12/08/2014 The Referendum Debate

we are

Treasury

National Party's director

referendum

campaigning

Stott.

As

and

opponents

who

submitted their questions and our submitted their questions and our

submitted their questions and our burnt

which have stood here. Guarding the which have stood here. Guarding the

which have stood here. Guarding the prospered

which have stood here. Guarding the the fastest in the UK and

which have stood here. Guarding the now the weapons of choice in the

which have stood here. Guarding the battle for the

which have stood here. Guarding the Party,

which have stood here. Guarding the Conservatives

which have stood here. Guarding the Scotland

which have stood here. Guarding the there

which have stood here. Guarding the those

which have stood here. Guarding the great detail

which have stood here. Guarding the best

which have stood here. Guarding the It's to the advantage

which have stood here. Guarding the And

which have stood here. Guarding the the advantage

which have stood here. Guarding the rest of

which have stood here. Guarding the a

which have stood here. Guarding the what's likely to happen

which have stood here. Guarding the were able

which have stood here. Guarding the saying

which have stood here. Guarding the Alexander? Yeah,

which have stood here. Guarding the real need for the

which have stood here. Guarding the currency

which have stood here. Guarding the Scotland

which have stood here. Guarding the currency union isn't going to

which have stood here. Guarding the happen.

which have stood here. Guarding the rest of

which have stood here. Guarding the idea

which have stood here. Guarding the change as big as

which have stood here. Guarding the child

which have stood here. Guarding the know

which have stood here. Guarding the spell

expecting to vote for this change expecting to vote for this change

expecting to vote for this change to

expecting to vote for this change have. But

expecting to vote for this change this.

expecting to vote for this change from the floor. I would

expecting to vote for this change he

expecting to vote for this change because

expecting to vote for this change wouldn't work for an

expecting to vote for this change Scotland.

expecting to vote for this change union what

expecting to vote for this change giving

expecting to vote for this change own

expecting to vote for this change up

expecting to vote for this change that

expecting to vote for this change oil and gas,

expecting to vote for this change from

expecting to vote for this change points.

expecting to vote for this change Guardian

expecting to vote for this change could

expecting to vote for this change as

expecting to vote for this change Danny, I work in

expecting to vote for this change UK and

expecting to vote for this change saying

expecting to vote for this change Scotland. It makes

expecting to vote for this change rest

expecting to vote for this change issue of

expecting to vote for this change will

expecting to vote for this change but why

expecting to vote for this change there really any I any need for a

expecting to vote for this change plan B?

expecting to vote for this change asking

expecting to vote for this change make

expecting to vote for this change exactly what we are

expecting to vote for this change become

expecting to vote for this change Ken,

expecting to vote for this change it's

campaign. I believe it's going to be campaign. I believe it's going to be

campaign. I believe it's going to be demanding

campaign. I believe it's going to be that the fiscal commission group has

campaign. I believe it's going to be clearly stated that

campaign. I believe it's going to be will happen

campaign. I believe it's going to be that

campaign. I believe it's going to be messers

campaign. I believe it's going to be Darling

campaign. I believe it's going to be P45.

campaign. I believe it's going to be union

campaign. I believe it's going to be currency when

campaign. I believe it's going to be what the

campaign. I believe it's going to be you have independence

campaign. I believe it's going to be of course

logical. But he goes on to say... logical. But he goes on to say...

logical. But he goes on to say... leads you immediately back

logical. But he goes on to say... watched

logical. But he goes on to say... the

logical. But he goes on to say... matter

logical. But he goes on to say... and pensions

logical. But he goes on to say... talking

logical. But he goes on to say... they promised a

logical. But he goes on to say... getting on a

logical. But he goes on to say... Edinburgh,

with here. It's about what is in our with here. It's about what is in our

with here. It's about what is in our brushing

with here. It's about what is in our weeks

with here. It's about what is in our enough.

