06/12/2017 Newsnight


06/12/2017

Similar Content

Browse content similar to 06/12/2017. Check below for episodes and series from the same categories and more!

Transcript


LineFromTo

They all told him not to.

0:00:070:00:11

The United Nations,

the EU - even the Pope.

0:00:110:00:13

In Gaza they reacted with anger.

0:00:130:00:15

But Trump insists it's

the right thing to do.

0:00:150:00:23

I have determined that it is time

to officially recognise Jerusalem

0:00:230:00:25

as the capital of Israel.

0:00:250:00:28

An ancient city at the heart

of a centuries old conflict

0:00:280:00:31

is thrust back into the spotlight

as the Palestinians

0:00:310:00:33

says it's deplorable.

0:00:330:00:36

And the Turkish President warns

Trump his decision could plunge

0:00:360:00:39

the region back into

a 'fire with no end'.

0:00:390:00:41

We speak to the Israeli

ambassador to the UK,

0:00:410:00:44

and key voices from the region.

0:00:440:00:51

Also tonight...

0:00:510:00:56

This spoof fundraiser shows

Africa donating radiators

0:00:570:01:01

to help Norway stay warm...

0:01:010:01:05

As UK celebrities run to the aid

of Christmas charity causes -

0:01:050:01:08

are we guilty of Poverty Porn?

0:01:080:01:10

We'll ask whether these campaigns do

more harm than good.

0:01:100:01:17

And remember the rave days

of the 1980s and 90s?

0:01:170:01:22

Then you probably weren't there.

0:01:220:01:23

Steve Smith was - constantly -

and tonight he tries to remember

0:01:230:01:26

Shoom with some of the big

names from the scene.

0:01:260:01:30

You're watching Newsnight,

and a little later this evening,

0:01:300:01:32

we're going to be talking

about the history of dance music

0:01:320:01:34

in the UK and around the world.

0:01:340:01:36

It might just go

a little bit Pete Tong.

0:01:360:01:46

Good evening.

0:01:460:01:48

What the Middle East needs

now, said no one ever,

0:01:480:01:50

is something to make the regions

politics more complicated.

0:01:500:01:52

America's President seems

to have missed the memo.

0:01:520:01:58

This evening, Donald Trump confirmed

a campaign pledge: the recognition

0:01:580:02:00

of Jerusalem as the capital

of Israel - a symbolic statement

0:02:000:02:03

fraught with practical implications.

0:02:030:02:06

In a tightly scripted address

he said he would build the US

0:02:060:02:09

embassy in that city,

insisting he was acting

0:02:090:02:11

in the pursuit of peace

between Israel and the Palestinians

0:02:110:02:14

and that the US supported

a two state solution

0:02:140:02:16

if agreed by both sides.

0:02:160:02:18

He was warmly thanked

by Israel's Prime Minister.

0:02:180:02:21

Fury from many on the other side.

0:02:210:02:26

Tonight, we ask what

the ramifications of this

0:02:260:02:28

move are likely to be.

0:02:280:02:29

But we start with this report

by Gabriel Gatehouse.

0:02:290:02:32

Jerusalem is many things to many

people. A place that embodies the

0:02:380:02:42

shared heritage of the world's great

civilisations and a city whose

0:02:420:02:46

ancient walls have long been an

incubator for their festering

0:02:460:02:51

divisions. Today, Donald Trump

walked into this most treacherous of

0:02:510:02:55

minefields, and pledged to shake

things up...

When I came into office

0:02:550:02:59

I promised to look at the world's

challenges. With open eyes, and very

0:02:590:03:05

fresh thinking. We cannot solve our

problems by making the same failed

0:03:050:03:14

assumptions and repeating the same

failed strategies of the past. When

0:03:140:03:19

that his announcement was

anticipated with foreboding in the

0:03:190:03:21

Middle East but there were hints he

may be aiming at an audience closer

0:03:210:03:26

to home. Therefore I am determined

that it is time to officially

0:03:260:03:32

recognise Jerusalem as the capital

of Israel. While previous Presidents

0:03:320:03:40

have made this a major campaign

promise, they failed to deliver.

0:03:400:03:49

Today, I am delivering.

If Donald

Trump's motivation was born in part

0:03:490:03:53

out of the desire to deliver are on

the pledges of 2016, then the

0:03:530:03:59

ramifications on this reach further

back in history. In 1948 when the

0:03:590:04:04

Jewish state was born, Israel

proclaimed Jerusalem its capital but

0:04:040:04:07

on the ground, the city was divided

into Western and Eastern sectors.

0:04:070:04:12

Israel in control of the West, and

Jordan the east, including the old

0:04:120:04:19

city. In 1967, in six days, the same

time it took the gold of the old

0:04:190:04:26

Testament to create the world,

Israel reach you the Middle East. --

0:04:260:04:34

again true. Israel seized the

eastern part of the city and

0:04:340:04:36

expanded the city limits. The

Palestinians want to see occupied

0:04:360:04:43

territory become the future of an

independent state. Today's

0:04:430:04:48

announcement has, in fact, been a

long time coming. In 1995 Congress

0:04:480:04:53

passed an act requiring the US

government to move it embassy from

0:04:530:04:58

Tel Aviv to Jerusalem. Since then,

every six months every president has

0:04:580:05:03

deferred that move on the grounds of

national security but today,

0:05:030:05:07

President Obama's successor promised

to put an end to that.

This is

0:05:070:05:11

nothing more or less than a

recognition of reality. It is also

0:05:110:05:16

the right thing to do. It is

something that has to be done.

With

0:05:160:05:23

that, at a stroke, and many

diplomats fear that America's

0:05:230:05:26

crucial role as a peace broker has

been fatally undermined.

