01/02/2017 Newsnight


01/02/2017

Similar Content

Browse content similar to 01/02/2017. Check below for episodes and series from the same categories and more!

Transcript


LineFromTo

The ayes to the right, 498. The noes to the left, 118.

:00:12.:00:21.

The Commons votes for Brexit, despite the fact that

:00:22.:00:24.

an overwhelming majority of MPs campaigned against it.

:00:25.:00:26.

Parliament and the public expressed different views, and it's

:00:27.:00:30.

That is an event quite unprecedented in our parliamentary history,

:00:31.:00:38.

whereby popular sovereignty is trumping parliamentary sovereignty.

:00:39.:00:42.

To vote against the majority verdict of the largest democratic exercise

:00:43.:00:46.

in British history, I think, would risk putting

:00:47.:00:50.

an overwhelming vote for Brexit, Labour was split three ways

:00:51.:01:02.

and hit by resignations, and there were hints

:01:03.:01:04.

We'll ask Remainer MPs if now is the time

:01:05.:01:07.

to submit to public opinion, or whether they should

:01:08.:01:09.

Also tonight, the case of the Nigerian quadruplets born

:01:10.:01:14.

in a British hospital at a cost of ?330,000.

:01:15.:01:20.

OK, I do understand that it's a very difficult time for you, but we do

:01:21.:01:25.

We'll debate the rights and wrongs of allowing

:01:26.:01:31.

US soldiers dealing with their experiences in Iraq.

:01:32.:01:47.

But the Taiwanese-born director has his own worries

:01:48.:01:49.

It's nerve-wracking, very uncomfortable.

:01:50.:02:12.

Well, we voted them in 21 months ago, and today MPs did

:02:13.:02:22.

the country's bidding, taking an historic step

:02:23.:02:23.

towards taking Britain out of the European Union,

:02:24.:02:25.

against, for most, their own judgement on the matter.

:02:26.:02:32.

Our political editor Nick Watt has been watching. 500 out of 650, the

:02:33.:02:40.

speaker and the Deputy Speaker do not speak, it was a significant,

:02:41.:02:44.

historical moment, quite an emotional time, I spoke to a

:02:45.:02:48.

Remained visited just before voting and they said it was the worst but

:02:49.:02:53.

they had ever cast and then I spoke to a happy The minister who said,

:02:54.:02:57.

I've been waiting all my life to do that. Downing Street are delighted

:02:58.:03:10.

with the vote, one reason is that they feel it is less likely that the

:03:11.:03:13.

House of Lords can delay the bill, and that is significant because

:03:14.:03:16.

Theresa May wants to get on and trigger Article 50 before her self

:03:17.:03:18.

imposed deadline at the end of March. One possible date is the

:03:19.:03:20.

European Council, March nine and tenth or before that because it

:03:21.:03:23.

needs to be a lengthy formal letter from the UK. The reason they want to

:03:24.:03:26.

get in early is that they have been advised that the European Commission

:03:27.:03:29.

and the European Council will be able to give their formal response

:03:30.:03:33.

before the first round of the French presidential election on April 23

:03:34.:03:39.

but only if they go early. It's all happening, they'll have to worry. If

:03:40.:03:44.

they don't go early the second round of the French election will be May

:03:45.:03:48.

seven and or those who will be president of France by them. Not a

:03:49.:03:55.

great day for Labour. Divided, 47 MPs defied a three line whip, three

:03:56.:04:00.

members of the Shadow Cabinet resigned, although between ten and

:04:01.:04:04.

13 Labour frontbenchers are still in place and as I understand it Jeremy

:04:05.:04:09.

Corbyn is in no rush to do the usual thing, to sack them, he's going to

:04:10.:04:13.

wait for next week and see if any of the amendments we see at the

:04:14.:04:16.

committee stage of the bill will be accepted by the government or voted

:04:17.:04:21.

on by MPs. The significance of that is, if that happens and if the bill

:04:22.:04:25.

is amended, maybe some of those Labour MPs would be able to vote in

:04:26.:04:30.

favour of it. The amendment that seems to be getting cross-party

:04:31.:04:34.

support is by Chris Leslie, former Labour Shadow Chancellor. And this

:04:35.:04:38.

would require the government to hold a parliamentary vote on whatever

:04:39.:04:41.

emerges at the end of the negotiations, deal or no Deal, at

:04:42.:04:45.

the moment they will only be a vote if there is a deal. And what former

:04:46.:04:50.

