24/02/2014 Newsnight Scotland

The

near

in

Scottish

Goldie.

here.

Isobel,

put to them on the latest put to them on the latest

put to them on the latest north-east

independent Scotland. Your coalition independent Scotland. Your coalition

independent Scotland. Your coalition idea

independent Scotland. Your coalition for Norway

independent Scotland. Your coalition That

independent Scotland. Your coalition it.

independent Scotland. Your coalition Swinton's

independent Scotland. Your coalition that

independent Scotland. Your coalition for

independent Scotland. Your coalition explicitly

independent Scotland. Your coalition money

independent Scotland. Your coalition have to

fund. Or you borrow, which seems fund. Or you borrow, which seems

fund. Or you borrow, which seems at ?840 billion?

fund. Or you borrow, which seems is

fund. Or you borrow, which seems SNP have produced

fund. Or you borrow, which seems indicate

fund. Or you borrow, which seems possible

fund. Or you borrow, which seems it's

fund. Or you borrow, which seems Fiona Hyslop, even in

fund. Or you borrow, which seems deficit.

fund. Or you borrow, which seems start paying into

fund. Or you borrow, which seems funds

fund. Or you borrow, which seems to

fund. Or you borrow, which seems that's come out of the North Sea.

fund. Or you borrow, which seems It's about stewardship

fund. Or you borrow, which seems best steward Scotland's

fund. Or you borrow, which seems Norway.

fund. Or you borrow, which seems have to

fund. Or you borrow, which seems conditions

Norway, you'll

They've

aside,

people

including your party, that we should including your party, that we should

including your party, that we should wealthiest

including your party, that we should can

including your party, that we should have not

including your party, that we should opportunity

including your party, that we should opportunity halfway

work, an oil fund with independence. work, an oil fund with independence.

work, an oil fund with independence. hear

work, an oil fund with independence. enter independence in a

work, an oil fund with independence. are

work, an oil fund with independence. opportunity to start

work, an oil fund with independence. paper,

work, an oil fund with independence. going

work, an oil fund with independence. you've

work, an oil fund with independence. white

work, an oil fund with independence. underestimated

work, an oil fund with independence. generous. That

work, an oil fund with independence. $113

two countries in the world that have two countries in the world that have

two countries in the world that have Iraq. My question

two countries in the world that have knocking the

two countries in the world that have suggested

two countries in the world that have dampen

two countries in the world that have independence? You don't think

two countries in the world that have would

two countries in the world that have and Chancellor of a

two countries in the world that have the

two countries in the world that have budget

two countries in the world that have benefitting to the tune

two countries in the world that have per person

Different choices might have been Different choices might have been

Different choices might have been at

Different choices might have been acknowledges in

Different choices might have been oil

Different choices might have been that

Different choices might have been necessary

Different choices might have been services. So you

Different choices might have been ways. That was

Different choices might have been SNP's

Different choices might have been campaign's

Different choices might have been country

Different choices might have been on

Different choices might have been spending

Different choices might have been most

Different choices might have been the moment and while

Different choices might have been blips upwards, the

Different choices might have been is

Different choices might have been reserves

Different choices might have been points: Norway,

Different choices might have been is. In terms

Different choices might have been rest of the UK.

Different choices might have been spending. In terms of, if you

Different choices might have been your oil fund in two ways,

Different choices might have been stabilise and

Different choices might have been nation,

stabilisation fund is important. stabilisation fund is important.

stabilisation fund is important. That's important.

stabilisation fund is important. tremendous opportunity,

stabilisation fund is important. If we

stabilisation fund is important. better place.

stabilisation fund is important. make the choice between a model

stabilisation fund is important. falls,

stabilisation fund is important. revenues from oil

stabilisation fund is important. past

stabilisation fund is important. public

stabilisation fund is important. he wasn't...

stabilisation fund is important. terms

stabilisation fund is important. if

stabilisation fund is important. Going

stabilisation fund is important. these

stabilisation fund is important. you,

stabilisation fund is important. environment and all parties supposed

stabilisation fund is important. commitment

stabilisation fund is important. saying,

stabilisation fund is important. about

stabilisation fund is important. disagree

stabilisation fund is important. at other

fair, in Scotland, the Scottish fair, in Scotland, the Scottish

fair, in Scotland, the Scottish We've

fair, in Scotland, the Scottish I

fair, in Scotland, the Scottish would

fair, in Scotland, the Scottish renewable energy.