Much of the

0:05:260:05:33

statement will leave a sense of

vacancy and many in Europe and

0:05:330:05:37

across the Arab world will wonder

where the process goes next, and

0:05:370:05:41

whether America, particularly under

President Trump, is committed to a

0:05:410:05:45

genuine and fair to state solution.

Donald Trump said that America was.

0:05:450:05:50

The United States would support a

two state solution. If agreed to by

0:05:500:05:56

both sides.

I think there was

evidence that some of those

0:05:560:06:01

diplomats, who have been trying to

reduce the negative impact of this

0:06:010:06:05

announcement, did get to work on

that text.

There was some

0:06:050:06:09

reassurance for the Palestinians who

want to return to pre-1967 borders.

0:06:090:06:15

We are not taking a position of any

final status issues. Including the

0:06:150:06:21

specific boundaries of the Israeli

sovereignty in Jerusalem or the

0:06:210:06:29

resolution of contested borders.

But

it does not really negate what is

0:06:290:06:34

still a very dangerous announcement

at a delicate time for the Middle

0:06:340:06:37

East. The sad thing is, many of

those extremists across the region

0:06:370:06:41

will be the ones celebrating this in

the morning.

Donald Trump has sent

0:06:410:06:46

his young son-in-law, Jared Kushner,

to the middle east in search of what

0:06:460:06:49

he calls the ultimate deal.

We want

an agreement that is a great deal

0:06:490:06:57

for the Israelis and a great deal

for the Palestinians.

I would be the

0:06:570:07:02

first one to celebrate if there is a

superbly crafted strategy behind

0:07:020:07:06

this announcement. But I won't be

holding my breath. We hear a lot

0:07:060:07:10

about Donald Trump being a great

deal maker and certainly in his book

0:07:100:07:14

he says you've got to hold back many

of the strongest cards you got. It

0:07:140:07:17

looks like he's played one of those

cards a little too early.

0:07:170:07:23

That was Gabriel Gatehouse.

0:07:230:07:25

In a moment we will hear

from the Israeli ambassador

0:07:250:07:28

Mark Regev and the Palestinian

academic Ghada Karmi.

0:07:280:07:29

Although we're not expecting

to resolve the regions issues

0:07:290:07:32

here in the Newsnight studio -

so they'll not be

0:07:320:07:34

debating head to head.

0:07:340:07:35

But first - our diplomatic editor,

Mark Urban is here.

0:07:350:07:39

What surprised you most about Donald

Trump's announcement?

I think that

0:07:390:07:43

given there was that nod towards the

two state solution and the statement

0:07:430:07:47

from the president Duterte was not

intended, the move today, to

0:07:470:07:53

prejudice issues, it could go he

could have acknowledged the idea to

0:07:530:07:59

have the capital in East Jerusalem.

It could have been something he did.

0:07:590:08:03

It's been many years since the

diplomatic game was about an

0:08:030:08:08

international solution for

Jerusalem, a zone to be ruled by the

0:08:080:08:13

international community. For decades

it has been about the two state

0:08:130:08:16

solution and for everyone who has

worked on that problem, every

0:08:160:08:18

diplomat I have spoken to for 30

years on this knows that the

0:08:180:08:23

Palestinian state without its

capital in East Jerusalem is not a

0:08:230:08:26

viable solution to the conflict.

And

what you make of those

0:08:260:08:30

internationally showing support for

the move?

There have been one or

0:08:300:08:34

two, interestingly, and going back

to that point the Czech Republic,

0:08:340:08:38

for example, today said that they

would the American lead and move its

0:08:380:08:41

embassy to Jerusalem. They also

mentioned the Palestinian aspiration

0:08:410:08:48

for a capital in East Jerusalem. The

Philippines followed suit but by and

0:08:480:08:53

large the reaction is negative. The

UK said they will not move their

0:08:530:08:57

embassy, many other European

countries taking a similar tone will

0:08:570:09:00

see if others join in with the Czech

Republic and the Philippines in the

0:09:000:09:05

coming days.

Mark Urban, thank you.

Let's pick up with our guests, let

0:09:050:09:12

me start with Ghada Karmi, Donald

Trump is right when he says the old

0:09:120:09:16

way is broken and there's no point

in repeating the same formula and

0:09:160:09:19

you've got to reach out to new

solutions?

He isn't right can he

0:09:190:09:23

does not know anything about it.

What the Middle East does not need

0:09:230:09:26

right now is a president like Donald

Trump. The reality is the American

0:09:260:09:35

president has endorsed an illegal

situation. Israel is in illegal

0:09:350:09:43

occupation of Arab Jerusalem, and

its sovereignty over West Jerusalem

0:09:430:09:48

is not recognised by the

international community. That is a

0:09:480:09:51

legal fact. Now, Donald Trump has

chosen to violate international law

0:09:510:09:57

by endorsing something very illegal,

which is Israeli controlled

0:09:570:10:05

sovereignty over Jerusalem, calling

itself the capital, this kind of

0:10:050:10:09

thing. This is very bad.

When he

says he is deeply committed to

0:10:090:10:14

peace, when he says that this is

nothing more than a recognition of

0:10:140:10:19

reality, do you not have faith that

this is the first step of what could

0:10:190:10:25

be a solution?

No, of course not!

First of all, it does not

0:10:250:10:30

acknowledge that the Palestinians

have any rights. I noticed your

0:10:300:10:38

commentator Mark Urban talking about

aspiration. Palestinians have a

0:10:380:10:41

right to the city. I was born in

Giroud Slim and an part of the

0:10:410:10:46

indigenous people of Jerusalem. I am

a native of Jerusalem. -- I was born

0:10:460:10:52

in Jerusalem. The fact that the

United States president cannot bring

0:10:520:10:58

himself to mention Palestinian

rights in the city is appalling.