with here. It's about what is in our this

with here. It's about what is in our together

with here. It's about what is in our tact

with here. It's about what is in our negotiations

with here. It's about what is in our about

with here. It's about what is in our negotiation,

with here. It's about what is in our away things that you would have gone

with here. It's about what is in our no, we will never

with here. It's about what is in our that

with here. It's about what is in our yes? That's

with here. It's about what is in our I

with here. It's about what is in our pound will be used. Whether

with here. It's about what is in our issue which is particularly

with here. It's about what is in our important

with here. It's about what is in our the

with here. It's about what is in our getting

with here. It's about what is in our use

with here. It's about what is in our currencies in

with here. It's about what is in our a question

with here. It's about what is in our Alexander.

with here. It's about what is in our has

with here. It's about what is in our don't

with here. It's about what is in our Bank,

with here. It's about what is in our there

with here. It's about what is in our world who

with here. It's about what is in our said, for

with here. It's about what is in our US dollar,

with here. It's about what is in our Panama

with here. It's about what is in our am not criticising

with here. It's about what is in our we aspire

with here. It's about what is in our because -

with here. It's about what is in our on. It

with here. It's about what is in our and,

with here. It's about what is in our disaster. Why

with here. It's about what is in our that's your plan B?

with here. It's about what is in our the

with here. It's about what is in our on this programme is the no

with here. It's about what is in our losing the argument and

with here. It's about what is in our it from

with here. It's about what is in our audience.

with here. It's about what is in our be

with here. It's about what is in our forgive

with here. It's about what is in our speaking

with here. It's about what is in our lectures on the future of

with here. It's about what is in our from

with here. It's about what is in our out... Is

with here. It's about what is in our encourage the audience

with here. It's about what is in our home

with here. It's about what is in our multiple

with here. It's about what is in our you

with here. It's about what is in our speak.

the working group paper. They are the working group paper. They are

the working group paper. They are is

the working group paper. They are arrangement with

the working group paper. They are United Kingdom. But what

the working group paper. They are seen so

the working group paper. They are to

the working group paper. They are so you do

the working group paper. They are audience, you

the working group paper. They are Scotland

the working group paper. They are pound

the working group paper. They are wait for

the working group paper. They are with

the working group paper. They are of

the working group paper. They are something

the working group paper. They are disappointed that this

the working group paper. They are thrashed out before.

the working group paper. They are then decide.

the working group paper. They are ready on the basis

the working group paper. They are two arguing

the working group paper. They are know who

the working group paper. They are Let's

the working group paper. They are freedom if

the working group paper. They are Well,

the working group paper. They are where

the working group paper. They are Australia. It happened with Canada.

the working group paper. They are With

the working group paper. They are cannot

the working group paper. They are here? If

the working group paper. They are idea to have its

the working group paper. They are with Angus!

the working group paper. They are time,

the working group paper. They are world and using

We will come to the man

We will come to the man dangerous to get it wrong.

We will come to the man mortgages, credit

We will come to the man accounts and current

We will come to the man you. The man

debate all irrelevant

well, I

voting no, you will

what

will

privatised as it is beginning to be

in England,

Health

way, but there is a financial impact

of

an

doesn't affect

NHS

our

vote

won't be

way

green,

the

affect on

in

hand up

independence. The man

with the

extraordinary

is

pretend that something that

other organisations that

I find it extraordinary. Nicky

would

fairly enthusiastic consumer of the

NHS.

work

see

the

concerned

Thomas

donate,

come there? And

budget

in Scotland

is a

the House

Danny Alexander,

me

privatisation agenda of

Service, arguably it

funding

of

from a

Government.

is about

being privatised. 95% of the

National

organisations. The National

Service in

time,

Service

resources

from oil

rise.

referring to,

pressure on

at the moment. If what

worried

"yes".

I

to the National Health

Kingdom. It

has been privatised. It is

to be looked at.

nonsense to say it

at

Scotland, yes, we

that Barnett

have to shrink,

back to

Studies

figures and

of

stability

of something bigger. The

NHS, we could do that

Angus? I would

of the

manifesto, written by one Danny

Alexander

the stability

want

make better

best placed people to make

about the

I'm not particularly

campaign.

