21/01/2014 The Referendum Debate

chance

answered. Tonight we are in

Greenock.

Our panel

Our panel Hislop,

Our panel actor

Our panel evenly

Our panel and

Our panel our

Our panel audience

Our panel seen those questions.

Our panel Watson. Would removing Trid

Our panel defence

Our panel Scotland.

Our panel save

Our panel be

Our panel society

Our panel based

Our panel certainly other

Our panel defence staff

Our panel questioning the

Our panel the big issues

Our panel a

Our panel opportunity in September to

Our panel Scotland,

Our panel The

Our panel inCoe herence

Our panel independence

Our panel have

Our panel child

Our panel clear by

Our panel Westminster that

Our panel would save allegedly would

Our panel of

Our panel the

Our panel alliance of nations across

Our panel of the world.

Our panel just

Our panel nuclear weapons. I want

Our panel world

Our panel moving

Our panel solution. Let's instead

Our panel multilateral

Our panel world

Our panel question

Our panel I

Our panel agree with

Our panel nuclear

Our panel think

Our panel say that

Our panel sooner would

Our panel of all nuclear weapons

Our panel in

Our panel Yes, so I suppose

Our panel Secondly, this is a

Our panel referendum

Our panel would

Our panel attack? The answer

Our panel thing

Our panel that

Our panel the

Our panel dislike

Our panel they are

Our panel but

Our panel defence

Our panel want

Our panel want to live within

Our panel is

Our panel something rather bigger than nuclear

Our panel weapons and SNP

Our panel debate.

Our panel to

Our panel face

Our panel what's best

Our panel Nuclear weapons are

Our panel wrong. It doesn't

Our panel right.

Our panel doesn't make independence

Our panel mistake.

Our panel have a debate

Our panel best for

Our panel making sure we

Our panel security

Our panel more

Our panel about what's best for Scotland and

Our panel how

Our panel unemployment and making

Our panel Let's

Our panel we

Our panel from the

Our panel far

Our panel during

Our panel also

Our panel and

Our panel care

Our panel think that

Our panel responsibility, the moral

Our panel responsibility, not least,

Our panel far

Our panel first

Our panel a

Our panel is

Our panel involved in closing down

Our panel decimating the

Our panel only the

Our panel to those people

Our panel Faslane

Our panel of

Our panel it's going to cost the Scottish

Our panel Government to

Our panel will take a couple

Our panel therefore

Our panel Thank you

Our panel is a

Our panel of

Our panel rid of the weapon but

Our panel the

nearest golf club and says I would nearest golf club and says I would

nearest golf club and says I would the Scottish

nearest golf club and says I would in

nearest golf club and says I would circle? The same

nearest golf club and says I would members of NATO

nearest golf club and says I would In

nearest golf club and says I would is

nearest golf club and says I would in

nearest golf club and says I would must

nearest golf club and says I would nuclear

nearest golf club and says I would the

nearest golf club and says I would nuclear

nearest golf club and says I would deflected

nearest golf club and says I would for defence are

nearest golf club and says I would different than

nearest golf club and says I would years ago

nearest golf club and says I would terms

nearest golf club and says I would provided. That's

nearest golf club and says I would that

nearest golf club and says I would place as

nearest golf club and says I would are

nearest golf club and says I would remains and can be developed

nearest golf club and says I would powerhouse in

nearest golf club and says I would be

at the conference. We want to join a at the conference. We want to join a

at the conference. We want to join a said

at the conference. We want to join a that Sterling was

at the conference. We want to join a neck of

at the conference. We want to join a would

at the conference. We want to join a UK. It's not

at the conference. We want to join a position

at the conference. We want to join a numbers don't

at the conference. We want to join a both for

at the conference. We want to join a the middle.