Tory Remained ministers are saying to the government is, you will be

:04:51.:04:57.

safe, it will be fine, how about a accepting this amendment? Blount

:04:58.:05:00.

will be talking to one the Labour Shadow Cabinet who resigned in a few

:05:01.:05:05.

minutes. Speech of the day George Osborne? I think we'd have to say

:05:06.:05:10.

that. He did say that while he supports Remain he will vote for

:05:11.:05:15.

triggering Article 50 because it would be a constitutional outrage if

:05:16.:05:17.

he tried to thwart the will of the people. But then he made a pointed

:05:18.:05:22.

intervention by saying that the government has decided not to

:05:23.:05:27.

prioritise the economy and they are prioritising controls of immigration

:05:28.:05:30.

and taking the UK out of the jurisdiction of the European Court

:05:31.:05:34.

of Justice. That's quite a thing for a former Chancellor to say who

:05:35.:05:37.

obviously decides to the Leeds. Believes that elections are decided

:05:38.:05:45.

on the economy. Then there will be battles over what form Brexit will

:05:46.:05:48.

take and he ended with the words, I will be in those fights in the

:05:49.:05:52.

couple of years ahead. Nick, thank you. Having given us the referendum

:05:53.:05:58.

most MPs felt they could not ignore it. Most MPs voted in favour of the

:05:59.:06:05.

referendum and then 47 of them voted against invoking Article 50 is a way

:06:06.:06:09.

of accepting the result. And some like Ken Clarke didn't want a

:06:10.:06:12.

referendum in the first place and voted against the result of all.

:06:13.:06:16.

None of us can remember an occasion like it. We know how the nation

:06:17.:06:23.

divides and Brexit but the most striking gap is between MPs and

:06:24.:06:29.

their electorate. Here is the public vote, yellow for Remain, blue for

:06:30.:06:34.

leave. This shows how different local authorities went in the

:06:35.:06:39.

referendum. And here is that the equivalent map for MPs looks based

:06:40.:06:42.

on their declared positions in the referendum. There have often been

:06:43.:06:46.

gaps between rulers and ruled yet the historic norm is that the rulers

:06:47.:06:52.

to get their way. Not this time. The referendum outcome shows how very

:06:53.:06:54.

out of touch the House of Commons is with the people. The only parties in

:06:55.:07:01.

favour of leaving work Ukip, with one MP, and the Democratic Unionist

:07:02.:07:08.

party in Northern Ireland, that makes nine MPs out of 650. The

:07:09.:07:14.

consequence is that for the first time in its history MPs have to vote

:07:15.:07:18.

for a policy which the vast majority of them, around three quarters,

:07:19.:07:23.

oppose. That is an event without precedent in our long parliamentary

:07:24.:07:30.

history. Other countries are familiar with direct democracy, the

:07:31.:07:36.

most famous case in recent decades proposition 13 in California,

:07:37.:07:40.

capping property taxes against the views of the political

:07:41.:07:42.

establishment. The death penalty was reimposed there as well as a public

:07:43.:07:48.

demand. Until recently in the UK, we have tended to go for representative

:07:49.:07:53.

democracy, vote them in and vote them out again if you don't like

:07:54.:08:03.

them. Then came the first Europe vote in 1975. It's beginning to look

:08:04.:08:08.

as if we may not have a single No venting area in Britain itself...

:08:09.:08:12.

But in that case nation and Commons have the same majority view. Europe

:08:13.:08:17.

has driven a coach and horses through the British constitution. We

:08:18.:08:20.

would not have had the idea of a referendum in the first place if not

:08:21.:08:25.

for Europe in 1975, when Harold Wilson used it to hold together a

:08:26.:08:29.

divided Labour Party, just as David Cameron used it to hold together a

:08:30.:08:40.

divided Conservative Party but in this case, by contrast with 1975,

:08:41.:08:42.

the people have voted against the wishes of the government. The

:08:43.:08:44.

Article 50 debate reflected the cognitive dissidents that our

:08:45.:08:48.

legislators feel. The point has been made to me that we are not delegates

:08:49.:08:54.

but when all your neighbours, local business people, local pharmacists,

:08:55.:08:57.

health professionals, your political allies and indeed your political

:08:58.:09:00.

opponents make a point that you have to take a stand on an issue, I feel

:09:01.:09:07.

this is the right course of action. I do accept that Lambeth voted

:09:08.:09:13.

overwhelmingly for Remain but as I have made it very clear this was a

:09:14.:09:18.

UK referendum, not constituency -based referendum... But and in the

:09:19.:09:28.

country how did Remain voters feel the MP should have voted? -- out in

:09:29.:09:30.

the country. Know we've come to the process and had a referendum and a

:09:31.:09:33.

democratic process and people have decided to leave I believe we should

:09:34.:09:39.

follow that process. Our MP is Tim Curran, the leader of the Liberal

:09:40.:09:43.

Democrats. He's going to the wire over the issue of a second

:09:44.:09:46.

referendum -- Tim Farron. Although my party has a three line whip in

:09:47.:09:50.

Westminster it does not have a three line whip on my views so I am very

:09:51.:09:55.

happy with my MP. We lost, that's the way of it, we have to make the

:09:56.:10:00.

most of it and try to unite again as a country and deal with the

:10:01.:10:04.

situation as we find it. He's decided to abstain because he wants

:10:05.:10:10.

to reflect his voters. Their beliefs. I don't believe he's

:10:11.:10:13.

reflecting them enough. I think he should have the courage of his

:10:14.:10:16.

convictions he should be representing us because it is his

:10:17.:10:22.

job. His job to represent us, his constituents. Certainly some mixed

:10:23.:10:29.

views from Remain voters. Was today the day for them to fold behind the

:10:30.:10:35.

majority? Earlier I spoke to two MPs who have campaigned to Remain yet to

:10:36.:10:41.

different decisions today, Nicky Morgan, the former Education

:10:42.:10:43.