0:10:580:11:01

That's the first problem. The second

problem is we know that Donald Trump

0:11:010:11:07

is not a free agent. He is

surrounded by pro-Israel advisers,

0:11:070:11:14

pro Israel officials...

To be fair

the American stance towards Israel

0:11:140:11:17

has not differed particularly from

one president to another.

No,

0:11:170:11:21

because it has always been dictated

by Israeli interests.

So he cannot

0:11:210:11:27

broker peace, or America cannot

broker peace?

Of course not, he is

0:11:270:11:32

compromised. He is surrounded by pro

Israel began discuss -- propaganda,

0:11:320:11:40

and he cannot operate as a free

agent, even if he had the will to do

0:11:400:11:44

it.

I want to talk about the

practicalities now. He said he is

0:11:440:11:49

calling on both sides to respect the

status quo. How should Mahmoud

0:11:490:11:53

Abbasi respond and how should young

Palestinian men respond if they feel

0:11:530:11:56

upset by what they have heard

tonight? -- Mahmood Abbas. Should

0:11:560:12:02

they legitimately protest or work

towards the two state solution he

0:12:020:12:07

talked about?

There's no two state

solution to talk about, if they have

0:12:070:12:12

gone out of the equation, I don't

know how they should but I know how

0:12:120:12:19

they feel. They will protest, they

are angry and they have every right

0:12:190:12:23

to be angry. What is dangerous about

this, because it's bad enough that

0:12:230:12:28

it is illegal, it is bad enough that

Trump is influenced by all kinds of

0:12:280:12:35

people...

I'm talking about the

practicalities. Do the moderates

0:12:350:12:39

just give up?

Listen, it isn't about

moderates, please let me be clear.

0:12:390:12:45

This is about a whole people who

have rights in that city. Of course

0:12:450:12:50

they are angry. Of course they will

protest. Nobody should be surprised.

0:12:500:12:55

Why I think this is so dangerous, is

because one of the first things that

0:12:550:13:03

might happen, and watch for this, is

that Israel would be emboldened to

0:13:030:13:07

take over the Islamic holy places,

it has had its eye on the mosque in

0:13:070:13:14

the city for a long time. If they

take it over now with a lot of new

0:13:140:13:18

self-confidence, watch what happens.

Let me put some of those points

0:13:180:13:27

over to Mark Regev. Thank you. Piece

in this area. Is it a joke?

This was

0:13:270:13:38

a just move for peace. Because there

is an international norm. Everybody

0:13:380:13:45

respects it.

A norm? The EU doesn't,

the Pope doesn't...

Let me make my

0:13:450:13:54

point, there is a norm that it has

respected every country's right to

0:13:540:13:59

choose their capital. The sovereign

right of every country on the

0:13:590:14:02

planet. There are countries, as you

know, Emily, who have changed their

0:14:020:14:07

capital cities.

Turkey, China... You

know how provocative the move is.

0:14:070:14:14

Why are we denied the right to

choose our own capital city? A right

0:14:140:14:19

every country on this planet has.

So

you can call it what you want, the

0:14:190:14:22

Palestinians can call it what they

want. My question is, from what you

0:14:220:14:26

have seen so far Donald Trump, what

makes you think that he is a classy

0:14:260:14:31

peace broker? What makes you think

that he is committed to solving the

0:14:310:14:35

world's crisis, that he has a firm

grip on international relations? Do

0:14:350:14:39

you

0:14:390:14:49

want to tie your country's future to

him as a peace broker?

I would urge

0:14:520:14:55

you to look at this decision on the

substance. The substance is

0:14:550:14:57

positive.

He says he is committed to

a two state solution and a peace

0:14:570:15:00

process and he's done that by deeply

offending and inflaming relations in

0:15:000:15:02

that part of the world.

Let's stop

for a moment. The Palestinians and

0:15:020:15:05

the Arab world say that they

recognise Israel within the 1967

0:15:050:15:07

boundaries and so we all know that

Jerusalem has been the capital of

0:15:070:15:13

Israel since 1949. Why is there a

problem with recognising Jerusalem

0:15:130:15:17

as the capital of Israel?

It is

extraordinary that you put that

0:15:170:15:21

question to me. You know this area,

you know the complexities inside

0:15:210:15:26

out. You have a responsibility,

don't you, to tell him that he is

0:15:260:15:30

wrong? Don't you think it would be

more important to not look at the

0:15:300:15:34

short term gains and to get the

longer term peace process right?

We

0:15:340:15:38

all have a responsibility to get it

right and what is the fact? That the

0:15:380:15:44

Israeli government sit in Giroud

Jerusalem, and when foreign leaders

0:15:440:15:51

sit there, they come to Jerusalem.

When foreign diplomats meet with

0:15:510:15:55

their counterparts, they come to

Jerusalem.

You do not acknowledge

0:15:550:15:59

how much offence it has caused to

Palestinian residents. Now, you

0:15:590:16:04

heard what our guest just said, that

it would embolden Israelis to forget

0:16:040:16:13

the sanctity of the mosque and all

of that. This is where you think

0:16:130:16:18

Israel can claim whatever it wants.

0:16:180:16:23

My Prime Minister said just two

hours ago that we will maintain the

0:16:230:16:27

holy sites and continued to keep the

status quo and the religious rights

0:16:270:16:33

of all people. You need to do more

than that. It is about respecting

0:16:330:16:38

people who call that their home and

assert their claim to it. So what is

0:16:380:16:42

the olive branch now that the

Israeli government has to offer to

0:16:420:16:48

Palestinians to recognise that this

is something they do not consider

0:16:480:16:52

fair?