fair, in Scotland, the Scottish Scotland, we all of

fair, in Scotland, the Scottish that. At the moment,

fair, in Scotland, the Scottish going

fair, in Scotland, the Scottish households

fair, in Scotland, the Scottish non-equate

fair, in Scotland, the Scottish shouldn't

fair, in Scotland, the Scottish taking

fair, in Scotland, the Scottish rather than

fair, in Scotland, the Scottish technology. Burning

fair, in Scotland, the Scottish the

fair, in Scotland, the Scottish renewables,

fair, in Scotland, the Scottish energy

fair, in Scotland, the Scottish that's

fair, in Scotland, the Scottish payers

fair, in Scotland, the Scottish centrally

fair, in Scotland, the Scottish energy.

fair, in Scotland, the Scottish every

that is very efficient, that uses that is very efficient, that uses

that is very efficient, that uses have

that is very efficient, that uses based

that is very efficient, that uses Minister announced

that is very efficient, that uses department

that is very efficient, that uses Scotland

that is very efficient, that uses that can be

that is very efficient, that uses coming

that is very efficient, that uses much

that is very efficient, that uses Think

that is very efficient, that uses energies.

that is very efficient, that uses forward. Thank

that is very efficient, that uses Annabel Goldie, your

that is very efficient, that uses working on a

that is very efficient, that uses inception.

that is very efficient, that uses the

haven't had before, and that is an haven't had before, and that is an

haven't had before, and that is an agreement

haven't had before, and that is an to what should be

haven't had before, and that is an Democrats.

haven't had before, and that is an the

haven't had before, and that is an interesting

haven't had before, and that is an explained field of federalism

haven't had before, and that is an they want to pursue.

haven't had before, and that is an Party has

haven't had before, and that is an with

haven't had before, and that is an debate. -- with Davidson.

haven't had before, and that is an Is

haven't had before, and that is an Democrats

haven't had before, and that is an there

haven't had before, and that is an those

haven't had before, and that is an fundamental decision,

haven't had before, and that is an Parliament

haven't had before, and that is an same?

haven't had before, and that is an the choice is not

haven't had before, and that is an and no trains. Can

haven't had before, and that is an proposing?

haven't had before, and that is an to

haven't had before, and that is an What you

haven't had before, and that is an anticipate,

haven't had before, and that is an in

that is not negative or unhealthy. that is not negative or unhealthy.

that is not negative or unhealthy. that what you get is

that is not negative or unhealthy. majority will go

that is not negative or unhealthy. radical

Parliament? I think we can be Parliament? I think we can be

Parliament? I think we can be its nature a strong

Parliament? I think we can be Scotland will respect

Parliament? I think we can be the unionist parties

Parliament? I think we can be either the SNP

Parliament? I think we can be in this. I

Parliament? I think we can be positive development. Lets

Parliament? I think we can be the

keeps on asking about what will keeps on asking about what will

keeps on asking about what will you

keeps on asking about what will it.

keeps on asking about what will pages,

keeps on asking about what will at least we have produced

keeps on asking about what will not said what you would do with a

keeps on asking about what will no.

prospectus... You are asking the prospectus... You are asking the

prospectus... You are asking the that they are

prospectus... You are asking the the next few

prospectus... You are asking the would it do only

prospectus... You are asking the measures

prospectus... You are asking the believers in terms

prospectus... You are asking the we see anything

prospect of working with other prospect of working with other

prospect of working with other the 18th

prospect of working with other yes vote

prospect of working with other electorate in Scotland

prospect of working with other SNP into

it not reasonable for them to be it not reasonable for them to be

it not reasonable for them to be their faith and

it not reasonable for them to be actually do under

it not reasonable for them to be settlement

it not reasonable for them to be interests?

it not reasonable for them to be Salmond, that final

abide by what ever the result was. abide by what ever the result was.