Secretary, voted in favour of Article 50, she said, to avoid a

:10:44.:10:47.

constitutional crisis. In Rachael Maskell who resigned as a member of

:10:48.:10:53.

the Labour Shadow Cabinet to read against Article 50. I first asked

:10:54.:10:54.

Nicky Morgan if she had found it Well, I was quite clear

:10:55.:10:57.

from the autumn onwards, that we needed a short sharp bill

:10:58.:11:04.

to trigger Article 50, that Parliament really,

:11:05.:11:07.

if which we were going to avoid a crisis in our democracy,

:11:08.:11:09.

needed to respect the democratic But of course, as many of us said,

:11:10.:11:12.

we'd really rather not have been in the situation of having this

:11:13.:11:16.

debate and having to Well, Rachael Maskell,

:11:17.:11:19.

you voted against triggering Article 50 last year,

:11:20.:11:21.

before last year you I came here to make sure

:11:22.:11:23.

the people I represent in York What we're trying to do is mesh

:11:24.:11:29.

together a referendum which is one process with a Parliamentary

:11:30.:11:35.

democracy, another process, and through the referendum

:11:36.:11:38.

we saw clearly the way that our constituents voted,

:11:39.:11:41.

and therefore it is incumbent on myself to bring that voice

:11:42.:11:43.

into Westminster, which But you voted for a national

:11:44.:11:45.

referendum, you didn't vote for a referendum in York Central,

:11:46.:11:50.

you voted for a national referendum, do you want to apologise

:11:51.:11:53.

to the public for voting for a national referendum,

:11:54.:11:55.

for which you were not willing We got a question put

:11:56.:11:58.

before us today in a bill, to move forward into a process,

:11:59.:12:04.

where we will be coming out of the single market and out

:12:05.:12:07.

of the customs union. Now I can't even remember that

:12:08.:12:11.

being on the ballot paper last June, and therefore we have an unelected

:12:12.:12:15.

Prime Minister, now moving forward to put forward her own position

:12:16.:12:25.

on how we should move forward. I think what is really important

:12:26.:12:28.

is we listen to where people Because that question was not

:12:29.:12:31.

on the ballot paper. That question wasn't,

:12:32.:12:34.

but the Brexit was, and there's only one model of Brexit on the table

:12:35.:12:37.

and you're voting against it. We know right back last summer

:12:38.:12:44.

there are so many models of Brexit and that's why the different Brexit

:12:45.:12:47.

campaigns couldn't Where we are moving

:12:48.:12:49.

forward to is important. What we have been saying,

:12:50.:12:52.

a people's Brexit is very different from a Theresa May Brexit,

:12:53.:12:54.

where she is going to take us out of the single market,

:12:55.:12:58.

out of the customs union and nobody Do you accept that point you could

:12:59.:13:00.

vote against Article 50 and say, until I get the kind

:13:01.:13:04.

of Brexit I support, I'm not You could have taken

:13:05.:13:07.

that position today. Look, I think we all thought

:13:08.:13:10.

about that, but I don't agree, It is a difficult thing

:13:11.:13:13.

to stand down from a job, in the shadow front

:13:14.:13:17.

bench, everything else. I do think it was incumbent

:13:18.:13:19.

on Parliament to understand how people voted and to pass the bill,

:13:20.:13:21.

and I think that's what hopefully we will see

:13:22.:13:24.

by the time we get to March. There is a separate debate to be had

:13:25.:13:27.

and that's why the publication of the White Paper tomorrow

:13:28.:13:30.

is important, about the terms of Brexit, and I think that

:13:31.:13:33.

many of us in Parliament and many, many thousands, tens of thousands

:13:34.:13:36.

of people outside have very firm views on that,

:13:37.:13:39.

which I hope the Government But you're not going

:13:40.:13:41.

to get that debate. If you nod through Article 50

:13:42.:13:45.

you are going to get Theresa May's Brexit,

:13:46.:13:47.

so you, I mean that is Theresa May has set out the 12

:13:48.:13:49.

pillars in her speech and they will be in the White Paper,

:13:50.:13:58.

but there is a negotiation Parliament needs to be involved

:13:59.:14:02.

in that, not in the process because she will negotiate

:14:03.:14:06.

and Government will negotiate but keeping Parliament updated,

:14:07.:14:10.

keeping an eye on what is happening in our economy, and what people

:14:11.:14:12.

are saying outside is going to be tremendously important,

:14:13.:14:15.

and that's where MPs can really add Hang on, you have just voted not

:14:16.:14:18.

to activate a referendum result. I voted according to the way the

:14:19.:15:06.

people who elected me asked me to. If an amendment comes up,

:15:07.:15:10.

for example, Nicky Morgan, that says yes, we will invoke

:15:11.:15:13.

