Together, I can tell the House they | 4:35:54 | 4:35:58 | |
have the potential to deliver
220,000 new homes across England. In | 4:35:58 | 4:36:04 | |
general terms, the government
believes garden communities offer | 4:36:04 | 4:36:08 | |
the potential to secure considerable
new housing, employment | 4:36:08 | 4:36:12 | |
opportunities, modern physical
infrastructure and new public | 4:36:12 | 4:36:15 | |
services. This is why the government
provides some funding to support | 4:36:15 | 4:36:19 | |
local authorities like those in
Essex to develop these proposals. I | 4:36:19 | 4:36:32 | |
congratulate my honourable friend
for this debate. We are all here | 4:36:32 | 4:36:36 | |
because we are concerned about the
effects of these garden communities, | 4:36:36 | 4:36:42 | |
that they must produce quality
communities. I know the department | 4:36:42 | 4:36:45 | |
is concerned these are not just
about housing numbers, the are about | 4:36:45 | 4:36:49 | |
creating quality communities and
with the infrastructure. There are | 4:36:49 | 4:36:54 | |
vital pieces of infrastructure which
must be upgraded in advance of these | 4:36:54 | 4:37:00 | |
new homes being created. Would he
took that into consideration? My | 4:37:00 | 4:37:08 | |
honourable and right honourable
friend are both right to raise | 4:37:08 | 4:37:13 | |
constituent concerns this additional
housing is supported by | 4:37:13 | 4:37:19 | |
infrastructure and public services
are right time. Something the | 4:37:19 | 4:37:23 | |
government and I wholeheartedly
agree and pie in the autumn budget | 4:37:23 | 4:37:27 | |
the government more than doubled
housing infrastructure fund, and it | 4:37:27 | 4:37:32 | |
additional £2.7 billion of funding,
bringing the total fund to £5 | 4:37:32 | 4:37:38 | |
billion. Thank you for giving way. I
would like to congratulate my right | 4:37:38 | 4:37:42 | |
honourable friend and your neighbour
for being an Essex champion and for | 4:37:42 | 4:37:48 | |
initiating the debate. Could I ask
my honourable friend, given the | 4:37:48 | 4:37:55 | |
things you said, in terms of new
housing and infrastructure, does he | 4:37:55 | 4:37:58 | |
not agree there should be support
for substantial regeneration in | 4:37:58 | 4:38:05 | |
towns like Harlow but have real
problems because the toners decaying | 4:38:05 | 4:38:09 | |
over everything being built at the
same time. We need desperate | 4:38:09 | 4:38:15 | |
regeneration of the town centre, for
example. He makes an excellent | 4:38:15 | 4:38:20 | |
point. The boundless economic
optimism we heard of Earl is | 4:38:20 | 4:38:27 | |
something the government is keen to
see and should actively support | 4:38:27 | 4:38:31 | |
through these proposals and through
the infrastructure and investment in | 4:38:31 | 4:38:35 | |
places like Harlow, you can make a
difference. The housing | 4:38:35 | 4:38:38 | |
infrastructure fund is designed to
provide exactly the kind of projects | 4:38:38 | 4:38:43 | |
that both my right honourable friend
and my honourable friend spoke of, | 4:38:43 | 4:38:50 | |
key infrastructure to unlock housing
growth. Just today, the government | 4:38:50 | 4:38:57 | |
announced 133 successful project
which will help unlock the potential | 4:38:57 | 4:39:01 | |
200,000 new homes. As my right
honourable friend mentioned, that | 4:39:01 | 4:39:06 | |
includes £7.3 million for a flood
relief scheme next door to her | 4:39:06 | 4:39:10 | |
constituency in mould and. And £5.5
million of funding to unlock over | 4:39:10 | 4:39:16 | |
500 homes in Colchester by
accelerating the delivery of a | 4:39:16 | 4:39:24 | |
housing development. I'm sure he
will welcome that investment. Of | 4:39:24 | 4:39:27 | |
forward fund element will also be
available for a small number of | 4:39:27 | 4:39:36 | |
strategic and high impact
infrastructure projects with bids of | 4:39:36 | 4:39:43 | |
up to £250 million. Expressions of
interest for this funding are being | 4:39:43 | 4:39:47 | |
assessed. I'm delighted to tell the
House that the county of Essex have | 4:39:47 | 4:39:51 | |
applied to this fund, including four
infrastructure specifically to | 4:39:51 | 4:39:57 | |
support the North Essex garden
communities. The best proposals from | 4:39:57 | 4:40:00 | |
across the county will be short
listed to go through to core | 4:40:00 | 4:40:05 | |
development in the coming weeks.