at the conference. We want to join a defence. Weapons

at the conference. We want to join a or nuclear

at the conference. We want to join a need. The

at the conference. We want to join a Force,

at the conference. We want to join a troops from

at the conference. We want to join a Thank you very

at the conference. We want to join a middle. It was

at the conference. We want to join a need to get

at the conference. We want to join a is just about us. We haven't

at the conference. We want to join a like

at the conference. We want to join a that they

at the conference. We want to join a SNP

at the conference. We want to join a Are

at the conference. We want to join a practically

at the conference. We want to join a Thank you very much. I can assure

at the conference. We want to join a you that speaking from

at the conference. We want to join a centre perspective, the

at the conference. We want to join a the

at the conference. We want to join a suddenly

at the conference. We want to join a the

at the conference. We want to join a point

at the conference. We want to join a has

at the conference. We want to join a claim

at the conference. We want to join a changed

at the conference. We want to join a fact there was a

at the conference. We want to join a deliver the NHS,

at the conference. We want to join a The

at the conference. We want to join a defend the

at the conference. We want to join a it's a joke.

at the conference. We want to join a employment, but to talk about

at the conference. We want to join a keeping jobs

at the conference. We want to join a saying, we

at the conference. We want to join a killers

at the conference. We want to join a the

at the conference. We want to join a don't forget you can

at the conference. We want to join a debate on twitter.

at the conference. We want to join a will be in

at the conference. We want to join a of the

at the conference. We want to join a BBC website and search

at the conference. We want to join a referendum debate. You can

at the conference. We want to join a e-mail us.

from Andrew

charity

shops,

reasons

there are massively

that go to the

issues

across

a debate about

the people at

bottom

dominated by the

independence. I will

main

be set out

independence.

the

ten

minimum

be set up,

exception, shows that progress can exception, shows that progress can

exception, shows that progress can ask Mr

exception, shows that progress can of that?

exception, shows that progress can economy,

exception, shows that progress can things

exception, shows that progress can campaign has

exception, shows that progress can the

exception, shows that progress can real social

exception, shows that progress can This

exception, shows that progress can successes

exception, shows that progress can across

exception, shows that progress can here

exception, shows that progress can We argued about

exception, shows that progress can think it's a reasonable question, Mr

exception, shows that progress can McKenzie. The

exception, shows that progress can answered however in

exception, shows that progress can power lies.

exception, shows that progress can the course of recent

exception, shows that progress can Conservative Government, a

exception, shows that progress can Government

exception, shows that progress can having

exception, shows that progress can from

exception, shows that progress can days,

exception, shows that progress can days

exception, shows that progress can local

exception, shows that progress can a Government in

exception, shows that progress can moment

exception, shows that progress can centralisation in

exception, shows that progress can from health provision

exception, shows that progress can policing, to just

exception, shows that progress can element

exception, shows that progress can legislating about

exception, shows that progress can at football

exception, shows that progress can revive

exception, shows that progress can Scotland

exception, shows that progress can councils,

exception, shows that progress can they once had and trusting

exception, shows that progress can actually run

exception, shows that progress can is a question of governments,

localism, and local democracy. localism, and local democracy.

localism, and local democracy. cannot

localism, and local democracy. Alex makes

localism, and local democracy. many powers?

localism, and local democracy. effect? I

localism, and local democracy. connection with my

localism, and local democracy. for

localism, and local democracy. protect that

localism, and local democracy. local. I

localism, and local democracy. from society

localism, and local democracy. there.

localism, and local democracy. Party.

localism, and local democracy. Scotland who have voted

localism, and local democracy. the past.

localism, and local democracy. type

localism, and local democracy. can deliver

localism, and local democracy. the UK Government

localism, and local democracy. Security in the

localism, and local democracy. whatever guise. We have started

localism, and local democracy. Scotland, we have cancelled the

localism, and local democracy. privatisation

localism, and local democracy. health

localism, and local democracy. the

localism, and local democracy. of

localism, and local democracy. don't share

localism, and local democracy. that?