Article 50, but we negotiate our way Would you support

:15:14.:15:17.

something like that? You clearly believe it,

:15:18.:15:22.

it is consistent with what the public voted for,

:15:23.:15:25.

it is a Brexit model, You would struggle

:15:26.:15:27.

not to vote for that? I wouldn't, because I think

:15:28.:15:31.

that the bill is a process bill I do think that there are amendments

:15:32.:15:40.

down about Parliamentary scrutiny and about the vote at the end

:15:41.:15:44.

and they will be debated next week. I think there is a separate

:15:45.:15:48.

White Paper process about the pillars that the Prime Minister

:15:49.:15:50.

has set out, and I do think, as I say, that Parliament has

:15:51.:15:53.

a really important role in informing ministers about what's happening

:15:54.:15:56.

on the ground in our constituency, what people are saying

:15:57.:15:59.

about the effects on their economy, their businesses, regulations,

:16:00.:16:01.

I am getting lobbied all the time by people who are saying how

:16:02.:16:03.

is this going to work? Can we make sure there is no cliff

:16:04.:16:06.

edge for example, in March 2019? Those things are important

:16:07.:16:10.

ministers hear. Rachael, do you think this indicates

:16:11.:16:12.

a computer collapse of discipline You voted what, threeways, for,

:16:13.:16:14.

against, in between, the party frontbenches,

:16:15.:16:20.

whips, everybody voting What does that say about the state

:16:21.:16:21.

of Labour at the moment? I think you'll find next

:16:22.:16:27.

week as we're talking through the amendments

:16:28.:16:29.

that we will be absolutely solid and making sure we have the process

:16:30.:16:31.

in place to call the Government to account, what we've been trying

:16:32.:16:34.

to do today is to put referendum into a Parliamentary democracy

:16:35.:16:37.

and we need to make sure that systems work as we move forward,

:16:38.:16:40.

because reality is there are two systems that clash, one which is

:16:41.:16:46.

about empowerment and clearly that is what I was doing,

:16:47.:16:50.

empowering the people You are empowering your constituency

:16:51.:16:53.

but ignoring the majority vote in the country that

:16:54.:16:56.

you voted to have. Every single MP has the right

:16:57.:17:00.

to represent those that elect them to Parliament and therefore

:17:01.:17:03.

that was absolutely right that MPs chose to do that today,

:17:04.:17:06.

but as we move forward we clearly are going to have amendments

:17:07.:17:11.

which put the scrutiny process behind this bill,

:17:12.:17:14.

which is absolutely crucial. We have amendments in there,

:17:15.:17:15.

particularly at the end of the process to make sure

:17:16.:17:18.

that the negotiation strategy, You are talking a brave talk here,

:17:19.:17:20.

Rachael, but the truth is your party has been all over the shop,

:17:21.:17:26.

basically, hasn't it. It does come down to the fact that

:17:27.:17:28.

some of them believe you have to stick with the result

:17:29.:17:31.

of what the voters said, and some like you have said,

:17:32.:17:34.

I want to go my own way or the way We're really clear as a party

:17:35.:17:38.

that we do not want a hard Brexit, a Theresa May Brexit,

:17:39.:17:45.

where she has gone and determined And what we have said,

:17:46.:17:48.

is that a people's Brexit would be incredibly different

:17:49.:17:52.

from what she has set out. She hasn't followed

:17:53.:17:55.

the will of the people, she has set out her own terms

:17:56.:17:58.

and we saw, just over the weekend, how easy it is that she could give

:17:59.:18:01.

away that power, to other countries and if you're signing trade

:18:02.:18:04.

agreements I would have to say where is the Parliamentary democracy

:18:05.:18:07.

in those processes? So there is much to discuss over

:18:08.:18:10.

the coming two years and we will certainly be

:18:11.:18:13.

at the table for that. Rachael Maskell, Nicky

:18:14.:18:15.

Morgan, thanks both. It seems more than twelve days since

:18:16.:18:20.

President Trump's inauguration, and the new normal arrived

:18:21.:18:23.

in US politics. Well, you can look at polls,

:18:24.:18:26.

the approval ratings But even better than polls,

:18:27.:18:30.

you can talk to people. Particularly those

:18:31.:18:35.

who voted for him. Yalda Hakim is in rural

:18:36.:18:37.

Pennsylvania, trying to find out Pennsylvania, Donald

:18:38.:18:39.

Trump's heartland. I can't believe that,

:18:40.:18:51.

I thought our country has progressed so much and we took

:18:52.:19:01.

like three steps back. If we stand up to other countries,

:19:02.:19:05.

we have to make America great again, It was counties like this facing

:19:06.:19:08.

a decline in manufacturing, shrinking population and rising

:19:09.:19:18.

immigration that moved heavily towards Donald Trump and his message

:19:19.:19:20.

of national restoration In his first week-and-a-half

:19:21.:19:22.

in office we have come here to ask He resonated with the working class,

:19:23.:19:51.