Westminster

absolutely

of Scotland, away from

cities

services. They have

checked shirt?

pretty keen

the

dismantle

claim

on the debate

tremendous idea and

using it

It

powers of independence. My powers of independence. My

powers of independence. My used at

powers of independence. My gentleman is right, it

powers of independence. My it

powers of independence. My line

powers of independence. My of

powers of independence. My proud of.

being slung by

the positives for

independent or

of income

knew

separate

will

Scottish

April, if you

Inverness you will

land and buildings transactions tax

because that power has been because that power has been

because that power has been fund

because that power has been Government. What I would like to

because that power has been see, what my

to be the responsibility of the to be the responsibility of the

to be the responsibility of the additional borrowing

to be the responsibility of the the Liberal

to be the responsibility of the long

to be the responsibility of the foundeded and we

to be the responsibility of the it in

to be the responsibility of the was has

to be the responsibility of the the Westminster cat out

to be the responsibility of the that

to be the responsibility of the vote

to be the responsibility of the off

told to quite simply shut up. What

will

The question is

governed

read all 19 pages of it,

two

Johnson let the Westminster cat out

of the bag

Conservatives. Now,

Strathclyde

recommendations. It's

to

with

what's happening

that

and

the current system.

in this

to

is

wished

the ballot paper. They could have

presented one.

their

produced

you vote no, this

road and the electorate

more than that. The gentleman would more than that. The gentleman would

more than that. The gentleman would Absolutely

more than that. The gentleman would Scotland's

more than that. The gentleman would setting up an independent

more than that. The gentleman would you. We will

more than that. The gentleman would minute.

more than that. The gentleman would All I can

more than that. The gentleman would because

more than that. The gentleman would Scotland

more than that. The gentleman would They're already looking

more than that. The gentleman would Prime

more than that. The gentleman would powers

more than that. The gentleman would hardly any at

more than that. The gentleman would an

more than that. The gentleman would interesting, I have

more than that. The gentleman would argument

more than that. The gentleman would Boris

more than that. The gentleman would of

more than that. The gentleman would is

more than that. The gentleman would leader.

more than that. The gentleman would think

more than that. The gentleman would here

more than that. The gentleman would about as thick

more than that. The gentleman would Everybody

more than that. The gentleman would border,

more than that. The gentleman would can't

more than that. The gentleman would 19th September

more than that. The gentleman would and will

more than that. The gentleman would As

more than that. The gentleman would Scotland's

more than that. The gentleman would unlike

more than that. The gentleman would Americans

more than that. The gentleman would countries

more than that. The gentleman would Bahrain,

more than that. The gentleman would Zealand, Australia, and many

more than that. The gentleman would It's

more than that. The gentleman would from

more than that. The gentleman would first

more than that. The gentleman would think

more than that. The gentleman would said of the 2012 Olympics,

whether we are governed carefully whether we are governed carefully

whether we are governed carefully Without

whether we are governed carefully in

whether we are governed carefully appreciate

whether we are governed carefully the

whether we are governed carefully hard, Nicky.

whether we are governed carefully questions.