localism, and local democracy. way we can get other handle on

localism, and local democracy. to

the front row, in the pink. I would the front row, in the pink. I would

the front row, in the pink. I would ignoring the

the front row, in the pink. I would OECD figures, the UK is the

the front row, in the pink. I would most unequal

the front row, in the pink. I would you. The

the front row, in the pink. I would about

the front row, in the pink. I would I

the front row, in the pink. I would disparity

the front row, in the pink. I would the front.

the front row, in the pink. I would understand,

the front row, in the pink. I would through the 1990s,

the front row, in the pink. I would about

the front row, in the pink. I would of your colleagues in

the front row, in the pink. I would interview said,

the front row, in the pink. I would say that

the front row, in the pink. I would would find more money for child

the front row, in the pink. I would care, you said

the front row, in the pink. I would small

that businessman who employs 23-30 that businessman who employs 23-30

that businessman who employs 23-30 rates taken

that businessman who employs 23-30 make

how you can boot the yes campaign how you can boot the yes campaign

how you can boot the yes campaign waiting

ludicrous these things exist, but ludicrous these things exist, but

ludicrous these things exist, but it

ludicrous these things exist, but banks

ludicrous these things exist, but Newcastle. The problem I

ludicrous these things exist, but intelligent person, because I can

ludicrous these things exist, but barely run my own bank

ludicrous these things exist, but fiscal. They

ludicrous these things exist, but handle

ludicrous these things exist, but unknowns.

ludicrous these things exist, but will be

ludicrous these things exist, but Scotland,

ludicrous these things exist, but is the

ludicrous these things exist, but you

ludicrous these things exist, but How

ludicrous these things exist, but There's

ludicrous these things exist, but Social

ludicrous these things exist, but the wealth we have in a more fair

ludicrous these things exist, but and

ludicrous these things exist, but arguments. Different countries will

ludicrous these things exist, but deal with things

ludicrous these things exist, but but, if you are close at your

ludicrous these things exist, but Government, I

ludicrous these things exist, but more adaptable to the needs you

locally. Like many other countries locally. Like many other countries

locally. Like many other countries reactive.

that under a UK Westminster that under a UK Westminster

that under a UK Westminster can see the dismantling of the

welfare state. That is happening welfare state. That is happening

welfare state. That is happening would have

spending limits, interest rates, spending limits, interest rates,

spending limits, interest rates, impact people right here in Scotland

spending limits, interest rates, but

spending limits, interest rates, terms of share of sterling, we would

spending limits, interest rates, have a

spending limits, interest rates, the

spending limits, interest rates, the UK?

spending limits, interest rates, bank

spending limits, interest rates, We

spending limits, interest rates, to move on to the next

spending limits, interest rates, Allison, a retired engineer. Why

won't Mr Cameron debate with Alex won't Mr Cameron debate with Alex

won't Mr Cameron debate with Alex debate

won't Mr Cameron debate with Alex a

won't Mr Cameron debate with Alex tiresome

won't Mr Cameron debate with Alex Prime

won't Mr Cameron debate with Alex UK. I

won't Mr Cameron debate with Alex if

won't Mr Cameron debate with Alex something, it

won't Mr Cameron debate with Alex he

won't Mr Cameron debate with Alex therefore,

won't Mr Cameron debate with Alex request.

won't Mr Cameron debate with Alex it were more complicated

won't Mr Cameron debate with Alex but it isn't.

won't Mr Cameron debate with Alex you probably should. On the

won't Mr Cameron debate with Alex hand, Mr Cameron can reader

won't Mr Cameron debate with Alex just as well as Alex Salmond

read a pole. All the polls are read a pole. All the polls are

read a pole. All the polls are indicate a no vote, so in that

read a pole. All the polls are sense,

read a pole. All the polls are there is

read a pole. All the polls are about that,

read a pole. All the polls are self-awareness.

read a pole. All the polls are LAUGHTER

read a pole. All the polls are He's

read a pole. All the polls are then,

read a pole. All the polls are campaign because I think

read a pole. All the polls are certain

read a pole. All the polls are very

read a pole. All the polls are and England.

