18/02/2014 The Referendum Debate

campaign is

Labour's

and

APPLAUSE

Tonight,

most beautiful village

It's

Benedictine

in

suffered from repeated English suffered from repeated English

story. A 19th century tourist guide story. A 19th century tourist guide

story. A 19th century tourist guide observance of

story. A 19th century tourist guide hospitality

story. A 19th century tourist guide sure

story. A 19th century tourist guide submitted

story. A 19th century tourist guide panel

story. A 19th century tourist guide question

story. A 19th century tourist guide with

story. A 19th century tourist guide the plan

story. A 19th century tourist guide Directors,

story. A 19th century tourist guide the

story. A 19th century tourist guide say

story. A 19th century tourist guide Barroso, say his plan on Europe,

story. A 19th century tourist guide it has changed down the

story. A 19th century tourist guide months, it's not going

story. A 19th century tourist guide think there

story. A 19th century tourist guide lot about currency this week in

story. A 19th century tourist guide response

story. A 19th century tourist guide Chancellor of the

story. A 19th century tourist guide people who have suggested

story. A 19th century tourist guide plan, include the Prime

story. A 19th century tourist guide Patrick

story. A 19th century tourist guide to

story. A 19th century tourist guide why?

story. A 19th century tourist guide fiscal

story. A 19th century tourist guide viable

story. A 19th century tourist guide last

story. A 19th century tourist guide that policy because George Osborne

story. A 19th century tourist guide tells them

tells them to. APPLAUSE

tells them to. say

tells them to. the

tells them to. currency

tells them to. suggests, Alex Salmond

tells them to. a plan? On the first point,

tells them to. not

tells them to. APPLAUSE

tells them to. On

tells them to. debate.

tells them to. under devolution

tells them to. Both

tells them to. man. Certainly, if the UK

tells them to. Government,

tells them to. party,

tells them to. wounds, everybody accepts the

tells them to. democratic will

tells them to. outrageous and

whether that transition is to the whether that transition is to the

whether that transition is to the that the

whether that transition is to the choice

whether that transition is to the APPLAUSE

great

Salmond

Sturgeon

Government

we're going. The currency is

sovereignty,

issues

currency...

APPLAUSE

On

know

Scottish

lamb

about

send

England.

answer

answer for 500

will it cost them?

exactly the

because

formal

say that

He

much

if

certain

not just because it

Scotland,

for

take

keep

keep the currency precisely

it is in

Scotland votes

English

union

union,

That's

the common-sense

mess now. It's a

completely

the

won't

currency will we have? currency will we have?

currency will we have? Are

currency will we have? options for an independent

currency will we have? conclusion

currency will we have? currency

currency will we have? best

currency will we have? Jenny

currency will we have? fascinating.

currency will we have? to

currency will we have? having

currency will we have? get the

currency will we have? everyone's

currency will we have? The lady

currency will we have? political

currency will we have? and

currency will we have? Scotland is not

currency will we have? called, but what it can do for

currency will we have? or not do

currency will we have? can't stop

currency will we have? unilaterally? Because

currency will we have? There's

currency will we have? this week that

currency will we have? Chancellor, it walks away from the

currency will we have? pound.

currency will we have? power to

currency will we have? the

currency will we have? sterlingisation,

currency will we have? what

currency will we have? against

currency will we have? institutions

currency will we have? pound

currency will we have? coins.

currency will we have? things as well.

currency will we have? is

currency will we have? said

currency will we have? for

currency will we have? they

currency will we have? sell to

currency will we have? Wales and

currency will we have? actually, we are

currency will we have? of last resort

currency will we have? we are going to offer to

currency will we have? they fail, we are going

currency will we have? that.

currency will we have? independent people too. It

currency will we have? cost

currency will we have? union."

currency will we have? to

currency will we have? The gentleman

currency will we have? Thank

currency will we have? I'd

currency will we have? before

currency will we have? Alex

currency will we have? said

currency will we have? around

was a speech at the Centre

European

a

neck.

circumstances of the euro have

changed, why

of sterling changed? Why

the

Let's answer about

theirs.