whether we are governed carefully income taxes

whether we are governed carefully powers Scotland is being given,

whether we are governed carefully they

whether we are governed carefully the powers I mentioned,

legislated for. That bill has passed legislated for. That bill has passed

legislated for. That bill has passed parliament, of all the parties, I

legislated for. That bill has passed think Angus

legislated for. That bill has passed been

legislated for. That bill has passed I don't think there is any

legislated for. That bill has passed powers

legislated for. That bill has passed wanted

point about being governed carefully point about being governed carefully

point about being governed carefully those

point about being governed carefully who

point about being governed carefully on

point about being governed carefully seeing

point about being governed carefully Police

point about being governed carefully things,

point about being governed carefully Islands enterprise that

point about being governed carefully take

point about being governed carefully man

point about being governed carefully given us the poll

point about being governed carefully bedroom tax. How

point about being governed carefully come

point about being governed carefully had the

point about being governed carefully in Scotland

point about being governed carefully that

point about being governed carefully present

point about being governed carefully made

point about being governed carefully income

and the Scottish Government. This is and the Scottish Government. This is

and the Scottish Government. This is powers

and the Scottish Government. This is to the

and the Scottish Government. This is offer. More powers guaranteed

and the Scottish Government. This is parliament so we have

and the Scottish Government. This is the

and the Scottish Government. This is this

and the Scottish Government. This is what the

and the Scottish Government. This is and

and the Scottish Government. This is campaign. I

and the Scottish Government. This is Do

and the Scottish Government. This is new

and the Scottish Government. This is safety's sake vote no. Does

and the Scottish Government. This is heart thing.

and the Scottish Government. This is up here.

and the Scottish Government. This is and

and the Scottish Government. This is that everywhere

and the Scottish Government. This is there

and the Scottish Government. This is being

and the Scottish Government. This is a

and the Scottish Government. This is know

and the Scottish Government. This is question

and the Scottish Government. This is or

and the Scottish Government. This is ourselves

and the Scottish Government. This is Nicky and then Danny.

and the Scottish Government. This is being

and the Scottish Government. This is be

and the Scottish Government. This is say,

and the Scottish Government. This is refused

and the Scottish Government. This is refused to put

and the Scottish Government. This is It's

and the Scottish Government. This is decision

and the Scottish Government. This is secret. There are lots

and the Scottish Government. This is west of Shetland being

issue is whatever happens oil and issue is whatever happens oil and

issue is whatever happens oil and revenue

issue is whatever happens oil and It's ?3 billion a year lower than

issue is whatever happens oil and the SNP

issue is whatever happens oil and massive

issue is whatever happens oil and the public finances of an

issue is whatever happens oil and independent

issue is whatever happens oil and do you

still important to our economy. The

value of oil

Sea

wealthy

should be

company

have a

have in September, more of the

status quo with no certainty, no

plan

Scotland. Or

better

oil,

Shetland had

expectations. Do you think there

a

that

asked

absolute

See into

seems

fire. The man in the middle.

the middle.

pointless

a lot.

out of the North Sea.

more expensive to get out of the more expensive to get out of the

more expensive to get out of the January

more expensive to get out of the secret

more expensive to get out of the Shetland as the first Prime Minister

more expensive to get out of the to go to

more expensive to get out of the while

more expensive to get out of the a

more expensive to get out of the Bond we have

Bond we have e had. It

price is going up. That

not be fair to

Scotland's economy. Oil's

that

and we should

in Scotland.

reason why we

than importing from all sorts

unstable

make

on

here, Scotland is a

to

either

19th September.

discussions

for the

idea.

and

think

goes.

that if

"yes" vote, that

Let's

your

the

think we don't want is

about this, are you worried about about this, are you worried about

about this, are you worried about will create divisions.

about this, are you worried about think

about this, are you worried about will

about this, are you worried about the

about this, are you worried about Scotland

about this, are you worried about your

about this, are you worried about independence.

about this, are you worried about it

about this, are you worried about that

about this, are you worried about this

about this, are you worried about minute

about this, are you worried about what

about this, are you worried about normal,

about this, are you worried about not

about this, are you worried about woman

about this, are you worried about Scotland

about this, are you worried about When I

about this, are you worried about election,

about this, are you worried about seat in

about this, are you worried about we are governed by

about this, are you worried about front,

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he because

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he everybody

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he feel any guilt?

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he done the

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he economic mess in this country.

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he question about

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he strongly-held

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he the comments

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he audience. We

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he result of

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he The rest

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he what's happening

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he discussing

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he studios,

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he before. We

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he other

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he live

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he right result. I hope it

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he broken

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he Edinburgh, followed by Aberdeen

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he the

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he to the

reconcile with her... Sorry? Does he very