I mean this is a blue collar town, you have a lot of industry here,

:19:52.:19:56.

hard-working people, everybody who comes to this place, punches a time

:19:57.:20:00.

clock. That is pretty much the way it is. Marty welcomes Donald Trump's

:20:01.:20:06.

tough stance on immigrants. It a privilege to come to the United

:20:07.:20:10.

States. I don't mean that in a way other than, that it is not a right

:20:11.:20:16.

to come to the United States. That's the price of what freedom is. The

:20:17.:20:20.

United States. If it takes a year, it takes two years, that is what the

:20:21.:20:25.

price of living in this country is. We have freedom here. It is a topic

:20:26.:20:30.

many people here feel strongly about. I am an hen sieve. They are

:20:31.:20:36.

volatile country, you have to be apprehensive. If we are letting you

:20:37.:20:42.

in, it is like, pay your dues like my ancestors did, line anybody

:20:43.:20:47.

else's did. They sat at Ellis "land for days because they wanted to be

:20:48.:20:51.

part of this country. Don't think you deserve the right, I mean I

:20:52.:20:56.

don't go over there. Jessica who works at the bar is one

:20:57.:21:02.

of the few people in this town who didn't vote for Donald Trump. I am

:21:03.:21:06.

appalled by it actually. I don't think it's right. I think it is

:21:07.:21:10.

unconstitutional. People have been becoming more and more outspoken

:21:11.:21:17.

about their racism. I have heard everything in this bar being said

:21:18.:21:21.

that racial slurs that I haven't heard in, I have lived here many his

:21:22.:21:26.

whole life and I haven't heard ever. They are outspoken because they

:21:27.:21:30.

think it is OK to use hate speech and hate language and hate people. I

:21:31.:21:33.

am not about that, you know. On the face of it the new policy seems

:21:34.:21:39.

straightforward. Immigrants from seven predominantly Muslim countries

:21:40.:21:44.

have been restricted from entering the United States, for 90 days.

:21:45.:21:48.

Some have viewed this as a ban on Muslims.

:21:49.:21:55.

Across the County, in the town at the local jewellery shop we meet

:21:56.:21:59.

Glenn. A lot of people are saying that Muslims are targeted, that this

:22:00.:22:05.

is a Muslim ban. Yes, once again I think you have to start somewhere

:22:06.:22:11.

and you look at 9/11, you look at bin haar den, you look a the Boston

:22:12.:22:16.

massacre, the terrorist attack on boss toe. -- bin haar den. They were

:22:17.:22:26.

all Muslim. It is hard you have to cat grinds that specific, but I

:22:27.:22:30.

think that it is a start. Do you think it is creating division in

:22:31.:22:34.

America? I think they have done that, not us. Because there are a

:22:35.:22:39.

lot of Muslims who live in this country. Yes, there definitely is, I

:22:40.:22:45.

think that they have done that, we haven't done that, that's, that is

:22:46.:22:49.

their brand, the brand they are portraying.

:22:50.:23:00.

Hi, nice to meet you. This woman is a Syrian American, and

:23:01.:23:06.

was born and raised in this town. She feels Donald Trump's stricter

:23:07.:23:10.

immigration policy is counter productive. I don't know how you

:23:11.:23:17.

could call it something, but worse than that, I feel it's, against

:23:18.:23:21.

every principle that the country was, our country was built on, when

:23:22.:23:30.

you divide you create mosh confusion, more mistrust, maybe

:23:31.:23:33.

hatred, you know, between two different kind of people who were

:23:34.:23:37.

brought up differently. Now, how is that going to prevent terrorism as

:23:38.:23:45.

opposed to create more? As Donald Trump attempts to shake things up,

:23:46.:23:50.

his hard line policies seem to be continuing, to resonate with many

:23:51.:24:01.

The government says it is going to try far harder to recoup the cost

:24:02.:24:06.

of NHS healthcare given to foreigners in Britain.

:24:07.:24:08.

The issue was in the public eye today partly because of the BBC 2

:24:09.:24:11.

documentary, Hospital, that revealed a rather unusual case

:24:12.:24:13.

of a Nigerian woman and her quadruplets born prematurely.

:24:14.:24:15.

She had been refused entry to the US, and was taken ill

:24:16.:24:18.

on a plane but ended up costing the NHS ?330,000.

:24:19.:24:21.

The thing is, Priscilla, the hospital bill is

:24:22.:24:32.

You're going to be in England for a while, aren't you.

:24:33.:24:40.

So, your husband, is your husband in Nigeria?

:24:41.:24:43.

Will he be coming over at all, under these circumstances?

:24:44.:24:50.

I do understand it's a very difficult time for you, you know,

:24:51.:25:02.

but we do need to talk about the charges for treatment.

:25:03.:25:09.

Also today, the Public Accounts Committee of MPs has said the system

:25:10.:25:12.