read a pole. All the polls are disconnect.

read a pole. All the polls are wedding,

read a pole. All the polls are applied both

read a pole. All the polls are which

read a pole. All the polls are Minister of

read a pole. All the polls are the next

read a pole. All the polls are have

read a pole. All the polls are He

read a pole. All the polls are not

read a pole. All the polls are Government versus

read a pole. All the polls are It's not

read a pole. All the polls are This

read a pole. All the polls are hoping

read a pole. All the polls are Salmond,

read a pole. All the polls are Scot

read a pole. All the polls are has a vote in this referendum

read a pole. All the polls are have

read a pole. All the polls are won't

read a pole. All the polls are Salmond

read a pole. All the polls are am

read a pole. All the polls are have

read a pole. All the polls are to be a debate and

read a pole. All the polls are before

read a pole. All the polls are points made by Alex has a

read a pole. All the polls are of truth about them. The

read a pole. All the polls are here in Scotland but probably

read a pole. All the polls are the franchise is

read a pole. All the polls are if

read a pole. All the polls are why should

read a pole. All the polls are This is a choice

read a pole. All the polls are Government where it's

read a pole. All the polls are people of Scotland on all

read a pole. All the polls are the Westminster

read a pole. All the polls are choice between two systems

read a pole. All the polls are Government?

read a pole. All the polls are If

read a pole. All the polls are Westminster, why are

read a pole. All the polls are William Hague and

read a pole. All the polls are second. First you said this

read a pole. All the polls are just a matter for the

read a pole. All the polls are complain about

read a pole. All the polls are views.

read a pole. All the polls are One

read a pole. All the polls are debate

read a pole. All the polls are should do is

read a pole. All the polls are issues that

read a pole. All the polls are SNP's stance on

read a pole. All the polls are response

read a pole. All the polls are debate with

read a pole. All the polls are the

read a pole. All the polls are talk about real issues and

read a pole. All the polls are reason

read a pole. All the polls are The question came from

read a pole. All the polls are be

you think, do you think we should be you think, do you think we should be

you think, do you think we should be the issue? The gentleman

you think, do you think we should be it's

you think, do you think we should be coming up and putting their other

you think, do you think we should be in?

you think, do you think we should be keep us part

you think, do you think we should be Should

you think, do you think we should be the

you think, do you think we should be Westminster is not a

you think, do you think we should be you?

you think, do you think we should be much.

you think, do you think we should be for

you think, do you think we should be is a

you think, do you think we should be Cameron

you think, do you think we should be to have

you think, do you think we should be fan

you think, do you think we should be campaign

you think, do you think we should be Conservatives

you think, do you think we should be That's

you think, do you think we should be the

you think, do you think we should be that is. Indeed,

you think, do you think we should be zone. One in five

you think, do you think we should be Scottish

you think, do you think we should be which suggests

you think, do you think we should be fundamentalist base of

you think, do you think we should be is roughly

you think, do you think we should be question.

you think, do you think we should be Black. Will

you think, do you think we should be wealth plans as proposed

you think, do you think we should be Scottish

you think, do you think we should be independent Scotland

you think, do you think we should be salary

you think, do you think we should be south

you think, do you think we should be that what you

you think, do you think we should be they

you think, do you think we should be going

you think, do you think we should be country

you think, do you think we should be the redistribution

you think, do you think we should be Scotland

you think, do you think we should be status quo.

you think, do you think we should be moment

you think, do you think we should be up and

you think, do you think we should be I am not sure they

you think, do you think we should be is

you think, do you think we should be and I

you think, do you think we should be Doesn't

you think, do you think we should be your

you think, do you think we should be uncertainty

you think, do you think we should be no because you won't

you think, do you think we should be tax rate will be in

you think, do you think we should be model will be able

you think, do you think we should be Scotland's economy? Have

you think, do you think we should be working to pay

you think, do you think we should be can

you think, do you think we should be is

you think, do you think we should be the

you think, do you think we should be making

you think, do you think we should be able to work for longer

you think, do you think we should be because

you think, do you think we should be many of

you think, do you think we should be young in terms of

you think, do you think we should be you

you think, do you think we should be Exchequer.