when you look

effects of keeping Stirling,

and maintaining trades, benefitting and maintaining trades, benefitting

and maintaining trades, benefitting conclusion that was come

and maintaining trades, benefitting that Stirling was

and maintaining trades, benefitting to

and maintaining trades, benefitting asked

and maintaining trades, benefitting eurozone

and maintaining trades, benefitting because

and maintaining trades, benefitting and

and maintaining trades, benefitting is

and maintaining trades, benefitting proposed the

and maintaining trades, benefitting ensure that there is not

and maintaining trades, benefitting countries

and maintaining trades, benefitting currency union

and maintaining trades, benefitting and in a stable

and maintaining trades, benefitting the UK shares

and maintaining trades, benefitting trade

and maintaining trades, benefitting argument doesn't

and maintaining trades, benefitting never said

and maintaining trades, benefitting that

and maintaining trades, benefitting about to get

and maintaining trades, benefitting serving the interests

and maintaining trades, benefitting I'm

and maintaining trades, benefitting think is

and maintaining trades, benefitting the

and maintaining trades, benefitting Scotland should

and maintaining trades, benefitting politicians

and maintaining trades, benefitting position

and maintaining trades, benefitting referendum?

and maintaining trades, benefitting politicians who're willing

and maintaining trades, benefitting ideas

and maintaining trades, benefitting for a

and maintaining trades, benefitting the important question,

and maintaining trades, benefitting kind of

and maintaining trades, benefitting This has

and maintaining trades, benefitting from

and maintaining trades, benefitting Jenny will have to decide if the

and maintaining trades, benefitting people

and maintaining trades, benefitting yes to

and maintaining trades, benefitting to Edinburgh giving a

and maintaining trades, benefitting he's

and maintaining trades, benefitting have said

and maintaining trades, benefitting not

and maintaining trades, benefitting will

and maintaining trades, benefitting stop debating the

and maintaining trades, benefitting the currency union because actually

and maintaining trades, benefitting it's not going

and maintaining trades, benefitting question for the SNP and Alex

and maintaining trades, benefitting Salmond and

and maintaining trades, benefitting currency

and maintaining trades, benefitting have

and maintaining trades, benefitting APPLAUSE

and maintaining trades, benefitting Who has

and maintaining trades, benefitting about Scotland, Jenny rolls

and maintaining trades, benefitting has her

and maintaining trades, benefitting Chancellor.

and maintaining trades, benefitting facts.

and maintaining trades, benefitting Treasury

and maintaining trades, benefitting Government, but all parties

and maintaining trades, benefitting conscience

and maintaining trades, benefitting union,

and maintaining trades, benefitting Scotland

and maintaining trades, benefitting been

and maintaining trades, benefitting a few

and maintaining trades, benefitting middle,

and maintaining trades, benefitting consequences

and maintaining trades, benefitting currency for

and maintaining trades, benefitting Scotland?

and maintaining trades, benefitting is

and maintaining trades, benefitting that

and maintaining trades, benefitting According

and maintaining trades, benefitting best plan.

and maintaining trades, benefitting best plan if we don't

and maintaining trades, benefitting Very

and maintaining trades, benefitting at the front

and maintaining trades, benefitting important.

and maintaining trades, benefitting Scottish Government and

and maintaining trades, benefitting side, it's

and maintaining trades, benefitting plan

and maintaining trades, benefitting conference

and maintaining trades, benefitting The

and maintaining trades, benefitting independence is

and maintaining trades, benefitting discussing

and maintaining trades, benefitting precisely

vote. vote.

vote. We'll

vote. Alison McWilliam? Gordon Brown today

vote. tells

vote. my

vote. OK. Under

vote. you be worried

vote. billion

vote. rise

vote. of

vote. pensions and

vote. placed

vote. the

vote. of the UK and

vote. dragged down

vote. to

I

I thing

I of a

I million

I than

I pot of five million people.

I advances

I all

I know what currency whir going

I using

stay. stay.

stay. shirt? Of

stay. population

stay. plan A

stay. McMe,

stay. Duncan Smith is

stay. privatising

stay. England and Wales at the

stay. is the biggest rise

stay. state

stay. inflation

stay. basically

stay. 2.5%.

stay. it always

stay. When

stay. yules to a state

stay. gets

stay. in

stay. the

stay. Chartered accountants for Scotland.

stay. They are the

stay. their proposals

stay. out

stay. millions of pounds

stay. holes

stay. schemes and

stay. allowed

stay. these

stay. in

stay. forward and know

stay. whether

stay. not

stay. Can

stay. No. What

stay. then? I'm not

stay. don't

stay. Everything you hear on the BBC

stay. the

stay. I

stay. believe

stay. Conservative

stay. The

stay. worried about

stay. worried

stay. understands

stay. societies,

stay. problem

stay. happening,

stay. about what we

stay. opportunities

stay. a rich

stay. Scotland. If

stay. fairly,

stay. risks

stay. Gordon

stay. then

stay. keeping

stay. part

stay. with the

stay. millions

stay. the people

stay. Sir in

stay. nobody mentioning the

stay. or any other expenses

stay. man

stay. Thank

stay. aged

stay. increase

stay. Thank you.