Let's be clear what's fair,

and legal. You cannot have peace

0:16:520:16:58

without Jerusalem being Israel's

capital, and those on the

0:16:580:17:03

Palestinian side you have these

dangerous fantasies that somehow we

0:17:030:17:06

are going to throw all of the dues

out of Jerusalem, that is a

0:17:060:17:11

nonstarter. President Trump has

drawn a line in the sand today to

0:17:110:17:16

say that it is time for the

Palestinians to recognise that the

0:17:160:17:21

Jewish people have rights to their

capital city, and it is good for

0:17:210:17:30

peace.

Congressmen Lee Zeldin is

Republican member of the Foreign

0:17:300:17:35

Affairs Committee in the US.

0:17:350:17:45

and Co-Chairman

of the House Republican

0:17:450:17:46

Israel Caucus.

0:17:460:17:47

Ilnur Cevik is chief advisor

to the Turkish President,

0:17:470:17:49

Recep Tayyip Erdogan.

0:17:490:17:52

The onus is now on the Palestinians,

according to Mark Trevor Grills, to

0:17:520:17:57

move on and accept the peace. --

Mark Regev. What do you say to that?

0:17:570:18:06

If you do not extend an olive branch

to the Palestinians, what can you

0:18:060:18:11

ask from them? What can you expect

from them? It's a very hard thing to

0:18:110:18:16

turn to these people and say,

Jerusalem is the capital, finished.

0:18:160:18:23

Now, if they had said, fine, West

Jerusalem, we have the capital of

0:18:230:18:34

Israel, the Palestinians have a

right for east Jerusalem to be their

0:18:340:18:39

capital.

So as a key player in the

region, what does Turkey do now? How

0:18:390:18:44

do you face this new reality?

Well,

Turkey is frustrated, deeply

0:18:440:18:54

frustrated, because Turkey feels

that while it wants to maintain

0:18:540:19:02

relations with Israel, for the sake

of the Palestinians, it is becoming

0:19:020:19:08

harder and harder for Turkey to

maintain a kind of plausible

0:19:080:19:12

relationship with Israel. The

Turkish president has already said,

0:19:120:19:19

we may even sever ties.

Do you think

that will happen now?

Turkey may

0:19:190:19:25

downgrade its relations. I don't

know. It depends how the situation

0:19:250:19:30

develops.

Would you be as bold with

your relations with the US now?

0:19:300:19:36

Well, Turkey has already announced

that it rejects the US decision. The

0:19:360:19:44

Turkish parliament, for the first

time, all the parties have come

0:19:440:19:47

together, the Kurds and the left

wing, everybody, for the first time

0:19:470:19:52

in nearly ten years, they have come

together to denounce the American

0:19:520:19:57

decision, and this shows it's not

only Recep Tayyip Erdogan, but its

0:19:570:20:03

across-the-board, all parties, who

are hugely against the Turkish

0:20:030:20:12

government, the opposition, have

come together to reject this

0:20:120:20:14

decision.

You heard the voice in our

film earlier saying that this is a

0:20:140:20:19

victory for extremists, who can ride

roughshod over moderate views now

0:20:190:20:26

and say, we have to respond to this

in the only way we see fit. What do

0:20:260:20:31

you have to do, as a key player in

the region, to make sure it doesn't

0:20:310:20:37

inflame? By severing relations, you

are ducking out, right?

The Turkish

0:20:370:20:44

president has said that this is one

of the options. He didn't say it was

0:20:440:20:51

going to happen.

You are his chief

adviser. What will you be advising

0:20:510:20:56

him tonight?

Our advice will be that

we need a kind of leveraged on

0:20:560:21:01

Israel. Some form of leveraged is

needed there. However, the

0:21:010:21:06

Palestinians have a right, and when

you do not answer to the demands of

0:21:060:21:15

moderate Palestinians who want

peace, who want just their rights,

0:21:150:21:21

who won Jerusalem, who have been

born in Jerusalem, to say, this is

0:21:210:21:27

my home. If they are denied those

rights, we are all playing into the

0:21:270:21:32

hands of those radicals.

Ilnur

Cevik, thank you for coming in.

0:21:320:21:36

Let's pick up now with Lee Zeldin,

member of the Republican Foreign

0:21:360:21:42

Affairs Committee. You have the Pope

against you, the UN, the EU, and

0:21:420:21:47

most countries. Do you have any

qualms about what your president has

0:21:470:21:51

done tonight?

I strongly support the

President's decision. It is a fact

0:21:510:21:58

that the capital of Israel is

Jerusalem. This is where the Israeli

0:21:580:22:05

Knesset is located. The offices and

homes of the Israeli Prime Minister

0:22:050:22:10

and president, the Supreme Court...

We need to all be honest with each

0:22:100:22:15

other. The fact is that the capital

of Israel is Jerusalem.

The draft

0:22:150:22:20

the core niceties seem to overlook

what a precarious position this has

0:22:200:22:27

put Israel and the Palestinians in

this evening.

Well, I would say what

0:22:270:22:33

really complicates things the most

is when you have Palestinian

0:22:330:22:39

terrorists murdering innocent

Israelis. Just yesterday, the house

0:22:390:22:44

of Representatives passed a Taylor

Force act. Taylor force was a

0:22:440:22:48

graduate of the United States

military Academy of West point who

0:22:480:22:53

was brutally murdered by Palestinian

terrorists.