abide by what ever the result was. example, David

abide by what ever the result was. membership

abide by what ever the result was. happen

abide by what ever the result was. wants more

abide by what ever the result was. on

abide by what ever the result was. are concerned

abide by what ever the result was. they have

abide by what ever the result was. proposal with

abide by what ever the result was. other

abide by what ever the result was. but no

abide by what ever the result was. worry is

abide by what ever the result was. choice of two

abide by what ever the result was. just

abide by what ever the result was. would we get

abide by what ever the result was. of the UK for voting

abide by what ever the result was. the case?

abide by what ever the result was. under a Conservative

abide by what ever the result was. be

abide by what ever the result was. Government

abide by what ever the result was. prospects for a no vote are very

worrying. worrying.

Cabinet coming into Scotland, Cabinet coming into Scotland,

Cabinet coming into Scotland, back to

Cabinet coming into Scotland, tone

you think the people in Scotland you think the people in Scotland

you think the people in Scotland question?

you think the people in Scotland right

you think the people in Scotland what George

you think the people in Scotland unexpected.

you think the people in Scotland currency

you think the people in Scotland some degree of national sovereignty.

you think the people in Scotland That

this in more detail... George this in more detail... George

this in more detail... George that absolutely people are entitled

this in more detail... George to come and give that

and then there was just no and then there was just no

and then there was just no no pre-negotiation. What

and then there was just no Westminster

and then there was just no deal

and then there was just no which

and then there was just no is

and then there was just no Kingdom

and then there was just no if

and then there was just no position,

and then there was just no there

and then there was just no issue,

and then there was just no style. To

and then there was just no Scots'

and then there was just no and

and then there was just no questions. How do you

and then there was just no what the

and then there was just no the

and then there was just no feel...

and then there was just no and

and then there was just no been counter-productive.

and then there was just no come

and then there was just no That was the difference

and then there was just no Cameron came in, left,

and then there was just no front

make yourself available... Hang on a make yourself available... Hang on a

make yourself available... Hang on a people living in other

make yourself available... Hang on a the

make yourself available... Hang on a independent,

make yourself available... Hang on a and

make yourself available... Hang on a polls and make a decision

make yourself available... Hang on a they want to do that, fine. But

make yourself available... Hang on a you

make yourself available... Hang on a of the UK have a right to

make yourself available... Hang on a would

make yourself available... Hang on a it would be

George Osborne or Ed Balls, after a George Osborne or Ed Balls, after a

George Osborne or Ed Balls, after a electorate and

George Osborne or Ed Balls, after a to not have a currency union,

George Osborne or Ed Balls, after a will

concern might be touching, but at concern might be touching, but at

concern might be touching, but at they right to

concern might be touching, but at tradable

concern might be touching, but at the opportunity

concern might be touching, but at union,

concern might be touching, but at way

concern might be touching, but at Remember, that

concern might be touching, but at of debt that the UK has

concern might be touching, but at recognise that we

concern might be touching, but at asset.

concern might be touching, but at possibility that you have judged

concern might be touching, but at this wrong, let's look

concern might be touching, but at possibility of Scotland having

concern might be touching, but at own

concern might be touching, but at that?

yes campaign are in favour of an yes campaign are in favour of an

yes campaign are in favour of an lots

yes campaign are in favour of an guidance

yes campaign are in favour of an in the

yes campaign are in favour of an out

yes campaign are in favour of an forward and

yes campaign are in favour of an planning process,

yes campaign are in favour of an between September

yes campaign are in favour of an that

yes campaign are in favour of an no, what is

yes campaign are in favour of an out,

yes campaign are in favour of an options.

yes campaign are in favour of an conclusion,

yes campaign are in favour of an that

yes campaign are in favour of an is

yes campaign are in favour of an and a currency

yes campaign are in favour of an 20 year

yes campaign are in favour of an differences.

yes campaign are in favour of an for

yes campaign are in favour of an whole

yes campaign are in favour of an measures

yes campaign are in favour of an other

yes campaign are in favour of an markets.

think. Currently,

sovereignty, at least

independence

sovereignty

1946 as

that are

currency

our

What constitutes

and

of

majority of

a separate currency, in a sense a separate currency, in a sense

a separate currency, in a sense Isobel's

a separate currency, in a sense was agreeing with the

a separate currency, in a sense the yes campaign.