stay. out that

stay. would

stay. has

stay. real. But

stay. I

stay. the

stay. ceked

stay. if

stay. could bring

stay. drifting

stay. the future.

stay. do. In

stay. about

stay. policy

stay. SNP's narrative

stay. these things until

stay. economy and oil

stay. This

Scotland, frankly, just does not Scotland, frankly, just does not

Scotland, frankly, just does not the

Scotland, frankly, just does not think there's any

Scotland, frankly, just does not scenario in which

Scotland, frankly, just does not independent

Scotland, frankly, just does not see

Scotland, frankly, just does not far more

Scotland, frankly, just does not Europe,

Scotland, frankly, just does not move,

Scotland, frankly, just does not something

Scotland, frankly, just does not together. It

Scotland, frankly, just does not something

Scotland, frankly, just does not That's

Scotland, frankly, just does not countries,

Scotland, frankly, just does not change a

Scotland, frankly, just does not have

Scotland, frankly, just does not humane

Scotland, frankly, just does not But I'm

Scotland, frankly, just does not progressive change

Scotland, frankly, just does not OK,

Scotland, frankly, just does not Conservative Home

Scotland, frankly, just does not policy

of the UK does. There is a question of the UK does. There is a question

of the UK does. There is a question Barroso

of the UK does. There is a question enagreement. There

of the UK does. There is a question one

of the UK does. There is a question country

of the UK does. There is a question of this island and

of the UK does. There is a question The

of the UK does. There is a question bowler

of the UK does. There is a question bolder by

of the UK does. There is a question point

of the UK does. There is a question who

of the UK does. There is a question stay. It didn't change

of the UK does. There is a question They

of the UK does. There is a question wanted

of the UK does. There is a question given

of the UK does. There is a question mainly people from

of the UK does. There is a question way, this is throwing up

APPLAUSE APPLAUSE

APPLAUSE mentioned

APPLAUSE EU. Sir David Edward,

APPLAUSE foremost legal brain

APPLAUSE Thank

APPLAUSE that in

APPLAUSE stick to immigration

APPLAUSE UK

APPLAUSE Thank you very

APPLAUSE for a minute. The

APPLAUSE Scotland

APPLAUSE been

scaremongering. I think it's scaremongering. I think it's

scaremongering. I think it's immigration

scaremongering. I think it's Europe. If you

movement, and the UK has movement, and the UK has

movement, and the UK has are part

movement, and the UK has and

movement, and the UK has way things

movement, and the UK has country,if

movement, and the UK has there

movement, and the UK has APPLAUSE

movement, and the UK has It

movement, and the UK has agreement

movement, and the UK has close on purpose.

movement, and the UK has common

movement, and the UK has flexibility

movement, and the UK has moment. Neither

movement, and the UK has economy. No,

movement, and the UK has they

movement, and the UK has different. But

movement, and the UK has can't come to agreement

movement, and the UK has the

movement, and the UK has common travel area

it's very close to each other. What it's very close to each other. What

it's very close to each other. What this

it's very close to each other. What wages that people have as a

it's very close to each other. What barrier to

it's very close to each other. What increase the number

it's very close to each other. What to increase immigration

it's very close to each other. What Scotland?

it's very close to each other. What CHEERING

Yes. In the

the members of the panel

understand

do

much. We'll try to

border question for a

hopefully

the discussion

Up

one of

sleep

Parliament

Thank you very

something

saying that this is about which saying that this is about which

saying that this is about which which

saying that this is about which sides,

saying that this is about which pro-independence

saying that this is about which national

saying that this is about which Frankly,

saying that this is about which there's probably

saying that this is about which people

saying that this is about which some

saying that this is about which of

saying that this is about which be having a

ideas about the future of Scotland, ideas about the future of Scotland,

ideas about the future of Scotland, live

ideas about the future of Scotland, it's a fair

ideas about the future of Scotland, things

ideas about the future of Scotland, the other.