Local authorities will then submit | 4:40:05 | 4:40:08 | |
final business cases the successful
bids being announced as early as | 4:40:08 | 4:40:13 | |
this autumn. More generally, my
right honourable friend is right to | 4:40:13 | 4:40:18 | |
highlight that garden settlement
community proposals are still | 4:40:18 | 4:40:20 | |
subject to examination, as part of
the local plan process. The hearings | 4:40:20 | 4:40:26 | |
with respect to plans concluded last
month, as she will now. I can | 4:40:26 | 4:40:32 | |
reassure my right honourable friend
that any formal responses her | 4:40:32 | 4:40:35 | |
constituents have made either to the
planning Inspectorate or to the | 4:40:35 | 4:40:40 | |
council as part of the draft plan
consultation will be considered by | 4:40:40 | 4:40:45 | |
the inspector in his determination.
Further, I understand that the | 4:40:45 | 4:40:51 | |
planning Inspectorate has sought
reassurance that all matters raised | 4:40:51 | 4:40:55 | |
by consultees on the draft plan have
in fact been provided and will hold | 4:40:55 | 4:41:00 | |
further hearings if procedurally
necessary. My right honourable | 4:41:00 | 4:41:05 | |
friend spoke in detail about local
plans. New homes need to be provided | 4:41:05 | 4:41:12 | |
through up-to-date local plans,
which are produced in consultation | 4:41:12 | 4:41:16 | |
with local people. I welcome the
progress which various councils have | 4:41:16 | 4:41:23 | |
made with local plan preparations.
Up-to-date plans produced in | 4:41:23 | 4:41:28 | |
consultation with local communities
are a vital element of the planning | 4:41:28 | 4:41:31 | |
system. They are the starting point
for planning decisions by local | 4:41:31 | 4:41:35 | |
planning authorities and planning
inspectors. As my right honourable | 4:41:35 | 4:41:40 | |
friend mentioned, local authorities
are required to identify a five-year | 4:41:40 | 4:41:44 | |
land supply of deliverable housing
stock. Identifying sites provides | 4:41:44 | 4:41:53 | |
clarity to local communities and
developers work where homes should | 4:41:53 | 4:41:55 | |
be built so development is planned
rather than as a result of | 4:41:55 | 4:42:00 | |
speculative application. However,
where there is insufficient land | 4:42:00 | 4:42:03 | |
available on which housing can
realistically be delivered, there | 4:42:03 | 4:42:06 | |
are measures in place that help
identify suitable sites. As my right | 4:42:06 | 4:42:13 | |
honourable friend acknowledged,
government guidance states that | 4:42:13 | 4:42:15 | |
local authorities should aim to deal
with undersupply within five years | 4:42:15 | 4:42:21 | |
were possible. However,
decision-makers have the flexibility | 4:42:21 | 4:42:25 | |
to consider each case on its merit
and it is for local authorities to | 4:42:25 | 4:42:31 | |
present their particular case to the
relevant decision makers. Are | 4:42:31 | 4:42:35 | |
housing high Paper acknowledges the
current policy on five-year land | 4:42:35 | 4:42:38 | |
supply has been effective in
delivering homes, but has had some | 4:42:38 | 4:42:43 | |
negative effects including an
increased number of appeals. Through | 4:42:43 | 4:42:47 | |
our housing White Paper, the
government propose reforms to land | 4:42:47 | 4:42:51 | |
supply is calculated to give more
certainty. The proposal offers local | 4:42:51 | 4:42:57 | |
authorities the opportunity to have
their plan agreed on an annual basis | 4:42:57 | 4:43:01 | |
and fix for a one-year period. It is
intended that this ability to fix | 4:43:01 | 4:43:06 | |
will reduce the number and
complexity of appeals by providing | 4:43:06 | 4:43:11 | |
greater certainty to all parties.