a separate currency, in a sense would

a separate currency, in a sense awe gree with George Osborne, do

a separate currency, in a sense agree with Jackson Carlaw,

a separate currency, in a sense Deputy Leader of the

a separate currency, in a sense Conservatives, who said if there was

a separate currency, in a sense a yes vote

a separate currency, in a sense sensible

pound, he would argue for it. Would pound, he would argue for it. Would

pound, he would argue for it. Would reality

pound, he would argue for it. Would separating

pound, he would argue for it. Would I will deal with

pound, he would argue for it. Would are

pound, he would argue for it. Would reality

pound, he would argue for it. Would think

pound, he would argue for it. Would interesting

pound, he would argue for it. Would union,

pound, he would argue for it. Would you

pound, he would argue for it. Would on. That

pound, he would argue for it. Would Alex Salmond,

pound, he would argue for it. Would that. Hang

pound, he would argue for it. Would voted for

pound, he would argue for it. Would debt. Now

pound, he would argue for it. Would Salmond

pound, he would argue for it. Would statement

pound, he would argue for it. Would Who owns the

pound, he would argue for it. Would foreign country and

pound, he would argue for it. Would country

pound, he would argue for it. Would that's

pound, he would argue for it. Would sense... Inconvenient

pound, he would argue for it. Would fact.

pound, he would argue for it. Would the

pound, he would argue for it. Would share

pound, he would argue for it. Would service

pound, he would argue for it. Would potentially? ? We're

pound, he would argue for it. Would important

pound, he would argue for it. Would take

pound, he would argue for it. Would Therefore it's in their interest...

pound, he would argue for it. Would You've made

pound, he would argue for it. Would what

pound, he would argue for it. Would that

pound, he would argue for it. Would on. We don't

pound, he would argue for it. Would share. Can you

pound, he would argue for it. Would court.

pound, he would argue for it. Would initiative and

pound, he would argue for it. Would to

pound, he would argue for it. Would England

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth union do

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth make

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth debt?

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth do

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth debt. That's a reasonable

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth view. You

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth where you're asking

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth to take

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth the debt and

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth don't

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth think there are

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth George Osborne

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth that

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth a shared

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth We would be in

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth of

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth debt, so

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth it

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth responsibility of

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth George

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth happened? We would make

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth a responsible

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth of

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth think the

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth responsible

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth the debt?

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth that

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth Plan B despite

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth get

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth occurrence

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth --

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth shared responsibilities. The cost

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth the UK Government

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth is

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth should

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth is

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth yes vote. It's

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth to

amount of that 1. 3 trillion worth you accept the

the UK if there isn't a currency the UK if there isn't a currency

the UK if there isn't a currency currency,

the UK if there isn't a currency there will be transaction costs,

depending on what Scotland decides depending on what Scotland decides

depending on what Scotland decides million?

depending on what Scotland decides these

depending on what Scotland decides actual costs

depending on what Scotland decides that.

depending on what Scotland decides Salmond has

depending on what Scotland decides answered is what the

depending on what Scotland decides for

Chancellor say it's in the best Chancellor say it's in the best

Chancellor say it's in the best would

Chancellor say it's in the best of

Chancellor say it's in the best and Danny

Westminster if Scotland has decided Westminster if Scotland has decided

Westminster if Scotland has decided saying is that

Westminster if Scotland has decided responsibly,

Westminster if Scotland has decided Osborne

Westminster if Scotland has decided if

Westminster if Scotland has decided Scotland

Westminster if Scotland has decided rates

Westminster if Scotland has decided that

Westminster if Scotland has decided currency

Westminster if Scotland has decided yes or no answer.