And you think this will

0:22:530:23:00

help?

I think it is a huge issue

that needs to be addressed. On the

0:23:000:23:03

one side you have a party trying to

promote peace, and on the other, you

0:23:030:23:10

are treating terrorists as heads of

state and financially rewarding

0:23:100:23:14

terrorism.

You have a president who

tries to ban Muslims of certain

0:23:140:23:18

countries even coming into the US.

Do you think he has the right man to

0:23:180:23:23

broker peace in Israel, in the

Middle East?

Pieces going to be

0:23:230:23:29

negotiated on the ground, regardless

of who the president is at any time.

0:23:290:23:34

It's going to be important that

whoever is in charge of Israel, or

0:23:340:23:40

the Palestinian authority, that they

have the ability to negotiate peace.

0:23:400:23:45

That has been won over course of

generations, not just years and

0:23:450:23:51

decades, but it has been elusive. I

don't know if any single person

0:23:510:23:56

outside of Israel and that region

are capable of doing this for them.

0:23:560:24:01

It really needs to be done on the

ground.

So maybe he should have

0:24:010:24:04

stayed out of it? One of our guests

just called President Trump a know

0:24:040:24:10

nothing American.

Again, the capital

of Israel is Jerusalem. I'm not

0:24:100:24:19

questioning that the Palestinian

authority is headquartered in

0:24:190:24:22

Romana. I have been there and met

with the Prime Minister of the

0:24:220:24:27

Palestinian authority. I don't

question that that is where they are

0:24:270:24:31

headquartered at. There's a certain

realities here. The Prime Minister

0:24:310:24:37

said to my face that he would not

recognise Israel as a Jewish state.

0:24:370:24:42

You also have to considered the fact

that if the Palestinian authority

0:24:420:24:48

leadership was in good faith

negotiating a deal, let's say people

0:24:480:24:52

are sitting down in 2018, there is

an element in the Palestinian

0:24:520:24:58

authority, Hamas, who will not rest

until Israel is wiped off the map.

0:24:580:25:04

Thank you for joining us.

0:25:040:25:08

Theresa May found a new form a words

today which may soon be

0:25:080:25:11

adopted by school children

and the work-shy world over.

0:25:110:25:13

When asked about Monday's attempted

Brexit deal on Northern Ireland

0:25:130:25:15

she merely claimed 'very good

progress has been made'.

0:25:150:25:18

It sounded a bit hollow

in the House of Commons -

0:25:180:25:20

and was met with laughter.

0:25:200:25:21

Tonight, however, there were some

positive sounds coming

0:25:210:25:23

from the Irish Taoiseach,

Leo Varadkar.

0:25:230:25:29

I agreed to examine any text that

they put forward in a positive

0:25:290:25:34

light, understanding that it is

within the interests of our country

0:25:340:25:38

to move to phase two. Those things

are important to Ireland, and I want

0:25:380:25:43

to get back to the point where we

have good relations with the UK

0:25:430:25:46

again. I would look at any text with

an open mind and a positive outlook,

0:25:460:25:50

but I emphasise the fact that when

it comes to the substance and

0:25:500:25:54

meaning of what was agreed on

Monday, I can't depart from that.

0:25:540:26:01

Our political editor, Nick Watt, is

here. How will those words be

0:26:010:26:06

greeted in Downing Street?

He says,

I'm open to new wording, but it must

0:26:060:26:11

be in addition to the current

wording. Theresa May wants to avoid

0:26:110:26:16

what happened at the weekend when

the DUP were not shown the wording.

0:26:160:26:22

She is consulting on the text and

she is talking to Sinn Fein. But she

0:26:220:26:28

has a very difficult balancing act.

She has to win back the DUP, but not

0:26:280:26:34

in a way that Sinn Fein tumble out

of the equation. It is very

0:26:340:26:39

difficult. A DUP source said this

evening that the wording is toxic

0:26:390:26:43

and has to go. Another DUP source

said they did not like the wording

0:26:430:26:48

and could just about envisage a

situation where the existing wording

0:26:480:26:52

stays, but the new wording would

have to be dramatically in their

0:26:520:27:00

favour for that to happen. Plus,

Michel Barnier has said,

0:27:000:27:03

effectively, that there is 48 hours

to sort this out.

And intervention

0:27:030:27:08

on Philip Hammond as well.

He told

the Treasury Select Committee that

0:27:080:27:13

it would be inconceivable for the UK

not to pay its financial settlement

0:27:130:27:18

of the UK, even if we don't have a

deal. Downing Street came out a few

0:27:180:27:23

hours later and said, I think not.

They said the offer from the UK was

0:27:230:27:28

contingent on getting that future

trade relationship. A few hours

0:27:280:27:33

earlier, David Davis, the Brexit

Secretary, confirmed that the

0:27:330:27:37

government hadn't carried out a

formal impact assessment of the

0:27:370:27:44

consequences of Brexit, and that was

enough to ensure that the Brexit

0:27:440:27:48

Select Committee, voting on party

lines, voted, but it is in not in

0:27:480:27:53

contempt of Parliament.

0:27:530:27:57

Every since Band Aid -

the charity single put together

0:27:570:27:59

by a host of A-list musicians back

in 1984, we've got used

0:27:590:28:02

to the idea of celebrities rallying

around to solve world poverty.

0:28:020:28:04

This Christmas will

be no different -

0:28:040:28:06

Ed Sheeran, Tom Hardy,

and Eddie Redmayne are all starring

0:28:060:28:09

in adverts aimed at raising money

for humanitarian crises -

0:28:090:28:11

child malnutrition, famine,

the war in Yemen.