The White Paper also indicated that | 4:43:11 | 4:43:16 | |
clearer and more transparent
guidance will set out how the | 4:43:16 | 4:43:20 | |
five-year land supply should be
calculated. | 4:43:20 | 4:43:28 | |
Revised national planning guidance
will be published for comment | 4:43:28 | 4:43:31 | |
alongside the consultation of the
National planning policy framework | 4:43:31 | 4:43:35 | |
before Easter of this year. My right
honourable friend next referred to | 4:43:35 | 4:43:40 | |
the production of neighbourhood
plans and the role that they play in | 4:43:40 | 4:43:44 | |
empowering local communities. I note
with delight that neighbourhood | 4:43:44 | 4:43:50 | |
planning is being embraced in her
constituency with at least ten | 4:43:50 | 4:43:54 | |
neighbourhood planning groups being
active. And as she sets doing their | 4:43:54 | 4:43:59 | |
best to support the government's
localism agenda. The government | 4:43:59 | 4:44:03 | |
wants to support such groups and we
have made £23 million available from | 4:44:03 | 4:44:09 | |
2018 through a neighbourhood
planning support programme. She | 4:44:09 | 4:44:13 | |
highlighted her concerns about
whether neighbourhood plans in | 4:44:13 | 4:44:18 | |
development get the status they
deserve in the planning process, | 4:44:18 | 4:44:22 | |
especially if communities are in her
words bombarded with applications. I | 4:44:22 | 4:44:27 | |
can tell her that the national
planning policy framework is clear, | 4:44:27 | 4:44:32 | |
that weight must be given to
emerging neighbourhood plans. We | 4:44:32 | 4:44:37 | |
have also laid out guidance to set
out where circumstances might | 4:44:37 | 4:44:42 | |
justify the refusal of planning
permission on grounds that this | 4:44:42 | 4:44:48 | |
would be premature in relation to an
emerging neighbourhood plan. Coming | 4:44:48 | 4:44:57 | |
next to comments about the
application consultation. The | 4:44:57 | 4:45:02 | |
government agrees that effective
consultation is an important part of | 4:45:02 | 4:45:04 | |
the planning process. Government has
clear and detailed expectations, | 4:45:04 | 4:45:09 | |
both statutory and in guidance
regarding the consultations of | 4:45:09 | 4:45:15 | |
parties who are affected by planning
applications. It is for the local | 4:45:15 | 4:45:19 | |
planning authority to ensure that
this consultation takes place | 4:45:19 | 4:45:24 | |
properly and in accordance with
these guidelines. If there are | 4:45:24 | 4:45:27 | |
points of concern these should be
raised with the local authority as | 4:45:27 | 4:45:31 | |
soon as possible. In conclusion,
Madam Deputy Speaker, we have | 4:45:31 | 4:45:38 | |
covered an extensive range of topics
in this very short debate this | 4:45:38 | 4:45:42 | |
evening. It seems to me that the
Business Secretary and indeed the | 4:45:42 | 4:45:47 | |
Chancellor should take note that my
right honourable friend is | 4:45:47 | 4:45:51 | |
single-handedly doing her bit to
drive up British productivity. But | 4:45:51 | 4:45:56 | |
this in seriousness is a testament
to the energy and passion with which | 4:45:56 | 4:46:00 | |
my right honourable friend cares
about her constituents and once they | 4:46:00 | 4:46:04 | |
are concerns aired and listen to by
government. I commend her for doing | 4:46:04 | 4:46:09 | |
exactly that this evening. The
question is that this house do our | 4:46:09 | 4:46:17 | |
journey. As many as all of that
opinion say aye. I. The ayes have | 4:46:17 | 4:46:24 | |
it. Order, order. | 4:46:24 | 4:46:31 |