The words "health tourism" are used a lot in this talk -

:25:13.:25:16.

It's not people coming here specifically to use the NHS

:25:17.:25:30.

Give us the scale of it The Government commissioned research

:25:31.:25:35.

into the cost of people specifically coming to the UK just to use the

:25:36.:25:39.

NHS, the so-called health tour ribs and what they found was it is a

:25:40.:25:43.

relatively small part of the generalised cost of foreign people

:25:44.:25:46.

coming to the UK and happening to be ill here, so, if we put up a graph,

:25:47.:25:54.

what we can show is that back in 2013, what the Government estimated

:25:55.:26:02.

was around ?200 million was spend on so-called health tourrieses, that

:26:03.:26:05.

was a bit less than if we look at the cost of just European people

:26:06.:26:12.

getting ill in the UK, so it is EU people, that is about 300 million,

:26:13.:26:16.

if you look at students who are not from the EU, that is about 450

:26:17.:26:20.

million, and finally, if you look at people who have come to the UK from

:26:21.:26:25.

elsewhere, it is about 1 billion we spent on care for them, while they

:26:26.:26:28.

are here. We get some of that money back. That is is right. These are

:26:29.:26:33.

gross number, we are basically, we are part of a scheme with other

:26:34.:26:38.

countries that means we are able to charge their state, we are not good

:26:39.:26:43.

at recouping that, if this was the 300 million we could have got, we

:26:44.:26:47.

only got about 50 million back, we can also charge patients from, we

:26:48.:26:52.

can't charge students but we can charge patients from elsewhere in

:26:53.:26:56.

the world for some of their care, again we only charge about ?25

:26:57.:27:00.

million in that specific year, so that why the Government is keen to

:27:01.:27:03.

clamp-down on this. The money they are oing to get, is that going to

:27:04.:27:07.

make a big difference, small difference, Tyne Griff presence to

:27:08.:27:13.

NHS budge bet? These are small numbers so the total was 2 billion.

:27:14.:27:18.

They are looking in their dream they are looking to recoup 5 million and

:27:19.:27:22.

that is coming from taxing students mainly. Fundamentally, they are

:27:23.:27:27.

giving the NHS hospitals incentives to find foreign people to charge and

:27:28.:27:31.

foreign people whose bills we can get for another state to pay, but

:27:32.:27:35.

it's counter-cultural for lots of #350e78 who work in hospitals to

:27:36.:27:38.

check the passports of people in their care. Thank you.

:27:39.:27:40.

Joining me now is the Chair of the Royal College of GPS

:27:41.:27:44.

Professor Helen Lampard Stokes, and the cancer surgeon

:27:45.:27:46.

Meirion Thomas, who is a campaigner on health tourism.

:27:47.:27:50.

We saw in that clip, an NHS person saying to a mother who had lost her

:27:51.:27:58.

child or two children I think, at that point, we need to talk about

:27:59.:28:02.

the bill. Are you comfortable with that as a kind of ethos in the NHS?

:28:03.:28:08.

Well, that case, is exceptional and there is some tragic elms to that

:28:09.:28:11.

case, perhaps we can just set that aside for just a moment, but the

:28:12.:28:16.

fact about maternity tourism is it is very common, for example last

:28:17.:28:23.

year, at St George's Hospital it was reported 1800 foreign lady who had

:28:24.:28:28.

delivered babies there will be and in represent speck 870 of those

:28:29.:28:32.

approximately were ineligible for NHS care. What would you do in those

:28:33.:28:37.

case, because those people, you are probably not going to be able to

:28:38.:28:40.

recoup a large amount. You can chase them. You won't get very much. What

:28:41.:28:45.

is the practical thing, you ask them to show their passport. The point

:28:46.:28:52.

about passports, it is just to do with non-urgent care, for elective

:28:53.:28:57.

cases. It is very little you can do for maternity cases because the

:28:58.:29:00.

Government is determined that anything to do with maternity is

:29:01.:29:03.

immediately necessary, and therefore they have to be treated. They are

:29:04.:29:08.

charged as you say, but, we know that only 16% of invoices that are

:29:09.:29:15.

issued are honoured. Right. Helen, why is it so difficult to just

:29:16.:29:21.

charge people at least the none elective, the non-emergency, the

:29:22.:29:23.

elective care. What is wrong with that? We don't have the

:29:24.:29:26.

infrastructure to do it. Because our NHS, wonderful NHS is free at the

:29:27.:29:29.

point of need, we don't have a charging system set up, there is no

:29:30.:29:34.

universal way of finding out if a patient should or shouldn't pay, so

:29:35.:29:37.

when you walk into a hospital, you and I don't carry any ID because we

:29:38.:29:42.

expect free treatment. When you see your GP you don't carry anything,

:29:43.:29:47.

there is no reason to. If we wanted to charge every body who would need

:29:48.:29:52.

to pay something, we would have to set up a huge infrastructure. You

:29:53.:29:58.

could have to ask me... Is that so difficult? Well, 1.3 million

:29:59.:30:05.

patients see their GP every day, let us get this in perspective. In

:30:06.:30:10.