0:28:110:28:13

Their intentions

are beyond reproach.

0:28:130:28:14

They raise awareness

and often millions of pounds.

0:28:140:28:16

But there is a growing

unease at the signals

0:28:160:28:18

these videos send out -

labelled "Poverty Porn"

0:28:180:28:21

by their critics.

0:28:210:28:22

One group of activists got

so annoyed by the campaigns

0:28:220:28:25

they launched their own response -

and award for the worst.

0:28:250:28:30

It's Africa's turn to help, croon

the singers in this spoof video.

0:28:510:28:54

The group tell of a need

to highlight the plight of poor

0:28:540:28:57

Norwegians, by bringing them

radiators in winter,

0:28:570:29:00

raising awareness of their

suffering in the cold.

0:29:000:29:06

It's the work of a Norwegian

campaign group, who tomorrow

0:29:080:29:10

will launch an award for the worst

charity video of the year.

0:29:100:29:17

I'm a father, and I know that

many of our children in the UK

0:29:190:29:22

are looking forward to holidays

and presents right now.

0:29:220:29:25

These children live

in a far-off country...

0:29:250:29:27

They're so tiny.

0:29:270:29:28

They're so tiny.

0:29:280:29:30

You do see them in the day,

and they're kids...

0:29:300:29:33

On the list, three British

celebrities, Tom Hardy,

0:29:330:29:35

Ed Sheeran and Eddie Redmayne.

0:29:350:29:37

These images are devastating.

0:29:370:29:40

We had hoped to never

see this again...

0:29:400:29:43

Their campaign featured

the desperate plight of starving

0:29:430:29:45

and homeless children,

the kind of heartbreaking images

0:29:450:29:47

that have long proved

successful when it comes

0:29:470:29:49

to shocking people into giving.

0:29:490:29:53

A simple step from us

here can save lives there.

0:29:530:29:57

The DEC's Yemen appeal

raised £26 million.

0:29:570:30:01

The East Africa one raised

more than £16 million.

0:30:010:30:05

Valuable sums that have helped

enormously in the short term.

0:30:050:30:09

# Do they know it's

Christmas time at all?

0:30:090:30:15

It all began here,

of course, in 1984.

0:30:150:30:17

# Feed the world...#

0:30:170:30:19

The nearly all-white choir of

Band Aid raised

0:30:190:30:21

millions using a fine

roster of celebrities.

0:30:210:30:24

The campaign was astonishingly

successful as a fundraiser,

0:30:240:30:27

and as a concept, emulated

consistently over the years since.

0:30:270:30:32

Despite widespread agreement

amongst NGOs in 2007,

0:30:320:30:36

the re-emergence of poverty porn

is causing concern.

0:30:360:30:40

It cements a narrative

of us and them, of the

0:30:400:30:43

patrons and the victims.

0:30:430:30:47

When you say context,

it is that they have to offer

0:30:470:30:49

something more than some

stereotypes and simplifications.

0:30:490:30:51

They have to show the location.

0:30:510:30:54

They have to give a voice

to the local population,

0:30:540:30:56

and also to highlight

the structural, underlying

0:30:560:31:00

issues, for example,

what are the causes for poverty?

0:31:000:31:03

And not just the simplified solution

or a quick fix to something

0:31:030:31:06

that has deeper roots.

0:31:060:31:10

MUSIC: You're My Best

Friend by Queen.

0:31:100:31:16

They prefer this sort of thing -

the hope and optimism of Batman.

0:31:160:31:21

# Whatever this world

can give to me...

0:31:210:31:23

But are we becoming oversensitive?

0:31:230:31:26

Isn't it better to try

and occasionally get things wrong,

0:31:260:31:30

as long as the intentions are good

and the money rolls in?

0:31:300:31:35

With me now is Afua Hirsch -

a journalist who called for an end

0:31:370:31:41

to 'poverty porn' in a Guardian

piece this week -

0:31:410:31:43

and Mark Goldring, he's a trustee

of the emergency fundraising group,

0:31:430:31:46

the Disasters Emergency Committee.

0:31:460:31:47

He's also chief executive of Oxfam.

0:31:470:31:52

It's very nice to have you both

here. For all of your reservations,

0:31:520:31:57

this works, this raises money, and

it saves lives, why would you and

0:31:570:32:03

pick it, Afua?

It depends on what

you are trying to achieve, we all

0:32:030:32:07

agree that it's important to raise

awareness of humanitarian crises,

0:32:070:32:11

I'm not suggesting we should be

apathetic or stage some kind of

0:32:110:32:15

intervention but it's a short-term

solution. I know it works and shocks

0:32:150:32:18

people and gets people to give money

in the short term but in the

0:32:180:32:22

long-term the message it sends is

that these people not equal, they

0:32:220:32:32

are others, they do not deserve the

same dignity. We would never show a

0:32:320:32:35

British child in that state of

nakedness. We are not protecting

0:32:350:32:37

their basic dignity. We are creating

a belief with deep historical roots

0:32:370:32:39

that these people are not agents of

their own lives, we should pity them

0:32:390:32:43

and at best we can offer them

charity in their hopeless future.

0:32:430:32:46

That is not true.

I wonder if you

have a sense of this, that there is

0:32:460:32:54

a division that these kinds of

adverts create?

If these adverts are

0:32:540:32:58

the main ways that we portray the

developing world, it would not be

0:32:580:33:03

right but the picture is much more

complicated. What we are doing is

0:33:030:33:06

challenging the issues that lie

behind that poverty. So, we told

0:33:060:33:15

positive stories about Bangladesh,

and the situation in Myanmar, but

0:33:150:33:19

there are nearly 1 million people

crossing the border and we have to

0:33:190:33:22

get aid to them today. In the same

way, Oxfam has been challenging our

0:33:220:33:27

own government for years on our

policy in Yemen, challenging the

0:33:270:33:31

Saudis and arms sales. We are saying

that we also need practical help.