you think, do you think we should be the

you think, do you think we should be back in

you think, do you think we should be go up, I think what will

you think, do you think we should be number of decades in Europe

you think, do you think we should be have a 3% or

you think, do you think we should be different

you think, do you think we should be suggesting that the child

you think, do you think we should be policy,

you think, do you think we should be tax in implementing the policy

you think, do you think we should be it

you think, do you think we should be will

you think, do you think we should be you will

you think, do you think we should be increase

you think, do you think we should be this in

you think, do you think we should be years

you think, do you think we should be have

you think, do you think we should be change

you think, do you think we should be us

you think, do you think we should be And it's redistribution.

you think, do you think we should be fundamental

you think, do you think we should be benefitting

you think, do you think we should be mothers and making

you think, do you think we should be families, we don't

you think, do you think we should be children

you think, do you think we should be the danger

you think, do you think we should be may

you think, do you think we should be agree

you think, do you think we should be is the Scottish Government

you think, do you think we should be don't

you think, do you think we should be need independence...

you think, do you think we should be not the radical

you think, do you think we should be transformtive child

you think, do you think we should be The powers

you think, do you think we should be not about changing women's

you think, do you think we should be It's

money to do it then, as well but money to do it then, as well but

money to do it then, as well but Westminster

money to do it then, as well but on

money to do it then, as well but childcare

money to do it then, as well but down to

money to do it then, as well but about

money to do it then, as well but with

money to do it then, as well but their vote which could have

money to do it then, as well but didn't

money to do it then, as well but That's not

money to do it then, as well but Why

money to do it then, as well but I voted against

money to do it then, as well but stages when the tax

money to do it then, as well but introduced. I

money to do it then, as well but if it returns

money to do it then, as well but We are dodging

money to do it then, as well but The point which

money to do it then, as well but earlier about

money to do it then, as well but haven't had

money to do it then, as well but a

money to do it then, as well but tax

money to do it then, as well but want is

money to do it then, as well but member

money to do it then, as well but get

money to do it then, as well but inclined to think

money to do it then, as well but Labour

money to do it then, as well but about

money to do it then, as well but not

money to do it then, as well but for independence, there

money to do it then, as well but pressures

money to do it then, as well but their

money to do it then, as well but border. Now, the

money to do it then, as well but Scotland this will encourage people

money to do it then, as well but to leave Scotland.

reason why the SNP are very careful reason why the SNP are very careful

reason why the SNP are very careful that in addition

reason why the SNP are very careful corporation

reason why the SNP are very careful Levied

reason why the SNP are very careful addition to that he sees

taxation. That sounds like a reason taxation. That sounds like a reason

taxation. That sounds like a reason who

taxation. That sounds like a reason disappointed

taxation. That sounds like a reason facts

otherwise, suggesting that, in otherwise, suggesting that, in

an independent Scotland governed by an independent Scotland governed by

an independent Scotland governed by more.

an independent Scotland governed by tax

an independent Scotland governed by have

an independent Scotland governed by being

an independent Scotland governed by sorts

an independent Scotland governed by Scotland

an independent Scotland governed by of

an independent Scotland governed by wealthy individuals. The

an independent Scotland governed by tax and

an independent Scotland governed by not

an independent Scotland governed by large

an independent Scotland governed by done and what

an independent Scotland governed by of

functioning, and also that council functioning, and also that council

functioning, and also that council like free

functioning, and also that council have

functioning, and also that council of

functioning, and also that council fairly.