England we have 7,500 GP surgery, that is a heap of infrastructure.

:30:11.:30:16.

Not, let alone, would you issue ID cards? Would you use passports. That

:30:17.:30:21.

would be an idea. That would make it easier. It would. It happens in

:30:22.:30:26.

other country, other countries charge people. Because they from the

:30:27.:30:30.

the charging structure, they don't have a health system pee at the part

:30:31.:30:34.

of need. This is small amounts of monument if we want to put the

:30:35.:30:39.

infrastructure in and spend hundreds setting it up we could do it. It

:30:40.:30:42.

would be a long time to get the return on investment. It does take

:30:43.:30:48.

infrastructure, ID cards, it is a huge change, and it St really a

:30:49.:30:50.

relatively small amount. It is not small amount, the whole

:30:51.:31:04.

point is, what these management companies were saying in their

:31:05.:31:08.

reports that they accepted only a tiny number of people identified,

:31:09.:31:12.

the problem is much bigger than the government thinks. What I have

:31:13.:31:16.

suggested is that for elective care in hospitals, I know it is not all

:31:17.:31:24.

of the patients and I fully understand it does not involve or

:31:25.:31:31.

doctors but I suggest the patient should present a passport and a

:31:32.:31:34.

utility bill in the name when they register. Loads of people don't have

:31:35.:31:41.

utility bills in the name! Every hospital has an overseas visitors

:31:42.:31:45.

offers. I am suggesting there is a screening tool, that is all. Does it

:31:46.:31:53.

work? Could you receptionist check on sweaty's utility bill? Do you

:31:54.:32:00.

know how difficult it is too identify passport? There are subtle

:32:01.:32:04.

features. I am certainly not trained to do it. You need proper equipment

:32:05.:32:08.

to scan it and say it's legitimate. That is what we're dealing with,

:32:09.:32:13.

passports are not the answer. If I said you won't make this happen

:32:14.:32:18.

until you have ID cards which have residents's entitlement in the UK

:32:19.:32:23.

would you go for that? It's going to have to happen in some form or

:32:24.:32:27.

other, they will have to be personal identification to prove that you are

:32:28.:32:33.

entitled to NHS care. Any health system comparable to ours, Sweden,

:32:34.:32:38.

Holland, France, Germany, wherever you go, we have to have it. OK.

:32:39.:32:42.

Helen, Meirion, thank you both. If you've missed it,

:32:43.:32:45.

the story so far is that all week we've been bringing you two-minute

:32:46.:32:50.

opinionated monologues, Tonight, the author Lionel Shriver,

:32:51.:32:52.

best known for her novel It's time to say

:32:53.:32:55.

what we really mean. Left-leaning pundits decry both

:32:56.:33:09.

Brexit and Trump as the fatal So, when the left wins it's

:33:10.:33:11.

a triumph of democracy. A rabble brandishing pitchforks,

:33:12.:33:17.

Barbarians at the gate. The Oxford Dictionary defines

:33:18.:33:25.

populism as "support for Yet lately, populism seems

:33:26.:33:27.

a byword for voters not To Remainers who want to rerun

:33:28.:33:33.

the referendum until Brexiteers get their minds right,

:33:34.:33:40.

populism means leaving important Of many ideological hues,

:33:41.:33:42.

populism classically urges common people to unseat

:33:43.:33:51.

an unjust governing class. So the American civil rights

:33:52.:33:55.

movement and Occupy Wall Yet especially since the EU

:33:56.:33:57.

referendum, commentators use one-size-fits-all populism to lazily

:33:58.:34:06.

lump together desperate Italy, Hungary, Austria,

:34:07.:34:08.

Holland, Germany, Denmark, Missing all the nuances,

:34:09.:34:12.

the American press makes no distinction between Ukip

:34:13.:34:19.

and France's National Front It's this one word that makes Brexit

:34:20.:34:27.

and Trump seem - mistakenly - The term is troubling

:34:28.:34:39.

because it's loaded. Since anyone who questions

:34:40.:34:41.

unfettered immigration is a suspect and backward,

:34:42.:34:43.

populist has become wink and nod It's polite code for

:34:44.:34:45.

racist, xenophobic, Some Trump voters may deserve these

:34:46.:34:49.

pejorative connotations So before reaching for

:34:50.:34:55.

the euphemism "populist", let's try substituting "bigoted",

:34:56.:35:10.

because if that's what we mean, Film director Ang Lee

:35:11.:35:12.

made gay cowboys popular with Brokeback Mountain,

:35:13.:35:25.

he made Life of Pi where the action is all confined to a small boat,

:35:26.:35:28.

he took a Taiwanese language film and made it mainstream,

:35:29.:35:31.

with Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon. He is no stranger to taking risks,

:35:32.:35:33.

and for his next trick the three-time Oscar winner has

:35:34.:35:36.

taken on the Iraq war. He's cast a British unknown

:35:37.:35:43.

in the lead, and experimented Billy Lynn's Long Halftime Walk

:35:44.:35:45.

is based on real events, about a group of US soldiers

:35:46.:35:49.

who are given a heroes' welcome at home, but struggle

:35:50.:35:52.

with the memories of what had really The film - out here this month -

:35:53.:35:54.

has been met with proverbial Ang Lee has been

:35:55.:35:58.

speaking to our culture For the first time in my life

:35:59.:36:02.

