24/04/2016 The Papers

The mother and a third child have been seriously injured.

Hello and welcome to our look ahead to what the the papers will be

With me are the broadcaster John Stapleton and the former

government minister and vote leave campaigner Esther McVey.

your first time with us, thank you. Thank you. You will keep us in good

order. Yes, it will be very civilised. Tomorrow's from pages,

starting with the Independent. Online as criticism from a group of

academics that both sides of the EU referendum are making misleading and

inaccurate statements. The Justice Secretary Michael Gove has written

in the Times that a free for all EU migration will put the NHS at risk.

The uncertainty facing the high-street retailer BHS is the top

story in the Guardian, with reports almost 11,000 jobs are at risk.

According to the metro girls as young as three are being sold by

their families for less than ?400 following the earthquake in Nepal.

Green belt under siege. That's the headline in the i. The FT says

Heathrow faces funding black hole for transport links to the airport,

third runway goes ahead. New Day leads on scientists and launching

new research into miscarriages. The express wants a snowy blast will

sweep across Britain over the next ten days. It wouldn't be right if we

didn't start with the EU referendum. Here it is on the Independent. The

verdict on the EU campaigns, actor -- academics criticising both sides.

Interesting pictures, they look like they are singing to each other. Kiss

and make up! Neither side coming out well in this. Well, maybe both sides

have had so much passion behind and they have as many people as they can

behind it, so they are getting a bit carried away. Then they are saying

it would cost every family ?3400, and the Alt say ?450 a week.

Temperatures are being raised either way. I guess going back to Barack

Obama, that raised... The president, he has raised the temperature is as

well somewhat. I thought it was interesting that we need to look at

what he said when he is talking about trade deals. We don't have a

trade deal with America. Europe hasn't got one. And we've happily

traded all this time and we have 56 billion going either way. We have

TTIP. Yes, controversial. Jeremy Corbyn was an out. When Barack Obama

came over here, and he is fully entitled to say what he wants to

say, but what's in America's interests... He wants TTIP. Now he

wants and is desperate to have it. It is in America's interests not

necessarily ours. I think the headline sums up what many people

including myself have thought. We hear these arguments, one set of

facts presented by one politician one day, the same facts represented

the next day by different politician and a different conclusion. What

this piece says is there is evidence to show a lot of them are bogus

claims, and supported by evidence and at worst simply untrue. At the

end of the day I think a lot of people like myself, I know you have

committed yourself, but a lot of people at the end of the day have

said to themselves, I don't know to believe in this. Who do I trust? You

look at the array of people before you. You say, do I trust that lot or

that lot? I am for in, on the basis that I have more faith in the people

saying stay in them come out. Why? What makes you say that, a gut

feeling? Yes. And with all due respect... Show me the piece of

convincing evidence produced by an independent body that says we would

be better off if we left. It is a stab in the dark. It is a flight

into the unknown. They cannot say with any degree of certainty that we

will be better off. I guess you are right, we don't know. There is lots

of supposition either way. I want to be a bit more like yourself, on the

fence, maybe more in. When I was a minister and going over to Europe on

doing the negotiations with the other ministers for employment it

was the first time I saw how Europe worked, how much it lacked a

democracy, how much it lacked transparency. How much you didn't

know what was going on. The fact laws are made not by elected people

but unelected people. That was the start. Then I thought, hang on it

doesn't sign its books. Anyone else who didn't do that would be in

prison. And don't think it is that safe staying in. I'm not saying it

is ideal. Some of the judgments that come down from the European courts,

leave you puzzled. But some of the judgments come down from our own

courts leave you puzzled. My view is better the devil you know. You say

it is not very democratic but other people will say, we vote for MEPs...

They don't initiate law. We send our ministers to all of those meetings

and the argument is if we are not round the table... Ministers here by

and large have been voting in. I would have thought like you until I

saw what happened and then I saw those people don't initiate laws.

When I see who's doing the deals behind the scenes, things you will

think you have got they can at the last minute Saints, you haven't. For

me the biggest thing is their finances. We said the banks were too

big to fail. We are getting that with Europe now. It would be better

if we could untangle ourselves because the finances across Europe

are bad. It will be close. A reminder, I don't have an opinion.

Just setting the record straight. Let's quickly look at the Telegraph.

We don't have the front page yet but we have some of the comments from

Boris Johnson's: in the Daily Telegraph. He is saying it is too

soon for those who want to remain to think it is in the bag. The vote

Leave have had a bad week. Boris's comments about Obama's background

even by his own supporters were said not to be the best. Even Nigel

Farage said go for the ball, not the man. Others have said it makes him

unfit to be a Prime Minister. Comments about his background when

very badly, even with his own supporters. But Boris, in his very

highly paid newspaper column said Cameron and his mates are growing

too soon. He criticised David Cameron. For achieving two thirds of

diddly squat in his prerendered random negotiations. He says, if

they think it is all over, they are mistaken. They are crowing too soon.