0:33:310:33:36

There is a lot in what Afua says

about how these images come across.

0:33:360:33:43

The problem is, as soon as you have

a spoof like the Norwegian one, and

0:33:430:33:48

people laugh, it almost releases you

from obligation. As soon as you are

0:33:480:33:52

in that position you go, I don't

want to be that person and endorse

0:33:520:33:58

that narrative.

We've seen this in

campaigns, since Band Aid, it works

0:33:580:34:07

as a one-off shock tactic but then

people become desensitised. Once you

0:34:070:34:11

see those images of babies with

flies in their eyes you lose

0:34:110:34:14

empathy. It's a very tired formula

and allows people to disengage

0:34:140:34:18

because ultimately they do not see

these people as humans...

Is that

0:34:180:34:22

right? You run many different kinds

of campaigns.

And we communicate on

0:34:220:34:28

complicated issues all the time. We

recently put out a film on taxation

0:34:280:34:34

and tax dodging. We put weeks into

crafting that film. The average

0:34:340:34:38

viewer watches it for about ten

seconds. What is happening with an

0:34:380:34:42

emergency appeal is that

broadcasters are putting something

0:34:420:34:45

together literally in hours and they

want to command attention.

So you

0:34:450:34:51

have ten seconds?

If the item it is

you don't have enough time to offer

0:34:510:34:55

someone basic dignity and respect...

I'm not saying that, I think there

0:34:550:34:59

is a difference between the images

and the overall effect. We are not

0:34:590:35:03

right to blame celebrities for that.

We need to look at the way we edit.

0:35:030:35:09

As an organisation, Oxfam, and many

like us, have strict guidelines on

0:35:090:35:13

using those kinds of images and

there are too many of them. There's

0:35:130:35:18

also a sense that there is an

emergency and we need to respond now

0:35:180:35:22

and that urgency needs to come

through.

We need context and to

0:35:220:35:28

protect the dignity of people we are

dealing with, they need the same

0:35:280:35:31

rights and treatments that we do.

To

both of you, thank you.

0:35:310:35:37

Who can say exactly how a cultural

phenomenon gets started,

0:35:370:35:39

but the Acid House phenomenon

in the late 1980s undoubtedly owed

0:35:390:35:42

a good deal to a group of DJs

who were inspired by what they saw

0:35:420:35:46

on the party island of Ibiza.

0:35:460:35:47

One of them was Danny Rampling,

whose legendary club

0:35:470:35:49

night in South London -

Shoom - celebrates its 30th

0:35:490:35:52

anniversary this week.

0:35:520:35:53

It helped to give rise to dance

culture and all that it

0:35:530:35:55

entailed: the super club,

tabloid controversy over ecstasy,

0:35:550:35:57

and the ubiquity of the 'smiley

face' emoji, that our parents always

0:35:570:36:00

believed was just a,

well, smily face.

0:36:000:36:02

We sent Stephen Smith to find out:

whatever happened to Acid House?

0:36:020:36:09

# Just a moment

0:36:090:36:10

# Please remain in your seats

0:36:100:36:12

# Please remain in your seats...

0:36:120:36:17

Many people said it

was like their church.

0:36:170:36:19

It was their new religion.

0:36:190:36:29

I could immediately see that this

was going to be huge.

0:36:310:36:34

I was already imagining that,

in a year or two, this

0:36:340:36:36

was going to be big over the world.

0:36:360:36:38

# Well, I need your love

0:36:380:36:40

# I need your love...

0:36:400:36:41

30 years ago, might you have been

making shapes amid the dry ice

0:36:410:36:44

and smoke of a gym in a south

London basement?

0:36:440:36:47

That's where DJ Danny Rampling

put a very British spin

0:36:470:36:50

on the easy-going, inclusive vibe

he'd found in the clubs of Ibiza.

0:36:500:36:53

After you, Danny.

0:36:530:36:54

Today, Newsnight's taking Rampling

back to his old haunt.

0:36:540:36:56

It's been a few years!

0:36:560:36:57

It's now available to rent,

if you're interested.

0:36:570:36:59

Is this very familiar?

0:36:590:37:05

No!

0:37:050:37:06

Not at all?

0:37:060:37:07

The entrance was around the back.

0:37:070:37:09

He hasn't been back here since

the club changed premises in 1989.

0:37:090:37:15

I could immediately see that this

was going to be huge.

0:37:150:37:28

So here we are.

0:37:340:37:35

Yes, here we are.

0:37:350:37:36

It didn't look like this back then.

0:37:360:37:38

How did it look?

0:37:380:37:39

Er...

0:37:390:37:40

It certainly didn't feel

as big as this as well,

0:37:400:37:42

because there were some changing

rooms in here, an office,

0:37:420:37:45

and then a gym area at the back.

0:37:450:37:47

This area here was

the main dance area.

0:37:470:37:48

Here?

0:37:480:37:49

Yeah, all this area here.

0:37:490:37:51

It it looks a little bit

trampled down, doesn't it?

0:37:510:37:53

Where did you have your DJ console?

0:37:530:37:55

It was on this side of the room,

so I'd be here with a torch

0:37:550:37:58

in my mouth, because it was quite

dark down here at times,

0:37:580:38:01

so I could see the vinyl.

0:38:010:38:03

Waving records around and jumping

around and shouting!

0:38:030:38:05

# Hey!

0:38:050:38:06

Britain had gone through

the Falklands War.