I feel close to somebody. In Ang Lee's new film,

:36:03.:36:11.

a platoon of US soldiers are flown back

:36:12.:36:18.

from the battlefields of Iraq and paraded

:36:19.:36:20.

as But they are not

:36:21.:36:21.

prepared for all the attention or the deafening

:36:22.:36:25.

pyrotechnics. All these explosions catapult

:36:26.:36:27.

them back to being in combat, in theatre,

:36:28.:36:30.

don't they? I got that from talking to the soldi

:36:31.:36:33.

the veterans who work The thing they talk most

:36:34.:36:41.

about is the sound, and they The other things, the celebration

:36:42.:36:48.

is a bother to them. When people thank

:36:49.:37:03.

them, so often when people come and thank the soldiers

:37:04.:37:05.

for their service, that's the line When people thank them,

:37:06.:37:08.

because they feel they Also what motivated me to make

:37:09.:37:12.

the movie is really the sympathy to the soldiers

:37:13.:37:22.

who are being misunderstood. That's what really moves me,

:37:23.:37:25.

more than timely or Ang Lee has taken on a war

:37:26.:37:33.

unpopular with the American public, as he has discovered

:37:34.:37:46.

at the box office. He also gave himself the technical

:37:47.:37:49.

challenge of shooting at 120 frames On the big screen, it

:37:50.:37:52.

gives greater definition, Such as making gunfights

:37:53.:37:59.

look convincing. I had the idea to have

:38:00.:38:08.

them shoot real bullets! It's sort of weird being honoured

:38:09.:38:11.

for the worst day of your life. The special effect person,

:38:12.:38:22.

they provided the armour, they were very smart,

:38:23.:38:25.

but this little spring, It's very exciting,

:38:26.:38:29.

a close-up of shooting, There are a ton of ways

:38:30.:38:41.

you could get shipped home, or I mean, you're

:38:42.:38:47.

a decorated hero, Billy, For stars including

:38:48.:38:50.

Kristin Stewart, there was no make-up on set, to suit

:38:51.:38:52.

the unforgiving high-speed cameras. So, no pressure then

:38:53.:38:57.

on the young British newcomer Joe Alwyn,

:38:58.:39:00.

who was cast in the lead after producers had

:39:01.:39:03.

seen hundreds of other hopefuls. You don't have money men saying,

:39:04.:39:08.

get somebody famous in that part? This movie's not expensive

:39:09.:39:17.

but it's not cheap either. There are some hesitations,

:39:18.:39:27.

there were, but I was It took a week or two

:39:28.:39:31.

to convince the And you have a few Oscars

:39:32.:39:43.

on your shelf so that The extraordinary Life Of Pi

:39:44.:39:47.

picked up four Oscars but what about accusations of racism

:39:48.:39:58.

at the awards, when the director's earlier adaptation

:39:59.:40:00.

of a Jane Austen novel was winning prizes,

:40:01.:40:14.

he was overlooked. When I did Sense And

:40:15.:40:16.

Sensibility it got seven nominations, and it won a lot

:40:17.:40:19.

including Golden Globes, best producer called me, she was crying,

:40:20.:40:21.

we've got seven nominations. But in the long run,

:40:22.:40:39.

I think they didn't know me. I just don't think they

:40:40.:40:46.

know me, I think it's Ang Lee was born in Taiwan,

:40:47.:40:51.

so does he appreciate Donald Trump's overtures to Taiwan, which

:40:52.:40:59.

seem to have upset the Chinese? By the way, I'm having

:41:00.:41:03.

Taiwanese passport. I'm not American yet,

:41:04.:41:10.

it's not my president, And we are a minority,

:41:11.:41:12.

it's a very small place, not recognised

:41:13.:41:39.

as a country, but it has its own sovereignty,

:41:40.:41:41.

and I'm just afraid that it will be used

:41:42.:41:43.

as a chip, a bargaining element. After reinventing the martial arts

:41:44.:41:46.

movie with Crouching Tiger, could Ang Lee be persuaded to work

:41:47.:41:59.

his magic on the British equivalent, From childhood I always

:42:00.:42:02.

imagined a Bond movie, it is But I think it's a brand

:42:03.:42:07.

you don't want to mess with, Don't seduce me any more,

:42:08.:42:12.

I might just want to do it! The Broccolis, if I've got that

:42:13.:42:20.

right, they watch this programme. Steven Smith with the film director

:42:21.:42:26.

Download Subtitles

SRT

ASS