I think it will be close. Do you? Yes. I think my generation, a lot of

my generation will vote to leave and I think the younger generation, if

they go to the polls, will vote to stay. There is a long way to go and

it will be close but I think you are right about the generational

difference. That was the generation that took us in. They say, we

thought it was one thing and is totally something else. I think it

is something to make note of, the older generation say, what a

mistake, let's get out. The FT and something different. Transport

crunch, black hole over Heathrow runway. This is about war would need

to be upgraded in the infrastructure leading up to it. I live near

Heathrow Airport. I am opposed to a third runway and have been for a

long time, as is Zac Goldsmith, the Richmond MP and other MPs in the

area. And so is Boris. Not just because of the increased aircraft

noise and pollution it will cause, but also we have said for a long

time, the congestion on the road that would cause. What this piece is

saying is TFL, transport for London, are saying the inquiry into the

third runway savagely underestimated the cost of upgrading these roads to

the tune of ?16 billion. Heathrow are saying that is nonsense. They

have listed in their assessment everything that needs to be done in

London. They are sticking to their guns and saying it will cost ?16

billion more than originally forecast. My personal view is it

will never happen. Your man David Cameron said we won't have a third

runway and then changed his mind, put it off and put it. Kicked down

the road. It shows how contentious it was, that there were so many

consultations and then looking at environment and all the other

things. To be honest, we are an island and we need various forms of

communication, getting people and goods on an off. I think we

personally need many more airports. I think you might need Gatwick,

Heathrow and I thought Boris's island for a future period of time

would be good as well. But we do need runways. I am not denying that.

I say there are pretty good economic and environmental reasons... Where

should it be? Gatwick. That won't be enough, where else? Another one in

Liverpool, Manchester... I think we need much more. Let's have a look at

the i. Jeremy Hunt rejects calls to trial junior doctor contracts. This

suggested rolling out junior doctor contracts in a limited number of

hospitals, just to test it. Jeremy Hunt is saying no. I think he was

also saying it was going to be slowly rolled out anyway. It was

slowly being rolled out and that is why he probably says what is the

difference between that and the pilot. It is simple, what the

proposal was, test it and have an independent body assess it and make

a judgment at the end of that trial period as to whether or not it

works. He said, you are having if you like it or not. If there is in

wrong with it, we will put it right along the way. He said let's go back

and have the discussions and negotiate. What were the doctors

offered, they were offered a reduction in the hours. It wasn't

about them working too much. They have an increase in wages. What he

was saying on Saturday we cannot afford for people to being on that

amount, double or extra time on Saturday. This slow roll-out was

what he preferred. I personally, I worked in the Department for Work

and Pensions, we did have pilots and reject if it worked and move it

forward. In this instance because the negotiations have gone on so

long they have foregone the pilot period and people have come forward

and said, we believe, or there might not be a strike. They never said,

this is what will be happening. Maybe he is getting the feeling to

kick this into the long grass. We have the potential of thousands of

operations and appointments being postponed this week. And people

suffering to some degree. This was a sensible compromise, wasn't it? Do

it on a trial basis? It was a way to end the deadlock? What you had seen

is that they were only possibilities, when you lead the

letter carefully there are many get out clauses. If he didn't think that

was watertight, what was being offered, he also said what we are

doing is a slow roll-out. Jeremy Hunt's later stance, people say it

is evidence of him being intransigent. I don't thing everyone

has the full facts. If you genuinely interested in your patience and want

what's best and then you looked at the deal on the table for what we

can afford... I have looked into the costings of locums, of the extra

hours and thought, how do we make that work for everybody to have a

good public service that we are all paying for question that is what we

want. With the i, and I declare an interest here. Fox's five points

from fairy tale finale. That is quite difficult to say. You did it

well. Thank you. Leicester City beat Swansea 4-0 today. It is lovely on

Twitter that people keep giving me a running commentary. It is a great

story. You may note, I am a big man city fan. Nothing would please me

more than if Man City won. Manchester City might still win the

Champions League, that is an option, but nothing pleases me more than

seeing Leicester City. Last year they were battling relegation. The

odds were 5000 to one. I remember at Christmas when they said this person

is that however much on and I thought it was fantastic then. To be

here now, and it is like a fairy tale football story. It is not all

about the money and it was on about the names, this is a team that has

come up. I watched them today on the telly and effortless as they were

scoring goal after goal. 18 months ago football fans like myself didn't

know who they were. Now we'll want them. Claudio Ranieri the current

manager is getting a lot of credit for what he has done. But how much

of their success is down to what Nigel Pearson set up? A big chunk of

that squad were his. I thought they play fantastically as a team. It is

not a load of individuals wanting to come on and show off. They are

coming together and say, let's do it together. That, to me, when I see

them working together is why they are where they are. They play as a

team and want to win. That is why they knock spots off anyone else in

the Premier League. It is so scary at this point. Terrifying. No, no, I

think they will do little stop they are well on the way now. No point

putting any money on now. If someone else beat them to the title they

would be very unpopular. They would. I think it should be like the Tour

de France where the winner on the final day is allowed to get on with

it. Finally, the Express, we know they love a weather story. We love

the weather in this country, love talking about it. Snowy blast to

sweep Britain. It seems like a bit of this with when we are close to

the end of April. The central heating went on again in my house

this weekend and I thought it will cost a lot of money, this bad

weather. It was cold. It is ridiculous that this time of year. I

have been deadheading my hydrangeas and look at this. I only did it last

weekend. Mrs Stapleton came in this afternoon and said it is too cold

for gardening. All the bedding plants after sale and you should not

buy them at this point unless you can put them cover. I sound like I

know what I'm talking about! Sometimes it snows in April. Whose

son that? I don't know. Prince. A lyric for every occasion. It was

quite civilised. I promised you. We were just warming up for the next

one! Esther and John will be back at 11:30pm for another look at the

front pages. Stay with us on BBC News, at 11 o'clock more on

President Obama's warning it could take the UK ten years to negotiate

its own deal with the US. Coming up next, Meet The Author.