functioning, and also that council relative. The

functioning, and also that council trillion

functioning, and also that council countries, we have not

functioning, and also that council GDP

functioning, and also that council Scotland's

functioning, and also that council put

functioning, and also that council issue

functioning, and also that council some

functioning, and also that council have

functioning, and also that council Scotland

functioning, and also that council Osborne

functioning, and also that council MacDonald.

functioning, and also that council Yes, because you have the CBI

functioning, and also that council Every trade

functioning, and also that council part

functioning, and also that council real

functioning, and also that council place

functioning, and also that council debate

functioning, and also that council is

functioning, and also that council and

functioning, and also that council right

functioning, and also that council rebate, so

functioning, and also that council with

functioning, and also that council sure if you do,

as part of the EU. Just to remind as part of the EU. Just to remind

as part of the EU. Just to remind going

European Union and the UK's European Union and the UK's

European Union and the UK's Scotland hasn't

European Union and the UK's independence, if

European Union and the UK's will

European Union and the UK's time?

European Union and the UK's There's

European Union and the UK's therefore

European Union and the UK's boats

European Union and the UK's is

European Union and the UK's we

European Union and the UK's the

European Union and the UK's about

European Union and the UK's fact we do

European Union and the UK's keeping a single market in Scotland.

European Union and the UK's The

European Union and the UK's apply

European Union and the UK's the

European Union and the UK's Gentleman three rows back. Would

European Union and the UK's Scotland be part of the EU

European Union and the UK's bizarrely, but

European Union and the UK's taken

European Union and the UK's members

European Union and the UK's want

European Union and the UK's part

European Union and the UK's Alex

European Union and the UK's five

European Union and the UK's to

European Union and the UK's businessman

European Union and the UK's replicated around every such club in

European Union and the UK's Scotland. Thank you. To the lady

European Union and the UK's over here.

European Union and the UK's to

European Union and the UK's European

European Union and the UK's uncertainty

European Union and the UK's proposed referendum for

European Union and the UK's Scotland. I

European Union and the UK's argument

European Union and the UK's gentleman in the front. I agree with

European Union and the UK's the

European Union and the UK's Scotland

European Union and the UK's to

European Union and the UK's is to stay in EEC,

European Union and the UK's likely with a Scots vote,

European Union and the UK's involved, to

European Union and the UK's cities,

European Union and the UK's migration.

European Union and the UK's interests

European Union and the UK's question was asked,

European Union and the UK's Everybody

European Union and the UK's interest in Scotland to remain part

European Union and the UK's of the

European Union and the UK's jobs,

European Union and the UK's aspects

European Union and the UK's we have our own

European Union and the UK's Scotland in terms of

European Union and the UK's European

European Union and the UK's behind

European Union and the UK's Government

European Union and the UK's discussing

European Union and the UK's areas, fishing,

European Union and the UK's from

European Union and the UK's people

European Union and the UK's and

European Union and the UK's interest

European Union and the UK's European policy.

European Union and the UK's public

European Union and the UK's years'

European Union and the UK's vote?

European Union and the UK's support

European Union and the UK's exam,

European Union and the UK's Blimey,

European Union and the UK's would vote for independence.

European Union and the UK's The ode to a mouse

European Union and the UK's with.

European Union and the UK's have

European Union and the UK's would be a good opportunity to

European Union and the UK's some poems. I

European Union and the UK's the

European Union and the UK's he

European Union and the UK's on

European Union and the UK's Would he have voted yes or

European Union and the UK's cares?

cares? APPLAUSE

and

have

Bobby

referendum. Fiona

about

enough but I

side

not have voted, he

on the base

that the

now.

quote. He has written in the first quote. He has written in the first

quote. He has written in the first exactly,

of time. I think in terms of that of time. I think in terms of that

of time. I think in terms of that indeed. A

of time. I think in terms of that Scotland next month we will be in

Kelso on the 18th of February and Kelso on the 18th of February and

Kelso on the 18th of February and the

Kelso on the 18th of February and good