ideas about the future of Scotland, To

ideas about the future of Scotland, identity

ideas about the future of Scotland, Kingdom, it's actually

ideas about the future of Scotland, piece

ideas about the future of Scotland, common defence,

ideas about the future of Scotland, intelligence,

ideas about the future of Scotland, with our

ideas about the future of Scotland, island that we

ideas about the future of Scotland, Scotland

ideas about the future of Scotland, Parliament.

ideas about the future of Scotland, debate on Twitter. If you

ideas about the future of Scotland, take

ideas about the future of Scotland, and

ideas about the future of Scotland, website.

ideas about the future of Scotland, Or

ideas about the future of Scotland, been said about

ideas about the future of Scotland, welfare

ideas about the future of Scotland, Stewart Hosie?

ideas about the future of Scotland, to be increased?

ideas about the future of Scotland, Hang

ideas about the future of Scotland, think

ideas about the future of Scotland, of

ideas about the future of Scotland, fund

ideas about the future of Scotland, for 32 years.

ideas about the future of Scotland, can fund

ideas about the future of Scotland, continue to

ideas about the future of Scotland, position

decades. For over three decades. If decades. For over three decades. If

decades. For over three decades. If try

decades. For over three decades. If hope

decades. For over three decades. If tens

decades. For over three decades. If lots

decades. For over three decades. If key

balanced society. balanced society.

balanced society. APPLAUSE

balanced society. What's your

balanced society. convinced.

balanced society. child care

balanced society. already

balanced society. countries that

balanced society. your white paper have

balanced society. highest tax rates in the world. The

balanced society. reason why they have

balanced society. welfare system.

balanced society. that

balanced society. question

balanced society. people

balanced society. tax take.

balanced society. employment there's

balanced society. cost.

balanced society. more

balanced society. pays

balanced society. don't

balanced society. at

balanced society. the

balanced society. corporation

balanced society. White Paper, the

balanced society. The SNP

balanced society. Joseph, the member

balanced society. hand-picked

balanced society. it

balanced society. Nobel

balanced society. spokesman,

balanced society. people

balanced society. residential homes and

balanced society. changed the

balanced society. people

balanced society. that there

balanced society. Westminster?

balanced society. Thank

balanced society. Mr

balanced society. creating these hundreds of thousands

balanced society. of

balanced society. Air Force Bases in Scotland,

balanced society. Thank

balanced society. got at

balanced society. bleak vision with the

balanced society. lady was talking

balanced society. get in proportion

balanced society. and

balanced society. the

balanced society. the entire North Sea from all of

balanced society. that oil because

balanced society. per

balanced society. right that

balanced society. geography, an ageing

balanced society. that's one of

balanced society. Democrat

balanced society. benefit

balanced society. ageing population. The

balanced society. greatest

balanced society. This in

balanced society. previous questioner

balanced society. policy would we have in

balanced society. business -- give

balanced society. So

balanced society. Scandinavian welfare

balanced society. salary

balanced society. for

balanced society. But

balanced society. a single set

balanced society. think

balanced society. wholesale.

balanced society. sobs

balanced society. more

balanced society. lessons to

balanced society. tax

balanced society. -- many countries. We have

balanced society. systematically undermine the

balanced society. solidarity, the

balanced society. with independence

balanced society. idea of what a quell fare

all about and put that into all about and put that into

all about and put that into Yes?

all about and put that into I

all about and put that into a em-Government,

don't want to be on that road. Just

to come

was

Westminster

Scotland's

that

Is On the

own

to take far more

Jenny, on

would welfare be

independent

be

society like

is my

right. I

chap

we

it. Ed Miliband's

reinstating the

want to

Can

single

out

what I want

lower incomes not

because

tax

you

question from Charlie

Is

Scotland

But...

APPLAUSE.

I

seen over the past week as

I think

English

sell

This

never

constituents that the

Kingdom now get

their kids up to

Scotland.

reality than bullying if I'm

There

up if you

saying

boy

not

bullying,

Spelling out the truth of where

Scotland

Thank

asking people in England

scandalous.

the people in Scotland.

in Scotland.

doesn't

Kelso. So

want to

not hearing

and the

the

Borders. On both

side

turning up in

between

My

My Thank

My Ruth Davidson?

My The people of England

My of the

My Britain, I want

My of

My around

My of

My and don't want

My and family

My say, you might not

My best tactic to keep

My might be

My feel

My intervention

My both sides

My relationship between Scotland

My neighbours,

My together

At least

the safe end of

to

in Kirkcaldy

details. Thank