0:38:060:38:07

It had gone through the rising

interest rates, and it had gone

0:38:070:38:10

through such high unemployment

as well at the same time.

0:38:100:38:12

So opportunities, particularly in

working-class culture, were limited.

0:38:120:38:14

They were pretty limited.

0:38:140:38:16

And this came along as a reaction

to that period as well.

0:38:160:38:25

Remind us who passed through here?

0:38:260:38:28

Gosh, there's so many.

0:38:280:38:29

Boy George was a regular here.

0:38:290:38:30

Martin Fry and Mark White of ABC.

0:38:300:38:32

Dexy's Midnight Runners,

Kevin Rowland, Genesis P-Orridge,

0:38:320:38:33

Leigh Bowery came down at one time.

0:38:330:38:35

There was one time, he walked

in down these stairs with his famous

0:38:350:38:38

look with the light bulbs on,

and the security guy, Eric,

0:38:380:38:41

said "Light bulb chops is here."

0:38:410:38:50

My brother said, "It's £5.

0:38:500:38:51

There is no guest list in here."

0:38:510:38:53

He said, "Darling, I don't pay

to get in anywhere!"

0:38:530:39:03

You might never know it to look

at it, but to many this is one

0:39:030:39:06

of the most story doors

in music history.

0:39:060:39:08

Within a few weeks of Shoom

opening 30 years ago,

0:39:080:39:11

people were queueing right down this

street in the wee small hours

0:39:110:39:13

to join in the scene and the fun.

0:39:130:39:23

# Acid, man

0:39:230:39:24

# Acid, man...

0:39:240:39:26

Of course, the smiley face was a 60s

symbol that they put

0:39:260:39:29

on the third Shoom flyer, I think

it was, and caught the moment.

0:39:290:39:32

They had happy, happy, happy banners

up in the Shoom, in the corridor.

0:39:320:39:36

And it was very much

like a family vibe that they had,

0:39:360:39:39

and that's part of the reason

that it caught the

0:39:390:39:41

imagination of people.

0:39:410:39:45

Time Out magazine's former nightlife

editor has been in more clubs

0:39:450:39:48

than you can shake a glow stick at.

0:39:480:39:50

He captured the impact

of Shoom from the get-go.

0:39:500:39:55

Obviously, there was already a great

one nighter club scene in London,

0:39:550:39:58

Manchester and elsewhere,

but this shifted the balance.

0:39:580:40:01

It was a quantum leap

into the mainstream.

0:40:010:40:07

# Everybody's free...

0:40:070:40:13

The 90s brought a boom and easy

credit, and the alumni at clubs

0:40:130:40:16

like Shoom began developing

a multi million pound leisure

0:40:160:40:18

industry around super clubs

and high-profile DJs.

0:40:180:40:25

Dance music has infiltrated the pop

tracks for a good few years now.

0:40:250:40:28

You know, your DJs are not these

nameless, faceless guys

0:40:280:40:32

in the corner of clubs.

0:40:320:40:36

They are people who have Vegas

residencies, whose heads take up

0:40:360:40:39

eight floors of a hotel building

in terms of ad space.

0:40:390:40:42

The DJs are huge, and the culture

around it is huge.

0:40:420:40:45

Vegas wouldn't put these people

on if they didn't make them millions

0:40:450:40:48

upon millions of dollars.

0:40:480:40:53

But what's this?

0:40:530:40:55

Woodwind and strings

on club anthems?

0:40:550:40:58

It's the work of ageless

turntablist Pete Tong

0:40:580:41:00

and the Heritage Orchestra.

0:41:000:41:02

It's very popular, but is this dance

coming of age, or just ageing?

0:41:020:41:06

The kind of rave generation

of the 90s clubbing phenomena that

0:41:060:41:11

happened, that generation,

this is the first time that

0:41:110:41:13

they've got old, old-er.

0:41:130:41:23

But that doesn't necessarily mean

that they want to slow down in terms

0:41:260:41:29

of their musical passion.

0:41:290:41:30

So I think it's definitely pulled

a big chunk of those

0:41:300:41:33

people back out again.

0:41:330:41:34

I think the other thing is that

it finishes early, which is good!

0:41:340:41:42

Back in south London,

Danny Rampling's getting ready

0:41:420:41:44

to mark 30 years of Shoom,

but not in the former

0:41:440:41:47

gym where it all began.

0:41:470:41:52

Presumably, the people who would use

this space will not necessarily

0:41:520:41:54

know about Shoom?

0:41:540:41:55

Not unless there's

a blue plaque outside!

0:41:550:41:57

Who knows?

0:41:570:41:58

That may happen at some point.

0:41:580:41:59

Yeah, I walk past here,

and yeah, I suppose I do get

0:41:590:42:02

nostalgic when I pass here.

0:42:020:42:04

Well, I think we should perhaps

leave before we fill up.

0:42:040:42:08

What do you say, Danny?

0:42:080:42:10

# Come into my life

0:42:100:42:11

# I got so much love to show you

0:42:110:42:14

I love coming back here.

0:42:140:42:16

# Boy, I adore you

0:42:160:42:18

# Come into my life

0:42:180:42:20

# I got so much love

to show you

0:42:200:42:23

# Come into my life

0:42:230:42:24

# Boy, I adore you...#

0:42:240:42:32

And with that, they left. And we

must too. That's all we've got time

0:42:320:42:37

for.

0:42:370:42:39

Evan is with you tomorrow.

0:42:390:42:40

Goodnight.

0:42:400:42:42

Goodnight.

0:42:420:42:47

Download Subtitles

SRT

ASS