Westminster if Scotland has decided for us

Westminster if Scotland has decided Government's

Government minister agrees with Government minister agrees with

Government minister agrees with the

Government minister agrees with or

Government minister agrees with expresses

Government minister agrees with not articulating a Plan B and they

Government minister agrees with will

Government minister agrees with an

Government minister agrees with proposal.

the Cabinet they've concerns about the Cabinet they've concerns about

the Cabinet they've concerns about out the

the Cabinet they've concerns about about

the Cabinet they've concerns about walking

the Cabinet they've concerns about white paper is an

the Cabinet they've concerns about tactic?

the Cabinet they've concerns about you're asking, that we've

the Cabinet they've concerns about forward, we've gone forward

collective Cabinet and a Government, collective Cabinet and a Government,

collective Cabinet and a Government, is of course,

collective Cabinet and a Government, couple

collective Cabinet and a Government, hopefully we will

collective Cabinet and a Government, Russia's

collective Cabinet and a Government, you

collective Cabinet and a Government, out

collective Cabinet and a Government, well.

collective Cabinet and a Government, are

concerns about in their countries concerns about in their countries

just check... Would you take just check... Would you take

just check... Would you take it was January

just check... Would you take raised that

just check... Would you take Hague. I

just check... Would you take and

just check... Would you take David

setting Our World offer of support setting Our World offer of support

setting Our World offer of support I think there is a

setting Our World offer of support feel

setting Our World offer of support happening and no

setting Our World offer of support heart bleed for

setting Our World offer of support we can

setting Our World offer of support humanitarian

setting Our World offer of support it's

setting Our World offer of support Westminster

setting Our World offer of support this?

setting Our World offer of support David bowo is backing -- Bowie is

endorsing the better together side. endorsing the better together side.

endorsing the better together side. side? I

endorsing the better together side. independence. I'm

endorsing the better together side. celebrities

endorsing the better together side. They're

endorsing the better together side. views. I think

endorsing the better together side. wake up to what the

endorsing the better together side. separated

endorsing the better together side. and

endorsing the better together side. into

endorsing the better together side. David

endorsing the better together side. you accept

endorsing the better together side. Kingdom

endorsing the better together side. the

endorsing the better together side. upset the budget that's just

endorsing the better together side. agreed,

endorsing the better together side. in agreement with the UK with the

allocation of the contribution that allocation of the contribution that

allocation of the contribution that that transition

allocation of the contribution that is what I was saying in terms

allocation of the contribution that budget. After a

allocation of the contribution that reopen

allocation of the contribution that independent

the UK that we would take our the UK that we would take our

the UK that we would take our the

the UK that we would take our rational way forward.

the UK that we would take our of

the UK that we would take our recent

the UK that we would take our the EU

the UK that we would take our independent Scotland

the UK that we would take our membership.

the UK that we would take our that the UK Government's job

the UK that we would take our attempt to

for independence, despite what the for independence, despite what the

moral obligation is to not allow moral obligation is to not allow

moral obligation is to not allow pre-negotiations. I

moral obligation is to not allow Scotland makes

moral obligation is to not allow problem

moral obligation is to not allow the

moral obligation is to not allow states adopt. There

moral obligation is to not allow contrary

moral obligation is to not allow happen,

moral obligation is to not allow other member

moral obligation is to not allow won't

moral obligation is to not allow UK

moral obligation is to not allow Conservative

moral obligation is to not allow and out

moral obligation is to not allow that subject,

moral obligation is to not allow reckless, about wanting

moral obligation is to not allow probably anti-European sentiment

moral obligation is to not allow England is different to ear.

moral obligation is to not allow say,

moral obligation is to not allow heaven

moral obligation is to not allow coming in?

moral obligation is to not allow the currency, what sort of currency

moral obligation is to not allow will we have?

moral obligation is to not allow it

moral obligation is to not allow what

moral obligation is to not allow going to do,

moral obligation is to not allow leap

moral obligation is to not allow people to a

moral obligation is to not allow people

moral obligation is to not allow vote. How comfortable would you

moral obligation is to not allow conducted by

moral obligation is to not allow it?

moral obligation is to not allow terms could be. But you cannot

moral obligation is to not allow because you are not a sovereign

moral obligation is to not allow state. Yell

moral obligation is to not allow read the White

moral obligation is to not allow of negotiation that you would

moral obligation is to not allow Paper that everything

moral obligation is to not allow things. A Government in

moral obligation is to not allow mode, a

moral obligation is to not allow vote immediately the

moral obligation is to not allow terms of presenting

moral obligation is to not allow and others

moral obligation is to not allow be

moral obligation is to not allow vote.

moral obligation is to not allow time for.